Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Disability Discrimination and Workplace Accommodations in California
Transcript
- 0:03Great to have everyone there in our webcast audience.
- 0:07I'm Terry Maggety, Chair of our Elder Law Committee
- 0:11for the Beverly Hills Bar Trust in the State
- 0:13section. And the first thing we do, of course,
- 0:17is to show appreciation, which is good, particularly
- 0:20after coming out of Thanksgiving. And our appreciation
- 0:23goes to our sponsors first. And I want to thank
- 0:29them one by one. And we'll start with the Sanborn
- 0:33team. They're all up in front of you on the screen,
- 0:36but I'm going to start with our longest running
- 0:40sponsor and that's Nancy Sanborn and Brian Joy
- 0:43from Sanborn team. They're real estate brokers
- 0:46and as with many of the people you see on the
- 0:49screen, they specialize in probates and conservatorships
- 0:54and trusts. and so we really appreciate them
- 0:59for being with us a very long time to help make
- 1:02these programs happen. Second, I think I may
- 1:07put them together because typically they are,
- 1:10which is Bond Services of California and Liberty
- 1:14Mutual Surety. Anyone that works in the probate
- 1:19space knows these folks because they provide
- 1:24top -notch services to all the attorneys and
- 1:29other professionals who are working the probate
- 1:33court. There's wonderful and we really appreciate
- 1:38what they do and thank you Bond Services of California
- 1:43and thank you Liberty Mutual Surety. Next, we
- 1:48have California Title Company, a title company
- 1:51that deals in our space, probates, conservatorships,
- 1:56trusts, specialized issues that are focused on
- 2:00older people or people with disabilities. So
- 2:04thank you, California Title Company. and also
- 2:09Pickford Escrow Company, an escrow company that
- 2:13works in those same areas that I mentioned. And
- 2:17all of us who are professionals in the area,
- 2:22probate, trusts, conservatorships, estates, know
- 2:25how important and Um, and, uh, uh, efficient
- 2:32and just overall, you know, resulting in a great
- 2:36product. Uh, it is when you're able to work with,
- 2:39uh, folks like our sponsors who specialize in
- 2:43our area. So thank you all the sponsors. And
- 2:46now our program today, um, we have a, uh, a great
- 2:51attorney, you know, you can't say enough good
- 2:53things about Leanne. Leanne. If she does, I mean,
- 2:57you could list all the different things she does,
- 2:59you know, discrimination on the employee side,
- 3:03of course, discrimination, harassment, retaliation,
- 3:06wage hour, whistleblower claims, all the different
- 3:10potential claims that are affecting employees.
- 3:14But when I say Leanne's special, because to be
- 3:17in where she is, she has to mix compassion for
- 3:23the folks she represents. because you know she
- 3:26has a relationship with them and it's very it's
- 3:31very nice and it makes the the process better
- 3:34but on the other hand as an attorney and advocate
- 3:39for them she is effective and ferocious and you
- 3:46know you let me put it this way It's nice to
- 3:49have her on your team and not the adverse party's
- 3:54team. So I want to thank her for being here.
- 3:58And the program today is aligned with our niche
- 4:01topics that we're always doing, which are, you
- 4:03know, they're either related to older folks or
- 4:06people with disabilities, but one or the other.
- 4:10Then we delve into, you know, micro areas that
- 4:14are affect our population. And today it's the
- 4:17disability population. And so it's disability
- 4:21discrimination and workplace accommodations in
- 4:24California. And with that, I'll turn the program
- 4:27over to Leanne. Thank you, Terry. That was an
- 4:32incredibly sweet introduction. I love being called
- 4:34ferocious. Wonderful. So yeah, just like Terry
- 4:38said today, we are going to talk about disability
- 4:42discrimination and workplace accommodations.
- 4:45Let me share my screen so we can get the slideshow
- 4:48up there. So disability discrimination is a large
- 4:52topic. And you can hit at it from a lot of different
- 4:55ways. You can talk about how you try one or what
- 4:58the burdens are for proving that an employee's
- 5:01suffered disability discrimination. Today, we're
- 5:04just going to really hone in and focus on this
- 5:07idea of workplace accommodations. And we're going
- 5:11to focus mostly on on California and not on the
- 5:16federal equivalent, though we will go into it
- 5:18a little bit. So that's my bio, that's my law
- 5:22firm. Like Terry said, I represent employees
- 5:25in employment disputes of all kinds, including
- 5:29disability discrimination. Okay, so today we
- 5:33are gonna understand the basics of disability
- 5:36protections. We're gonna talk about what a reasonable
- 5:39accommodation actually means. We're going to
- 5:42talk about the interactive process, which is
- 5:44really where the meat of these kinds of cases
- 5:47come in. We're going to talk about some pitfalls.
- 5:51And then I'm going to talk about some of the
- 5:53real -world cases that I've had that sort of
- 5:56deal with these accommodations. So why does this
- 6:00topic matter? I think it matters a lot because
- 6:04we have an aging workforce and you know the chart
- 6:07sort of shows you but the number of Americans
- 6:09over the age of 65 is going up and people are
- 6:12staying in their jobs longer whether that be
- 6:14because of choice or because financially people
- 6:17need to work you know longer and into into older
- 6:20ages but we're seeing it and so with that you
- 6:24end up with sort of you know, chronic conditions,
- 6:27you end up with like mobility issues and stamina
- 6:30and vision and hearing, chronic pain, all of
- 6:34that sort of increases. And then you end up needing
- 6:37to deal with that in the workforce and the workplace.
- 6:42And so. That's the first reason why it matters.
- 6:46The second is that there are a lot of product
- 6:48conditions that affect a large number of people
- 6:51in the workforce in California, whether that
- 6:53be arthritis or diabetes, long COVID, post -surgery
- 6:59restrictions, and mental health conditions. This
- 7:01comes up a lot, and I get calls about it all
- 7:05the time. The third reason why I think it's Why
- 7:08it's important is that I think that these legal
- 7:10protections are misunderstood, and I think that
- 7:13there's a lot of misinformation about what needs
- 7:17to happen to accommodate an issue with a disability
- 7:21in the workplace. And I think that there's a
- 7:23lot of anger that employees are faking or that
- 7:26employers are required to go to great lengths
- 7:28to try to accommodate these disabilities and.
- 7:33It's honestly a much, it's not as complicated
- 7:38of a process, and it's something that early intervention
- 7:43can prevent. If you talk to your employees, employers'
- 7:48employees talk, you can really avoid this kind
- 7:51of litigation. OK. So let's talk about the legal
- 7:56framework. Laws apply. So we're going to focus
- 8:01on FIHA today, which is the California Fair Employment
- 8:04and Housing Act. And that is California's broad
- 8:09anti -discrimination law. So it covers more than
- 8:12just disability discrimination, but disability
- 8:14discrimination is one of the areas that's covered
- 8:17by FIHA. So in order to qualify for FIHA protection,
- 8:21the employer has to employ more than five employees.
- 8:24And then the definition of what What constitutes
- 8:28a disability under FIHA is that it needs to limit
- 8:31a major life activity. So it's pretty broad.
- 8:33We're going to talk about that. And then there's
- 8:35no caps on damages under FIHA. The federal equivalent,
- 8:39which is really like the baseline, is the Americans
- 8:43with Disabilities Act, or the ADA. And so that's
- 8:45something that all of the states have to comply
- 8:47with. And then California's is more protective.
- 8:50So ADA is the floor, and then California raises
- 8:53it. And under federal law, you have to have 15
- 8:58employees. So it starts to bigger workforces
- 9:01that you need for the ADA. And the definition
- 9:05of disability is narrower. So whereas in California,
- 9:08you only have to limit a major life activity
- 9:11under the ADA, you have to substantially. limit
- 9:16it in order to qualify as a disability. So it's
- 9:20a harder standard for what the employee is suffering
- 9:22for it to meet that definition of disability.
- 9:24And then there are caps on damages under the
- 9:27ADA. So what counts as a disability? So under
- 9:34FIHA, disability is any physical or mental condition
- 9:38that makes it harder to do a major life activity.
- 9:42OK, so and that you can look at this case that
- 9:45sort of defines what that means. And so it's
- 9:49broad. And it uses the word limits. And so it
- 9:53just needs to make that task more difficult.
- 9:56It doesn't require severe or long -term impairment.
- 10:00And again, unlike federal, it doesn't have to
- 10:03substantially limit. Sorry about that. So here
- 10:10are some examples. that disability can impair,
- 10:17and then it would qualify under FIHA. So if what
- 10:21you are suffering makes it harder to walk or
- 10:24lift or concentrate, if your vision is impaired,
- 10:27if your hearing is impaired, anything that makes
- 10:30it harder to do everyday tasks would qualify
- 10:32under FIHA as a disability. So that would include
- 10:37like arthritis, diabetes. cancer, depression,
- 10:42hearing or vision loss, if you break your leg,
- 10:45if you have surgery and you need to recover,
- 10:48if you're pregnant, if you're coming back after
- 10:51pregnancy and you know you're not fully healed,
- 10:54all of those count as disabilities. So once you
- 11:00have a disability. And once you find that your
- 11:03disability is making it difficult to do your
- 11:06job, what an employee would ask for is a reasonable
- 11:10accommodation. And so listen, I broke my leg.
- 11:15It's hard for me to walk around the office. I
- 11:20need some assistance with that. That's the kind
- 11:22of thing where you would ask for a reasonable
- 11:24accommodation. And so it's just you're asking
- 11:26for a modification. that would allow the employee
- 11:29to perform the essential job duties. So employee
- 11:35has to be able to perform the essential job duties
- 11:37no matter what. But if there is an accommodation
- 11:41that allows them to do that, then it's reasonable
- 11:44for the employer to offer it. And so it's really
- 11:46just about enjoying equal employment opportunities
- 11:49so the employee can continue to work safely.
- 11:54So the phrase that you'll see is essential job
- 11:58duties. So the employer isn't required to eliminate
- 12:03the job duties. They don't have to modify what
- 12:08the employee has to do in order to complete their
- 12:10job, but they do have to maybe provide something
- 12:14that would allow the employee to perform. those
- 12:18job functions. And so what does that look like?
- 12:21The kinds of things that I see the most, the
- 12:24kinds of things that the employees who call me
- 12:26are asking for are like a modified schedule.
- 12:30Maybe they need one day off and one day on. Maybe
- 12:33they want to come in and start their day earlier
- 12:36and leave their day earlier. That's a modified
- 12:39schedule. They ask for equipment. like an ergonomic
- 12:43chair or a standing desk. I think those have
- 12:45become pretty commonplace nowadays. A lot of
- 12:49employers offer them anyway. They're available
- 12:52for employees if they need them. Remote work.
- 12:56After COVID, I think we learned that a lot of
- 12:59jobs that people thought could not be done remotely
- 13:02actually can be done remotely. And so that is
- 13:05something that I see employees ask for. Or even
- 13:09like a hybrid situation. Can I come in? at the
- 13:12office three days a week and work from my home
- 13:14two days a week. Another thing that actually
- 13:18qualifies as a reasonable accommodation is reassignment
- 13:21to a different position. Now, one of the main
- 13:25cases on this is this Neiman Marcus case. An
- 13:28employer doesn't have to create a new position,
- 13:30but if there is a position open, and the employee
- 13:34is qualified for that position, then it is a
- 13:36reasonable accommodation to at least explore
- 13:40whether the employee can take that job. And so
- 13:42you'll see this a lot, like when someone perhaps
- 13:44has a physical job, like they're out in the field,
- 13:47maybe they're in pest control or inspections
- 13:50of some kind and they've injured themselves and
- 13:54there is a desk job. Somebody who routes people
- 13:57to the inspections or somebody who's doing a
- 14:00less physical job. And if that's open and if
- 14:03the employee is qualified to do it, then that
- 14:05could be a reasonable accommodation. You'll see
- 14:07a lot of requests for lifting limitations. I
- 14:11can lift, but I can't lift over 15 pounds, something
- 14:14along those lines. And also extended or intermittent
- 14:19leave can be an accommodation. I need to take
- 14:21a few weeks to heal. I might need to take a day
- 14:25or two sporadically throughout the next 12 weeks
- 14:30or so. And that can be a reasonable accommodation
- 14:32under the right circumstances. And so what does
- 14:37an employee have to say in order to get that
- 14:40accommodation? Like, what are the magic words?
- 14:43There are none. They can say I need help because
- 14:45I'm hurt. They can actually specifically ask
- 14:48for a reasonable accommodation. And, you know,
- 14:51employees tend to be a lot more savvy. I think
- 14:53people are... pretty well aware of their rights.
- 14:56And so they may use that exact language. I need
- 14:59a reasonable accommodation. Might be my doctor
- 15:01says I can't do my job without X, Y, or Z. But
- 15:05any sort of combination of those words means
- 15:08that the employer needs to act. They need to
- 15:11do something. They now have a duty to respond.
- 15:14They have a duty to interact. And that is another
- 15:19phrase that you hear a lot in the disability
- 15:21discrimination world, just engaging in the interactive
- 15:25process. So employee comes and says, hey, I hurt
- 15:28my leg. I can't drive. I need help getting to
- 15:34the office, or I need to work remotely. And so
- 15:37now... The employer has to hear that and has
- 15:40to engage in this interactive process. And the
- 15:44employee needs to communicate. The employee needs
- 15:46to lay out what it is that they need help with.
- 15:52and maybe even come up with some ideas of how
- 15:55they can be helped. And then the employer and
- 15:57the employee need to share information. The employer
- 16:00needs to explain why something might not be reasonable
- 16:03and offer alternatives, consider different alternatives
- 16:07other than perhaps what the employee proposed.
- 16:10And then even if an accommodation is given, the
- 16:13employer needs to follow up and make sure that
- 16:15it's working and that the employee is capable
- 16:18of doing the job now. And so one of the main
- 16:21cases on this interactive process is this Jensen
- 16:25case, and it says that the process must be timely,
- 16:29it must be good faith, and it must be thorough,
- 16:32okay? And actually failing to engage in the interactive
- 16:36process is its own cause of action of our California
- 16:39law. So even if ultimately it would be impossible
- 16:44to accommodate the disability that the employee
- 16:46has brought up, the employer still has to engage.
- 16:49Otherwise, there is a cause of action for failure
- 16:51to engage in the interactive process. So it's
- 16:53important. And so these are sort of the employer's
- 16:57obligations. Respond promptly. I cannot tell
- 17:01you how many cases I think would never have come
- 17:05to me had the employee or had the employer just
- 17:08responded. promptly. That delay, when an employee
- 17:11says, hey, I need help, that creates so much
- 17:15anger. It gets everything off on the wrong foot.
- 17:18Whereas if the employer says, hey, I hear you,
- 17:21let's talk about it, I think you immediately
- 17:24defuse things. So responding promptly, very important.
- 17:28The employer is allowed to request medical information
- 17:33if it's necessary and only what is necessary.
- 17:36So that doesn't mean that you get to look at
- 17:38your employees medical records for 10 years back,
- 17:41you know, from every doctor they've ever seen.
- 17:43But what you could request is a doctor's note.
- 17:46Hey, you know, you're saying that you have this
- 17:48condition, especially maybe a condition that
- 17:50you can't see or that you weren't aware of. You
- 17:53know, you have this condition. Can you document
- 17:56it? And oftentimes the doctor will will say what
- 18:00they think the accommodation should be, or they
- 18:02will explain what the limitations are. This person
- 18:05can't lift more than X amount. So I think that
- 18:09doctors know can be really helpful. Now, if the
- 18:12disability is obvious, there may not be a need
- 18:15to request a doctor's note. If the employee is
- 18:19pregnant and you're well aware of that, you don't
- 18:22have to go and request a doctor's note for that.
- 18:25So some disabilities, that may not be necessary.
- 18:28And so then the employer's obligation is to explore
- 18:32all reasonable options. And then I would say
- 18:37an employer obligation, it's not necessarily
- 18:41required, but I think it's incredibly helpful,
- 18:44is to document the process. When I get one of
- 18:48these cases, I'm going to request the employee's
- 18:51personnel file. And if my employee is saying,
- 18:54hey, or my client is saying, hey, I have brought
- 18:56in a doctor's note. I brought a doctor's note
- 18:58in every three weeks. I sent emails. I should
- 19:02see that in the file. I should see the doctor's
- 19:05note. Oftentimes, I'll see notes from HR saying,
- 19:09hey, we received John's doctor's note. We told
- 19:12John we could not accommodate it, but we were
- 19:15willing to offer this. It's very helpful to see
- 19:18that. And oftentimes, if I'm early in a case
- 19:21and I've just requested the records to determine
- 19:23if I'm even going to take that case, if I see
- 19:26that back and forth and I see the employer really
- 19:29tried to engage, I may decide that's not a case
- 19:32I'm going to take. So I think the documentation
- 19:35is helpful for both sides. And then obviously,
- 19:39the employer needs to avoid retaliation, discipline.
- 19:44or pressure. Those are going to give rise to
- 19:47additional causes of action. So that's what the
- 19:51employer has to do when the employee has requested
- 19:55an accommodation. The employee also has responsibilities.
- 20:01The employee has to also communicate. has to
- 20:04explain what their limitations are. If they're
- 20:07being offered suggestions, they have to explain
- 20:10or offered accommodations. They have to explain
- 20:11why that accommodation won't work. There is some
- 20:15case law where cases have not gone well for employees
- 20:17because it became very clear that they didn't
- 20:21want the accommodation they eventually wanted
- 20:23to sue. So, you know, the employee also has responsibilities,
- 20:27provide that documentation when it's appropriate,
- 20:30participate. try the proposed accommodations.
- 20:33If the employee is asking for one thing and the
- 20:36employer comes back with something different,
- 20:39the employee, if possible, should try that proposed
- 20:42accommodation in good faith and see if maybe
- 20:44that allows them to perform their job duties.
- 20:49So just because an employee comes and says, I
- 20:54need this accommodation, that does not mean that
- 20:56the employer has to say, yes. California uses
- 21:01the term undue hardship, but it is a high standard.
- 21:05It doesn't mean that what the employee is requesting
- 21:07is inconvenient or annoying. It doesn't mean
- 21:12we've never done this before. That's not going
- 21:14to meet the high burden of undue hardship. It
- 21:17means something more serious. It means that it
- 21:20would be either incredibly onerous or impossible
- 21:25for the employer to accommodate. what the employee
- 21:29is asking for. And so those kind of come into
- 21:31a few categories. Significant expense, so cost.
- 21:37This one is going to really hinge on the size
- 21:40of the employer and what the employee is asking
- 21:43for. If the employee says, hey, I need an ergonomic
- 21:46keyboard, and you are Amazon, and you say, no,
- 21:50it's absolutely too expensive, that's not going
- 21:53to fly. But if you are a really small employer
- 21:58and they ask for, the employee asks for a very
- 22:03expensive standing desk or something that does
- 22:07have a high price tag associated with it, that
- 22:10could be too costly and could actually rise to
- 22:14the level of an undue hardship for the employer.
- 22:18Another one, and probably the one that I think
- 22:20I see the most, is just major operational disruption.
- 22:25You're asking for equipment that would make it
- 22:28hard for people to move around in the workplace,
- 22:32something that would really make it difficult
- 22:35for the employer to continue performing the job.
- 22:40And that could be if you're requesting perhaps
- 22:43extended leave and the employer can't afford
- 22:47to not have someone in that position because
- 22:50that job is really necessary and they're a small
- 22:53company, then that might qualify as undue hardship.
- 22:58And then the last one that you see is safety
- 23:00risks. If there's no safe way. for the employee
- 23:04to perform this job with an accommodation, then
- 23:09that would be an undue hardship. And so if it's
- 23:11very heavy machinery or you're in a high -risk
- 23:14medical setting, rules that require emergency
- 23:20response, that could then be an undue hardship
- 23:24and not an accommodation that would be reasonable
- 23:26for an employer to make. Now, if the employer
- 23:32says, hey, can't accommodate undue hardship,
- 23:36what can an employee do? One of the very first
- 23:39questions that I'm gonna ask is, well, are there
- 23:42other employees with similar accommodations?
- 23:44Like, have they given these kinds of accommodations
- 23:46in the past? You know, I see this a lot with
- 23:49like remote work, things like that. It's like,
- 23:51you can't accommodate this employee, but there
- 23:53are five other employees who work from home.
- 23:57I don't really believe that this is an undue
- 23:59hardship. You know, the size of the employer,
- 24:02you know, you're telling me that you can't leave
- 24:04this job open, but you're huge and you employ
- 24:06100 people in this position, you know, across
- 24:08the state of California. Like, I don't, I don't
- 24:10know if I believe that. Did you just say no right
- 24:14away or what steps did you take to try to make
- 24:16the accommodation work? Did you engage in the
- 24:18interactive process? Did you provide fair alternatives?
- 24:23We also look for discriminatory words that went
- 24:27along with it. They called him too old to do
- 24:30the job or something along those lines. If I've
- 24:34got that coupled with this refusal to accommodate,
- 24:38that might be a case there. And so the sort of
- 24:42case on this is Green versus State of California.
- 24:45And what it says, though, is that the burden
- 24:47is on the employee. So the employee has to show
- 24:51that they can perform their essential job functions
- 24:54with the accommodation. Okay. So if an employee
- 25:03sues, what are the remedies? So hopefully you
- 25:09never get to this point, because hopefully the
- 25:11employee has come, has requested an accommodation.
- 25:17The employer has engaged good faith in that interactive
- 25:21process, and either they've been able to reach
- 25:25a resolution and they've been able to find some
- 25:29sort of accommodation that works, or the employee
- 25:33understands through the back and forth that there's
- 25:36not going to be something that's feasible. But
- 25:39lots of cases don't end like that. They end with
- 25:42the employee eventually bringing. a lawsuit and
- 25:45when the employee brings the lawsuit, the employee
- 25:48is going to ask for certain things. They're going
- 25:49to ask for reinstatement. I've actually never
- 25:54seen an employee get reinstatement, but it is
- 25:57a potential remedy that that employee can ask
- 26:00for. Back pay, so the wages that they lost in
- 26:05the past because they were terminated, they're
- 26:09going to ask for that. also going to ask for
- 26:13wages going into the future. They're going to
- 26:16ask for emotional distress damages, which can
- 26:20be hefty. They might ask for policy changes,
- 26:24injunctive relief. Ask that the employer revamp
- 26:27its policies on reasonable accommodations. And
- 26:31then they also can ask for punitive damages.
- 26:41So I wanted to talk about some actual real world
- 26:46cases that I have dealt with because I think
- 26:50it's more helpful to hear how it plays out in
- 26:56reality. So I had a case where my client was
- 27:02pregnant. It was like a large gas station company.
- 27:07And she was a manager at one of these gas stations.
- 27:12She was a superstar. She had basically been promoted
- 27:15from lowest level all the way up through the
- 27:18company. She gets pregnant. She is not doing
- 27:23well. Super, super nauseous, really, really sick.
- 27:26but she is making it work. She is driving like
- 27:29an hour to get to her job, throwing up all the
- 27:32way there, but she's making it work. And as,
- 27:36you know, she's sort of progressing through the
- 27:38pregnancy, there's some rumblings. You hear some
- 27:41comments about, you know, she's not as good a
- 27:44worker as she was, you know, before, but then
- 27:47she suffers like a very serious complication
- 27:50with her pregnancy. And she has to go to the
- 27:54emergency room. So she is not able, obviously,
- 27:58to show up for work that day because she is admitted
- 28:01into the hospital. And her doctor is pretty adamant
- 28:05that she's going to have to go out on full -time
- 28:07leave early because of the complications to the
- 28:11baby. And so the doctor faxes over a doctor's
- 28:15note explaining that she's at the hospital and
- 28:21that she's likely going to need to be on leave
- 28:24through the rest of her pregnancy. And he faxes
- 28:26it to the number that my client had given him.
- 28:31That's the number where you're supposed to send
- 28:33these sorts of things to HR. Her supervisor reaches
- 28:38out to her via text. She says, hey, my doctor's
- 28:41sending a note. I can't talk. I'm in the hospital.
- 28:45He proceeds to bombard her with taxing. He hasn't
- 28:48gotten the facts. And she essentially cannot
- 28:51deal with that because she is in a medical emergency.
- 28:54She's in the hospital for over a week. And when
- 28:57she gets out of the hospital, they have fired
- 28:59her. And they said, we never got the doctor's
- 29:02note. So no call, no show. You're fired. And
- 29:06in that case, the reasonable accommodation was
- 29:09honestly waiting. I think they did. The doctor's
- 29:14note, I don't believe that. But let's say it's
- 29:17true. Let's say the fax machine didn't work or
- 29:19it didn't go through. They understood she was
- 29:22in a medical emergency. And waiting for the doctor's
- 29:26note, waiting to understand the parameters of
- 29:29what she was going to be requesting for an accommodation
- 29:31is a reasonable accommodation. And so that's
- 29:34a real world case where I saw that play out.
- 29:38I also had another case where this employee worked
- 29:43in like a doctor's office and her job was essentially
- 29:45to be the person who got yelled at by patients
- 29:47when they were unhappy with you know whatever
- 29:49had occurred during their doctor's visit and
- 29:53she broke her leg and so she had to drive a pretty
- 29:57far way to get to the doctor's office and she
- 30:00couldn't drive and so she tried to take public
- 30:02transportation but that was really difficult
- 30:04with like with a broken leg and it was temporary
- 30:06you know she needed like six to eight weeks probably
- 30:08and so she asked if she could do her job remotely
- 30:11And her employer said, no, can't do it remotely.
- 30:15You have to be here. It's an in -office job.
- 30:18We can't accommodate that. And it essentially
- 30:20resulted in her having to quit because she couldn't
- 30:24get herself to work. And under certain circumstances,
- 30:28saying, hey, listen, this is an in -person job,
- 30:32That might be a reasonable response. But in this
- 30:36situation, there were nine other employees with
- 30:40the exact same job title that she had who either
- 30:43worked fully remote or hybrid. And so I just
- 30:47didn't see that as a reasonable accommodation
- 30:49when you're permitting other employees to do
- 30:52the same thing. Seems like the job can in fact
- 30:54be done. The central job functions can in fact
- 30:56be done remotely. So that was one case I had.
- 31:03Another case where sort of an accommodation came
- 31:06up was a case where, you know, my client was
- 31:08like a clerk, like an associate in a drug store.
- 31:11Also had sort of worked her way up and she was
- 31:14now like a shift lead. And she got pregnant,
- 31:19took her pregnancy leave and came back and she
- 31:23had an injury from giving birth. She had like
- 31:26an injury with her tailbone. And it caused her
- 31:30to not be able to lift really heavy boxes. Now
- 31:34prior to going out on leave prior to to even
- 31:36being pregnant she hadn't been lifting heavy
- 31:40boxes because she was a pretty slight woman and
- 31:45you know she wasn't going to be able to lift
- 31:46like a 30 pound box and bring it out to stock
- 31:50the shelves and so some other employee had always
- 31:52done that for her. She'd really never been lifting
- 31:56as part of her job and she'd been doing the job
- 31:58for years. But this company does have a job description.
- 32:04And these job descriptions come up when you have
- 32:05these kinds of cases. You look and you see like,
- 32:07what are the essential job functions? What does
- 32:09an employee need to do to do this job? And lifting
- 32:12over 15 pounds was listed on the job description
- 32:16as an essential job function. And so their position
- 32:19was she can't perform her essential job functions
- 32:22without an accommodation. And so, you know, with
- 32:27or without accommodation. So we don't have to,
- 32:30it's an undue hardship. You know, we don't have
- 32:31to accommodate it. But I pointed to the fact
- 32:34that not only had she never been lifting and
- 32:37I, you know, the job description might say one
- 32:39thing, but what they're doing on a day to day
- 32:41basis is actually what's essential to the job.
- 32:43Not only was she not lifting, but there were
- 32:45other employees who also were not lifting in
- 32:48other locations across California. Some because
- 32:51of, you know, a disability and an accommodation
- 32:54and some simply because like my client, they
- 32:56were sort of slight. people and they weren't
- 32:59able to lift these really, really heavy boxes.
- 33:01And it had been pretty easy for the company to
- 33:04accommodate them by having another employee bring
- 33:06the boxes out or, you know, she could use a trolley,
- 33:09things like that. So that's another case where
- 33:13the employer said undo hardship and, you know,
- 33:15we didn't buy that. And then the last case I
- 33:20have is an employee who was working in an office
- 33:24job and had very severe PTSD and so as a result
- 33:32of this very severe PTSD she suffered panic attacks
- 33:37and so she would need when she was having these
- 33:41panic attacks to take a break and you know be
- 33:44able to kind of leave the floor take a minute
- 33:49and then come back and so she wanted to be able
- 33:51to take 15 minute rest breaks sort of when these
- 33:55panic attacks were happening and they were infrequent
- 33:57but they did happen. And in that situation they
- 34:02said they couldn't not only did the employer
- 34:03say you know the boss say we can't accommodate
- 34:05that but he used these words like she's unstable
- 34:10and unreliable that sort of suggested to me that
- 34:15this really wasn't about you know, the effect
- 34:18that accommodating this would have on the boss,
- 34:20it was really more about the boss's feelings
- 34:22about this employee having this disability and
- 34:25needing this help. And I have seen a real increase
- 34:30in, like, mental and emotional disabilities.
- 34:33I get a lot of calls about that, PTSD or anxiety
- 34:38attacks, those sorts of things. And a lot of
- 34:42these kinds of cases result in an employee asking
- 34:45for leave. And it gets confusing when you have
- 34:52these cases where the accommodation itself is
- 34:56Lee, because under California law, there's obviously
- 35:01FIHA that we're talking about, but there's also
- 35:06CIFRA. And CIFRA gives employees... the right
- 35:10to take leave for medical conditions, their own
- 35:14medical conditions and the medical conditions
- 35:17of loved ones. And so the way that FIHA and CIFRA
- 35:22work together can be really confusing, but essentially
- 35:25FIHA says, you've got to accommodate a disability,
- 35:29right? And CIFRA says, if an employee needs this
- 35:33leave, it's protected. So the accommodation itself
- 35:36is the use of the protected leave. under CIFRA.
- 35:41And so you're entitled to job protection under
- 35:46CIFRA for a certain period of time to 12 weeks
- 35:49if your employer meets the requirements. And
- 35:53so that's the accommodation that the employee
- 35:56is asking for. They're asking to use their mandated
- 36:00leave as the accommodation. But sometimes that
- 36:03job protection extends. Sometimes that employee's
- 36:08leave extends beyond that 12 -week job production.
- 36:12And then that request for additional leave can
- 36:16also be a request for an accommodation. Okay,
- 36:19I know I got my protected 12 weeks, but now I
- 36:23actually need additional... leave beyond that.
- 36:28And then the employer would have to determine
- 36:30if it can grant that accommodation. You'd go
- 36:32through the interactive process and you determine
- 36:35if that was an undue hardship to grant that additional
- 36:38leave. And depending on the size of the employer,
- 36:42it might very well be. A small employer is probably
- 36:46not going to be able to have an employee that's
- 36:48in an important job position be gone for a year.
- 36:55And so that's a little bit of how those two play
- 36:59together, but it can be a little bit confusing.
- 37:04Okay. So those are the main cases that I've dealt
- 37:10with fairly recently dealing with this issue.
- 37:13But the key takeaways for today is that the definition
- 37:18of what is a disability is broad. And if it impairs
- 37:23any sort of life function. It's likely going
- 37:27to qualify as a disability and the employer is
- 37:30going to have to determine if they can accommodate
- 37:32it. I think another really important takeaway
- 37:35is early honest communication is critical. The
- 37:42interactive process is a conversation. It's not
- 37:45a form, you know, it's not a check the box. It's
- 37:49going to be different depending on the situation
- 37:51and what the employee is asking for. And I think
- 37:55the other really key takeaway is that most problems
- 37:58are solved long before we get to the litigation
- 38:03phase. And so if you can engage in that process,
- 38:09then I think you can avoid this kind of litigation.
- 38:14And I have noticed that we have some questions
- 38:18in the chat. I'll try to come in to help facilitate.
- 38:22Yeah, because there's a lot of them. So I was
- 38:25going to wait. And we may get more. I mean, I
- 38:29have some myself, but I'll leave mine to the
- 38:32end, only if there's time. OK, the first question
- 38:36we have is, what if the employee's injury is
- 38:38visible? Broken leg in a cast. Does the employer
- 38:43have a duty to ask if the employee needs an accommodation?
- 38:48I really like that question. It's tense, right?
- 38:53You can go through and you can read the law and
- 38:55there's no strict answer on this. If the employee
- 39:00has a broken leg and the employee is able to
- 39:03get to work, seems like they can drive or perhaps
- 39:06they haven't had any issues getting to work and
- 39:09their job isn't one where they're limping around.
- 39:12They have a desk job, they're able to kind of
- 39:14be in an easy setup and doesn't seem to be any
- 39:17problems. I mean, maybe you don't need to ask
- 39:20there, but I don't think it can hurt. I don't
- 39:22think it ever hurts if you notice that someone
- 39:25is injured, your employee is injured, to say
- 39:27to them, hey, can I help in some way? Are you
- 39:31having any issues? Is there anything that we
- 39:34can do? So I mean, you're not required to, but
- 39:39I do think it's probably not a bad idea to raise
- 39:43the issue early. Great. The next question is,
- 39:48If an employee is on workers compensation and
- 39:52exchanging information, is that process enough
- 39:55for the interactive process? So the really complicated
- 39:59thing about disability discrimination is how
- 40:02it interplays with so many other areas of law.
- 40:06So we talked a little bit about how it has like
- 40:10an interplay with CIFRA because that protects.
- 40:12you know, gives you job protection to deal with
- 40:16like medical issues. It also has an interplay
- 40:19with worker's comp if the employee got injured
- 40:22at work. So if your employee gets injured at
- 40:26work, you are required under California law to
- 40:28have worker's compensation insurance. And so
- 40:31now the employee is going to go through that
- 40:34process and they're going to see a doctor. that's
- 40:38gonna get paid for through the worker's comp,
- 40:41and they're gonna do what they need to do to
- 40:43assist that injury. And then at the same time,
- 40:48they may need accommodations at work to deal
- 40:51with that injury. And so... Yeah, I mean, it
- 40:56could be enough. It also depends on where the
- 41:00documentation is going. I have had cases where
- 41:02all of the doctor's notes and all of the things
- 41:04that are happening with workers comp are going
- 41:08through the workers comp, you know, insurance.
- 41:10And so the employer is not even really seeing
- 41:13any of that. And so then you don't know, you
- 41:16know, if there are things that are needed. But
- 41:18if those doctor's notes are, you know, if all
- 41:21of those records are sort of going through the
- 41:23employer as well, then that could be sufficient.
- 41:27At the end of this process when the employee
- 41:30is ready to come back to work, if they've been
- 41:33out on leave, then you would now need to engage
- 41:36in that interactive process. Okay, you've given
- 41:38me time to deal with this injury that I got at
- 41:40work and I'm back now and I'd like to go back
- 41:44to my job, but I need to not be able to lift
- 41:48over 15 pounds. whatever the issue is, you would
- 41:52now engage in the interactive process at that
- 41:54point and determine if you can accommodate it.
- 41:58So workers' comp is just an overlay that kind
- 42:01of makes things more complicated, but it's not
- 42:03necessarily going to take the place of your interactive
- 42:06process as the employer. The next question is,
- 42:10is pregnancy in and of itself considered a disability
- 42:14or is it only a disability arising out? pregnancy
- 42:18covered under FIHA. Am I pronouncing it? Is that
- 42:21the acronym you guys use in the business? FIHA.
- 42:25Yes. Pregnancy is a disability. Pregnancy is
- 42:29in and of itself a temporary disability, like
- 42:31breaking your leg. At some point, you're not
- 42:34going to be pregnant anymore. But while you are
- 42:36pregnant, it is a disability. And also after
- 42:42you've had the baby, you still may have injuries
- 42:46that are pregnancy related that need to be accommodated.
- 42:50So pregnancy creates a whole host of issues.
- 42:55And it's also, you could be very early in the
- 42:58pregnancy and you can have incredible sickness
- 43:02that needs to be accommodated. So it's in and
- 43:05of itself a disability and the things that flow
- 43:08from it are also a disability. Very interesting.
- 43:12And there is a whole other There's protected
- 43:15pregnancy leave that can interplay with all of
- 43:19this as well. But yes, it is a disability. Very
- 43:22interesting. I'm going to go back. One person
- 43:25asked a few questions, so let me get some other
- 43:28questioners and then swing back and get the person's
- 43:31other questions. When hiring, can an employer
- 43:37prospectively identify a disability that is disqualifying
- 43:41for the job? For example, a job in which attention
- 43:44to detail and dollars is critical. People with
- 43:48ADHD are not eligible for this position. It feels
- 43:53like a very dangerous game that you would be
- 43:56playing there. First of all, if they haven't
- 43:58disclosed to you that they have a disability
- 44:00and you have just sort of said this person seems
- 44:04like they have ADHD and they won't be able to
- 44:06do this job, you are discriminating based on
- 44:09a perceived disability. So you can be wrong or
- 44:12right, and that can get you into trouble. You
- 44:16know, when you interview someone, if part of
- 44:20the job duties are being detail oriented and
- 44:22things of that nature, and the person is interviewing
- 44:24in a way that shows that they're not detail oriented,
- 44:27I wouldn't jump to the fact that they have a
- 44:30disability. I would say, hey, look, listen, you
- 44:31know, it doesn't seem like this person's detail
- 44:34oriented. They don't seem organized. You know,
- 44:36they showed up late to the meeting, things like
- 44:38that. are are not protected. But once you start
- 44:42trying to determine if this person has an underlying
- 44:45disability at the early stages, you're going
- 44:47to you can get yourself into into trouble there.
- 44:50But there is a difference between, you know,
- 44:53screening for for character traits that you think
- 44:57would make somebody a bad fit for this job and
- 45:00screening for disabilities. There are two different
- 45:03things. OK, if a physician. needs leave from
- 45:09a hospital due to a legitimate injury and the
- 45:12medical corporation is statewide. In your experience,
- 45:16what is the number of physicians that would be
- 45:18considered enough so that the employer cannot
- 45:21claim undue hardship? Oh, these are very specific.
- 45:26Look, we read this one because I didn't fully
- 45:29understand that. If a physician needs leave from
- 45:31a hospital due to a legitimate injury and the
- 45:33medical corporation is statewide, in your experience,
- 45:35what is the number of physicians that would be
- 45:37considered enough so that the employer cannot
- 45:39claim undue hardship. So I mean, I don't have
- 45:41like a, it's 10. I don't have a number like that.
- 45:44But I do think that you are dealing with a high
- 45:49risk job. You are dealing with safety issues.
- 45:52You have all of the markings that can create
- 45:55an actual undue hardship. So it's gonna depend.
- 45:59How big is this company? How many doctors are
- 46:03in this area? What have they done in the past?
- 46:07when somebody has needed leave? Have they accommodated
- 46:10it? Why aren't they accommodating it now? Is
- 46:13there another more nefarious reason? You're going
- 46:17to look at all of those factors. And here's the
- 46:20thing. One trier of fact could say, no, that
- 46:23wasn't an undue hardship under the exact same
- 46:25facts. And one trier of fact could say, oh, it
- 46:27absolutely was. So I mean, it's the law. It's
- 46:30messy, and it's squishy, and there are just no
- 46:33right answers. So in a case like that, if you're
- 46:35the employer, document everything. What did you
- 46:41do to determine if you could give this employee
- 46:43leave? And what did you consider when you determined
- 46:45that it was an undue hardship? And I would be
- 46:48very transparent about that. Because if there's
- 46:51litigation, then that's what you're going to
- 46:52use to show I did the best I can. If you're an
- 46:55employee and you're coming at this saying, hey,
- 46:59I don't think that this is, my employer says
- 47:01undue hardship and I don't think it is an undue
- 47:03hardship. Well, then I would look at what kind
- 47:06of leave have they granted to other employees
- 47:07in the past? How important is your job? How do
- 47:13vacations work right now when you go out on vacation,
- 47:15who fills in for you? You're just gonna look
- 47:18at the underlying facts to try to figure out
- 47:20what makes sense. We have quite a few others.
- 47:25A question, we get into another area, which is
- 47:28what's essential. What determines whether a job
- 47:31responsibility is essential? That's continuing
- 47:34on that last discussion a bit. And can an employer
- 47:37in a service industry claim that being understaffed
- 47:40makes an accommodation and reasonable hardship?
- 47:45Okay, so what is an essential job function again?
- 47:49Squishy. There's no set answer. A job description
- 47:54is a great place to start. So if you've got a
- 47:56job description for the position, it's in a restaurant,
- 48:00it's a server, let's look at what you have said
- 48:04outside of this litigation, outside of this request
- 48:06is essential. And under staffing, can result
- 48:12in an undue hardship. If you are a small restaurant,
- 48:16you employ three people, and one of those people
- 48:19needs to go out on an extended leave, that's
- 48:22probably an undue hardship, right? But if you
- 48:26are Red Lobster, you probably can afford. you
- 48:31know, to let that person go out on leave. You
- 48:34can fill the position and still probably have
- 48:35a position for that employee when they come back
- 48:38for leave. Now, sometimes understaffing is Is
- 48:42done sort of on purpose right there keeping in
- 48:45restaurants they try to keep the margins really
- 48:47thin because it's hard to make money in a restaurant
- 48:49and so i guess you could try to make the argument
- 48:51that. You were willfully under staffing but i
- 48:55mean i don't think that's gonna get you very
- 48:56far if it's a it's a small restaurant and they
- 48:59need the bodies to do the job then it might be
- 49:02an undo. just like if you're running a restaurant
- 49:06and it is obviously gonna be a requirement that
- 49:10employee be able to get the food to the table
- 49:13and if that employee breaks their leg and they
- 49:15can't walk and you can't keep that job open,
- 49:19that's not gonna be a reasonable accommodation
- 49:21because that employee can't perform their essential
- 49:23job functions. But if there's a cashier position
- 49:27that is open in that restaurant, and this employee
- 49:30is qualified for that position, then you at least
- 49:32need to interview them to see if they can take
- 49:34that cashier position, because that would be
- 49:37a reasonable accommodation. So very facty. And
- 49:41we're back to workers comp again. When it's a
- 49:44workers comp case and other staff is being accommodated,
- 49:47can they claim, whoops, it's just. Can they claim
- 49:50hardship due to the fact that they've already
- 49:53accommodated other staff? How can one bring up
- 49:57the accommodations of others since it's usually
- 50:02private information? Okay, so it's a workers'
- 50:06comp case and I will preface this by saying I
- 50:08do not do workers' comp. I do have credible referrals
- 50:12for you for workers' comp lawyers if anyone needs.
- 50:15He needs one. But let's say that the employee
- 50:19is out on leave or is requesting to be out on
- 50:23leave. And there are 10 other employees who are
- 50:26out on leave for their own medical issues. Again,
- 50:30that could be an undue hardship now. There's
- 50:32only so much that the employer can financially
- 50:36accommodate before it's not going to be able
- 50:38to run its business. How do you bring up the
- 50:42accommodations of others? employees know a lot.
- 50:47So I will have employees call me and say, I know
- 50:50Sheila worked remotely last year when she, you
- 50:54know, had an issue with her, you know, whatever
- 50:57her gout. And I know that. And, you know, I have
- 50:59that information. but it's also something that
- 51:02you request in discovery. So one of the first
- 51:04things that I'm gonna get out when I file one
- 51:07of these cases is I'm gonna ask for discovery
- 51:08on the accommodations that you've granted to
- 51:10other employees. And they might not give me those
- 51:12employees names and they might not lay out all
- 51:15of the medical issues that they have, but I am
- 51:18gonna be able to get discovery on the fact that
- 51:20you've allowed nine other workers to work remotely
- 51:23in the last three years. So it's gonna be a combination
- 51:28of office gossip and actual discovery that you're
- 51:32going to ask for in the case to figure out what's
- 51:35really going on in the workforce. And the next
- 51:40question, this one may be a bit too detailed,
- 51:45and the person may just have to reach out to
- 51:47you directly, but I'll try to. Get to the gist
- 51:52of it. Uh, the person says, this is the anonymous
- 51:55attendee employee needs to work. The doctor note
- 51:58says employee needs to work remotely during pregnancy.
- 52:03Okay. If the employer cannot accommodate, then
- 52:06she's disabled. I'm not sure what that means
- 52:07exactly there, but the employer did not ask for
- 52:10more info. They just said, job can't be remote.
- 52:13Don't return unless until you have a note from
- 52:16the doctor. She knew she couldn't get that and
- 52:19left her position. This is a little very specific
- 52:22here. They claim she voluntarily quit because
- 52:25she was forced to quit. But employee says to
- 52:29them verbally about pregnancy difficulty. This
- 52:33may be just too much, Leigh Ann. Too much detail.
- 52:37How much responsibility? You know, it sounds
- 52:40like questions when they're at that level of
- 52:43specificity with a specific, this sounds like
- 52:47a very specific case that I think someone should
- 52:50just Reach out to you directly on is that sound?
- 52:53Yeah, I mean, I will say that when you're you
- 52:57are dealing with You know these requests for
- 53:01accommodation if the doctor's note says this
- 53:04person has to work remotely end of story. That
- 53:08does make it difficult for the employer to engage
- 53:11in the interactive process, but they should still
- 53:13try. So they should say, hey, listen, we can't
- 53:15let you work remotely, but what we can do is
- 53:18offer you to come in a little earlier and leave
- 53:22a little earlier, or we could modify your hours.
- 53:24So it doesn't take away the employer's responsibility
- 53:28to engage in the interactive process and see
- 53:31if you can come up with you know, a middle ground.
- 53:34And I will say that all of these cases, these
- 53:37disability discrimination cases, result in the
- 53:39employer saying, you voluntarily quit, and the
- 53:42employee saying, I was constructively discharged.
- 53:44That is just the name of the game, because that's
- 53:47how it usually ends. They don't necessarily fire
- 53:50the employee, but the employee will say, like,
- 53:53I can't work here anymore because I can't. do
- 53:56this job without this accommodation that you're
- 53:57not getting me. So it's very common for the employer
- 54:00to say you quit and the employee to say you constructively
- 54:02discharge. Okay. Another question is how do you
- 54:05handle employees who can't identify their medical
- 54:08condition or someone who has several different
- 54:11medical conditions? Just get the medical records
- 54:14and go for from there. I mean, I would ask for
- 54:17a doctor's note. I wouldn't necessarily ask for
- 54:19the medical records, but you know, if an employee
- 54:21is saying to you, listen, I can't do this part
- 54:25of my job, and they don't have a reason for it.
- 54:29They are just saying like, you know, I don't
- 54:31feel well or something along those lines. That
- 54:34might not be a disability, right? It has to be
- 54:36a disability. What is it that's causing them
- 54:39to not be able to perform their job duties? I
- 54:41mean, were they tired because they were out?
- 54:44you know, late at a concert the night before,
- 54:46like, not a disability, right? So, I mean, I
- 54:48would ask for that doctor's note. That's a situation
- 54:52where it is reasonable to ask because you don't
- 54:54understand what the disability is and what the
- 54:57accommodation is that they're requesting. And
- 54:59so at that point, the doctor's note is going
- 55:00to be your best friend. And they're usually pretty
- 55:03clear about what it is the doctor thinks the
- 55:06person can't. do. You know, I think that this
- 55:10person can't lift and they shouldn't be lifting
- 55:11more than 15 pounds. And then you know, okay,
- 55:14here's what they're asking for and here's what
- 55:18they need the accommodation for. Can we accommodate
- 55:20that? Is that feasible? Is lifting an essential
- 55:23job function? If it is, then it could be an undue
- 55:27hardship. It's an unreasonable accommodation.
- 55:30So now I'm gonna go back to someone who has a
- 55:33question before, but let's get the person's second
- 55:36question. If an employee has the ability to use
- 55:39protected leave, why would there be a need for
- 55:43further accommodation? Assuming that leave is
- 55:45the requested accommodation. Yes, so employee
- 55:48gets injured and employee goes out on protected.
- 55:53Cifra medical leave. The employer has to, assuming
- 55:56that they employ enough employees, has to accommodate
- 55:59that, right? But let's say that those 12 weeks
- 56:02of protected leave runs out and the employee
- 56:04says, you know what, I need four more weeks.
- 56:07Well, they don't get job protection under Cifra.
- 56:10It's not automatic. But we now need to determine
- 56:14if that additional leave is a reasonable, can
- 56:18be reasonably accommodated. You know, can you
- 56:21go another two weeks, four weeks, six weeks without
- 56:24this employee, is that an undue hardship? So
- 56:27yes, you have to accommodate that initial request
- 56:31for leave because it's protected under CFRA,
- 56:34but then they may want leave after that, which
- 56:36happens all the time. Got it. And we have just
- 56:40a couple of minutes left. Let me squeeze in.
- 56:43A couple items. Oh, wait a minute. Do we have
- 56:46a new one there? Oh, I'm going to try one more
- 56:49from someone else before I squeeze in anything.
- 56:52Post -pandemic, have you experienced claims of
- 56:54disability accommodation made by employees who
- 56:57insist they must wear masks while working in
- 56:59their public -facing position? Waiters, cashiers.
- 57:03I have. I see it a lot. I would take the position,
- 57:09and there is no... definitive answer here. I
- 57:13take the position that there are very few, I
- 57:16can't even think of any jobs where you can't
- 57:19accommodate an employee wearing a mask. I mean,
- 57:22we've all gone to restaurants. We've been seated
- 57:25by people who are in masks. We have been waited
- 57:27on by people who are in masks. People have shown
- 57:31us to dressing rooms and given us clothing, wearing
- 57:33masks. I think that that is a reasonable accommodation.
- 57:38And especially if the employee has like an underlying
- 57:40medical condition or something that they're very
- 57:43concerned about, I think that is a very minimal
- 57:46ask that to me is in the category of saying like,
- 57:50you know, should I get my employee an ergonomic
- 57:52mouse? Like, yeah, you should go and spend that
- 57:54$30 and buy that mouse for your employee because
- 57:57I think that that's a reasonable accommodation.
- 57:59And if your employee is saying, hey, I am, you
- 58:02know, very concerned about getting COVID or getting,
- 58:05you know, getting a bad flu because I have an
- 58:07underlying medical condition or just because
- 58:09I don't want to get it. I don't think that it's
- 58:13a big ask to wear a mask, but I have had people
- 58:16call me and say that their employer is refusing
- 58:19to accommodate that. So, I mean, it is happening,
- 58:22but I think that's an unreasonable. it's unreasonable
- 58:25for an employer to refuse to account. So we have
- 58:27two minutes, one minute. Oh, one minute. Let
- 58:29me, I'll ask two 32nd questions. Attorneys fees.
- 58:33I didn't see something in attorney's fee. Are
- 58:35there any statutory attorney's fees? Beehaw has
- 58:38a whole statutory attorney scheme. And so, yes,
- 58:42absolutely. you get attorney's fees as the employee
- 58:46in a fee hot case. So that's very significant.
- 58:50And two, insurance coverage. Do you get into
- 58:54that ever or not? Or usually is it under specific?
- 58:57You have to get a specific policy and not under
- 59:00your general comprehensive liability. So I am
- 59:03plain of sight. So my knowledge of how insurance
- 59:06works is I say, does your company have insurance,
- 59:10like do I ask the employer if they have insurance?
- 59:12And then they say yes. If they say yes, then
- 59:14I'm going to ask for what those policy limits
- 59:17are. Standard, you know, EPLI insurance is going
- 59:20to cover a disability discrimination case. The
- 59:24only areas where, you know, insurance isn't going
- 59:27to apply in the employment context is like for
- 59:29wage and hour claims. That's often not going
- 59:31to apply. But, you know, employers oftentimes
- 59:33don't have insurance. They don't have EPLI insurance.
- 59:36And so you're, you know, You're liable. That
- 59:39was what a great presentation. And if there anything
- 59:42else, there may we may have missed one question
- 59:44there. Someone could can, of course, contact
- 59:46Leanne directly and and maybe she could help
- 59:51with your your specific issues. But thank you.
- 59:55Thank you. Thank you. What a great presentation.
- 59:58Boy, I learned a lot. So I'm sure everybody else
- 1:00:01did too. So thank you everyone in the webcast
- 1:00:05audience. We had a great turnout. Thank you Leanne
- 1:00:09again and see everybody else at the next program,
- 1:00:12which we're planning for January. Okay. Okay.
- 1:00:16Bye now.