Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP272: The Evolution of Ecommerce Replatforming - Insights & Advice Based On Project Experience
Transcript
- 0:00I see this all the time where like there's unknowns coming up
- 0:03for a project that's distracted a couple of the key people in
- 0:06the internal team. Suddenly UAT is under resourced.
- 0:09And then that's one of the big friction points because then the
- 0:11client's not happy with the UAT phase and kind of what's come
- 0:15out of that. And then the agency, you know,
- 0:18is they need to keep, they need to keep to their timeline just
- 0:22from a, you know, agency and business perspective.
- 0:26Yeah. And essentially, I mean, to be
- 0:27honest, most friction comes from this style of thing.
- 0:29It's where unknowns come up. And, you know, people don't
- 0:32really have contingency around time just because they're so
- 0:35stretched. Yeah.
- 0:37And then that's where you start to compromise or you start to
- 0:39like under deliver on the project.
- 0:42Yeah. And I'm going to be honest here,
- 0:45one of my biggest frustrations historically with with SAS Weld,
- 0:49when people are coming out of legacy, whether it's legacy SAS
- 0:53or legacy systems moving into more modern SAS tech setups, is
- 0:59there have been too many projects where timelines and
- 1:03budget have been really underestimated because there's a
- 1:07perception that there is no complexity.
- 1:09It's the platform does it, it's fine.
- 1:10As we both know, no matter how good all these platforms are,
- 1:14Shopify Centre, big commerce, Commerce, you name it, and
- 1:17they're all very good at what they do.
- 1:19You're listening to Inside Commerce, a weekly econ
- 1:21strategy, technology and CX focus podcast hosted by
- 1:24experienced digital consultants and RE platform specialist James
- 1:27Goedekel Rogers. Get insights into ecom strategy,
- 1:29leading brands, hear from industry thought leaders and
- 1:31leading tech vendors with practical advice to help you
- 1:34improve your online CX. This episode is sponsored by
- 1:39Shopify. We're focusing on, we're coming
- 1:43back to our roots, actually, there's this podcast usually
- 1:45called RE Platform, where we focus quite extensively around
- 1:48re platform, technology selection, technology change.
- 1:52And we're coming back to this point though, because actually
- 1:55the market's moved on. Quite, Vince.
- 1:56Since we launched the podcast in 2019, the environment around
- 2:00which technology change happens has shifted.
- 2:03There is a kind of a greater emphasis around strategic
- 2:06decision making rather than tactical replacement of tech.
- 2:08And that's had an impact on how projects run and the
- 2:11considerations people need to think about when planning for
- 2:13the project. So we thought it'd be a really
- 2:15good idea now to start 2025. We know that there are several
- 2:19businesses, whether it's SMEs or large enterprises who are going
- 2:22to consider their tech stack this year and some advice and
- 2:25pointers around key considerations due to the shift
- 2:29in the market. So it's just myself and Paul
- 2:32today. Paul is joining us from New
- 2:34York. Is it NRF you're out there for?
- 2:36I can never remember. Yeah, yeah, yeah, NRF and
- 2:39meeting a few clients. I am also in the middle of we
- 2:42work because the booths are all visit.
- 2:44So hopefully the sound will be fine, but there is a slight risk
- 2:47and if that does up large midwife, yeah.
- 2:51Yeah, but if you hear screaming in the background, it's not
- 2:53crazy lunatics, it's just the rest of Paul's team of Avant
- 2:55being animated in a we work. So have I set that up well
- 3:00enough? Paul, anything else you wanted
- 3:01to add About what why we're talking about this today?
- 3:04No, I think, I think that's it. And I think we obviously talked
- 3:07a bit before we start recording. I think we've both got different
- 3:09views on like why, why the kind of process has changed so much,
- 3:13why the kind of buying or how people buy software has changed
- 3:17a lot. Yeah.
- 3:20And I think, you know, we've probably recorded really similar
- 3:22episodes like four years ago, and I think that would be
- 3:25completely different. So no, I think that I completely
- 3:28agree. Right.
- 3:30Let's, let's let me, let me do my first point and then you can
- 3:33build on this because we, we've talked a lot about how our roles
- 3:36potentially in projects are changing and, and the type of
- 3:38businesses that bring us in and and the type of projects we get
- 3:41involved in. And I think if you go back to
- 3:442019 when we first started, it was quite traditional for
- 3:47businesses to go to a independent agency consultancy
- 3:51like tech Specialists and bring them in to help them do
- 3:55technology evaluation to look at which platforms might be right,
- 3:58why etcetera. And whilst that still happens,
- 4:01it doesn't happen to the same cadence as it used to.
- 4:05And the projects that used to be about Company A is on Salesforce
- 4:10and Magento Hybris, whichever platform and the, and the
- 4:13business wants to change its e-commerce platform because
- 4:16either the cotton was not right or the functionality is not fit
- 4:18for purpose or the upgrade path is just prohibited.
- 4:22Actually now we're seeing the market mature a bit to having a
- 4:26more strategic lens on technology change and not just
- 4:29looking at, OK, how do we pivot out Hybris for Salesforce?
- 4:33Yeah, Hybris for Shopify, Hybris a big comet, but actually we
- 4:37want to change and we've got operational needs and we've got
- 4:40business need, technical needs. What is the right architectural
- 4:43vision and strategic architectural and systems
- 4:46direction for us as a business And where does E com fit in that
- 4:50road map and E com platform is not always the driver for
- 4:53change. So that's what I'm seeing, which
- 4:55is why I think that the the markets evolved and change.
- 4:57Do you want to do you want to riff on that?
- 4:58Like what? What?
- 4:59What are you seeing from your side?
- 5:01Well, I think that I completely agree.
- 5:03I think the other thing is if we think about it, because I guess
- 5:08I think back, you know, take a look at it four years ago, so
- 5:11roughly when we started the podcast 1, I think that was
- 5:15probably less of a dominant player than there is for the.
- 5:19I mean the other thing I would say is we're largely talking
- 5:22about mid market brands. I think it'd probably be
- 5:25slightly different in B2B or even like you know, super
- 5:28enterprise FMCG world. But I think there's probably
- 5:32there's probably less of a dominant player.
- 5:34There was more bespoke development in a project and
- 5:37more customisation and more complexity.
- 5:41Whereas now I think a lot of the time, you know, people are
- 5:45buying a SAS product and a number of other SAS products
- 5:47around that and they're kind of flying into an ecosystem.
- 5:51And I also think that the platforms are maybe a little bit
- 5:54more mainstream than the folks. I think historically.
- 5:58And actually I think a lot of this is a lot.
- 6:00I think procurement in general around digital has probably
- 6:03evolved quite a lot. And what we were talking about
- 6:07four years ago, you know, you'd probably have a head of an IT,
- 6:10an IT director or someone maybe more technical that we'd be
- 6:14leading this project. And, you know, they'd probably
- 6:18go straight to a consultant. And I think, you know, the first
- 6:20point of call was, OK, we need someone that's agnostic.
- 6:23We'll just understand some market and, you know, has like
- 6:26APA capability to really, yeah, understand our business, our
- 6:30requirements, where we're going, and then kind of map out the
- 6:33technical side and then start a kind of RFIRFP process.
- 6:38Whereas now it feels like a lot of the projects are led by
- 6:41business users and there's more consideration around.
- 6:46I think there's just less consideration and maybe less
- 6:48risk from a technical perspective a lot of the time,
- 6:52which is then leading to a different level of conversation
- 6:56and it is more around kind of business requirements than
- 7:00technical requirements. So I think some of it's and the
- 7:03other thing I would say is that agencies got significantly
- 7:06stronger in this area and like the level of conversation
- 7:09certain agents now. So back in the day, I think the
- 7:11SIS would typically understand, let's say Magenta, who would
- 7:15understand which entering inside out, but they wouldn't have any
- 7:17knowledge at all of the other players in the market.
- 7:21And they're probably be more technical than business.
- 7:24Whereas now I feel like it's a bit more balanced with the
- 7:27agencies and they're maybe a bit more strategic.
- 7:29I think the platforms have got way stronger pre sales.
- 7:32So they're willing to like absorb some of the effort around
- 7:36that kind of Viva piece I talked about earlier.
- 7:41Yeah. But I mean, yeah, I would still
- 7:43say, I mean, I do still think there's a lot of like change
- 7:45management needed and a lot of, I still think there's a really
- 7:48important role for like independent inputs.
- 7:51And I think there's a lot of risk when you don't have that
- 7:56level of like independent due diligence.
- 7:58However, I think it's probably not needed as much as it was
- 8:02four years ago. Yeah, I think the, the, the term
- 8:05ecosystem is the critical one here.
- 8:07That's what I'm seeing a lot more of is that people are
- 8:08thinking about ecosystem, not just platform.
- 8:11And you're right the the other point.
- 8:13So the agency bit there, there's been a a rapid growth in multi
- 8:17platform agencies. And I don't think this is just
- 8:20what Shopify's done, although it has led to some agencies who
- 8:24used to be maybe a Magento specialist, then also do Magento
- 8:27plus Shopify. You've got agencies who were
- 8:31previously like only big commerce only had big commerce
- 8:33to Shopify. He was Shopify only doing cross
- 8:35multiple. And within that you have to have
- 8:38greater internal technical consultancy capability because
- 8:42there's knowledge transfers that are required.
- 8:45And there's the the lens of how you solve problems that were
- 8:49done in one platform particular way and bring them into a new
- 8:51data model and a new a new like way of managing theme.
- 8:55So I think that inevitably has therefore led to more people
- 9:00going to an agency to select technology.
- 9:04And I've actually recommended this.
- 9:05I mean, I've recommended like agencies that we both know well
- 9:09who are multi agency, whether that's a base 48 or GPMD, you
- 9:13know, friends at line shop. There are a lot of people out
- 9:16there who do this to say actually, do you know what the
- 9:18the nature of this project means?
- 9:19You don't need a specialist consultant on top to do the core
- 9:23of it, but you can use them tactically.
- 9:26So the market is changing and evolving, but I think ecosystems
- 9:30are growing because that that leads us on quite nicely into
- 9:32our next point, which is about I personally think that even
- 9:36though I know you've said about you can do leaner projects in
- 9:39some ways, because of the the, the nature of the modern tech,
- 9:42especially like SAS world where you have lots of pre-existing
- 9:45integrations. We're not building out loads of
- 9:47integrations from scratch. Actually, I'm seeing this shift
- 9:52in project management demands in these projects because I think
- 9:56maybe Shopify big commerce is a while back when people were
- 9:59looking at just putting in SAS didn't have as many additional
- 10:04third parties involved in the mix as such a plethora of third
- 10:08party integrations now and all these stats, most of the
- 10:11business I work with now, it involves re evaluating that
- 10:14wider tech stack around E com at the same time and going right,
- 10:17OK, we've got 12 third parties. We're not just going to assume
- 10:20we're keeping these because some might not integrate well the new
- 10:23platform, some might integrate well, but actually they're not
- 10:26best in class in that ecosystem and there are better options and
- 10:29more modern. So I'm seeing an increase in a
- 10:31lot of projects I'm actually seeing, whereas previously
- 10:34people go, right, let's strip out numbers.
- 10:36I'm seeing increased number of dependency, which is not an
- 10:40issue. It just means that from a
- 10:42project management point of view, timeline planning can
- 10:43become harder because you've got to think about the stage gates
- 10:46of when one person's work is holding up the start of another
- 10:51work stream. So I do think it it's shifting
- 10:54the challenges in project management.
- 10:57Yeah. So I mean, I think, I think that
- 10:59was part of the project has changed quite a lot as well.
- 11:01Like again, if we go back to like some fairly big projects,
- 11:04four or five years ago, if you talked about project management,
- 11:07you would be talking about a hardcore project manager with,
- 11:11you know, a specific focus on like Agile or waterfall,
- 11:16entirely focused on delivery. Whereas now I think you're
- 11:20obviously project managed quite a few builds and I think the
- 11:24project managers and not traditional, you know, delivery
- 11:28focused people that people that understand E com like, you know,
- 11:32they can input to solutions and to business requirements,
- 11:34whatever else. And I think the thing that even
- 11:37after what you just said there, I think the risk is when you go
- 11:39really lean on a project that you're not really capitalizing
- 11:43on the opportunity to like rebuild everything and get the
- 11:46most out of all the third parties you're buying.
- 11:48So I think one of the reasons why I think, and I think the
- 11:52other thing is some projects, you might have had four
- 11:54independents in the past and now you've got one.
- 11:56But in my opinion, bringing in a a third party project manager or
- 12:01someone to like overlook or govern the project just gives
- 12:05you more time to get more out of the project as well.
- 12:07So there's like the de risking side, you know, having someone
- 12:10that's done it lots and lots of times.
- 12:12But there's also, you know, if you're pulling it, if let's just
- 12:15say as an example, right, you're moving to Shopify and you, you
- 12:18know, get rid of a dynamic yield and you move to a
- 12:21personalisation platform within Shopify.
- 12:24If your, you know, internal team is entirely focused on the
- 12:27migration, it's very unlikely they're going to have the time
- 12:30to like implement that personalisation vendor
- 12:33particularly well. And then as soon as you finish
- 12:35the the project, you're, you know, completely back into BAU
- 12:38and you've got all the other distractions.
- 12:40And I think for me, you're like getting the most out of these
- 12:43projects can actually add like shed loads of value.
- 12:46You're actually having resource to like, yeah, make sure you
- 12:49like really do get the most out of that change because it's
- 12:52unlikely you're going to have that opportunity again where
- 12:54you've got that much like focus on yeah, technology.
- 12:59Yeah, I think that's a really good point and that resonates
- 13:02with a few of the projects I work on.
- 13:03We're going to come back to this, but I don't describe it as
- 13:05project management. I describe it as customer lead
- 13:07role, which is a more ecom strategic lens focus than peer
- 13:11PM. Because now unless you're a big
- 13:14enterprise, unless you're an enterprise level where you
- 13:16fundamentally need a project management office within your
- 13:18business to be a counterpart to the PMO that's in the BSIA lot
- 13:24of SME projects, you don't need a full time PM unless there are
- 13:29other projects within like maybe there's ERPS and stuff and you
- 13:32have a project manager because the ecom bit is one part of a
- 13:35wider program. But actually it is, it's the
- 13:40it's the customer lead role. I think that that is becoming
- 13:43more and more critical because it's hard unless you can second
- 13:48somebody in a business to take over this responsibility and
- 13:52that it's not going to impact materially other parts of the
- 13:54business from them dropping off their day-to-day.
- 13:57You need a, you need a customer lead to be the counter, the
- 14:00conduit between agency and client.
- 14:03And actually the, the complexity from a development point of view
- 14:07in some respects has reduced significantly because there's
- 14:09less hardcore integration work going on now, because modern
- 14:13platforms have more integrations pre built with third parties,
- 14:16which all the data flows are pretty much pre done.
- 14:19There's a lot of configuration work and there's themed of them
- 14:21at work. But actually you're not starting
- 14:23from base, you're you you've got 80% of it done.
- 14:27What you then get, as you just teased out is you've got set up
- 14:31work and you've got the UX piece to think about because it's OK,
- 14:35Well, you've got personalisation engine.
- 14:37OK, great. OK, how's that working?
- 14:39On what pages, what the rules, what product data do we need to
- 14:43have right and set up that's going to be fuelling this?
- 14:45Have we thought this through? And without, with a cut, without
- 14:48with a project manager, a project manager will get
- 14:49something done, but they won't be the have the e-commerce
- 14:52expertise to start questioning garage.
- 14:55There are the 20 tasks are precursors to this launch
- 14:58because they are strategic or tactical or merchandising based
- 15:02in order to get the right set up in order for this product to
- 15:05work effectively and deliver results.
- 15:07So I'm seeing a lot, there's a lot and people underestimate
- 15:10this. The the day-to-day effort to get
- 15:12this all set up across every facet of a new store launched is
- 15:16quite significant. Yeah, I completely agree.
- 15:21Yeah. I think it's just, I guess a lot
- 15:23of it's more resourcing and like again change on that side.
- 15:28Yeah, it is. It's about, it's about the type
- 15:31of resource you need. And this, This is why we wanted
- 15:33to do this episode, because it doesn't mean that the whole
- 15:35world's changed. It's just how you execute
- 15:37delivering projects and the type of skill set you need to get
- 15:40your racy properly mapped out is shifting.
- 15:43And I mean, I've got an example at the moment, the project where
- 15:45we're doing, you know, it's not a massive, it's not a massive
- 15:49site. It's only got about 400 SKUs.
- 15:52That's 2020 million plus business.
- 15:55But it's subscriptions is a part of it.
- 15:58And alongside a platform move, there's actually going to be a
- 16:04subscription engine move. And the reason for doing that is
- 16:07because there's many reasons, commercial functionality,
- 16:10integration, capability, simplicity.
- 16:12But actually all of a sudden you then realise what the knock on
- 16:15implications are that because you've now got more third
- 16:18parties involved, because you're now doing a subscription on top
- 16:21of the platform, then you've got the payments fees and you've got
- 16:24two different payments third parties involved.
- 16:27And then you've got to think about what the impact that has
- 16:30from a existing customer point of EC.
- 16:32You've got to have the customer care lens.
- 16:34Then you've got to think about like the, the, the management of
- 16:37issues and errors and how you factor there.
- 16:39And then you suddenly realise all these extra tasks a tumble
- 16:42out of not just changing a platform, but changing a third
- 16:45party alongside the platform. And if you don't have the the
- 16:49lead role internally to go alongside the PM at the SI, what
- 16:55you find is the SI have a really well structured product plan,
- 16:58but you don't have, you haven't given the inputs for them to
- 17:01make sure that the Sprint plans have got the right level of
- 17:03tasks aligned to it and that you're delivering as and when
- 17:06needed for them to hit their milestones.
- 17:10Yeah, great. I think the other thing is it's,
- 17:12it's about the alignment as well because if you if they're a
- 17:15task, if they're like big parts of the project that aren't
- 17:17resource proxy. So you just mentioned finance
- 17:20and payments BM one. Yeah, it might you haven't
- 17:23planned a subscription migration well enough.
- 17:25So that could be another one and you just end up with these like
- 17:28time phase of needing to assign additional time for those
- 17:31errors. And then you're not aligned with
- 17:33phases against the agency phase of what you just said.
- 17:36But the next point I think is a really good example where I see
- 17:39this all the time where like there's unknowns come up for a
- 17:42project that's distracted a couple of the key people in the
- 17:45internal team. Suddenly UAT is under resourced.
- 17:48And then that's one of the big friction points because then the
- 17:50clients not happy with the UAT phase and kind of what's come
- 17:54out of that. And then the agency, you know,
- 17:56is they need to keep, they need to keep to their timeline just
- 18:01from a, you know, agency and business perspective.
- 18:05Yeah. And essentially, I mean, to be
- 18:06honest, most friction comes from this style of thing.
- 18:08It's where unknowns come up. And, you know, people don't
- 18:11really have contingency around time just because they're so
- 18:14stretched. Yeah.
- 18:16And then that's where you start to compromise or you start to
- 18:18like under deliver on the project.
- 18:21Yeah. And.
- 18:23I'm going to be honest here, one of my biggest frustrations
- 18:25historically with with SAS Weld when people are coming out of
- 18:29legacy, whether it's legacy SAS like legacy systems moving into
- 18:34more modern SAS tech setups, is there have been too many
- 18:39projects where timelines and budget have been really
- 18:43underestimated because they there's a perception there is no
- 18:47complexity. It's the platform does it, it's
- 18:49fine. As I, we both know, no matter
- 18:51how good all these platforms are, Shopify centre, big
- 18:54commerce, commerce, say you name it, and they're all very good at
- 18:56what they do. No platforms perfect.
- 18:59And and just because it's SAS and you've got like, you know,
- 19:03the hosting, the application support, don't you don't have to
- 19:05worry about that doesn't mean there aren't going to be things
- 19:07coming out the woodwork where you go, shit, that doesn't work
- 19:10how we expected. We've got to either do some
- 19:12additional coding or we've got to find a different third party
- 19:14and plug in and do some, you know, more QA work and more UAT.
- 19:17So I think we're seeing as well a bit more maturity now in that
- 19:21space of adding buffer into project.
- 19:24I'm working with a couple of agencies at the moment I think
- 19:25are really, really good at doing this because they know that
- 19:28these dependencies bring risk and we're spending more time and
- 19:32you know, risk charters like you go back for four years in in
- 19:36true like modern SAS platform, how effective are the risk
- 19:39charters that people are building out dumb agencies grave
- 19:41a lot. It's very light level, very
- 19:43powdery. Now there's greater detail and
- 19:46rigour going into this and I think, I think merchants listen,
- 19:49need to understand this. As I you know, there are
- 19:52elements that get de risked but you get new risks added in by
- 19:54taking a different approach to technology.
- 19:57Yeah, completely. OK, I did have a point there,
- 20:00but I completely forgot what I was going to say.
- 20:02Very annoying. It will come back to you mate in
- 20:04a moment of inspiration. Did I trigger you on risk?
- 20:08Because it's it's sick. I know how excited you get
- 20:10talking about. Risk.
- 20:11No, that was it. I've remembered.
- 20:13No, I think it's, I think if like to be honest, I think this
- 20:15is a Shopify thing. Like I could say the SAS
- 20:18platform is very much a Shopify thing.
- 20:21I think there's a temptation in Shopify world because there's so
- 20:23many high profile projects that have been delivered really
- 20:26quickly. I think there's a temptation to
- 20:29rather than invest time and building some invest in class to
- 20:32try and deliver the full migration within 8 weeks.
- 20:36And that is a bit of a just, I think like you say, the shop.
- 20:39Buy world matured. A lot over the last 18 months,
- 20:42there's still a lot of like that kind of thinking around.
- 20:47Yeah. And yeah, it's not usually
- 20:48there's not even really a commercial rationale for it.
- 20:51It's more than just that. People just associate the SAS
- 20:55migrations and Shopify migrations with, you know, let's
- 20:57just do it quickly, whereas actually you can invest more
- 21:01time in the design phase or yeah, more time and you getting
- 21:04the most out of the build phase. Yeah.
- 21:08And there's, you know, inevitably there's a strong PR
- 21:11angle to a story of saying we managed to launch a site in 812
- 21:15weeks and migrate this many SKUs etcetera.
- 21:18And that can't be underestimated.
- 21:19But but yeah, I'm with you on this.
- 21:21I mean, I am naturally a, a cautious person in projects
- 21:24because I see what happens when you you run at pace and you try
- 21:29and there's, there's a classic, classic like triangle in terms
- 21:32of like speed, speed to market, scope cost and you have to trade
- 21:39off on something. If you go as fast as you can, it
- 21:40impacts either scope or cost, essentially both.
- 21:44You know, if you try and have the best scope possible, then it
- 21:46obviously impacts your speed to market.
- 21:49So you can't have everything and there's always an impact and a
- 21:53compromise. And I would rather err on the
- 21:55side. And I've always worked with
- 21:56clients to say, look, you need to put more time in for Uati
- 21:59think you must see UAT surprises people that even on a recent
- 22:03project I had actually because we're trying to hit a deadline,
- 22:06the we got our approach UAT slightly wrong and we let more
- 22:10stuff come out of QA that shouldn't have done if we been a
- 22:14little bit more tightly controlled on it.
- 22:16And even having done these projects time and time again,
- 22:18you the faster you work, you will always find issues coming
- 22:22out the woodwork. Yeah, I completely agree.
- 22:27And I think the other thing is, is like UAT is not just one
- 22:30round of testing, you've also got the remediation work, you've
- 22:33got retest. Like I think, yeah, it's very
- 22:35easy to, yeah, just not manage that well and end up with, yeah,
- 22:41I guess delays or, again, friction or like misalignment
- 22:45off the back of that face. Yeah.
- 22:48And this is where this is where I again, I think the customer
- 22:51lead role is really important because and it's something that
- 22:53I believe really strongly and is, you know, agencies are
- 22:57brilliant at doing QA work. They'll you know, some agencies
- 23:01are better than those visual QA were on top of the like the
- 23:04technical QA. But it will always, there will
- 23:07always be things that a that a non e-commerce specialist won't
- 23:11spot and having a buffer between the client team and the agency
- 23:16to to have pre UATUAT. So QA in the UAT to look at it
- 23:22and go, that's not right. That shouldn't do this or that
- 23:25user journey isn't quite right. You know, that's not going to
- 23:27learn and being able to do that and have a couple of weeks where
- 23:31you can do that to align with a a within a Sprint free prior to
- 23:36release for full UAT of stakeholders is massively
- 23:39beneficial. And it's about having the right
- 23:41mindset in the project that goes, yes, it's functionally
- 23:44great, but it this doesn't look how it should do.
- 23:46And this is way off brand. And do you know, actually we're
- 23:49missing a core, a core element of this, even though it's past
- 23:53unit testing, actually from an econ point of view, it has to do
- 23:57AB and C And you see us and search a lot like on site search
- 24:00experiences. So I think that This is why I
- 24:03keep banging on to people about customer lead roles.
- 24:04And you don't have to pay an external specialist.
- 24:07You can have somebody internal as long as you've got the
- 24:10resource bandwidth to absorb it. Yeah, yeah, I completely agree.
- 24:17How do you have interest, the people you work with, how do
- 24:19they approach this type of RAM? I mean, it's my customer leads,
- 24:22my terminology, other people call it different things.
- 24:24How many of them? How many of them appoint someone
- 24:27internally versus how many then get an external?
- 24:30To be personally honest, I think it varies so much.
- 24:32I I've not really heard anyone else call it customer lead.
- 24:35I think usually it'll be something need or just lead I'd
- 24:39say. But yeah, I'd say it's complete,
- 24:41complete mix. And the other thing is I think
- 24:43sometimes quite often you'll have someone internally as the
- 24:46lead and then they'll supplement maybe gaps in their knowledge or
- 24:49experience with inputs. So I still see a lot of projects
- 24:52where might be that they would bring in resource purely for
- 24:56testing or yeah, purely for certain areas.
- 25:00So maybe like not just implementation, but delivery of
- 25:03like tracking and analytics for example.
- 25:06But I'd say most of the time it'll be internal or external or
- 25:10a combination of both. I think that's the other thing
- 25:12is, yeah, like we're working on a project at the minute and
- 25:16Shams working as the lead, but they've got an internal lead as
- 25:20well because there's a number of things that are very like
- 25:23nuanced about their internal business, particularly from a
- 25:26back office perspective. And like, yeah, they they just
- 25:29feel more comfortable having someone in that role internally.
- 25:33And again, it's a fast project. So the reason that we're
- 25:36involved is just because they want to de risk the fact that
- 25:40it's a fast project a little bit.
- 25:42But yeah, I would say it's complete mix to be perfectly
- 25:45honest. I don't know if you were great.
- 25:47No, I do. I think it's a lot of it depends
- 25:50on size of business and the extent of the team.
- 25:52Because if if you're a false growth econ team, you only got
- 25:56two people in your within the internal team trying to succumb
- 25:59one of them for at least 50 and it has to be at least 50%.
- 26:03Because on a project there's so many day-to-day tasks and they
- 26:06ramp up the near you get to UAT and pre launch.
- 26:09And for a lot of businesses, they don't have the luxury of
- 26:10being able to give somebody 50% of their time or more because of
- 26:14the material impact on the trading and the site.
- 26:15So I often find that though, those are the businesses that
- 26:19they either take the hit and accept that there's going to be
- 26:22some, some bumps and they rely on the PM at the SI or they will
- 26:27bring in an external person. And then it'll be a real mix
- 26:30between those who just want to APM.
- 26:34And I've seen people go for APM when they've got multiple
- 26:36streams running concurrently. Like maybe there's, I've seen
- 26:39this where someone's got like a, whether it's, I think it's a
- 26:41NetSuite and there's, there's work going on at the next suite
- 26:45level as well that has a dependency on E Com.
- 26:48And then you've got the E Com and they might even have another
- 26:50one. So they bring in then APMA true
- 26:52traditional PM makes sense because you're getting into
- 26:55project program management and that's not an e-commerce
- 26:59strategist customer person is not so well versed in the PMO
- 27:03disciplines around those, those stream concurrency.
- 27:07Whereas if it's purely about get the E Com delivered to the best
- 27:09standard and fight our corner to protect our best interests so we
- 27:13make the right decisions, then I think that's when the, the, the
- 27:16external customer league can really help.
- 27:20So this leads us on to the commercials bit.
- 27:23And my, one of my big bug bears has always been that TCO models
- 27:28tend to be completely undercooked and do not have
- 27:30nearly enough detail and don't have enough stress test in those
- 27:33scenarios. And the, the two bits I'm going
- 27:35to draw out are where I, I think things have changed and where
- 27:38people have to fundamentally change their approach to this is
- 27:41when you, when you launch, you have to understand there's dual
- 27:47running, but you have to understand the timings of when
- 27:50license fees are going to start being incurred.
- 27:52Because you don't just incur a license when you're in live
- 27:54production and selling. You incur a license when you
- 27:57need, when you're spinning up environments and you're using
- 27:59the software. And that's the standard SAS
- 28:02model. So the negotiations around
- 28:05licensing are a little bit different these days about yes,
- 28:08you'll, some vendors you can get a, you can negotiate the actual
- 28:13license cost rate. Others you can tap into a
- 28:17promotional offer where you get X month 3, but there will be a
- 28:21cost at some point prior to launch.
- 28:24And I've seen too many models where people go right, we've got
- 28:26a straight cut over and you're like, no, no, no, you're under
- 28:29cooking your costs to your your CFO.
- 28:33Yeah, completely, Gracie, that all the time.
- 28:34The other thing that I think comes from experience is a lot
- 28:37of the time there's SAS vendors, there's room to negotiate and
- 28:40even to be honest with like the platforms.
- 28:44Yeah. So I think that's usually a
- 28:45really nice little area where I completely agree that yeah,
- 28:49people start the costs from the build.
- 28:52The other thing is depending on which vendors you're using, you
- 28:54might have professional services costs that people don't consider
- 28:57as well. Yeah.
- 29:00And the other thing and like to be honest in there's so many
- 29:03little variables in that world that I just think there's
- 29:06typically a gap on. So like the other one maybe less
- 29:09so now. But in Shopify world where you
- 29:11have multiple expansion stores, there's usually, you know, some
- 29:15overhead as a result of using apps across multiple expansion
- 29:20stores and there's so many other little things like that.
- 29:22And the other things are like overages around like usage
- 29:27limits and stuff like that. So like, and that's quite common
- 29:30through migrations when you're doing loads of testing.
- 29:33So yeah, lots of little variables.
- 29:35I think you just, you're only really going to learn from
- 29:38failing in those areas. So it's an experience, right?
- 29:42It is and it's, you know, the phasing of cost is critical
- 29:46because you have CapEx and OpEx budgets and CF OS want to know
- 29:52when cost is landing because there will be some which is
- 29:55going to be new budgeted for like you know, cap CapEx for the
- 29:58the development and build of the site versus how your OpEx costs
- 30:02are going to flow across the next few years.
- 30:05And there's going to be certain times when a cost line that
- 30:09you've currently got is removed and it might not be replaced
- 30:12because you've got some efficiency in your build, like
- 30:14you know, you've taken out a third party because you no
- 30:16longer need it, because it's, it's handled in the new
- 30:19platform. Then you've got others where
- 30:21you're adding costs in and what I've seen is too many times
- 30:24where like the app fees and you're right how they scale.
- 30:28So somebody might have put in a budget that OK, we're we're on,
- 30:31we're on the premium plan. Great.
- 30:33That's $200 a month without realising that they're they're
- 30:37about, you know, 100 grand a month away from tipping into
- 30:42enterprise, which is going to be exponentially more.
- 30:45And then you realise that if if you make those decisions wrong
- 30:48and you haven't looked at your growth metrics and then put the
- 30:51right formulas in to to set these to escalate over the
- 30:54years, you can undercook by 10s of thousands per annum
- 30:58eventually when you're going across 10-15 different app
- 31:01providers or third parties. Yeah, absolutely.
- 31:07What else, what else are you seeing in in, in changes to to
- 31:11like commercials at what impact you seeing people in terms of
- 31:14how they approach commercial negotiations?
- 31:18Yeah, good question. I mean, I think at the moment
- 31:24there, I think there's a lot of vendors that are very, I think
- 31:29there's a lot of new entrants into some of the platforms that
- 31:33we work with ecosystems and they're very, very expensive.
- 31:38And then maybe it's almost like slightly different scale of cost
- 31:42to some of the obvious like players that are in the market.
- 31:46And I feel like a lot of those guys are coming in with really
- 31:49they're, you know, they're very mature from a sales perspective
- 31:52and maybe they're they're going in with a list price, but
- 31:56there's a lot of room for POC and a lot of room for them to
- 32:00come down market. But I think that the big trend
- 32:02there, it's not really anything new.
- 32:04It's more just that I think there's a lot of enterprise
- 32:06vendors coming into the Shopify space.
- 32:08It's probably where I'm going with it.
- 32:10I'm a little bit in central as well.
- 32:11And some of the others. Yeah.
- 32:14And I think it typically, I think it's hard for some of
- 32:18those vendors to represent clear value for money because of the
- 32:22low costs in our ecosystem. Yeah.
- 32:27But I think the big thing is that, you know, people want to
- 32:29use them. And, you know, I could put
- 32:31content square in that bracket. I could put dynamic yield in
- 32:33that bracket. Loads of.
- 32:36Yeah. I think it's just a slightly
- 32:37different kind of quote that people are used to or like
- 32:42scale, of course, that people are used to.
- 32:44But yeah. And that would be the only trend
- 32:46I'd say that I've seen at the moment on that side.
- 32:51Yeah, I think, I can't really think of anything else.
- 32:56I think for me the, the, the biggest shift I'm seeing is, is
- 33:00the need to factor time in amongst the whoever the
- 33:04commercial procurement leads are in your business for contract
- 33:08reviews and contract negotiations.
- 33:10Because often you'll find that you need to do 2 or 3 or even 4
- 33:15rather than just the single one for your e-commerce platform.
- 33:19And I have given people the heads up that their other
- 33:22changes are coming and then looking at the current contract
- 33:25end date and looking at when you'll be starting the new
- 33:28contract with the new provider and looking at what the gaps
- 33:30are. Because sometimes you find
- 33:32you're out of contract, but you're not launching for another
- 33:34three months. You now need to have an interim
- 33:36agreement with that existing third party to cover you and
- 33:39give you some buffer so that if your launch is delayed, you're
- 33:42not only going to have a cut off service that's going to material
- 33:45impact customers or going to screw up your ability to trade.
- 33:49Yeah, and you're right. Why don't you?
- 33:50It's not new, but I think I'm saying I think there's more need
- 33:54now in in in projects to think this through more detail.
- 33:58Yeah, absolutely. And I think the only, the only
- 34:00other thing I was going to say, I've seen a few of our clients
- 34:02get stung with contract lamp and I so this is rare nowadays.
- 34:07Like a lot of the modern vendors who are starting from, you know,
- 34:10really kind of bootstrap start up are way more flexible and you
- 34:16know, I think they're a lot more confident in their product
- 34:19maybe. But the enterprise vendors, you
- 34:22know, when they're going to people putting the list price in
- 34:24front of you and then bringing it down alongside a three-year
- 34:27contract, I just don't think anyone unless, you know, it's a
- 34:30platform that you're really happy to invest in and like
- 34:33commit to. I don't think anyone should be
- 34:35shining three-year contracts, particularly with like CRM
- 34:39products and yeah, vendors that you know that that could be
- 34:44reasoning to move and you know, you're heavily reliant on
- 34:47support levels and things like that.
- 34:49So I think that's still something where some of our
- 34:51clients are particularly unhappy of a vendor.
- 34:53They've still got two years left on that agreement.
- 34:56I think that's something that we shouldn't do today.
- 35:01Cool. So that's I think I wrapped up
- 35:03quite nicely. So the, the aim of this was just
- 35:05to do a stock take of how things have have been evolving in the
- 35:09tech selection market and in the like project approaches, things
- 35:15to look out for. And I think the key, I guess my
- 35:16key takeaways, but would be is that is that actually now it's
- 35:23more about ecosystem. As you said, that's the perfect
- 35:26word, not just econ platform to take the time internally to
- 35:31assess what it is you're trying to change and achieve.
- 35:34So you've got a clear articulation of that prior to
- 35:36engaging with any offenders because you've got to scrutinize
- 35:39the impact on ecosystem, not just on platform removal and
- 35:42replacement. And you can sometimes be be
- 35:46sidelined by a complexity you hadn't thought about.
- 35:49If you only look at the platform and not the ecosystem, then it's
- 35:53the actually technical discovery, which has always been
- 35:57important. It's, it can't always be done in
- 36:00a couple of weeks, which I know some, some businesses try and
- 36:04rush it through. Often you need to take the time
- 36:06and often you need multiple phases.
- 36:07Discovery, it's really teased. I did one recently where we did
- 36:10one main round of technical discovery to get to a platform
- 36:12decision and then a second round to validate some of the
- 36:15assumptions that needed a more deep dive with their IT team to
- 36:18get into some of the data processes behind the scenes and
- 36:21some of the other integration. So technical discoveries, it's
- 36:24just you cannot scrimp and save on it because you'll just end up
- 36:27creating even more costs later down the line.
- 36:30And then think about your project control structure.
- 36:34Do you have, do you need a proper PM?
- 36:36Because it's like proper project management office and multiple
- 36:40work streams. Do you need the customer lead
- 36:43role, the person who's got that e-commerce oversight, who can be
- 36:47your voice in the project because you don't have somebody
- 36:49in their day, say, role who can give up at least 50% of their
- 36:52time to this project? Those are my key takeaways.
- 36:55What about you? Yeah.
- 36:57I mean, I think mine's probably pretty similar.
- 37:01I think it's just a case of de risking by ensuring that you've
- 37:05got resource available all the way through the project and then
- 37:08allowing contingency original to be similar to what we said.
- 37:11But yeah, I think that would be mine.
- 37:13I I think we've probably, that's something that's probably been
- 37:16fairly consistent. I think if we did this four
- 37:18years ago, we probably would have said that exact same thing.
- 37:22And I think that's still, you know, really important for like
- 37:24any big project or change project where you're, you know,
- 37:27working across multiple teams and yeah, changing lots of kind
- 37:31of key systems. But yeah, I think that's it
- 37:34really. Cool and thanks everyone for
- 37:37listening. Hope it was useful and
- 37:39interesting. Disagree with us on anything
- 37:41brilliant. We love disagreements and that's
- 37:43how we learn. Reach out to us, do comment on
- 37:45our LinkedIn post and also let us know, you know, agencies,
- 37:49consultants, we work with a lot of you.
- 37:51How do you see these projects evolving?
- 37:54How do you see the market change and how people need to think and
- 37:57adapt in order to to cram for technology change successfully
- 38:00in 2025? Do you let us know you're
- 38:04listening to the Insidecommerce podcast?
- 38:06Hosted by experienced consultants James Gert and Paul
- 38:08Rogers, Insidecommerce is your fast tracked additional
- 38:11knowledge featuring interviews with leading e-commerce
- 38:14retailers, industry thought leads and the C-Suite key tech
- 38:16companies to explore the latest digital strategy, customer
- 38:19experience and tech. Discover what the latest trends
- 38:22really mean and get practical advice based on experience to
- 38:25help fine tune your E Comm strategy and tech stack.
- 38:28Follow us on LinkedIn and reach out to James and Paul if you'd
- 38:31like to discuss an e-commerce project.
- 38:33We hope you enjoy the latest episode.