Latest / Legally Speaking with Michael Mulligan / Employment Law, Language Rights, and Wildfire Liability
Transcript
- 0:00Adam Stirling: It's time for Legally Speaking, joined as always by barrister and solicitor, with Mulligan Defense Lawyers Michael Mulligan.
- 0:05Adam Stirling: Morning, M michael, how are we doing?
- 0:08Michael Mulligan: Hey, good morning.
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: I'm doing great.
- 0:09Michael Mulligan: Always good to be here.
- 0:10Adam Stirling: Interesting items that are on the agenda for today.
- 0:13Adam Stirling: First, wrongful dismissal.
- 0:14Adam Stirling: It says Notice legislation, contracts and the common law.
- 0:18Adam Stirling: Sounds like it's complicated.
- 0:20Adam Stirling: That's a mouthful, it is so complicated.
- 0:23Michael Mulligan: That's a mouthful it is.
- 0:24Michael Mulligan: So this is a brand new court of appeal decision in BC, and it's a case that involves a claim of wrongful dismissal in the sense of not providing enough pay in lieu of notice.
- 0:38Michael Mulligan: And the way that works is this when somebody works in a non-union job is this when somebody works in a non-union job, just like a person, an employee is free at any time and for any reason to quit and go do something else.
- 0:52Michael Mulligan: The same is true for the employer.
- 0:55Michael Mulligan: The employer is free to fire an employee at any time for any reason they see fit.
- 1:01Michael Mulligan: But there is this concept of notice, and that really comes in two different ways, and how much notice or pay in lieu of notice is required, and so there is a both at the provincial and the federal level.
- 1:21Michael Mulligan: There are acts that deal with employment, and they would set out an amount of notice that somebody would need to be paid as a minimum if they are fired without cause, and that's an important concept as well If an employee does something which would amount to cause for being terminated, let's say they steal something from their employee or engage in some other very serious conduct, the employee could be fired without any notice or pay in lieu of notice sort of as you would expect right.
- 1:56Michael Mulligan: If an employer finds an employee is stealing things, for example, you don't have to keep them working there, nor pay them to stop.
- 2:02Michael Mulligan: But if an employer is looking to fire somebody and they don't have cause to do so, they are required to provide either notice or pay in lieu of notice.
- 2:16Michael Mulligan: And the amount of notice that would be required, or pay in lieu of notice, and an employer could do either.
- 2:23Michael Mulligan: Right, an employer could come and say look, I'm terribly sorry, we've had a terrible business turned down.
- 2:28Michael Mulligan: I need to fire you for that reason.
- 2:30Michael Mulligan: But you know, I'm going to give you, you know, two months and you'll still work here for two months and that'll be it, if that was the amount of notice required.
- 2:38Michael Mulligan: Or they could say look, you're terminating.
- 2:40Michael Mulligan: Terribly sorry, business has taken a downturn.
- 2:42Michael Mulligan: I'm going to pay you for the two months and you don't have to show up here.
- 2:45Michael Mulligan: They could pick either, right, and how long that time period is has a minimum which is set by statute, both for jobs that are regulated provincially and those that are regulated federally, and that would come in the form of a provision in both the provincial and federal legislation which would calculate that based on how long somebody has worked there for, typically like the federal legislation, which is what's at play in this particular case, because the employee in question worked for Harbour Air Seaplanes and in that case that's federally regulated, and so there is a provision in the federal legislation that provides that once somebody has worked somewhere for a period of three months, they're entitled to two weeks wages or notice in lieu.
- 3:45Michael Mulligan: And if somebody's worked there longer, then there's a formula to calculate how much they would be due.
- 3:51Michael Mulligan: Somebody who's worked for more than 12 months continuously for an employer would be entitled to sort of a formula here about five days wages plus two days wages based on each year of employment, and so there's a little formula set out in there.
- 4:07Michael Mulligan: Now there's also a concept of notice or pay in lieu of notice, which would be referred to as the sort of common law amount of notice that would be required, and the idea there is that if somebody has an employment contract that doesn't say anything about how much notice a person would be entitled to or let's say there's no written employment contract at all, it's just those statutory provisions that somebody would be entitled to notice if an employer is terminating them without cause or again pay in lieu of notice, and that amount might be significantly greater than what is the minimum set out in the statute.
- 5:00Michael Mulligan: And a court would ultimately look at things like you know, how long did the person work there?
- 5:06Michael Mulligan: But they would also look at things like how specialized was the employment?
- 5:09Michael Mulligan: Could the person readily find other employment or not?
- 5:13Michael Mulligan: And so you could have somebody who might be entitled to much more notice at common law than what the statute would provide, depending on their circumstances Interesting and here the person who was fired, and they had a fairly senior position there.
- 5:29Michael Mulligan: They were somebody who worked as a manager, I think, in terms of maintenance.
- 5:34Michael Mulligan: They were paid $170,000 a year, plus benefits, dental insurance, long-term disability, life insurance, hospitality and tourism perks, and then an executive bonus which, for a couple of years, had been in the neighborhood of $84,000.
- 5:49Michael Mulligan: The person had worked there starting in May of 2017, and they were fired through no fault of their own in March of 2020 as a result of the COVID pandemic.
- 6:02Michael Mulligan: Not too many people were flying on seaplanes in March of 2020.
- 6:06Michael Mulligan: And so Harbour Air played them off.
- 6:09Michael Mulligan: They hadn't done anything wrong.
- 6:11Michael Mulligan: And the interesting thing there was that this senior employee had an employment contract which dealt with the issue of notice.
- 6:20Michael Mulligan: And the way they did it is that the employment contract said that the amount of notice a person would be entitled to under the contract was what they would be entitled to under the legislation.
- 6:34Michael Mulligan: And so the thing that arose there the employee and the harbour air paid them some $10,203, which was a couple of weeks' salary plus another five days, sort of a calculation under the federal legislation.
- 6:51Michael Mulligan: And the person went to court and their argument was well, hold on, I would be entitled to more than that at common law.
- 6:57Michael Mulligan: I had a senior job.
- 6:59Michael Mulligan: It would be hard to find equivalent employment, this sort of thing.
- 7:02Michael Mulligan: And so the issue became Is that provision in their contract, the one that says the amount you're going to get is the amount required by the legislation?
- 7:12Michael Mulligan: Is that enough to override that sort of common law presumption that you might be entitled to more than that based on those kind of factors Seniority, how long you've been there, for you know how specialized the job is, that kind of thing is that kind of thing.
- 7:31Michael Mulligan: And so the issue was and on this particular point.
- 7:32Michael Mulligan: The law is that if you're going to contract out of the common law presumption with respect to notice, that has to be done clearly in the contract, right.
- 7:41Michael Mulligan: The intention of the parties has to be clearly expressed that no, that's not what they're agreeing to and we allow people to do that.
- 7:47Michael Mulligan: Right.
- 7:48Michael Mulligan: You can't contract to something below what you would be entitled to under the legislation.
- 7:54Michael Mulligan: But you can contract for that amount, right, just like you could have a provision that would allow more, like if you could.
- 8:03Michael Mulligan: Let's say, some very specialized employee says look, I'll come to your well, come and work for you, but if you choose to fire me, I'm entitled to one year's salary.
- 8:11Michael Mulligan: Okay, well, both parties agree to that.
- 8:13Michael Mulligan: Fair enough, that's sort of how contracts work.
- 8:30Michael Mulligan: In the contract this that Harbour Air Group may terminate your employment at any time without cause, so long as it provides appropriate notice and severance in accordance with the requirements of the Canadian Labour Code.
- 8:38Michael Mulligan: That's what it read, and their argument was well, that wasn't clear enough and that argument did not succeed at the trial level, and so it resulted in an appeal to the BC Court of Appeal, and the Court of Appeal pointed out that there were some differing decisions in different provinces in Canada with respect to how that sort of similar language is to be interpreted, but they found in British Columbia.
- 9:05Michael Mulligan: This is the approach when you're assessing a contract, and I must say I like this sort of how the world should function.
- 9:10Michael Mulligan: It said, when a judge is interpreting a contract, it should be a practical, common-sense approach to contract interpretation.
- 9:17Michael Mulligan: It requires a judge to read the employment contract as a whole, consistent with the surrounding circumstances and factual matrix known to the parties at the time they entered into the contract.
- 9:26Michael Mulligan: What do these people agree to?
- 9:28Michael Mulligan: Was this a clear agreement?
- 9:30Michael Mulligan: And on that basis, given that sentence I read to you about, or that provision I read to you about what is required, they found that's just clear, you can read that.
- 9:43Michael Mulligan: And that was clear and unambiguous and that was what the parties agreed to.
- 9:46Michael Mulligan: And so, on that basis, found that the employee was not entitled to more than the statutorily required amount.
- 9:56Michael Mulligan: Another interesting thing arose, because the amount the person was paid became an issue about.
- 10:00Michael Mulligan: Well, was the $10,000 and something dollars?
- 10:03Michael Mulligan: Did that amount to his wages?
- 10:04Michael Mulligan: Because there is another section of that federal legislation that wages refers to quote every form of remuneration for work performed.
- 10:13Michael Mulligan: And so we made a secondary argument saying what about my bonus?
- 10:17Michael Mulligan: What about my travel benefits?
- 10:19Michael Mulligan: What about this and that?
- 10:21Michael Mulligan: And the Court of Appeals said well, that's not really before us.
- 10:24Michael Mulligan: You're arguing here that this was void because it was unclear, that this was void because it was unclear and so on that basis there could be some further negotiations about whether there'd be some entitlement to a portion of that annual bonus or how do you quantify the value of the medical benefits or other things that he received.
- 10:42Michael Mulligan: But I thought it was an interesting case from the Court of Appeal clarifying all those points, both in terms of when somebody could be fired and those different amounts of pay or notice.
- 10:52Michael Mulligan: And it could be either that somebody would be entitled to either under the statute or at common law those amounts can be different.
- 10:59Michael Mulligan: But the court found that that provision was clear, that the parties had agreed that in this case he was entitled to the employee was entitled to what the statute provided and not potentially the greater amount that he could have been entitled to had there been no contract or that clause had not existed.
- 11:17Michael Mulligan: So that's the latest from the BC Court of Appeal about wrongful dismissal and notice.
- 11:23Adam Stirling: Michael Mulligan with Mulligan Defence Lawyers.
- 11:25Adam Stirling: Legally Speaking will continue right after this.
- 11:27Adam Stirling: Legally speaking continues on cfax 1070, joined with michael mulligan by mulligan defense lawyers.
- 11:34Adam Stirling: Michael, what's next on our agenda today?
- 11:37Michael Mulligan: uh.
- 11:37Michael Mulligan: Next on the agenda today is a decision out of the supreme court of canada that just came out, uh last month uh, concerning language rights for trial.
- 11:46Michael Mulligan: Uh, that's been causing a bit of chaos in the criminal courts in BC as they sort out how to manage it.
- 11:54Michael Mulligan: And this arises out of a BC case originally and it was a man who was charged with sexual assault.
- 12:04Michael Mulligan: The man was francophone but he was bilingual and he wound up having a trial in English and he was convicted and then, on appeal for the first time, he raised the issue about not having been told about his right to a trial in either English or French pursuant to Section 530 of the criminal code.
- 12:27Michael Mulligan: Pursuant to Section 530 of the Criminal Code and that didn't get them anywhere in the BC Court of Appeal, but in the Supreme Court of Canada it most certainly did.
- 12:41Michael Mulligan: And that section of the Criminal Code Section 530, has some special provisions dealing with language rights and they go further than what you know.
- 12:47Michael Mulligan: If a person doesn't speak English, they have a right to an interpreter right.
- 12:50Michael Mulligan: We don't have people have trials where they don't understand what's going on, but there are some special requirements when somebody wishes to have a trial in French or English.
- 13:00Michael Mulligan: And those sections which changed a few years ago impose some obligations on judges to make sure that an accused person is aware of their right to choose a trial in French or English.
- 13:14Michael Mulligan: And In particular, they require now a judge to ensure that a person is aware of their right to have a trial in French or English.
- 13:25Michael Mulligan: Now you have to be able to function in that language.
- 13:28Michael Mulligan: If you don't speak French, you can't just to be mischievous, show up and say I want it in French and then have an interpreter.
- 13:35Michael Mulligan: But you know, even though a person might speak both French and English, as the accused of this case did, there's an obligation to tell them look, you can have a trial in either language.
- 13:45Michael Mulligan: Which do you prefer?
- 13:47Michael Mulligan: And if somebody makes that request prior to the trial being fixed, they have a right to it.
- 13:55Michael Mulligan: It's not discretionary.
- 13:56Michael Mulligan: If somebody comes along later, like, shows up at their trial for which they've been waiting for, you know, for months, and sort of pops in and says, oh, by the way, I think I'll go with French, I have to get rid of the judge and everything and find somebody who's bilingual or speaks French, then there's a matter of discretion.
- 14:12Michael Mulligan: But the other thing about this section the Supreme Court of Canada pointed out is that a previous version of it only required a judge to ensure that somebody was aware of their rights to a trial in French or English when the person didn't have counsel, sort of on the theory there that if a person has a lawyer, their lawyer is going to tell them you know, hey, if you want a trial in French, you have a right to that.
- 14:33Michael Mulligan: But the amended version of it does not provide that, and so a judge is required to ensure that a person knows about this.
- 14:43Michael Mulligan: And here there just wasn't any record that this man had been properly told.
- 14:47Michael Mulligan: Crown pointed to things like there's some fine print at the bottom of a form that the person would sign at the police station when they're being released talking about this.
- 14:55Michael Mulligan: But the Supreme Court of Canada said look, there's just no basis to believe that was understood or pointed out.
- 15:01Michael Mulligan: It is only in English on one side of the form that the person signed, and that wasn't enough.
- 15:07Michael Mulligan: Nor were other sort of generalized things that were talked about in court, and the Supreme Court of Canada found that the failure to do this tell a person about their right to choose language of their trial was jurisdictional and the effect was new trial, and so he will come back and have a new trial in British Columbia, presumably in French, after all of this, but it has caused a fair bit of disruption now in BC and, I imagine, other provinces dealing with.
- 15:39Michael Mulligan: Well, now what?
- 15:40Michael Mulligan: Because you've got thousands of people that are off in the system who may not have had a judge made sure that the person was aware of their language rights.
- 15:51Michael Mulligan: And so, for example, the BC Supreme Court is sort of there, everyone must show up in court and confirm this, which is producing chaotic circumstances of trying to get everyone, like all these accused people, into court to have this read to them.
- 16:07Michael Mulligan: And so courts are now in the process of sorting out.
- 16:10Michael Mulligan: Well, what does it mean for a judge to ensure that a person is aware of this Like?
- 16:15Michael Mulligan: Can they, for example, rely upon a written confirmation from an accused person, or could they rely upon a specific representation by counsel who says look, I've spoken to my client about this.
- 16:25Michael Mulligan: You know he has elected a trial in French.
- 16:27Michael Mulligan: You know, is that sufficient right?
- 16:31Michael Mulligan: Because it doesn't say how the judge has to ensure that a person knows about it, but the judge does have that responsibility to make sure that a person is aware of it, and it has to be done in a timely way, because if you tell the person too late in the process, it moves from the right to pick the language of your trial to you might get to have a trial of that language, depending on what the judge says.
- 16:52Michael Mulligan: The other thing which is interesting about all of this, of course, in addition to having to work through, how is the system going to just deal with this to make sure that language rights are properly dealt with and the accused people are aware of it and nobody's denied that, and how do you make that work?
- 17:07Michael Mulligan: The other element of it what about all the other cases that have gone before right?
- 17:12Michael Mulligan: Not only are there thousands of cases in the system.
- 17:15Michael Mulligan: Does this mean potentially appeals for all sorts of cases?
- 17:19Michael Mulligan: This mean potentially appeals for all sorts of cases where the person might have had a right to a trial in another language and they weren't clear in French, for example, and they weren't clearly told about that, and so it'll be interesting to see how that works itself out.
- 17:32Michael Mulligan: The courts are just still in the process of sorting out how that should happen in a procedural way to ensure that people are told about their rights while not doing it in a way that causes the entire system to go into convulsions.
- 17:47Michael Mulligan: Trying to line everybody up to tell them this and having the judge read them two pages of the criminal code Is that really what was intended here?
- 17:56Michael Mulligan: And so it's an example of how we're sort of in the process of sorting out you know how exactly to interpret what the Supreme Court of Canada has said, to make sure this is done, but done in a fashion that's efficient and doesn't breach anyone's rights.
- 18:11Michael Mulligan: All right, ladies from the Supreme Court of Canada, french or English, we've got four and a half minutes left, okay, well, one more case that people should know about, given the warm weather approaching uh and this was a bc supreme court judicial review of a decision, uh, involving a penalty and um recovery order under the wildfire act.
- 18:34Michael Mulligan: so this is important to know about if you're going to have a fire.
- 18:36Michael Mulligan: Yeah, uh, now that act and associated regulations set out a whole bunch of obligations on people depending on the kind of fire they're having and where it is, and so this particular case involved a fellow who was wanting to build a house up in northwestern BC and he was cleared a bunch of plant material off of the land and he was burning it to dispose of it, and it amounted to a quote, category 2 open fire, which is carefully defined in the regulations as a one pile not exceeding two meters in height and three meters in width, or two piles not exceeding two meters in height and three meters in width.
- 19:16Michael Mulligan: I'm not sure why you have to define both the one and two it seems to me you could have probably made that clearer, but in any case, and then there are a bunch of requirements to do, things like make sure the fire is safely extinguished.
- 19:26Michael Mulligan: This man had the fire and then it burned down to just smoldering embers.
- 19:33Michael Mulligan: He poured the evidence was 25 liters of water on the fire, 25 gallons of water on the fire.
- 19:40Michael Mulligan: Believed it was extinguished.
- 19:41Michael Mulligan: He then came back to the site over eight subsequent days, looked at it nothing was burning.
- 19:47Michael Mulligan: And then, sadly, 10 days after this fire, 11 days after the fire, he was driving by the property, noticed smoke, phoned firefighters and a quick, very quick from the bc wildfire crew.
- 20:02Michael Mulligan: They showed up there within uh like an hour.
- 20:05Michael Mulligan: The ground crews, helicopters, tankers, I think, boy, they put this thing out.
- 20:10Michael Mulligan: But the net cost was one hundred thousand six hundred and eighty dollars and twelve cents, uh, and the man was ordered to pay $100,000 plus a $3,000 fine and he appealed that decision and it got to this case, which was the judicial review.
- 20:32Michael Mulligan: And on the judicial review the judge found that the original decision, which had been reviewed by a commission, there's like a statutory appeal process.
- 20:42Michael Mulligan: They had made significant mistakes in terms of how they had the threshold that they had put on the man when determining whether he had done what was required to ensure that the fire wasn't continuing to burn, basically.
- 20:58Michael Mulligan: And so the judge on the judicial review found, first of all, they imposed a much higher standard on him than what was required.
- 21:08Michael Mulligan: Oh, you know the man in addition to pouring the 25 gallons of water on it, he dug into the pile with a shovel, didn't see anything burning, and then, of course, came back for eight days and nothing was burning.
- 21:19Michael Mulligan: I guess it was smoldering underground or somewhere that couldn't be seen, and then sparked up when winds came quite a while later.
- 21:27Michael Mulligan: Apparently, something can happen.
- 21:29Michael Mulligan: Apparently there are fires that smolder all year, like over the winter, and can then spark up again when they're underground.
- 21:35Michael Mulligan: So the judge doing the judicial review found that they'd imposed too high of a standard on the man and, in addition, the commission and the original decision maker had made just a factual mistake when they found that he hadn't there's no evidence about how far he dug into this thing to see whether it was out when there was in fact evidence before them that he dug two feet deep into the pile to ensure that it was extinguished.
- 21:59Michael Mulligan: And so, given what the man had done in terms of checking it, putting water on it, digging into it, coming back day after day and seeing nothing.
- 22:06Michael Mulligan: The judge on the judicial review found in this circumstance the man had done what he needed to ensure this fire wasn't going to spread.
- 22:15Michael Mulligan: But the big takeaway for people is you could have very, very significant financial liability for these things.
- 22:22Michael Mulligan: This was very fortunate that the fire service showed up so promptly, managed to get this thing put out.
- 22:27Michael Mulligan: Even at that it had burned several acres.
- 22:30Michael Mulligan: And so be very careful in the warm weather lest you find yourself on the hook for potentially $100,000 or more putting out a fire.
- 22:40Michael Mulligan: So whatever category of fire you have, and whether it's one pile or two piles, make sure that it's out and do everything that's required, or else you may find yourself on the hook for a very big bill.
- 22:53Michael Mulligan: So that's the Wildfire Act and regulations.
- 22:56Adam Stirling: Michael Mulgan, with Mulgan Defense Lawyers, legally speaking, during the second half of our second hour every Thursday.
- 23:01Adam Stirling: Michael, thank you.
- 23:02Adam Stirling: Thank you so much.
- 23:03Adam Stirling: Have a great day.
- 23:04Adam Stirling: All right, you too, take care.
- 23:05Adam Stirling: Quick break Back in a moment.