Latest / Sages, Icons & Heretics / A Conversation with George Young
Transcript
- Sages Icons and Heretics A Conversation with George Young Mix: Hello and welcome to our next episode of Stages, Icons, and Heretics, a podcast about the management consulting profession. Today I'm joined by George Young. George and I overlap for about eight years at Deloitte, and for the last eleven or so years, eleven, eleven and a half years, I've worked with George at Calypso, which is a consulting and professional services firm that he co founded back in in two thousand four. And since since founding it is Folded to Rockfall Automation and George, I think we're right on the heels of a a recent promotion for you just last week. Yes. George and I knew each other at Deloitte, didn't really seriously start getting to know each other as I was contemplating joining Calypso. And funny, after a couple of conversations, the funny story is George minded and dined me at McDonald's in in Chicago to try to close me and close the deal. So thanks again, George. for bringing me on board. It's been a great experience to clip so Yeah. It was the flagship McDonald's in Oak Brook. Yeah, because no expense was spared. Yeah, I should be I should be quite honored. Yeah, the other thing I wanted to talk about is you know when I came up with the name of Sages, Icons and Heretics to the name of this podcast, I especially thought of you on the heretics part of it. I think you're both a sage and an icon, but I've come to value your your heretical view of the profession. So hopefully we'll get to cover some of that today. So I guess what I want to start off with is how in the world did you get in c into consulting? Was it intentional? Was it opportunistic? Was it somewhere in between? How did you get that in? It was totally accidental. I was in the chemical industry. And while I was in the chemical industry, I was managing a plant here in Houston. And they it was really weird, but I got promoted into a business position because the fellow before me had actually been murdered in Brazil and they needed somebody to take that position. And I don't think maybe I was their first choice, but they said, hey, let's do this. And you should go get an MBA. So go to University of Houston, Clear Lake, get your MBA. And I said, well, I really don't want to get an MBA, first of all. Because I have a PhD. I figured I'm probably smart enough. Why do I need to get an MBA? Now, I I really appreciated getting the MBA. But anyway, they forced me to get my MBA. And then I went to, but I said, if I'm going to get an MBA, I want to go to Rice. Rice is the best program in Houston. So I went to Rice. And while at Rice, I took an operations management class that was run by a guy named Robert Flatt. Just one of the most influential people really that I knew. And a lot of the Houston Deloitte office would use Robert. He was a a vice president for Cooper Cameron. And he introduced me to Mattress Mack, for all you Houston people that know who Mattress Mack is, but just a great guy. And anyway, apparently a bunch of well, I remember Richard Avant, principal in the Houston. Deloitte office came and taught one of our classes. And, you know, apparently a number of the consulting companies asked Robert, Hey, who do you have that's a student that might be interested in consulting? He recommended me. So I was not in the career center. I was planning to stay with the chemical company and continue, but I started getting interest and I said, Well, you know, I'll listen. And this is where maybe you were talking about me being a heretic. I I had a very poor opinion of consultants because when I was managing the plant, we were implementing SAP, and we had one of the leading management consulting firms leading, you know, as our implementation partner. And I hated working with them. And I couldn't wait to get them out of my plant. And Famously, one of my rice colleagues at the time, I remember one time there was another consulting presentation by another firm, and I wrote in his notebook the person was just going on spouting all this management consulting gibberish, and I wrote in his notebook those who can do those who can't consult. And he kept that piece of paper because then Not more than a year later, I was working for Deloitte. So I went the short story is I went to Rice, didn't ever think about going to management consulting. Robert Flatt in his class introduced me. I I interviewed with 13 consulting firms, all of them, and had offers from most. And then I had a final senior, it's not a senior project, but you had like In your second year, you had to do what they called it an action learning project. And I did a a consulting project with a local oil field services company and a guy named Lovett Baker. He was the professor, but he was also just a legend in Houston. I believe he was the founder of the Texas Commerce Bank. Anyway, Lovett Baker was a larger than life figure, also like Robert Flat to me and he told me, he said, Look, you're meant to be a consultant. Because he's he just saw the way I did the final presentation to the executive board at the oil field services company. And so I say, you know, I wasn't that far along in my career, but I was fairly far along. I was on a an executive track. And the interesting thing also was that when I interviewed Deloitte offered me the lowest job title. So I was offered a position as a senior consultant and various people, all of whom you know, Jim Bragg, Richard Mizzuno, people like that in the Houston office at Deloitte, they said, We don't care how long it takes you to be in rank, but you won't be able to become a partner in the firm if you don't understand what the work of a senior consultant is. And that came me well. So I took the lowest position offered. And I also took it Richard Mizzuno and his dry sense of humor. Once I was offered the position, he was like, Well, you know, George, you know, can take the offer. I don't know why you would, but you know, I think you would do fine here. So that was I don't know. what that says about me, but I took the the lowest status offer, but I was serious about getting into consulting and I really bought into this idea that if you don't know what a senior consultant does, how could you manage their work? So that's how I I came to Deloitte. Yeah. But I don't think I realized that you're actually a campus hire. So that's that's another interesting piece of information for me. About you. It's been a profession of yours for decades, many decades now. You've been a musician. I would argue you were an academic. You'd spent a lot of time at college. You know, you were an operator and most recently a consultant. So what what about out of all those things you have done has kept you in consulting and been a calling for you all these many years? So for me, people always say to me, boy, you got a PhD. You you really wasted your time, didn't you? That's really a dumb thing to do, don't you think? And I was like, What are you talking about? That was the most valuable experience I'd had because when you earn a PhD in science, you have to come up with an original idea and prove it in a thesis. And in my case, I was synthesizing mixed metal organic compounds that had never been made before. And so what runs through my career and what I get excited about is just doing new stuff all the time. And I look at consulting problems and what I do. I just I think I'm still an RD. It's a different research and development playing field. When I was in the chemical industry, I did lots of stuff with artificial intelligence. I was doing neural networks in the 80s. And now I'm managing deployment of huge AI projects. So I think it was a significant advantage of for me was that I got this PhD. I learned to value innovation and constantly learning. That's one cool thing about consulting is you can't do the same thing for five years. You have to reinvent yourself every three, maybe every five. At the most. Yeah, it might be increasing. I know you and I were raised on that three to five. It might be less than that now. It's a constant challenge to be relevant. So it's interesting that you're looking at your career through the lens of R and D. That makes sense to me the way you described it. Through that lens, R and D projects, some succeed, some fail, some fail and revisited to make better. How's that lens shape how you serve clients and how you created and led firms? Whew. Well, one thing in R D, it's really hard. in my thesis, you have an original idea, you have to prove it. It took me a long time to get my PhD. I it some people can get theirs in four years. Yeah, you could theoretically get it in three, I think, in chemistry. I went to Ohio State. Some people maybe one or two people in my class did it in three, but it took me six years because For two and a half years, every reaction that I tried did not work. That was two and a half years of banging my head against the wall. And I kept just trying different things. And then eventually, once I found the key, the unlock, then everything fell into place and I was I was good to go. Got lots of papers and and you know, everything worked out. But It certainly teaches you perseverance, failure. I think, I was also in punk rock bands and things. I had a band and back then some people really loved punk rock, but we would show up and we'd go play shows where people thought they were gonna hear Journey, and we'd come on and they really just absolutely hated us in a very visceral and physical fashion. So, being able to stare failure in the face from that R and D perspective and then literally having to run for your life from a bunch of people who wanted to beat the crap out of you. Those things help you put things in perspective. When you have a bad project, was it really that bad? Yeah, great somebody hit you over the head with a beer bottle? No, they didn't. Yeah, great point. Yeah, I believe On one occasion you at least got knocked out by a flying beer bottle. Knocked out, dragged off the stage, and stabbed. Another of the George eclectic experiences, no doubt. So I'd want to ship a little bit to talk about, you know, when we were rising through the ranks, we were it was pounded into us to learn the consulting process as a core foundation for everything we did in consulting. So You just talk a bit about what the consulting process means to you and maybe in the context of our last decade or or so. What it why is it important as a foundation for a broader set of professional services? Once again, I'll go back to RD. it's it's not first of all, I don't really believe in this so-called management science. Having a PhD in a real science, sometimes I get a little bit carried I I I feel like the word science can get bandied a about a little bit loosely. But what management consulting is at its core is probably two things. But what we're talking about here is problem solving. I think it's problem solving, and then there's the intangible and the really important part, which is caring about people, caring about your client. And we'll probably get to that later, but focusing on the process of consulting. It's really about problem solving. And so to me, that's why I think I was always really good at it, because I approached I approach any consulting project and I was taught by consultants and then passed that along to the people of of Deloitte and Clip. So the first thing you do is a situation assessment, a data analysis. You gotta get all the data together. And I really believe in the case study method. Case study learning in MBA school, one thing it does is it does set you up to be a consultant because in a case study you're presented with all kinds of data, 80% of which is 100% irrelevant. Doesn't doesn't matter at all. So you have to look at all the data, but then you have to glean what's significant. And then you have to develop hypotheses. Which you have to test empirically and then socially, because there are possible political and emotional or whatever landmines. There almost always are. Most of the problems that companies have are apparent to everybody except those involved, or maybe they're even apparent to those involved, but they really Just don't wanna look under the covers. And then maybe talk a little bit about, we there is consulting as a capability and then consulting with other service lines around it. implementation, data science, model development and application, managed services, lots of other things. How is consulting as a capability important for a broader portfolio of professional services? You're you're talking about the changing nature of I guess the characteristics of consulting because it used to be that consulting, strategy consulting, or just go in, do a high level analysis, have some recommendations, present your results, and then people would pay you a lot of money and maybe implement these things or not. I joined Deloitte. in what I would say the the golden era of ERP and IT consulting, where the real dollars were driven by large technology implementations, hundreds of millions of dollars of services to fundamentally replat well, not replatform, but establish an enterprise platform that a company was going to use. And started off that the strategy then became focused on why would you do an ERP and what is the business case? Why would you even do this stuff? And then of course the organizational change management part, which is we not only have to justify we why we would do it, but we have to realize that nobody really wants to do anything differently, and we have to consider what are the barriers, what are the motivations for change, and helping clients get there. And now as we've moved from the golden age of IT consulting to consulting that is really services driven. And companies are looking for solutions that that maybe they're going to even outsource. They're looking for Partners that will help them with turnkey solutions if it's not very strategic. And if it is very strategic, we're developing artificial intelligence and very, very interesting, innovative things that have nothing to do with enterprise software that really are are being built and integrated into the enterprise software. It's just fundamentally changed. So now consulting is. the leading edge. It's an important part. It's a differentiator. It's not the focus. So I don't know if I'm making sense. I'm saying that the center of gravity has shifted, but the the core foundation of consulting enables us to be successful in that broader portfolio of professional services. Yeah. The best way to illustrate it is, McKinsey, which was the paragon of strategy consulting, I believe That something like 70% of their services are now IT driven. I think that's the reality of the professional services marketplace today. It makes sense because what you have to do as a service provider is you have to provide something of value to a client that they can't do themselves, either because they don't have the manpower or they don't have the the capability. They don't want recommendations. They want implemented solutions and they want it quickly. The time compression has just been amazing. The original ERP projects that you and I were part of might be a five-year implementation, right? And now people are saying they want full implementation with SaaS and things like that. They want the software loaded, running. In three to six months. That world has changed dramatically. For a hundred billion dollar company. Yeah. I think I want to shift gears a little bit. For those, you know, young consultants earlier in their career that may be on. Can you talk a little bit about as you rose to the ranks career wise, what worked and didn't work as you progressed through the you know the organization at different levels with your aspirations to become a partner and eventually lead lead organizations? I've always just liked to do what I like to do. So I've never I gave the commencement address at Youngstown State, my alma mater, and one thing that I said in the and I don't know if anybody in the audience paid any attention. I I know I was short, and the president of Youngstown State, Jim Dressel, said that was great. That was under ten minutes. He said that was dynamite. Anyway, the theme was you're young, you're going out there. You can never really know what's gonna happen. And in my case, everything, this is really true. Anything that I ever said I would do, I have not done. And everything that I ever said that I wouldn't do, I have done. I said I would never be a management consultant. I said I would never work in business. Basically, when I got out of when I was in graduate school, I thought that corporations were evil. So I didn't ever think I would even go into business. I didn't own a shirt with a collar. I said I would never live in Texas and I would never live in California. And now I have a place in both states. I'm Buddhist and I believe in this very strongly of the ability to be present and to see things in the moment. And so for me, things just sometimes are apparent, like that. Opportunity to go into consulting. I was curious. Let's go do that. So I did that. And then when I was there at Deloitte, this one of the problems is you get there and then everything's geared for you to be a partner. So yeah, I went ahead, I became a partner. While I was working my ass off, killing myself to become a partner, I never really actually did the due diligence to know what a partner did. I wanted to be a partner because that was the top. But then when I became a junior partner, I learned, no, this is the bottom. I'm now the new the new kid on cell block D. And I was like, I also tell people sometimes it's like when you're in high school, you're a freshman and you get invited to the senior party, and then you walk in the door and you're like, do I really want to be here? Deloitte had changed and because of Sarbanes, Oxaly, and all that stuff, but I got to be a partner at Deloitte because I loved management consulting. I wanted to do it. I loved Deloitte. And it was a rude awakening to achieve that and then realized that the firm that I joined in Texas, what I really loved was the Texas practice. And I learned that the Texas practice of Deloitte was unique and not representative of the firm. And that The broader firm was not something that I really loved. And then I'm like, man, I'm a partner in a firm that that I'm not sure I really want to be part of. And I was very depressed. I was like, just I was not doing good work. I was not, I I think I was I was in a really bad state. And my co founder of Calypso, Bill Poston, Bill's a a wonderful friend and a even better manipulator. He and I met at a retirement party for one of our mentors, Jim Prag, and he just Bill over the course of six to eight hours walked me through what it might be like to start a new firm and convinced me that I always have a a great sense of how to sell things and how to put complex ideas into simple packages. By the end of the day I was like just jazzed to go start a new consulting firm. But I had no desire. I had had no desire prior to that day to start a new firm. I don't know what that says, but I do things that I like, that I enjoy. I've never had a five year plan. I've never had a three year plan. I do have a ninety day plan. I believe in ninety day planning. Yeah. Interesting 'cause you led the firm by following the market. And I think what you're saying is that you've led your career by following the market for George and what that looks like and where there's opportunity and where that opportunity matches your interest and aptitude. Yeah, it's it's it's the market. Yeah, that's true. It's the market for George. So one thing that that is good I think that makes this is a difference between a successful entrepreneur and an unsuccessful one is The market tells you whether your idea is good or bad. Well, and I shouldn't say whether it's good or bad. It's just there's great ideas that it's not the time or whatever, right? But it's like, okay, don't stay married to this one thing. If it doesn't work, it doesn't work. Move on. Yeah, it makes sense. Wanna explore a little bit what you've how I did for you for me again is a little bit more that the heretic in you. You've talked about it in your career. I've also observed it At Calypso where you know when confronted with an opportunity or an issue or a challenge, and the conventional wisdom is to turn right, you turned left. I can think of five to ten of those times where you would do something and I'd be like, Okay, you know what, George? I wouldn't have done that. And then you do it and it turns out okay. So maybe talk a bit about you know, your How that happens? Is that intuition? Is it being in the moment? Is it a contrarian in you? What what what about your makeup? How did you turn left when others would have turned right? Well, I think that what happens is number one, I think when you are a contrarian and you have success, people magnify your successes. I always told people that. Bill Poston and I when we founded Calypso, ninety percent of the decisions we made were wrong. But the 10% that were right were really right. They were really right things to do. So I think sometimes what happens is you and then it's like, what do they call it? Confirmation bias or something, where you remember those things and you're like, because there were several times when I said, okay, team. This is what I think we should do. What do you think? And the partner group said, No, that's that doesn't sound like a good idea at all. And I said, Okay, well, I've heard you and I do love all of you, but we're gonna do it this way and I need your support and let's see how it plays out. And luckily, you know, guys trusted me enough that we did it. And for the big decisions, it turned out to be the right path. Now, how did I can't know whether I'm gonna be right or wrong. Nobody could. I do think it's that analytics though, and being really in the moment and plugged in. And also I have no and maybe it's the punk rock in me. I have no attachment to the status quo. Okay, I built my house, time to burn it down. You know what I mean? It's like what I've created, I don't have any attachment to. That was yesterday. And then maybe that's the Buddhism part, right? Attachment is is an evil thing. You become attached to objects, you become attached to ideas. You should try to free yourself from attachment. And then maybe that helps with the decision making. How much of you know who you become as a leader is grounded in your formative experiences as a consultant? So if you think maybe you just kind of highlight an early client experience that really formed you as a consultant. No, and how that how you drew on that to then progress and move and build and grow. Yeah, there's just so many. My Deloitte experiences. My first project that I really came in into my own on was a an R D project that that I did with Joe Vitali out of the Cleveland office of Deloitte for a company called Lubrazol and re-engineering their R D, re engineering new product development. And what I learned there was and what I loved about consulting was that to me the secret is putting together a great team, giving them the the the goalpost, and then letting them do it the way that team can best do it. it's what I preach now at Rockwell Automation is and it's heretical. I'm not a management and control person. I believe in leadership and development, not management and control. And Joe on that project allowed me as a senior consultant, but with a lot of chemical experience and chemical RD experience. He had me lead the team basically. And he had me lead him. You know, that was also the managing, managing upward. You'd be like, Okay, so Georgia, I'm the partner. I gotta go in this meeting with the CEO. What do I need to tell him? And I was writing the scripts. And then the other thing was he brought me in the room. Then he he developed me. He was not like that's the worst part of consulting where you hear these stories of people working 120 hours and they don't get they don't get a chance to share the stage. Joe, Joe really gave me that opportunity. And then the next big project that I was on was Project Renaissance with Jim Bragg in Houston with Baker Hughes. And there Jim gave me, and Baker Hughes and and their leadership gave me an open canvas. I ran what we called get ready projects. And what these were were a whole bunch of projects that were meant to. make a return on investment in a very short amount of time that would pay for the enormous amounts of money that they were spending on the SAP implementation. So we did cycle counting, we did plant four floor redesign. We did new product development, re-engineering, product and SKU rationalization. Just like anything it was a was a management consultant's dream And we delivered on it. And again, the confidence in those leaders. I love that they put that that confidence in me. That's what I learned at Calypso too was get rid of the hierarchy. We've got people. If the senior consultant knows how to do it best, listen to that person. You know what I mean? I do. I think back and some of my I remember Maybe remember better projects I did as a senior consultant and manager than I did in the middle pack of the career here. Cause they were so formative and to help shape me, you know, as a consultant too. Well, good. So a little bit about the Sage part of this. You're looking back at your career, what's the best advice anyone has ever given to you along your thirty years in this business? Okay. For this one, I'll go with Joe Buccilli, another Cleveland partner. His advice was it's never as good as it seems and it's never as bad as it seems. Consulting for me, I was I was just born to do this. I I recognize it. That's why I keep doing it. That's why I'm still doing it. I I don't know what I'm what I'm gonna do. People think I'm pathetic because I think I'm just gonna keep consulting until I croak. But I just think it's like a drug. I just love solving problems. I love doing what I'm doing, working with Different clients seeing new things, managing the development of people. It's just, I don't know. I just love it. And but the thing is, the highs and lows of consulting can be extreme. I've been fired in very unceremonious ways, and that's pretty heart wrenching. And then I've delivered incredible work and yet three months later lost an engagement. Because maybe maybe I was filled with hubris and didn't pay attention to things. I don't know. But that's the one thing you learn. And I think it it I think it makes you if you've if you've been a management consultant for thirty years, you probably have no rough edges whatsoever because you've been beaten by the winds and storms of business for so long that you pretty much can get through anything. That's been my experience too. I I would say that the highs are even euphoric at times to be they are. You c you can see it. You've seen young consultants just with a meteoric rise and then they hit a couple of bumps and they can't handle it and they're they're done. Yeah. There's something about an end of phase report out with a really senior executive team when you crush it. And walking out of that, that feeling walking out of that meeting, no knowing how well that went. and contrast that with I had one experience where we were pitching a project to a a a senior team and it went horrible. Even at the point where the as I was walking out of the room, a senior client guy said, You gotta quit trying so hard. It was the final slap and walked out of that meeting and left the team and I it was a new port beat and I went out. By myself, got a beer, went out to the beach and just sat there for an hour contemplating. So I yeah, I agree with you. The highs are highs and the lows are low. Yeah, that's what makes it fun. And and also I think the thing is, again, it's problem solving, it's thinking on your feet. That is why I think the punk rock stuff helped me out a lot, because I've got rid of the stage fright and you never really knew what was gonna happen when you step up there. And that's a little bit the same. In management consulting, you c sometimes the room shifts within a a debrief. And you and I have done this together before, where we went into a meeting with a plan and it became obvious in the first five minutes. That plan was the wrong one. And so we just changed completely and luckily most of the time it worked. Well, we're nearing the end of our time here, George, together. I guess is our final close for those listening in. We just asked about the best advice you'd ever receive. What advice do you have for those contemplating a long career in management consulting? Well, I would say, well, why do you want to do that? First of all, I I would just question why I would question how anybody would know they want to be a management consultant. I would say Look into things and find out if you like it. If you're intellectually curious and you're okay with constantly being challenged, might be a good opportunity for you. It's incredibly rewarding, but you can make more money. If you want to make money, if optimizing financial return is your objective, this is not the profession for you. So there's easier ways to make a living and there are more lucrative ways to make a living. You have to really like the process. You have to really like the challenge. That's what I would say. Well, George, thank you so much for your time today. It's been a a fun journey through your career and hearing your insights and learning more about the heretic in you. So thank you again for participating. I really appreciate it. You're welcome.