Latest / Onramp Bitcoin Media / Wake Up Call (11.25.24): Brennan Warble, Partner at Active Capital Partners
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to another episode of Wake Up Call.
- 0:03Before we get started, please like, share and subscribe to on
- 0:06ramp media channels to receive the best Bitcoin education and
- 0:09content in the industry. And also be sure to check out
- 0:11our latest research report titled Bitcoin the Emergent
- 0:15Asset class has arrived. This is a three-part series
- 0:18aimed at introducing important Bitcoin centric concepts to the
- 0:21institutional allocator world. Part 1 available now and
- 0:25LinkedIn. The show notes explores Bitcoins
- 0:26volatility and why it is a uniquely desirable
- 0:29characteristic of the asset that can boost returns and dampen
- 0:32volatility in traditional portfolios.
- 0:35Wake Up Call aims to educate financial professionals on the
- 0:38merits of the Bitcoin investment thesis.
- 0:40How this asset class represents both a threat to legacy
- 0:43financial service businesses and an opportunity to differentiate
- 0:46oneselves to retain and attract new clients.
- 0:49Hosted by Mark Connors on Ramp's Head of Global Macro Strategy
- 0:52and Rich Kerr on Ramp's President of Managed Wealth,
- 0:55this weekly show seeks to provide financial professionals
- 0:58the wake up call they need, prompt them to have an open mind
- 1:01with respect to Bitcoin, rethink their prior assumptions, become
- 1:04more educated on the topic, and learn from others who are
- 1:07already farther down this path. Wake Up Call is live streamed on
- 1:11LinkedIn every Monday morning and the recording can be found
- 1:14across on RAMP media channels. Now time for the show.
- 1:18Hey everybody, welcome to today's wake up call.
- 1:22We have a special guest with us today and Brendan Warble from
- 1:26Active Capital Partners. Rich Kerr is taking the day off.
- 1:30So it's just the two of us today, but a timely topic.
- 1:35Brendan joins us to discuss the history of convertible bonds and
- 1:41timely because on CNBCI, think about 10 minutes ago, Brennan,
- 1:45we had Michael Saylor talking about his purchase of 55,000
- 1:48Bitcoin and really how he's manufacturing the purchase of
- 1:56Bitcoin by selling volatility. So that's today's topic.
- 2:00It's, it's a new, it's a new phenomena to have a company buy
- 2:04Bitcoin, but it's not a new phenomena to introduce
- 2:08convertibles into a marketplace. So 1st, I'm going to go and talk
- 2:12a little bit about Brendan's background and, and touch on it.
- 2:17And, and truth be told also Brendan and I've known each
- 2:20other for a long time because we were both in the convert world
- 2:24and, and, and grew up in the same area.
- 2:27So we've been having more stories on, on the markets for
- 2:31quite a while. Happy to have you here, Brendan.
- 2:34So why why don't you go and tell us a little about Active Capital
- 2:37Partners, you know, the boutique that you advise, I think I mean
- 2:42from cap raises to talent to strategy and you know, you're
- 2:45taking your 30 plus years and and then talking to up and
- 2:49coming and maybe not so up and coming firms.
- 2:51Yeah, well, thanks, Mark. Thanks for having me.
- 2:53And yeah, Mark and I have been classmates, schoolmates,
- 2:57friends. Mark was a client for a little
- 2:59while. He was a competitor for a little
- 3:01while. So I've seen all sides of of
- 3:04Mark and and joining this little podcast has been is awesome.
- 3:09So thanks for having me. You bet 3 Active Capital
- 3:11Partners is an advisory boutique investment bank.
- 3:16We we raise third party cap, we raise capital for issuers to
- 3:20raise capital for companies. And so I'm doing on taking, as
- 3:26Mark said, 30 years of experience on Wall Street with
- 3:28some great old friends who I worked with at places in the
- 3:32past and applying what we've learned to help corporates
- 3:36navigate capital raises, cap structure advisory, as Mark
- 3:40said, we do the whole bit. But before I got here, there was
- 3:44a time in my life when I spent 100% of my day on convertible
- 3:48bonds and and the convertible ecosystem.
- 3:53So I literally worked on issuing, distributing,
- 3:59originating, selling and trading convertible bonds for the 1st
- 4:041015 years of my career. It was a fantastic time.
- 4:07As Mark said, this is not a new trade.
- 4:09Even this structure, the 0 coupon is the 1st 0 coupon was
- 4:15issued by Waste Management 1985 was called a liquid yield
- 4:18option. Note something that we developed
- 4:20when I was at Merrill Lynch by some super bright corporate
- 4:25finance folks. Merrill Lynch had a very strong
- 4:27Chicago corporate finance team and was able to get some forward
- 4:32thinking CFOs willing to issue unique structures that solve
- 4:36very specific problems. But back to Mark's point about
- 4:41volatility in the commerce market and and Michael Saylor's
- 4:44trades, it is fascinating. And now also with the whole
- 4:48options complex around Bitcoin exploding just in the last four
- 4:51days, which is, you know, options are yet another
- 4:55volatility instrument to trade the underlying.
- 4:59There's just a lot going on in this space right now.
- 5:02So timing is excellent. But taking it back to converse,
- 5:05the reason commercial bonds exist is because there were many
- 5:09usually lower credit quality junkie companies that had risky
- 5:12cash flows or no cash flows. And because they were so
- 5:16volatile, the option that they'd be selling in the convertible
- 5:19bond market was worth a lot, right?
- 5:21Because if if you can, and you'd always have to think like a
- 5:24hedge fund, like, OK, if, well, if I can get long that
- 5:28volatility by selling off the bond floor and just be trading
- 5:31an option, which is what a lot of folks did back then.
- 5:35The convert market came into existence because people said,
- 5:37OK, if I'm getting a current income and then I can insulate
- 5:42myself from stock prices by shorting the stock.
- 5:44If your hedge fund, then of course I, I, I can extract the,
- 5:50the volatility and make some money.
- 5:54Similarly, if you were a traditional investor and you
- 5:56said, well, if I'm getting a coupon that's going to pay me
- 6:00back my premium that I'm paying over the stock price, the
- 6:03conversion premium, it's going to be very difficult to
- 6:06underperform the stock on the upside or the downside as long
- 6:09as I've got a long enough horizon.
- 6:10So said differently, if you have a, you know, a 10% yielding
- 6:13security with a 20% premium in two years, you're going to have
- 6:19guaranteed yourself outperforming the common stock
- 6:21on the upside. And of course, in the downside,
- 6:24you always do much better because of these bond floors.
- 6:27And friends, so let's so you talk about waste management in
- 6:3085, let's put this in perspective.
- 6:34Mike Milliken developed a high yield market in the in the early
- 6:3880s and it was on the back of, you know, the double recessions
- 6:43that kind of cracked companies down, made assets very cheap.
- 6:48Interest rates peaked in 1981 at 16% in a 10 year and all of a
- 6:54sudden asset value started to go higher from that point.
- 6:57High yield is a great time to do high yield.
- 6:59And then so that was the birth of credit really in a new asset
- 7:03class that he he basically fathered with with.
- 7:07Yep. Drexel and then, you know, a
- 7:10little bit into other companies, but then equity volatile.
- 7:13So this is a new one. So then converts really were
- 7:15born off of that as a as a side chain because they weren't as
- 7:19big as a high yield market. Is that fair?
- 7:21No, the convertible bond market in the, you know, 90s was
- 7:25relatively small. It's very obscure little market.
- 7:28We used to joke there were only like 30 or 40 people that really
- 7:30understood this market because who else would spend their whole
- 7:32day on it? It was too small.
- 7:34But it's interesting you, you mentioned Milken, because some
- 7:38of the folks that came out of that group were big supporters
- 7:42of the convertible bond market. So Howard Marks who went on to
- 7:45found Oak Tree at the time was at Trust Company, the West.
- 7:49And Trust Company was one of these forward thinking firms.
- 7:52And Howard really drove this thinking that if these
- 7:55securities are cheap, then then we ought to be allocating
- 7:59capital to them. And he of course came at it from
- 8:02a credit standpoint, right? Because at the end of the day,
- 8:05even if you look at this most recent micro strategy bond, you
- 8:09know, something like 80% of the asset is going to be the bond
- 8:12floor and then the balance is going to be the option that's
- 8:14embedded in it. So what was interesting about
- 8:20the convertible bond market then is you needed issuers, right?
- 8:24So if a very junky credit couldn't fund itself in the high
- 8:26yield market, it would often come to the convert market
- 8:29because there were there was a different environment and there
- 8:31there might be a way to to raise capital.
- 8:34What really changed the market was when firms like Merrill
- 8:38Lynch went out to corporates and said, hey, just so you know,
- 8:42you've got this asset on your balance sheet, you probably
- 8:44don't know what it is. It's called volatility and there
- 8:46are ways to to monetize it. Now there were some very sharp
- 8:52treasury offices at places like Microsoft that understood their
- 8:56volatility was valuable and they used to trade it.
- 8:58And they usually the most common way to do that was through a put
- 9:01writing program. So if you had high Vol and you
- 9:04had a buyback, stock buyback already in place, you just write
- 9:07a put as a treasure. And then if you got hit on the
- 9:09stock, you were happy because you had a stock buyback anyway.
- 9:12You know, if the stock went down and if it didn't go down, then
- 9:15you realize you're high volatility, right?
- 9:16Because you're selling volatility.
- 9:19That was sort of an early precursor into going to a lot of
- 9:22these corporates and saying, OK, you're a pretty high Vol stock,
- 9:26which means the convertible bond market will pay a lot for that
- 9:29embedded option that's in your convert.
- 9:32And then we can drive down your interest expense.
- 9:35And the 0 coupon was a game changer because it was actually,
- 9:39they weren't paying out interest, but they could deduct
- 9:41that interest against their earnings as if they were.
- 9:44And then if the stock went up a lot, like in the case of
- 9:46MicroStrategy, 55%, most treasurers were very, we're
- 9:51thinking or most CFOs would think, jeez, if my stocks up
- 9:5450%, life's pretty good. If it ends up converting out,
- 9:56it's I can suffer the dilution and I'd be happy with that
- 9:59transaction. So now, now what's different
- 10:03about what sailors doing is he loaded up his balance sheet with
- 10:07a risky asset to get the volatility.
- 10:09So he almost did it backwards. He said, OK, I'm going to go
- 10:12find a Bitcoin. It's super Vol.
- 10:15I'm going to go buy a bunch of it.
- 10:17Mostly issuing stock back then when he first started back in
- 10:212020 and then as his stock became more volatile because he
- 10:26had such a large chunk of Bitcoin on his balance sheet,
- 10:31then he could take the next step, which is come to the
- 10:33convertible bond market and issue a really high premium 0
- 10:37coupon convertible bond. That is a win win for him and
- 10:43for his investors because he's getting that high premium.
- 10:45He's he's, you know, he's getting the proceeds, he's going
- 10:50out and buying Bitcoin. And to this point, it's been a
- 10:52virtuous circle. It's worked.
- 10:55I, I, I know Mark, you've done a lot of work on micro strategy
- 10:58and you know this company, you know much better than I do and
- 11:01I'm not giving any investment advice.
- 11:02I, I I. Yeah, this is not.
- 11:04This is basically highlighting the fact that we've gotten a lot
- 11:07of calls saying what's going on, is this, you know, a forest or
- 11:11is this a game? And it's like, no.
- 11:13And as Brendan said, there's this asset that's latent to most
- 11:18people unless you can structure it.
- 11:22And God knows Wall Street love structure because you create it.
- 11:26And then they're like, now this is what you're giving me as a
- 11:29package. I now have the ability to take
- 11:31that package and harvest the volatility that is in a
- 11:37convertible bond or even in the equity by trading options
- 11:41against it. And, and and that's the real
- 11:45game here, folks, is to to notice that.
- 11:47So this is a different calling we've had in the past.
- 11:50Brennan is not in a Bitcoin focus firm.
- 11:53Brennan brings the the traditional finance history in
- 11:58alternatives and what micro strategy has done is they've
- 12:01created a new alternative, as you said brand, they reverse
- 12:04engineered it. They recognized Bitcoin's
- 12:07volatility over here. They brought it into their
- 12:10capital structure, invited it in their capital structure
- 12:13explodes. Then they sell that that 100%
- 12:18volatility to the market for 50 Vol.
- 12:22So that's the difficult concept maybe for some, but the the $3
- 12:27billion Brennan of of 0 converts they sold, what was the premium
- 12:32on the equity? So that was a 55% premium versus
- 12:37the last sale when when they issued it?
- 12:39So when a convertible bond, like I don't know who you want to
- 12:42think of in the old days, you know, but those convertible bond
- 12:44traders, they see that and do they get the knife and fork out
- 12:48and get ready to go. The real trick in the in the
- 12:51micro strategy trade to me is because this is a very
- 12:56attractive vehicle to hedge funds.
- 12:57Now there are some traditional outright investors who will want
- 12:59that payoff profile of downside protection with most of the
- 13:02upside, but the initial buyer is somebody who understands
- 13:05volatility really well. So just breaking down the
- 13:08specific bond, right, it's a five year bond.
- 13:11It's got it, as Mark said, a 55% premium and a 0% coupon.
- 13:15So it's paying absolutely no yield, but you do get your money
- 13:19back at the end of five years if, if the stock has gone down.
- 13:24So if you're trying to break it down and say, well, what's this
- 13:27thing worth? You'd say, OK, well
- 13:29MicroStrategy could probably issue straight debt I'm
- 13:32guessing, but 8-9 percent in in the high yield market if they
- 13:36wanted to. And if you did the present value
- 13:38for 0 that gets you like $68 worth of of stock around value
- 13:43of the security. And the balance is, is the
- 13:47option premium that you're paying as an investor.
- 13:51And if you line up the similar strike, there happens to be a
- 13:55two year, 2.2 year call on MicroStrategy.
- 13:59If you line it up and, and look at it, it actually trades around
- 14:0332 Volt. So, so you'd say 32% of spot,
- 14:07excuse me, not Volt. So that tells you that a 2
- 14:12point, a 2:00-ish year option is trading at the same price as
- 14:15these guys are buying a five year option.
- 14:17So that to me is a cheap security.
- 14:20So, so the, the tricky part it though is you do need to get
- 14:23your hedge off if you're, if you're a arbitrageur.
- 14:26The great thing is once that security's out there because
- 14:30these convertible bonds are incredibly convex, meaning the,
- 14:34the, your participation goes up as the stock goes up and your
- 14:40participation goes down as the stock goes down.
- 14:42So we call that delta, right? So your delta increases as
- 14:48stocks go up and it decreases, it goes down the the gamma,
- 14:52which is what these guys want to own is your rate of change of
- 14:55that delta. And so when I say think like a
- 14:57hedge fund, if you're a hedge fund and you buy the
- 14:59MicroStrategy convert, you short the appropriate amount of shares
- 15:02and you get these gappy moves. You come in, you know, over the
- 15:05weekend and, and MicroStrategy stock or Bitcoin goes down, you
- 15:09know, 20%, you're supposed to be on a 70% hedge, but you're
- 15:12actually on a 50% hedge because of that gap lower.
- 15:14So you got to go in and buy those shares, which is all pure
- 15:16profit. Similarly, if it goes up, if you
- 15:19have a big gap move up, you're going to have a profit on the
- 15:21upside. But what that also means is, and
- 15:24this is Mark and I were talking about how as Bitcoin matures as
- 15:27a market, it just sucks in new investors and new people with
- 15:31different perspectives and ideas.
- 15:32So imagine, you know, there's a a convertible arbitrager who
- 15:36never had to have an opinion on Bitcoin up until Michael started
- 15:39issuing all these converts. And now all of a sudden they've
- 15:42got to get up to speed and understand the asset class.
- 15:46And as life goes on, these guys move on and they go be a risk
- 15:49manager at a pension or endowment.
- 15:51And then somebody says, I want to add Bitcoin to their strategy
- 15:54and they say, well, jeez, I actually understand this asset.
- 15:56So and this is just how you move an asset into other markets.
- 16:02So you start in, you know, purely Bitcoin, then you move
- 16:05into the equity market, then you move into converts.
- 16:07Now we've got a whole options complex and each one of these
- 16:10nodes brings in a whole additional group.
- 16:13And so to me, that's also what smooths volatility and brings it
- 16:17down because there's not only the natural incremental buyers
- 16:21that you've brought in from different asset classes, but
- 16:24you've also have that very technical selling and buying of
- 16:30a convex security. As it goes down, you've got
- 16:31natural buyers, as it goes up, you've got natural sellers.
- 16:34And that dampens volatility over time.
- 16:35And and does what I think most people hope and expect will
- 16:39happen with Bitcoin is that it eventually will become a more
- 16:42stable asset. Yeah, that and that, that
- 16:45concept, I know that Brian Cabela is our Chief of strategy
- 16:48is going to cut that out and put that on a snippet what you just
- 16:51said, because that is what everyone's saying.
- 16:54Is this cycle different for Bitcoin?
- 16:56And it's going to be a function of, well, has the constituency
- 17:00changed And absolutely it has. As you said, we now have people
- 17:05who aren't just outright, not just punters, not just, you
- 17:09know, buy and hold, but we have people who are trading on a
- 17:12conditional basis because of the new instruments.
- 17:17Now back to the micro strategy, specifically what he's really
- 17:20doing, Mark, is he's trying to outrun his dilution, right?
- 17:23So he's saying, I know you had some slides and you read the the
- 17:29most recent quarterly earnings report, but you know, here's a
- 17:33company who lost $18 million on their core business in the most
- 17:36recent quarter, right, but somehow has been the best
- 17:40performing stock. And the S&P 500, it's up, it's
- 17:46up over 3000%, while Bitcoin's only up like 700% since he
- 17:51started buying it. And so you'd say like, well, how
- 17:54can that happen? And the answer is he is
- 17:56outrunning the dilution. So I'm just going to read you a
- 17:59quote from his earnings report. This is Michael Saylor.
- 18:02He said our objective continues to be to accumulate Bitcoin
- 18:05holdings at a faster rate than we issue shares.
- 18:08We've demonstrated a solid track record of doing so.
- 18:11To assess our performance and achieving a strategic objective.
- 18:14We've introduced a new key performance indicator last
- 18:16quarter, which we refer to Bitcoin yield.
- 18:19To reiterate again, we define Bitcoin yield as a period to
- 18:21period percentage change in the ratio of our total Bitcoin
- 18:24holdings to our assumed diluted shares outstanding.
- 18:27So that is by definition, he's saying, as long as I keep buying
- 18:31this asset and it keeps going up, it's not going to be
- 18:34dilutive, especially if I'm selling high premium convertible
- 18:36bonds, because I'm getting that gap between spot and and the
- 18:39premium. And eventually it will convert
- 18:42out if the stock goes higher. If it goes lower, there's a, you
- 18:45know, there's a bill to pay, right, that you get to put the
- 18:47bonds back to him. But that also will create a
- 18:51fascinating ecosystem for, for the whole, you know, Bitcoin and
- 18:57and MicroStrategy and then the options all around it.
- 18:59So it's wonderful that we've got all these options about now,
- 19:02Mark, you've got, you know, literally you've got two times
- 19:04ETF's, you've got spot, you've got convertible bonds.
- 19:07Now you've got, you can buy puts, you can sell calls, you
- 19:10can take advantage of tax mitigating strategies.
- 19:12If you're long one of the ETFs, you can, you can create income
- 19:16by selling calls against your position.
- 19:19Or if you, you know, are worried about the downside, you mean you
- 19:22don't want to pay your tax bill, you can buy puts.
- 19:25So it really to me, as I said earlier, it's just this
- 19:27incredible maturation of a market that's happening in real
- 19:30time, like since a year ago. Think of all the instruments
- 19:33that are available now when it used to be, you know, for a lot
- 19:38of folks it was like, well, I could buy Grayscale and worry
- 19:41about where my coins are or, or, or I could buy physical, you
- 19:46know, I could actually buy Bitcoin and store it.
- 19:48Then I got to worry about where my keys are.
- 19:51Yeah. Now you know you can buy an ETF
- 19:53in a Fidelity account and you can sell calls against it and
- 19:57you can create yield without having to worry about any
- 19:59counterparty credit risk. You're selling calls that are
- 20:02backed by the options Clearing Corporation OCC zero credit
- 20:04risk. It's it's just.
- 20:07Fascinating and phenomenal to see this market continue to to
- 20:11move and. Fast, Brendan, the the I bid
- 20:14options came out just last week. Is that right?
- 20:16And then on to FBTC and the other ones.
- 20:19Yeah. And So what was really
- 20:20interesting about that? Sorry to jump in, Mark.
- 20:22Yeah, yeah. We've only got two or three days
- 20:26of data, so it'll be interesting.
- 20:27But usually when you have options, you've got what we call
- 20:33options skew. I know Mark talks about, you
- 20:35know, skew of performance, but the idea that because more
- 20:41people are interested in buying downside protection because and
- 20:43markets tend to gap lower and they tend to, you know, slowly
- 20:47go up. It's volatility on the downside
- 20:50is always more expensive or usually more expensive in the
- 20:52options market than upside because there are just more
- 20:55buyers of downside. There are more people looking
- 20:57for protection and there's less people looking to sell upside,
- 21:01excuse me, buy upside in Ivy initially and then the others as
- 21:05they came on Thursday and Friday, we didn't see that.
- 21:07We saw basically flat skew, which means there were more
- 21:10people. And if you looked at actual
- 21:12strikes, because we get to see all this data, which is also
- 21:14very cool, it there were more people buying calls than there
- 21:19were people buying puts. So now if you want to be a
- 21:22contrarian, you'd say we've got an asset that's had this massive
- 21:25run and nobody wants to hedge that.
- 21:26That seems interesting, except for the supply demand dynamic,
- 21:32which at this moment in time is so far skewed to, to buyers and
- 21:36so far skewed away from, from sellers and that we've, we've
- 21:40got less Bitcoin coming on every day and then we've got
- 21:42incremental new buyers. It could be that.
- 21:44OK, well, it just makes sense to be long, not, you know, not
- 21:47short. So, but I, I did not, I was kind
- 21:51of surprised by that because when we saw GLD like the gold
- 21:55ETFs come in and options there, you did see that people were
- 21:59buying, you know, downside. Now maybe that's because there's
- 22:02producers who need to hedge that.
- 22:03There's all kinds of reasons for it, but it's different and
- 22:06unique. It'll be interesting to see how
- 22:07that plays out over the next 6121824 months.
- 22:11Are you ready to secure your future with Bitcoin?
- 22:13At Onramp, we're revolutionizing how you can save for retirement.
- 22:17Onramp has just launched the industry's first Bitcoin IRA
- 22:20product with multi institution custody, designed to give you
- 22:23unparalleled security, transparency and Peace of Mind.
- 22:26With Onramp, you can verify your assets on chain and protect them
- 22:30with the support of three independent institutions,
- 22:33reducing risks and enhancing security.
- 22:36At Onramp, we believe that Bitcoin is the most important
- 22:38asset of the 21st century. The hard part is securing it
- 22:41right. There are shortcomings with
- 22:43keeping your coins on an exchange, but also with setting
- 22:46up your own self custody arrangement.
- 22:48Onramp solves for these concerns.
- 22:50Our multi institution custody solution maximizes security and
- 22:53minimizes counterparty risk, ensuring that your Bitcoin
- 22:57remains securely in your possession and provides built in
- 23:00inheritance planning to ensure your family is protected as
- 23:02well. On Ramp provides Peace of Mind
- 23:05for your Bitcoin journey, whether for your whole stack or
- 23:07for part of it as a complement to your existing self custody
- 23:10set up. For more information about our
- 23:12services as well as our new Bitcoin IRA product, check us
- 23:16out at on rampbitcoin.com. Yeah.
- 23:19And as and more people will come up with stories and that's why
- 23:22we're staying to the structure. And I, I love what you're doing
- 23:25by just talking about how people play when they see the high Vol
- 23:28asset come in. Historically they would be well
- 23:33harvesting it through a convert etcetera as an issuer and and
- 23:36taking in that excess cash without paying coupon because
- 23:41there's another person who can buy the convert and then sell
- 23:44the equity. That's one way to do it.
- 23:47And then as you're saying, when you look at those highball
- 23:51stocks, though, only looking at the stock people know that
- 23:55markets, you know, as we talked about it, it's the escalator in
- 23:58the way up and the elevator shaft in the way down.
- 24:02And we know we, we, we tend to be, you know, fear based
- 24:05amygdala focused creatures, so that we'll be buying puts more
- 24:12than calls to protect that that investment.
- 24:15But that's not the case with what we've seen with, with
- 24:17Bitcoin. And I'm going to do a side shot
- 24:20here to talk about the core asset and what I think Sailor
- 24:25did. And as you said, as more people
- 24:28migrate from an ARB trader and they then go to a pension fund,
- 24:32they're going to be able to say, Oh, I, I know Bitcoin.
- 24:35So what he's done is at a minimum is he has accelerated,
- 24:40call it, you know the adoption cycle of Bitcoin.
- 24:46And, and so this is a report we put out last month and this is
- 24:53an example of, you know, we talked about performance skew or
- 24:55asymmetry. Bitcoins return profile is
- 24:59different. Its volatility has more upside
- 25:02than downside. There's no other asset that I've
- 25:06seen single stock or commodity that currently has this.
- 25:11Sometimes growth stocks out-of-the-box like Tesla five
- 25:13years ago would have a little bit of it, but it fades.
- 25:16Bitcoins been persistent. So this is one, one example when
- 25:21people say Bitcoin is a like a 3 * X brand.
- 25:23You've heard people say, you know, our, our friends may say,
- 25:26yeah, you know, Bitcoins like a just a 3X on NASDAQ, you know,
- 25:31it's high beta. So then we say, all right, well,
- 25:33maybe if that's the case, then if we bought Bitcoin and sold
- 25:38NASDAQ, we should have the three times performance up and down
- 25:41against it. And this little exercise we have
- 25:44done here is we've said, let's take a three month performance
- 25:47of Bitcoin and then let's get along that performance and sell
- 25:52Nasdaq's performance against it. Well, as you see, Bitcoin has
- 25:58more upsides and downsides and more frequently.
- 26:01So the concept of asymmetry is borne out by just looking at
- 26:05over the past seven years, if you were long Bitcoin, you
- 26:10performed better than NASDAQ on a very non normal distribution.
- 26:16And that's the core and that non normal.
- 26:19And Michael Saylor is now bringing that asymmetry to the
- 26:24to the unwashed. We'll call them to to to tratify
- 26:28who never knew about it. And then I, I guess I'll persist
- 26:33in this discussion of the volatility in our report by
- 26:39saying that when you look at upside and downside volatility
- 26:45equities here, this is looking at the large cap equity index,
- 26:51which is basically the S&P, It has upside volatility of like
- 26:5411. That's just looking at the up
- 26:57days, the volatility of only up days, but the down days have a
- 27:01higher volatility again, back to that elevator shaft and they're
- 27:04way down. And bonds are definitely
- 27:07negatively skewed or have more downside 4.4 versus 2.5.
- 27:13But Bitcoin, which we know is like a 50 or 60 Vol when you
- 27:16look at all the stats together. But if you RIP it apart, and
- 27:19we're going into the technical weeds here, I, I know I'll get a
- 27:21buzzer soon to get out of here, but this is what people in the
- 27:25market are doing. Michael Saylor has allowed
- 27:27people by creating a convertible bond to RIP out the good Val
- 27:33versus bad Val. Bitcoin, when you look at all
- 27:35the days together up and down, it has like a 55 Val now.
- 27:40It used to be 100. It's gone down.
- 27:42But when you only look at the good days, its volatility is
- 27:46three times or more greater than its downside.
- 27:49It has more upside than downside.
- 27:52Gold is similar, but to a lesser degree.
- 27:56So I'll, I'll go back to our regularly scheduled program here
- 27:59now. But the the reason we bring that
- 28:03up is because as Chris Kiper noted last week and on our call,
- 28:10Brennan, and what you're talking about is no one knows this.
- 28:14Investors still say bitcoins too volatile.
- 28:17That's the number one answer at Fidelity for five years in a row
- 28:20on why investors don't buy it. Sailors saying, oh, I think
- 28:26you'll like this volatility. And then people take the next
- 28:31step on adoption. So is is there an analog in in
- 28:36your career, Brennan, on an emergent technology or or
- 28:42strategy where it went, you know, from the periphery like
- 28:47into a wrapper like this or? Well, yeah, I would say actually
- 28:50the the convertible bond market in general is a great example.
- 28:55I mean, taking it out to the macro again.
- 28:57So I remember there was a time, so when when we went out to
- 29:01these issuers and we said, hey, you've got this asset, you can
- 29:04monetize it. The response was universally
- 29:06like that's great, I'd like to do that.
- 29:08And we had this rush of issuers in the 2000s or so where
- 29:12corporates were just issuing bonds constantly.
- 29:14And I remember Henry Sueka, who was one of the founders of
- 29:17Highbridge, was in her office. And he was like, are you guys
- 29:20going to just issue a convert on every company in the S&P 500?
- 29:24But this is insane because we've been this very small sort of
- 29:27insulated market and and there weren't massive pools of
- 29:32capital. And we said, yeah, that's the
- 29:34plan. We'd love to do that if we
- 29:35could. And then he said, well, we're
- 29:37going to need to attract more capital to this market if you're
- 29:39going to do that. Of a sudden what came was this
- 29:41sort of jerk water backwater market started to grow and many
- 29:48of these what we now think of the largest multi strategy
- 29:53institutional hedge funds like a Citadel Highbridge.
- 29:57They all started as these dedicated little convertible
- 29:59arbitragers. And then they they realized that
- 30:02they needed more capital. And so they went out and they
- 30:05raised more capital to invest in this market.
- 30:07And then all of a sudden they need they couldn't deploy all
- 30:09their capital because investors like the returns that they were
- 30:12getting. And so they broadened out in the
- 30:14long short equity and credit and and then stat ARB and and and
- 30:18became these, you know, monsters.
- 30:19So sailors just kind of going back to the roots.
- 30:22He's saying, look, this is a great place to raise capital
- 30:263020, thirty years ago, and it's a great place to raise capital
- 30:29for me now because of these unique dynamics where I'm
- 30:33selling an asset that, as you said, most of the world thinks
- 30:36is bad, right? So he's literally benefiting
- 30:40from this asset that you're just said people don't want.
- 30:43So he's saying, OK, well, I I hear you that, but there are a
- 30:46group of people who love volatility.
- 30:48So let's find them, bring them into the fold and let's give
- 30:52them what they want and let's take those proceeds and invest
- 30:54in what we want, all of which works to lower the volatility of
- 30:58the asset over time, I believe. Yep, home.
- 31:01Run print that one and and you touched on it briefly, but you
- 31:06know, one of the most successful largest hedge funds in the world
- 31:10starting in what market? Yeah.
- 31:12Convertible bonds. Convertible bonds.
- 31:14Yep, CDL Securities Ken Griffin. You know, Ken Griffin when he
- 31:19was at Harvard had a seat on the Merrill Lynch Boston office desk
- 31:22because he wanted to access to a Bloomberg Terminal.
- 31:25And there's a very forward thinking sales guy named Terry
- 31:27O'Connor who said, you know, I'd like to make a bet on this guy
- 31:31and let him come in and, and and trade.
- 31:33And he did. And because of that, Terry and
- 31:38and Merrill enjoyed a very great relationship with Ken and
- 31:41Citadel for a long time. But yeah, that, that was, you
- 31:45know, a, a brand new market and, and new investors.
- 31:47And now they're, you know, you've seen how these firms have
- 31:53prospered and moved into different markets.
- 31:55And now Citadel trade something like, I don't know, 40% of
- 31:58equities and even bigger number of options every day.
- 32:01So it's it, this is how a mark, as I said 100 times on this
- 32:04call, this is how a market matures and gets bigger and and
- 32:07and less volatile, not the other way around.
- 32:09Yeah, and. And back to the point about
- 32:11Terry, is it O'Connell O'Connor? Yeah.
- 32:15O'Connor OK I. I, I should know that the fact I
- 32:17got an Irish guy's name wrong is just not good.
- 32:20So the fact that Terry O'Connor saw that and then brought in Ken
- 32:25Griffin, it's always the edges, you know, it's, it's always
- 32:28someone on the edge sees something is involved, persists.
- 32:34And then the stepwise function I believe is, is what sailors done
- 32:41by injecting this unique volatility into a familiar
- 32:46instrument where everyone knows how to look at it, but no one
- 32:50has a model to look at what I think is basically liquid
- 32:56venture capital, which is what Bitcoin is.
- 32:58It's just, it's a, it's a software that was released into
- 33:01the wild. It got escaped velocity in being
- 33:05fully decentralized. It got adoption serves purposes
- 33:09people still don't don't know what it is, but still he goes,
- 33:12don't worry about it. I now have a company where I can
- 33:16have enough critical mass to give you a wrapper around it.
- 33:21So then you can monetize it and and that I think, as you said,
- 33:26is going to be you know, that's the Boston Maryland.
- 33:29He's basically created the that Merrill Lynch office where he's
- 33:34what what he's. What he's really done, Mark, is
- 33:36he's created different payoff profiles for different levels of
- 33:40risk, right? So, so to your point, it is a
- 33:43volatile asset and some people would say, you know what, I'd
- 33:45prefer to own that volatile asset in something that gives me
- 33:48some downside protection in case I'm wrong.
- 33:51So Michael Sayer is saying, hey, here you go, you, you can own
- 33:54this asset. Now you get into the credit
- 33:56quality of MicroStrategy. If the stock does go down and,
- 33:59and, and that's, you know, something I'll leave to the
- 34:01credit analyst, but you know, the deal is you get the upside
- 34:05of Bitcoin without the downside. And if the stock, excuse me,
- 34:09MicroStrategy, to the extent you think MicroStrategy is
- 34:11correlated to Bitcoin, and we all know it has been, but you
- 34:14get the upside of MicroStrategy stock with less downside.
- 34:19So you get your good Vol to the upside and you mitigate the
- 34:22downside, the downside Vol. And there are some folks in the
- 34:26world, especially institutions who say, I'm happy to take that
- 34:30payoff profile versus just being long Bitcoin or being long a
- 34:34double Bitcoin ETF. So as I was saying before, now
- 34:40we have all these different payoff profiles to for any
- 34:42investor. So it's not just, OK, I'm long
- 34:45Bitcoin spot and I'm going to get that return.
- 34:49You've got, you've got different ways to play the same theme that
- 34:55you can customize to your risk profile that's more tolerable to
- 34:59you, which should mean you're going to be able to hold it if
- 35:02things go sideways in the short term.
- 35:06Yes, you, you. You definitely have and and he's
- 35:11been will say this. I will comment on on sailors
- 35:14approach. It's thoughtful and he's laid it
- 35:18out. There are some assumptions of
- 35:19course on on performance of the of the company's ability to pay
- 35:24its capital structure. He has refinanced debt, he's
- 35:28issued debt. If you look at his cash
- 35:31position, just to let you know that you know, the man is an
- 35:34engineer. His cash flow from operations,
- 35:38even with billions of dollars flowing in and out of his
- 35:41company is within I think $1.2 million.
- 35:46His cash flow at beginning of, you know, nine months ago, the
- 35:52September nine months ago versus December, 9 months ago numbers.
- 35:56So he's, he's very surgical in how he's managing his capital
- 36:02structure. So he he is thoughtful and as
- 36:04you said, he's giving you a bond, a convert equity,
- 36:09different payoff structures. He understands the marketplace
- 36:14very well. It's an excellent point, Mark.
- 36:16Because from far away it just looks reckless, right?
- 36:19If you don't really dig into it, it, it just you're like, what is
- 36:23happening here? And then you, you dig in into it
- 36:25deeper and deeper and you say, OK, there is a very clear
- 36:28strategy here. And it's, it's interesting to to
- 36:31see it play out in, in real time.
- 36:33Yeah. So Brendan, if, if we're, we're
- 36:38going to wrap up here in, in, in a minute or two.
- 36:42Is there anything else? That is interesting.
- 36:45You think be worthwhile to advise us and who we're speaking
- 36:48to in this call are people who maybe have half a foot or toe
- 36:51into Bitcoin, but really have a traditional asset business and
- 36:56are interested in in Bitcoin or in its use in a traditional
- 37:03portfolio? Well, I'm going to go back.
- 37:05To to my roots and and just plug the convertible bond market.
- 37:08So so a Goodyear of issuance in the convertible bond market is
- 37:11like, you know, 100 billion, right?
- 37:14And it's 300 billion ish size market.
- 37:17And and because as stocks go up and they do have an upward bias,
- 37:23they the the winners get selected out and they get called
- 37:25away. You make you enjoy the upside
- 37:27and then they're gone. And so you have to constantly
- 37:29replenish yourself. But to the extent you are
- 37:32interested in Bitcoin and, and, but you just want to put a toe
- 37:35in now the convertible bond market is, is actually a good
- 37:38way to do it because there are dedicated convertible bond
- 37:41managers that will, that just invest in this space.
- 37:44And they're, they're, they're have to be invested in these
- 37:47securities because all of them are, are judged on an index like
- 37:52any portfolio manager. And these indexes are going to
- 37:54absorb these bonds. So if you've got, you know, $8
- 37:57billion of convertible issuance into $100 billion issuance, all
- 38:01of a sudden that's 8% of us coming to the market.
- 38:03But now there are other, you know, we didn't talk about,
- 38:05there are other corporates who are copying sailors trade.
- 38:09And I would expect that that you'll see more of that.
- 38:12And so the and and by the way, if you're a convertible R, you'd
- 38:19be very happy to do this same trade with a separate different
- 38:23corporate issuer, because then you've got less, you know,
- 38:26portfolio risk to one credit. So I would expect you to see
- 38:30more other companies issuing convertible bonds and investing
- 38:35in Bitcoin as as the treasury function starts to look at
- 38:38Bitcoin as an asset. You know, we know we've got this
- 38:40Microsoft. Oh, I was hoping I was.
- 38:43Hoping you can bring that up because in in sellers chart and
- 38:47and we posted on our LinkedIn Microsoft like it's 10 year
- 38:53numbers up 24%. It's five year numbers up 22%.
- 38:57It's one year numbers up 12% and it's just it's rate of return is
- 39:01declining over time. And tell the owns what you're
- 39:07about to talk about. Well, just that they're.
- 39:09Voting on whether the Treasury should be allowed to hold
- 39:12Bitcoin now, I would say Microsoft historically has been
- 39:14a incredibly sophisticated Treasury operator.
- 39:17I mentioned earlier in the call that they used to trade their
- 39:19own volatility before anybody else did and they they viewed it
- 39:24as an asset and they viewed it as their asset.
- 39:26They, they were very, very, we used to do synthetic convertible
- 39:30bonds on occasion for a dedicated convertible bond
- 39:34manager who wanted exposure to a specific stock that didn't have
- 39:37a convert outstanding. And the Microsoft guys hated the
- 39:41idea that somebody else was monetizing their volatility.
- 39:43They just, they, they, I remember that.
- 39:44Yep. Naked flex their muscles.
- 39:46A bit obviously at A, at a, you know, so I would, I don't know,
- 39:51I'm not predicting what will happen with with Microsoft, but
- 39:54I am predicting that there will be other issuers who have seen
- 39:58the ability to monetize your volatility and potentially, you
- 40:04know, buy Bitcoin and stick it on their balance sheet and then
- 40:07increase their own volatility and do the trade all over again.
- 40:09We've already seen, I think we have two now.
- 40:10Maybe there's more globally that I'm not aware of, but Medic
- 40:15planet you got. You know, and then Sembler
- 40:19Scientific have done it, OK. Dylan.
- 40:22Dylan. Leclair went over and joined the
- 40:25Japanese company and same thing their, their numbers are like,
- 40:29you know, triple the market cap just since doing the Bitcoin
- 40:32trade. Yeah.
- 40:34Well, this has been great, Mark. Thank you for having me on.
- 40:36I really appreciate the opportunity and it's been fun,
- 40:39Brandon. It's so fun because as I'm doing
- 40:42this, I'm like, wait a minute. I remember as you said, we were,
- 40:45you know, I was a client for a while and then, you know,
- 40:48competitor. But it was, I knew you'd have
- 40:51the stories and you and you brought it.
- 40:52So thanks for that. My pleasure.
- 40:55All right. Cheers.
- 40:56Take care. All right, see you.
- 40:58Thanks for listening to this. Week's episode of the show.
- 41:01If you found the information valuable, please share the
- 41:03episode with a friend or leave a rating on your favorite podcast
- 41:06app. All the links we discussed in
- 41:07today's show will be in the show notes inside your podcast app.
- 41:10Before we finish, a quick reminder that On Rat Media is
- 41:13for informational and entertainment purposes only, and
- 41:15nothing should be construed as investment or legal advice.
- 41:19Regardless of where you are on your Bitcoin journey, we'd love
- 41:21to hear from you. Visit onrampbitcoin.com/contact
- 41:25to schedule a consultation with one of our private Client
- 41:27Advisors.