Latest / The National Debt Podcast with Fexingo: Treasury, Borrowing, and Long-Term Fiscal Outlook / How the Fed Pays Banks to Lend the Government Money
Transcript
- Lucas: So there is a line item in the federal budget that almost nobody talks about, and it is now costing us around three hundred billion dollars a year. I am talking about interest on reserves — the money the Federal Reserve pays banks just to park their cash overnight. Luna: Three hundred billion. That is more than we spend on the Department of Education. And most people have never even heard of it. Lucas: Right. And it is a direct consequence of how the Fed steers interest rates now. Instead of buying and selling Treasuries to hit a target, the Fed sets a rate on reserve balances — currently three point six five percent — and that is essentially the floor for short-term rates. Banks earn that on their reserves, and the Fed pays it out of its own earnings, which eventually flow back to the Treasury. But when the Fed is paying more than it is bringing in from its own portfolio, the Treasury has to make up the difference. Luna: So the cost of the national debt is not just the coupon on Treasuries. It is also this quiet subsidy to banks. And I have to say, listeners like you who follow these details are exactly why we keep this show ad-free. If you get value from walking through the economy with us, you can support us at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. It goes directly to production costs, nothing else. Lucas: And we genuinely appreciate that. Without listener support, we would have to take sponsors, and we would not be able to dig into things like the mechanics of the Fed's balance sheet. Which is exactly what we are going to do now. Luna: So, how did this become such a big deal? I mean, the Fed did not always pay interest on reserves. Lucas: No. Before 2008, the Fed did not pay interest on reserves at all. It used open market operations — buying and selling securities — to keep the funds rate in line. But when the crisis hit, the Fed created trillions of reserves through quantitative easing, and it needed a way to control rates without flooding the system. So Congress gave it the authority to pay interest on reserves, and that became the primary tool. Luna: So it was a crisis response. But now, even as the Fed shrinks its balance sheet, it is still paying on a massive pool of reserves. Lucas: Exactly. The balance sheet is down from its peak, but reserves are still over three trillion dollars. And with the fed funds rate at three point six three percent, the cost is enormous. The Fed paid out over one hundred seventy billion dollars in interest on reserves last year, and that is a direct hit to the Treasury's bottom line. Luna: And that is on top of the interest on the public debt itself, which is now over one trillion dollars a year. I mean, we just saw the 30-year yield at five point two seven percent, and the 10-year at four point seven five. So it feels like every corner of the borrowing complex is getting more expensive. Lucas: And that is the key. The national debt is thirty-nine trillion dollars, and the debt to gdp ratio is a hundred twenty-two point six percent. But it is not just the size of the debt — it is the cost of carrying it. And interest on reserves is a big slice of that cost that is easy to overlook because it is buried inside the Fed's remittances to the Treasury. Luna: Right. So when the Fed makes money on its securities, it sends it to the Treasury. But when it has to pay banks, it has to eat the difference, and that reduces what it sends. In some quarters, it actually sends a negative remittance — the Treasury has to foot the bill. Lucas: Exactly. And that is not hypothetical. We have seen negative remittances in recent years, and that is a direct line from the Fed's operating cost to the federal deficit. It is part of why the deficit, even though it narrowed to one point seven seven trillion in the last fiscal year, is still stubbornly high. Luna: So, is this something the Fed could just turn off? I mean, why not just lower the interest on reserves rate and save the Treasury money? Lucas: That is the question, and it gets to the heart of how monetary policy works. The Fed sets the interest on reserves rate to steer the fed funds rate. If it drops that rate too far below what the market would otherwise set, the funds rate could fall below target, and the Fed would lose control of short-term rates. That could feed inflation or create instability in money markets. Luna: So it is a trade-off. The Fed is essentially paying banks to keep the system stable, but that stability has a price tag that shows up in the debt. Lucas: And it is not just the Fed. The Treasury itself is borrowing more, issuing more T-bills and longer-dated debt to finance the deficit. And with rates where they are — the 2-year at four point two eight, the 10-year at four point seven five — every new auction locks in higher interest costs for decades. Luna: And we have talked before about the refinancing cliff, about the maturities. But this is a different angle — it is the ongoing operational cost of the monetary system itself. Lucas: Exactly. And there is a deeper design question. Why does the Fed need to pay interest on reserves at all? There are proposals to move to a different framework, like paying interest only on required reserves, or even going back to a corridor system where the Fed uses its balance sheet more actively. Luna: But those proposals would not save much in the near term, because the Fed would still need to keep the funds rate where it is, and banks would still find ways to earn on their reserves. Lucas: Right. The interest on reserves is not a gift to banks; it is the price of controlling the money supply in a system with abundant reserves. The Fed could try to drain reserves and move back to a scarce-reserve regime, but that would take years and would be very disruptive. Luna: So we are kind of stuck with this cost for the foreseeable future. And the question is, how do we manage it as part of the broader debt picture? Lucas: One thing the Treasury can do is issue more long-term debt to lock in rates before they go higher. But that comes with its own risks — if inflation stays sticky, long-term yields could rise even more. The market is already nervous; we saw the 30-year yield jump to five point two seven percent, and the term premium is widening. Luna: And foreign demand? We have talked about that cooling. If foreign buyers pull back, the Treasury has to rely more on domestic banks and the Fed itself, which circles back to the interest on reserves issue. Lucas: It is all connected. The Fed is the buyer of last resort, but it is also the entity that pays banks to hold reserves. So the Treasury's borrowing costs and the Fed's operating costs are two sides of the same coin. Luna: So, for the average person, what does this mean? I mean, we talk about trillions and basis points, but does this affect someone's mortgage rate or the price of groceries? Lucas: It does, indirectly. The Fed funds rate influences consumer borrowing costs — from credit cards to adjustable-rate mortgages. When the Fed keeps the policy rate at three point six three percent, that filters into what you pay to borrow. And when the Treasury pays more to borrow, that can crowd out private investment and slow growth. Luna: So it is not just an abstract accounting issue. It is part of the cost of living. Lucas: Exactly. And that is why we are going to keep digging into this, because the more you understand the plumbing, the better you can anticipate where rates and the economy are heading. Luna: And I think a key takeaway is that the Fed's interest on reserves is not just a technical detail. It is a major fiscal cost that we need to address. Lucas: But there is no easy fix. The Fed is between a rock and a hard place — it needs to control inflation, but it also has to manage the cost of doing so. And with inflation still above target, the pressure is on. Luna: We saw that headline about manufacturing survey showing inflation worries worse than pandemic era. So the Fed cannot just cut rates and forget about it. Lucas: Right. And that brings us back to the debt. As long as the Fed has to keep rates high to fight inflation, the cost of interest on reserves will stay elevated, adding to the deficit and the debt. It is a cycle that is hard to break. Luna: So, what would you like to see happen? What is the ideal path from here? Lucas: Ideally, the Fed would bring inflation down to target without tanking the economy, then normalize the balance sheet and eventually move back to a scarce-reserve regime. But that is a multi-year process, and in the meantime, the interest on reserves line item is not going away. Luna: So, for investors and policymakers, the message is: keep an eye on the Fed's remittances, because that is a leading indicator of fiscal pressure. Lucas: Absolutely. And for the rest of us, it is another reason to be realistic about the debt trajectory. This is not just about the Treasury's bond auctions. It is about the entire ecosystem of borrowing and lending that the Fed manages. And until we have a broader fiscal conversation, these costs are just going to keep piling up. Luna: Well, Lucas, I think we have given everyone a lot to chew on today. Lucas: And the question I would leave you with is: how do we design a monetary system that is both effective and affordable? Because right now, we are paying a very high price for stability.