Latest / James O'Brien Daily / Has Trump just handed Putin the upper hand?
Transcript
- 0:02This is a global production.
- 0:06Welcome to today's James o' Brien Daily.
- 0:08Sit back and enjoy all the best bits from my daily LBC show where we get into the biggest news stories of the moment.
- 0:18I didn't go all in on the suggestion that Starlink had been deliberately switched off in order to help Vladimir Putin commit war crimes in Ukraine.
- 0:33Okay, Starlink is the satellite system owned by Elon Musk, but not, it transpired a little later yesterday, although some people may have known this already, not controlled by Elon Musk.
- 0:48The.
- 0:48The elements of his technology that are relevant to this conversation are controlled by the Pentagon, by Donald Trump, ultimately by the President of the United States of America.
- 1:00And I think this is interesting.
- 1:03Forgive me if you don't, but part of the reason I didn't go all in on it was because I couldn't quite believe it and I couldn't obviously prove it.
- 1:13So we had a journalist from the Financial Ties booked towards the end of yesterday's program who was going to sort of explain everything to us, dot the I's and cross the t's.
- 1:23And I was a little bit reluctant.
- 1:24And I don't know if this is a sign of me being, I don't know, some sort of subconscious cowardice.
- 1:32I didn't want to do it on my own because I didn't feel that I had the qualifications.
- 1:36I read everything that was available, I watched everything that was available, and I was probably 80% certain that either Elon Musk or Donald Trump or both had deliberately sabotaged Ukrainian military activity.
- 1:54And I think the other reason why I was a little bit wary of going all in on this yesterday was because I still can't quite believe it.
- 2:02I still can't quite believe it.
- 2:06There's also a danger.
- 2:07And listen, I mean, this is just one of the small crosses you have to bear when you do what I do for a living.
- 2:12But if you are of the left or of a liberal disposition and you make a mistake, however small, it will be hung around your neck forever.
- 2:20I try very, very hard not to speak ill of the dead, but some prominent right wing figures who've passed away recently had truly hideous CVs and yet received almost wall to wall hagiographies when they passed.
- 2:33And it just struck me that, you know, when Ed Miliband dies, we'll probably be talking about bacon sandwiches.
- 2:40And yet when people who have been either convicted of terrible crimes or who have written absolutely hideous words pass away if they are perceived as being of the right, then so domina, so biased is our media that they
- 2:53get canonized in obituaries.
- 2:56It's just a little observation.
- 2:57I really hope that I didn't bottle it yesterday.
- 3:00I really hope I didn't step back, as it were, from stating what I thought was true because I was too worried about what would happen if it subsequently, through no fault of my own.
- 3:12But of course, that doesn't matter.
- 3:13In the crucible of the British media, it turned out not to be true.
- 3:17I just put that in, in passing because there's another element to this.
- 3:20If you are perceived as being of the right or whatever phrase you prefer, then you can kind of act more or less with impunity.
- 3:31Volodymyr Zelenskyy, for example, gave an interview last night to the British journalist Piers Morgan, who has historically been one of Donald Trump's biggest cheerleaders.
- 3:39I mean, to the point, if I recall correctly from when I was on Twitter of sort of going after anybody who criticized Trump like a rat up a drainpipe.
- 3:47But nothing sticks to these people.
- 3:50I don't think that Morgan was pro Brexit, but, you know, the general type is pro Brexit, pro Trump, pro Boris Johnson, whatever it may be, but certainly in his case, very, very pro Trump.
- 4:02And what are we supposed to do?
- 4:04We are supposed to just forget that even people who kind of said after the January 6th atrocities that this was now untenable kind of crept back into the fan club subsequently?
- 4:17Well, those of us who sat absolutely resolute in the camp that says, the man's disgusting, the man is depraved, the man is, is morally bankrupt, probably.
- 4:29You know, there aren't that many people lucky enough to have a high profile in the UK media who have done that.
- 4:36But if they were to make a mistake, God forbid, it would be, it would be shouted from the rooftops.
- 4:42But you can sort of silently remove your slavish support for Donald Trump and no consequences whatsoever.
- 4:49I just genuine, I know this is a bit self indulgent or at least self referential, but I find it, I find it absolutely fascinating, absolutely fascinating that you can now see it coming down the slipway, the revisionism.
- 5:08By this time tomorrow, nobody would ever have written a column in a British newspaper or gone on social media in a position of prominence in the British media, or stood up, with the possible exception of Nigel Farage, who
- 5:18I can't really see wriggling off this particular hook.
- 5:20By this time tomorrow, nobody would have, nobody would have been a big fan of Donald Trump.
- 5:24Nobody ever would have used the phrase Trump derangement syndrome.
- 5:27To describe people who have been proved right about absolutely flipping everything.
- 5:31Will they literally just watch it happen?
- 5:34If they do, if they.
- 5:35If they are shameless enough not to go all in now on recognizing Trump's depravity, then it will become a question about whether or not we should still be supporting Ukraine or have we spent.
- 5:46Because this is what Trump is doing.
- 5:48You want to know what Vladimir Putin wants?
- 5:50I don't think I've said this before.
- 5:52Apologies if somebody else has, but I would stick it on a T shirt.
- 5:57Seriously, put it in the Louvre if you want to know what Vladimir Putin wants.
- 6:03Have a look at what Donald Trump is doing.
- 6:06And he's taken to social media today or last night to attack Volodymyr Zelenskyy and to critique US Support for Ukraine.
- 6:17I know he's been in power now for quite a long time, but.
- 6:20But it's all Joe Biden's fault and, and somehow he had nothing to do with any of it, and they shouldn't have given him money and he's just a failed comedian anyway.
- 6:26It's a.
- 6:26It's a hideous rant.
- 6:28But that, of course, is all that Trump does.
- 6:30It's all he's ever done, and it's all he ever will do.
- 6:33A hideous rant.
- 6:35And, and, and there it is.
- 6:38Here we are, all of the people that have spent the last couple of years and people wrote columns, you know, about how good it was going to be.
- 6:47All the usual suspects.
- 6:49Jacob Breeze, mog, almost certainly all your Daily Telegraph comment writers, Kemi Badenok, Nigel Farage.
- 6:55Oh, Trump's gonna be great.
- 6:57He's upsetting all the right people.
- 6:59And, And I think Ukraine is really important to British politics, let alone the humanitarian side of it and the peace side of it.
- 7:08But everyone agreed that we should be backing Ukraine, right?
- 7:11It was really weird the way those planets aligned.
- 7:15Apart from a few tankies and, and terminally online weirdos, everybody agreed that we had both a moral and a diplomatic responsibility to Ukraine.
- 7:24And it came from a beautiful place.
- 7:25I don't understand where it came from, because the British public can be so easily persuaded to hate all foreigners, as we saw during Brexit and subsequently.
- 7:35And, and remember that Brexit was not about people of color.
- 7:38Brexit was about getting rid of Eastern Europeans.
- 7:40It was about getting rid of Poles and getting rid of white people.
- 7:43White.
- 7:44The wrong kind.
- 7:45Remember Farage talking about people not speaking English on.
- 7:47On trains?
- 7:49It wasn't just about color.
- 7:51It was a rolling out of the red carpet for Eastern European people.
- 7:56Not long after, we became the first population in history to impose economic sanctions on itself because so many people had been persuaded that Eastern European people were their enemy.
- 8:05It was a beautiful moment in British history, actually, that.
- 8:10And of course it was.
- 8:11I mean, government facilitated, but it involved armies of British families throwing open their doors for people fleeing the scene of a war crime.
- 8:25And we stepped up, I think we may have stepped up more enthusiastically and more effectively than any other country in Europe.
- 8:32I'm probably wrong about it.
- 8:33I mean, certainly not Poland.
- 8:34Stop it, James.
- 8:35Shut up now.
- 8:36I mean, you know, we did well.
- 8:38We don't have to have been better than everybody else and turning into one of them.
- 8:43And now we are contemplating irrefutable evidence that Donald Trump, the politician most beloved of Nigel Farage, the politician who Richard Little John at the Daily Mail wishes was governing this country, the politician that Boris Johnson insisted was going
- 9:02to be an absolute mensch for British interests, the politician that people were queuing up to tell us was upsetting all the right people and doing all the.
- 9:11All the right things.
- 9:12Donald Trump is inarguably on the side of Vladimir Putin in an illegal war against Ukraine.
- 9:20The President of the United States of America is on Vladimir Putin's side.
- 9:25And we can sit here till the cows come home arguing over whether or not it's because he's been blackmailed by Vladimir Putin or whether it's because he is so fundamentally base and driven so entirely by atavistic appetites that
- 9:41he will just all always go wherever he thinks his self interest lies.
- 9:45Imagine not being able to conceive of what a principle is.
- 9:49This is what you have to do.
- 9:51We have wasted hours, days, weeks on this program trying to analyze Donald Trump.
- 9:58Why is he doing this thing?
- 9:59How should Andy Burnham handle him?
- 10:01Should Sir Keir Starmer have done this, that or the other.
- 10:04I have sat here inviting your calls and pontificating and stroking my chin and wondering why he's doing this.
- 10:12It's a waste of flipping time, it's a waste of energy, it's a waste of time and it's a waste of your attention.
- 10:23Because he does what he does because he can.
- 10:26And if there is a path in front of him that involves depravity, amorality and siding with dictators and war criminals against democracies and decency, he will just go there.
- 10:41He will just go there.
- 10:43It doesn't really matter.
- 10:45Quotes.
- 10:46Why?
- 10:47Question mark.
- 10:47End quotes.
- 10:48He just will.
- 10:50I don't even think it's always self interest.
- 10:52Sometimes I think the cruelty is the point.
- 10:55So you can't imagine a conscience so curdled that it derives epic pleasure from other people's pain.
- 11:02But those are the only policies he's ever offered to his supporters.
- 11:05Vote for me.
- 11:06I will hurt some people who are not you.
- 11:09And then, of course, we have the leopards eating face principle.
- 11:11When it kicks in, people realize, actually, no, he will hurt you as well.
- 11:14And other people will cheer.
- 11:16It's not just that Nigel Farage's party conference, that people get beaten up by the crowd.
- 11:20It happened at one of Trump's recently as well, and Trump started mocking the man being assaulted by his fans for being overweight.
- 11:27Donald Trump mocking people for being overweight.
- 11:30It's like me mocking people for being smug.
- 11:33You can't even begin.
- 11:34You see what I mean about the waste of time and energy in analyzing this stuff?
- 11:40It's like asking why Al Capone had people killed.
- 11:44You know, it's like asking why Vladimir Putin sends goons to this country to try to murder and to successfully murder, in Alexander Litvinenko's case, critics of his regime.
- 11:54That's just who they are.
- 11:56It's what they do.
- 11:57We can't use our intellectual capacity to work out who these people are.
- 12:02It's just shocking, isn't it?
- 12:04And what's most shocking is that for me, at least, because of what I do for a living and how much I despair at the state of public discourse in this country, the speed with which all of the people
- 12:15who said he was going to be great will now wash their hands of him completely.
- 12:19Here's one of them, actually.
- 12:20Here is Piers Morgan interviewing Volodymyr Zelensky about his reaction to the discovery that Trump had agreed to buy Russian oil.
- 12:29Let me rephrase that.
- 12:30That Trump had agreed to let American motorists subsidize Vladimir Putin's war crimes in Ukraine.
- 12:37It's a pity that we are losing.
- 12:40We are losing strong partner.
- 12:44So this is my opinion, and you.
- 12:47Think you're losing America.
- 12:49Yeah, but.
- 12:50But not because of us.
- 12:52We.
- 12:52I mean, this.
- 12:53We can't be weak.
- 12:54Otherwise, we can't survive.
- 12:56Otherwise we will.
- 12:57We will just.
- 12:58We are not selling our country.
- 13:00Look, guys, it's not about business for us.
- 13:02It's just our life.
- 13:04And this is our country.
- 13:06It's our body.
- 13:07So our home, our children.
- 13:09And this is very important for us.
- 13:11That's why it's painful when President Trump chooses one side, not our side, but we are okay that he's in the middle, but if you're in the middle, you have to stay in the middle, not on the wrong side.
- 13:26And then Elon Musk came forward yesterday to blame Donald Trump for imposing speed limits on the Ukrainian drones that use his Starlink technology.
- 13:36An extraordinary intervention.
- 13:38Another man responsible for blowing so much smoke up Donald Trump's backside, it started coming out of his ears.
- 13:44Another one now sort of turning around and apparently having some sort of second thoughts.
- 13:49The Pentagon set a speed limit on Ukraine's drones, which massively compromised their capabilities.
- 13:55In fact, as Volodymyr Zelenskyy put it, people would die as a result.
- 14:02And Ukraine's former Defense minister accused Musk of having done it.
- 14:05And Musk responded by saying that the shields, the systems, the star shield systems are owned and controlled by the US Government.
- 14:13Any limits on speed or usage are decided by the US military and potus.
- 14:17And frankly, I don't care, because if you did so much, if you did as much as Elon Musk to put Donald Trump in the White House, to put Don Trump in charge of that decision, then you may as
- 14:26well have made the decision yourself.
- 14:28It's a little bit like inviting a sociopath to babysit and then wringing your hands and keening and wailing when you come home to discover that he's hurt your children.
- 14:38I.
- 14:38I mean, it's just unbelievable, the mess that we are in now.
- 14:42And it is defined and distilled down to one single thing.
- 14:46The President of the United States of America is on the side of.
- 14:51Of the war criminals in an illegal war.
- 14:55Two questions.
- 14:56What does that mean?
- 14:57And the second question, what should we do?
- 15:00John's in Halifax.
- 15:01John, what would you like to say?
- 15:02Morning, James.
- 15:03How are you doing?
- 15:03I'm all right, mate.
- 15:04Yeah.
- 15:05I was just talking to Ashley there.
- 15:07Well, we can do.
- 15:09I should say I'm going to Ukraine on Saturday with a group of people from Leeds from our organisation.
- 15:16I volunteer with an organization called Drive to Save Lives, and we've sent 500 4x4 pickup trucks, ambulances, fire engines, you name it.
- 15:26I just think the important thing is, you know, that we're all on the same page with regard to Trump and these guys.
- 15:33Well, I mean, I think that what are the people who are volunteering, I'm talking about and probably most of your listeners, but my point is that we can do something about it ourselves.
- 15:42James.
- 15:42Oh, you're a good man.
- 15:44You know, you're a good man.
- 15:45I'm going to take you right back to the very beginning, okay?
- 15:48If I can.
- 15:48And I'm gonna say, why?
- 15:50Why did you and your friends and colleagues Decide to take it upon yourselves to get aid out to Ukraine.
- 15:54Well, our friend Taras from Bradford set it up at the beginning of the full scale invasion scores, hundreds of people have joined up since because they feel, well, one of our American volunteers put it best.
- 16:08I think life's not a spectator spot.
- 16:13And this is, I sometimes wonder, I worry sometimes, John, that the Second World War spoiled us a bit in the context of how complicated conflicts can be because the Second World War was good versus evil.
- 16:27We may not have been entirely clear about how clear that division was at the time, but my God, with the benefit of hindsight, we certainly are.
- 16:34And for me, this has always been the same.
- 16:36This has always been exactly the same.
- 16:38You have a murderous expansionist dictator illegally invading sovereign territory and trying to essentially suppress the population.
- 16:46And yet I, I still don't think everybody sees it that clearly.
- 16:50I still don't think everybody sees it as clearly as you.
- 16:52So what did you see that other people missed?
- 16:54James?
- 16:55I've been in Lviv and we know, well, Lviv is the city in the west and that's where we tend to deliver our vehicles to be distributed to the front.
- 17:02I've been in Lviv when there's been large scale protests against Zelensky sacking his defense secretary and things like that.
- 17:13It's a free society.
- 17:15There's the, you know, there's every stripe of religion, people, it's not, and I hate this when people say, oh, it's corrupt, it's not perfect.
- 17:22It's.
- 17:22This is that it's a free country and the people are working towards improving the democracy.
- 17:28They're doing it as a free sovereign nation and they've been invaded by, for my money, a fascist authoritarian empire.
- 17:36It's not just your money.
- 17:37So what, what do we think the significances of the fact, and I suppose that historians of the future will sit there and splutter at the fact that we didn't all realize this after that attempted humiliat of Zelenskyy in
- 17:47the Oval Office.
- 17:48And that was extraordinary.
- 17:50It could have been choreographed by Vladimir Putin that moment.
- 17:53But if there were any lingering doubts that Trump is not absolutely on Putin's side in this war, they have now gone.
- 17:59What's the significance of that?
- 18:02I personally, I think it goes back.
- 18:03Quite a bit further.
- 18:04If you look at the Russian actions in Chechnya at the beginning of Putin's reign, when you see what it did to Grozny, when you see what it did to cities within the Russian Federation, when you see it was
- 18:17undermining and attack the Estonian national Internet, not with.
- 18:23The connivance and approval of the President of the United States of America.
- 18:27You're absolutely right.
- 18:28This takes it to a whole other level.
- 18:30Yeah, the expansionist agenda has been there since pretty much.
- 18:33He came in as a great supporter of Glasanost and perestroika.
- 18:37One of his key mentors was the actual author of the new Russian constitution.
- 18:41So he played the whole of Russia like a rusty old fiddle.
- 18:44But I'm talking about the pivot of this year or this administration, Trump's second term.
- 18:50Term.
- 18:51What on earth does it mean for Ukraine that Trump is on Putin's side?
- 18:55What does even, and I know we can only speculate, but I'd like you to try, what does it even mean psychologically and emotionally for the Ukrainian people to have.
- 19:04To have felt the support, albeit often inadequate support, of pretty much the entire world, and now they know that Donald Trump is on Vladimir Putin's team.
- 19:14I can only speculate.
- 19:16Of course, I'm going to be in Ukraine on Saturday and Sunday.
- 19:20I'll be talking to people and we'll find out.
- 19:21But from, from what I've spoken to people, the things that we're seeing, the messages that were coming back, they find it heartbreaking that, you know, they are making the ultimate sacrifice.
- 19:34We work with people of lots, you know, who support veterans, families and things like that.
- 19:39And to see that, you know, a country, for all its faults or rights or wrongs, that people in Ukraine and other countries have seen as a beacon of freedom and democracy, to see them, basically, I mean, Cash Patel
- 19:53is actually in Moscow tweeting from the Kremlin.
- 19:55Is that true?
- 19:56I've done it again, John.
- 19:58I've done it again.
- 19:59It's been shared.
- 20:00I know.
- 20:01And I, I haven't triple checked it yet, so I haven't said it on air.
- 20:04I, you know, this isn't a BBC.
- 20:06I haven't got a hundred people handing me slips of paper and helping me, help me put it out.
- 20:09But is it true that Cash Patel has done this?
- 20:11Is it definitely true?
- 20:12As far as I'm aware, I've already shared to me from a very, very.
- 20:15Head of the FBI.
- 20:16That's correct, yes.
- 20:18Yeah.
- 20:18Is it?
- 20:19And I've read the line from Russia with Love.
- 20:20Surely that's not true.
- 20:22That can't be true.
- 20:23Well, is it too big?
- 20:25Jesus.
- 20:26I'll be honest here.
- 20:26I woke up yesterday and I thought, surely the leader of A three world isn't sharing a video of a poor unfortunate guy getting mauled by a tiger.
- 20:33In Doncaster against the express desires of that family.
- 20:37God rest him.
- 20:38Yeah.
- 20:39So that's where we are.
- 20:40And can people support what you're doing?
- 20:42People can support us.
- 20:44There are.
- 20:45We are just one group across a uk.
- 20:47There's great groups in Mackel Field Aid, Ukrainian, There's Jeeps for Peace in Scotland.
- 20:52There's lots of groups, lots of Ukrainian clubs, especially in cities across the north of England with like Bradford and Salford, Keighley, with Ukrainian diasporas.
- 21:02But our group is Drive to Save Lives.
- 21:04We're easily findable on Instagram and again, it's just for two or three thousand pounds.
- 21:10We can get a decent Mitsubishi Ford Ranger, whatever, and we take them.
- 21:16We took one the other week to a lad from the Midlands who's fighting as a British volunteer.
- 21:22So people can do that and these trucks and these ambulances do make a massive, massive difference.
- 21:28The name of your organization, once again.
- 21:29You're such a good man.
- 21:30You've done two things there.
- 21:31You've mentioned other people that are in the same sphere as you, which is.
- 21:34There's lots of other great.
- 21:35I know there are, but just tell me the name of yours.
- 21:37Once again.
- 21:38Ours is Drive to Save Lives.
- 21:40And anybody who wants to raise the money to get a truck, we can facilitate the fundraising.
- 21:45We're completely volunteer powered.
- 21:48There's no money, no overheads.
- 21:49The volunteers even pay their own.
- 21:51I can't let you go.
- 21:52Yeah, I just listen because you're a modest man, clearly, but I want you to try.
- 21:55I've got a lot to be modest about.
- 21:57Well, haven't we all?
- 21:58Haven't we all?
- 21:59But why?
- 22:00Why are you doing it?
- 22:01I will Brought up a trade unionist, the labor movement and always been an anti fascist.
- 22:07That were always part of my makeup.
- 22:09And the people I grew up with, the people I worked with, went to university with and I suppose you always thought, well, what.
- 22:16What would you do if.
- 22:17If it started happening again?
- 22:18You know, if we look back to Spain and international volunteers and stuff and obviously I'm not putting myself in that category.
- 22:24I'm not on the front line or anything, but, you know, people just see it's just solidarity with a democratic country and wonderful people in Ukraine and we just want to help them.
- 22:37And you're.
- 22:37You're a star.
- 22:38You just are.
- 22:39And, and thank you for what you and your colleagues do and all the other organizations you mentioned as well.
- 22:43Time for a short break now.
- 22:44Afterwards, the best callers in the business.
- 22:55John's in Kingsland.
- 22:56John, what would you like to say?
- 22:58Oh, yeah, just take me cap off to the last fellow that was on what top guy.
- 23:03But I want to talk about the allegiances that have been spoken about with Russia or whatever it is that Trump has.
- 23:12And I think that, that we're actually, as a nation, especially overestimating Trump's humanity.
- 23:20I am.
- 23:22I'm going to have to say this very politely.
- 23:26I don't care.
- 23:28In what way.
- 23:29I don't care anymore.
- 23:31I've spent, what, two years trying to, trying to analyze him, trying to work out what his allegiances are, what his motivations are, why he's doing what he's doing, whether or not Keir Starmer should do this and Andy Burnham
- 23:44should do that.
- 23:44And would we be like, more like Mark Carney or is Mark Rutter a.
- 23:49A ridiculous human being?
- 23:50And.
- 23:50And I don't think it matters.
- 23:52This isn't a criticism of you, mate.
- 23:53I don't think we've got that.
- 23:55Yeah, we've not got the vocabulary.
- 23:57He's an ogre.
- 23:59You might as well ask why the giant in Jack and the Bean Store is going to grind his bones to make his bread.
- 24:04There's no point sitting here looking for psychological motivations that come from our shared vocabulary of common decency, because he, he don't speak that language, John.
- 24:13It doesn't.
- 24:13But also, he has no allegiances.
- 24:15So this allegiance that was, that has been said, he's now making with Russia, I don't think exists.
- 24:21The only allegiance he's got is to himself.
- 24:24And I think that he's made a deal with Russia because he knows he's stuffed in the, in the polls coming up.
- 24:31So he's trying to bring this oil in to try and temporarily lower prices out there for the petrol, gas, whatever you want to call it.
- 24:38And switching off Starlink, if, if Elon Musk is correct, and that was.
- 24:41That was a White House or.
- 24:43That's my point.
- 24:44Go on, then.
- 24:45Because Russia is stupid.
- 24:47Putin is not stupid.
- 24:48He said, yeah, okay, you can buy this oil off me, but I want you to lower the Starlink space speeds.
- 24:54Yeah, okay, all right, I'm glad.
- 24:56I'm glad I didn't.
- 24:57But I'm glad I didn't bite your head off because, well, I mean, you can't.
- 25:03You can't throw Occam's Razor in a skip, can you?
- 25:05Just because, just because Donald Trump is immune to any sort of form of moral or psychological analysis, Occam's razor is, is what is less left, the thing that makes the most sense?
- 25:15Why on earth would Donald Trump do this?
- 25:17Answer.
- 25:17Because Vladimir Putin told him to.
- 25:19And if he wants to be able to announce a completely trifling amount of diesel making its way to American consumers, essentially inviting them to subsidize Vladimir Putin's war crimes in Ukraine, then Putin returns by saying, what's in it
- 25:35for me, Donald?
- 25:36What's in it for me?
- 25:38It's a transaction.
- 25:40Exactly.
- 25:41And Trump is purely a transactional person, as long.
- 25:44As long as it's to his personal benefit.
- 25:46Yeah.
- 25:46All right.
- 25:46So.
- 25:47And now, having already said so what at the beginning of your contribution and then regretted it, I'm going to say so what again, because what.
- 25:53What does it mean in the context of what this all means for us?
- 25:57Well, I think what it means for us is we need to be working really hard in building stronger alliances around the world.
- 26:04Now, I get it, we've got them.
- 26:07But we need to be looking to what I would call the more sensible countries around the planet.
- 26:13For example, Australia, Japan, Nordics, Canada.
- 26:19Did you vote Brexit?
- 26:21Did I vote Brexit?
- 26:25No, I certainly did.
- 26:26No, I didn't think you did, but I just wondered why you were listing countries that aren't in the European Union.
- 26:31Well, the EU is next on my list.
- 26:33It's about flipping time.
- 26:34Because I was just thinking, wouldn't it be nice if there was a kind of single market or a bloc or some sort of customs union that might extend into defense as a sort of successor to the busted flush
- 26:47or at least to the sabotage NATO that Donald Trump is responsible for?
- 26:50Wouldn't it be nice if we could be part of a group like that?
- 26:53And wouldn't it be silly if we'd all voted to leave it.
- 26:58And make these alliances, both economically, militarily, and, for better words, shun the United States until he's gone?
- 27:09Yeah.
- 27:09Well, even after he's gone, to be better prepared for anything that might happen in the future.
- 27:16The key question here, of course, is, and I keep coming back to this, I've been back to this again and again and again and again and again.
- 27:23Why was Nigel Farage so bothered by a European army?
- 27:27I remember when he wasn't slagging off foreigners, all he ever talked about and praising Putin, all he ever talked about 10 years ago was how awful it would be to have a European army.
- 27:35Do we have any idea why that was yet?
- 27:36Yet even today, 10 years later, 10 years after the referendum, why was Nigel Farage so opposed to a European army?
- 27:44For the same reason that Donald Trump is doing what he's doing.
- 27:46Do you think so?
- 27:48Yeah, 100%.
- 27:49Nigel Farage is a carbon copy of Donald Trump.
- 27:51He'll say whatever he wants to, he can say for his own benefit.
- 27:55That's it.
- 27:55But even though what I think you said about, or your deployment of Occam's Razor seems accurate, that I still stand by my original line, if you want to know what Vladimir Putin wants, have a look at what Donald
- 28:05Trump is doing.
- 28:07I don't know that.
- 28:08I mean, I suppose.
- 28:08Suppose we could say, if you want to know what Vladimir Putin wants to happen in Britain, have a look at what Nigel Farage is doing.
- 28:15Exactly.
- 28:16Cut from the same cloth.
- 28:17Trump.
- 28:18Trump and courage.
- 28:20Yeah, Champ and sewage.
- 28:21We don't.
- 28:22Yes, exactly.
- 28:23That was the name of my first band.
- 28:24Thank you, John.
- 28:25Lovely stuff.
- 28:26There you go.
- 28:26A little lesson for me there.
- 28:27I was about to jump down his throat for trying to psychologically analyze Donald Trump, and it would have been a mistake to do so, but I stand by that observation.
- 28:36With no further ado.
- 28:37Christopher Miller is the chief Ukraine correspondent in Kyiv for the Financial Times, and he was due to join us yesterday, but we were rather overtaken by events.
- 28:45Talking, actually, that interview with Evan Gershkovitz.
- 28:48So not exactly changing the subject, but I think when I sat down with Evan a week ago, we both probably would have expressed shock at Trump making it quite so clear that he now is allied with Vladimir Putin's
- 29:01interests when it comes to the war against Ukraine.
- 29:04So the first question I'd ask you, Christopher, is, is how do you or we or anybody convey the sheer scale and importance of this moment?
- 29:16Well, I guess it's maybe difficult to put into words, but it's hugely important.
- 29:22The things that Donald Trump is threatening to withhold or withholding and cutting things like intelligence or speed limits on.
- 29:32On Starshield Starlink terminals in Ukraine are things that matter for.
- 29:39I mean, this is the difference between life and death here.
- 29:43I mean, Zelenskyy's been very clear about that.
- 29:46Not being able to properly defend yourself, not getting intelligence that tells you when an incoming Russian attack is headed for the capital of Kyiv, where I am right now with 4 million people.
- 29:59When Starlink systems stop working in the middle of operations, the result is people die.
- 30:07We saw that last week.
- 30:09We saw that over the course of the last few days when Ukraine stopped striking Russian oil refineries and heeded Donald Trump's unilateral energy ceasefire declaration.
- 30:21And the Russians broke it day in and day out, and numerous people died.
- 30:25I think, you know, the count yesterday was 10.
- 30:27But for sure, last week there were more than 100 civilians killed.
- 30:30And so it's a life and death difference.
- 30:33And is there any room for even a scintilla of doubt that responsibility for this decision lies with the Pentagon or the White House or effectively both?
- 30:43I mean, you know, we haven't gotten a response from the White House or the Pentagon about what happened.
- 30:50We do know.
- 30:51I've just been speaking with President Zelensky's team as they travel through Europe, and they were saying that Star Shield Starlink connectivity and functionality has been restored.
- 31:03So the military is now being now able to use the drones and other systems with the Starlink system.
- 31:13So something has happened between last night and this morning that has allowed Starlink to come back on.
- 31:20We don't know what's happened with intelligence still, because we don't know until an attack happens if that intelligence is coming through in time.
- 31:30But there's little doubt that something is at play here.
- 31:37Two things happening simultaneously of this magnitude.
- 31:43It's rare.
- 31:43It's very rare.
- 31:45And you refer also, of course, to a story you have out today about the US Proposing that European countries.
- 31:52And again, I'm going to have to say this slowly because it is or would once have been unthinkable.
- 31:57European countries unfreeze some Russian sovereign assets that were immobilized after Moscow's invasion of Ukraine and wait for it, because this is extraordinary.
- 32:10Transfer them to a vehicle overseen by Washington.
- 32:15Yeah, yeah, that's right.
- 32:16This is what we reported myself and my colleagues in the ft, you, you know, for some weeks now, but specifically during the latest meeting in Miami between Donald Trump's special envoys, Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff, and the Ukrainians
- 32:32and European National Security advisors, the Americans suggested that they unfreeze the Europeans unfreeze the hundreds of billions of dollars or portions of it now and give it to Russia as sort of an incentive to come along and start
- 32:47negotiations, which, of course, the Europeans immediately shut down.
- 32:51The Ukrainians certainly are not on board with this and have been screaming to the high heavens about how Russia's frozen assets should be given to it for reparations and to help with its defense.
- 33:04I don't see this going forward the way the Donald Trump administration would like to, but it's one part of many that the Trump administration is, you know, trying to introduce into these negotiations.
- 33:19That looks certainly like they're helping out the Russians, the aggressor here, and not Ukraine, the country that has been invaded.
- 33:26Well, it looks like they're ticking off items on a Vladimir Putin flavored wish list, really, regardless of what the response is, you know, have you done that yet?
- 33:34Have you asked for our money back yet?
- 33:36Have you turned off Starlink yet?
- 33:38I mean, it is.
- 33:39I don't want to labor the point, but it is, as you acknowledged at the very beginning, it's almost hard to articulate the significance of this.
- 33:45And Zelensky, who's been a model of diplomacy throughout, I mean, most obviously during that hideous experience in the Oval Office, he appears to have reached breaking point this week as well.
- 33:57Yeah, he expressed his frustration to me even a couple of weeks ago.
- 34:01I met him for an interview here in Kyiv.
- 34:03We were going to meet at his office and we had discussed this the night before a big Russian attack.
- 34:08And instead he let me know the next morning that we were going to meet at a school where a Russian drone had crashed into the side of the building and left a giant gaping hole.
- 34:17And during that interview, he said, our Western partners, Europe included, but particularly the United States, are not doing enough.
- 34:25He reiterated that to my colleagues in London yesterday, where in an interview, he really sort of, I think, opened up and kind of let loose his frustration toward the Trump administration.
- 34:37And finally, Christopher, how does this land in Ukraine among ordinary people who no doubt have had suspicions and who will be following events more closely than the average Brit or American, obviously.
- 34:48But the now unavoidable truth of Donald Trump's allegiance, whether it's opportunistic or something more sinister to Vladimir Putin's interests, how does that affect the Ukrainian public or the Ukrainian morale?
- 35:05Do we think?
- 35:06The Ukrainians have been pretty clear eyed about Trump for many, many years.
- 35:09I mean, even before the full scale invasion, the things that he would say about Zelenskyy himself and Ukraine during his first impeachment in 2019 were not flattering.
- 35:17Right.
- 35:18So the Ukrainians are very politically smart, savvy people.
- 35:22They read up and they don't have a very high opinion of Donald Trump.
- 35:26They're, of course, extremely worried that his fealty to Putin is going to lead to the United States, its biggest political and military backer, forcing it into negotiations that would see Ukraine make concessions here and not Russia.
- 35:43So the mood is dark and grim.
- 35:46But when Donald Trump does these things, withholding intelligence or cutting Starlink connections or attacking Zelensky personally, it only works to bolster Zelensky's popularity in the country and really to get the Ukrainians to of, you know, circle the wagons.
- 36:01Well, I suppose we can't avoid the fact that European leaders haven't done enough to sort of preemptively fill the vacuum that would be left by.
- 36:08By Trump's ultimate withdrawal.
- 36:11Yeah, they're working on it in many ways.
- 36:13You know, there is a lot of money from the European Union coming to Ukraine.
- 36:16That money helps keep the government afloat, helps helps keep weapons flowing to Ukraine.
- 36:21That money, some of it does go to the United States through this pearl system that is meant to procure defensive weaponry and other military equipment for Ukraine's defense.
- 36:34Right.
- 36:35They're hitting Russia with harsher sanctions, too, you know, so they are doing what they can.
- 36:41There are certain things, of course, that they, or certain gaps rather, that they can't fill.
- 36:45But there are certain things, again, like, for example, Patriot interceptor missiles, which Ukraine is desperate to have, that defends against Russia's ballistic missile attacks that Europe has in some stocks in some countries, but of course, don't want to
- 37:00give up because of the global shortage of them.
- 37:02But they can't produce them in the numbers that the Americans can.
- 37:07And so they're never going to be able to completely fill the gap, which is why it's so important that not only Europe, but the United States remain united in support of Ukraine here.
- 37:19Christopher Miller, thank you, and my apologies for inconveniencing you yesterday, Christopher.
- 37:23As I said, the FT's chief correspondent in Kyiv, chief Ukraine correspondent in Kyiv, and doing a better job than me, perhaps, of conveying the sheer magnitude of this moment.
- 37:34Time for a short break now, but when we get back, we'll be moving our focus to another huge story from today's news agenda.
- 37:50I've been increasingly wondering, I'd love to know what you think about this.
- 37:53How much damage do you think the phrase legitimate concerns has done to public discourse in this country?
- 38:00You remember for a very long time, you'd hear someone say something racist and you'd say, that's a bit racist.
- 38:05And someone else would say, no, they've got legitimate concerns about immigration.
- 38:09And you sort of ask what their legitimate concerns were, and they'd say something like, oh, well, in, in my part of town, if you're an immigrant, you get a free shop.
- 38:19You say, pardon, what have we had on the show over the years?
- 38:22Free Shops was the first one.
- 38:24I hadn't been doing this job very long.
- 38:26And, and I remember thinking, I'm 99, sure.
- 38:31You don't get given a free shop simply by dint of having been born somewhere else.
- 38:36And this was even before Facebook ruled the world.
- 38:39So I don't know how these stories spread back in the day.
- 38:42And then I, a woman telling me they got free cars, did that call get clipped up.
- 38:47I think that might have been during the era of clipping up calls and, and going via, you get a free car.
- 38:52Is it legitimate concerns?
- 38:55We've got legitimate concerns.
- 38:57And I used to sit here thinking, well, maybe they do, maybe they do.
- 39:01So when the numbers start plummeting, everyone will relax again, don't they?
- 39:06Whether you're talking about people forced to cross the Channel in small boats because the Tories shut all the safe and legal routes, or whether you're talking about net migration fig, which understandably and inevitably rocketed as a consequence of
- 39:19Brexit, when they start plummeting, everyone will calm down.
- 39:24Right.
- 39:24If you've got legitimate concerns, then when they are addressed, they will cease to be concerns.
- 39:32If they were legitimate.
- 39:34There it is.
- 39:35That's the Jigsaw.
- 39:36And.
- 39:37And of course, Keir Starmer's Labour government thought that they were, or treated them as if they were legitimate concerns.
- 39:43They've got legitimate concerns.
- 39:44Okay, all right, we're addressing your legitimate concerns.
- 39:47The numbers have plummeted.
- 39:49Yeah, but I'm still really angry.
- 39:51There's still too many.
- 39:52I'm still really.
- 39:53Well, hang on.
- 39:53How legitimate were your concerns in the first place?
- 39:56Also, you keep saying you don't care about legal migration, you only care about illegal migration.
- 40:02Illegal migration is a drop in the ocean.
- 40:04Why is it the thing you own, the only thing you ever talk about?
- 40:07And why are your politicians coming out and saying there's too many black faces on the table telly if they have legitimate concerns about current levels of migration?
- 40:16How can there be too many black faces on the telly if you're only expressing legitimate concerns?
- 40:21I.
- 40:22I think it might be one of those phrases that we've allowed to be unchallenged in our discourse.
- 40:29Because who honestly thinks that Nigel Farage has ever led a party that is not riddled with racism?
- 40:38Go on, put your hands up.
- 40:39The only people who would argue that Nigel Farage has never or not led every parties ever led is riddled with racism are racists who aren't ready to admit it yet.
- 40:48Racists who love him that aren't ready to admit it yet.
- 40:52You may be aware that ITV has undertaken.
- 40:55ITV has done some journalism.
- 40:57There you go.
- 40:58That's.
- 40:58That's how you describe it.
- 40:59BBC used to do this sort of thing.
- 41:01The.
- 41:01ITV has done some journalism where they have spent time with.
- 41:05With reform counselors and reform candidates and talked to them and listened to them.
- 41:12That's.
- 41:13That's the judge.
- 41:13So I imagine Richard Tice is claiming already.
- 41:16I think I may have seen a clip somewhere.
- 41:17Richard Tice is claiming already that this is profoundly unfair.
- 41:20How dare you listen to our candidates and report what they have said.
- 41:25Okay, mate, that's.
- 41:27It's an interesting take there.
- 41:28You've got on.
- 41:29On a free media.
- 41:30So ITV have been spending time with, with Reform UK candidates and councillors and a deputy mayor, for example, in.
- 41:39In Solihull, and they have been listening to them and recording them and telling you what they have said.
- 41:44I need to warn you in advance that although we have bleeped things and being very careful that you.
- 41:53There will still be profoundly offensive ideas conveyed and some of the language that we are permitted to broadcast will be pretty offensive as well.
- 42:00And this is just the tip of the iceberg that the program will be broadcast on Inside Reform UK.
- 42:08And although 50% of me says this is up there with reporting that the Pope's a Catholic or bears shallalalalala in the woods because of that phrase.
- 42:16Legitimate concerns because of the insistence from Farage for the best part of 20 years that, oh, we vet our candidates.
- 42:23And just because we didn't do a very good job of vetting them in the past doesn't mean that we're not going to vet them really well now.
- 42:30We've got the best vetting process we.
- 42:32I've done more than anybody else to keep the far right out of British.
- 42:35And he's allowed to say these things.
- 42:37Things.
- 42:38It's extraordinary, isn't it?
- 42:41You see, today is a day actually for recapping, isn't it?
- 42:46Because how many people that told us Donald Trump was going to be fantastic or that everyone was exaggerating how awful Donald Trump was?
- 42:53How many of them are exactly the same people that allow Nigel Farish to claim that his parties are not riddled with racists or that his vetting system is somehow successful, or that it's not his fault when it turns
- 43:05out that he attracts racists like.
- 43:08Like moths, a flame.
- 43:10How many of the same people responsible for cheerleading Donald Trump have also allowed that phrase legitimate concerns to pass into common parlance without actually asking people to define precisely what is legitimate about them?
- 43:27Because too many people with brown faces on the streets of Birmingham for Robert Jenrick, or too many black people in adverts on the telly for Sarah Poachin?
- 43:36Those are not legitimate concerns.
- 43:38Those are racism.
- 43:40They are racist observations.
- 43:43Objectively racist.
- 43:45I don't like that because it's Brown.
- 43:47I don't like her.
- 43:48I don't want to see him.
- 43:50Because they are not white.
- 43:51That's racist.
- 43:52Right.
- 43:53It's got nothing to do with immigration and everything to do with racism.
- 43:57And how scared are people of saying that?
- 44:02Still?
- 44:03We haven't been scared, have we?
- 44:05We haven't fallen for this, have we?
- 44:07It's all a bit Catholic, today's show, isn't it, with a big C, A bit of self flagellation at the top, worrying that we've been sort of gaslit into not saying what we know to be true.
- 44:16I don't think that's true.
- 44:17But who?
- 44:18Honestly, tell me this isn't the phone in.
- 44:21Well, maybe it is, but it would be very odd if anybody rang in.
- 44:24Who here is surprised to discover that Nigel Farage's latest political party is absolutely riddled with racists?
- 44:32Really?
- 44:32You're surprised?
- 44:33Oh, would you like to buy a bridge?
- 44:35You can go and have a look at it.
- 44:36It's just down by the Tower of London.
- 44:38It's an amazing bridge.
- 44:39It opens up in the middle.
- 44:40It's yours for £2 million.
- 44:41I'll have it shipped to wherever it is you are by tea time tomorrow.
- 44:44Who here is actually surprised?
- 44:47I've got a really interesting question forming in my mind about what's happening here, but I haven't actually really got it on the tip of my tongue yet.
- 44:59It's something to do with misdirection or misinformation, because when ITV broadcast this program on Sunday, there is a.
- 45:08A presumption that we will be shocked.
- 45:11And yet at the same time, the least shocking thing anybody in the British media could report that Nigel is that Nigel Farage is leading a party absolutely riddled with racists.
- 45:21So something has gone horribly wrong here.
- 45:24Here.
- 45:25Whether it is a failure properly to scrutinize and challenge his ridiculous claims that he roots racism out of the party, or that his vetting process is anything other than an exercise in cashing checks and rubber stamping applications, or
- 45:38that he only ever acts when the situation becomes untenable.
- 45:46What possible reason can there be for this, this sort of ship of bigotry still being afloat?
- 45:56That's the bit I don't quite get.
- 45:58Do you see what I mean?
- 46:01What I really want to talk about is optimism, hope and the idea that two things.
- 46:10Number one, the very positive response to Kemi Badenok's rejection of Suella Brevam's race that has seen her looking at the polling and the analysis of the polling.
- 46:20I mean, part of this so called Badenot boost is down to the media that brought you Brexit, Boris Johnson, Liz Truss, austerity and Donald Trump cheerleaders now telling you that Cami Badenot is going to be brilliant.
- 46:30I mean, that is an extraordinary exercise in both self and public delusion.
- 46:35But one thing the public have genuinely responded to is her attack in her conference speech on reform UK's racism and boost in the polls probably has more to do with that, or at least as much to do with
- 46:51that as it does with the nonsense being spouted by right wing media about her being some sort of cross between Boudicca and Margaret Thatcher.
- 47:00So that's good news, right?
- 47:02That means that right wing voters are responding positively to a rejection of racism.
- 47:09Now, I want you to be honest with me.
- 47:12I'm obviously a kind of enormous cliche, lefty, liberal, metropolitan elite, champagne, socialist, all of that malarkey.
- 47:21I have been pleasantly surprised by that.
- 47:24The numbers aren't enormous, but they're significant.
- 47:28Right wing voters attracted to a rejection of racism.
- 47:34Now, what is that?
- 47:35The corollary of that is the corollary of right wing voters repelled by racism.
- 47:42It's the same thing in a way.
- 47:44You're not going to be attracted to a rejection of racism unless you are repelled by real racism.
- 47:54And that's why I want you to talk to me next.
- 47:58And I'm playing you some of the fruits of ITV's journalism with that warning that it's pretty grim stuff, although, I'm afraid, entirely predictable.
- 48:08I don't think we get to sit here going, oh, oh, some Reform UK politicians have said some absolutely hideous things about people of color and Muslims and black children and who can genuinely claim to be shocked?
- 48:19Who's going to sit here going, I can't believe I voted for them.
- 48:22They're massive racists.
- 48:26Color me shocked.
- 48:27Clips will be with you short.
- 48:30But I think I'm a white bloke, you see, he might shoot me down in flames for this.
- 48:38Should we be a little bit more upbeat about this country's attitude to racist politicians?
- 48:44We're going to take a short break now, then you will help me illuminate this conversation with your thoughts.
- 48:58Have a listen to some racists who are very big fans of Nigel Farage.
- 49:03I know that because they joined his political party, they applied to be candidates for his political party and they in many cases got elected as representatives of his political party.
- 49:13And, and although reform being riddled with racists is, is right up there with the Pope being a Catholic and bears preferring sylvan idylls for their lavatorial habits, it still matters.
- 49:27And, and we'll work out why.
- 49:29Surely here is a man called Alan Feeney who is the deputy mayor of Solihull and a councillor for reform.
- 49:37So when a house comes up for.
- 49:39Sale, white people need to be in there.
- 49:41You almost need to out out Muslim.
- 49:44The Muslims.
- 49:45You'd need a proper nuclear option.
- 49:48Like literally, literally drag them at their homes, stick them on planes and off to Pakistan, which you'll never do in a month of Sundays.
- 49:55I'd be saying no more than 1% of British population can be non white.
- 50:02Crikey.
- 50:03That's bad news for Sveta Braverman, Zia Youssef, Nadim Zahawi, sundry other senior members of Nigel Farage's racist enterprise.
- 50:11Here's someone called Dean Miller who was elected as a councillor for Bromley and was sent to make a field because he's obviously very highly thought of in the party that really carefully vets candidates for racism.
- 50:23He was sent to campaign in Makerfield during the recent by election there that they lost.
- 50:29We've been ethnically cleansed out of London.
- 50:32Because you never usually get any like that.
- 50:34So anyone over in Bromley and now, you know, only like massive logic are in community there.
- 50:41No, just like this.
- 50:42It's like all the ethnic kids, they're.
- 50:45Not, you know, they're not animal disabled to say it.
- 50:51I'm not great.
- 50:52I'm not racist.
- 50:53You know what I mean?
- 50:53But sorry to sniggle, I'm not racist.
- 50:58But it's crikey.
- 51:00And.
- 51:00And this character has resigned.
- 51:02Remember how many times I've said to you, where there is racism, there will be misogyny.
- 51:07The.
- 51:07The two go hand in hand because it is weak.
- 51:10Men desperate to impose some sort of control on others, others who are different from them.
- 51:18So it doesn't matter whether they are ethnically different or whether they are women.
- 51:23Just I am a man and I am inadequate and I am therefore desperate to enjoy dominion over either people of color or women.
- 51:31Including if you follow the tradwife movements in the United States of America and elsewhere, including women in my own family.
- 51:38Yeah.
- 51:39I think you've probably come across a man like counselor Chris Whelan in your life.
- 51:43But he may not have been quite as blatant as this.
- 51:48If she was my daughter.
- 51:49It still be bat night on a Thursday.
- 51:56Time for your bath.
- 51:59I'll wash it properly this time.
- 52:01Yes.
- 52:02Oh, God.
- 52:03We're looking end up in the papers.
- 52:07I'm really sorry that I have to repeat this to you.
- 52:10It's worth bearing in mind because I'm drawing parallels between racism and misogyny, between Donald Trump And Nigel Farage, Donald Trump has talked about how he would have dated his own daughter in, in a slightly different universe.
- 52:21That man just said in public, in reference to a female reform candidate, in reference to one of his colleagues, if she was my daughter, it would still be Bath Knox on a Thursday.
- 52:33He's now resigned on personal and health grounds.
- 52:37Of course he has.
- 52:38And listen, I think it's time we stop pretending that this is a surprise or that this is a balanced conversation or that no, it's perfectly possible to be attracted to this party even if you're not a racist.
- 52:53Should we just start being honest about this now?
- 52:56And in order to avoid the misery of that conclusion, I'm asking you whether or not maybe, just maybe the disgust that this will cause, coupled with the booster Cami Badenok's fortunes that her rejection of racism entailed yesterday, means
- 53:12that people like me maybe need to start being a little bit more upbeat about tolerance in this country.
- 53:21I don't know.
- 53:22And I do know that as a white bloke, I don't get to make that decision.
- 53:25I just get to ask you that question.
- 53:26Eli is in Rochester.
- 53:28What are reckon.
- 53:29Oh, hi James, a long time listener, first time caller to you actually welcome.
- 53:35Yes, I think it's yes and no.
- 53:39Yes, in the sense that is good to actually hear the leader of a major right wing party actually addressing the fact that there is racist connotations and pushing back against that.
- 53:52And no, because then we lose sight of the fact that it's my worth as a human being or even belonging to the country that is being discussed, you know, and that should never be something that is okay.
- 54:07Even if it's 10 people left that, that we're talking about, you know, like the inherent value that I have.
- 54:14It's, it's just, but if someone is.
- 54:16Quite, if someone is questioning that, then, then it is not only necessary, but it is welcome, welcome that somebody else challenges it.
- 54:25Even though, and, and this is why I made the observation a moment ago about my own ethnicity, because I would have missed this point.
- 54:31Even though it's going to make you very uncomfortable to be the subject of that conversation, you have to welcome the counterbalance to the bigotry.
- 54:39Yes, absolutely, I do welcome that.
- 54:42But the caveat is that pushing back because it's her children does not mean that she understands, understand the connotation of what actually happens on the ground in everyday life.
- 54:54And the second part is that now as a black person, I have to start thinking when people look at me, you know, for more than Two seconds.
- 55:02Yeah.
- 55:04What are they thinking?
- 55:04Are they judging my, you know, what thoughts do they have towards me?
- 55:08When my kids interact with other kids, I have to start thinking, is it okay for my kids to go to their houses and things like that?
- 55:15She would never experience that.
- 55:17And those things are not addressed.
- 55:19So she's only talking about it in the sense, oh, they're English.
- 55:22But what about the day to day experiences for the everyday man?
- 55:26Then she may not be addressed.
- 55:28No, you're absolutely right.
- 55:30So how do you respond when you hear a bloke with even less experience.
- 55:35Well, considerably less experience of racist ideation than Cami Badenot.
- 55:41Although I think she denies that institutional racism exists and I fully acknowledge that it exists.
- 55:46So, you know, it's a little bit more nuanced than you might have expect.
- 55:49Forgive me, Eli, it's not, it's not as black and white as it might be.
- 55:53But, but when you hear me on the radio suggesting that maybe we need to maybe, maybe.
- 55:59Because here's what I think.
- 56:01Reform and people who have sought to appease them have thrown open the door to racism, that they have allowed it to be publicly acceptable, once again, to be racist.
- 56:13You don't get fired for saying there's too many black people in Birmingham or there's too many black people on telly.
- 56:18That's hideous.
- 56:19I can only imagine, I would feel, if that was me, or more pertinently, my children, that people like Robert Jenrick and Sarah Potion were describing or Suella Braverman was telling, that they can't be English, that they're not English.
- 56:32And I have spent, we perhaps have spent the last few years thinking, worrying, noticing how many people flock to that maypole.
- 56:42How many people are now dancing around that maypole.
- 56:46The, the, the thing I'm flirting with today is the idea that there may not be quite as many people as we thought.
- 56:54And that when the racism that is endemic in any organization that Nigel Farage ever leads becomes absolutely crystal clear, as it is now, that some people drawn to that, this is where I'm going to sound either very naive
- 57:09or, or fatally optimistic.
- 57:11Some of the people currently thinking they might vote for him, him, they will actually be put off.
- 57:18James.
- 57:20Be gentle with me.
- 57:21Eli, be gentle with me.
- 57:23I'll try.
- 57:24About 20 to 25% of the population supports reform.
- 57:29Yeah, but do they know how racist it is?
- 57:34If they've heard of their policies and every single policy they have, have.
- 57:41There's a tread of discrimination running through it.
- 57:44That's simply not true.
- 57:45Some of it is designed entirely to further enrich cryptocurrency.
- 57:49Billionaires based in foreign countries.
- 57:51Apologies.
- 57:52And they are based in foreign countries, Eli.
- 57:54So there's nothing racist about that.
- 57:57That's.
- 57:57That's very true.
- 57:58But if you think about that, right, that means about 1 in 4 to 5 people already subscribe to reform.
- 58:04And there's the other hour rated, you know, all the other hour starting parties that other people are starting support.
- 58:10And then there's also the, you know, the slice of the conservative that also have the discriminative outlook.
- 58:17Right.
- 58:18The biases.
- 58:19Then we're looking at about.
- 58:21I'm being generous here, 30%, 1 in 3 people, James.
- 58:26So you're not deriving any optimism whatsoever from both the boost to Cami Badenoch's political fortunes by her rejection of reforms.
- 58:36Racism.
- 58:36But as you've reminded me, perhaps not all racism.
- 58:39Or the expected revulsion at the revelations regarding Faridge's racist army that will be in the ITV documentary on Sunday.
- 58:50That's what they should have called it, actually.
- 58:52That is correct, yes.
- 58:53I am not.
- 58:54And because we, I think a lot of people take solace in the fact that we don't have lynchings and, you know, very, how can I put it, you know, the in your face racism and thinking, oh, we're not
- 59:08lynching people and we're not saying all black people.
- 59:11But they don't understand that these biases needs to be spoken about.
- 59:14And I don't want it to be platform and that just be the only thing we speak about.
- 59:18No, of course not.
- 59:19But it is, it is endemic.
- 59:23Ali is in Birmingham.
- 59:24Ali, what made you pick up the phone?
- 59:26Hi, Jane, I am actually in that video that ITV News put out.
- 59:34Okay.
- 59:34I'm.
- 59:35I'm the chap whose door he knocks on in the orange shirt.
- 59:39And we had a good old chat, me.
- 59:42And it was very polite, it was very cordial.
- 59:48And to see and hear what he said after he left my doorstep was quite a shock.
- 59:56Tell me a bit about the conversation that you had.
- 59:58Well, we.
- 59:59It was a long haul conversation and I don't want to say too much because your producers have told me I got to be very careful about what I say.
- 1:00:08But the long and short of it is we discussed a lot of different topics and in the community in general, there's a lot of accusations, should we say that Alan Feeney targets Asian households with regards to planning permission
- 1:00:25and stuff like that?
- 1:00:26And that is what I put to him.
- 1:00:27Oh, I see.
- 1:00:28Okay.
- 1:00:29And that is what was on tape.
- 1:00:31So that he displays discriminatory approaches in his work as a councillor and deputy mayor of Solihull.
- 1:00:37And you put that allegation.
- 1:00:38Allegation to him?
- 1:00:40Yes.
- 1:00:40Okay.
- 1:00:41And, you know, he.
- 1:00:42He almost had me convinced, James, I'm not gonna lie to you.
- 1:00:44He was very personable.
- 1:00:48And the scary thing is, is this the same person who 10 minutes later was saying, we want to drag them out of their houses?
- 1:00:57Well, let's have a little listen.
- 1:00:58Let's have a little listen to what he said about people like you.
- 1:01:02You'd need a proper nuclear option.
- 1:01:05Like, literally drag them at their home, stick them on plant planes, and off to Pakistan.
- 1:01:09Did he shake your hand?
- 1:01:11He did.
- 1:01:12He absolutely did.
- 1:01:13And, you know, he came across as very likable, James, and I hate to admit that.
- 1:01:20No, no, it's the point.
- 1:01:21That's the point.
- 1:01:22That's the point.
- 1:01:23The bizarre thing is, and this is one of the reasons why I hate what happened so much, is me and my brother were texting the night before this came out.
- 1:01:31Yeah.
- 1:01:31And I was saying, oh, well, you know what?
- 1:01:32Alan Feeney, he's actually all right with me.
- 1:01:35And my brother's like, no, he's not.
- 1:01:36He's a racist.
- 1:01:37And the thing that I hate most is now I admit that my Buddha's right.
- 1:01:41Gotta go back to your brother and give him some.
- 1:01:43Yeah, give him some kudos.
- 1:01:44Did you.
- 1:01:45I mean, from my point of view, and you're obviously following local politics that.
- 1:01:49That.
- 1:01:49That they're more closely than I am, but, I mean, did you not subscribe?
- 1:01:54I think your brother probably did that reform is a racist enterprise.
- 1:01:59I.
- 1:01:59Or were you persuadable that it isn't or wasn't?
- 1:02:02No, I.
- 1:02:03I knew that they had severe racial elements to it.
- 1:02:06Sure.
- 1:02:07But I am.
- 1:02:08I am neither right wing or left wing.
- 1:02:11I am, you know, I'm some of the other and some of the other.
- 1:02:13Yeah.
- 1:02:14And it was a case of, let's see what he's about and let's see if he can account for what he has said online, because that's the only interaction I'd had with him.
- 1:02:24Yeah, I see.
- 1:02:25And again, he came across as very, you know, very good.
- 1:02:29But, you know, you look at people like Stephen then, and they come across as.
- 1:02:35It's quite clear that he is in it for the money.
- 1:02:38Yes.
- 1:02:38And, you know, the attention, where to someone like Alan Feeney, it is far, far, far more vicious and sinister because he is actually in a place of authority now.
- 1:02:51Yes.
- 1:02:52And he has these opinions, and that is what is scary.
- 1:02:55And do you have any Confidence or optimism that when these sorts of moments are.
- 1:03:01Because I can tell you now what the defense will be.
- 1:03:03The defense will be, oh, well, they don't investigate anybody else or oh, our vetting process is still a bit embryonic and it will and it will get better.
- 1:03:10And I don't know why racists are attracted to me like moths to a flame or flies to a large pile of.
- 1:03:16What do you think when this stuff comes out, it will put people off?
- 1:03:21Absolutely not.
- 1:03:22No.
- 1:03:22Oh, man.
- 1:03:23No, really.
- 1:03:24I'll tell you why I say that is.
- 1:03:27I know you're right.
- 1:03:28If it's something that I've realized is people like myself, I'm first, second generation immigrant, my parents come here.
- 1:03:37In my immediate family, there are doctors, there are, you know, we've got quite a successful family.
- 1:03:44Sure.
- 1:03:44And you know, I've realized that there is nothing that any minority in this country can do do that will make us acceptable to racist.
- 1:03:56Nothing.
- 1:03:57No matter, no amount of integration, there's always going to be a sticking point.
- 1:04:01So, for example, they say, oh, you know, we all congregate in certain communities.
- 1:04:05Well, we move out, you know, to, to make our lives better, to better areas that, oh, well, they're moving in.
- 1:04:09Yeah, you know, we don't want them in there.
- 1:04:11There's never going to be a point where they turn around and say, okay, yeah, you know, we accept you, but.
- 1:04:15Things were better 10 years ago.
- 1:04:19Yeah.
- 1:04:20So they can get better again.
- 1:04:24I think they're gonna get worse for the.
- 1:04:25Goodbye, James.
- 1:04:25I really do now.
- 1:04:27And, and your previous call, I was talking about his, his daughter and I want to make a very, very quick anecdote.
- 1:04:33Of course he, he spoke about how his daughter had this incident and you know, and he didn't know how to handle it.
- 1:04:41We, me and my wife, we've got a five year old and a one year old, both girls, and my wife's a secondary school teacher, so.
- 1:04:47So my wife said to me one day, she goes, we need to sit down and we need to have a conversation with our daughter about racism.
- 1:04:54And I was like, well, why does she need to know about that?
- 1:04:57She goes, if we don't tell her that she's different or that she's a certain skin tone, somebody else is.
- 1:05:05And that was a conversation that I had to have with a five year old.
- 1:05:08And I'm glad that we did because in her school a situation arose where another little girl didn't want her to play because my daughter had picked a Moana doll, which is slightly darker skin and child didn't want my
- 1:05:20daughter to play with her because of this darker skinned doll.
- 1:05:25And I'm glad that we had that conversation forewarned, forearmed.
- 1:05:28I mate, I've got a crack on.
- 1:05:30We'll talk again, I hope.
- 1:05:31Thank you for that.
- 1:05:32And hey Ali, before, give my regards to your brother.
- 1:05:35Yeah?
- 1:05:35I will be, my love.
- 1:05:39What a show.
- 1:05:40Powerful, insightful, educational, right across the board.
- 1:05:44And if I feel like that, I hope you do too.
- 1:05:46If you didn't, then why not get involved yourself and increase the quality of contrib?
- 1:05:51If you think that's possible, you can call.
- 1:05:53You can WhatsApp me every weekday from 10 on 03-456-060973 or text 84850.
- 1:06:01I hope to speak with you soon.
- 1:06:03This has been a global production.