Latest / Kentucky Tonight / K-12 Issues Before the Kentucky General Assembly
Transcript
- 0:01[♪♪]
- 0:11GOOD EVENING.
- 0:12WELCOME TO KENTUCKY TONIGHT.
- 0:13I'M RENEE SHAW.
- 0:14THANKS FOR JOINING US.
- 0:16OUR TOPIC TONIGHT: K-12 ISSUES
- 0:18BEFORE THE KENTUCKY GENERAL
- 0:18ASSEMBLY.
- 0:20LAWMAKERS FACE SEVERAL IMPORTANT
- 0:22ISSUES, AFFECTING KENTUCKY
- 0:24SCHOOLS, AS THE SESSION ENTERS
- 0:25ITS FINAL DAYS.
- 0:27WILL LAWMAKERS CHANGE KENTUCKY’S
- 0:29POLICY ON NON-TRADITIONAL
- 0:30INSTRUCTION, AFTER SOME KENTUCKY
- 0:32SCHOOL SYSTEMS USED UP THEIR NTI
- 0:33DAYS BECAUSE OF WINTER WEATHER?
- 0:38WHAT CAN BE DONE ABOUT
- 0:40LOW-PERFORMING SCHOOLS?
- 0:42THERE ARE CONCERNS ABOUT
- 0:43FUNDING.
- 0:44AND IS A REQUIRED MOMENT OF
- 0:45SILENCE IN SCHOOLS A GOOD IDEA?
- 0:47TO TALK ABOUT ALL THESE ISSUES,
- 0:48AND MORE, WE HAVE FOUR MEMBERS
- 0:49OF THE KENTUCKY GENERAL ASSEMBLY
- 0:51IN OUR LEXINGTON STUDIO:
- 0:53STATE SENATOR STEPHEN WEST, A
- 0:55REPUBLICAN FROM PARIS AND CHAIR
- 0:56OF THE SENATE EDUCATION
- 0:57COMMITTEE;
- 0:59STATE SENATOR REGINALD THOMAS, A
- 1:00DEMOCRAT FROM LEXINGTON, SENATE
- 1:02MINORITY CAUCUS CHAIR AND MEMBER
- 1:03OF THE SENATE EDUCATION
- 1:04COMMITTEE;
- 1:06STATE REPRESENTATIVE █SCOTT
- 1:08LEWIS, A REPUBLICAN FROM
- 1:09HARTFORD AND CHAIR OF THE HOUSE
- 1:10PRIMARY AND SECONDARY EDUCATION
- 1:12COMMITTEE;
- 1:13AND STATE REPRESENTATIVE TINA
- 1:14BOJANOWSKI, A DEMOCRAT FROM
- 1:16LOUISVILLE AND MEMBER OF THE
- 1:17HOUSE PRIMARY AND SECONDARY
- 1:18EDUCATION COMMITTEE.
- 1:21WE WANT TO HEAR FROM YOU.
- 1:23YOU CAN SEND YOUR QUESTIONS AND
- 1:24COMMENTS BY X — FORMERLY TWITTER
- 1:25-- AT PUB AFFAIRS KET.
- 1:28SEND AN EMAIL TO K-Y TONIGHT AT
- 1:30K-E-T DOT O-R-G.
- 1:32OR USE THE WEB FORM AT K-E-T DOT
- 1:33O-R-G SLASH K-Y TONIGHT.
- 1:36OR YOU CAN CALL 1-800-494-7605.
- 1:43WELCOME ALL OF OUR GUESTS.
- 1:45WE ARE THE SAND IS RUNNING OUT
- 1:47OF THE HOURGLASS, RIGHT?
- 1:49JUST THIS FULL WEEK HERE LEFT TO
- 1:51GO BEFORE THE 10-DAY VETO PERIOD
- 1:54A LOT TO GET ACCOMPLISHED AND
- 1:56TODAY Y'ALL IN THE SENATE WERE
- 1:58BUSY IN THE EDUCATION COMMITTEE
- 2:00IN PARTICULAR.
- 2:01WE'RE GOING TO DIGRESS FROM THE
- 2:04K-12 AND TALK ABOUT HOUSE BILL 4
- 2:06THAT DEALS WITH DIVERSITY,
- 2:08EQUITY AND INCLUSION, POLICIES
- 2:11PROGRAMS AND OFFICES AT COLLEGES
- 2:13AND UNIVERSITIES THAT WOULD DO
- 2:15AWAY WITH THAT.
- 2:16THERE WAS INTERESTING DISCUSSION
- 2:17IN COMMITTEE TODAY AND I WANT
- 2:19YOU, CHAIRMAN WEST TO TALK ABOUT
- 2:21THAT BILL.
- 2:22DID IT LEAVE THE COMMITTEE THE
- 2:23SAME WAY IT CAME IN?
- 2:25>> ABSOLUTELY, RENEE, THANKS FOR
- 2:28HAVING ME, HAVING US.
- 2:29HOUSE BILL 4 DID LEAVE THE
- 2:32COMMITTEE CLEAN TODAY.
- 2:36SENATOR KNEEL PROPOSED A
- 2:40COMMITTEE SUB DEFEATED IN THE
- 2:43COMMITTEE.
- 2:43IT WILL LEAVE CLEAN.
- 2:44IT'S IMPORTANT TO REALIZE THIS
- 2:45IS AFTER A COUPLE OF YEARS OF
- 2:48DISCUSSION ABOUT D.E.I.
- 2:50LAST YEAR, REPRESENTATIVE DECKER
- 2:53HAD THE BILL IN THE HOUSE AND
- 2:55SENATOR WILSON HAS A DIFFERENT
- 2:57BILL IN THE SENATE.
- 2:59AND IT WAS NOT AGREED TO AT THAT
- 3:01TIME.
- 3:02SHE WORKED HEAVILY OVER THE
- 3:04INTERIM ON THE TOPIC AND WE HAD
- 3:07MULTIPLE INTERIM COMMITTEE
- 3:09MEETINGS ON D.E.I.
- 3:10POST-SECONDARY D.E.I. TO DISCUSS
- 3:11IT.
- 3:13AND EVEN AS WE GOT INTO JANUARY
- 3:15THERE'S BEEN A LOT OF BACK AND
- 3:16FORTH ON THE TOPIC AND
- 3:18NEGOTIATIONS BACK AND FORTH
- 3:19BETWEEN THE UNIVERSITIES AND
- 3:21ENTITIES.
- 3:22AND WHAT YOU SAW TODAY IN
- 3:23COMMITTEE WAS THE PRODUCT OF
- 3:25THOSE EFFORTS OVER A COUPLE
- 3:27YEARS' TIME.
- 3:28>> Renee: ARE THE UNIVERSITIES
- 3:29PLEASED OR MAYBE PLEASE SECOND
- 3:31NOT THE RIGHT WORD BUT SATISFIED
- 3:33WITH WHAT LOOKS TO BE THE FINAL
- 3:35PRODUCT?
- 3:35>> I DON'T KNOW IF THEY WILL BE
- 3:39100% SATISFIED I CAN DEFINITELY
- 3:42SAY THEY GOT A LOT OF WHAT THEY
- 3:43WANTED IN THE WORK PRODUCT.
- 3:45WE MET WITH THEM IN OUR OFFICES
- 3:48AND THEY AS WE GOT INTO SESSION,
- 3:51SHE MADE HER INITIAL BILL
- 3:53REQUEST AND PROPOSAL AND THEY
- 3:56MADE IT THROUGH THE HALLWAYS.
- 3:58AND GAVE US THEIR REQUESTED
- 4:00CHANGES.
- 4:00AND I DO BELIEVE WE MADE SEVERAL
- 4:03CONCESSIONS AND CHANGES IN THE
- 4:04BILL.
- 4:05I SAY WE, THE REPUBLICAN CAUCUS
- 4:08MAJORITY.
- 4:09SO, YEAH, DID THEY GET ALL THEY
- 4:12WANTED?
- 4:13NO.
- 4:13BUT THEY GOT QUITE A BIT.
- 4:16>> Renee: SENATOR THOMAS YOU HAD
- 4:18SHARP COMMENTARY DURING THE VOTE
- 4:21EXPLANATION WHEN THE VOTE WAS
- 4:22TAKEN AND BEFORE.
- 4:23YOUR OPPOSITION TO THIS MEASURE,
- 4:26IF YOU WANT TO TALK ABOUT
- 4:28SENATOR NEAL'S WHAT HE WAS
- 4:30PROPOSING IN HIS SERIES OF
- 4:31AMENDMENTS OR COMMITTEE
- 4:33SUBSTITUTE AND WHY THAT WAS NOT
- 4:35SUCCESSFUL.
- 4:35>> WELL, SENATOR NEAL'S LAID OUT
- 4:38SEVERAL AMENDMENTS HE THOUGHT
- 4:40MADE A BAD BILL AND IT IS A BAD
- 4:42BILL, A LITTLE BIT PALATABLE.
- 4:48A LITTLE BIT BETTER IN TERMS OF
- 4:50DEALING WITH UNFORESEEN
- 4:51CONSEQUENCES.
- 4:52THE FACT THAT A LOT OF THE
- 4:53LANGUAGE IF YOU READ IT
- 4:57LITERALLY, CAN RESULT IN EXTREME
- 5:01CIRCUMSTANCES, THINGS THAT WERE
- 5:03NOT ANTICIPATED.
- 5:04THINGS THAT ARE VERY HARMFUL.
- 5:06I WOULD LIKE TO GO BACK A SECOND
- 5:07TO TALKING ABOUT UNIVERSITIES.
- 5:09IT'S VERY TELLING IN THIS PIECE
- 5:11OF LEGISLATION THAT NONE NOT ONE
- 5:14OF OUR EIGHT STATE UNIVERSITIES,
- 5:16RENEE, TESTIFIED IN SUPPORT OF
- 5:18THIS BILL.
- 5:18THAT TELLS YOU A LOT ABOUT HOW
- 5:22DYSFUNCTIONAL THIS BILL IS FOR
- 5:24STATE UNIVERSITIES WHO PRIDE
- 5:25THEMSELVES ON AND DEMAND BECAUSE
- 5:27OF WHAT THEY ARE IS HIGHER
- 5:29EDUCATIONAL INSTITUTIONS HAVING
- 5:33INPUT AND THOUGHT AND
- 5:35CONSIDERATION FROM A VARIETY OF
- 5:37GROUPS.
- 5:38WOMEN, PEOPLE OF DIFFERENT
- 5:40RACES, BLACKS, BROWNS, PEOPLE
- 5:43DIFFERENT NATIONAL ORIGINS.
- 5:46RELIGIONS, THE JEWISH COMMUNITY,
- 5:48THE MUSLIM COMMUNITY THE
- 5:49CHRISTIAN COMMUNITY.
- 5:50ALL THAT IS GONE NOW.
- 5:53>> Renee: DID THEY TESTIFY
- 5:54AGAINST THE BILL?
- 5:54>> THEY DIDN'T TESTIFY AGAINST
- 5:56THE BILL BUT THEY DIDN'T TESTIFY
- 5:57FOR IT, EITHER.
- 5:59THEY WERE SILENT AND WE
- 6:00UNDERSTAND WHY THEY WERE SILENT.
- 6:04BECAUSE THEY ARE STATE
- 6:05UNIVERSITIES AND APPROPRIATION
- 6:07DEPENDS ON STATE MONEY LET'S
- 6:08CALL IT LIKE WE SEE IT.
- 6:10AND IT'S JUST SAD, RENEE, THAT A
- 6:13STATE AS DIVERSE AS KENTUCKY IS,
- 6:17AS AGAIN HISTORICALLY INCLUSIVE
- 6:20IN HOW WE'VE APPROACHED
- 6:22LEGISLATION IN THE PAST TOOK A
- 6:24MAJOR STEP BACKWARD TODAY BY THE
- 6:27SENATE VOTING THIS BILL OUT OF
- 6:30COMMITTEE.
- 6:31>> Renee: THERE ARE 16 FLOOR
- 6:32AMENDMENTS FILED BY THE
- 6:34DEMOCRATIC LEADER IN THE SENATE
- 6:35AND PERHAPS THAT IS DUPLICATIVE
- 6:37WHAT HE ATTEMPTED IN COMMITTEE
- 6:39BUT THERE ARE 16 AMENDMENTS.
- 6:41WILL THIS BILL BE ACTED ON
- 6:44TOMORROW OR THIS WEEK BEFORE YOU
- 6:46TAKE THAT 10-DAY VETO PERIOD?
- 6:48>> AS OF RIGHT NOW, I CAN'T
- 6:51ANSWER THAT QUESTION.
- 6:52IT'S BEEN A BUSY DAY AND WE JUST
- 6:55GOT OUT OF COMMITTEE A LITTLE
- 6:56BIT AGO.
- 6:57I DO NOT HAVE AN ANSWER TO THAT
- 6:58QUESTION FOR YOU TONIGHT.
- 7:01>> Renee: WOULD THE INTENT BE TO
- 7:02MAKE SURE IT'S VETO PROOF AND
- 7:04NOT ACT ON IT WHEN YOU COME BACK
- 7:06AFTER THE 10-DAY VETO PERIOD
- 7:08FROM THE GOVERNOR WHERE IF YOU
- 7:10ACT ON IT THEN HE CAN VETO IT.
- 7:12>> ABSOLUTELY 100% FOR SURE.
- 7:16WE INTEND TO ACT ON IT SOON, I
- 7:19BELIEVE THAT IS A LEADERSHIP
- 7:21DECISION.
- 7:21>> Renee: SURE.
- 7:22>> BUT I DON'T HAVE AN ANSWER
- 7:24FOR YOU RIGHT NOW.
- 7:26>> Renee: AND ALL THE AMENDMENTS
- 7:27ARE ON-LINE IF YOU WOULD LIKE TO
- 7:29SEE THOSE AT LEGISLATURE.KY.GOV.
- 7:35I WANT TO ASK THE HOUSE MEMBERS
- 7:38ON THIS BILL YOU ACTED ON IT
- 7:39LAST WEEK.
- 7:40>> IT WAS LAST WEEK.
- 7:42>> Renee: I WILL GO TO YOU FIRST
- 7:46REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI.
- 7:47>> I THINK HB4 IS AN ATTACK ON
- 7:50THE RECRUITMENT AND RETENTION OF
- 7:53STUDENTS IN KENTUCKY'S PUBLIC
- 7:54UNIVERSITIES.
- 7:55IT'S GOING TO CREATE A CHILLING
- 7:58EFFECT WHEREBY IF SOMETHING IS
- 8:00NOT NECESSARILY ALLOWED UNDER
- 8:02LAW, PEOPLE ARE GOING TO BACK
- 8:04UP.
- 8:04THERE WAS A DISCUSSION TODAY IN
- 8:06YOUR COMMITTEE ABOUT --
- 8:09I CAN'T REMEMBER --
- 8:11WOMEN IN SOMETHING.
- 8:12AND THE UNIVERSITY HAS PULLED
- 8:14BACK WOMEN IN ARTS I BELIEVE IT
- 8:16WAS.
- 8:16AND THE UNIVERSITY PULLED BACK
- 8:18UNDER CONCERNS THAT WOULD BE
- 8:20CONSIDERED NOT ALLOWED.
- 8:22I THINK ONE CLARIFICATION I'D
- 8:24LIKE TO MAKE WHEN TALKING ABOUT
- 8:28THE BILL ON THE FLOOR
- 8:29REPRESENTATIVE DECKER MENTIONED
- 8:32SEVERAL TIMES OR INFERRED THAT
- 8:35DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND INCLUSION
- 8:36PROGRAMMING HAD A NEGATIVE
- 8:39IMPACT ON MINORITY STUDENT
- 8:40ENROLLMENT.
- 8:41AND I DID RESEARCH AND THERE ARE
- 8:43QUITE A FEW THINGS THAT ARE
- 8:45IMPACTING ENROLLMENT.
- 8:46FEWER COLLEGE-AGED STUDENTS
- 8:48BECAUSE OF THE DECLINE IN THE
- 8:49BIRTH RATE FROM THE 2008
- 8:51RECESSION.
- 8:52STRONGER LABOR MARKET PEOPLE ARE
- 8:54MORE LIKELY TO GO TO WORK THAN
- 8:57SCHOOL.
- 8:58NOT ENOUGH SUPPORT FOR LOW
- 9:00INCOME AND FIRST GENERATION THE
- 9:01COSTS OF HIGHER-ED AND THE
- 9:03IMPACT OF POLITICAL INTERFERENCE
- 9:06CREATING AN UNWELCOMING
- 9:07ENVIRONMENT FOR STUDENTS OF
- 9:09COLOR.
- 9:10WE NEED TO DO FORT D THAT WE CAN
- 9:12TO ENSURE ALL OF OUR STUDENTS
- 9:14ARE SUCCESSFUL.
- 9:15AND I DON'T THINK THIS IS THE
- 9:16WAY TO GO.
- 9:18>> Renee: CHAIRMAN LEWIS WELCOME
- 9:19THIS IS YOUR FIRST TIME ON AND
- 9:21YOU ARE A NEWLY MINTED CHAIRMAN
- 9:24OF THE PRIMARY AND SECONDARY
- 9:25EDUCATION COMMITTEE.
- 9:26YOU DID HAVE THE OPPORTUNITY TO
- 9:27VOTE ON HOUSE BILL 4 AND I WILL
- 9:30DEFER TO YOU FOR FURTHER REMARKS
- 9:32ABOUT IT.
- 9:32>> I VOTED FOR THE BILL.
- 9:36UNLIKE ANY BILL IS IT A PERFECT
- 9:38BILL?
- 9:39PROBABLY NOT.
- 9:39WE MAYBE COMING BACK NEXT
- 9:42SESSION AS WE DO TO LOOK AT IT
- 9:44AGAIN AND SEE IF WE CAN IMPROVE
- 9:46IT.
- 9:46IT'S NOT A PERFECT BILL.
- 9:49BUT IT WAS ENOUGH THAT I COULD
- 9:51VOTE YES.
- 9:53>> Renee: DID IT GO FAR ENOUGH?
- 9:54>> YES, I THINK IT DID.
- 9:56I THINK IT WENT FAR ENOUGH.
- 9:58AND AGAIN IT'S JUST A TOUCHY
- 10:00SUBJECT.
- 10:01YOU GOT PEOPLE ON THIS SIDE AND
- 10:03PEOPLE ON THIS SIDE AND
- 10:05HOPEFULLY WE'VE MET ENOUGH IN
- 10:06THE MIDDLE AND LIKE CHAIR WEST
- 10:10SAID, THE UNIVERSITIES
- 10:13RECOMMENDED TO US SEVERAL THINGS
- 10:15THAT WERE IN THE BILL.
- 10:16THEY DID HAVE INPUT IN IT.
- 10:18>> Renee: WHEN IT CAME TO
- 10:19CONCERN FROM MEMBERS OF THE
- 10:21VETERAN COMMUNITY AND OTHERS,
- 10:24ARE THEY HELD HARMLESS IN THIS
- 10:27LEGISLATION?
- 10:27>> I BELIEVE SO.
- 10:30AND I BELIEVE AS WITH ANY LARGE
- 10:32PIECE OF LEGISLATION, THIS IS A
- 10:35BIG DEAL.
- 10:36THIS IS A REALLY LARGE BITE AT
- 10:40THE APPLE.
- 10:42DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND INCLUSION
- 10:44IS A HARD THING TO REGULATE AND
- 10:46GET YOUR HANDS AROUND.
- 10:47SO I THINK THE VETERANS WILL BE
- 10:51HELD HARM BUILDING BUT THE
- 10:53UNIVERSITIES WILL NEED TIME TO
- 10:54REACT AND ADJUST POLICIES AND
- 10:56THINGS OF THAT NATURE.
- 10:57IN THE BILL, ONE KEY CHANGE THAT
- 10:59WAS MADE IN THE BILL IS WHERE WE
- 11:01TAKE AWAY THE PRIVATE RIGHT OF
- 11:04ACTION.
- 11:04>> Renee: WHICH MEANS IN
- 11:05LAYMAN'S TERMS?
- 11:06>> THAT MEANS IN THE ORIGINAL
- 11:09VERSION THE BILL HAD IN IT THE
- 11:12RIGHT OF A PRIVATE INDIVIDUAL TO
- 11:13SUE THE UNIVERSITY IF THE
- 11:18ESSENCE OF THE BILL WASN'T MET.
- 11:20THE UNIVERSITIES CAME TO US TO
- 11:22REMOVE THAT.
- 11:22THAT WAS REMOVED.
- 11:24AND NOW ENFORCEMENT IS REALLY
- 11:26CARRIED OUT BY THE ATTORNEY
- 11:28GENERAL THROUGH A WRIT PROCESS.
- 11:31AND SO IN THIS CASE, THE
- 11:33ATTORNEY GENERAL WOULD BE THE
- 11:36PROSECUTOR.
- 11:37AND LIKE ANY OTHER PROSECUTOR
- 11:39THEY HAVE SOME LEVEL OF
- 11:41DISCRETION.
- 11:41AND SO I DON'T SEE OUR CURRENT
- 11:43ATTORNEY GENERAL IF THIS BILL
- 11:45WERE TO BE PASSED ALL THE WAY, I
- 11:47DON'T SEE THEM GOING AFTER
- 11:49VETERANS IN ANYWAY.
- 11:51ANOTHER KEY POINT THERE IS A LOT
- 11:52OF CARVE OUTS IN THE BILL.
- 11:56ESPECIALLY EXISTING FEDERAL LAWS
- 11:58ESPECIALLY THOSE PERTAINING TO
- 12:00VETERANS AFFAIRS.
- 12:01>> Renee: IS IT FAIR SENATOR
- 12:03THOMAS TO SAY THE UNIVERSITY FOR
- 12:06SOME THE UNIVERSITY OF KENTUCKY
- 12:08DIALED BACK THE D.E.I. EFFORTS
- 12:09AND POLICIES AND OFFICES AND
- 12:11PROGRAMS IN ANTICIPATION OF THIS
- 12:13LEGISLATION?
- 12:13>> I THINK THAT'S FAIR TO SAY
- 12:15THAT.
- 12:17BUT, RENEE, I DO WANT TO GO BACK
- 12:19TO ONE POINT MADE BY
- 12:21REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI.
- 12:22I MENTIONED TODAY WAS BEING
- 12:29DEBATED WE HAVE MET WITH FIVE
- 12:32STATE UNIVERSITY PRESIDENTS.
- 12:34PRESIDENT CAP LAWSUIT TOW BEING
- 12:36ONE.
- 12:37CAPILOUTO.
- 12:39OF ALL OF THEM INDICATED,
- 12:41REPRESENT ANY, THAT THEY HAD
- 12:43SEEN A DECLINE IN STUDENT
- 12:45ENROLLMENT.
- 12:46THE BRACK STUDENT ENROLLMENT
- 12:48THIS YEAR AFTER THE SUPREME
- 12:50COURT DECISION IN THE HARVARD
- 12:52CASE IN 2023.
- 12:54>> Renee: ON RACE BASED
- 12:55ADMISSIONS.
- 12:55>> THEY'VE SEEN A DECLINE AND I
- 12:58SUSPECT NOW AS REPRESENTATIVE
- 13:01BOJANOWSKI SO APTLY POINTED OUT
- 13:03BECAUSE OF THE POLITICAL
- 13:05INTERFERENCE NOW WITH HOUSE BILL
- 13:064 AND THE FEELING AND ATTITUDE
- 13:11THAT BLACKS AREN'T WELCOME AND
- 13:13WOMEN AREN'T WELCOME IN COLLEGE
- 13:16EDUCATION YOU ARE GOING TO
- 13:18CONTINUE TO SEE A CONTINUOUS
- 13:21DECLINE IN BLACKEN ROLL.
- 13:22IN OUR STATE UNIVERSITIES.
- 13:25>> Renee: JUST BECAUSE OF THE
- 13:26POLICY?
- 13:26>> JUST BECAUSE OF THE POLICY.
- 13:29THE POLICY IS NOT WELCOMING TO
- 13:32PEOPLE OF DIFFERENT RACES,
- 13:33PEOPLE DIFFERENT RELIGIONS,
- 13:35WOMEN: AND I POINTED OUT TODAY
- 13:36THAT THE BIGGEST WINNER SINCE WE
- 13:40STARTED DIVERSITY, EQUITY AND
- 13:42INCLUSION HAS BEEN WOMEN.
- 13:43WOMEN HAVE MADE SIGNIFICANT
- 13:45GAINS IN TERMS OF ENROLLMENT AND
- 13:48HIRING HIGHER EDUCATION BECAUSE
- 13:50OF THE DIVERSITY EQUITY AND
- 13:52INCLUSION.
- 13:52>> Renee: YOU THINK THOSE GAINS
- 13:53WILL BE REVERSED?
- 13:55>> I THINK YOU WILL START SEEING
- 13:57A SLIDE.
- 13:58>> Renee: AND THEY WILL GO INTO
- 13:59THE WORKFORCE AND SKIP HIGHER
- 14:01EDUCATION EXPERIENCE ALTOGETHER?
- 14:02>> I PREDICT, RENEE, OVER THE
- 14:06NEXT SEVERAL YEARS AS LONG AS
- 14:07THIS POLICY IS IN PLACE YOU WILL
- 14:09START SEEING A SIGNIFICANT
- 14:12DECLINE IN ENROLLMENT, PUBLIC
- 14:17UNIVERSITIES AND A DECLINE IN
- 14:18WOMEN ENROLLMENT.
- 14:20>> Renee: FURTHER COMMENT ON
- 14:21THIS BEFORE WE GET TO K-12
- 14:23ISSUES?
- 14:24GO AHEAD.
- 14:25>> QUICK COMMENT IT'S IMPORTANT
- 14:27TO NOTE I BELIEVE THE POOL OF
- 14:29STUDENTS ATTENDING
- 14:31POST-SECONDARY IS DECLINING
- 14:32SOME.
- 14:33SO YOU DO HAVE THAT IN THE
- 14:35BACKGROUND.
- 14:36AND IT'S ALSO VERY IMPORTANT TO
- 14:37POINT OUT ALL THE CURRENT
- 14:39FEDERAL PROTECTIONS REGARDING
- 14:42ENROLLMENT, YOU CANNOT BE
- 14:44DISCRIMINATED AGAINST ON THE
- 14:45BASIS OF RACE, ETHNICITY ALL
- 14:48THOSE STAY IN PLACE.
- 14:49NOTHING'S CHANGED.
- 14:50WHEN YOU ARE TALKING ABOUT
- 14:52ENROLLMENT THERE SHOULD BE
- 14:53NOTHING OUT THERE TO PREVENTED
- 14:54ANY MINORITY FROM ATTENDING
- 14:57COLLEGE.
- 14:57>> Renee: BUT FOR SOME WHO MAY
- 14:58HAVE ENJOYED SCHOLARSHIPS THAT
- 15:00WERE MINORITY DRIVEN NOT JUST
- 15:02FIRST GENERATION COLLEGE STUDENT
- 15:05THAT WERE RACE OR GENDER BASED.
- 15:08THOSE NO LONGER WOULD BE
- 15:10ALLOWED, IS THAT CORRECT?
- 15:11>> THAT'S CORRECT.
- 15:13BUT THERE IS A A WAY TO GET
- 15:15AROUND THAT.
- 15:17THE WAY THOSE WOULD WORK IS IN
- 15:19MY OPINION, THOSE WOULD STILL BE
- 15:23AVAILABLE, BUT IF THE STUDENT
- 15:24WANTED THE SCHOLARSHIP IT WOULD
- 15:26HAVE TO BE ADMINISTERED BY A
- 15:28DIFFERENT ENTITY.
- 15:30THE ENDOWMENT IF THE MONEY WENT
- 15:32TO THE ENDOWMENT, U.K., YOU HAVE
- 15:35THE U.K. ENDOWMENT IF THEY
- 15:38ADMINISTERED THAT SCHOLARSHIP OR
- 15:39THE PRIVATE ENTITY WHO PRODUCED
- 15:41THE SCHOLARSHIP GAVE IT DIRECTLY
- 15:43TO THE STUDENT THAT WOULD BE A
- 15:45WAY TO GET THEIR MONEY IT WOULD
- 15:47HAVE TO FLOW THROUGH A DIFFERENT
- 15:50SOURCE.
- 15:50>> AGAIN, SENATOR WEST IS A
- 15:52LAWYER IF YOU READ THE LANGUAGE
- 15:55AFFILIATED ENTITY WITH THE
- 15:56UNIVERSITY, THEN YOU ALSO
- 15:59PROHIBITED FROM DOING --
- 16:00SUBJECT TO THE PROHIBITIONS THE
- 16:02UNIVERSITIES ARE.
- 16:03AND A FOUNDATION UNDER STATUTE
- 16:06WOULD BE AN AFFILIATED ENTITY.
- 16:08>> Renee: IF YOU HAD A PRIVATE
- 16:10CITIZEN A WOMAN IN
- 16:13UNDERREPRESENTED INDUSTRY LIKE
- 16:15HVAC AND LET'S USE OUR COMMUNITY
- 16:17COLLEGES AND SHE HAD PUT A
- 16:19SCHOLARSHIP TO GET MORE WOMEN
- 16:21INTO THAT INDUSTRY, WOULD THAT
- 16:23BE PROHIBITED?
- 16:24AND SHE OFFERED A SCHOLARSHIP IN
- 16:26HER NAME FOR THAT CAUSE?
- 16:27>> SO LONG AS SHE GAVE THE
- 16:29MONEY, THE ANSWER IS YES.
- 16:30BUT THAT IS NOT TYPICALLY HOW IT
- 16:33WORKS.
- 16:33GENERALLY IT WORKS IS THAT THE
- 16:36DONOR WILL GIVE THE MONEY TO THE
- 16:37UNIVERSITY AND SET THE
- 16:40RESTRICTIONS AND PROVISIONS HOW
- 16:41THAT SCHOLARSHIP IS TO BE DOLLED
- 16:44OUT.
- 16:46YOU ARE CORRECT, IF A PRIVATE
- 16:47INDIVIDUAL WANTS TO PRIVATELY
- 16:49DONATE THE MONEY YES THEY CAN DO
- 16:52SO.
- 16:52>> Renee: MOST OF THE TIMES YOU
- 16:53ARE SAYING THEY GO THROUGH THE
- 16:55UNIVERSITY.
- 16:55>> AND THE UNIVERSITY DISPERSES
- 16:58THOSE FUNDS.
- 17:00>> Renee: OFTENTIMES THESE
- 17:01THINGS DO HAVE OTHER ITERATIONS
- 17:02AND AMENDMENTS THAT COME AND
- 17:04SUBSEQUENT YEARS.
- 17:05WE'LL KEEP OUR EYE ON IT.
- 17:07BUT THIS BILL SEEMS TO BE MOVING
- 17:09FORWARD.
- 17:10K-12 LEGISLATION.
- 17:11YOU ALSO HAD IN YOUR COMMITTEE
- 17:14TODAY CHAIRMAN WEST, HOUSE BILL
- 17:17240 BY REPRESENTATIVE TRUITT
- 17:19THAT WOULD NOW IT STARTED OFF IF
- 17:21A KID WAS NOT READY IN
- 17:23KINDERGARTEN THEY WERE IN
- 17:23KINDERGARTEN AND THEY DID NOT
- 17:24PASS A CERTAIN TEST OR PERFORM
- 17:26WELL ENOUGH TO ADVANCE TO THE
- 17:28FIRST GRADE THEY WOULD BE HELD
- 17:30BACK BUT THERE WAS A CHANGE IN
- 17:31THE BILL TODAY, CORRECT?
- 17:33>> YES, THERE WAS A LAST-MINUTE
- 17:34CHANGE.
- 17:35WE ACTUALLY ASKED FOR THE CHANGE
- 17:36IN THE SENATE.
- 17:39THE HOUSE GRACIOUSLY AGREED.
- 17:43IT CHANGED THE MAY THE MAY IN
- 17:49KINDERGARTEN AND IT ADDED FIRST
- 17:51GRADE.
- 17:52AND SO --
- 17:53>> Renee: IS THAT A SHALL IN
- 17:57FIRST BUT A MAY IN KINDERGARTEN.
- 17:58WHAT IS THE RATIONAL FOR THAT?
- 18:00>> WE FELT AND THERE'S DEBATE
- 18:03OVER THIS, BUT AFTER DISCUSSION
- 18:05WITH THE HOUSE, CO-CHAIR LEWIS
- 18:08AND REPRESENTATIVE TRUITT, THEY
- 18:11ARE FURTHER ALONG IN FIRST
- 18:13GRADE.
- 18:14THERE'S MORE ABILITY TO SEE
- 18:16THEIR PROGRESS THROUGH TESTING
- 18:20AND WHATNOT.
- 18:20SO YOU CAN BETTER YOU KNOW AT
- 18:23THAT POINT BETTER WHERE THEY
- 18:24ARE.
- 18:25IN KINDERGARTEN, YOU ARE DOING A
- 18:26LOT MORE OF BASIC INSTRUCTION.
- 18:31WHERE THE BATHROOM IS AND HOW TO
- 18:33INTERACT WITH OTHER KIDS.
- 18:35SO IT WAS AN EFFORT TO GIVE A
- 18:37LITTLE BIT MORE ABILITY FOR THE
- 18:39TEACHER AND THE PRINCIPAL TO
- 18:40MAKE THAT DECISION.
- 18:43AND GIVE THEM ANOTHER YEAR.
- 18:45>> Renee: CHAIRMAN LEWIS DO YOU
- 18:46AGREE?
- 18:46>> I DO AND WORKED WITH
- 18:49REPRESENTATIVE TRUITT.
- 18:50AND IT STARTED OUT KINDERGARTEN
- 18:52AND ONE OF THE REASONS WAS 54%
- 18:54OF THE KIDS COMING TO US ARE NOT
- 18:56READY.
- 18:57A LOT HAVE NOT BEEN IN PRESCHOOL
- 18:59AND SO FORTH.
- 19:01AND THE WHOLE POINT IS PUT THE
- 19:02FOCUS WHERE WE JUST QUIT PASSING
- 19:06KIDS ALONG THAT AREN'T READY OR
- 19:08AREN'T READING AND WE MOVE THEM
- 19:10ALONG.
- 19:11THE KEY POINT THERE IS THIRD
- 19:12GRADE.
- 19:12WE HAVE TO GET THE KIDS ON
- 19:16READING LEVEL AT THIRD GRADE AND
- 19:17THIS IS A STEP IN THE RIGHT
- 19:19DIRECTION.
- 19:20A LOT OF STATES ARE HOLDING KIDS
- 19:22BACK IN THIRD GRADE.
- 19:23AND I THINK THAT IS TOO LATE.
- 19:25IF THEY ARE STRUGGLING IN
- 19:27KINDERGARTEN, THEY CAN HOLD THEM
- 19:28BACK THERE BUT THEY CAN'T HOLD
- 19:30THEM TWICE.
- 19:31IF THEY HELD THEM BACK IN
- 19:33KINDERGARTEN THEY CAN'T HOLD
- 19:34THEM IN THE FIRST GRADE.
- 19:36AND RESEARCH SHOWS IT DOESN'T DO
- 19:38VERY WELL IN THE LONG-RUN.
- 19:40SO I THINK THE MORE FOCUS WE CAN
- 19:42PUT ON THE K-3 THE BETTER OFF WE
- 19:45ARE THAT HAS BEEN A LOT OF OUR
- 19:47EMPHASIS THIS TIME IS ON BILLS
- 19:49FOR EARLY ED.
- 19:50>> Renee: SO OUR VIEWERS
- 19:51UNDERSTAND WHO MAKES THE
- 19:53DECISION ON HOLDING THE CHILD
- 19:54BACK?
- 19:54>> WELL, IT WOULD BE THE
- 19:57TEACHER, ADMINISTRATOR,
- 19:58CONVERSATION WITH THE PARENTS
- 20:00AND ULTIMATELY THE PERFORMANCE
- 20:02IF THEY HAVE THE BASIC SKILLS
- 20:04IT'S NOT JUST ONE TEST THAT
- 20:06WOULD HOLD THEM BACK.
- 20:07THE ASSESSMENTS THEY GIVE ALL
- 20:10YEAR LONG.
- 20:10IT IS A CUMULATION OF ALL THAT
- 20:12TOGETHER IN A YEAR AND NOT JUST
- 20:14BASED ON ONE TEST.
- 20:15>> Renee: IF PARENTS BALKED AT
- 20:18THAT AND RESISTED THAT DO THEY
- 20:20HAVE A RECOURSE TO ADVANCE THEIR
- 20:23CHILD?
- 20:23>> THEY WOULD NOT IF IT IS THE
- 20:26FIRST GRADE BECAUSE IT SAYS
- 20:27SHALL.
- 20:28AND PART OF THE BILL IS THAT IN
- 20:32TIMES IN DISTRICTS I WAS FORMER
- 20:34SUPERINTENDENT 13 YEARS AND I
- 20:35KNOW THE PUSHBACK.
- 20:36WE WOULD HAVE A KID THAT WASN'T
- 20:38READY AND WE'RE SAYING OUR BEST
- 20:41ADVICE WOULD BE TO HOLD HIM
- 20:42BACK.
- 20:43AND THEY DIDN'T LIKE THAT AND
- 20:46OUR PRINCIPAL AND TEACHER MOVED
- 20:47THEM ON.
- 20:49AT THIS POINT IT IS A STATE
- 20:50REQUIREMENT AND WE HAVE FOR THE
- 20:52BENEFIT OF YOUR KID WE HAVE TO
- 20:54HAVE YOUR CHILD READING ON GRADE
- 20:57LEVEL BY THIRD GRADE.
- 20:58IT IS A WIN FOR THE SCHOOLS TOO,
- 21:00AND WE HOPE IT IS.
- 21:02BUT WE HAVE TO HAVE HIGH
- 21:03EXPECTATIONS IF WE'RE GOING TO
- 21:05GET HIGH RESULTS WE HAVE TO HAVE
- 21:07HIGH EXPECTATIONS AND I BELIEVE
- 21:09AGAIN THIS MAYBE IS A PART OF
- 21:10IT.
- 21:12THE READING BILL OF 22, WAS
- 21:14ANOTHER GOOD STEP WE'RE SEEING
- 21:16GOOD RESULTS.
- 21:17I DON'T KNOW IF YOU ARE AWARE
- 21:18OUR SCORES THAT COME OUT THE
- 21:20TEST THAT EVERYBODY IN THE
- 21:21COUNTRY GIVES WHOOSH EIGHTH IN
- 21:23FOURTH GRADE READING.
- 21:25SO YEAH, THE PROFICIENCY IS NOT
- 21:27WHERE WE'D LIKE IT TO BE BUT
- 21:29WHEN YOU COMPARE US IN THE
- 21:31UNITED STATES WE ARE EIGHTH.
- 21:32I THINK THAT ALL THE WORK THAT
- 21:34WE'RE DOING THERE WILL PAY OFF
- 21:37LATER.
- 21:37>> Renee: I WANT TO GO TO YOU
- 21:39REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI THIS
- 21:42WAS DIFFERENT THAN WHEN YOU
- 21:43VOTED ON IT.
- 21:44>> THIS IS THE FIRST I'VE HEARD
- 21:47OF THE CHANGE.
- 21:48I AM A SPECIAL EDUCATION
- 21:50TEACHER.
- 21:50AND IF WE'VE GOT KIDS GETTING
- 21:52THE FOUNDATIONAL SKILLS WHEN
- 21:54THEY ARE VERY YOUNG THEN MANY
- 21:56CHILDREN MAY NOT END UP NEEDING
- 21:58SPECIAL EDUCATION SERVICES.
- 22:00SO IT'S VERY CONCERNING WHEN
- 22:02KIDS MOVE ON TO GRADE TO GRADE
- 22:04TO GRADE WITHOUT BEING READY.
- 22:06I THINK ALSO WHAT HAPPENS THAT I
- 22:09SEE IS KIDS WHO ARE MORE
- 22:11PRIVILEGED ARE MORE LIKELY TO
- 22:13SPEND ANOTHER YEAR IN PRESCHOOL.
- 22:14THERE'S PROGRAMS CALLED JUNIOR
- 22:17KINDERGARTEN.
- 22:17AND KIDS WHO ARE MAYBE MORE AT
- 22:19RISK ARE MORE LIKELY TO REGISTER
- 22:21THE BEGINNING OF THE YEAR.
- 22:22SO THERE IS A BIG DIFFERENCE
- 22:24BETWEEN A FIVE-YEAR-OLD I HAVE A
- 22:26STUDENT RIGHT NOW WHO DOESN'T
- 22:28TURN SIX UNTIL JUNE.
- 22:29A FIVE-YEAR-OLD ALL YEAR OF
- 22:31KINDERGARTEN AND A CHILD WHO IS
- 22:33SIX.
- 22:33I WILL HAVE TO REFLECT A LITTLE
- 22:35BIT ON THE FIRST GRADE PART WHAT
- 22:38I'M GRATEFUL I STRONGLY DISAGREE
- 22:40WITH RETENTION IN THIRD GRADE.
- 22:42OR FURTHER.
- 22:44THE RESEARCH REALLY INDICATES
- 22:45THAT THERE IS MORE OF A
- 22:47LIKELIHOOD OF DROPPING OUT OF
- 22:49SCHOOL.
- 22:50BUT IF WE GET IT WHEN THE CHILD
- 22:52IS YOUNG AND THERE'S NOT THAT
- 22:56SOCIAL PRESSURE, BECAUSE THEN
- 22:57YOU'VE GOT A PEER GROUP AND
- 22:58MOVING ON WITH THE GROUP OR NOT.
- 23:02I THINK IT WILL BE A GOOD THING.
- 23:05>> Renee: SENATOR THOMAS?
- 23:06>> WELL, I DON'T WANT TO BELABOR
- 23:09THIS TOO LONG.
- 23:10I'M STRONGLY IN SUPPORT OF THE
- 23:12BILL BECAUSE I ACTUALLY LIVED
- 23:13THE BILL.
- 23:15MY WIFE AND I HAD THREE
- 23:17CHILDREN.
- 23:19MY WIFE AT THAT TIME WHO WAS A
- 23:21KT APPOINTMENT BY THE WAY OUR
- 23:24YOUNGEST CHILD HAD DYSLEXIA.
- 23:26AND BY THE TIME HE GOT INTO
- 23:28THIRD GRADE HE COULD NOT READ ON
- 23:30GRADE LEVEL WE HAD TO MAKE THE
- 23:32TOUGH DECISION WHAT TO DO.
- 23:33WE MADE THE RIGHT DECISION TO
- 23:37KEEP HIS NAME WAS PHILLIP IN
- 23:39SCHOOL ANOTHER YEAR AND I'M
- 23:40PROUD TO SAY HE IS A COLLEGE
- 23:42GRADUATE FROM U.K.
- 23:43AND DOING VERY WELL.
- 23:45VERY WELL IN WASHINGTON D.C.
- 23:48WORKING FOR MAYOR LINDA BOWSER.
- 23:52I AM A STRONG SUPPORTER OF THIS
- 23:54BILL BECAUSE I KNOW IT WORKS.
- 23:56>> Renee: THERE SEEMS TO BE
- 23:57AGREEMENT.
- 23:58LOOK HOW THAT WORKS,
- 23:59BIPARTISANSHIP ON FULL DISPLAY.
- 24:01LET'S SEE IF WE GET THERE ON
- 24:03THIS TOPIC.
- 24:04MISSED SCHOOL DAYS WE KNOW IT'S
- 24:06BEEN A TOUGH FIRST START OF 2025
- 24:08WITH THE WINTER STORMS AND THE
- 24:11FLOODING AND SO MANY OF THESE
- 24:13SCHOOL DISTRICTS PARTICULARLY IN
- 24:14THE EASTERN PART OF THE STATE,
- 24:16STEPHEN WEST THEY HAVE USED UP
- 24:19NTI DAYS THERE'S BEEN
- 24:21CONVERSATION AND YOUR COMMITTEE
- 24:23KICK TO DO OFF HOUSE BILL 240
- 24:25THAT HAD A PLAN FOR FORGIVENESS
- 24:28OF SOME OF THOSE DAYS THE
- 24:29COMMISSIONER WOULD BE EMPOWERED
- 24:30TO DO.
- 24:31WHAT DO YOU THINK OF THAT?
- 24:32IS THAT BILL STILL INTACT AS IT
- 24:35CAME IN?
- 24:35>> THE BILL IS NOT INTACT BUT IT
- 24:38HAS MOVED FORWARD.
- 24:39IT WAS A VERY, VERY GOOD PIECE
- 24:42OF LEGISLATION REPRESENTATIVE
- 24:44TRUITT WORKED REALLY HARD ON
- 24:45THAT PIECE OF LEGISLATION.
- 24:48WE HAD THE 10NTI DAYS ALREADY.
- 24:54REALLY AN UNPRECEDENTED YEAR FOR
- 24:58THINGS HAPPENING.
- 24:58WE HAD A SHOOTER DOWN IN
- 25:00SOUTHERN KENTUCKY LAUREL COUNTY
- 25:02AREA THAT THERE WERE SCHOOLS
- 25:04DOWN THERE CLOSED FOR SEVERAL
- 25:05WEEKS AT A TIME.
- 25:07>> Renee: AND THERE IS A
- 25:07SEPARATE BILL THAT ADDRESSES
- 25:09THAT?
- 25:09>> THERE IS A SEPARATE BILL ON
- 25:11THAT.
- 25:12BUT THIS BILL 241 WILL HELP TO
- 25:14ADDRESS THAT.
- 25:15AND WE HAD THE SNOW AND THE ICE
- 25:17AND THEN RIGHT IN THE MIDDLE AS
- 25:19WE WERE CONSIDERING THIS PIECE
- 25:21OF LEGISLATION, THE FLOODS IN
- 25:23EASTERN KENTUCKY HIT.
- 25:25AND THERE ARE SOME SCHOOLS NOW
- 25:27WHERE THERE ARE NO ROADS TO THE
- 25:28SCHOOL.
- 25:30AND SO THEY ARE NEGATIVELY
- 25:33IMPACTED.
- 25:33I THOUGHT REPRESENTATIVE TRUITT
- 25:35WAS THOUGHTFUL ABOUT THE
- 25:37LEGISLATION.
- 25:37IT ALLOWS FOR SOME FIVE
- 25:40ADDITIONAL CALAMITY DAYS.
- 25:42IT IS A MAY RATHER THAN SHALL.
- 25:45THE COMMISSIONER MAY GRANT THOSE
- 25:47CALAMITY DAYS AFTER THE SCHOOL
- 25:50HAS DONE ITS BEST JOB TO MEET
- 25:54ALL THE USE ALL THE OTHER DAYS
- 25:55AND THINGS IT CAN DO FIRST.
- 25:57SO IT WAS A GOOD COMPROMISE.
- 26:01FOR THOSE OUT THERE WHO MAY WHO
- 26:04HATE NTI DAYS AND MAY WORRY
- 26:07ABOUT THAT THIS HAS A ONE-YEAR
- 26:10SUNSET.
- 26:10THIS BILL IS ONLY FOR THIS
- 26:12SCHOOL YEAR.
- 26:14>> Renee: BUT THERE ARE CHANGES
- 26:16BECAUSE WHEN REPRESENTATIVE
- 26:17TRUITT CAME BEFORE THE COMMITTEE
- 26:18LAST WEEK, HE SAID I'M AFRAID
- 26:21THE AMENDMENT THAT THE SENATE
- 26:23COMMITTEE ATTACHES IS MAKING A
- 26:24GOOD BILL BAD AND HE WAS GOING
- 26:26TO WORK TO HAVE HIS OWN BILL
- 26:29DEFEATED.
- 26:29WHAT DID YOU DO TO IT, SIR?
- 26:32>> WELL, IT WASN'T JUST ME.
- 26:37OTHERS WERE INVOLVED.
- 26:40YEAH, TO THAT PART OF SESSION,
- 26:44WHERE THERE IS A LITTLE BIT OF
- 26:45HORSE TRADING SO TO SPEAK.
- 26:47THIS OCCURS EVERY SESSION.
- 26:50WHERE YOU IN ORDER FOR ONE PARTY
- 26:52TO GET WHAT THEY WANT YOU START
- 26:54COMBINING TWO BILLS INTO ONE,
- 26:56THREE BILLS INTO ONE THAT SORT
- 26:58OF THING AND THAT IS WHAT
- 26:59HAPPENED HERE.
- 27:00SO JUST TO SET THE STAGE, THE
- 27:03OTHER PART OF 241 EXISTS WAS
- 27:08SENATE BILL 268 A BILL DEALING
- 27:11WITH VIRTUAL SCHOOLS.
- 27:11WE HAVE A UNIQUE THING HAPPENING
- 27:14WITH VIRTUAL SCHOOLS IN
- 27:15KENTUCKY.
- 27:16WE PASSED OPEN ENROLLMENT
- 27:18LEGISLATION WHICH ALLOWED
- 27:19STUDENTS TO VENTURE OUTSIDE
- 27:21THEIR DISTRICTS AND DO OPEN
- 27:23ENROLLMENT.
- 27:24AND WHAT THAT HAS LED TO THIS IS
- 27:27NOT A PILOT PROJECT.
- 27:29THIS IS JUST SOMETHING THAT
- 27:30OCCURRED NATURALLY IN THAT
- 27:32SPACE.
- 27:33A LITTLE SCHOOL CALLED CLOVER
- 27:35PORT OPENED TO BECOME A VIRTUAL
- 27:39SCHOOL.
- 27:39THEY HAD ENROLLMENT OF 300
- 27:41STUDENTS AND IN THAT YEAR'S
- 27:44TIME, THEY ADDED 2700 ADDITIONAL
- 27:47STUDENTS FROM ACROSS THE STATE.
- 27:49THEY'VE HAD SOME ISSUES.
- 27:52THEY'VE GROWN REALLY, REALLY
- 27:53FAST PART OF THEIR PROBLEM.
- 27:56AND I'M ALSO CHAIR OF FROM
- 28:01ADMINISTRATIVE REGS COMMITTEE.
- 28:03THE KENTUCKY DEPARTMENT OF
- 28:04EDUCATION WAS PREPARED TO SHUT
- 28:06DOWN CLOVER PORT SCHOOL AND
- 28:09INTRODUCE A 10% CAP.
- 28:1110% OF THE UNDERLYING ENROLLMENT
- 28:13COULD NOT BE VIRTUAL.
- 28:15AND IT WOULD HAVE IMMEDIATELY
- 28:16SHUT DOWN CLOVER PORT.
- 28:18WE HAD A LENGTHY EDUCATION
- 28:20COMMITTEE ON THE TOPIC.
- 28:22THESE PARENTS FROM CLOVER PORT
- 28:24SHOWED UP IN A BIG WAY.
- 28:27TRAVELING LONG DISTANCES, 300
- 28:29PARENTS OR MORE TO ADVOCATE FOR
- 28:30THEIR SCHOOL.
- 28:32AND AT THE END OF THE DAY, THE
- 28:34SENATE MADE THE POLICY DECISION,
- 28:39EDUCATION POLICY DECISION THAT
- 28:39WE WOULD TREAT THIS MAYBE AS
- 28:41MORE OF A PILOT, GIVE IT ANOTHER
- 28:44YEAR TO BREATHE AND SEE WHERE WE
- 28:45COME OUT.
- 28:48ULTIMATELY, CLOVER PORT CAME TO
- 28:49US WITH LANGUAGE, A COUPLE
- 28:51THINGS THEY SAID WE'LL PUT IN A
- 28:55THREE-YEAR SUNSET IF WE ARE NOT
- 28:57PERFORMING WITHIN THREE YEARS
- 28:58AND THE LEGISLATURE DOES
- 29:00NOTHING, CLOVER PORT GOES AWAY.
- 29:02AND SO THAT'S ONE OF THEIR
- 29:04PROVISIONS.
- 29:05THEY ALSO ADDED A 2% CAP.
- 29:08SO CLOVER PORT CANNOT CAPTURE
- 29:10MORE THAN 2% OF ANY DISTRICT'S
- 29:13STUDENTS.
- 29:14IF THE PUBLIC SCHOOLS OTHER
- 29:16PUBLIC SCHOOLS CLOVER PORT IS A
- 29:17PUBLIC SCHOOL.
- 29:18IF THEY ARE WORRIED ABOUT THEM
- 29:21TAKING TOO MANY STUDENTS WE'VE
- 29:23INSTITUTED A 2% CAP.
- 29:24THAT IS IF 241 AS AMENDED WITH
- 29:28COMMITTEE SUB MAKES IT THROUGH
- 29:30THE PROCESS.
- 29:30>> Renee: AND TO THE REPORT CARD
- 29:32SHOWING THEY ARE IN THE RED IS
- 29:33THE LOWEST LOW-PERFORMING SCHOOL
- 29:36HOW DO THEY BECOME FORTHFIED IN
- 29:40THEIR PERFORMANCE?
- 29:40>> SURE.
- 29:41YOU KNOW, IT'S THEY ADMITTED
- 29:45THAT OUR KIDS IN ELEMENTARY
- 29:47SCORE ARE NOT PERFORMING AT
- 29:49LEVEL.
- 29:52BUT THEY MANY OF THE KIDS COMING
- 29:54IN FROM OTHER SCHOOLS WE ARE IN
- 29:56A BAD PLACE COMING IN.
- 29:58THEY ARE NOT MIRACLE WORKERS.
- 29:59THEY CAN'T TURN AROUND A KID IN
- 30:02THREE OR FOUR MONTHS TIME.
- 30:03THEY NEED TIME.
- 30:05AS WE --
- 30:05IT'S ONE OF THOSE THINGS IN
- 30:08FRANKFORT YOU HAD TO BE THERE.
- 30:09WE CAN READ NUMBERS ON PAPER AND
- 30:11GO THROUGH BILLS BUT WHEN YOU
- 30:13SEE THE TESTIMONY OF THE
- 30:14PARENTS, THAT'S WHEN YOU IT
- 30:16CLICKS.
- 30:17AND WHAT WE FOUND IN THAT
- 30:19TESTIMONY IS MANY OF THESE KIDS
- 30:22WERE FLEEING HORRIBLE
- 30:24SITUATIONS.
- 30:25THEY MAY NOT HAVE RECEIVED THE
- 30:27PROPER SERVICES AT THEIR PUBLIC
- 30:29SCHOOL FOR EXAMPLE, MAYBE THEY
- 30:31WERE BEING BULLIED ON-LINE MAYBE
- 30:34BULLIED IN GENERAL AT THEIR
- 30:36SCHOOL.
- 30:37MAYBE THEY HAD CERTAIN IEP'S AND
- 30:41PROBLEMS WHERE THEY WERE NOT
- 30:42ABLE TO BE SUCCESSFUL.
- 30:44THESE PARENTS WERE PASSIONATE.
- 30:47AND WE'VE GOT MULTIPLE TEXTS ON
- 30:52MY PHONE SAYING THANK YOU.
- 30:54THIS WAS MY LAST OUR LAST
- 30:56CHANCE.
- 30:57SO IT WAS VERY COMPELLING.
- 30:59AND WE FELT THAT MAYBE THEY
- 31:03DESERVED A SECOND CHANCE.
- 31:04>> Renee: IS THIS PERSUASIVE
- 31:06ENOUGH TO YOU SENATOR THOMAS?
- 31:07>> LET ME SAY THIS, RENEE, MY
- 31:10COLLEAGUE TO MY RIGHT,
- 31:12REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI,
- 31:15WAVING, SO BEING A GENTLEMAN
- 31:16THAT I AM I WILL DEFER TO HER.
- 31:19>> ALL RIGHT.
- 31:20SO TO START WITH, VIRTUAL
- 31:23SCHOOLS GENERALLY ACROSS THE
- 31:24NATION HAVE LOW ACHIEVEMENT
- 31:26RATES.
- 31:27WE KNOW THAT.
- 31:28IT'S IN THE RESEARCH.
- 31:29I WANT TO TALK SPECIFICALLY
- 31:30ABOUT THE CONTRACT THAT CLOVER
- 31:32PORT HAS WITH A COMPANY CALLED
- 31:34STRIDE K-12.
- 31:36IT IS A FOR-PROFIT EDUCATION
- 31:38SERVICE PROVIDER TRADED ON THE
- 31:40NEW YORK STOCK EXCHANGE.
- 31:42IN 2024 THE COMPANY HAD 230,000
- 31:45STUDENTS TO WHOM THEY ARE
- 31:47PROVIDING VIRTUAL EDUCATION AND
- 31:48SALES OF $2 BILLION.
- 31:51THIS IS NOT A SMALL START UP WHO
- 31:53NEEDS A PILOT PROGRAM TIME TO
- 31:56FIGURE OUT WHAT'S HAPPENING.
- 31:57THIS IS A FOR-PROFIT COMPANY.
- 32:00NOW I HAVE AN MBA I KNOW WHAT
- 32:02THE PURPOSE OF A CORPORATION IS
- 32:04TO INCREASE SHAREHOLDER VALUE.
- 32:07AND THIS SPECIFIC COMPANY IS
- 32:09NOTORIOUS FOR TRYING TO DO THAT
- 32:11WHICH THEY ARE SUPPOSED TO DO
- 32:12FOR THEIR SHAREHOLDERS THROUGH
- 32:14ISSUES WE'VE SEEN IN KENTUCKY
- 32:18SUCH AS INCREASED STUDENT
- 32:20TEACHER RATIOS.
- 32:22THEIR MAJOR ISSUES ABOUT THAT.
- 32:24ATTENDANCE ISSUES.
- 32:25AND LET ME TALK A LITTLE BIT
- 32:27ABOUT HOW THEIR CONTRACT HOW
- 32:28THEY ARE PAID THIS I FIND THE
- 32:30MOST CONCERNING.
- 32:33WHETHER OR NOT THE PARENT
- 32:34WANTINGS EDUCATION, THERE ARE 65
- 32:36VIRTUAL SCHOOLS OFFERED IN
- 32:37KENTUCKY BUT ONE GROWING
- 32:39EXPONENTIALLY.
- 32:41AND CLOVER PORT RECEIVES ALL THE
- 32:44MONEY SEEK TITLE ONE, SPECIAL
- 32:46ED, ENGLISH LANGUAGE, LOCAL,
- 32:48STATE, FEDERAL, FACILITIES,
- 32:50CAPITAL OUTLAY FUNDING THEY GET
- 32:52ALL THAT MONEY AND THEY HAND
- 32:55BACK 3% TO CLOVER PORT OR
- 32:58$250,000.
- 32:59AND ANY MONEY THEY DON'T SPEND
- 33:01IS WRITTEN IN THEIR CONTRACT IS
- 33:02THEIR PROFIT.
- 33:04SO MY CONCERN AND I HOPE MY
- 33:07COLLEAGUES' CONCERN IS THERE
- 33:09NEED TSZ TO BE TRANSPARENCY HOW
- 33:12THIS MONEY IS SPENT.
- 33:13DOES THE SCHOOL NOT HAVE TO DO
- 33:15OUR PROCUREMENT POLICIES WHERE
- 33:17WE HAVE TO GET BIDS FOR
- 33:19ANYTHING?
- 33:20ALL I'VE SEEN IN THE PAYMENT
- 33:21WORK IS A LINE ITEM THAT SAYS
- 33:24EDUCATIONAL CONSULTING FEES THAT
- 33:26CLOVER PORT PAYS TO STRIVE K-12
- 33:30AND I FIND THAT CONCERNING.
- 33:31>> Renee: IS THAT ADDRESSED IN
- 33:33THE AMENDED HOUSE BILL 241 WHERE
- 33:35YOU REQUIRE THAT GREATER
- 33:37ITEMIZATION AND TRANSPARENCY?
- 33:38>> THAT IS NOT IN THE
- 33:41LEGISLATION.
- 33:43WE HAD A ROBUST DISCUSSION ON
- 33:45THAT TOPIC, ESPECIALLY IN OUR
- 33:49SENATE CAUCUS ON THIS IS A NEW
- 33:53THING.
- 33:54THIS IS NEW TO THE STATE OF
- 33:55KENTUCKY.
- 33:56AND SO THAT'S A LARGER QUESTION.
- 33:58I THINK WE'LL GET INTO THAT IN
- 34:01THE INTERIM HOW DO WE TREAT
- 34:03VIRTUAL SCHOOLS AS IT PERTAINS
- 34:05TO THE SEEK FUNDING FORMULA.
- 34:08CAN WE CLAW BACK FOR SCHOOL
- 34:10FACILITYINGS THINGS THEY DON'T
- 34:11NEED FACILITIES IF THEY HAVE A
- 34:13VIRTUAL PROGRAM.
- 34:13BUT I WOULD LIKE TO ADDRESS ONE
- 34:15THING.
- 34:16I'M CONVEYING WHAT WE'VE BEEN
- 34:19TOLD.
- 34:20THE SEEK COMPONENT FOR CLOVER
- 34:22PORT IS ROUGHLY 5 TO 6,000 PER
- 34:26CHILD.
- 34:26THAT IS THE SEEK COMPONENT.
- 34:28THESE KIDS MOVING OVER THEY
- 34:30DON'T GET THE LOCAL COMPONENT SO
- 34:32THEY DON'T GET THE VALUE OF
- 34:34LOCAL MATCH OR LOCAL TAX.
- 34:37I'M BEING TOLD OF THAT 5 TO
- 34:396,000, 2600 HAS TO BE SPENT FOR
- 34:43A TEACHER.
- 34:44AND SO AT LEAST 2600 IS GOING
- 34:47PER TEACHER.
- 34:50THE MONEY FLOWS MUCH OF IT TO
- 34:52STRIDE TO THE CONTRACTOR, AND
- 34:56THEN WHAT I'M BEING TOLD IS ALL
- 34:58THAT MONEY IS GOING TO CLOVER
- 35:00PORT.
- 35:01SO THE INFORMATION I HAVE IS
- 35:02THEY ARE SPENDING MORE THAN THEY
- 35:04ARE RECEIVING PER STUDENT AT
- 35:06CLOVER PORT RIGHT NOW.
- 35:07BECAUSE THIS IS A START-UP.
- 35:09ANYTIME YOU HAVE A START-UP
- 35:10BUSINESS YOU WILL HAVE UP FRONT
- 35:12COSTS CAPITAL IMPROVEMENTS AND
- 35:14THINGS.
- 35:15SO STRIDE.
- 35:17>> Renee: IT DOESN'T SOUND LIKE
- 35:18IT IS A START-UP.
- 35:19>> THE CONTRACT READS THAT
- 35:22STRIDE K-12 GETS 100% OF THE
- 35:23MONEY AND GIVES BACK 3% AND
- 35:26THAT'S IT.
- 35:28>> Renee: I'M CURIOUS ABOUT
- 35:29CONNECTING A COMPLICATED BILL TO
- 35:31A BILL THAT MANY SCHOOL
- 35:32DISTRICTS ARE COUNTING ON TO GET
- 35:35SOME REPRIEVE FROM THE MISSED
- 35:37SCHOOL DAYS TO THE KIDDOS AREN'T
- 35:39GOING TO SCHOOL IN JUNE.
- 35:41IS THERE CONSIDERING ALL THE
- 35:42QUESTIONS THAT ARE STILL OUT
- 35:44THERE ABOUT THIS PROGRAM, ANY
- 35:48CONSIDERATION OR SEVERING THE
- 35:49TWO BILLS OR IS IT TOO LATE TO
- 35:51DO THAT?
- 35:52>> I THINK IT'S TOO LATE.
- 35:55ONE THING I WILL SAY AND I'M
- 35:59JUST SPEAKING AS TO HOW THE
- 36:02COMMITTEE WENT, HOW THE PROCESS
- 36:04WENT WHEN WE PASSED THE BILL,
- 36:06THERE WAS A ROBUST CONVERSATION
- 36:08WITH REPRESENTATIVE TRUITT ON
- 36:11HIS BILL AND HOW A COMMITTEE SUB
- 36:14WAS ADDED.
- 36:16AND SENATOR GIVENS SPOKE TO
- 36:20REPRESENTATIVE TRUITT AND I'M
- 36:22JUST CONVEYING WHAT WAS SAID IN
- 36:26COMMITTEE, THAT MAYBE THE VOTES
- 36:27WEREN'T THERE OR 241 AS A
- 36:31STAND-ALONE BILL.
- 36:32SO I KNOW THERE WERE COMPLAINTS
- 36:35ABOUT, YOU KNOW, A SUBBING OUT A
- 36:40BILL AND TIMES A SUB WILL HELP
- 36:43YOU GET WHAT YOU WANT AND THERE
- 36:44WAS THAT DISCUSSION THAT 241
- 36:47MAYBE ON ITS OWN WOULDN'T PASS.
- 36:49I CAN TELL YOU THIS, IN THE
- 36:53SENATE, THERE'S BEEN MUCH
- 36:54DISCUSSION ON NTI IN THE DISLIKE
- 36:57FOR NTI AND KIDS BRINGING HOME
- 37:01PACKETS AND JUST LEARNING 30
- 37:03MINUTES A DAY AND THAT IS
- 37:05COUNTING AS A FULL SCHOOL DAY.
- 37:08THERE'S THAT PUSHBACK.
- 37:09REPRESENTATIVE TRUE SIT A
- 37:10PRINCIPAL.
- 37:11I THINK HE DOES A GOOD JOB WITH
- 37:14NTI AT HIS SCHOOL.
- 37:16I'M NOT DISPARAGING WHAT HE HAS
- 37:19DONE.
- 37:20THAT IS SOME OF THE DISCUSSION
- 37:21THAT WENT INTO THE DECISION.
- 37:23>> Renee: IF OUR VIEWERS ARE
- 37:24WATCHING OUR COVERAGE THEY WOULD
- 37:26HAVE SEEN SENATOR GIVENS SAY
- 37:28THAT THE VOTES WERE NOT THERE
- 37:30WITH HOUSE BILL 241.
- 37:32IF THAT WASN'T ATTACHED.
- 37:34BUT NOW I'M SURE YOU ARE HAVING
- 37:36CONVERSATIONS REPRESENTATIVE
- 37:37TRUITT ABOUT ARE YOU ALL
- 37:38ACTIVELY TRYING TO GET IT KILLED
- 37:40NOW IT HAS THIS ADDITIONAL?
- 37:43>> HERE'S WHAT I THINK AND IT IS
- 37:46A COMPLEX ISSUE.
- 37:47I DON'T THINK WE CAN LET CLOVER
- 37:49PORT GO ON WITH PUTTING MORE
- 37:52GUARDRAILS WITHOUT PUTTING MORE
- 37:55GUARDRAILS THAN WHAT WE HAVE.
- 37:56THAT IS DISCUSSION MOVING
- 37:57FORWARD.
- 37:57IT IS A NEW PROGRAM.
- 37:59THEY HAD GROWN TREMENDOUSLY.
- 38:02BUT I'M NOT A FAN OF VIRTUAL TO
- 38:04START WITH.
- 38:04I THINK A TEACHER IN THE
- 38:06CLASSROOM IS BETTER.
- 38:07I'M NOT A FAN OF NTI.
- 38:10WE HAD TO HAVE THEM ESPECIALLY
- 38:11WITH OUR EASTERN KENTUCKY
- 38:13DISTRICTS.
- 38:14AND I KNOW DISTRICTS TRY TO USE
- 38:17THOSE SPARINGLY AND THIS IS AN
- 38:19UNUSUAL YEAR.
- 38:20THE BILL DID NOT GIVE THEM MORE
- 38:22NTI DAYS THE REASON WE NEEDED
- 38:25THAT BILL WE WERE ADDING TIME TO
- 38:26THE END OF THE SCHOOL DAY TO
- 38:28CATCH A LOT OF THEM UP AND
- 38:30WOULDN'T HAVE TO USE NTI DAYS.
- 38:32THE ISSUE NOW IS THAT WE ARE
- 38:35DRAGGING ALONG SO THAT IS ALMOST
- 38:37GOING TO BE A MOOT POINT TO
- 38:41ADDING THE SCHOOL DAY.
- 38:43THE K-5 PART OF CLOVER PORT IS
- 38:45WHAT REALLY, I GUESS IS
- 38:48CONCERNING TO ME.
- 38:51BECAUSE IT'S HARD TO TEACH A KID
- 38:53TO READ.
- 38:54BUT I DON'T KNOW HOW YOU CAN DO
- 38:56IT K-1 VIRTUALLY.
- 38:59UNLESS YOU HAVE SOMEBODY WITH
- 38:59THEM.
- 39:01THERE COULD BE SOMEBODY RIGHT
- 39:02THERE THAT IS HELPING AND YOU
- 39:04HAVE 342K-1 KIDS AND ANOTHER
- 39:08ISSUE FOR ME IS THIS YEAR ALONE
- 39:11482 DROPPED OUT ALREADY.
- 39:13SO IF THEY ARE DROPPING OUT ARE
- 39:15THEY COMING BACK TO THE PUBLIC
- 39:16SCHOOLS AND ARE THEY GOING TO BE
- 39:18FURTHER BEHIND?
- 39:19AND WE HAVE TO DEAL WITH THAT.
- 39:21BUT I JUST THINK THAT I DON'T
- 39:23THINK WE KILL IT ALTOGETHER BUT
- 39:25I DO THINK MAYBE WE PUT MORE
- 39:27GUARDRAILS IN ESPECIALLY THE K-5
- 39:30PART AND SOME OF THE THINGS THAT
- 39:32REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI TALKED
- 39:33ABOUT ABOUT THE CONTRACT ISSUES
- 39:36AND DO GUIDELINES WITH K-5.
- 39:39SO AND I'M SURE THIS DISCUSSION
- 39:41IS GOING TO CONTINUE.
- 39:42AND HOPEFULLY WE CAN GET
- 39:44SOMETHING BECAUSE WE NEED THE
- 39:48COUNTER BILL SOONER THAN LATER.
- 39:50HOPEFULLY WE CAN COME TO AN
- 39:52AGREEMENT ON THE TWO ISSUES ON
- 39:54ONE BILL.
- 39:55>> Renee: BY FRIDAY.
- 39:55>> CAN I SPEAK ON THAT TO
- 39:57RESPOND BRIEFLY TO CHAIRMAN
- 40:01LEWIS.
- 40:07ED SENATOR COULD CONSTANTLY SAY
- 40:09WE'LL BE BACK IN NINE MONTHS.
- 40:11AS WE END SESSION WE WILL BE
- 40:13BACK IN SESSION NINE MONTHS FROM
- 40:15NOW.
- 40:16ACTUALLY BE BACK IN SOONER WE
- 40:17WILL BE BACK IN JUNE.
- 40:20AND SO THERE IS A COMMITMENT.
- 40:22THERE IS A COMMITMENT TO
- 40:24CONTINUE TO LOOK AT VIRTUAL,
- 40:28ADJUST ESPECIALLY THE FUNDING,
- 40:30ADJUST HOW IT WORKS AND KEEP OUR
- 40:32EYE ON THIS SO THERE IS A
- 40:34COMMITMENT IN THE SENATE TO KEEP
- 40:36CLOSE EYE OUT.
- 40:38>> Renee: SENATOR THOMAS?
- 40:38>> ONE MINUTE, RENEE.
- 40:41REPRESENTATIVE BOJANOWSKI DID A
- 40:43GOOD JOB TALKING ABOUT STRIDE
- 40:46INCORPORATED.
- 40:46BUT I WANT TO POINT OUT THREE
- 40:48THINGS FOR YOUR VIEWERS.
- 40:53IN 2012 FLORIDA SANCTIONED
- 40:56STRIDE BECAUSE THEY WERE
- 40:58CERTIFYING TEACHERS TO SIGN
- 41:00CLASSES THAT DID NOT EXIST.
- 41:01THEY WERE SAYING THE CLASSES DO
- 41:03NOT EXIST BUT YOU MUST SIGN IT.
- 41:05THEN STRIDE GOES TO CALIFORNIA,
- 41:07AND GETS FINED $160 MILLION FOR
- 41:10LYING ABOUT ENROLLMENT.
- 41:12THEN, RENEE, THEY GO TO GEORGIA,
- 41:17AND THE SCHOOL SPLITS FROM THEM
- 41:20DUE TO POOR STUDENT PERFORMANCE
- 41:22AND SCHOOL LEADERS DESCRIBE AS
- 41:24HAVING RECEIVED OVERPAID
- 41:25SERVICES.
- 41:26SO WE'RE TALKING ABOUT A COMPANY
- 41:28THAT HAS GONE THROUGH THREE
- 41:29STATES IN 10 YEARS, ALL THE
- 41:31STATES SANCTIONED THEM OUT OF
- 41:33THERE FOR LYING, CHEATING AND
- 41:35STEALING.
- 41:37SO I JUST WANT TO POINT THAT OUT
- 41:39TO YOUR VIEWERS ABOUT THIS
- 41:41COMPANY.
- 41:41AND THAT'S BEEN UNREFUTED.
- 41:45>> Renee: TAKE A TOUGH PIVOT AND
- 41:46GET TO VIEWER QUESTIONS HERE AS
- 41:47OUR TIME IS RUNNING OUT.
- 41:49AND IT DOES THAT WHEN YOU HAVE
- 41:51SUCH ENGAGING DISCUSSION.
- 41:52THIS IS FROM MARTIN IN
- 41:55LEXINGTON.
- 41:56WHY ISN'T THERE MORE FOCUS ON
- 41:58BILLS TO STRENGTHS EN K-12
- 42:00EDUCATION RELATED TO CIVICS AND
- 42:03NOT JUST THE FEDERAL GOVERNMENT
- 42:05ISN'T THIS MORE IMPORTANT
- 42:08EDUCATING CITIZENS THAN BILLS
- 42:10RELATING TO THE 10 COMMAND
- 42:11MEANTS OR THE U.S. FLAG IN K-12
- 42:15CLASSROOMS?
- 42:16>> I THINK WAS IT LAST YEAR I
- 42:18THINK WE PASSED THAT ON CIVICS
- 42:21AND THIS YEAR WE HAVE A BILL
- 42:22THAT STRENGTHENS CIVICS, SENATE
- 42:25BILL 68.
- 42:26SO I THINK THERE IS GOING TO BE
- 42:28MORE THINGS TO DO THAT.
- 42:29AND I THINK IT WAS A START LAST
- 42:30YEAR.
- 42:31BUT CONTINUING THIS YEAR.
- 42:32>> AND WE ALSO HAVE A BILL ON
- 42:35FINANCIAL LITERACY TO REQUIRE A
- 42:36COURSE ON FINANCIAL LITERACY
- 42:39WHICH IS KIND OF LIKE CIVICS ONE
- 42:41OF THOSE LIFE SKILLS SOMETHING
- 42:42YOU NEED TO KNOW ABOUT IN ORDER
- 42:44TO BE A PRODUCTIVE ADULT.
- 42:46>> I THINK MARTY IS RIGHT.
- 42:49WE SPEND TOO MUCH TIME TALKING
- 42:51ABOUT RELIGIOUS LIBERTY AND NOT
- 42:52AS MUCH TIME TALKING ABOUT CORE
- 42:56SUBJECTS THAT ARE GOING TO
- 42:57BENEFIT THE STUDENTS LONG-TERM
- 42:59AND REWARD THEM AS THEY BECOME
- 43:01ADULTS AND MOVE INTO THEIR
- 43:04CAREERS.
- 43:05>> I WOULD CHIME IN AND AGREE
- 43:09WITH YOUR VIEWER THAT WE DO NEED
- 43:11TO FOCUS MORE ON CIVICS.
- 43:13WE DO NEED TO FOCUS ON FINANCIAL
- 43:16LITERACY.
- 43:18REPRESENTATIVE MEREDITH HAS A
- 43:19GOOD BILL I THINK IT'S 342.
- 43:22SENATOR RECALLINGS AS A PIECE IN
- 43:2668.
- 43:26THERE ARE EFFORTS BEING MADE TO
- 43:27MAKE THAT MORE ROBUST.
- 43:29WHENEVER WE HAVE THESE
- 43:31DISCUSSIONS WE ALWAYS SEEM TO
- 43:32HAVE A FEW PROBLEMS WITH HOW
- 43:35MUCH CLASS TIME CAN YOU DEVOTE
- 43:37TO THAT WE'RE ALWAYS KIND OF
- 43:39BUCKING UP AGAINST THAT A LITTLE
- 43:40BIT.
- 43:41>> Renee: AND SENSE HE MENTIONS
- 43:43IT ABOUT THE MOMENTS OF SILENCE,
- 43:46LET'S TALK ABOUT THAT.
- 43:47I KNOW THERE'S ONE BILL SENATE
- 43:49BILL 19 THAT DOES THAT.
- 43:50WHY IS THAT NECESSARY?
- 43:51THIS IS A SHALL NOT A MAY?
- 43:54>> IT IS.
- 43:56>> Renee: BECAUSE IT EXISTS THAT
- 43:57THEY CAN DO IT AND NOW THEY ARE
- 43:59REQUIRED TO.
- 43:59>> I THINK THAT IS CORRECT, YES.
- 44:02A MOMENT OF SILENCE BILL.
- 44:05MORE OR LESS, THE REASON THIS
- 44:08WAS BROUGHT FORWARD AND IT HAS
- 44:10PASSED THE SENATE AND IT'S OVER
- 44:11IN THE HOUSE, IS THAT THE
- 44:15PROPONENTS OF THE BILL BROUGHT
- 44:17STUDIES THAT SAY IF YOU PUT THIS
- 44:19IN PLACE IN SCHOOLS, IT HELPS
- 44:23THE KIDS WITH THEIR DAY AND
- 44:25GIVES THEM A BETTER MENTAL
- 44:26FOCUS.
- 44:27THAT WAS THE REASONING BEHIND
- 44:28THE BILL.
- 44:30WE'LL SEE IF IT MAKES ITS WAY
- 44:32THROUGH THE PROCESS.
- 44:33>> Renee: BUT IT DOESN'T ALLOW
- 44:35TEACHERS TO LEAD A PRAYER OF ANY
- 44:37SORT OR RELIGION.
- 44:38WE WANT TO MAKE SURE OUR VIEWERS
- 44:42UNDERSTAND WHAT DOES AND DOES
- 44:43NOT DO.
- 44:44>> YOU KNOW, I'M NOT AGAINST
- 44:47PRAYING BUT WE CAN DO THAT IN
- 44:49SCHOOLS NOW.
- 44:51AND I DON'T KNOW HOW MANY
- 44:52SCHOOLS THERE ARE SCHOOLS THAT
- 44:53DO PLEDGE OF ALLEGIANCE
- 44:55EVERYDAY.
- 44:55THE DISTRICT I'M FROM WE DO THAT
- 44:58EVERY YEAR, ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS
- 44:59WHATEVER.
- 45:00IT'S SOMETHING WE CAN ALREADY
- 45:03DO.
- 45:04AND IT'S REALLY NOT GOING TO --
- 45:07WE'RE GOING TO HAVE A MOMENT OF
- 45:08SILENCE AND IT WILL HAPPEN.
- 45:10BUT A LOT OF PEOPLE ARE DOING
- 45:12THAT NOW.
- 45:13>> Renee: ARE YOU FOR IT OR
- 45:14AGAINST IT?
- 45:15>> HERE'S WHAT I DON'T LIKE.
- 45:17I LIKE PRAYING OBVIOUSLY.
- 45:21BUT IS THAT SUPERINTENDENT IS
- 45:23COMING OUT AT ME I HATE WHEN
- 45:25THINGS ARE MANDATED ON SCHOOL
- 45:27DISTRICTS.
- 45:27AND FOR YEARS I MEAN, EVERY
- 45:29SESSION THAT I WOULD BE HERE, I
- 45:31WOULD BE WATCHING WHAT THEY ARE
- 45:33DOING HERE COME MORE MANDATES
- 45:35AND I GO DOWN THE HALL FUSSING
- 45:37AND CARRYING ON.
- 45:38I THINK WE HAVE TO BE CAREFUL ON
- 45:39WHAT WE MANDATE.
- 45:41WE ASK SO MUCH OF OUR SCHOOLS
- 45:43NOWADAYS.
- 45:45FROM RELIGION TO RAISING THEM.
- 45:48WE RAISE A LOT OF KIDS NOW
- 45:50BASICALLY.
- 45:51WE REALLY DO.
- 45:52FROM THE TIME WE GET THEM
- 45:54SOMETIMES WE ARE THEIR NURSES,
- 45:56PARENTS, WHATEVER.
- 45:59AND AGAIN IT ALARMS ME WHEN WE
- 46:02START MANDATING THINGS.
- 46:04>> Renee: THE KID AND THE
- 46:05TEACHER IN HER RAISES HER HAND.
- 46:07>> I'M TRYING TO BE PATIENT.
- 46:09I'M GRAVELY CONCERNED.
- 46:10BECAUSE I THINK THE MOMENT OF
- 46:12SILENCE LAWS AND HAPPENING
- 46:14ACROSS THE NATION ARE STRATEGIES
- 46:15TO RETURN PRAYER TO OUR SCHOOLS.
- 46:19EVERYONE ANYONE CAN PRAY DURING
- 46:21THE SCHOOL DAY BUT TO MANDATE A
- 46:23MOMENT OF SILENCE AND I WATCHED
- 46:24THE COMMITTEES TODAY.
- 46:26I WATCHED THE KET BROADCASTS ON
- 46:28THEM.
- 46:29AND THE PERSON SITTING NEXT TO
- 46:31SENATOR WAS NOT AN EDUCATOR HE
- 46:33WAS NOT A RESEARCHER HE WHATS A
- 46:36RABBI.
- 46:37DON'T TELL ME THERE'S NOT AN
- 46:38INTENT FOR THIS TO BE PRAYER.
- 46:40WE CAN DO IT ALREADY.
- 46:42AND I THINK THIS JUST PUTS
- 46:44ANOTHER BURDEN ON TEACHERS.
- 46:45IN ORDER TO MAKE THE KIDS SIT
- 46:48QUIETLY.
- 46:49AND I THINK UNLESS WE COME BACK
- 46:51AND DO SOMETHING SERIOUS ABOUT
- 46:53CELLPHONES MAJORITY OF THOSE
- 46:54OLDER KIDS WILL BE LISTENING TO
- 46:57MUSIC DURING THAT MOMENT OF
- 46:58SILENCE.
- 46:59AND TO ME, I'M STRONGLY AGAINST
- 47:02THE BILL BECAUSE I THINK IT IS
- 47:04AN INTENT TO BRING PRAYER BACK
- 47:06TO OUR SCHOOLS.
- 47:08>> Renee: SENATOR THOMAS?
- 47:09>> I VOTED FOR THE BILL.
- 47:12AND I THINK YOU HAVE TO TAKE
- 47:14BILLS ON THEIR FACE-VALUE.
- 47:16THAT'S WHAT I DO WHEN I ARGUE
- 47:18FOR OR AGAINST BILLS AS SENATOR
- 47:20WEST KNOWS.
- 47:21WHAT DOES THE LANGUAGE SAY AND
- 47:22WHAT DOES IT ALLOW OR PROHIBIT
- 47:24AND GO FROM THERE.
- 47:26THIS BILL MANDATES A MOMENT OF
- 47:29SILENCE.
- 47:30IT SAYS NOTHING ABOUT PRAYER.
- 47:31AND AS I SAID ON THE FLOOR TO ME
- 47:33THERE IS A DIFFERENCE BETWEEN
- 47:35TALKING ABOUT RELIGION AS I SEE
- 47:37IT A SWORD OR A SHIELD.
- 47:39USED FOR A SWORD I'M TOTALLY
- 47:42OPPOSED TO ACTIONS.
- 47:44IF IT'S BEING USED AS A SHIELD
- 47:46TO HELP PEOPLE COPE OR REFLECT
- 47:49OR DO WHATEVER, THEN THEY CAN DO
- 47:51THAT.
- 47:52I THINK REPRESENTATIVE
- 47:54BOJANOWSKI IS ABSOLUTELY RIGHT.
- 47:55MOST OF THE STUDENTS WILL BE ON
- 47:58THEIR CELLPHONES LISTENING TO
- 47:59MUSIC.
- 48:00IT DOESN'T MATTER HOW YOU USE
- 48:01YOUR MOMENT OF SILENCE.
- 48:03YOU CAN DO YOUR HOMEWORK IT SAYS
- 48:06NOTHING ABOUT PRAYER AND HOWEVER
- 48:07THAT IS USED TEACHERS WILL BE
- 48:09ABLE TO SPEND THAT MINUTE OR TWO
- 48:11AND MOVE ON TO THE DAY.
- 48:12>> IT DOES LIST PRAYER IN THE
- 48:14BILL AS ONE THING THAT STUDENTS
- 48:16COULD BE DOING DURING THAT TIME.
- 48:19NOT REQUIRED I AGREE.
- 48:20>> THAT IS NOT PART OF THE
- 48:24CHANGES MADE IN SENATE BILL 19
- 48:25LET'S BE CLEAR ABOUT THAT, TINA.
- 48:31[INAUDIBLE] THE CHANGES THAT
- 48:34MADE SENATE BILL 19, SAY NOTHING
- 48:36ABOUT PRAYER.
- 48:37>> LOOK AT IT AGAIN.
- 48:39>> Renee: OKAY.
- 48:40LET'S TALK ABOUT CELLPHONES IN
- 48:41CLASSROOMS HOUSE BILL 383, WOULD
- 48:44FORBID THEM.
- 48:45WE KNOW THAT KENTUCKY EDITION ON
- 48:47KET WE'VE DONE STORIES WITH
- 48:50BOURBON COUNTY WHO HAD YOU KNOW
- 48:52THIS SUCCESS WITH NOT HAVING
- 48:54CELLPHONES IN CLASSROOMS.
- 48:55I MEAN FIRST OF ALL, AND I'LL GO
- 48:57TO YOU FIRST.
- 48:58WHAT IS THE WISDOM OR IRRATIONAL
- 49:03FOR --
- 49:04>> IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS WE
- 49:05DON'T HAVE THE ISSUE.
- 49:06WE TELL THE KIDS PUT IT IN YOUR
- 49:08BACKPACK AND THEY DO.
- 49:10MIDDLE AND HIGH SCHOOLS IS
- 49:11DIFFERENT THING.
- 49:13FERN CREEK HIGH SCHOOL IN
- 49:14LOUISVILLE HAS A POLICY WHERE
- 49:15ALL STUDENTS WHEN THEY COME IN
- 49:17THEY PUT THEIR PHONE IN A POUCH
- 49:19AND THEY KEEP THEIR POUCH WITH
- 49:21THEM ALL DAY.
- 49:23SHE IS HAVING TREMENDOUS
- 49:25SUCCESS.
- 49:25SHE SAID IN THE FIRST TWO WEEKS
- 49:27OF SCHOOL, STUDENTS CHECKED OUT
- 49:28MORE BOOKS FROM THE LIBRARY THAN
- 49:30THEY HAD THE ENTIRE PREVIOUS
- 49:32YEAR.
- 49:34SO IT IS VERY CONCERNING FOR US
- 49:37ALL OF US, CELLPHONES ARE AN
- 49:40ADDICTIVE DEVICE.
- 49:41BUT WHEN YOU ARE IN SCHOOL AND
- 49:43YOU ARE LEARNING, I THINK THAT
- 49:45YOU NEED TO HAVE THAT PUT AWAY.
- 49:48IT'S LIKE BE THE PARENT IN THE
- 49:49ROOM.
- 49:52AND TAKE AWAY THAT DISTRACTS US
- 49:54FROM OUR LEARNING.
- 49:56>> Renee: THERE WAS
- 49:56CONSIDERATION ABOUT KIDS WHO
- 49:59HAVE MEDICAL DISABILITIES OR
- 50:00COULD BE AN EMERGENCY OF SOME
- 50:02SORT WHERE YOU NEED IT TO HAVE A
- 50:04CELLPHONE.
- 50:05>> AN ACCOMMODATION OR SPECIAL
- 50:07EDUCATION NEED ANY OF THOSE ARE
- 50:08FINE.
- 50:10WHAT THE PRINCIPAL FROM FERN
- 50:12CREEK MENTIONED IS IF THERE IS
- 50:14AN EMERGENCY, IT IS BETTER FOR
- 50:17THE FIRST-RESPONDERS TO KEEP ALL
- 50:18THE CHILDREN SAFE IF THERE
- 50:20AREN'T THOUSANDS OF MESSAGES
- 50:21GOING IN AND OUT OF THE BUILDING
- 50:24AT THE SAME TIME.
- 50:25SO I UNDERSTAND.
- 50:26PARENTS ARE AFRAID AND THEY WANT
- 50:28TO BE ABLE TO CONTACT THEIR
- 50:30CHILD IF THERE IS AN ARMED
- 50:32INTRUDER.
- 50:32I GET IT.
- 50:33THESE POUCHES THAT FERN CREEK
- 50:36HAS THEY MAYBE I SHOULDN'T SAY
- 50:38THIS CAN BE CUT APART WITH
- 50:41SURGICAL SCISSORS AND EVERY
- 50:43CLASSROOM HAS THAT IF THERE IS
- 50:45AN EMERGENCY THINGS CAN BE DONE.
- 50:46BUT I THINK WE ALSO HAVE TO
- 50:48THINK ABOUT WHAT IS THAT IS A
- 50:51VERY RARE OCCASION.
- 50:54HOW DETRIMENTAL IS TIME SPENT ON
- 50:55THE CELLPHONES?
- 50:56WE HAD A MEETING WHERE AN AUTHOR
- 50:59OF THE BOOK THE ANXIOUS
- 51:00GENERATION WAS ON.
- 51:02AND SINCE WE'VE HAD CELLPHONES
- 51:04PARTICULARLY WITH THE
- 51:06REARVIEW --
- 51:08THE REVERSE MIRRORS WHERE YOU
- 51:09CAN DO THE SELFIES AND THE
- 51:12LIKES, ANXIETY IN OUR YOUNG
- 51:15GIRLS HAS GONE UP EXPONENTIALLY.
- 51:17IT IS A MENTAL HEALTH CRISIS.
- 51:19AND I AGREE WE AS A SCHOOL
- 51:23LEGISLATING FOR SCHOOL DISTRICTS
- 51:24NEED TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT.
- 51:26>> Renee: YEAH.
- 51:26WHAT DO YOU THINK?
- 51:27>> I WOULD VOTE FOR THAT BILL
- 51:29TOMORROW IF IT CAME TO THE
- 51:31SENATE FLOOR.
- 51:31WE'VE GOT TO STOP THE USE OF
- 51:34CELLPHONES BY HIGH SCHOOL
- 51:35STUDENTS IN THE CLASSROOM.
- 51:37IT'S WORKING WELL IN OTHER
- 51:39SCHOOL DISTRICTS ACROSS THIS
- 51:40COUNTRY.
- 51:40WE OUGHT TO BRING THAT TO
- 51:42KENTUCKY.
- 51:43>> Renee: FLORIDA AND TENNESSEE.
- 51:45I HAVE A GRANDDAUGHTER AND I
- 51:47TOLD HER I WOULD VOTE FOR THE
- 51:49BILL AND SHE SMIRKED AT HER
- 51:52GRANDFATHER WE OUGHT TO HAVE
- 51:53THAT BILL AND I WOULD VOTE FOR
- 51:55IT.
- 51:56>> Renee: CHAIRMAN WEST?
- 51:56>> THIS IS ONE OF THOSE
- 51:58BIPARTISAN MOMENTS.
- 51:59I CANNOT AGREE MORE.
- 52:03IT'S REALLY COMMON SENSE, YOU
- 52:05KNOW IF YOU ARE ON YOUR PHONE AT
- 52:07SCHOOL, YOU ARE LITERALLY
- 52:09DISTRACTED FROM YOUR WORK AND
- 52:10FORT YOU ARE DOING.
- 52:12BUT I WOULD REALLY URGE YOUR
- 52:15VIEWERS IF THEY HAD ANY DOUBT IF
- 52:18THEY COULD GO INTO THE KET
- 52:19ARCHIVES AND REVIEW OUR
- 52:21COMMITTEE HEARING WE HAD IN THE
- 52:23INTERIM, I REPRESENTATIVE
- 52:25BOJANOWSKI TALKED ABOUT THE
- 52:26ANXIOUS GENERATION AN INDEPTH
- 52:29BOOK AND STUDY A GENTLEMAN OUT
- 52:31OF NEW YORK GAVE AN EXCELLENT
- 52:33PRESENTATION.
- 52:33IT IS ASTOUNDING THE DIFFERENCE
- 52:36NOT HAVING A CELLPHONE MAKES AS
- 52:39IT PERTAINS TO MENTAL HEALTH,
- 52:42JUST ADDICTION ITSELF.
- 52:43MANY OF OUR STUDENTS THEY ARE
- 52:45PHYSICALLY ADDICTED TO THE
- 52:47CELLPHONES.
- 52:48AND THIS WOULD BE A GOOD WAY
- 52:49MAYBE TO HELP BREAK THAT
- 52:51ADDICTION A LITTLE BIT.
- 52:53SUICIDE PREVENTION.
- 52:54YOU KNOW, A BIG COMPONENT OF
- 52:56TEEN SUICIDES HAS TO BE DIRECTLY
- 53:00RELATED TO THEIR CELLPHONES.
- 53:03SO MENTAL HEALTH ADDICTION,
- 53:05SUICIDE PREVENTION, YOU GET TO
- 53:06THAT BEFORE YOU EASTERN GET TO
- 53:09THE LEARNING LOSS.
- 53:10AND SO A KEY COMPONENT ALSO WAS
- 53:12TREMENDOUS LEARNING LOSS BY
- 53:14HAVING THEM IN SCHOOL.
- 53:15I THINK THIS IS A CLEAR MOMENT
- 53:17OF AGREEMENT.
- 53:19>> Renee: YEAH.
- 53:19>> SEVERAL DISTRICTS ARE DOING
- 53:20IT WITH GOOD RESULTS.
- 53:22MY FORMER DISTRICT WHERE I WAS
- 53:24SUPERINTENDENT DID IT TWO YEARS
- 53:25AGO AND THEY WILL SAY THAT THE
- 53:27REASON THEIR TEST SCORES WENT UP
- 53:29AT THE HIGH SCHOOLS THIS IS ONE
- 53:30OF THE REASONS.
- 53:31I THINK IT'S GOOD.
- 53:32I THINK THERE'S BIPARTISAN
- 53:34SUPPORT FOR IT.
- 53:35AND HOPEFULLY WE CAN GET IT
- 53:37PASSED.
- 53:38>> Renee: WELL, TIME FLIES.
- 53:41QUICKLY, WANTED TO TALK ABOUT
- 53:43LOW-PERFORMING SCHOOLS.
- 53:44BUT I REMEMBER AND YOU ALL
- 53:47REMEMBER THAT EDUCATION ROBBY
- 53:50FLETCHER SAID THERE IS A $40
- 53:52MILLION SHORTFALL.
- 53:53ARE YOU GOING TO DO ANYTHING
- 53:55ABOUT THAT?
- 53:56WHAT CAN YOU DO?
- 53:57AND WHAT CAN YOU DO BEFORE MARCH
- 54:0028TH?
- 54:01>> I DO NOT HAVE AN ANSWER TO
- 54:02THAT AT THIS POINT.
- 54:04THAT'S I'M NO LONGER ON THE
- 54:06PREPARATION REVENUE COMMITTEE
- 54:07BUT I KNOW THEY ARE WRESTLING
- 54:09WITH THAT SUBJECT.
- 54:10I DO KNOW THE GOVERNOR HAS
- 54:12ALLOWED $15 MILLION TO FLOW IN
- 54:14THAT HE'S ALLOWED TO USE IN
- 54:17THESE SITUATIONS.
- 54:18SO I WOULD SUSPECT MAYBE WE'LL
- 54:20DO SOMETHING WE'LL SEE.
- 54:23BUT THERE ARE POTS OF MONEY THAT
- 54:25CAN BE MOVED AROUND BUT THAT IS
- 54:27CURRENTLY IN NEGOTIATION.
- 54:28AND I'M NOT SAFE TO SAY HERE
- 54:30TONIGHT WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN.
- 54:31>> I WOULD LIKE TO SAY OF THE
- 54:35$14.MILLION AT THE GOVERNOR
- 54:38FOUND EIGHT MILLION IS GOING TO
- 54:39CLOVER PORT FOR THE VIRTUAL
- 54:42SCHOOL.
- 54:43>> Renee: OKAY.
- 54:44WE'LL LEAVE THAT THERE.
- 54:46ANY OTHER FURTHER COMMENT ON
- 54:47THAT?
- 54:47>> NO.
- 54:48>> Renee: AND YOU GO BACK AND
- 54:51LOOK AT SHOWS AND WE TALKED
- 54:52ABOUT WHAT ARE YOU GOING TO DO
- 54:54IN 30 DAYS AND ONE WAS
- 54:56ADDRESSING LOW-PERFORMING
- 54:57SCHOOLS IN LIGHT OF THE FACT
- 54:58THAT THE CONSTITUTIONAL
- 55:00AMENDMENT 2 FAILED.
- 55:01BUT THERE DOESN'T SEEM TO BE
- 55:03CONVERSATION ABOUT THAT AT THIS
- 55:04JUNCTURE.
- 55:05IS IT TOO LATE FOR THAT?
- 55:07>> ACTUALLY WE HAD PASSED
- 55:10LEGISLATION THAT DEALS WITH THAT
- 55:11ON THE COMPREHENSIVE.
- 55:14>> Renee: THE TSI.
- 55:16>> WE MOVED THAT FROM THREE
- 55:17YEARS TO ONE WHICH IS GOING TO
- 55:19GET LOWER PERFORMING SCHOOLS
- 55:21MORE HELP.
- 55:23AND WHEN THEY GO INTO DISTRICTS
- 55:26THEIR RECORD IS GOOD.
- 55:27THAT WOULD ALLOW THEM TO PICK UP
- 55:3020 MORE SCHOOLS ON THAT LIST.
- 55:32THINGS LIKE THAT ARE READING
- 55:33BILL, OUR KINDERGARTEN BILL,
- 55:35THINGS LIKE THAT ARE GOING TO
- 55:36ADDRESS OUR LOWER PERFORMING
- 55:38SCHOOLS, TOO.
- 55:40>> Renee: I STAND CORRECTED.
- 55:42ANY OTHER PIECE EDUCATION WISE
- 55:44YOU KNOW IS GOING TO GET ACROSS
- 55:45THE FINISH LINE.
- 55:46THE SCHOOL DAYS HAS TO HAPPEN
- 55:48WHETHER IT'S WITH OR WITHOUT
- 55:50241?
- 55:50>> I THINK IT WILL.
- 55:52JUST TO GO BACK TO CLARIFY ONE
- 55:56THING, 298 PASSED OUT OF SENATE
- 55:58EDUCATION TODAY.
- 55:59AND WE'VE ALSO PASSED OUT OF
- 56:01SENATE A SCHOOL OF INNOVATION
- 56:03BILL 207.
- 56:04THAT IS AN EFFORT TO WORK ON
- 56:07LOWER PERFORMING SCHOOLS.
- 56:09>> Renee: WE'LL KEEP FOLLOWING
- 56:10IT AND YOU CAN ON KENTUCKY
- 56:13EDITION EACH WEEKNIGHT WE BREAK
- 56:14THIS DOWN AND "COMMENT ON
- 56:16KENTUCKY" WILL DO THE SAME
- 56:17FRIDAY AT 8:00 P.M. RIGHT HERE
- 56:19ON KET.
- 56:20THANK YOU FOR JOINING US.
- 56:22WE'LL TALK ABOUT THE GENERAL
- 56:24ASSEMBLY AGAIN NEXT MONDAY NIGHT
- 56:26HERE ON "KENTUCKY TONIGHT".
- 56:28TAKE GOOD CARE AND I WILL SEE
- 56:30YOU TOMORROW NIGHT.