Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / NCUA Exams: Insights and Trends with Todd Miller & Steve Farrar
Transcript
- 0:03Do you want to maximize your success with NCUA?
- 0:06Join Mark Treichel as he shares with you the insider's view on passing
- 0:09your exam with Flying Colors.
- 0:12The With Flying Colors podcast is sponsored by Credit Union
- 0:15Exam Solutions by Mark Treichel.
- 0:17If you would like to work directly with the Credit Union Exam Solutions
- 0:20team and receive support to optimize your results with NCUA so you save time
- 0:25and money, visit us at marktreichel.
- 0:27com to find out more.
- 0:35Treichel: Hey everyone.
- 0:35This is Mark Treichel with another episode of with flying colors.
- 0:38I'm back with two frequent guests to two of my team members, Steve
- 0:43Farr and Todd Millard guys.
- 0:44How are you doing today?
- 0:46Steve: Doing good.
- 0:48Very well.
- 0:49Treichel: Very well.
- 0:50All right.
- 0:50And we're going to, we're going to chat today about what we're seeing, what we're
- 0:55hearing in the landscape of our credit union conversations with our clients with
- 0:59just general conversations we're having with credit unions at transitioning over
- 1:03the last couple of years, what NCUA is doing as it relates to exams right now.
- 1:08But before we jump into that, let's The folks that listen to every podcast
- 1:14know who Steve and Todd are, but for, we might have some new listeners today.
- 1:19Steve, why don't you give a little bit of your background in credit, in
- 1:23the credit union world and at NCUF.
- 1:26Steve: All right.
- 1:26Sounds good.
- 1:27My career over 30 years in, so it can really be broken into two parts.
- 1:31The first half of it.
- 1:33It was spent in the field in the, as in the examiner ranks, most of it is a
- 1:39problem case officer working on the, those troubled credit unions, mainly on the West
- 1:46Coast, but I ended up being involved in conservatorships throughout the nation.
- 1:51Then I ended up in the central office about the time Mark went into the
- 1:56central office and I worked remotely in the division of risk management.
- 2:01And that was a great job because I got to be involved in lots
- 2:04of issues throughout my career.
- 2:07Some of the more interesting ones is I ended up writing the enforcement
- 2:11manual was involved in the corporate resolution, and then the last part
- 2:16of the career, I worked mainly on the risk based capital regulation.
- 2:21Treichel: Very good.
- 2:22Very good.
- 2:22And Todd a little summary of your 34 plus years at NCUA.
- 2:28Todd: I spent 34 years.
- 2:29I would break my career into three parts instead of two parts.
- 2:32I spent about a decade or a little bit more as an examiner
- 2:36and a problem case officer.
- 2:38Then I spent a decade or so as a capital market specialist, a
- 2:41regional capital market specialist.
- 2:43Then I spent the last 11 years of my career as a director of special actions
- 2:47in the Western region, supervising problem case officers and capital market
- 2:52specialists and That tenure started right during that last recession.
- 2:56So it was a pretty busy time as a director of special actions
- 3:00during that last recession.
- 3:02Treichel: Boy, isn't that the truth.
- 3:03So two funny stories that just popped into my head before we start off.
- 3:07I, Steve, you mentioned that you came into the central office about the time I did.
- 3:12And there, there's a correlation there because when I was the, and if for
- 3:16those NCOA folks listening here's a little bit of NCOA history, you may
- 3:19not be aware of the Agency did not have remote staff other than their examiners.
- 3:25If you worked in the office, you had to be in the office.
- 3:27If you worked in the office of examination of insurance, you
- 3:30needed to be in the office.
- 3:32And up until that point in time, leadership had not wanted to do that.
- 3:37And then And I director Dave Marquis was having trouble getting his positions
- 3:41filled and getting good applicants.
- 3:44And I said why don't you offer a remote position?
- 3:47You might get someone like Steve Farr to apply.
- 3:49Cause Steve and I had worked together in the West coast and he, and Dave
- 3:53looked at me, he goes, can I do that?
- 3:55And I said, sure, why not?
- 3:56So we announced it, the announcement came out and Jane Walters comes
- 4:00running up from the fourth floor says.
- 4:03What's this?
- 4:03You're letting he and I take remote staff.
- 4:07This doesn't make sense.
- 4:08And I said well, Jane, I think, they need to have a broader pool.
- 4:12And I think they can do these jobs from the field and don't
- 4:15necessarily have to be there.
- 4:17And we need our best and brightest to be willing to take raises.
- 4:20And if you got really smart people sitting in Montana, they're
- 4:23never going to be in Montana.
- 4:24The agency can be better if we offer these.
- 4:28I might not have given that example, but that was what was in my head.
- 4:30Cause but I did suggest to Dave that Steve might apply.
- 4:34Lo and behold, Steve did apply.
- 4:36He ended up getting the position and then later actually ended
- 4:38up moving to the East coast.
- 4:40And so that's the history of.
- 4:42The remote analyst, the remote anything at NCA goes back to that
- 4:46conversation between Dave Markey and I.
- 4:48And of course, they might have gone there at some other point in time, but
- 4:51we had then opened it up to the regions and they ended up starting doing that,
- 4:55which created better career paths.
- 4:57And then Steve and I.
- 4:59You talked about conservatorships and different things you worked on
- 5:02the corporate crisis and then I got thrust into the corporate crisis and
- 5:07needed to bring in people that I, A, that I trusted and B, that were smart.
- 5:11And Todd, sometimes you'll refer to your last year at Westcorp.
- 5:15When I swore you to secrecy and brought you in to help us figure
- 5:18out next steps at West core.
- 5:20So there, those are two additions to the journey that you two were
- 5:24on and which bring back fond and fond memories, but scar tissue.
- 5:29All right, guys.
- 5:30So it's been an interesting year so far in credit unions.
- 5:35It's been an interesting couple of years in the economy.
- 5:38And we're seeing.
- 5:40As I like to say there's a rhythm to what we're seeing based, on, on
- 5:44history and also based on where the trends and examinations are going.
- 5:48But let's speak a little bit to the conversations we're having
- 5:52the things that we're seeing repeating out in credit union.
- 5:56land as it relates to examinations.
- 5:59Anybody want to proffer up one thought first here?
- 6:03Todd: Sure, I can go first.
- 6:05It's interesting each year NCUA issues a supervisory priorities letter and what
- 6:11we see are somewhat consistent with that.
- 6:13If you look at the last couple years back in 2022 2023 When that
- 6:17yield curve inverted and you started seeing rates climb those years there
- 6:23was a heavy focus in our clients.
- 6:25Almost all of them were getting doors and findings on interest
- 6:28rate risk and liquidity risks.
- 6:31A lot of our clients were asked to reduce their interest rate
- 6:34risk back in 2022 and 2023.
- 6:39Loan concentration issues seem to have been an ever present thing
- 6:43during the last two or three years.
- 6:46As we got into last year and this year, we have an emerging type of trend, and
- 6:51it's probably a positive one where the examiners seem to have a very increased
- 6:57focus on board governance, and there's lots of pieces to that board governance
- 7:02one, but that's a big one that we're seeing here in the last year and a half
- 7:06or so is this focus on board governance and our board members putting, having
- 7:11appropriate oversight over their staff.
- 7:15And then the commercial lending has been a big thing last year and this
- 7:18year, especially, and the other thing we're seeing, and this has been a
- 7:22constant during this whole time, is they're really focusing on weaknesses
- 7:30in commercial lending programs.
- 7:33We've even had a couple of clients that have been told to cease commercial
- 7:36lending until they fix some of their internal controls and program monitoring.
- 7:41So that's a new one.
- 7:44That's a good one,
- 7:45Steve: Todd, because that, just imagine, though, if you're listening to this and
- 7:48then Sui came in and your program that is probably your cash cow and has a
- 7:54number of staff in there and they tell you to cease that, just think of how the
- 7:59impact of that has on you and now you have the challenge of, If they're good
- 8:03people retaining them while you're not producing new volume it's so that is it's
- 8:10a huge obstacle, but needed to be done in most of those cases, because the risk
- 8:15could become just so great but boy, that, that's, that is almost a poison pill,
- 8:21Treichel: That, that.
- 8:22That word cease.
- 8:23I remember when I was executive director credit union on the East Coast that
- 8:28in the region I used to supervise a really smart examiner actually put
- 8:33into a use the word cease, right?
- 8:37Which is not a good word to use in the exam, just because of the concept
- 8:42of cease and desist order, which is like this legal document that is
- 8:46rarely used, but it's used in banking.
- 8:47It's used at NCUA on very rare occasions, but discontinue, you'll
- 8:52see people use, but I think.
- 8:54That one particular case that I am mentioning might have been what
- 8:58triggered I know, Todd, in some of our conversations, you have
- 9:02mentioned that if you're going to tell someone they have to stop doing
- 9:07something that the policy now at N.
- 9:09C.
- 9:09U.
- 9:09A.
- 9:10Is That needs to be run up the flagpole to a higher level.
- 9:13Is there anything you can share relative to your memories on how that policy works?
- 9:18If someone's going to say stop commercial what does that trigger at NCUA?
- 9:22Todd: Ceasing anything at NCUA requires your supervisor's approval.
- 9:27An examiner doesn't get to make that choice themselves and while it's not
- 9:32required, I suspect anytime a supervisor has got a recommendation from an examiner
- 9:38about ceasing a program, I'm pretty certain that supervisor is going to have
- 9:42a conversation with the ARD as well.
- 9:45It's going to be a couple levels above an examiner's head that it's going
- 9:48to sign off on a door or an action that says cease an activity because
- 9:54there's just reputation risk involved in that there has to be a certain high
- 9:58degree of risk to the insurance fund when you tell a credit union to see
- 10:02something because you are creating reputation risk for that credit union.
- 10:06Like Steve says, you risk people leaving at that.
- 10:10Is going to be a short term thing.
- 10:12Generally, when NCOA asks you to cease a program, they have conditions in
- 10:16place before you get to restart that line of business again, and usually
- 10:22the problems are severe enough that you don't get to fix those, or you're
- 10:26not able to fix those in two or three months, it's usually an extended period
- 10:30of time to meet all the conditions you need to meet to restart that again.
- 10:35So they're pretty significant actions on the part of the agency.
- 10:40Treichel: We did have one situation where we were able to assist a credit
- 10:44union that had the worst word ceased come forward in a draft document, but
- 10:49the things that Steve mentioned and Todd that you just mentioned that if
- 10:52you shut a program off in totality, it's harder to turn it back on.
- 10:57And oh, by the way, what happens to your staffing?
- 10:59And will you be positioned to keep them or not?
- 11:02And in that particular instance, without going into details, we were able to it.
- 11:08The credit union and with discussions with us, we're able to get the N.
- 11:12C.
- 11:12U.
- 11:12A.
- 11:13to give a little bit more flexibility relative to that.
- 11:16Now you can see them telling or we've seen them say that they need
- 11:22to cease because of non compliance.
- 11:24And we've seen them.
- 11:26Tell credit unions to cease because of concentration risks, or perhaps that
- 11:31they don't believe the concentration risk the risk appetite, if you will, has been
- 11:38adequately defined by the credit union.
- 11:40So it couldn't be that particular topic.
- 11:43I've seen it coming from different directions.
- 11:45Any thoughts on?
- 11:46I don't think risk appetites is anything we've discussed here yet.
- 11:50But board governance, concentration risk appetite.
- 11:53Any thoughts on what we've seen or what you're hearing on the risk appetite front?
- 11:57Because that's a subcategory of a theme of a lot of our discussions
- 12:01that that I'm recalling from the last two, three, four months.
- 12:05Todd: It's somewhat interesting, and the agency says cardians outside
- 12:09of ones that don't need enterprise risk management type programs.
- 12:13But more and more, if you actually read the doors that people are getting
- 12:18the board governance issues, they're getting specific to concentration risk.
- 12:22And we've been seeing this for the last 3 years.
- 12:24They want cardians to justify.
- 12:27Their risk appetite and those concentration risk limits.
- 12:30They want actual modeling support that those limits are appropriate.
- 12:35And those are all directions of they're really moving every institution out there
- 12:39towards having a reasonable capital plan.
- 12:43A reasonable risk appetite state.
- 12:45So they're getting everyone 80 percent to an enterprise risk management program.
- 12:50That seems the direction that they're pushing.
- 12:52I think some of this board governance is a subset of that too.
- 12:57They want the boards to know exactly what the risk appetites
- 13:01is in their credit unions.
- 13:02They want to know what the credit unions risk position is and there's a greater
- 13:06expectation, or at least their Putting down on paper, a greater expectation for
- 13:12boards to supervise and hold management accountable for these risk positions.
- 13:19And that's not a bad thing.
- 13:20It's probably a good thing.
- 13:22Treichel: In the whole management accountable in, in corporate governance,
- 13:26I've said this, I don't know if I've said this on the podcast, but I've said this
- 13:30in some conversations with clients, it almost seems as if when the examiners see
- 13:37something that happened, they didn't like.
- 13:39Whether there was zero board governance or 80 percent of what NCUA wanted
- 13:45to see in board governance, they raise it as a board governance issue.
- 13:49It's, here's a program that went awry, or here's a program we're questioning,
- 13:55or here's a program that doesn't have enough safeguards around it.
- 13:58NCUA staff have been have had advanced training on board governance when maybe
- 14:05when they got down together in New Orleans last year, but it's definitely
- 14:09a theme that's running through that.
- 14:11If there's a door that's tied to a, B or C.
- 14:15It may also be linked to board governance, but.
- 14:18Todd: We see that word appropriate oversight quite often.
- 14:23We see them holding board governance accountable for a higher level of
- 14:27accountability for strategic planning.
- 14:30Profitability issues are under that umbrella board governance that we've
- 14:34seen a very big one that we're seeing is.
- 14:38They expect board members to have a hand in due diligence on new programs.
- 14:45New programs have come up multiple times in the last year where there's
- 14:48an expectation the board is fully aware of the risks and rewards of new
- 14:53programs and they're throwing that under the board governance issue.
- 14:58Treichel: Even going so far as possible new programs.
- 15:02I've seen credit unions get dinged where they're just contemplating, think we might
- 15:06be thinking about having a discussion.
- 15:08Why wasn't the fact that you might be thinking about possibly having a
- 15:12discussion in your board minutes which in that particular instance was a little
- 15:16bit farther than I think reality would have been appropriate in, but it's
- 15:20definitely a focus that they're having.
- 15:23And one of the thing that popped into my head and I, this is some research I
- 15:27need to do There is no broad requirement for enterprise risk management.
- 15:32The ones credit unions is where that all started.
- 15:34And there is an expectation at ones that they are going to
- 15:38have enterprise risk management.
- 15:39Corporate credit unions by regulation are required to have
- 15:42enterprise risk management.
- 15:44Somewhere along the line.
- 15:45And I'm not really certain when there is a portion of NCOA's examiner's
- 15:50guide that says, there enterprise risk management guidelines for
- 15:54large credit unions, but it does not define what large credit unions are.
- 15:58And as I'm thinking through that we've talked a little
- 16:01bit about the Chevron case.
- 16:02The way the examiner guide works now, it's like a living, breathing document.
- 16:07They go in there, they make a change to something, it's
- 16:11not announced to the world.
- 16:13It might be redacted.
- 16:14So the world really doesn't know what it says.
- 16:16But there's this new section, whether it's 6 months, 12 months, 18 months.
- 16:20I'm guessing it's more around a 6 month timeline on enterprise risk management.
- 16:25It's going to be interesting.
- 16:26To see how that trickles down.
- 16:29I think the challenge ultimately that they have is if they come out
- 16:33with a letter to credit unions on enterprise risk management that
- 16:37could lead to people pushing back.
- 16:38That could lead to what's this board member one in it.
- 16:41What does that board member want in it?
- 16:43And so there's A subtler way for NCUA to effect change, and that's by dropping
- 16:49it into the examiner finding or dropping it into the national Supervision Policy
- 16:53manual, which is also heavily redacted.
- 16:56So it makes it challenging for credit unions to understand the expectations.
- 17:00It makes it challenging for it just makes it challenging because of the whole, the
- 17:04challenge of safety and sound is bringing, being a broad brush that NCA paints with.
- 17:09Frequently.
- 17:09Steve, you and I had talked a little bit about the challenges of the new world
- 17:15that might become because of Chevron.
- 17:17Any guys, anything I've said there trigger anything in your head.
- 17:21Steve: Let's just cover the topic of what we see a lot of it.
- 17:24It's just frustration and that the frustration is usually directly
- 17:29associated with their communications.
- 17:31With their examiner, which is I'm telling you that's been going on since, since
- 17:37the Babylonians cross Euphrates, right?
- 17:39But we know that the whole time, but what's happening now is you
- 17:43do have, examiners getting back into the credit unions and looking
- 17:49at things a little bit more.
- 17:51And, they don't really have frustration with what problems
- 17:55they're finding that the credit union has, that's usually not the issue.
- 17:59There usually can be an agreement with, yeah, here's what our problems are.
- 18:03Sometimes the frustration is in exactly how it's going to be fixed
- 18:07and the cost of which that's going to be and the timeframes for that.
- 18:10But if it really comes down to the main thing is that.
- 18:14How you're communicating with that examiner can have a lot to do
- 18:17with how you see your regulatory process working for or against you.
- 18:24We understand, there's these different between, the different generations and
- 18:28how they want to go about communicating, but it is and I, and we hear about a lot.
- 18:34So we we tell, the credit unions, do what you need to do on your end of
- 18:38the communications, and when you have a communication with your examiner,
- 18:43whoever, follow up with that email that says, here's what we discussed, here's
- 18:47my understanding of it, but to try and reduce that frustration level, and I know
- 18:52you guys will have more thoughts on that.
- 18:55Treichel: That's a great conversation that I think we should have.
- 18:58I got a couple of thoughts, but Todd, I'm going to let you chime in first.
- 19:02Todd: The communication part has always been an issue, and I think
- 19:05some of it today, they missed a lot of things during COVID years.
- 19:09And we're seeing that with some of our clients that they're bringing
- 19:12the issues to light that actually existed for a couple years and
- 19:16were not brought up before.
- 19:18Like Steve says, that creates a little bit of frustration.
- 19:21NCUA's policy and practices have always been when you have issues that
- 19:26the credit union needs to address, they're supposed to sit down with
- 19:29management and have a conversation.
- 19:31How do we best address these?
- 19:33There should be some give and take.
- 19:34There should be some give and take on timelines to correct things.
- 19:38And more and more of what we're seeing is exam reports are taking a long time
- 19:44from the time they finish field work till they get to the credit union and
- 19:47then the credit union gets surprised.
- 19:49You know that they get a door and they're given 60 days or 90 days to fix it and
- 19:54it's a total surprise that they haven't had this discussion about this issue
- 19:59with their examiners during the exam.
- 20:02And I think some of that is maybe resource constraints on the part of NCUA.
- 20:06They're a little bit behind.
- 20:09Maybe some of it's just you know, they got into bad communication
- 20:13habits during COVID and aren't used to sitting down and talking to management.
- 20:17Some of this is on credit unions.
- 20:19We have some one client where none of their management teams are
- 20:22on site, even though the credit union examiners came on site.
- 20:25So there's both sides to the communication breakdowns.
- 20:29Credit unions, you're responsible for your members.
- 20:31So if your examiners not doing their part, I guess you have to step up your
- 20:36game and do your part a little bit more.
- 20:39But communications is a big piece of this and surprises don't go over well
- 20:44and some of our credit unions just seem to be surprised more and more that they
- 20:48get a report and there hasn't been a full discussion of these doors in them.
- 20:53Treichel: It's I wrote after Steve.
- 20:56Brought this topic up.
- 20:57I wrote down resources and no surprises or surprises and there
- 21:00really shouldn't be surprises.
- 21:02Back in the day you had to give them the draft report when the examiners
- 21:06were allowed to give camel in the full report a week before any meeting.
- 21:11And, today we just last week there, there were credit unions finding out
- 21:17at the joint conference, what the code was not having seen any documents other
- 21:21than draft doors that were delivered.
- 21:23Two months earlier and the timelines had already passed and it's a little
- 21:27bit almost like trying to get.
- 21:29Sadly, I think there's a little bit at the agency of trying to
- 21:32get toothpaste back in the tube.
- 21:34They're having difficulty getting their work done timely.
- 21:37They brought it up at their board meetings that the only 80 percent of code.
- 21:413 is we're done within policy.
- 21:43Excuse me.
- 21:44Only 67 percent of code.
- 21:453 is we're done within policies.
- 21:47Only 80 percent of code.
- 21:494 is we're done.
- 21:50It within policy meanwhile, camel codes are getting worse, meaning
- 21:54they're having to do more follow up exams at the credit unions.
- 21:58They have while half their staff has come on since the or more of their staff
- 22:04has come on since the Great Recession.
- 22:05And it hasn't seen the churning of the challenges of what camel
- 22:09codes can do to their resources.
- 22:11And, oh, by the way, what it can do to credit union resources when comes
- 22:14back every 6 months instead of every.
- 22:1812 months or 18 months if you're on an extended cycle.
- 22:21So yeah, the communication, it goes back to the beginning of time.
- 22:26And it's wreaking havoc in some situations.
- 22:29And so the best advice for credit unions is what Steve said there that To document
- 22:34what your agreements are encourages taping of exit conferences, which when
- 22:40they first came out with that approach, I really didn't think was necessary.
- 22:43But the more time goes on, I think that's a pretty wise
- 22:46step in the electronic world.
- 22:48We're living in here today.
- 22:50What todd, you brought up Previously, the heavy focus on interest
- 22:54rate risk and liquidity risk.
- 22:55That's seems to be trending down in 2024.
- 22:58We've talked about board governance.
- 23:00Steve, I know you have mentioned on the topic of board governance.
- 23:04We're seeing it a lot, but there's a document that you
- 23:06like to refer clients to a lot.
- 23:08Could you do you remind me what that is?
- 23:11Steve: Yeah, it's something I carry with me almost everywhere I go anymore.
- 23:14So it's it's was put out by the FDIC, and it's the title of it is Guidelines
- 23:20Establishing Standards for Corporate Governance and Risk Management for
- 23:25Covered Institutions with Total Consolidated Assets of 10 Billion
- 23:29or More, and this was put in the Federal Register in October of 23, 23.
- 23:36We do find, there's this trickling down it's really good guidance and I've
- 23:40shared it with some people I know that are on boards of large credit unions and
- 23:46they're like, wow, we're not subject to that because they're usually below 10
- 23:52billion, but the guidance, they find it to be really helpful and as a good tool
- 23:56towards training, training their board members, And just it's a requirement to
- 24:02have them read through it because it has a wonderful definition of risk appetite.
- 24:08And, the training of the board and the responsibilities, the 1st, 2nd, 3rd line.
- 24:15It is something that we do, we have been sharing with anybody that is starting to
- 24:19get that corporate governance question.
- 24:23Treichel: Yeah, that's a really good document.
- 24:25Like you said, they're not, you might not be a 10 billion dollar credit union, but
- 24:28whatever size credit you are, you can.
- 24:31Learn good basic principles by reading that document.
- 24:35And you might glean, if you're a small credit union, you might glean two or
- 24:38three things that you might want to add.
- 24:41If you're less than 10 billion you could probably bullet proof your
- 24:45board governance if you took a lot of those principles into play.
- 24:48And of course there's costs associated with it, but some of it's just
- 24:51common sense on things you need to think about, like having an ethics,
- 24:55a link to it, et cetera, et cetera.
- 24:58Todd: I think you can even circle back a little bit more and
- 25:01understand why NCUA is doing this.
- 25:03If you look at all their letters and you look at the regulation, they use this word
- 25:08with risk management systems commensurate with your size and complexity.
- 25:13And the fact of the matter is, As credit unions even cross that billion dollar
- 25:18threshold and you start having complexity where you got commercial lending programs,
- 25:23you got third party lending programs, you've got direct real estate lending
- 25:27programs, you're selling things on the market, you have a high level of interest
- 25:32rate risk, even though your asset size might be a long ways away from 10 billion,
- 25:37your complexity is approaching that level and realistically to stay competitive
- 25:42and operate your institution in a safe and sound manner, your risk management.
- 25:47processes have to evolve to almost where they're at that point.
- 25:51I tend to call it like a ruler of sophistication.
- 25:54And even when I was a director of special actions and I'd get a billion
- 25:59dollar code for, we would actually put in our door that, they needed to get an
- 26:05enterprise risk management system in place before they got out of special actions.
- 26:09Cause the reality is once you get a code for, and you get it fixed, you
- 26:13want it fixed to the point where it's never going to come back to that again.
- 26:17You don't want to see problems repeated and having good risk
- 26:21management systems in place.
- 26:22It prevents those problems from being repeated down the road again.
- 26:27Treichel: That reminds me of a conversation.
- 26:30Again the conversations bleed together.
- 26:32The longer we do this, whether it was on a different podcast or with a client
- 26:36where you made the point of when.
- 26:38When you went into capital markets, how the agency was behind the curve on banks
- 26:42and credit unions were behind the curve.
- 26:45And now that's more of a mature understanding at NCUA and at
- 26:48credit unions, albeit it's been challenged over the last couple
- 26:51of years with things going on.
- 26:53And the, the correlation to that's where corporate governance is at, right?
- 26:59NCUA doesn't require enterprise risk management.
- 27:02They probably should, at least at some level, but The way they're
- 27:07bootstrapping that is by raising the bar on corporate governance
- 27:11which in general is a good thing.
- 27:13We might see it on steroids sometimes when it doesn't need to be on steroids,
- 27:17but it's a good discipline for everybody to be aware of and to wherever they're
- 27:21at on it to improve is a good thing.
- 27:25Steve: Along those lines, another topic I want to bring up is that, we,
- 27:28I think we've seen issues where there was more requirements for different
- 27:33types of stress testing and Todd, I'm sure that you might have kind of
- 27:38thoughts on that because there's a cost and benefit associated with those.
- 27:42And if you agree that's something that we've been seeing a little bit more of.
- 27:47Todd: We've seen this actually we've been seeing it for the last three
- 27:50years is on the concentration risk and it reflects actually back to any
- 27:55policy limit you set, whether it's liquidity limits, whether it's interest
- 27:59rate risk limits, whether it's loan concentrations, borrowing levels, there's
- 28:05an increasing, it's not an increasing, it's been there for the last three years.
- 28:10There's an expectation from examiners now that credit unions can
- 28:13analytically support those limits, along the rulers of sophistication.
- 28:19You use experience.
- 28:21Hey, this is where we set the limit.
- 28:22We think this is appropriate.
- 28:24While that was appropriate in the past it doesn't seem to be
- 28:27sufficient for examiners today.
- 28:30They want stress testing for these limits.
- 28:33In some cases there's Simpler, less expensive ways to do that
- 28:37stress testing at other times.
- 28:39Some of the stress testing gets very costly and expensive.
- 28:42It's very sophisticated.
- 28:44We've seen credit unions where examiners on just on their documents resolution.
- 28:50They want commercial loan portfolios stress tested at an individual loan level.
- 28:55So the expectations for some of that stress testing and supporting
- 29:00of concentration limits is getting very high and It's been
- 29:04there for the last three years.
- 29:05We see it almost all the time and it used to be You looked at these limits
- 29:13per net worth and it was examiner's judgment, you know this examiner.
- 29:16He's comfortable with 400 net worth in first mortgage loans and then You
- 29:22know, examiner B comes in, and this young lady is not comfortable with 400.
- 29:28And then someone like Steve or I come in, we're comfortable with 500.
- 29:31There's different informal risk levels that examiners set
- 29:36based on their own experience.
- 29:38Anymore they're moving away from that.
- 29:39And, they're not leaving it up to examiner judgments.
- 29:42We're just seeing doors and bindings that Credit union, you need to
- 29:47support your risk limits in some analytical way, shape or fashion.
- 29:51And like I said, sometimes it's easier to do.
- 29:54Sometimes it's extremely expensive process for credit unions to go through.
- 29:58And it almost leads back to, and credit unions don't, or examiners
- 30:02don't articulate it this way.
- 30:04But it really leads back to just about every credit union needs
- 30:07to have a capital plan nowadays.
- 30:09And, right now that's only expected of ones.
- 30:12But, you mentioned it earlier, Mark, some of these expectations on ones credit
- 30:16unions seem to be filtering down to credit unions, that are even under a billion
- 30:21dollars in some cases when it comes to stress testing concentration limits.
- 30:26Treichel: And that becomes a challenge.
- 30:27I know, The, the board packages.
- 30:30So if you have board governance, what does board governance need?
- 30:32You need to have a capital plan.
- 30:34You need to stress test this.
- 30:36You need to stress test that.
- 30:37And there's this danger of, let's just add another, let's just add
- 30:45another layer of documents to, to what the board has to see that the board
- 30:51has to sign off on beyond what the regulations say the board has to approve.
- 30:56And it's because you become, Lucille ball trying to get the chocolates
- 31:00onto the, into the chocolate box.
- 31:02Cause there's only so many hours a day.
- 31:03There's only so many resources and the smaller you get, the
- 31:07less of those resources you have.
- 31:09But an NCOA examiner see something good in a 10 billion credit union.
- 31:13And then they do it in an 8 billion and then they do it in a 6 billion.
- 31:16And the trickle down is real.
- 31:19It just happens.
- 31:20I knew it happened when I was at NCOA, but.
- 31:23We see it all the time here, and it's a delicate balance between it all being
- 31:29wise and good to creating a burden that is just gonna lead to unnecessary
- 31:35mergers, et cetera, et cetera.
- 31:37Any thoughts on.
- 31:39Where we're at on that pendulum or any disagreements on how I frame that there.
- 31:44Todd: I think it goes back to Steve's earlier words where there's, this is one
- 31:47of the areas that creates frustrations for the credit unions because the examiners
- 31:51will still support this analytically do a stress test, but then they'll, the credit
- 31:57union will ask, okay, what does that mean?
- 31:58And what is expected of us?
- 32:00And then the.
- 32:01Examiners can't really articulate what they want.
- 32:04We want to stress test.
- 32:05Okay.
- 32:06How do we go about that?
- 32:07And then it's dead silence from the examiners.
- 32:10And that builds in some of that frustration and that they set
- 32:13expectations for this, but then they can't articulate what they want.
- 32:18What is sufficient for them?
- 32:21Or how does the credit go about it?
- 32:23So they leave the credit and hang and we expect you to do this, but
- 32:26we're not going to tell you how or how much money it should cost
- 32:30or what will be acceptable to us.
- 32:32It's go through the process and then we'll decide whether it's good or not.
- 32:35On the back
- 32:36Treichel: end.
- 32:37Yeah, we'll tell you if it's beautiful.
- 32:38That builds in
- 32:38Todd: frustration because Steve said, these things cost money and you don't want
- 32:41to spend money and go through this with good intentions and then your examiners
- 32:45tell you that's not good enough after you spent 50, 000 and took a month.
- 32:50And I don't think, I think this is one of the things That examiners, they
- 32:54don't necessarily dig into expenses that and they're told not to dig into
- 32:59expenses, unless there's problems, but I think for a lot of examiners.
- 33:04They don't really understand the costs involved with some of the
- 33:07things they put in their doors.
- 33:09Maybe your problem case officers and your more experienced long term
- 33:12examiners do, your younger examiners and by and large, I'd say on average,
- 33:17most of your examiners have no idea what the cost is for those doors
- 33:23that are writing to the credit union.
- 33:25And sometimes, and you do see this, especially with newer
- 33:29examiners, they the doors create more problems than they solve.
- 33:33Treichel: Yes, we've seen a handful of those instances as well, for sure.
- 33:36So, what else we what other trends are we seeing?
- 33:39Any other thoughts on what's going on?
- 33:42I think the only one we haven't
- 33:44Todd: talked about
- 33:46We're seeing a lot of that and one thing that we've seen in multiple
- 33:51clients, three or four of them, there's really this whole focus.
- 33:55And this is coming from the agency at the top on consumer compliance.
- 34:00You got to make sure you get your reg Z and truth and lending
- 34:02and all that stuff squared away.
- 34:04If you're letting third party people fill documents out for you, And this is
- 34:09one of those issues where it seems to bypass the COVID years where it didn't
- 34:15get looked at and maybe some of it, it's just NCUA's renewed emphasis on this,
- 34:20but third party relationships, you need to make sure all the documents of those
- 34:24third party loans, especially have all this truth in lending, consumer compliance
- 34:29issues, BSA issues all squared away.
- 34:32Because NCOA seems to be digging into those types of issues with
- 34:36third party lending relationships.
- 34:39Treichel: Yes, indeed they are.
- 34:40That's going to continue because, let's see, we're, the NCOA board has
- 34:45a they probably their agenda for July will come out today I believe, because
- 34:50their board meeting's next week.
- 34:52And They'll either talk about where their budgets at or have a vote on
- 34:56the budget, but we used to do some reconfiguring at budgets like that.
- 35:00I'm guessing with this board, they might not.
- 35:02I'm not sure if Todd Harper's back.
- 35:03Chairman Todd Harper is back in the building and back at
- 35:06work for this board meeting.
- 35:09He may be.
- 35:10But there's the mid year budget and then coming up in November, there is the budget
- 35:14where Chairman Harper is going to have his first vote as a chairman with a Democrat
- 35:19who is also very pro consumer compliance.
- 35:23As they have expanded into this area where they're watching Reg Z closer, where
- 35:28they're watching all these regulations, As it relates to 3rd party originations,
- 35:34they're starting to see trends in certain things in that arena, which will fuel the
- 35:39fire for the into a board to perhaps say, we need nor specialists in this arena.
- 35:45And I know there's things going on at the agency where
- 35:47they're retooling some of that.
- 35:48I think there will be a big reveal.
- 35:51At some juncture probably at the budget briefing where they say they'll come out
- 35:57and they'll say we want to add 20 and then they'll say that they listened and
- 36:01they'll come in and they'll only add 10.
- 36:02they'll take out 10 of them and say, they listened to the industry, but
- 36:05there's going to be more done in that.
- 36:07They're talking about doing separate compliance exams.
- 36:10They've alluded to that.
- 36:11There hasn't been a lot said about it, but there will be some sort of reveal
- 36:14relative to that would be my guess.
- 36:16Thanks.
- 36:17So yeah, that's a, that, that's going to be a growing area
- 36:20of review by NCUA for sure.
- 36:23Todd: All right, guys, information security.
- 36:26It's what information security is probably worth talking about, too.
- 36:30It's always been an emphasis within CUA party unions have always actually
- 36:35been appreciative of what those regional information specialists
- 36:39provide on exams, in the past, their work has mainly been, Put out his
- 36:43supplementary facts or exam findings.
- 36:46We rarely see doors on information security.
- 36:49Of course, we have a big information security event going on right now.
- 36:53I think cranes can maybe expect increased scrutiny in that area.
- 36:59They've been feeling it for years, but it wouldn't surprise me of
- 37:03things that were supplementary facts and findings in the past.
- 37:06Don't find their ways to doors given what's happened in the last week.
- 37:11Treichel: It's yeah, without naming names, everybody is going to know
- 37:14probably what we're speaking to.
- 37:16But, there have been discussions and chatter that I've seen that
- 37:21this incident is mainly dance.
- 37:24You a continuing to beat the drum on 3rd party.
- 37:28Vendor authority which I think this could be the straw that breaks the camel's back,
- 37:33if you will, no pun intended on camel.
- 37:36But we could see we could see that we've, I've seen two different stories
- 37:40out where leaders in the industry are saying, no, they shouldn't have it and
- 37:45someone came out yesterday and said maybe they should, in light of things that
- 37:48are going on And, NCOA does post mortem reviews on things when things go bad.
- 37:54And there's clearly going to be lessons learned from what's going on
- 38:00in one particular credit union right now which has dragged on far longer,
- 38:05I think, than I'm sure that they had wanted or their members had wanted.
- 38:09And I'm really surprised how under, how limited the press has been nationally on.
- 38:16That particular event I am going to have a podcast coming up talking
- 38:21about how are we going to frame it on having good communication
- 38:26plans for when things go wrong?
- 38:27Because going back to the theme of this how important communication is with N.
- 38:32C.
- 38:32U.
- 38:32A.
- 38:33It's even more important when your members win when things go wrong.
- 38:36John McKechnie, former PACA director, and I are going to get on and talk about
- 38:40that sometime here in the near future.
- 38:42Definitely challenges out there.
- 38:44Steve any thoughts on that particular topic?
- 38:47Steve: No, I think we covered it.
- 38:48It's not fun to talk about.
- 38:49So let's not talk about it
- 38:51Treichel: if that's a wrap.
- 38:53Yeah.
- 38:55I love it.
- 38:55All right, guys.
- 38:56This was fun.
- 38:57I'm sure we missed a few and, when we chat tomorrow with another client or a
- 39:01pre talk with the client or something, I'm sure we'll go, you know what?
- 39:04We should have brought up X, but this will be something maybe we'll
- 39:07have every quarter where we just say, what are the trends we're seeing
- 39:10in our conversations with Craig.
- 39:11Interesting
- 39:12Todd: on the cyber attack.
- 39:13As you look at Patelco, I've seen another article.
- 39:15The average is 22 to 28 days to recover from one of these.
- 39:19And like another one, it's not getting lit.
- 39:22National attention.
- 39:24I don't know if there's any Lithia car dealers where you guys are at.
- 39:27Lithia is a big national chain.
- 39:30They had a cyber attack.
- 39:32It's over a month ago, and I know a person here in Billings.
- 39:35They're still doing everything by hand.
- 39:37Are you kidding me?
- 39:38Wow.
- 39:39Their whole service department by hand.
- 39:40You go buy a new car.
- 39:42It's all the dock person.
- 39:43They're filling it all out by hand.
- 39:46Their systems are still down, and that's over a month ago.
- 39:50Treichel: I guess that's why the NCWA board always frequently says I can't
- 39:53sleep at night because of what I'm hearing about cyber security and that
- 39:58car dealership problem the ransomware we're talking about Things are,
- 40:04things seem to be ramping up, right?
- 40:06I think we'll be seeing more and more of this, which means ends may, we'll
- 40:09be talking more and more about it.
- 40:11And perhaps having you add some more things to your budget that you can't
- 40:15have, can't afford, but that you need to do all right, guys, this has been fun.
- 40:19Any last thoughts?
- 40:21Todd: No.
- 40:22I thought you were done already when I started talking about the 22 days.
- 40:26Treichel: I was done, but then, we started talking about the 22 day
- 40:29average, and we forgot to weave in that.
- 40:32We forgot to weave in that reference to the car the car implosion, that
- 40:35car software that's it's crazy stuff.
- 40:37All right, guys, this has been fun.
- 40:39Listeners.
- 40:39I want to Steve Todd.
- 40:40Thank you listeners.
- 40:42I want to thank you for listening.
- 40:44As always.
- 40:44I hope you'll listen again soon.
- 40:46Mark Treichel signing off with flying colors.
- 40:55Thank you for joining us on this episode of with flying colors, subscribe on
- 40:59your favorite podcast app to hear future episodes where subject matter experts
- 41:03of all varieties will provide tips on how to achieve success with NCUA.
- 41:07If you would like to learn more about how we assist credit unions, check
- 41:11out our services at marktreichel.
- 41:13com.