Latest / No Way Out / Stop Training Things That Aren't the Thing: Police Training & the Real OODA Loop | Pete Blair, PhD
Transcript
- 0:00Pete Blair, PhD: When I talk to people seems to resonate most with them is to say anybody you talk to and you say, Hey, the best way to get good at something is doing that thing.
- 0:11Pete Blair, PhD: And everybody shakes ahead and goes, Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 0:14Pete Blair, PhD: The best way to get good at something is to do that thing I'm trying to get good at.
- 0:18Pete Blair, PhD: And then you say, So why are we doing so many things that are not the thing?
- 0:22John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 0:23John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then there is no way out we can eliminate the feature just by the note.
- 0:35John R. Boyd: We don't know how to do this.
- 0:36John R. Boyd: There is no way out.
- 0:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, welcome back to No Way Out.
- 0:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm Brian Pontch Rivera.
- 0:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: My guest today is Dr.
- 0:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Pete Blair.
- 0:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: He's the executive director for Alert.
- 0:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh that's the Advanced Law Enforcement Rapid Response Training Center.
- 0:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And he's a professor of criminal justice at Texas State University.
- 1:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Alert trains police officers all over the country to respond to active attacks.
- 1:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Pete also writes tactical science on Substack.
- 1:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Make sure you check that out.
- 1:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And if you train anybody for anything, go read it.
- 1:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now, here's why I wanted Pete on our podcast.
- 1:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Pete asks a very simple question that makes trainers squirm a little.
- 1:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Everybody agrees that the best way to get good at something is to do that thing.
- 1:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So why do we spend so much time training doing things that aren't that thing?
- 1:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Think about a cop who shoots a great score on a flat range off a timer beep at a paper target that never moves and never lies to him.
- 1:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Then he walks into a real encounter where the person in front of him moves, talks, decides.
- 1:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They have their own observe-oriented side acloop.
- 1:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We get into constraints-led approach and why good training looks messy.
- 2:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We get into John Verveke's four ways of knowing, which Pete brought into police training and why learning to ride a balanced bike tells you more about skill than any classroom ever will.
- 2:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And we get into the OODA loop.
- 2:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Pete explains how policing learned the linear version and we put Boyd's full sketch next to his perception action loop, what he calls POW.
- 2:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They end up closer than most people think.
- 2:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So if you coach, train, or lead people who have to perform when it counts, this one's for you.
- 2:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Here's Pete Blair.
- 2:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: All right, Pete Blair calling in from uh Texas.
- 2:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I've been looking forward to connecting with you after reading some of your work on Substack and of course some of your papers where you're talking about the constraints-led approach applied towards training, uh, not just uh sports training, but probably more importantly where it's being applied to right now is in our first responders or police forces.
- 2:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Pete, uh thanks for being here with me today.
- 3:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sure.
- 3:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Happy to be here.
- 3:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's talk about police training in general.
- 3:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What are the needs?
- 3:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's happening, and and what are you seeing with regard to uh nonlinear pedagogy coming into that space?
- 3:11Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, so I think if you you look at police training, a lot of it's very traditional in in how it's run.
- 3:17Pete Blair, PhD: If you were to uh you know think about to how most people were trained in sports when they were a kid, where we have these very decontextualized kind of drills that we do.
- 3:27Pete Blair, PhD: Like I can think of soccer practice, so you can think of the putting the orange cones out on the field and dribbling around the orange cones to learn how to dribble and do that.
- 3:35Pete Blair, PhD: And and police training draws a lot on that traditional kind of methodology, the idea that we're gonna take the thing, we're gonna learn the thing out of context, we're gonna focus and get the action perfect.
- 3:45Pete Blair, PhD: And then after we have the action perfect, we're gonna add the context back in.
- 3:49Pete Blair, PhD: And then that's supposed to carry forward.
- 3:51Pete Blair, PhD: And then police training being that it's very time constrained, that we don't have an infinite number of hours to do training, oftentimes the focus is just on that getting the physical action correct, and then maybe there's a little bit at the end trying to connect it to the actual thing, but oftentimes that's kind of given short shrift just because of time constraints.
- 4:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I told guests in the past that my background in fighter aviation, and we didn't really decompose everything.
- 4:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We actually learned in stages.
- 4:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, you don't learn how to run a checklist and and then go fly and all that.
- 4:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What we did do, and this is me reflecting back upon it, that is you you you you're you're thrown into the deep end, kind of.
- 4:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Not not you're not in a 4vx or anything like that, but you're introduced into a world that you're not used to, right?
- 4:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that whole space of training in fighter aviation was different than anything we saw in when when I was a kid, right?
- 4:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it just happens to be really powerful.
- 4:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'd I'd all all argue that naval aviation has one of the best skill acquisitions approaches in the world because we do something known as plan brief, execute debrief.
- 4:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh basically we're tightening those feedback loops and we're asking the right questions, and and it just emerged out of necessity.
- 4:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: As a parent, I didn't know coaches didn't know how to do this, right?
- 5:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I just assumed everybody did it this way.
- 5:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um and then I watched, I'm like, well, I must have been doing something wrong in naval aviation, or maybe that's just rare.
- 5:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What I'm finding now is this is very important, especially in the age of AI where we have to build adaptable people.
- 5:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We have to train this way.
- 5:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I know a lot of folks can say, well, I we already do this.
- 5:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So let me give you some more context in my background, and I think you can build on this.
- 5:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One of the things I learned about in SEER training, so you know, escape and resistance and evasion is if you get shot down and the Marines are there to pick you up, the last thing you want to do is start charging after a bunch of Marines that are coming to save you with a gun, you know, pulled out of your, you know, in your arm, in your hand.
- 5:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's actually happened before.
- 5:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And the reason for that is these Marines have an orientation that they are there to find a big threat, right?
- 5:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it didn't dawn on me until after all these uh these awful school shootings and things that happened over the last 20, 30 years that most people are not trained like that.
- 5:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They don't know that the police that they're running into are humans, right?
- 6:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That that they are trained away and and they're there to respond to a situation.
- 6:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And maybe it's not the best training.
- 6:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: They're not bad people, but but that that kind of dawned on me over the last several years is that because of my training, I know better than to go get upset at a police officer who's trying to calm down a situation, right?
- 6:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean, because of I don't understand what's going through their orientation, what their uh uh disposition is, what their threats are, what their day was like, what they had for dinner the night before.
- 6:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I don't know that.
- 6:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But uh can you talk a little bit about that?
- 6:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that from from the perspective of a of a civilian engaging with police and police engaging with a threat?
- 6:41Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, so one of the things that we do, we have our civilian response training that we do, we talk about specifically how to behave when you encounter the police.
- 6:50Pete Blair, PhD: And we do that in large ways by pointing at, you know, imagine that you're the police officer, you're ending this situation, here's what's going on, it's chaotic, you don't know who's the good guy, who's the bad guy.
- 7:00Pete Blair, PhD: Uh, you may have seen people shot, you can smell gunpowder, all those sorts of things.
- 7:04Pete Blair, PhD: And then you're encountering people who you don't know who they are and you don't know that the threat's been dealt with.
- 7:09Pete Blair, PhD: And so taking that point of view of, you know, understand what's happening in this given situation, and this is how you behave when you do it, right?
- 7:17Pete Blair, PhD: So listen to commands, move slowly, don't argue, you know, all those sorts of things that uh that go into that by understanding that this is the situation, the context that the cop is dealing with, and you have your own context that, you know, he's supposed to understand how you're dealing with that as well.
- 7:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 7:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then something else, when we talk about training, and I have a lot of friends that are police officers around here in Virginia Beach.
- 7:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And uh we, you know, we've had several folks meet up with us in Quantico uh to talk about some of these topics.
- 7:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But one thing I didn't know, and I'm I'm an Airedale, right?
- 7:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So aviation background.
- 7:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We learned this in the military in about the last 20 or 30 years.
- 7:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When you go out to a range and you shoot a gun, and then just talk about training again, just because you're a sharpshooter at the range that doesn't mean you're gonna be qualified in a gunfight, right?
- 8:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and not that we want to get in a gunfight or anything like that.
- 8:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When I go to the range with my friends, I'm there to get in a flow state, be present, and have all that stuff.
- 8:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'm not there to get the heart rate up and run around and do all that.
- 8:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But in in real situations that uh you know our first responders face, can you talk about how their training impacts how they respond?
- 8:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sure.
- 8:23Pete Blair, PhD: I think there are several things.
- 8:24Pete Blair, PhD: One is that the only real outcome measure that's usually required by a state on firearms training are qualifications tests.
- 8:33Pete Blair, PhD: So those are known tests where you're you shoot from fixed and known distances, you shirt shoot certain numbers of rounds at different targets, you might have reload drills built into that and some other things.
- 8:44Pete Blair, PhD: And it's done oftentimes off of a timer, you know, an audible beep that you hear that starts the action.
- 8:50Pete Blair, PhD: You shoot that set course of fire, you have to do it within a certain period of time, you have to have a certain accuracy level in order to pass that.
- 8:57Pete Blair, PhD: That's usually the thing that qualifies people for and consider that now you can you can carry a gun, you're you're qualified with this gun.
- 9:05Pete Blair, PhD: And there's, you know, a role for that mark.
- 9:07Pete Blair, PhD: I would I would call that marksmanship type training.
- 9:09Pete Blair, PhD: You know, there's a role for understanding that you can hit a target and to do some things like that.
- 9:13Pete Blair, PhD: But then when we think about what's the actual context we're trying to prepare a police officer for, and it doesn't look like that, right?
- 9:20Pete Blair, PhD: They're not shooting at a blank target, they're interacting with the person who's doing things.
- 9:25Pete Blair, PhD: That person may be trying to uh mislead them about what they're doing and what their actions are.
- 9:30Pete Blair, PhD: And then they have to make a judgment that deadly course is required, then they have to be able to execute that.
- 9:35Pete Blair, PhD: Oftentimes the subject's moving, the police officer may be moving, light conditions vary, distances vary, all those things that that go in, cover varies.
- 9:43Pete Blair, PhD: And so police training usually goes beyond just we're shooting at targets on a flat range and fixed and known courses of fire.
- 9:50Pete Blair, PhD: But again, it's that how much time do we have and how much focus do we spend on this thing, which is easy to measure.
- 9:56Pete Blair, PhD: You know, it's easy to measure range qualifications.
- 9:59Pete Blair, PhD: They shot so fast and they hit so many rounds and those sorts of things.
- 10:02Pete Blair, PhD: But then the thing that we're concerned about is not so much that they can shoot on a target range very quickly, but that they can be in a real life situation, they can assess what's happening, they can decide that force is needed.
- 10:13Pete Blair, PhD: And then when that force is needed, they can use the correct amount of force to engage the attacker to stop the threat.
- 10:19Pete Blair, PhD: And then they have to also know when to stop shooting because they can't just continue to put rounds into somebody who's been neutralized or stopped.
- 10:25Pete Blair, PhD: And then all the things that go on the tail end of that, which is you just shot somebody, and now how do you continue to go about doing that?
- 10:31Pete Blair, PhD: And usually those things get again, it's compressed later on after because that we have this known qualification we have to shoot.
- 10:38Pete Blair, PhD: So there's a lot of focus on passing that qualification.
- 10:41Pete Blair, PhD: And then after that's passed, then we start worrying about now do we do scenarios and those sorts of things and in the training that we do.
- 10:48Pete Blair, PhD: And so that cuts into that time, and then oftentimes the scenarios are done kind of as a end capstone, and there's a lot less time dedicated to those than there is to the actual marksmanship type training that happens on the range.
- 11:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So there's a you you brought up scenarios, uh, you know, having spent a lot of time in the military with active shooter training, uh, which is generally just desktop training, a bunch of people sitting around a table talking about what they might do in a situation uh kind of in a sterile environment.
- 11:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What what I ended up doing is actually running scenarios in the buildings we were in and we would move around.
- 11:19Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I I don't, I'm not saying that's exactly the type of training you want to do, but getting out there to kind of experience and what what it would look like in the space you're in.
- 11:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and and I know that's a little uncomfortable for people to go do, they much rather sit around a table and go, here's a what-if scenario.
- 11:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Having spent time reading about naturalistic decision making, NDM recognition prime decision making and things like that, I understand you have to be put in a context to know how to do things.
- 11:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And when you do that, and I'm gonna put my parent brain back on, when you when I watch my girls warm up and I'm guilty of this, you know, it's it's them shooting, you know, in a static environment and I watch them, I'm like, oh, they're gonna be great tonight because they're making their baskets, or they're gonna be horrible because they're not making the basket.
- 12:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That has nothing to do with it, right?
- 12:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's it, that's not telling me anything.
- 12:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So uh where I'm going with this is the context matters, right?
- 12:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you have to create that context for folks.
- 12:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I want to ask you this in the training that you're doing now, it it does it look sloppy, does it look like it's a they're failing, or or what what's it look like?
- 12:24Pete Blair, PhD: So if you adopt a full ecological dynamics approach where you're saying we're going to give you an intention, this is what you're trying to accomplish, right?
- 12:32Pete Blair, PhD: The CLA, the classical CLA four parts.
- 12:35Pete Blair, PhD: We're gonna give you an intention, this is what you're trying to accomplish.
- 12:38Pete Blair, PhD: We're gonna constrain it to afford you being able to learn.
- 12:42Pete Blair, PhD: So we're not gonna throw you in something that's so large and so complex that you can't figure out what's going on and you don't know how to do, how to function, right?
- 12:49Pete Blair, PhD: We're gonna start with a smaller environment, a smaller thing, but we're also very concerned about making that environment representative.
- 12:56Pete Blair, PhD: And the the biggest thing for representative design is that whatever information and decisions you're making in the actual performance environment, we want that information to be present to the best that we can in the actual training environment.
- 13:08Pete Blair, PhD: So if if part of your performance environment is dealing with somebody who's trying to attack you back, then we want you to have a training environment that involves people trying to attack you back, right?
- 13:18Pete Blair, PhD: That's that's part of what we're we're gonna do.
- 13:20Pete Blair, PhD: And then that's representative design.
- 13:22Pete Blair, PhD: And then the last thing is repetition without repetition, which is we want people to achieve the goal that we set for them.
- 13:28Pete Blair, PhD: We're not so curious so focused on did they do it with this exact motion or this exact technique in how they did it, as long as they achieve the goal.
- 13:37Pete Blair, PhD: Now, certain things work better than others, right?
- 13:39Pete Blair, PhD: So people are gonna gravitate toward things and you're gonna nudge them toward things that that work better or worse.
- 13:44Pete Blair, PhD: But when you do that kind of training that is not about show me this exact action, by definition, it's going to look messier when you do the training because you're allowing them to explore the space, you're allowing them to see things.
- 13:57Pete Blair, PhD: Now, obviously, if you're doing things that if you're dealing with real firearms, you have real safety concerns and you can't let those safety concerns be violated.
- 14:04Pete Blair, PhD: But you are allowing people to work on these things and try to figure them out themselves.
- 14:09Pete Blair, PhD: And then as the coach, you're spending more time not on do this or do that, but more time on adjusting the environment to help them see the things that are important so that they can pull those things, they learn those things and they start to be able to use those things to guide their actions.
- 14:22Pete Blair, PhD: Coaches do, you know, in that model sometimes interject direct things.
- 14:26Pete Blair, PhD: Usually you'll start with, you know, hey, what happens if you try this?
- 14:29Pete Blair, PhD: And then makes a suggestion to nudge them toward a different solution.
- 14:32Pete Blair, PhD: But it can turn into, hey, I just need you to do this this time.
- 14:35Pete Blair, PhD: Do it.
- 14:36Pete Blair, PhD: You know, that happens if the other things don't work.
- 14:38Pete Blair, PhD: But yeah, oftentimes there people are making errors, but the way you set the training environment up, they should know when they make an error that this didn't work.
- 14:46Pete Blair, PhD: This didn't help me achieve the goal.
- 14:47Pete Blair, PhD: So I've got immediate feedback that I failed in trying to achieve the goal.
- 14:51Pete Blair, PhD: And now we're working in that environment a lot.
- 14:53Pete Blair, PhD: And so I'm getting to move toward things that are going to help me perform better, that that I'm gonna get to where I can achieve the goal more consistently.
- 15:01Pete Blair, PhD: And then in a lot of us use a challenge point kind of framework with the idea that we want to adjust how hard people are working based upon their success rate.
- 15:10Pete Blair, PhD: And so if they've got a hundred percent success success rate, there's not learning going on because they're they're able to do this correctly every time.
- 15:16Pete Blair, PhD: And so then we're gonna adjust the constraints of the environment to make it more complicated, more difficult, so that that success rate drops.
- 15:23Pete Blair, PhD: And we just use as a general rule that 70% success rate.
- 15:27Pete Blair, PhD: It's enough success that you don't feel like you're a total failure and you're picking up some things, but you're also not doing it all the time.
- 15:33Pete Blair, PhD: You're not succeeding all the time, so that you're you're clearly having work to get better.
- 15:38Pete Blair, PhD: And then once you get better, we we change those constraints again.
- 15:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That kind of reminds me of the flow channel where you want to be just above above it and you know, you're you don't want to be too below it, but you got to stay above it to keep the challenge up there.
- 15:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then something else that uh we always like to reiterate that uh we learn best from failures, right?
- 15:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we don't just because we're really successful at something and and failing in front of others that are failing as well uh is is not a bad thing.
- 15:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Question to you about you brought up open-ended questions.
- 16:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I like the way you you phrased that uh with the question you asked there.
- 16:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But what about debriefing?
- 16:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How does that fit into this type of training?
- 16:09Pete Blair, PhD: So oftentimes in in CLA, they don't they don't talk about it.
- 16:13Pete Blair, PhD: In our own practice, we always are doing hot washes after we run a scenario.
- 16:17Pete Blair, PhD: We do a quick, hey, what are things that went well well?
- 16:20Pete Blair, PhD: What are things that didn't go well?
- 16:21Pete Blair, PhD: What might you try next time when we do this?
- 16:24Pete Blair, PhD: Okay, ready, let's go.
- 16:25Pete Blair, PhD: You know, and that's that quick, quick debrief, identify what's going well, what's not going well, and then let's reset and let's do it again.
- 16:32unknown: Okay.
- 16:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Do you think there's room for do you think there's room for debriefing to be um brought into CLA?
- 16:37Pete Blair, PhD: Is it Yeah, I so I I'm not one of these people who is a, hey, this is the only thing you're gonna use, and this is the framework and model that you have to use.
- 16:45Pete Blair, PhD: I think coaching, you're trying to make, you're trying to take advantage of all the different things that are out there.
- 16:50Pete Blair, PhD: I think they serve different roles.
- 16:51Pete Blair, PhD: If I have a chance to get another rep in, I'm gonna focus on doing the reps, right?
- 16:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 16:56Pete Blair, PhD: I want to get as many reps as possible when I'm doing something.
- 16:59Pete Blair, PhD: But that doesn't mean there isn't a role for later on people doing reflection and and having write reflective practitioner type journals and those sorts of things to try to to do that.
- 17:09Pete Blair, PhD: But if I've got we're together and we have time to do training, I want to do as many reps as we can during that time.
- 17:15Pete Blair, PhD: During other times, there are other activities that we could do that could also be helpful to learn, right?
- 17:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's great.
- 17:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That reminds me of Coach Signetti at at Indiana.
- 17:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh short amount of practice time, getting the reps in and then debriefing later on and fixing the the situations they have.
- 17:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh I want to go back in time.
- 17:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so you let's go back to where and how you just what how did you come across CLA?
- 17:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Was it from within the uh first responder community?
- 17:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Go back in time and walk me through what was going through uh the steps that got you to this.
- 17:45Pete Blair, PhD: So I I ran into the whole ecological dynamics thing from running into Rob Gray's book, How We Learned to Move.
- 17:51Pete Blair, PhD: And I don't remember how exactly I ran into it, but I I try to read broadly.
- 17:56Pete Blair, PhD: I'm you know, I'm an academic by trade, and so I'm always trying to read different areas, different fields, things that'll give me ideas that can improve what we're doing.
- 18:03Pete Blair, PhD: And I ran into that book, and that book was like flipping a light switch for me.
- 18:07Pete Blair, PhD: I was like, oh, and you said before that a lot of people say, oh, we're already doing these things.
- 18:11Pete Blair, PhD: And I think that's true in a lot of ways, because I think a good coach is out there, they're looking, they're they're trying to identify what is helping performance, how do I move performance forward?
- 18:20Pete Blair, PhD: And so a lot of times they've discovered these things already.
- 18:23Pete Blair, PhD: And what I find that academics usually do, and this is our our dirty secret of academe, that applied academics usually are just validating stuff that practitioners have already discovered.
- 18:34Pete Blair, PhD: And then as part of that validation, they also apply a theory to it.
- 18:37Pete Blair, PhD: And then oftentimes that theory can give the practitioner ideas of things maybe they haven't seen yet or tried yet to go and take what they're doing more deeper.
- 18:46Pete Blair, PhD: And that that would, I would uh describe that as my experience of saying, hey, here's the thing, here's the thing I've seen a lot of our really effective instructors doing that seems to work really well.
- 18:56Pete Blair, PhD: And now here's an explanation for why that might be happening, and then that gives suggestions for here's how you might be able to take it farther.
- 19:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that goes back to something we we've talked about on the show, which is mass observation of something.
- 19:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Through that, we understand the the why and we can repeat it.
- 19:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We can we can amplify it in other domains.
- 19:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's consistent.
- 19:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So when people push back on CLA, ecological dynamics, and because of their position that we're already doing this, when I watch a practice and I spend an hour watching a practice and I see maybe five to ten good minutes placed into some type of representative design, some small-sided game, and the rest spent in doing everything everything else, I'm just saying, hey, let's flip that around a little bit.
- 19:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Let's spend 80% of our time doing this representative game design, small-sided games, and then spend our other time on that.
- 19:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So it it's just getting coaches to see that that they are, yes, they are already doing this, but it's it's occupying a small piece of their training.
- 19:51Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah.
- 19:52Pete Blair, PhD: And I I think the thing that when I talk to people seems to resonate most with them is to say, anybody you talk to and you say, hey, the best way to get good at something is doing that thing.
- 20:02Pete Blair, PhD: And everybody shakes their head and goes, Yeah, yeah, absolutely.
- 20:04Pete Blair, PhD: The best way to get good at something is to do that thing I'm trying to get good at.
- 20:08Pete Blair, PhD: And then you say, So why are we doing so many things that are not the thing?
- 20:11Pete Blair, PhD: Yes.
- 20:12Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, you know, and then they go, Well, you got to break it down, you gotta do these things.
- 20:16Pete Blair, PhD: And and that's that traditional model that thinks you really have to isolate these components as opposed to a uh a more encompassing model that says, let's get in that environment and let's get it close to the thing and within reason, right?
- 20:28Pete Blair, PhD: We have to constrain it so it doesn't overwhelm people and and people don't get hurt and and all those things that go on there.
- 20:34Pete Blair, PhD: But the idea that look, if we're trying to train somebody to do a thing, let's make the training look as much like the thing as we can.
- 20:40Pete Blair, PhD: And that's just taking that to an extreme.
- 20:43Pete Blair, PhD: And I I think uh Greg Souders, who does a lot of work in the jiu-jitsu space, is really the you know, kind of the the first guy to really get in there and start doing ecological dynamics training as the core of what he's doing in jiu-jitsu and really has done a lot of deep thinking about how he does things.
- 20:59Pete Blair, PhD: But if you just look at his practice and you say, okay, I'm trying to create jujitsu competitors that are going to go out and win, and you look at his practice time, and he is spending essentially the whole hour of practice time doing jujitsu.
- 21:12Pete Blair, PhD: They're fighting each other.
- 21:13Pete Blair, PhD: Now they're fighting each other in limited, constrained ways, and they're focusing on certain things to learn certain aspects of the game and those sorts of things, but they're spending that whole time against somebody who is trying to stop them from doing what they're trying to do, and they're trying to do something to that person, right?
- 21:27Pete Blair, PhD: And that they're doing that struggle the entire time.
- 21:30Pete Blair, PhD: And then you think, okay, look at normal jujitsu practice where you do some warm-up and then they show you three techniques.
- 21:36Pete Blair, PhD: If you got a good coach, those three techniques are connected to each other.
- 21:40Pete Blair, PhD: You start them under no resistance, maybe there's a little bit of resistance by the end of the techniques, and then we spend the last 10 minutes or 15 minutes of class rolling where we're fighting each other, right?
- 21:49Pete Blair, PhD: And you wonder who's going to get better at fighting in the jiu jitsu context the guy who does 10 minutes at the end of class, or the guy who's in class fighting the entire time.
- 21:59Pete Blair, PhD: And then the question is, well, what about the techniques and the technical skills and that?
- 22:03Pete Blair, PhD: And that's where, you know, Greg's genius about how do you steer people in practice to identify these things that are critical to your success and and how do you produce control of a person and how do you produce submissions and those sorts of things?
- 22:16Pete Blair, PhD: And that's the, you know, but he's not doing that in practice by saying, here's step one, here's step two, here's step three, here's step 45, and now you've got a submission.
- 22:25Pete Blair, PhD: It's we're gonna focus on this particular thing in this area.
- 22:28Pete Blair, PhD: You're trying to do this, the other person is trying to do this thing that's preventing you from doing this, go, right?
- 22:33Pete Blair, PhD: And then they're they're opposing each other the whole time.
- 22:36Pete Blair, PhD: So they get very good at dealing with people opposing them.
- 22:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 22:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So the what you just brought up over the last few minutes is probably the most important part.
- 22:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, and I tried to convey this to coaches and parents.
- 22:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Talking about AAU sports, you always hear coaches say, we need more game time.
- 22:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's where they're gonna get better.
- 22:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And my it it took me a while to realize, no, that's not true.
- 22:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It should be the practice, the training is where they get better, right?
- 22:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's that's what's important.
- 23:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you create those conditions there?
- 23:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and that I think gets lost on folks because to parents, it sounds good.
- 23:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We need to travel around the country, get our kids exposure, get some playing time against some really good opponents.
- 23:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, what are you doing in training then?
- 23:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's practice for?
- 23:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 23:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 23:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 23:17Pete Blair, PhD: And certainly you can make, you know, what you see in the sporting world is a lot of in team sports, a lot of small-sided games.
- 23:22Pete Blair, PhD: We're focusing on a certain aspect of the game in this situation.
- 23:26Pete Blair, PhD: This is the situation we're setting up, and now we're working.
- 23:28Pete Blair, PhD: We put different constraints in in order to force people to go do different things and explore different parts of how the game might work.
- 23:34Pete Blair, PhD: But that idea that we're out here learning the game by playing the game, right?
- 23:39Pete Blair, PhD: And as opposed to I'm gonna teach you all these little subskills, and then I'm gonna take those subskills and you're gonna get dropped in, and then that's when you're gonna figure out how they fit.
- 23:47Pete Blair, PhD: And again, it's just a different model of coaching.
- 23:49Pete Blair, PhD: The old old school coaching traditional model says, yeah, you break all those things up and you got to show them each of those things.
- 23:56Pete Blair, PhD: The ecological dynamics model says, no, we need to put them in a context that matters because if you don't, you can show them all these little things, but then they're gonna still have to relearn those things because they have to learn how to connect them to perceptual cues that they're gonna have in the actual game environment.
- 24:10Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, the environment is a key word, and and you have been following John Boyd for a while, his oodaloop.
- 24:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: One of the key things he said uh early on in the 70s is I'm your environment, you're my environment.
- 24:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And what happened along the way to understanding John Boyd's work is we got this linear four-step oodle loop.
- 24:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I know first responders, I know police officers love to talk about observer to side act.
- 24:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Take me through that journey and that lens of the oodaloop and how much more powerful, I like what you call it, pal, right?
- 24:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh perception action loop, how much more powerful that that is.
- 24:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I'll add to that as we go.
- 24:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So go back and walk me through how uh prevalent the the OODA loop is and why it might be a good starting point, but let's look at the perception action loop, and I'll argue that it's already in there.
- 24:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So over to you.
- 24:56Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, so I I I would agree that first of all, I think Boyd was ahead of the scope in a lot of these things and talking about how these things fit together.
- 25:04Pete Blair, PhD: I I see you've got the more involved uh chart up behind you there on the on the whiteboard.
- 25:09Pete Blair, PhD: And so I I I think it's there, but very much the OODA loop you'll see in a lot of law enforcement training, people talk about it.
- 25:14Pete Blair, PhD: It's usually taught as a cycle, right?
- 25:16Pete Blair, PhD: Observe, orient, decide, and act, uh, and that we're going through that.
- 25:19Pete Blair, PhD: And that the idea is a lot of times it's used to explain reaction time stuff.
- 25:23Pete Blair, PhD: That's how I used it in some of my early work is to talk about, yeah, when you've got somebody there, and we you know, one of the original reaction time studies we did involve having a police officer who's got his gun up, sided down on the suspect, ready to shoot.
- 25:38Pete Blair, PhD: Suspect's got the gun down by their side or up by their head like they're faking suicide.
- 25:43Pete Blair, PhD: And then I would ask people, okay, if the suspect decides to shoot that per the officer, who's gonna shoot first?
- 25:49Pete Blair, PhD: And the the answer is almost always, well, the officer, of course.
- 25:53Pete Blair, PhD: And then you can use that oodle loop to explain the idea of, well, not really, because what's happened in this particular case is that the suspects already decided that they're gonna do this and they're just executing the physical action, right?
- 26:07Pete Blair, PhD: And then what the officer has to do is see that physical action, orient on what does that mean in this particular context and the circumstances that it indicates that it requires a deadly forced decision for the decide, and then they have to execute that action.
- 26:22Pete Blair, PhD: So that's oftentimes the way that that's explained in traditional law enforcement.
- 26:26Pete Blair, PhD: And I think when you see Boyd's fuller explanation of that, those things are not happening in anywhere near that sequential thing that's that's going on.
- 26:34Pete Blair, PhD: You have, yeah, exactly on this chart here, you have the different feedback loops that are going on, you have these implicit things that are happening and all that.
- 26:43Pete Blair, PhD: And so but it still is that initial way that people ran into it, which is there here's this cycle that's that's happening, and we're gonna go through each step of the cycle.
- 26:54Pete Blair, PhD: So I I think with with that change and when you see what he's talking about with more emergent things that are happening, with the implicit guidance things that are happening, I think you end up with something that's that's closer to what the ecological dynamics approach would talk about, certainly with the perception action loops happening there, the the feedbacks that he's got going on.
- 27:14Pete Blair, PhD: I would just say that you know, over time i in the ecological dynamics community that those those separations have been rounded off to the point where you were talking about Rob's most recent book that he he put out where the decision making is really just a phase change that happened in that perception action loop that that occurred.
- 27:31Pete Blair, PhD: And and you're deciding the whole time.
- 27:33Pete Blair, PhD: It's just you only observe that decision when it actually has some consequence for something and makes that thing change, and it's going there.
- 27:40Pete Blair, PhD: And I think Boyd was hitting on that with some of his implicit guidance things that he was talking about.
- 27:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And yeah, I think those are the those two pathways at the top, the implicit guidance control pathway that goes orient to observe is part of our perception, uh, is our filter filtering mechanism.
- 27:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then that one that goes from orient to act is is could what we what we call skills or intuition, right?
- 28:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So perception is already inside the oodle loop and action is going to be honest with you, it's already there, right?
- 28:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we don't have to worry about the bottom part of the oodle loop and ecological dynamics because what we're trying to do is is really focus on the outside, the uh the environment, right?
- 28:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's what we we we started this point with is that environment, uh, and I'll just sketch that up real fast real fast.
- 28:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That is the stuff on the left, right?
- 28:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That is uh these three things over here.
- 28:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And my pen's not working, but that's all right.
- 28:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That on the left side there, you have unfolding circumstances, and that's that's uh going back to scenarios we were talking about earlier.
- 28:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: As I'm your environment, you're my environment, I'm an agent, you're an agent.
- 28:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: When I take an action, it might you might pick up that information, you might not, right?
- 28:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's what that unfolding circumstance is on the left side is the un unfolding interaction with the environment.
- 28:51Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's uh hopefully you can help me get this right.
- 28:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We take some type of action on the environment and we get some type of feedback from it.
- 28:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That that couples with our perception, right?
- 29:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 29:02Pete Blair, PhD: And those are those are going on constantly.
- 29:04Pete Blair, PhD: You know, that's the and and I think that's what Boyd's talking about when you see his his stuff talked about more deeply, is that these these things are there.
- 29:12Pete Blair, PhD: And I think at his time when he was doing this, he he didn't have the the language and the the the research kind of focus that has happened since then.
- 29:21Pete Blair, PhD: And I also see a lot of his still within that that realm, the the cognitive language coming in that you know is not so much on the ecological psychology, so the more cognitive psychology language, which is is still the dominant form of psychology and explaining psychology, but that you can see that language show up in in how he talks about some things.
- 29:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I had the uh the the linear oodaloop up, and I want to go to uh I'm sorry, I only have the CLA uh from uh this is from Alex Saramas' book.
- 29:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So walk us through this.
- 29:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I mean you you we talked about the linear oodaloop and the good oodaloop.
- 29:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now let's talk about this part.
- 30:01Pete Blair, PhD: So basically, if you go through this process, what they're saying is that you have an environ a set of constraints, and those that's what that triangle is, is the different constraints.
- 30:12Pete Blair, PhD: So you have individual constraints that are the the person themselves, what they're capable of, what they can do.
- 30:18Pete Blair, PhD: You have task constraints, which is what you're asking them to do in the training thing, what are what is it I'm asking to do as far as the task goes.
- 30:26Pete Blair, PhD: And then you have the environment, which is how environments vary, whether it's in lighting or different courts or whatever might happen there.
- 30:34Pete Blair, PhD: All those are impacting that perception and action loop that's in there.
- 30:41Pete Blair, PhD: And then as that perception action loop is running within those constraints, you have movement solutions that emerge from those those constraints interacting with perception and action loop.
- 30:52Pete Blair, PhD: And those are the those are the skills that come out.
- 30:56Pete Blair, PhD: Does that make sense?
- 30:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It does.
- 30:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, no, and it it I just want to make sure our listeners understand that we're not bashing John Boyd's oodloop.
- 31:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're saying that the linear one is not necessarily the correct oodaloop.
- 31:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh the more involved one that you brought up that's behind me is more representative of that.
- 31:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you also pointed out that uh, you know, the dominant approaches to cog cognition are psychology, yeah.
- 31:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, so we're not talking about the mechanisms here.
- 31:23Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh there are competing mechanisms on how we perceive reality, but we we you don't need to know that as a coach and you don't need to know that as a trainer.
- 31:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Would you agree with that?
- 31:34Pete Blair, PhD: Uh I don't think you need to.
- 31:36Pete Blair, PhD: You'll get some purists who will argue about how far you have to go into different arguments about the reality of it.
- 31:42Pete Blair, PhD: But I I think if you really boil down into any training task that you do, it would be hard to think of a training task that doesn't follow the CLA in some way, shape, or form, right?
- 31:54Pete Blair, PhD: You're giving a goal, you've got constraints about what they're trying to do, you're trying to make it whatever you're doing look like the real world in some way, and maybe traditional training doesn't worry about the representative design as much.
- 32:06Pete Blair, PhD: And then you have repetition without representation, which again, those second two are probably the things that people would differ on.
- 32:12Pete Blair, PhD: But as far as you're using constraints in your training and you're setting a goal on what you're trying to do, everybody uses those two steps.
- 32:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I'm just gonna play a video for you.
- 32:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh this is actually taking um I I think this is right, Alex Rama's work and bending everything we just went over.
- 32:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're gonna I'm gonna demonstrate this.
- 32:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You said individual is the uh your individual constraints, height, weight, wingspan.
- 32:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You you brought up environment, you brought up task.
- 32:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, those to me, when you equate that to the OODA loop, is outside information and unfolding circumstances.
- 32:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then uh you look at your perception action loop, which we we went through, right?
- 32:46Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's perception action.
- 32:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're not getting into the mechanisms with this like we just talked about.
- 32:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And of course you get into movement, skills, uh, skills emerge.
- 32:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Now when you look at this through the lens of the OODA loop, and I think this goes into it, it's just this right here.
- 33:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Nothing changed, right?
- 33:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We said keep we're gonna focus on the top part of John Boyd's OODA loop and then uh uh we may need to change that perception to to have that incoming stimuli from the observation or our senses.
- 33:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But other than that, I think uh first responders who have uh are are following uh excuse me, I'll that's the flow channel stuff.
- 33:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll stop that there.
- 33:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think I think first responders who are talking about the OODA loop can actually find that to be useful by understanding that the real oodle loop affords them the opportunity to understand CLA.
- 33:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's all right there in front of them, right?
- 33:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 33:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And it's just it's just, hey, let's stop talking about this linear OODA loop thing and start talking about CLA, ecological dynamics, get that environment in there.
- 33:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then if you want to get into the the mechanics of how things work and strategy, we could do that later.
- 33:52Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But I think what CLA is doing and should be doing for organizations is getting the focus on the environment, setting those constraints, and and I gotta ask you this, and understanding the individual.
- 34:03Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So no two individuals are alike, right?
- 34:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So so you know, there's a situation where my girls play multiple sports and they get injured when they run long distance over hard surfaces, easier than anybody else, I would say.
- 34:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you have to change, excuse me, you have to understand those individual constraints and then work around them with the external or environmental constraints and go, okay, we have to change, we have you have to create a new program so you don't get injured.
- 34:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is that true in police training?
- 34:29Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That you you can't just do a peanut butter spread and say, this is how everybody gets trained?
- 34:33Pete Blair, PhD: Uh of course.
- 34:34Pete Blair, PhD: Because you're looking at, if you just think about officer size, right?
- 34:38Pete Blair, PhD: You get some officers who are are not big, you know, they're five feet tall and a hundred something pounds.
- 34:44Pete Blair, PhD: And then you get people who are six foot five, two fifty, or three hundred pounds.
- 34:48Pete Blair, PhD: The the way that those two officers are going to have to approach putting hands on somebody to control them is gonna be different, just because of that difference in physicality that they have.
- 34:58Pete Blair, PhD: Then you have your your, if you want to talk about their background and their upbringing, you know, did they were they trained as a wrestler when they were coming up?
- 35:05Pete Blair, PhD: Were they trained as a boxer?
- 35:07Pete Blair, PhD: Were they all those things are gonna kind of affect how they like to approach and think about situations and and do those things?
- 35:13Pete Blair, PhD: Did they grow up fighting with their siblings, you know, which is that that's a big difference we have now, you know.
- 35:19Pete Blair, PhD: My my generation, everybody got punched in the face at some point growing up, you know, that that was gonna happen.
- 35:25Pete Blair, PhD: And that's not the case now.
- 35:27Pete Blair, PhD: That's that's the exception.
- 35:29Pete Blair, PhD: And so getting somebody who's never had that experience before and then being on the street and having to to deal with that is another thing to overcome because you haven't experienced that before.
- 35:39Pete Blair, PhD: And if you haven't experienced before, it it can be really frightening.
- 35:42Pete Blair, PhD: You might think you're gonna die, you know, all those things that they go into that.
- 35:45Pete Blair, PhD: So dealing with all those individual differences that are there in the background and then trying to adjust training to do that.
- 35:51Pete Blair, PhD: And there are there are certain things.
- 35:52Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, I'm a jiu-jitsu guy myself, and so I'm short, stocky guy, and a lot of jujitsu uses triangle chokes, which involve using your legs to choke somebody with getting their arm in between your legs and and choking them with your legs wrapped around their head and their arm, basically.
- 36:07Pete Blair, PhD: And I have short, stubby legs, so you know I can do triangle chokes on like eight-year-olds, and then that's that's kind of the end of it.
- 36:17Pete Blair, PhD: But then you do that every day, right?
- 36:19Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, yeah, yeah.
- 36:20Pete Blair, PhD: I know other guys that have super long legs and they can do triangle chokes on everybody all the all day, every day.
- 36:26Pete Blair, PhD: So that's part of that that idea of you know, you have to adapt the training to what people are doing.
- 36:31Pete Blair, PhD: And it's also paying attention in the training environment that some people are going to catch on to some things very quickly and other people aren't.
- 36:38Pete Blair, PhD: And so you have to be paying attention to that so that you're continuing to challenge the person who's caught on quickly, but you're also not overwhelming the person who's taking longer to catch on.
- 36:48Pete Blair, PhD: You're you're working with them to help them.
- 36:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, and I I think that's a nice connection back to flow and the flow channel.
- 36:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I know Rob uh wrote about that recently and talks about it on his podcast.
- 36:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think like and you brought this up earlier that you're you're pulling from different domains and uh you're you're a chef, and I think that's what most coaches and trainers need to be is there is no one uh size fits all approach.
- 37:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You got to look at different things and go, okay, from the world of debriefing and effective teamwork, I can take this, and over here I could take this from CLA, and I could take this from high reliability theory, and I could take this from naturalistic decision making, red teaming, you name it.
- 37:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You could bring all these things together.
- 37:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that's that's the beauty of this right now, is you need more people to be chefs.
- 37:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And in your line of work, uh, when you're working with different agencies, FBI, local police sheriffs, how are they how's the uptake on this?
- 37:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are they receptive to this?
- 37:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Is there a demand for this type of thinking?
- 37:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Where are we?
- 37:39Pete Blair, PhD: It's it's across the board, right?
- 37:41Pete Blair, PhD: So the the one thing you can say about policing is that there is no consistency anywhere, right?
- 37:45Pete Blair, PhD: So when we talk about policing, we say we have roughly 18,000 police agencies in the United States.
- 37:51Pete Blair, PhD: And the reason we say roughly 18,000 is that we don't actually know how many agencies that we have.
- 37:56Pete Blair, PhD: And all those agencies operate under sure constitutional law affects all of them, that it constrains what they can do.
- 38:03Pete Blair, PhD: But then they have their own state law that constrains what they can do and and how they look at things and have to deal with things.
- 38:08Pete Blair, PhD: And a lot of times they're fairly similar, but there are differences between those.
- 38:12Pete Blair, PhD: And then you have individual agency policy and procedure on top of that, which even though something's legal in state law, it may be outside of policy or procedure for an agency.
- 38:20Pete Blair, PhD: So that creates a lot of difference in how things are.
- 38:24Pete Blair, PhD: And so there are some agencies that are very interested in this stuff and trying to pick it up and implement it and do it as quickly as they can.
- 38:31Pete Blair, PhD: And then there are other agencies who don't want to hear it.
- 38:34Pete Blair, PhD: You know, we just are gonna do what we've always done and we think it's good enough.
- 38:38Pete Blair, PhD: And um, you know, I think a lot of times there's some defensiveness because people feel like when you say, hey, there's a better way to do this, that you're telling them they've been doing wrong for all this time.
- 38:47Pete Blair, PhD: And, you know, I would say I I engaged in a lot of that type of training for a long time when I was coming up because that's how I was taught to train, and that was the best that I knew.
- 38:56Pete Blair, PhD: And we did the best that we could and and and got the results we did.
- 39:00Pete Blair, PhD: And for me, I I don't get upset when somebody suggests, hey, here's another training methodology, is it oh, that means I'm not doing a good job.
- 39:08Pete Blair, PhD: I get excited, like, oh, I can do better.
- 39:10Pete Blair, PhD: And so that's the point is is not to say you know what you're doing is wrong and bad.
- 39:14Pete Blair, PhD: And I think Rob probably hits the the nail on the head here is that humans are so fantastic at learning that almost no matter what you do, they're able to gain something from it.
- 39:24Pete Blair, PhD: The question is, can we make it more efficient, especially for us in law enforcement where training time is really limited?
- 39:30Pete Blair, PhD: We want to get the the maximum benefit out of any training that we do.
- 39:33Pete Blair, PhD: And so it it takes, you know, I'm always looking to see what we can do to do more and get further than than what we're doing and and have people do things.
- 39:41Pete Blair, PhD: And so again, it just there's no consistency across agencies.
- 39:45Pete Blair, PhD: Some agencies are very interested in this, some are not.
- 39:47Pete Blair, PhD: Most state standards are still written in such a way that they don't really encapsulate these ideas.
- 39:53Pete Blair, PhD: You're still going to see every state having a firearms qualification score that you have to shoot, you know, whatever number of rounds that these targets set up this way within these time constraints as their primary firearms test.
- 40:05Pete Blair, PhD: Some states have mandatory lists of defensive tactics, techniques that you have to go through and and do these things.
- 40:12Pete Blair, PhD: Uh, you have to be able to demonstrate each one of those techniques in a particular way.
- 40:16Pete Blair, PhD: Um, so there's a lot of variation.
- 40:19Pete Blair, PhD: And with anything in this area, when you introduce something new, it's going to take time to turn the ship.
- 40:23Pete Blair, PhD: And that's certainly the case in in our organization and alert that we have we do training all over the country.
- 40:30Pete Blair, PhD: We have hundreds of instructors, we have existing material, we have hundreds or thousands, probably tens of thousands of certified instructors who've taken training from us in the past.
- 40:39Pete Blair, PhD: And so as you move toward this kind of methodology, it takes time for all that stuff to kind of filter through and percolate through about how you do it.
- 40:47Pete Blair, PhD: And so it's it's an ongoing thing.
- 40:49Pete Blair, PhD: And and you know, I will say that it's it's interesting to me because the thing that people always grab onto about what they really like about our training is our force-on-force-based scenario training.
- 40:58Pete Blair, PhD: That we put you in realistic scenarios and we make you work through those scenarios.
- 41:03Pete Blair, PhD: But we also are still doing some traditional skills blocks.
- 41:06Pete Blair, PhD: Here's how you do these kinds of things, and doing some sit-down lecture in the classroom and and all those things.
- 41:12Pete Blair, PhD: And so it's a matter for us of trying to, hey, how do we turn these things so that many more things look much more like the scenario-based training, just smaller scenarios when we're focused on certain things.
- 41:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, that's what we lived.
- 41:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, we always had red air, uh, we always got to see an enemy.
- 41:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, they would always simulate different versions of threat aircraft.
- 41:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We would know that going in.
- 41:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We understand the context we're going into.
- 41:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So those are the constraints.
- 41:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Putting an F-18 out there and saying you're you're going to be simulating a generation three fighter, a third gen fighter, that type of thing.
- 41:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you know, we that's the experience that I had.
- 41:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So again, coming out of the military, coming into the civilian world, I'm looking around like, did I do something wrong the whole time?
- 41:50Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I do want to get nerdy with you, some academics uh that uh we can pull from.
- 41:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Can you talk about the four P side here in a moment?
- 41:57Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Sure.
- 41:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So Yeah, and let me give you some background.
- 42:00Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So I I came across your four P work uh from Rob Gray's new book, right?
- 42:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then I went back and I saw some of your papers on it and some of your Substack on it.
- 42:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I do have one of your slides from your Substack.
- 42:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Would that be helpful?
- 42:12Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 42:13Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But you want to take us through it?
- 42:16Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, so the uh the four Ps comes really out of philosophy and cognitive science.
- 42:22Pete Blair, PhD: And the argument, uh and it again, this is kind of it gets academically nerdy because in trying to look at the different systems and models and things that people have of training and how they think these things work, it takes you into the philosophical realm in some areas, and then I I found this uh John Vervake's work, and he's a philosopher who works as a cognitive scientist, trained as a philosopher, works as a cognitive scientist, and he has this model that he calls the four P's.
- 42:54Pete Blair, PhD: And he essentially argues that there are four kinds of knowing.
- 42:56Pete Blair, PhD: There's propositional knowledge, that's you know facts about things.
- 43:00Pete Blair, PhD: So cats or mammals is oftentimes used as the example.
- 43:05Pete Blair, PhD: Then there's procedural knowing, that's you know how to do something, like ride a bike or shoot a gun, whatever it might be.
- 43:12Pete Blair, PhD: There's perspectival knowing, it's you know what it's like to be in that situation.
- 43:17Pete Blair, PhD: And then there's participatory knowing, which is is probably the most difficult to explain, but that's knowing by being.
- 43:24Pete Blair, PhD: It's assuming a role is a good way to think about it.
- 43:26Pete Blair, PhD: And so if we just a little bit of detail on that, so propositions by their nature are linguistic or language-based, right?
- 43:35Pete Blair, PhD: So I gotta say it or I gotta write it down.
- 43:37Pete Blair, PhD: That's really cool because I can say a bunch of propositions, and that's what we've been doing in this podcast is kind of trading propositions back and forth.
- 43:45Pete Blair, PhD: So I can transfer them to a large group of people very quickly, and it's it's valuable that way.
- 43:50Pete Blair, PhD: And it's good when I'm talking to other people to try to explain what's going on and what we're doing.
- 43:54Pete Blair, PhD: It has its own memory system called semantic memory, which is it's Language memory.
- 44:02Pete Blair, PhD: And then you have procedural knowing.
- 44:03Pete Blair, PhD: Those are skills.
- 44:04Pete Blair, PhD: When we think about skills, that's what people usually think about as procedural skills.
- 44:08Pete Blair, PhD: It you can't really transfer by telling.
- 44:11Pete Blair, PhD: I can help you a little bit with that.
- 44:12Pete Blair, PhD: You could read a book on riding a bike, it might help you a little bit to get started, but ultimately you don't know how to ride the bike till you get on the bike, right?
- 44:18Pete Blair, PhD: You have to get on the bike and do it.
- 44:21Pete Blair, PhD: And it has a different form of memory that's called procedural memory, and those two memory systems are separate within you.
- 44:30Pete Blair, PhD: So there's some research on damage to one area and still being able to learn any other area and those sorts of things.
- 44:36Pete Blair, PhD: But one of the implications of this is if I were to so if you just think about this, think about a lot of the things you have skills in, and and we can stay with bike riding if you want, that's fine.
- 44:46Pete Blair, PhD: If we talk about bike riding and I say, how do you ride a bike?
- 44:51Pete Blair, PhD: Your initial response is probably well, I just ride a bike.
- 44:55Pete Blair, PhD: You know, that that that's what you do.
- 44:56Pete Blair, PhD: You don't have the propositions to explain it.
- 44:58Pete Blair, PhD: Now, if I push you on it, you'll come up with an explanation.
- 45:01Pete Blair, PhD: You'll tell me, okay, here's what I do, this is what's happening when I'm riding the bike.
- 45:06Pete Blair, PhD: Uh there's an area of sports research that looks at high-level performers who are explaining what they do in their sport, whatever it might be.
- 45:14Pete Blair, PhD: Let's say it's a basketball player talking about this fantastic jump shot they have.
- 45:18Pete Blair, PhD: And they'll have the basketball player go through and describe, you know, tell me how you do this amazing thing that you do.
- 45:24Pete Blair, PhD: And they'll go through and describe it in great detail, they'll demonstrate it, they'll tell you all the steps, all those sorts of things.
- 45:30Pete Blair, PhD: Then they'll go watch game footage, and that is not what happens.
- 45:34Pete Blair, PhD: Okay.
- 45:35Pete Blair, PhD: And it's not because that person is lying to you, it's because we don't have that's a different form of memory, and they aren't directly connected to each other, and so it's it doesn't have great access.
- 45:46Pete Blair, PhD: Then you have perspectival knowing.
- 45:49Pete Blair, PhD: Again, that's knowing by being in the situation, right?
- 45:52Pete Blair, PhD: It it that's involved with things like situational awareness.
- 45:56Pete Blair, PhD: What do I pay attention to?
- 45:58Pete Blair, PhD: But also really importantly is it's can it's part of what controls your skills, right?
- 46:03Pete Blair, PhD: Your how and when of your skills, because you don't go around just firing off your skills at random.
- 46:08Pete Blair, PhD: You do them in circumstances that are appropriate and you adapt them based on the conditions that you're operating in.
- 46:14Pete Blair, PhD: So that's the perspectival knowing.
- 46:17Pete Blair, PhD: Participatory is again that that idea of role.
- 46:20Pete Blair, PhD: And I usually when I talk about this, I talk about as I get further away from propositions, I start waving my hands a lot more because propositions don't do a very good job of explaining what this thing is is really about.
- 46:33Pete Blair, PhD: So think about participatory knowing is it's reciprocal.
- 46:36Pete Blair, PhD: And oftentimes I'll use a picture of a mother and a child.
- 46:39Pete Blair, PhD: As the mother is raising the child, she's definitely impacting the child and how the child grows up, but the child's also impacting her and changing her.
- 46:47Pete Blair, PhD: So there's this reciprocity that's going on.
- 46:50Pete Blair, PhD: It's associated with again the idea of a role that I'm assuming a role, it's about meaning in life, it's about uh belonging, those sorts of things that are tied into participatory learning.
- 47:03Pete Blair, PhD: So if you this particular picture you have is the traditional model of training, which usually starts with the foundation of propositions.
- 47:12Pete Blair, PhD: I give you all the facts and figures and details about things first, and after you have that, those facts, then we start worrying about the procedural, how do you do something that's in that area?
- 47:25Pete Blair, PhD: So you can think about it in terms of uh firearms training, that's fine.
- 47:29Pete Blair, PhD: That's usually talked about.
- 47:30Pete Blair, PhD: I'm gonna bring in the classroom, gonna teach you the nomenclature of the firearm, gonna show you all the parts of the firearm.
- 47:36Pete Blair, PhD: I'm gonna tell you the fundamental firearm safety rules.
- 47:40Pete Blair, PhD: I'm going to show you pictures oftentimes of this is what proper site alignment looks like.
- 47:46Pete Blair, PhD: And when bullet hits here, it means your sights are like that.
- 47:49Pete Blair, PhD: Bullet hits here, your sites were like that, right?
- 47:51Pete Blair, PhD: And I'm gonna show you those images, and then after we've done all that classroom time, we're gonna go out to the range, and then we're gonna start working on shooting at targets on the range, oftentimes on a on a flat range with a fixed target.
- 48:05Pete Blair, PhD: Oftentimes the target doesn't even look like a person, really, it's just some kind of outline silhouette thing.
- 48:10Pete Blair, PhD: And once you get good at shooting on the range, then we might add perspectival by putting you in a few scenarios that that's there.
- 48:18Pete Blair, PhD: That's usually late in the in the training.
- 48:21Pete Blair, PhD: And oftentimes there's little concern given about participatory, it's just kind of assume that participatory comes along with whatever it is.
- 48:29Pete Blair, PhD: And what Verbake models is that that model is actually opposite of this, that the core of all learning is participatory.
- 48:39Pete Blair, PhD: You assume a role.
- 48:40Pete Blair, PhD: And whether you specify that role to a person beforehand or not, they automatically get it.
- 48:46Pete Blair, PhD: So if I go out and we're doing firearms training and I don't give you a specific role, you're gonna have the role of I'm a student in a firearms training class, right?
- 48:56Pete Blair, PhD: But I could also give you the role of you are a police officer acting as a police officer acts, and I can give you a situation, all those sorts of things to kind of give you a framework for.
- 49:07Pete Blair, PhD: But the idea is that I have this role, I'm a police officer, that shapes my perspective, that effect impacts what am I trying to achieve in this situation?
- 49:17Pete Blair, PhD: What am I trying to accomplish here?
- 49:19Pete Blair, PhD: That informs what procedural things I do to try to achieve those goals, the techniques, tactics, and things like that that I use.
- 49:27Pete Blair, PhD: And throughout the entire thing, you're getting the propositions that go along with you being able to talk about and explain these things with other people as you as you're doing that.
- 49:37Pete Blair, PhD: So that's kind of the Verveki's idea, is that participatory is the ground from which all these other forms of knowing come from.
- 49:45Pete Blair, PhD: And when I talk about the four P's, basically the argument is we should take that seriously and we should think seriously about when we're training somebody, what is the role that we are training them for, and we should try to connect whatever we're doing in training to that role.
- 50:01Pete Blair, PhD: Right?
- 50:02Pete Blair, PhD: So we're we're connecting it to that.
- 50:04Pete Blair, PhD: If I'm gonna be uh an air combat pilot, that's the role I'm training you for is to be an air combat pilot, which would be a different role than if I'm training you to be a cargo pilot, right?
- 50:17Pete Blair, PhD: So that that affects how you're gonna view things and how you're gonna think about how this all unfolds and how you do that, and it and it goes down from there.
- 50:26Pete Blair, PhD: And then usually the uh example I I'll ask people when I talk about it, okay, have you ever been trained this way?
- 50:32Pete Blair, PhD: And then oftentimes they're like, No, I've never received training like this.
- 50:36Pete Blair, PhD: And you'll say, How'd you learn how to ride a bike?
- 50:40Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah.
- 50:40Pete Blair, PhD: And that's that's what your parents did, right?
- 50:43Pete Blair, PhD: They didn't have you a classroom in your house that they took you in, wrote all the parts of the bike on the whiteboard.
- 50:49Pete Blair, PhD: Here are the roles of the road, here are, you know, here are all these things that are there.
- 50:53Pete Blair, PhD: They took you out and you were going to become a bike rider.
- 50:57Pete Blair, PhD: So I am going to be my role now is I'm a bike rider, right?
- 51:00Pete Blair, PhD: And I'm going to learn how to be a bike rider.
- 51:02Pete Blair, PhD: That gives me a perspective about what things are important for bike riding, right?
- 51:07Pete Blair, PhD: And then I start to learn the procedure of bike riding.
- 51:11Pete Blair, PhD: How do I pedal?
- 51:12Pete Blair, PhD: How do I balance?
- 51:13Pete Blair, PhD: How do I steer?
- 51:14Pete Blair, PhD: All those kind of things.
- 51:15Pete Blair, PhD: And I'm learning the words of these things throughout, oftentimes as they're necessary or needed.
- 51:21Pete Blair, PhD: So you're you're learning the physics of bike riding, at least implicitly, by getting on the bike and feeling the balance.
- 51:28Pete Blair, PhD: You're learning things that are coachable, that are helpable.
- 51:32Pete Blair, PhD: You know, when you see the kid looking right in front of the bike as opposed to looking further ahead and those things that they're they're giving you that.
- 51:38Pete Blair, PhD: But you're learning it by engaging with the thing in the role that you're actually going to use that thing in.
- 51:45Pete Blair, PhD: And then oftentimes when we talk about gaining skills or or things, we'll we'll talk about, well, it's like riding a bike, and the implication seems to be that it's easy.
- 51:56Pete Blair, PhD: But bike riding's not easy.
- 51:59Pete Blair, PhD: Okay, it's a complex skill.
- 52:01Pete Blair, PhD: You have an object that you're interacting with that you have to balance on two wheels across all these different environments while there's uh other things in the environment, traffic and all those things you have to be aware of.
- 52:11Pete Blair, PhD: It's actually a very complex skill.
- 52:13Pete Blair, PhD: But most of us, even if you haven't ridden a bike in decades, I can give you a bike and you can get back on it and you're you're riding within a few seconds.
- 52:22Pete Blair, PhD: And if I were to ask you what are the things you grab onto to steer the bike, you know they're handlebars, and if I ask you what about the things you push to make the bike go, you know they're pedals.
- 52:31Pete Blair, PhD: That has stuck with you all this time.
- 52:33Pete Blair, PhD: So perhaps when we talk about it's like riding a bike, it's saying more about how we learned this than about how difficult the actual thing is.
- 52:46Pete Blair, PhD: So that's the the kind of four piece idea.
- 52:50Pete Blair, PhD: And and the core of it here to me is really to think about very carefully when you're doing training, what is the role that I want them to occupy, and then can I connect that training to that role so that we're not making these isolated things that happen that aren't connected to things.
- 53:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I I say this, we we lived in Europe uh when my kids were younger, where they were born over there, and we had access to the only bikes you could buy at the time over there were the balance bikes.
- 53:16Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We'd never seen them before, right?
- 53:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But everybody in Germany had, you know, all the kids riding around these little bikes, and we get back to Seattle, we moved to Seattle, and the girls never got had training wheels on their bike, and and they were riding their bikes before anybody else.
- 53:26Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And that to me is just representative of design.
- 53:28Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The the you know, you're bouncing you have to balance on a bike using your feet, and and that's how they learn their balance.
- 53:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And they I think that's where they learn to pick their heads up and all that, because they're in a context, right?
- 53:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Whereas training wheels, can you give me the equivalent of training wheels in your world?
- 53:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What would that look like?
- 53:43Pete Blair, PhD: So to me, the problem with training wheels is they create false affordances, right?
- 53:47Pete Blair, PhD: They give you false balance points.
- 53:49Pete Blair, PhD: So, first off, when they're first put on, and this is the people oftentimes don't use them the way they originally intended to.
- 53:54Pete Blair, PhD: The idea is that you never have the training wheels actually touching all the way, that there's always a little bit of gap so that there's a little bit of balance going on when I'm learning.
- 54:03Pete Blair, PhD: And as they get better, they're supposed to get higher and higher so that they just kind of serve as a last second stop gap if I really mess up.
- 54:10Pete Blair, PhD: But they create, they aren't exposing you to the core skill of bike riding, which I would say is balancing while in motion, right?
- 54:16Pete Blair, PhD: And so you're learning something.
- 54:18Pete Blair, PhD: You're learning something about pedaling, you're learning something about steering, and as you raise those wheels, you're learning something about balance.
- 54:24Pete Blair, PhD: But the balance bike to me goes straight at look, the core skill of this is balancing while in motion.
- 54:30Pete Blair, PhD: And it gives you immediate access to that.
- 54:32Pete Blair, PhD: And then you just add the pedaling later, right?
- 54:34Pete Blair, PhD: It's like we just get that out of the way, you're gonna balance, you're gonna learn to do this, and then you're zooming around.
- 54:38Pete Blair, PhD: And and like you said, the transition for kids when they go to a pedal bike tends to be very easy, right?
- 54:43Pete Blair, PhD: They just move over and then they just they're just adding that.
- 54:46Pete Blair, PhD: So, so that's the the core idea.
- 54:48Pete Blair, PhD: A lot of times in in law enforcement, what you know, what amounts to the training wheels is being less effective.
- 54:55Pete Blair, PhD: I don't know that there's a a clear analogy.
- 54:58Pete Blair, PhD: You know, what I would say is what happens more often in law enforcement is probably instead of using a balanced bike versus training wheels, is more like I put you on an exercise bike so that you can get your pedaling down correctly, and then I put you on a real bike, and now you're supposed to be able to pedal because I taught you how to pedal.
- 55:16Pete Blair, PhD: And and it's missing the those core components, it's decomposed is the way we usually talk about it.
- 55:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So that's kind of like training brings out the the wrong thing.
- 55:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I would I I would try to think so your exercise bike analogy would be I'm trained on a bike that's stationary inside a gym in a static environment, but that's not the world I'm operating in.
- 55:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Correct.
- 55:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Okay.
- 55:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Correct.
- 55:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And then something else I heard from you is the limited training time.
- 55:42Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And I think that's another reason this is important.
- 55:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh we always joke around that uh, you know, in the military, we spent 99% of our time training and maybe one percent actually executing, and and that's not necessarily what where you want to be.
- 55:54Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We want that closer to zero, right?
- 55:56Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, but in your environment, you get it's the other way around.
- 55:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I imagine it's closer to one percent time training and 99% doing.
- 56:03Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, 1% might be generous once you're out of the academy, right?
- 56:06Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, yeah.
- 56:06Pete Blair, PhD: You're actually in the field, you're spending almost all your time on duty, and you get a very little bit of training.
- 56:12Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, depending on the state, the mandated training per year is somewhere between 20 and 40 hours.
- 56:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So what you put into that 1% absolutely matters, right?
- 56:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 56:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And and I think uh that's what we're talking about today, is is uh that participatory uh side of this.
- 56:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you create those conditions and that 1% training to have the 4P model uh I would say not emerge, but follow that the the in the in the flip model.
- 56:35Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, well, I also think that you you if you don't get a chance to have formal training, you start looking for opportunities to do training within your regular work.
- 56:43Pete Blair, PhD: And that's where some of those skills, like you talked about, like debriefing, after every whatever you do, you arrest a subject, we can sit down, we can debrief it afterward and say, hey, you did this and I did this, and this is it, you know, we work coordinated or whatever it might be, and we can we can talk about it, and then next time we can try to do better on how we approach that thing.
- 57:01Pete Blair, PhD: And so then we're getting something in a in a very representative environment, right?
- 57:06Pete Blair, PhD: We have less control over the constraints about how we approach it, but we are doing the thing, and we're doing the thing in a thoughtful way to try to improve our skill.
- 57:14Pete Blair, PhD: We're not just running from thing to thing to thing to thing.
- 57:18Pete Blair, PhD: We're trying to actually, can I get a training rep out of this?
- 57:20Pete Blair, PhD: And I I use the example of uh Austin.
- 57:23Pete Blair, PhD: They recently had that shooting on Sixth Street at Buford's bar, and they had a fantastic response to that where the the police were on the bad guy very quickly.
- 57:32Pete Blair, PhD: They stopped the bad guy, they also had medics into the scene very quickly and they got everybody to the hospital very quickly, like all the things that you can do to make things go well during an active attack type event.
- 57:42Pete Blair, PhD: And part of that is yes, they're doing the training and and they do good training, and that's that's great.
- 57:46Pete Blair, PhD: And they've got people that they train way beyond the normal standard of their officers, so they have that enhanced capability and that there are always some of those people around wherever something might happen.
- 57:55Pete Blair, PhD: But then they get to practice these skills in that environment every weekend because every weekend they deploy officers to Sixth Street and they deploy a rescue task force that has officers combined with medics.
- 58:07Pete Blair, PhD: And then every week on Sixth Week, Sixth Street, there are medical emergencies happening, there are fights that break out, and they're able to go.
- 58:14Pete Blair, PhD: Now we're gonna deploy and we're gonna deal with this situation.
- 58:17Pete Blair, PhD: And then, okay, we're we're encountering this.
- 58:19Pete Blair, PhD: This is as real as it gets because it is real.
- 58:21Pete Blair, PhD: It's a lower stakes thing that we're dealing with.
- 58:23Pete Blair, PhD: And then you get all these reps of doing this over and over and over again in these lower key situations.
- 58:29Pete Blair, PhD: And then when the big thing kicks off, these things just carry over because we've already got a ton of reps dealing with this kind of thing and the real world.
- 58:36Brian "Ponch" Rivera: On the art and science of debriefing and the education of attention.
- 58:40Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You know, uh, we spent a lot of time talking to experts in the field of debriefing, but I don't think anybody's ever broken it down like that where you you know, when we debrief in training, we're instructors and and we're taking folks through uh the syllabus.
- 58:53Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I've reflecting back on it, we're spending a lot of time on the education of attention.
- 58:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So we're creating that situational awareness.
- 59:01Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh can you talk a little bit about that?
- 59:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How do you how how does CLA fit into this?
- 59:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: How are you guys working that that education of attention for training police officers and policing?
- 59:10Pete Blair, PhD: So, what we're trying to do, if you want to educate attention, means that the information they're supposed to be paying attention to has to be in the training environment, right?
- 59:17Pete Blair, PhD: So you have to reflect that.
- 59:20Pete Blair, PhD: That's what representative design is about is what is the core information that's going to be here.
- 59:24Pete Blair, PhD: The simple proxy for that is the more realistic your training is, the more like the real thing, the better chance that you've got the correct things in your training and the better chance that it transfers from there.
- 59:34Pete Blair, PhD: But there's no reason you can't extend that beyond just the normal practice environment and look at your daily performance and be, you know, reflective about that.
- 59:43Pete Blair, PhD: I mean, that goes all the way back to Schoen's reflective practitioner stuff way back in the day.
- 59:48Pete Blair, PhD: And there have been other models of it since then.
- 59:50Pete Blair, PhD: But that idea of instead of just going through your life and showing up for work and doing that, if you spend a little bit of time about thinking about in this situation, how did this turn out?
- 59:58Pete Blair, PhD: What mattered, what didn't matter, what do I need to work on, then you're building that training cycle into your daily practice and trying to improve on particular things, right?
- 1:00:08Pete Blair, PhD: And uh it's not as clean as the training environment, right?
- 1:00:11Pete Blair, PhD: But it that doesn't mean you shouldn't be learning from things.
- 1:00:14Pete Blair, PhD: And cops do learn an enormous amount when they start going out and working in the field and they get very good at the things they do on their daily basis.
- 1:00:22Pete Blair, PhD: It's the things that are rarer that are more difficult for them because they don't get those practice reps.
- 1:00:27Pete Blair, PhD: But if you think about how to turn those field activities into practice reps, you might be able to do that.
- 1:00:32Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Great.
- 1:00:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Hey, so uh I'm gonna be mindful of your time today.
- 1:00:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: There's one thing I do want to bring up, and that was in your traditional model of 4P.
- 1:00:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh, you brought up the procedural side of things.
- 1:00:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That's one reason why you don't want to buy a book from a leader who uh wrote a book about leadership because they probably don't remember how anything worked, right?
- 1:00:47Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Right.
- 1:00:49Pete Blair, PhD: It's it's really difficult to go back and try to unpack how you did things.
- 1:00:53Pete Blair, PhD: And I I think one of the big things that we talk about instructors is as a subject matter expert in your area, you do know an enormous amount about that area.
- 1:01:03Pete Blair, PhD: You gain that uh enormous amount of knowledge by interacting with the world and your environment and doing all those things.
- 1:01:10Pete Blair, PhD: And the verbal channel or the linguistic channel is not, it's not worthless, has some value, but it's not the best way to get information across to people.
- 1:01:20Pete Blair, PhD: And so what we try to do in our training is your job as the subject matter expert is to take this thing that you know and create the experience for the learner so that they know it now too, right?
- 1:01:32Pete Blair, PhD: So I create that environment that this thing that I know is important that I learned, you're in the environment, you encounter this thing, and now you know it too.
- 1:01:39Pete Blair, PhD: Because there's so much beyond even somebody who's thought really deeply about what they do and and how to verbally explain it, there's still so much implicit knowledge that's going on there that they can't possibly get it all out there.
- 1:01:51Pete Blair, PhD: And so that that's a big part of why we argue like if you want to get good at the thing that you're trying to do, you should do the thing.
- 1:01:58Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:01:59Pete Blair, PhD: And because that knowledge is there, and and yes, there are explicit things we're gonna hit on that we want you to know, but there's also all this implicit stuff that goes along with it that you can't you can't unpack in many cases.
- 1:02:11Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh so your tactical science substack uh is awesome.
- 1:02:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh question to you on books.
- 1:02:15Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We you brought up books a few moments ago.
- 1:02:17Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Are there any books for police officers or trainers in in the policing uh domain to read about?
- 1:02:24Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, which book do you recommend?
- 1:02:25Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What's out there right now?
- 1:02:26Pete Blair, PhD: So for the ecological dynamics, I always talk about reading uh Rob Gray's How We Learned to Move.
- 1:02:31Pete Blair, PhD: That's it his first book.
- 1:02:32Pete Blair, PhD: That's the place to start and see if you're interested in those kind of concepts.
- 1:02:35Pete Blair, PhD: And then he's got a whole series of books.
- 1:02:37Pete Blair, PhD: Uh I don't know anything that's written specifically for law enforcement on the constraints led approach as far as a book length kind of treatment of it.
- 1:02:45Pete Blair, PhD: You know, that may be something after I've been doing this long enough and get enough experience doing it that that might might come out of that.
- 1:02:52Pete Blair, PhD: And hopefully we'll do some research in the area to try to try to validate some of the things we're doing.
- 1:02:56Pete Blair, PhD: But you know, the how we learn to move is the is the place to start for the ecological dynamics approach to things.
- 1:03:02Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah.
- 1:03:02Brian "Ponch" Rivera: If I remember right, I I have that book right behind me somewhere.
- 1:03:04Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not that old, right?
- 1:03:05Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's what, five years old?
- 1:03:06Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, it's something like that.
- 1:03:08Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's not that old.
- 1:03:09Brian "Ponch" Rivera: So you this is relatively new with the things that you're exploring at the moment, right?
- 1:03:12Pete Blair, PhD: I mean, this is So the approach has been around for several decades now, you know, and really even going further back, if you talk about the ecological psychology part of it, that's been longer.
- 1:03:23Pete Blair, PhD: But ecological dynamics in the sporting world is has a couple decades worth of time that people have been using it in the sporting context.
- 1:03:30Pete Blair, PhD: And then now it's it's been expanding into other areas, and you know, law enforcement is a new idea for sure.
- 1:03:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And you're one of the early adopters of this, or we're I think so.
- 1:03:41Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I think we're we're there at that that cutting edge trying to figure things out.
- 1:03:44Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:03:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Great.
- 1:03:45Brian "Ponch" Rivera: What where can our listeners find more about your work?
- 1:03:48Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Um, what are you doing next?
- 1:03:49Brian "Ponch" Rivera: That type of thing.
- 1:03:50Pete Blair, PhD: Uh well, the uh organization that I work for is Alert A-L-E-R-R-T, that's for advanced law enforcement rapid response training uh.org.
- 1:03:59Pete Blair, PhD: And there's our website there that talks about all the training that we do.
- 1:04:02Pete Blair, PhD: And then you mentioned tactical science.substack.com, which is the the newsletter blog that I I post to.
- 1:04:08Pete Blair, PhD: It's free.
- 1:04:09Pete Blair, PhD: You can go check out that.
- 1:04:10Pete Blair, PhD: And sometimes I'm talking about training things and specifically, and other times I'm just reviewing kind of literature in the policing use of force area uh and giving summaries of that.
- 1:04:20Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah, I I like using Substack in writing because it it just gets the ideas out there to see if anybody has any challenges or uh help you think through that.
- 1:04:27Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's not a definitive, hey, this is how it all it is.
- 1:04:30Brian "Ponch" Rivera: It's it's it's a thought process, right?
- 1:04:31Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We're always learning.
- 1:04:32Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, certainly.
- 1:04:33Pete Blair, PhD: Certainly.
- 1:04:33Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, it's it's different.
- 1:04:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Yeah.
- 1:04:35Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, hey, uh Pete, Doc Blair, I really appreciate your time.
- 1:04:38Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Love to have you back on, maybe down the road when when uh I think CLA is going to grow over the next several years.
- 1:04:43Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I may be wrong about that, but if I have anything to say about it, I definitely want more folks uh looking into it and experiencing this and seeing how powerful the concepts are, the the constraints are, understanding that.
- 1:04:55Brian "Ponch" Rivera: We you know we've had Alicia Jurao on, uh who's who's gone through context is everything.
- 1:04:59Brian "Ponch" Rivera: She sent me a note the other day talking about asking about something on the constraints and uh actually the uh some mechanisms of neuroscience and and what's being written over there.
- 1:05:07Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Uh but I I think the big thing I want our listeners to make sure they take away from this is that is that linear oodaloop is it's okay.
- 1:05:14Brian "Ponch" Rivera: But if you look at the bigger picture, you'll start to see the external environment.
- 1:05:18Brian "Ponch" Rivera: You can start to see elements of the CLA.
- 1:05:21Brian "Ponch" Rivera: And again, um it's just an invitation.
- 1:05:22Brian "Ponch" Rivera: The oodaloop is an invitation to dive deeper into these things.
- 1:05:26Pete Blair, PhD: Yeah, when you see Boyd talk about it in more detail, there's a lot more there than just that simple linear loop.
- 1:05:33Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Well, great.
- 1:05:34Brian "Ponch" Rivera: I'll keep you on here for a moment, and then uh we'll call it the uh end of the podcast for now.
- 1:05:37Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks again, talk player.
- 1:05:39Brian "Ponch" Rivera: Thanks for having me on.
- 1:05:40John R. Boyd: What am I getting at?
- 1:05:41John R. Boyd: The underlying message is very simple, then.
- 1:05:43John R. Boyd: There is no layout.
- 1:05:45John R. Boyd: Unless we can eliminate the feature just cited.
- 1:05:51John R. Boyd: Well, problem though, we don't know how to do this.