Latest / And Now For Something Completely Machinima / S6 E238 The Art of the Duel (Aug 2026)
Transcript
- Damien Valentine 01:00 Hello, and welcome to another episode of And Now for Something Completely Cinema. I'm Damian Valentine, and I'm joined by Tracy Harwood. Tracy Harwood 01:07 Hello, Damien Valentine 01:08 and Phil Rice. Phil Rice 01:10 Hello, Damien Valentine 01:10 Ricky is absent at the moment. I'm not sure he was too thrilled to hear that Halo is being premade, so he's he's left us. But I'm sure once he recovers from the shock of that, he will rejoin the show in the future. This week we're going to be discussing my film pick of the month, and it's it's a short video called well, it's about creating a fight scene between Anakin Skywalker and Count Dooku, based on cut footage from Revenge of the Sith, but animating it in the style of the Clone Wars animated series. And what you've got here is a video that it does show the completed fight. It's about 30 seconds long at the very end of the clip, and that's it's really well done. But the main reason I chose it was before that he shows this whole process of why he chose that scene, analyzing the footage, animating the characters, and discussing some of the issues he encountered along the way before he finally was able to complete it, and I thought, you know, this is actually really interesting to see the making of it more than the the actual fight scene because it it's it's 30 seconds long, but it feels like it's 10 seconds long because it's so fast and then it's over, and it's just kind of like a middle of a fight scene. So unless you're really familiar with the film, you don't really know what's going on there, and I guess it's not really the point. So I chose it because I really enjoyed this process that he had of making it, and I thought, you know, I'm going to share this because it'll be interesting to see what you two think of Tracy Harwood 03:00 it. It Phil Rice 03:01 was fascinating. Go ahead, Tracy. Tracy Harwood 03:04 Well, I've got lots to say. Do you want to go first? Damien Valentine 03:07 Go first. I'll Phil Rice 03:08 go ahead, Tracy. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely. The the making of is is the the reason to watch this. First of all, it's I found it very clever. So what he did is he he found some footage, I guess some some behind the scenes footage that showed part of the choreography that was intended to be filmed for this fight in the movie that never made it to the final cut. But it's like a behind-the-scenes look of of the the actor and stunt person, you know, doing the moves, and so he used that as the base. It was just a very brilliant hook of for someone who, if someone is like really into Star Wars, this is a chance to see something that was never part of the original. Yeah, there's, there's, it's very smart to to use that as a an attraction. But the making of stuff was so fascinating. I think not just because some of the problems that he ran into are familiar ones, if you've made anything, but then he talks through how he resolved them. You know how, and sometimes it was just a matter of I had to just keep doing it again and again when he was trying to get the faces just right, and Damien Valentine 04:34 yeah, Phil Rice 04:35 he would model the face, and then the way the light played off it exposed these flaws, and so he had to go back to it again, and yeah, these are familiar things. One thing that was really impressive is, and again, it was all you know, the footage was sped up, but even so, his understanding of how to use light well, especially. For this style, was just so so impressive. Like just clearly, some some some study of some kind has gone on there. Even if it was just study, you know, on the internet, but you can see it in the in the thumbnail as as well. That just the the the use of the red and blue contrasting light to highlight different parts of the faces and stuff-it's just wonderfully done. He didn't really talk a whole lot about his thinking behind the lighting, but that was something that jumped out to me visually. If that he really knew how to do that, and the other-I think the other problem-solving approach that he used that was really impressive to me was how towards the end he talks about how he handled the the giving the the blades a swish look as they move through the air. That wouldn't work in a if he was going for like a photo reel type of thing, but in that style it is perfectly appropriate. Like it, that's. I don't know how they do it in the the real show, the animated show, but his technique. There's just no denying that the the the effect is perfect, just wonderful. So, you know, it's it's a little fast to be called a tutorial. It's not a tutorial, but it's one of those videos that you can kind of watch, and he shows you enough visually and with what he's sharing in in his talking that you've got enough to go on. That hey, I want to learn how to do that technique. There's enough there where you can dig deeper if you want to, you know, somewhere else. So, I like that kind of video. It's it's short and sweet and inspirational, you know, to to see not just the outcome. You know, I don't think I would have been inspired particularly by the final product. I don't know why. It just wouldn't have really been impactful on me, but seeing how what he went through to build it and the the obstacles that he overcame, yeah, that's that's it's it's a nice a nice form for a video that that I'm tempted to to find ways to emulate that form of brief intro. Here's what I'm doing, showing that how to, but in very nutshell form, detailed nutshell. It's a weird mix, right? And then here's the finished product. I think the other person that I've seen do that is Ian Hubert. I think his name is the the guy who's really good with Blender, he did a series of, I think he called them his lazy tutorials. Tracy Harwood 07:47 Yes, yes. Phil Rice 07:48 They were very brief, but it's the same concept. If I wanted to do this, and then he narrates his way through it, you're seeing all this stuff happen. His are kind of jokey because inevitably, at some point in this short video, he's going along at a measured pace, and then suddenly he does like 10,000 things in the next three seconds, and so then I just built the rest of the city, and blah blah blah blah, and here's the finished product. So he's doing it with humor in mind. This was a more more serious approach, and not not intentionally designed to lose you, like Ian's are. I love it. Yeah, so I'm glad you shared Tracy Harwood 08:27 it. Yeah, Damien Valentine 08:28 Tracy. Before we begin, I will just say that if it had just been the 30 second clip, I would probably watched it, enjoyed it, but I wouldn't have shared it through reviews. Tracy Harwood 08:36 Interesting. Well, yeah, because I went through the same thought process as both of you guys. Really, I mean, I got fair bit to say about this as well. Naturally, done a bit of digging and all the rest of it. I probably would have preferred these two things as being separated out, actually. But I agree for for for the purposes of us reviewing it, it had to be it has to be together, doesn't it? But I will come back to that because I think, like like Phil and and like you, Damian, I would not have given this much of a second thought. I don't think, but I'll probably come back to that again later on. I think one of the things I really enjoyed about the film is that it's it's evident that you're you know it's it's a bit more than a Star Wars fan animation that we're looking at. It's it's most definitely a creator that has you know he understands a lot about film criticism and how it's expressed through animation. I think this guy knows a lot about filmmaking. Actually, I think the starting point is really fascinating, and I had a look at the the whole of the the cut film. That you know the the Nick Gillard original choreography. I watch the whole thing, and I'm you know it's it's a really impressive thing to even think about having a go at trying to animate that, and then rather than recreating the entire deleted sequence, what he's doing clearly is just focusing on a section of it, not not the whole thing, because I can't imagine how difficult that would have been actually. So instead of trying to reproduce it frame by frame, I think what this guy is doing really well is he's recognizing that there are some some very fundamental things going on that he needs to address, and the choreography from the live action just simply doesn't work in the Clone Wars visual style, as is the very first point that he makes, which I think is really interesting because it's that it's at that point that he says that I think, oh, okay, now I'm going to have to listen to what he's saying in a lot more detail than perhaps I would have done if he was just saying, "Right, I did it like this. I did it like that. So, what he's he's saying then is, I I couldn't simply copy the choreography directly. Instead, I've got to interpret it, or reinterpret Phil Rice 11:24 it. Yeah, that was a key moment. I think. Tracy Harwood 11:25 Yeah, exactly. Which that's the point. As I said, that's the point. I sort of sat up and started to think, okay, we're not looking at just another Star Warsy type thing here. Then, I mean, most fan films really are concerned with accuracy, and they they're basically asking things like, "Can I recreate Star Wars? Well, this isn't asking that at all. It's more about how how do I translate Star Wars into a completely different artistic language whilst preserving what makes it emotionally powerful. Doing it that's that's the essence of what he's doing here. Entirely different approach. Converting, Phil Rice 12:05 if not enhancing, Tracy Harwood 12:07 exactly. I'm Phil Rice 12:07 thinking specifically of the sword cross that he put in there. There's a Tracy Harwood 12:12 lot. There's a lot going on that's just not a straight copying and and and you know recreating the the choreography at all. He's he's really elevating the work beyond that, and it's super interesting. I think it's it's kind of funny actually because it's the second film this month that we've looked at that's taken that exact same approach to creating something through the lens of a different medium, and even if we think about what Ricky's first pick was as well, the Fixer was doing something the same as well. So it's really interesting that we've got all this selection of films that are looking at one thing and and you know looking at it through the lens of another thing. This is exactly in that in that model, I think. So comparison between Revenge of the Sith and the Clone Wars is one of the kind of the strongest parts of what he's trying to do. Nick Gillard's lightsaber choreography is really fast. It's kind of fluid, and you know, it's almost kind of continuous. The actors are are fencing at this just extraordinary speed, and these movements are flowing one into the other. I can't imagine how difficult that was to act it, let alone try and then animate it. I mean, the the Clone Wars was deliberately. I mean, the the you know the the the movements are. You know, what he's trying to do is sort of pull them apart a little. He's trying to sort of, and he's trying to sort of anticipate or present the anticipation of the attacks more strongly. He's trying to sort of create the silhouettes as as being more exaggerated and follow, and those sort of follow through poses are being held for a little bit longer than they were in the in in the Gillard's version of it, making making sort of quite clear that there's a strike and a you know and a fight taking place, and and I guess from an audience point of view, that makes it easier for us to sort of see it and read it because somehow we can inherently read it when it's people, but it's harder when you're looking at it just as animation. And I think I think that's the clever bit in what he's doing. Really, I think animation kind of always relies on principles like anticipation and sort of staging and silhouette. So rather than kind of forcing live action choreography into animation, he's basically creating this kind of hybrid, and he's he's sort of combining the choreography with the kind of visual grammar of the Clone Wars to produce something that feels kind of a. Authentic to both. I think that's that's a really clever thing that he's tried to do here, and I think he's done it really well. Actually, there's an awful lot of sort of thought that's gone into the storytelling. I mean, that as you said, Palpatine, for example, instead of beginning with a wide establishing shot, he's kind of immediately on a close-up of Palpatine's face, and he's then you know the camera sort of slowly moving around him as he's kind of watching the duel. That's an interesting strategy because it immediately tells us that there's something important about what we're looking at. He's not just this character is not just watching events unfold, just by the way he's looking or seem to be looking at the two characters fighting, and and he's the way that he's been orchestrated into that scene. It's very evident that there is a a control sense of control being portrayed in that character, and just in that one shot alone, he's captured that sort of essence and that depth. I think that kind of it it echoes perfectly what McDermott's performance was trying to portray in in Palpatine, where evidently that character very rarely needed to actually fight, as I understand it. I think everyone else believes they're making choices while he's quietly directing events from the shadows. But to have caught that in the animation, very interesting. I think towards the end, the creator deliberately mirrors the final kind of lightsaber clash with Skywalker and Vader, sort of locking sabers in front of the Emperor. Tracy Harwood 16:52 But I think he's tapping directly there into George Lucas's favorite storytelling ideas, which is kind of visual rhyming. I mean, as I understand it, Lucas often describes Star Wars as a saga built around these kind of repeated visual thematic patterns. You know, Anakin's journey echoes Luke's. The throne room in Return of the Jedi echoes the Chancellor's office in the you know in the invisible hand in in Revenge of the Sith, and these kind of Phil Rice 17:23 Vader loses a hand, Luke loses a hand. Tracy Harwood 17:26 Yeah, this kind of Phil Rice 17:27 sometimes very very Tracy Harwood 17:28 deliberate sort of, you know, they they face similar moral choices in different circumstances, and those patterns are repeated again and again. I think that's a very interesting thing, and and here what you've got is the creator recognizing exactly that as he kind of points out in both scenes. Palpatine is watching the same story unfold. Got a young Jedi gradually giving into aggression while he's quietly manipulating events in the background, and it kind of transforms the created, recreated composition from simple fan service, I guess, into visual story to telling rooted in the mythology of the Star Wars itself. Now, the character animation, I think, is handled just as thoughtfully. Anakin is introduced by sort of leaping into the frame, and his camera movement is energetic and kind of unpredictable, and he's always kind of leaning forward and pressing into the attack. And that's that's kind of you know even that brief smile before the duel accelerates that kind of suggestion that he's going to enjoy the fight. You can kind of see see that in the in these characters, it's it's it's really fascinating to sort of watch how he's done it, and then in contrast, you've got this Duco character or Duku Duku Duco Dooku. I mean, his movement is controlled, it's measured, it's elegant, and it and the inclusion of this kind of signature salute immediately kind of establishes his personality before a single blow is kind of exchanged, and you know the silhouettes you've got that he's you know it's done so well it's designed to kind of combine Christopher Lee's live action with the look of you know the the tales of the Jedi, and it's done it so stylistically. It's very clever. It's really very clever. I I think none of the decisions that you see are kind of accidental. They're all examples of this guy's craft in using movement to communicate character rather than simply animate action, so for me technically the project is really impressive. The you know he discusses rebuilding the character sculpts you know multiple times as you said for refining light to separate the characters from the background, which I think is. A very interesting approach. I think there's a lot of craft in that. You also pointed that one out. I think as well, Phil. I think he's introducing volumetric lighting to kind of increase the depth and even creating this kind of procedural lightsaber arc system in Blender, rather than kind of just animating a motion trail by hand. I can't imagine how challenging that would have been to even attempt to to do it that way. It's the obvious kind of way to do it, but but it's that kind of thing that makes me think this guy's got a lot of skill behind what he's what he's doing. He's got a a workflow approach to this that is is basically what I would consider to be professional animation, rather than just somebody coming at this cold, so to speak. I think it's what makes this especially relevant for machinima and virtual filmmaking. Is is basically these demonstrating how accessible these digital tools are now, but I think you have to have the craft in there as well to sort of exploit the the tools. And I think you know something like this really shows you that having some of the craft makes the the decisions that you're making a little bit more, you know. There's more depth to it than just sort of picking something that you're going to copy. For example, I think you know, compared with many modern Star Wars films, which often just sort of, I guess, focus on the, you know, the sparkle and the spectacle of what ILM were were doing. I think this project feels much more interested in trying to get underneath the skin of the the film and and try and understand the language through which it's it's it's portrayed. That's a depth of stuff that we don't see all that often. Actually, I think it's what makes this piece quite compelling. It's it's it's an exploration of adaptation and visual storytelling and and kind of cinematic language, and it demonstrates that great fan filmmaking isn't about reproducing every frame perfectly. It's about understanding the creative decisions and then trying to find a way to express them, and I think there's a lot of thought that's gone into that. Tracy Harwood 22:25 So back to then my first comment on why present this as a how-to and then a film. I guess a final question I had to think about when I was reflecting on it really is why you know if they'd have been separated, would I have appreciated all the detail that's gone into the making of it? And I don't think the answer to that is yes by any means, because I just don't think I would have taken in the the depth of the craft that this guy has shown in in in making it, I would certainly have appreciated the detail and the editing, but not the decision making as it's been explained. This is not a how to in the way that you know you see a lot of these tutorials put on. I don't I don't see it in the same way as the Ian Huber example, even this is this is a you know there's there's more to this than than it's a it's it's not a traditional how to for me. I think part of that is because I don't really have all the insight into Star Wars and the and the canon that sort of sits behind it. That lots will have that that will sit and watch this. But I think mainly it's because because of the animation craft that it's embodying. I mean, it's a little bit like when I showed you the Live Fire Fens demo ran where she'd adapted the demo man and turned it into the ram, and I later gave you a link to her creative process, but you only saw the film. Now, that's not actually a criticism here, because in fact, I think it's probably the biggest compliment you can play and pay the filmmaker. Actually, if you just shown me the final animation, I'd have come away thinking, "Yeah, that's that's fantastic. It's a great recreation of the of the of the you know the choreography of the fight. It feels really polished. The choreography has real weight to it. The lighting is beautiful, and it all feels remarkably authentic. And I. I'd I'd absolutely recognize the the high quality of the of the work, but I wouldn't have recognized why it was high quality, because without that explanation, I just wouldn't have known almost, you know, that every movement has. Redesigned, for example, I probably would have just assumed he'd have copied and deleted bits of the choreography. Yeah, I just wouldn't have got it. I wouldn't have had any idea that Anakin's face had been rebuilt again and again, or that Duco's you know face had been kind of blended in the way that it has. Even a lot of the technical work that that I've just sort of commented on, it's just hidden. It's it's one of those situations really where the better the work, the less you notice. You know, you notice what's been done? I think there are a few things I think experienced animators and filmmakers might have picked up on. You guys have clearly done that. You can feel that the combat has kind of anticipation, and the choreography feels slightly more readable than than a live action version, but even then, I don't think most people would identify why it feels so different without that sort of making of, which really highlights the craftsmanship that's gone gone behind it. But what it reminded me of is actually it's a little bit like practice-based research. If you're familiar with research through practice, the final animation is almost like the creative artifact, while the making of it is the kind of exegesis of it. If you like, the artifact demonstrates the solution, but the exegesis kind of explains the question, the methodology, the kind of countless decisions that led to it. And without that context, you'd never fully appreciate the originality of the work. So perhaps the greatest irony here is that the film succeeds almost too well. The adaptation is so seamless that most viewers will simply accept it as as kind of natural. They won't notice the hundreds of creative decisions that make the work what it is. Tracy Harwood 27:14 I think that sort of final 30 seconds just looks completely effortless, but only because the first six minutes reveal just how much thinking and experimentation and craftsmanship has actually gone into it. But fundamentally, they've just disappeared underneath the surface of it. So for me, it's a really great pick. It's a real provocation, I think, for our for our comments. Yeah, I really enjoyed having a think about what what was going on here, and yeah, I I would not have watched it as the 30 seconds. Yeah, and Phil Rice 27:59 the thing is, is that 32nd clip without context because it doesn't have any narrative context unless you happen to be in the mindset and know where to place Tracy Harwood 28:14 it Phil Rice 28:15 in the sequence of the film, and that doesn't come naturally. Like a student of Star Wars might do that, but most people will just be okay. This is a clip, a 32nd clip like that. That's something that would be in someone's art station profile. Tracy Harwood 28:30 Yeah, Phil Rice 28:30 because then the profile is the context. This is stuff I've made, and so it's little pieces. And sometimes those are just screenshots and they're 32nd clips or whatever. And that's what the finished product is. So rather than, like you said, recreate the whole scene to give it the context of narrative. Maybe we're looking at this wrong. Like he refers to the 30 seconds there as the finished product, but I think that the the finished product is. I think the whole reason for posting it on YouTube is for that intro part. That wasn't there. That wasn't there to justify. Tracy Harwood 29:07 Yeah, Phil Rice 29:08 the 32nd clip. The 32nd clip is there to justify Tracy Harwood 29:11 the six minutes. Phil Rice 29:12 What he really wanted to talk about. Tracy Harwood 29:14 Yeah, I agree. Phil Rice 29:15 And you're right too that it differs substantially from Ian's in a few regards, but the key one is Ian never ever talks about why. Tracy Harwood 29:26 Yeah, Phil Rice 29:27 he doesn't explain his decisions really. He explains the how to, and he might explain how in a technical capacity only. But that's not the theme of his videos. But this was less about the tech and more about why I chose to do this, or here's the problem, and here's why. Here's why the animation, when brought over from live action, wasn't working. He didn't just notice it; he identified what specifically about it was making it lack it. Energy and then how do I add energy to it? And so he changed the the transition curves, which anyone who's worked with animations in iClone know that's a tool that's right there. It's maybe underused, right? But you know, a sword swing that's just a straight linear motion is much different than than that, you know. And that's all transition curves. That's part of Blender. That's part of any animation platform. So that was the tech. But the most interesting part about that wasn't transition curves. You don't have to understand transition curves to see what he was saying there. So that is brilliantly presented for an audience that didn't need to really understand Star Wars, like you do not need to have a fascination with Star Wars to appreciate this video, and you don't have to have a background in animation to appreciate this either, because he explains enough of it. You know, we understand things like energy of motion. You don't need to know iClone or Blender or anything to get that. You know, so Tracy Harwood 31:06 yeah. Phil Rice 31:07 And we understand how you know light affects. We understand the the psychological effect of showing that Dooku's salute. You don't need to know anything about tech or Star Wars to appreciate that, you know, as a Star Wars fan, as someone you know, if you know Star Wars or you know about George, then you really appreciate it because you know that he based these Jedi. One of the sources of inspiration was knights and samurai. You know, like these. That's that's why people who criticize the original lightsaber battle between Darth Vader and Kenobi in A New Hope in the first Star Wars movie, they criticize it compared to today's very acrobatic, you know, Jedi battles, and say that it lacked lacked energy, but that wasn't what that battle was about. This was two old warriors facing off in this ritualistic combat, and it didn't need to have backflips and stuff, you know. So Tracy Harwood 32:14 yeah, yeah. Phil Rice 32:15 Anyway, I've seen someone actually recreate the the Darth Vader and Kenobi thing in in CGI and added. I've Damien Valentine 32:22 seen that too. Phil Rice 32:23 Yeah, and it's neat looking and stuff. But I've heard someone make the case. I can't remember who it was that first made the case in the video, but they they talked about the you know to to to say that that you know battle is lacking because it doesn't have acrobatics, is completely missing the point. Tracy Harwood 32:44 Absolutely, what Phil Rice 32:45 these face-offs are. These are two characters with history, and there's a ritual, and there's a somberness, and you know. So yeah, and this guy understands all of that, I think, and works those things in. I think he did a better job of rhyming some of the ideas about this scene than the original movie did. Tracy Harwood 33:05 Yes, that that Phil Rice 33:06 crossing sabers thing. That's such an iconic scene from Return of the Jedi, and his his instinct to put that in there. To me, in the movie, this face off between these two, I was obsessed with other details and never really made a giant connection between it. I saw okay, so it's kind of somewhat analogous, you know. But in Return of the Jedi, it's father and son. There's that dynamic, and you never really, you never really feel like Luke has been headed to the dark side. He may be teetering a bit, but he's-you don't feel like he's that he's really going to go there. He just got finished telling his father, "I still believe that you can be saved. When they're in the elevator, you know, so you don't expect Luke to to fully go dark, Anakin. By this point, we've seen him do a lot of, lot of stuff that that makes you think he's not on the right path at all. You know, so I got hung up on that. And then, if I'm not mistaken, Damian isn't Palpatine, isn't he strapped into that chair still? He's like a yeah, Damien Valentine 34:20 some kind of binder holding his wrists in place. Right Phil Rice 34:23 now, we all know that he could have just gotten out of that real quick, and he was deliberately staying there. But all of those things kind of distracted me, and so I didn't really get the rhyme like I do now, having seen this little clip. So it's very, very Effective, Damien Valentine 34:42 yeah, yeah. There's some things in it like he was talking about how taking the live action footage and just doing it directly wouldn't work, and I was thinking, yeah, I've I've had some experience with that. If those actors in the clip had motion capture suits on, and they recorded that data when they were filming. That scene originally, and then you try to bring it into any kind of animation software, it would look really stupid. Like he's trying like that, and they're doing like that, but much faster than I can. It would look like that, and probably worse, because even though the character models are designed to have a fairly human skeleton and move like humans. They don't, and I can't explain it because I don't necessarily have the right technical knowledge to explain it correctly. But if you ever try doing anything like that, you know what I'm talking about. Like the characters, just talking about the way the bones work on the digital characters just don't quite mimic human characters, and you'll get things like the lightsaber will go through the heads, and they'll do that, or something like that. And it's not just because it's wrong; it's just something about the way the data will translate. And so, the way he changes this and adapts, uses some of the Clone Wars style animation. He makes you think. So that's why they changed it for the animation when they're doing the animated series. You you get that appreciation of why thing the animation show isn't quite like the live action stuff in ways you might not necessarily thought about until someone like this comes along and explains why they didn't do Phil Rice 36:17 it. I think some of that is analogous too to the the when actors perform on a theatrical stage versus on camera, motion is handled in a different way. You have to do things differently and bigger in theater. It's it's it's a similar type of thing that there's something about the the animated platform that needs more motion than, and I don't know how to fully explain it either. It is part of it is the limitation of the way that the the joints or the ligaments, so to speak, work with these models, but also it just there's something about the animated look, that yeah, those unnatural amplifications to movement really increase the energy. And I don't know how much of that is just because that's the way it's been done for so long in anime and other things like that. Is that just that we're visually primed to expect that, or you got to figure they must have done it for a reason too? You know, so yeah, it's it's it's interesting to think about. Damien Valentine 37:30 Well, I'm glad you both enjoyed it, and yeah, I think the point of it was not those 30 seconds at the end. It was the whole. There's lots of videos out there. Someone will set out to make something, and the whole point of the video is to show them making it. They don't necessarily go step by step, but they're showing the progress, and they'll talk about whatever they're making, and then they'll show the final result at the end. And the final result is just was this how what I ended up with, but it's more about the part. The it's the journey is more important than the destination, Phil Rice 38:04 and you have to think he must have thought of that before starting out because unless he's just someone who films everything he does, you know, just records his screen all the time and after the fact goes, I should tell people how I did this. This was interesting. No, he probably thought about it ahead of time, which is great. Damien Valentine 38:21 All right, so that wraps up this week's video. If you've got any comments on this video, Star Wars or adapting footage for animation or anything of these things that we've been discussing, please send us an email at talk@completemachinera.com. For now, goodbye from me and from Phil And Tracy, Tracy Harwood 38:41 goodbye. Speaker 1 38:42 Hello, Damien Valentine 38:42 see you next week.