Latest / Migraine Relief Code with Dr. Amelia Scott Barrett, MD / Top 3 Things You Need to Know Before You Try Keto for MIgraine
Transcript
- 0:00Everybody seems to be talking about keto for migraine these days, so I want to give you
- 0:06three important pieces of information so that you can make the best decision for yourself
- 0:10about whether or not this is a piece of your recovery plan.
- 0:15So Doctor.
- 0:16Josh Turknet wrote a great book about keto for migraine, outlined how he recommends that
- 0:21people use it and the kind of results he is seeing.
- 0:24Doctor.
- 0:25Alina Gross created a ketone supplement for people with migraines called Brain Ritual.
- 0:33These have created a lot of talk about what this energy production type of headache is,
- 0:40this metabolic migraine.
- 0:42Who are the people who really benefit from keto and how do you do it safely?
- 0:49So those are some of the things that I'd like to explain to you.
- 0:53Question number one: Does keto actually work?
- 0:58And yes, it does.
- 0:59It can be a piece of a recovery plan for you if you have a certain type of migraine.
- 1:05Here's a study that was published in 2023, the EMI Keto trial.
- 1:11Basically what they did is they divided people with a high BMI above twenty seven who needed
- 1:18to lose weight anyway into two different types of diets either kind of a regular diet or a
- 1:24ketogenic diet.
- 1:26All right, and then they compared how the two different groups did.
- 1:29Now, people were having 10 to 15 headache days a month at baseline and one month after
- 1:38starting keto, their headaches had dropped by about five headache days per month.
- 1:43So they dropped down to having maybe five to 10 headache days per month instead.
- 1:49So I mean, it's not a cure, but it can be an important piece of your recovery plan if you
- 1:55are one of the people who has that type of migraine to where you are likely to benefit
- 2:02from it.
- 2:03So that brings us to our second point.
- 2:05How do you know if you are one of the people who could benefit from keto because it's not
- 2:10easy, right?
- 2:11Like low carb is not all that much fun.
- 2:15So if you're going to do all this work, how do you make an intelligent decision about whether
- 2:19or not this is likely to work for you?
- 2:21How long do you give it?
- 2:23How keto do you need to be.
- 2:26And so I think there's some useful guidelines to help us make these decisions.
- 2:30So if you have the energy production type of headache, which of course you can find out by
- 2:36going to theheadachequiz.com, If you have that type of headache, then you are more likely to
- 2:42benefit from keto.
- 2:44And here's why.
- 2:45So we've known for maybe twenty years that some people with migraine have suboptimal versions
- 2:51of a gene called SOD2.
- 2:54What does that have to do with anything?
- 2:56Alright.
- 2:57Here's how I want you to think of your cells.
- 2:59Your cells have an engine inside, makes the energy, makes the cell go.
- 3:05Right?
- 3:06For that fuel source, your brain can either use glucose and I want you to think of that as
- 3:11being like a regular gas burning car.
- 3:14Okay.
- 3:14It makes a lot of exhaust, you can flood the engine.
- 3:18There are all these things that can happen with that.
- 3:20Right?
- 3:20And then compare that to using ketones as an energy source, which are a lot cleaner.
- 3:27You don't flood the engine.
- 3:29You don't really make exhaust even.
- 3:33So it's a much cleaner fuel source.
- 3:36Now here's the key thing.
- 3:38For the people who have suboptimal versions of this SOD two gene, the what that gene does is
- 3:45it cleans up exhaust.
- 3:48Okay.
- 3:49So does it make sense now?
- 3:51Like, if you have problems clearing out that exhaust, you're not gonna do as well on this
- 3:56glucose fuel source.
- 3:58Glucose is just carbs.
- 4:00Right now if you if you don't if you have a great version of this gene it's not going to
- 4:05matter that much for you your body's cleaning up all that exhaust like not a problem like you
- 4:10passed your emissions test right I mean you know so for some people, keto is not going to
- 4:16make much of a difference, but for people who have that, a suboptimal version of that gene,
- 4:23keto is going to have a much bigger impact for them.
- 4:25Right?
- 4:26Okay.
- 4:27So you can of course have your genes tested.
- 4:30That's one way to answer this question.
- 4:33But if you don't know, just keep that in mind that there are subsets of people who who are
- 4:39going to respond better and subsets who don't.
- 4:41You can identify that by going to theheadachequiz.com and figure out if you have
- 4:45that energy production type and if you do, you are more likely to get better with keto.
- 4:50Now, problem number three: How to do keto?
- 4:54Here's where I differ from some of the other thought leaders in this area.
- 5:00Lot of people who do keto end up eating a lot of saturated fat.
- 5:04This is not a good idea for those of us with migraine.
- 5:08Did you ever get an MRI scan of your brain and your doctor told you you had white spots, white
- 5:14matter lesions, microvascular ischemia?
- 5:17People can call it a lot of different things.
- 5:19You know what that is?
- 5:20Itty bitty clogged arteries.
- 5:23Know what saturated fat does?
- 5:26Clog them more.
- 5:28So it is not a good idea for us with our particular types of vascular genes that we have
- 5:35to be eating a lot of saturated fat.
- 5:37You just can't do it.
- 5:38So there was a super well done article about this.
- 5:43Let me show you the data.
- 5:45All right, this article was published in 2024.
- 5:48This is an amazing study.
- 5:51They followed half a million people for upwards of twenty five years.
- 5:59Really, really well done study.
- 6:01And they found that you can cut your risk of dying of a heart attack by twenty five percent
- 6:10in this super simple and easy way.
- 6:12And you know what it was?
- 6:14Replacing animal sources of fat with plant based sources of fat.
- 6:20Alright, now I want to explain to you how easy this is.
- 6:23All you had to do was replace 5% of your total calories.
- 6:27So that's like maybe a 100 calories a day.
- 6:31And that's all you had to do to cut your risk of dying of vascular diseases like heart
- 6:36attack, stroke, that kind of thing by twenty five percent.
- 6:39Okay, guys.
- 6:40This is so easy to do.
- 6:42This is as simple as cook your eggs in olive oil instead of butter.
- 6:47Like, who cares?
- 6:48They taste great both ways.
- 6:50Right?
- 6:50Super easy change to make.
- 6:53Some changes might be a little harder.
- 6:55Instead of having cheese and crackers, have chips and guacamole, have vegetables and
- 7:02hummus.
- 7:03Like, it's so easy to swap out just a 100 calories a day with something from plan a to
- 7:09plan b.
- 7:10You can switch from high fat yogurt to low fat yogurt.
- 7:13I mean this is really easy to do to make such a subtle change in the composition of what you're
- 7:21eating and have such a dramatic impact on your health.
- 7:25I want to make it crystal clear to everybody out there that this advice like eat all the
- 7:30bacon and sausage and cheese that you want when you go keto, that is not true if you have
- 7:36migraine.
- 7:37Maybe it's true for some people who have absolutely phenomenal saturated fat processing
- 7:41genes, but for most of us, it's not the case.
- 7:44So I want to be sure if you do decide to go keto, that you're going to do it safely.
- 7:49Now, is true that you can have plenty of other kinds of fat sources like guacamole, lots of
- 7:58olive oil, you can have lots of nuts.
- 8:01There are plenty of ways to make sure you stay full.
- 8:05You know, don't, we don't want you going hungry.
- 8:08That thing about not getting hungry with the migraine brain that that's real.
- 8:11That's real.
- 8:12We don't want that.
- 8:13We want your brain to have plenty of fuel.
- 8:15When your brain doesn't have that fuel, it will absolutely generate the first step in migraine,
- 8:21which is cortical spreading depression.
- 8:23And I almost Here is my visual of what I'm thinking in my brain when I think of cortical
- 8:28spreading depression.
- 8:29It's like an ice cream cone melting.
- 8:31If your neuron is an ice cream cone just fresh out of the case, nice scoop, They have to stay
- 8:38that way.
- 8:39They expend a lot of energy staying cold, keep them.
- 8:43They don't really stay cold.
- 8:44Okay.
- 8:44This is just an analogy, but they they expend a lot of energy to stay in that state.
- 8:49Okay.
- 8:49They're pumping a lot of ions is really what's happening.
- 8:53And then, when that ice cream cone starts to melt, that's how I envision a neuron that's
- 8:59about to go into cortical spreading depression and trigger a migraine.
- 9:02Maybe that analogy helps for you to that kind of visual image.
- 9:06So you want your neurons to have all the energy they need to be pumping those ions, to be like
- 9:12the ice cream with the cold that's super cold so that they can do their job and keep your
- 9:18brain healthy.
- 9:19And then the last question people often have about ketosis is Does it make any sense to take
- 9:25extra ketones if you're not going to go keto?
- 9:28And I'm going to say no.
- 9:30I know that other people disagree with this, but here's why I say that.
- 9:33There's a little bit of a switch that happens in your body metabolically.
- 9:39If your brain cells are running on glucose, you know, the kind of the dirty fuel versus
- 9:45ketones, kind of that clean fuel, It's kind of an either or doesn't really do both at the same
- 9:50time.
- 9:51So to me, it doesn't make any sense to be burning carbs, know, having oatmeal for
- 9:56breakfast or something like that, and then take a bunch of ketones.
- 9:59I think your body's gonna kind of go what?
- 10:01Like, I think it's better to do it the way nature intended, which is either we have carbs
- 10:06now or we don't.
- 10:07I mean, cavemen didn't have a lot of carbs.
- 10:09Right?
- 10:09This is how we evolved is actually eating a pretty low carb diet.
- 10:14So in my opinion, it does not make a lot of sense to take extra ketones unless you're gonna
- 10:20go keto.
- 10:21And if you are, fantastic.
- 10:23Then take those extra ketones, get more out of what you're already doing, like, In that case,
- 10:30then I think it does make a lot of sense because your body's already here in EV mode.
- 10:34You're just, you're like going to the supercharger in that circumstance, right?
- 10:38You're doing extra ketones, you know, you're fueling that car really fast, really strong,
- 10:43really amazingly full, right?
- 10:45So think of it that way.
- 10:47And then the last thing I want to say is that people get a lot of a benefit about just being
- 10:52low carb, kind of more of a Mediterranean style approach where you you are having some carb
- 10:59from things like chickpeas, beans, legumes, lentils, all those sorts of high fiber
- 11:08vegetable products.
- 11:11I think that this is really important because people who have the inflammatory subset of
- 11:18headaches are not gonna do well on keto because they're not getting enough fiber to support gut
- 11:23health, to reduce inflammation.
- 11:26And so if you cut out all of that nice healthy fiber so that you can have like zero carbs,
- 11:35then you're kind of making the whole inflammatory subset worse.
- 11:41So you got to think about that in terms of headache type that keto can make some headache
- 11:47types worse just because of what you're eliminating.
- 11:49And I think if you've got that brain chemistry type and you need all those different
- 11:54phytonutrients and you're cutting out vegetables in order to stay strict keto, that's
- 12:01going to do you a disservice too.
- 12:03So a nice way to think about this is how about we just cut out the carbs we all know we
- 12:08should.
- 12:09Straight up sugar, dessert, alcohol, ice cream.
- 12:14How about we just cut out the obvious carbs that cavemen did not eat?
- 12:18Let's keep the carbs from things like maybe a half a cup or a cup of beans every day, maybe
- 12:25from some vegetables, carrots which have a little bit of carbon in them.
- 12:29There's still plenty of nutritional value in that in terms of the phytonutrients, the plant
- 12:34based nutrients that you're getting from them.
- 12:36I personally think that's a much smarter and more sustainable approach to keto.
- 12:41Because in this study that I was telling you about at the beginning, almost half of people
- 12:46dropped out over time because you just can't eat that way long term.
- 12:51Your body, I think, starts to talk to you and tell you, hey, I need some fiber to keep this
- 12:55whole gut bacteria thing happening, to keep those guys happy, to keep your health on target
- 13:01that way.
- 13:02Hey, I need some phytonutrients to make my brain go, to make all the systems work the way
- 13:08they're supposed to.
- 13:09We need the nutrients and plants.
- 13:10We used to get like the vast majority of our calories from plants.
- 13:15Know, our bodies are wired that way and when we don't have them, I think your body starts to
- 13:20talk to you and say, I am not happy with what you're doing here.
- 13:24I'm not getting what I need from your food.
- 13:26And no taking a vitamin pill does not replace real food.
- 13:29They're helpful.
- 13:30We need them.
- 13:31They're not enough.
- 13:32You need to do the hard work of making good healthy choices.
- 13:36But I think our body starts to talk to us when we get too much into like just meat, just
- 13:42avocado.
- 13:42Do you know what I'm saying?
- 13:43So I think that's our body saying, hey, we need a little more variety in what we're eating
- 13:49here.
- 13:50We need a nutrient dense diet to support optimal brain health because our brain is
- 13:56really the canary in the coal mine.
- 13:58It is the first thing that's going to go wrong and if you've got migraine that's how it's
- 14:02going to come out.
- 14:03And so I think the people who don't do well on keto or they give up over time, I think they're
- 14:09actually listening to their body say, We need a little more nutrient diversity here.
- 14:14And remember too that nobody's migraines fully went away in any of these studies on keto.
- 14:20I know that there may be people out there who have that experience, but in general, that's
- 14:25not what happens.
- 14:26In general, it is a piece of your recovery plan and it can absolutely give you a jumpstart.
- 14:34I mean, do you want to have five fewer headache days next month?
- 14:37Sure.
- 14:38Right?
- 14:38We'd all take that.
- 14:40Yeah, that's a step in the right direction, especially if you have that energy production
- 14:44type of headache, or if you know your genetics already, you know that your SOD2 is impacted
- 14:50for you, or if you know that you have a high BMI and your weight needs to come down a little
- 14:56bit anyway, that's going to be a super effective way to do it and get fewer migraines
- 15:00to boot.
- 15:02Hope that explained a few things to you about number one, does keto work?
- 15:06Number two) Is it for me?
- 15:08How do I decide if I should try it?
- 15:10Three) How to do it safely if you are a person who has typical migraine genetics.
- 15:17If you think this kind of information is helpful for people with migraines, please hit
- 15:22like and subscribe because that helps the algorithm find them.