Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 08/20/26 EPISODE 017: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN: COLONEL E.H. TAYLOR CURED OAK - 2026 RELEASE
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: Man, guys, I'm excited. We are gonna be doing a bottle review of a of a brand new release, Colonel Taylor Cured Oak. And for me, I've only ever tried this bottle one time in my life. It only released one time in my our lives back in 2016, and that's when I tried it. So we are 10 years later trying the Colonel Taylor Cure Dog. But as always, let's start with some introductions. Shane here, Rox Bourbon Review. Welcome back, my friend. James. 10 to AZ whiskey, I believe. I'm gonna have to check that. John Carlo, ⁓ Life Well Made Co. on Instagram. Yes. ⁓ I'm Scott. And Scott, voice this evening, our voice of God is Scott. And ⁓ man, this is this is really cool. So let me get this thing poured up. We got a Colonel Taylor cured oak 100 proof as all except for barrel strength. ⁓ come in and we got some th there's a lot of history on this. So we're gonna get this poured so you guys can have an opportunity to nose this up while we give a little bit of history about Colonel Taylor, who he was, what is cured okay bottled and bond. No, we just had to get her bikini off. All right, let's think let's get the pop on this thing. Decent. And ⁓ before we proceed, let's give a shout out to our friends over at El Paisano Liquors in Tempe for hooking us up with this bottle not three hours ago. ⁓ nice. Very nice. So ⁓ we said I said, Hey, I'm coming through. Need to grab a bottle for the podcast. And ⁓ he's like, I j I got this one in. You want to pour them absolutely. ⁓ Let's ⁓ let's get it, let's pour it up, and let's see how good it is. So we are tasting tonight the Colonel Taylor cured oak. And ⁓ obviously this is made by Buffalo Trace. Let's dive in here. So if you're new, anybody in the room, do you know raise your hands? Do you know who Colonel Taylor, Colonel E. H. Taylor was? No hands raised. So let's d we we have some general consensus of who he was, right? ⁓ but the history on this is is super cool for me. ⁓ and and frankly, this is one of the reasons I got into bourbon was the history behind it. There's no history behind vodka. They fucking put potato or wheat or whatever in a still, it comes out white, you drink it a day later. Right? Bourbon, for me, the history is what absolutely sold me into this hobby and this and this passion of mine. So Colonel. And Colonel E. H. Taylor or Buffalo Trade this product was one of the first that I ever I ever got and was introduced to. So Colonel Edmund Hayes Taylor Jr. lived from 1830 to 1923. And he's widely considered the founding father of the modern bourbon industry. He was a banker, mayor, state legislator, and a visionary distiller. Taylor Taylor revolutionized whiskey production through the technological innovation of architectural grandosity and pioneering consumer protection laws. He was born in C Columbus, Kentucky. Taylor was raised in a prominent political circles. His grand uncle was US President Zachary Taylor. He began his career in banking and finance, which gave him a deep insight into the capitalization and trade. Recognized for his civic leadership and political acumen, he was awarded the honorific title of Kentucky Colonel, and served 17 years as the mayor of Frankfurt alongside stints in the Kentucky House of Representatives and the State Senate. So Taylor entered the Spirits trade in the 1860s, purchasing and modernizing several historic properties. His most famous endeavor was the creation of the OFC Old Fire Copper Distillery in 1870, the site known today as Buffalo Trace Distillery. In Frankfurt Frankfurt, Kentucky, as well as the nearby old Taylor Distillery, which is now known as Castle and Key. Founding the so in from 1869 to 19, or excuse me, 1869 to 1870, he founded the OFC distillery. He purchased the site along the Kentucky River and constructed the old fire copper distill copper facility, implementing steam heating systems. inside aging warehouses to regulate climate year round. Back in eighteen eighty seven, he moved over to construct a distillery modeled after after a European castle, complete with manicured gardens, a sunken spring house, and a classical colonade designed to attract tourism to Bourbon count the Bourbon County. So in eighteen ninety seven he lobbied Congress alongside Treasury Secretary John G. Carlyle to pass landmark consumer protection legislation. Guaranteeing product purity. So in the late nineteenth century, the market was flooded with rectified, adulterated spirits containing harmful additives like iodine, tobacco juice, and formaldehyde. Taylor spearheaded the fight for authenticity, culminating in the Bottle and Bond Act of eighteen ninety seven. To bear the bottle and bond designation, whiskey has to meet strict federal mandates. Y'all know these things? Yeah. ⁓ anyone wanna chime in? What do you guys think the bottle and bot act contains? Hundred proof. Hunterproof? ⁓ to be bottle and bot? To be considered a bottle and bot it's gotta be at least four years old. At least four years old. Gotta be ⁓ aged in a federally bonded warehouse. Correct. ⁓ 100 proof. Hunterproof. And that's all I think that's all I One more thing. Something to do with the barrels? ⁓ no. Distilled by a single distiller in a single season. Distillery during a single distillation season. so ⁓ so one of the Kayla ⁓ excuse me, Taylor transformed bourbon making from a crude farm endeavor to a precise science. Insisting on pure copper fermenters and stills to strip harsh sulfur compounds from the distillate, he pioneered the steam hit heating. steam heated rick houses to cycle barrel maturation during harsh Kentucky winters. And he implemented industry hygiene standard standards unheard of in the 19th century distilleries to ensure batch consistency. ⁓ today's Buffalo Trace legacy with ⁓ Taylor collection, so there's quite a few offerings that that show up in the in this Colonel Taylor ⁓ most prominent is their small batch, which is a hundred proof. It's bottled and bottled bottled and bond. Then there's their single barrel. ⁓ they also have a one variant that comes off the 100 proof, which is their ⁓ barrel proof version. They've got a straight rye component at a hundred proof, and then they've got several special releases. Some of those include the four-grain, warehouse sea, ⁓ tornado surviving, and the gr amaranth grain of the gods. Anybody tried the Amaranth Grain of the Gods? No. I've had it one time. Yeah. Kind of different. Not my favorite, but really good. All right. So we are tasting Colonel Taylor cured oak. And it's one of the most famous and highly decorated and sought-after unicorn releases from Buffalo Trace limited edition line. It was released in May 2015 as a one-time special drop in the H. Taylor lineup. It quickly, ⁓ quickly achieved legendary status among collectors for its unique barrel curing experiment. So, what is it? ⁓ so the story behind this is really centers around the stave process. So standard whiskey barrel staves are typically seasoned outdoors in the elements for anywhere from between six months to one year before being charred. For the cured oak release, Buffalo Trace instructed their Cooperage Independent Stave Company to age the white oak staves outdoors for a massive ⁓ for a massive six months to seventeen months in the sun, wind and rain far longer than the standard barrels. Extending ⁓ extended outdoor weathering allows nature, fungi, and rain to leach out harsh, astringent wood tannins while breaking down Wow, this is a big word, a mech heme hemicellulose into natural wood sugars. Well, that's a big one. New one for me. W when charred these wood these cured staves yield vastly higher concentrations of vanilla, coconut, and caramelized sugar compounds into the whiskey. All right. All right. So this bourbon was distilled in nineteen or not this particular bourbon. The bourbon initially when they released in twenty sixteen was distilled in nineteen ninety eight. Using the Buffalo Trace mash mill number one, low rye, high corn. It was aged for seventeen years in warehouse C. So long. That's crazy. Do you know do you know how long this one? Yes. It's a little bit less. Yeah. Well, I would assume a lot of bit less a lot of bit less, yeah. Okay. Ten years, I believe. Okay, it is 10. I'll get to that. I don't remember. I think it's ten years and something and change. ⁓ so the initial batch, it was released in May twenty fifteen. It was seventeen years old. It was a hundred proof. MSRP on that back then was si 70 bucks. On the secondary right now, and you guess this is what you're gonna find a bottle of twenty fifteen cured oak for? Three grand. ⁓ fifteen hundred. I told you that earlier. Three grand to four grand. Four grand. Wow. ⁓ and it did win whiskey of the year. In the 206 Jim Murray's 2016 Whiskey Bible. ⁓ because the limit the liquid spent 17 years in heavily weathered oak, the flavor profile is dominant, ⁓ dominated by dark, antique wood notes, but but lacks the bitter, astringent, over oak mouthfill that usually plagues a 17 year old bourbon. So the difference between that version and this version, which is 11 years later, 17 years to 10 years. Both are at 100 proof. The stave curing time. On the twenty fifteen version was thirteen to seventeen months. This version exactly thirteen months. It's the same mash bill. Any any guesses on inflation? It was seventy dollars. What's the inflation now on MSRP? On MSRP, ⁓ I guess 150. 80 bucks. ⁓ it went up ten dollars in ten years, which is great. ⁓ what do you what's the secondary? We talked about the secondary on the the twenty fifteen, it's anywhere from three grand to four four plus grand. ⁓ on this version, you're looking at a secondary of I think around 400, isn't it? Four to seven hundred plus. ⁓ okay. On secondary. Depending on where you can go. I think it's been coming out a little bit more. I think it's around four to five hundred right now. It has been coming down. I am not gonna read the notes. Yep. Let's let's get into this whiskey. I'm excited about this. I personally got to try this one time. ⁓ for those that are local here here in Arizona, there used to be a restaurant bar in downtown Gilbert. Called 500 North. It was next to G GCM Liquor. I believe the owners owners owned them. It was a, I think it was a Greek restaurant with a whiskey bar. Crazy. but they used to do half ounce pour flights. ⁓ and back then I did a half ounce of this. I did a half ounce of the seasoned oak or seasoned wood Colonel Taylor. ⁓ Kentucky Owl Batch One Rye, a Four Roses Limited Edition from 2012, I think is what it was. And then one other. I can't remember what it was. But anyway. I haven't smelled it yet. Have you Al smelled it? While I get an opportunity to nose it, you talk about it. I have nosed it already. And I think James has already tasted it. I've done both. A lot of vanilla on the nose. Can you smell now? ⁓ does it just come and go? ⁓ I just don't like to try to do the nose. Stop it. You're so Yeah, I'd just like to drink it. But you What? Sure, we all like to drink it, but I thought you literally couldn't smell it. Is anybody getting any cotton candy? I I get cotton getting a lot of candy. Yeah. Wow, there's a that's a great call out on that. On the nose. Like white sugar thing going on. Very sugary. Uh-huh. Sugary for sure. Very sugary. I got like sugar. Like a lollipop when I first smelled it. Okay. Sugar vanilla. Yeah. On the nose. Very sweet. Forward. I don't get a lot of oak, which is interesting on the nose at least. Yeah. Well this would be a shocker when you taste it. It's heavy oak. Heavy oak heavy oak on the nose. Ten ten years, I mean, in ⁓ you know, that cured oak, so Looking at the glass, super viscous on this. The legs are just like they don't even want to drip down the side of the glass. ⁓ for a hundred proof, obviously this has been you know cut down to a hundred proof ⁓ for the bottling, but the viscosity on it viscosity on this is really nice. You're right, James. Very heavy oak. Yeah. In a bad way, good way. Don't like it. No, I mean I like it. I mean it just that's mostly what you or what I taste. ⁓ on the oak. There's something ⁓ see the vanilla, I've smelt it in the a little bit, but I don't get any vanilla on the palate palette. Yeah, agreed. Almost getting an Numbing? That might be the other 12 pores we've had before this. Could be. Could be. I don't think I don't I personally I went back to the nose. That I love that cotton candy call out note. Really? There's a sweet, like almost like a cherry strawberry cotton candy. Strawberry for sure. Yeah. ⁓ I love it. The nose on this thing's incredible. I could sit there and just my wife likes to say, ⁓ make a candle out of it. This is this is like a absolute house air freshener. I'd love to smell this all over the house. It it's it's funny though because it it's 100 proof, but it it tastes a little hotter than a hundred proof. It does taste a little hotter. It does. And yeah, it's We've had some really good pours tonight and this isn't meeting those standards. You don't like it. Me, I don't think it's crazy by any means. If if it was eighty eighty dollars, sure, but it's not doing it for me personally. It is eighty dollars. I know, I know, I know. That's what I said. You can buy it for eighty dollars. So if you can buy it for eighty dollars, sure, cool to have. But man, it is ⁓ it's not super special for me. Okay. Yeah. I think it's too oaky for I get a lot of oak. Okay. ⁓ Yeah, not my favorite tonight. Okay. Not not your favorite. Interesting. Yeah, it's very oak forward for sure. ⁓ it the the nose and the finish are completely different. Like completely different and the taste as well. ⁓ it it is it is it worth four hundred bucks? ⁓ no. It's it's not. It's good, but ⁓ I'm yeah. I enjoy it. Obviously it's cured oak for a reason and so it's very oaky and I think that makes it proofier than it is. That's I mean f it's pushing higher than that. But I like it. ⁓ there's something else on the palette that I'm trying to get. I mean the no vanilla, I mean it's some not caramel, but some sort of ⁓ gosh, I don't know, I'm toffee or some sort of toffee type. Okay. But that's it. There's not much besides ⁓ I'm maybe toffee esque and then oak and that's all you got and that's that's all I'm getting. You know. I don't know. I like it. I mean, I think it's a nice pour to have, like to have a I think a si like a glass to share, yeah. ⁓ share a hundred percent because it's so unique and it's a unicorn. But like to have like I don't think it's something that you want to drink the whole time, but like some of the others, but like it's fan I mean, I think it's a great bottle to have. On your bar. Yeah. It's it's not a daily sipper, my personal opinion. Yeah. Okay. I mean it's it's definitely something to share and it's you incredibly unique, of course. Yeah. I think it's very interesting. I think it adds a la I think that oak adds a layer of complexity that you don't get on the small batch and the other offerings from Colonel Taylor. Maybe absent the barrel proof, because that thing's just incredible. It's a great pour. It's ⁓ it's it it it that that that almost should be. not in the Colonel Taylor line because it's just it's it's not the under other proof is and also also hot take why the fuck did they put a hundred proof BTAC Colonel Taylor in and not the barrel strength proof like fifty version fifteen year old barrel proof Colonel Taylor in a BTAC. You're gonna these people are pending a thousand dollar on secondary crazy. That you can Right now the market's getting flooded with it and it's absolutely incredible. But for me, I really like this. I think it's a change up. ⁓ it's not it's not your standard Buffalo Trace product. I d the oak is not super tannic, which I like. It does have it retains some of the sweetness to it and the nuance that you get in the oak. ⁓ would I like to get a little bit more of that caramel and the vanilla in the palette that I got on the nose? Yes. The nose is incredible. If we're We don't always do the radiant scale, but the nose for me is like eight and a half. Palette's probably like a seven and a half. It's just step down. It's still a solid drinker. Do I wish I paid four hundred dollars for it? No. But also, I didn't pay four hundred dollars for this. So thanks again to everybody. On on average, I've paid two hundred dollars for this. This but but it I'm trying to remember back because it's been ten years since I'd last tried this and and I only had a half ounce sip at the time and I thought it was phenomenal. And and but that was a seventeen year old bourbon where this is a ten year old can't compare ⁓ It's it's not the same. Yeah. It's the same label. It's not the same. The the weather that happened in those months too, right? I mean, that could affect things tremendously. The wood at that time. I mean, between single barrels in general, like you have such variety. So I mean, you never know the wood that was used at that time could be a lot different. And and listen, we may be making all these assumptions and it hasn't opened. I just went back, I nosed, now it's giving me brown sugar on the nose, and the front of the palate is like dehydrated strawberries. We may have to do a follow-up review of this in a month to see if it's changed and opened up more. But my wife likes to let her glass sit for ten minutes to four hours ⁓ before sampling. Because it does it does tend to change ⁓ the flavor profile with a little bit of air on it. I like it. I'd buy another bottle, but not for four hundred dollars. But I do think it's a bottle to have. Like if you can get it. ⁓ yeah, 100% grab it. And it's a definitely a bottle to share and to have. Especially if you're trying to complete the lineup of the Colonel Taylors, the vertical. I I mean there's there's crazy bottles out there that I don't have. ⁓ Amaranth, Green of Gods, Warehouse C, F four grain. I don't have e any of those. That's the warehouse C, right? Is it tornado warehouse C? There is also a a warehouse that's not tornado. Is there? I think so. Okay. Well, I don't have that one either. and I've seen I've seen I've seen one in my life. It was two thousand dollars. I'm like, nah, sorry. Not gonna spend two thousand dollars on that bottle. Keep it on your shelf. Maybe next year. No, no. But I definitely but I definitely think if you can get it for you're not gonna I mean, very rarely get it for eighty bucks if you're gonna get it at Safeway or Fries randomly. But like if you can get it for a hundred bucks, hundred and twenty I think it's worth a hundred bucks. ⁓ I do t especially to have it and to put it I like it in your in your I'm a collector, it's go of course I'm gonna grab it. You know, it's a big ⁓ Taylor fan in general. This I would I would not go crazy for this though. Like don't pay above secondary. Don't think this is gonna blow you away. ⁓ I don't know if I don't think this one's going to the stratosphere of three, four thousand dollars a bottle. Ever. but also with the bourbon glut that's happening right now, there's probably these seem to be a more available. ⁓ yeah. ⁓ does it say how many bottles they released? No, it doesn't. I couldn't find that information. So it tends tends to say that they probably have ⁓ a ton of them and they probably will re-release it again. I was told I was I heard that they released quite a bit 'cause they're trying to cut down on the secondary bullshit. And so they're gonna release it like f kind of off to the you know crowds. Well, I love that, dude. And I think for for those that are into whiskey and have been collecting a while and you're just trying to hold bottles for value, I mean it's not your time. ⁓ but if you enjoy drinking whiskey, there's a lot of great stuff coming out right now. So man, thank you guys. Appreciate tasting this for sharing bottle ⁓ bottle breakdown ⁓ with us. Let us know in the comments. Have you picked up a Colonel Taylor cured oak? Have you seen one on the shelves? ⁓ My personal thanks to El Paisano Liquors. Stay tuned. We got a few barrel picks coming out there in the near future. My guy over there, Amido, Yusuf, thank you so much. We'll see you next time on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Cheers. Hello. Cheers.