Latest / The Jeremy Ryan Slate Show / New France's Economic Power Sparked Everything
Transcript
- 0:15Welcome back to the Jeremy Ryan Slate show.
- 0:16I am your host Jeremy Ryan Slate, the CEO and Co founder of
- 0:19command your brand. We help our clients to combat
- 0:22council culture by placing them on the right podcast and new
- 0:25media can check us out over at commandyourbrand.com or also I
- 0:30recently purchased the podcast election.com after the past
- 0:34election we have. So you can also go there and get
- 0:35to commandyourbrand.com as well. Reminder to like this video,
- 0:38leave his comment and smash the subscribe button.
- 0:40If you support liberty freedom and want to build a better
- 0:42future. Guys, I'm very excited about the
- 0:44conversation we have coming to you today.
- 0:47Not too long ago I was on normal world on the blaze and today's
- 0:51guest was actually the the Co host that day.
- 0:54He was filling in for for Dave Landau and we got a chance to
- 0:57hang out. And I was like, man, I got to
- 0:59have a conversation with these guy.
- 1:00So, So Jimmy McCartney, welcome to the show, man.
- 1:03Thank you so much for having me, Jeremy.
- 1:04I'm super pumped to be here buddy.
- 1:06Yeah. So I guess in addition to to
- 1:09looking like the second coming, why don't you tell people a
- 1:11little bit about your background because I think people know you
- 1:15really as a comedian. But in actuality, we're going to
- 1:17talk about today is is a lot of what you actually have
- 1:20accreditation in. So tell us a little bit about
- 1:21that man, and then what we're going to talk about today.
- 1:23Yeah, absolutely. So my name is Jimmy McCartney
- 1:25and I'm a stand up comedian and I perform all over the country.
- 1:29But prior to being a full time comedian, I actually was
- 1:32educated and went to school for social studies and I have a
- 1:35master's degree in social studies education with a
- 1:38bachelor's in history. And when I was in school I
- 1:41specialized in Canadian studies with a minor in Canadian
- 1:44studies. And so the main thing that I
- 1:46really focused on when I was in school was the history and
- 1:48development of New France as a colony.
- 1:51And so it's a part of history that kind of gets overlooked and
- 1:53a lot of people don't know much about it.
- 1:55But it's incredibly significant for so many different reasons.
- 1:58And also, I believe it's important for people to know
- 2:01about it because it'll give, I think it'll give people a
- 2:03different perspective on colonization and how not all
- 2:06colonies were run the same way. I guess just out of curiosity,
- 2:10like why do you think it's overlooked too?
- 2:11Because I'm a very informed guy. I've read a lot of stuff.
- 2:14I taught APUS history when I was a teacher for a couple years.
- 2:18I was totally unaware of this I guess.
- 2:20Why do you think it just doesn't get me any play man?
- 2:25I don't know, it's hard to say. I mean, I would think more than
- 2:27anything, just because the population of New France was so
- 2:30low, maybe it was just deemed to be less significant, but it
- 2:33honestly, the, the population size of New France was one of
- 2:36the key components as to why it is so important historically.
- 2:39So to answer your question, I really don't know why it gets
- 2:41overlooked. It's it's honestly a disservice
- 2:43because it's incredibly important.
- 2:45We also like a lot of kids and I'm sure, you know, like we
- 2:47learn a lot about Spanish colonies, not just British ones,
- 2:50but how the how the Spanish ran their colonies and their empire,
- 2:54even a little bit with the Dutch, but not so much with the
- 2:56French in their North American assets.
- 2:58And it's a really, really big disservice to history because
- 3:02New France was run so much more differently than not only the
- 3:05Spanish Empire, but also the 13 colonies of the United States.
- 3:08So so let's talk a little bit about New France.
- 3:12You know, Cartier starts his his exploration in in 1535.
- 3:16So let's, I guess without getting too weighed down by the
- 3:20dates and stuff like that, let's talk a little bit about, you
- 3:22know, what is New France? How does it come about, you
- 3:24know, and, and what was so different about it compared to
- 3:27like how things operated here in America?
- 3:29Yeah. So the short of it, New France
- 3:32is effectively what you would think of modern day Quebec in
- 3:35Canada, primarily along the Saint Lawrence River Valley.
- 3:38And the two cities that everyone knows about are Quebec City and
- 3:41Montreal. And like you mentioned, Jeremy,
- 3:44the first main explorer that's kind of credited with the
- 3:46foundations of New France is Jacques Cartier.
- 3:48Came over in 1535, didn't really do too much, just kind of pretty
- 3:51much put the stake in the ground, said this is ours.
- 3:54A few other settlers came and went over the next few years.
- 3:56The big thing that really happened, that was a major
- 3:58turning point is when Samuel de Champlain came over in 16 O 8.
- 4:02And that's when things really started to pick up and change.
- 4:05Samuel de Champlain is a very fascinating person in history
- 4:08because he led the expedition for the French.
- 4:11But what's noteworthy about him, he was not going over with a
- 4:14mindset of conquest. He was actually raised with his
- 4:18father and his uncle. I believe it was the secondary
- 4:21source that we're navigators. So his mindset was primarily
- 4:24about exploration, seeing new things, charting things, not
- 4:27conquering and enslaving. So he came over in 16 O 8.
- 4:32And the term Quebec is a, is a term that means like where the
- 4:35river, where the water narrows. So it's not as you look at Yeah.
- 4:38And if you look at Quebec City, it's an unbelievably important
- 4:42and good place strategically because not only is it where the
- 4:46Saint Lawrence River narrows, it's also on a very, very steep
- 4:50Cliff face. So it's like ideal.
- 4:52It's so close to the perfect skiing as well, Montre Blanc.
- 4:55But anyway, yeah. Yeah, exactly, exactly.
- 4:59So it's just a very important person or place geographically.
- 5:02So anyway, Samuel de Champlain came in sixteen O 8 found that
- 5:05location, settled it. Now this is one of the most
- 5:08important parts that I believe in all of modern history.
- 5:11So when Samuel de Champlain first got over here, he made
- 5:15immediate good relations with the Native Americans that he
- 5:17first encountered, primarily the Algonquins who were hunter
- 5:21gatherers, but also the Hurons who were similar to the Iroquois
- 5:24and, and their beliefs and the way that they operated.
- 5:27So he made good relationships with them when he first landed.
- 5:31And then what they wanted to do was sail down the Saint Lawrence
- 5:34into what is now Lake Champlain, which was named after him.
- 5:38And basically in order to solidify the relationship with
- 5:41those Native Americans, they sailed down together where they
- 5:44encountered the Iroquois, who are very powerful Native
- 5:47American group that were located in modern day New York State.
- 5:51And they were long time enemies of both the Algonquin and the
- 5:54Huron and other Native Americans.
- 5:56So basically, the Algonquins and the Hurons were like, hey, those
- 5:58guys over there are the bad guys.
- 6:00They're our enemies. And in order to solidify this
- 6:02dynamic, this relationship, Shamiel D Champlain actually
- 6:05went into combat with the Algonquins and the Hurons.
- 6:08And the coolest part about this whole thing is that in the midst
- 6:11of that first battle where he fought alongside his Native
- 6:14American allies, he actually stood up wearing metal armor and
- 6:18a metal helmet with what is like a precursor to a musket picture,
- 6:22like an old version of a shotgun.
- 6:24And the Iroquois had never heard a gun.
- 6:26Obviously, they'd never seen it. They'd never seen these massive
- 6:29ships. So they see this man standing up
- 6:30with metal like modern day Iron Man with this massive musket.
- 6:34And he releases this incredibly loud sound with like, all this
- 6:36smoke. And I think it was three of
- 6:39their chiefs where two of them died right away and one of them
- 6:42was severely injured. And they had never seen that.
- 6:44So the Iroquois fled. They were like, what is that?
- 6:47And this permanently solidified the relationship with the
- 6:49Algonquins and the Hurons. And they're like, the French are
- 6:51homies. These are our guys.
- 6:53Like, let's go. So the reason why that's so
- 6:57important is because even from the very beginning of New
- 6:59France, Samuel de Champlain created very, very close bonds
- 7:03with those Algonquins, Hurons, and the other Native Americans
- 7:06and simultaneously immediately made enemies with the Iroquois,
- 7:11who that's also not the native term for the Iroquois were the
- 7:14Hootenoshaw name, which means the people of the longhouse.
- 7:17So anyway. But that's just like.
- 7:21The The Babylonians called Noah open the pitch 10 but that's
- 7:24neither here nor there. But anyway, continue.
- 7:26Yeah, similar idea, similar idea.
- 7:28And so the reason why the British established
- 7:31relationships with the Iroquois is because the idea of the enemy
- 7:34of my enemy, right. So the British have been going
- 7:36to war with France forever and they start colonizing in New
- 7:39York and, you know, Virginia, Pennsylvania, and they encounter
- 7:43the the Iroquois and they're like, hey, we hate the French.
- 7:46And then the British are like we do too.
- 7:48So the alliances that eventually culminated in the French and
- 7:52Indian War were set at the very, very beginning.
- 7:55Now, the reason why New France developed so differently than
- 7:58other colonies was the way it was set up.
- 8:01They had a very, very low population as opposed to the
- 8:04British 13 colonies. At the time of the French and
- 8:07Indian War, which takes place a very long time later, there was
- 8:09only 100,000 people or less that were living there as opposed to
- 8:13over 1,000,000 that were living in a 13 colony.
- 8:15So they had a very low population, but also the
- 8:17incentives for what they were going for in the colony was so
- 8:20vitally important and it was primarily focused around the fur
- 8:23trade at the time. The fur trade was like it.
- 8:27It was like the equivalency of getting the newest iPhone,
- 8:31getting a Tesla. Your fur hat that you wore in
- 8:34Europe was a status symbol of how wealthy you were, how
- 8:37modern, how popular. Everything.
- 8:40The fur hat was like it. And so the fur trade was
- 8:43unbelievably massive. But in order to have furs, it's
- 8:46not like mining gold. You need to have land that needs
- 8:49to come from primarily from Beavers that are out in the
- 8:51wild. So how do you get those?
- 8:53The Native Americans who know the land, so the French for an
- 8:56economic reason, developed incredibly good relationships
- 9:00with the natives, not just like are around Quebec and Montreal,
- 9:03but in the surrounding areas, which is how New France was able
- 9:06to control such a massive area with a very, very low population
- 9:10because they had some direct economic ties to the different
- 9:12Native American groups. And the guys that used to go out
- 9:15into the woods were called the cord duois, like the runners of
- 9:18the woods. And they had such good
- 9:20relationships with exceptions, obviously, I'm not trying to
- 9:23claim everything is perfect hunky Dory.
- 9:25But overall they had extremely good relationships with the
- 9:28Native Americans. And they would trade things like
- 9:31axes and and metal products for these furs.
- 9:35And so they were able to, the French were able to develop
- 9:37trade networks that were unbelievably massive from modern
- 9:41day Ohio down the Mississippi River all the way up to Quebec,
- 9:44northern Quebec. It was unbelievably massive.
- 9:46And they did it with a very, very small force because they
- 9:49had good economic relationships. And the most interesting thing
- 9:52about the core Dubois, the the fur traders is a lot of them
- 9:56actually married Native American women.
- 9:58And this led to the creation of the Metis people who are, I
- 10:02think Metis translates to like mixed race.
- 10:04So effectively it was just blending of the culture of the,
- 10:07of the core Dubois and the local Natives.
- 10:11And they're still alive today and primarily in Manitoba and in
- 10:16Canada and Ontario as well. And so the, the, the dynamic
- 10:19that New France created, primarily driven by the fur
- 10:23trade, which did not require massive amounts of land, it
- 10:26required good people to navigate to track down furs in, in, in
- 10:31trading led to stronger and social relationships with the
- 10:36Native Americans that were very different than other colonies.
- 10:40So here's the thing that's really interesting.
- 10:42It's interesting, this interesting that it's France
- 10:44again. And I'm I'm going to take a
- 10:45little bit of a detour and bring us right back.
- 10:47This is this is quick, but are you familiar with what the
- 10:51Albigensian Crusade is? Have you heard that term before?
- 10:55No, I haven't. So in from the years 12 O 9:00
- 10:58to 12:29, there's this part of, of Southern France, we know it
- 11:03is today like Provence and areas like that where they had like
- 11:08kind of gotten to this point where men and equal women were
- 11:10equal. They had like voting rights and
- 11:12stuff. And this is in the 1200s.
- 11:13They had gotten to this place. And what it did is it ended up
- 11:16freaking out the Pope so that it was one of the only crusades
- 11:19other than the one on Constantinople, where the
- 11:22Christians actually turned on their own people.
- 11:24And there was like millions of people killed in this part of
- 11:26France. So it's just very interesting
- 11:29that the French seem to keep doing these things right?
- 11:33And then they could keep getting broken down throughout history.
- 11:35Is is once again, I have no French to me, but I just find
- 11:38that interesting. So I guess looking at that then
- 11:41how does this thing breakdown or, or kind of where does this
- 11:44thing go? Because it sounds like, you
- 11:46know, obviously it's not perfect, but it sounds like
- 11:47there's some like, you know, some mercantile agreements and
- 11:51stuff here and they're looking at it more business and
- 11:53expanding land and stuff. So how does this whole thing
- 11:55change? So I mean, this pretty much
- 11:58continued up until this like the 1750s where there was, like I
- 12:03said, right before the start of the French and Indian War, there
- 12:05was about 100,000 people that lived in New France.
- 12:08That was it. It was very, very small with a
- 12:10massive area. Primarily the fur trade was like
- 12:13the main thing. And then this, this supporting
- 12:17economy. So like hotels, restaurants,
- 12:19that kind of a thing, a little bit of farming, which I don't
- 12:21do, you know, the Montreal Canadiens in the NHL, Yeah, has
- 12:26the Habs. So that stands for the
- 12:28habitants, which were like the farmers that line the Saint
- 12:30Lawrence River. I've.
- 12:33Heard that phrase? I had no idea that's where it
- 12:35came from. Yeah, yeah.
- 12:37And the thing that's really interesting is that those farms
- 12:39are very, very uniquely shaped. When we think of farms, we
- 12:42primarily think of like a grid, because the Saint Lawrence River
- 12:46was like the primary source of everything.
- 12:48What they did was they gave each habitant family very narrow
- 12:52strips of land that each touched the, the, the Saint Lawrence and
- 12:56went back a very long ways. So when you look at those farms,
- 12:59there's lots of very, very thin rectangles that line the Saint
- 13:03Lawrence River. And so anyway, that was pretty
- 13:07much how things went. A little bit of farming, a
- 13:08little bit of a commerce and, and support economy, but
- 13:12primarily driven through the fur trade.
- 13:14And there were mishaps, there were missteps.
- 13:16Nothing was perfect. But overall, the relationship
- 13:18that the the French had with the Native Americans was really,
- 13:21really solid. Well, eventually in the 1750s
- 13:25when things started to break down even worse with the
- 13:28British, you saw things kind of spiral out of control.
- 13:31And George Washington actually, when he was fighting for the
- 13:33British was leading some of the initial skirmishes that took
- 13:37place between the French and the British over control over like I
- 13:41think it was near modern day Pittsburgh.
- 13:44And so the Seven Years War breaks out, which a lot of
- 13:46people consider to be the First World War because wars were
- 13:49breaking out in Europe and the colonies overseas were starting
- 13:51to to fight. And so effectively the two lines
- 13:54that were drawn were the British with the Iroquois, who that line
- 13:59was drawn with Samuel de Champlain in 16 O 8 / 150 years
- 14:02before, which is pretty fascinating, and the French with
- 14:05their multiple different Native American allies.
- 14:09And so the war broke out and it was a really, really, really
- 14:12interesting war because it was 2 completely different systems and
- 14:16two completely different ways of navigating things.
- 14:19Eventually what ended up happening was the British with
- 14:21their Navy were able to blockade Quebec.
- 14:24And then eventually General Wolf for the British was able to draw
- 14:28out General Montcalm for the French on the Plains of Abraham,
- 14:31which are like a flat plain near Quebec City.
- 14:34And they had a battle which the French lost and they lost Quebec
- 14:36City. And then not far long after
- 14:38that, New France fell. But what's really interesting is
- 14:44with 100,000 residents and a very, relatively very small
- 14:48army, France was able to control an unbelievably massive amount
- 14:52of land. And it was primarily because of
- 14:54the relationships that they had with the Native Americans and
- 14:56the commerce that flew with it. And a lot of people talk about
- 14:59like the merits of capitalism, about why it's so good.
- 15:03And I don't know if you have you ever heard the phrase of like
- 15:04forced altruism through trade? What the idea of your enemy is
- 15:09not going to it's, I guess it's what Thomas Friedman in in
- 15:12modern times calls the the Golden Arches theory of
- 15:16economics, where if any two countries have a McDonald's,
- 15:18they're too economically tied, so they're not going to fight
- 15:20each other. Is that what you're talking
- 15:21about? More or less the idea of when
- 15:23you're trading with people, you're not going to go to war
- 15:25with them, right? So I, I think the primary thing
- 15:28to think about with this when we think of New France, it's like,
- 15:30again, I want to reiterate, not everything was perfect.
- 15:32However, it was drastically better and a lot, a lot more
- 15:39peaceful than other colonies because it was derived through
- 15:41trade, through the fur trade. And so they had a very, very
- 15:45different relationship and it led to so many different things.
- 15:48And there's actually further implications from it.
- 15:50And one of them is one that everyone knows.
- 15:51We all hear about the Cajuns. Everyone knows about the Cajuns.
- 15:54We all hear about them. They're a massive population
- 15:56down in Louisiana. They actually came from the area
- 15:59of, of North America called Acadia.
- 16:02Now Acadia is where modern day Nova Scotia is and the Acadians
- 16:07were French settlers that were very peaceful.
- 16:09And I believe the natives that were there were the Mikmac and
- 16:11they had good relationships with the Mikmac.
- 16:13These are basically just peaceful farmers.
- 16:15In one of the wars before the French and Indian War, the
- 16:18British actually gained control over this and they told the
- 16:20settlers that were there. They're like, listen, you can
- 16:22stay here, you can live, but we need you to sign an oath of
- 16:24allegiance that you'll never take arms against the British.
- 16:27And they asked the the Acadians multiple times to do this and
- 16:29they just refused. They said we're not doing that.
- 16:31They, they didn't really do anything drastic, but they
- 16:33didn't sign the oath of allegiance.
- 16:35And eventually during the French and Indian War, the British
- 16:37decided to deport them. And so there was about 10,000 of
- 16:41these Acadians and the vast majority of them were taken at
- 16:43gunpoint and spread out everywhere.
- 16:46They weren't genocided. The base, the British, the
- 16:48British basically said we're going to break them into tiny
- 16:50little pockets throughout all of our empire around the world, and
- 16:52then they'll integrate and then they'll disappear on their own.
- 16:56What ended up happening was one contingent of them, a large
- 16:59contingent of them went to were ended up in Louisiana and they
- 17:03did. French territory at this point
- 17:04until until the Jefferson administration, so that makes
- 17:07sense. OK.
- 17:08And So what ended up happening was the, the Acadians were doing
- 17:12correspondence with the different tiny little pockets in
- 17:15the Carolinas and in Britain, in France, some of the Acadians
- 17:19actually ended up all the way in the Falkland Islands off of
- 17:22Argentina. And they basically sent
- 17:24correspondence and they said, this is our largest group come
- 17:26here. And so a lot of them relocated
- 17:28to Louisiana. And the Acadians, the, the slang
- 17:32term to Cajun. And that's how we have the
- 17:34modern day occasions today. And there's over 800,000 of them
- 17:36today. And so Yep.
- 17:40And so that's, that's a history that a lot of people don't know.
- 17:43But the most important aspect of all of this is that the French
- 17:46and Indian War, which the British won, they defeated New
- 17:50France and Quebec, it fell and now the British gained control
- 17:54over this, but the war was incredibly costly.
- 17:56So the most interesting and important aspect of all of this
- 17:59history is that as a direct result of the French and Indian
- 18:01War and the British claiming control over New France, the
- 18:04British parliament decided to levy taxes on its on their
- 18:08subjects. And they said, well, we
- 18:10primarily defended the 13 colonies and they benefited the
- 18:13most from this. They should be paying.
- 18:15So we're going to implement taxes, and this is where the
- 18:18taxes started coming from. That directly led to no taxation
- 18:22without representation. Wow.
- 18:24OK, so there's a that that's I didn't consider that.
- 18:27That's wild. So if this doesn't happen, we
- 18:29may not like maybe we would have gotten there eventually, but we
- 18:32may not have had the American Revolution.
- 18:34So that's that's an interesting part of it.
- 18:36But I guess one thing in in the notes you sent me, you mentioned
- 18:39as well that there was some sort of what did it, what did it say
- 18:45here? Some sort of a betrayal or
- 18:47something like that. What?
- 18:50What was that and what did that? What part did that play in this
- 18:53this situation? Some sort of a?
- 18:55Did you give me a little more context?
- 18:56Hey, I'm trying to find the notes I had written here, so
- 18:58just bear with me here here. What did you say here?
- 19:05I have a lot of information here which is great.
- 19:06Just bear with me here. Yeah, take your.
- 19:09Time. Oh, it says downfall.
- 19:10Quebec captured with deception, New France calls falls What was
- 19:14the deception element? So effectively, like I said,
- 19:18Quebec was incredibly, incredibly the amazing defensive
- 19:23position because it's where the water narrowed and it was at a
- 19:25very steep clip face. And so effectively what General
- 19:29Wolf was able to do in the night time was able, he had his men
- 19:32climb up the Cliff face and he made, he made the British or the
- 19:36French believe their position was getting so entrenched that
- 19:39General Montcalm, if he would have done what he should have
- 19:41and stayed and waited. Their backs were against the
- 19:43water. He could have probably
- 19:45obliterated them. But he general Wolf was able to
- 19:47make the Montcalm think that their position was gaining more
- 19:50and more strength. So instead of staying behind the
- 19:53walls of Quebec City, which are still there today, they're
- 19:55massive. They're, they're so well built
- 19:57and they had tons of cannon. Montcalm believed that the only
- 20:01solution that they had, because the British were more and more
- 20:04of them were forming ranks, that they had to go out and fight
- 20:07them. And instead of staying behind
- 20:09their walls and defend themselves, they went out onto
- 20:11the Plains of Abraham and it drew out the French army.
- 20:14And even though the British Army was much smaller, the French
- 20:17army wasn't as well equipped for like standard.
- 20:20European line fighting as opposed to like hit and run
- 20:23tactics that they learned alongside the Native Americans.
- 20:25So the British were able to beat their ranks and cause them to
- 20:28break, and then eventually they had to abandon Quebec City.
- 20:31So because of General Wolf doing something that was honestly very
- 20:34crass and very bold by climbing up the walls at night and
- 20:37forming a line, he brought the French out to combat instead of
- 20:41staying behind the walls to defend themselves.
- 20:43And then eventually Quebec City fell.
- 20:45And when that happened, Montreal was next.
- 20:48And then after that, New France fell completely.
- 20:51And now a word from our sponsors.
- 20:53Wellness company and their doctors are medical
- 20:55professionals you can trust and their new medical emergency kits
- 20:58are the gold standard when it comes to keep you safe and
- 21:01healthy. This medical emergency kit
- 21:03contains an assortment of life saving medications including
- 21:06hypermectin Z pack. Rest assured knowing that you
- 21:09have emergency antibiotics, antivirals, and antiparasitics
- 21:12on hand to help you and your family stay safe from whatever
- 21:15life throws at you next. So you can support the Wellness
- 21:26company by heading over to TWC dot health slash JRS, that is
- 21:29TWC dot health slash JRS, get up to 15% off select products,
- 21:36support the Wellness company and help support this show.
- 21:40Thanks again. So, Jimmy, there's a couple
- 21:42hypotheticals I want to look at here because I feel like there's
- 21:45so many angles you could take on this.
- 21:46But I guess the first one is, if you look at, you know, the
- 21:49French Revolution isn't a crazy amount of time after this,
- 21:54right? Like timing wise, we're we're
- 21:55less than 100 years to, you know, people's heads getting
- 21:58chopped off in, in in France. And I guess do you think this
- 22:03played a part in this? Because this is a massive
- 22:05territorial change and it's going to, you know, not too long
- 22:07after this, they're going to start selling these these
- 22:09colonies to the Americans. Do you think that this played a
- 22:13part in the French Revolution? I mean, I would say directly
- 22:17absolutely, because I mean, if you think about the context that
- 22:20immediately after this is what led to the American Revolution.
- 22:23And then after that, I do know for sure that during the French
- 22:25Revolution, a lot of people were claiming like, if the Americans
- 22:27are doing this, why not us, you know, and also the economic
- 22:31hardships that come from that. So I'm, I'm not an expert on
- 22:33that completely, but I do know that these things are not
- 22:36independent. They're very, very linear and
- 22:37they're all directly connected. So I'm sure that in some ways
- 22:40the sentiment of, you know, what was lost now.
- 22:44Now the economy isn't doing as well.
- 22:46The Americans have freedom that we don't have.
- 22:48Maybe we should have that too. So I'm sure that I'm.
- 22:52So let's say the French and Indian War doesn't happen,
- 22:55right? What's the fallout from that?
- 22:58Like? I guess how do you think North
- 23:00America forms differently if that conflict doesn't happen?
- 23:07Well. I know there's a lot to consider
- 23:09in that one. Yeah, for sure.
- 23:11I mean, everything would have been different because the
- 23:12French, even though they had very small populations, they had
- 23:15forts that were lining all across North America claiming
- 23:19their territory. So the French would have claimed
- 23:21a massive territory that would have led eventually.
- 23:23I mean, the French and Indian War, the Seven Years War, was
- 23:26inevitable. It was going to happen at some
- 23:27point between the British interests and the French because
- 23:31the British were imposing further and further westward,
- 23:33which is what kind of sparked it to begin with.
- 23:35So I feel like it would have been inevitable.
- 23:38I, I can't really see a way that it wouldn't have happened.
- 23:41But one of the things that's interesting to consider is just
- 23:43the fact that like the way that the the war took place was so
- 23:47different than most and also like the implications that they
- 23:51had, the ripple effects of them were so profound.
- 23:54And one of the things that a lot of people know, like people know
- 23:56of Quebec right as a province, but the people there are French
- 24:00speakers. And as opposed to, and this is
- 24:03one thing that I didn't talk about before, but this is
- 24:05something that's really important because it does
- 24:07relate. It's not speculative.
- 24:08It it relates directly to today. So Canada has over 30 million
- 24:12people in it. Montreal is one of the largest
- 24:14French speaking cities in the whole world.
- 24:16These are the direct descendants of the Quebecois that were there
- 24:19during the French Canadian war. Most of those people did not
- 24:21relocate, they stayed. Now the British had a problem on
- 24:24their hands because after they defeated the French and New
- 24:27France falls, they have all these people.
- 24:29I think at the time there was like 60,000 or so citizens, non
- 24:33military combatants that were living in Quebec.
- 24:35This was way bigger than the Acadians.
- 24:36They didn't have the resources to ship them out like they did
- 24:39with the Acadians. So the British basically said,
- 24:41listen, here's the deal, you are going to be British subjects.
- 24:44Now all we ask of you is that you basically just say that
- 24:47you're British subjects. And the British did something
- 24:49that was very lenient, which wasn't typically common in
- 24:52history. They said you were allowed to
- 24:54keep your language, you can continue to speak French, and
- 24:57you can keep your Catholicism as opposed to being Protestants.
- 24:59So the British were actually pretty lenient to the citizenry
- 25:02of Quebec. And the reason why that's
- 25:03interesting is because those people through generations,
- 25:07obviously their population kept increasing, their culture, their
- 25:09way of life kept developing. And this led to in 1995, I
- 25:13believe, it was a referendum where the Quebecois, the modern
- 25:16day Quebec, were the descendants of those settlers hundreds of
- 25:18years ago. They literally had a referendum
- 25:21to try to separate from Canada because they remember that they
- 25:24were once a French call or a New France.
- 25:26They were not British controlled.
- 25:28And they have never really viewed themselves that way.
- 25:30It's still today in Canada. There's a lot of tension, not to
- 25:33a point of violence, but just like a lot of cultural division
- 25:36between the Quebecois and the English speakers.
- 25:38So much so that the license plate of Quebec says Jaime
- 25:42Sauvien, which means I remember, it's literally a statement of
- 25:46remembering how they were not originally a British territory.
- 25:49And so there's been multiple times in history where the the
- 25:52Quebecois have have tried to start movements to separate from
- 25:56Canada as a result of this. So the ripple effects of what
- 25:59happened with New France are still affecting us today, not
- 26:02just with the creation of the United States and all of the
- 26:04things that led from that, but also the Quebecois themselves
- 26:07that live there. And here's where it gets even
- 26:09Wilder. Not all of the Acadians were
- 26:12deported. There were some that managed to
- 26:14stay away from the deportation process.
- 26:16And there's still quite a few of them that live in Prince Edward
- 26:19Island, New Brunswick, a little bit in Nova Scotia.
- 26:21And if you see anyone with a license plate on the front that
- 26:24looks like the flag of France with a Gold Star in the top
- 26:26corner, that's the flag of Acadia.
- 26:28And so those people still exist today.
- 26:30And so the ripple effects of New France are still affecting us in
- 26:33massive, massive way. Are there any other like ripple
- 26:38effects or or modern occurrences you see because of this?
- 26:41Like things like maybe we're not considering or cultural things
- 26:44or or whatever there might be. Absolutely.
- 26:46So there's a thing in Quebec called the language police, and
- 26:51effectively Quebec still has. Like like what kind of language?
- 26:56It's not their only role. It's not like they're police
- 26:58officers that go around with guns and they just say speak
- 27:00French. Like, it's not, it's not quite
- 27:02like that, but the French. I don't know.
- 27:04When I've been to Paris, they kind of look down on you if you
- 27:06don't speak French, but you know.
- 27:08That's a, that's like a very, very French thing of feeling
- 27:11that way. But basically in Quebec there
- 27:15are many, many language laws where if you are doing commerce,
- 27:18you have, you have to, you are required by law.
- 27:22Like let's just say you're, you're allowed to start a, a
- 27:24business. If you're an English speaking
- 27:26person, you can do that. But let's say that you are an
- 27:29English business and you're sending an e-mail to another
- 27:31English business and you know, both of you are primarily
- 27:34anglophones, people who speak English first.
- 27:36You are still required by law to send that e-mail with French in
- 27:39it. Signs have to be written in
- 27:42French first. There are many, many laws that
- 27:44the Quebecois have instilled in Quebec to make sure that because
- 27:48they're afraid, they, they know that the United States has over
- 27:50300 million people. English speaking Canada is like
- 27:5323 million. They see that English is all
- 27:55around them and they're afraid that if they allow English to be
- 27:59spoken too much, that eventually it'll get washed out and then
- 28:01they'll dissipate as a culture. And so still today there are
- 28:04many laws. And like I said, it's not like
- 28:07the police go around with guns, but you do get fines and stuff
- 28:10if you don't adhere this. And it's still an important part
- 28:12of France, of Quebec today. Wow, this is, this is very
- 28:16interesting to consider because I feel like if any one of these
- 28:18large events, there's so much, so many permutations that that
- 28:21could happen. I, I guess from that
- 28:23perspective, do you think the American colonies always would
- 28:27have broken off in the way they broke off or, or, or what?
- 28:29How do you think this would have affected, I guess, things
- 28:32outside of Quebec, like looking at things like here in America?
- 28:36That one's hard to say. I mean, because we all know that
- 28:39the whole taxation without representation thing was the
- 28:41spark, that that was it. Not to say that something
- 28:43wouldn't have eventually led to it.
- 28:45I'm sure that eventually maybe cultural differences could have
- 28:48done it, but that was the that was the primary spark, and those
- 28:51taxes were levied as a direct result of that war.
- 28:54Do you think that if the British, because I think the
- 28:57thing that's interesting too is I look at you look, I look at
- 29:01other occurrences of this in the world and like one that came to
- 29:04mind for me is like the Punic wars between the the
- 29:08Carthaginians and the Romans. And the Carthaginians are
- 29:11actually interestingly enough, you know, the Romans are the
- 29:14conquering state, which is very similar to the British.
- 29:16And the Carthaginians are more of like this mercantile state
- 29:18where they even have like a, a board that made all of their
- 29:21decisions, which is it's really, really interesting if you
- 29:23understand like for them, like economics was like their major
- 29:25thing and this didn't match what the Romans believe.
- 29:27So I guess like, like looking at it, do you think that if the
- 29:32British approached economics in a different way, this could have
- 29:36affected how the American colonies formed?
- 29:39It could have. It could have, but this is the
- 29:41thing that I think that's important to consider.
- 29:43When I said multiple times that France had much better
- 29:46relationships with their Native Americans that were in the area
- 29:48that they controlled as opposed to the British, I don't
- 29:51necessarily think that it was because the French were somehow
- 29:54morally superior or. No, I'm not.
- 29:57I'm not saying that. I'm I'm just saying like their
- 29:59their viewpoint on how they operated.
- 30:00Oh, no, for sure. That's what I'm getting to.
- 30:02I think that I think that the reason things happened the way
- 30:05they did was purely, purely based on the situation.
- 30:08So Quebec is much further north, so the growing season is
- 30:12shorter. It's not as fertile for for
- 30:14farming. The resources that the the
- 30:16French were there for was, like I said, there were other things
- 30:18like lumber and fishing and stuff like that, but it was
- 30:20primarily the fur trade. I think that is the key.
- 30:23I honestly think the key to all of it is not cultural
- 30:25differences between the French and the British, but rather the
- 30:27incentive as to why they were there.
- 30:29So to answer your question, it depends.
- 30:32I mean, the what, what are the things we think about most of
- 30:34the 13 colonies farming tobacco, cotton.
- 30:36I think the British system would have probably been pretty
- 30:39similar to what it was regardless of, of other factors
- 30:42or, or if they had a different perception.
- 30:44If I think what would have changed it is what are the
- 30:47things that they were looking for when they were there, You
- 30:49know, like what are the resources that they were there
- 30:51for? I think that would have been the
- 30:52key into determining whether or not the British navigated their
- 30:55colonization differently than they did.
- 30:58Very cool Jimmy, this has been really interesting, man.
- 31:00I've really enjoyed this conversation and I and it, it
- 31:02lived up to what I was hoping for too, because when, when I
- 31:05get a subject I know nothing about, I am thrilled.
- 31:08And not to say I know everything about everything, but I'm, I'm
- 31:10aware of a lot of things. So for people watching this, you
- 31:13know, how can they connect with you?
- 31:14How can they learn more about you?
- 31:15And we're definitely gonna have you on the show, you know, again
- 31:17in the future. But but where can we find you,
- 31:18man? Yeah so on Instagram and TikTok,
- 31:22it's the exact same thing. It's 6 letters.
- 31:24It's GYM like a gymnasium YIV like India, Violet GYMYIV.
- 31:30And I have over 250,000 followers on TikTok and over 700
- 31:34on Instagram. But when I say that 700, that's
- 31:37not 700,000. It's only 700 followers on
- 31:39Instagram. So if you guys want to follow me
- 31:41on Instagram, that would be awesome.
- 31:43Like I said, I am a comedian. Like Jeremy mentioned, I'm a
- 31:46comedian. So you're going to find comedy
- 31:47content on there. But I do try to do things that
- 31:49are not just hacky, low hanging fruit stuff.
- 31:51I try to do stuff that hopefully a lot of my comedy is supposed
- 31:55to be like relevant to cultural issues and things like that.
- 31:59It's funny because you and I were talking a little bit before
- 32:01we we got going here as well. And I always tell people, Oh, my
- 32:03degrees in the Roman Empire, because I don't want to sound
- 32:05like too highfalutin, but what my master's degree is actually
- 32:09in is the apotheosis of Roman emperors.
- 32:11That's becoming of a God of Roman emperors.
- 32:13And I feel like across history people, man, like nobody really
- 32:16cares about history until the shit hits the fan.
- 32:18And then they want to talk to us about history.
- 32:20So like for the last, like, you know, 15 years, I've done
- 32:23nothing with my degree. And all of sudden they're like,
- 32:25this feels like Rome and we're talking about it.
- 32:27And I feel like it's, it's similar to a lot of these, these
- 32:29concepts of U.S. history. People have had to kind of do
- 32:31like other things to figure out how to make money.
- 32:35But I, I, I'm glad to see that, you know, we're getting to have
- 32:37more of these conversations. And I definitely appreciate you
- 32:40coming out here to have it, man. And I really thank you for
- 32:43having me because I, I honestly believe and I'm not connected to
- 32:46it. I'm not French really hardly at
- 32:48all. It's like less than 5% of me is
- 32:50French. So it's not like I'm over here
- 32:52rooting for France and thinking that they're amazingly
- 32:54altruistic. I think though, that
- 32:56understanding the history of New France is incredibly important
- 32:58for people to know so that they don't just get this view of
- 33:01history of Europeans just going over enslaving, killing
- 33:05everybody. All the other dynamics and
- 33:07cultures were like oppressed and everything was terrible.
- 33:10They were very different between different colonies and history.
- 33:12History is a lot more complex than just what you see on like a
- 33:16Jeopardy answer or a Google search and I think New France.
- 33:19Go ahead, go ahead. No go.
- 33:21Ahead, all I was going to say is I think that New France is a
- 33:23very strong testament to how things are much more different
- 33:27and much more complicated than what you know most people know
- 33:30or want to think about. It's not as easy as as as yes or
- 33:33no, or as simple as black and white.
- 33:35Well, it's interesting. Too, Because I think like, you
- 33:37know, once again as being somebody, as I mentioned, I I
- 33:39taught APUS history. This is like 10 plus year more
- 33:43than 15 years ago when I did that.
- 33:45And even in the, in the, the, the lessons you're supposed to
- 33:49teach, it's kind of like, you know, the French are up there.
- 33:51They did some fur trapping and blah, blah, blah.
- 33:53But let's talk about Henry Hudson.
- 33:54Let's keep going South. So like we don't, we just don't
- 33:57even discuss it. I think that's the same thing
- 33:58I've seen with these conversations with Rome is like,
- 34:01it's not that we're saying it's different.
- 34:02It's not that we're saying it didn't happen.
- 34:03It's just not covered. And I think when something isn't
- 34:06covered, you can't learn from it.
- 34:07And that's why these conversations are so vital.
- 34:10Exactly, and to bring it full circle at the reason why I was
- 34:13talking about why I believe capitalism is such a good
- 34:15economic system is because the development of New France is
- 34:18completely testament to that. They didn't even speak each
- 34:21other's language. They literally couldn't even
- 34:22speak hello. But through commerce, they were
- 34:24able to develop massive trade relationships.
- 34:26That list lasted for over 100 years.
- 34:29So I believe personally, as you know, I support capitalism, like
- 34:33it. New France's testament as to
- 34:34why, you know, trade amongst nations is prosperous and good
- 34:38for everyone. Wow, cool.
- 34:41Well, once again, to those you out there listening, reminder to
- 34:44like this video, leave us a comment and smash the subscribe
- 34:46button for liberty freedom and you want to build a better
- 34:48future. We will have Jimmy back here in
- 34:50the future. So thank you everyone for
- 34:52listening.