Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Cuteness Aggression, Fat Phobia, Introversion, and Daddy Issues
Transcript
- 0:00Hey, deserving listeners. I thought I would read some patron emails. This
- 0:04first email is from anonymous middle tier patron. They say, hi, doctor
- 0:09Kirk. I've heard you say many times that one of the most important parts
- 0:14of an effective apology is setting out a path forward, saying what you're going
- 0:20to do in order to change a harmful or hurtful behavior. At the same
- 0:24time, for those of us that have these behavior patterns ingrained it deeply enough,
- 0:30like lying reflexively under stress, I feel like it takes time to change
- 0:35those patterns. What are some good ways to convey that you're serious about making
- 0:40changes without making promises you might not yet be able to keep. End of
- 0:44email. Yeah, it's a really good question. So what I'll say is
- 0:48that it depends, but if I am understanding what you're getting at. With
- 0:53my wife, for example, when I apologize to her about something that I
- 0:59did in conflict, I will often if I think it's necessary, I'll say,
- 1:04and it often is, I'll say something like, so I feel bad
- 1:08about what I did. I'm sorry. Here's why I did it. I
- 1:11was triggered. It's sound an excuse, but it you know, it does
- 1:15provide some background and I'm gonna really really try not to do this again,
- 1:19but I'm pretty sure i'm gonna do it again because I have this problem and
- 1:25I've always done this even before I met you. I'm better than I was
- 1:30before, but you know, obviously I still have problems, and I apologize
- 1:38in advance for doing it again. I'm gonna do everything in my power not
- 1:42to do it again, and by that I mean continue to think about it.
- 1:49I try to actually catch myself. I notice when I'm triggered. I
- 1:55know it. I know it. Lack of differentiation feels like and I I
- 2:00actively am pushing back on a lot of verges that I have a lot of
- 2:02stupid things that pop into my head. Things to say that I know are
- 2:08that they feel right in the moment, but I intellectually know that they're not
- 2:13right, because I'm mature enough to get that now. But some things sneak
- 2:16through or I you know, when I'm really really triggered, it's really hard
- 2:23for me to stay differentiated. So I'm sorry. I'm going to try not
- 2:29do it again, but I probably will, and I'm I'm sorry for that.
- 2:32So you know, I say something like that, and I think you
- 2:36know that usually will carry the day. If someone that's you know, the
- 2:43person getting the apology, if they hear that, I'm guessing that that would
- 2:49go a long way. And it's important to demonstrate that you are indeed trying
- 2:58to do something. I mean, I tell people this, I'm like,
- 3:00look, you can make all the mistakes with me, you can do all
- 3:06sorts of things to me, but if you apologize and recognize what you did,
- 3:12then I'll wipe the slate clean. And even if I know that you're
- 3:16going to do it again, even if you know that you're going to do
- 3:20it again, if I know that you care and you have remorse without any
- 3:24ifans or butts or any kind of excuses, then yeah, we're good.
- 3:30You know, you can. You could be the biggest jerk face on the
- 3:35planet to me, you know, within reason, I suppose, but you
- 3:37know, all the normal kinds of hurts and transgressions you can do to me.
- 3:45But if you fully apologize and I really believe that you care and that
- 3:50you're working on it, and you know within reason, then then we're we're
- 3:55fine. That The problem that I have, though, is that very few
- 4:00people actually apologize. So you know, these little things that happen in relationships.
- 4:08They just build up over time, and over time you start to wonder,
- 4:12do they care, do they have remorse, do they care about my
- 4:15feelings? Do they think at all about how they impact other people? And
- 4:19that's what hurts. It's not the transgression, it's the lack of taking responsibilities,
- 4:26the lack of apologies. You know, someone could like, what your
- 4:30problem is, lie reflexively under stress and then if you apology. You know,
- 4:35if you did that to me. Let's say you did it to me
- 4:38literally every day, and that'd be pretty awful. Right if you went to
- 4:42someone and say, yeah, you know, my friend or my partner lies
- 4:46straight to my face about important issues at least once a day. If you
- 4:50said that to someone, the other person would probably be like, you should
- 4:55leave that person. That's pretty awful. But to me, that's not the
- 4:59issue. The issue is do you apologize even though you know you're going to
- 5:03do it again? Do you have remorse and can you convey that? Are
- 5:08you working on it? Because when you do that, and this is what
- 5:11I do in my office, then you're on the same team. You're not
- 5:15working against each other. You're both on the same team against the problem.
- 5:18This is a narrative postmodern technique of trying to externalize the problem that I think
- 5:25is really quite effective and therapy and also in relationships. The idea goes is
- 5:28that you say this reflective lying issue. And so for you, patron,
- 5:33you have a partner, Let's say, instead of your partner is against you
- 5:40and the lying, you should be on the same team, you and your
- 5:43partner against the lying. The two of you work, so you have to
- 5:47recruit your partner to be on your team against the lying, even though the
- 5:51lying harms your partner, but it impacts you as well obviously. So you
- 5:59say, I have a problem with lying, and I don't like it.
- 6:02I want to get rid of it, but it won't go away. I'm
- 6:05working on getting rid of it, but I don't know if I'll ever get
- 6:09rid of it because I've been in therapy for fifteen years and I still kind
- 6:13of do it sometimes when I am under a lot of stress. And so,
- 6:17partner of mine, can you be on my team with me against the
- 6:21lying? You know, there's a way of phrasing it, there's a way
- 6:26of thinking about it. But the only way you can be on the same
- 6:30team with your partner is if you tell your partner your entire internal process.
- 6:34And the only way you can tell your partner entire internal processes is if you
- 6:39know you're at least most of your internal process, because then your partner can
- 6:44be, oh, you're not choosing to lie to me. You don't wake
- 6:47up in the morning and say I'm gonna lie to my partner. This is
- 6:50something you do reflexively based on trauma or habit from when you were a child
- 6:56or something, and huh, so you know, it's sort of like if
- 7:00you had cancer. For example, Most couples as they go through this feel
- 7:05like it's well in the best case scenario, it's the couple is on the
- 7:11same team against the cancer, right, But the cancer can impact a lot
- 7:15of things. It can impact one's mood and how differentiated you are, so
- 7:21it can affect the marriage. Right. But if the marriage is against the
- 7:28problem and they don't think of the problem as being of the person, meaning
- 7:33that the lying, if you externalize it from yourself and you're sometimes it's good
- 7:41to even have a name for it, to have this entity name of just
- 7:46like, well, that's my dad inside of me, or that's my trauma
- 7:51in me, and I'm trying to get rid of that, you know,
- 7:56some kind of word for it. Then it's just like you're really triangulated,
- 8:01which is a good thing. It's like me and my partner are triangulated against
- 8:05this one thing. So that's another way to help with the ongoing nature of
- 8:13our problems. Yeah, John Gottman found this as well, but I don't
- 8:18know. I might even emphasize it even further than John Gottman does. That
- 8:24the you know, all of you right now that are in a relationship,
- 8:28in a long term relationship, or you're at the beginning of a long term
- 8:31relationship, you probably already know the problems with your partner, and your partner
- 8:37probably already knows the problems with you. So the common narrative is like,
- 8:45well, you got to change those things, or you got to go to
- 8:48therapy. You change those things ninety nine point nine percent at the time,
- 8:52though, the problems that you see in your partner and the problems that your
- 8:56partner sees and you will never go away. You will be dealing with those
- 9:00problems for the rest of your lives together if you stay together. And that
- 9:05sounds depressing. It makes it sound like therapy doesn't work or something. But
- 9:11it does work. It just mitigates it quite a bit. Right, You
- 9:18can take it from a nine out of ten to a two out of ten
- 9:20sort of thing. Right, it happens instead of every week, it happens
- 9:26once a year, and that's a huge improvement. Right. And so whenever
- 9:33you're apologizing to your partner about something that you did when you were triggered,
- 9:39this question patron applies to I'm guessing every single time you apologize to your partner
- 9:46about something that is wrong with your personality. And I think that this notion
- 9:52is hard to swallow and not necessarily recognize you and by clinicians, But I
- 9:56think it's important to recognize because it's the reality. And I think the notion
- 10:03that somehow it's different than this causes a lot of shame. And a lot
- 10:09of people, when they're apologizing, will believe it's wrong to admit that they're
- 10:16going to do this again, you know, because to admit you're going to
- 10:18do it again means that you don't care, presumably, But to it to
- 10:24me, when I'm admitting I'm doing that, I'm going to do it again,
- 10:28I am recognizing reality and I am not being flipped about I'm not like,
- 10:37yeah, sure I did it once, and you know I'm going to
- 10:39do it again because who cares to me. It's like it gives me pre
- 10:46remorse, you know, It's like I have remorse for what I did yesterday
- 10:50to you, Stacy, and I know I'm going to do this a thousand
- 10:56more times before I leave this plane of existence, and I'm pre remorseful for
- 11:01all those times. I'm going to do this stupid thing again. I'm trying
- 11:05not to and I'm new everything in my power not to do it, but
- 11:09I'm going to do it again, and I feel horrible about it because there's
- 11:13something wrong with my personality, you know. I think that that is just
- 11:18recognizing reality and also recognizes that it's not a matter of getting rid of something,
- 11:24it's a matter of managing it, all right. This next email is
- 11:28from middle tier patron Hannah from Indiana. Hannah from Indiana. She says,
- 11:33Hello, doctor Kirk Honda, I had a dream about you the other night.
- 11:37I thought it was really interesting and meaningful, so I thought you might
- 11:41want to hear it, just chamming in, Yeah, I absolutely want to
- 11:45hear it. If y'all ever have a dream about me. I would love
- 11:48to hear it. When I have a dream about other people, I almost
- 11:56always tell them. I think it says a lot of things. I think
- 12:00it says that you know, I'm not only actively thinking about you, my
- 12:05subconscious is actively thinking about you. And also, I mean, unless the
- 12:09dream is like a coworker and you were having sex with them or something,
- 12:16obviously you should think twice about doing that. But if it's not going to
- 12:20bother anybody, then I think it's really interesting. Anyway, going on with
- 12:24the email in the dream, I ran into you somewhere in public and thanked
- 12:28you for your content and for the impact you've had on my life and my
- 12:33healing. I thanked you for showing me what qualities I want in a therapist
- 12:39so that I could seek my own therapist. We were having a conversation about
- 12:43attachment and how children grow up with the model of their parents and eventually break
- 12:48that model. I had a profound realization during that conversation that I need to
- 12:52know the problem before I can break it. During that time, you asked
- 12:56if I was anxious and suggest a mindfulness coming exercise. I told you I'm
- 13:01always anxious, and it's normal, you said, I don't deserve to feel
- 13:05that way. Let me know, what do you think. I thought the
- 13:07dream was pretty cool and of email, yeah, I really like that.
- 13:11I realized a long time ago that all of us are going to internalize each
- 13:18other if we're in a relationship with each other. I first realized this when
- 13:24I was starting out as a therapist and paying attention to this sort of thing.
- 13:30When my mentors would be in my head during sessions. I would be
- 13:35thinking about what they would think about what I was doing, or what I
- 13:41should do or something. And then as I was learning object relations, it
- 13:46all ties into that internalizations interjects that kind of thing, and then I would
- 13:50start to hear from students and from clients telling me that I was in their
- 13:56head, and people would often be kind of sheepish about it. They would
- 14:01say, you know, I was in a fight with my partner the other
- 14:05day, and you know you were. I don't know if this makes you
- 14:09feel weird, but you were kind of in my head telling me, you
- 14:13know, comforting me or helping me. And I realized that not only does
- 14:18this happen normally, and it's a it's a good sign that the client or
- 14:24student trusts me and is benefiting from me. But I also learned that people
- 14:31are ashamed of it sometimes, you know, they feel like there's something wrong
- 14:37or creepy about it. And so I set out to really normalize that and
- 14:43talk about it. And then when I hear people having dreams about me,
- 14:48it's the same thing that that's what I think of. I think of well,
- 14:52especially a dream like this where it's literally me as a therapist. Now
- 14:58have you internalized me? Well, you've internalized a version of me, right,
- 15:03the therapist, podcaster, professor version of me. But that's not the
- 15:09entire me, right. You know, in real life, if you ran
- 15:15into me in public or something and you were well, I don't know.
- 15:20I feel like when I was going to say, I don't know if I
- 15:22would be very helpful, because in real life, you know, I'm a
- 15:28real person. But I do find that when I am in public and I
- 15:33run into people, or I meet a fan of the show or something like
- 15:39that, or I run into a former student or something, I find that
- 15:45the conversation naturally kind of gravitates there. I think both of us are sort
- 15:50of used to that that dynamic or something, and so it kind of goes
- 15:56to that place, plus I find that, you know, I think I
- 16:02said during my mom's interviews that I was never the sort of person that people
- 16:07came to with their problems. And I don't know how true that is exactly,
- 16:11because when I was in high school, early high school, I signed
- 16:15up for what they called Natural Helpers, which is this program that helps people
- 16:22students to be listeners. So I don't know why I would have wanted to
- 16:29do that. There wasn't any I'm not I don't remember any reason. You
- 16:33know, you'd think someone that's in ninth grade that signs up for this program
- 16:38would be the sort of person that identifies as a good listener or you know,
- 16:44and so maybe I was kind of that way about I don't know,
- 16:47I don't really feel that way. And sometimes I forget that I did that
- 16:51because I have this narrative that I just weirdly decided to become a therapist when
- 16:56I was twenty four and had never considered it. Four'd never consider anything even
- 17:00close to psychology, and yet I have this this thing that I volunteered for
- 17:10it, and there weren't many of us. There was maybe like four or
- 17:15five of us in my entire class of like three hundred and fifty four hundred
- 17:19students, so and I remember them materials. I remember it had listening skills,
- 17:26communication skills, that kind of thing. And I'm just wondering, like
- 17:30what I was thinking, what was motivating me? But I think another angle
- 17:37to it is that I've always been the sort of person that isn't shocked by
- 17:44taboo topics. I am not afraid to talk about I've never been afraid to
- 17:48talk about deep concepts or difficult stories. You know. I don't know what
- 17:56that is about me, but I do remember in high school and college when
- 18:02I would be at a party or something and I just didn't want to talk
- 18:06about the normal stuff, and so I would ask questions to go deeper.
- 18:11Or I when when someone would go kind of deep, I seem to not
- 18:18flinch at it, and so the person would go even deeper because they might
- 18:22not get a lot of opportunities to talk to someone who doesn't flinch, you
- 18:25know. And so I think I've always been that sort of person that doesn't
- 18:30flinch when things go deep, and I find that most people do. They'll
- 18:34you know, the whole phrase of like you know, TMI. You know,
- 18:38sometimes I think it's appropriate, but I think a lot of times it's
- 18:41just a phrase to ridicule and shame people for talking honestly and authentically, or
- 18:48you'll you'll notice that people will say like, well, that's morbid, or
- 18:52you know, well, or we're getting emotional now. You know, people
- 18:56have these shaming phrases that they have when they're uncomfortable, and I've always tried
- 19:03to issue that. I've always tried to not only not do that, but
- 19:07also really go overboard and demonstrate that if you want to talk about something that's
- 19:14more interesting than the normal bullshit, then you know I'm I'm your person.
- 19:18So please, I'm bored, Please talk with me about something that's more interesting
- 19:23than the normal shit that people talk about all day. And I remember thinking
- 19:29that when I was in high school. In fact, the Liza was one
- 19:34of the original co hosts of the podcast, and we've known each each other
- 19:41since preschool and be friends, but we became really good friends in high school
- 19:45because she was that way too. We would stay up all night long and
- 19:49literally until the sun came up and just talk and talk and talk about deep
- 19:56things whatever we wanted to talk about. And you know, like I would,
- 20:03I would drive over to her house, and my parents were pretty lax
- 20:08with rules. So I could, you know, hop in the Honda Civic
- 20:14and drive off. And my parents were just like, okay, have a
- 20:15good night. And and uh, Lita had much more conservative parents that didn't
- 20:26want her staying out at night. But so I would go to her window
- 20:30and I'd knock on her window and she would crawl through a window. And
- 20:33then we'd get in my car and drive somewhere and and just talk all night
- 20:37and listen to music. And normally, when you hear that sort of thing,
- 20:41you think, oh, it's a it's a prelude to having sex,
- 20:45drugs and rock and roll, and uh, we just wanted to talk all
- 20:51night long and and we would, you know, just frolic in the moonlight.
- 20:57And that's when I in love with being a night owl. I loved
- 21:03night time because no one was up, everyone was asleep, and we could
- 21:11do whatever we wanted to. We would go to like our elementary school that
- 21:15we grew up going to, and we would just walk around the elementary school,
- 21:19and you know, it just felt like we owned the elementary school,
- 21:25you know, And we would listen to music and dance around and I don't
- 21:30know, just stuff like that. So you know, I've always been that
- 21:33sort of person. But anyway, so when I am in public now and
- 21:41I run into a fan or something and we end up talking, I find
- 21:44that I think that's another reason as to why conversations kind of go deeper,
- 21:49because I just have a value that I am up for talking about difficult things,
- 21:57you know. And and a little tip for people if you want to
- 22:00be comfortable with this sort of discussions, these sort of discussions is I think
- 22:07what people worry about is they don't know what to say, and they're worried
- 22:14that if they open up a can of worms that they might be there for
- 22:18the next five hours or something. And those assumptions are faulty, meaning that
- 22:22you know, say I run into a fan or something and she's like,
- 22:32oh my god, you know, you really helped me with my trauma,
- 22:37And someone who's more anxious about it might go like, oh, don't ask
- 22:42her about her trauma because that's well, that's kind of a bad example because
- 22:47I would have caution about asking about someone's trauma. But or you know,
- 22:52let's like she says, you help me through a really difficult time that I
- 22:56had three years ago, and then I think what people would worry about is
- 23:00like, well, if I ask her what was the difficult time, then
- 23:07it might lead to like a five hour conversation when you know, because I'll
- 23:11feel weird about cutting it short or something. I'll feel feel weird about extracting
- 23:18myself from the conversation. And that's one worry. I think. Another worry
- 23:22is like it feels invasive, or you don't want to ash you. I
- 23:30think another worry that people have is they don't want to shame the other person
- 23:34by asking them about a difficult situation because they think it's shameful to have a
- 23:40different I think that's literally what people think, you know, and that's just
- 23:44it's so weird. So so I'll ask, you know, oh, what
- 23:49what happened? So I know enough about how to ask questions as a therapist
- 23:55and as a human that there's ways of asking that gives the other person a
- 24:00way out of it. Right, I'm not pressuring them with my language for
- 24:03them to tell me everything when they don't really want to. So I might
- 24:07just look at them and say, oh, what happened? Or I might
- 24:11say huh, well, if you want to tell me about it, I'd
- 24:17be curious, but you don't have to, you know, something like that.
- 24:19And what I find is people want to talk about it. You know.
- 24:26If it's one thing I've learned about being a host on this podcast is
- 24:29that there's a lot of people out there that want to talk about the fullness
- 24:34of life. You know, I was about to say people want to talk
- 24:37about the difficulties, but really, you know, people want to talk about
- 24:41everything. They want to talk about all aspects of life. It's just that
- 24:45with a lot of relationships, a lot of situations, you're not allowed to
- 24:49talk about the negative. So it's not that I am attracted to the negative
- 24:55per se. I'm just attracted to the entirety of human experience and the entirety
- 25:00of people's experience, and the entirety of people. So it just so happens
- 25:07that society suppresses the negative. So I meant, I'm fully here if someone
- 25:11wants to talk about that, and and so then as the person, let's
- 25:17say they're like, oh, well it was really hard, and you know,
- 25:19they start kind of going down that road. Then let's say that that
- 25:26you know, they're kind of yammering a little bit longer than I have time
- 25:30for. No fault to them, but I just I have to go or
- 25:36something. Then I would just say something like, hey, I actually have
- 25:41to go, but please tell me more. But just know that I someone's
- 25:48waiting for me and I have to be there in a couple of minutes.
- 25:49Now, what will likely happen is the person will be like, oh my
- 25:52god, I'm so sorry. I go ahead and go, and I'll be
- 25:53like, no, no, no, I pleased. I finished the story
- 25:57for me because I really want to know what happened. I just was worried
- 26:03that I might not get to the other story. So because I really want
- 26:07to know what happened, what happened there. You know, there's ways of
- 26:10managing it. I think I feel like I have that ability and it's not
- 26:15hard to do. I think another assumption is that YET have in a situation
- 26:21like that, is that you know, people are stronger than I think people
- 26:23give people credit for. And uh, you know, because like in that
- 26:26situation, I'm sort of cutting someone short, and I think people have this
- 26:30general assumption that if you do that to someone, they're going to be like
- 26:34devastated by it, and that's not usually what happens, you know. And
- 26:40so as a concert sorry, I keep going and as a consequence, people
- 26:47just avoid talking about anything. Right anyway, I'm on a ramble. But
- 26:53but yeah, I like your I like your dream. Let's take a break.
- 27:02All right, back from the break, I have a couple announcements.
- 27:06If you didn't know, we are having our fifteenth anniversary show on September sixteen
- 27:12and seventeen as a live broadcast on YouTube. So if you want to join
- 27:18us there, you can do that. I don't know exactly what time we're
- 27:22going to be broadcasting. I think we're gonna start at ten am both days,
- 27:26see at the time, and we're gonna do seven and a half hours
- 27:30to reach day for a total fifteen hours, so do that. Also know
- 27:36that Amberto and Bob are on cameo, so if you want to get a
- 27:41cameo from either of them, that is available. And also let's do an
- 27:48opp these people became patrons all the way back in twenty twenty. We have
- 27:53Alex from Forest Hills, New York. We have Kneelu far from Maryland.
- 28:00We have Anna from hu Is that Hungary? I'm gonna guess Hungry Sharagine from
- 28:07Honolulu, Hawaii. Wow, the fires in Maui, which is not the
- 28:12island that Honolulu was on. Right Wow, just awful, just awful.
- 28:21I hope everyone's okay. I saw this news report or a video or something
- 28:26of a local who was obviously still experienced a lot of grief and difficulty and
- 28:37maybe their house burned down, I don't know, and they were very angry
- 28:41about the tourists that were having fun times on the beach, and they're like,
- 28:49there's you know, there's two ways of experiencing the island right now.
- 28:55One is is all the locals that are just their lives are just completely upended
- 28:59and and it's awful. And then there's all these rich tourists that are here
- 29:03just like acting like our I don't know, like our pain doesn't exist or
- 29:11something. And on one hand, I totally get that, and I think
- 29:17that it just shows just how painful and how difficult and how how much these
- 29:25people probably feel ignored. You're right, It's if they were in New York
- 29:29City or Nashville. I'm guessing there would be a lot more attention, a
- 29:34lot more aid or something. I don't know, but because you know,
- 29:38sometimes so I feel like Hawaii is my home town, even though I've only
- 29:47been there a few times because when I'm there, it's so familiar to me,
- 29:53because it's so Japanese American or Asian American infused it. White people are
- 30:00the minority there to the extent that sometimes white people are absolutely massively discriminated against
- 30:10it in Hawaii and bullied and violently harmed by happ as like myself, which
- 30:17is awful. And yeah, anyway, so when I go to Hawaii,
- 30:22other than that, I feel very much at home, and so everything that
- 30:29happens there, I feel an affinity towards and I But I don't think that
- 30:37people do. I think a lot of Americans think of Hawaii as like not
- 30:44even of the United States, or they think of it as just this tourist
- 30:48destination and that's all it is. You know, no one thinks of New
- 30:52York State as just a tourist destination, right, you know you think you
- 30:57know that people live there, and yeah, there are tourist destinations in New
- 31:00York. But or California with Disneyland, you know, people understand that people
- 31:07live in Disney well, or live in live in California. Well, Hawaii
- 31:11is a regular US state with regular Americans that are living regular lives in Hawaii.
- 31:19Isn't just a place for tourists, right, So I think when the
- 31:26fire has happened, people are just like, huh, well, this foreign
- 31:32country had this thing happened. Who cares that sort of thing, which is
- 31:34its own kind of cynicism and awfulness. But anyway, so I get the
- 31:41pain and the hurt and how difficult things are. I had this urge just
- 31:48to like find some sort of charity to send money to, because you just
- 31:55got to figure that people are going to need and maybe after I record this,
- 31:59I'll look that up. But on the other hand, I do sympathize
- 32:04with vacationers also, you know, someone work because Hawaii, especially to people
- 32:12on the West Coast, it's not that expensive to fly out to Hawaii and
- 32:15stay there. It might sound really fancy, and it is, but it's
- 32:21not as fancy as as other kind of destinations, like like going to Europe,
- 32:25for example. People on the East Coast might be like, oh,
- 32:29going to Europe, that's not a big deal. But for me it's Seattle.
- 32:32It's it's a pretty big deal expense wise and time wise. Going to
- 32:37Hawaii it's it's not as anyway, so I get that if you had a
- 32:45family that was saving up all year to go to Hawaii and they go to
- 32:51Hawaii and this tragedy happens, you know, I'm going to take a guess
- 32:57and say that they care, and they're also thinking, but this is our
- 33:00one vacation for the year and so and the kids are here, and we
- 33:07don't want to just be a downer the whole time, so we're going to
- 33:09try to have a good time. And you know, I could see that
- 33:13as well. And I don't know what those tourists were doing exactly, you
- 33:15know, if they were just like dancing on the graves of people. You
- 33:20know, I don't know, but I've sympathized with both people. I guess
- 33:24it's my point. And the thought I had was, well, that woman
- 33:30probably is walking around neglected and hurt and forgotten in general, and therefore if
- 33:37she wasn't walking around feeling that way, she probably wouldn't be as angry towards
- 33:43some tourists that were making the most out of a very difficult situation. You
- 33:46know. So anyway, Sharaine, thanks for being a patron. We have
- 33:53Marika from Ithaca, New York. We have Stephanie from London, we have
- 33:57Lola from London. Wait, a lot of people running. Anna from London.
- 34:01Oh, the places are alphabeta call. Okay, so we got Stephanie,
- 34:06Lola, and Anna from from London. We got Laura from Los Angeles.
- 34:10We have Alice from Miami. We have or no, sorry, Malma
- 34:15Sweden. Why why did I read it as Miami. Alice from Sweden.
- 34:20We got Jack from the same I think state Malma in Sweden. So Alice
- 34:25and Jack from Sweden. We got Geffen from Canada and Donna from Michigan,
- 34:35Brandy from New York, Claire from Australia, Amanda from New Jersey, Leah
- 34:42from Oakland, Bianca from Oceanside, Joshua from Pendleton, Kentucky, and Jeff
- 34:49from San Francisco. Thank you so much for being a patrons through thick and
- 34:52thin. Seriously, Okay, I want to maybe try to get to all
- 35:00the rest of them upper tier patron emails, but I don't know if I'll
- 35:04succeed. Let's see middle tier patron Kim from Arizona. Good old Kim.
- 35:08She says, I recently heard of the concept of cuteness aggression, which I
- 35:13find to be curious, fascinating and relatable. It's the feeling you get when
- 35:19you see a cute baby animal and you feel so overwhelmed by its cuteness that
- 35:23you want to squeeze it very intensely, or smother it with kisses, or
- 35:28some other well intended behavior that could actually harm the cute creature. Sometimes I
- 35:32notice my jaw and mouth can tighten up whenever I witness an animal that I
- 35:37find to be unburiably cute. Where does this impulse come from? And what
- 35:43evolutionary advantage does this trait have to be perpetuating itself through time? How is
- 35:49it possible to have such loving feelings for acute animal while simultaneously having subconscious driven
- 35:54behaviors that could harm it? Are there any particular profiles of clients who might
- 35:59have challenges controlling this impulse more than others, such as people living with early
- 36:05childhood trauma and certain disorders. It's bizarre, fascinating concept that something can be
- 36:10loved to death and of email. Yeah, well along. The short answer
- 36:17to a long answer is that we don't know. There are you know,
- 36:24we don't know why we do anything, but we have some pretty solid hypotheses
- 36:30and theories as to why we do some things, But regarding this one,
- 36:37it's hard to know which. Also, you know, I'll modify the question
- 36:43that you ask a little bit, Kim. Our behavior isn't necessarily evolutionary,
- 36:49quote unquote, in that there are things that we might do, or impulses
- 36:53or urges that we might have that is very common for humans to have that
- 37:00might not actually serve a purpose for survival or for procreation. In fact,
- 37:07we might have some urges that overall actually harm that. But the way that
- 37:14our brains work and the way that biology works and DNA, it's possible that
- 37:20when there are trade offs. It's sort of like the thing that I think
- 37:22about sometimes is when they start and I'm pretty sure this is right. When
- 37:27they started to breed wolves, wild wolves and other wild dogs, they found
- 37:35that as the dogs became more tame through the generations, their tails became more
- 37:43more curly cued, more curved, you know, up, you know what
- 37:47I'm saying. And it's not like the breeders were breeding dogs that had a
- 37:53curled tail. It's just this side effect. And at the time they didn't
- 37:59know and maybe they still don't know. But essentially, when you're you know,
- 38:02selecting for a particular trait, you know, within the DNA situation.
- 38:08Because I'm not a biologist, I can't I don't know the language or even
- 38:12if this is actually accurate. But when you know you're selecting for docile dogs,
- 38:19dogs that aren't aggressive or aren't violent, then you know dogs that are
- 38:24okay with humans, then the changes that are happening happening DNA wise that are
- 38:30being selected for through the gene pool have this ancillary DNA effect of having the
- 38:37curly queue tail and other kinds of things like that. I could be having
- 38:40all this wrong, but I know that the principle is right, that there
- 38:44are things that we were selected for as a species and have and continually are
- 38:49selected for. By the way, because we're not like done with evolution.
- 38:52Evolution never stops, it just keeps going. That there there are things that
- 38:58we were selected or behavior morphology this kind of thing that are necessary or are
- 39:06beneficial to the environment given procreation and survival. But there are ancillary effects to
- 39:10that that come along for the ride, so to speak. So you know,
- 39:15this cuteness aggression thing could be part of that, because it's hard to
- 39:17know, like why would we have this urge to want to smother and eat.
- 39:24Having said that, there are some obvious psychoanalytic ideas about wanting to internalize,
- 39:35right, because you know, there's this really funny sketch by Key and
- 39:38Peel where they get into this topic of cuteness aggression. These two women see
- 39:45a puppy, I think, and they're just like, I just want to
- 39:46I just I just want to squeeze that puppy so much. And the other
- 39:51woman's like, yeah, I just want to pick up that puppy and just
- 39:53bite its a little head off and and and spit out its skull or I
- 39:57don't know, it just escalates, right anyway, Why do we want to
- 40:00do that? It's it's so weird, right, So you know, the
- 40:05psycho analysts might say something that we want to internalize it, we want to
- 40:09have it in us. Like Jeffrey Dahmer was a lonely, struggling person who
- 40:15desperately wanted a partner or a friend, as pretty well depicted in that TV
- 40:21series, and felt like he couldn't get it through normal means, and so
- 40:27he would kill men and eat them right and hold on to their body parts.
- 40:32I think that's a viable hypothesis as to why he did what he did.
- 40:37I don't think it's the only theory or the only way of looking at
- 40:40it. I don't think it exactly explains the whole thing, but because his
- 40:45fascination with bodies and and sin you and whatnot goes back to when he was
- 40:51very young. But anyway, so that's one explanation. Another could be that
- 40:58you have we have this dichotomy inside of us that Freud proposed of life and
- 41:04death and and wanting to create and also wanting to destroy. As he Freud
- 41:12was watching World War One, he developed this death instinct thing and it you
- 41:16know, and you'll see there's a lot of evidence of this behavior, even
- 41:21in young children. You'll see them build up the blocks and then they want
- 41:25to destroy it. Right they have the food on there in front of them,
- 41:30they want to fling the plate and see the macaroni and cheese go flying.
- 41:35You know, there's a power to that. And when we see something
- 41:40cute, we might, given our internal conflicts, we might feel that more
- 41:46so than others. To me, that explanation doesn't really resonate. I feel
- 41:53the cuteness aggression a lot as well. You know, I was earlier tonight,
- 42:00I was just I was hanging out. Stacy and I were having dinner,
- 42:05and then afterwards I watched TV and I just thought our little dog was
- 42:10so cute, and I picked her up, and I know that she's not
- 42:15exactly excited about being picked up. She was tired and sleeping, and I
- 42:21didn't care. I just I wanted her to I don't know, just I
- 42:27wanted to kind of mess with her or something. So there are hypotheses,
- 42:32and so I don't I don't have a strong grasp on them, but I'll
- 42:37just kind of lightly ramble about him. One of the hypothesies that I think
- 42:43is possible is that when we obviously evolved to be very attracted to cute things,
- 42:52and it makes sense, you know, when it comes to little children,
- 42:57right children have big eyes and big heads. They're defenseless, they have
- 43:01higher voices, they're you know, they have a certain look to them,
- 43:06right typically, and lo and behold, when you look at cute cartoons or
- 43:12the kind of animals that were attracted to, they have big eyes and big
- 43:16heads. You know, there's a reason why puppies are particularly cute to us,
- 43:21because really a lot of dogs are cute to us, regardless of their
- 43:23age. But when they're puppies. They're really cute because it has those markers
- 43:29defenselessness kind of. They're often clumsy, big eyes, they have little barks,
- 43:37you know, woo woo, and it just melts you on the inside
- 43:40because we evolved to be melted by defenseless small creatures because it serves us,
- 43:47because it helps us to make sure we pay attention. And you know,
- 43:51I noticed this when I was pretty young, that when I was around family
- 43:55and there was an infant in the room, then everyone paid attention to that
- 44:00infant, including me, to the point where sometimes there'd be like, I
- 44:06don't know, fifteen of us and the infant would just be sitting in the
- 44:10middle of the living room, and all of us would just be smiling in
- 44:15a circle around the you know, sitting and the couches and stuff around the
- 44:20infant, just hanging on everything that the infant did. We'd just be like,
- 44:27oh my god, she blinked her eyes. That's so cute, you
- 44:31know, and we'd just be fascinated. And then I also noticed that as
- 44:36that yeah, I also noticed that as that child grew through the years,
- 44:45you know, became two years old, four years old, seven years old,
- 44:50that that compulsion drops off very quickly, you know, and I noticed
- 44:58that it's like, what is it that? And it started to develop or
- 45:02become aware of the hypothesis that we evolved to be very very very very very
- 45:08very very attracted to infant children, which can bleed over into other species or
- 45:16even into cartoons like Hello Kitty and that sort of thing. So we evolved
- 45:22that mechanism to be extremely fascinated and take a tremendous amount of joy by just
- 45:30observing or being with the cute creature. And it's possible that when we have
- 45:37that intense emotion towards the infant, towards the cute puppy, that a lot
- 45:45of emotions start to become triggered and come along for the ride, not only
- 45:52just pleasure and joy fixation, but also aggression. And I don't I don't
- 45:59know. I don't know if I've seen any research on this, but I
- 46:02don't know if people follow through with the aggression, you know it. We
- 46:07have this heuristic in our society that if you think about aggression, it's a
- 46:14slippery slope to becoming aggressive, and certainly it can be for many people,
- 46:19but it's not necessarily true. You can have really aggressive thoughts and never act
- 46:24on it, never want to act on it. So I don't know if
- 46:28this is one of those situations or not, but I think that we might
- 46:32have this. We're just so. It's sort of like when clients fall in
- 46:38love with their therapists. They a lot of emotions are happening towards a therapist
- 46:45because the client, in all likelihood went through a lot of abandonment trauma's growing
- 46:50up, and so the client is having just a lot of desire to be
- 46:55understood and be safe with the therapist. And there's all this gratitude and love
- 47:05and connection that the client is feeling towards the therapist, and along for the
- 47:08ride comes sexual attraction romantic attraction, right, because the client wants deeply to
- 47:19be with the therapist twenty four seven, which is natural and it's interpreted internally
- 47:27or it comes along for the ride that the romance and the sex. Right.
- 47:30So, you could think of cuteness aggression as something along those lines of
- 47:36just like, I want to be with this cute puppy. I want to
- 47:40touch it and love it and have it, and I also want to smash
- 47:45its nose into its face. I want to smother it until it can't breathe
- 47:52anymore, you know, And when I say it, I think it's jokey
- 47:58because it's going too far. I don't know if people want to. I
- 48:04don't know if people want to smother it to kill it, right, I
- 48:07think, which I think leads to another theory that I think is actual.
- 48:10Possibly. So, when I was two, maybe three, no, it
- 48:16was probably two, two and a half, there was a neighbor, a
- 48:20girl named Becky, and she was a year older than me, I think,
- 48:25and I really liked her. She was my friend that lived next door.
- 48:31And I also, I think, had a two year old version of
- 48:36a crush on her. And I remember, I'm pretty sure I visually remember
- 48:42this because it's a story that I remember remembering when I was, you know,
- 48:47four years old and seven years old. It's one of those memories.
- 48:51And I remember I was outside in her front yard next door, and it
- 48:57was a sunny day, and I remember just being really attracted to her.
- 49:01Now at the age of two, what does that exactly mean? It just
- 49:06I think it just meant like I just had affection, right, two year
- 49:10old affection towards this, you know, like anyway, So I had that
- 49:16feeling, and I had this impulse and I bit her on the cheek.
- 49:22And I didn't draw blood or anything. I just I just had this urge,
- 49:27you know, I just like, Okay, I want to have you
- 49:30or something. And I bit her on the cheek and she started to cry,
- 49:34and I was confused, and so I walked home, which was next
- 49:37door. And by the time I got home, Becky had told her mom,
- 49:42and then her mom called my mom on the phone right next door.
- 49:46And when I got home, my mom was just hanging it up. She's
- 49:51like, what did you do? And I couldn't explain it. Maybe I
- 49:55was three and a half, because it sounds like anyway really young, and
- 50:04to my memory, with which God knows if it's accurate, I wanted like,
- 50:10if I was older, I probably would have just hugged her right and
- 50:15held her tight or something. Or I would have held her hand or something
- 50:21I don't know, put my arm around her. But because I was so
- 50:23young and I didn't understand how these things work, I didn't modify my impulse,
- 50:32which was to bite her. So I think it's possible that I was
- 50:37having cuteness aggression in that moment and I literally acted on that urge of wanting
- 50:44to bite. Now, at that moment, I didn't want to kill her
- 50:46and I didn't want to eat her, but I did want to bite her,
- 50:52and I did bite her and it backfired like royally, And what is
- 51:00that? Right? You know? Is it just this? You know?
- 51:06Another analogy to this is cats. If you've ever hung out with cats,
- 51:10and not all cats will do this, but a lot of cats will that
- 51:15when they are grooming and loving someone another cat or a dog or a human,
- 51:23they will lick. That's how they care, you know that, Like
- 51:28we pet the cat and the cat will lick us. And so as the
- 51:32cat is licking, you know, you imagine a mother cat licking their their
- 51:37children to clean them and to soothe them, and so they're doing that to
- 51:43us, So the cat might be doing it to me, and then you'll
- 51:46see the cat will get kind of a little bit more ears back, and
- 51:52then we'll just start biting, you know, Like I've had cats that would
- 51:58do this. They be licking, licking and their loving and then all of
- 52:00a sudden ears go back and they just chomp down. And if you don't
- 52:07do anything, like if you don't react, then they just go back to
- 52:12licking again. Yeah, I'm sure. I'm sure there are a cat people
- 52:19out there that know exactly what I'm talking about. And you know, if
- 52:23you're not a cat person, then you're just like, well, all cats
- 52:25are psycho, which I guess it is one interpretation, but I think cat
- 52:30people will say that, well, yeah, cats are psycho, but it's
- 52:34it's also maybe cuteness aggression. I think another possibility is that for the cat,
- 52:45they have, you know, various different instincts. Right. One instinct
- 52:49is to take care of their young, and they will transfer that onto the
- 52:53humans. But also they have an instinct to kill and eat things, living
- 52:59things, and so maybe there's just times when they're loving that this wire gets
- 53:06crossed and they have this urge that they would have towards prey that they were
- 53:13eating. You know, it's like I'm licking a creature that's alive. I'm
- 53:19licking a creature that's alive. I'm liking. Wait, there's a creature that's
- 53:22alive in front of me. What do I do with creatures that are alive?
- 53:24Oh? I eat them? So I have to chomp down. I
- 53:28think it, you know, it could be something like that. I think
- 53:30another instinct that might be involved is the instinct to play cats included humans as
- 53:38well. That it's you know, not only are we attracted to cute children
- 53:45and to take care of them, to tune to them and pay attention to
- 53:50them, feed them, and protect them, but also we have an urge
- 53:54to interact with them. And if you've ever interacted with children, they often
- 54:00like to play rough and tumble right age appropriate, even at like uh,
- 54:07you know, twelve months, kids will like to you know, you could
- 54:12say peekaboo is a version of rough and humble, right, there's a there's
- 54:16some risk and and fear to it. And I think that we as as
- 54:28adults have a commensurate instinct to play with and I think that the biting,
- 54:34the aggression could encourage that, you know, that they're urged to pick up
- 54:39the child and throw them in the sorry, the urge to you know,
- 54:47pick up the child or too you know, play fight with the child.
- 54:54I think it's another possibility that we have that in stink to do that,
- 55:00and our instincts internally aren't very refined, and so we might consciously perceive them
- 55:07as I want to smash the puppies facing but the instinct is actually trying to
- 55:14motivate us just to interact and play rough and humble. So I'm sure there
- 55:19are other theories, but you know that's by discussion on that. All right,
- 55:23let's take a break, all right, let's do another opp We have
- 55:30Julie from Belgium. We have Jonathan from Seattle. We have Laura from Seattle.
- 55:37We have dev from Seattle. We have Stephen from Maryland. We got
- 55:42Seaweed from California, Mark from Tacoma, Brittany from Tallahassee, Florida. We
- 55:47have Anna from Switzerland. I Iowanna from washing DC, and the following folks
- 55:55did not list where they live, so we got Heidi, Jane, Sarah
- 55:59Door, Sheila, Nikil Ruby, Liz, and Shannon from God knows where.
- 56:05Thank you so much for being a patron through thick and thin. So
- 56:07for you gamers out there, I thought that I would do a little update
- 56:10on the video game situation that I'm in. For some of you, you
- 56:15might remember that Amberto and I played Age of Empires religiously for a couple of
- 56:21years, very frequently at night against the AI, and then we played Company
- 56:27of Heroes because I was getting bored of Age of Empires, so I pushed
- 56:31a company of Heroes because there's a new version. These are all real time
- 56:36strategy games, tactical games. And then Diablo four came out, so Amberto
- 56:40and I are playing that, and I have not played Diablo since I think
- 56:45the first one came out in the late nineties, and it's fun. I
- 56:49play, of course, the Passive Exile, which is similar to Diablo,
- 56:54and one of you works for that company. We've emailed together. And then
- 57:01bald Gate three just came out, so of course I've been playing that,
- 57:06and I sort of feel like a Balder's Gate hipster because not only did I
- 57:10play the original versions, but when the early access version of Baller's Gate three
- 57:17came out a few years ago, I was playing it. Also Alina,
- 57:22who works for the podcast, was playing it as well. And then when
- 57:27the full version came out just a couple weeks ago, suddenly everyone was talking
- 57:30about it and I'm like, yeah, we've known, it's been great for
- 57:34a long time. So welcome to the bandwagon people, all right. Sext
- 57:42emails from anonymous middle tier patrons, she says this is in reference to the
- 57:46video that you made about Jackie meeting Marshall's Family on Love is Blind. How
- 57:52do you deal with the fatigue of always being the differentiated one and taking a
- 57:57deep breath and walking away? Sometimes I feel like I shouldn't bother because I
- 58:02will get hurt in the process repeatedly, while the other person can continues to
- 58:07lash out, stop, apologize, and repeat the cycle. End of email.
- 58:12Well, you know, it really depends on the situation. But the
- 58:15definition of differentiation is not emotional control. And I think that sometimes people think
- 58:22that the definition of differentiation is taking actions that you feel during and after,
- 58:30maybe sometimes ten years later, to have been the right action. I mean,
- 58:35that's one definition. There's others. But the point I'm making is that
- 58:40you know, if you're in a situation where you're with family and they are
- 58:45hurting you, they're being jerk faces, and sometimes you decide, look,
- 58:52I'm not going to get entangled in this. I'm just going to walk away
- 58:54and take a deep breath. And then a week later, a month later,
- 58:59you look back and you think, yeah, that was probably the best
- 59:01choice given the circumstances. But if you a month later look back and say,
- 59:07you know what, I should have actually said something, I should have
- 59:12blasted them back. I should have like just become unhinged to because I deserve
- 59:19to become unhinged. Sometimes then you weren't being differentiated in the moment at least
- 59:23potentially depends on how you look at it, but you can, as a
- 59:28differentiated person decide in a mature manner to let someone have it and to stand
- 59:35up for yourself. So differentiation is not control or turning their cheek. It's
- 59:40about making decisions that you feel, after thinking about it in a calm manner,
- 59:47was the best action to take. For undifferentiated folks, they very frequently
- 59:53will react in a reactionary way, emotionally reactive way in the moment, and
- 1:00:00later they'll regret it. They probably don't admit to others and maybe even to
- 1:00:04themselves that they regret having done that. You know, you'll hear people say
- 1:00:08like, look, I'm I'm just a wild carter. You know, I
- 1:00:13say it how it is. You know, often people who say these things
- 1:00:17because they frequently will become emotionally irreactive in situations. These individuals I find often
- 1:00:24are making excuses to themselves because they don't know how to control themselves, so
- 1:00:30they're wrapping the narrative around their behavior to justify themselves and to give them some
- 1:00:36semblance of self esteem. But deep down they're actually not only looking at themselves
- 1:00:40and regretting their behavior, but they also are negatively impacted often, you know,
- 1:00:45being fired from a job, or losing relationships, or having people not
- 1:00:51really respect you, or bad parenting. So you know you're saying that you
- 1:00:58always take a deep breath and walk away. Well, what I would ask
- 1:01:00you is is that when you're calm a month later or a week later,
- 1:01:06is that what you really want to do, Because maybe it is. Maybe
- 1:01:09at the end of the day, you're just like, look, there's really
- 1:01:12no reason to get into it with these people. They don't listen. But
- 1:01:15maybe it's not. Maybe you're thinking I would if I wish there was a
- 1:01:21way where I could stand up to them in the moment, that I would
- 1:01:23be proud of myself later. Maybe it's not reducing you myself to their level.
- 1:01:30But walking away and taking a deep breath is I think, just disrespecting
- 1:01:36me and also not communicating to them that this is bullshit. So you know,
- 1:01:40there's a lot of different options. The other thing I'll say is that
- 1:01:45for me, you're asking how do you deal with the fatigue of always being
- 1:01:52the differentiated one. Well, what I'll say to that is that this is
- 1:01:57my style and life. There's a lot of things in this bucket. For
- 1:02:00me. When I am dealing with someone who was chronically bothersome to me,
- 1:02:07once we cross a threshold, I go on a campaign to extract myself.
- 1:02:13I might use the gray Rock method I've talked about that before, or just
- 1:02:17make a clean break and you know, cut that person out of my life,
- 1:02:22or maybe if they're in my family, which you know, I don't
- 1:02:25know if that's ever happened because I'm blessed with a pretty level headed group of
- 1:02:31people in my family, but if there were, maybe I just sort of
- 1:02:37drift away a little bit or just don't react much or don't get you know,
- 1:02:43because for people that are who lash out a lot, they often lash
- 1:02:49out at people that are closer to them. The further you are from these
- 1:02:52people emotionally and physically, the less likely they are to target you. And
- 1:02:59when I learned that, I feel like I learned that in my twenties because
- 1:03:02I would have people like this in my life, and my initial style was
- 1:03:07to try to work it out with people because I had faith in people back
- 1:03:12then, I guess, or at least I had faith that I, if
- 1:03:16I worked hard enough, I could win them over, right, And so
- 1:03:21I would try to engage and say, hey, let's let's work on this.
- 1:03:25There's a solution here. And when I found that for some people there
- 1:03:30really was not a solution there. Their issues were so and I didn't know
- 1:03:36this at the time, but so characterologically based in a deep schema distortion or
- 1:03:40personality disorder, that there really wasn't any point in me from my you know,
- 1:03:45if I was a therapist or maybe their parent, maybe I would have
- 1:03:51the leverage or the time to be able to go on that campaign. But
- 1:03:54if I'm just a friend or a co worker, I'm not going to change
- 1:03:59their personality from my peer position. And so I, after a while of
- 1:04:04you know, banging in my head up against the wall, I either experimented
- 1:04:09trial and error, someone told me or something. But I learned that for
- 1:04:13some people, if I don't have the role to actually, if I don't
- 1:04:18if I don't believe I have the role to effectively go on a campaign to
- 1:04:24change the person and or their relationship, then sometimes they make the determination that
- 1:04:29it's just best that I just drift away and draw boundaries. Now, you
- 1:04:34can draw boundaries in a very noticeable way, but sometimes that just makes it
- 1:04:40worse, right because the person who lashes out, they might become even more
- 1:04:45lashing out if you draw boundaries that they notice. Right, So sometimes it's
- 1:04:50best to gray rock and to just sort of emotionally drift and as they might
- 1:04:56comment, you know, they might say something like, jeez, you know,
- 1:04:59you're really kind of distant lately. You know, I just say phrases
- 1:05:03like well, you know, I'm real busy or something like that, because
- 1:05:09it's what's best for me. I'm trying to you know, I tried for
- 1:05:13a bit to change the situation for the two of us and determine it wasn't
- 1:05:18going to work. And so, uh, you know, even if it
- 1:05:20requires I guess lying, which isn't great, and especially given my policies about
- 1:05:27lying, but I think in some situations it's justified, a situation like this
- 1:05:32where you know you're being abused by someone chronically, that it's okay to lie
- 1:05:39to uh, you know, get the person off of you. So and
- 1:05:45I've and I've done this effectively a number of times where I extract myself from
- 1:05:53the toxic person's radar such that they stop bothering with me, and I might
- 1:05:58see them every once in a while, but they just don't consider me to
- 1:06:02be a target. It's not I'm not useful in that way, or or
- 1:06:09they try to engage, but there's there's so little track record there in recent
- 1:06:15times to make it so that I feel obligated to respond, you know,
- 1:06:19So you know that's what I'll say about that regarding differentiation and always walking away.
- 1:06:28That's sext emails from anonymous middle tier patron. She says, how can
- 1:06:31I shake off a deeply ingrained schema that I, as an overweight woman,
- 1:06:38will never be seen as attractive to a man? Is there a stigma amongst
- 1:06:43men about dating fat women? Can you tell me from a straight male's perspective
- 1:06:48about if there is a stigma amongst men about dating overweight women that I believe
- 1:06:55there to be, and please be honest. I suspect you will say something
- 1:06:59like men are attracted to all body types, because that's the kind thing to
- 1:07:02say, and politically correct thing to say. But it's likely that I won't
- 1:07:06believe you. What can I do to actually believe you? If you say
- 1:07:10that sorry for exposing these horrible, triggering false schemas. I wish I never
- 1:07:15had them imprinted on me, and it seems to be the fight of my
- 1:07:18life too free of them. But nothing has worked in the email. Yeah,
- 1:07:25well, I'm sorry that I'm guessing in terms of what experiences you've been
- 1:07:30through. It's not hard to imagine what experiences you've been through in your family
- 1:07:36and or in society and in dating situations. But that is horrible. To
- 1:07:44feel like there's something inherently unattractive or disgusting or undateable about you is just so
- 1:07:54abusive for any individual or any society to do that to a group of people
- 1:08:00for no reason. And so I'm sorry. But to specifically answer your question,
- 1:08:04you say, is there a stigma amongst men dating fat women? Yeah,
- 1:08:11there's a stigma among people of all genders dating people with larger bodies.
- 1:08:16Absolutely. If someone showed up at a party with a new partner and the
- 1:08:24new person was larger than yeah, I don't know what everyone would think,
- 1:08:29but I'm pretty sure percentage of people would think, oh, huh, why
- 1:08:35are they dating that person? Are they rich? Or they could do better
- 1:08:40than that or whatever. Yeah, there's an absolute stigma about that. Having
- 1:08:44said that, there are indeed, scientifically speaking, plenty of people who are
- 1:08:48attracted to people with all body types, maybe even specifically larger bodies. So
- 1:08:57that's well understood and well known and well documented. All you have to do
- 1:09:00is look around at the varying relationships and people of different sizes and and you
- 1:09:08know they're not faking it. Right, if you see someone marrying someone who
- 1:09:13is who has a larger body, it's not like the person marrying the person
- 1:09:18with the larger body is faking it. You know, it's it's real,
- 1:09:21the attraction, the romantic attraction, everything. So and for these individuals,
- 1:09:29they're not they're not quote unquote settling for someone with larger with a larger body,
- 1:09:32that's the you know, that's they're they're attracted to that person. And
- 1:09:38maybe it doesn't have anything to do with the body size, because personality is
- 1:09:43deeper than one's body, right, But but maybe does Maybe the person's type
- 1:09:47is literally someone that is has a larger body. So those people are out
- 1:09:53there now for those people that are attracted to people with larger bodies or have
- 1:09:59that as an option in terms of their type, repertoire, if you will.
- 1:10:02Might some of them avoid dating people with larger bodies because of the stigma.
- 1:10:06Yeah, I imagine that that does happen. But you know, attraction
- 1:10:12is hard to mitigate, and if people are given a chance to fall in
- 1:10:19love or meet each other and fall in love, then often stigma doesn't stand
- 1:10:28a chance against that. So I have total faith that if you were to
- 1:10:32date enough people, you would find a lot of people would be attracted to
- 1:10:38you and and it would be genuine. And you talk about having a schema
- 1:10:44around this, which I totally understand. I imagine most people with large bodies
- 1:10:49have this schema. Not everyone, but but I imagine most, if not
- 1:10:55all, the people who don't let it get to them have either done enough
- 1:11:00work or they were protected to some extent by their circumstances or family or something.
- 1:11:05But the way we address those schemes is through corrective experiences. And so
- 1:11:13you know, you can't really do this in therapy. Exactly. It could
- 1:11:15be facilitated through therapy, but the corrective experience that you're looking for is for
- 1:11:21someone to be attracted to you for who you are and for your body,
- 1:11:27and a therapist can't do that, which is unfortunate because you know, then
- 1:11:31you have to just enter into the general pool of people out there, the
- 1:11:38fish in the sea, which is hard for everyone regardless of body size.
- 1:11:42So a therapist can help you with that, to help you to you know,
- 1:11:46whether the storms, so to speak. But you absolutely deserve that.
- 1:11:51And you were saying earlier like that you won't believe me, And I suspect
- 1:11:58that as I say this, that all the things that I'm saying, that
- 1:12:02your schema is much louder in your mind than me saying this. But you
- 1:12:06know, every bit helps, so I would continue to talk to others a
- 1:12:13therapist. Also go online. There's a lot of you know, body positivity
- 1:12:18movements sort of content on the internet that you can absorb. For me,
- 1:12:27when I am trying to rid myself of the schemas and the messages about society
- 1:12:34about body shape and size, it pretty quickly becomes dismantled when I listen to
- 1:12:44people who know what they're talking about. Lyndy West, for example, she
- 1:12:47completely blew my mind. I don't know, like fifteen years ago, she
- 1:12:51was locally famous here in Seattle, and I can't remember where I heard her
- 1:12:57talk, Maybe a podcast or something maybe about gamer Gate, I don't know,
- 1:13:01but the way that Lyndy West talks it just I felt like I felt
- 1:13:09a similar feeling, like with my mentor Phil Kushman when he would talk about
- 1:13:14society and history and personality and psychology and other kinds of things. And I
- 1:13:20would listen to Phil Kushman, and as I would listen to him, I
- 1:13:24would just feel this like physical you know, like in the Bible when Saul
- 1:13:30has the fish scales fall from his eyes and now he can see the light.
- 1:13:35It's a similar feelings. There's a physical feeling to it. When I
- 1:13:39was listening to Lyddy West, it was similar. I just remember her talking
- 1:13:44about fat phobia and I just remember thinking like, oh my god, yes,
- 1:13:49this makes so much sense. So seeking that sort of content out,
- 1:13:56I think would help. You know, if you're really lost in your own
- 1:13:59mind, and given the way that you're you're talking, you're really just lost
- 1:14:04to the messages that you've been that you've internalized from abusive messaging to you,
- 1:14:12And if you just stew in that, in that in those voices, then
- 1:14:18you truly are going to be lost there. There's there's no thinking your way
- 1:14:24out of this you you have to be exposed to the truth and you have
- 1:14:28to start having experiences along those lines, So you know I would do.
- 1:14:31There's also support groups and other kinds of activities for people, so you know
- 1:14:38I would look into that sort of thing. But if it's one thing,
- 1:14:42if you believe me about one thing, if you've ever believed anything that I've
- 1:14:45said, believe me on this one thing. That you have so much worth.
- 1:14:51You are as worthy as anyone else on the planet, and you have
- 1:14:58so much to give, and someone out there, a number of people really
- 1:15:04want what you have to give. They wouldn't be settling to be with you.
- 1:15:10They would deeply desire to be with you because they're lonely in the same
- 1:15:15way that everyone else is lonely, right, and they want contact, and
- 1:15:20they want someone just like you to love them and be attracted to them.
- 1:15:26You are a wonderful human being and all those voices that have told you otherwise
- 1:15:31are complete bullshit, and let's get angry at it. It's next to emails
- 1:15:38from middle tier patron Erica from Tampa, Florida. She says, I have
- 1:15:42a friend that I believe may qualify for dependent personality disorder. The unique thing
- 1:15:47about her is that she is an identical twin that relies heavily on our twin
- 1:15:53but also on a significant other. We became friends a few years ago before
- 1:15:58she went through a nasty divorce, but I noticed she immediately wanted to find
- 1:16:00another partner and fantasized about her life with someone she had only been with on
- 1:16:05a few dates. I am curious if she displays these tendencies because she is
- 1:16:11very closely bonded to her twin, and if twins are more likely to have
- 1:16:14these types of dependent behaviors and of email. So the answer to your question
- 1:16:19is no, twins aren't more likely to develop dependent personalite order. But I
- 1:16:25could see why you would think that dependent personalite order is very particular, and
- 1:16:31it has to do often not only with being dependent on people, but also
- 1:16:36being under functioning. So someone who is you know, the description that you
- 1:16:43give to me here is that she went through a nasty divorce and then she
- 1:16:47immediately wanted to find another partner. That's not necessarily that could be a hallmark
- 1:16:54of dependent personality, but dependent people ondependent personality disorder spectrum. Remember that they
- 1:17:00have a schema that they're incompetent that they need not only to find a partner
- 1:17:05necessarily, but they need someone to do everything for them because they inherently believe
- 1:17:13that they can't do things on their own. So they're helpless, and they
- 1:17:17often have a codependent overfunctioner who is in their life also with a mirror image
- 1:17:25of their issues. You know, the issues of the codependent person are you
- 1:17:29know, similar, but they manifest as I'm going to control someone else or
- 1:17:32take care of someone else. So it's possible that what you're observing if if
- 1:17:40this individual is you know, very needy of other people, that it has
- 1:17:45to do with some some other personality spectrum or construct that we would talk about,
- 1:17:50maybe borderline, I don't know. But the other thing is that,
- 1:17:55uh, you know, I'm guessing Erica, if we could talk for a
- 1:17:59long time, your friend, that there would be more data there. But
- 1:18:02so this might not be applicable. But for people when they go through a
- 1:18:08difficult breakup, a nasty divorce for example, and they very quickly start dating
- 1:18:15and start fantasizing about spending the rest of their life with that person, you
- 1:18:20know, it's not necessarily a problem. It can be it's often pathologized and
- 1:18:26pete friends and family will worry about it, like, oh my god,
- 1:18:29all you just got divorced six months ago and now all of a sudden you
- 1:18:32have this like really intense relationship. And yeah, I mean, could it
- 1:18:38be a destructive thing, sure, But I find that in our society there's
- 1:18:43this very quick judgment about that sort of thing, and I find that to
- 1:18:47be unfair to people. Could it be a problem, sure, But the
- 1:18:54opposite could be a problem. You know. The ideal that people will often
- 1:18:57talk about is after a breakup, particularly difficult one is that you would stay
- 1:19:01single for a while, maybe not even date for a while. And that
- 1:19:05can be a problem too. But you're not going to get a lot of
- 1:19:08people that will shame that. They'll be like, oh good, you're finding
- 1:19:11yourself or something. And if that's what someone wants to do, then that's
- 1:19:14what someone wants to do. But that can also be a problem. The
- 1:19:16person might be avoiding their needs for romance and sex and companionship, and you
- 1:19:23know it might have low self esteem because of their breakup, so they don't
- 1:19:26think anyone would ever date them, and you know that that's a problem.
- 1:19:30Their needs aren't being met. Sometimes rebound relationships are just what the doctor ordered.
- 1:19:36Now, hopefully for the individuals in the rebound relationship, everyone is somewhat
- 1:19:44aware of that possibility, you know, so you don't over commit or tell
- 1:19:49someone you know, give someone the wrong expectations and that sort of thing.
- 1:19:53But you know, there's nothing wrong with that. But you know, if
- 1:19:57you heard a friend that just went through an ascy divorce and they came to
- 1:20:00you and they're just like, you know what, I just want to get
- 1:20:03into another committed relationship, a rebound relationship for six months because I just don't
- 1:20:12want to be alone through the next six months. You're not going to find
- 1:20:15a lot of friends that are going to smile at that. You're going to
- 1:20:18find a lot of people to be like. That sounds really pathological, and
- 1:20:21it can be, but it's not necessarily pathological. So I'm guessing, though,
- 1:20:27Eric, if we could, you know, if you could tell me
- 1:20:29more, there's I'm guessing more indications of neediness and lack of self esteem or
- 1:20:34desperation. And that's really the key is how desperate is is? She?
- 1:20:42Is? It? Just like And the other thing I'll say is that sometimes
- 1:20:46in the randomness of life, you just happen to meet the one after you
- 1:20:51go through a nasty divorce. It happens. You can go through a real
- 1:20:57nasty divorce and then just by happenstance, the person you meet at work or
- 1:21:03over tender or whatever, or you just say, you know what, I
- 1:21:08just want to hook up with someone. Sometimes that person that you meet is
- 1:21:13kind of inconveniently present right after a nasty divorce, because a lot of people
- 1:21:20are going to stigmatize the fact that you're just going to start up another relationship.
- 1:21:24You know, sometimes that happens, and when you find the one,
- 1:21:27when you find the person that really works with you, then it's kind of
- 1:21:31stupid to just throw that away because people don't think you've had enough time from
- 1:21:38your nasty divorce. So, you know, it's just it's hard to know.
- 1:21:42And the other thing that you're saying is that she was fantasizing about her
- 1:21:45life with someone she'd only been on a few dates with. You know,
- 1:21:48again, I'd have to hear more to pathologize that it's not inherently pathological.
- 1:21:56I find that a lot of friends have a lot of anxiety, and it
- 1:21:59makes sense that she went through a real nasty divorce and you, Erica,
- 1:22:03were there with her going through the nasty divorce, supporting her, and then
- 1:22:10once the you know, once the nasty divorce is over, then all of
- 1:22:15a sudden, she's dating again, and you're just like, shit is She's
- 1:22:18just going to repeat the same pattern and then I'm going to have to watch
- 1:22:23her suffer, which I don't want to do. And I wish more people
- 1:22:27in your position Erica would reflect on that and just say I'm experiencing anxiety and
- 1:22:33I'm worried and it hurts me to watch her do this, and then just
- 1:22:38tell her that, right, instead of diagnosing and trying to predict the future
- 1:22:43of your friend, just say, like, another issue for you, Erica,
- 1:22:47is like you might feel like your friend doesn't fully recognize all that you've
- 1:22:53done for her during the nasty divorce. You know. The other thing I'll
- 1:22:58say is that it's possible that you are the codependent overfunctioner. There's no indication
- 1:23:05here, but there's some minor yellow flags that your friend the twin is an
- 1:23:13under functioner and incompetent in a lot of ways, or acting incompetent, and
- 1:23:18you're the one who, due to your past, feels responsible to help her
- 1:23:23with that, which can increase your anxiety as she starts to do things that
- 1:23:28seem reckless, like dating someone and fantasizing about spending the rest of life with
- 1:23:32them, and then you start to get upset and angry and you want to
- 1:23:38diagnose her with something. Yeah, it's a really short email, so I'm
- 1:23:43throwing out just a lot of different possibilities. It's also possible that she is
- 1:23:48dependent personality and that it would be best to sort of manage the relationship from
- 1:23:55that perspective, because you're not going to be able to change it if she
- 1:23:58does have a personality disorder, And you know you could be a friend but
- 1:24:02not necessarily to dependent on her being healthy. You know that you can you
- 1:24:10can be friends with someone who is spiraling right without necessarily getting upset at them
- 1:24:15or trying to change them. So you know you could be looking at a
- 1:24:18situation like that as well. I don't know. So I just got this
- 1:24:21email from a long time listener of the podcast ed and I know some of
- 1:24:29you out there on the Facebook fan page know of him. And I asked
- 1:24:33him if it's okay if I could read his email on the air, and
- 1:24:36he said yeah, And I want to read this email because it's just so
- 1:24:42great. It's really great for me to get an email like this from Ed
- 1:24:47because, as you know, someone who talks in this microphone all day long,
- 1:24:54it feels good to have certain people that I know one time one fan
- 1:25:01of the year at least, I believe that's the award that I gave him,
- 1:25:08and I sent him a mug and anyway, it feels you know,
- 1:25:14for some of you who have been listening for a long time, you might
- 1:25:18not have ever emailed in, and so I have no idea who you are,
- 1:25:24and that's fine because you know, what are you gonna do. And
- 1:25:28for a lot of you who have emailed in, I you know, read
- 1:25:32the emails, but I don't necessarily know who you are as a person.
- 1:25:36You know, So there's only a small set of people who I feel like
- 1:25:42I know to some extent kind of, and it feels good to have return
- 1:25:50emails from those people like Ed, because it just has a continuity to it.
- 1:25:57You know. I don't know why this is coming up for me,
- 1:26:00but I'm talking to this microphone a lot, make a lot of content.
- 1:26:04I've been doing it for fifteen years, and most of the people in my
- 1:26:09personal life have no idea what I talk about in this podcast. My wife
- 1:26:13doesn't even listen to the audio podcast. I mean occasionally she will, but
- 1:26:15it's pretty rare. So there's this intimate world in which I'm talking. You
- 1:26:21know, my other co host Berto, Rebecca Bob. They probably don't listen.
- 1:26:26They're probably not listening to this episode because it's I don't know if I'm
- 1:26:30guessing they might listen to their episodes that they're in, but an episode like
- 1:26:34this, I'm guessing they're not listening to. So no one in my personal
- 1:26:39life knows what you and I have, and it feels like something big to
- 1:26:46me. It feels significant to me what you and I have in this podcast
- 1:26:53relationship. And I don't get a chance to interact with anyone really in my
- 1:27:00personal life about what this is because you know, sometimes I'll be talking with
- 1:27:06Stacy and I'll be like, yeah, you know that came this came up,
- 1:27:10this, this was a huge thing in the podcast a couple of months
- 1:27:13ago, and I and then I remember, oh, that's right. You
- 1:27:17don't listen to the podcast, so you have no idea like this whole drama
- 1:27:20that happened on the podcast last month. It's just you have no idea what
- 1:27:26that is, and so it. I guess that's another reason why it just
- 1:27:30feels good to get an email like this. So I thought i'd just read
- 1:27:33it. What's up? What's up? My Pacific Northwest psychoanalytic brother, Ed's
- 1:27:40another therapist. Been a bit since I've emailed, but be assured, I'm
- 1:27:45always listening. It's ten pm here in New York, and I just mustered
- 1:27:47the energy to get up and make some eggs. So, of course,
- 1:27:51so Ed has COVID similar to me, and so Ed saying I finally got
- 1:28:00the energy to makes it makes So of course I did what I always do
- 1:28:03and popped on an episode of psychology in Seattle to listen to while I cook
- 1:28:08and eat. And I listened to your episode Kirk health Woes. You know
- 1:28:11the episode rest talking about having COVID. Yeah, me too. After evading
- 1:28:15it all this time, I tested positive for COVID last Tuesday, the eighth.
- 1:28:19I believe what a suckfest. I saw fish at Madison Square Garden on
- 1:28:25July twenty nine. In August fifth, so perhaps I got it there.
- 1:28:29Mom's been in and out of the hospital, so maybe there, But who
- 1:28:31knows. My doctor prescribed pax Lovid, which was an ordeal in itself.
- 1:28:36I'm three days off of it, still feel pretty crappy, hoping not to
- 1:28:41have a rebound case. My wife Sue has it too. I did two
- 1:28:45sessions today as a therapist, right. I was pretty exhausted after. I'm
- 1:28:50going to do one tomorrow and continue to rest Tomorrow as our twenty fifth anniversary
- 1:28:56me and Sue. Did you know the twenty fifth nursary is actually the COVID
- 1:29:00anniversary. Uh yeah, I was along those lines. I mean, Stacy's
- 1:29:08birthday is today that I'm recording this, and she turned fifty, which is
- 1:29:15a big deal. I turned fifty two and a half years ago in the
- 1:29:18middle of the of the lock, you know, the middle of the pandemic,
- 1:29:21so I didn't have any sort of party, but I didn't have COVID
- 1:29:26at the time, so at least Stacy and I had a little party for
- 1:29:29the for my birthday, I'm pretty sure. Anyway, So anyway, you're
- 1:29:33ed having your twenty fifth anniversary, which is the COVID anniversary together and I,
- 1:29:39uh yeah. And it comments on what I was getting at in the
- 1:29:44episode. I was talking about this where although these are small losses, there's
- 1:29:48still losses, and so many of us have lost so many things. And
- 1:29:55you know, some people emailed in and we're talking about how they got COVID,
- 1:30:00you know, two years ago, three years ago, and they're still
- 1:30:02not feeling okay. They still are tired and unable to think clearly because COVID
- 1:30:11really messed them up. And yeah, I mean there's so much of that
- 1:30:16that has been going on, and and how shitty it feels to go through
- 1:30:21that, and especially when so many people either sweeping under the rug or they're
- 1:30:27just like, look, people get sick, it's just a flu like move
- 1:30:30on in life, or or they think that you're a whimp because you're scared
- 1:30:35of COVID, or you're a whimp because you didn't recover fast enough, like
- 1:30:41and it must be your fault, like you don't have a healthy lifestyle or
- 1:30:44whatever. And you know, it sucks, and as exemplified by my wife
- 1:30:51crying into her left ors, you know, it just breaks my heart all
- 1:30:56the suffering and pain. And for you too, Ed, you and your
- 1:31:00wife and your anniversary, you know, it sucks. So going out with
- 1:31:04your email, did you know that the twenty fifth anniversary is the COVID anniversary.
- 1:31:09We're going to eat soup. It'll be wild. We got married in
- 1:31:13Connecticut twenty five years ago. Actually, you got married on my wife's birthday.
- 1:31:18It was blazing hot outdoor ceremony. I saw a sweat coming through the
- 1:31:24front of my best man's suit. It was a hot one makes for a
- 1:31:28good funny memory. We have found musical common ground Ben Folds. I love
- 1:31:32him. I think he's an absolute genius. You know, I was talking
- 1:31:35about how I won't be able to see him because or I was thinking I
- 1:31:42wasn't going to be able to see him, And it turns out that,
- 1:31:44yeah, I probably can't go to the show saw him last September at the
- 1:31:48theater here on Long Island. What a treat I was supposed to go.
- 1:31:53So then he talks about other things that he had to miss out on,
- 1:31:58and then he says, at least the indictment, the fourth indictment provided some
- 1:32:01entertainment. And hope yesterday and today, Yeah, I hope that you and
- 1:32:05Stacy are getting to feeling better now and getting back to your lives. Goes
- 1:32:10without saying. The podcast continues to teach me so much and bring so much
- 1:32:14joy. Those are my COVID adult ramblings. Yeah, so we're not really
- 1:32:20back to our lives. Although I did do a lot of chores today,
- 1:32:25which felt good. I actually washed all of the bedding because in my time,
- 1:32:31and you know that it was when I was bedridden. I felt like
- 1:32:33I was sweating a lot, you know, having fever, and I was
- 1:32:39also eating in bed because I couldn't sit up. Stacy would make me a
- 1:32:43bagel and then I would just kind of scoop it into my mouth while I
- 1:32:46was laying down. So I was pretty sure there's a lot of crumbs around.
- 1:32:49So it felt good to clean all the bedding. All right, let's
- 1:32:54take a break. All right, this episode was going and long, but
- 1:33:00I am going to try to actually get to all these upper tier patron emails.
- 1:33:05Okay, This next emails from middle tier patron from Latvia. She says
- 1:33:11that she has preoccupied attachment a textbook case. I guess, she said,
- 1:33:15and then she has a question. I tend to end up in friendships that
- 1:33:19I think are safe and intimate, but as soon as something more challenging happens
- 1:33:24in my life where I would need a bit of support. For example,
- 1:33:27my grandma passing or my divorce. My close friends tend to disappear. I
- 1:33:31feel like I'm shutting down after all these experiences. What advice would you give
- 1:33:35to someone with preoccupied attachment to cultivate safe and close friendships. I am in
- 1:33:41long term therapy, so I have that part covered end of email. Well,
- 1:33:45it's hard to tell patron from that via. On one hand, it's
- 1:33:50possible that you just have terrible friends who are jerk faces, and it's just
- 1:33:57been unlucky that you've had these sorts of friends, So that's possible. Another
- 1:34:04possibility is that if you do have a severe enough case of preoccupied attachment,
- 1:34:11that either the people that you choose to be friends with are particular in this
- 1:34:17way in that so sometimes, and this is not always the case, of
- 1:34:23course, but sometimes people with preoccupied attachment will tend to match up well with
- 1:34:30in a somewhat pathological way, with people that are takers. Because for the
- 1:34:34preoccupied person, they're so desperate for any semblance of attunement and security that they
- 1:34:43will make excuses about relationships and people so that they can be in denial about
- 1:34:49the reality of it so they can keep the relationship going. And then when
- 1:34:55it's really clear that they're not the sort of people that give you know,
- 1:35:00like preoccupied people might work well with narcissistic people, not always, but they
- 1:35:03can. And so the narcisstic person, the legit, not the Internet version
- 1:35:11of a narcism, but the legit narsisistic person doesn't have the capacity, doesn't
- 1:35:15notice that you're suffering. So, you know, there's a possibility that you
- 1:35:20have a lot of jerk faced friends, and it has to do with your
- 1:35:23proccupied attachment, you know, because it affects the sort of people that you
- 1:35:28establish relationships with. The other possibility is that you have friends that are capable
- 1:35:35of caring for you, but due to your preoccupied attachment, you have reactivity
- 1:35:41to them that pushes them away. For example, let's say that you're going
- 1:35:47through your divorce and there's a lot of triggering that's happening to you, and
- 1:35:53you reach out to a friend, you text them in the middle of the
- 1:35:56day. You're having a crisis and you're just like, I'm going through kind
- 1:35:59of hard time and I need support right now. And the friend is busy
- 1:36:08for some reason, a legit reason. You know, they have their own
- 1:36:12life, so they get the text and they care, but they can't reply
- 1:36:17right away, but they do plan on replying, and then they after work,
- 1:36:24they get the kids to bed or whatever, and then they reply and
- 1:36:27they say, oh, my god, tell me what's going on. Well,
- 1:36:30in the eight hours that it took him to reply to you, you
- 1:36:33might have downward spiraled with them, given your traumas such that when you get
- 1:36:40that text finally after eight hours, you hate that person or are very very
- 1:36:45hurt by that person, and then it might be reflected in your response like
- 1:36:51wow, eight hours later, you might say, or you might be so
- 1:36:57upset that you don't even reply, or something like you know, who knows.
- 1:37:00I don't. I'm not accusing you of anything. I don't know.
- 1:37:02But in your email, you're saying you have a textbook case of preoccupied attachment,
- 1:37:06which makes me think that there's a there's probably some distorting that's going on
- 1:37:13for you and overreactivity, because that's the hallmarkt preoccupied attachment, and there's no
- 1:37:16way around that. You can't really change that until you get enough healing,
- 1:37:24and so that's another possibility. I would give that the strongest possibility that the
- 1:37:31and what that'll do is that you will have quote unquote close friends, but
- 1:37:39they might be real short because at some point these sorts of things will happen
- 1:37:45and you'll feel very betrayed and you will act out and people will be confused
- 1:37:53or hurt or you know, they have their own personality issues and then they
- 1:37:57reject you, and then that locks in that occupied attachment, right, so
- 1:38:01you know, I don't know, but that would be what I would explore.
- 1:38:06The key is that you deserve to have support and close friends. And
- 1:38:13if you do have severe preoccupied attachment, unless you are really actively working against
- 1:38:20your impulses, then relationships are going to be intense and then they're going to
- 1:38:27blow up there. So you have to have a lot of systems in place
- 1:38:32to avoid that. Like you would go to your friends and say, look,
- 1:38:38I have preoccupied attachment. You know, before you feel betrayed by a
- 1:38:42friend, you say, look, I have this problem. Here's how it
- 1:38:45plays out, and here's how you could help me with it. And if
- 1:38:48I ever lash out at you, it's because I'm misinterpreting something which happens sometimes,
- 1:38:56and so please just work with me on it or something, you know,
- 1:39:00like, unless you have a system like that, in all likelihood especially
- 1:39:05if you have severe preaccupied attachment. The relationship is going to trigger you.
- 1:39:10You're going to react, they're going to reject, they're going to wonder what's
- 1:39:15happening and walk away, and then you're going to be even more traumatized by
- 1:39:18yet another relationship that ends, even though the person did care and did have
- 1:39:24the capacity. But you know, given the way things play out, it
- 1:39:29just keeps repeating itself. So you know, that's my guess. And you're
- 1:39:33in therapy, so your therapist would know a billion times more than I do
- 1:39:38about this. Right. Sext email is from upper tier patron Moirat. She
- 1:39:42says, there's a study that shows that the methodology of therapy doesn't matter for
- 1:39:47results, and this is called the Dodo Bird study. They are saying that
- 1:39:55it's the results that matter, and too many therapists are hung up on methodology,
- 1:39:58which can stagnate therapy, resulting in poor outcomes. I wanted to know
- 1:40:01if you agreed or not and why or why not? Here is to study
- 1:40:05linked below end of email. Yeah, so, there has been a fair
- 1:40:11amount of research in the last thirty years comparing the different methods of therapy,
- 1:40:17whether it's psychodynamic, or CBT or narrative or EFT or something and what you
- 1:40:28know, there's a lot of different things I can talk about this. It's
- 1:40:30pretty complicated, but long story short, the consensus seems to be that it
- 1:40:38doesn't matter necessarily or it doesn't matter. But when they look at the cause
- 1:40:45of positive outcomes and therapy, you know, when they're trying to figure out
- 1:40:50the difference between therapy that works, in therapy that doesn't work, the method
- 1:40:56of therapy, the theoretical orientation you know, CBT s, wantalytic, humanistic,
- 1:41:00that kind of thing that only attributes to something like ten percent of the
- 1:41:08change in the outcome. And and there are other things that are much more
- 1:41:13important, like circumstances for the client, or the client's resources, the internal
- 1:41:18resources of the client, or the relationship the relationship between therapist. And this
- 1:41:24is off top of my head, so don't quote me on all this,
- 1:41:26but the relationship between the therapists and the client is much more important the quote.
- 1:41:30You know, the strength of the relationship is something like thirty percent of
- 1:41:35the outcome of therapyist is dependent on the relationship and only ten percent is dependent
- 1:41:42on the type of therapy that's being used. And this is a pretty revolutionary,
- 1:41:46shocking result because when you talk to therapists, and particularly when you think
- 1:41:53about training programs, and especially when you talk to the insular groups of therapy,
- 1:42:00you know, methods like CBT or psychoanalytic, they will talk about how
- 1:42:04their model of therapy is so important, right, and that sometimes the other
- 1:42:10types of therapy are all bullshit. You know, it's it's It wouldn't be
- 1:42:14unusual for a psychodynamic therapist or humanistic therapist to call cognitive behavioral therapy a sham,
- 1:42:21and vice versa. So this Dodo Bird study Dodo Bird meaning that I
- 1:42:29think it's an allegory from a Lewis Carroll book for you know Alison Wonderland,
- 1:42:34where there's a race, you know, the Alison Wonderland. It's the psychedelic
- 1:42:42kind of nonsensical thing. And Alice comes upon these creatures that are racing.
- 1:42:48They're gonna they're about to have her. I don't know if I have this
- 1:42:51right, but they're going to have this race, and they will, you
- 1:42:57know. They say go and then everyone runs random directions, I think,
- 1:43:00and then the person that is running the race says, everyone wins. I
- 1:43:06think I have that right. I don't know, and I think the Dodo
- 1:43:11birds somehows and well, I don't know. I could be wrong about all
- 1:43:14that, but that's the metaphor that I think of when I hear about these
- 1:43:17sorts of things, that it doesn't matter what sort of therapy model you use,
- 1:43:25as long as you use one of them and you care about it,
- 1:43:27then seems to affect things. What's more important are these other things that are
- 1:43:30completely outside of theory, And Okay, so what do I think about it?
- 1:43:36Well, it depends on the conclusion that people have, because I think
- 1:43:42the simplistic conclusion is that theory doesn't matter and you shouldn't bother learning theory,
- 1:43:49and I think that's a big mistake, because yes, the other thing that
- 1:43:56I'll say is that whenever we lump in quote unquote all therapists and all clients
- 1:44:03and all therapy modalities into one bucket, it's it's really weird, really,
- 1:44:11And I get it because I remember when I was younger, I saw it
- 1:44:14this way. But the more experienced I got, the more I'm like,
- 1:44:16why are we doing this? You know, like if you just said in
- 1:44:20the medical world, if you said, like you lumped all of medicine and
- 1:44:27all patients and all types of treatment into one bucket. You know, like
- 1:44:31you have all the medications, all the different classes of medication, and then
- 1:44:36all the types of surgeries, and you have dentistry and pedietry and ob gyn
- 1:44:44and neurology and psychiatry. You know, you put in cancer treatments and and
- 1:44:53everything. You just throw everything into one bucket and then you say does medicine
- 1:44:59work? Well, you know, you're throwing a heterogeneous thing. There's too
- 1:45:05many types of things in there. So the question might be worthy, but
- 1:45:11it's much more relevant to say, does this particular cancer treatment work for this
- 1:45:17particular type of cancer? Right, and you look at the outcomes there.
- 1:45:21So with therapy, why don't we do that? Because people come to therapy
- 1:45:26for a variety of reasons. They might come in because they want to quit
- 1:45:30smoking, or they might want to self actualize, or their marriage might be
- 1:45:35falling apart, or they might have trauma, or they might be depressed.
- 1:45:39You know, there's just literally millions of types of reasons why people come to
- 1:45:44therapy. So the question, a much more relevant question is what types of
- 1:45:49therapy tend to work for those particular issues and those studies are much more illustrative
- 1:45:59of what sort of models people should be using. The other thing, the
- 1:46:03other conclusion, there's a lot of research in this area, which is that
- 1:46:08knowing a lot of the theories, and especially the main ones, and knowing
- 1:46:12them well and being able to tailor the treatment to the clients that of the
- 1:46:16other way around has much better outcomes for the client. So that doesn't when
- 1:46:23I read all that research, that doesn't tell me that theory doesn't matter.
- 1:46:28It absolutely does. The other thing that I pull, and I've talked about
- 1:46:30this and I'm ranted about it many times, is that when in these studies
- 1:46:35they say that thirty percent or something of the outcome depends on the relationship,
- 1:46:40whereas only ten percent depends on the model. Well, when I hear that
- 1:46:45the relationship matters more than the model. For some models, the relationship is
- 1:46:49the model. For attachment oriented therapy, for transference oriented therapy, for humanistic
- 1:47:00therapy. These are explicitly about the relationship. So if you find that the
- 1:47:06relationship is so important to the two positive outcomes and therapy, to me,
- 1:47:14you're hearing attachment oriented therapy is very important, and transference based, you know,
- 1:47:21psychodynamic relationship based therapy is very important. Humanistic therapy is very important,
- 1:47:28particularly the kinds that focus on the relationship, right, making sure that it's
- 1:47:33a good alliance, making sure there's a good bond, making sure that there's
- 1:47:38a lot of goodwill there that the client feels cared for. So those are,
- 1:47:44you know, explicitly human in some humanistic camps, those are that's explicitly
- 1:47:49attachment orient therapy. Right, So this idea that the model doesn't matter,
- 1:47:55it's like, well, but I think what these studies find is that relationship
- 1:48:00orient therapies are very, very important. And yeah, certainly absolutely learned cognitive
- 1:48:09therapy, learning behavioral therapy. There's some important elements there that you should be
- 1:48:14using in your therapy with particular clients at particular times, but you definitely should
- 1:48:20be learning humanistic attachment orient therapy. That's my thoughts on that, right.
- 1:48:26Sext emails from anonymous Upteer patrons, she says, Hi, doctor Kirkanna,
- 1:48:30I'm struggling with avoidance, introversion and people pleasing schemas. Avoidance, introversion and
- 1:48:36people pleasing schemas. I recently went on a trip with my cousin and some
- 1:48:41friends, and I felt moderately uncomfortable the whole time, I feel like my
- 1:48:45people pleasing tendencies that with my people pleasing tendencies, I frequently dismiss my needs
- 1:48:49as selfish, bad and always doubt my perceptions. The frequent thoughts I had
- 1:48:55during the trip are am I being too fussy? Or judgy for not liking
- 1:49:00the way things are done? So just chiming in? Yeah, so hard
- 1:49:06to know exactly, But that doesn't mean even if you are being fussy.
- 1:49:12What I tell people with this problem is the question of are am I being
- 1:49:18too fussy? Am I being too judgey? Am I being too quick to
- 1:49:24be upset about something? That is not the best question to focus on,
- 1:49:29because you can't really know that in the moment, and in all likelihood you
- 1:49:34are often answering that in the positive, like, yes, I am being
- 1:49:40too fussy and my feelings don't matter. The other thing is that even if
- 1:49:45you are being too fussy, that doesn't mean that you just shut up and
- 1:49:48put up. For me, I am not. I mean, I have
- 1:49:54people pleasing tendencies, but I have bigger parts of my personality that mandate that
- 1:50:00I say something when I'm bothered by something, or I indicate it or something.
- 1:50:05And so for me, I know that sometimes I am being too fussy,
- 1:50:10but I still fucking say it. Now. I don't demand, but
- 1:50:15I'll say I don't know if I'm being too fussy, but I don't like
- 1:50:17this and I don't want to do it. There was a moment with my
- 1:50:23friends I went on a trip before the pandemic, and it was we were
- 1:50:29at Tahoe skiing and we were walking outside to kind of walk around the town,
- 1:50:34and it in that moment was very snowy and windy, and I was
- 1:50:39I was not in a good mood to begin with. I think I needed
- 1:50:43a nap, and the four of us head outside and we're gonna we start
- 1:50:47walking, and I just said, I just abruptly said to my three childhood
- 1:50:53friends that I was annoyed with the snow and the wind and the you know,
- 1:50:58the sleet like hitting my face. That I was going home and I
- 1:51:02just said, this annoys me. And I turned around and I went back
- 1:51:04to the hotel room and took it out. Was I being fussing in the
- 1:51:09moment, Yeah, I was. I being kind of a dick with the
- 1:51:12way I was saying it. Yeah, But I don't care because I deserve
- 1:51:16to assert myself and I didn't bother them, and I extracted myself. So
- 1:51:21you know, being too fussy doesn't mean you shut up. You know,
- 1:51:26you go on. Maybe there are the type of people I like to see,
- 1:51:30and maybe these people are type of people I like to see in frequently.
- 1:51:33Try me in here. Yeah, you know, it can be annoying
- 1:51:38to hang out with certain people for a long period of time, certain kinds
- 1:51:42of people. So absolutely, I keep putting so many people in this category.
- 1:51:46What's wrong with me? Why do I hate people just chemming in here?
- 1:51:50Yeah, it's possible that I doubt you hate people. I think that's
- 1:51:55often the phrase that people will use, and I think that's actually self destructive
- 1:51:59too. Ify that way, because I don't think that's what's happening. It'd
- 1:52:03be weird if you were actually disliking people and didn't want to have fun with
- 1:52:10people. The problem could be that if you do have, particularly if you
- 1:52:14have severe introversion, that you're really only you can really only tolerate particular kinds
- 1:52:20of interactions for a particular amount of time. If you see, you went
- 1:52:27on a trip with your cousin and some friends, Yeah, if you're introverted,
- 1:52:30that is really going to challenge things unless you're very cognizant of your needs
- 1:52:35and you tell everyone that you're introverted and you need time to recharge, you
- 1:52:41need time alone. So if you were stuck, especially if you're in a
- 1:52:45hotel room with everyone or something, then yeah, you're going to get annoyed
- 1:52:49really fast, because essentially what's happening is your brain is being taxed to the
- 1:52:56max. In an ideal situ you spend time with friends because you want to
- 1:53:03and you don't hate people, but your brain is working really hard to stay
- 1:53:10engaged, particularly in a larger group like that, or you know, so
- 1:53:15you know you like it, but you only want to do it for an
- 1:53:17hour maybe at the most, and then you want to go back to isolation
- 1:53:24or maybe just one friend or something and you just want to look at your
- 1:53:28phone or watch TV or do some work or something. And then you do
- 1:53:32that for five hours and then you spend another hour with your friends. So
- 1:53:38if you don't pay attention to that, and or you're being oppressed by a
- 1:53:43lot of extroverts, then you're it's natural to start having a lot of negative
- 1:53:47associations with socializing and start concluding maybe I hate people going on. Let's see,
- 1:53:56maybe it's because I'm masking and I'm not being myself. But being myself
- 1:54:00equals being more quiet? Is that being rude? I'm not sure how to
- 1:54:05approach this. Is that a symptom of avoiding attachment and therefore I should work
- 1:54:10on it? Is it just introversion? So I shouldn't force myself to change
- 1:54:15and to email? Yeah, well, I think I probably answered it to
- 1:54:17the best of my ability. Obviously I would talk with her therapist about this
- 1:54:23and explore it. All right, we've arrived at the last upper tier patron
- 1:54:26email anonymous annual patron from Arizona. She says, I'm a thirty six year
- 1:54:30old hetero asexual woman who grew up with an unfortunate collection of male role models
- 1:54:39through internal family systems, I have discovered that I have a little girl part
- 1:54:44of me who desperately wants love and affection from a father figure. But I
- 1:54:48don't know how to help this little girl inside of me. How does a
- 1:54:53thirty something woman find someone to play the role of her surrogate emotional father at
- 1:54:59this phase life? I sometimes daydream about how rapturous it would feel for this
- 1:55:04little girl to finally wind up in the safe and loving arms of a gentle,
- 1:55:09loving man who welcomes her. But I feel pessimistic about finding one that
- 1:55:14could handle a high level of childlike affection and cuddling. Our relationships where one
- 1:55:18person must fill the role left by an emotionally absent parent A recipe for disaster
- 1:55:24and of email, Well, I commend you, patron for being aware of
- 1:55:30this and going to therapy for it, because now you're at the beginning of
- 1:55:33a wonderful journey. And yeah, it sounds a little weird, but having
- 1:55:41an emotional father figure, at least for a time, is what you need
- 1:55:47and what you deserve. So the I think it's tempting to think of it
- 1:55:55as you would have a surrogate father who would you know, cuddle you and
- 1:56:01take care of you the way that you needed when you were four years old,
- 1:56:04this sort of thing, and you certainly could have a relationship like that.
- 1:56:10But I want to focus on the last part of your email here,
- 1:56:15where you're like, you know, our relationships where one person must fill the
- 1:56:19whole left by an emotionally absent parent A recipe for disaster. Well, the
- 1:56:25answer to that is every relationship is you know, filling an emotional hole left
- 1:56:32by our childhoods, meaning that all good relationship, my relationship with my wife
- 1:56:40is correcting for you know, whatever kind of traumas that we went through prior
- 1:56:45to us meeting each other, including our childhoods. So all close relationships are
- 1:56:54filling those holes. You know, there's nothing unusual about you. I think
- 1:57:00the differences is that you just really recognize the need that you have, and
- 1:57:03I guess it might be kind of particular, and that you really do identify
- 1:57:08a young girl inside of you that needs to be held and cared for.
- 1:57:14But you could have a romantic relationship with someone who temporarily is this way for
- 1:57:20you. It wouldn't be the dominant way, because it would be a two
- 1:57:24way relationship, right, So sometimes you'd be taking care of him and sometimes
- 1:57:29he'd be taking care of you. So you could absolutely have that and that
- 1:57:33would be very very normal. I think often we will hear stories about the
- 1:57:41opposite gender direction, where you have a woman who is very motherly to her
- 1:57:46husband and will take care of him when he's sick and will talk to him
- 1:57:51in a certain way at times that is that of a young boy and a
- 1:57:57mom. But you can absolutely have that in other direction gender wise, and
- 1:58:01you can just be conscious about it, you know, so you can make
- 1:58:05a deal with your the next partner you have or your current partner and say
- 1:58:11like, Okay, it's Tuesday. It's it's the day where you take care
- 1:58:15of me in the way that a father would, and I'm gonna talk and
- 1:58:19you're gonna listen, and you're gonna hold me the way a father might.
- 1:58:25And then on Thursdays, I'm gonna mother you. You know, there there's
- 1:58:30nothing wrong with that. You're gonna get a lot of side glances from people
- 1:58:34if you describe it. But this is a well understood, corrective experience for
- 1:58:42people that I think is happening all the time naturally anyway, for healthy couples,
- 1:58:47they might not word it this way or even be conscious that this is
- 1:58:51happening, but you know, these are things that are happening all right,
- 1:59:00next time you hear me. And aside from a rerun, and by the
- 1:59:03way, we're only doing one rerun a weekend now. We used to do
- 1:59:09two, but Stacy was telling me that we ran out of reruns, so
- 1:59:14we're kind of piecing it out a little bit more so, there's only one
- 1:59:18rerun on the weekend, but when we have new episodes coming out on Monday,
- 1:59:24I believe it'll be Amberto and Me, you know, going on our
- 1:59:29deep dive with the Duggers, the Dugger family, which I'm finding to be
- 1:59:32extremely fascinating, So tune into that. And everyone, please take care of
- 1:59:39yourself truly, because you deserve it. You really, really really do.