Latest / Serves You Right / #61 Agent Cru (aka Addison Rex): 7 Brutal Truths About Buying “Discount” Wine
Transcript
- 0:02I breakdown the challenges that wine's currently facing.
- 0:06They just always get it wrong. Not because what they're saying
- 0:09in particular isn't correct and well founded, but because
- 0:13there's three other completely legitimate variables and
- 0:15perspectives that also have a massive impact.
- 0:22Thank you for listening to Serves You Right.
- 0:24My name is Andrew and today I got a chance to sit down and
- 0:27talk to Agent Crew, AKA Addison Rex, CEO of Wine Spies.
- 0:35Wine Spies is a very interesting business model. 365 days a year,
- 0:40a new cell on a different bottle of wine.
- 0:44When it's gone, it's gone. And as you buy wine, you begin
- 0:48to collect them and they will ship you a free case when you
- 0:51get to 12. Fascinating stuff.
- 0:54We get to dig into the process behind picking the wines, what
- 0:58exactly the logistical and data needs are of a company of that
- 1:03size, How even at this scale with all the pH DS they've
- 1:08hired, with all the data scientists, human judgement is
- 1:11still more accurate when it comes to projecting purchases
- 1:15than all the data models combined.
- 1:18And all the things that you rarely get to hear in the wine
- 1:22industry. How the more you know, the more
- 1:25you realize you don't know and everything in between.
- 1:28I really, really enjoyed sitting down and talking to Agent Crew.
- 1:31I hope you enjoy it too. This is Serves You Right.
- 1:34My name is Andrew. Let's get to it.
- 1:40Agent Crew, thanks for joining us on Serves You Right.
- 1:42And yeah, thanks for putting up with my absence earlier.
- 1:46No. Happy to be here.
- 1:47I even got my spy shades. For the Yeah.
- 1:51So how did you end up going by the name Agent Crew?
- 1:56How'd you get into the wine roll?
- 1:58Yes, I've been undercover at Wine Spies for eight years now,
- 2:02which is mind blowing. And when I went undercover, my
- 2:05real name is Addison Rex. It's not like some crazy trade
- 2:07secret. Yeah.
- 2:09My LinkedIn will will point you in that direction pretty fast.
- 2:12But yeah, all of us actually use our code names at Wine Spies.
- 2:16And the first thing you have to do is choose it because that's
- 2:19what your e-mail is going to be. And I definitely wanted to be
- 2:22Agent Rex because, I mean, come on, that's my like, only chance
- 2:25I'm ever going to get in my life to be Agent Rex.
- 2:28And Agent Red, the founder of the company, is like, Nah, man,
- 2:31it has to be a code name. So I've been crew and believe it
- 2:34or not, we actually call each other our code names.
- 2:37There's like 20 wine spots now. Yeah, which which, for someone
- 2:40listening, communicating with everyone at Wine Spies by
- 2:45e-mail, does get confusing because.
- 2:47Yes. You have no faces to put with
- 2:49anything. It's just like, agent this,
- 2:51agent that, and you're like. And avatars.
- 2:53Am I talking to Agent Burgundy now?
- 2:55Agent crew? Like who am I out here?
- 2:58You know, you're actually, it's totally fair and you're
- 3:00completely right. And people do like, it's like,
- 3:02is it noir? That's the wine buyer.
- 3:03Who's the logistics guy? But what's funny about that is
- 3:07it's just a name. So really, if you think about
- 3:11it, I mean, it should be no less confusing than Daniel and Steve.
- 3:14You know, if anything, it's more unique.
- 3:15And you would think that you'd be able to associate it better
- 3:18with what that person does. But people do forget all the
- 3:21time. Like, which one?
- 3:22You know, the people have been working with us for years.
- 3:24Which one is which one is crew again?
- 3:26It's. Just different enough, you know,
- 3:28it is just outside the norm enough.
- 3:30You know, before we started this, I was talking to you.
- 3:32It occurred to me your name Addison Rex.
- 3:35And then one other podcast guest I'd had Matthew Justice, both
- 3:38perfect. Either superheroes or super
- 3:41villain names. Like, yes.
- 3:43And like the fact that you could have gone to Doctor Rex or
- 3:46something. But yeah, I guess you had to be.
- 3:48I think about that a lot. Yeah.
- 3:51I've always felt like it was, you know, it's, I kind of feel
- 3:53about it like remembering Gladiator when Maximus homie
- 3:58says that is a great name. You must kill your name before
- 4:02it kills you. So AD crew was my escape hatch
- 4:06for sure. Now I don't have to write a book
- 4:07or become an actor or something. There you go.
- 4:11We did not come here to just talk about names.
- 4:13So Wine Spies for the listener at home who has not had the
- 4:18pleasure of checking out wine spies, what is it?
- 4:20And yeah, start there and we'll go from there.
- 4:24Yeah, absolutely. Yeah, an increasingly smaller
- 4:26population. Glad to say Wine Spies is
- 4:29beginning out there. We've been doing it for 18
- 4:31years. So it's pretty wild now that I'm
- 4:34going out in the real world and, you know, people have heard of
- 4:37us are like, oh, I love Wine Spies, But put simply, we sell
- 4:40one different wine every day. So it's a traditional flash sale
- 4:43site in that way shy away from that term.
- 4:46I'm proud of it. It's a hard work to bring 365
- 4:50different wines to you guys or our operatives as we like to
- 4:53call our customers every year. So it's a 24 hour sale, clock
- 4:57strikes midnight, brand new wine goes up and then our little
- 5:00secret sauce, besides all of our code names and spy magic is we
- 5:04have a feature called lockers. And so you can basically
- 5:07aggregate purchases together over time.
- 5:09So buy 2 bottles a day, one bottle tomorrow, 3 bottles two
- 5:13months from now. And then when you get a full
- 5:15case, you can ship that for free a lot.
- 5:19There's not, we don't have a ton of competitors, but those that
- 5:21we do, many of them are, you know, buy 6, get free shipping.
- 5:26So that's kind of the big, the big deal.
- 5:28That makes it much more accessible because you can take
- 5:30a flyer on a $50 bottle. Maybe you don't want to spend
- 5:34300 bucks on a wine you haven't tasted.
- 5:36But hey, this, this, this looks really pretty interesting. 70%
- 5:39off the day. I'll, I'll try a bottle.
- 5:42And then we, we only sell wines that we love.
- 5:45That's the other benefit of the model.
- 5:47You can really curate, hyper curate the selection because
- 5:49you're only putting that one wine up.
- 5:51And it's not like a giant store, you know, where you have to have
- 5:53thousands and thousands of skews.
- 5:55So you know, the wines are always great.
- 5:58So it's very sticky because people get their wine and you
- 6:01know, if they're all good, you know, you might come for the
- 6:04deal and then stay for finding wines that you had wouldn't have
- 6:07otherwise found yourself. OK.
- 6:10Yeah. So you've got a couple of
- 6:12different pretty powerful levers there.
- 6:15You have the daily instantiation of FOMO one day discount.
- 6:21Get it while it's here. It's going like and.
- 6:25The Bobo is real too. It will be gone, and it might.
- 6:28Sell out that day, Yeah, no, it it does sell out for those
- 6:32listing. You know you can, you can see it
- 6:34and then when it's gone, it's gone.
- 6:36Sometimes it will show back up right But not we try to.
- 6:41We have to, you know, we play a hard guessing game where we try
- 6:43to buy exactly what we need for the day.
- 6:45And sometimes we go a little bit over and it might appear in the
- 6:48store for a few days like a month later, but it's usually
- 6:51very small quantities. But yesterday, I mean, we sold
- 6:54three different cabs from the same producer and every single
- 6:57one of them sold out. We sold all three out before
- 7:00noon. And those are like, they're
- 7:02gone. That's it.
- 7:03That's never coming back. There you go.
- 7:05Yeah, you have that. And you have a mechanism where
- 7:11you can kind of turn purchasing discounted items like into a
- 7:15game. You know, it's like, like, you
- 7:17know, level up, you're getting XP points, the bottles.
- 7:20And then when you get to 12 you you level up or but you get the
- 7:23free shipping instead of leveling up.
- 7:26Yeah, no, totally. And I mean actually that's why
- 7:28you say that because we've we've got a really, really
- 7:32enthusiastic audience. I mean our operatives are, you
- 7:35know, super fans and we've really been wanting to add on
- 7:38some actual bragging rights and that kind of thing.
- 7:42Coming soon, we think you'll start.
- 7:44Seeing it seems like it's only a step to like the tin case badge
- 7:48and you're like. Yeah.
- 7:49Yeah, you know the the, the Super operative.
- 7:53Yeah, and they deserve it. We have legit super operatives.
- 7:56We we launched a Facebook group last year, which you know, we
- 8:00didn't necessarily expect to amount to anything.
- 8:02And it turned into this amazing community.
- 8:04And I'm not just saying that because of the pod.
- 8:06It's like it's so cool getting to interact with everybody.
- 8:10And now we've got a stable of moderators from our, from our
- 8:13operative audience and they're just, you know, they're just
- 8:17great. Like, you know, they, we're, we
- 8:18don't have a brick and mortar. We have an awesome HQ here in
- 8:21Petaluma, but it's not necessarily open to the public.
- 8:24And people are like, hey, can we come hang out with you guys?
- 8:26So, you know, now they just come and kick it.
- 8:29We do the pasting together. We had two guys come out last
- 8:32Friday and it's just, it's so fun.
- 8:35I mean, you know this guy, you know, now just for just for fun
- 8:40produces, you know, like content for us all the time.
- 8:44He he made us all custom hats. You know, it's like.
- 8:49Yeah. It's so cool.
- 8:51Yeah. Shout out operative, Operative
- 8:53Mark Stevens. Thank you man.
- 8:54That's awesome. Yeah.
- 8:55I mean, that is, you know, kind of the pro and con of the
- 8:59Internet business. You, you don't have a space.
- 9:02The Pro is you don't have a space.
- 9:04So everywhere is your space kind of thing.
- 9:06Yeah, you mentioned the curation elements, 365 days, 365 wines,
- 9:15they all have to be good. How do you ensure that that
- 9:18happens? Yeah, they taste a lot of bad
- 9:22wine. Yes, for sure.
- 9:23That's. The truth every Friday is, is
- 9:26our tasting panel. That's the one day that we're
- 9:29actually all physically in office too.
- 9:31Funny how that works. Bust up with the wine and
- 9:33everyone shows up. But you know, there's anywhere
- 9:35between 20 to 40 bottles on the table.
- 9:39And obviously by the time that they're there, there's probably,
- 9:44you know, there's been many conversations have we've
- 9:46investigated them. You know, it's gone through a
- 9:49little bit of a curation process, but you don't know
- 9:51until you taste it whether it's going to work.
- 9:53So, you know, there'll be as many as 10 different agents
- 9:57sitting around the table of varying levels of wide knowledge
- 10:00and competence from, you know, super expert master of wine
- 10:05level to just guy off the street kind of thing, which I think
- 10:09really works to our benefit, having all those different
- 10:12opinions and palates. And it's not like it's it's
- 10:15democratic, it's not a vote. It's more just a consensus
- 10:19emerges and again, because people, you know, there's the
- 10:23Italian guy, there's the Burgundy lover, you know, I'm
- 10:26the Zen, the basic, the basic bitch Zen guy and you know, big
- 10:31red blood guy. You got to have your Zen guy.
- 10:33Yeah, man, I feel the niche very well.
- 10:35Let me tell you, man, it's funny because it's like sometimes like
- 10:38my Zen palette I think is more representative of what people
- 10:43that like Zen 4 enjoy versus our wine buyers.
- 10:48Incredibly knowledgeable and super professional in terms of
- 10:51his ability to taste things from a professional lens.
- 10:55And yet, you know, he's got a very, you know, it's a more
- 10:58esoteric educated palette in that way.
- 11:01And so the Zens that he might find more interesting are might
- 11:05not necessarily be the ones that someone that was excited to
- 11:09click on that Zen. That's why they got it.
- 11:10You know what I mean? Sure.
- 11:12No, sure. Yeah, so I'm overcomplicating
- 11:15it. The the first step is that we
- 11:17taste the wine and we we, we come, we like the wine.
- 11:19It can't have any flaws. It can't.
- 11:21That's the lowest bar to clear. It's very obvious.
- 11:24Did anyone get sick? No.
- 11:27Right. Yeah.
- 11:28Does this taste like crap? But there are objective faults
- 11:31that wines have, you know, smoke, taint this oxidized, you
- 11:36know, there's tons of things that can happen.
- 11:39You're answering the question, why are they discounting this?
- 11:41You know, why are they giving us this deal?
- 11:43Is it because they want to move product or is it because they
- 11:45want to get rid of product? Well, so I mean, back in the
- 11:49day, that is for sure true. That's where people would first
- 11:53go to discounts, especially when that started that that it's
- 11:57still this whole model did not exist.
- 11:59You know, in 2007 when Wine Spy started, that was kind of like
- 12:02there was us and and Wine Woot and that was it.
- 12:07And so now there's a bunch of different reasons.
- 12:11One of the big ones is just end of vintage.
- 12:14So if you've got your wine out in distribution, you can imagine
- 12:18that, OK, it's on all of these different wine lists and
- 12:21hundreds of different restaurants that have carried
- 12:24this wine and it says 2017 Sauvignon Blanc.
- 12:27Well, now it's time for the 2018.
- 12:29If you just run out of wine, that restaurant goes to, goes to
- 12:32reorder and it's just not available, your sales machine
- 12:36breaks down super quickly. So before you actually run out
- 12:39of inventory, you want to start switching over to the next one.
- 12:44And so very often there's a couple of pallets of a
- 12:46particular skew left and that's what's very convenient to just
- 12:51move all that at once after you've done your distribution
- 12:54switch to the next vintage. So that's a very big one, you
- 12:59know, and, and a good example of why why a winery might be in the
- 13:02position of selling perfectly good wine for less than they
- 13:05might have otherwise gotten right.
- 13:08Another one which is always a good reason is cash is great to
- 13:12have, you know. Payrolls Friday you.
- 13:15Know exactly and we buy a lot of wine so it's a volume sale far
- 13:19more than do we buy the kind of wine the distributor would buy.
- 13:22So that is a big reason. But another reason, which is,
- 13:25you know, took 20 years to build but is now a very real reason,
- 13:29is marketing. You know, we've got an audience
- 13:32of genuine wine lovers who are far from just wanting to buy
- 13:37cheap wine. They actually want really high
- 13:40quality, expensive wine. And because they buy so much
- 13:43expensive wine, they want to make sure they're getting a good
- 13:46deal. And they also want to check out
- 13:49stuff that they might not have otherwise have heard of
- 13:51themselves. So, you know, we sell this wine
- 13:54one day and then it's gone. So oh, my God, I love this wine.
- 13:58It's the best I've ever had, you know?
- 14:00Who made this again? Producer, I want more.
- 14:03Well, you can't get it from wine spies.
- 14:05So you know that that's something that over time, it's
- 14:08now word of mouth, You know, we work directly with hundreds of
- 14:12different producers and more and more and more.
- 14:15It's like XYZ Winery just ran a sale and started getting a ton
- 14:19of calls afterward. Had a great time.
- 14:21Do you want to sell? Do you want to buy any of our
- 14:23wine and sell it? So yeah, the squat wheels
- 14:26definitely spun up that way in terms of the sourcing.
- 14:29No, no, that's great. I mean, just kind of going back
- 14:31through those. I was kind of thinking when you
- 14:33were talking about that vintage change.
- 14:36If you are a winery, and if you want to really infuriate some
- 14:40conscientious and attention to detail heavy Psalms out there,
- 14:45don't do what wine spies says. Send out mixed vintages like I
- 14:50have no joke from smaller distributors ordered wine over
- 14:53the course of three weeks and gotten old vintage, new vintage,
- 14:57old vintage on different deliveries.
- 14:59And like you can always tell the smaller guys that may not have
- 15:03fully functioning systems of rotation.
- 15:06Yes. And you know, I would say the
- 15:08good thing about America is about 9095% of people don't
- 15:12care. Yeah.
- 15:13I mean, you know, unlike Europe, we have a lot of stability more
- 15:18or less in growing conditions. Yeah, there's variation, but
- 15:21California is usually pretty hot.
- 15:22Usually things go pretty well for the large percentage of what
- 15:25you see from California. Like there's not a huge amount.
- 15:29There are fires, there's there's variability for sure, but a lot
- 15:34of the mass market stuff is marketed and also mass produced
- 15:37like you like you just don't see a lot.
- 15:39But for 5%, some people care and some people, like, really care.
- 15:44I tend to agree. I mean, it really depends on the
- 15:46style of the winery. Like, for example, you know, a
- 15:49place that specializes in blends like kamis.
- 15:52Kamis is going to taste like kamis pretty much every year,
- 15:55and they can blend towards that target.
- 15:57If you're dealing with like a single vineyard, you know, tiny
- 16:00pork and Pino, then yeah, it's going to it's going to change
- 16:04more. And we do sell, you know,
- 16:05upmarket very expensive single vineyard stuff all the time.
- 16:10I mean, broadly agree with what you're saying, which is that
- 16:13there's not as much variation. The main thing that I think
- 16:16people end up caring about for our DTC consumers is more just
- 16:20that we sold this wine that happened to have this 98 point
- 16:23score. The next vintage just doesn't.
- 16:26And typically what happens is, is that, you know, we place an
- 16:30order for this wine, they're like, oh, we thought we had X
- 16:32amount an inventory, but we're actually like 3 cases short.
- 16:37Can we replace that with the subsequent vintage which hasn't
- 16:39even received scores yet? So but people are tend to be
- 16:43pretty cool about it. I will say that doesn't happen
- 16:46too often, but. Sure, sure.
- 16:47And, you know, I think on that note, it'd be good for us to
- 16:52say, like, have you ever heard of Kelly White?
- 16:55Kelly White I don't think I have.
- 16:57Wine writer for Guild Psalm. She just wrote a book, Wine
- 17:00Confident in her her old book Napa.
- 17:03I forget the full title, but it's like 1000 pages on Napa.
- 17:06It's crazy, Yeah. Cool.
- 17:09Wine Confident is more consumer focused, yeah.
- 17:11No, I know her. And yeah, one of the things she
- 17:15says is wine loves its contradictions.
- 17:16So like, trust me, anything we say here, you can always find an
- 17:20example of the option that's one.
- 17:21Of the true. Good things about wine.
- 17:23It's one of the terrifying things like everything I said
- 17:26immediately fell apart when you say what?
- 17:28Single vineyard or small production, right.
- 17:30For sure. Absolutely.
- 17:31Yeah, yeah, cuz. That's actually such a big
- 17:34challenge. And I mean, I think one of the
- 17:36reasons why so many of the wine pundits that are trying to
- 17:38really, I break down the challenges that wine's currently
- 17:42facing, they just always get it wrong.
- 17:45Not because what they're saying in particular isn't correct and
- 17:49well founded, but because there's three other completely
- 17:52legitimate variables and perspectives that also have a
- 17:54massive impact. You know, and, and it's, it's
- 17:59such a giant landscape of wine that people tend to gravitate
- 18:04their lens, myself included, you know?
- 18:07Yeah. And I mean, it's, it's a hard
- 18:09question to even begin to answer.
- 18:11What does it mean to know why? And the closest that I've gotten
- 18:15to an acceptable answer that I can live with is to be fully
- 18:19aware of how much you don't know and like, which is like the
- 18:23worst way to define your field. It's like I know for sure that I
- 18:27am not good with the sub regions of China.
- 18:30Like take the. Master Sam test.
- 18:32I am failing that section. I know that.
- 18:34And the more you know, the less you know.
- 18:36I mean, it's, it's hilarious because I mean, I'm keenly aware
- 18:40of this fact because I'm surrounded by so many people
- 18:44that are just orders of magnitude more informed than I
- 18:47am. And yet I've been doing this
- 18:49professionally for 20 years and like, you know, run this company
- 18:52and do pretty good. And there's a bunch of esoteric
- 18:57information, specific one involved in that.
- 19:00And if I talk to somebody outside the industry, they're
- 19:02like, you know, I can answer any question that they have, you
- 19:05know, pretty much. But then you get into the world
- 19:08of wine. It's like, how do you how does
- 19:11my our wine buyer Agent Noir, we have two agent Roti as well,
- 19:14both of them incredibly knowledgeable.
- 19:16So I don't want to give the routine short shrimp, but I
- 19:19mean, I just am constantly like impressed.
- 19:22How do you know that like on the other side of this tiny CLO of
- 19:26this obscure Bordeaux vineyard that no one knows about is this
- 19:30other, you know, much more prestigious place?
- 19:32It's like, how can you keep all this stuff, you know, like in
- 19:36your head At the same time, I just, I can do that with movies.
- 19:41I don't know why I could do that with wine.
- 19:44Yeah, well, I mean, wine fulfilled 2 loves of mine that I
- 19:47knew. You know, as a kid I always was
- 19:51just such a nerd. I did well in school.
- 19:54But on the other side, I like to sneak out and party.
- 19:56You know, it's just like it had alcohol and it had.
- 20:00Learning. And like those two, when they
- 20:02combined, it's like, OK, I can do this, You know, it gives me
- 20:05something to do with a glass of wine in hand.
- 20:08Yeah. That's why I sold similar origin
- 20:10stories there. Well, I did.
- 20:12I did want to click on that because I you know, it's easy to
- 20:16joke about your taste and you say like I'm the typical sin
- 20:19drinker, basic like which fair enough.
- 20:23I'm just going to speak from experience.
- 20:24Prisoner Camus since pay my bills so I love them.
- 20:28Totally. How did you begin to develop
- 20:32your chase? Because you you weren't always
- 20:33at wine spies. You worked in the wine industry
- 20:35beforehand too. Yeah, so my family's winery is
- 20:38Deerfield Ranch. That is definitely where my
- 20:41palate came from. You know, it's right in the
- 20:43middle of Sonoma Valley. If you're unfamiliar, it's it's,
- 20:46I mean, it's a pretty notable Sonoma Valley winery at this
- 20:48point. We got 23,000 square foot cave
- 20:51tasting rooms right in the center of it.
- 20:53So, you know, it's it's been going since 82.
- 20:55It's a real operation. And Robert Rex is my father's
- 20:58brother, my uncle, and he's the winemaker.
- 21:00And that's kind of how I made that choice early on to get into
- 21:04wine in the 1st place was I was like, oh, this is an option.
- 21:06I'll do that. You know, and Robert has always
- 21:10had since the very beginning, blending philosophy, which is
- 21:13that, you know, basically every single varietal as its own
- 21:17ingredient and they all have something to bring to the table.
- 21:20And you don't make a soup with just one ingredient.
- 21:23You know, at the very least you're adding salt.
- 21:25And I and I just think that that's so right.
- 21:28And I think, you know, you could, there's just no matter
- 21:30how good a single over idle expression is of terroir, it
- 21:33might be interesting, you know, from kind of an educational
- 21:37point of view to delve into the expression of that particular
- 21:43vineyard or whatever. But I think that that wine could
- 21:46probably have been made better with the addition of something
- 21:49else. And so I just, you know, almost
- 21:52every single one of Deerfields wines and they would do
- 21:55everything from, you know, like Pinot to Rees laying.
- 21:59I mean, it's we do the whole gambit.
- 22:01There's way too many skews that we do, but every single one of
- 22:04them is a blend. I don't think there's a single
- 22:06one that's not a blend. And I really just, and my uncle
- 22:10doesn't talk so much about and making wine about different
- 22:13flavor compositions. Instead, he talks much more
- 22:16about structure and the shape of wine.
- 22:18And that had a huge impression on me where I'm really looking
- 22:21for a full mouthfeel. I want, I want a full mouthfeel
- 22:24and I want it to be as complex and interesting as possible.
- 22:28And I just think that every varietal has its own tanning
- 22:31expression and structure in your mouth and they hit different
- 22:35spots. And so, yeah, I really, I really
- 22:38kind of just grew up in that mindset set.
- 22:41And very often it's those kinds of those kinds of experiences
- 22:46which, you know, for me are most often to be found in your kind
- 22:50of big, big crazy blends. Yeah, and it helps.
- 22:54I also like the the the creativity that it allows you
- 22:57for where you've got all your board over idols.
- 23:00But then, you know, screw it, we're going to throw a little
- 23:03bit of Zin in there too, you know, just to give it that nip
- 23:05pallet lift. Like I love that you can do that
- 23:08and not be as constricted. Yeah, Now it it helps having
- 23:12that freedom in America. It adds its own issues because
- 23:16there's, you know, no solutions in life, only trade-offs, I
- 23:18believe. Well, I love that.
- 23:21Yeah. Like, you may have that freedom,
- 23:24but you know, there is an assurance of typicity in the old
- 23:28world where there are laws where, like, you may not be able
- 23:31to blend Zen In and Bordeaux, but you always know you're going
- 23:34to get a Bordeaux Blend. You always know about what it's
- 23:37going to taste like. I I do like when you were kind
- 23:41of talking about your family's blending philosophy, it made me
- 23:45think of something I've been noticing more and more.
- 23:47I've noticed it first with bartenders, the ones that kind
- 23:51of call them the mixologists are like like that construct
- 23:53cocktails. I can always tell the people
- 23:56that are truly deeply passionate about it.
- 23:58Most people, you know, average Joe on the street, you ask them
- 24:01what they drink, what they like. It's usually a binary thing.
- 24:05I drink whiskey. I don't my drinks a Manhattan.
- 24:08You like one thing, whereas when you start talking to bartenders
- 24:11that construct cocktails, they they talk about like I need
- 24:14something for the attack the middle, you know, like you break
- 24:18it apart. And I think I would only assume
- 24:19that blending would give you sort of a similar.
- 24:22And I love craft cocktails for that exact reason.
- 24:25That's definitely like my other interest in in.
- 24:27I wouldn't call it a passion for me because I don't spend some
- 24:30time doing it. But when I go to a bar like that
- 24:33is what I enjoy. I had very rarely drink wine at
- 24:36a bar. You know, In fact, I would say
- 24:38never partially actually due to the challenges around selection,
- 24:41right? But I mean, I just, that's, it's
- 24:44so fun for me because you are able to just have that blank
- 24:48canvas of a beverage and those kinds of bartenders that you're
- 24:52saying that you're passionate about, you always, always,
- 24:54always immediately identify them because their eyes light up when
- 24:57you say, I'm feeling like this. I want something like that.
- 25:00And they can really like kind of try to figure out that puzzle
- 25:04and actually want to do it rather than just be like this
- 25:06guy. Quick story.
- 25:08I was in Florence last year for Vin Italy which is super fun.
- 25:12Well, I've never been, but it looks fun, yeah.
- 25:14It is so fun. Four 400,000 wines in four days.
- 25:18Not that I had 400,000 wines in four days.
- 25:21I was. Just agent crew.
- 25:22That was crazy. But so we were staying in
- 25:26Florence afterwards and there was this one bartender that was
- 25:31at we went there every single night because the first night
- 25:34I'm like, this is the coolest bartender ever.
- 25:36And we got to know him and ever for a few days.
- 25:38And I told him about my obsession with Peaky Blinders.
- 25:41And I'm like, I need you to make the perfect Tommy cocktail, like
- 25:46captures his essence. And he spent two nights, he told
- 25:51me like sleepless, couldn't figure it out.
- 25:54Was just like trying so hard to work on it.
- 25:57And then a light bulb went off on his head.
- 25:59And the next day I came and he was he was smoking a cigarette.
- 26:04And all I did was he poured a glass of whiskey.
- 26:07And then he got the smoker out. And it has little, you know, cup
- 26:10where you can put whatever you want in there to smoke it.
- 26:12And he just put his cigarette in the smoke and then just used his
- 26:16cigarette to infuse the whiskey with cigarette smoke.
- 26:20It sounds, it sounds disgusting, but honestly, it was just like,
- 26:24yeah, this is it. What else could Thomas Shelby's
- 26:26drink? Let's get a cigarette.
- 26:29Yes, as a note to the kids at home, nicotine toxicity is a
- 26:34thing. It is very easy to reach that
- 26:36threshold if you infuse it into spirits.
- 26:39So just like be careful this this was done by professionals
- 26:41at Finn, Italy. Not not not for your amateurs at
- 26:44home. For sure.
- 26:47I I do have to ask because I noticed that directly behind you
- 26:51is the golden ratio. Like is balance just something
- 26:55you like to remind yourself of? Did you pick it because it looks
- 26:58pretty? My father My father is actually
- 27:00an architect. Cool.
- 27:02And so I've always also loved design and I definitely did not
- 27:06want to, you have to be super passionate about being an
- 27:08architect to actually want to go down that road.
- 27:11And I, I saw architecture close enough that I knew that wasn't
- 27:13the thing that I was going to spend my time doing.
- 27:16But I really definitely have a deep appreciation for it.
- 27:19And the golden, the golden ratio is definitely overblown when it
- 27:25comes to how it's actually applied to architecture.
- 27:27There's a lot of myths around that.
- 27:29But it's still a very cool thing.
- 27:31And I do love it. And I designed my my dad's
- 27:34businesses logo and it's based on the the golden ratio.
- 27:38So there's a little history there.
- 27:40But also, yeah, that's pretty. No, I mean, that's cool.
- 27:42I mean, yeah. And you know, it's probably good
- 27:45for the listener at home. The golden ratio, if I remember
- 27:49correctly, it was the ancient Greeks that discovered it.
- 27:53So if you look at your hand, you can actually see it.
- 27:56The length of the larger like knuckle compared to the smaller
- 28:01one is the golden ratio. And it holds true throughout
- 28:04your whole hand. You see it all through nature.
- 28:06And yeah. Pine cones and stuff like that.
- 28:13Yeah, I mean, it's weird. And I mean like you can you can
- 28:16overlay it on a lot of famous buildings.
- 28:18And I think that rather than there being a real attempt to
- 28:25implement it, it's that it's a naturally pleasing shape to the
- 28:29human eye that. People just if you make
- 28:30something that looks nice, it might end up being that ratio
- 28:33kind. Of exactly yes.
- 28:36Well, because, you know, we didn't evolve in a vacuum.
- 28:39We we grew up as a species in nature and nature has to have
- 28:44some rule of thumb and so might as well pick one where the
- 28:47bigger things related to the smaller and the same ratio just
- 28:50makes sense kind of replicate and.
- 28:53Yeah, totally. That would a couple.
- 28:54Million years later, yeah. And I mean, actually it's super
- 28:57close to, you know, the ratio that I'm looking at you on my
- 29:00screen right now, you know, like this letterbox.
- 29:03And it was just kind of it it's yeah, it probably is because
- 29:07because, you know, we're creatures of nature and have
- 29:10observed it. And yeah, pretty cool, man.
- 29:12Hey, I should have gotten my wine glasses.
- 29:13My kind of podcast. Wine and philosophy, alright.
- 29:16Yeah, Hey, no. Well, I mean, go back to wine.
- 29:20You know, your dad being an architect, which is something I
- 29:22don't think I realized. It does make sense why you'd
- 29:25have such a propensity to look for structure when it comes to
- 29:29wine blends. You know, I feel like people
- 29:31always kind of grab the metaphor from their life that makes
- 29:34sense. And like if you're, if you're
- 29:36dealing in a round construction, not a terrible spot to begin.
- 29:41It's an interesting observation. I mean, I, I actually think
- 29:43there might be some legs there, you know, because there's a
- 29:45certain type of person that's a lot more poetic, you know, and,
- 29:50and they lean in a lot more to the descriptors, you know, that
- 29:54kind of are whimsical. That's how they like to enjoy
- 29:57wine, you know, and a little bit.
- 29:58Then there's people that are more like storyteller kind of
- 30:02thing. And like, that's really their
- 30:04entry to a glass of wine and and you can tell that it really
- 30:08matters to them, you know what, what went behind getting this
- 30:12wine into their glass for them to really get the most enjoyment
- 30:15out of it. So yeah, maybe I'm more of that
- 30:18kind of structure building kind of guy that that actually is my
- 30:23passion. This HQ that I'm sitting at, we
- 30:25bought bought this building a few years back and I've just
- 30:28been playing Mrs. Winchester, going like room to room and
- 30:31remodeling it and making it all super crazy and cool.
- 30:34That that that blank thing right there is actually a fish tank
- 30:37that's covered up right now. Cool, cool, cool.
- 30:40The fish are there, so that will be a saltwater reef tank
- 30:42shortly. But that's I just love design
- 30:44and it's so much fun. That's my hobby.
- 30:46Cool, cool, cool, cool. So I feel like we left the
- 30:51tasting a little bit early. We kind of went on a side note
- 30:54there. So it's just consensus.
- 30:56There's no voting. There's no has there ever been
- 30:59like a tiebreaker when you're deciding one person's rooting
- 31:02for a wine? Everyone else is like, I don't
- 31:04know. Yeah, I mean, I guess at the end
- 31:06of the day, I'm the tiebreaker, but the truth is it happens
- 31:09quite rarely. So first, you know, the first
- 31:12thing hurdle has to clear is do we love this wine?
- 31:15Genuinely love it as a group? Is this a good wine?
- 31:17Is it representative of whatever this wine is trying to be?
- 31:21That's super important for us. And then if the answer to that
- 31:24question is yes, and many wines that we taste do not pass that
- 31:28bar, then it's about the economics.
- 31:31So we go, we're like, all right, this wine is would be, you know,
- 31:36a good deal to our operatives at this price point.
- 31:40Can we go and meet that? And I think that, you know, so
- 31:44the the answer to that question might subsequently be no.
- 31:47And there's very, you know, so there's very often we love this
- 31:50wine. We can't sell it because the
- 31:52money's not right. So both of those questions.
- 31:54Have no scarecrow. Yeah.
- 31:58You know, and those we have, we do very, very occasionally get
- 32:02those kind, you know, we've sold Screaming Eagle, we have sold
- 32:05Scarecrow. You know, obviously discounts
- 32:07are going to be much lower. What what we, what we, we hang
- 32:11our hat on is, is that we are going to be the best price that
- 32:14you can get that wine in the world that day.
- 32:17And so that might be a dollar less than what it's out there
- 32:20for very frequently. It's, it's more than that.
- 32:22But you know, we just, we're going to be the best price you
- 32:25can get it. And so if it's Scarecrow, OK, we
- 32:27might have gotten you, you know, the we might have gotten it to
- 32:30you for $370 instead of $385 is what which is a screaming.
- 32:35Deal, yeah. Right.
- 32:39I've tried to buy it for a while.
- 32:41I'm in the middle of Omaha, NE, so we get like 3 bottles once a
- 32:44decade and that's about it. So yeah, it is.
- 32:48Hard out. There allocations are definitely
- 32:52a thing, yeah. Totally.
- 32:54You're subject to them too. Sure.
- 32:56It's so funny how that end of the spectrum for the California
- 33:00wine industry works. Yeah, I'm sure it's even more
- 33:04the Wild West than out here. You're right there.
- 33:08Yeah. And it's it's a.
- 33:09Very regulated state I'm sure. I can only imagine.
- 33:13Yes, we try to cross our TS and dot our is for sure.
- 33:16But no, I mean, honestly, just on the on the industry side, I
- 33:20mean, it's, you know, everybody, every brand kind of has a
- 33:23different outlook on it. And, you know, I think that some
- 33:27are much more aware of Wine Spies as a genuine marketing
- 33:32opportunity, like we were talking about earlier.
- 33:34And some producers up and down the spectrum of notability just,
- 33:38you know, don't get that. And and and and conversely,
- 33:43producers up and down the spectrum do get that.
- 33:45So, you know, that's there's a reason why we'll have wines on
- 33:48the site that people are shocked that we can get.
- 33:50It's like, yeah, they know that Wine Spies is actually a great
- 33:52place to showcase these wines. And then it's a it's, you know,
- 33:57it's highly competitive and there's distributors and
- 34:00shifting allegiances and, you know, people come and go.
- 34:03It's, it's, it's fun. I mean, that keeps it very
- 34:06interesting. There's.
- 34:07Definitely wild, Wild West out there.
- 34:09Yeah. I mean, it is.
- 34:12It's a cool idea. If I'm a winery, I stand behind
- 34:16my product. You know, I feel like a lot of
- 34:18success in business comes downstream of being able to find
- 34:22customers, being able to find someone to buy your stuff.
- 34:25If you stand behind it and think they'll buy another, why
- 34:28wouldn't you take the discount, actually get paid to get
- 34:31customers? You're like.
- 34:32That's a good. Win win proposition.
- 34:34Yeah, totally. You know, and I mean, like if
- 34:36you think about it, you know, we, you know, we, we don't often
- 34:40buy a line below the cost that it took to produce it.
- 34:43So, you know, they're always making some money, but as you
- 34:46say, you're making some money and getting the best marketing
- 34:50you can get. You know, I mean, even very
- 34:54notable brands that, you know, think that they're just
- 34:58ubiquitous, that is simply not the case.
- 35:01You know, probably in reality like 80% of the the wine
- 35:05drinking audience that would seriously consider buying your
- 35:08wine has never heard of you. If you're enjoying this so far,
- 35:12please take a quick moment, hit that subscribe button.
- 35:15All right, back at it. It's interesting too.
- 35:19I did want to ask you a couple of different directions and feel
- 35:22free to take it either way you want.
- 35:24I was hoping to ask you either about trends and drinking and if
- 35:28you've seen any changes with kind of the low and no
- 35:32development that we've been seeing.
- 35:34But I also very interested in what it's like to run a business
- 35:38where you're shipping wine to, I'm assuming 50 states, but
- 35:42probably not all 50 states because some don't allow wine
- 35:44shipments. Like, navigating those legal
- 35:47hurdles seems like a nightmare to me.
- 35:50It's like, either way, I'm happy to talk.
- 35:53Yeah. Yeah, 2 super different
- 35:54questions there. Obviously, the whole, the whole,
- 35:57you know, no low thing. First of all, I think it's a
- 35:59convenience for the industry to lump those into the same
- 36:03category. I think that they're like really
- 36:05different in terms of what people want from the experience.
- 36:08No alcohol versus low alcohol. We, you know, I, I think that
- 36:12the low alcohol phenomenon makes a lot of sense for people that
- 36:16really like and want to enjoy wine for the same reason they
- 36:20might gravitate towards old world wines in the 1st place,
- 36:23because they're lower alcohol. You know, you're definitely
- 36:25having less glasses of, you know, 17% Dry Creek Zin.
- 36:31You know that at 11.5% burgundy for sure.
- 36:35That's an interesting point. Like that's the lunch with a
- 36:38glass of wine versus a lunch with a martini.
- 36:40It's going to be a way different outcome.
- 36:42Way different and people know that.
- 36:45And so that you know, and so when you're talking about like
- 36:47sub 10% wines, we've experimented like one of our
- 36:51favorite winery partners is Julian Fayard and, and he came
- 36:55out with a selection called like Le Chardonnay and stuff, which
- 36:59varietal line and they did not get a warm reception on our
- 37:03platform, which we were kind of surprised about.
- 37:05So that was like my only one direct market test that I can
- 37:08speak to beyond just kind of being a general industry
- 37:11observer. And you know, it's really hard
- 37:12because a lot of these things get conflated.
- 37:15It's like, what was it the product positioning where you're
- 37:18trying to make it like a fun party wine instead of the
- 37:20serious wine because Ferrara is a serious winemaker.
- 37:24You know, maybe that had an impact on it.
- 37:26People had an expectation that it's going to be, you know, a
- 37:29more frivolous wine drinking experience, whereas maybe what
- 37:33they want is, you know, the real deal, but just less of the the
- 37:37buzz. One glass instead of two or
- 37:40something, Yeah. Yeah.
- 37:42And then the whole no alcohol thing is just, I think a
- 37:45completely different category because you know that that makes
- 37:49total sense. If someone like wants to have a
- 37:52wine drinking experience but doesn't want to have any
- 37:55alcohol. The problem there is, is that
- 37:57they just, they suck. I mean, I, I have tried these
- 37:59four years continuously and I'm always checking it out to see
- 38:03where it's at. And I mean, like, you know, even
- 38:06as, as you know, recently, the only thing that I've ever had
- 38:09that remotely approximated like an actual wine was Savio Savio
- 38:17Blanc. That's the only thing I've had
- 38:19that's kind of gotten like right, never a red wine remotely
- 38:22approaching it. And I've had no alcohol beers,
- 38:26you know, that are shockingly good examples.
- 38:31I will raise by hand, have you had caliber from Guinness?
- 38:34Yeah, no, I have. That I will drink that by
- 38:37itself, it's good. It is.
- 38:39Percent, like I like it and that's what people want.
- 38:41They're like, I want a Guinness, but I got to drive or whatever
- 38:43or, you know, XYZ reason. But I love Guinness and I want
- 38:48to have the flavour of Guinness in my mouth.
- 38:49No 100, it's, it's phenomenal. And there's a whole bunch of
- 38:52different examples of, of beers hitting that spot And they, they
- 38:55figured out pilsners a long time ago and loggers.
- 38:58And now they've figured out more complex stuff like Ipas and
- 39:01things. And the there people have tried
- 39:03so many different techniques and approaches for wine.
- 39:06And I, I'll be the first person to welcome it when someone does
- 39:09a, a competent pinot or a cab. I've just simply not had it yet.
- 39:13So I think for the serious is sorry to go on about it, but
- 39:16like, I think for the people that most want that is people
- 39:20that love wine, want wine in their glass, but they just for
- 39:24whatever reason, don't want the alcohol experience while you're
- 39:28checking none of those boxes, you know, And so people see the
- 39:32trends of these things are supposed to like mocktails.
- 39:35And then the wine industry and particularly the more corporate
- 39:39side of it is like, oh, no, we're losing share of throats
- 39:42are ready to drink beverages and craft cocktails.
- 39:44And now there's this whole Nolo thing.
- 39:46What am I going to do? Let's, you know, pour a ton of
- 39:48money trying to pump up this, you know, Nolo brand.
- 39:51And then the consumers get the product at Trader Joe's and
- 39:54they're like, oh, this is horrible.
- 39:58Yes, yeah, yeah. You know, the thing I've found
- 40:02missing from all the no lows is always like it is the alcohol
- 40:08mouth fill itself. Like that's the hard part about
- 40:11it. If you're going to imitate that,
- 40:13what are you imitating it with sugar, right.
- 40:15You know, and if you're doing that, but that's, that's a
- 40:18tough, tough line to walk too. Totally.
- 40:21There is one. Have you tried liars, LYRE,
- 40:25apostrophe S? It's only in a can, which is the
- 40:28downside of it. They do a sparkling wine best
- 40:32I've found. It's actually what I serve in my
- 40:33restaurant. But them and like the other
- 40:37flavors they have, it's the after taste like you, you know,
- 40:41the after taste of alcohol. It has a very distinct finish
- 40:45and it's it's the other part that I haven't found anyone's
- 40:48been able to imitate well. I will try it.
- 40:51I mean like listen, I I mean what I said.
- 40:52I'm not a hater. If someone could and then great.
- 40:55I'm really, I don't worry about these kind of threats to the
- 40:58industry just because wine's been around for, you know, 4000
- 41:01years and it's not going away anytime soon.
- 41:04And I mean, you know, I've, I've known people that have worked in
- 41:07restaurants, been in bars, been managers while being pregnant
- 41:12and wanting people to know and like, that's a great case.
- 41:15I've known people that have either given up drinking and
- 41:17I've known quite a few who should you know, having those
- 41:20options is. Champagne toasts being the one
- 41:22person that doesn't have the oh. You got a glass of cranberry?
- 41:26Like sure, OK, cool. It's.
- 41:27A bummer man, I totally get that.
- 41:29Yeah, exactly the. Other side of it too, and this
- 41:32might be improving and this is a total anecdotal story, but you
- 41:35know, the education aspect of the people that are selling it,
- 41:40you know, like I remember I was in New New York City and it went
- 41:43into this, this store that was only sold non alcoholic
- 41:47beverages, but they were all, you know, alcohol replacement
- 41:50beverages and it was a big store.
- 41:52They had like. Like 200 skews and there are two
- 41:55people working there. They're like super New York
- 41:57hipster looking people. And I'm like, you know, I'm on
- 42:01the wine industry and they have like a good like 100 different
- 42:04wines to choose from. I'm like, my question was pretty
- 42:06simple. What is your most authentic
- 42:09tasting red wine here? And both of them looked at me
- 42:14completely blankly. And they're like, I don't know,
- 42:15I don't drink, so I don't know what wine is supposed to taste
- 42:19like. And I'm like, OK, well, can you
- 42:22just point me at 2 bottles at your customers and said they're
- 42:24good. They're like, I guess like,
- 42:26these are OK. So I bought both of them to
- 42:30check them out. They were on both immediately
- 42:33down the sink, like not even remotely approaching
- 42:36drinkability. You know, it's like, all right,
- 42:39well, you're going to have a big problem if your customer base is
- 42:43is people that that love wine and for whatever reason can no
- 42:46longer drink it with alcohol in it.
- 42:48And then the people that are selling it are just not those
- 42:51people. For sure, For sure.
- 42:55Yeah. And you know, it makes me think
- 42:57I've thought this for a while. It's like, I think, I think we
- 43:01might look back in 20 years and realize that perhaps we were
- 43:04approaching the problem incorrectly.
- 43:07I, I talked to the guy that runs a bar above and he actually
- 43:11teaches a class for bartenders on constructing non alcoholic
- 43:15cocktails. And the way he puts it is if you
- 43:19start thinking that you're replacing booze, you're starting
- 43:24off losing. But if you think of like a
- 43:25classic drink, you have 3 ounces of fluid and in a normal drink,
- 43:302 ounces of that is taken up by default by alcohol.
- 43:34But if you no longer have that constraint, you actually have 3
- 43:37oz you can do anything with like you can you.
- 43:40Like, I don't know if what we should be doing is imitating red
- 43:43wine, right? Maybe we should be making some
- 43:46new like, that's why I really respect the rise of things like
- 43:48kombucha. Like maybe there's something
- 43:50that actually can fill its own space that we don't need to
- 43:53make, like an alcoholic kombucha, you know, like, or
- 43:55super alcoholic booze, you know, like.
- 43:57I strongly agree with this attitude.
- 43:58That is the direction to look, you know, and I'm like, I think
- 44:01mocktails, for example, are wonderful.
- 44:03It's like you want to have something interesting and fun in
- 44:05the presentation. The only difference is, is that
- 44:08I just don't want to pay $3 less than my $20 cocktail for a
- 44:12mocktail because we know that the reason you're charging me
- 44:15$20.00 for this ridiculous beverage is because it's
- 44:17supposed to get you drunk. So you know, and the, we all
- 44:20know what the markups are on this stuff.
- 44:22So why don't instead, you know, you charge me $10.00 for your
- 44:26mocktail and then and I will gladly do that.
- 44:29And I and I completely think that your head is in the right
- 44:31place. Like it's, we need to stop
- 44:33trying to recreate alcohol. It's impossible.
- 44:36And instead say like, what is the purpose of having this
- 44:39beverage at this moment and approach it that way to be, as
- 44:43you know, much of a fun experience for that moment.
- 44:46Yeah. And I do think too, it also
- 44:48points that I think there's another issue, the low offering
- 44:52that you had that just didn't go over well on wine spies.
- 44:57It was even thinking, you know, when Psalms people in the
- 45:00business, when we talk about low alcohol wines, we usually will
- 45:04use the shorthand of like food friendly.
- 45:07Are you like like we even have to we don't describe them as low
- 45:11alcohol, high acid. It's always food friendly or
- 45:13like, you know, refined, like we're missing the words to
- 45:16define, like the words that are going to unlock it and make it
- 45:19acceptable and the thing that people turn to too.
- 45:22I think you're on the right track there and that and that's
- 45:25why I was saying it could have been a confound about the way,
- 45:28you know, the packaging was positioning it as, you know, the
- 45:31the fun party beverage. It's like, no, well, maybe
- 45:33people specifically want to have that same level of, you know,
- 45:37sophisticated experience. They just want to be able to
- 45:40have three glasses instead of 1. You know, you know, you're 100
- 45:45and 100 LB woman, you know, like 1 glasses of, you know, you
- 45:51know, 15% is, is, you know, is going to put you a little bit
- 45:56over where you want to be at that moment.
- 45:58But you want to be able to continue to your lunch and take
- 46:02a sip the whole time without running out of your Chardonnay.
- 46:04It makes perfect sense. And I mean, yeah, I think you're
- 46:07on to something. There's a reason why old World
- 46:08wines are often described exactly that way.
- 46:12And also that we figured out many years ago how to talk to
- 46:15the American consumer about Old World wines, you know, and food,
- 46:19food friendly, being one of those.
- 46:20Things and to be honest, it's still not working, but we're
- 46:22trying like, like the, the problem is the old world wines,
- 46:26they're food friendly, yes, but they also, they decided to label
- 46:29them all in German, French, Italian, like and no American's
- 46:32going to try to pronounce any of that.
- 46:35Yeah, I, I was thinking as you're talking about the lady
- 46:38drinking 3 glasses of 15% alcohol.
- 46:41It's something I do and I've never actually talked to anyone
- 46:44about this. When I think about something
- 46:46like that with like 3 glasses of high alcohol wine one day,
- 46:51probably two years ago, I looked at it and I thought if I have
- 46:55three of these add that up, that's 38%.
- 47:00And then I realized would I like that's basically 40% that's
- 47:03basically vodka. Like would I drink this much
- 47:06vodka? I remember that was when I like,
- 47:08I had one. I'm like, I'm good today.
- 47:11Or think about it in beers, like if you have 3 glasses of 15%
- 47:14wine, OK, that's 9 beers, you know, like if it's like 5% beer.
- 47:20So yeah, I mean, it makes total sense, like to have that kind of
- 47:24alternative. And that's why I, again, I'm not
- 47:26a hater at all. I mean, I think that there's a
- 47:28place for all of this stuff. But kind of getting back to the
- 47:31initial thrust of the question, which is like, oh, am I
- 47:34concerned about, you know, these kinds of things, You know, like,
- 47:38every single year it's some sort of new doom and gloom.
- 47:41Like, you know, when White Claw came out, it's like seltzer is
- 47:44destroying the wine industry and Dry January is destroying the
- 47:47wine industry. Not ready to drink beverages,
- 47:49destroying the wine industry. You know, Gen.
- 47:52Gen. Z is drinking spirits.
- 47:54It's like, OK, all of these things can be true.
- 47:57And it's also true that for all of history, when people got
- 48:01older, they started discovering and falling into the, you know,
- 48:05discover the joy and love of wine.
- 48:07You know, imagine, imagine my surprise now that the
- 48:11millennials are getting older, they're drinking more wine.
- 48:14It's like, who could have ever predicted?
- 48:17But every time, yeah, what? What was old is new again.
- 48:21Yeah, I do feel like you got a point that the wine industry is
- 48:24capable of destroying itself. It does not need any outside
- 48:28force. It will.
- 48:29It'll chew you up and eat you out on its own, so don't.
- 48:32And there were, you know, when I was, when I was, when, when my
- 48:35uncle got his license in Sonoma County, there's like 300
- 48:39licensees. Now there's something like like
- 48:4210,000 licensees, you know. And so is it, is it, is it
- 48:47really the fact that the sheriff thread is dipped down, you know,
- 48:50like 3% and then we're seeing this insane retraction and it's
- 48:55hard out there for small producers, which is happening
- 48:58that it's hard. Could it possibly be the fact
- 49:00that these corporations like Constellation and vintage Wine
- 49:04estates have continuously gobbled up these small
- 49:07properties until they become huge, unwield, legalized so that
- 49:11they're unable to efficiently operate and so that they're just
- 49:14not paying attention, divesting or going bankrupt and they're
- 49:17getting split up. I don't know, maybe it's those
- 49:19things as well. Well, I think, I think on that
- 49:22theme of what is old is new again, look to the European
- 49:26Union, they had subsidies, their vineyard area exploded and now
- 49:32they have the vine pool scheme. And so opportunity incentivizes
- 49:37growth, growth incentivizes more growth.
- 49:40And then all of a sudden we have a sea of Trebiano and no one to
- 49:44buy it. And what are you going to do?
- 49:47Yeah. Totally.
- 49:48Then that's. Our constellation right there.
- 49:50You're never going to end that. And rather than just, you know,
- 49:53thinking the sky is falling, I mean, should you in fact, you
- 49:56know, do things to react to change?
- 49:58Like of course, but what you shouldn't overreact.
- 50:01I mean, you know, the whole Moscato craze is like, is like
- 50:05we see, you know, like on paper, there's a lot of annual reports
- 50:10that, that wineries look at for trends.
- 50:12And then it's like, OK, there's like 3% growth in Cabernet, but
- 50:16Oh my God, there's 17,000% increase in people drinking
- 50:20Moscato, you know, and it's all, and then people start spilling
- 50:24ink all over the, the wine press about it and, and it's like, OK,
- 50:28well, 17,000% increase over what, you know, like it was such
- 50:32a small fraction. And then the next thing you
- 50:34know, everybody is, you know, planting Moscato instead of
- 50:38Solomon Blanc, you know, and then it takes two or three years
- 50:42for those grapes to come online, you know, and all of a sudden
- 50:46there's just this insane glut of Moscato in reaction now. 4 year
- 50:52old fads everyone. I said stop tricking Moscato and
- 50:57I was like Oh no, we got to RIP this out and plant piot Grigio.
- 51:02It's just like it's comical in the extreme.
- 51:04But also, you know, every individual decision kind of made
- 51:09sense in that chain. It's just when it happens at
- 51:11scale and people are just, you know, hyper reactive to whatever
- 51:16trends are that I think you just get these wild swings.
- 51:20Yeah, well, I mean, I feel bad for the wine industry and I feel
- 51:25like I at least get a smaller view of the problem they're
- 51:29facing. Like so I I run a steakhouse in
- 51:32Omaha and we have to protect out an order and we don't get the
- 51:37steaks in house. We we get those pre packaged and
- 51:39sent to us from a contractor and like the amount of work, the
- 51:44amount of weeks worth of data that we compile to put together
- 51:48what we think we will need to order is intent.
- 51:50I mean, it is our senior kitchen manager's main job for the week.
- 51:54Like because we can't run out of steaks and you know what, we
- 51:56don't want to throw away steaks. Yeah, so.
- 52:00How often that's get like what's your how, how often you know,
- 52:04what's your overage underage and how consistent are you on it,
- 52:08you know? We will.
- 52:09So we look back for the previous four weeks.
- 52:13We have a big Excel sheet we put on all that because we do about
- 52:17six to seven different cuts. Then we add on a couple butchers
- 52:20cuts to just as features. We will always predict that we
- 52:24are going to grow about 10%. Last year.
- 52:27We put on what we have on hand and then we submit it.
- 52:31We get it one, one shot a week. We order about 10 days out and
- 52:35we kind of ride the wave and make it happen.
- 52:38It's super interesting. I mean, because you know, we
- 52:40selling one wine a day for 18 years, we've got, you know, a
- 52:43mountain of data. And the number one thing that we
- 52:47have to do similarly to your steak situation is make sure
- 52:51that we don't under buy, right? You know, because if we could
- 52:54have sold more wine and we absolutely should have.
- 52:56But if we overbuy because of the one wine a day model, you know,
- 53:00it's a big problem. And you can imagine if we cut,
- 53:03you know, $100,000 and end up selling $50,000 of that in one
- 53:07day, you know, you do that a bunch of times in a row.
- 53:10How long can you sustain that loss?
- 53:12Yeah. Right, so you got to make these
- 53:15bets correctly and you know, just, you know, just like your
- 53:19executive chef there, you know, that's basically, you know, our
- 53:22job is to to to be excellent prediction machines there and
- 53:25get that right. And we've, you know, spent lots
- 53:28of money over the years trying to do data science on all this
- 53:33stuff, hiring pH DS, you know, and as AI ramps up, just always
- 53:37throwing this data set at, you know, the latest model and
- 53:40saying, like, give us next week's predictions.
- 53:42And what's so cool is you can back test it against your
- 53:46actual. So you could go and look at your
- 53:48actual covers. You could have you know you can
- 53:50throw whatever you your Excel sheet is at the thing and try to
- 53:54predict next week, but then use that same model to go and test
- 53:58against past weeks. Would this have served me well
- 54:03or not? And see what the actual
- 54:05predictive validity of it was over time.
- 54:07And anyway, that's a long story to say that still to this day,
- 54:12us humans are much, much, much better at predicting how much of
- 54:16A given wine we should order. Any algorithms, models we've
- 54:19been able to figure out. And for us, it's because there's
- 54:22so many independent variables. It's like the label, the the
- 54:26producer, the wine maker, the score, you know, And then
- 54:29similarly to you guys, I'm sure it's like, what's the vibe out
- 54:33there? Like, you know, are people you
- 54:35could tell in your town? Are people feeling festive and
- 54:38going out? Did everyone decide, you know,
- 54:40at this Christmas, let's just stay in, you know?
- 54:43Yeah. But those X factors that are
- 54:45hard to capture, like Christmas Eve is something that a, that a
- 54:47robot can capture. But just knowing the general
- 54:50sentiment of your community next week, like, you know, I'm
- 54:53feeling holly jolly and going out or people feeling close to
- 54:57home. Did this New Year's come with
- 54:59the Does your particular community feel like, hey, you
- 55:03know, let's tighten our belts around here or like, screw it,
- 55:07New Year's resolutions are for suckers?
- 55:10Yeah, I'm trying to remember, I think it was Morgan Hassell that
- 55:14said that the problem with big data is the problem with all
- 55:19like prediction errors. It all comes from the past and
- 55:22so like you only need one novel event.
- 55:25COVID and the best data analysis in the world just did not catch
- 55:30it. It was something novel.
- 55:31And also data sets will skew for what's in the data set
- 55:35obviously. So, you know, we sell a lot of
- 55:38cabs and so if you ask it what, what varietal should we sell,
- 55:43you know, even after you normalize, it's still like you
- 55:47should sell cab. And so then you sell more cab
- 55:50and then you ask it, you know, two months from now what should
- 55:52we sell? It's like you should sell even
- 55:53more cab. And then, you know, then a year
- 55:55from now, you know wide spies only selling cabs.
- 55:58Just like the robots told them to.
- 56:00Yes, I think. Prophecies.
- 56:02I forget the guys name. I think it was George Box.
- 56:05Maybe George Fox is a British statistician.
- 56:08That said, all models are wrong, some are useful.
- 56:11He's like, this is a good, good rule of thumb.
- 56:15Yeah. So.
- 56:16Yeah, I think that's wise. I do want to.
- 56:19I want to make sure we talk about it because I am
- 56:20fascinated. I can only imagine the
- 56:23logistical nightmare that shipping wine in the US is.
- 56:27It's like you have 50 different little countries.
- 56:29Yes. And actually I say 50, but I
- 56:32want to be clear, I'm sure you don't ship to some because I'm
- 56:34sure there's somewhere may not be legal maybe maybe I'm wrong.
- 56:37Too. No, that is correct.
- 56:39OK, Yeah, it caused the challenge.
- 56:41And I highly encourage anyone that loves wine to go support
- 56:45Free the Great, which is, you know, the Tom Work who's the
- 56:49president of the National Association of Wine Retailer
- 56:52that's been his pet project for years.
- 56:54And there's, you know, there's the wholesale lobby, which most
- 56:57people don't even know the term 3 tier in the general public.
- 57:00But almost every single wine that you drink and certainly at
- 57:04a restaurant has been brought to you courtesy of the three tier
- 57:06system, which is going for a producer to a distributor, to a
- 57:10retailer. Those are the three tiers and
- 57:12then to you and the retailer might be the restaurant.
- 57:16Everyone gets a cut too, so it increases the price as well.
- 57:20Everyone takes their pound of flesh on that and that process
- 57:23and the wholesaler in particular takes a very large pound of
- 57:26flesh. And that is really a legacy
- 57:30model of the the Prohibition era where right after a prohibition,
- 57:36there was, you've probably heard of Tide House laws.
- 57:40And so basically like there was a lot of distillers that owned
- 57:44the actual salons or wood forest, the saloon to only sell
- 57:48their particular whiskey, for example.
- 57:50And so a lot of these like situations on the ground right
- 57:55at the end of prohibition were codified into the system that
- 58:00persists today and that greatly benefits the wholesale tier.
- 58:05And consequently, after 100 years, they've got all of the
- 58:08money, you know, and there's really only, you know, the
- 58:11Southern, Southern Glazers Republic breakthrough, There's
- 58:14very few of them. Southern Glazers is the giant
- 58:17juggernaut. And so they're just a really,
- 58:20really, really powerful lobby. And they want to make sure that
- 58:23everything goes through that distribution chain rather than
- 58:26you being able to buy wine from whoever is selling it from the
- 58:30producer and stuff. So it's a super asymmetrical
- 58:33war, but that we're on the side of the righteous for sure, and
- 58:37the side of the consumer. And there's constantly Supreme
- 58:40Court cases that are being testing this over time.
- 58:44But it's actually a super interesting legal question
- 58:47because the Commerce Clause, which forces 50 states to
- 58:50operate with basically the same trade laws.
- 58:54Are you Interstate travel or not?
- 58:55Yeah. It's that that that that does
- 58:59not apply to alcohol in the same way because as.
- 59:03Prohibition. Yeah.
- 59:05At the constitutional amendment level.
- 59:08And so in these cases are being constantly decided in different
- 59:11ways, like the different appellate courts have taken
- 59:14wildly different positions on it.
- 59:16So there's hope that the Supreme Court will take up a important
- 59:20case on this this year again. But yeah, we'll see.
- 59:24In the meantime, free the grapes and just following Tom work is
- 59:28the best anyone can do. And, and, and being vocal about
- 59:31it because I mean, seriously, it is a massive disservice to the
- 59:35wine drinking community, you know, as it sounds like you're
- 59:38well familiar with it. Yeah, well, it's so it's an
- 59:41interesting thing because I do want to make sure that the
- 59:43listener who may not be familiar with the history here, like Tide
- 59:47House laws do serve a purpose, that there was a lot of
- 59:51corruption. There was a lot of nasty stuff
- 59:53that happened pre prohibition. Like there's a reason that some
- 59:56of these laws came into effect. Like if you run the distillery
- 1:00:00and you also are running the bar, you are incentivized to
- 1:00:03make sure whoever's in the bar serving as much whiskey as they
- 1:00:07physically can. And you have people getting just
- 1:00:10trashed and all the societal ills that led to prohibition.
- 1:00:15No it. Was.
- 1:00:16Yeah, it was answering a problem. 100 years.
- 1:00:20Ago the solution. It's like, you know, the whole
- 1:00:22thing about democracy, it's the worst form of government.
- 1:00:25It's just better than all the others like.
- 1:00:26Totally. It it solved an issue and you
- 1:00:29can actually see what it's like without this.
- 1:00:31Like the UK still has tight houses still like they've had
- 1:00:35fights with pubs over brews, like, so it's not something that
- 1:00:40you know is inevitable as societies.
- 1:00:43Yeah, continue. I totally agree that these are
- 1:00:46like the same kind of, you know, high level challenges as you see
- 1:00:50Thomas Soul, you know, no solutions, only trade-offs.
- 1:00:52That is of course all true. And yet, you know, we are in a
- 1:00:56circumstance now where there are there is there is both
- 1:01:00regulation which is not law, you know, and legislation on the
- 1:01:03books, which is 100 years past its sell by date.
- 1:01:06And the Tide House law specifically, you know, says
- 1:01:09that that that no producer shall give a retailer a thing of value
- 1:01:13is how it's designed, how it's described.
- 1:01:16Well, in the 21st century, you know, that's come to say things
- 1:01:19like a thing of value could be a social media post.
- 1:01:22So if you're a small winery and you've made a placement that
- 1:01:25dusty bottle shop, you know, in in Kentucky can't even say like,
- 1:01:30hey, guess what Deerfield wine now available at your local
- 1:01:33retailer. That is considered a thing of
- 1:01:35value under tied house laws. And and also because the
- 1:01:38enforcement mechanisms it's so you know, they're so hard to do
- 1:01:42this at scale. Very many of the individual
- 1:01:45states ABC's alcoholic beverage controls.
- 1:01:47They just go extremely hard in the paint in terms of being
- 1:01:51punitive. When they catch it, they.
- 1:01:54Didn't force it all. So when they just decide, OK,
- 1:01:57I'm going to make you the pariah and absolutely nail you to the
- 1:02:00wall for sure. It's like that's.
- 1:02:03Right, while I was defending their source, trust me, I was
- 1:02:07not going to side with it because the the solution we
- 1:02:11landed on created this three tier system and in a lot of ways
- 1:02:15it created a legal bully that wants to keep down the smaller
- 1:02:20guys like the big distribution channels want to stay the big
- 1:02:23distribution channels. And anywhere that I've been that
- 1:02:27has had local ordinances where you can have local beers, have
- 1:02:31local wides, like relaxing the distribution laws in terms of
- 1:02:35local or like easing things up, it has been a net positive.
- 1:02:38Santa Fe, where I'm from, they just, they changed the license
- 1:02:41where you instead of like $1,000,000 a liquor license or
- 1:02:45something crazy, you can now buy a special one where it's all
- 1:02:48local spirits and local brews. Yeah.
- 1:02:50And they've had an explosion of different local spots.
- 1:02:52It's like that's that's hard for you know, you know, and.
- 1:02:57And I mean, like, look, I'm actually, we were very
- 1:03:00spiritually aligned here because, you know, I also love
- 1:03:03to play devil's advocate and there's no one-size-fits-all
- 1:03:06solution. Like for like the lobbying
- 1:03:08question. Like I was just complaining
- 1:03:10about how the wholesaler have all the money and so they're
- 1:03:12able to get, you know, their version of the legislation
- 1:03:15usually put into practice. You know, that is true, but also
- 1:03:19how else are you going to do it? They started cracking down on
- 1:03:23the fulfillment houses themselves because many
- 1:03:25producers, large and small ship from the same consolidated
- 1:03:29fulfillment companies and they realize, oh, this is where all
- 1:03:31the wine is. Let's go make them licensees.
- 1:03:34And so the the Uniform Commission Code, which is a non
- 1:03:38governmental body, which is as the wonderful intent of saying,
- 1:03:43hey, we got 50 states, let's not have 50 completely different
- 1:03:46sets of worded laws. Your state can come grab the
- 1:03:50Ucc's suggested legislation on this and we'll do the research.
- 1:03:55And and so you're, you know, you're a little tiny state
- 1:03:58Assembly office doesn't have to do it.
- 1:04:00Great idea. What happens, You know, the
- 1:04:02wholesale is like if we just get the USDC to adopt this suggested
- 1:04:07legislation there it's going to be and copy and paste it quickly
- 1:04:10amongst 7 different states, which is what's happened.
- 1:04:13But now what's the alternative? Well, someone has to write the
- 1:04:16suggested code. Who should do it?
- 1:04:18Well, certainly it should be the people that have the most
- 1:04:21interest in it because they're the ones that are knowledgeable
- 1:04:23about it, you know, So that's where it really is.
- 1:04:26There's no end to this game. But hopefully Tom, that's what
- 1:04:29I'm saying. Like, hopefully Tom Work got
- 1:04:31enough momentum to get the UCC to listen to the retailers when
- 1:04:34they were drafting that at that time, you know?
- 1:04:37I've got two ways to respond to that.
- 1:04:39One, it is the liquor industry's form of the end of Stranger
- 1:04:44Things. No one's gonna be happy.
- 1:04:46And I wanted to bring us back to the beginning where we said wine
- 1:04:50loves its contradictions. So a thread through all of this.
- 1:04:54But a perfect way to end it. I'm not gonna lie, this was by
- 1:04:57far my favorite part I've ever been on.
- 1:04:59I really enjoyed it. Yeah, thanks.
- 1:05:01It's been a pleasure. Well, agent crew for the
- 1:05:04listener at home, where could they go to find out more about
- 1:05:06you? Wine spies, figure out what
- 1:05:08you're doing and watch for the sale.
- 1:05:11Yeah, absolutely. Wine spies.com, it's the place
- 1:05:13to be. Also available in the iOS App
- 1:05:15Store. Android coming soon maybe.
- 1:05:17But yeah, it's an awesome deal every day.
- 1:05:19We write insane amount every single day about the wine.
- 1:05:23So at the very least it's fun to take a look, see and learn a
- 1:05:27thing or two about a wine you never heard of.
- 1:05:29Really appreciate you got. Me on of course and you know, go
- 1:05:32online by the time you listen to this, there might be an option
- 1:05:35to become a super operative so yes, yes.
- 1:05:39Actually, very possibly that is true.
- 1:05:41So, yeah, Andrew, thank you very, very much.
- 1:05:43Agent Crew, it was a pleasure and thank you again for
- 1:05:47listening to Serves You Right. Episodes of this show come out
- 1:05:51every Tuesday and Thursday. If you have not had a chance,
- 1:05:55please go and check out the website servesyourightpod.com.
- 1:05:58You can find all past episodes and a contact form in case you
- 1:06:03need to get in touch with me and soon so much more.
- 1:06:07All right. That's about it.
- 1:06:10Thank you.