Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Gifts With Purpose: Decoding the Types of Testamentary Gifts and Their Consequences
Transcript
- 0:02Welcome to Gifts with Purpose, Decoding the Types
- 0:06of Testamentary Gifts and their Consequences.
- 0:09We are thrilled to have you join us today. My
- 0:12name is Jacqueline Yu and I'm a co -chair of
- 0:15the Beverly Hills Bar Association's Trust and
- 0:17Estates Law Section. Before we begin, I'd like
- 0:21to take a moment to thank our sponsors. Bond
- 0:24Services of California, Liberty Mutual Surety,
- 0:28California Title Company, Pickford Escrow Company,
- 0:31and the Sanborn team. Now onto the program. We
- 0:35are delighted to welcome Mark Stern and Julia
- 0:38Hay as the speakers for today's presentation.
- 0:41Mark Stern is a partner at Greenberg Gloucester
- 0:43LLP. Mark's practice focuses on representing
- 0:46individuals in connection with the retention
- 0:49and disposition of their wealth, including estate
- 0:52planning, transfer tax planning and premarital
- 0:55agreements, and in connection with obtaining
- 0:58benefits left to them by others, including estate
- 1:00and trust administration and probate litigation.
- 1:05Julia Hay is a partner at Greenberg -Lusker LLP.
- 1:07Julia's litigation experience includes high net
- 1:11worth disputes, high asset divorce proceedings,
- 1:14and probate litigation. Her entertainment practice
- 1:16includes successfully resolving at trial, in
- 1:20arbitration, complex business disputes involving
- 1:23profit participation, motion picture production
- 1:26and distribution, rights ownership, copyright
- 1:29and trademark infringement, idea submission,
- 1:32and other entertainment related conflicts and
- 1:34contractual disputes. We can't wait to see what
- 1:37they have to share with us today. Mark and Julia,
- 1:40the floor is yours. Thank you, Jacqueline. The
- 1:47program today is going to talk about the different
- 1:50types of gifts that exist and the consequence
- 1:52of those gifts, the different types of gifts.
- 1:56We don't know where you fit in. the spectrum
- 1:59as an attendee, whether you're a draftsperson.
- 2:03We hope that what we have to share will be helpful
- 2:06for the draftsperson, also for the person who's
- 2:10on the administration side. If you are given
- 2:15a trust or you're dealing with a trust following
- 2:18somebody's death, you need to know and understand
- 2:21the rules and who's going to get what. Obviously,
- 2:25what the draft side It affects that. If you have
- 2:30questions today, we will do our best to answer
- 2:33them. If you want to just put them in the question
- 2:38screen at the bottom of the Zoom. And if we're
- 2:43not able to get something during the program.
- 2:46then we will circle back and try to get to it
- 2:49at the end of the program. Without further ado,
- 2:53Julia is going to start and talk about the different
- 2:56types of gifts that are out there. Thank you
- 3:00everyone for joining us today. We'd like to start
- 3:02off by going over these six different categories
- 3:06of testamentary gifts, which are specific, general,
- 3:11demonstrative, pecuniary, annuity, and residue.
- 3:15We'll go through each of those. Specific gifts.
- 3:21A specific gift is a transfer of specifically
- 3:24identifiable property. So, for example, a ring,
- 3:28a painting, a car, a piece of real property or
- 3:32an interest in a company or an LLC. You're transferring
- 3:35specific rights and some very straightforward
- 3:38examples. I give my diamond ring to Kelly or
- 3:42I give my home at 123 Main Street to the trustee
- 3:46of the home trust. Another example, I give my
- 3:50membership interest in HackMeWidget LLC to Fran.
- 3:55So the key here is just making sure it's a very
- 3:58specific gift. Now, by contrast, a general gift
- 4:01is a transfer from general assets of the transfer
- 4:06that was not given as a specific gift. For example,
- 4:10instead of saying, I give my diamond ring to
- 4:12Kelly, it would be, I give one of my rings to
- 4:14Kelly, but it would not be a specifically identified
- 4:17Ring. Next slide, please. Due to the unspecific
- 4:22nature of general gifts, we would always try
- 4:26to avoid those and try to make a specific gift
- 4:28if possible. The next category, a very common
- 4:33category of gifts, is a pecuniary gift. And a
- 4:36pecuniary gift is a specified gift of money.
- 4:42For example, I give $10 ,000 to Kelly, I give
- 4:49$50 ,000 to each of my grandchildren. Or for
- 4:55example, I give the maximum amount that I can
- 4:57leave free of tax to a specific beneficiary or
- 5:01trust. Here, the key is it has to be a fixed
- 5:04dollar amount or a dollar amount that is determinable
- 5:07by the provisions of the trust or the instrument,
- 5:11the estate instrument. It can also be, another
- 5:16example, I give Blake an amount equal to the
- 5:19value of the ACME widget LLC memberships that
- 5:23were given to Fran. So again, a money gift that
- 5:26is specifically identifiable. So going to the
- 5:31next category would be an annuity. Now, an annuity
- 5:36is a pecuniary gift that is payable. periodically
- 5:40over time. Some examples, you know, Kelly shall
- 5:44receive an annuity of $10 ,000 for a period of
- 5:47five years after my death. Another example, you
- 5:50know, Fran shall receive monthly payments of
- 5:53$5 ,000 during their lifetime. So once again,
- 6:00there has to be a fund from which the annuity
- 6:03is paid and it has to be done over a period of
- 6:07time. So and then the next category is a residue
- 6:15gift, which is the remainder. It's a transfer
- 6:21property that remains after all specific and
- 6:24general gifts have been satisfied. So it's effectively
- 6:26the remainder of the estate. So for example,
- 6:29I give the residue of my estate to Kelly or You
- 6:33can also divide that between different beneficiaries.
- 6:36I give the residue of my estate 40 % to Kelly
- 6:39and 60 % to Fran. Another example, I give it
- 6:45to all of your children by right of representation.
- 6:49I give the residue of my estate to my issue who
- 6:54survived me by right of representation, which
- 6:56would then pass to their... children as well.
- 7:00And then I give the residue of my estate to the
- 7:02marital trust. So again, it's the leftovers and
- 7:05you're choosing where the remainder will go.
- 7:11Okay. So now, you know, that's a general overview
- 7:15of the types of gifts. But what does the recipient
- 7:22actually receive from each of those gifts? So
- 7:25if it's a specific gift, the recipient will receive
- 7:29the specifically identified and gifted asset.
- 7:34If, for example, there is a mortgage encumbering
- 7:37the asset, they also will take on that asset
- 7:41with the mortgage encumbering the asset, even
- 7:43if there is a general clause in the will to pay
- 7:45all debts. They also will receive the net income
- 7:49from the assets starting from the date of death.
- 7:58Now, the question here is about expenses. If
- 8:01there's expenses, including property taxes and
- 8:05income that exceed the income, then the net expense
- 8:10is borne by the state for that. that first year.
- 8:15So as Mark and I have said before, it's kind
- 8:17of like the first year free examples. So if there's
- 8:23expenses that are incurred, they're borne by
- 8:26the state for the first year until the first
- 8:29anniversary of the testator's death or until
- 8:32there's been a distribution of the property to
- 8:34the beneficiary or the beneficiary takes position
- 8:37of the property. So that is essentially a way
- 8:42to keep the expenses with the estate until one
- 8:46of those three events occurs, or the beneficiary
- 8:50in some instances can avoid incurring those expenses
- 8:53for that first year. Again, the allocation of
- 8:57expenses is based on when they accrue, not when
- 8:59they are paid. In this instance, the same rules
- 9:02apply both to states and to trusts under the
- 9:06probate code. I believe Mark has some specific
- 9:11examples. So going back to the last slide for
- 9:14just a second, one of the important things that
- 9:18Julia said is that by holding the property in
- 9:22the estate for the first year, the estate will
- 9:25pick them up, the expenses, if the expenses exceed
- 9:28the income. Whereas if it's distributed out,
- 9:31then the expenses get shifted over to the beneficiary.
- 9:35And so there may be either some tension or some
- 9:38opportunity to shift or have one versus the other
- 9:42pay by deferring the distribution. If you just
- 9:47make the distribution two months after the date
- 9:49of death, then the beneficiary will pick up those
- 9:51expenses attributable to that property after.
- 9:55the distribution rather than having the estate
- 9:57pay for it for the first year. Going to the next
- 10:00slide, it is not, we all in elementary school
- 10:05learned that addition was associative. That means
- 10:10that you can either do two plus four and then
- 10:13add three, or you can do four plus three and
- 10:16then add two. It doesn't matter the order in
- 10:18which you do it, it's the same. That's not the
- 10:21case here. There's an example. one, the property,
- 10:27this is now the specific gift, generates income
- 10:31of 100 and has an expense of 60, then in the
- 10:35first example, the beneficiary will receive $40
- 10:40on account of that added income. And in year
- 10:43two, when it's not the estate paying because
- 10:46it's charged to the beneficiary after the first
- 10:49year, those are reversed. The beneficiary will
- 10:52be charged the negative 40, so the net is the
- 10:56beneficiary will end up with zero, and the estate
- 10:59will end up with zero of income because again,
- 11:02they offset the 40 overage and the 40 shortfall.
- 11:05If instead you switch it so that the first year
- 11:09there is net income of 40, then the second year,
- 11:14there is, excuse me, I said it backwards. In
- 11:18the first year, there is a loss of 40. There's
- 11:22expenses in excess of income of 40. Then the
- 11:25estate will pick up that 40. And in the second
- 11:27year, you have net income of 40, the beneficiary
- 11:31will receive that. In this second hypothetical,
- 11:34because of the timing and the way it occurs,
- 11:36the two do not offset, and the estate pays the
- 11:4040, the beneficiary receives 40, and there's
- 11:42a net of 80 difference there, whereas in the
- 11:46first, they offset. So again, you can get radically
- 11:49different results, and you have to actually look
- 11:51and see what happens during each period. As Julia
- 11:55said, it's when they accrue not when they're
- 11:58paid. So you can't shift this by simply refusing
- 12:01or delaying payment. Next slide. Now, in a situation
- 12:09where a specifically gifted asset is sold by
- 12:11the estate, the beneficiary receives the proceeds
- 12:15from the sale plus interest on the net proceeds
- 12:17beginning on the first anniversary of the testator's
- 12:21death. So again, there's that year gap, and any
- 12:23interest on those proceeds would stay with the
- 12:26estate for that first year, and then after that
- 12:28first year, the interest would then go to the
- 12:31beneficiary. that it's not the net proceeds just
- 12:36as they morph, it's the interest on the net proceeds.
- 12:39And we'll talk about that later. My guess is
- 12:42that today most accounts aren't generating sufficient
- 12:46interest income to offset the interest that is
- 12:50payable to the beneficiary. OK. And now we have
- 12:56a specific example. that Mark will share with
- 13:00us. I actually was faced with this recently in
- 13:05the last several months. The individual died
- 13:07in September of last year and had a home in Pacific
- 13:10Palisades. They left it to Charity C. The home,
- 13:15like many properties in the Palisades, burnt
- 13:17down in January. In March, the trustee because
- 13:23again, these rules apply both equally to trusts
- 13:25and estates. The trustee said, we'd like to distribute
- 13:28this property to you for X, Y, and Z reasons.
- 13:33And the charity contacted me and I said, no,
- 13:36I don't think that that benefits you. If the
- 13:39property continues to be held by the... trust,
- 13:43then the trust will need to pay the expenses
- 13:46through September of 2025, which include property
- 13:49taxes and insurance. Yes, maybe there's no insurance
- 13:53for a dwelling, but there's still liability insurance
- 13:55for the property. And so the estate will pick
- 13:58all those up if... the property is retained by
- 14:02the trust estate through September, and I don't
- 14:05see any benefit charity to getting the property
- 14:09early, specifically in this case, because there's
- 14:12a lot of vacant lots in the Palisades, and it's
- 14:17not like there's any opportunity to quickly sell
- 14:20it. The supply is munching in excess of demand
- 14:25in the Palisades right now. So on balance, the
- 14:28charity said, no, it's not worth it. We'll consider
- 14:32taking this in September when we don't have to
- 14:35pick up the expenses and we can push off more
- 14:38of the expenses to the trust for a greater longer
- 14:41period of time. And then going to the next slide,
- 14:45another example with a specific gift. A specific
- 14:49gift is a gift of securities. That would also
- 14:52include securities received from stock splits,
- 14:55acquisitions, reorganizations, or reinvestment
- 14:59plans. However, it would not include pre -death
- 15:05cash dividends. Those would not go to the beneficiary.
- 15:11And then Yes, we can go to the next slide. Okay.
- 15:17Now, if a specifically gifted asset was sold
- 15:19during the testator's lifetime, the beneficiary
- 15:22is entitled to receive any unpaid portion of
- 15:25the purchase price and any security for that
- 15:28obligation, any unpaid eminent domain award,
- 15:31and any unpaid fire or casualty insurance for
- 15:34recovery or injury to property. Then some more
- 15:41examples. If a specifically gifted asset was
- 15:44sold during the testator's lifetime, however,
- 15:46by their conservator, their agent under a durable
- 15:49power of attorney while incapacitated, or the
- 15:51trustee of their revocable trust while incapacitated,
- 15:55then the beneficiary would be entitled to receive
- 15:57a pecuniary gift in amount equal to the net proceeds
- 16:00of the sale. And these same rules would apply
- 16:03during if an asset is taken by eminent. domain
- 16:07during this period. And there are some exceptions
- 16:09that do apply to this. So the purpose of these
- 16:12rules generally is that if the testator did not
- 16:19direct the sale, the law tries to carry out the
- 16:24testator's wish that the beneficiary receive
- 16:27that property. And we're going to see how the
- 16:31purpose of these rules that the beneficiary not
- 16:34be deprived because somebody other than the testator
- 16:37sold it carries out in some of the exceptions.
- 16:42Okay. And then again, similarly, if a specifically
- 16:46gifted asset was encumbered during the testator's
- 16:49lifetime by their conservator, their agent under
- 16:52durable power of attorney while incapacitated,
- 16:55or the trustee of their revocable trust while
- 16:57incapacitated, The beneficiary is entitled to
- 17:00receive a pecuniary gift in the amount equal
- 17:02to the outstanding encumbrance amount on the
- 17:05date of death. And again, there are some similar
- 17:08exceptions that apply. And again, the purpose
- 17:11of these rules is to ensure that the beneficiary
- 17:14gets what the testator intended when somebody
- 17:17other than the testator has made the. OK, go
- 17:24to the next slide. The rules we just discussed
- 17:30relating to a sailor encumbrance by a conservator
- 17:32do not apply if the conservatorship is terminated
- 17:35more than one year before the testator's death.
- 17:38If there is an adjudication of the testator's
- 17:40incapacity, I'm sorry, an adjudication of the
- 17:43testator's incapacity is not required for the
- 17:47agent action rules to apply and the principle
- 17:49is presumed to be incapacitated when the action
- 17:52was taken. An adjudication of the testator's
- 17:55incapacity is also not required for the trustee
- 17:58action rules to apply, although there is no presumption
- 18:01of the principal's incapacity. Do you want to
- 18:06expand on that? Going back to that last slide
- 18:09for one second, again, the first exception here
- 18:12is that if the testator recovers capacity such
- 18:20that the conservatorship is terminated and it
- 18:22goes on for more than one year, the presumption
- 18:25is that that person will fix and address whatever
- 18:28happened while they were incapacitated. That's
- 18:31the purpose of that exception. And then moving
- 18:36on to pecuniary gifts, which once again are a
- 18:41fixed dollar amount gift. So the beneficiary
- 18:44would receive the amount specified and also interest
- 18:49at seven percent, three percent under the legal
- 18:52rate beginning on the first anniversary of the
- 18:54testator's death. So if those gifts are You're
- 18:58not satisfied within the 1st year and are paid
- 19:00out after that 1st year, the beneficiary would
- 19:02receive interest beginning on the anniversary
- 19:04of the testator's death and the interest accrued
- 19:06during that 1st year would stay with the estate.
- 19:10And the same rules also apply to trust under
- 19:13probate code. Okay. Now, with respect to an annuity,
- 19:21what does the recipient receive? Again, that's
- 19:24a pecuniary gift payable over time. They would
- 19:27receive the amount specified payable at the end
- 19:29of the period specified in the instrument. Again,
- 19:35interest. at 7%, 3 % under the legal rate, if
- 19:39not paid when due, again, except that no interest
- 19:42accrues during the first year after the testator's
- 19:45death. That's that same one -year rule, and the
- 19:47interest would stay with the estate. And these
- 19:50rules also apply both to trusts under the probate
- 19:54code. So now moving on to the residue, which
- 19:59is kind of the remainder of what remains after
- 20:01all specific and general gifts have been made.
- 20:04What does the benefit recipient receive? The
- 20:07remaining assets after all other gifts have been
- 20:09satisfied. The remaining net income. to be distributed
- 20:14pro rata to the residuary beneficiaries. And
- 20:18an important note here is that fiduciary fees,
- 20:21legal and accounting fees are also charged to
- 20:24the residue. So that would come out of the residue.
- 20:27And these same rules also apply to trusts under
- 20:30the probate code. As an example of that last
- 20:35one, I'm dealing with a situation where a beneficiary
- 20:40was given a a gift of real property that was
- 20:44sold several years ago and the trustee has since
- 20:48resigned and we're looking to get a new trustee.
- 20:52The beneficiary said, you know, we'll agree to
- 20:57new trustee X if new trustee X agrees that they're
- 21:01not going to take any fees out of our gift. And
- 21:05the response was, well, that's what the law provides.
- 21:08you know, you don't have anything to worry about.
- 21:10And shortly thereafter, beneficiary agreed to
- 21:14allow the new trustee to start serving. Now let's
- 21:19talk about satisfaction. So certain testimony
- 21:22gifts can be satisfied during the testator's
- 21:25lifetime. In the situations where this would
- 21:30occur is that the testimony instrument provides
- 21:32for satisfaction. or the transferee executes
- 21:36a contemporaneous writing indicating that the
- 21:38transfer is in full or partial satisfaction of
- 21:40the gift, and the gift is the same property as
- 21:44the specific gift. Let me do an example of that
- 21:47first one. I do many estate plans which say I
- 21:52give a million dollars to Charity X reduced by
- 21:56contributions to Charity X made during my lifetime.
- 22:01Right. And then in other examples, if, for example,
- 22:06you were providing to give $100 ,000 to a specific
- 22:08beneficiary, full or partial satisfaction can
- 22:12be made during the lifetime if there is a specific
- 22:16contemporaneous writing indicating that that
- 22:19transfer is intended to satisfy the gift in full
- 22:23or in part. So, and where there is satisfaction,
- 22:31the amount of the satisfaction will be determined
- 22:34on the earlier of the transferee acquiring the
- 22:37property and the transfer's death, or the transfer
- 22:41executing a contemporaneous writing indicating
- 22:43that the value is conclusive. And if the recipient
- 22:48of a lifetime gift satisfies a testamentary gift
- 22:51pre -deceases the transfer, the gift is still
- 22:54fully or partially satisfied unless the transfer
- 22:56provides otherwise in writing. That's straightforward.
- 23:03So here are some examples, I guess, that we were
- 23:06just discussing. So there's a gift in trust is
- 23:10$100 ,000 to Fran. If Fran predeceases the settler,
- 23:15the gift is to be distributed to Fran's issue
- 23:17who survived the settler by right of representation.
- 23:20However, the transfer while alive gives Fran
- 23:23$20 ,000. So after the $20 ,000 gift is made,
- 23:27Fran then dies. So what happens? The remaining
- 23:31$80 ,000 goes to Fran's issue. Okay. Do you want
- 23:40to enter? Okay. So is this mine? You can start.
- 23:48So there's a whole bunch of reasons why gifts
- 23:50can abate, that the state will not, or the fund
- 23:55will not be, trust or state will not be sufficient
- 23:58to satisfy the gifts, such as creditor claims,
- 24:01payment of taxes, need to satisfy a gift to an
- 24:07omitted spouse or child, so property that was
- 24:09not intended or expected to be siphoned off.
- 24:12gets paid elsewhere, the value of the estate
- 24:16goes down, or redemption, sale or loss of specific
- 24:20assets that Julia will discuss. Yeah. So there's
- 24:25a couple of different examples where there, I
- 24:29guess, has been abatement found by redemption
- 24:32and then when there has not. been abatement found.
- 24:36So for example, so a mere change in form of an
- 24:39asset doesn't result in abatement. For example,
- 24:42if you change the corporate form from a partnership
- 24:45to a corporation, or if there's a reorganization
- 24:48of a corporation, or in one instance, there's
- 24:51a case where a two strands of pearls were then
- 24:56became one strand, and they found that there
- 24:59was no abatement. However, some contrasting examples
- 25:02where there was abatement, if you find a bank
- 25:05account was closed and the proceeds were used
- 25:07to purchase securities, that gift does abate,
- 25:11and then a meet. Another fun example, a mink
- 25:15coat that was cut into a mink stole and the court
- 25:18found that that change of form of the gift did
- 25:21abate. Another example, land transferred to a
- 25:26note. The amazing thing about the mink coat,
- 25:29mink stole, and two strands of pearls and one
- 25:32strand of pearl is that there are actually California
- 25:34cases addressing that. These were litigated to
- 25:38court appellate decisions. So yeah, we're not
- 25:42just making up those examples. So if there is
- 25:48abatement, the gifts will abate in the following
- 25:50order. First, property not disposed of by the
- 25:54instrument, residuary gifts, and then general
- 25:58gifts, first to the transfers non -relatives,
- 26:01and then to the transfers relatives. And then
- 26:09it. For specific gifts, it would be to the transfer's
- 26:12non -relatives and then to the transfer's relatives.
- 26:16And relative is a person to whom property would
- 26:19pass from the transfer under California intestate
- 26:22secession if the transfer died intestate and
- 26:25there was no other person having priority. So
- 26:27there is a priority given to preserve gifts to
- 26:32the transfer's relatives. And again, under this
- 26:36definition, a grandchild can be a relative and
- 26:39is a relative, even though the intervening parent
- 26:42is still alive. Okay, so now we're going to go
- 26:46ahead and look at some of the tax consequences
- 26:49of these different gifts, and Mark is going to
- 26:52take the lead on this part. Okay, so Julie has
- 26:55covered... Who gets what under various scenarios?
- 26:59If there's more by virtue of net income or if
- 27:02there's less because there's been a satisfaction
- 27:04or abatement, who's going to bear that or who's
- 27:07going to enjoy that? Now we're moving to the
- 27:11tax consequences because we have to understand
- 27:13who gets the tax liability in various scenarios.
- 27:20And most entities are either taxable, like an
- 27:24individual, or a C corporation, or a pass through,
- 27:27like a partnership, or S corporation. And the
- 27:30unique thing about trusts and estates is that
- 27:32they exhibit characteristics of both. Sometimes
- 27:36they're a tax planity, and sometimes they are
- 27:39a flow through. And the linchpin for that is
- 27:42something called the distribution deduction.
- 27:45If there's a distribution deduction, then the
- 27:48income is that the trust or estate gets to deduct
- 27:52flows through to the beneficiaries and they're
- 27:55taxed. And the portion of the trust or estate
- 27:59income that is not part of the distribution deduction
- 28:02is taxed to the trust or estate. The distribution
- 28:07deduction is based on something called D &I,
- 28:10which is distributable net income, a big term
- 28:13in the Internal Revenue Code under Section 643.
- 28:17Next slide, please. What is DNI? You start with
- 28:23income generally determined in the same manner
- 28:25as for an individual with certain adjustments.
- 28:28It is very different from fiduciary accounting
- 28:31income. Basically what Julia just went over was
- 28:34fiduciary accounting income, which is the most
- 28:36important. Who gets the dollars? And what I always
- 28:39tell clients is as long as the tax rate is under
- 28:42100%, it's better to get the dollars and pay
- 28:45tax than not to get the dollars or property.
- 28:49The DNI serves two purposes, one quantitative,
- 28:54how much, and the second is qualitative, the
- 28:57character of the income that is taxed to either
- 29:00the entity or the individual. Next slide. We're
- 29:04going to see this. in the following example.
- 29:08Let's assume, hold on for a little bit second
- 29:10there, that the trust has relatively simple.
- 29:14It has a partnership distribution of 30. So for
- 29:17fiduciary accounting purposes, it's a receipt
- 29:20of $30. And so the FAI is 30. You can hit the
- 29:23next slide somewhat to get to the next line.
- 29:26The K1 shows 20 of income. So for tax purposes,
- 29:29it's only 20 of income. For tax exempt income
- 29:33of 10, There's FAI, actual dollars received,
- 29:3610. The tax on that is zero. And finally, fees,
- 29:41the actual fees payable are six, but for fiduciary
- 29:45accounting purposes, fees are charged one half
- 29:48against income and one half against principal.
- 29:51So there's only a charge against income of three.
- 29:53For tax purposes, we have a slightly different
- 29:55allocation, which is that we have 20 of taxable
- 30:00K1 income and 10 of non -taxable total of 30,
- 30:06and one -third of that is the tax exempt. So
- 30:09we have only two -thirds, attributable to the
- 30:13partnership, of the fees deductible. And one
- 30:17-third is not deductible. So the six goes down
- 30:19to four for deduction. And notice that the FAI
- 30:21here is 37. The person entitled to the income
- 30:25would get 37, but the tax here is only 16. So
- 30:30again, radically different. Okay. There is a
- 30:36rule that we'll come back to in a little bit,
- 30:39the separate share rule, where if an estate or
- 30:43trust has multiple beneficiaries who have substantially
- 30:45separate independent shares, those shares are
- 30:47treated as separate estates or trusts for DNI
- 30:50only. And this occurs quite regularly. Next slide.
- 30:59And we'll see it occurs quite regularly if there's
- 31:03a residual gift where even to the issue. We'll
- 31:07talk about that later. So specific gifts. Satisfying
- 31:13a specific gift does not carry out D &I to the
- 31:15beneficiary. And again, the citations for this
- 31:18are in the other written materials that are included
- 31:22in today's presentation that have been sent by
- 31:26the Beverly Hills Bar Association or available
- 31:29from them. So there is no D &I out to the beneficiary
- 31:33by satisfying a specific gift. However, an amount
- 31:37which can only be paid from income is not considered
- 31:40a specific gift and therefore does carry out
- 31:43D &I to the beneficiary. This applies to both
- 31:46income items that are subject to the specific
- 31:48gift or income attributable to the specific gift,
- 31:51as I'll show in an example in an upcoming slide.
- 31:55Finally, the income from the specific gift is
- 31:57treated as a separate share. Thus, that DNI and
- 32:01the income from that is treated separately from
- 32:05other assets. As an example there, if I give
- 32:08Julia my shopping center at 123 Main Street,
- 32:16then the nature of the income that she gets is
- 32:20going to be rental income. And it's going to
- 32:23be pegged to the income of that property. Next
- 32:28slide. So here's an example. If we satisfy a
- 32:35specific gift of Blackacre, then the beneficiary
- 32:38does not get any DNI attributable to that because
- 32:42we simply satisfied the specific gift. However,
- 32:47if Blackacre generates income, and because Julie
- 32:51has told us that the recipient of Blackacre is
- 32:55entitled to receive the net income, then that
- 32:58income, which can obviously only be satisfied
- 33:01out of income does carry out DNI to the beneficiary.
- 33:05So the beneficiary will receive both Blackacre
- 33:08and for income tax purposes, the net income from
- 33:13Blackacre. Next slide. A pecuniary gift. The
- 33:19satisfaction of a pecuniary gift does not carry
- 33:22out DNI unless the distribution is required to
- 33:24be made or is actually made in more than three
- 33:26installments. So that's a big one. You have to
- 33:28watch out if you're administering an estate or
- 33:32trust how many installments you distribute a
- 33:35pecuniary gift. Obviously drafting, you can say
- 33:38somebody gets $100 ,000 that would generally
- 33:41not carry out DNI when we satisfy it, but...
- 33:44If it's satisfied in $40 ,000 increments, or
- 33:48excuse me, $33 ,000 increments, then it would
- 33:53still be okay. If it's satisfied in $25 ,000
- 33:56increments, then there would be DNI. The payment
- 34:00of interest on the delayed funding of the pecuniary
- 34:02gift is income to the recipient, okay? So that
- 34:06they are going to get income, the recipient.
- 34:10from that interest of 7%. The IRS takes the position
- 34:14that the interest paid by the state or trust
- 34:16is personal interest and therefore not deductible.
- 34:18It used to be that it was personal interest and
- 34:20it would be deductible, but under the rules that
- 34:24have subsequently come into play, that income
- 34:29is no longer deductible because it does not fall
- 34:33within the appropriate bucket under section 163H.
- 34:38And so you want to try to avoid that where possible,
- 34:41which means satisfying pecuniary gifts within
- 34:44one year to avoid the payment of interest where
- 34:47possible. Next slide. satisfying a pecuniary
- 34:54gift with an appreciated asset. So let's say
- 34:56the gift is $100 ,000. When somebody dies, the
- 35:00basis of property gets stepped upward down to
- 35:03fair market value. Let's say the basis of the
- 35:06property is 80 and we use that asset because
- 35:08it's grown in value to 100 to satisfy a gift
- 35:12of 100. Well, that's treated as a deemed sale
- 35:16by the estate or trust such that 100 of gift
- 35:21satisfied, 80 basis, there'd be 20 of gain. And
- 35:28under the Keenan case, Keenan versus commissioner,
- 35:31the gain does not pass out. It's not an item
- 35:35of DNI, and it is borne by the estate or trust
- 35:39that has made the gift. There is not necessarily...
- 35:44an equivalence if the property has gone down
- 35:47in value because of the related party rules under
- 35:51267. Next slide, please. The loss will be allowed
- 36:00only if it's an estate transaction under 267.
- 36:07Finally, the satisfaction of a residual gift
- 36:09does carry out DNI regardless of what's distributed.
- 36:13It's the value of what is distributed, not the
- 36:18nature of the property that is determinative.
- 36:24residual beneficiary who's going to get $100,
- 36:28the same treatment, tax treatment will occur
- 36:30if a painting worth $100 or some other property
- 36:34worth $100 is distributed for income tax purposes
- 36:38when we satisfy that gift to the residual beneficiary,
- 36:41then that's treated as a distribution of $100
- 36:44of DNI. And by the way, I mentioned earlier about
- 36:48the quantification of income. The simple way
- 36:51to remember it is if the trust has 75 of income,
- 36:58the rules are that there's 75 of income to be
- 37:02allocated. We don't know whether that income
- 37:05is all going to go out to the beneficiary because
- 37:07it's part of the DNI that gets distributed or
- 37:10it's all going to stay in the estate or trust,
- 37:13but the maximum amount of income is 75 subject
- 37:17to the Keenan rule if there's a Keenan gain.
- 37:20So that if the beneficiary receives a million
- 37:23dollar distribution from an estate or trust and
- 37:25the estate or trust only has $40 ,000 of income,
- 37:28then we're only talking about $40 ,000 of income
- 37:31to be apportioned, not a million. Next slide.
- 37:37So here is the separate share rule. If we have
- 37:42an estate that's tributable equally to my issue,
- 37:47and let's say all three children survive, so
- 37:50each gets one -third. In that situation, if we
- 37:54have $120 of income of the estate, then each
- 37:59child's one -third share is 40. So if we make
- 38:04a distribution of different amounts of different
- 38:06children it's not certain that all the DNI will
- 38:10pass out to the beneficiaries. Again, you'd think,
- 38:14oh, look, and you look in the distribution column,
- 38:16there's 140 being distributed and the DNI is
- 38:19120, so all the DNI goes out to the beneficiaries.
- 38:23That's not the case here. Why? Because in this
- 38:25case, Alex gets 95, which is an excess of their
- 38:29share. They do get all the DNI for their share.
- 38:32Blake, however, only gets 30, where they're share
- 38:35of their DNI is 40, so that means that 10 is
- 38:38left in the estate, and Cameron gets 15, so that
- 38:42they will receive DNI of 15, but 25 of their
- 38:47DNI stays in the estate, and the estate ends
- 38:50up getting taxed on 35. The beneficiaries cumulatively
- 38:54will have income of 85 to pay tax on. Next slide,
- 39:02please. Now I'm going to move to slightly more
- 39:08complicated issues involving the marital deduction.
- 39:13A married individual often utilizes a plan that
- 39:17provides for a portion to be subject to tax at
- 39:22the first death and not at the second death.
- 39:25Now, some of that may not be done anymore because
- 39:28of portability, but there are issues with portability.
- 39:32You have to file an estate tax return to claim
- 39:35it. If the surviving spouse remarries and then
- 39:40that second spouse predeceases, the first spouse's
- 39:44credit that was ported gets lost, and the surviving
- 39:48spouse will be left with the second spouse's
- 39:50unused credit, if any. So there are all sorts
- 39:53of issues there beyond the scope of this presentation.
- 39:57So I'm going to go back to the typical AB or
- 40:03marital credit trust situation with It may not
- 40:09be needed for many clients who have smaller states.
- 40:13But by the way, if the plan, regardless of need,
- 40:16has an AB trust or marital trust and credit trust,
- 40:19then post death it needs to be implemented even
- 40:23if it wasn't needed. The example there is if
- 40:26the husband and wife today combined have a $10
- 40:29million estate, they don't need a marital trust
- 40:32and a credit trust. They could just give it all
- 40:34outright to the surviving spouse or put everything
- 40:36in a credit trust or a residual trust of the
- 40:41decedent's property, and it would all work without
- 40:44any adverse tax consequences. But if they have
- 40:48a different plan, then it has to be implemented.
- 40:51Next slide, please. So the three trusts that
- 40:56we typically create are the survivor's trust,
- 40:59which hold the surviving spouse's property, the
- 41:02credit trust, which holds the deceased spouse's
- 41:04property that's subject to a state tax. Again,
- 41:07that would be up to $13 .99 million today. Next
- 41:11year, that number goes to 15 million, and thereafter
- 41:14the amount will be 15 million with the annual
- 41:19cost of living adjustment. And then finally,
- 41:21the marital trust, which holds the deceased spouse's
- 41:23property that qualifies for the marital deduction
- 41:26in excess of the amount that passed to the credit
- 41:29trust. Next slide. practitioners post -death
- 41:38could play games. How could they play games?
- 41:41There was a limited marital deduction, and in
- 41:44community property states, you didn't get much
- 41:46of a marital deduction because the surviving
- 41:48spouse was already deemed to have their half
- 41:51by virtue of their half of the community. They
- 41:53changed all that in 1981 with the unlimited marital
- 41:58deduction, but practitioners could still play
- 42:01games by taking an asset that had a value on
- 42:07date of death of one thing, but had a different
- 42:08value and a lower value at the date of funding
- 42:11to use that to satisfy the gift. And these games
- 42:17the IRS put a stop to in 1964 through RevProc
- 42:226419. So now the division must be made in one
- 42:26of several ways. Next slide, please. First, you
- 42:31can have, and I'm going to come back to these
- 42:33things, A, B, and C, and the types of funding.
- 42:37So you have, first of all, what type of gift?
- 42:41It's a non -marital pecuniary is the A. Basically,
- 42:46the credit trust is a pecuniary gift. I give,
- 42:49simply put, $13 .99. We'll call it $14 million.
- 42:52I give $14 million to the credit trust. And that
- 42:56means the residue would be the marital trust
- 42:58funded using either date of distribution or fairly
- 43:01representative funding. We'll talk about what
- 43:03these mean in a moment. Date of distribution.
- 43:07as the name implies, is the date that actually
- 43:11the gift is funded, and the Fairly Representative
- 43:14is a little bit more complicated and requires
- 43:18that the gift be funded using assets Fairly Representative
- 43:21of the appreciation or depreciation post death.
- 43:25The second way of doing this, the B thing, is
- 43:29a Merital Procurement. I give to the Merital
- 43:31Trust everything in excess of $14 million. So
- 43:35again, the A is I give $14 million to the credit
- 43:38trust, everything else to the marital. B is I
- 43:41give everything in excess of $14 million to the...
- 43:45and the balance to the credit trust. Here again,
- 43:49data distribution funding, also fairly representative
- 43:52funding, and something called minimum worth funding
- 43:55that we'll talk about in a next slide or two.
- 43:57And then finally, it can be a fractional, which
- 44:01is both gifts or residue, residual, and funded
- 44:04by fractional funding or pick and choose funding,
- 44:07which probably works. We'll talk about each of
- 44:10these in a moment and the consequences. person,
- 44:14you should know what you're using and why. If
- 44:18you are getting a document that's handed to you,
- 44:21it doesn't really matter what somebody has. You're
- 44:23going to have to play out what they have and
- 44:27go with that. Next slide. So, date of distribution
- 44:32requires assets to be used to fund the peculiar
- 44:35gift at the date of distribution. As the name
- 44:37implies, there's a single target, which is the
- 44:39date of distribution value. So, if we have a
- 44:41$15 million $14 million gift, excuse me, to the
- 44:45credit trust, then you need to find assets that
- 44:47on the date of distribution have $14 million
- 44:50value. And by the way, some assets today may
- 44:53be valued at $8 million and we distribute those,
- 44:55and then you need $6 million down the road. Don't
- 44:59forget, as Julia talked about before, this is
- 45:02a pecuniary gift, so it's not satisfied within
- 45:04one year, it's gonna get interest. For the date
- 45:09of distribution, we only have to value the assets
- 45:11once on the date of distribution and the date
- 45:15of death. But there's only a second valuation
- 45:21on the date of distribution. It may result in
- 45:23keen and gain if there are appreciated assets.
- 45:27Next slide. For fairly representative, it's actually
- 45:33two constraints. Date of death, there's one constraint.
- 45:37Look at what the date of death value is. For
- 45:38fairly representative, we first need to look
- 45:40at the date of death values, and we need to look
- 45:44at the date of distribution values to find out
- 45:47what the overall appreciation or depreciation
- 45:51in the assets that could be used is. Without
- 45:53knowing what the overall appreciation or depreciation
- 45:56is, we can't select assets that are fairly representative
- 46:00of that overall appreciation. or depreciation.
- 46:04And so we have the two targets, again, both of
- 46:08them, and requires valuation of all assets available
- 46:12for distribution. So whereas in the data of distribution,
- 46:15you only need to value the assets actually being
- 46:18used to fund the pecuniary gift, here you need
- 46:20to revalue all assets, again, potentially a greater
- 46:23cost. Next slide. Also, the fairly representative
- 46:30may limit funding options. So the simple example
- 46:33is you have two assets, they both have the same
- 46:34distribution, excuse me, same date of death value,
- 46:39but one has gone up by $20 and the other has
- 46:44gone down by $20. The only way you can get fairly
- 46:48representative, which is no overall appreciation
- 46:51or depreciation, is to take equal parts of A
- 46:54and B. That's the only way you can do it. And
- 46:57so your hands are tied. You could not use 40
- 47:00% of A and 60 % of B or any other thing other
- 47:04than X % of A and X % of B to satisfy Fairly
- 47:09Representative. When you have more assets, then
- 47:13obviously you can potentially get the Fairly
- 47:15Representative in different ways. Perhaps. Again,
- 47:18you need to look at those assets and see what's
- 47:20available. Next slide. Minimum worth. So data
- 47:27diffusion and fairly representative are available
- 47:30for both A, which was the Myrtle. A, which was
- 47:34the credit pecuniary, and B, which was the marital
- 47:36pecuniary, but minimum worth can only be used
- 47:40for the marital pecuniary. Here, we value each
- 47:43asset at the lower of its basis and date of distribution
- 47:46value. Again, it requires two different appraisals,
- 47:50potentially one on date of death, which is the
- 47:52basis, and another on the date of distribution.
- 47:55It likely overvalues the property to the marital
- 47:58trust, which is one of the reasons why the IRS
- 48:00approved it. overvaluing the property of the
- 48:03marital trust undervalues the property to the
- 48:06credit trust. So not the optimal estate tax result.
- 48:10And I would therefore, as a draft person, not
- 48:13recommend this in most cases. Next slide, please.
- 48:18This is some examples of the, going back, sorry,
- 48:22before we get to that, you don't have to go back
- 48:23on the slide. The other possibility is fractional,
- 48:29where there's two possibilities of funding. One
- 48:31of them is, again, the four, which is the fairly,
- 48:35is the fractional of everything. And I refer
- 48:37to that as the hacksaw approach, that if, the
- 48:41relative values of the credit trust and the marital
- 48:43trust are two to one, then each and every asset
- 48:47gets allocated in that two to one ratio. Doesn't
- 48:51matter what it is, completely fair, completely
- 48:54objective. Nobody's going to complain because
- 48:57whatever. The other one is pick and choose, which
- 49:00is that you basically do fractional, but you
- 49:05can potentially to pick some assets to satisfy
- 49:09parts of the gifts. And it doesn't have to be
- 49:11a pro rata funding. The first one has to be pro
- 49:13rata funding. Second one is non pro rata funding.
- 49:16That has not been expressly and explicitly blessed
- 49:18by the IRS. It probably works, but not 100 %
- 49:22sure. So let's go through these. A1 again, A,
- 49:26B, C, and D refers to credit pecuniary first.
- 49:31B is the marital pecuniary and C is the fractional.
- 49:35So if we assume that the value of the estate
- 49:37has gone up from 25 to 30 million. It's gone
- 49:41up in value by 5 million. Scheme A1 is that the
- 49:48date of distribution satisfying the non -merital
- 49:50gift, the merital gift, excuse me, let me take
- 49:58a slip back. If we satisfy the Non -marital gift
- 50:00for the peculiar amount of $14 million. It gets
- 50:03$14 million. The residue, which is now $5 million
- 50:05more, goes to the marital trust. Next option
- 50:09is that if... We use fairly representative. You
- 50:14can see that the non -marital gift shares in
- 50:16some of the growth, which is a generally good
- 50:19result. We generally want to have the non -marital
- 50:22gift higher. If you go to the B funding scheme,
- 50:26the marital pecuniary, then we see if there's
- 50:28a $5 million growth, the entire $5 million goes
- 50:31to the residue and goes to the non -marital gift,
- 50:34which is a great result. If we use fairly representative,
- 50:37then we have the same results as in A2, B2 is
- 50:42the same as A2. But again, we have differences,
- 50:45you can hit return, because the one gift is pecuniary,
- 50:52and so there's income differences. And then for
- 50:55B3, we don't really know whether it's going to
- 50:58be more or less in the Merrill Trust, you can
- 51:00hit return again. It's possible that the Merrill
- 51:03Trust could eat up everything. And the non -marital
- 51:06trust could be as little as zero. Again, it could
- 51:10be that if we have enough cash, it could be that
- 51:13only $11 million goes to the marital trust. With
- 51:16the two fractional, you can hit return twice,
- 51:21we're going to get the same 13 .2 and 6 .8. Both
- 51:25of them are treated as residual gifts, the marital
- 51:27gift and the non -marital gift. Now, let's notice
- 51:31by the way that you have a great result. In B1,
- 51:35if there's five million of appreciation, and
- 51:38in A1, you've got a limiting gift of $14 million
- 51:42if you have the non -marital gift as a pecuniary.
- 51:45Let's go to the next slide, which is the value
- 51:48has gone down by $5 million. Here, notice we
- 51:52preserved the non -marital gift under A1, and
- 51:55the entire hit is borne by the marital trust.
- 51:58Under A2, that's reversed. If you can hit return,
- 52:02and you're gonna see that the non, excuse me,
- 52:05A2 is fairly representative, not, sorry, A2 is
- 52:07fairly representative, so they both take a share
- 52:09of the hit. B1, where we have the, myrtle gift
- 52:15is the peculiar gift, it's gonna get what it's
- 52:18supposed to get, and the residue gets any gain
- 52:20or loss, or any growth or depreciation. Hit the
- 52:25return, please. You're gonna see that it gets,
- 52:29Only 9 million. And then the fairly representative
- 52:32in B2, again, the same results, different on
- 52:36income. B3, again, we don't know how much of
- 52:39the 20 million will go to the marital trust.
- 52:42It could be all. And then in the fractional,
- 52:48you're going to have the same results of 8 .8
- 52:50and 11 .2 in both instances. You can hit return
- 52:54twice. But notice that what was so good in B1,
- 52:59if it went up in value, was the worst result
- 53:02if it went down in value. And what was just a
- 53:06limiting result, again, extra to the marital
- 53:10trust in A1 was a really good result if things
- 53:15go down in value. So part of deciding what to
- 53:18use, you have to make some predictions. The fairly
- 53:21representative or the fractional aren't nearly
- 53:23as good on the upside, but also protect against
- 53:25the downside. Next slide. So now generation skipping
- 53:33transfer tax. There are GST implications for
- 53:37the nature of the gift as well. Very brief overview
- 53:41of the GST tax. The tax itself is the amount
- 53:46involved times the applicable rate. The applicable
- 53:49rate equals the highest estate tax rate, which
- 53:51is currently 40%, times the inclusion ratio.
- 53:54The inclusion ratio is one less the applicable
- 53:57fraction. And the applicable fraction is the
- 54:00GST exemption allocated divided by the value
- 54:03of property transferred as adjusted. So again,
- 54:06a lot of definitions there in getting to the
- 54:09actual amount of tax. It is good to have an inclusion
- 54:12ratio of zero, so it's good to have an applicable
- 54:16fraction of one, i .e. GST exemption allocated
- 54:20divided by the value of property is one. We have
- 54:23a million dollars of property, we allocate a
- 54:25million dollars of GST exemption to it, the fractional
- 54:27fraction is one, the inclusion ratio is zero,
- 54:30means that there's no GST tax. Obviously, if
- 54:33there's no GST exemption allocated, then the
- 54:37inclusion fraction is zero, the inclusion ratio
- 54:41is one, and the applicable rate is 40%. Next
- 54:45slide, please. The applicable fraction, what
- 54:51is the denominator? For the pecuniary gift satisfied
- 54:54with cash, the denominator is the pecuniary amount.
- 54:56If it's satisfied with something other than cash,
- 54:59then if the gift must be satisfied using date
- 55:01of death or fairly representative funding, denominator
- 55:04is the pecuniary amount. Again, it's somewhat
- 55:06easy. If pecuniary gift was satisfied other than
- 55:09cash, cash, and the gift is not required to be
- 55:11satisfied using date of death or fairly representative
- 55:14funding. Then the denominator is the date of
- 55:16distribution value of the property satisfying
- 55:18the pecuniary gift. Next slide. So notice the
- 55:21date of distribution. Residual gift after pecuniary
- 55:24gift that carries appropriate interest, the denominator
- 55:26is the date of death value of the property available
- 55:29to satisfy the residual gift reduced by the pecuniary
- 55:32amount, okay? And appropriate interest can either
- 55:35be state law 7 % satisfied within 15 months after
- 55:39death. So if we have a document that overrides
- 55:43California law, if it's satisfied within 15 months
- 55:45after date of death, it's still okay. Or if the
- 55:48pecuniary gift receives a proride share of the
- 55:50income from the fund from which it is satisfied.
- 55:52Again, that would only typically happen in a
- 55:56residual gift. So maybe it's actually going to
- 55:58work. And then there's special rules for residuals.
- 56:02I'm not going to go through these other rules.
- 56:04We're a little bit more deep. because we're running
- 56:06out of time. And I do want Julie to have a chance
- 56:10to finish up. So if you can go through the remaining
- 56:13generation, skipping transfer tax slides, which
- 56:15are in your material, maybe it was only the one,
- 56:19they're also talked about in the outline. Julia?
- 56:23Okay. And finally, to sum up, when can estate
- 56:27distributions be made? Must generally be made
- 56:29after obtaining a court order. However, and they
- 56:33can be made using the notice of proposed action
- 56:36procedures under the following circumstances
- 56:38if the time for filing creditors claims has expired,
- 56:42the personal representative determines that distribution
- 56:45won't cause loss to creditors or injury to the
- 56:48state or any person, or you're just to distribute
- 56:52the following property, basically income received
- 56:54during administration to the persons entitled
- 56:56to that income. tangible personal property, including
- 57:00vehicles with a total value of $50 ,000 or less,
- 57:04and cash to satisfy a pecuniary bequest not exceeding
- 57:08$10 ,000 to any one person. So that's general
- 57:12overview of when items can be distributed. And
- 57:17again, those rules all follow the fiduciary rules
- 57:21that Julia started off with at the beginning.
- 57:23I see that there's one question. in the chat
- 57:27takes a partial mortgage. I'm not sure I understand
- 57:32what a partial mortgage is on a previously fully
- 57:37owned property that was specifically devised.
- 57:41So the answer is that a mortgage follows the
- 57:47property so that If there's a house and it's
- 57:52subject to a mortgage, even if there's a general
- 57:54clause in the Willow Trust saying pay all debts,
- 57:56the beneficiary of that property takes the mortgage.
- 58:01I don't know if that answers that. Again, I'm
- 58:03not sure what a partial mortgage is, if that's
- 58:05something different than a regular mortgage.
- 58:11Any other questions? Thank you for your time.
- 58:16Thank you, everyone. All right. That concludes
- 58:19today's presentation. Thank you so much, Mark
- 58:21and Julia, for your time today and thank you
- 58:23to our audience. Have a great morning, everybody.
- 58:27Thank you. Thank you.