Latest / Together 4 Good: Making Sense of Life and Faith / Sunday School Remix: Doubting Thomas
Transcript
- 0:00What if Doubting Thomas was just having a really bad week?
- 0:03I'm Pastor Nate at Bethany Lutheran Church, and this is the
- 0:07Sunday School Remix podcast. Welcome to the Sunday School
- 0:10Remix, the show where we take Bible stories you learned as a
- 0:13kid and look at them with fresh eyes each week.
- 0:16We dig into the context and the overlooked details, and we often
- 0:20discover interpretations we never heard growing up.
- 0:24This isn't about winning arguments, but simply hearing
- 0:27God's living Word speak to our lives again today.
- 0:31So grab your Bible and put aside your assumptions and let's dive
- 0:34into another episode of the Sunday School remix.
- 0:39So the story of the disciple Thomas, famously known as
- 0:43Doubting Thomas, can be found in John chapter 20, beginning at
- 0:48verse 24. We often read this story on the
- 0:51Sunday after Easter Sunday. If you have ever been a clergy
- 0:56person, a preacher, you know that this is the Sunday that
- 0:59always gets assigned to the intern or to the new pastor or
- 1:03the associate pastor. So I found myself preaching on
- 1:06this text a lot during my career, probably over 15 times
- 1:12already. I don't even know how that's
- 1:13possible because I've only been ordained for 14 years.
- 1:16Anyways, Doubting Thomas is one that shows up every single year
- 1:20in the Raza biased common lectionary.
- 1:23And in the story the way that it goes is that the IT first tells
- 1:28us that all the disciples were together in one place except
- 1:33Thomas. And so the disciples are all
- 1:36together in one place when all of a sudden, Oh my gosh, Jesus
- 1:39appears. And Jesus appears even though
- 1:42the doors are locked. It tells us.
- 1:45And he shows the disciples his wounds and they rejoice and
- 1:49believe. Now, Thomas wasn't there.
- 1:51We don't know what he was out doing.
- 1:53I mean, he had to go to the store.
- 1:55I don't know, had to do his taxes.
- 1:58Thomas isn't there. And when he hears from his
- 2:02friends what's happened, he says unless I get to put my hands in
- 2:06his wounds, I will not believe. And then from that day forward,
- 2:11he was forever known as a Doubting Thomas.
- 2:16Poor guy. But what I find so interesting
- 2:19about this particular story is all of the assumptions that we
- 2:23bring to it. Because somewhere along the way,
- 2:25we attached that label Doubting Thomas, which by the way, never
- 2:29appears as a title within the Bible itself.
- 2:33But because we've made that lens for ourselves of how to read the
- 2:39text, we just assume the worst about this guy.
- 2:42Oh my gosh, he just doubts. But let's stop and consider the
- 2:46entire context of how this happens.
- 2:49So Jesus is crucified on a Friday and he he is nailed to a
- 2:55cross and put on a hill so that everyone can see.
- 3:00What you need to know is that execution in the those times was
- 3:05a specific tool of the Roman government that ensured that a
- 3:10charismatic leader would be put to death and that it would show
- 3:16Rome's power over that particular leader.
- 3:19So that is why Jesus was crucified.
- 3:22Rome wanted to show the world that this Jesus movement that
- 3:26they were starting to get whispers about was put to an
- 3:30end. This is Rome's way of stamping
- 3:33out movements that may one day pose a threat to Roman power.
- 3:38Here's what I find so neat about that, and I promise we'll get
- 3:41back to Thomas in a second. But this idea that the
- 3:46crucifixion is Rome's way of making sure that the Jesus
- 3:51movement never overcomes Roman power, that Roman power is
- 3:57maintained. And there's something so
- 3:59beautifully ironic. And I'm not a Catholic, but but
- 4:03to recognize that today we would say the heart of Christianity,
- 4:07like one of the halls most powerful places of all Christian
- 4:11influence is in Rome. The Vatican is inside the city
- 4:17of Rome. And So what the Roman government
- 4:21in Jesus time so desperately wanted to prevent that they
- 4:25crucified Jesus somehow that led to the complete reversal to what
- 4:32we see today. It's just a a neat reminder, I
- 4:34think, as we think about the, the, the what we see within the
- 4:39world today that so strongly speaks to the power of Jesus
- 4:44message and to God's upside down ways of work.
- 4:49The crucifixion is supposed to be an ending, but it really was
- 4:53a beginning and a strengthening of the Jesus movement because of
- 4:57Jesus's death and then resurrection.
- 5:00So anyways, back to Thomas and the disciples in that room, the
- 5:05disciples, everyone else, the other 10, mind you, Judas is not
- 5:09there. They tell Thomas what's
- 5:10happened. They've seen the risen Lord and
- 5:14they saw his wounds. And so they believe that Jesus
- 5:17is risen. And Thomas says, unless I get to
- 5:20do the same thing as you, I will not believe I can resonate with
- 5:25that type of sentiment. Maybe you've had that in your
- 5:28own life of faith too, where there's been somebody else who
- 5:32has some sort of big, dramatic, charismatic experience, some
- 5:36sort of incredible God moment, and you're jealous.
- 5:39You're thinking, gosh, like what?
- 5:40Why can't I have an experience like that?
- 5:44Well, isn't Thomas kind of saying the same thing?
- 5:47Not only that, but putting this all in the context of Roman
- 5:51crucifixion and recognizing how traumatic that must have been
- 5:56for all of the disciples to see their rabbi, this person that
- 6:02they followed around for three years, this man who they thought
- 6:05was the Messiah, to see him brutally, shamefully crucified
- 6:12and knowing that in those days crucifixion was the firm ending.
- 6:17It was the dark period that ended the sentence on any sort
- 6:22of leaders possible continued movement.
- 6:25Imagine just how depressed, how heartbroken the disciples must
- 6:32have been to see that and to just assume, rightfully so, this
- 6:38was the end of all that they had once believed.
- 6:42So if you're in that mindset, wouldn't you have a few doubts
- 6:47too? Don't you think?
- 6:49Wouldn't you want to see the risen Lord and physically touch
- 6:54the wounds in his hands before you could undo all that you had
- 6:59seen on Friday? Before you could believe that an
- 7:03individual, no matter how special, could come back from
- 7:06something like crucifixion? See, I I don't think we should
- 7:09call him Dowden Thomas. I think we should call him
- 7:12Honest Thomas because he was actually honest about what he
- 7:19was feeling and what he needed in order to believe.
- 7:22And I don't think that if any of us were in his position, we
- 7:25would have behaved differently. So with all of this, Thomas,
- 7:32yeah, he, he feels left out. And there's this incredible
- 7:37moment in the way that John tells the story in his gospel is
- 7:42that a week later, Jesus does return and Jesus does provide
- 7:47Thomas with exactly what he was looking for the the the
- 7:51emotional woundedness that he felt is healed by Jesus
- 7:56returning just for him. And so this is another story of
- 8:01Jesus coming back for the one. Jesus tells parable about the
- 8:05women who loses a coin and searches her house for the one
- 8:08lost coin, or the shepherd who loses one of his sheep and
- 8:12leaves the 99 in order to go back for the one.
- 8:16And the story of doubting Thomas, honest Thomas that we're
- 8:20calling him now, is the story of Jesus coming back for the 110
- 8:25disciples got to see the risen Lord, and one of them wasn't
- 8:29there for some reason. And he was plagued with doubt
- 8:33and questions and couldn't believe that Jesus actually
- 8:36could overcome the cross. But Jesus did and Jesus does,
- 8:44and Jesus comes back for Thomas, for that one disciple so that he
- 8:49can touch the wounds and so that he can see and believe.
- 8:55And so for all of us today, as we struggle with doubts and have
- 9:02questions about our faith, maybe we need to be a little more
- 9:05compassionate with one another. It's not just as simple all the
- 9:10time as as the Bible says it, so you must believe it.
- 9:13I, I wish it were that simple, but there's things in our life
- 9:16like trauma, terrible experiences that affect how we
- 9:21feel about the stuff we're taught to believe.
- 9:25And there's moments in time where it just seems too
- 9:28difficult to go on. Or there's moments where we find
- 9:31ourselves wishing that we could have an experience like someone
- 9:34else. And I think what this story of
- 9:37Doubting Thomas is telling us is that Jesus will come back for
- 9:41the one for you. We don't know when, we don't
- 9:44know how, but continuing to show up, it's not as if Thomas ran
- 9:50away and and denounced the other disciples.
- 9:54He was together with them a week later when Jesus shows up again.
- 9:59There's this really interesting linguistic phrase also within
- 10:02this whole story that in the original Greek talks about how
- 10:06the doors are locked. And it says that both times, the
- 10:08first time that Jesus appears and the second time that Jesus
- 10:12appears, and sort of the way that it's written in the
- 10:15original Greek seems to suggest, And apparently in the early
- 10:19Christian Church, this was a title they gave Jesus.
- 10:22They talked about Jesus as the God of locked doors.
- 10:26And it's this idea that a locked door isn't a barrier for Jesus.
- 10:32Our doubt isn't a barrier for Jesus.
- 10:35Our trauma isn't a barrier for Jesus.
- 10:39Our feeling left out isn't a barrier for Jesus.
- 10:43He can overcome these locked doors, these obstacles that we
- 10:49encounter. And that's all kind of baked in
- 10:52the how John writes this story. The final piece of this whole
- 10:58passage that I think is so neat is as you get to the end of John
- 11:02chapter 20, there's this moment where the writing style shifts
- 11:08and and it's sort of like the breaking the 4th wall
- 11:11phenomenon. And if you've ever seen this in
- 11:14TV show or just, or Broadway plays, breaking the 4th wall
- 11:17means when a character kind of exits out of the story that's
- 11:22going on and speaks directly to the listener.
- 11:27If you've ever seen Ferris Bueller's Day Off, it's a great
- 11:29example of it where throughout the movie, Ferris will turn and
- 11:32look at the camera and talk to me.
- 11:33Wait, you're still here. This is this great moment at the
- 11:35end of the film, you're still here.
- 11:36What are you doing? Go home or there's other times
- 11:38we're like, how could I possibly we need to go to school on a day
- 11:41like today? And so it's Ferris connecting
- 11:43with the audience who's viewing it, breaking the 4th wall.
- 11:47Well, in the Gospel of John at the end of this honest Thomas
- 11:51story, we see this moment where the writer of the Gospel says
- 11:56like, but these things have been done so that you may come to
- 12:01believe. And so it's, it's kind of
- 12:03putting the emphasis. It's, it's as if John is done
- 12:06writing this story and then looks up and turns to us and
- 12:08says, will you still believe? I think this is also where the
- 12:13doubting Thomas thread comes through because it really feels
- 12:16like John is writing this in order to press us on that
- 12:19question, what, what will you do?
- 12:22But I think as you look at it in the context of everything else
- 12:24we've talked about, yes, Jesus does all these things so that
- 12:28you may believe. And it's not about you being
- 12:31good enough or smart enough or brave enough to believe.
- 12:36Unlike Thomas, I don't know. It's more about look at all of
- 12:40the ways that Jesus is breaking through locked rooms and locked
- 12:44doors to find you, that Jesus would come back for the one.
- 12:49And what if the one is you? What would it mean for your life
- 12:53to really trust that Jesus is going to all of these lengths so
- 12:58that you might believe, so that your life might be changed by
- 13:02the story? This has been another episode of
- 13:06the Sunday School Remix podcast. I'm Pastor Nate Pricinger, thank
- 13:10you so much for watching. And remember, Sunday school was
- 13:13just the beginning. See you next time.
- 13:16Thank you for listening to the Together for Good podcast.
- 13:19If you'd like more resources for your walk of faith, please visit
- 13:22our website bethany-denver.org or download our mobile app by
- 13:27searching Bethany Connect in your phone's App Store.