Latest / FE exam in the car / DOES ANIMAL PROTEIN CAUSE CANCER1
Transcript
- 0:01Welcome to Celebrity Exercise and diet Secrets. We discuss how celebrities stay in shape
- 0:07and more. So, let's get started. Does animal protein cause cancer?
- 0:32Well, this is one that you hear a lot about and we're going to
- 0:35find out. We're going to talk a little about the China study as well.
- 0:38The relations between animal protein and and cancer, of course, is complex,
- 0:42like most things are always say, life isn't simple. It's usually very
- 0:45nuanced and complex. No single food, though, is, including animal protein
- 0:50in this case, is a direct cause of cancer. Some studies suggest,
- 0:53and that's the key word, the high consumption of certain types of animal protein,
- 0:59particularly process and red meats, may be associated another keyword, with an
- 1:03increased risk. These are not causal. Process and red meat according to the
- 1:07International Agency for Research on Cancer and WHO has classified processed meat as a group
- 1:15one carcinogen, So we're talking bacon, deli meat, stuff like that,
- 1:21meaning it has sufficient evidence to link it's a cancer in humans, particularly collrectal
- 1:29cancer. Now again sufficient evidence to Lincoln, red meat has been classified as
- 1:33a group to a carcinogen, which means it is probably carcinogenic to humans with
- 1:37the strongest associations again being with corectal cancer, but also associations with the pancreatic
- 1:42and prostaate cancer. The mechanisms behind the potential link between red and processed meat
- 1:49are not super clear, but they may include presence of certain chemicals. These
- 1:53chemicals included in nitroso compounds, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, and heterocyclic amine which can
- 2:00cause DNA damage that increases the cancer risk. But the things that are important
- 2:06here's the concept I call fit frequency, intensity, type, and time that
- 2:10all those letters apply. But frequency is going to be important. The risk
- 2:14associated with me consumption appears to be dose dependent, right, the poisons in
- 2:17the dose, and in this case, a higher consumption of red and process
- 2:22meets is linked again just linked to a higher risk of certain cancers. Again,
- 2:27frequency is going to be important. Quantity is going to be incomportant,
- 2:31so intensity we can refer that as quantity. Type is gonna be what type
- 2:37of meat are you eating? It's a difference between fish, deer, beef,
- 2:44and those are the three key factors. And also how many years have
- 2:47you done this? Also, genetic predispositions are going to play a role here.
- 2:52What about the rest of your diet. That's going to play a role
- 2:54any history of collectoral cancer in your family. And I remember again the risk
- 3:00is not uniform across all types of protein. Poultry, fish, and dairy
- 3:04products do not have the same level of association, so it's even weaker.
- 3:08Some studies even suggest that certain types of fish and dairy may have protective effects
- 3:13against form of cancer. Some argue this could kind of wash out the other
- 3:16ones. Maybe soets cancer is are really a combination of all kinds of things
- 3:23genetics, environment, lifestyle, diet as a whole. But what about the
- 3:29China study. Everybody talks about this when you're looking at this. This was
- 3:31done by the doctor T. Colin Campbell of Corneille University. The study was
- 3:36conducted in the eighties. I believe it was some of the key points.
- 3:39As the China Studies said, it was one of the most comprehensive studies of
- 3:42nutrition ever conducted. It collected data from sixty five countries in China, analyzing
- 3:46the diets, lifestyle habits, and disease mortality rates or rural populations. The
- 3:51study found correlation there's the key word, between animal based consuming conceptions and increased
- 3:55risk of chronic diseases, including types of cancer, heart disease, the chronic
- 4:00conditions. On the face of it, listening to it, you hear sixty
- 4:03five countries analyzing this and analyzing that, and it really sounds strong. But
- 4:09there's a lot of limitations to this study. Now, one of the central
- 4:13conclusions of the China study is the purported health benefits of a whole food,
- 4:16plant based diet, so we know there's a motive behind it. Doesn't mean
- 4:19necessarily bad, but there is a motive behind it. The research suggests that
- 4:25the populations consuming diets high and vegetables and fruits with little to no animal products
- 4:29had lower rates of chronic disease. Doesn't mean they don't have other ones,
- 4:32though criticisms the conclusions drawn from the China study have been subject to criticism by
- 4:36a lot of people. Why cannot Again, it's not causation, it's just
- 4:41correlation. You can also critique the interpretation and generalization of the data. Let's
- 4:46look at it more specifically and find out what else we can find here.
- 4:51I mentioned it's correlational, so it's a correlation between the variables such as diet
- 4:57and disease, which is not causation, and so it cannot conclusively prove that
- 5:01one causes the other. We don't know how much of it contributes compared to
- 5:05the other players such as genetics and lifestyle choices. The other thing is the
- 5:11China study were collected through surveys, which can be very very high in inaccuracies
- 5:15due to the self reporting and recall bias. In addition, the interpretation of
- 5:19complex dietary data to make broad dietary recommendations has always been a point of contention
- 5:25among scholars. Their refinings were also based on observations from rural Chinese populations in
- 5:31the eighties, which of course may not be generalizable to other populations due to
- 5:36differences in genetics, environment, lifestyle, and so forth. Their lifestyle is
- 5:42very different than Western diets and lifestyles. Others have also accused the China study
- 5:48of selective reporting, suggesting that only data supporting the hypothesis that animal protein contributes
- 5:54to chronic disease were emphasized, while other data that might contradict were downplay or
- 5:58ignore. This critique points to the potential for confirmation bias and presenting and interpreting
- 6:03the study's findings. The health effects of diet are complex because you're influenced by
- 6:11complex interactions between different nutrients and the overall dietary pattern. So focusing on one
- 6:15itemic animal protein without equally considering the role of other dietary factors such as the
- 6:20intake of process foods, maybe how about sugar and transfats may oversimplify this relationship.
- 6:27So, no, there is no conclusive evidence that animal protein causes cancer.
- 6:32Now if you say cause forget about it, you can throw that out
- 6:35the window because there's definitely nothing that proves that and that's it for now.