Latest / Five Games for Doomsday / Daryl Andrews
Transcript
- 0:04Out of the street corners. They scream. You knew it was coming.
- 0:08You've been waiting for this for months, rumor hardened into fear, and now
- 0:12they scream at you, the sirens, their hysterical wail, tearing through the
- 0:16white noise of the city, and you run. You run to pick up
- 0:20those things that can never be replaced, a picture of them in the days
- 0:24when they still loved you, your mother's wedding ring. And then you turn
- 0:27to your shelf of games. You only have room for five. Five Games
- 0:34for Doomsday. Five Games for Doomsday is a show in which board game personalities
- 0:41are thrust into a cabin in the woods to outrun an oncoming disaster, but
- 0:45can only take five of their games with them. But which will they choose.
- 0:50My guest this week is at the vanguard of a new generation of game
- 0:53designers. A former prison guard and pastor, he's a prolific designer with many
- 0:57credits to his name. First published Into fourteen, he came to prominence in
- 1:00twenty seventeen through Sagrada. My guest this week is Daryl Andrews. Daryl,
- 1:06Welcome to the cabin. Oh, thanks for having me. So my first
- 1:10question is then it's how difficult was it for you to pick the five games
- 1:12to take to the cabin? Excruciating? I don't know how has no idea,
- 1:21and so what was your criteria? Was there nostalgia? Was it pure
- 1:23practicality? Yeah? I ended up being very nostalgic. I think with my
- 1:30choices, I just continued in my mind to eliminate being like what would break
- 1:36my heart more to let go of. So it's very much like what tugged
- 1:40at my heart? And does that spread out to your normal life? Are
- 1:46you a nostalgic person in general? Yeah? You know, it's funny.
- 1:49This exercise definitely made me notice that I do. I think I'm maybe a
- 1:56little nostalgic. And also it made me realize is that when I choose games,
- 2:01I usually choose older games that I love playing new games. I love
- 2:06playing a variety of games, but I usually let other people choose the game.
- 2:10And so I've there's been talk for the last decade about the Golden Age
- 2:16of board games, and I'm starting to think that we're tipping over into the
- 2:22Silver Age of board games. And when I look at the Golden Age,
- 2:24I think of these classic designers like Rosenberg and Knitzia and Feld. Am I
- 2:30wrong or are we just getting better? Yeah? I think I think games
- 2:38we are kind of standing on the shoulders of each of those designs. So
- 2:43every time we need games that replace something on our shelf, or something that
- 2:49took all the best parts of a game earlier and then added something a new
- 2:53twist, a new a new way to look at it. So we are
- 2:58enjoying the benefits of all those, as you describe golden years. So let's
- 3:04go back to the beginning then, So your Canadian and Canadians have this reputation
- 3:08for being incredibly nice. How true is that? I don't think it's true
- 3:14at all. I think we just hide it. Well. I think we
- 3:19you know, for instance, I always suggest like like if you look at
- 3:23hockey, which it is such a popular sport in Canada, and yet it
- 3:29includes fighting and includes people like smashing and breaking bones and gritting and playing anyway,
- 3:36So I think as a nation we're just we're good actors. I think
- 3:40we like the reputation of being the nice, the nice you know, younger
- 3:46brother of Usa. And so when did games into your life? Then?
- 3:53Yeah, it's funny. I've all as long as I can remember I've been
- 3:57a board gamer. I have loved games from a very young age, which
- 4:00was a bit tricky because I am an only child, and so I was
- 4:05constantly recruiting friends even you know, my mother was a great cook and would
- 4:12always have many people over for dinner, and I would be recruiting all dinner
- 4:15long for people to play after dinner a game. I would request board games
- 4:19and then play them by myself and try to figure out the strategy and pretend
- 4:24to be two or three different people. So board games has always been an
- 4:28integrated, integral part of my life. And what were those early games?
- 4:32Were they the sort of classic sort of mass market stuff you Sorries, your
- 4:39monopolies. Yeah, absolutely from the start, you know, I had them
- 4:43all you know, sorry Trouble Monopoly, and I love them. I played
- 4:48them. But I also was introduced to a few other games that stood out
- 4:54as feeling different from a young age, and those games like even Scotland Yard
- 5:01or um I remember Hotels or Boardwalk. They were they were games that were
- 5:09adjacent to the mass mass market but also had a little more strategy, a
- 5:15little more influence from I later realized like German games. We were often referred
- 5:20to as as we started to discover that there were games beyond Hasbro and Mattel.
- 5:28And so when did when did the hobby games come into your purview and
- 5:32what were the what were the first hobby games that really grubbed you. Yeah,
- 5:36I mean early on, I didn't even know the difference. And I
- 5:40think it really became on my radar when I played a lot of risk in
- 5:46college. We had like lists of rules that we would vote on because you
- 5:50know, the week before someone tried to manipulate something, and so we would
- 5:56vote on all these extra rules before playing our games. And then after a
- 6:00risk we stumbled into Katan or back then Settlers of Katon and we started doing
- 6:06a lot of tournaments with that, and then from there we discovered Puerto Rico,
- 6:14and again that became just kind of our weekly habit that I just had
- 6:18a game group and it was just people that I look forward to getting back
- 6:24together around the table and trying to kick each other's butt. But but really
- 6:29it was just an excuse to be together. And so when did you start
- 6:32designing then, and did you feel that you had an aptitude full rate from
- 6:38the beginning. You know, it's funny, I did not think I would
- 6:42be a game designer. I look back now and I can see it,
- 6:46but I at the time, especially in college, and even after that,
- 6:50I started to get to know some game designers. But before that I never
- 6:56even thought about like who makes these things. I just to assume, poof
- 7:00they were there. And then I started running actually some board game tournaments across
- 7:06Canada called the Great Canadian Board Game Bluitz, and it was actually a tournament
- 7:11that would happen. It was established well before me, but they would have
- 7:15tournaments across Canada at game stores and I discovered the one in Toronto, got
- 7:21to know the organizers, started to fall in love with these events, and
- 7:25I would participate in them, and they did this phenomenal thing. They had
- 7:30one round of games that were all designed by Canadian designers, and it was
- 7:34the real first moment that the name and the person became personal. And I
- 7:41found out that my favorite game at the time was designed by someone who lived
- 7:46in my city, and so I had to track them down. I had
- 7:49to find out. So my favorite game at the time was Belford and it
- 7:54was designed by Sen Fong Limb and Jay Cormier, and Sen lived in my
- 7:58city of London, Ontario, Canada, and so we became friends and started
- 8:03gaming together. So you've already mentioned your first game then, and this is
- 8:09this is a classic, and it's an old one. This is Scotland Yard.
- 8:11So where does this rank do you think in the pantheon of hidden movement
- 8:15games? Yeah? I mean as a child, I was already playing it,
- 8:20studying it. I still think it holds up today. It's funny.
- 8:24I just introduced it to my local game group a month ago and none of
- 8:30them had even heard of it, and they all loved it. Was a
- 8:33great time, and it reminded me of my love for it, that it's
- 8:37just pure and it's clean. It does hidden movements so well. There have
- 8:43been other games obviously that have done it. But the other one that I
- 8:48was thinking from my childhood that kind of introduced me to the hidden movement was
- 8:52Stop Thief. And both Scotland Yard and Stop Thief are these just like magical
- 8:56moments of this tension, especially if you're as either the person who's running or
- 9:03on the hide, or you're leading your group to try to track them down.
- 9:07It just it feels so good when you catch someone on the run.
- 9:11So that that was kind of like the beginning. But I you know,
- 9:16since then, there's been games like Spector Ops or Mine Management, Fury of
- 9:20Dracula. All these games use hidden movement, but I think they all have
- 9:24thanks to Scotland Yard for being like the og, the true pure hidden movement
- 9:31capture you know that person, and I've been chasing that ever since. I
- 9:37just I love that game and I love introducing people to it. Yeah.
- 9:41So one of the most torturous experiences I've ever had gaming was Fury of Dracula,
- 9:46especially I had the version that had the reset card in it, and
- 9:50I always say, I always flip the table when the person playing Dracula played
- 9:54in. I mean, do you think there's a purity to Scotland Yards,
- 9:58that the sort of a timelessness. Yeah, I do. I think,
- 10:01you know, there's something about you know, I love Furior Tracket. I
- 10:05try to play it like every Halloween. But there's a lot of rules to
- 10:09him. There's a lot of extras, and yet Scotland Yard is like very
- 10:15elegant. It is easy to teach, and yet it creates so much fun.
- 10:20And all you're doing is running point to point, spending taxi tokens or
- 10:26underground tokens, trying to just be on the same spot as someone that's on
- 10:30the run. So simple yet just does it so well. So I want
- 10:35to talk now about your sort of varied work outside of games. So you've
- 10:39been a prison guard. How did that happen and how was it? Yeah,
- 10:45it's a pretty crazy job. I was just reminiscing about just the absurdness
- 10:52of the job. I worked in a max security like custody detention center for
- 10:58young offenders between sixteen and eighteen, and it was like such an extreme of
- 11:07offenses that these these young people were in there for. But I got into
- 11:13it because I have a background in education and youth work, and I had
- 11:18actually moved to my city and was looking for a new just kind of like
- 11:22part time job. I was exploring the idea of trying to do board game
- 11:26design longer or do it more, and so I kind of I needed this
- 11:31mix of a job that I could do but I could walk away from.
- 11:35I could even you know, depending on if I was doing overnight shifts,
- 11:39I could think of game design while you know, on shift. But it
- 11:43was a wild job. It was just a crazy thing to think, like,
- 11:46for instance, their their favorite thing to watch on TV was the TV
- 11:50show Cops, just sitting around watching them commentate and yell and say like no,
- 11:58no, no, go, love flug over that fence. He's not
- 12:01gonna be able to get out over that fence. And it was just just
- 12:05a very unique experience. And did he mold your views on the criminal justice
- 12:11system and incarceration in general? You know, it really did it. I
- 12:16worked for an organization that was actually a private company hired by the government,
- 12:20and the unfortunate stat was they were considered a success because the repeat offender return
- 12:28rate was only seventy five and I'd say only because traditionally it's closer to ninety.
- 12:33And what that really showed me was that these these places of incarceration were
- 12:41really cyclical. There was a lot of family dysfunction. I would sit in
- 12:46a lot of like when visitors would come and I would literally catch, you
- 12:50know, parents trying to smuggle in drugs, all kinds of sad moments where
- 12:56you just go like, this is a bigger problem and it can't really be
- 13:01about incarceration. It really needs to be about trying to restore and try to
- 13:07work on you know, these problem these bigger problems. So thankfully we had
- 13:11things like a lot of counselors on staff, we had the school, and
- 13:16we really worked with these young people and trying to give them the ability and
- 13:20the tools and really the goal of trying to give them a better life,
- 13:26a way to stop choosing kind of the destructive choices they were making, and
- 13:33try to find ways to encourage restoration and and and try to find a better
- 13:37way. See, you've also worked as a pasta. How is faith multiju
- 13:43as a person? Yeah, it's funny. I I often don't talk about
- 13:48the fact that I was a pastor because I know the church has hurt a
- 13:50lot of people and a lot of people have been mistreated, but you know,
- 13:58at its core, I've also met a ton of people with different faith
- 14:01within the gaming community, and I think it's kind of special because there's a
- 14:05lot of people within the game community that appreciate things like sharing a table,
- 14:13feeling like you know, every person matters, that were equals that, you
- 14:16know, the quality time of getting to share a game together. And I
- 14:20think, you know, my faith gives me a reason to appreciate those things
- 14:24and to value and try to you know, lift people up and so I
- 14:31think I think games do that. I think games give people chances to explore
- 14:35and to have fun and and and to share stories with each other, so
- 14:41that I see, there's a nice overlap there. So you'll know, in
- 14:46the industry primarily as a designer, but you've also DiPT tour into board game
- 14:50publishing. How does it differ from the role of a designer. Yeah,
- 14:56it's very different. And I learned I am not a publisher. I learned
- 15:01that there's a lot of hats, and I'm thankful, you know, I
- 15:05love I love a good hat, but I don't necessarily want to wear all
- 15:09of them. And so I worked with some really wonderful people when I did
- 15:13Maple Games. But I realized, you know, things like I really didn't
- 15:18get to explore and and and spend much time on creative you know, I
- 15:24lost a lot of opportunities to do that. You know, I would delegate
- 15:28or hire people to get to do that, but I didn't get to do
- 15:31that myself. I also, um, you know, lost chance to build
- 15:37relationships and be out in the community because I was so busy with the next
- 15:39project and the next project. And so I think publishers, you know,
- 15:43project management in general is you kind of have to be so focused on making
- 15:50sure all the trains are on time that you don't necessarily get to explore or
- 15:54participate as much as I wanted to. So I'm thankful for publishers. It's
- 15:58the reason I signed games with publishers, as I like working with them.
- 16:03I'm not against the idea of maybe, you know, kickstarting the odd game,
- 16:07but the predominant way that I will make games as working with publishers and
- 16:11enjoying the benefits that they have a variety of skill sets. So your next
- 16:18game then is another classic, and this is El Grande. Why do you
- 16:22think this game is so well regarded? Oh? I love Al Grande.
- 16:27It's funny. I just again, I just recently played this about a month
- 16:30ago. I had a few friends over, one that many gamers would know
- 16:36as Eric Lang. He's a local when he's not traveling the world, and
- 16:41we just were reminded how much it is such a clever game. It is
- 16:48I think so well regarded because everyone that comes out of that game, if
- 16:53you win or you lose, you go like, oh I wish I did
- 16:56this, or there was this great moment during the during the game at this,
- 17:00and so it creates like just big moments really with very few turns.
- 17:07You don't take a lot of turns, but each decision is excruciating and meaningful.
- 17:14And area control games are numerous, It's one of the most popular mechanics
- 17:19in gaming. Has it been an area control game to rival El grand Do
- 17:23you think? Oh? I you know, I have a hard time thinking
- 17:29anything could surpass it. Honestly, my very first game that I designed was
- 17:36significantly influenced by Al Grande, and that was The Walled City. And my
- 17:41goal with that game was to try to make Al Grande even faster, even
- 17:47fewer turns. And it's funny because I feel like, in some ways I
- 17:52accomplished that with my co designer stevens Hower. But I think also we created
- 17:56like too much analysis paralysis is like brain melting at times. And and I
- 18:03think of other area control games that I love. I think of I'm sure
- 18:07I'm butchering how you say it, but TOA or Troy's or you know,
- 18:11Mambassa, which has been remade into sky sky Mines, or I don't know
- 18:18other ones. I'm kind of thinking Hansa, Tautnica, uh Rococo, you
- 18:25know, all these games that I love that do it, do it but
- 18:27kind of adding more and getting heavier, and yet like I just think Al
- 18:33Grande is like so like accessible while at the same time it gets you all
- 18:41the juicy moments. Still, the only other kind of game that I think
- 18:45has kind of done it recently in an in an elegant way that rivals it.
- 18:51I was thinking, m is Ethnos. I think Ethnos is a really
- 18:56clean, elegant area control game that I think gives it a good run for
- 19:02his money. An older one that I loved that has a great area control
- 19:06as a mission Red Planet, I think that's another another one that I really
- 19:10enjoy that I think rivals it, but it still stands among so many designs
- 19:15as to me, like the Pinnacle. So you worked with Volfgang Karma.
- 19:21How much of an honor was that. Yeah, I'm still pinching myself and
- 19:26it's been a few years now. It's it's crazy, Like I literally just
- 19:32like when I get an email back, I squeal, like I just I
- 19:36can't believe that, Like he even knows who I am, and he's gracious
- 19:41and kind and smart and gentle, and I mean he is when I'm his
- 19:48age. If I can be anything like Wolfgang, I will be a happy
- 19:52man. It really is a privilege, and he is really encouraging and support
- 20:00of open minded. We're actually working on a bunch of games right now and
- 20:07I yeah, it's just amazing to get to work with him. And do
- 20:11you think he would be on the mind rushmore of game designers. Oh,
- 20:17definitely, like without I mean, he would be the first carved in in
- 20:21my opinion. I'm sure other people have different opinions, but he is.
- 20:26He is numero una. So I want to talk now about what you're known
- 20:30for in this industry, which is your work as a designers. So Sagrado
- 20:34was the first game you did that really hit. Why do you think that
- 20:38was? Yeah, I know, it's funny. I think about it often
- 20:44because you know, if I could just redo that all the time, that
- 20:47would be great, But I think luck in timing and interest it was.
- 20:52It's funny because when I pitched that game around, I pitched it around to
- 20:56seven publishers that turned it down, and each process was, you know,
- 21:02a month or two of evaluation and no, and another publisher and no.
- 21:06And it was funny because at the time it was just kind of considered like
- 21:11a dice game should be like fifteen twenty bucks should be small, and that
- 21:15wasn't at all what we were pitching. People were like scratching their head when
- 21:19we said there were ninety dice involved. And yet I think especially with Floodgates
- 21:29help, it really captured our vision and our dream of it being this gorgeous,
- 21:33thinky puzzley game that was still accessible, and I kind of think it
- 21:37was just leb I say lucky in timing is a few games dropped around the
- 21:42same time, and thankfully we were part of like the start of it,
- 21:45of just people really looking for, you know, new themes, themes that
- 21:51weren't you know, just like dudes on a map or trading in the Mediterranean,
- 21:55and it was pretty and it was something that engaged, but it wasn't
- 22:00hard to learn, and we just kind of got lucky that like a bunch
- 22:03of people were looking for games that scratch that itch that we're quick, that
- 22:08everyone could play, that you could play with a partner, that you could
- 22:11play with a family member, even even like it's it's funny, I get
- 22:17I get bugged all the time that dice are too luck driven, and we
- 22:22tried to mitigate that as much as possible. But I also think luck's just
- 22:25really important to be part of a game. I think sometimes a game is
- 22:29too thinky or rewards too much the one type of thinker. And so the
- 22:36game did well to kind of scratch that itch of a little bit of luck,
- 22:38a lot of puzzle, pretty and fast. And so, you know
- 22:42you've spoken about your previous professions. When did you become a full time designer.
- 22:49Yeah, I was trying to pinpoint when it was. It was kind
- 22:55of a gradual shift, you know. When I was doing, for instance,
- 22:59like prison guard work, you know, that was part time, and
- 23:02I kind of joked that it was my jobbie, a little bit of hobby,
- 23:06a little bit of work. But I think it's been coming close to
- 23:11eight or nine years now that I made the shift to try to do games
- 23:18full time. I did a bit of a bit of development work. I
- 23:22tried, you know, wherever I could kind of get a little contract here
- 23:26or there to compliment or supplement. But it was really then that my wife
- 23:33said, yeah, just go for it, and she has a good job.
- 23:34We don't have any kids, and she said, you know, when
- 23:37else, you know, in life can you go for a dream, chase
- 23:41it and try to get in And I do think that was, you know,
- 23:45a really huge thing for my wife to support me through that and gave
- 23:49me a chance to go to conventions just you know, chase down people work
- 23:56with a variety of designers, you name it. I was just really trying
- 24:00to find myself, find my voice, and and try to get games out.
- 24:03They take a long time to eventually come out as well, so the
- 24:07lead time is quite long. And if anyone's friends with you on Facebook,
- 24:11you'll see that you do an awful lot of traveling. What are the challenges
- 24:17to being a professional game designer? Do you need to get out there,
- 24:21go to all the conventions, and make the network. So I think pre
- 24:26COVID it was necessary. I think conventions are and still are one of the
- 24:33best places to get in front of get in front of influencers and decision makers.
- 24:41I think it can be you know, kids, mit of just you
- 24:45know, being able to kind of read the room and see what people need.
- 24:48And a lot of that information doesn't disseminate or get out, so those
- 24:53relationships are a big deal. I think it's important. But I do think
- 24:57that COVID helped all of us try to think of ways that we can connect,
- 25:03you know, through Zoom being able to use you know, different services
- 25:08like tabletop simulator, so that other people that can't attend conventions can still get
- 25:15their games out there, can still get in front of decision makers. And
- 25:19so I think, actually it's just now even broader. There's more than one
- 25:23way to do it, like a good strategy game. I still really gravitate
- 25:29to face to face and you know, that connection to try to work in
- 25:36this industry. But part of it is because that's what I enjoy and that's
- 25:38how I'm wired. I've always, with all my co designers, been the
- 25:42person who pitches our games and does a lot of the communication between the publisher.
- 25:48You know. I have co designers, for instance, Adrian who did
- 25:52Sagrato with me, who has only I think been to two conventions in his
- 25:56life, because we differ on what skill sets we bring to the to our
- 26:02partnership. And I like travel, and he has four kids and loves being
- 26:07home with them and wants to soak that time up. And so I think
- 26:11he went to Dice Tower East once and thought that was the biggest convention ever
- 26:17and was like this is too much. So yeah, different people, different
- 26:22different strategies, and you vote with ips. How different is it working on
- 26:27designs that IP based compared to designs that you come up with the theme yourself.
- 26:36Sure, you know, I'm a big fan of a variety of pop
- 26:40culture things, movies, podcasts, TV shows, toys, you name it,
- 26:47and so for me getting to play with different IP has been really exciting.
- 26:52I've got to work on some stuff that if I could tell my younger
- 26:56kid version that I'd be part of, you know, Batman and teenage Mutant,
- 27:00Ninja, Turtles and Back to the Future, I wouldn't believe. I
- 27:03wouldn't have believed myself. And it's it's really been quite quite a joy.
- 27:10But it's very different. I mean, there's different restraints and approvals and weird
- 27:15things that you know, you can't really talk about because you just kind of
- 27:19have to bite your upper lip and enjoy that you get to work in that
- 27:23environment. I use an example like Titanic. To this day, people always
- 27:30bug me about how Molly is not a character in the game, and trust
- 27:33me, that's one of my favorite characters. But this Bates is incredible.
- 27:38But we couldn't get them in because we didn't have approvals. But that's also
- 27:42something where when it comes out, they don't want us to be talking about
- 27:47or emphasizing, so we just kind of suck it up and see on every
- 27:51message board like why is Molly not in the game? And that just kind
- 27:55of comes with the territory of when you work with IP, you're privy to
- 27:59summon nation that never really gets out there. And so you got to design
- 28:04a game in an IP that I was particularly interested in because it was for
- 28:07one of my favorite podcasts, which is Last Podcast on the Left. How
- 28:12did you get that gig? And how was it to work on that IP?
- 28:18Yeah? I was super surprising. I will confess when how it came
- 28:22about was I thankfully have gotten to work on a couple of games with Goliath
- 28:30publisher that I actually has quite an international reach. Their headquarters is in Amsterdam,
- 28:36their US offices are in Texas, and I got to work on Oregon
- 28:42Trail with them and a few other projects, and then they approached me with
- 28:48this podcast and I'll confess I a had not listened. I had heard of
- 28:53it, and I knew the comedians from other other works that they had done,
- 29:00but it was funny. I'd never listened to it, and I was
- 29:02I was actually quite skeptical that a podcast could be a good license for a
- 29:06board game, and they encouraged me to give it a listen. And they
- 29:11had offered a few other podcasts ideas for games as well, and I listened
- 29:17to last podcast and died laughing and thought that they were hilarious. And I
- 29:22also noticed that their fan base was so loyal and so engaged, and I
- 29:27thought, wow, okay, this could be different, but this sounds like
- 29:30a fun challenge. And so I got connected with Marcus and Ben and them,
- 29:37and we got on some calls and they're even crazier in real life.
- 29:42And it was, you know, a bunch of phone calls where I'd get
- 29:45off the call and ask Goliath, like, am I allowed to do half
- 29:51that stuff? And Goliath would say nope. And you know, there was
- 29:56a tight rope of figuring out ideas that they had and you know things that
- 30:03goliathe, you know, being in mass market toy environments and such, had
- 30:07certain things they do not feel comfortable to include. But I got to act
- 30:11as that that middle person to kind of capture and kind of try to translate
- 30:18the wild fund that they do on their on their show and try to translate
- 30:23it into a game, and it was a real joy to do. They
- 30:27were awesome to work with, really encouraging, and yeah, it was fun
- 30:33to even see like they would put a tweet out and instantly, within like
- 30:37a few hours, every copy on Amazon was sold out, and it was
- 30:41just like, oh wow, Like that's the power of fans of like people
- 30:45that really believe in in support and they've really encouraged through a lot of work
- 30:52and a lot of episodes to build that trust. So your next game then
- 30:57is another classic, and this is Carcasson. So what's really interesting is this
- 31:06game is twenty years old and still manages to be so popular. But what
- 31:11I see is a lot of designers who come on here, pick this one
- 31:15and all the big three You've got tickets ride Caucasson and Katan. Carcasson is
- 31:21by far the one that designers pick the most. Why do you think that
- 31:25is? Yeah, oh, that's an interesting observation. And you know,
- 31:29if I'm probably not unique in thinking how just elegant and clever tile placement can
- 31:38be in And there were other examples of games that did it, and there
- 31:41are you know, more games that are coming out that do tile placement,
- 31:45but Carcasson just feels like this really great simple I can just put down a
- 31:51tile and then I can grab another tile and just show how they fit together,
- 31:56and we make something together, this in essence a piece of art of
- 32:00a map, and we all get to be part of this creative process.
- 32:05And I just think as a designer, I think it's one of the most
- 32:08elegant design games. I look at it and I just think, like,
- 32:14that's what I would aim for, is a game that you can almost just
- 32:17pick up the pieces and start playing and know what you're doing, and yet
- 32:22excruciate all the moments of where do I want to add this, and you
- 32:27know then the extra layers and different themes, and it's just it's just like
- 32:32a great platform for being able to play through a whole bunch of different narratives
- 32:38in a really compact, small box, a thirty minute experience, and yet
- 32:45it's still, like you said, like twenty years later, they're coming up
- 32:50with all kinds of fresh ways to present it. One of my favorites recently
- 32:54was playing on maps where you add the tiles on top of it and those
- 32:58maps. All of a sudden, it was just like a whole new game
- 33:00again. And yet all I was doing was TWE placement, and yet it
- 33:05just works. And so has it been an inspiration to you as a designer?
- 33:12You know what's funny, I think about it a lot at times.
- 33:15Sometimes I'm almost scared of or intimidated by it because I think it does it
- 33:20so well. So sometimes I almost steer clear of it. I did,
- 33:23and I fear that sometimes I just think I'm just adding complexity or muddying it.
- 33:30But you know, when a good game comes out that I've been working
- 33:35on something that's similar, I just kind of go like, oh, I
- 33:37don't need to make that game anymore. Someone else did, Like I remember,
- 33:40you know that moment or that feeling with Kingdomino or like Baron Park or
- 33:46Isle of Sky, like those games just managed to do what I was trying
- 33:52to dabble with with TWE games, And so I don't I don't know if
- 33:59I've I've hit it yet, but I definitely am inspired by it constantly and
- 34:05and challenge to try to think of other games. A recent game that I
- 34:09just adored in this last year was Acropolis and again just super simple twel game,
- 34:16but you know they they added a few twists, and yet it's just
- 34:21really quick and easy and clever. And so to what degree do you think
- 34:25games incorporate both, you know, cognition and a sense of touch. Yeah,
- 34:36it is so satisfying, like the tactile nature of twel placement and just
- 34:43you know, how things fit together that I think that physicality is a really
- 34:46important element to games. I think, you know, sometimes we refer to
- 34:50things as gimmicks or you know, even like with Sagrada, like fitting the
- 34:54dice in the window. There's just like really important moment where you can take
- 35:00a good idea and make it a great thing. If it feels good,
- 35:05if it clicks, if it if it you know, just creates this you
- 35:08know moment. I say to people, if you can make people feel either
- 35:13creative or clever, you're doing something really positive and you're you're you're probably onto
- 35:19something. And so I think tactile gives you that immediate, like in your
- 35:23bones moment where you're like, oh, that felt good. So I want
- 35:28to talk now about your partnerships. So in the in the email that you
- 35:32send to me preparing for the show. You said that craning games is a
- 35:36blending of mass, psychology and art. Can you elaborate on that, Yeah,
- 35:40sure, I mean it's funny. I at least I try to do
- 35:44that. I don't know if it's Sometimes you know, there's people that are
- 35:47experts at one thing, and I'm I'm I'm maybe an expert of none,
- 35:51but a jack of all trades. And so I like to think that that
- 35:55blending. And often even why I codesign is because you're trying to find this
- 36:01mix of scratching, you know, the puzzle, the mind, but also
- 36:07the psychology, the why though you know what's fun you know, who are
- 36:12we are we trying to deduce? Are we trying to read each other?
- 36:15Uh? And then and then the beauty the art of a game, I
- 36:20think, and and just the the experience. I think, you know,
- 36:23we need all of those things, uh to justify our time or a reason
- 36:29to to do games over something else. And so um, I like to
- 36:35think, you know, my background and my experiences, my education helped me,
- 36:39you know anything, from being a prison guard, where I you know,
- 36:43literally was trained to you know, read if someone's a lie, telling
- 36:47a lie, or concealing something, the fact that my wife's a psychotherapist and
- 36:52we regularly chit chat about human behavior and human psychology all the time. You
- 36:58know, all those things blend into like what what I'm trying to make and
- 37:02the people I work with. I use this example all the time. But
- 37:07for instance, Adrian, my co designer for Segrata, is very thinky,
- 37:15puzzlely minded, math minded, and he brought up the idea of the five
- 37:21color theorem, which if anyone is not familiar with that, you've probably seen
- 37:25it in one form or another. If you look at like maps, especially
- 37:29postal maps, you'll see like each of the regions you never have the same
- 37:32color region next to each other. And that helped influence, you know,
- 37:37we just started to kind of geek out on that idea and developed Segrata of
- 37:42this idea of no two numbers and two colors next to each other. And
- 37:45again it's taking that but then playing with it and simmering and trying to distill
- 37:52it down to its best moments, I think is what game design is all
- 37:55though. And so you've co designed many games, Why does that work for
- 38:02you? Yeah? I am the type of person that, first of all,
- 38:07I've just always loved like team sports and seeing what you know. You
- 38:13know, almost like a good improv like where you say yes and you just
- 38:16keep kind of bouncing off each other and it doesn't always work. And it's
- 38:20a chemistry thing, and it's really important to find people that you work with
- 38:23and it's no insult to the other person. You almost kind of don't know
- 38:29until you try, and you have to try with a bunch of people to
- 38:31find who you jive with best. You know. It is similar to like
- 38:37jamming with music, like you can have a perfectly good musician, but the
- 38:42coming together is really important. And I think that matters for games because then
- 38:45as you find that, I find I can work on three games with co
- 38:51designers more than one game by myself because that energy and that ability to kind
- 38:57of pass the game back and forth breaks through any roadblocks that by myself I
- 39:01might hit, But my co designer might not find that to be a problem
- 39:06at all, and they'll kind of riff or progress off of an idea that
- 39:09I might get stuck on for weeks and they just don't get stuck with that
- 39:15at all. I also think it helps me create and tell stories that I
- 39:19would never come up with myself. I think working with different, you know,
- 39:22different people helps me find you know, interesting stories, you know,
- 39:30interesting perspectives because it's outside of my head and it's sometimes in someone else's head
- 39:36and we have to talk about it. We have to figure out, we
- 39:38have to push past, you know, my own assumptions. So even like
- 39:43explaining a rule, it makes sense in my head, but if it doesn't
- 39:45to my co designer, then they're going to ask questions and they're going to
- 39:50help, you know, clarify and vice versas. So I am a big
- 39:53proponent of co design because I think it is one of the most rich and
- 39:59constru active ways to spend your time. And what do you bring to the
- 40:04partnership? Would you say, Yeah, that might be a better question for
- 40:08my co designers other than stress or frustration. But I you know, I
- 40:15am at maybe a little bit of a chameleon because I often try to adapt
- 40:21to my co designers so often, depending on what they enjoy and what their
- 40:25strengths are, I might try to kind of go to the compliment of that
- 40:30I do naturally, like like I was mentioned earlier, pitch games and do
- 40:35a lot of the business side of of game design as well. Just because
- 40:38of experience and such. But uh, I also I am finding I sometimes
- 40:45like to try to do the opposite now. I you know, some of
- 40:50my my past relationships, I had a lot of you know, Matthew people
- 40:53or puzzling people. And it's funny because a lot of people would say,
- 40:57like, oh, that that's not your style. I enjoy those things too.
- 41:00So I'm just trying to find different co designers to work with so that
- 41:07I can stretch different muscles and work on different sides of a game. And
- 41:12how do these collaborations come about? If there's a designer out there listening to
- 41:17this thinking I'd like to work with someone, how do you go about getting
- 41:21the collaborations? Yeah, that's really really good question. I'm sure it's very
- 41:25different for each person. I mean, part of it is just relationship.
- 41:30I think a lot of the people I've gotten to work with over the years,
- 41:35I've either play tested their games or they've play tested for me, and
- 41:38we've you know, come up with something that we thought would be fun to
- 41:43work on together. Sometimes it you know, it's just a matter of persistence.
- 41:49I know for myself, because I work on a bunch of different games
- 41:52and with a bunch of different people. If someone lets it fade or someone
- 41:57feels bad to kind of poke me, it'll probably kind of drift away.
- 42:02But those that have been you know, really good at checking in and progressing
- 42:07on a design when it's their time to work on stuff, I think like
- 42:12that becomes inspiring, and that becomes like, oh, let's jump on that,
- 42:15like, oh, next week, let's let's have a specific time to
- 42:19push that game a little further. Um. Yeah. And I think also
- 42:23a major one is people that are willing to put in the time and the
- 42:28work to really like play tests. I'm a big proponent of like let's not
- 42:32just talk about it, but let's see what players say, let's see how
- 42:36people react. And so when I work with people, the perk is we
- 42:40usually have two different code design like like play test groups. And so because
- 42:45of that, they can play tests with their circle and come back with information
- 42:51and and and same for me. And it's really exciting to hear, oh
- 42:54this was their feedback. Oh cool, let's see you know, like you
- 42:58progress off of that, you riff off of that. So I think I
- 43:00think it's really important to put yourself out there, get to know people,
- 43:04play test stuff and just kind of, um, see what's possible. And
- 43:10so if you could work with anybody in the industry that you haven't worked with
- 43:16yet, who would that be? Oh, as a long list, it's
- 43:23funny. So Wolfgang has been obviously a huge one. I recently also been
- 43:28doing some work with Alan R. Moon and that's been a dream. Um.
- 43:31Other people that come to mind the Brunos. Bruno Cathala has designed many
- 43:37of my favorite games. Also Bruno Fadut, although they're very different designers yet
- 43:44I love both of their works. Um. Elizabeth Hargraves would be amazing to
- 43:49work with. She's so talented. Um. Eric Lang, It's funny,
- 43:57we've been friends for many years and we've never co designed. M Yeah,
- 44:02many friends. I mean I think of like Kathleen Mercury is someone that would
- 44:07love to work with THEO Revere. Um. You know, people that make
- 44:13games that I really enjoy. I think of like shem Phillips or Phil Walker,
- 44:19Harding, Um, Michael Keisling, uh Sebastian Deschampum. Yeah, I
- 44:27mean I could I could really list probably hundreds of all my favorite designers that
- 44:32I would love to work with someday. So your next game then is another
- 44:37classic, and this is Liar's Dice. While you're taking this one to the
- 44:42cabin. I you know, it's funny and there's probably a little bit of
- 44:45association for me. But I just think so many times in my life when
- 44:51I've been in a cabin I played Liars Dice. I think I think of
- 44:55like just like it is something that just scales completely well. I love dice
- 45:00obviously, Um, I think it's just like a great It gives me like
- 45:07poker vibes of like reading people and bluffing while just getting to that fun part
- 45:12as fast as possible. And uh, I just I just think it really
- 45:16creates some really highlight moments. I have a lot of house roles too for
- 45:20a liar's life, so I feel like you can kind of like switch it
- 45:23up or change it up as you play, and it just it just always
- 45:28creates some really funny, great moments. And so are you drown. It's
- 45:34very easy when you're into hobby games to be very much focused on the next
- 45:37thing coming out and and the sort of classics of the hobby world. But
- 45:42are you are you drawn to more traditional games? I think I think in
- 45:46some ways yes, in some ways no, I am guilty. If you
- 45:50ask my wife, she would say, I'm always asking to play a new
- 45:52game, like why can't we play the same game twice? And I am
- 45:55guilty of constantly wanting to kind of research and experiens the new. But I
- 46:01still come back. I feel like I come back to my roots that I
- 46:05started, you know, as a kid playing all the kind of traditional games
- 46:09and classics like Uno and and uh risk and you name it, and and
- 46:15so because of those kind of like my background and kind of circling back to
- 46:21the nostalgia, I think I have an appreciation for things that can be really
- 46:25simple and and and that can be kind of enjoyed by the why this possible
- 46:32um audience. And so I think I think that's why, you know,
- 46:37something like liars Dice is something that I just always want to have with me
- 46:40just in case I want everyone to feel included. I want, you know,
- 46:45anyone even you know, not to not play because they're intimidated by the
- 46:49rules. But it you know, I still I still love a good chewy
- 46:52game, but but it has to be with people that that want to experience
- 46:57that. So what can we learn from these games? Do you think?
- 47:02I mean, what can you learn as a designer. I mean, I'm
- 47:07constantly asking myself, how can I take, you know, especially more hobby
- 47:13game moments, like things that we're learning and we're experimenting with, but making
- 47:17them accessible. I think I think my at my, uh, you know,
- 47:23real happy moments are if I can take something that I've discovered this deep,
- 47:29you know, in our geekdom, in our nerddom of love for games,
- 47:34and then find ways to to bring that to the masses. I think
- 47:37that would be a really fun and great moment to be able to help people
- 47:43discover games that maybe they didn't even know that they loved games, and and
- 47:47and some of that is kind of translating or or or playing kind of these
- 47:52more in depth games and then and then finding ways to to to play with
- 47:58them in more accessible ways. So I want to talk now about the future,
- 48:02and you're you're a prolific designer, so hopefully this will be a fairly
- 48:06long list. What do you have coming out in the future. Yeah,
- 48:10I mean, I think it's like a double edged sword. Like games,
- 48:14they take so long that you almost forget about them for a bit, or
- 48:17at least I tell myself to forget about them. So that I don't.
- 48:20You know, there's delays and different things that come up, but I can
- 48:24think of a handful of games that are coming. One that I'm really excited
- 48:29about. Arcane Wonders has titled it lay Lines, and it's a co designed
- 48:35with both Gang Cramer, and it's really beautiful art. It's it's actually a
- 48:40reimagining of Again, I'm going to butcher how you say this, and all
- 48:45the German friends will tell me how poor I speak. But ox assle it
- 48:51was a trucking game that won the spiel Jejar in the early eighties, and
- 48:55so that game's coming out with Arcane Wonders and hopefully if that does well.
- 49:01Actually, Wolfgang and I have a kids game playing with some of the characters
- 49:06that were developed for lay Lines, with another game that you know might come
- 49:10down come out down the road as long as ley Lines does, oh well
- 49:15does well. This last year was kickstarted and it will finally be coming out
- 49:20as Sagrada Artisans with Floodgate. That is the legacy game that Adrian and I
- 49:25have been designing for a few years and as one of the biggest and best
- 49:30things I think I've ever designed, and I'm really excited for people to experience
- 49:34it, because legacy games are really hard to tell people about. You kind
- 49:37of have to just experience them. Um Others, there's Missed Wind. It's
- 49:44a game with a smaller publisher, First Fish Games. Adrian and I made
- 49:49this game actually a number of years ago, and they're hoping to kick start
- 49:52it and hopefully the second quarter of this year. You know, April may
- 49:59time working on art right now. But it's a pickup and delivery game set
- 50:02in this beautiful fantasy world of floating whales. And yeah, we're really,
- 50:08really quite proud of the game and think First Fish has done a really great
- 50:13job of creating a whole world that maybe again if the game, if the
- 50:16game takes off, we have ideas for other game set in the same world
- 50:21or environment. Beaver Camp as a game that Adrian and I made for Elf
- 50:29Creek and it's going to be set in the Honey Buzz universe. I pitched
- 50:37to them that I really thought that they needed a beaver game, but if
- 50:39they do it, it had to be Canadians that designed it, and thankfully
- 50:44it was us. I have an upcoming a license game. I can't talk
- 50:50about the license quite yet. For Goliath because it's unannounced, but it'll be
- 50:54a big deduction game with a really kind of fun nostalgia brand that people will
- 51:02recognize, and that should come out at gen Con. I have another license
- 51:07game with Upper Deck that I'm co designing with Morgan Danteville, who I had
- 51:13designed Dark Knight Returns with, and we're really excited to be working on a
- 51:17second game together. I can't talk about that license yet. We have I
- 51:27co designed with Alan Moon and Bobby West called Folding Space that we signed with
- 51:31Maestromedia and look forward to that coming out. It originally was going to come
- 51:37out a few years ago that didn't work out, so we're really excited to
- 51:40finally have that coming out to the world. I got a couple of games
- 51:46with twenty fifth Century that I'm really excited about, one called Saint Augustine that
- 51:51I co designed with Philip Dabari. Saint Augustine is about the city in Florida
- 51:58that's actually been control by eight different countries, has a really gorgeous castle.
- 52:05At Also my twenty fifth Century, I have a co designed with Bobby West
- 52:08called Chipmunks, about little chipmunks running around the monastery grounds making beer. Yeah,
- 52:15what else is there? I have a historical two player game coming out
- 52:20with a new publisher. That was a new challenge. I was really excited
- 52:23about have a game signed with Valiant Comics that might be coming out. I
- 52:30don't know. I haven't heard from them for a little while. Yeah,
- 52:35I mean, and then know a few others that are early stages, but
- 52:38that'll be over twenty twenty three, twenty twenty four, some of the games
- 52:44coming out. And so you know, even the coolest thing can become prosaic
- 52:51if you do it all the time. And we rarely stop to sort of
- 52:54focus on the blessings that we have in life. But what are the joys
- 53:01of being a game designer? Yeah? Well, I mean you mentioned I
- 53:07get to travel, and it is truly a blessing. I actually still I
- 53:13steal this statement from Eric lang He a long time ago. I asked him,
- 53:16you know, a similar question, you know, what did he enjoy
- 53:21and why was he a game designer? And he said, and it's stuck
- 53:24with me ever since, but that one of his wind conditions if you thought
- 53:28of life that way, was getting to travel, and that this job not
- 53:32only encouraged it, but also it became, you know, a way to
- 53:37be inspired. And so for me, travel is this mix of work and
- 53:42recharging and inspiration, and yeah, it's part of my wind conditions. And
- 53:46so that's one of the great joys is getting to see people and cultures and
- 53:53just see beauty and then get to try to translate that into a little package
- 53:59that people can buy and have fun with. And so what would you hope
- 54:05that people get out of your games? Yeah, I mean for me,
- 54:13like it's it's almost like when you're doing your job right, they almost don't
- 54:16notice yet. And so I think similarly, if I can make some games
- 54:20that people just lose themselves in that they find, you know, some meaningful
- 54:24connection or fun where you know, like I love when I get like I
- 54:30don't get it very often, but the odd like message like oh, you
- 54:35know, I play this with my grandma and it's a chance for us to
- 54:38see each other every week, or Sagrada had like I've seen people get tattoos
- 54:45of or include on like a birthday cake or a wedding cake. Things like
- 54:52that are just like really special, and I think easily keep me motivated to
- 54:59try to make good games. So your last game then is another classic.
- 55:05This has been the theme of your games on this show, and this is
- 55:07cribbage. So why am I so intimidated by this game? Yeah? I
- 55:15don't know. It's funny. I don't know if it's it's abstract nature or
- 55:22what I mean. I feel like there's a question for you. Why why
- 55:25do you think it's so intimidating. Well, it's it's one of those games,
- 55:29isn't it that you imagine sort of that have been that's been played for
- 55:32hundreds of years, and it's gnarly old people sat around tables and if you
- 55:37play the wrong card, they will do that thing where they just look at
- 55:42you and tut and it destroys your soul, you know, Sure, Sure,
- 55:47I mean, yeah I was. I can attest to that only because,
- 55:52again, kind of playing back to the nostalgia trend, this was a
- 55:55game that I played religiously with my grandfather. My grandfather has now passed,
- 56:00but he lived in Australia and quite a distance from Canada, and every time
- 56:07he would come to visit us, he would usually stay at our house for
- 56:09like a month every year, and when he did, we basically spent a
- 56:15month of every day, you know, getting the kettle on playing a bunch
- 56:19of Crib hands, and if I screwed up, he definitely let me know.
- 56:24It was hardcore, but it also was just like this great battle.
- 56:30You know, for others, maybe it's chess or or you know, whatever
- 56:37it might bridge, but for me it was Crib. I just I love
- 56:40it. I think it's the kind of game that, even like posture wise,
- 56:45there's like a really great moment when you can play a game and just
- 56:50kind of like sit back and relax, but also be like leaning forward and
- 56:54engaged. And when those moments happened that it's all within the journey of a
- 56:59game that you can kind of talk and play, think hard and not think
- 57:05at all at times, then you're in like a really fun rhythm, and
- 57:10you know, I kind of equate it to like baseball. I'm a huge
- 57:15baseball fan, and I love going to a baseball game where at moments am
- 57:20I glued to the strategy, and at other times I can just lean back
- 57:23and have a beer and enjoy the sunshine. And I think Crib kind of
- 57:28does that in game form, in this little tiny box with a few pegs
- 57:35and a deca cards. And is this a popular game in Canada. I
- 57:40mean, you're probably right that it's probably an older demographic. Still, I
- 57:45would imagine it's pretty rare to find a lot of young people that are into
- 57:49it. But I have seen a bit of a resurgence. It's funny.
- 57:52I've seen even conventions more and more people talking about, oh, like,
- 57:57I'll bring my crib board and if you know, we have some downtime,
- 58:00maybe we'll play a quick game. And so I don't I don't know what
- 58:05that's attributed to, but it seems like it might be getting a little,
- 58:09a little pick up, a little a little more interest again, and so,
- 58:15how would you persuade someone to play this game? Yeah? I mean,
- 58:22so it's funny. I out of all of the games i'm there,
- 58:28all are usually better with more players, and this is the one game that
- 58:32is very two player centric. And I think my pitch or my my try
- 58:39at trying to get to persuade someone to play would be I want to spend
- 58:44quality time with just you and and let's do that with this game. And
- 58:50so I think it becomes just like a great chance to have some good chats
- 58:54and and just one on one time. So one more question. So,
- 59:00yeah, you're heading out to the cabin and you go around a corner and
- 59:04the back door the car flies open. Four the games fly down a ravine
- 59:08into a river, and a swept away to posterity. Which game do you
- 59:12hope is sitting on the backseat of the car? Oh? No, this
- 59:15is Oh, this is a nightmare. I already went through the emotional heartache
- 59:20of these five. Oh my goodness. Oh I was afraid of this question
- 59:27if it was coming or not. You know, Okay, the game designer
- 59:31in me, says l Grande, Because I could probably repurpose all the parts
- 59:37to make the other games. I think, Yeah, that's that's my instinct
- 59:40is grab the game that has the most component so that I can repurpose and
- 59:46design more games with it. Excellence. So if people want to get hold
- 59:51of you and they want to find out what's coming from you and all of
- 59:54that good stuff, how can they go about doing that? Yeah? I
- 59:58try to be on all the different kind of social platforms. You can find
- 1:00:00me on Facebook and Twitter and such. Usually it's at Daryl M. Andrews.
- 1:00:06It looks like Daryl Andrews and being my middle initial and yeah, please
- 1:00:12reach out, happy to chat, especially if you're a game designer. You
- 1:00:15know, I really try to encourage and support game designers. I know a
- 1:00:22little bit of the struggle and the journey, and you know, I think
- 1:00:25I really believe in a rising tide helps our boats. So it's a great
- 1:00:30way to support one another. And if you just like games, I mean
- 1:00:34reach out, let's chat, let's maybe even meet at a convention to play
- 1:00:37a game together. Excellent, Well, Daryl Andrews, thank you very much.
- 1:00:42Oh thanks for having me. You can support the show in many ways.
- 1:00:45You can tell your friends, you can talk about it on social media.
- 1:00:47You can talk about it in your own blog, podcast, or video.
- 1:00:51You can support it directly by going to Patreon dot com, forward slash
- 1:00:53five GFD for rolling donation, or for a one off donation hitting the PayPal
- 1:00:58link at the bottom of the website five Games for Doomsday dot com. It's
- 1:01:00these donations that keep the show going. Also, if you want to say
- 1:01:05something nice about the show, if you want to say something horrible about the
- 1:01:07show, you can contact me on Twitter at five Games for Doomsday or send
- 1:01:10me an email at five Games for Doomsday at gmail dot com. Also,
- 1:01:14if you want to join the discord, go to five Games for Doomsday dot
- 1:01:16com and follow the link there, and if I've managed to scream off from
- 1:01:21the rolling fandangos and the unbelievable amount of shit I accumulate, I'll see you
- 1:01:25in two weeks for another buy Games for Doomsday