Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / Tucker Carlson VS. Reality (with Aron Ra)
Transcript
- 0:01Understand the thinking atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol, an
- 0:09idea. The population of atheists this country is going through the rule, rejecting
- 0:14faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the truth,
- 0:20it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand on a
- 0:24book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world. Take
- 0:29the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness. Truth Usian wisdom will
- 0:33come to you that way. Assume nothing, question everything, and start thinking.
- 0:42This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Seth Andrews. We did a
- 0:57show recently on the awfulness of talk Carlson. You can find it in the
- 1:02archives. It aired last year as I went back twenty years to find soundbites,
- 1:08quotes, opinions, perspectives, and just general toxicity from this former Fox
- 1:15News prime time host who is now just running around saying awful things as a
- 1:21freelancer and on his own terms. He just did the Joe Rogan podcast and
- 1:26I had to talk about it with my brother and the Lord arn Raw,
- 1:32fellow atheist activist and an educator, specifically on well, you do a lot
- 1:37of palaeontology, I know, but Darwin's theory of evolution. Arren, hey,
- 1:42brother, and good to see you man, Thank you you too.
- 1:47I have so many I mean, you caught me on a day we were
- 1:49up all night with the storms. I'm not rested, I'm cranky, I'm
- 1:53sweary, and so I'm going to say that I am so frustrated at the
- 1:59peaceeople who just love goddamn fucking Joe Rogan. I listened to him talk to
- 2:06Tucker Carlson and it was about all kinds of crazy stuff, and he just
- 2:12he does this thing Joe does where he's like, right, oh, interesting,
- 2:16and if he pushes back, he pushes back just a dent and then
- 2:21he says nothing else. In fact, let me start with a clip as
- 2:24they began the conversation talking about UFOs and the Bible. No, it's not
- 2:31American technology well, or Russian or Chinese. It predates you know all of
- 2:38that, Well, some of it does, right, Like for sure,
- 2:40the Kenneth Arnold sightings that was really early on, that was like the nineteen
- 2:46early nineteen fifties. He was seeing these flying saucers, these discs that were
- 2:50moving over mountains. Well, right, I mean the prophet Ezekiel writes about
- 2:53it in the first chapter Wheels in the Sky. Yeah, that's a crazy
- 2:58one. Well it is crazy if you read it, it's like, oh
- 3:00wow, you know, and so not just you know the Hebrew scriptures,
- 3:06like it's all over every Vedic texts of course. So these are spiritual phenomenon.
- 3:12There's no evidence there from another planet. I mean, I think that's
- 3:15the op that's the lie, that they're from Mars. Look space. The
- 3:21atmosphere is really well monitored, right, both for military for defense reasons,
- 3:25but also because it would be nice to know when asteroids are coming. And
- 3:30there's no evidence, has never been any evidence that there are lots of these
- 3:32objects, these vehicles coming into our atmosphere from somewhere else in other planet.
- 3:37There's no evidence of that at all. H So they're from here, and
- 3:40they've been here for thousands of years, whatever they are, And it's pretty
- 3:46clear to me that there are spiritual entities whatever that means, are supernatural,
- 3:51and which is to say supernaturalis means above the natural, above the observable of
- 3:57nature, and they don't behave according to the laws of sciences as measured by
- 4:05people, you know, and they've been here for a long time, and
- 4:11there's a ton of evidence that are under the ocean and under the ground.
- 4:13So like with that fact set, what do you conclude? Lots do unpack
- 4:17arin So he's talking about the Bible and the Vedis and for thousands of years
- 4:23people have seen shit, but it can't be from outer space, but it
- 4:27is buried under the ground in the oceans. I remember when I was when
- 4:30I was a kid, when I was like twelve or thirteen, and I
- 4:33had or maybe even eleven, when I when I referenced the Bible for something
- 4:39about a shield in the sky, that somebody had seen a shield in the
- 4:42sky. I can't remember because what what translation I was even reading at that
- 4:46time. But I don't know what all of these phenomena are, or if
- 4:54in fact they are all the same thing. So I'm not going to say
- 5:00that they are extraterrestrial, nor am I going to say that they are spiritual,
- 5:04whatever that means. Yeah, because there's there is no spirit. No,
- 5:15there can be optical illusions, there could be a number of other things,
- 5:17maybe things we haven't even happened across. I would think that a lot
- 5:23of these phenomena are a mix of different things. You know, I've heard.
- 5:28My own family has given me their observations of what they called the UFOs,
- 5:31and on at least two of those occasions it turned out to be the
- 5:35northern lights. They just didn't know what the northern lights were. Okay,
- 5:42so it's awesome. No, it's awesome. Every time somebody throws a frisbee
- 5:46into the air and takes a photograph. The people who want to believe will
- 5:50believe. I am also, this is absolutely true. There is someone in
- 5:57my family, a devout biblever, who is convinced, and people are going
- 6:02to think I'm making this up, who is convinced that the UFO sightings are
- 6:06the UAP sidings are. The unidentified things are in fact spacecraft, but they
- 6:13are not carrying extra terrestrials. They are carrying or being piloted by the Nephelum
- 6:20as referenced in the Book of Genesis, right, the giants. We're talking
- 6:26about the angels who came down and fornicated with human women, and then there
- 6:30were giants around the time of Noah's ark. And she believes, this adult
- 6:34woman with a college edic of a master's degree, she believes that these spaceships
- 6:43will land Nephelm are going to come out and they are in league with the
- 6:46Catholic Church, so they and the Pope are apparently going to go and have
- 6:51a kagger and plan the apocalypse. It's just jacked up. So to hear
- 6:58somebody reference the Bible, know, the Ezekiel, to me just blows my
- 7:01mind. Well, I noticed that he said that there's when he's talking about
- 7:05that there's no evidence of transitional species, or of Darwinian mechanisms or whatever,
- 7:12or just evolution in general. But he also uses the exact same tone of
- 7:15voice when he says that there's no evidence of the different type, different possible
- 7:21natures for unidentified flying objects. You know that he was there's no evidence,
- 7:26there's no evidence of that at all. But that's that's exactly what he said
- 7:31about transitional species. So now hang on, let me make sure I'm understanding.
- 7:34Forgive me. He's saying there is no evidence that it is from out
- 7:40there, outer space, beyond our atmosphere. Yeah, so if we're if
- 7:46we're we've seen where some of these UFOs are actually photographed in space, you
- 7:51know, so I mean plenty out there and buy out there. We couldn't
- 7:56mean the entirety of the cosmos. There can be all kinds of it,
- 8:00not not intelligently designed, but you know, there can be phenomenon that produces
- 8:07lights certainly, you know, even what we perceive to be objects, the
- 8:11things that like. There was one that was recently analyzed. It was we
- 8:15talk about how it flew fantastically fast, so much faster than everything that we
- 8:20own, and then they realize that it's a forced perspective situation where the ocean
- 8:28far on the other side of this object is moving very fast because you're turning
- 8:31your camera to follow this object, and so it looks like the ocean is
- 8:35moving at this ridiculous speed, when in fact the object isn't going anywhere near
- 8:39that speed. And so if they're not all the same thing, if they
- 8:43don't require all one explanation, you know, there can be many. I
- 8:48mean, like I said, in one case, somebody mistook you know,
- 8:52the Northern lights or whatever. Who knows what object they might have been seeing.
- 8:56It could have been space de breed that they might have been photographing from
- 9:00the International Space Station or whatever. There can be optical illusion lights. There
- 9:07can be a number of different things involved. And I would say that that
- 9:09Joe Rogan was on the ball with one thing where he said that a lot
- 9:13of this could be technology that we have that maybe not even our own government
- 9:18knows all about, because if you want to keep something secret, you don't
- 9:22tell a lot of people, and you certainly wouldn't be telling a lot of
- 9:26government officials. I just love the fact that beyond the planet space agencies like
- 9:33World Space Agencies, Tucker Carlson is apparently mapped the hundreds of billions of galaxies
- 9:39in the universe to be able to just say nah, nah, absolutely,
- 9:41it's totally impossible. It must be something biblical that's buried in the ocean and
- 9:48under the ground. Do you remember where they announced the SR seventy one when
- 9:52they revealed that to the public. I do not. The SR seventy one,
- 9:56I'm guessing, is what a planeplane. It's a mock three plus byplane.
- 10:03It goes as ridiculous speed at an incredible altitude, so it's virtually undetectable,
- 10:07or was undetectable at the time that it was an operation. They didn't
- 10:11announce that to the public until the early eighties, I think, and it
- 10:16had already been in service for like twenty years they were using this thing,
- 10:20I think late in the Vietnam saga. They've had it for a while.
- 10:26So all the while that they're bragging that they're breaking the sound barrier, and
- 10:30they can. They have planes that can go faster than sound, they don't
- 10:33tell you how much faster than sound. They don't tell you that they've got
- 10:35something that rides on the edge of the orbit where that rides on the edge
- 10:39of the atmosphere and can go mock three plus and they won't even tell you
- 10:43how fast it goes. But it can cover the United States in thirty minutes,
- 10:50and they don't tell you that until it's been decommissioned, declassified or decommissioned.
- 10:56Well, it wasn't. It wasn't being used as a spyplane anymore,
- 11:01is what they're telling us. So now, at the risk of sounding paranoid,
- 11:07I'm thinking, you didn't tell us that this thing existed in the twenty
- 11:09years that it's been in operation. And now you say, well, we've
- 11:13had this thing for twenty years. We just didn't tell you. But now
- 11:16you know that this thing exists, And I'm thinking, wouldn't you have replaced
- 11:20that Oh you know yet, that secret we have something else, And like
- 11:28I said, I don't want to be paranoid about it. I just it's
- 11:30likely if they kept that secret, what's the chances that they have some other
- 11:35type of technology that they haven't announced yet. I pulled up that classic quote
- 11:39from Arthur C. Clark. Any sufficiently advanced technology is indistinguishable from magic.
- 11:48Okay, I don't want to interrupt the next thought, which is going to
- 11:52be a long win, and we'll start with a clip from Tucker Carlson explaining
- 11:54why evolution is crap, and then get are In Raw to weigh in next.
- 12:13Talking here to my buddy arn Raw, we're speaking about the April nineteenth
- 12:16interview with Tucker Carlson on the Joe Rogan podcast. He believes that all of
- 12:26those generations passed were wiser, smarter, more enlightened, even more educated than
- 12:33we are, and they rightly embraced biblical creation, whereas we went into evolution
- 12:41for which there is no evidence and science is walking away. Here's a clip.
- 12:46I don't actually think that individuals. I don't think I'm that important.
- 12:52My life is that important. I don't I will die. I know that,
- 12:54and I try to keep that in mind every day but you're important to
- 12:56everybody that cares about you. You're important to the people. But if we
- 13:00don't think, if we don't think people are important, then what do we
- 13:03think is important? I guess that's what I'm not necessarily that we don't think
- 13:05people are important. But if evolution is real, and if there is,
- 13:09this is instant, I don't know, but it's it's it's visible, like
- 13:15you can measure it in certain animals. You can measure adaptation. Yeah,
- 13:18but there's no evidence that. In fact, I think we've kind of given
- 13:22up on the idea of evolution. The theory of evolution is articulated by Darwin
- 13:24is like kind of not true and in what sense, Well, in the
- 13:30most basic sense, the idea that you know, all life emerged from a
- 13:33single cell organism and over time and there would be a fossil record of that,
- 13:37and there's not. There's not a fossil record of transitionary species like species
- 13:43that are adapting to its environments. Tons of record of adaptation, and you
- 13:48see it in your own life. I mean, I have a lot of
- 13:50dogs. I see adaptation and dogs, you know, through the shore litter
- 13:56to litter. But no, there's no evidence at all, that non zero
- 14:01that you know, people, you know, evolve seamlessly from a single cell,
- 14:05Amiba, No, there's not, there's not there's no chain in the
- 14:09fossil record of that at all. And that's why you don't actually hear people
- 14:13you hear to make reference to evolution, because the theory of adaptation is clearly
- 14:16obviously true, but Darwin's theories totally and that's why it's still a theory almost
- 14:22two hundred years later. You know, No, we have not found that
- 14:26at all, and I can't even guess. I mean, I have my
- 14:30own theories on it, but they're not proven. What are your theories?
- 14:33God created people, you know distinctly and animals? I mean, I think
- 14:37that's like, I think what every person on Earth thought until the mid nineteenth
- 14:41century actually right, But it's not a new idea. They didn't have computers,
- 14:46they didn't have a general understanding that we have today of the process.
- 14:50Do you think we understand more now? Yes? Really you don't think that
- 14:54we understand more today. They stand way less. We understand so little that
- 14:58we're actually sitting here allowing like a bunch of greedy, stupid, childless,
- 15:05childless software engineers in northern California to flirt with the extinction of mankind, so
- 15:13no previous generations would be like what, no, stop now when he's talking
- 15:18about the childless software engineers. The front part of that clip, they were
- 15:22talking about AI and how we are creating what could be a runaway I don't
- 15:28know, technology that might surpass us, become a god, wipe us out.
- 15:33I think Tucker actually suggested that we drop nuclear weapons on all the data
- 15:39centers where AI is being developed. I'm sure there won't be any literal fallout
- 15:43from that. But when he this is an example of Joe Rogan just sort
- 15:48of chuckling because he's talking about evolution Tucker and he says evolution is real.
- 15:56Tucker says, is it? Everything that Carlson said about evolution, every every
- 16:03single sentence was wrong. I mean where he says we don't have any evidence,
- 16:07where he says that there's no there's no fossil record of that. When
- 16:11he when he's just absolutely every single sentence, he said, well that's why
- 16:14it's still a theory two hundred years later. Just all of it is wrong.
- 16:18Let me tee you up to go point by point, all right,
- 16:22there's no evidence that all life, especially human life, specifically human life,
- 16:27originated from a cell, an original cell. Yeah, embryology, we all
- 16:33we you know, somebody was telling me that, one of the believers was
- 16:37telling me, you know that I didn't come from a you know, a
- 16:40single cell. I didn't come from a drop of gou And I'm like,
- 16:42really, how were you? How were you created them? Because all of
- 16:45the rest of us were formed from spermatozoa, from a zigo, from a
- 16:52drop of goo. And the guy was very confused by that. And then
- 16:56when you get into as I did my fifty part series on the systematic classification
- 17:00of life, I explained the taxonomy for human evolution. And then where I
- 17:07would throw in, okay, embryological evidence, here's genetic evidence, here's fossil
- 17:11evidence, and so on. And here's where we've pinpointed beneficial mutations and identified
- 17:18them as where exactly they are on the code on and when what this was
- 17:22a you know, this was a missense you mutation that resulted in this this
- 17:26feature, and and and and here's er vs that we share in common not
- 17:30just with other apes, but with what with the other Old world monkeys and
- 17:33so forth. I include all of this data. It's like nine and a
- 17:37half hours worth of viewing. And this is this is all the evidence that
- 17:41the Tucker Carlson says doesn't exist at all. I mean none, zero,
- 17:45And I'm doing this is a summary. This is the briefest summary I can
- 17:52give, and I don't even have a master's degree, much less a PhD.
- 17:56I'm giving you the bachelor level of the information. If you want to
- 18:02get more advanced in that, there's a fucked ton more that I didn't show
- 18:07that he's where he's talking about. That there's none. So we have overwhelming
- 18:11evidence from a whole bunch of different fields for the commonality, you know,
- 18:18like the single cell organ at least for a last universal common ancestor. I
- 18:22would say, what applies at least for eukaryots, Maybe not for the procrits,
- 18:29because evolution is by definition and ancestor descendant relationship, and with unicellular microbes
- 18:37you get a lot of horizontal gene transfer and other processes like endosymbiosis where one
- 18:42cell engulfs another and then they start working in symbiosis. There's there, and
- 18:48these are not They're not evolution in the traditional sense of being an ancestor descendant
- 18:53relationship. There's not a lineage there, nor even a branching tree pattern.
- 19:00And in fact, the branching tree that we recognize for Eukaria arises out of
- 19:06what would be better described as a as a network, like a like a
- 19:10spider web, rather than a root, if that makes any sense. But
- 19:17there's a there's a lot of complexity there, but we have we have the
- 19:19evidence to indicate that we do. What we don't have any evidence for at
- 19:25all is his creation by God. And in fact, we have a whole
- 19:30lot of evidence that the narrative that he's citing for the creation by God,
- 19:34we have evidence against that. So no evidence for it, plenty of evidence
- 19:38against it. He says that these these these extraterrestrial beings are spiritual, right
- 19:45we have we don't. It's not just that we don't have evidence of spiritual
- 19:49anythings, it's that we have substantial evidence against them, and specifically for the
- 19:56soul. I've interviewed a handful of philosophers and neuroscientists. I've interviewed Patricia Churchland
- 20:04recently to seized, Daniel Dennett, a handful of other neuroscientists, and they've
- 20:08all come to the same conclusion. Everyone that has talked to me has said
- 20:12that there's no support at all for mind body dualism, neither in philosophy nor
- 20:19in neuroscience right exactly where it would be. If such things were real,
- 20:25there would be evidence in neuroscience of it, and instead what we have is
- 20:30profound evidence to the contrary, that everything about your personality or quality, that
- 20:33the essence of what is yourself who you are, can be physically manipulated by
- 20:40drugs, by trauma, by degradation or disease, things like this. So
- 20:45there's no spirit, there's no soul, there's no magic. All of the
- 20:51combined religions together can't show that there's a there there. Not only are they
- 20:57violently at war with each other as to what each group wants to make believe,
- 21:03but they can't show that the common thing they agree on exists. They
- 21:07can't even show that that there if. I often say this that if there
- 21:11was a supernatural aspect of the universe, there would be some indication of that
- 21:19and people. So you can't. You can't ask for physical evidence of a
- 21:22supernatural thing. Yeah, you can. If magic existed, you would have
- 21:26gandolf Obi wan Hermione you know, Spock, these people would be showing that
- 21:33you can actually do a mind meld. You can actually you can actually do
- 21:37these you can demonstrate this to some reliable ways. Okay, so science can't
- 21:42explain it. Can we verify that it's there? I don't have to know
- 21:47how to explain it. It can remain completely inexplicable by science. When when
- 21:51a faith healer walks into a child a child cancer center, and then all
- 21:56of the children's children children's cancer goes into remos, and every time he walks
- 22:00in and does this, I'm going to have to concede that, Hey,
- 22:04there's a there there, that's a thing that happens. I mean, why
- 22:07is this guy only doing these tent revival things where he's breaking in the money
- 22:14from all these roubs. Why doesn't he ever actually walk into children's medical center
- 22:18and do some fucking good Why does that never happen? Was because it's not
- 22:22real? Well, you bring up a salient point that doesn't get brought up
- 22:26enough. Doctor Julian Mussolino has written a book called The Soul Fallacy, and
- 22:30he made the point that you have made. It's that the soul interacting with
- 22:37the physical would still be there would be a point of interaction there something measurable.
- 22:42The way I put it is that whenever God reaches his immaterial hand into
- 22:48the prime material plane to affect some physical change, he pulls his arm out,
- 22:52dripping with physics, you would see a physical response to some sort of
- 22:57agent that is outside side the physical It's the same reason that who was the
- 23:03gentleman who had the pipe. He had some sort of an industrial accident and
- 23:07the rod goes through his brain and it damages his brain and he begins to
- 23:12exhibit personality changes. It's because the physical brain was his essence, so to
- 23:18speak, no magic required. It's funny listening to Tucker Carlson, I was
- 23:22reminded of Christopher Hitchens talking to another Fox News host, Sean Hannity, who
- 23:29was saying the most asinine things and asking what you and I know are rude,
- 23:33aimentary questions, And he said, you give me the impression of someone
- 23:37who has never heard any position against your opinion ever, Like you sound like
- 23:42someone who has never had these conversations. So when when Tucker says, it's
- 23:48just a theory, that's why, at two hundred years later, evolution is
- 23:51just a theory I mean, come on, people are walking away. How
- 23:53would you respond, Well, Democritus proposed twenty five hundred years ago that all
- 24:03elements, all compounds, can be broken down into elements, but that the
- 24:07element can only be broken down to what he called an atom. This is
- 24:11what he theorized. That the atom is the smallest divisible element of the smallest
- 24:17indivisible part of any element that still retains the chemical properties of that element.
- 24:23So that's atomic theory, and it's still a theory thousands of years later because
- 24:33it's never been proven, because science has a rule that no theory can ever
- 24:38be proven, because if you prove something, well, then you stop looking
- 24:44into it, don't you, And you're never going to improve. You're never
- 24:47going to improve if you prove. If that makes any sense, well,
- 24:51hang on, I mean if I say that evolution has been proven, if
- 24:55I say it even in the more colloquial sense, I mean there's utility in
- 24:59that world there. I mean, it has been demonstrated, it has not
- 25:02been debunked, et cetera. The problem is this. The problem is that
- 25:07science has this definition that proof. Absolute proof only exists in mathematics, So
- 25:15absolute proof cannot exist in science. Science is not mathematics. They're closely joined.
- 25:21They work communism, but they are different disciplines. But when people are
- 25:26talking about whether it's been proven, yeah, they're not using that that term.
- 25:30They're using the colloquial thing. They're using the notion of a more.
- 25:36It's not absolute proof, it's a provisional proof. It's it's according to an
- 25:42overwhelming preponderance of evidence beyond reasonable doubt, to a point where a jury would
- 25:48would uniformly agree that, yeah, this is the If this theory is true,
- 25:52then we should see this, this and this. We actually do see
- 25:55this, this and that. So yeah, effectively that evolution has been proven,
- 26:00Einstein's relativity has been proven, and of course atomic theory had been proven
- 26:07even before Oppenheimer, even before they set off the bomb, germ theory,
- 26:11all those, Yeah, you had the cell theory of disease and all of
- 26:15that, and yeah, these remain theories, they are also facts. But
- 26:22then we have such a fundamental misunderstanding of science that people would think that a
- 26:25theory is just a guess. Like Tucker says, well, I have my
- 26:27own theories about No, those are first of all, they're not theories at
- 26:30all, because science considers that a theory is not a guess. It's a
- 26:37body of knowledge. It's a field of study. That's what a theory is.
- 26:44In my high school, for example, they taught a class in music
- 26:47theory. And I remember, just because I was an obnoxious kid, I
- 26:52through the door open one day during class. I wasn't in the class.
- 26:55I just burst into the class to interrupt them, and I said, you
- 26:57can't teach music in school just a theory. It's never been proven. You
- 27:06were that guy even as a young person, like the Seeds of Rebellion,
- 27:11and you were a contrarian even back then a little bit. Yeah, But
- 27:18I want to bring up something else that that that Tucker had mentioned when you
- 27:23mentioned that, it's like he's never talked to he's never talked to an evolutionary
- 27:29biologist. That seems evident for him to say, no evidence of that at
- 27:33all, nuns zero, right, He's clearly never spoken to anybody who knows
- 27:37dick about this subject. But then he goes on about how the left,
- 27:42because you know he has to. He says it's binary. He says everything
- 27:47is binary, and that's the problem, and he wants to divide everything between
- 27:52good and evil. So when he was talking about these the whoever is,
- 27:59who were whatever is involved in the UFOs, you know, he's just deciding
- 28:02that they're spiritual, he's decided that they're beings. These are all assumptions.
- 28:07And then he says that it's binary whether these beings are good or evil.
- 28:11Well, it's if it were that these uh, these phenomena are at the
- 28:17hands of some agent, and these are beings of whatever type, then they,
- 28:22like us, will not be binary. You know, there's this there's
- 28:27this curve. I forget that, the the I forget what it's called.
- 28:37But but you know, most people actually side right around the middle, and
- 28:41it's it's harder and harder to reach either extreme where he thinks everybody is,
- 28:47and that everybody's either at this extreme or at this extreme, when virtually nobody
- 28:52is at those extremes. They're all more or less intimately, and that you
- 28:56have to be more and more radical to get closer to the extremes where he
- 28:59thinks everybody is. So it's not a matter of being binary that it's good
- 29:03or evil. If these were beings, then like us, they're going to
- 29:07be They're going to be a mix, and they're going to have a certainly
- 29:11you know, different nuance, and we will completely agree with them on this
- 29:15point and this point, but maybe not so much that one. And maybe
- 29:18they have this completely aberrant idea over there. It's not just that the world
- 29:23is not just black or white. It's not just that there's a spec that
- 29:26there's a gray scale, there's a spectrum of color. There's so many other
- 29:32things to consider that in a binary mindset, like t Tucker keeps reverting back
- 29:37to, you can't even begin to conceive all or you consider all these things.
- 29:41So when you talked about politically, he's divided everything binary again, and
- 29:45so it's just the left versus the right. And of course it has to
- 29:48be the far right versus the far left, because we can't have moderates.
- 29:52You liberals become the same thing as leftists. And that's just the way you
- 29:56divide everything moderate right wingers, because far leftists and all of that. And
- 30:04he wants to put a category on whether whether the opposition then is good or
- 30:10evil. So of course he's decided he's good, therefore left is evil.
- 30:15And when he's talking about AI, then he's talked about how these uh,
- 30:18did these people have no problem with AI. He has a problem with AI,
- 30:22and the leftists don't have a problem with AI. I've yet to meet
- 30:26a leftist who did not have a problem with AI. Seriously, Well,
- 30:32let's say concerns, and I want to be clear, I don't I'm not
- 30:37just talking about the paranoid aspect of AI, that we've created something that is
- 30:42that is too smart to to be controlled and all like that. That could
- 30:47be a reasonable thing to worry about in the future. My issue, I
- 30:52have several other issues with AI that don't have anything to do with that.
- 30:56It's it's the way that the AI produces artworkwild you know, by by basically
- 31:02plagiarizing all these other artwork projects and piecing things together so that you can just
- 31:06have an easy cheat on the So there's an ethical thing with AI the way
- 31:11it's being implemented dealt with, and the AI that we have now is not
- 31:14even AI that people worry about, you know, there's wholly different categories there.
- 31:21Apparently all the people developing AI decided to not have families or not have
- 31:26children either. It's amazing how he apparently has surveyed she's canvassed the entire technological
- 31:33landscape to see, and those who are childless are than what I mean.
- 31:38I've got a couple of lovely step children. I don't I never parented a
- 31:42child. I qualify as child less. I guess in that way somehow that's
- 31:48supposed to diminish me, is it? Does it diminish me morally? I
- 31:52mean, I'm trying to figure out what his point is. Yeah, well,
- 31:56she doesn't want me to identify her on this, I'm sure, But
- 31:59I know somebody who was a mother of three who's working the development of AI
- 32:04and she has problems with it. She's working for the development of AI and
- 32:07she has problems with AI, as does everybody on her team, as does
- 32:13everybody that reviews her work. Everybody has a problem with AI. Well,
- 32:16I don't mean to derat we are talking evolution. I'm one of those guys
- 32:21that I have used AI tools like to partition out shows, and there have
- 32:27been some times when I couldn't find the art that I needed for something.
- 32:30I try to filter AI out of my image searches when I'm using stock images,
- 32:36but there have been times when I had no other choice and has been
- 32:38a resource. But at the same time, I feel the way you do.
- 32:44I used an AI image because somebody, the person that I was addressing,
- 32:49had used this image of based their argument on this image, and so
- 32:52I used it. And I was criticized for using their image against them because
- 32:59they use that image. I'm not promoting AI they did. I'm just showing
- 33:05you what they created that where they created this. But there's so much criticism
- 33:08about it. To say that nobody on the left has any problem with AI
- 33:13is just is myopic and stupid and wrong. There are two issues concerns that
- 33:19I have, and I don't want to become my parents, you know,
- 33:22we're like these kids today. But I don't think this falls into the same
- 33:25category. The first reason is the one that you mentioned where instead of being
- 33:30a tool for the human creation, you know, art and expression and writing
- 33:37and painting and music and all these things that I think are part of the
- 33:42human experience, and when machines replace us in that way by often plagiarizing stuff
- 33:52that has already been done and mixing it into a soup and taking the human
- 33:55element out of this wonderful form of express and I have real concerns, you
- 34:00know, I think technology should serve us, not replace us, unless it's
- 34:05a menial task. You know, they become the calculators that help us to
- 34:09do what we do more efficiently. The second thing is, I think we're
- 34:14moving so freaking fast. What's that line from Jurassic Park, right signedists,
- 34:21we're so busy doing it because they could they didn't stop to think if they
- 34:24should. I'm not sure we've stopped to assess the implications of what we're making.
- 34:30So I have another friend, my best friend of all time, was
- 34:36doing He was driving for Lyft or uber or one of these, and they're
- 34:43testing self driving cars in Phoenix, and so he's paid to not drive a
- 34:50car. He sits in the passenger seat. He's supposed to monitor everything.
- 34:54You can't. If you touch your phone at all, you get fired.
- 35:00You have to be paying attention to the road. All of that. Well,
- 35:02somebody, one of these self driving cars ran over somebody at one point,
- 35:07and the whole project gets scrapped. And they look at the driver of
- 35:15this driverless car, and at the moment that they hit that person, he
- 35:16was looking down. He wasn't looking at the road, and so the whole
- 35:21project is scrapped. Somebody got killed. That's the end of it. That's
- 35:24you know, we're not going to have self driving cars yet. You were
- 35:29an American atheist in Phoenix, you saw downtown you had that little that cab
- 35:35driving around by itself with the lie dar thing on the roof. It's exactly
- 35:37what my friend was driving or not driving. They went ahead with it anyway,
- 35:43it didn't matter. And what they did was they just took the human
- 35:46out of it. They had a human in the car that was supposed to
- 35:50prevent this from happening. The human didn't prevent it from happening, so they
- 35:52removed the human and just let the car drive around downtown by itself anyway.
- 35:58And you order the car with an app, you know, the car pulls
- 36:01up, you get in, and then it takes you where you're supposed to
- 36:06go, and all that, no driver at all. I don't know if
- 36:09I'm opposed to that. I mean, I would live in a minority report
- 36:13future where you could just make a car your living room, chill out and
- 36:16whatnot. But let me help you with this, Okay, friend, I'm
- 36:22gonna put Tucker hang on, people, I gotta put talker over here for
- 36:24another three minutes. Go ahead, go ahead. My friend is again driving
- 36:30for Uber ear lyft I get him confused whichever one it is. But that's
- 36:37because he he needs a way to make money, and the other industries that
- 36:42he was working in, it just it's easier for him to do this.
- 36:45Then the cost benefit, the travel benefit, the commute of times and all
- 36:51that, it's easier for him to do that. Now, what happens when
- 36:54he can't do that? Because he trained the machine to replace him and it
- 37:00replaced him, which is what's going to happen. So in Arizona, now
- 37:05there is a truck that's been driving from Tucson to Phoenix on it I think
- 37:08a daily route. It's doing the same thing as that light our taxi downtown
- 37:13Phoenix. It drives by myself completely. When you replace the trucking industry with
- 37:20automated trucks, and you've replaced all the cashiers with automated cash you know,
- 37:23to put the self scan thing right, how can we complain that there's not
- 37:29enough jobs when we've automated everything. When you've got forty five percent of the
- 37:34of the workforce is in you know, driving something, whether it's trucks or
- 37:38taxis or whatever's that's almost half. How can you say to go get a
- 37:45job, there's no jobs to get. So that's one of my complaints with
- 37:47automation and with a Now everyone knows what it's like when we are at a
- 37:52convention and I'm sitting at a table with a root beer and ur and is
- 37:57drinking something as thick as pens oil with a cryptic Viking name that probably has
- 38:02fire coming out of it, and we start talking and you look up and
- 38:07it's hours later. This is why. Because you put us in a room,
- 38:12you put ron in a room, and time time speeds up or slows
- 38:15down. I can't really decide, but you are just that good. Coming
- 38:22up, I'm going to talk about a biogenesis, the first cell. Right,
- 38:27there's a first cell argument, and that's where it all came from,
- 38:30including us. I'm going to talk to arn about that next. My supporters
- 38:44on Patreon get the show early and commercial free. You can sign up at
- 38:47patreon dot com. Slash Seth Andrews continuing my conversation here with arn Raw,
- 38:59I want to talk about out a biogenesis. People say there must be a
- 39:04creator because who created the first cell? It. Let's allow that everything came
- 39:10from a single cell. Who made the cell? Hence, God, how
- 39:15would you respond, well, almost every part of that is wrong too.
- 39:21That it's not that everything came from a single cell. There was never a
- 39:25point when it was just one and there was there's this there's this vast gray
- 39:32period as to whether these these first cells are alive or not. Because we've
- 39:40got these precursor stages. People always want to say, you know, you've
- 39:45got this powder that we just get this inorganic substance sand or whatever and just
- 39:50pour it into this blender and out pops a rabbit. That's what they're asking.
- 39:53When when is science ever produced life from non life? They don't understand
- 39:59that it is many different increments of different chemical processes in different in different environments.
- 40:05There's different processes that are not even related to each other that can happen
- 40:08sequentially but in different environments. So I've been following this a little bit.
- 40:14I've got a list of a few dozen, or at least a couple dozen
- 40:17of different peer reviewed studies for different aspects of this, for how this developed,
- 40:22how that other thing developed this one. And then you get up into
- 40:27homeostasis, which is like the final criteria when all of the chemical things going
- 40:32on in the cell have differentiated from the exterior of the cell to maintain a
- 40:38kind of temporary balance, and then we can call that life. But that's
- 40:45still although biochemistry is grotesquely unnecessarily complex, so complex and inefficient that the complexity
- 40:57alone argues against a design that you wouldn't a designer wouldn't make something this bad.
- 41:04Okay, a designer would make something that worked better, more efficiently,
- 41:07and wouldn't have all of these different parts. Is like this. You know
- 41:12this is a haphazard compilation, that something this complicated could only happen by accident.
- 41:19Sure, the most effective efficient designs are whittled down to have the most
- 41:23economy a few as necessary moving parts. Yet people see something that's wildly complicated
- 41:30and they say, well, the complexity proves design. No. An efficient
- 41:37simplicity would be the hallmark of an intelligent designer. And what we have throughout
- 41:40biochemistry is just insane complexity and inefficiency. And the way that life developed was
- 41:49not as the believers always want to say, it wasn't like in this.
- 41:53They imagine the world as it is today and then suddenly, poof something came
- 42:00alive, and because they have to shorten everything, they always want to look
- 42:04at every evolutionary change. They want to say that an individual fish decided to
- 42:08grow legs and then walked out on the land. They want they want everything
- 42:13to it's going to be an individual in the course of one lifetime, and
- 42:17it has to be like, you know, one hundred million years worth of
- 42:22diversity happening in one lifetime of that one individual. That there's no way you
- 42:27can understand evolusion when you're trying so hard not to. How did a rabbit
- 42:31give birth to a kangaroo, give birth to a shark, give birth to
- 42:35a primate, right, give birth to a monkey fish? Frug, Yeah,
- 42:39it's just weird. One of the resistances I hear out there is when
- 42:45I say the human animal, you know, we're an animal, and a
- 42:50lot of believers blanch. They will physically blink where we're humans, there were
- 42:54humans and there are animals. And I try to explain how animals are categorized
- 43:01using my civilian knowledge base. I know you've had this conversation in much more
- 43:07depth. I come to you and say, I ain't no animal. Ecclesiastes
- 43:13three eighteen to twenty one. The Bible admits that we are but beasts and
- 43:16that the only reason people will people refuse to acknowledge. This is our vanity.
- 43:22That's what the Bible says. Well, describe or define animal a human
- 43:28animal? What makes me an animal? Well, the common definition biologically you'll
- 43:32get a little bit of if you look it up in regular dictionaries. Some
- 43:37dictionaries will include unicellular life forms of like protests and such, they'll call unicellular
- 43:45animals. There's no such thing. By definition, all animals are multicellular.
- 43:50They're mult multicellular eukaryotes with an internal digestive tract, meaning we're heterotroph We have
- 43:58to we sustain ourselves by ingesting and digesting other living cells, so we can't
- 44:05reproduce, so we can't feed ourselves via photosynthesis. We can't exist on sunlight.
- 44:09We must consume external organisms to survive. That's one of the criteria for
- 44:15an animal. Yeah, that's the whole thing. Really multicellular, you multicellular,
- 44:21you carry it heterotrophe. Doesn't it have something to do with you know,
- 44:23we have the symmetrical eyes and ears, arms, legs, et cetera.
- 44:28We have most animals don't. No, I mean I know those flounder
- 44:31doesn't educate me, Come on, educate Okay, Well there are they're like
- 44:38tenophores that don't have any organs at all, and they have cilia with which
- 44:45they move around. They can even produce lights and such, but they don't
- 44:47have actual organs, and they eat like every animal has to eat. The
- 44:54simplest animal is a sponge and that has a a system of tubes and cilia
- 45:02that they attracted the their their food and and and and digested internally like everything
- 45:09else. And there are a vast array of very simple animals that don't have
- 45:17eyes, that don't have any organs or that you know, or that have
- 45:22very few, and that just don't fit, and so many of them don't
- 45:27move. Is it true that at some point in our development, both the
- 45:32top and the bottom, the front and back of me was just an asshole?
- 45:37Is that true? That is the difference between protostomes and deuteros domes.
- 45:44Well, of course, I mean that's what I was going to say.
- 45:45I mean, next, but go ahead, I mean, I know what
- 45:49you're I know what you're talking about. But go ahead and elaborate in a
- 45:52common folk out there. Go ahead, for the when the when the zygot
- 45:57first exists, when you of the two gammeats meat, and they produce a
- 46:00zygot and it's a single cell. Now the cell starts multiplying. Now that
- 46:06cluster of cells, the first structure to be developed is this invagination on one
- 46:14side that continues through to the other side. And so at least with nephros
- 46:21I think it's nephrozoans that we have this passage that goes all the way through
- 46:24where where things like sea and enemies and stuff like that, and jellyfish they
- 46:32don't they have a mouth that is also their anus, so they take food
- 46:37in and have to expel it in the same place. But then we have
- 46:38nephrozoans that the passage goes all the way through mouth on one side, anus
- 46:44on the other. And it's the difference in which one develops first. So
- 46:50in us, in humans, or at least in the classical definition of the
- 46:54deuterostome, that first structure, that first imagination, which eventually continues through to
- 47:01become the other whole, the tunnel through that first thing becomes your asshole.
- 47:09And so there is a point when that is literally all we are. When
- 47:17I was a Christian, I remember thinking about evolution in terms of robbing me
- 47:23of my specialness. I was just a monkey. My granddaddy wasn't a monkey.
- 47:28I don't know. And then of course the conversation is, well,
- 47:30I'm related to the monkey, but I am not a monkey. But you
- 47:35disagree? Am I a monkey? Are? Right? Yeah? We all
- 47:37are. A monkey is any member of the taxonomic sub order of Anthropoidia,
- 47:44also known as Semiformes. In either place, it's the monkey clade. If
- 47:49you describe what the diagnostic characteristics are that identify any monkey that applies to all
- 47:55universally accepted monkeys, then you're describing people. And then a subset of that.
- 48:01You've got the Old World monkeys and the New World monkeys, and then
- 48:04there's some extinct groups too. But if you describe the Old World monkeys Katarini,
- 48:09all the diagnostic characteristics thereof is distinguished from the New World monkeys. Again,
- 48:14you're describing people, and then there's another distinction. People often distinguish the
- 48:20modern Old World monkeys from the apes, but there's a fossil group that is
- 48:24also Old World monkeys, pro play Epithecoidia that a lot of people neglect.
- 48:29If you describe what those characteristics, you know it still applies to it to
- 48:34us. If you describe what the subset of Old world monkeys called apes.
- 48:38That's any member of the taxonomic superfamily Hominoidia, and that's that's lesser apes and
- 48:45great apes. But if you if you describe what great apes are, that's
- 48:49Hominidae. Again, you're describing people. And this is how the cladistics works.
- 48:53It includes all of our all of all of the descendants of a given
- 48:59group, without making any exceptions. This idea that I wasn't created by a
- 49:04divine king used to just I don't know, it diminished me. I'm just
- 49:09I came out of the muck. I'm as common as the other animals,
- 49:14you know, the lower things. And of course I had to totally change
- 49:17my perspective to see my connection with the living world as really, if,
- 49:22for lack of a better word, even more miraculous, you know, if
- 49:25they're a natural miracle kind of thing. Where as imperfect as evolution is.
- 49:31I feel a greater connection to all living things today. Imagine you know,
- 49:37somebody comes somebody comes to you and they're like in the middle class economically,
- 49:42and they tell you that they started out as a great billionaire, but they
- 49:45pissed it all away. You know, that's their fall from grace or you
- 49:52know, they arose from humble beginnings. They were in the projects. They're
- 49:55the self made man. They got their own education, they work, they
- 49:58worked the three jobs, got to where they are. You know, that's
- 50:01the story, right, They came from nothing, they arose to something.
- 50:05That's where we are right in evolution. So that's the more appealing tale to
- 50:09me. And then you know the Buddhist idea of I love this joke and
- 50:15that the Buddhist goes up to a hot dog vendorances make me one with everything.
- 50:22If that's the goal, we are inextricable. We are animals. We're
- 50:28part of this biosphere. We are a part of nature, not apart from
- 50:31it. And I have a sense of massive sense of belonging. Well,
- 50:36since we know not to get our science from Tucker Carlson, is there a
- 50:40series of videos on evolution science based videos or resources that you would point this
- 50:49audience too, and I can link it in the description box. Well,
- 50:52as I mentioned before, I did do because I noticed that nobody had done.
- 50:58I did a series of videos of fifteen fifty part series on the systematic
- 51:00classification of life that shows are the human evolutionary lineage literally from Microbes to Men
- 51:08fifty videos, which is a summary. It just blows my mind. Are
- 51:16and if nothing else, it's my chance to see you, which I rarely
- 51:20get to do these days. You and I are both speaking in Sarnia,
- 51:23Ontario at the Bluewater Atheist Humanist Conference coming up in August, So I am
- 51:30looking forward to, you know, seeing you again, and I'm sure you'll
- 51:32have that drink that is thick and dark black and there's smoke and fire coming
- 51:37out of the top and whatnot, and we'll catch up then. But it's
- 51:42always a pleasure, my friend. And you keep kicking and educating out there,
- 51:45okay, thank you, and you keep communicating because you are a great
- 51:49at that very kind thank you. Follow The Thanking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter
- 51:54for a complete archive of podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts
- 51:59featuring the Thinking Atheist logo, links to atheist pages and resources, and details
- 52:04on upcoming free thought events and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinkingatheist
- 52:09dot com.