Latest / This is VANCOLOUR / Simran Singh: Why aren't Canadians having kids anymore?
Transcript
- 0:02Check podcasts, Happy New Year and welcome back to This is Van Color.
- 0:11More and more Canadians are deciding that they don't want kids. In fact,
- 0:15the data shows that this is a growing trend in this country. Here to
- 0:19explain the trend and what's motivating more Canadians to go child free. As a
- 0:23senior staff writer for The Daily Hive, she is Simmeren Singh and this conversation
- 0:28is supported by shelter Point single malt whiskey distinctly Vancouver Island, uniquely shelter Point.
- 0:38So, Cimmarn, you dug into this. What is this trend with
- 0:42regard to Canadians not having kids? Explain it to us? Yeah, mo,
- 0:45I got into this series out of curiosity for myself. Okay, I'm
- 0:49now in my thirties and I've been married for several years and kind of reaching
- 0:52the age where like, you're like kids. So I started to kind of
- 0:55connect it to my work a little bit and see if people were choosing to
- 0:59have kids and those who weren't why. And before we dove into this conversation,
- 1:03I do want to make clear that there's many people who want kids but
- 1:06cannot have kids and struggle with fertility. And loss. And you know that
- 1:11is such an important subject that I don't want to glaze over. But for
- 1:14the sake of the story that I'm talking about today, it's about women specifically
- 1:17who have chosen not to have children, and as you mentioned, we're seeing
- 1:21it a little bit more, especially in Canada. I have some stats to
- 1:25shoot at you, okay, hear that Canada has definitely given out a lot
- 1:29of information about this in the past year, because it seems to be heavy
- 1:33on people's minds. So a February twenty twenty three report from Stats Canada highlights
- 1:38that in twenty twenty two, more than a third of Canadians age fifteen to
- 1:42forty nine did not even intend to have children. And then in the economic
- 1:46forecast we're looking at right now, as Stats Canada talked to some Canadians between
- 1:49and they found that between fifteen and twenty nine, young Canadians said that the
- 1:53economic climate right now did not even foresee them to have children. Okay,
- 2:00so an affordability thing. Affordability is a huge thing. And then overall,
- 2:04the agency noted that over the decade, a number of women, the number
- 2:07of children per women in Canada has been on a general downward trend, falling
- 2:12from one point six y nine in two thousand and nine to one point four
- 2:15to three in twenty twenty one. That's children one point sixty nine children average
- 2:20to one point four to three in twenty twenty one. So twenty twenty one
- 2:23is like the latest of their data is that we're collected. So we're seeing
- 2:29children on the downcline in Canada. We're seeing people maybe choosing to wait or
- 2:35choosing to not have kids at all. And I think it has to do
- 2:38with a whole lot of factors. And before we get into that, I'm
- 2:42really curious, is this a millennial thing or was this a trend that always
- 2:46kind of existed but maybe it's now more pronounced with our generation with millennials.
- 2:50That's a good question. And you know what, I don't know I can
- 2:53have the end albeit all answer thing here, but you know, I did
- 2:55speak to millennial women for my series, and I think it is becoming a
- 2:59grown millennial thing for a number of reasons when it comes to finances, our
- 3:04economic climate, the environment, and just you know, I think the environment.
- 3:09The environment isn't that shocking. It's ten degrees and winter, but yeah,
- 3:15people are thinking about really, Okay, so because of climate change?
- 3:20So are they doing it because they don't want kids in an environment where you're
- 3:23going to have climate catastrophes or because they don't want to contribute to a growing
- 3:28population that is fueling climate change. Maybe both of those things. Because you
- 3:31know, I think a lot of millennials are thinking about when their parents had
- 3:35kids. It was a different time gen X. A lot of them were
- 3:38immigrants. They came to this family with the purpose of building a family.
- 3:42A lot of us also saw our mothers and what they went through and through
- 3:45a lot of probably therapy and reflecting on our own childhood trauma. We're really
- 3:50thinking about do we want to bring kids into this world? Are we ready
- 3:54to bring things kids into this world? And that's a thought process that I
- 3:58think more millennials are taking on than maybe past generations. We're really doing that
- 4:02self reflection, right. It's interesting because we talk about this idea of overlapping
- 4:06crises, right, the affordability crisis, the climate crisis, And I never
- 4:12thought about this idea of people choosing to have kids or not in that lens,
- 4:16but apparently that's really what's framing these decisions, right, Yeah, if
- 4:21you want to call it a perfect storm, maybe it is because right now
- 4:25we're living at a time where there's a lot of different crises, sure,
- 4:29and a lot of people are thinking about what it means for them and what
- 4:32it means for the future. I think when you bring in to the fact
- 4:35that a lot of people are struggling to buy homes or afford rent, put
- 4:40groceries in their fridges every week, you know, even trying to secure that
- 4:44job and chase after their professional goals, those are all things people are thinking
- 4:47about. And then when you bring in you know, different global crises happening
- 4:51right now, the state of the world, I think it's weighing heavily on
- 4:55people's minds, and particularly to women as well. I think a lot of
- 4:59women are thinking about their lives and what they truly want for them when it
- 5:02comes to their professional goals, what fulfills them. They're thinking about domestic labor.
- 5:06We actually talk about domestic labor now to a society, absolutely living up
- 5:12chores, the mental load that you have to take on being you know,
- 5:16a woman in as heter heteronorma relationship. So those are all things that women
- 5:23in particular are thinking about as well, Like do we really want to do
- 5:26this in the world we're living in or are we able to find fulfillment in
- 5:30different ways? Are we happy without kids? And that seems to be the
- 5:32truth for someone now in your investigative reporting, in your interviews and looking at
- 5:38the data, was there one motivating factor that seemed to be bigger than the
- 5:42others or was it pretty evenly spread out in terms of the reason that people
- 5:46were giving to not have children. You know what, it's really subjective.
- 5:48But when it comes to the women I spoke to, a lot of women
- 5:53really felt that they never had a maternal instinct and they found so many passions
- 5:59in their and things that they wanted to work towards in their life that they
- 6:01just felt that they don't want to have children. And I think that's kind
- 6:06of a driving factor for many women. And then you know, it's subjective
- 6:12though, right, So it's really independent. It's up to you. It's
- 6:15what impacts your life, what's happening in your life right now. So I
- 6:18don't think there's one particular factor or anything like that that we can pinpoint.
- 6:24But you know, I think for Canadians it's the affordability factor. It is
- 6:29really the affordability factor. And I spoke to one scholar out of the University
- 6:32of Victoria, Susan McDaniel, who has researched this, and said, right
- 6:36now, in the time we're living in right now in Canada, it's definitely
- 6:40the financial issues people are facing and bringing a kid into the world, it
- 6:44costs money. Stats Ken also did another research study this past year and they
- 6:48found out that raising a child from age zero to seventeen costs approximately three hundred
- 6:54and sixty thousand dollars and then when you add the universe allaw on miss economy,
- 7:00university and tuition, it goes up by twenty nine percent on average.
- 7:04Wow. So it's a lot of money, and it's spread out over a
- 7:08period of time. And it's not to say that if you don't want if
- 7:11you're worried about finances, I'm sure you can make it work if you really
- 7:14want kids, But if the dollar is on top of mine, then that's
- 7:17something you're think. Thank you. Now, obviously everyone is entitled to their
- 7:20own personal choices, but I do feel like government is going to be looking
- 7:25at this because obviously government does want people to have kids and create community and
- 7:29all that stuff, and they'll be looking at that and maybe perhaps tailoring some
- 7:32policies to be a more parent friendly country, whether that's ten dollars day daycare
- 7:38or you know, hopefully affordable housing at some point. Yeah, I think
- 7:42that's something that governments do have to pay attention to do, especially you know,
- 7:45right down Canada or Canadian government. There is ten dollars day daycare.
- 7:48There are credits for parents, but is it really enough like daycare spaces.
- 7:53I'm not as parent, but I hear from you know, my friends who
- 7:55are parents, how just like insane it is for daycare and how stri it
- 8:00is. And you have to think about daycare before even bringing a child into
- 8:03this world. So governments really do need to think about what Canada is going
- 8:07to look like in the next fifty years. And we have the issue of
- 8:11immigration that's weighing so heavily on people's minds right now. And immigration is one
- 8:16way to bring new workforces and talent into a country. But this is really
- 8:20important in the growth of Canada's landscape over the next century. What's going to
- 8:26happen when we see people moving out of the country, people choosing not to
- 8:28have kids. It's kind of an unknown, right now. But I would
- 8:33hope that you know, government officials are looking at this and thinking, how
- 8:35do we make it easier for people who want to become parents, Not only
- 8:39that, how do we make fertility you know programs and things like that more
- 8:46accessible? Totally? Yeah, especially as people folks on their careers, particularly
- 8:50in their twenties, and look at having kids if they want to have kids
- 8:52in their thirties, right, fertility and fertility treatments become huge. Treatments are
- 8:56not cheap and you have to be pro financially to you know, have these
- 9:03treatments and you know, pay for them. So that's an issue too that
- 9:05I hope governments look into the really quickly when we think about in general,
- 9:11and this is a general population, not an individual case by case basis.
- 9:16Are parents versus non parents? Is there a difference in happiness or overall contentment,
- 9:20Like, is there something that we can look at and say, well,
- 9:22non parents actually end up being happier. That's a great question, and
- 9:26I think if I set an answer, I would like like the internet healthy.
- 9:28Yeah, I'm setting you up. I'm setting you up for disaster.
- 9:31I'm going to take the very you know, easy way out and say it's
- 9:35really up to you, and your happiness is in your hands. I think
- 9:39a lot of people who don't want to be parents get questioned a lot,
- 9:41especially women, get told they're selfish or like they're going to get lonely when
- 9:45they're older. But I think a lot of people who are child for you
- 9:48by choice have thought about those things and they're happy and content with that decision.
- 9:52And people who have kids are happy and content with their decision as well.
- 9:56But one of the last things I want to say is, as a
- 9:58society, what we can do is just generally stop asking people about their status
- 10:03quo oh. I think we should all be on board for that absolute.
- 10:05We should normalize not asking people or prying about when they're going to have a
- 10:09kid. Simmron, this was such a pleasure. Thanks so much for your
- 10:11time tonight. Thanks mo folks, make sure you catch her work at the
- 10:16Daily Hive. She is Simmeren sing thank you to Shelter Point Single Malt Whiskey
- 10:20for supporting local conversations and being the whiskey of choice for parents and non parents
- 10:26alike. Now after some business, I wish people happy New Year for the
- 10:30entire month of January, but is a whole month of New Year's greetings too
- 10:35long. Comedian Dino Archie will travel the low road and tell us when to
- 10:39stop singing Happy New Year. And that's up next