Latest / Boring Science / 100 Sleepy Facts About Dark Matter _ The Invisible Universe Explained for Sleep
Transcript
- 0:00Speaker 1: Good evening, and welcome back to Boring Science for Sleep. Tonight,
- 0:05here on this quiet little corner of the internet, we
- 0:08are going to drift gently into one of the deepest
- 0:10mysteries of the cosmos. So before we begin, take a
- 0:14slow breath, settle into your pillow, and allow the night
- 0:19to grow a little quieter around you. If you're comfortable,
- 0:23feel free to leave a comment below and share something
- 0:25simple with us. Where in the world are you listening
- 0:28from tonight? And what time is it where you are?
- 0:32It's always wonderful to see how many different corners of
- 0:35the planet gather under the same sky. Now, let's begin
- 0:39our slow journey. Imagine for a moment that you are
- 0:42floating far above the Earth. The blue glow of our
- 0:46planet fades behind you as you drift deeper into space.
- 0:50Stars stretch endlessly in every direction. Galaxies spiral quietly in
- 0:55the distance. Nebula clouds glow softly like cosmic fog At
- 1:00first glance, the universe seems full of light stars, galaxies,
- 1:05brilliant explosions of energy scattered across the darkness. But something
- 1:10remarkable hides behind that beauty. Something enormous. Something invisible. Because
- 1:17the truth is, most of the universe cannot be seen
- 1:21at all. Not with telescopes. Not with cameras. Not even
- 1:26with the most powerful instruments humanity has ever built. In fact,
- 1:31everything we can see, every star, every planet, every galaxy,
- 1:36is only a tiny fraction of what actually exists. The
- 1:40rest is something scientists call dark matter. Dark matter does
- 1:45not shine. It does not reflect light. It does not
- 1:49glow or sparkle or flicker across the night sky. It
- 1:53is completely invisible. And yet, it seems to be everywhere.
- 1:59Galaxies spin as if enormous unseen masses are holding them together.
- 2:04Light bends around invisible structures drifting through space. Clusters of
- 2:09galaxies move as though they are surrounded by giant halos
- 2:13of hidden gravity. Again and again, astronomers look into the
- 2:18universe and see the same strange clue. Something is there.
- 2:23Something massive. But we cannot see it. It is almost
- 2:28like a shadow Not a shadow cast by light, but
- 2:31a shadow woven into the very structure of the cosmos.
- 2:35A silent partner to the universe we know. Some scientists
- 2:39like to imagine dark matter as the hidden skeleton of
- 2:42the universe. If ordinary matter stars, gas and galaxies is
- 2:46the glowing skin of the cosmos, then dark matter may
- 2:50be the invisible framework beneath it. Holding everything in place,
- 2:55shaping the largest structures in existence, guiding the slow dance
- 3:00of galaxies across billions of years. And yet, we still
- 3:05do not know exactly what it is. Tonight, we are
- 3:09not going to rush through complicated equations or dense physics. Instead,
- 3:14we will take a gentle journey. 100 quiet facts about
- 3:19dark matter. 100 small glimpses into one of the universe's
- 3:23greatest mysteries. Along the way, we'll explore how astronomers first
- 3:28discovered hints of this invisible substance, how galaxies revealed its
- 3:33presence through their motion, how enormous cosmic webs stretch across
- 3:38the universe, and how scientists are still searching for the
- 3:42particles that might finally explain what dark matter truly is.
- 3:46Each idea will arrive slowly, softly, like distant stars appearing
- 3:53one by one in the night sky. Because dark matter
- 3:56reminds us of something profound. The universe is not only
- 4:00what we can see, most of it remains hidden. And
- 4:04perhaps that is part of what makes the cosmos so beautiful.
- 4:08Even after centuries of astronomy, even with telescopes that can
- 4:12see billions of light years into space, the universe still
- 4:17holds secrets. Quiet ones, waiting patiently for us to discover them.
- 4:23So tonight, As your mind begins to relax and your
- 4:26thoughts grow lighter, imagine yourself drifting through the invisible architecture
- 4:31of the cosmos. Galaxies floating like islands in a dark ocean.
- 4:36And around them, vast halos of unseen matter guiding their motion.
- 4:42A universe where the greatest structures are shaped by something
- 4:45we cannot even see. Let the mystery settle gently into
- 4:49your thoughts. And as we begin our journey through these
- 4:52sleepy facts about dark matter, allow the quiet rhythm of
- 4:57the cosmos to guide you slowly toward rest. When we
- 5:01look up at the night sky, the universe appears full
- 5:05of light. Stars shimmer across the darkness. Galaxies glow faintly
- 5:10in the distance. Nebulae spread like delicate clouds between the stars.
- 5:16For centuries, Astronomers believed that these glowing objects made up
- 5:21the universe itself. Everything that existed could be seen, or
- 5:26so it seemed. But as telescopes grew more powerful and
- 5:30measurements became more precise, scientists began to notice something strange.
- 5:36The universe was behaving as though much more matter existed
- 5:39than we could actually see. Something unseen seemed to be
- 5:43shaping the motion of galaxies. Something invisible was pulling on
- 5:47the cosmos. And slowly, almost quietly, astronomers began to realise
- 5:53that the visible universe might only be a small part
- 5:56of the whole story. In fact, modern science suggests something
- 6:01rather astonishing. All the stars, planets, dust, gas and galaxies
- 6:06we can observe make up only about 5% of the universe.
- 6:10Speaker 2: 5%.
- 6:12Speaker 1: Everything we have ever seen through telescopes. Every galaxy photographed
- 6:18by space observatories, every glowing nebula drifting across the cosmic ocean,
- 6:24together they form only a tiny fraction of what exists.
- 6:29The remaining 95% appears to be made of something else entirely.
- 6:34Some of it is called dark energy, which influences the
- 6:37expansion of the universe, and a large portion of it
- 6:41is something more mysterious. Something that does not shine, does
- 6:46not glow, and cannot be seen directly. This mysterious substance
- 6:51is what scientists call dark matter. The name might sound dramatic,
- 6:56but it simply reflects the fact that this matter is invisible.
- 7:00It does not emit light. It does not absorb light.
- 7:04It does not reflect light. In fact, Dark matter interacts
- 7:09with light so weakly that even our most sensitive instruments
- 7:12cannot detect it directly. And yet, its presence can be
- 7:17felt through gravity. Gravity is the key that revealed the
- 7:21hidden universe. Because while dark matter may be invisible, its
- 7:26mass still pulls on other objects. Just like the gravity
- 7:29of a star can guide the orbit of a planet,
- 7:32dark matter influences the motion of galaxies and clusters of galaxies.
- 7:37In this way, astronomers began to see its fingerprints scattered
- 7:41throughout the cosmos. The first clues appeared nearly a century ago.
- 7:46In the 1930s, a Swiss astronomer named Fritz Zwicky studied
- 7:51clusters of galaxies, vast collections of hundreds or even thousands
- 7:56of galaxies bound together by gravity. Zwicky carefully measured how
- 8:01fast these galaxies were moving inside their clusters. What he
- 8:05found puzzled him. the galaxies were moving far too quickly.
- 8:09According to the visible mass in the cluster, the stars
- 8:12and gas we could see, the cluster should not have
- 8:15had enough gravity to hold itself together. If only visible
- 8:19matter were present, the galaxies should have drifted apart long ago.
- 8:24But they had not. Something unseen was holding the cluster together.
- 8:30Something heavy. Something invisible. Zwicky suggested that the cluster must
- 8:35contain large amounts of missing mass, mass that could not
- 8:40be seen with telescopes. At the time, many astronomers considered
- 8:45the idea unusual, even speculative. But over the decades that followed,
- 8:50more evidence began to appear. In the 1970s, astronomer Vera
- 8:56Rubin made one of the most important discoveries in modern astronomy.
- 9:00Rubin studied how stars move inside galaxies. In a galaxy
- 9:05like the Milky Way, stars orbit the galactic center, much
- 9:09like planets orbit the Sunday. If most of the mass
- 9:12in a galaxy were concentrated near its center, we would
- 9:15expect stars farther away to move more slowly. This is
- 9:19how planetary systems behave. Planets close to the Sun move quickly,
- 9:25while distant planets move more slowly. But when Rubin measured
- 9:29the motion of stars in galaxies, she found something surprising.
- 9:33Stars at the edges of galaxies were moving just as
- 9:36fast as stars much closer to the centre. According to
- 9:40visible matter alone, those outer stars should not have been
- 9:43moving that quickly. If they were, they should have flown
- 9:47off into intergalactic space. Yet they remained in stable orbits.
- 9:52The only explanation that made sense was that galaxies were
- 9:56surrounded by enormous halos of unseen matter. These halos contained
- 10:01far more mass than the visible stars and gas combined.
- 10:05Once again, gravity was revealing something hidden. Imagine a galaxy
- 10:10floating in the darkness of space. Its spiral arms glow
- 10:14with billions of stars. Clouds of gas drift between them,
- 10:19From a distance, the galaxy appears like a luminous island
- 10:23in a cosmic ocean. But according to modern astronomy, the
- 10:27glowing stars we see may only be the bright center
- 10:30of something much larger. Surrounding the galaxy is an enormous
- 10:34sphere of dark matter, a halo extending far beyond the
- 10:39visible edges of the galaxy. Invisible, silent, yet incredibly massive,
- 10:47This halo's gravity helps hold the galaxy together, guiding the
- 10:51motion of its stars across billions of years. Without it,
- 10:55many galaxies might not exist in the stable forms we
- 10:58observe today. Dark matter also shapes the universe on the
- 11:02largest scales imaginable. If we could somehow map the distribution
- 11:07of matter across billions of light years, we would see
- 11:10something remarkable. Galaxies are not scattered randomly through space. Instead,
- 11:16They form enormous patterns, long filaments stretching across the cosmos,
- 11:22vast clusters connected by invisible structures. Between them lie enormous
- 11:28empty regions called cosmic voids. Astronomers call this arrangement the
- 11:33cosmic web, and according to computer simulations, dark matter may
- 11:37form the underlying framework of this web. Ordinary matter, The
- 11:42gas that forms stars and galaxies collects along the gravitational
- 11:46scaffolding created by dark matter. In this sense, dark matter
- 11:50may have shaped the entire architecture of the universe. Yet
- 11:54despite all this evidence, dark matter itself remains unseen. No
- 11:59telescope has ever photographed it. No laboratory has definitively detected
- 12:05its particles. Scientists know it exists primarily through its gravitational influence,
- 12:11It is like watching leaves move across a still pond
- 12:15and realizing that something unseen must be stirring the water
- 12:18beneath the surface. The effects are visible, but the cause
- 12:22remains hidden. And that is part of what makes dark
- 12:26matter so fascinating. It reminds us that the universe still
- 12:30contains deep mysteries. Even now, after centuries of scientific discovery,
- 12:36we are only beginning to understand the true nature of
- 12:39the cosmos. Most of the universe is invisible, and yet
- 12:44it quietly shapes everything we see. Galaxies spin within halos
- 12:49of unseen mass. Clusters of galaxies drift through oceans of
- 12:53hidden gravity, and the largest structures in existence may be
- 12:57built upon a foundation we cannot yet fully understand. As
- 13:02we continue our gentle journey tonight, we will explore how
- 13:06astronomers uncovered more clues about this invisible substance. Because galaxies
- 13:11themselves hold some of the most intriguing hints. When scientists
- 13:16carefully studied how galaxies rotate, they discovered patterns that could
- 13:20not be explained by ordinary matter alone. Something unseen was
- 13:24guiding the motion of the stars. And that puzzle led
- 13:28to one of the most important discoveries in modern astronomy.
- 13:32When astronomers first began studying galaxies in detail, they expected
- 13:36them to behave much like smaller systems we already understood.
- 13:40For example, consider our own solar system. The Sun sits
- 13:45at the center, holding the planets in orbit through gravity.
- 13:49The closer a planet is to the Sun, the faster
- 13:52it moves. Mercury completes its orbit quickly, racing around the
- 13:57Sun in just 88 days. Farther away, Neptune moves much
- 14:02more slowly, taking more than a century to circle the
- 14:06Sun once. This pattern makes sense. The Sun contains almost
- 14:11all the mass in the solar system, so its gravity
- 14:14dominates everything else. Astronomers once assumed that galaxies would behave
- 14:19in a similar way. At the center of a galaxy
- 14:22lies a dense region filled with stars, gas, and often
- 14:27a supermassive black hole. Farther out, the spiral arms stretch
- 14:32into the darkness. If most of the mass were concentrated
- 14:35near the center, then stars near the edges should move
- 14:38more slowly than those closer in just as distant planets
- 14:42move more slowly around the Sunday. But when astronomers actually
- 14:46measured how stars move within galaxies, they discovered something unexpected.
- 14:52Something puzzling. Something that did not match their predictions at all.
- 14:57In the mid-20th century, astronomers began mapping the rotation curves
- 15:02of galaxies. A rotation curve is simply a graph showing
- 15:06how fast stars move at different distances from the galactic center.
- 15:11To measure this, scientists observe the light coming from stars
- 15:15and gas clouds. Because these objects are moving, their light
- 15:18shifts slightly in frequency, a phenomenon known as the Doppler effect.
- 15:24By measuring these shifts, astronomers can determine how fast the
- 15:28stars are orbiting. And when they plotted those speeds against
- 15:31distance from the galactic center, They expected to see a
- 15:35curve that gradually dropped. Stars near the centre would move quickly.
- 15:41Stars farther away would slow down. But the results told
- 15:45a different story. Instead of slowing down, the stars at
- 15:49the edges of galaxies were moving almost just as fast
- 15:53as those much closer to the centre. The rotation curves flattened.
- 15:58Imagine watching a spinning carousel. You might expect the outer
- 16:02horses to move more slowly, gently circling the centre. But instead,
- 16:08they race around at nearly the same speed as those
- 16:11near the middle. This is essentially what astronomers observed in galaxies.
- 16:16The outer stars were moving far too quickly to be
- 16:19held by the gravity of visible matter alone. According to
- 16:23the amount of mass we could see the stars, gas
- 16:25and dust The outer regions of galaxies should not have
- 16:29enough gravitational pull to keep those stars in orbit. If
- 16:33the visible matter were all that existed, many of those
- 16:36stars should simply escape. They would drift away into the
- 16:40vast emptiness between galaxies. But they do not. Galaxies remain stable.
- 16:47Their stars continue orbiting calmly for billions of years. Something
- 16:52unseen must be holding them together. This realisation slowly led
- 16:57scientists to a remarkable conclusion. Galaxies must be embedded in
- 17:01enormous halos of invisible matter. These halos extend far beyond
- 17:07the visible edges of the galaxy itself. While the stars
- 17:10and gas form the bright spiral arms we see in photographs,
- 17:14the majority of the galaxy's mass lies in this invisible
- 17:18halo surrounding it. The halo acts like a gravitational cocoon,
- 17:23It provides the additional pull needed to keep the outer
- 17:26stars moving at their observed speeds. Without it, galaxies might unravel.
- 17:32Their stars would slowly drift away into intergalactic space. But
- 17:37with dark matter present, the galaxies remain intact, spinning slowly
- 17:43through the cosmic darkness. Imagine standing far above a spiral galaxy.
- 17:49From that vantage point, you would see a beautiful disk
- 17:52of glowing stars arranged in delicate spiral arms. At the
- 17:57center lies a bright core where billions of stars cluster
- 18:01tightly together. But beyond the visible light lies something far larger,
- 18:06an enormous sphere of dark matter, invisible, silent, extending many
- 18:14times farther than the galaxy's luminous disk. Inside this vast halo,
- 18:19the galaxy's stars move like tiny sparks embedded in a
- 18:23much larger gravitational structure. It is almost as if the
- 18:27galaxy is floating inside an invisible bubble of mass. This
- 18:32invisible halo also helps explain why galaxies formed in the
- 18:36first place. In the early universe, matter was not evenly distributed.
- 18:42Small clumps of dark matter began pulling material together through gravity.
- 18:47Over time, ordinary matter gas and dust fell into these
- 18:50dark matter structures. Inside these gravitational wells, stars eventually formed.
- 18:57Galaxies were born. In this way, dark matter may have
- 19:01played a crucial role in shaping the structure of the
- 19:04cosmos from the very beginning. Without it, galaxies might not
- 19:08have formed as easily. The universe might look very different
- 19:12from the one we see today. Astronomers have now measured
- 19:16rotation curves for hundreds of galaxies, from small dwarf galaxies
- 19:21to enormous spirals like the Milky Way. And again and again,
- 19:26they find the same pattern. The stars move too quickly.
- 19:31The visible matter is not enough to explain the gravitational
- 19:34pull required to hold galaxies together. Once more, the hidden
- 19:39mass of dark matter appears to be guiding the motion
- 19:42of the cosmos. Even our own galaxy, the Milky Way,
- 19:46seems to be surrounded by such a halo. The visible
- 19:50disk of the Milky Way stretches about 100,000 light-years across,
- 19:56but the dark matter halo surrounding it may extend several
- 20:00times farther. Some estimates suggest it could reach hundreds of
- 20:04thousands of light-years into space. Within that enormous sphere lies
- 20:09most of the galaxy's mass. Yet it remains invisible. We
- 20:14detect it only through the motions of stars and satellite
- 20:17galaxies orbiting the Milky Way. They move as though they
- 20:20are responding to a gravitational presence we cannot see. And
- 20:25so the galaxy puzzle became one of the most important
- 20:28clues in modern cosmology. The strange motion of stars revealed
- 20:32that the universe contains far more matter than our eyes
- 20:36can detect. Something hidden surrounds galaxies. Something massive and silent.
- 20:43Something that shapes the structure of the universe itself. We
- 20:47call it dark matter, but its true nature remains one
- 20:51of the greatest mysteries in science. As our journey continues,
- 20:56astronomers will discover even more ways to observe the influence
- 20:59of this invisible substance. Because sometimes, dark matter reveals itself
- 21:05not through the motion of stars, but through the bending
- 21:09of light itself. And that strange phenomenon will lead us
- 21:12to another powerful clue about the hidden universe. By now,
- 21:17we have seen how the motion of stars inside galaxies
- 21:20revealed something mysterious. Stars at the outer edges of galaxies
- 21:24move far too quickly. Galaxies themselves behave as if they
- 21:28contain far more mass than we can see. But astronomers
- 21:32did not stop there. If dark matter truly exists, if
- 21:36enormous halos of invisible mass surround galaxies, then its gravitational
- 21:41influence should appear in other ways as well. And one
- 21:44of the most beautiful clues appears not in the motion
- 21:47of stars, but in the way light itself travels through space.
- 21:53According to Einstein's theory of general relativity, gravity does not
- 21:58simply pull objects together. Instead, Massive objects bend the fabric
- 22:03of space and time. You can imagine space like a
- 22:07stretched sheet. If a heavy ball is placed on the sheet,
- 22:11it creates a dip in the surface. Smaller objects rolling
- 22:15nearby will curve toward that dip. In the universe, massive objects, stars, galaxies,
- 22:22and clusters of galaxies create similar distortions in the structure
- 22:26of space itself. And when light passes through those distortions,
- 22:31its path bends. This phenomenon is known as gravitational lensing. Normally,
- 22:38light travels in straight lines. But when it passes near
- 22:42a massive object, the curvature of space causes it to
- 22:45follow a curved path instead. In some cases, this bending
- 22:50can act like a cosmic lens. Light from distant galaxies
- 22:54can be magnified, stretched, or even duplicated as it passes
- 22:59through the gravitational field of another massive object. To observers
- 23:04on Earth, the distant galaxy may appear distorted into arcs
- 23:08or rings. Sometimes multiple images of the same galaxy appear
- 23:12in slightly different positions, all because gravity has bent the
- 23:16path of the light along its journey. It is as
- 23:19if the universe itself contains giant natural telescopes. Gravitational lensing
- 23:25provides astronomers with a powerful tool, because the amount of
- 23:29bending depends on the mass of the object causing the distortion.
- 23:34By carefully measuring how light is bent, scientists can estimate
- 23:38how much mass is present even if that mass is invisible.
- 23:41And when astronomers began applying this technique to galaxy clusters,
- 23:45they discovered something remarkable. The visible galaxies and gas inside
- 23:50the cluster did not contain nearly enough mass to produce
- 23:53the observed lensing effects. The distortions were far too strong.
- 23:59Something else had to be contributing to the gravitational pull.
- 24:02Once again, the conclusion pointed toward dark matter. Galaxy clusters
- 24:07are some of the largest gravitationally bound structures in the universe.
- 24:12Each cluster can contain hundreds or even thousands of galaxies.
- 24:17Between those galaxies lies vast amounts of hot gas glowing
- 24:20in X-ray light. This gas alone contains more mass than
- 24:24all the stars combined. But even when astronomers include the
- 24:28mass of this hot gas, the numbers still do not
- 24:31add up. The gravitational lensing, observed around many clusters, suggests
- 24:36that most of their mass is still hidden, invisible, yet
- 24:41undeniably present through its gravitational influence. One of the most
- 24:45famous examples of this phenomenon is known as the Bullet Cluster.
- 24:50This system consists of two galaxy clusters that have collided
- 24:53with one another. During the collision, the galaxies themselves mostly
- 24:58pass through each other because the distances between stars are enormous.
- 25:03But the clouds of hot gas inside the clusters slowed
- 25:06down and piled up in the center of the collision.
- 25:09This created a remarkable situation. The visible gas, which contains
- 25:15much of the ordinary matter, became separated from the regions
- 25:18where the strongest gravitational lensing was observed. In other words,
- 25:23the gravitational mass did not line up with the visible matter. Instead,
- 25:28it appeared concentrated in regions where there was little visible
- 25:31material at all. The simplest explanation was that a large
- 25:35amount of invisible mass had passed straight through the collision.
- 25:39Mass that interacts very weakly with normal matter. mass that
- 25:43behaves exactly as dark matter is expected to behave. Gravitational
- 25:48lensing also reveals the presence of dark matter halos around
- 25:52individual galaxies. When astronomers observe distant galaxies through powerful telescopes,
- 25:58they sometimes detect subtle distortions in the shapes of background galaxies.
- 26:03These distortions occur because the foreground galaxy bends the light
- 26:07travelling behind it. By analysing these tiny changes in shape,
- 26:12scientists can map the distribution of mass surrounding the galaxy.
- 26:16The results consistently show that galaxies are surrounded by enormous
- 26:20halos of unseen matter. These halos extend far beyond the
- 26:24visible stars and gas. In fact, the dark matter halo
- 26:29may contain five to ten times more mass than the
- 26:32visible galaxy itself. Imagine once again looking at a galaxy
- 26:36from afar, Its spiral arms glow softly with billions of stars.
- 26:42But beyond those luminous arms stretches a vast invisible structure.
- 26:47A halo of dark matter surrounding the galaxy like a
- 26:51faint gravitational cocoon. This halo does not emit light. It
- 26:56cannot be photographed directly. Yet its presence can be mapped
- 27:00through the bending of light and the motion of stars.
- 27:04It shapes the galaxy's structure. guides its rotation, and influences
- 27:10how it interacts with neighboring galaxies. Gravitational lensing has now
- 27:15become one of the most powerful tools in modern astronomy.
- 27:19Space telescopes such as Hubble and James Webb routinely observe
- 27:23lensing effects across the universe. Some distant galaxies appear stretched
- 27:28into long arcs. Others form nearly perfect rings known as
- 27:32Einstein rings. where light from a background galaxy is bent
- 27:36symmetrically around a massive foreground object. Each of these distortions
- 27:41tells a story about the distribution of mass in the universe.
- 27:45And time after time, that story reveals the same surprising conclusion.
- 27:51Most of the mass is invisible. Most of the universe
- 27:54is hidden. Through these delicate distortions of light, astronomers have
- 27:59begun mapping the invisible structure of the cosmos, like tracing
- 28:03the outline of something hidden beneath a sheet. The galaxies
- 28:07we see may simply be the glowing markers of a
- 28:09much larger gravitational framework, dark matter forming the scaffolding upon
- 28:15which the universe is built. And yet, despite all these clues,
- 28:19the rotation of galaxies, the motion of clusters, the bending
- 28:24of light, we still do not know exactly what dark
- 28:26matter is made of. It remains one of the deepest
- 28:30mysteries in modern science. As our quiet journey continues, we
- 28:35will begin to explore the possibilities. Because scientists have proposed
- 28:40many ideas about what dark matter might be. Some believe
- 28:44it may consist of entirely new particles. Others imagine hidden
- 28:48sectors of physics waiting to be discovered. And somewhere in
- 28:52those possibilities may lie the answer to one of the
- 28:54universe's most enduring questions. So far, we have followed the
- 28:59quiet clues scattered across the universe. Stars moving too quickly
- 29:05inside galaxies. Clusters held together by unseen mass. Light bending
- 29:11around invisible structures drifting through space. All of these observations
- 29:16point toward the same mysterious conclusion. Something massive exists throughout
- 29:22the cosmos, yet it cannot be seen. But what exactly
- 29:26is dark matter? What substance could fill the universe, shaping
- 29:30galaxies and clusters, while remaining completely invisible to our telescopes?
- 29:36To answer that question, scientists have turned to the strange
- 29:40world of particle physics, because dark matter might not be
- 29:44made of ordinary atoms like the matter we know. Instead,
- 29:48it may consist of entirely new kinds of particles, particles
- 29:52that rarely interact with the familiar matter around us. Particles
- 29:57that pass silently through the universe and through us, almost
- 30:01without leaving a trace. One of the earliest and most
- 30:05widely studied ideas involves particles known as WIMPs. The name
- 30:09stands for Weakly Interacting Massive Particles. It may sound technical,
- 30:15but the idea is actually quite simple. WIMPs would be
- 30:19particles with mass, meaning they contribute to gravity. but they
- 30:23interact only through extremely weak forces. Unlike ordinary matter, which
- 30:29interacts strongly with light and electromagnetic forces, WIMPs would mostly
- 30:34ignore these interactions. Light would pass right through them. They
- 30:39would not glow or absorb radiation. And because they interact
- 30:43so rarely with ordinary matter, detecting them would be incredibly difficult. Yet,
- 30:49if large numbers of these particles filled the universe, Their
- 30:53combined mass could easily explain the gravitational effects we observe
- 30:57in galaxies and clusters. Imagine drifting through the galaxy, surrounded
- 31:02by countless invisible particles. Trillions of them passing quietly through space.
- 31:09Even passing through your own body without you ever noticing.
- 31:12If WIMPs exist, this may be happening right now. Because
- 31:17dark matter halos surrounding galaxies would contain enormous numbers of
- 31:21these particles. they would move silently through stars, planets, and
- 31:26interstellar gas.
- 31:28Speaker 3: Invisible.
- 31:30Speaker 1: Undetectable to our senses. Yet quietly shaping the universe through
- 31:34their gravity. For decades, scientists have designed experiments to try
- 31:39to detect WIMPs directly. Some of these experiments are located
- 31:44deep underground, shielded by thick layers of rock. The reason
- 31:49for this unusual location is simple. Deep beneath the surface,
- 31:53detectors are protected from cosmic rays and other particles that
- 31:57might interfere with the measurements. In these quiet underground laboratories,
- 32:02sensitive instruments wait patiently. If a WIMP particle were to
- 32:06collide with an atom inside the detector, even very gently,
- 32:11it might produce a tiny signal, a faint flash of light,
- 32:15a small vibration in the detector material. Scientists watch carefully
- 32:20for these signals hoping to catch the rare moment when
- 32:24a dark matter particle reveals its presence. So far, no
- 32:28confirmed detection has been made. But the search continues. Another
- 32:34fascinating possibility involves particles called axions. Axions are hypothetical particles
- 32:41that were originally proposed to solve a completely different problem
- 32:44in physics. But over time, scientists realized that axions might
- 32:49also make excellent candidates for dark matter, Unlike WIMPs, axions
- 32:54would be extremely light. In fact, they might be billions
- 32:59of times lighter than an electron, yet they could still
- 33:03exist in enormous numbers throughout the universe. And if enough
- 33:07of them were present, their combined mass could account for
- 33:10the gravitational effects attributed to dark matter. One of the
- 33:14intriguing properties of axions is that they may interact with
- 33:18magnetic fields in unusual ways, Under certain conditions, an axion
- 33:24particle might convert into a photon, a particle of light.
- 33:29And that possibility has inspired a new kind of dark
- 33:32matter detector. Some experiments place powerful magnets around extremely sensitive
- 33:38instruments designed to detect faint photons. If axions are passing
- 33:43through these magnetic fields, they might occasionally transform into detectable signals.
- 33:49These experiments are incredibly delicate. Scientists must eliminate almost all
- 33:55background noise. The faintest whisper of light could hold the
- 33:59key to discovering a new particle. A third possibility involves
- 34:03particles we already know exist. These particles are called neutrinos.
- 34:10Neutrinos are tiny, nearly massless particles produced in enormous numbers
- 34:15inside stars, supernova explosions and nuclear reactions. Every second, trillions
- 34:22of neutrinos pass through your body, yet you never notice them.
- 34:27They interact so weakly with matter that they almost always
- 34:30pass straight through. For this reason, some scientists once wondered
- 34:35whether neutrinos might account for dark matter. After all, they
- 34:40are invisible and extremely abundant. But over time, researchers discovered
- 34:46that neutrinos are probably too light and move too quickly
- 34:49to explain the structures we see in the universe. Dark
- 34:53matter appears to form stable halos around galaxies and clusters. Neutrinos,
- 34:59moving at nearly the speed of light, would tend to
- 35:02spread out too evenly across space. So while neutrinos contribute
- 35:06a small amount of mass to the universe, they are
- 35:09unlikely to account for the majority of dark matter. Even so,
- 35:14Studying neutrinos has helped scientists understand the strange world of
- 35:18particles that interact only weakly with matter. And this understanding
- 35:23continues to guide the search for dark matter. Today, researchers
- 35:28explore many possible candidates. Some theories suggest entirely new families
- 35:34of particles. Others propose hidden sectors of physics that interact
- 35:39only through gravity. There may even be particles we have
- 35:42not yet imagined. The possibilities stretch as wide as the
- 35:46universe itself. What makes the mystery of dark matter so
- 35:50fascinating is that it sits at the crossroads of two
- 35:54great scientific fields. Astronomy reveals its gravitational influence across galaxies
- 36:00and clusters. Particle physics attempts to identify the particles that
- 36:05might produce that influence. Together, these disciplines are working toward
- 36:10the same goal. to uncover the nature of the invisible
- 36:14matter shaping the cosmos. And yet, for now, dark matter
- 36:19remains just beyond our reach. We see its effects everywhere,
- 36:24in the motion of galaxies, in the bending of light,
- 36:29in the structure of the cosmic web stretching across the universe.
- 36:33But the particles themselves remain hidden, like faint shadows behind
- 36:38the glowing stars. As our journey continues, we will begin
- 36:43to explore how this mysterious substance may surround every galaxy.
- 36:48Invisible halos stretching far beyond the luminous disks of stars.
- 36:54Massive structures that help hold galaxies together as they spin
- 36:57slowly through the cosmic night. And within those halos lies
- 37:02one of the most important pieces of the dark matter puzzle.
- 37:05When we look at photographs of galaxies, what we see
- 37:09is beautiful but incomplete. A spiral galaxy appears like a
- 37:13glowing pinwheel in the darkness of space. Billions of stars
- 37:17stretch outward in elegant arms, circling a bright central core.
- 37:22Clouds of gas and dust weave delicate patterns between the stars,
- 37:26sometimes forming luminous nebulae where new stars are born. But
- 37:31this shining disk of stars is only the visible portion
- 37:34of something much larger. Astronomers now believe that every galaxy
- 37:39is surrounded by an enormous halo of dark matter, a vast,
- 37:43invisible sphere that extends far beyond the galaxy's glowing edges.
- 37:48These halos cannot be seen directly. They emit no light
- 37:52and reflect none, yet their presence is revealed through the
- 37:56quiet pull of gravity. And in many cases, the halo
- 38:00contains far more mass than the stars themselves. Imagine drifting
- 38:05far above a galaxy and watching it from a distance.
- 38:10The spiral arms glow softly, slowly turning like a cosmic carousel.
- 38:16At first, it appears that the stars themselves form the
- 38:19entire structure. But if we could somehow see the dark
- 38:23matter halo surrounding the galaxy, the picture would change dramatically.
- 38:28Instead of a flat disk floating in empty space, the
- 38:33galaxy would appear embedded within a huge spherical cloud of
- 38:37invisible mass. This halo might extend several times farther than
- 38:42the visible galaxy. While the bright disk of stars may
- 38:45stretch 100,000 light years across, the dark matter halo could
- 38:50reach three or four times that distance. The galaxy we
- 38:53see is simply the luminous center of a much larger
- 38:57gravitational structure. These halos help explain many of the puzzles
- 39:02astronomers have encountered. Earlier, we spoke about how stars near
- 39:06the edges of galaxies move too quickly to be held
- 39:09by visible matter alone. The dark matter halo provides the
- 39:13extra gravity needed to keep those stars in orbit. Without it,
- 39:18the outer regions of galaxies might slowly unravel. Stars would
- 39:22drift away into intergalactic space. But with the halo present,
- 39:27the galaxy remains stable. the invisible. mass surrounding it gently
- 39:31guides the motion of billions of stars. Dark matter halos
- 39:36may also influence the shape of galaxies. Galaxies are not
- 39:40all the same. Some form elegant spirals like the Milky Way.
- 39:45Others appear as smooth ellipses, Some are small dwarf galaxies
- 39:50containing only a few billion stars, while others are enormous
- 39:53systems with hundreds of billions. The structure of each galaxy
- 39:58is shaped by the distribution of matter within it, and
- 40:01dark matter halos play a major role in that distribution.
- 40:06As ordinary gas falls into the gravitational well created by
- 40:09dark matter, it begins to cool and condense. Over time,
- 40:14that gas forms stars, Those stars gather into rotating disks, clusters,
- 40:21and bulges. In this way, the invisible halo acts like
- 40:25a kind of cosmic framework. Ordinary matter settles into this framework,
- 40:31creating the galaxies we observe. In the early universe, this
- 40:36process was especially important. Shortly after the Big Bang, matter
- 40:41was spread almost evenly across space. Tiny fluctuations in density
- 40:46gradually grew as gravity pulled matter together. Dark matter may
- 40:51have been the first substance to form these gravitational clumps.
- 40:55Because it interacts very weakly with radiation, it could begin
- 40:59gathering long before ordinary matter cooled enough to form stars.
- 41:04Over time, these clumps grew into larger and larger halos.
- 41:09Gas fell into them, stars formed, galaxies emerged. In this way,
- 41:16dark matter may have acted as the scaffolding of the universe,
- 41:19guiding the formation of the first cosmic structures. Astronomers have
- 41:24developed sophisticated computer simulations to study how dark matter halos evolve.
- 41:30In these simulations, billions of particles representing dark matter interact
- 41:35through gravity. Over time, they form complex structures that resemble
- 41:40the cosmic web observed across the universe. Within that web,
- 41:45Halos grow and merge. Small halos combine to form larger ones.
- 41:51Galaxies form within them. Clusters of galaxies gather at the
- 41:55intersections of massive filaments of dark matter. When scientists compare
- 42:00these simulations with observations of real galaxies, the results are
- 42:05strikingly similar. The patterns match. The structures align. It is
- 42:11as though the invisible matter predicted by the models truly
- 42:14exists shaping the architecture of the cosmos. Dark matter halos
- 42:20are not smooth, uniform spheres. They are thought to contain
- 42:24smaller clumps known as subhalos. These substructures may host smaller
- 42:29galaxies often called dwarf galaxies that orbit larger systems like satellites.
- 42:35The Milky Way itself is surrounded by many such companions.
- 42:39Tiny galaxies drifting quietly through the halo Some contain only
- 42:44a few million stars. Others are even fainter. Yet their
- 42:49motions reveal that they are embedded within the same invisible
- 42:53gravitational environment. Each satellite galaxy traces the contours of the
- 42:58Milky Way's dark matter halo. Even galaxy clusters, the largest
- 43:03gravitationally bound systems in the universe, possess enormous dark matter halos.
- 43:10In these clusters, the halos become immense. They extend millions
- 43:14of light years across space. Galaxies orbit within them like
- 43:19small islands floating in a vast ocean of invisible mass.
- 43:23Hot gas fills the space between galaxies, glowing faintly in
- 43:27X-ray light. But most of the cluster's mass remains unseen.
- 43:32Dark matter dominates the gravitational landscape. Sometimes astronomers can even
- 43:38map these halos indirectly. Using gravitational lensing, They measure how
- 43:43the halo bends the light of more distant galaxies. By
- 43:48studying these distortions carefully, scientists can reconstruct the distribution of
- 43:53mass surrounding the cluster. The result often reveals intricate patterns
- 43:57of dark matter stretching across the cluster like an invisible map.
- 44:02A map drawn not in light, but in gravity. All
- 44:06of this evidence points toward a remarkable idea. The universe
- 44:10may be filled with structures we cannot see, Galaxies are
- 44:14not isolated islands of stars. They are luminous markers embedded
- 44:19within vast halos of dark matter. Clusters of galaxies float
- 44:23inside even larger structures. And all of these systems connect
- 44:28through the immense cosmic web that stretches across billions of
- 44:32light years. The visible universe, the stars and galaxies we photograph,
- 44:37is only the glowing surface of something much deeper. Beneath
- 44:41that surface lies an invisible architecture shaping the cosmos. And yet,
- 44:47despite the growing evidence, one profound mystery remains. We still
- 44:53do not know what dark matter is made of. We
- 44:56see its influence everywhere. But the particles themselves remain hidden.
- 45:01Somewhere in the depths of space, or perhaps even passing
- 45:05quietly through the Earth right now, those particles may be
- 45:09waiting to be discovered. As our journey continues, we will
- 45:13explore how scientists are searching for them. Because around the world,
- 45:18researchers have built experiments designed to detect the faintest whisper
- 45:22of dark matter itself. And those experiments are listening carefully
- 45:27in the deepest, quietest places on Earth. If we could
- 45:31travel far enough away from the Milky Way, far beyond
- 45:35the stars of our galaxy, and look back at the
- 45:37universe from an unimaginable distance, the cosmos would reveal a
- 45:42structure that is both beautiful and surprising. At first, we
- 45:47might imagine galaxies scattered randomly through space, tiny islands of
- 45:52stars drifting in every direction. But that is not what
- 45:55astronomers observe. When scientists map the positions of millions of
- 46:00galaxies across the universe, a pattern begins to emerge. A
- 46:05vast network. A delicate structure stretching across billions of light-years.
- 46:11This immense arrangement is known as the cosmic web. In
- 46:15this web-like structure, galaxies gather along enormous strands called filaments.
- 46:21These filaments stretch across space like threads of glowing silk.
- 46:25Where several filaments intersect, massive clusters of galaxies form. And
- 46:31between these filaments lie enormous empty regions known as cosmic voids.
- 46:36Vast spaces where very few galaxies exist at all. If
- 46:40we could see the universe from far away, the pattern
- 46:43might resemble a sponge, or perhaps a network of rivers
- 46:47and tributaries spreading across the darkness. The luminous galaxies we
- 46:52see are simply the bright nodes along these filaments. But
- 46:56the true structure of the web extends far beyond what
- 46:59our eyes can detect. Dark matter is believed to form
- 47:02the invisible framework of this cosmic web. In the earliest
- 47:06moments of the universe, tiny fluctuations in density began to grow.
- 47:11Gravity slowly pulled matter toward the slightly denser regions. Over
- 47:16millions of years, those small irregularities became larger structures. Dark matter,
- 47:23interacting mainly through gravity, began gathering into vast filaments and halos.
- 47:29Ordinary matter, gas, and dust followed this gravitational blueprint. As
- 47:34gas flowed into the densest regions of the web, It
- 47:37cooled and condensed. Stars formed. Galaxies appeared. In this way,
- 47:44dark matter may have acted as the architect of the
- 47:46large-scale universe. The galaxies we see today formed along the
- 47:51invisible scaffolding created by dark matter. Computer simulations of the
- 47:56universe offer remarkable glimpses into how this process might have unfolded.
- 48:01In these simulations, scientists model billions of particles representing dark matter.
- 48:07As the simulation evolves, gravity pulls the particles together. Over time,
- 48:13the particles arrange themselves into complex structures that strongly resemble
- 48:18the cosmic web observed by astronomers. Filaments stretch across vast distances,
- 48:25clusters form where filaments intersect, and enormous voids open between them.
- 48:30When researchers compare these simulated maps with real observations of
- 48:34galaxy distributions, the similarities are striking. It is as though
- 48:39the dark matter blueprint, predicted by theory, matches the structure
- 48:44of the real universe. These filaments are truly immense. Some
- 48:50stretch across hundreds of millions of light years. Galaxies drift
- 48:54slowly along them, pulled by the gravitational currents of dark matter.
- 48:59Clusters grow larger as matter flows inward along the filaments.
- 49:04like water moving through channels toward a lake. Even our
- 49:07own Milky Way galaxy is part of this cosmic web.
- 49:11We reside in a region of the universe known as
- 49:13the Laniakea Supercluster, a vast structure containing tens of thousands
- 49:19of galaxies connected by these invisible gravitational threads. Our galaxy
- 49:24drifts quietly within this enormous network, one small node in
- 49:28a structure that spans the observable universe. Although dark matter
- 49:33itself cannot be seen, astronomers have found indirect ways to
- 49:37trace the cosmic web. One method involves studying faint clouds
- 49:42of hydrogen gas that lie between galaxies. When light from
- 49:45distant quasars passes through this gas, it leaves subtle fingerprints
- 49:50in the spectrum of the light. By analysing these patterns,
- 49:54scientists can map the distribution of matter across large regions
- 49:57of space. These maps reveal the same filamentary structures predicted
- 50:02by simulations. The glowing galaxies appear to trace the outlines
- 50:07of a much larger invisible network. like dew droplets clinging
- 50:11to the threads of a spider's web. Another technique involves
- 50:16gravitational lensing. Just as dark matter halos around galaxies bend light,
- 50:22the massive filaments of the cosmic web can also distort
- 50:25the light of distant galaxies. By carefully measuring these distortions,
- 50:30astronomers can infer where large concentrations of dark matter must exist.
- 50:35The results again point toward an enormous interconnected network. An
- 50:40invisible structure binding the universe together. What makes the cosmic
- 50:45web especially fascinating is its scale. Individual galaxies may span
- 50:50tens or hundreds of thousands of light years, but the
- 50:54cosmic web extends across billions of light years. It is
- 50:58the largest structure known in the universe. Yet even this
- 51:02vast network continues evolving. Galaxies slowly drift along the filaments.
- 51:08Clusters grow larger as they gather surrounding matter, and the
- 51:12cosmic voids between filaments gradually expand. Over billions of years,
- 51:18the web slowly changes shape, a slow cosmic dance unfolding
- 51:23across unimaginable distances. Dark matter plays a crucial role in
- 51:29maintaining this structure. Because dark matter interacts primarily through gravity,
- 51:34it remains stable over immense periods of time, It forms
- 51:38the gravitational backbone that keeps the cosmic web intact. Ordinary matter,
- 51:43the stars and galaxies we observe, simply traces the outlines
- 51:48of this hidden framework. In this sense, dark matter may
- 51:52be the true skeleton of the universe, invisible yet essential.
- 51:58Without it, the large-scale structure of the cosmos might look
- 52:01entirely different. Galaxies might never have gathered into the patterns
- 52:06we see today. And so, once again, we encounter the
- 52:10same remarkable idea. The universe we can see is only
- 52:14part of the story. The glowing galaxies and stars are
- 52:18merely the visible threads in a much larger tapestry. Beneath
- 52:22them lies an invisible structure woven from dark matter. A
- 52:26cosmic web stretching across the universe, guiding the formation of galaxies,
- 52:33shaping the architecture of the cosmos. and reminding us that
- 52:37even the largest structures in existence may be built upon
- 52:40something we cannot yet fully understand. As our quiet journey continues,
- 52:45we will turn our attention to the scientists searching for
- 52:48the particles that might make up dark matter. Because while
- 52:52astronomers map the cosmic web across the universe, physicists here
- 52:56on Earth are building experiments designed to detect the invisible
- 52:59particles themselves. Deep underground, In the quietest laboratories imaginable, instruments
- 53:07are listening for the faintest whispers of the dark universe.
- 53:11By now, the clues pointing toward dark matter are scattered
- 53:15everywhere across the cosmos. Galaxies spin as though invisible halos
- 53:20surround them. Clusters of galaxies bend light more strongly than
- 53:25visible matter can explain. The vast cosmic web stretches across
- 53:29the universe, guided by hidden gravitational structures, And yet, despite
- 53:35all of this evidence, one important piece of the puzzle
- 53:38remains missing. No one has ever directly detected a particle
- 53:43of dark matter. Astronomers can see its influence through gravity,
- 53:48but the particles themselves remain hidden. So scientists have begun
- 53:52searching for them in a different way. Instead of looking
- 53:55only into the sky, they have built experiments here on
- 53:58Earth quiet laboratories designed to detect the faintest whisper of
- 54:03invisible particles passing through our planet. If dark matter exists
- 54:08as particles drifting through space, then our galaxy should be
- 54:11filled with them. The Milky Way's dark matter halo surrounds
- 54:15our galaxy like a vast invisible ocean. And because the
- 54:19Earth orbits within that halo, we are constantly moving through it.
- 54:24This means that dark matter particles may be passing through
- 54:27the Earth right now, passing through the atmosphere, through the
- 54:31ground beneath our feet, even through our bodies. But because
- 54:36dark matter interacts so weakly with ordinary matter, these particles
- 54:40rarely leave any trace of their passage. Detecting them requires
- 54:45instruments of extraordinary sensitivity. To build such detectors, scientists must
- 54:51first eliminate as much background noise as possible. Cosmic rays
- 54:55constantly bombard the Earth's surface. Particles from space collide with
- 55:00the atmosphere and produce showers of energetic radiation. These signals
- 55:05could easily overwhelm the delicate measurements needed to detect dark matter.
- 55:11So many dark matter experiments are built deep underground, hundreds
- 55:15or even thousands of meters beneath the surface. The thick
- 55:19layers of rock above act as a natural shield, blocking
- 55:23most cosmic radiations. In these quiet underground environments, detectors can
- 55:28listen more carefully for rare interactions. One such experiment might
- 55:32be located inside an abandoned mine or deep within a mountain.
- 55:37In these silent chambers, enormous tanks filled with ultra-pure materials
- 55:42wait patiently. Some detectors use liquid xenon, a dense noble
- 55:47gas cooled into liquid form. Others use crystals of germanium
- 55:51or silicon. The idea is simple. If a dark matter
- 55:55particle passes through the detector and collides with an atom,
- 55:59it might transfer a tiny amount of energy. That energy
- 56:03could produce a faint flash of light or a small
- 56:06electrical signal. Sensitive instruments monitor the detector continuously, searching for
- 56:12these rare events. Even a single confirmed signal could be
- 56:16a historic discovery. These experiments must operate with extraordinary precision.
- 56:23The materials used in the detectors must be extremely pure,
- 56:27free from natural radioactive contaminants. Even a tiny amount of
- 56:32radiation from the surrounding environment could produce signals that mimic
- 56:36the effect of dark matter. Scientists carefully select materials, filter
- 56:42the air, and design elaborate shielding systems. In some laboratories,
- 56:47the detectors sit inside water tanks or layers of lead
- 56:50designed to block stray radiation. The goal is to create
- 56:54one of the quietest environments on Earth, a place where
- 56:58even the smallest signal might be noticed. So far, these
- 57:02experiments have not produced a definitive detection, but they have
- 57:07dramatically improved our understanding of what dark matter cannot be.
- 57:11Each new generation of detectors becomes more sensitive than the last.
- 57:16They rule out certain possibilities while narrowing the range of
- 57:19particle masses and interaction strengths that dark matter might have.
- 57:24In science, sometimes discovering what something is not is just
- 57:28as important as discovering what it is. While underground experiments
- 57:32listen quietly for dark matter particles drifting through Earth, another
- 57:37search is taking place in powerful particle accelerators. One of
- 57:41the most famous of these machines is the Large Hadron Collider,
- 57:45or LHC, Located beneath the border between France and Switzerland,
- 57:50the LHC is the largest and most powerful particle accelerator
- 57:55ever built. Inside a circular tunnel nearly 27 kilometers in circumference,
- 58:01protons are accelerated to extraordinary speeds, approaching the speed of light.
- 58:07These protons are then collided head-on inside massive detectors. The
- 58:13energy released in these collisions briefly recreates conditions similar to
- 58:17those that existed just after the Big Bang. Physicists hope
- 58:21that these high-energy collisions might produce new particles. Particles that
- 58:26have never been observed before. If dark matter consists of
- 58:30previously unknown particles, the LHC might be capable of creating them.
- 58:35But detecting such particles is not straightforward. Dark matter particles
- 58:40would likely interact very weakly with the detectors. In many cases,
- 58:44they might escape the detector entirely without leaving a direct trace. Instead,
- 58:50scientists look for missing energy. If a collision produces particles
- 58:54that carry away energy without interacting with the detector, that
- 58:59missing energy might suggest the presence of dark matter. Another
- 59:03approach involves looking for indirect signals of dark matter. If
- 59:07dark matter particles occasionally collide with one another in space,
- 59:11they might produce other particles that telescopes can detect. For example,
- 59:16collisions between dark matter particles might generate gamma rays or
- 59:20other high-energy radiation. Astronomers search for these signals in regions
- 59:25where dark matter is expected to be abundant, such as
- 59:28the centers of galaxies. These observations are incredibly challenging, because
- 59:33many other processes can also produce similar radiation. But by
- 59:38studying the patterns carefully, scientists hope to find subtle clues
- 59:42pointing toward the nature of dark matter. All of these
- 59:46efforts underground detectors, particle accelerators, and astronomical observations are part
- 59:52of a global search. Thousands of scientists across the world
- 59:56are working together to solve one of the greatest mysteries
- 59:59in modern physics. What is the invisible matter that shapes
- 1:00:03the universe? What particles fill the vast halos surrounding galaxies?
- 1:00:09And why do these particles interact so weakly with everything
- 1:00:12we know? For now, the answer remains just out of reach.
- 1:00:17The detectors continue listening quietly beneath mountains and mines. The
- 1:00:22particle accelerators continue smashing protons together at incredible energies, and
- 1:00:28telescopes continue scanning the heavens for subtle hints of the
- 1:00:32dark universe. Each experiment brings us a little closer to
- 1:00:36understanding the invisible side of the cosmos. As our journey continues,
- 1:00:41we will explore how scientists use powerful computer simulations to
- 1:00:45understand how dark matter shapes the formation of galaxies and
- 1:00:48the cosmic web. Because even when we cannot see dark
- 1:00:52matter directly, its influence can still be modeled. And through
- 1:00:56those simulations, we may glimpse the hidden architecture of the
- 1:01:00universe itself. Even though dark matter cannot be seen directly,
- 1:01:05scientists have found a remarkable way to study it. They
- 1:01:08build entire universes inside computers. These digital universes begin with
- 1:01:14simple ingredients. Particles representing dark matter, laws of gravity based
- 1:01:20on Einstein's equations, and the conditions believed to exist shortly
- 1:01:24after the Big Bang. From there, the simulation begins. Tiny
- 1:01:30fluctuations in density appear across a virtual cosmos. Gravity slowly
- 1:01:35pulls particles together. And over time, millions, then billions of
- 1:01:40simulated years, the universe begins to take shape. Clusters form.
- 1:01:46Filaments stretch across vast distances. Galaxies gather at the intersections
- 1:01:51of the cosmic web, all guided by the invisible pull
- 1:01:55of dark matter. These simulations are not simple animations. They
- 1:02:00are complex scientific experiments performed inside powerful supercomputers. Each particle
- 1:02:07in the simulation represents a large amount of dark matter,
- 1:02:11sometimes millions. Sometimes billions of particles attract at once. At
- 1:02:17every moment, the computer calculates how gravity pulls each particle
- 1:02:21toward all the others. These calculations must be repeated again
- 1:02:26and again as the simulated universe evolves. The result is
- 1:02:31an incredibly detailed model of cosmic structure, one that allows
- 1:02:35scientists to explore how the universe might have grown over
- 1:02:39billions of years. One of the most famous simulations is
- 1:02:42known as the Millennium Simulation. In this project, researchers used
- 1:02:47a massive supercomputer to simulate the evolution of the universe
- 1:02:51across more than 13 billion years. The simulation tracked billions
- 1:02:57of dark matter particles as they formed halos, clusters, and filaments.
- 1:03:02When scientists visualized the results, something extraordinary appeared. The simulated
- 1:03:08universe looked strikingly similar to the real one. The same
- 1:03:12web-like structures emerged. The same clusters formed at the intersections
- 1:03:17of filaments. Even the distribution of galaxies resembled the patterns
- 1:03:22astronomers observe in the night sky. It was as though
- 1:03:26the invisible architecture of the cosmos had been revealed through mathematics.
- 1:03:31But simulations can do more than simply reproduce what we see.
- 1:03:35They allow scientists to explore how galaxies might form within
- 1:03:39dark matter halos. In the early universe, clouds of gas
- 1:03:44were drawn into these halos by gravity. As the gas cooled,
- 1:03:48it began to collapse into rotating disks. Inside those disks,
- 1:03:53stars ignited. Over millions of years, those stars gathered into
- 1:03:59the galaxies we observe today. By adjusting the physical conditions
- 1:04:03in simulations such as the strength of gravity or the
- 1:04:06properties of dark matter particles, scientists can study how these
- 1:04:10changes affect galaxy formation. If the results no longer match
- 1:04:15the real universe, the model must be adjusted. In this way,
- 1:04:19simulations become powerful tools for testing cosmological theories. Many modern
- 1:04:25simulations also include the effects of ordinary matter. Gas flows
- 1:04:30through the cosmic web Supernova explosions release energy into surrounding regions.
- 1:04:37Black holes at the centers of galaxies generate powerful jets
- 1:04:40that influence star formation. These processes interact with the dark
- 1:04:45matter framework, shaping the final appearance of galaxies. The simulations
- 1:04:50must carefully balance all of these effects. Too much energy
- 1:04:54from supernovae and galaxies may fail to form properly. Too
- 1:04:59little and galaxies become unrealistically massive. By comparing simulated galaxies
- 1:05:06with real observations, scientists refine their understanding of how the
- 1:05:10universe evolves. One of the most fascinating insights from these
- 1:05:15simulations is the idea that galaxies grow through a process
- 1:05:18of cosmic merging. Small dark matter halos form first. Over time,
- 1:05:24gravity pulls them together. They merge into larger halos. The
- 1:05:29galaxies inside them collide and combine as well. This process
- 1:05:33continues across billions of years, gradually building larger and more
- 1:05:38complex structures. Our own Milky Way galaxy likely grew this way.
- 1:05:44Over its long history, it may have absorbed many smaller
- 1:05:47galaxies drifting through the cosmic web. The faint stellar streams
- 1:05:52observed around the Milky Way today may be the remnants
- 1:05:55of those ancient mergers. Simulations also reveal how dark matter
- 1:06:00halos surround galaxies in complex shapes. Rather than perfect spheres,
- 1:06:06many halos appear slightly stretched or irregular. They contain smaller subhalos,
- 1:06:12tiny clumps of dark matter orbiting within the larger halo.
- 1:06:16Some of these subhalos host dwarf galaxies. Others remain dark,
- 1:06:21containing very few stars at all. These invisible structures may
- 1:06:25still influence the motion of stars and gas within larger galaxies.
- 1:06:30Astronomers continue searching for evidence of these hidden substructures through
- 1:06:34careful observations. Another important role of simulations is predicting how
- 1:06:40the universe should appear when observed through telescopes. By generating
- 1:06:44virtual galaxies and clusters, scientists can compare them directly with
- 1:06:49real astronomical surveys. Large sky surveys such as those conducted
- 1:06:54by modern observatories map millions of galaxies across enormous regions
- 1:06:59of space. When these maps are compared with simulated universes
- 1:07:04researchers can test whether the models accurately describe reality. So
- 1:07:09far the presence of dark matter provides one of the
- 1:07:13best explanations for the patterns observed in these surveys. Without
- 1:07:17dark matter the simulated universe fails to produce the structures
- 1:07:22we see. Galaxies do not cluster correctly, the cosmic web
- 1:07:27becomes far less pronounced, and the distribution of matter no
- 1:07:31longer matches observations. In this way, computer simulations act like
- 1:07:36a bridge between theory and observation. They allow scientists to
- 1:07:41explore the hidden forces shaping the universe. They provide a
- 1:07:45way to test ideas that cannot yet be examined directly.
- 1:07:49And they reveal how invisible matter might sculpt the grand
- 1:07:53structure of the cosmos. The universe inside the computer becomes
- 1:07:58a laboratory where astronomers can experiment with cosmic history. Despite
- 1:08:03their sophistication, these simulations still rely on assumptions about the
- 1:08:07nature of dark matter. Scientists must choose how dark matter behaves.
- 1:08:13Does it interact only through gravity? Does it have additional forces?
- 1:08:18Does it consist of heavy particles or extremely light ones?
- 1:08:23Each possibility produces slightly different cosmic structures. By comparing these
- 1:08:28models with observations, researchers slowly narrow the range of possibilities.
- 1:08:34The hope is that one day, the simulations will match
- 1:08:38reality so closely that the true nature of dark matter
- 1:08:42becomes clear. For now, these digital universes offer a fascinating
- 1:08:47glimpse into the invisible side of the cosmos. They show
- 1:08:50us how dark matter may weave the cosmic web, how
- 1:08:54galaxies might grow within hidden halos, and how the universe
- 1:08:58itself evolves around it. across billions of years. Even when
- 1:09:02we cannot see dark matter directly, we can still explore
- 1:09:06its influence through the language of mathematics and computation. As
- 1:09:10our quiet journey continues, we will turn our attention to
- 1:09:13some of the more unusual ideas scientists have proposed about
- 1:09:17dark matter. Because while many theories focus on new particles
- 1:09:22like WIMPs or axions, others suggest that our understanding of
- 1:09:26gravity itself might need to change. And those possibilities open
- 1:09:30the door to some of the most intriguing questions in
- 1:09:33modern physics. So far in our journey, dark matter has
- 1:09:37appeared as a quiet but powerful presence in the universe.
- 1:09:41It shapes galaxies. It bends light. It forms the invisible
- 1:09:47scaffolding of the cosmic web. But despite decades of research,
- 1:09:51scientists still do not know exactly what dark matter is
- 1:09:55made of. And whenever a mystery remains unsolved for this long,
- 1:09:59scientists begin exploring many different possibilities. Some ideas follow the
- 1:10:04path of particle physics, searching for entirely new particles. But
- 1:10:09others ask a deeper question. What if the mystery is
- 1:10:12not hidden matter at all? What if the laws of
- 1:10:15gravity themselves behave differently on cosmic scales? This idea leads
- 1:10:20to one of the most intriguing alternatives to dark matter,
- 1:10:24a concept known as modified gravity. According to our current understanding,
- 1:10:30gravity follows the rules described by Newton and later refined
- 1:10:34by Einstein. These theories have been incredibly successful. They explain
- 1:10:39the motion of planets, the bending of light around stars,
- 1:10:43and the expansion of the universe. But some scientists wonder
- 1:10:47whether these laws might change slightly under certain conditions, especially
- 1:10:52when dealing with extremely large distances or extremely weak gravitational fields.
- 1:10:59One proposed theory is called MOND, which stands for Modified
- 1:11:03Newtonian Dynamics. MOND suggests that gravity may become stronger than
- 1:11:08expected when the gravitational pull becomes very weak, such as
- 1:11:12in the outer regions of galaxies. If this is true,
- 1:11:16then the stars moving quickly at the edges of galaxies
- 1:11:19might not require invisible matter after all. Instead, gravity itself
- 1:11:25might behave differently than we once thought. Mond has had
- 1:11:28some success in explaining the rotation of galaxies. In some cases,
- 1:11:33the theory predicts star motions quite accurately without requiring dark
- 1:11:38matter halos. But Mond also faces challenges. When astronomers study
- 1:11:43galaxy clusters and gravitational lensing, the modified gravity models often
- 1:11:48struggle to explain all the observations. This has led many
- 1:11:52scientists to believe that dark matter still provides a more
- 1:11:55complete explanation. Yet the idea remains fascinating. It reminds us
- 1:12:01that even the fundamental laws of physics may still hold surprises.
- 1:12:05Another intriguing possibility is the existence of something known as
- 1:12:09the dark sector. If dark matter consists of new particles,
- 1:12:14those particles might not exist alone. Just as ordinary matter
- 1:12:19includes many different particles, electrons, protons, neutrons and more, the
- 1:12:24dark universe might contain an entire hidden family of particles
- 1:12:29interacting with one another. Some scientists imagine that dark matter
- 1:12:33particles could interact through forces that are invisible to us.
- 1:12:38Perhaps there are dark equivalents of photons, mediating interactions between
- 1:12:43dark particles. Perhaps dark atoms and dark radiation exist in
- 1:12:47parallel with the ordinary matter we know. This hypothetical realm
- 1:12:52is sometimes called the dark sector. It would be a
- 1:12:55shadow universe overlapping our own, interacting only weakly with ordinary matter.
- 1:13:01Most of its activity would remain invisible to our instruments,
- 1:13:06but its gravitational influence would still shape the cosmos. If
- 1:13:10such a dark sector exists, the universe might be far
- 1:13:14more complex than we currently imagine. Entire processes could unfold
- 1:13:19within the dark sector structures forming, particles interacting without producing
- 1:13:23light or radiation that we can detect. From our perspective,
- 1:13:28these events would remain hidden, yet their combined mass would
- 1:13:32still influence the motion of galaxies and the growth of
- 1:13:35cosmic structures. In a way, the universe might contain layers
- 1:13:40of reality. the visible universe we observe with telescopes, and
- 1:13:45a hidden universe made of particles we have yet to discover.
- 1:13:49Some theories even propose the existence of exotic particles beyond
- 1:13:53the familiar categories studied in particle physics. These particles could
- 1:13:57have unusual properties. Some might be extremely heavy, interacting only
- 1:14:03through gravity. Others might be incredibly light, forming wave-like structures
- 1:14:08across galaxies. In certain models dark matter could behave almost
- 1:14:13like a cosmic fluid. In others it might form clumps
- 1:14:18or vortices on enormous scales. Each possibility leads to slightly
- 1:14:23different predictions about how galaxies form and evolve. By comparing
- 1:14:27these predictions with astronomical observations scientists attempt to narrow the
- 1:14:32field of possibilities. One particularly unusual idea involves something called
- 1:14:37ultralight dark matter. In this model Dark matter particles are
- 1:14:42so incredibly light that their quantum properties become important on
- 1:14:47galactic scales. Instead of behaving like individual particles, they may
- 1:14:52act more like waves spread across vast distances. These waves
- 1:14:56could form gentle interference patterns, influencing how stars move within galaxies.
- 1:15:03Such models might explain certain features observed in the distribution
- 1:15:07of stars in dwarf galaxies. Though still speculative, they offer
- 1:15:12a reminder that the universe may operate in ways far
- 1:15:15stranger than our everyday experience suggests. Another possibility involves particles
- 1:15:20that interact through entirely new forces. Just as the electromagnetic
- 1:15:25force governs interactions between charged particles, dark matter might experience
- 1:15:30its own unique force. This force would not affect ordinary matter.
- 1:15:35It would operate only within the dark sector. If such
- 1:15:39forces exist, they might influence how dark matter clumps together
- 1:15:43or spreads across the universe. Detecting these effects would be
- 1:15:48extremely challenging, but subtle patterns in galaxy formation might provide clues.
- 1:15:54Despite the many theories, scientists remain cautious. The mystery of
- 1:15:59dark matter sits at the frontier of modern physics. Each
- 1:16:03idea must be carefully tested against observations. Some models will
- 1:16:08eventually be ruled out, others may gain stronger support, and
- 1:16:12perhaps somewhere among these possibilities lies the true explanation. The
- 1:16:18invisible substance shaping galaxies might turn out to be a
- 1:16:22new particle, or a hidden sector of physics, or even
- 1:16:26a subtle modification of gravity itself. For now, the dark
- 1:16:31universe remains largely unexplored, But that uncertainty is part of
- 1:16:36what makes the search so exciting. Science moves forward not
- 1:16:41only through answers, but through questions. Each observation opens the
- 1:16:46door to new possibilities. Each theory invites deeper investigation. And
- 1:16:52with every experiment and telescope observation, we move a little
- 1:16:57closer to understanding the hidden side of the cosmos. As
- 1:17:00we approach the final part of our journey tonight, we
- 1:17:04will turn our thoughts toward the future. Because new telescopes,
- 1:17:08new detectors, and new experiments are already being built. These
- 1:17:13instruments may soon reveal clues that have remained hidden until now.
- 1:17:18And somewhere in the quiet darkness between the stars, the
- 1:17:22true nature of dark matter may finally begin to emerge.
- 1:17:26Even after decades of research, dark matter remains one of
- 1:17:29the greatest mysteries in modern science. we have seen its
- 1:17:33influence across the universe, in the spinning motion of galaxies,
- 1:17:39in the bending of light through gravitational lensing, in the
- 1:17:43delicate threads of the cosmic web stretching across billions of
- 1:17:46light years. And yet, the particles responsible for all of
- 1:17:51this remain unseen. But the search is far from over.
- 1:17:56In fact, The coming decades may be the most exciting
- 1:18:00period yet in humanity's effort to understand the invisible universe.
- 1:18:04Because new telescopes, new detectors and new experiments are being built,
- 1:18:10each designed to reveal more about the hidden structure of
- 1:18:13the cosmos. One of the most powerful tools in this
- 1:18:16search will be the next generation of space telescopes. Observatories
- 1:18:21such as the Nancy Grace Roman Space Telescope are being
- 1:18:24designed to map the universe with extraordinary precision. By observing
- 1:18:29millions of galaxies across vast regions of space, these telescopes
- 1:18:34will measure subtle distortions caused by gravitational lensing. Through these measurements,
- 1:18:40scientists can create detailed maps of dark matter across enormous
- 1:18:44areas of the sky. These maps may reveal how dark
- 1:18:48matter clusters around galaxies, how it flows through the cosmic web,
- 1:18:52and how it influences the growth of cosmic structures over
- 1:18:56billions of years. In essence, astronomers will be able to
- 1:19:00trace the invisible architecture of the universe with unprecedented clarity.
- 1:19:06At the same time, New ground-based observatories are also preparing
- 1:19:10to survey the sky in remarkable detail. The Vera C.
- 1:19:14Rubin Observatory, for example, will conduct one of the most
- 1:19:18ambitious sky surveys ever attempted. Over the course of 10 years,
- 1:19:23this telescope will repeatedly scan the entire southern sky. It
- 1:19:28will capture billions of galaxies and track how they move
- 1:19:32and change over time. Among the many discoveries expected from
- 1:19:36this project are improved measurements of dark matter's distribution throughout
- 1:19:40the universe. By studying the shapes of galaxies and the
- 1:19:44subtle bending of their light, scientists can infer where dark
- 1:19:47matter must be concentrated. Slowly, piece by piece, the invisible
- 1:19:53map of the cosmos will become clearer. While telescopes look
- 1:19:57outward into the depth of space, Experiments on Earth continue
- 1:20:01their quiet search for dark matter particles. Underground detectors are
- 1:20:06growing larger and more sensitive with each new generation. Some
- 1:20:10experiments now contain several tons of liquid xenon, carefully shielded
- 1:20:15deep beneath mountains or mines. These detectors wait patiently for
- 1:20:19the faint signal of a dark matter particle colliding with
- 1:20:23an atom. Even a single confirmed interaction could change our
- 1:20:27understanding of the universe. The moment when such a signal
- 1:20:31is finally observed would mark one of the most important
- 1:20:34discoveries in the history of physics. Particle accelerators may also
- 1:20:38play a role in revealing the nature of dark matter.
- 1:20:42Future upgrades to the Large Hadron Collider and proposed new
- 1:20:45accelerators may reach even higher energies. By recreating conditions similar
- 1:20:50to those just after the Big Bang, these machines may
- 1:20:53produce entirely new particles. If dark matter consists of such particles,
- 1:20:59their signatures might appear in the debris of high energy collisions.
- 1:21:03Physicists would detect them indirectly through missing energy or unusual
- 1:21:08particle interactions. These experiments require enormous precision and patience, but
- 1:21:14the potential reward is extraordinary. They could reveal entirely new
- 1:21:19forms of matter. Astronomers are also exploring new techniques for
- 1:21:23studying the dark universe. Some projects focus on observing faint
- 1:21:28hydrogen clouds between galaxies. Others measure the cosmic microwave background,
- 1:21:34the ancient light left over from the birth of the universe.
- 1:21:38Tiny variations in this background radiation can reveal how dark
- 1:21:42matter influenced the early cosmos. By combining these observations with
- 1:21:47simulations and theoretical models, scientists hope to narrow the possibilities.
- 1:21:53Each experiment adds another piece to the puzzle. Yet despite
- 1:21:57all these efforts, the mystery of dark matter remains open.
- 1:22:01And in some ways, that mystery is what makes it
- 1:22:04so fascinating. Science does not always move in straight lines.
- 1:22:09Sometimes it advances through decades of quiet searching, through experiments
- 1:22:14that rule out possibilities, through observations that raise new questions.
- 1:22:19Dark matter sits at the frontier of this process. It
- 1:22:23challenges our understanding of both particle physics and cosmology. And
- 1:22:28somewhere within that challenge lies the opportunity for discovery. Perhaps
- 1:22:33dark matter will turn out to be a new particle
- 1:22:36waiting to be detected. Perhaps it belongs to a hidden
- 1:22:39dark sector of physics. Or perhaps the answer will require
- 1:22:44an entirely new way of thinking about gravity and the
- 1:22:47structure of the universe. For now, the dark universe continues
- 1:22:52to surround us, invisible, silent, yet profoundly influential. It shapes galaxies,
- 1:23:01it guides the formation of cosmic structures, and it reminds
- 1:23:06us that the universe still holds many secrets. As we
- 1:23:10reach the end of our journey tonight, we are left
- 1:23:12with a quiet sense of wonder. Most of the universe
- 1:23:16remains unseen, yet through careful observation, patient experimentation, and the
- 1:23:22curiosity of countless scientists, we continue to explore its hidden depths.
- 1:23:29The story of dark matter is still unfolding, and somewhere
- 1:23:33in the vast darkness between the stars, the answer may
- 1:23:36already be waiting. As our quiet journey through the hidden
- 1:23:40universe comes to an end, we return once more to
- 1:23:44the night sky. When we look upward, it feels as
- 1:23:47though we are seeing everything the cosmos has to offer.
- 1:23:51Stars shimmer softly across the darkness. Galaxies glow faintly in
- 1:23:56distant clusters. Nebulae drift like gentle clouds of light between
- 1:24:01the stars. But tonight we have discovered something remarkable. Most
- 1:24:07of the universe cannot be seen at all. The stars,
- 1:24:10planets and galaxies that fill our telescopes make up only
- 1:24:14a small fraction of what truly exists. The rest, the
- 1:24:18vast majority of the cosmos, remains invisible. Dark matter forms
- 1:24:23enormous halos around galaxies. It stretches through the cosmic web.
- 1:24:29It quietly shapes the motion of galaxies across billions of years.
- 1:24:33Yet even now, we still do not know exactly what
- 1:24:37it is. And perhaps that is part of the beauty
- 1:24:40of science. Human beings are still learning. Still exploring. Still
- 1:24:46asking questions about the universe that surrounds us. Each generation
- 1:24:51builds new telescopes, designs new experiments, develops new ideas that
- 1:24:57bring us closer to understanding the cosmos. But even with
- 1:25:00all that knowledge, the universe continues to hold mysteries. Quiet ones,
- 1:25:07patient ones, waiting for curious minds to discover them. Tonight,
- 1:25:12as you rest, it can be comforting to remember that
- 1:25:15we are part of that story. Tiny observers on a
- 1:25:19small planet, drifting through a galaxy that floats inside an
- 1:25:23invisible ocean of dark matter, a universe far larger and
- 1:25:27stranger than we once imagined, yet also peaceful in its
- 1:25:32quiet rhythms, galaxies turning slowly through the darkness, stars burning
- 1:25:39gently across the cosmic night, and somewhere beyond the reach
- 1:25:43of our telescopes, the hidden structure of the universe continuing
- 1:25:47its silent dance. Now, It is time to let your
- 1:25:51thoughts slow down. Allow the vastness of the universe to
- 1:25:55settle softly in your mind. There is no need to
- 1:25:58solve every mystery tonight. The cosmos will still be there tomorrow.
- 1:26:04And the next night, and the night after that, endless
- 1:26:08questions waiting patiently beneath the stars. So close your eyes.
- 1:26:13Relax your breathing. and let your mind drift gently through
- 1:26:17the quiet universe we have explored together. In a moment,
- 1:26:22soft ambient music will begin to play. Let the calm
- 1:26:26rhythm of that music guide you into rest. Thank you
- 1:26:30for spending this peaceful journey beneath the stars. Good night,
- 1:26:35and sleep well.
- 1:26:43Speaker 3: Thank you for watching.
- 1:27:14Speaker 2: Thank you for watching.
- 1:28:47Speaker 3: Thank you. Thanks for watching! Thank you for watching.
- 1:30:06Speaker 2: This is the first time that I have seen this
- 1:30:11type of object. you you you.
- 1:32:02Speaker 3: Thank you.
- 1:32:59Speaker 2: Thank you for watching. you you you you you.
- 1:35:12Speaker 3: Thank you. Thank you for watching. Thank you. you Thank you.
- 1:38:13Speaker 4: You Thank you for watching. Thank you.
- 1:40:18Speaker 2: Thank you.
- 1:40:40Speaker 1: Thank you.
- 1:41:05Speaker 3: Thank you.
- 1:41:36Speaker 5: Thank you for watching. This is the first time I've
- 1:42:53ever seen this. I've never seen anything like this. I've
- 1:43:02never seen anything like this.
- 1:43:18Speaker 3: Thank you. Thank you. Thank you for watching.
- 1:44:29Speaker 2: Thank you for watching. Thanks for watching! This is the
- 1:46:51first time I've seen this in real life.
- 1:46:52Speaker 3: This is the first time I've seen this in real life.
- 1:47:22Speaker 2: Thank you for watching.
- 1:48:10Speaker 3: You you you.
- 1:48:55Speaker 2: Thank you.
- 1:49:18Speaker 3: Thank you. Thank you for watching.
- 1:50:14Speaker 2: Thank you for watching. Thank you.
- 1:52:36Speaker 3: This is the first time I've seen this in real life.
- 1:52:37This is the first time I've seen this in real life.
- 1:53:07Speaker 2: Thank you for watching.
- 1:53:36Speaker 3: You you you.
- 1:55:03Speaker 2: Thank you.
- 1:55:28Speaker 3: This is the first time I've seen this in real life.
- 1:55:29This is the first time I've seen this.
- 1:55:30Speaker 2: In real life. Thank you for watching. This is the
- 1:56:29first time that I have seen this kind of thing.
- 1:56:34This is the first time I have seen this kind
- 1:56:37of thing. Thank you.
- 1:58:00Speaker 3: Thank you for watching. Thank you. Thank you.
- 2:00:25Speaker 2: Thank you. Thank you.
- 2:01:13Speaker 3: Thank you for watching.
- 2:01:44Speaker 2: Thank you for watching. you you you
- 2:03:26Speaker 3: Thank you.