Latest / Psychology In Seattle Podcast / Borderline Abuse (Chapters 1-6)
Transcript
- 0:00Hey deserve listeners. I've been a therapist since nineteen ninety six, so more
- 0:06than twenty seven years now. I've been a professor since nineteen ninety seven,
- 0:12so twenty six years. I've been a content provider a podcaster since two thousand
- 0:19and eight, so over fifteen years. And as with any other therapists,
- 0:27I have had many, many moments that have been very meaningful to me as
- 0:34a professional, as a clinician, as a human being, I've had many
- 0:39moments with clients, and all therapists can attest to this that you'll have a
- 0:46day of working with clients. You'll see seven or eight clients, maybe more,
- 0:51and each individual client can have a dozen amazing moments that occur in the
- 0:58span of that hour long session. And those moments you feel it when it
- 1:03happens, but they just breeze right past because we have to continue to do
- 1:11our jobs, and we have a client coming up next, and then we
- 1:15have to drive home, and we have to eat, and we don't have
- 1:19time to really sit and contemplate the I don't know, there's no real adjective
- 1:29for it. The only word I have is that I am in awe of
- 1:37these moments. I recently just saw the eclipse for the second time, and
- 1:44there's no words to describe. You've seen pictures, undoubtedly, but unless you're
- 1:49actually there in totality, there's just nothing that describes it. And it's the
- 1:56same with being a therapist, and us therapists will be having eclipse like moments,
- 2:02just moments of pure awe and wonderment, will be having those moments,
- 2:09perhaps several times a day, and in a long career. I've been a
- 2:15therapist for twenty seven years. Just imagine how many moments there are like that,
- 2:21and you know, there's nothing different about me. Every other therapist will
- 2:23say the same thing. And then as a professor, similarly, just so
- 2:30many moments with students, you know, and teaching in class or working with
- 2:36them and seeing them grow and seeing them develop and seeing them develop their own
- 2:40confidence. That moment that spark that occurs for a student where they say,
- 2:46I think I can do this. I've wanted to be able to believe that
- 2:51I can do this, and now I feel like I can do it.
- 2:54And those moments where you help a student, a supervisor at Trey any to
- 3:00help a client and they come to you afterwards and say it worked, I
- 3:06did it. I helped somebody. I finally am doing the work and they
- 3:12appreciated it, and I just feels so good. It's like a drug.
- 3:19And as a content provider, as a podcaster, there's just so many moments
- 3:25of interacting with the listeners, of interacting with my co hosts, having discoveries
- 3:34for myself, expressing myself, and so many episodes that are very important to
- 3:44me. I mean, every episode is important to me, but some are
- 3:51more memorable to me, more meaningful to me. And there are times as
- 3:58a content provider where I will be making something or have made something recently,
- 4:03and I'll be thinking about it and think, I think this piece of content
- 4:10or this episode or whatever, this thing that I'm making that I'm going to
- 4:15post is a significant piece of my career. This piece is at least for
- 4:25me. I don't know if other people are going to see this way,
- 4:28but for me, this piece of content represents me as a professional, as
- 4:34a clinician, as a professor, as a content maker, as a podcaster,
- 4:39and as a human being. And recently I made something that as I
- 4:47was making it, I had that realization. Again, I didn't know if
- 4:53anyone else would see it. That way or care. But to me,
- 4:58as I was making it, I thought, Oh, this feels like it
- 5:02represents so much of who I am as a professional and as a human being.
- 5:09So many things of my career and my life and my struggle are represented
- 5:16right here in a very what I felt to be a very compelling package of
- 5:24content. And that piece of content was a set of reaction videos that I
- 5:31was making to Love is Blind season six. If you're not aware, I
- 5:38started reacting to reality TV four years ago, at the very beginning of the
- 5:44pandemic. I had never watched reality TV really before. I was one of
- 5:49those people that just considered it to be quite silly and frivolous and not entertaining.
- 5:56But at the beginning of the pandemic, maybe even in the first day
- 6:00or two of the lockdown, I was wanting something to pass the time because
- 6:06we were all just going to be stuck at home twenty four to seven,
- 6:10and that I'd never been in that situation before, and everyone was turning to
- 6:15all sorts of things. Some people were making bread, some people were starting
- 6:19to write their novel. Well, I was gonna do some content. But
- 6:26in addition to that, I thought, well, maybe Stacy, and I
- 6:30should watch something that will occupy the time. And something that I was hearing
- 6:35a lot about was this reality TV show on Netflix called Love Is Blind.
- 6:41And back then Netflix had a very good reputation. I don't think it has
- 6:46that reputation now. But if you remember when Stranger Things first came out and
- 6:50other shows like making a Murder Debt documentary, there was a time when,
- 6:58at least for me and the people around me, everything that Netflix made was
- 7:01considered to be must see TV kind of, And since Netflix had made its
- 7:10own reality TV show, it seemed like, well, maybe this show will
- 7:14be different because Netflix made it. It sounds funny saying that now, because
- 7:17I think people consider Netflix to be filled with just all sorts of unwatchable things,
- 7:26and including me, That's how I feel about it. Back then,
- 7:30it was different, or it was a tail end of that or something.
- 7:32Anyway, So I said, hey, Stace, let's watch this reality TV
- 7:38show. So we queue up start watching it, and I found myself really
- 7:45wanting to get my hands around this show because there was so many things it
- 7:48was provoking me to talk about. So I made a reaction video and posted
- 7:55it, figuring it would barely do anything on the Internet, there would be
- 8:00maybe a few hundred views or something, which was typical for me, and
- 8:03that would be gratifying, but certainly wouldn't be life changing or wouldn't change my
- 8:07career. And then, I don't know, four or five days after I
- 8:11posted the episode, suddenly they just took off and it just went through the
- 8:18roof. I mean, if you look at my graph on YouTube, basically
- 8:22everything before the pandemic, in terms of the number of views per day or
- 8:28per month that I was getting, it basically looks like zero. It looks
- 8:31like I didn't have a YouTube channel before the pandemic. You really have to
- 8:37zoom in quite a lot to even see how the graph is not zero,
- 8:43you know what I mean? Because I was getting millions and millions of views
- 8:48almost overnight, and I have found that love is blind. The TV show
- 8:56is my favorite thing to react to on YouTube because it provides me with so
- 9:03much opportunity to talk about things that I'm passionate about, things that I want
- 9:09to spread the word about, things that I use myself in my own relationships,
- 9:13particularly in my marriage, and that really came into sharp focus during season
- 9:22six because there is this couple Chelsea and Jimmy, who have the kind of
- 9:30conflict that I have worked with so many times in my office and also as
- 9:39a supervisor. The kinds of things that Jimmy and Chelsea, particularly Chelsea was
- 9:45presenting, has been a big topic of my work with my supervisors in that
- 9:56and I get into that, And basically this is an introduction for me packaging
- 10:03my reaction videos into an audio format. So if you've already seen all these
- 10:09reaction videos, then I suppose this will be a second time through this if
- 10:13you're interested. But if you haven't seen those, I really wanted to share
- 10:18it with you because for the podcast people that don't watch my channel, I
- 10:24want you to at least be given the opportunity to listen to what I consider
- 10:31to be some of the most important work I've ever done in my life.
- 10:39It wasn't prepared for, which is interesting. I didn't take notes beforehand.
- 10:45I didn't decide to talk about this. It was just provoked in me because
- 10:52I was watching Jimmy and Chelsea have their relationship and particularly have conflict, which
- 11:01I think adds to the specialness for me. Because it was all off the
- 11:09cuff, it was all spontaneous, It all just came from top of mind.
- 11:13It's not something that I had to manufacture at all. It's just of
- 11:18my soul at this point. It's in my bones. It's of me.
- 11:24All that I said, all that I emphasized, and the things that the
- 11:28stories that I tell in this series, the anecdotes, the client stories,
- 11:33the memories that I have, the personal aspects of this. It really goes
- 11:43in all those directions spontaneously, which I think makes it more meaningful to me,
- 11:50and I think it might make it more listenable or watchable, depending on
- 11:54where you're consuming this, because it's spontaneous in that it moves naturally, if
- 12:05that makes sense right. It's not something that follows an outline or has the
- 12:09introduction and in the middle and then the conclusion. It's all reactive, right.
- 12:15It's almost like a story, you know, like a hobbit lives in
- 12:20a hobbit hole and then some dwarves come and try to recruit him to be
- 12:26their burglar, and then you know, you just follow the story. It
- 12:30just whereas if you just tell this story in all one outline, it isn't
- 12:35as interesting. It's interesting to see the progression. And I wonder if this
- 12:43series of episodes has an element to it. You know, it's me starting
- 12:48the journey, especially now that I'm recording this introduction. Well after recording these
- 12:54episodes, and as you listen to this audio you can you will know that
- 13:05at some point, as I'm recording these reaction videos, it occurs to me
- 13:09how important this work is to me, and maybe it'll be interesting to think
- 13:16about, like when was it that that it kicked in? You know.
- 13:20Now, Another thing that I should say is that after I recorded six episodes,
- 13:28six videos, I went back and recorded some introductions as a way to
- 13:39explain what these videos were about. So when these videos start, when I
- 13:48start showing the when I start playing the audio versions of the videos, you'll
- 13:52hear me also introducce. So it's almost like there's three different you know.
- 13:56It's sort of like Budapest Hotel. Now, it's like a story within a
- 14:01story within a story. I mean, it's not that grand, but I
- 14:05just thought i'd say that so it wouldn't confuse people. So yeah, I
- 14:11made twelve chapters of this series. If you want to, you can go
- 14:16to YouTube and watch all twelve. I made a playlist called borderline Abuse on
- 14:22my channel and if you watch the videos, it helps because there are some
- 14:30visuals, you know, the clips that I'm watching, it might help,
- 14:33but you know, I imagine that eighty five ninety percent of the content can
- 14:39be gathered just from listening to the people argue. In this series, I
- 14:46am mainly watching Jimmy and Chelsea have conversations, fighting and making up this sort
- 14:52of thing. But I also go back and watch other couples from previous seasons
- 14:58of Love is Blind, and I think I am pretty clear as I am
- 15:05watching those clips what and who I am reacting to. So I'm guessing that
- 15:13audio wise, it'll be clear what I'm talking about. And in these episodes
- 15:18it's mainly me talking. I don't play a lot of clips. I mean,
- 15:22there's a fair amount of clips, but because it provokes so much in
- 15:28me to talk about borderline personality, to talk about diagnosing, to talk about
- 15:33treatment, to talk about corrective experiences, to talk about attachment theory and preoccupation,
- 15:37and how hard it is to work with these people and how some of
- 15:43them can become abusive, and how difficult it can be to be married to
- 15:48someone like this, but how glorious it can be to go through recovery not
- 15:52only for the person with borderline, but also for everyone around them. It
- 15:58happens, and I get into all and so I wanted the audio podcast listeners,
- 16:06you know, those of you who don't watch me on YouTube at the
- 16:10very least, I wanted you to know that this series is very, very
- 16:17important to me. So I edited all twelve chapters into three very long audio
- 16:25episodes that I will be airing this week. So listen to those if you
- 16:30care to. And now let's get to those episodes. Hey, desermer listeners.
- 16:37So this is a bit unusual that I'm adding an intro at the beginning
- 16:41of this episode. I have already watched this fight between Jimmy and Chelsea.
- 16:45I actually watched it last night until late in the evening. I reacted to
- 16:51it. I recorded all of it this morning. I spent all day editing
- 16:56all of that, and I found that the whole fight actually takes up six
- 17:03episodes of mine. Some of the episodes are more typical length twenty minutes ish,
- 17:10but some of the episodes are are much longer than that. So you
- 17:12might think, Wow, why would Kirk talk for so long about one scene
- 17:18on this show? Kirk must have been yammering a lot, and I feel
- 17:22weird talking to myself in the third person. Third person right anyway, But
- 17:29yeah, I did talk a lot, but I didn't go on any tangents.
- 17:30What I decided to do early as I was watching this was to really
- 17:37use this opportunity to go a little further into things that I have talked about
- 17:44briefly before in these reaction videos, because I think that this show, and
- 17:49this scene and this third fight between this couple provides an excellent opportunity to show
- 17:57what I talk about often, not only as a YouTuber, but as a
- 18:00professor and as a therapist, and as a supervisor, and as an author
- 18:06and as a friend. I talk with people about this in my personal life.
- 18:08I bother people with it all the time because I'm very passionate about this,
- 18:14and you'll see that as I get into it, particularly at the end
- 18:18of the sixth episode. I want to be clear that I'm not diagnosing.
- 18:22I don't know what's happening here. It's all edited, This could all be
- 18:25faked. I could be reading it wrong. Even if I were deciding to
- 18:30diagnose, I don't have enough information to go off of. But as a
- 18:34professor and a supervisor. It is very frustrating for us to try to explain
- 18:41to our trainees, to our students who are therapists about certain concepts of personality
- 18:48and behavior and communication personality disorders. It's really hard to really explain what these
- 18:57disorders are. We're often reading the symptom list, maybe providing a vignette.
- 19:04Sometimes in my class, I'll show a fictional movie like Revolutionary Road, for
- 19:11example, with Kate Winslet and Leo DiCaprio. But it's a fictional movie.
- 19:14It's not made for educational purposes. It's made for entertainment, and it's always
- 19:21kind of a stretch because the author is just inventing things. It's not an
- 19:25actual human reacting from actual traumas, relational traumas, reacting to actual stakes.
- 19:32You know. So when I started watching reality TV four years ago on this
- 19:37channel, I have found that occasionally, very occasionally, these reality TV shows
- 19:45will provide me, as an instructor, as a professor, really excellent data
- 19:51to show people, and I will at times, and I know some of
- 19:53you out there are professors yourself and will show it as well. Not to
- 20:00say that we're saying this is what actually is happening, but this is something
- 20:04that would look like something that would happen clinically, right. There's a huge
- 20:10gap there. And I'm not just saying that to avoid being sued. I
- 20:14actually believe that to be true. When you are a clinician and you work
- 20:18with people at the ground level for years and years, you understand, as
- 20:23I do, that people are very complicated. There's always a very rich story
- 20:30and personal, unique experience to everybody that cannot be gleaned by watching edited scenes
- 20:37in a reality TV show. So the kind of things that I get into
- 20:42in these six episodes are borderline personality disorder, preoccupied attachment to some extent,
- 20:49disorganized attachment. Get into communication how to resolve conflicts. I suppose I get
- 20:55into avoidant attachment style as well. I get into a time when I lied
- 21:03to the cops. I also get into a lot of abuse, because the
- 21:10way in which the popular culture talks about and thinks about abusive people is only
- 21:17one type of abusive person, one profile. And I want everyone to you
- 21:23know, if I told you that, well, you know, women can
- 21:27be abusers too. I'm sure a lot of you, if not all of
- 21:32you, think, at least intellectually sure, absolutely, why would it not
- 21:37be that case. But if you've never seen it or had it explain to
- 21:41you what it would look like, then you might intellectually understand it, but
- 21:47not really understand it. And I want people to really understand it, not
- 21:52so that anyone on the show is labeled with something or hated by the public
- 21:57or attacked online. Don't ever ever do that. Don't DM these people and
- 22:03yell at them or participate in the ridicule online. It's straight up bullying.
- 22:07It's not okay. That's not why I do it. Why I do it
- 22:10is because you will come across these people. You might have these people in
- 22:15your life right now, you might have had them in your past. You
- 22:18might actually even be one of these people who are abusive. And I want
- 22:23to make the world a better place, and I believe through education then that
- 22:29might be facilitated. Perhaps I don't know, that's what I'm trying to do.
- 22:33So I decided early in this fight. I said, you know,
- 22:37I'm just going to really go for it. I'm going to provide a lot
- 22:40of angles, a lot of my passion. You could argue that this is
- 22:45the core of who I am. If when I die and they decide,
- 22:51for whatever reason, to highlight some content of mine as quintessential me or core
- 22:56to me. At this point, I think think these six episodes are those
- 23:03episodes. Is that content. It represents so many things about me, so
- 23:07many things about my professional life, what I'm passionate about. It's not the
- 23:12only thing that I do professionally, but it represents what I do well.
- 23:18Because I get passionate about, I get into it, I get emotional,
- 23:23and I at the same time will say that's a problem what that person is
- 23:30doing. I'm also saying, and that person deserves so much love and so
- 23:37much of our care. They're not doing it because they are choosing to do
- 23:42it. They're not doing it because they set out to do it. They
- 23:45are having a reaction based on relational trauma that is well understood and has been
- 23:51well understood in my field for almost one hundred years. And the way these
- 23:56kinds of things are talked about online is setting to me. Even among clinicians,
- 24:02people will say, throughout my career, and I hope that you're okay
- 24:07that the next six episodes will just be about this scene, and you'll be
- 24:12okay with the fact that each episode is kind of an odd length. What
- 24:15I decided to do was I decided to put major story beats at the beginning
- 24:21of each episode, so that's why the episodes are kind of in strange lengths.
- 24:26What I'm going to do after recording this intro is I'm actually going to
- 24:30watch season two of Love Is Blind and compare and contrast Nick and Danielle their
- 24:37presentation to Jimmy and Chelsea. Not as a way of ridiculing them or anything
- 24:42or labeling them, but just personally, I'm just curious because it's been years
- 24:47since I watch that, but I keep remembering details that are similar. The
- 24:52reason why I want to do that is just because I'm personally curious. But
- 24:55the reason why I want to post it is that I want to further the
- 24:59understand that this is not something that's particular to these individuals. This is something
- 25:04that is very very common. It's a very very common thing, and there's
- 25:08a spectrum. You can have people that are mild this personality disorder or moderate
- 25:15or severe. Often online you'll hear people talk about the severe, which is
- 25:19fine, but if you're moderate and maybe just a little subclinical, meaning that
- 25:26you wouldn't actually qualify for the label in the DSM. It's not a demarcation
- 25:32line where above that line you're a problem and below the line you're not.
- 25:36Anywhere on that spectrum, you're going to have distress and difficulty and cause a
- 25:41lot of problems for yourself and other people, not because you're a jerk face,
- 25:47but because of well understood attachment disruption reactivity. So I want to say
- 25:53all that, and the next number of days will just be the fight,
- 26:00and let me know what you think in the comments. Let's watch who I
- 26:03want to spend my life with. So I'm so cranky with you this morning.
- 26:11I was like, man, I'm so mad at him, but I
- 26:14love him with all my heart, like I love you, she says.
- 26:18She was so cranky with him this morning. And she says, but I
- 26:22love him. I love you so much. Normally I would think this is
- 26:26just a good conversation about regular kinds of things. But given what we've seen
- 26:33before, Yeah, both of the fights she starts with either the cutesy voice
- 26:41there, which isn't a bad thing. It's nice to be cutesy, softens
- 26:45the blow or just your way. But it either is that voice or it's
- 26:52more relaxed or more kind of fun. People have been talking about over the
- 26:56years, this concept of the cool girl, right, this notion of women
- 27:02who will feel that they need to suppress who they really are and act like
- 27:07they're totally cool with whatever the guy wants to do, whether it's be polyamorous
- 27:15or play video games all day, you know, meaning that the woman is
- 27:21not really wanting to do that, and she will act like she's super cool,
- 27:27either on purpose or subconsciously out of desperation or something. And I think
- 27:33maybe for some they might look at Chelsea as a candidate for that. Jimmy
- 27:41was talking about AD's body and then She's just like, yeah, everything's fine,
- 27:44and then clearly later she was not fine with it. There's also a
- 27:48chance that at the party with Ad and the body and all that stuff,
- 27:52that Chelsea actually was generally okay with it but just got locked in at it
- 27:56later because of her base line transference issue. That's happening anyway, So normally
- 28:03I would be thinking, I guess, just a regular conversation, but this
- 28:07could literally be step one out of twenty that leads to them escalating. I
- 28:12hope not, but like I said, right from the beginning of their first
- 28:18fight, I said, we've seen this before on the show. We saw
- 28:22between Nick and Danielle, and at some point I actually want to compare these
- 28:27two as a demonstration. I also kind of want to get into the concepts
- 28:30that I'm revolving around more explicitly. I sort of refer to them, and
- 28:37I think this is potentially such a good example that I can really kind of
- 28:45get into the weeds. Not the weeds, but I could get specific.
- 28:49But I don't know. So I'm hoping for the best, but I am
- 28:52bracing for the worst too. But last night, crank at me. I
- 29:00can't be cranking with you. That was the most reasonable thing for me to
- 29:03do. The camera crew leaves and you shower and get ready to go.
- 29:07I asked you to go out, and I know that you did not ask
- 29:11me. Okay, again, normally i'd be thinking, now, you know,
- 29:15they're both lightly talking about it. This is a good tone to have
- 29:22as you're trying to communicate, but pretty quickly, honestly, she is escalating,
- 29:29which is a pattern with the so not only Nick and daniel from season
- 29:33two and this couple. But I have seen this dynamic and what I am
- 29:40hypothesizing what's going on here I've seen this happen so many times in my office,
- 29:45and these couples I will treat for several years, and I've actually and
- 29:51I've treated a lot of people that fit his profile individual and individual therapy and
- 29:56her profile in individual therapy. It was an early special of mine that I
- 30:02learned, you know, trial by fire. I had a client early in
- 30:06my career. You know, I'm twenty seven and fresh out of graduate school
- 30:11and flying by the seat of my pants, and I had a client that
- 30:17wasn't exactly like her, but was I think similar in terms of schemas and
- 30:22relational traumas and reactivity. And it was an intense experience that I learned a
- 30:32lot from a lot of who I am today as a human, but also
- 30:36as a clinician. The stuff I am or about my point of view was
- 30:41formulated during that time. So I have a lot to say about this,
- 30:47and I already have said a lot about it. But I feel like this
- 30:49could be almost like a graduate level course on how to see this sort of
- 30:56thing. Often as a professor, I'm describing things and I don't have a
- 31:02good example to show, or the examples I have are actors, because you
- 31:07can't it's hard to ethically film clients, but apparently it is no problem at
- 31:15all to just film people who might actually be exhibiting some of the very obvious
- 31:22signs of things that we talk about in graduate school. But anyway, so
- 31:26specifically, what we're hearing is she's saying, well, she's saying, he
- 31:32went out. That was the most reasonable thing for me to do. The
- 31:36camera crew leaves, and you shower and get ready to go. I asked
- 31:38you to go out, and I know that you did not ask me.
- 31:41It was one of my friend's birthdays. You asked me. Okay. So
- 31:45she's, you know, highlighting that the camera crew leaves. What does that
- 31:51have to do with it? To her? I don't know, but it
- 31:53kind of sounds like she thinks, as soon as no one's around holding you
- 31:59home, then you bolt, because it'd be another thing if she just said
- 32:04last night, you left. But you know, she's highlighting as soon as
- 32:07the camera crew leaves. And then he says it was a birthday party or
- 32:14a birthday get together or something, and he says, I asked you to
- 32:17go, and she says, no, you did not. Okay, go
- 32:20with you. You did not. I knew, damn well, you did
- 32:22not want to go with me one, and I did ask you, he
- 32:24did, I did ask you, I you can go with me. You
- 32:28were already bundled up, right, So, given previous fights about these kinds
- 32:32of details, I would put my bunny down that Jimmy is actually more accurate
- 32:39to the story. He could be misremembering, He could be lying, I
- 32:44think given his presentation. If this isn't true, then I'd put my money
- 32:49down on him just misremembering. Plus, do we think that Jimmy, unless
- 32:54they had a huge fight, which it doesn't sound like that was the case,
- 33:00he do we think that he would just like ditch her, just just
- 33:05walk out the door while she's like, don't leave me unless it's a fight.
- 33:09But if it wasn't a fight, then yeah, I'm sure that he
- 33:14must have at least asked her. Now, maybe he was thinking, you
- 33:19know, he wasn't super enthusiastic about her coming or something. But anyway,
- 33:22so let's imagine that he did say do you want to come? And he's
- 33:28also saying I knew damn well that you wouldn't want to come. Is that
- 33:31because she doesn't like to socialize or she was tired? What you did not
- 33:37have any desire to go with me, and I don't blame you. I
- 33:38was going for an hour. I had wondered. It was a very short
- 33:44time, so I will give you that an hour. Usually in contrast to
- 33:50Jeremy, I'm thinking, oh boy a, we're looking at another five third.
- 33:52Did he did he meet up with Jess? What's happening so so?
- 34:00And what time did she say? Let me rewind at me, I can't
- 34:07be cranky with you. That was the most reasonable. Okay, So I'm
- 34:10rewinding it. And he's like, you can't be cranky with me? And
- 34:14she says I can be cranky normally. Again, I would think cranky is
- 34:20just mildly a little cranky, maybe cutesy cranky or whatever. But given what
- 34:28we've seen, it could have been fairly hostile cranky. So he is bringing
- 34:37that up, and it's good to see that he's advocating. I don't know
- 34:40if he's being fair. I'm guessing that he at least is in the direction
- 34:46affair. And then she says I can be cranky. I don't know what
- 34:51she means by that, but in line with what I was saying before about
- 34:55abuse can take many forms, and someone can be abusive without the other person
- 35:01feeling abused. That needs to be clear. Someone can be abusive to me,
- 35:07and if I'm differentiated enough, I have enough support. I see it
- 35:10as it is. There's a chance that I won't feel underneath their boot,
- 35:15that I won't feel harmed, that I won't feel afraid, that I won't
- 35:20feel in danger. I'll be saying, Oh, they're either trying to make
- 35:24me feel afraid, or they're having an overreactivity and they're resorting to some sort
- 35:30of defense. And if I don't hold on to my differentiation, I will
- 35:35start to be afraid, and I will start to feel like I need to
- 35:38appease them or something. So I want to be clear about that. But
- 35:44I just want to put that short little phrase in that column of evidence that
- 35:50there's a mindset that she has, that she resorts to a pattern when she
- 35:55is threatened attachment wise. And I'll say this again as well, that in
- 36:02my experience, and I learned this through experience, no one ever taught me
- 36:07this, by the way, and I don't hear a lot of people,
- 36:09if anybody, really talking in this way, So that makes me suspicious about
- 36:15this whole point of view. But for abusive people, there's a set of
- 36:20them that are the way that people typically talk about them, where they wake
- 36:22up in the morning and literally say I'm going to abuse this person, or
- 36:27they start a relationship saying, Okay, I have to hold back my abuse
- 36:30of behavior because they're not going to take it. I have to suck them
- 36:31in and then I'll abuse them. Certainly, there are people like that,
- 36:35but in my experience, is pretty rare. I mean, we're talking about
- 36:37a psychopath, someone who prays on other people and enjoys it. Says.
- 36:44The vast majority of abusers that I treated who were court mandated because they committed
- 36:49a crime of domestic violence and they were ordered by the court to attend the
- 36:54treatment program that I was a part of. I would work with these people
- 36:59and it was hard, you know. Literally none of them wanted to be
- 37:02there and thought that they had committed a crime. All of them thought that
- 37:06they were being treated unfairly. All of them thought that it was no big
- 37:09deal. All of them thought that their partner was really the abusive one.
- 37:15And we would look into it. We would talk to the partner periodically,
- 37:20and of course we would talk to the individual. We look at the police
- 37:22report all that kind of stuff, and ninety nine times out of one hundred
- 37:27we would conclude no, no, no, the right person was convicted of
- 37:30this. Plus you know, court juris blah blah blah, anyway, do
- 37:36wrong things happen in court? Yeah, but you know anyway, So what
- 37:39I learned was that all of them that I came across, and then subsequently
- 37:45in my private practice, I would treat abusers as well perpetrators. They all
- 37:51have massive attachment insecurity and learned or developed this pattern of retaining attachment security through
- 38:00control and what we would call abuse, And they are operating from this desperation
- 38:07of retaining an attachment. They don't set out to abuse. They set out
- 38:12to retain attachment like everyone else does. But instead of having other kinds of
- 38:17behaviors that are based on trust and self awareness and emotional regulation, they have
- 38:24a set of behaviors that are available to them that are coercive, domineering,
- 38:30controlling, harmful, and they don't know it in the moment. They're not
- 38:37thinking I'm trying to tear this person down. To them, it feels rational
- 38:43to them. It feels like it's commensurate with the situation, like I don't
- 38:49know if they're going here, but they're talking about him last night having gone
- 38:52out with his friends for an hour. For most people, if as long
- 38:58as it is the way that it looks, he just went out with his
- 39:00friends, for most people, they would, you know, even if they
- 39:02were kind of hurt, they'd be like, I just I just kind of
- 39:05wanted to spend some time with you last night. And on a scale from
- 39:08one to ten about hurt, it might be a two or three. But
- 39:13for people that have these kinds of traumas the two or a three, or
- 39:17even if it's a one, to most people, it'll feel like an eight
- 39:21or nine, maybe even a ten. So so to give it an analogy
- 39:25for typical people, for people without this condition, it would be as if
- 39:32he had cheated and you know, cheated for a month. You know,
- 39:42if your partner cheated on you for a month behind your back and just didn't
- 39:47even apologize for it. You discover it and they're just like, yeah,
- 39:51what are you going to do. You're going to be a ten, right,
- 39:54You're going to feel very, very hurt, and in the moment that
- 40:00you find out about it, and they're just denying it or they're acting like
- 40:02it's no big deal. There's a lot of possible understandable reactivity from the victim
- 40:10from you, right. You know, I'm just trying to think if I
- 40:14were in that situation. You know, I can imagine saying, I can't
- 40:19believe you did that to me. I can't believe you have no heart.
- 40:23You are a psychopath. You know, I probably start diagnosing from that moment.
- 40:31It's not right, but it is. It makes sense given how I
- 40:36think, and I suppose things that are available to any therapists do that.
- 40:38By the way, it's not a good look, but meaning that therapists,
- 40:45when they're in a conflict with their partners will naturally try to pull the therapist
- 40:51card and say, well, I'm the expert, and so you got to
- 40:53listen to me. It's usually not a good or a fair thing to do
- 40:58anyway, so I would I don't know. It's hard for me to know
- 41:04what I do, but we can imagine someone getting, you know, pretty
- 41:07livid, right, screaming I can't believe you did this, You storming out,
- 41:14I don't know, tweeting about it. That isn't uncommon. I don't
- 41:16recommend that. But whereas for people with the condition. I'm hypothesizing that she
- 41:24suffers from the the minor hurt of him going out with his friends for an
- 41:31hour could feel like a ten, and thus the react, the reaction to
- 41:37it will be a ten, even though it's only a one or a two,
- 41:43right, and then that reaction like like getting back to that that first
- 41:47scenario where you know, say I find out that someone cheated for a month
- 41:52and and they're actually asking me, hey, I don't want to break up,
- 41:55you know, please let's not don't you know, please don't break up
- 41:59with me? And I'm just like, well, if you want to make
- 42:02this work, then you you have to give me all your passwords because you
- 42:08know something like that, right, or you're gonna have to share your location
- 42:12with me, or you can't go with those friends anymore, you know,
- 42:15because as a temporary measure of like, if you really want to show me
- 42:21that you really want to work on this relationship, then you're going to start
- 42:24making some sacrifices until I trust you again, so that in uh, you
- 42:31know, look through one lens is controlling of me right to say you can't
- 42:36do these sets of things I am you know, it's an ultimatum of a
- 42:42sense, but I think most people would agree. We could debate the wisdom
- 42:45of that, but we could we wouldn't look at that and say, like,
- 42:50well, what an unreasonable partner to ask for the passwords or demand the
- 42:55passwords, you know, like you could see the person of my position saying,
- 42:59look, unless you give me the passwords, then we're done. If
- 43:01you really want our work, give me the passwords so that I can see
- 43:05your DMS moving forward. I don't need to see what happened in the past,
- 43:07but I do need to see what's going forward because I can't trust you.
- 43:12But if it's only a two, like you just went out for an
- 43:15hour, then people with this condition will feel like it's a ten and they
- 43:22were modeled something or they learned something that because you know, for some people
- 43:24when it's a ten, they bolt right, but for these people, they
- 43:28lean in and control. And so even though it's a two, and I
- 43:31don't think she'll do this in this situation, but you know, specifically,
- 43:36but the drastic measure could be resorted to, you know, something that category
- 43:42of telling him I must have all your passwords. You left last night for
- 43:46an hour, I need all your passwords, even though there's no reason to
- 43:52think that that drastic level of reaction of control is answer it with the situation.
- 44:01So that is what I saw as what most abusive people were operating from.
- 44:08It would look different. Sometimes it was violent, sometimes it was quiet,
- 44:14Sometimes it was loud. Sometimes it was more emotional. Sometimes it was
- 44:17verbal. Sometimes it was more gaslighting. Sometimes they would threaten to involve other
- 44:27people, or there would be triangulation of the kids or something. You know,
- 44:30there was a lot of different specific behaviors, but it was all operating
- 44:36from that place, and it was all abuse. I asked you to go
- 44:38out, and I know that you did not ask me. It was one
- 44:42of my friend's birthdays. You ask me to go with you. You did
- 44:45not. I knew, damn well, you did not want to go with
- 44:46me one and I did ask you. I did ask you. I thought
- 44:50you can go with me. You were already bundled up. You did not
- 44:52have any desire to go with me. And I don't blame you. So
- 44:55there's more context. I was wondering if that was the case. That was
- 44:59one of the the things I thought. And Okay, so she refutes that,
- 45:02then we'll have some questions. But if she doesn't then once again,
- 45:07as with other fights they've been in, she will say something that he will
- 45:13say, well, wait no, you know, like when she says you
- 45:15haven' kissed me today and he runs over kisses her, and then he says,
- 45:19well, wait no, I did kiss you twice a day and she
- 45:21didn't refute that. But for people with this condition that I either think they
- 45:24have to exaggerate to be paid attention to, which actually shoots them in the
- 45:29foot, or their brain will actually rework memories to fit how they feel it
- 45:37happened. I was going for an hour. I had wondering. It was
- 45:42a very short time, so I will give you that. It was more
- 45:45of driving. Girls in the pods said hey, amass that where are you?
- 45:52We see her face changing. I didn't land on a good screen there,
- 45:58So that's might be the key right there that if the is that what
- 46:05right? We'll remind that. But she said the other women in the pods
- 46:08knew he was out, so were other women in the pods at this part.
- 46:15That wouldn't make any sense because he's meeting up with unless one of the
- 46:19friends that had a birthday was one of the other guys on the show,
- 46:22and then the other women were there, so I don't know. But let's
- 46:28let's assume he's only gone for an hour, so what could have happened?
- 46:34And she did say, i'll grant you that you were gone for a short
- 46:37time. Okay, Now, maybe there's something Jimmy did that was legit.
- 46:40I don't know, so we'll wait and seem. I'm sure we'll hear if
- 46:44there is something. But for her, it's possible that he left and she
- 46:52was like slightly triggered, right, and then someone calls and says, hey,
- 46:58I know that he's out. How come you're not with him? And
- 47:01it highlights that feeling or it highlights that, you know, like she's on
- 47:07the fence, she's holding on. She's like, he's just gonna go off
- 47:10for a little bit. It's a birthday party. Everything's fine. I'm bumped.
- 47:14I didn't want to go. I could have gone, but I don't
- 47:15want to go. And everything's gonna be off. Everything's gonna be fine,
- 47:19everything's gonna be fine, everything's gonna be fine. Hold it together. You
- 47:22get this call and it's like, see, that's what I'm talking about.
- 47:24He shouldn't have left, you know, And just in her mind anyway,
- 47:28so I don't know. We'll keep an eye on that. I was going
- 47:31for an hour. I had wondering. It was a very short time,
- 47:36so I will give you that. It was more of driving. Girls in
- 47:38the pods said hey, a mass is that where are you? That was
- 47:45more imbarsing was I didn't see and then she says, it's embarrassing. What's
- 47:52embarrassing about it? If my wife was out and people called me and said,
- 48:00I know your wife is out with friends, how come you're not with
- 48:05her, I'd be like, what, why are you calling? What?
- 48:14What's it to you? And huh, It's like the where does that question
- 48:21even comfort? Why would you call her and say how come you're not with
- 48:23it? Like? What's but Okay, someone calls me, I would say
- 48:32I decided not to go, or she literally didn't invite me because she doesn't
- 48:37want me there because she's hanging out with her friends. How about that?
- 48:44How but they saw you? So Mackenzie, I don't even know what Mackenzie
- 48:51looks like. She knows what you okay. I seem to remember McKenzie being
- 48:57one of the others in the odds. I wrote down the names of the
- 49:02people and yeah, McKenzie yeah, McKenzie. We saw a short interview with
- 49:12her, so McKenzie was the one probably that called her. And apparently Mackenzie
- 49:19was at the place that he was at and okay, so was that it
- 49:29that Mackenzie just happened to be at the same place or was McKenzie part of
- 49:32the friend I don't know. Let's watch. Oh I didn't. I wasn't
- 49:37out hanging out with other girls. I think the girls are right, And
- 49:42then he said, I don't even know what Mackenzie looks like because although I
- 49:46met her in the pods, I was she there, which and then she
- 49:52didn't really refute that, So that sounds like McKenzie, you know, just
- 49:58saw him that he wasn't with Mackenzie and others. Okay, like, why
- 50:01is he out and you're not with him? I'm like, man, girl,
- 50:06your girl was to go to man exactly Why are your hammering me?
- 50:09Yeah, yeah, the same reaction exactly exactly, so right, Why are
- 50:19you hammering me about it? And why were you grumpy the whole time?
- 50:22And why are we talking about it right now? I'm with my friends for
- 50:28an hour. He even said most of the time he was gone was driving,
- 50:30which really points to, you know, unless it's a work night or
- 50:37something school night, or he guess don't really like those friends. But I'm
- 50:40guessing that left to his own devices, he probably would have stayed longer.
- 50:44Why would you, you know, drive twenty five minutes to stay fifteen minutes
- 50:47and then drive twenty five minutes home. But anyway, so she claims that
- 50:53when Mackenzie called says, how come he's out without you? She says that
- 51:00she said to Mackenzie, I'm tired. That's why I'm not there. Okay,
- 51:06end of story, right, But no, and I don't blame her
- 51:09at all. I sound frustrated. It can be frustrating to have a friend
- 51:19or a partner like this. It can be frustrating to have a client like
- 51:23this. And I don't know what this is. I don't even know if
- 51:27I'm seeing it accurately. But at the very least we can say that there's
- 51:30a fair amount of preoccupation right now. There's a good chance, not a
- 51:35good chance, sorry, there is a slight chance that there are a lot
- 51:39of really horrible things happening behind the scenes that Jimmy is doing to her,
- 51:44and she's reacting from that. It certainly doesn't look that way, but I
- 51:47can never know. But anyway, at the very least, we can say
- 51:50there's a fair amount of significant preoccupied attachment to anxious attachment, and it could
- 51:55be hard, you know, working and especially being in a relationship with someone
- 51:59like that. You know, there's a lot of paranoia and assumption and blame
- 52:04and criticism and anger and overreactivity. You know, it's it's hard enough to
- 52:10be in a relationship, it's really on another level when and you know,
- 52:15the same goes for avoiding attachment too. But avoiding attachment can just be more
- 52:22hurtful than frustrating, I guess, and certainly being what a preoccupied person could
- 52:25be very hurtful. You know. Preoccupied people are just more noticeable, I'll
- 52:30just put it that way. And when it comes to disorganized and fearful attachment,
- 52:34that's a whole other thing. But I need to stop acting like I'm
- 52:39frustrated or feeling frustrated and exhibiting it because she's she's not doing this by choice.
- 52:47I definitely believe that she is operating from her traumas and it's the only
- 52:57thing she knows now. As always, we can say, given the awareness
- 53:02of mental health services and therapy and whatnot. We can hold her responsible for
- 53:09doing what she can to address this. And I did hear from my contact
- 53:15that worked on the show that Chelsea is working very hard in therapy and enjoying
- 53:19it. Now. I don't know if it sounded like it might have happened
- 53:22after the show, and my contact with the show told me that the show
- 53:25actually helped connect the cast a number of people on the cast to therapists and
- 53:32paid for a portion of it. I would like to see the show pay
- 53:37for all of it, because they make a lot of money. But what
- 53:40are you going to do? And so maybe maybe Chelsea is in the beginning
- 53:49of her recovery. I really really hope so, so you know, maybe
- 53:52this is just the normal course of that sort of thing. The vast majority
- 53:58of people that do suffer from her issue that she is exhibiting, which I
- 54:02don't know if she actually is suffering from, do not go to therapy at
- 54:07all and continue to suffer themselves mostly and cause a lot of suffering around them,
- 54:13Like your girl wants to go tovand exactly why are your hammer meal on
- 54:17that? Because like, well, I don't want to be with someone who
- 54:20wants to go out and party. That's why I'm hammering you. Abt yikes,
- 54:28triple yikes. No, I hope she rescinds what she just said.
- 54:43I don't want Okay, I'm reeling. Let's rewind exactly why are your hammer
- 54:50meal on that? Because like, well, I don't want to be with
- 54:52someone who wants to go out and party. I don't want to be with
- 54:55I'm hammering on you because I don't want to be with someone who goes out
- 55:01and party. Even if he did go out and party, which I would
- 55:07not call what he did going out and party. I would call what he
- 55:09did, in all likelihood making an appearance. Because in no world, if
- 55:17he's gone for an hour and he's only there for at tops, you know,
- 55:22thirty minutes, in no world is that an acceptable amount of not acceptable,
- 55:30but a meaningful amount of time that you go to an event, someone's
- 55:35birthday party. You know, showing up for half an hour can be insulting
- 55:40to some people, but it might not have been. So that is not
- 55:45party. That's that's a courtesy show up. And then of course you don't
- 55:49want to just sit there and not have at least one drink. You know,
- 55:52now, maybe he's lying. She's not refuting anything that he's saying.
- 55:55So let's just say that it's accurate. So that's not that's not going out
- 56:01and partying. That's that's going to an event that he feels like he needs
- 56:07to go to or or or wants to write. Who cares doesn't matter.
- 56:10So even if he was partying, that doesn't even matter that detail of did
- 56:17he do something that was untoward, you know, if he had stayed out
- 56:22till two or something and then you know, didn't drive drunk, but he
- 56:25takes Neuber home and he is like, you know, obnoxious and intoxicated.
- 56:30Even if that happened, which it's not even in a ballpark of that,
- 56:36even if that happened, given the context for her to say, I'm hammering
- 56:40you because I don't want to be with someone who goes out and parties,
- 56:46I don't. I don't now if she's saying it's a deal breaker and I'm
- 56:51sorry, that's one thing, meaning that she recognizes that's unreasonable, But her
- 56:57tone and her history up until this point, there are many, many,
- 57:00very concerning ticks in the column of abusive behavior. And I do not say
- 57:07that lightly. I don't know if it's happening. I don't know if it's
- 57:10all fake. I don't know if it's edited weird. I don't know how
- 57:14he feels about it. I don't know, but I do know that this
- 57:19show goes out to the general public and they watch this and assume that some
- 57:22of it is real, which I'm sure some of it is, but I
- 57:25can't know. And I consider it my job to point out things that might
- 57:32not seem like what they are, but they are what they are, which
- 57:37is it's definitely abusive. Now, if they stay together and everything continues as
- 57:44is, I don't know what we would see in five years. Would we
- 57:46see a furthering and a more intensifying of the abuse than I am that I
- 57:52think I'm seeing, or would we see something else? Is this just a
- 57:57temporary thing? I can't know. I can't predict the future very often though,
- 58:00when you see this sort of thing, it does get worse. And
- 58:02I say this so that you can know for yourself, so that you can
- 58:06protect yourself and the people you love. And as I've said before, if
- 58:09you are abusive, because you could actually be abusive like her or similar to
- 58:15her, or you were in the past, or you might be in the
- 58:17future. Then calling it what it is will help you to know, Oh,
- 58:23I'm doing that thing. I'm not hitting him, but I am engaging
- 58:29in control, which is what this is. We'll watch, maybe she'll maybe
- 58:32she'll rescind this, and I doubt she will. Maybe the next day she'll
- 58:37be like, I'm sorry, I never should have said that. I doubt
- 58:38she will. But this we've already heard, and I've already laid out that
- 58:45he felt emotionally coerced to have sex with her. I don't know if we
- 58:50would call that a sexual assault or a rape, but that says something he
- 58:55said. I also don't know if he wasn't giving any maybe he wasn't asserting
- 59:01himself at all, and she just thought he wanted to do it completely as
- 59:07well. Who knows, But I noted that when that happen in that first
- 59:09fight, right, was that the first fight? So there's there was a
- 59:15fight in the kitchen the klinging. That was the second fight, right?
- 59:20Oh right, So I'm actually going back through my notes and yeah, their
- 59:24first fight was after the party with the bean dip thing. Their second fight
- 59:31was after he was at work during the day and then he met her.
- 59:37Her friends. And then now we're seemingly in the beginning of their third fight,
- 59:43which I would take you guess and say that if this follows the typical
- 59:45pattern that I see clinically, he and I said this at the very beginning,
- 59:51that he had a lot of patients in that first fight, But like
- 59:55Nick and Danielle, his patience will start to wane, and he will start
- 1:00:01to be less patient, more assertive, more defensive, more avoidant, more
- 1:00:08angry, more hurt, more concerned, more worried, And we did see
- 1:00:15in that second fight, so we'll look at it here too. That second
- 1:00:16fight in the kitchen, he wasn't as all giving you that first fight.
- 1:00:22He was really like trying to play Kate, trying to accommodate, trying to
- 1:00:28be nice. And then he's the one that went up to her and he
- 1:00:30didn't say anything critical or he didn't have any request. He basically just said,
- 1:00:36yes, I'm sorry, it's my fault. And I worried that if
- 1:00:39he continues to do that, it could be really bad for him. So
- 1:00:45we'll see his in intensity of his response. And I'm sorry I'm drilling down
- 1:00:50on this, but I don't often get a chance to really drill down on
- 1:00:54this and really show things. And if I'm predicting this right, it should
- 1:01:00be interesting, I think to y'all, aside from you clinicians that know this
- 1:01:05anyway, I want it to be interesting to you that I in the very
- 1:01:07first fight was speculating pretty strongly that the future would end up here, that
- 1:01:15we would see more fighting. They would get worse, He would get more
- 1:01:21defensive, she would become perhaps more escalating. I don't know if I talked
- 1:01:25about control, but in the second fight I saw the signs I pointed about.
- 1:01:31I said, if this continues, her control at least, I thought
- 1:01:36this will also progress. I'm trying to do a lot of conclusions, but
- 1:01:40there's a lot of ticks in that column. I don't want anyone to attack
- 1:01:45her for this. She doesn't wake up in the morning and decide to do
- 1:01:50this stuff. Often, the most problematic or hated person on these shows is
- 1:01:55the person who deserves the most love and grace from us. Now, there
- 1:02:00are people that deserve to be attacked, you know, people that are absolutely
- 1:02:06empirically harmful and don't take any responsibility and don't try to get help, or
- 1:02:13if they do, they don't really use therapy very well. Anyway, we
- 1:02:16don't know that about Chelsea. I feel so bad for her. I have
- 1:02:22treated so many people like her, and I've been in the trenches with them
- 1:02:27and the amount of suffering and the complete lack of attunement and security and love
- 1:02:35that they have experienced in their life. You know, the pain is so
- 1:02:39deep. It's the pain of a three year old who's being abandoned for weeks.
- 1:02:46Just the pain that these people feel. And it's rational that they feel
- 1:02:54it. They transfer it onto their partners unfairly, but the pain is real
- 1:02:59anyway. So this is the beginning of a coercive control of you cannot have
- 1:03:06friends, and this is where it begins. And it's good to see this
- 1:03:09because the way that the Internet talks about this element of an abusive relationship where
- 1:03:15they will isolate you, is almost always framed as a volitional choice that the
- 1:03:22abusive person sets out to implement. I hope to you it doesn't look like
- 1:03:28she woke up this morning and says I'm going to stop him from having friends
- 1:03:32because that's who I am and I'm tricking him. She is reacting off the
- 1:03:37cuff. It feels right to her, you know, she brings us up,
- 1:03:42and she's not completely I'm guessing sure as to what she's exactly upset about.
- 1:03:47She's sort of walking herself through it, and then she's walking herself through
- 1:03:53it and she's not getting what she wants from him. I don't know if
- 1:03:58he can do anything that would please her, but I imagine what she would
- 1:04:02want is him to say, yeah, I'm sorry that I left, I
- 1:04:04was a terrible partner, something like that, which would make no sense,
- 1:04:10right, but you could see five years down the road, after being abused
- 1:04:15and stripped away of your own agency, you could see someone in Jimmy's shoes
- 1:04:19actually say something like that, right, but you know even believe it from
- 1:04:24the gaslighting. But anyway, so he says, what do you tet?
- 1:04:29Like? I aws going for an hour, and then said I will give
- 1:04:31you that, because I think she was surprised by being reminded of that.
- 1:04:36I don't think that was front and center. He's helping her, so that
- 1:04:42didn't you know. She's looking under a lot of rocks trying to find why
- 1:04:46does she feel upset? Because she just feels very upset because of her past,
- 1:04:51because she's transferring. She doesn't know it. She feels like she was
- 1:04:58abandoned, she feels like she's being a It's a ten out of ten.
- 1:05:01She deserves to feel that way. It is right that she feels that way.
- 1:05:06It is right that she feels that way. But he has nothing to
- 1:05:10do with it, is the thing. But she doesn't know that. I'm
- 1:05:13guessing. So then she is talking with and then she's like, yeah,
- 1:05:17Mackenzie. And then at first it's still accusing, and then I think,
- 1:05:24unbeknownst to her, she is recalling what happened, and she says, well,
- 1:05:29I you know, she asked me, and it was humiliating. And
- 1:05:33when she asked me, I just said, look, you know, I'm
- 1:05:36tired. You girls got asleep. And then he's like, okay, well
- 1:05:42you just answered your own question. So what's happening? And she doesn't know
- 1:05:47where to go with that. So and she's also not getting what she is
- 1:05:54the fantasy that she's hoping for him, which again he could never provide.
- 1:05:59Take it from me. Clinically, there's no solution to this. I've had
- 1:06:02clients because so the idea with the reparative work with these clients is there's a
- 1:06:09lot of emotional regulation there, you know, there's DBT kind of stuff,
- 1:06:13but the source iff I do is more just general emotional regulation, cognitive behavioral
- 1:06:17therapy kind of stuff, self awareness, and that can take a long time.
- 1:06:23And then the other prong of the therapy has to do with corrective experiences,
- 1:06:28and there's a lot of research on this relational therapy, and the idea
- 1:06:33that goes back over one hundred years is that as the relationship between client and
- 1:06:40therapist intensifies and it's professional and ethical and you know, it's all those things,
- 1:06:45but the individual who you know, the client, has never had closeness
- 1:06:50and so when they finally get a safe relationship and therapist that knows how to
- 1:06:55manage this not only just behaviorally but also in their heart, will really make
- 1:07:01the client feel safe, perhaps for the very first time in our life,
- 1:07:04and then all of this need will come pouring out of them of like oh,
- 1:07:08finally have someone, and they'll be they'll be clinging to the therapist,
- 1:07:12sometimes stalking the therapist or asking for more sessions, or being very preoccupied,
- 1:07:19which is par for the course. That's a sign of therapy working. It's
- 1:07:25not a welcome side effect, but it has to happen given the way that
- 1:07:30the brain works so through that intense relationship that the therapist doesn't necessarily engineer,
- 1:07:39but it welcomes as a very clear sign that okay, because without that you
- 1:07:45can't have repair. It's just it's just like an acquaintance. You have to
- 1:07:47have that reality, that dependence. And then the therapist proceeds to professionally and
- 1:07:55ethically with boundaries, with the frame of therapy, prove to the client that
- 1:08:00you know the client is worthy of security and love and worthy of not being
- 1:08:05abused, and that other people can indeed be trusted, and that when the
- 1:08:13client is on the fence of me thinking I think, I think he has
- 1:08:18my back, I think he can be trusted, but I have a feeling
- 1:08:21that he hates me. That's a common dilemma and that question mark that that
- 1:08:30that that question needs to be repeatedly answered by me, by my by what
- 1:08:38I say, but also by my behavior. And one of the ways you
- 1:08:42prove it is that you are you stick with the client through thick and thin,
- 1:08:47even when the client is being very hostile, might even threaten tossue me,
- 1:08:53and I just love and stick with and stay differentiated, stay in con
- 1:09:00tact, but you know, hold on to my sanity. It's very hard.
- 1:09:03It's very very hard. It's intense, and not every therapist wants to
- 1:09:10do this sort of thing or can, and many therapists don't even know what
- 1:09:15I'm even talking about, which is upsetting. But because a lot of these
- 1:09:18people end up in therapy anyway, So through that, the client learns over
- 1:09:25time, Oh, I am lovable and I can trust other people. I
- 1:09:30am worth it. Other people do have love and don't always want to harm
- 1:09:38me, don't always want to leave me. And boy, have I tested
- 1:09:43this therapist so many times. I have put this person to the test and
- 1:09:48they have stuck with me. This person really must be trustworthy. Maybe I
- 1:09:55can trust other people. Maybe I don't have to. Well, so there's
- 1:09:59the cognitive side of just like maybe I don't have to constantly question other people.
- 1:10:01But through that reparative work, they actually don't get triggered as often and
- 1:10:08don't get triggered as as intensely. So anyway, what she's doing right now
- 1:10:15is she's resorting. You know, she feels a certain way and she's backed
- 1:10:20into a corner of well, yeah, I did just say that. Mackenzie
- 1:10:24called and I said, I'm tired, so you know, there's a split
- 1:10:27second of like, well, why am I upset? But she's still upset,
- 1:10:30So then she goes for it and says, you will not have friends.
- 1:10:34Essentially, it's not direct, but that's the dilemma he is now put
- 1:10:39in. He either has to say, Okay, I won't have friends,
- 1:10:45I won't go out with anybody for any reason without you. But it sounds
- 1:10:51like she doesn't want to do that anyway, I won't do that, and
- 1:10:58is that okay? And then the victim will think, Okay, we can
- 1:11:02finally relax. I've sacrificed a lot, and maybe now everything will be okay.
- 1:11:10No, because the feeling stays. So the abuse continues, and the
- 1:11:15the agency and the power of the victim just gets smaller and smaller and smaller
- 1:11:20because there is no end point to the control. There is no end point
- 1:11:26to feeling secure from the abusive person until they recover from very focused treatment from
- 1:11:38a very focused specialist. There is nothing that the victim can sacrifice that will
- 1:11:45make the client make the abusive person feel secure enough such that they won't get
- 1:11:49triggered, such that they won't react with their typical habit of control. So
- 1:11:57I hope that all makes sense. And what we just saw was a triple
- 1:12:01yikes because in context of everything else that's happening. She's in therapy now,
- 1:12:09but that doesn't guarantee anything but you and maybe Jimmy will say no with the
- 1:12:16altar or whatever. But without some major changes, there are some major signs
- 1:12:27that there's gonna be a lot of suffering that she's gonna cost. So let's
- 1:12:30watch exactly why are you hammering me on that, because like, well,
- 1:12:33I don't want to be with someone who wants to go out and party.
- 1:12:36That's why I'm hammering you about it. Is I drove there, i'd one
- 1:12:41drink, and I came home. But is that something I want to deal
- 1:12:44with? I do like to go out and have drinks socially, And so
- 1:12:47that was edited, but she didn't rescind what she said. She doubled down
- 1:12:51It's not something I want to deal with, which is not a good sign.
- 1:12:56I was hoping. I don't know that she would say, well,
- 1:13:00you know, you can go with your friends, And maybe she did say
- 1:13:01something like that and they edited it out, but I don't know. Let's
- 1:13:04continue to watching it. That's more of a wine cocktail bars, or like
- 1:13:10like maybe going to a brewer on a Saturday and getting home any time.
- 1:13:14I don't want that. I don't want to want that. Baus, No,
- 1:13:16it's not okay. So I've heard some allegations from you know, people
- 1:13:23that watch the show and maybe even other cast members that say that Jimmy had
- 1:13:27deceived her. So maybe this is what this is about. He certainly looks
- 1:13:31like he's telling the truth, right, and maybe he's not, or maybe
- 1:13:35he forgot, but let's rewind this. But I think what he's saying is
- 1:13:41I said that I occasionally like to go to a wine bar or something.
- 1:13:46It sounds believable anyway, And then she says, but it's not something that
- 1:13:54I want. Okay, then you don't go. End of story. You
- 1:13:59know, like if I go to my friend's house to watch a football game,
- 1:14:04my wife's not into that. I've tried to drag her along at times,
- 1:14:08but she, you know, she it's just not her thing. So
- 1:14:14my wife isn't into that. End of conversation. Pretty easy solution. But
- 1:14:20what she's saying, what she's looking for is Okay, I will never do
- 1:14:26that again because you don't want that. Cocktail bars are like, like maybe
- 1:14:31going to a brewer on a Saturday and getting home time. I don't want
- 1:14:35that. I don't want to want that. Bars, No, it's not
- 1:14:38you said you did not do anything. In the pause, you said I'm
- 1:14:42not into going out. I'm not like, that's not my thing. I'm
- 1:14:45guessing that Jimmy, I don't know. Am I biased for Jimmy? I
- 1:14:49want to be clear. I don't know. He could have done all those
- 1:14:51things. He could have lied. I don't know, but given the track
- 1:14:55record of this couple and their behavior and the way he's looking, it seems
- 1:15:00likely that in the pods he says I'm not a I'm not an every night
- 1:15:04party or I'm not even a frequent party. I don't stay out late.
- 1:15:09You know. Earlier, just a bit, you know, ten seconds ago,
- 1:15:12he was saying, I like to go to wine bars or a brew
- 1:15:14pub, and I like to have a few drinks and then come home at
- 1:15:18a reasonable hour. He said that I like to come home at a reasonable
- 1:15:23hour. Now, maybe that's all lies. I don't know. But but
- 1:15:28even then, you know, let's say you're dating someone and they say,
- 1:15:30yeah, I'm not really the sort of person that does all that stuff.
- 1:15:33I like to get home at a reasonable hour, and then one night they
- 1:15:38stay out really late. Well, you're not going to be like you lied
- 1:15:41to me. It would just be like, you know, if you were
- 1:15:43concerned, you'd say I thought you said. And then the person's like,
- 1:15:45well, I don't do it that often, or at least on my scale
- 1:15:47of what not, that often means it means this, and maybe they meant
- 1:15:51different things, right, it's it. I want to I hope I want
- 1:15:57to draw these distinctions, because if you just watched the conversation, it could
- 1:16:02be I think, tricked into thinking that there's actually something that they're fighting about.
- 1:16:09I have seen nothing yet. Now maybe there is, and there's something
- 1:16:14that's being unsaid or they'll eventually reveal it. But there is no basis for
- 1:16:19this conflict. Nothing, there is no reason, there is, nothing has
- 1:16:25happened. That's what people with this problem will do is they will imagine threats.
- 1:16:32They will make up, they will interpret, they will invent attachment threats
- 1:16:39that don't exist, not because they're Dirk faces, but because it was the
- 1:16:44assumption that usually would work out. When they were children, they learned to
- 1:16:47basically assume abandonment and betrayal and harm is happening because generally speaking, that was
- 1:16:55the case, and that gets locked in neurologically, and they have all that
- 1:17:00trauma that is unresolved, and so it just feels they carry it with them.
- 1:17:04I mean not on purpose, but it well, it's shackled to their
- 1:17:09to their neck, and so when things happen, every just you know,
- 1:17:14the past and the present get all jumbled up. So but I want to
- 1:17:16be clear about that because there's a lot of angles. If you're in his
- 1:17:20shoes, it's important to hold on to that so that you don't get tricked
- 1:17:26into thinking that there's a basis for the hostility or what she's doing. I
- 1:17:30mean, just think about the situation that, you know, after the camera's
- 1:17:35left, he's like, oh, there's this birthday party of a friend,
- 1:17:39I got to make an appearance. I'm gonna go. And then she's all
- 1:17:43bundled up and he just knows not to ask, and she didn't want to
- 1:17:47go anyway, So they knew that about each other. He bolts, He
- 1:17:53gets there, one drink, stays for fifteen thirty minutes, comes home.
- 1:17:59That's it. That's it. Gone for an hour, maybe hour fifteen minutes
- 1:18:05whatever. That's what's at stake here. No cheating, no hint of cheating.
- 1:18:13No, no, I mean I guess there's a chance that he cheated.
- 1:18:17He's a fast cheater. She doesn't have any evidence of cheating. All
- 1:18:24she has is a you know, one of her friends says, I see
- 1:18:27him, and what kind of a person sees him from across the room.
- 1:18:32And now maybe the person was like, hey, girl, you know,
- 1:18:35are you here because Jimmy's here? Are you around? You know? I
- 1:18:41don't know, but like I'll just say it's I don't know. I don't
- 1:18:45know what McKenzie did, but it's just another middle school bullshit thing that happened
- 1:18:49on this season. There's just so many like little things where I'm like,
- 1:18:55if you were thirteen, I would get it, but but I don't know.
- 1:18:58I'll give Canci the bend for the dap. Maybe McKenzie was just like
- 1:19:01where are you? Or Mackenzie had been fed a bunch of things by her
- 1:19:08that made her believe that Jimmy was this horrible cheater or something, and so
- 1:19:13she was primed. I don't know who cares, but I want to be
- 1:19:16clear where so if you're in his position, in a relationship or you were
- 1:19:21in the past, and because this is where the gas This is how gaslighting
- 1:19:26works. This is how gaslighting begins if he is coerced or lacks support,
- 1:19:33or is support is stripped away, or he has been through this before,
- 1:19:36or he lacks the self esteem or the ability to protect himself from the onslaught.
- 1:19:44You are at a y in the road. You can either continue to
- 1:19:46fight and incur more escalation and abuse from the abusive person, or you can
- 1:19:53just believe the bullshit and just convince yourself, Yeah, I must have din
- 1:20:00something horrible last night. I don't know exactly, but I did, and
- 1:20:03I'm so sorry, honey. Please please stop abusing me. I will never
- 1:20:08do it again. You went to repeat that enough times, Even if the
- 1:20:11first hundred times you still know that you didn't do anything wrong, But the
- 1:20:15hundred and first time you do that, your brain starts to believe it.
- 1:20:18It's easier to believe it than to not, because if you believe it,
- 1:20:21then you can quickly respond and avoid being abused. Fast forward five years,
- 1:20:29and you believe you have no ability to evaluate reality, and you believe that
- 1:20:38you are a piece of shit. You believe that you are to blame.
- 1:20:42You believe that you deserve the abuse, and she could never hit him.
- 1:20:48I don't think that will happen. I don't even know if she is like
- 1:20:56that, but I'm saying this as a jumping off point so that you can
- 1:21:00know to protect yourself. You sat there and lied to me. I hear
- 1:21:04from someone who I said, I love going to wand bars, I like
- 1:21:06going to call bars, and I like getting home at a decent and then
- 1:21:09I hear your man is out, like where are you? How embarrassing?
- 1:21:15Like it's very embarrassing. So she's she's spiraling. It's exactly so weird.
- 1:21:24So you know, at the beginning of this, there was the tiniest bit
- 1:21:28of tension and I wouldn't even call attention, but I felt tense because I
- 1:21:33know their pattern, her pattern, And I said, there's a pretty good
- 1:21:40chance that we are at the beginning of a fight, and I'm guessing it
- 1:21:45gets worse from here. And I feel terrible for these two, particularly her,
- 1:21:51because there's a good chance that he won't stay with her in the same
- 1:21:58way that Nick and Danielle, in the same way that all the you know,
- 1:22:02he doesn't come across like the sort of person that would not see at
- 1:22:10least this is not workable. But I don't know, so if that's true,
- 1:22:15I feel bad for him because he's being treated poorly, But I feel
- 1:22:19more bad for her because he can leave and might not ever be in another
- 1:22:25relationship like this again. She will always be in a relationship like this until
- 1:22:30she recovers, and the recovery could take decades of therapy. I've worked with
- 1:22:34couples, I've worked with clients like her, and depending on the severity,
- 1:22:39which let's hope it's more on the mild side, minimum five years of intensive
- 1:22:45therapy with a specialist and she meaningfully participates. She randomly finds a specialist,
- 1:22:50which isn't super easy. Even if I told her what sort of therapists to
- 1:22:57look for and she actually looked for those phrases on their profiles, it wouldn't
- 1:23:00be guaranteed that that therapist would actually know what they're talking about, or be
- 1:23:04a good match, or have an open slot. It's hard, so I
- 1:23:10feel more bad for her, truly, if I'm even close to the mark,
- 1:23:14and now I feel like I'm getting a facade from you, and I
- 1:23:16don't like that. I do like to go out every once in a while,
- 1:23:19and I just want to understand where I'm at. I want you to
- 1:23:23understand, Yeah, there's a facade. Why did you lie to me?
- 1:23:28It's just spinning out control because a theme of this disorder is betrayal, abandonment,
- 1:23:36and a betrayal, abandonment, betrayal. And I'll just give you the
- 1:23:39name borderline personality. But if you google it or you've seen any tiktoks about
- 1:23:45it, you probably have been misinformed. It is everything I've been saying so
- 1:23:47far is I've been referring to borderline. Now, borderline is Complicated's a lot
- 1:23:53of different types, or at least a few different distinct types and presentations and
- 1:23:59severe and different clinicians will see it differently. There's a ton of stigma about
- 1:24:03it. There's many clinicians that will believe, I've heard this in consultation meetings,
- 1:24:09that you can never cure or you can never treat someone with borderline,
- 1:24:15which is ridiculous given all the research demonstrates that you can. I just don't
- 1:24:20understand why people would believe such an unscientific thing. I personally and my close
- 1:24:29colleagues, Bob being one of them, have effectively helped people with borderline personality.
- 1:24:35People with borderline personality are not evil the way that they're often portrayed.
- 1:24:41I guess they can be, but anyone can be evil. People with borderline
- 1:24:44personality can be good partners. You can recover halfway from your borderline personality and
- 1:24:51be for the most part, completely functioning in your relationships. People with borderline
- 1:24:59personality often are successful in life. They're not more successful than other people,
- 1:25:04but you know they have regular lives. They don't. You wouldn't know that
- 1:25:09someone was borderlined if you worked with them or they were your friend. They're
- 1:25:13not broken individuals. They're not horrible human beings. They just have a particular
- 1:25:18version of relational trauma that felt like abandonment and betrayal to them. Sometimes that's
- 1:25:26literally abandonment. Sometimes it's literally betray me abandonment meaning like dad just leaves,
- 1:25:31or that both the parents have issues with drugs and alcohol and the child's taken
- 1:25:38away. I'm trying to remember what we heard about Chelsea's early life. She
- 1:25:43I don't have any notes about that. I assume I would have wrote something
- 1:25:45down if she had disclosed anything she did say. I struggle with feeling lovable
- 1:25:53she said, I've been cheated on a lot, And so normally when you
- 1:25:56hear someone say that I've been cheated on a lot, you think, oh,
- 1:25:58that sounds tart terrible. Certainly can contribute to this, but this typically
- 1:26:02is derived from early childhood experiences. If you're raised well enough and then you
- 1:26:06get cheated on a lot as an adult, it doesn't result. It might
- 1:26:11result in like hints of this or temporary moments of this. But she's so
- 1:26:16and I'm not diagnosing her. I want to be clear. No way am
- 1:26:20I diagnosing her. I hope it's clear that I never diagnosed her afar,
- 1:26:26not just because I'm trying to avoid a lawsuit, which I don't think would
- 1:26:29ever happen anyway, But I actually don't believe I could possibly diagnose someone.
- 1:26:34I know. I can't diagnose someone over a TV show. When I diagnose
- 1:26:40people with borderline personality, it might literally take me twelve months to gather enough
- 1:26:45information from a client that is very open in therapy and sharing a lot of
- 1:26:49information with me for you know, fifty two sessions for fifty two weeks of
- 1:26:56the year. I need a lot now. I need less time than that
- 1:27:00with some clients like two months or something, but never with as little information
- 1:27:05as I know from her. So every bone in my body is not diagnosing
- 1:27:12her because I you know, it'd be like saying that you would marry someone
- 1:27:16having only met them for ten days. No one would ever do that anyway,
- 1:27:23I don't, But I just want to understand where I'm at. I
- 1:27:25want you to understand where I'm at because I haven't went out in three months.
- 1:27:29Oh, I know where I was. So you have actual abandonment.
- 1:27:32You have actual betrayal, which can be things like lying or even abandonment can
- 1:27:40feel like a betrayal. But also you can have parents that are still together
- 1:27:45who abuse you, either emotionally or physically sexually. It's often emotional abuse in
- 1:27:50my experience, but it could be any form of abuse, and typically if
- 1:27:54you have physical abuse, it's also at least emotional abuse verbal abuse. But
- 1:27:58for the child, they aren't being abandoned, but in essence they are right
- 1:28:02because as a parent, you are abandoning, you know. It's sort of
- 1:28:09like when Obi Wan says that Darth Vader killed your father or killed Anak and
- 1:28:15your father Luke. It's a it's sort of a metaphor, right, because
- 1:28:20your mother has left you and abandoned you, and now this person who looks
- 1:28:28like your mother, not literally, but you know, the splitting. And
- 1:28:30that's another thing that people with borderline will do. I'm not diagnosing here,
- 1:28:35but it's a hallmark of borderline that there will be what we call splitting,
- 1:28:41and that they will I you know, idealize attachment figures, meaning that they're
- 1:28:46they're all good, all good, they can do no wrong. And she
- 1:28:49kind of does that to Jimmy when things are going well, he's perfect,
- 1:28:53everything's great, to what we call devaluation, where there's no one between.
- 1:29:00You're either perfect and wonderful and needed and oh my god, I just need
- 1:29:03you so much. And it's real. It's not it's not an act.
- 1:29:08Too. As soon as there's even the slightest hint of abandonment, betrayal,
- 1:29:13or harm, it's boom, black and white too. You are worth.
- 1:29:18I can't believe what you did to me. You you're a liar, you're
- 1:29:25a cheater, you don't care about me. You treat me like shit.
- 1:29:28You didn't even kiss me today. You've like like it, and it's it's
- 1:29:31real, and there's there's no nothing in between, and you can't convince the
- 1:29:39person to see the gray zone in between because developmentally they are not capable of
- 1:29:46it, because that is something that is developed early in life through secure attachment.
- 1:29:50You know, children feel that way about their parents. They either love
- 1:29:55you, love you, love you, and then they just hate you,
- 1:29:57hate you. And if if you have kids, you've seen that. It's
- 1:30:00not like extreme, but it's pretty normalized. Right. Parents are used to
- 1:30:05their kids just suddenly, you know, it's like you're playing and they just
- 1:30:10love you and everything's fine, and then you say, Okay, it's time
- 1:30:13to go to bed, and they and they just they just hate you.
- 1:30:15Even seven year olds, you know, will do this sometimes, right,
- 1:30:17you know, they still have a remnant of that, And with enough attunement
- 1:30:23and emotional reflecting like okay you're very upset and security and safety, the child
- 1:30:30will learn. They have this like experiential learning of like, oh, I
- 1:30:34guess, I guess no one's all good and no one is all bad.
- 1:30:40And mom is mostly good and sometimes really annoying. But you know, even
- 1:30:44when she's annoying, I know that she's she's a good person. So certainly
- 1:30:49I can express my frustration, but I can't just be like completely unhinged with
- 1:30:56my upsettedness torture because you know, most of the time she's great with people
- 1:31:00with borderline. They never had that security to make that shift, and so
- 1:31:05they retain that very infantile way of looking at attachments in particular, and so
- 1:31:13they're doomed to that. Now, with therapy and correactive experiences and cognitive behavioral
- 1:31:18therapy and emotional regulation, they can create workarounds in the temporary and then eventually
- 1:31:27actually experience through their intense relationship with their therapists that there are great They will
- 1:31:32experience the gray and thus feel the gray and operate from the gray rather than
- 1:31:41operating from what you know where they're coming from, because you know, you
- 1:31:45can tell them there's a gray zone and they'll cognitively be able to understand it,
- 1:31:48but they do not internally believe it. You know, the one percent
- 1:31:54of them that is their pre funnel cortex will say, yeah, I get
- 1:31:58it that nothing's black or white. But the ninety nine percent of them,
- 1:32:00the rest of their limbic system and the rest of their body knows that there
- 1:32:05is only black and white. But I just want to understand where I'm at.
- 1:32:14I want you to understand where I'm at because I haven't went out in
- 1:32:15three months, so exactly. But like I I can hurt you what I
- 1:32:24want. Friends, I say, hey, you know what I'm really in
- 1:32:26the pros. Yeah, there's He's still trying to rationally argue his points.
- 1:32:35He believes that she will understand logic. I mean, well, she understands
- 1:32:41logic, but that he believes she'll be convinced by it. But she's spinning
- 1:32:47out of control. And the way she interprets these conversations because she'll talk about
- 1:32:53it later, is he's not a good communicator. You know. In the
- 1:32:56previous fight when they were making up on the bed, she said you you're
- 1:33:00a terrible communicator or something like him or the phrase. But she says,
- 1:33:03oh, you're terrible, And I would say he is superior. Yeah,
- 1:33:12I mean, imagine Clay in his shoes. So he's he's doing pretty well.
- 1:33:17And he doesn't have triggers like there's in terms of what we've seen,
- 1:33:24he doesn't present a lot of reasons for her to be triggered. So I
- 1:33:30mean, just think about the quote unquote triggers that well, they're not quote
- 1:33:33unquote. Just let's review the triggers. Well, I guess the first trigger
- 1:33:40was, you know, I think could be triggering to a lot of people.
- 1:33:43He's drunkenly talking about how hot Adea is. I still contend that that
- 1:33:49conversation, the beginning of that conversation was edited out because I have a hard
- 1:33:55time believing Jimmy just offers that up without her, you know, priming the
- 1:34:00pump somehow. You could call me bias for Jimmy. I don't know,
- 1:34:04but given Jimmy's pattern, he's not the sort that would just take a left
- 1:34:10turn on a conversation and just be like, oh my god, she is
- 1:34:13so stacked. Like maybe I don't know him, maybe he's a d bag.
- 1:34:16I don't know. But anyway, point is that it's important to remember
- 1:34:21this stuff that you can't argue. There's no way out of it. The
- 1:34:27only possible thing, and I said this during their last fight, that I
- 1:34:30think he could do is just really not say much at all and just say,
- 1:34:34hey, I'm with you, and I'm sorry, and I want you
- 1:34:39to know that I love you. I've done this sort of working couples,
- 1:34:41and I love you. I mean, well, if they were in therapy,
- 1:34:46there would be all these procedures of emotional regulation, checking in with your
- 1:34:51distress level, awareness of your tendency to spin out, signs of spinning out.
- 1:35:00But the very least what he could be doing right now is is just
- 1:35:04saying, hey, you know, I'm sorry. I'll think about it,
- 1:35:09and I see that you you were hurt by that is that? Is that
- 1:35:15what I'm hearing? Okay, well I do not want to hurt you.
- 1:35:19You know, instead of trying to argue the point, I imagine for a
- 1:35:25lot of people in the audience would say, well, of course he's saying
- 1:35:28those things. He deserves to say those things, and he does. But
- 1:35:30if he wants this relationship to work, which I think he does, he
- 1:35:35can't get into it like the way you would argue about like what sort of
- 1:35:40restaurant you should go to? Well, you know, we went to pizza
- 1:35:43last night, so let's not go to pizza. And you like to go
- 1:35:46to taco places, let's go there. You know, it's not a it's
- 1:35:50not a you're not debating with someone that is speaking verbatim what they mean.
- 1:35:58Like she's saying a lot of if you just sort of cattle everything she's saying,
- 1:36:00it's all over the place, What is it? What's the problem exactly?
- 1:36:08And then she lands on, well, I just don't want to be
- 1:36:11with someone that leaves the house for an hour and has one drink with their
- 1:36:16friends at their birthday party. I don't want to be with someone like that.
- 1:36:20I don't want someone to be out and for someone else to see you
- 1:36:26and have them call me and question me on what's happening. I don't want
- 1:36:30that to happen. The shit I'm really trying to like dive into this man,
- 1:36:34and you don't give two shits. Hey, you don't think that I
- 1:36:39care about to just yeah, yeah. And I think her I think it's
- 1:36:45getting worse, and I think she knows that she crossed a bit of a
- 1:36:49line there. I can usually see that on our face when she extends,
- 1:36:56And then I think there's a part of where it's like, oh, I
- 1:37:00doubt she'll apologize. But the other element that I've been saying from the very
- 1:37:05beginning is if you're in his shoes, because he doesn't exhibit it very much.
- 1:37:12He did during the last makeup when they are on the bed, But
- 1:37:15it's very hurtful. This it's very painful to be on the receiving end of
- 1:37:20this. I mean, forget about if it's abusive or not, because of
- 1:37:24course that would be very hurtful and worrisome. But to have someone to have
- 1:37:30your partner that you have loved and invested time in and showered with affection,
- 1:37:36to have them over what seems to be like nothing, to have them just
- 1:37:43say, well, what phrases she's saying, I'm really in the process of
- 1:37:46this shit. I'm really trying to like dive into this man. And you
- 1:37:51don't give too shit, right, you don't give two shits? And maybe
- 1:37:59he doesn't, but I think he does. And to put all this effort
- 1:38:06and to commit to someone, to put a ring on her finger and make
- 1:38:12plans to marry, introduce her to the family, and you've done nothing wrong.
- 1:38:17The only thing we can point to you is that he commented about AD's
- 1:38:24body. And you know, if we want to say that was a wrong
- 1:38:28thing, then that's one wrong thing. But in the vast catalog of interactions
- 1:38:34that they've had to characterize that whole thing, from choosing her over Jessica,
- 1:38:42from asking her to marry him, to all the kisses and the loves and
- 1:38:47putting up with the previous fights forgiving her without her apologizing to characterize that is
- 1:38:54not giving a shit about me or this relationship. At the very least,
- 1:39:01it's demoralizing. You know. It's sort of like you work hard at your
- 1:39:04new job. You're working, you're working, your boss comes over, it
- 1:39:08just says, well, you're lazy. Have you done any work today?
- 1:39:13And you're like I did. Always says well, that's not much. You
- 1:39:17feel like, well, what's the point. Why am I even putting effort
- 1:39:21into this thing? So at the very least, but more fundamentally, you
- 1:39:28just feel like you're nothing. You feel like you don't matter, You feel
- 1:39:30like over time you start to be gasolight into thinking, I guess I am
- 1:39:35that sort of person. I don't. I'm not a good partner. I
- 1:39:40deserve to be yelled at. It could be very, very hurtful, and
- 1:39:45I guess. As a side note, little tip, don't say stuff like
- 1:39:48that to your partner unless you're sure that it's healthy or helpful to say.
- 1:39:54I can't imagine a situation where it would be, but those kinds of statements
- 1:40:00will come out of people's mouths, and it's like, what do you want
- 1:40:02the other person to do? Now? Maybe you have a partner that actually
- 1:40:09doesn't care at all and you're breaking up at them or something, then okay,
- 1:40:13But just because it feels like that doesn't mean that it is that,
- 1:40:16and sure doesn't mean you should be saying it, because once it's out there,
- 1:40:21I mean, this could be the turning point for his love. This
- 1:40:25is the third time, like we saw with Nick and Danielle, this could
- 1:40:28be the fight where the flame finally gets snuffed out. Well, you don't
- 1:40:33think that I care about to just because I want to go out and like
- 1:40:36have one drink just to make an appearance for a friend and come right back.
- 1:40:39That's not the kind of person I want to be with. Is that
- 1:40:42the kind of person you are? Because it's not the person I want to
- 1:40:44be with? Yeah? Yeah, And his face is not promising for her.
- 1:40:51His face looks like resigned. You know the fact that even I think
- 1:40:57in the first fight he would have been more like wait what, because in
- 1:41:00the first fight he was assuming that she would be coming from potentially a rational
- 1:41:05you know, a rational place, a place that made sense. You know,
- 1:41:11when your partner says something like that to you're like, wait, am
- 1:41:13I missing something that? Did I do something I think that's where he's operating
- 1:41:15at first. I think he's been through it enough times now where he's like,
- 1:41:20really, he kind of has that look on my face, which I
- 1:41:24said, is not a good sign for the relationship. It's not if that's
- 1:41:29what you want. I can't like the life I described to you. It's
- 1:41:32not the life I'm getting, though I love you and I want to be
- 1:41:36around you, but like and as a as a typical pattern for them,
- 1:41:41and I will say it coincides with the abusive cycle that as the intensity increases
- 1:41:47and the victim is pleading and trying to accommodate the abuser, but eventually the
- 1:41:54victim will just give up or be demoralized or want a distance, and then
- 1:42:00the abuser will start to be nice even in the You know, sometimes this
- 1:42:03cycle is framed as like over a number of weeks, but it can happen
- 1:42:10in the span of just a few minutes. So I'll rewind this not because
- 1:42:15I know that it's happening here, because the way that this cycle is often
- 1:42:19depicted in the media and on Twitter and stuff is in the it's one particular
- 1:42:25profile, perhaps the easiest profile to identify, But in my experience, the
- 1:42:29vast majority of abusive relationships don't look anything like the typical profile or the common
- 1:42:35profile that is proposed, meaning that it's you know, it's almost always a
- 1:42:40man that's beating a woman, and it's always violent. And then she's black
- 1:42:47and blue and she is, you know, at her wits end, and
- 1:42:54someone sees her bruises, like her mom, and then her mom says what's
- 1:42:59going on? And then the victims like, I don't know, and then
- 1:43:03the mom says, it's abusive. You need to get out of it.
- 1:43:06And then the wife starts to kind of distance a little bit and maybe even
- 1:43:12moves out temporarily stays with the mom. That's when the abuser will suddenly be
- 1:43:16nice flowers and the forgiveness. I'm going to therapy, I'll never do it
- 1:43:20again. Okay, So that happens, But that's, in my experience,
- 1:43:25not a common case of what I see in my office, you know.
- 1:43:30And I did treat perpetrators that were like that, But even the ones that
- 1:43:33were convicted, they might have even had a moment like that, but in
- 1:43:39the day to day abusive cycle, it wouldn't always look that obvious. And
- 1:43:43so this is an example of what it could look like where it's not that
- 1:43:48typical profile. But let's if that's what you want. I can't like the
- 1:43:55life I describe to you. The life it's not the life I'm getting,
- 1:43:58though I love you and I want to be around you. But like,
- 1:44:00and she's done this before, I don't know. I probably didn't mention it,
- 1:44:05but it's it's an example. I don't know if that's what's happening.
- 1:44:08I want to be clear. I'm probably gonna annoy everyone with a lot of
- 1:44:12caveats. I'm not diagnosing, and I'm not saying that she's abusive, not
- 1:44:15because I want to avoid a lawsuit, but I literally believe it to be
- 1:44:18true that I don't know because I'm watching it at a TV show. Also,
- 1:44:24I'm terrified that as I go out on a limb with some of these
- 1:44:29parallels that I'm drying, that someone will claim and pull out of context a
- 1:44:35clip of me saying things that might look like I am diagnosing or labeling her.
- 1:44:40I'm not. I'm not. I wish like there could I should just
- 1:44:44maybe have a like something on the screen. I had been away from you
- 1:44:49for like a total of like three and a half hours. You're like I'm
- 1:44:54like extensively partying since you've met me, and I'm not. That's not me.
- 1:44:57And now you're questioning whether I'm lying. You know you told me that
- 1:45:00you told me that I was sorry, I'm sorry. Do you not understand
- 1:45:02this? And he's defending himself and it sounds believable, but I don't know.
- 1:45:10And then now without listening, because he's trying to respond to what she's
- 1:45:15saying, he's you could argue he's over talking too, I suppose, but
- 1:45:19at least his responses are in light of what she is saying. You know,
- 1:45:26he's directly addressing what she's saying. When he has sufficiently addressed it,
- 1:45:31she she'll just shift, not because she's doing it volitionally, but because it
- 1:45:36feels abandoning and betraying. So her brain subconsciously will figure a justification for her
- 1:45:45feeling. She'll mold reality to her feeling. And so I think we're seeing
- 1:45:53that again, and she is now going to attempt to dominate the conversation things
- 1:45:59I told you in the pods. Do you know you told me that you
- 1:46:01told me that I was sorry, I'm sorry. Do you not understand the
- 1:46:04situation we're in? Because if you don't. Then we're on a way different
- 1:46:08page. I don't understand the situation differentations. I don't understand the situation.
- 1:46:12We don't know it's the last night, or just the fact that I'm interrupting
- 1:46:15you. Okay, yeah, I don't know what to say beyond that.
- 1:46:20I mean, they're both kind of interrupting each other, so that's not really
- 1:46:25saying much. But you know her body stance, the way in which she's
- 1:46:30trying to get control dominance of the conversation. She comes across as a very
- 1:46:34nice and very accommodating, very sweet person, and you would not look at
- 1:46:44her and think that she is an abusive person. And it would be hard
- 1:46:48to watch this for most people and even think that that's what's happening. But
- 1:46:54I don't know. Sometimes I sell people short. Maybe it is more obvious
- 1:46:58to people if it was to let me know in the comments, Well,
- 1:47:00I imagine to you it would at least be on your radar. If you've
- 1:47:04been watching my channel, you also might know this intimately yourself. You might
- 1:47:10even be a specialist in this area as a clinician. We don't know it's
- 1:47:14the last night, or just the fact that I'm interrupting, you girls from
- 1:47:17the pods are there, and then I find out you're with your girls.
- 1:47:20That's not cool with me? Is that cool with me? Okay? So
- 1:47:28was he there with other women? But he said, I don't know what
- 1:47:34Mackenzie looks like. What other was his friends. He has friends that are
- 1:47:43women, and they were all real clear about how that's all. Okay.
- 1:47:49She did say I've had boyfriends in the past that had girlfriends, friends who
- 1:47:55were women. Who And then she said, you know, I've always been
- 1:47:59cheated on. Oh, I was going to talk about that briefly. That
- 1:48:04Normally, when we hear someone on the show say I've been cheated on a
- 1:48:09lot, you know, of course we believe them. Why would we not,
- 1:48:13But given their presentation, there's a chance, now, has she been
- 1:48:16cheated on? You know, a lot of people have been so that probably
- 1:48:20has happened. But there's a chance that a good number of what she believes
- 1:48:27and knows were incidents of her being cheated on. She was not cheated on
- 1:48:32the way she's talking about him. Imagine if they did break up, how
- 1:48:39the narrative would completely spin from reality. That's why we call it borderline.
- 1:48:45In the past, when It was first being observed in the thirties, forties,
- 1:48:49fifties. The analysts, the evaluators, the therapists would notice that with
- 1:48:57some clients that had a lot of emotional volatility seemed to be schizophrenic delusional,
- 1:49:03you know, for someone that is you know, there's a lot of different
- 1:49:06presentations of psychosis, but one might be that you have someone that you know,
- 1:49:15phases in and out of episodes in which they have close nations and delusions,
- 1:49:21like they believe that their therapist is the devil. Okay, you know,
- 1:49:28that's something that could happen. I had a client once that looked out
- 1:49:31the window and looked at just some random people in the street and said that
- 1:49:36those people were FBI agents that were following him, and they weren't. So
- 1:49:44those are delusions, right, that's psychosis, break from reality. And for
- 1:49:48the early analysts, they would see this and they would they they thought of
- 1:49:54it as a form of schizophrenia, because you know, there's a lot of
- 1:49:57variations of schizophrenia. There's a lot of types and intensities. Sometimes it starts
- 1:50:02with a little bit of delusion and then you see it go away, and
- 1:50:05then it gets worse over time, like with bipolar or something. If it's
- 1:50:09not everyone with bipolar has delusions, but some do anyway, and schizophrenia is
- 1:50:15very noticeable, right, So you can imagine a lot of early people in
- 1:50:17psychology were very well aware of schizophrenia because it's very obvious when someone has an
- 1:50:26episode, and a lot of the early work and theory had to do with
- 1:50:31trying to explain that or and treat it and da da da. So when
- 1:50:35this other sort of client comes around that seemingly has signs of delusions, the
- 1:50:44delusions were always relational though along these lines you betrayed me last night, you
- 1:50:50lied to me, you don't give a shit about this relationship, and then
- 1:50:57I know you cheated on me, okay. Is like hearing these there's a
- 1:51:02lot of manifestations of that, and the analyst is saying, oh, this
- 1:51:05person's delusional like schizophrenia. But over time they would observe that it wasn't a
- 1:51:11global delusion, It wasn't in all contexts. You know, someone who's schizophrenic,
- 1:51:17they will have delusions when they're particularly you know, within their episode.
- 1:51:23That is, you know, like if they hear voices, for example,
- 1:51:27they hear voices all the time. I mean depending, but or they don't
- 1:51:31only have delusions like you know, the guy that saw FBI agents out of
- 1:51:35the window, he doesn't only see FBI agents when one particular person shows up.
- 1:51:41You know, there's the paranoia and the persecution is in multi context with
- 1:51:47in multi situations, whereas for these patients, they only seem to have delusions
- 1:51:53about people they are close to, particularly you know, their their main attachment
- 1:51:57figures. Maybe the analysts too, But they don't misunderstand their friends, or
- 1:52:03their coworkers or their you know, people that they just know acquaintances or something.
- 1:52:10They have no delusions about most humans. It's only people that they're close
- 1:52:14to. What's going on here that doesn't make any sense. So their borderline
- 1:52:18schizophrenic. They're borderline psychotic. They're on the border between non psychosis and psychosis.
- 1:52:27That was the word that stuck. It's a weird word because most people
- 1:52:32today do not think of borderline as being in between non psychosis and psychosis.
- 1:52:39It's perhaps one of the initial observations. But you know, the name stuck,
- 1:52:45so just know that. But it highlights that one of the first things
- 1:52:48that's noticeable is that the individual will actually believe they're not lying, but they
- 1:52:55will believe things that are just completely untrue. And why do they do that?
- 1:53:00Well, the model that I follow is that they have such an intense
- 1:53:04feeling and they also have a schema that they developed early in life that was
- 1:53:08based on what was happening, that they actually will reform their memories to comply
- 1:53:15with their feeling and with their schema. And we all do this to some
- 1:53:18extent. Like a common example that is more often talked about would be you
- 1:53:25have a police officer that's racist and against black people because of the indoctrination by
- 1:53:31society, and rolls up on a crime scene and there's a black man suspect
- 1:53:41unarmed, and the police officer has a lot more adrenaline than if the suspect
- 1:53:48was white because of his beliefs, his schema that black people are more dangerous,
- 1:53:55and so because of that schema, they have an increase in their adrenaline
- 1:54:00and are much more likely to see threat when it doesn't exist. They reach
- 1:54:04into their pocket, peace officer posa gunshoots them, whereas if the person was
- 1:54:09white, they would wonder, but they wouldn't just immediately do that. So
- 1:54:14was the police officer delusional? We wouldn't frame it that way, but you
- 1:54:18exaggerate that, and you will have something that looks delusional, be borderline delusional,
- 1:54:25but it's not. We don't characterize it that way. It's just emotional
- 1:54:30memories, you know. Another example that is way more common is that couples
- 1:54:35will come into my office at having been in a fight earlier in the day,
- 1:54:39and both of them will have completely different memories and stories as to what
- 1:54:43happened during the fight. One person will say, and you've all been here,
- 1:54:46by the way, because I so have I but I'm confident that all
- 1:54:50of us have a small version. That's the other thing about all personage stores
- 1:54:56and including borderline, that it's not like an alien from matter space. You
- 1:55:00know. People with borderline aren't like a different species of human there. They
- 1:55:03have an exaggerated defense mechanism, an exaggerated process that we all have. So
- 1:55:10we all have that seed of borderline, and that when we're in a fight
- 1:55:15and we're hurt and we're upset and we're confused and are adrenaline's going, and
- 1:55:18then we sit down and we both tell the story of the conflict, and
- 1:55:23one person might say something like, well, you said that, you know
- 1:55:30last you know, this morning, when we were in the fight, you
- 1:55:31said that you knew that you were wrong, and then the other person,
- 1:55:36no, I didn't, I never said that. And they believe these things
- 1:55:40to be true. They're so sure of it, and either one is right
- 1:55:44and the other one isn't, or they're both wrong. Either way, one
- 1:55:47or both of them is filtering their memories, which are squishy things and neurons
- 1:55:54through their emotions. They're also encoding. And you know in the present,
- 1:55:58they're encoding persons through their emotions, and it will be encoded having especially if
- 1:56:05the emotions very intense, it'll be encoded as a as a as a a
- 1:56:12corrupted memory, if you will. So she might be doing that. Well,
- 1:56:19the pods are there, and then I find out you're with your girls.
- 1:56:23That's not cool with me. It's not cool with me. If if
- 1:56:28it's offending you that I have girlfriends, and that's another whole other issue.
- 1:56:31Who are you with last night? Who are you with last night? Oh
- 1:56:35my god? Yeah, I don't know. You probably know because I'm guessing.
- 1:56:42It all gets fleshed out. But so I think by implication, she
- 1:56:47thinks that he was with his girlfriends, his friends, who were women,
- 1:56:53and he's getting up and walking away. Some people will call this stone walling.
- 1:56:59It's not exactly stone Walling's. It's more well, it could be it
- 1:57:03depends on your definition, but it could be even healthy for him to do
- 1:57:08this. The healthiest response is I need to break. You know, we
- 1:57:12talked about this in therapy. I need an hour or a half an hour
- 1:57:15to calm down because I'm starting to lose control of my emotions. And we
- 1:57:21all understand that when that happens, we don't operate from a place of groundedness,
- 1:57:29and I probably won't be able to hear you. I'm certainly not going
- 1:57:32to be able to say things that are going to be functional. So I
- 1:57:35need to break. So he could be doing that, but or he's obscuring
- 1:57:40some guilt that he has. I don't know. They established that he was
- 1:57:44only gone for an hour, so even if his friends were there. Now
- 1:57:49I could see a scenario where his girlfriends were there and he knows it'll trigger
- 1:57:57her, so she doesn't want so he doesn't want to and has been trying
- 1:58:01not to mention that even though nothing happened, and so now he's like,
- 1:58:04shit, Now I have to say that or I already said they weren't there.
- 1:58:09I don't know, so I guess we'll find out. Okay, you're
- 1:58:13not being respectful to me. How am I not being respectful to you?
- 1:58:15How? How every day? Who do you hang out with every single day?
- 1:58:20Where do you go when you when you're not here? I have been
- 1:58:25with you everything. Do you go when you work? That's where we're not
- 1:58:27on the same page. I don't know the landscape. Did he do something
- 1:58:31wrong? Maybe he did, maybe he didn't. It's strange he's not just
- 1:58:35saying, what are you talking about? No, I wasn't with that group
- 1:58:43of friends, and even if I was, it wouldn't make a difference.
- 1:58:45So he hasn't been saying that. I don't know. Do you go when
- 1:58:49you work? Here? Really? Here? You? I went to my
- 1:58:55apartment one day I work. Do you text all day? Who do you
- 1:58:59text? Is she accurate? I can't depend on her narrative because of the
- 1:59:06things that she has already said in the previous fights, including this one.
- 1:59:12But she you know, she could be honest something I don't know. I
- 1:59:16guess we'll find out. If you're fishing for me to tell you that I
- 1:59:19text my girlfriends all the time. I see, if you want to sign
- 1:59:23up with me, you have to sign up for all my friends too.
- 1:59:26It's a respecting name at a step back from hanging out with girlfriends. If
- 1:59:30that's what you want right now, maybe he's obscuring something, but it kind
- 1:59:34of looks like he's saying no. Yeah. But plus, even if he
- 1:59:41did text with I think the calling him girlfriends might not help the situation for
- 1:59:45her. But like, I don't think I would call women that. I'm
- 1:59:51like, I wouldn't call Rebecca a girlfriend. I just call her a friend.
- 1:59:57What does gender have to do with a friend anyway? So like I
- 2:00:00don't, I don't call guy friends boyfriends. I mean, if you do,
- 2:00:05I suppose it's fine. But anyway, so he is I think saying
- 2:00:15maybe I did text. I think he thinks if we get into this detail,
- 2:00:21then she is going to feel like she will have justification for this whole
- 2:00:27thing, because yeah, I have friends that are women, and yeah I
- 2:00:31do text him sometimes, But what does that mean about any Why are we
- 2:00:36even now? Were they at the thing last night? Because that's what she's
- 2:00:41saying, or has she just completely jumped ship and she's on a different ship
- 2:00:45because she's done that a number of times, a step back from hanging out
- 2:00:49with girlfriends. If that's what you want, you haven't asked me if I
- 2:00:53have, apparently haven't. Yeah, I tend to believe him. I don't
- 2:00:57know. I worry that somehow how everyone is on her side or a good
- 2:01:01portion of you, and you're just like you're so. I would like to
- 2:01:05think that I am balanced and smart experienced enough to not just be biased for
- 2:01:15one gender. Someone said that once in the comments. Actually just say,
- 2:01:17oh my god, you're so you're so biased for men, just like You'll
- 2:01:21forgive that. But you know, in context, when I started watching these
- 2:01:28various shows, I noticed that there are a lot of people that are being
- 2:01:31triggered one and which I get, and two that there's a tradition of watching
- 2:01:40these shows in which you're supposed to blast and hate and make fun and ridicule
- 2:01:45all of them. And if I'm not participating in that, then that must
- 2:01:48mean that I'm somehow biased for somebody, you know what I mean. And
- 2:01:50I'm just like, well, I'm not going to blast anybody anyway. But
- 2:01:55I do worry about that. I guess in this moment because I'm really but
- 2:01:59I will that like when I watched the Amber Heerd Giant Up trial. I
- 2:02:02don't know. I can't know anything, but if I were to put my
- 2:02:06money down, I would say that he's telling me the truth right now.
- 2:02:10But if there was a conversation. So she's claiming that she is. She
- 2:02:15has asked him to stop or to scale back with his relationships with his friends
- 2:02:24who happened to be women. Let's rewind that. She claims that she said
- 2:02:27that and was ignored, but the way she delivered it it seemed real lackluster.
- 2:02:31So let's rewind my friends too. It's a respecting names, a respect
- 2:02:35step back from hanging out with girlfriends. If that's what you want. You
- 2:02:39haven't asked me if I have, apparently haven't license when tell me right now,
- 2:02:44do you want me to take a step back? Yeah? You know
- 2:02:45what I mean? Yeah? And he I think is operating on this notion
- 2:02:53that if he just keeps pointing out reality that she'll say, oh okay,
- 2:02:58yeah, but she just it's like a politician. They just skip. She's
- 2:03:01not doing that on a purpose. But it doesn't matter what you're talking about,
- 2:03:06it's just going to be derailed onto another set of tracks, it's just
- 2:03:14whack a mole. And so if you're ever in a situation and you can,
- 2:03:18especially if you start to identify it in between the fights, because it's
- 2:03:23hard in the moment, you can have oh we're and really a lot of
- 2:03:28fights are like this in all relationships, but the ability to see it from
- 2:03:30above and be like, oh, we're not in a zone of rationality right
- 2:03:36now because of how adrenaline filled we are right now, So trying to debate
- 2:03:44this is useless. That that's not really what's happening. You know, if
- 2:03:48we just I talk about content versus process, it's a fundamental therapist skill to
- 2:03:55pay attention to that. And the content is they're talking about him having spent
- 2:04:00an hour away last night going to a birthday thing with his friends. That's
- 2:04:04the content and some ancillary things to that, but that is not really what's
- 2:04:10being discussed in my estimation. The process is that he's confused and trying.
- 2:04:15He's I think he's hurt. I think he's starting to get frustrated and demoralized
- 2:04:19and for and he's trying to express that and for her, Like he hasn't
- 2:04:24said that directly, but if he were in his feelings and could communicate that
- 2:04:29it might even help. I imagine it would for him to say something along
- 2:04:31those lines. And for her, she feels abandoned and betrayed independent of what's
- 2:04:39actually happened, I think, and what she wants deep down is not to
- 2:04:45feel that way, and she probably has no rational way of getting out of
- 2:04:53that really, So that's that's what's happening. She feels betrayed and abandoned,
- 2:05:00and she's accusing him, you did this to me, you made me feel
- 2:05:03this way. And the content, the words, and the points that she's
- 2:05:10bringing up are irrelevant to Actually what's happening is just like a it's disconnected from
- 2:05:17that feeling, really, but it feels connected for her. Of course,
- 2:05:20I do want to go I'm not willing to take a step back. Okay,
- 2:05:30I think he said I'm not willing to take a step back from my
- 2:05:33from my friends, and under normal circumstances, he would have had a more
- 2:05:41diplomatic delivery. But yeah, you can't ask your partner and demand and emotionally
- 2:05:48coerce your partner into not having their friends, regardless of the gender, not
- 2:05:56under all circumstances. But unless there's some legitimate reason like your friend tried to
- 2:06:03kill our kids, or your friend is a bad influence. But even then,
- 2:06:11really it's still your partner's choice. You can ask, like, I
- 2:06:14don't think it's a good idea to have that friend. So that's a good
- 2:06:18sign. I you know, what we want all victims of abuse to do
- 2:06:23is to not give up their friends, because that's the beginning of the end
- 2:06:29for the victim. Sho're not taking willing to take a step back? I
- 2:06:43have, I have said that makes me uncomfortable. Yeah, the shift from
- 2:06:48the first fight to the second to the third is notable. That he is
- 2:06:55in this fight just walking away I think, knowing that it's not of any
- 2:07:00use to continue, and there doesn't Well, I guess in the second fight
- 2:07:04he did eventually get there, but he left. But he might be more
- 2:07:10calm. I mean, I'm sure he's freaking out on the inside, but
- 2:07:13he might be less than the second time because he's more just resigned. She
- 2:07:16is now chasing now she isn't. I mean, he didn't leave, so
- 2:07:21it's not as triggering to her. But yeah, I mean, we'll see
- 2:07:27how this goes. But I was hoping she was going to regulate and reorient
- 2:07:32but I don't know why I thought that would happen. There's even when they're
- 2:07:36talking the next day. Well, she did say that one time that she
- 2:07:41knows she's sensitive, but it was real brief and seemed to be briefly felt
- 2:07:46or in a shallow way. Not that she's shallow, but because if she
- 2:07:53really, if I'm gauging even close to the mark down the road of recovery,
- 2:08:00she wouldn't just say I'm sensitive. What she would say is I have
- 2:08:05relational traumas and complex PTSD or whatever construct she's taught or learns or something.
- 2:08:11And because of all that, I will misinterpret what's happening when things are happening
- 2:08:20to make it look like I'm being a bandon betrayed, and I will overreact
- 2:08:24and I will become in a rut of that thing, and I will go
- 2:08:30on the attack, and I need a lot of help with that. I'm
- 2:08:35getting help, And I also would ask that you help me in the following
- 2:08:39ways. And if I am being unfair to you and you need to get
- 2:08:43away from me, then leave. I don't stop and wait for my feelings.
- 2:08:48You don't deserve that. That's different than all the entirety of all the
- 2:08:54things she says, even when she's calm, right, the entirety was you're
- 2:08:58a airable communicators. What she says to him, and you know, it's
- 2:09:01a lot of messages at him that he needs to change, and then a
- 2:09:07couple minor asterisks of her saying that you know, she needs to work on
- 2:09:11our emotions intersensitivity, but anyway you are, you know, I mean,
- 2:09:15that's the way it looks. I don't know. Maybe she's capable of a
- 2:09:16lot of self awareness, but given what I'm seeing, I wouldn't be surprised
- 2:09:22if like I wouldn't be surprised even after a year of therapy. Well,
- 2:09:28I'll just talk about my personal experience, so and clinical experience is that people
- 2:09:31with her profile in times of calm, particularly if they're not in a relationship,
- 2:09:37they can actually be persuaded to adopt and maybe operate from a mode where
- 2:09:43they seem to exhibit a fair amount of insight into something that happened in the
- 2:09:48past, at least in the direction that would seem to have some promise to
- 2:09:56some optimism around it. But as soon as they're back into a relationship,
- 2:10:00you know, their transference just takes over, it's involuntary. So even though
- 2:10:05she might in interviews today a year later, exhibit some reflection which I don't
- 2:10:11even know if that is happening. After the season is over, I plan
- 2:10:15on seeking out kind of stuff like that, but that wouldn't necessarily mean that
- 2:10:20she's all good and that it'll never happen again. And we've seen it,
- 2:10:24you know. Zeneb is actually worth mentioning here too. I don't know,
- 2:10:28but at least the signs was that she falls in love with Cole. They
- 2:10:35go to the getaway the very first day. He wakes up super early,
- 2:10:41she's still in bed, and he sneaks out and goes to the gym,
- 2:10:45and he comes back and in his kind of oblivious way, is I think,
- 2:10:52perfectly pleasant. I don't know. We heard a lot of accusations from
- 2:10:56Zeneb about that morning, but nothing seemed to be concrete. But she definitely
- 2:11:01felt like he completely abandoned her and betrayed her and blew her off. She
- 2:11:05didn't identify anything particular, and in the end, he's just like, I
- 2:11:09didn't want to bother you because you were asleep. I felt like I was
- 2:11:13doing your favor by being quiet, because it was so early in the morning,
- 2:11:16I didn't want to wake you up. I thought I was being courteous,
- 2:11:18And you know, she was just convinced that he had betrayed her.
- 2:11:24And there were other moments kind of like that, right, like with the
- 2:11:28with the cuties moment. Actually she told a story right that he had just
- 2:11:35completely body shamed her. And then the producers of the show after the reunion
- 2:11:43showed the scene, and you know the scene. I suppose there could be
- 2:11:48a variety of interpretations, but I think the consensus among the vast majority was
- 2:11:54that although you could call Cole a bit uneducated or unaware of how some people
- 2:12:03and maybe everyone might be sensitive to the kind of some of the things that
- 2:12:07he says, that when you look at it, it was not even close
- 2:12:11to the way she characterized that. I mean, she she was identifying that.
- 2:12:16I remember now. She was like, let me prove to you that
- 2:12:20he's a horrible person. Let me give you one of the stories. So
- 2:12:24she's not incentivized in that moment to only give a mild story. She's really
- 2:12:28trying to go for a home run, and she remembers that story to be
- 2:12:33horrible, and at the very least it wasn't horrible, right, and might
- 2:12:39even just be completely innocuous to most people you know anyway, So I don't
- 2:12:46know, but it is a tack in the hypothesis evidence column of the reworking
- 2:12:52of the memory based on a schema and a relational trauma that is operating in
- 2:12:58the present, because she might have been very betrayed and very abandoned when she
- 2:13:03was young, and maybe it might even have been particularly around body and food
- 2:13:09and that kind of thing. And then when she's with him, the slightest
- 2:13:13possibility of interpreting something in that way, she interprets that way, and she
- 2:13:16blows it out of proportion, and then it ruminates and then it becomes the
- 2:13:20truth, and then it feels very horrible because when you think that your partner
- 2:13:26would do that to you, you're very hurt. Of course you are.
- 2:13:28But the memory and the perception is distorted. It could be completely invented,
- 2:13:35or the very least it's very exaggerated. So you know, we can add
- 2:13:41her. And I hate that my three examples on this show are women,
- 2:13:46because you know, a lot of research will say that of the people diagnosed
- 2:13:50with borderline, two thirds identify as women, but a lot of other research
- 2:13:56will and I ascribe basically to this finding that because of the bias of the
- 2:14:03evaluators people with borderline, men with borderline will often be characterized as either not
- 2:14:09having borderline or having narcissistic personal disorder, when if you just looked at the
- 2:14:16behaviors and behaviors can these disorders can at times present a little differently depending on
- 2:14:22gender socialization, but we can imagine that being true right because of bias and
- 2:14:31of assumptions. One detail of this is that when you have a man,
- 2:14:37a male client who is very sure of himself the way someone with borderline might
- 2:14:43present and can be controlling and maybe verbally abusive for whatever reason, clinicians tend
- 2:14:54to assume that that's narcissism, when in my book, I you know,
- 2:15:01depending on more presentations with evidence of abandon and honestly, borderline and narcissism in
- 2:15:11a certain way could be characterized as the same disorder with just slightly different flavor
- 2:15:18differences in the trauma and the defense. But they're basically operating from the same
- 2:15:22place. They have a lot in common honestly that I won't go into.
- 2:15:24But so I'm trying to think if there's an example from this show of a
- 2:15:31male that might have had signs. I mean, the problem is with men
- 2:15:39that they might be operating from the borderline trauma, but they might be socialized
- 2:15:46to run away. Oh. Actually, Carlton Diamond and Carlton he was briefly
- 2:15:54on season one, right, So he meets Diamond, they become engaged to
- 2:15:58go on the getaway, and he discloses that he's bisexual, and later she
- 2:16:05would say it's okay that he's bisexual, but she wasn't really clear on that.
- 2:16:07At the very least, she was being clear that she felt hurt and
- 2:16:11concerned that he had lied to her, which I think a lot of people
- 2:16:15would be. And now, on the other hand, there's a lot of
- 2:16:20biphobia that would cause normally good people that would never lie or obscure something about
- 2:16:26themselves resort to that because of worries of literal murder I suppose, but at
- 2:16:35the very least mistreatment or being treated unfairly anyway. So the way that Carlton
- 2:16:41reacted, well, no, that doesn't fit because I think he just has
- 2:16:46a tough guy persona that he resorts to when he feels like he's It's slightly
- 2:16:52I mean, that's just the first person that I thought, maybe, well,
- 2:16:56I suppose Matt from season three calling in Matt. You remember, Matt
- 2:17:03would see betrayal from Colleen where it didn't seem to exist, and he would
- 2:17:09get intimidating. He would become unglued emotionally. So I think Matt is a
- 2:17:15good candidate for adding to the group of people that I would say if they
- 2:17:22went to therapy, it would be worth exploring this construct of borderline. I
- 2:17:26don't I don't have a physical relationship with them. I want you to trust
- 2:17:31me. You do, though you fucking do? You told me fucked her,
- 2:17:35And the fact that you're saying you're unwilling No, I don't get fucked.
- 2:17:39I know you fucked her and you told me that because I want you
- 2:17:41to trust me and I do. Okay, that's new information. It's irrelevant
- 2:17:52because we don't even have it as established that the friends who are women,
- 2:18:00did he have sex with all of them or just one of them anyway,
- 2:18:03were even there last night, and even if they were, and even if
- 2:18:09he had been texting his friends who include some of these past partners or something,
- 2:18:16it's a conversation. It looks like they've had. In fact, it
- 2:18:20kind of looks like they had a conversation off camera and either said, let's
- 2:18:26not talk about that in front of the I mean, I suppose one reason
- 2:18:30why you wouldn't talk about the front of camera is that you don't want to
- 2:18:33out somebody else. Right that the woman might not want that to be on
- 2:18:37international television for whatever reason, you know. But anyway, so you know,
- 2:18:46because the way the internet works, she might forever be known as Jimmy's
- 2:18:54f buddy. Yeah, so he told her, right, she didn't find
- 2:19:01this out. He volunteered this, which demonstrates trustworthiness. He didn't have to
- 2:19:07he could have. I think a lot of people would actually say, you
- 2:19:09don't have to tell Chelsea about that, or you could wait to tell Chelsea
- 2:19:13about that. It sounds like from what we're hearing that he said, let's
- 2:19:20meet up with my friends who happened to be women. And by the way,
- 2:19:24I just want to tell you that I used to date one of them,
- 2:19:28or we got together one time when we got drunk or whatever. Yeah.
- 2:19:33You know, now, in some cultural circles that is a huge no
- 2:19:37no, it's not a huge no no in my circle. Tell you we're
- 2:19:43all adults and you can. We all know that you can have sex with
- 2:19:50someone and maybe even have a five year long romantic sexual relationship with that person,
- 2:19:54break up, be friends with that person, and have that person be
- 2:19:58of no oh threat to your current relationship or future relationship. I'm going to
- 2:20:05take a guess and say that there's some of you that disagree with that,
- 2:20:09or that the rest of the world majority of the rest of the world would
- 2:20:13disagree with that. But empirically, scientifically, experientially it's true. Now,
- 2:20:20can some people have a problem with that. Can some people have a hard
- 2:20:24time with banaging their temptation or something? Yeah, But inherently it's not a
- 2:20:33given that a former partner is a threat to me. If I met someone
- 2:20:39that was still friends with a number of their exes, I would consider that
- 2:20:43to be a green flag. I wouldn't know what it meant, but in
- 2:20:48my world, that's a good sign. Because I'll give you an example.
- 2:20:52Chelsea probably does not have good relationships with any of her exes. Now,
- 2:20:58maybe she does, but there's a chance that she doesn't. And given her
- 2:21:01pattern with Jimmy, we can see why that would happen. Not only because
- 2:21:07she would alienate someone who wouldn't want to be friends with her moving forward.
- 2:21:11But also she would invent things that happened that didn't happen, which I don't
- 2:21:18know. I wish they would just tell us the landscape. We're the friends
- 2:21:24there. It doesn't matter if the friends were there last night. She's implying
- 2:21:28that they are or she is this completely jumped ship and she's just on a
- 2:21:33completely other topic that has nothing to do with him going to a birthday party
- 2:21:39last night for an hour. He was gone for an hour. He's probably
- 2:21:41at the party for ten minutes half an hour. But anyway, so we're
- 2:21:43learning that he did have sex with one of them. Okay, I don't
- 2:21:46trust you, but I'm uncomfortable with it. I told you off camera that,
- 2:21:50like I know, but that I don't want to talk. Okay,
- 2:21:52So it sounds like I was right about that. But that was good that
- 2:21:54she said that. Actually I did say it was okay with it, but
- 2:21:58I'm a I'm uncomfortable. So she's differentiating a little bit. Let's oh,
- 2:22:03you fucked her, and you told me that because I want you to trust
- 2:22:07me, and I do. I do trust you, but I'm uncomfortable with
- 2:22:09it. Okay. That is the first moment I've seen in this fight when
- 2:22:15I I'm like, okay, we might be cresting the hill, because that
- 2:22:20was that was rational, That was that was Differentia. Uncomfortable is a much
- 2:22:26more understandable word. Then you don't give a shit about this relationship and you're
- 2:22:31lying, you're a liar. I'm uncomfortable with it. It's expressing from her.
- 2:22:37Of course she's uncomfortable with it. I I one hundred percent imagine that
- 2:22:43she is uncomfortable with it. Not everyone in her shoes will be uncomfortable with
- 2:22:46it, but I understand that she's uncomfortable with it. And she even said
- 2:22:48she even agreed. Yeah, I know that you told me that, so
- 2:22:52I could trust you. Know, I'm a yes, I'm so she's even
- 2:22:56hearing and saying, yes, I agree with you. So are we cresting
- 2:23:01the hill? Tell me we're cresting the hill? I told you off camera
- 2:23:03that, Like, but I don't want to talk about that. I'm sorry,
- 2:23:07but it was like a lover of respect, I introduced you to her,
- 2:23:09I like, put her in a situation and I love her. Yeah.
- 2:23:15Right, So if anyone's a liar and a betrayer. It's her in
- 2:23:18this moment they had agreed. It sounds like that she wouldn't talk about this
- 2:23:24in front of the camera. We agreed you weren't going to say it,
- 2:23:28and it didn't look like she was saying it in a controlled way. It
- 2:23:31has just come bursting out of her. But again, was this woman even
- 2:23:37at the thing last night? And even if she was, what difference does
- 2:23:41it make? But this is a respect issue. You're not single. She
- 2:23:45keeps using this word respect, which is in its entirety, this I think
- 2:23:50the first time she's been hammering on this word in its entirety. If we
- 2:23:54look at the situation through the abuse lens, these are the kind of concepts
- 2:24:00and words that abusers controllers will use. It sounds nice, right, It's
- 2:24:07like, well, yeah, respect of course, And when she tells her
- 2:24:11friends and her support system about what's happening through her distorted lens, the word
- 2:24:16respect might be coming up a lot. And so it's hard to debate that.
- 2:24:24But when you look at how she's using it, right, and you
- 2:24:30know there's some relatability there, right, But if you just look at the
- 2:24:35whole landscape, he has a friend that is just a friend, unless there's
- 2:24:41some detail that we haven't been told who he happened to have sex with in
- 2:24:46the past. He is friends with this person, and he doesn't want to
- 2:24:52just not be friends with a person because he now is engaged, because he's
- 2:24:58loyal and he likes this friend, and as a matter of respect, he
- 2:25:09stays friends with his friend and tells his fiance that he's friends with her and
- 2:25:16had sex with her in the past. It was probably a long conversation and
- 2:25:20Adam, as a matter of respect, interduces them to each other. So
- 2:25:26I wonder, because I was wondering, why does he only have friends that
- 2:25:30are women, because it didn't seem like that. So I wondered if the
- 2:25:33producers engineered that thing to trigger her or something I don't know. Or he
- 2:25:39said, I want to get out ahead of this whole thing because I have
- 2:25:43friends that are women and I need to race to them knowing each other so
- 2:25:50that she can have some peace of mind. We could see that kind of
- 2:25:52sounds like that's what he's doing, but she's framing it as this whole scenario
- 2:25:56is that he is disrespecting her and that justifies control. The message is not
- 2:26:05I want respect or I want you to love me. The message is I
- 2:26:09don't want you to have friends. That's what this whole thing is about.
- 2:26:15I don't want to be with someone that goes out for an hour. I
- 2:26:18don't want to be with someone that has friends that are women. I don't.
- 2:26:22This is how it starts. And if you comply or even just kind
- 2:26:26of put up with months later, a couple of years later, a few
- 2:26:31years later, he will have no friends and be he will be completely under
- 2:26:37control and completely succumbed to her point of view. Even right, that's the
- 2:26:45message. If she wants to say I'm worried that you cheated on me last
- 2:26:50night, or I'm worried you're going to cheat on me, or I'm worried
- 2:26:54you're you're but she doesn't say that right because I don't think she even thinks
- 2:26:58that that's really what's happening. What's really happening is you do things that trigger
- 2:27:07me. You do things that make me feel abandoned and betrayed. You do
- 2:27:11things that make me get very worried. What are their sex? Well,
- 2:27:16you left the house, you hung out with friends, I wasn't there.
- 2:27:22That's it. You text people even that, right, she's even getting into
- 2:27:28that. I don't know. It could be a coincidence. I could be
- 2:27:33reading into it wrong. He could be legitimately doing things that are about I'm
- 2:27:37still waiting for a fact to happen to be established. But she's even mentioning
- 2:27:45texting. She's mentioned that and said it's disrespectful or that sort of view,
- 2:27:52that sort of the face that she has of when she was like, tell
- 2:27:58me who you're texting all day? And if he's not doing anything bad,
- 2:28:05which I don't think that he is. Maybe he's texting his friends who are
- 2:28:07women frequently, but I think it would be a massive stretch to say that
- 2:28:13and therefore he's cheating or he's a d bag or he you know, even
- 2:28:16if he is texting, people text with their friends. I have a friend
- 2:28:24who's a woman who's texting me right now that during my pauses, I've been
- 2:28:28talking with her about Chelsea because she's a therapist too. My friend brought up
- 2:28:35Chelsea. So Christy, if you're out there right now and sort of the
- 2:28:39timeline, it's right now, but Chrissy's been on the podcast before, actually,
- 2:28:46so where was I? It's late, But I find this scene to
- 2:28:56be so fascinating, as you can tell by how much I'm having And I
- 2:29:03know some of you are going to, like Kirk watch the show, you're
- 2:29:05yamoring too much, and I know a lot of a lot of you will
- 2:29:07say, no, no, we come here for the amoring. So you
- 2:29:09know, I get all that, and I'm not asking for reassurance, but
- 2:29:13to the people who don't like me amoring, I am committed to this topic
- 2:29:20because it spans so many different areas of suffering in human lives today that if
- 2:29:28there's one thing I can do, it is to highlight and really drill down
- 2:29:35on this. You know, you'll hear me talk about preoccupation or borderline or
- 2:29:39abuse here and there. But this is giving me such a good opportunity.
- 2:29:43I don't even remember Nick and Danielle's footage being this useful in this way anyway.
- 2:29:50So she's bringing up texting. That's what I said about And by implication,
- 2:29:54I think, if I'm reading it right, is it's a foray.
- 2:29:58You know, it's the beach head into eventually winning the war of isolating him
- 2:30:03entirely, not volitionally. She doesn't wake up in the morning and say I
- 2:30:07want to isolate him, So I can control him. It's when he texts,
- 2:30:13or even the possibility of him texting feels very threatening to me. And
- 2:30:18because I have no way of determining if my feelings and my thoughts are rational
- 2:30:24or not, because I was not attuned to growing up, I'm lost in
- 2:30:28my emotion and I just know that if he stops texting, and he stops
- 2:30:35leaving the house, and he stops having friends, I know or think I
- 2:30:39will feel better. So that's what I am going after. I'm not going
- 2:30:43to say it directly because I know enough that that's ridiculous, but I will.
- 2:30:46I will mention it, I will send the message because that is the
- 2:30:50message. You will not have friends. You won't have friends that are women,
- 2:30:52you won't have friends that are men. You won't leave the house.
- 2:30:56He says he's left, that he's left her her he's left the house three
- 2:31:01and a half hours total. So if that's true. Does he work from
- 2:31:05home? I don't know, but or is that outside of working? I
- 2:31:09don't know. But the message is, don't leave, don't ever go to
- 2:31:13a bar with friends and have one drink, even if it's just for an
- 2:31:16hour. Don't text. These are the messages now I'll hold out that at
- 2:31:22the end of this thing or in a future episode, evidence will come out
- 2:31:24that he's a d bag. That happens sometimes like sk in whatever season that
- 2:31:28was, he seemed like a total stand up guy and then stuff came out
- 2:31:33later. So I don't know. I'm just using this in the same way
- 2:31:37that I did with the Amber heard Johnny Depp trial. Being clear. I'm
- 2:31:41just talking about my clinical experience and the theory and the history and the research
- 2:31:50that is real. And I'm using this as we could be watching a fictional
- 2:31:54movie and I'd be talking about this. I'm saying nothing about this particular situation.
- 2:32:00Is it one time thing, calling and texting and being with each other
- 2:32:03when I'm gone out of town. It is because they care, because it's
- 2:32:07because of what. You're not single, Jimmy anymore. You're not I'm not
- 2:32:13out doing like hanging out with women. Who are you with us? If
- 2:32:18you don't hold on to reality. This is how gaslighting, even as a
- 2:32:22as an audience member, and I felt myself kind of doing that. I'll
- 2:32:26rewind it. But she's the way she's talking. You're just like, wait,
- 2:32:30what's happening. They have established between the two of them that he has
- 2:32:35left once and it was for an hour one time, one time, one
- 2:32:43time, two times, and that's it. And yet when she says this,
- 2:32:48it's starting to be like, wait, what's happening because it's because of
- 2:32:52what. You're not single, Jimmy anymore. You're not I'm not out doing
- 2:32:58like hanging out with women last night? Who are you with last night?
- 2:33:01You start? She seems so sure of herself. And this is the you
- 2:33:07know, the analogy that I give here is if me and my wife are
- 2:33:13trying to remember something that happened a year ago and I'm like fifty percent or
- 2:33:18even eighty percent sure that I remember it going a certain way, and my
- 2:33:24wife says, no, no, no, it was this other way.
- 2:33:26And I'm like, what percentage? And she's like, I'm one hundred percent
- 2:33:28sure this thing happened. And I a lot of people would be like,
- 2:33:33well, you're one hundred percent sure, and I'm only eighty percent sure,
- 2:33:35So I'm gonna guess and say that you're right. That's a natural cognitive shortcut
- 2:33:43heuristic bias that I think is natural to have. And when you are in
- 2:33:48a relationship with someone with borderline, they are so sure of themselves because they
- 2:33:54are sure of themselves, and they're very desperate to make sure that their narrative
- 2:33:58is is dominant. Because they're so desperate. Nobody is one hundred percent sure
- 2:34:05of their stance. He's not one hundred percent sure. It's not rational to
- 2:34:09be one hundred percent sure. You should always have some question mark, right.
- 2:34:15That's where the abusive person gets their foot in the door, and you're
- 2:34:20like, well, I guess I don't even in your own mind. I
- 2:34:22was like, well, I'm pretty sure I didn't do anything wrong, but
- 2:34:26boy are they sure I did? So maybe I'm wrong. And then it
- 2:34:30plants the seed and then you fast forward. You do that enough times and
- 2:34:33it's just all the emotional coercion and just the bother of having to fight about
- 2:34:37it, and you just give up your ability to gauge realities. I guess
- 2:34:41I'm just wrong. For the second, I was with eight Forttorney brothers and
- 2:34:50two of their girlfriends. Okay, okay, do you think I'm lying to
- 2:34:52you about that? Yeah? I do, because I heard well sre She
- 2:34:56says, So we just had a factual numerical eight of my fraternity brothers and
- 2:35:03two of their girlfriends. Okay, is he lying about that? Let's find
- 2:35:07out what she said. I heard from other people that you were not with
- 2:35:09just for Trinity brothers. Who were you with? Right? And then she
- 2:35:15says, I heard from other people that you weren't just with your fraternity brothers.
- 2:35:18Well, yeah, he just said he wasn't just with this retectory.
- 2:35:22He said there were two of their girlfriends. And then he's like, who
- 2:35:26told you this, Mackenzie. She doesn't answer that question in the edit,
- 2:35:31and then she's like, who are you now? Maybe she knows something,
- 2:35:33Maybe there's some big reveal. I'm going to take a guess and say that
- 2:35:37would have been revealed a long time ago if there was something remotely close to
- 2:35:41being factual or even some piece of evidence. I'm guessing she's just she's just
- 2:35:48derailing to something else, because every road is a is a dead end because
- 2:35:54there's no there's nothing there I know, not with Jess. I've never saw
- 2:36:01Jess. Jess all right, well, yeah, that's quite a thing.
- 2:36:05If that's true, then I mean, even then, well but that would
- 2:36:15not be helpful if he did. So say in a world where that with
- 2:36:22everything that she said that she has said thus far though, I'm I will
- 2:36:28wait to draw any conclusions. But even if that, so let's just go
- 2:36:31if that were true, would it justify some of what she's saying. Well,
- 2:36:37yeah, I mean if if he met up with Jess or even just
- 2:36:41saw her, like, oh, there's Jess over there, and didn't as
- 2:36:46soon as possible tell Chelsea about that, that that would be a problem.
- 2:36:52Would it actually be you know, it could be that he is so terrified
- 2:36:58of triggering her that and that will happen. That this is one of the
- 2:37:03pitfalls of being in a relationship with someone like this that you will rationally contemplate
- 2:37:11lying sometimes out of self preservation. You know, let's just say, for
- 2:37:16instance, that Jess just happened to come on the scene and he's like,
- 2:37:20oh shit, Jess is here. And then even let's just say Jess walks
- 2:37:24in where they were and he's just like, okay, I gotta go,
- 2:37:26and he doesn't even talk to Jesse. He walks out and he's driving home.
- 2:37:30He's like shit, shit, shit shit. I know she's I know,
- 2:37:31Chelsea's already going to be triggered by the fact that I'd even left.
- 2:37:35And if I say that Jess showed up. It's she's going to blow it
- 2:37:39completely out of proportion. So I'm just going to say that I didn't that
- 2:37:46Jess wasn't there. Maybe I'll all claim that I didn't even see Jess.
- 2:37:50You could imagine in his shoes someone saying and planning to do that, right,
- 2:37:56And the problem is is that when victims do this, that they can't
- 2:38:01remember all the lies or they'll be evidenced to the contrary. And then the
- 2:38:07abusive person really lays in not because they are you know, evil, but
- 2:38:13because they're already paranoid and inventing abandonment and betrayal as it is. But when
- 2:38:20they actually have a factual betrayal and you might even say, yeah, I'm
- 2:38:24sorry I lied about that, then that's just game over. Then they have
- 2:38:31no reason to question their you know, it justifies all their paranoia, right.
- 2:38:37It's just like all those times when I was when you were claiming that
- 2:38:41I was wrong, those things were all probably all right as well, you
- 2:38:46know, sort of like flat earthers or you know, confirmation bias. Right,
- 2:38:50So I don't know, but if I were to put my money,
- 2:38:54I would say that. So getting back to what I was saying a while
- 2:39:01back that for people with borderline, they will invent things. Remember borderline schizophrenic,
- 2:39:07borderline psychotic. They will have delusions, They will make stuff up and
- 2:39:13believe it the way that they might claim that they are an alien, you
- 2:39:22know, that an alien came from outer space and possessed their body, or
- 2:39:28that Joe Biden has a demon inside of him, and they're very convinced.
- 2:39:31You know, you know, not everyone with delusions or schizophrenia has that type,
- 2:39:37but you know what I'm saying, And to argue with someone that is
- 2:39:43in the middle of a psychotic episode that their perceptions are wrong is futile,
- 2:39:48just like well, you must be part of the conspiracy or something like that.
- 2:39:52So borderline psychotics. So for people with borderline, when they're triggered,
- 2:39:58they will invent reality to fit how it feels. It feels like he is
- 2:40:05betraying me. It feels like he has left me. It feels like he's
- 2:40:09cheating, and it feels like it's Jess. You know what, Jess was
- 2:40:16there, and you know what, Mackenzie told me that Jess was there,
- 2:40:20and you know what McKay' you know, I've seen this, can it can
- 2:40:24progress? So I don't know what's happening here? Maybe Jess was there.
- 2:40:28We'll watch. But for people with borderline, they will there will be an
- 2:40:33initial question mark or an initial paranoia that you know what, I bet you
- 2:40:41Jess was there? Okay, then fast forward. Jess was definitely there.
- 2:40:45I can just feel it. Fast forward. Mackenzie told me that Jess was
- 2:40:50there. Fast forward, Mackenzie told me that Jess was there, and Mackenzie
- 2:40:54sent me a video proving that Jess was there. Now, this is not
- 2:41:00this is just normal human emotional memory and emotional reasoning. Fast forward further.
- 2:41:09I know that you have had sex with Jess multiple times. Fast forward.
- 2:41:13I know that you have had sex with multiple women while you've been with me.
- 2:41:18Fast forward, I know that you secretly married Jess and she's in the
- 2:41:22basement right. Maybe I'm going a little far, but see, and all
- 2:41:28this is based on nothing, and people with borderline will do this and they're
- 2:41:33not at fault for it. It's happening automatically for them because of what they
- 2:41:39went through growing up, and as it intensifies, they become more and more
- 2:41:43hurt. They've had a lifetime of abandonment and betrayal that was real. Well,
- 2:41:48they had a whole childhood that was filled with real abandonment and betrayal,
- 2:41:54and because of that abandonment and betrayal, they created it in their adult life.
- 2:42:00Now, some people with borderline will actually find people that have a tendency
- 2:42:05to betray and abandon and then they actually will be abandoned. That doesn't seem
- 2:42:09to be happening right now, but you know, there's a chance that she
- 2:42:15has been abandoned and betrayed by actual partners factually, and in part she was
- 2:42:20seeking those people out unconsciously because she's trying to recreate what was happening, at
- 2:42:26least metaphorically when she was young. Not that she's to blame for the betrayal.
- 2:42:31Whoever betrayed or or harmed her abandon her there to blame for it.
- 2:42:35But you know that often is the pattern, and when the partner doesn't fit
- 2:42:41the pattern, the borderline person will make them fit, either just by convincing
- 2:42:48themselves that it is happening, or by slowly manipulating the partner to actually do
- 2:42:54those things, because it's not hard to imagine that over time he will break
- 2:42:58up with her, which is an abandonment, or in a worst case scenario,
- 2:43:03he will cheat on her and be discovered something like that, right,
- 2:43:07or he will lie to her in a very factual way. So it can
- 2:43:13be a self fulfilling prophecy, particularly if the relationship is long term. You
- 2:43:16know, imagine if this relationship continues like this and he is a victim and
- 2:43:22she is being abusive, which I can't know, you could imagine that five
- 2:43:26ten years. You know, say he's been isolated from his friends, and
- 2:43:31then one day he's out and about and he bumps into one of his old
- 2:43:37friends, the woman that he had sex with the past, and she comes
- 2:43:43up to him and he's just like, oh my god, you got to
- 2:43:45leave, you know. And then the friend manages to get close to him,
- 2:43:52and he starts to slowly open up over time, you know, he
- 2:43:56gets a burner phone or something. They're texting, and he's like, yeah,
- 2:44:00this has been happening, And slowly this old friend is like, oh
- 2:44:03my god, you're being abused, you know, And then he starts to
- 2:44:07say, yeah, I guess I am, you know. And then he
- 2:44:13is so demoralized and so sad and so gas lilt and so desperate, and
- 2:44:18he's you know, he's been abandoned himself by everybody because he's been made to
- 2:44:24cause them to abandon him, and he's been abandoned by his partner. He's
- 2:44:28abandoned himself. And this oasis comes of someone that actually cares, someone that
- 2:44:33listens to him, and he starts to feel a natural compulsion to have more
- 2:44:41contact with this former friend in a clandestine way. And then he one night,
- 2:44:50you know, they have a couple of drinks and he's just so appreciative
- 2:44:52of her and they kiss. So in that moment, he is cheating.
- 2:45:00We can see how that would happen, right, We could see how the
- 2:45:05desperate, controlling effort to prevent him from cheating causes him to cheat. It's
- 2:45:11still his fault he's cheating, but in that context, we can see why
- 2:45:15that would happen. Right. So I don't know if that's what we're seeing,
- 2:45:18but it's something I see all the time clinically. I mean not all
- 2:45:24the time, but you know, frequently. But anyway, this see what's
- 2:45:28just there. Let's find out you probably already know we are you with I
- 2:45:31know I was not with Jazz. I've never saw Jess. I heard Jess.
- 2:45:37Yeah, it doesn't sound very confident. I heard it was Jess.
- 2:45:41So I wouldn't be surprised if right now she is so paranoid that it's Jess,
- 2:45:48that she is strategizing that if she is, you know, sort of
- 2:45:52like interrogation police officers, you know, we know you're guilty. In fact,
- 2:45:56it looks like that, right the investigator has no proof or very circumstantial
- 2:46:01proof that the suspect committed the crime, you know, say it's a break
- 2:46:05into a house or something, and the police officer. In fact, I
- 2:46:11was being questioned by police one time. Well they'll tell the story, okay.
- 2:46:16So I'm not proud of it. I regret it deeply. I do.
- 2:46:22Me and my friends were in college, were probably eighteen, and we
- 2:46:28were at this large party speaking of fraternities. I was in a fraternity and
- 2:46:35then me and my friend for some reason, decided to just go for a
- 2:46:39walk. And it would have been I don't know, three in the morning,
- 2:46:41and we went onto the University of Washington campus, and long story short,
- 2:46:48I thought it'd be funny. I'm eighteen. I thought it'd be funny
- 2:46:54if we pulled a fire alarm. It's terrible, and so I pulled the
- 2:47:00fire alarm and then me and my friend. We you know, we go
- 2:47:03running and then we see a cop and so, but pretty far off,
- 2:47:09and so I say, okay, stop, don't don't run because that makes
- 2:47:11us look guilty. So we'll just casually walk down the street. But it
- 2:47:15looked ridiculous because there wasn't anyone else around, and you know, a cop
- 2:47:18comes up, detains us, puts us in the back seat of the squad
- 2:47:22car, starts to question us, and we're like, we don't know what
- 2:47:28you're talking about. We don't we don't know what you're talking about. And
- 2:47:31the cops leave, you know, the front seat of the of the squad
- 2:47:35car. And hopefully they didn't have microphones. They apparently didn't. I think
- 2:47:39they do today. But I turned to my friend. I don't know why
- 2:47:43I knew about. Maybe I watched too many movies or something, but anyway,
- 2:47:46I turned to my friend, who I'm still friends. I've been friends
- 2:47:50with him since preschool. So I turned him and I say, no matter
- 2:47:52what they say, don't admit it. No matter what they say, don't
- 2:47:56admit it, no matter what they say, and the it's terrible. It's
- 2:48:03terrible. It's terrible. It's terrible. Kids, it's terrible. Don't do
- 2:48:07that. I should I just shouldn't have pulled the stupid alarm. I mean,
- 2:48:09it's awful. You know, it causes problems. You know, someone
- 2:48:13could have been afraid, It pulls fire aid away from legit fire situations.
- 2:48:20It's it's awful. I was eighteen. The cops come back into the car
- 2:48:26and they say, well, we know you did it, and I'm like,
- 2:48:28oh shit, but I'm like, don't admit it, and my friend's
- 2:48:33I mean and they say, well, we have a witness that says that
- 2:48:37they saw you, not when you pulled the fire alarm, but just after
- 2:48:41running away from the fire alarm, And it sounded pretty believable, you know,
- 2:48:45and just on a on hope that the police officers were relying about it,
- 2:48:52which I didn't think they were. I said, well, I don't
- 2:48:56want to talking about it. Wasn't us. And my friend said, yeah,
- 2:48:58I don't want to talk about wasn't us. It goes back and forth
- 2:49:01for a while, and then they let us go. I'm going to take
- 2:49:03a guess and say they did not have a witness that saw us, because
- 2:49:07if they did, I think we would have been in handcuffs. So again
- 2:49:13I was eighteen. I've never talked about this story. I don't think on
- 2:49:16the podcast before anyway. So in that moment, you know, you've seen
- 2:49:22all the procedurals where a police officer will act like they're very confident because they're
- 2:49:30hoping for a confession. They're they're putting the screws to someone, right,
- 2:49:33I think that's what she's doing. She suspects strongly that Jess was there,
- 2:49:39but has no evidence, and is hoping that if she says someone told me
- 2:49:45I know, I know she was there, that he will say, okay,
- 2:49:48fine, she was there, so but maybe she was there, let's
- 2:49:52find out for who are you with? I know I was not with j
- 2:50:00I never saw jeszz I heard it was Jess. Oh my good. Embarrassing
- 2:50:07right now, And it looks like she is giving up on that. And
- 2:50:15it would be weird if she were there. Honestly, well, I guess
- 2:50:18it wouldn't be weird if was there with Mackenzie. But anyway, he was
- 2:50:22with his fraternity brothers. Why would they be with Jess, So anyway,
- 2:50:31maybe she was there. She seems to be giving up pretty you know,
- 2:50:35if Jess were there, she would have brought up Jess a long time ago,
- 2:50:39right, I heard it was Jess. Oh my good embarrassing? Right,
- 2:50:46well, it got well, I was in bed and you were out
- 2:50:52right, So she's it's just once she hit a dead dead end of roade.
- 2:50:56You just you just switched to another road. And who's lying now?
- 2:51:01Who's betraying? Now? Her? She's lying? Just straight up. I
- 2:51:09heard it was Jess from who who told you that? Nobody told you that?
- 2:51:16Now, maybe I'm wrong, maybe someone did that, But you know
- 2:51:20who's lying now? I don't know one of them. You probably know who.
- 2:51:24I think you're fishing. I think you're fishing. Do you think I'm
- 2:51:26fishing? Yeah, when I'm getting told that you're out at a bar,
- 2:51:31I think that you're insecure about the Jess thing. I don't know have a
- 2:51:35clue what Jess looks like other than the picture of Jeremy job. Really,
- 2:51:37you didn't tell me that interesting? So well, now she's kind of slurring
- 2:51:41her words. I didn't. I mean, it's evening. Is she intoxicated?
- 2:51:46Could be a factor, for sure. She doesn't seem terribly intoxicated,
- 2:51:52and she's acted this will say. The first time was the after that first
- 2:51:58party outside where they met everybody at the getaway, she probably was drinking.
- 2:52:03Then, well we know she was drinking. Then at least some she seemed
- 2:52:05terribly intoxicated then, or did she He seemed pretty intoxicated. And then the
- 2:52:13second fight was in the evening and she could have been drinking then too,
- 2:52:18So yeah, it could be a factor. But then the next days when
- 2:52:22I presumably she's not intoxicated, but god knows, probably not. Although she
- 2:52:28seems to be more level headed, she still kind of operates from all of
- 2:52:33these assumptions. Plus, when people get intoxicated, they don't suddenly in such
- 2:52:39a patterned way present like this. You know, it couldn't be a factor.
- 2:52:43Though. In fact, if I were treating a couple and they had
- 2:52:48this issue, I would raise that question, and I would suggest that both
- 2:52:54of them think about, especially for a span of time, that they both
- 2:52:58think about not drinking at all, because it can make it a lot harder
- 2:53:01and a lot of damage can happen when you lose your ability to think straight
- 2:53:07and when you're just operating from your limic system. That was a Kardashian,
- 2:53:13I said. Jeremy said, she looks oh right, So I thought he
- 2:53:18had seen her Instagram. Jess said that he friended her, followed her,
- 2:53:24and then she was she ignored it first and then she looked again and he
- 2:53:30had rescinded the follow request. But now he's saying that Jeremy showed me her
- 2:53:37Instagram. Okay, it doesn't really matter. It doesn't matter this whole narrative
- 2:53:46that somehow he is just waiting to be a Jess or really wanted to be
- 2:53:50with her. We have no evidence that that is true. It could be
- 2:53:54true, but there's been nothing substantial that that is true. There just isn't.
- 2:54:03It's all from her and kind of just from the way they're editing it.
- 2:54:09Maybe it is. I'm going to take a guess and say that they
- 2:54:13break up, or at least they're not a yes yes at the altar,
- 2:54:18and we'll just never know, because say they do break up, it would
- 2:54:24be rational if he did date Jess. It wouldn't be a terrible thing because
- 2:54:30he did connect with Jess, and Jess wants to at least see with him,
- 2:54:35so you'd have two consensual people. Chelsea doesn't have any ownership over him,
- 2:54:41so it would be normal for that. I don't know if that would
- 2:54:43I don't even know if he's going to break up with her. But if
- 2:54:46that did happen, then that would solidify in Chelsea's mind and maybe a lot
- 2:54:50of the audience's mind that yes, oh, he never wanted to be with
- 2:54:54Chelsea, he always wanted to be with Jess. I think that's all based
- 2:54:58on this assumption that Jess makes about herself, that she's this obvious, that
- 2:55:05she's obviously superior as a person or or a woman to Chelsea. There's been
- 2:55:13no evidence that that's how he sees it. If anything, there's been ample
- 2:55:20evidence to the contrary. Can he look at Jess and go like, well,
- 2:55:22wow, she looks like or she's attractive. It doesn't mean anything.
- 2:55:26He could be And maybe, you know, maybe there's something that came out,
- 2:55:28like he's been cheating on Jess the whole time. Maybe Jess is under
- 2:55:31the bed hiding. I don't know. We have already talked about this last
- 2:55:35night, and you never mentioned the just thing until to night. I felt
- 2:55:37like shit last night and I didn't say anything. He was like, maybe
- 2:55:41really sad. And we're seeing the pattern that she's run out of roads to
- 2:55:46go down and she's now appealing to emotion it's not volitional in all likelihood,
- 2:55:56it's just she's run. She's been convinced. I think that's actually what just
- 2:56:00happened, is that, in a sense, she kind of crossed the hill.
- 2:56:03And we've seen this, this is the third time we've seen it on
- 2:56:05camera where he scraps and scrapes and begs and stays in the fight and doesn't
- 2:56:15get nasty. I mean, you could say the nastiest thing he said was
- 2:56:18call her clinging. I think a lot of people would say that that's fair.
- 2:56:22I would say, don't say that word. You can say the concept,
- 2:56:26however you're defining it, but the word is pretty hurtful. But you
- 2:56:33know, aside from that, you know he's just sticking with it, and
- 2:56:39eventually he wins her over. And if this is going to work, I
- 2:56:41suppose that's what needs to happen, and it just do a lot of other
- 2:56:43things and then eventually she just she's convinced. Okay, he passed the test,
- 2:56:50So now I'm just going to ramp down a little bit and I will
- 2:56:56feel satisfied. Basically, he owed that he under circumstances where a lot of
- 2:57:03my partners would just walk out the door or something he's still trying, and
- 2:57:09I crossed the line by lying to him that I heard that Jess was there.
- 2:57:13I mean, the fact that she's not hammering on that just tells me
- 2:57:18that she was lying, just straight up lying I heard Jess was there.
- 2:57:22So we've seen this pattern and in the past. The first time I was
- 2:57:30encouraged when you know, he goes over to her there in the bungalow thing
- 2:57:33at the getaway and he's like, I'm so sorry. I didn't want to
- 2:57:37hurt you. And she has eye contact and she says, you hurt me
- 2:57:41or something. You know, you seem to listen to me, but she's
- 2:57:43soft, and then they make up and she says, I can't stay mad
- 2:57:48at you, and you need to not do that again. He's like,
- 2:57:52I'm sorry, I'm sorry. It's a cycle, and it's inevitable until she
- 2:57:58gets focused treatment and dedicate hates herself to working on those things and dedicates herself
- 2:58:05to questioning. You know, a big part of the treatment of borderline is
- 2:58:09to question, not to state, but to question. This is I'm constantly
- 2:58:15doing this for a variety of clients. But that okay in the moment,
- 2:58:20and maybe even right now, Jess or not Jess, Chelsea, you have
- 2:58:26a strong suspicion that he's abandoned you, or that he's cheating on you,
- 2:58:30or he's lying to you, or he doesn't love you, or something you're
- 2:58:33strongly convinced of that. I don't know if he is or he isn't,
- 2:58:37But I ask, if you want things to get better for you in your
- 2:58:41life, just introduce a question mark. Now. In my head, especially
- 2:58:46if it's an ongoing relationship, I would heavily suspect that the partner does indeed
- 2:58:52love and is not cheating and that all that kind of stuff. So,
- 2:58:54but I don't know, you know, and I can't convince someone who is
- 2:59:00orderlying, you know, psychotic borderline schizophrenic, that the delusion doesn't exist.
- 2:59:05You can't. It's it doesn't work, it's too rigid, it's too entrenched.
- 2:59:09So I would say, just just introduce a question just just a question
- 2:59:15mark, and you know it. It's reasonable, right, It's hard to
- 2:59:18argue against that. Just add a question mark. Now, if I don't
- 2:59:22have a good enough relationship foundation with a borderline client, even with that intervention,
- 2:59:30they will feel potentially deeply betrayed by what I said. Because it feels
- 2:59:35like what I'm saying, which essentially is true, that their feelings aren't valid
- 2:59:43or aren't reasonable, the way they think is distorted, and I can talk
- 2:59:50until I'm blue in the face that everyone distorts and everyone isn't rational all the
- 2:59:56time. So I'm not accusing you of anything. I'm not accused of anything.
- 3:00:01I do it. I might even give examples, but because of their
- 3:00:05abandonment and betrayal trauma, just me suggesting that in a deep attempt, and
- 3:00:11I might even state it to help them, they will feel that I have
- 3:00:15just completely betrayed them, that I hate this person. I'm throwing them to
- 3:00:22the wolves. I've always hated them, And so the therapy is very delicate.
- 3:00:30You can't just go headlong into what might help without considering how you as
- 3:00:37a therapist, particularly as they bond to you, might trigger them, which
- 3:00:41always happens, And this is why a lot of people with borderline blow out
- 3:00:46of therapy. Even when I do it right, it has happened that a
- 3:00:48borderline client has terminated with me and I never see them again, and it
- 3:00:54breaks my heart because I'm working real hard and I wonder if they'll ever go
- 3:00:58back to therapy because they might be convinced that it was useless, and it's
- 3:01:05a terrible, a terrible result that I do everything in my power to avoid.
- 3:01:09So what I tend to err on the side of caution that until I
- 3:01:15know that I've cleared all the minds in the minefield, I will not head
- 3:01:20into the minefield, meaning I don't even suggest things like that. It might
- 3:01:24take me months, if not years, to even suggest some of the things
- 3:01:28that I'm saying, because it doesn't do any good to present it, you
- 3:01:35know, And so I have to spend the time to build the rapport,
- 3:01:39build the trust, build the relationship, have them really believe in my heart
- 3:01:46that I care about them and that I do not hate them or want to
- 3:01:52abandon them or judge them. And only then can I take a step into
- 3:01:56the minefield and say, you know that story that you told me, I
- 3:02:01don't know, but let's let's add a question mark there. Maybe you're right,
- 3:02:07but let's add a question mark there. And even then, even after
- 3:02:11a very strong relationship, there will still be transference and feelings of abandonment and
- 3:02:16betrayal and criticism. But I will detect that, and I'll have enough relationship
- 3:02:22to be able to detect it, and I'll be able to make up for
- 3:02:26it. You know, justin McKenzie, I didn't see McKenzie. I damn
- 3:02:30sure didn't see Jazz. To me, it sounds like E're fishing. You
- 3:02:33don't even have an explanation for it. If your explanation is Mackenzie told you
- 3:02:37that, then I can hear you out. But you're yeah, he is
- 3:02:41every reason if I understand the situation right to be exasperated. He's been really
- 3:02:48functional and helpful to her up until this point. There's so many other reactions
- 3:02:54that we could imagine. Like I said in earlier, it imagine if Clay
- 3:02:56were in these shoes. I'm not saying that Clay is wrong or something,
- 3:03:01you know, just imagine another person in his shoes how they would react.
- 3:03:05It would just be completely different. And so he's he's hung in there.
- 3:03:09I've seen a lot worse. You know. There are things that if I
- 3:03:13could talk to him, I would suggest if he cared to change. But
- 3:03:18but he's held it together, and now that things are starting to calm down,
- 3:03:22now he has legit things and he might escalate himself. It wouldn't be
- 3:03:28strange if he did if he you know, if he did, and then
- 3:03:31he might make some mistakes. He might actually play right into her hand by
- 3:03:35saying something or doing something that she can point to as like, see,
- 3:03:41you are betraying me, you are lying to me, you are mean to
- 3:03:45me, you're the abusive one. Let's see what happens. Did did Mackenzie
- 3:03:48tell you that? Where'd that come from? What did you do last night?
- 3:03:52When you left? What did you say to me? I'm going out
- 3:03:58and going out? Well, that's not the kind of person I want to
- 3:04:03be with. Maybe they added something out, but I thought she would say,
- 3:04:11you said, I'm going out and I don't care about your feelings.
- 3:04:16I'm going out and I'm gonna have sex with Jess, Like, well,
- 3:04:20yeah, he went out and you didn't want to go, so he went
- 3:04:26for an hour at a birthday thing and then came back home. What was
- 3:04:31he supposed to say, I'm not going out, I'm I'm being sorry.
- 3:04:35It's bad, it's frustrating, I guess. Okay, Well, so I'm
- 3:04:39being triangulated, and probably you are too that when you watch something like this,
- 3:04:45it's normal to get involved, over involved, affected, But we can
- 3:04:50center ourselves. I can differentiate myself and say I'm not there, I'm not
- 3:04:54in that situation. I'm not them. I don't have I don't even I
- 3:04:56don't even have anything at stake, and so I need to regulate my closeness.
- 3:05:03I'll stay in contact, but I won't just lose myself into it and
- 3:05:07start to take it on as if it's personal to me or I'm going through
- 3:05:11it. Stop the sarcasm. If you want to be that kind of you
- 3:05:18don't want to be on me, Anderson, I want to be with The
- 3:05:20only night that I went out that you also didn't go be with your friends
- 3:05:24was last night, and I was going an hour and a half total just
- 3:05:26to make an appearance for a friend's birthday. I don't think that's unreasonable.
- 3:05:30I really don't. And by the way, as a therapist differentiation and counter
- 3:05:35transference management, the system of counterference management has to be robust and well practiced,
- 3:05:43and there has to be a lot of wisdom and experience involved in it,
- 3:05:48and it had frequently, especially as the treatment intensifies, I might spend
- 3:05:54half of my energy just managing my countertransference in session, especially when a client
- 3:06:00is coming after me, which which happens so I have to hold on,
- 3:06:05and I have very much failed at times. There was one time when someone
- 3:06:09was really coming after me, and it was the first foray into borderline symptoms
- 3:06:16that i'd seen. I suspected something was going on, but I hadn't.
- 3:06:22It was in the beginning, like the first few months or something. And
- 3:06:24I held it together and I was fine for the first I don't know,
- 3:06:28twenty minutes, and you know, I did my normal stick. I was
- 3:06:33just like, yeah, I hear you, you know. And so I
- 3:06:35was still with the client and telling myself, this is normal, it's okay.
- 3:06:41I think I'm seeing something here. I don't know the accusations here are
- 3:06:48you know, there's no foundation to it. It's you're You're okay, everything's
- 3:06:52fine. But then the client said this, said this one thing. And
- 3:06:58that's what people sometimes know what to do, because when they were young,
- 3:07:05they were socialized to figure those those points out, you know, and keep
- 3:07:13trying various different things until they till they get that point, because not because
- 3:07:18they're evil, but because they're trying to test the other person to see if
- 3:07:22are you really for real? Do you really not hate me? What if
- 3:07:26I did this to you? Do you still not hate me. What if
- 3:07:28I did this to you, do you still not hate me? And they
- 3:07:31have a lot of hostility, a lot of reasons to be angry and hostile,
- 3:07:35so they're also trying to get you in that way, not all of
- 3:07:37them, but sometimes anyway. So she's doing that to me, and you
- 3:07:41know, I'm managing it, and then all of a sudden, she got
- 3:07:45I don't know what it was, but she got me. And the adrenaline.
- 3:07:50It's just a feeling of danger, of deep, deep danger that's irrational.
- 3:07:56There's nothing, there's no danger, but it feels so dangerous. It's
- 3:08:01so terrifying. And my body just went through the roof. I was dripping
- 3:08:07and sweat and I couldn't think, and I just wanted to run out of
- 3:08:09the room. I mean, it was, it was truly terrifying. So
- 3:08:16that's why Kunter transference management has to be very, very robust. I would
- 3:08:22say that mine was. But I was ill prepared for even the possibility that
- 3:08:28I needed to be on my toes with this client because I hadn't And looking
- 3:08:33back, it's been a long time, but since this particular session, but
- 3:08:39I suspect that I was overworked and hadn't really sat down to think about my
- 3:08:43approach with this client, and hadn't really sat down to think about my conceptualization
- 3:08:48of this client. And although I was probably doing okay work, I just
- 3:08:52hadn't spent the time that would have helped me to be more on my toes.
- 3:08:58In the moment, I'm gonna be honest with you. I don't think
- 3:09:01that's unreasonable. I'm actually I think this conversation is unreasonable. I do too.
- 3:09:05It makes me really, really really question what the fuck I've done.
- 3:09:11Yeah, as I said in an earlier video when she says that it can
- 3:09:18really hurt if you're in his shoes. If we're understanding the situation right,
- 3:09:22he's just like, wait, what, I've dedicated all my time and love
- 3:09:26to you. I've put up with so much stuff. I just went to
- 3:09:31a birthday thing to make an appearance for an hour. I haven't been together
- 3:09:37with Jess. I didn't see my friends who were women. And even if
- 3:09:41I did whatever, And I'm in this because I love you and depend on
- 3:09:48you loving me too, And because of nothing, you now are telling me
- 3:09:56you want to break up with me. His She's the one with her hard
- 3:10:00in her sleeve. He's not. It's tempting to look at him and say
- 3:10:03that he doesn't have a heart, that he is, he doesn't have a
- 3:10:09horse in the race. You know, he's just like blank, But on
- 3:10:13paper he is. He's just as much in this relationship as she is.
- 3:10:18And it, you know, kind of looked that way. I don't know,
- 3:10:22but it looked more and more like he was legit planning on marrying or
- 3:10:26even after the second fight. And to have someone say that, you know,
- 3:10:28in the past, the first fight he would have been pleading, but
- 3:10:31now you could just the weight and the repetition, the chronic names, especially
- 3:10:37in a short period of time. They these three fights I think have taken
- 3:10:41place over the span of maybe maybe like ten days seven days, So every
- 3:10:46other day or every third day, there's something like this for no reason,
- 3:10:52and it can be very hurtful, and you just think, I love you
- 3:10:58all this effort, and and you still reject me. And this is the
- 3:11:03curse of the relational traumas of abandonment and betrayal that create this defense mechanism called
- 3:11:09borderline. Is that they will do the rejecting and then be rejected and think
- 3:11:16that they were rejected when they were doing the rejecting this conversation, I don't
- 3:11:24want to be with someone who's who wants to go out a lot like you
- 3:11:28do. Okay, well, and exactly, Okay, it's all back around,
- 3:11:33and she's saying very similar sentence, and I have a feeling she might
- 3:11:37have said this to previous people. I don't know, but at any rate,
- 3:11:43she is saying, I don't just imagine that that your partner on the
- 3:11:50Okay, fine, if you have a preference, or you get concerned,
- 3:11:54or you know, let's have a conversation. But if your either interire out
- 3:11:56and this is how abusive relationships start. I don't know if that's what's happening
- 3:12:03right now. But if he gives in and says, okay, fine,
- 3:12:07I won't go out anymore, I won't do it anymore, well, that's
- 3:12:09not going to solve her feeling in all likelihoods. So she's going to have
- 3:12:13the same feeling, the same transference, the same recreations, the same projective
- 3:12:18idivocation, and she'll get fixated on another thing, not consciously, but uncle,
- 3:12:24okay, you can't have those friends. And then eventually okay, fine,
- 3:12:28I won't. I won't have any friends that are women, I'll I'll
- 3:12:31stop talking to them, and then there's a little bit of a reprieve,
- 3:12:37and then it's something else, you know. So there's all these tests of
- 3:12:43like, can I get some sacrifice from you, you know, some control
- 3:12:50so that I can feel safe. You're sitting here drunk telling me you don't
- 3:12:52want to be with me anymore. So I don't like sitting here. I
- 3:12:56don't think that makes me feel. Yeah, so he's at least saying that
- 3:13:00she's intoxicated, which I was wondering about. I don't know how intoxicated she
- 3:13:03has. You know, some people can be fairly intoxicated and have no signs.
- 3:13:07But I'm going to take a guest and say that she's not out of
- 3:13:11her mind, that this is representative of how she is normally. I'm willing
- 3:13:15to work through it. But if you're gonna sit here and tell me that
- 3:13:18this is changing how you feel, it changed how I feel too. I
- 3:13:22love you, I'm in this for you, met my family. You don't
- 3:13:26want to be with me anymore? You think that's okay just to say because
- 3:13:28you're emotional? Do you not think that I care about you? You don't?
- 3:13:31You just think I'm like, fool. Yeah, yeah, at least
- 3:13:37from his side, I'm glad he's able to speak his mind and he's I
- 3:13:41mean, there's so many more escalating sort of things he could be saying or
- 3:13:46doing right now, he's being very reasonable. He's in touch with that feeling.
- 3:13:50It's like, do you not think that I love you? What?
- 3:13:56How am I supposed to deal with that? This is pointless if I do
- 3:14:01love you and I put all this effort in it, and you're just like
- 3:14:03no, because I met up with my friends for an hour and you're telling
- 3:14:09me that I can never do that again. Yeah, it seems like it
- 3:14:13might be dawning on him. I don't know, but I wouldn't be surprised
- 3:14:16if she, upon realizing that she truly is losing him, that she convinces
- 3:14:28him to come back. If he is leaving right now, it might happen
- 3:14:33right now, it might happen later or something that. That's the pattern,
- 3:14:37that's the pattern. Well, shit, every time I tell you how I
- 3:14:41feel you, do you know what I've given? Do you think I'm full
- 3:14:43of shit? With everything I've told you? I don't care to be with
- 3:14:45you either. Yeah, makes total sense to me, if this edit is
- 3:14:54representative of what actually happened. The problem is if he says that, although
- 3:15:00it might get to her and she might start to relent, that statement will
- 3:15:05even on its own, live and breathe in her mind for the rest of
- 3:15:11their relationship, potentially until she recovers, if she ever does. And also
- 3:15:16it's likely to be exaggerated. So even if this does work out, a
- 3:15:22week from now, that sentence that he just said will be taken out of
- 3:15:26context and blown up as yet another as and it's factual that he did say
- 3:15:31that. But if the full statement is if if you are going to say
- 3:15:39that, then I don't want to be with you either, even said if
- 3:15:41you're saying you don't want to be with me, then I don't want to
- 3:15:43be with you. Right But a week from now it could be you told
- 3:15:46me you didn't want to be with me, and then it's used as a
- 3:15:50weapon against him to make him feel guilty and to control. All I can
- 3:15:56do is continue to get you to trust that I'll be a good husband.
- 3:16:00But if you're sitting here saying that you don't even trust the things I'm saying
- 3:16:03to you in front of my friends and family, then I don't care to
- 3:16:05be with you either, I give it. Yeah, yeah, I don't
- 3:16:13know the future. I think normally I would think it's over, but I
- 3:16:18think a lot depends on him, and I doubt that. Well, what
- 3:16:24does depend on I think, Well, in a perfect world, they would
- 3:16:31have a couple therapists that would be able to help them with this. And
- 3:16:35he still might leave. She may still might leave, but at least,
- 3:16:41like if I were suddenly just you know, teleported in that room, one
- 3:16:46of the things that I would try to do is introduce some of the things
- 3:16:50I'm saying and see if well, in this state, she's not going to
- 3:16:54be like this. But if I was teleported in the room and then I
- 3:16:58waved a magic wand and they all calm, and it's like therapy wizard.
- 3:17:05I would say to her, you know, explain some of this stuff,
- 3:17:09and I would get her on board with at least some of it, or
- 3:17:13at least understanding it. And then I would say, are you willing to
- 3:17:18work on these things intensely? You don't have to commit to years of therapy,
- 3:17:24but are you willing to start? Here's a therapist, another therapy wizard
- 3:17:30has just emerged, and you can work with that person or me or whatever.
- 3:17:35Well not me, me, me, because I watched this show.
- 3:17:37But anyway, Plus, my practices has been closed for years. I see
- 3:17:43clients, but I haven't had any openings anyway. And for him, I
- 3:17:50would say, are you willing to be an adjunct to this treatment? And
- 3:17:54you're gonna have to make some changes too, and a lot of what you
- 3:17:58need to do is be an assistant to her recovery. Now, maybe you,
- 3:18:05Jimmy, have a whole set of things that just aren't being revealed right
- 3:18:09now that we might discover, but at the real least, what's happening right
- 3:18:11now? Blah blah blah, And that if if they say, yeah,
- 3:18:15we're willing to start, then I would say, then let's do it.
- 3:18:18And if this continues to go as it did today, then I would predict
- 3:18:24that, you know, it'll just be upward and onward. It's not going
- 3:18:28to change quickly, but I'm confident that with time and a lot of effort
- 3:18:33and a lot of bumps in the road, it will slowly get better over
- 3:18:37time. What do you want to do with that? That's what I would
- 3:18:41do, Therapy wizard, we have two weeks to figure out. If we're
- 3:18:46getting married and you're worried about partying, I'm not into it. Yeah,
- 3:18:54she's coming back to that. We have two weeks to figure out for get
- 3:18:58married, and you're you're partying one partying is he two? That's a binary.
- 3:19:05You could have come with him if you weren't tired. You even told
- 3:19:11Mackenzie you didn't want to go because you were tired, aiming, and then
- 3:19:13he's just saying, look I and that's smart and it's the best thing to
- 3:19:20do right now. It's like it's a broken record at this point. It's
- 3:19:22like we keep coming back here and it never ends. So I'm done.
- 3:19:28Yeah, it makes sense. I really don't. So that shows a lot
- 3:19:33about your character. I've done nothing but proud So I don't know. But
- 3:19:35with abusive people, when you start drawing boundaries, they'll find some way to
- 3:19:41attack that. And he is establishing a limit here, a preference of like
- 3:19:50and because if he continued to stay engaged, she would just keep doing the
- 3:19:56loop until she heard what she wanted to hear. But he establishes a limit.
- 3:20:01And so the abusive person, not because they're evil necessarily, but because
- 3:20:05they're threatened. They're terrified. They're they're in tremendous pain, and they're interpreting
- 3:20:11things through a lens that they developed from the very two years old, three
- 3:20:13years old, and so they have to they have to get the person,
- 3:20:18they have to re engage. It's it's classic, and they'll be good at
- 3:20:22it, you know. Through threats, sometimes it can be like okay,
- 3:20:28Vine, I mean if some of you might even heard, you might have
- 3:20:33even heard your abusive partner saying, so, okay, fine, if you're
- 3:20:35not going to engage with me, then I guess we're just gonna head to
- 3:20:37divorce and I'll see you in court. And you know what, I have
- 3:20:41a lot of money and a lot of really powerful friends, and I can
- 3:20:43guarantee you you're not going to have access to your kids. That's a very
- 3:20:46common thing that you'll hear and if you just re engage. You know,
- 3:20:52we saw this with Amaranth the phone call. I don't know what we are
- 3:20:56seeing exactly, but it had that look, right. It is operating from
- 3:21:03You have one person that is operating from rationality and trying to have a conversation
- 3:21:09and the other person it doesn't matter what you're talking about, it's just control.
- 3:21:15It's just trying to make the other person feel bad. It's just trying
- 3:21:18to stay engaged because the loss is too painful. And so he's like,
- 3:21:24Okay, well there's no use talking about this. He's already addressed that issue
- 3:21:28and it's ridiculous on his face. And so, you know, she says,
- 3:21:33she kind of goes for the gusto there. It's like, see,
- 3:21:37that just shows where you're at. And she probably knows that he tries to
- 3:21:43be a good person. And if she, you know, accuses him of
- 3:21:46being a bad person, which is you could argue is kind of what she's
- 3:21:50saying, then it sort of causes him to become engaged again, which did
- 3:21:56work. I'm not into it. I don't care to have this conversation.
- 3:22:01I really don't. So that shows a lot about your character. I've done
- 3:22:05nothing but prove to you where I'm at with you. You don't think that
- 3:22:09I love you. You have showed me. If you don't think I love
- 3:22:13you, I don't want to be here. You don't think I love you.
- 3:22:16I don't know. So now she's relenting a little bit because she sees,
- 3:22:22oh, he actually means business. Right now, I can't say what
- 3:22:26I just said earlier. I mean what she said was it doesn't matter if
- 3:22:33you love me, I don't want to be with you. If you go
- 3:22:35out for an hour to hang out with friends that I don't want to be
- 3:22:41with you. That's what she said. It's not gonna work. Ok.
- 3:22:52Yeah, I would say on the scale of things, he was quite fair.
- 3:22:56I thought he was going to get a lot worse because it would just
- 3:23:01be common for that to happen. So yeah, I mean, what's what's
- 3:23:07he supposed to do? I mean that there's there's things he could have done,
- 3:23:11like just asked for forgiveness or change the subject or just say hey,
- 3:23:20can we hold hands or can we take a twenty minute break? Just please?
- 3:23:24You know, there's there's things he could have done that might have helped,
- 3:23:28but he probably doesn't know that. And it's also maybe a good thing
- 3:23:33that he's finding this out. Honestly, do anything cycle If this was the
- 3:23:52first time, I would say, Okay, she she recentered, she feels
- 3:23:58bad. She he's the one approaching, she's expressing vulnerability. It's very very
- 3:24:05positive, very very positive when you see the pattern, because if this was
- 3:24:11no longer followed by what we have seen three times in the span of a
- 3:24:16week or so. Then okay, But if we see the pattern happen over
- 3:24:22and over again, what is this exactly other than just a point on the
- 3:24:26circle of the pattern. It's just an effort to open back in, not
- 3:24:33volitionally, valitionally. She is trying to get him back, but she doesn't
- 3:24:37set out to abuse. I think she is experiencing so much pain that it
- 3:24:43feels like it's the only it's a desperation. The analogy that I give sometimes
- 3:24:48is you're at a burning building and there's there's smoke everywhere, and the flames
- 3:24:56are coming in at you, and you see a window that's open, and
- 3:25:03you start running, and there's maybe you're at work and there's a couple coworkers
- 3:25:07who are on the ground and you're choking and you're about to pass out.
- 3:25:11You might just blow right past your coworkers and jump out the window without saving
- 3:25:16them, or you might even like step over them, step on them.
- 3:25:20The instinct for survival is strong, right. We wouldn't, I hope,
- 3:25:26fault that person for doing that. They were, in their mind, seconds
- 3:25:33away from dying themselves. There's just an overwhelming sense of self preservator. Now,
- 3:25:37not everyone to do that, but we I don't think we should fault
- 3:25:39someone for doing that in the same way people with these kinds of traumas that
- 3:25:43I'm hypothesizing that she suffers from. That's where they're operating from. It's desperation,
- 3:25:52and their seeming lack of empathy is fueled by just how much tremendous distress
- 3:26:00and pain that they're in. But anyway, so she's she's trying to she's
- 3:26:07suddenly nice. Yeah, and I think it's genuine in the way that it
- 3:26:11can bet he's walking away, she bars his exit, which you could say
- 3:26:22on one side, she's just being compassionate or kind. Looked another way,
- 3:26:30in the whole pattern, it's just the beginning of physical imprisonment. He's trying
- 3:26:35to get away. He has, he has the right to get away.
- 3:26:39Him responding to this, you know, I don't know. I don't know.
- 3:26:41Yeah, I could be just seeing total innocent things. I don't know.
- 3:26:46I'm just saying this as a jumping off point for in all likelihood,
- 3:26:50if anyone is really paying attention to this, their situations were way, way
- 3:26:56worse and more chronic than this. Is that That's all I'm addressing. I'm
- 3:26:58not talking sucking necessarily about these two. Wait, what did you say?
- 3:27:05What do you say you overstepped my boundaries? Okay, yeah, I think
- 3:27:15what he's saying is I have a limit to how much I can take.
- 3:27:20And also for you to say that that's that's too much, that's too hurtful,
- 3:27:30it's too much of a red flag or something, and yeah, unfortunately,
- 3:27:37yeah, unfortunately. Now I want to be clear, if anyone on
- 3:27:43this show deserves grace and love and care, it's her. If I'm reading
- 3:27:48or write, there's a chance that the the small amount of grace and love
- 3:27:56and security that she has received in her life, it's very small. That's
- 3:28:03where all this comes from. Typically, and so she's not a jerk face.
- 3:28:09She's operating from what it feels rational to her. It's a well known
- 3:28:13condition. That's the thing. She isn't the first person to suddenly make these
- 3:28:18behaviors and interpret things like this. It's well interested. Sort of like if
- 3:28:22someone has a I don't know, cancer or something and they have symptoms of
- 3:28:31the cancer, you would say like you're lazy or you're making it. You
- 3:28:33know, It's like it's a human ailment that happens, and this is well
- 3:28:39understood. It's one of the original identifications of personality, dating back to the
- 3:28:45early twentieth century. There have been many that have come before her and many
- 3:28:50that will come after. Unfortunately, she's a common product of a very well
- 3:28:54understood trauma that happens to people, and so if anyone does deserves care,
- 3:29:00it's her. And it just breaks my heart thinking where this is headed.
- 3:29:07It just breaks my heart. You know, we saw that one seen when
- 3:29:09he left the condo or whatever, the townhouse, and that the crying that
- 3:29:16she had it. You know, the depth of the pain is is I
- 3:29:22wouldn't wish it on my worst enemy. Honestly, it's it's it's horrific,
- 3:29:26and I have such empathy for it and such compassion for it, which is
- 3:29:30why I've dedicated so much of my career throughout my career, throughout my life,
- 3:29:35not only specializing and treating people like this, who often get rejected by
- 3:29:41other therapists, by the way, but I also yamor about it and dedicate
- 3:29:46how many episodes to this very conflict, just because I want people to understand,
- 3:29:52and it also informs a lot of other personality. It's because you know,
- 3:29:56the lessons learned here can be a pla to all the personality sorders.
- 3:30:01You could argue any social might not be that one of those, but I'll
- 3:30:05get into that in a deep Dip someday. But there are personality sorders that
- 3:30:09aren't in the DSM, you know, just any all of us have relational
- 3:30:13traumas and defenses from that and will misperceive and it'll fuel emotions that will fuel
- 3:30:20behaviors that will shoot us in the foot. It's universal, but these people
- 3:30:26in particular deserve so much love and so much care. It just breaks my
- 3:30:31heart, just breaks my heart. Now she's in therapy and it sounds like
- 3:30:35things are going well, so that brings a lot of hope, and I'll
- 3:30:41just hold on to that. I guess it's super late right now. My
- 3:30:46voice is gone. The last thing that I'll say, it's sort of an
- 3:30:52asterisk, is that even a good portion of my job as a professor and
- 3:31:00as a supervisor has to do with this as well, because my supervise ees
- 3:31:05will often have a client like this, or someone with narcisstic person I or
- 3:31:09histrionic those three are similar, and my superviss will come across the kind like
- 3:31:16that. And even if I prepare them. There will always be a fairly
- 3:31:24significant amount of distress that the therapist will go through. It can be quite
- 3:31:28a shock, and the natural inclination is to blame the client and reject the
- 3:31:33client, and to have clinical reasons to do so, whether not ready for
- 3:31:37therapy, or they're not respecting my boundaries or whatever. And certainly, if
- 3:31:43a client is being hostile and harmful as a therapist, you have absolutely the
- 3:31:48right and the duty to draw some sort of limit there. But even without
- 3:31:54that, the therapist will just fall into countertransference, which is very compelling,
- 3:32:01and to either reject the client completely or just reject the client emotionally, such
- 3:32:07as the client just doesn't want to come into therapy anymore. And then I
- 3:32:11work side by side with that therapist, guiding them along the way and explaining
- 3:32:20to them that you were kind of a therapist therapist before this client. But
- 3:32:26now comes the real test to see if you really are a therapist, And
- 3:32:31if you can get through this, you'll be a real therapist and you'll be
- 3:32:35so much stronger and so much more wise and so much more able. But
- 3:32:41now's the time to really pay attention to what's happening and your counter transference.
- 3:32:50If you don't pass this test, there's a chance you might become one of
- 3:32:52those therapists that just has no idea how your counter transference causes you to reject
- 3:32:58a client because the client is using projective idemvfication to recreate a relationship in their
- 3:33:03past. That causes you to want to reject the client, and you'd play
- 3:33:07right into that and just further the damage to the to the client instead of
- 3:33:11actually being a real therapist and seeing it for what it is and at the
- 3:33:16very least not rejecting them and at best actually helping a person that needs help.
- 3:33:22You know, I might even say that when you decided to become a
- 3:33:26therapist, you probably thought that you were going to treat people who wanted treatment
- 3:33:30or who were easy to treat, like yourself. You know, a lot
- 3:33:33of people become therapists thinking that all their clients are going to be like them,
- 3:33:37because they really only have experience with one client before they enter graduate school.
- 3:33:43And I say, but real therapists, and I you know, I
- 3:33:48consider this to you know, people could argue with me about this, and
- 3:33:52I wouldn't have a leg to stand on in terms of facts or science.
- 3:33:54But philosophically, the calling to become a therapist is a transcendent spiritual calling.
- 3:34:03It's not just like I'll do this job. It is a calling to help
- 3:34:09truly and to if you can make sacrifices for the greater good of humanity,
- 3:34:18for the greater good of the client sitting across the room, which I believe
- 3:34:24real therapists will do, as my colleagues and I that are real therapists will
- 3:34:30do. It would be so much easier for me to have never treated someone
- 3:34:35with borderline. I would probably make more money. I certainly would have less
- 3:34:39stress. I would not be blamed, no one would sue me, nobody
- 3:34:46would think. No one would even know really, because I would be the
- 3:34:50one. If you know, someone asked me, have you ever turned with
- 3:34:54a client? And I would say, yeah, I turnay with a client
- 3:34:56that last year, And let me tell you. And I could easily come
- 3:34:58up with a very fancy, justifiable reason as to why I terminated with a
- 3:35:03client that actually was presenting in a very typical way as a cluster b person
- 3:35:09I disorder and I just either recognize it and just decided to get rid of
- 3:35:13them, or I had no idea what I was seeing and I just got
- 3:35:16lost in my counter transference. So why would someone do that? You know,
- 3:35:22why would a physician work for doctors without borders and go to a far
- 3:35:28fung place across the planet and volunteer their time or at least work for very
- 3:35:33little money, put themselves potentially in danger to help human beings. It's a
- 3:35:37calling. When I work with my supervises, I say this to them,
- 3:35:45which you might say, well, it's quite a load to put in there
- 3:35:48put on them, And all I can say is, well, they signed
- 3:35:52it to become a therapist. So here it comes. Here comes the client
- 3:35:56that in my view, needs you the most. Are you ready? Do
- 3:36:03you have what it takes to go through the steps to be able to fait.
- 3:36:09It's going to be hard and there might be some sleepless nights, but
- 3:36:13there is solace on the other side of this. You know, there's an
- 3:36:18adjustment period. So do you have what it takes? And I do this
- 3:36:26for many reasons. One I do it for the therapists benefit, because I
- 3:36:35a part of the reason why I could die right now and feel like I
- 3:36:39did not waste my time is because I did that in the past. I
- 3:36:45want to give my therapists that i'm training a chance to have that. Plus
- 3:36:50the people that I work with, I know that they entered the field the
- 3:36:54same reason I did is because they truly felt that calling. And I know
- 3:36:58that if I shepherd them and mentor them and help them and protect them,
- 3:37:03that they will realize their life mission if they manage this. So you know,
- 3:37:13I don't want them to jeopardize their purpose that they identified for themselves.
- 3:37:18Of course, also do this because I want people with borderline and other clusters
- 3:37:22to be personality s orders to be helped not only for their sake, but
- 3:37:28everyone around them, because all those including their own children. By the way,
- 3:37:33because people with personality s orders most of them have kids, and those
- 3:37:37kids are in all likelihood going to have issues if their parents have no way
- 3:37:43of managing things, but with an ability to manage things, particularly with recovery,
- 3:37:52they'll be like any other parent. So I do that for that reason.
- 3:37:58So I dump that load onto my supervise e's and I'm with them.
- 3:38:03I'm not going to fail them if they decide not to. And I've had
- 3:38:07supervisees who have said, as they go through it, so I can't do
- 3:38:09this. I just can't. I just can't. I don't want to be
- 3:38:13Okay, I don't chastise them, but I'm not going to let them off
- 3:38:16the hook because I'm not judging them. I'm going to advocate for them.
- 3:38:22I'm not going to refer clients to them of that sort or anyone even close
- 3:38:26to that sort, because they're saying they don't want that and they can't do
- 3:38:31it. I don't trust them with those kind of clients. But it's their
- 3:38:33choice, and they're the ones that are giving up on their purpose that I
- 3:38:41that they told me that they had. So it's their choice, and I
- 3:38:43know I don't even hold on to that. I might see them at a
- 3:38:48professional conference five years later and it probably doesn't even come up to my brain.
- 3:38:52It's not the primary thing I think of with that supervise e. So
- 3:39:00but I don't say, like, you're still a real therapist, because that's
- 3:39:07not what I believe. I'm adamant about that. To me, it's like
- 3:39:13if an er doctor decides I don't want to work with gunshot victims. It's
- 3:39:18too icky, it's too hard, it makes me feel bad. What No,
- 3:39:28Now, we could argue that if you are like that as a physician,
- 3:39:33then maybe you're a pediatrist and you don't work in the er okay,
- 3:39:37And if you're a therapist, then maybe you work in a particular kind of
- 3:39:41venue that you won't even come across people like that. Now I do talk
- 3:39:46with those supervisors and say, okay, well, now we have to switch
- 3:39:48to something else, which is how do you screen clients who might have this
- 3:39:52disorder? Because it's unethical for you to accept any old client because the percentage
- 3:39:56of them are going to have a cluster be preconise and you won't be able
- 3:40:01to detect it from a phone conversation or over email. So you have to
- 3:40:05have some way of adequately determining those clients who might have this disorder, and
- 3:40:13you have to err on the side of caution. And even if someone has
- 3:40:18minor signs, you have to say, well, given my choice not to
- 3:40:22treat these people and not learn how to treat these people, I have to
- 3:40:26refer them to someone else, even if there's a sixty percent chance that they
- 3:40:31don't have a cluster be. But I can't take that risk because if I
- 3:40:35start with them and nine months in determine that they have a cluster be and
- 3:40:39then refer them out. I'm another abandoner, and I probably won't find out
- 3:40:46until they do attach to me, at which time they start to transfer on
- 3:40:50to me, and then I'll oh, here it is. That's the worst
- 3:40:54time to abandon a client, just because you don't want to treat those things.
- 3:41:01So okay, then you have to screen, and most of the therapist
- 3:41:05anecdotally that do this kind of stuff, they don't screen at all. Really,
- 3:41:11so I consider it to be immoral. It's not really considered to be
- 3:41:18an ethical violation. Generally speaking, it can be, but not usually.
- 3:41:22So I'm passionate about it, and I've been yammering I'm gonna call it quits.
- 3:41:28I do want to actually parallel the footage that we have of Danielle and
- 3:41:37Nick from season two and actually just see I'm personally curious and actually just watch
- 3:41:45like little snippets of their first fight side by side and then their second fight
- 3:41:48side by side, because I keep saying and thinking that there's these parallels that
- 3:41:54really point to this isn't a Chelsea thing, It's not a Danielle thing.
- 3:42:00It's a human thing that happens when you are treated a certain way, when
- 3:42:05you're a child, so I want to kind of line that up, but
- 3:42:11my throat is very in my throat is literally in pain because I've been yammering
- 3:42:18so much and it's late, so until next time. Yeah, I feel
- 3:42:26like I really just yammered and yammered and preached and preached. I'm passionate about
- 3:42:31it. I am. I deeply am, I deeply am, and I
- 3:42:37think it deserves the passion. And take care of yourself because you deserve it,
- 3:42:43you really, really do.