Latest / Free Cities Podcast / 178 - 8 Hard Truths from 25 Years of Investing in Free Cities | Patri Friedman
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome to the Free Cities podcast. My name is Timothy Allen and this is the official podcast
- 0:17of the Free Cities Foundation.
- 0:30Hello and welcome to this episode number 178 of the Free Cities podcast.
- 0:37Yes, that's right folks, we are one-stop shop for everything Free Cities, charter cities,
- 0:43SEZs, network states, startup societies, pioneer communities, intentional communities,
- 0:48pop-up cities, governance, innovation, seasteads, homesteads, freesteads. I like that one,
- 0:54I only heard that one this week, freesteads. There's so many ways to describe all this stuff,
- 0:59these days. Anyway, you know me, I'm a simple man. It's all free cities to me. Anyway, welcome again
- 1:04from Prospera. Yes, I'm still here reporting from the front line. I've done three out of my
- 1:12four weeks of living here. Not looking forward to going, to be honest. It's great. But I've got to
- 1:18go off to the US next week to Austin to record some shows there and also to visit the Running
- 1:27remote conference apparently the biggest remote work gathering in the world i'm told looking
- 1:33forward to that one this episode is brought to you by veritas villages they're our lead sponsor
- 1:39of course and yes they're building off-grid freedom-oriented communities across latin america
- 1:45designed for people who value sovereignty resilience and a higher degree of personal
- 1:51autonomy and as you may have heard they've recently secured approval for a new 340 acre
- 1:58development in the highly coveted area of Atenas in Costa Rica that's a quiet
- 2:04valley known for its very mild year-round climate rolling hills and what you would call a slower
- 2:12more livable pace of life than nearby San Jose this project is happening alongside their other
- 2:19projects in Nicaragua and Panama. Veritas Villages have a very strong alignment with the Bitcoin
- 2:27ethos. You can purchase your property with Bitcoin, you can spend Bitcoin within the communities
- 2:32themselves, and they'll help you set up mining rigs at your home to make the most of your excess
- 2:39energy production. They also have a what I would call pretty sensible and real-world Bitcoin
- 2:46treasury strategy. All in all, they're a trailblazing Bitcoin citadel company, if you ask
- 2:52me. Anyway, if you're curious to learn more or explore becoming a resident, you can find out more
- 2:57at www.veritasvillages.com forward slash free cities. Please mention us and jump in the show
- 3:04notes if you just want to click on that link and go to it. All right. So today's episode, well,
- 3:10I suppose it's a bit of a reality check for you all. If you've been following this space for a
- 3:15while, which I'm sure you have, you'll know there's no shortage of big ideas here, bold
- 3:21visions and let's be honest, a fair bit of what people might call LARPing. If you don't
- 3:28know what that is, look it up. So I think every now and then it's probably worth stepping
- 3:34back and asking ourselves what actually works in this space. My guest today is Patrick Friedman.
- 3:42He's been in this world for around 25 years, one of the true OGs.
- 3:47He was here in the early days of seasteading through to investing in real world free cities via Pronomos Capital.
- 3:55And what's interesting about Patri is he's not really selling the dream here anymore.
- 4:01He's pretty much stress testing it.
- 4:03In this conversation, we break down what he sees as the eight hard lessons that he's learnt during that quarter of a century of investing in free city projects.
- 4:15Why so many projects fail, where people go wrong and what it really takes to build something that survives contact with reality.
- 4:24We get into seasteading versus land-based free cities, the difference between communities and actual jurisdictions, why economic engines matter much more than ideology, and why perhaps controversially, I suppose, experience tends to beat youthful ambition in this space.
- 4:43I hope that doesn't offend some of you.
- 4:45There's also a bigger thread running through all of this, which is where governance itself might be heading, especially as technology, i.e. AI and global competition starts to reshape the landscape.
- 4:59So this one's less about what sounds good and more about what actually holds up best in the real world.
- 5:07Thanks for coming on the show, Patry. See you next time. Right. Value for value supporters.
- 5:12here's the rich list this week according to my fountain.fm dashboard in first place well done
- 5:20mate christopher albanese second place matthias third justin bianchi fourth lapin and fifth
- 5:27shadrach thank you the ogs of this show donating bitcoin streaming bitcoin many thanks to you all
- 5:36and anyone that wants to get involved jump on over to fountain.fm where you can support the
- 5:42show with a subscription or streaming sats also if you wouldn't mind please drop us a review on
- 5:47your podcasting app i always forget to tell people right everything you could possibly need about
- 5:53everything well it's in the show notes and don't forget last thing freecities.fm is the place to go
- 6:00if you want to dive into the whole archive of this pod there's nearly 200 episodes over there
- 6:06which I've recorded pretty much over the last four years.
- 6:11I haven't missed a week, believe it or not.
- 6:13I've been releasing something every Friday for nearly four years.
- 6:17We've been here every step of the way documenting this movement,
- 6:22the original and the best, even though I say so myself.
- 6:25Tell your friends as more and more people get interested.
- 6:29I'm noticing that happen and Google Trends is showing that too.
- 6:33send them my way and I'll get them up to scratch on what's been going on up until this point right
- 6:38time for your eight lessons from Patry you better grab a notebook and pen for this one
- 6:45and when you do of course you know what to do just sit back relax and enjoy my conversation with
- 6:51Patry Friedman
- 7:03I've got to ask you, okay, because you're a bit of a seasteading OG,
- 7:13what's your opinion on it currently?
- 7:15What do you think about seasteading sort of now?
- 7:20I think that there are kind of like certain niche use cases that it probably works for.
- 7:26you know one that i've heard recently for example is doing psychedelic therapy on ships
- 7:33flagged by countries that where those psychedelics are legal so you know it's a little bit like the
- 7:40the dutch abortion boat women on waves which brought a dutch flagged vessel to countries
- 7:45where abortions were illegal and then um you know people could get on the boat and go to
- 7:51international waters and have an abortion. Well, that's a real thing. Yeah, this was in the 80s,
- 7:5790s, maybe. I covered it in my seasetting book that I wrote in the early 2000s. And so it's an
- 8:03example of the way that the law of the sea works, where a ship is a bit like a floating embassy of
- 8:09a country You register with a country you fly the flag and you under their laws and you out past 12 nautical miles And so it a way of bringing different legal systems to different geographic places And that incredibly powerful And I think that that something that very
- 8:26unique about the legal environment of the ocean. And there's various things that you could do with
- 8:31that, you know, whether it's psychedelic treatments or more general, like cutting edge medical
- 8:36treatments like I do here in Prospera, you know, where you and I are talking today,
- 8:40you know you could do them on a ship but more generally the ocean is just very difficult
- 8:46very expensive you know I'm I started working on the seaside idea it's been like 25 years
- 8:54we haven't had a lot of progress and you know meanwhile we have this whole charter cities and
- 9:01zones thing which just seems much more tractable it's less romantic it's not as good as a meme
- 9:06It's not as fun, but it works a lot better in the real world as a way to improve governance, to develop different rule sets.
- 9:15And so for me, like I love the fun and the romance of Seasteading.
- 9:19And I think it's, you know, that kind of like meme quality is great.
- 9:23But as a practical way to get to use different rule sets, to get to design different rule sets, you know, which is what I'm all about.
- 9:33I think it's just, it's just, you know, much worse.
- 9:36What about long-term? Do you believe in it long-term?
- 9:43I'm not sure, but I do believe in space-steading long-term.
- 9:50And, you know, one of the reasons that I like the ocean is that it's a different physical medium.
- 9:58Like, it has literally different properties, and that's why a cruise ship is as big as a skyscraper.
- 10:05The cruise ship is like a skyscraper lying on its side.
- 10:08And it moves all around, goes to different countries,
- 10:12does trans-oceanic voyages.
- 10:15And this medium of buildings can move,
- 10:20which is true on the ocean and mostly not true on land,
- 10:24although it's always a funny video when it is.
- 10:28It's even more true in space.
- 10:31You can move buildings even more easily in space.
- 10:35You know, obviously not, I don't mean like lifting out of gravity well, but once you're
- 10:39out of gravity well and in space, you can move buildings around.
- 10:42And this is important because it means that you can, instead of just voting with your
- 10:49feet or voting with your wallet by leaving a badly run jurisdiction to go someplace better,
- 10:55you can vote with your building.
- 10:57You can vote with your house.
- 10:59You can vote with your factory, you know, with your office headquarters.
- 11:03and so when the physical infrastructure is able to move around,
- 11:10I call this dynamic geography, and rearrange itself,
- 11:13this puts incredible competitive pressure on the jurisdictions to do a good job.
- 11:19And I just think on Earth, there's so much land
- 11:22and there's so much more we can do with that land.
- 11:26I'm not sure that we'll need the ocean for space.
- 11:29obviously it's incredible for all kinds of ocean specific things um but as far as places to build
- 11:37society uh i don't think we need the ocean we got lots more we can do on land um but from a
- 11:44conceptual and a future standpoint i i do think that this kind of dynamic geography thing is going
- 11:51to become real as we settle space that the well the conclusion i drew coming from say like the
- 11:59the sort of prosper model, the private governance model,
- 12:03seasteading at least, or the idea behind it,
- 12:06say cruise shipping even,
- 12:07is a better way of doing the land-based version
- 12:12because you can't move.
- 12:13So as a meme, I think it is great.
- 12:16It is much more real for me
- 12:19because you can literally move the building.
- 12:22However, it doesn't go unnoticed
- 12:25that a lot of space projects use the ocean to train,
- 12:28you know like um i'm i'm surprised you don't think that there's a future in it before space
- 12:34do you honestly do you think that people will make it to space before they make it out into
- 12:38the ocean to to sort of create communities i mean it seems like it's a function of technology really
- 12:43and that's the only limiting factor here but i i get the feeling we get sea stuff before we got
- 12:49space stuff possibly i mean i i think it's about economics right like it both the ocean and even
- 12:57more so space are very difficult operating environments, very expensive. And so it doesn't
- 13:03make sense to go there unless you're getting something that makes it worthwhile. And, you know,
- 13:08we see potential in space with, say, asteroid mining as an example. Like there are resources
- 13:14out there that might make it worth it to go and get them. You know, and on the ocean, the resources
- 13:20that are worth it to go out and get is mostly oil. And we're doing that. And, you know, there is some
- 13:29amount of permanent population for that where the, you know, amount of value extracted in the
- 13:34expensive, difficult operating environment is made up for by the value of the resource. And that's
- 13:38why we're doing it. But, you know, unless somebody finds or creates some new resource that requires
- 13:45people to live out there that is valuable enough that it kind of you know pays for the costs of
- 13:52going out and being in that operating environment uh i'm just not sure how it would make any economic
- 13:58sense have you heard about these rare earth nodules at the bottom of the sea yes because that that's
- 14:03pretty much i mean if it's true it's hard to say but people seem to believe it is you know sure but
- 14:08but why do you need to why do you need a city on the ocean to extract those modules like we get the
- 14:15oil without mostly cities on the ocean. True, true. I think that arises from the fact that,
- 14:22I mean, obviously coming from a seasteading perspective, one of the ways to create a city,
- 14:27even on land is the same as to have a business model there and start with a business.
- 14:31So hopefully, I mean, seasteaders would hope that that would evolve into a city. I agree.
- 14:36We don't see oil rig cities. I mean, we see quite big oil rigs and, you know, hundreds of people
- 14:41living on them. But yeah, so I mean, hope, hope is great. And, and there's a lot of hope in this
- 14:49space. And that's great. And, you know, the people who don't have the hope should get the hope. But
- 14:54once you have hope, you also have to consider practicality, right? We only have so much time,
- 15:00we only have so much resources. And I think that, you know, kind of, yeah, hoping that an industry
- 15:08evolves in the direction you want is just is not a very good bet yeah and your theory would be then
- 15:14that in space if you're mining an asteroid you need a proper colony out there whereas on the sea
- 15:20you don't need a colony so chances are they'll they'll be that will happen at sea but it won't
- 15:25be in the city format right yeah i mean you can can you can think about like what are the costs
- 15:30of transport versus the cost of staying out there right so with an oil rig they can resupply it um
- 15:37You know, an oil rig makes so much money that you could resupply it by helicopter if you had to, although you prefer not to.
- 15:43So you can resupply it, you can bring people there, and you don't need self-sufficiency because you can bring the stuff there and import it to this environment where it would be hard to be self-sufficient because it's so difficult and expensive.
- 15:57But in space, the transport costs for material are so high that I don't think that – not that a space colony is going to be fully self-sufficient.
- 16:09There's going to be some amount of stuff like high-value, low-weight things that are worth lifting into orbit to import there.
- 16:16but the the costs of getting there are so much higher than the costs of getting
- 16:21someplace on the ocean that you know the math says that a lot more needs to
- 16:26happen locally you need to be a lot more self-sufficient do you think that the
- 16:32sort of space memes are realistic at the moment I mean Elon seems to talk about it quite a lot and I get mixed answers to that question Some people say well yeah it a bit like AI In five years everyone lost their job
- 16:45And other people say in 18 months or in five years, it won't make any difference.
- 16:49What do you think about the space prospect?
- 16:52I don't think that it does not look to me like we are close to being able to settle space
- 16:59and close as in like it's within years.
- 17:01but launch costs are steadily decreasing you know our launch velocity is increasing
- 17:08and you know it's not it's not 50 years away that we're going to be able to settle space but it's
- 17:15also not going to happen in the next five years right it's it's it's somewhere in that in that
- 17:19in between you know it's not it's not an either or yeah and on the topic of space have you thought
- 17:25much about the governance models in space? Have you got a preferred version?
- 17:31You know, it's interesting. I think I've been trying to figure out this tension I have in myself
- 17:38of like being all about governance experimentation, but yet hating to get pinned down
- 17:45to any particular governance model. And I think the reason is that I just kind of have a brain
- 17:52that's very relentless about trying to like take things to like higher and higher levels of like
- 17:58of leverage of metaness etc and so for me it's like hey i see this huge problem in the world
- 18:04which is that our governance is pretty crappy there's not very much competition our legal
- 18:11systems are bad we don't have good incentive for our government and as a result they don't work
- 18:15very well and i think that if we can try new things we're going to fix that but i try to keep
- 18:20like pretty agnostic about what new things to try. You know, the model that I'm focused on these days,
- 18:27you know, for a variety of reasons, both, you know, because I'm kind of like, I'm a libertarian
- 18:32and a free market person and an entrepreneur. And, you know, I ran the first charter city
- 18:39investment fund, Pernomus Capital for five years, is the like the for-profit corporation that
- 18:49is the government that sets the rules to try to attract people, to try to attract businesses and
- 18:56GDP, which is the prosper model. That's kind of the model that I feel inspired to put my time into.
- 19:03But in terms of my work in general, I just try to stay very agnostic. And I say,
- 19:09it's my job to try to change the world so that people with ideas for different methods of
- 19:14governance can try them out. But there are so many different ideas that I can't track them. I can't
- 19:21process them. I can't read all the constitutions that people send me. And so I'm just very, very
- 19:27kind of hands off on those details, right? So that I can like laser focus on like change the world
- 19:35so that the people who are passionate about some particular model or some particular type of
- 19:41governance have a chance to put it into practice and then we can see how it works amen to that
- 19:47right um i was listening to your talk yesterday and you know i've taken a screenshot here you put
- 19:56you currently writing up what i've learned um from fund one and i thought it was an interesting list
- 20:04especially the first one um number one you wrote down here lessons learned is that founders tend
- 20:10to be in their 40s not their 20s yeah that's quite contentious yeah i mean in especially i mean the
- 20:17free cities and sort of charter city space is is you know it's a massive spectrum and i find that
- 20:23on you know you kind of on one end you have a lot more youngsters and more you know and on this sort
- 20:29of network state end you find a lot of much more younger people and but um yeah the youngsters
- 20:34wouldn't like to hear that can you can you sort of like validate that 20s not 40s sorry 40s not
- 20:4020s. Yeah. I mean, so I kind of started out with it with the assumption like, hey, what we see in
- 20:47the Silicon Valley startup world, you know, I spent 25 years from, you know, 1998 to 2023 or
- 20:54something in the California Bay Area, is that you have these hotshot 20 something founders who
- 21:01sometimes build these incredible companies and turn out to be amazing, badass geniuses. And that
- 21:07that's kind of who you're looking for. And what I've seen in this space is that,
- 21:14you know, and there's data to contradict this, actually. I've seen like investment fund data
- 21:19that actually like found it depends on the industry. But founders in their 30s and 40s
- 21:25actually succeed more often because they have more experience. But, you know, kind of like
- 21:31In this space specifically, what we're doing is it's a startup on hard mode.
- 21:37And a startup is already hard mode.
- 21:40And when you're doing something that difficult, you really need an exceptional person with exceptional experience because it's just that hard.
- 21:51And people in their 20s, every exceptional person was in their 20s once, but they didn't have the exceptional experience then.
- 22:01And, you know, another thing about this space specifically is that to do the charter city model, you need to be sitting down with heads of state and senior ministers and talking to them about how you're going to do this win-win partnership to develop their country, to bring jobs.
- 22:19And that's just much harder for someone in their 20s than someone in their 40s.
- 22:23And, you know, it probably should be. And, you know, which is not to say that that that some 20 something founder won't go and kick ass and make a chart like it could definitely happen.
- 22:36But as far as like like placing my bets. Right. I just I just really think that we need really experienced people who have experience working with governments and regulators to tackle this like super, super hard problem.
- 22:52Like it's just that hard, you know, and, you know, in Fund 2, I'll invest in people of any age.
- 23:01But in terms of my kind of like recruitment efforts, like what I'm looking for, it's really like incredible experienced founders because I think that they're the best bet.
- 23:12Of course, it's also hard to get them because they're the best bet for a lot of things.
- 23:17right but i think that the potential of this space is big enough that we should be trying
- 23:22harder to get those people it might also be because um the the charter city free city sort of
- 23:29proposition is very long term and often that's a function of an older an older mind as well
- 23:36i think the the sort of yolo mentality of youngsters is great because it creates you know
- 23:43a lot of innovation but you know i know charter cities that have been in production for five years
- 23:49and then they fell apart on the fifth year you know and that takes a lot of um conservatism
- 23:55really it takes a it takes a lot of you know of of waiting and waiting for the right moment
- 24:01and you can't be you you can't be anxious to to achieve which is something it's a characteristic
- 24:07I find a lot about young founders.
- 24:12But yeah.
- 24:14Yeah, be hungry to achieve,
- 24:17but don't be anxious to achieve.
- 24:19Yeah.
- 24:20Like you gotta have a chip on your shoulder
- 24:21to take on a big hard problem.
- 24:23But you also, some things can't be rushed.
- 24:26Rush what you can, but not everything can be rushed.
- 24:29And some of the most important things can't be.
- 24:31Well, also when you're young,
- 24:32sometimes you don't have the time in your life
- 24:35to experience something long-term.
- 24:37I mean if you're in if you're in your early 20s, you've not really done anything for a long time except be a teenager really and
- 24:43That's not necessarily useful
- 24:45But yeah in your 40s you probably had a solid 10 years between 30 and 40 where you are hopefully working on something very long term
- 24:54Most people do if I think if you think about it because people tend to get into their their stride in their 20s and then often continue through Although we see how that changes with all this you know AI craziness
- 25:07and everything. Well, yeah, I agree. A lot is changing now. It is. But the fatigue sets in
- 25:16whenever I start talking about AI now. Yeah. Because we could have a conversation about
- 25:19anything and you could preface it with yeah but ai yeah it's weird i mean i don't know it is i mean
- 25:26we this is a really really interesting time to be alive you know i i have this line that the the
- 25:32the 21st century started in 2020 with covid i mean in theory it had started in 2000 and there
- 25:38was all the tech and the dot-com and that's all part of everything but i think that we kind of
- 25:42didn't realize it. And like, this is the decade when, you know, starting with COVID, we kind of
- 25:50realized, wait, this is not the same as the 20th century. Like the world has changed. Like things
- 25:56are different. Our tech is different in ways that are like profoundly affecting society in all kinds
- 26:01of ways. And I really think that that's playing out. And, you know, here we are at the midpoint
- 26:06of this like first decade of the 21st century.
- 26:10And now suddenly we have the rise of AI.
- 26:15So it's like, yeah, this is a different time.
- 26:19But it's hard, right?
- 26:20Like, you know, I actually have an AI background.
- 26:27You know, I did a master's at Stanford in AI.
- 26:31I was the first person, as far as I know,
- 26:33that I've been able to find who wrote an AI bot
- 26:37that beat online poker players, humans, for real money back in 2006.
- 26:43Yeah.
- 26:44Did you use it much?
- 26:46A few months after I launched, the U.S. made it all illegal.
- 26:51But how did they know?
- 26:52Regular story.
- 26:53I mean, they made online poker illegal broadly.
- 26:56Oh, right.
- 26:57Yeah, not bots, online poker.
- 26:59But that's not what I'm passionate about, right?
- 27:02What I'm passionate about is improving governance,
- 27:05creating better societies,
- 27:06like empowering people to be able to create
- 27:08new types of self-gurning communities.
- 27:11And that's what I've sunk my time into.
- 27:13And that's what I'm going to continue to put my time into.
- 27:17But it's also, it's kind of tricky
- 27:19when like everything's changing around you.
- 27:21While we're on the subject then,
- 27:23are you an AI doomer or are you like?
- 27:26Yes, I'm not a guaranteed doomer.
- 27:29I think there's a significant risk of significantly bad things happening.
- 27:35And I think that people who think that there is no risk, I think that's just kind of unwise and short-sighted.
- 27:44We are the apex predator of this planet.
- 27:47That's why we get to take out the oil.
- 27:48That's why we get to go to space.
- 27:50That's why we get to live and breed and have there be 8 billion of us.
- 27:53And if you create something that is a new apex predator, that changes everything.
- 28:02And it doesn't mean that it's guaranteed to go terribly, but I think it's extremely myopic to not see a huge threat in that.
- 28:14But I don't know how much it matters because I don't think there's any stopping it.
- 28:18have you thought have you done any thought experiments into the future about
- 28:23what the point of free cities might be in the in the distant ai future yes it it's really tough
- 28:30because um i have thought about this a bit you know it's like the the short and medium term are
- 28:38easy right there's all kinds of ways to use ai to do better governance um you know we're working
- 28:44with Alpha City, one of our portfolio companies, on AI-based regulators for a new 21st century
- 28:51financial center.
- 28:52There's a lot of ways to use it.
- 28:54But in the long term, right, it's like, what are these ideas about?
- 28:59It's about finding good systems of rules, experimenting, competing with them.
- 29:03But that's partly a reaction to our human history, especially the last few thousand
- 29:12years and the ways that nation states work and have arisen, the ways that laws work and have
- 29:17arisen. And if you transition to an economy where everything is happening with AI and digitally and
- 29:24online and the physical world is like less and less important, because online you do have,
- 29:30you know, easy creation of different rule sets that are opt in, right? Like every, you know,
- 29:36crypto network gets to define their own governance and experiment with it. And so like the more of
- 29:44our stuff, the more value is like in the digital world, that makes the physical world less
- 29:52important. Now, the physical world still matters, still matters a lot, right? It's like a choke
- 29:57point. But then like, if someone else controls the physical world, if an AI controls the physical
- 30:03world than like what what even is a free city well exactly and i think that i mean arguably
- 30:11arguably ai's gatekeeping the physical world are is an inevitability really when you when you think
- 30:18it through why wouldn't they because um you know well the reason they might not is because there'll
- 30:26be a pushback an ai pushback to the authoritarian ai that wants to control everything but um it's
- 30:33hard to predict whether that would what that would eat how that would even play out yeah i mean most
- 30:38of my hope is is kind of is like it's human augmentation right it's like humans using ais
- 30:44to um to like to be able to outperform using ais to make us smarter like anything that keeps like
- 30:52the human brain and human values kind of at the core and driving things and owning things
- 30:58to me is like where the hope lies you know but once it's like some ai fighting some other
- 31:03AI like we've already lost. Well, also the interesting predicament is the idea of abundance
- 31:09produced by AI. I mean, arguably, I mean, once again, who knows, but it's easy to predict that
- 31:16if you follow the timeline far enough, AIs create complete abundance, that the price of everything
- 31:21trends to, or the price of most of the things we've covered trends to zero because it's robots
- 31:27building new robots, building things, making things. That's an interesting place to live.
- 31:33complete abundance, extreme abundance. I mean, you really have to think, you have to self-reflect
- 31:41at that point. Who am I? What am I? Because if you think about most of the things we do,
- 31:47it's about scarcity. It's about, you know, getting scarce things, incorporating scarce
- 31:53things into our life, life, scarce ideas, you know, I don't know. I love the thought experiments,
- 32:00but I really haven't got a clue whether it's even going to happen that way.
- 32:06Scarcity is a law of the universe.
- 32:08There will always be scarcity.
- 32:11You can think about it as there's physical reality
- 32:14and there's how we manipulate physical reality, yet we want.
- 32:18We want energy.
- 32:20Okay, we can burn wood.
- 32:21We can make water mills.
- 32:23We can go get oil.
- 32:24and like the best possible technology is like the way of manipulating physical reality to get the
- 32:33most for the least and they're they're you know on a given planet there there are some like best
- 32:40ways of getting the most for the least energy or clean water or or whatever and you know the
- 32:47abundance is like ai helping us move towards that like efficient frontier faster but there still
- 32:53remain physical limits. There's only so much fossil fuels. There's only so much uranium.
- 32:58Like, okay, you make solar panels and surround the sun, but the sun only makes a certain like
- 33:03fixed amount of energy. Well, okay, now you go to like other stars, but that takes time
- 33:08and that takes resources. So like there will always be scarcity. But I think what's much
- 33:13more realistic is that like a lot of prices come down a lot. We get much better at manipulating
- 33:19to get what we want. So it's like some degree of abundance, a degree of abundance that,
- 33:24you know, should be able to solve anyone being hungry, right, or cold, you know, but not that
- 33:32we can kind of all have all the things we want. That's impossible.
- 33:36Do you think at that point, AI will be governance as well?
- 33:41AI will certainly play a big role in governance. And but you know, the question of like,
- 33:45who will control the world, you know, I don't have an answer to.
- 33:50True. Me neither. But I mean, we can predict, we can extrapolate what we think is happening. And
- 33:57I mean, one of the obvious ones would be that AI becomes very intelligent, which it already is. And
- 34:04it, you know, manifests a supreme intelligent that kind of knows better than we do,
- 34:11which is, you know, normally I would think that's an abhorrent idea that someone knows what's best
- 34:18for someone else. But in the case of AI, it may well be. And at that point, the sensible thing to
- 34:24do might be to say, okay, let the AI decide then. Well, I mean, the issue there is like,
- 34:29what are the AI's goals and values, right? So it's like, if I'm just delegating something that
- 34:35thinks better than me, but will do exactly what I want. Wonderful. Of course, I'd love to do that
- 34:42and take it to advice. But something that, you know, I mean, I think as well as I do,
- 34:47and I'm pretty stubborn and independent, and I don't want to be governed, and I want to like set
- 34:50my own destiny. And, you know, something that thinks even better than me is, you know, it's
- 34:57gonna at least implicitly have some goals and values. And, you know, I like Eliezer's work on
- 35:04this what he calls like the alignment problem right and and if you if the issue is that is is
- 35:10whether you can trust that this thing that thinks better than you will do what's in your best
- 35:14interests and so yeah i'm happy to delegate decisions to it but like i don't want to delegate
- 35:19power and resources to it do you think so do you think looking out for your fellow humans is an
- 35:26inherent property of a human then yes so would it not arise but not necessarily an inherent property
- 35:32of like a praying mantis or a black, black widow spider, right? It's, it's like, we keep in mind,
- 35:38you know, I think this is one reason people get a lot of stuff about AI wrong is like,
- 35:43you know, we, we evolved from monkeys. So we are, you know, we're, we're mammals,
- 35:48we're primates, and we're specifically this like tribal primate. And so kind of like empathy and
- 35:55not wanting to hurt other people and, you know, valuing others of your species, like all of that
- 36:02it's not necessarily universal to life. It's not even universal among different species on earth.
- 36:09It's, you know, it's much more of like of a primate thing. And so, you know, but of course,
- 36:15all of our stories and everyone we know and all of our experiences are all primate experiences.
- 36:20We live in this primate dream world because the praying mantises, you know, can't invent the Tesla
- 36:26or SpaceX, right? We just step on them. And so like all of our thoughts about what is a mind
- 36:34are all kind of based on this very certain type of mind, which I love, you know, I mean,
- 36:43not surprising because I am one. Like I want the universe to have lots more of these types of
- 36:48minds, but it's just one type of mind and like other species, right? What is a super intelligent
- 36:55praying mantis gonna do you know probably go slice a lot of things with like those like those
- 37:01skyth arms but wouldn't yeah maybe but there is a there is a kind of there's a there's a factor of
- 37:08evolution at work there if you think about it um you know you you can argue that a praying mantis
- 37:16if it got super intelligence might not hack the head of its partner might not i mean um because
- 37:24Because arguably we are higher up in the evolutionary system than them, loosely speaking.
- 37:30I mean, I can't prove it to you.
- 37:32It would be nice.
- 37:32It would be nice.
- 37:33I can hope.
- 37:34But I think that, yeah, I think that there's certain kind of like rational values, right?
- 37:42Like, you know, something that's more intelligent is going to look at like, what do I gain and lose from this?
- 37:48And there are a lot of ways in which cooperation is game theoretically beneficial.
- 37:53So I do think that you get like some of those good things from the math, from the physics of the universe as it applies to economics and cooperation and instability and respecting property rights and things like that.
- 38:08I just think that most people's intuition takes that way too far because they expect everything to be like a primate.
- 38:16So you don't believe things like the golden rule, for example, you don't think they're universal.
- 38:20in a sort of evolutionary sense.
- 38:23Sooner or later, you understand the golden rule, for example.
- 38:27And presumably you push through that as well.
- 38:30Who knows what's beyond things like do unto others as you do unto yourself.
- 38:33I don't know.
- 38:35Yeah, I don't think that there's something in the game theory of the universe
- 38:40that says that like a newly dominant species should not wipe out the old dominant species.
- 38:47I yeah should the newly dominant species like should you have cooperation and and respect with
- 38:53others of a similar power level to yourself yeah I think that's in the game theory of the universe
- 38:58but should you not step on ants yeah no that's not in the game theory of the universe
- 39:03yeah let's not black pill ourselves though hey let's go back to your list of lessons learned
- 39:12even though they don't matter.
- 39:15They might matter.
- 39:16There are also good futures.
- 39:18Oh, here's a good one.
- 39:20Here's one I've got an opinion on as well.
- 39:22Build for locals, not nomads.
- 39:25Yeah, you know, there's...
- 39:27It's like if you're building a new city,
- 39:32there's this idea that like,
- 39:33oh, who are the people we can get to come to this new place?
- 39:36It's the people who kind of don't live anywhere right now.
- 39:39But there's two problems with that.
- 39:41The first is people who are nomadic are not people who are settled in one place.
- 39:47And so getting them to visit, great.
- 39:50Getting them to stay, well, that's kind of contrary to that population.
- 39:55And then, you know, the other issue is that, like, when you're small, it's hard to compete with things that are really big.
- 40:05And so you want to, like, you want to compete locally, not globally, unless you think you can actually be, like, the best in the world.
- 40:11You know, this is kind of like a general principle for building companies.
- 40:17And, you know, you want to find the niche where you have an advantage.
- 40:20And the thing about nomads is that, you know, if you're trying to attract locals and be a better place to live in the country where you are, you're competing with the rest of that country.
- 40:31If you're trying to attract a nomad, you're competing with the entire world.
- 40:35And that's really hard for a small new community, which has less infrastructure, fewer restaurants, fewer people, like just less of everything except the better rules.
- 40:45It's really hard to compete for those people.
- 40:48It's really hard to attract them because they could live in Lisbon or Bali or San Francisco or London or whatever.
- 40:56Right.
- 40:56And so I think that it just makes a lot more sense to build for locals.
- 41:03And there's other reasons.
- 41:04Right.
- 41:04Like, you know, the kind of biggest stability and protection for these startup societies is, like, the loyalty of the local population because you are making their lives better.
- 41:20That's what protects you from changes in political party, you know, from corrupt officials trying to get something from you, like, protects you from all kinds of things, is that you are there making value, making people's lives better visibly.
- 41:33and they know it and everyone knows it and then they are your best defenders And so it like nomads are less useful to you defensively much harder to compete for
- 41:46whereas locals are much more beneficial
- 41:49and much easier to compete for
- 41:52because you're in some developing country,
- 41:55and you're like, okay, I'm going to make a village, a town,
- 42:00eventually a city that's a better place to live
- 42:03and the rest of this country,
- 42:04and that just seems like a much more plausible win.
- 42:08I mean, arguably Morazan versus Prospero
- 42:12is a good example of this.
- 42:13Morazan, you don't need to convince people
- 42:16to move to Morazan.
- 42:17They want to move there.
- 42:20Yeah, and they have more residents, right?
- 42:21I mean, Prospero is at, I think, less than 100,
- 42:24like, you know, average full-time residents.
- 42:27I would say that.
- 42:28Morazan is more.
- 42:29I've had a, I have had that same opinion for a while.
- 42:34But recently I've decided that nomads play a role.
- 42:40Absolutely.
- 42:40And I would say that in a place like Prospera, invite everyone.
- 42:45Yeah.
- 42:45Don't say, right, this is, invite everyone.
- 42:48And I think the role they play often is publicity.
- 42:52Yeah.
- 42:53They're very good at publicizing places.
- 42:54You can see a number of cities around the world that have been rejuvenated by Instagram pictures of people who are living there
- 43:03and working on the computer and doing all that kind of stuff.
- 43:05Yeah, I mean, I think they add a ton.
- 43:08It's a good clarification.
- 43:10I kind of mean specifically for, like,
- 43:12trying to grow your permanent population.
- 43:14I'm saying that's a tough market.
- 43:16But is it great to get nomads to come?
- 43:20Absolutely.
- 43:20To come to your conferences, you know, to bring ideas,
- 43:25to be, like, interesting people, you know,
- 43:27to come be, like, occupants in your hotels.
- 43:30Like, it's great.
- 43:32They play all kinds of roles.
- 43:34I just think it's dangerous to count on that as what's going to be your permanent population.
- 43:39What do you think the best business strategy with nomads is then?
- 43:43Little nodes around the world and places to stay?
- 43:46Or is it something that they all grow out of in the end anyway?
- 43:49It's not my focus.
- 43:51My focus is on I want to build those cities that write their own laws.
- 43:55Fair enough.
- 43:56Okay.
- 43:57What does it say next?
- 43:59L1s and L2s are very different.
- 44:02Yeah, so an L1 is something like Prospera, you know, and an L0 is something like Honduras, you know, or one could argue my fund Pronomos, you know, which like Honduras because it's a layer above Prospera, their constitution, their treaties and their criminal law govern.
- 44:22You know, Pronoma is because we are working with a bunch of layer ones.
- 44:25We want to invest in layer ones.
- 44:27A layer one is something like Prospera, you know, or our company, Alpha City, many others
- 44:33in space who are trying to build like this platform, this city that writes its own laws.
- 44:38And then an L2 is a community.
- 44:40Maybe it's a nomad community or a longevity community, a group of people who are probably
- 44:48too small to negotiate with a head of state and do everything it takes to get to build
- 44:55a city that writes its own laws, but who are hungry for those cities, who want them, who
- 45:03want the regulatory benefits, who want the freedoms.
- 45:07And so they're incredibly important.
- 45:09They're customers for the L1s, and they're incredible customers for the L1s, because
- 45:15if you don't have L2s, then the L1 is having to try to sell people like individually, right,
- 45:22to get them to move there. And with the L2, it's like, okay, now I can negotiate with a much smaller
- 45:28number of like community leaders and understand them as customers. Like what does their community
- 45:34want? What would it take to get how many of them to move here? And, you know, they're kind of like,
- 45:41you know, almost like a representative for a larger number of people. And that just makes
- 45:45everything work better. And then within the L2, you know, an L2 can have its own unique culture
- 45:50and approach to things. It can build its own, you know, physical infrastructure within the L1 city
- 45:58that works how it wants it to. You know, it can customize laws and regulations within the container.
- 46:06You know, kind of all of the L1s are, you know, they have their legal system they're creating.
- 46:11But if you want to add things onto it, you know, that apply to your district or your people, you're welcome to do so.
- 46:17You know, these things are mostly voluntarist and contractual.
- 46:21So L2s are incredibly important.
- 46:25L1s are incredibly important, too.
- 46:26We need them both.
- 46:28The issues, I think, is when people mix them up.
- 46:31So, you know, I'm often talking to kind of L2 leaders who are like, so I should be starting a charter city, right?
- 46:38And it's like, no.
- 46:40I mean, if you have enough people and enough experience that you can sit down with the
- 46:45head of state and convince him that you can impact this country enough to pass national
- 46:49legislation and raise the money to build a city, then please, we desperately need more
- 46:54L1 founders.
- 46:55Please do that.
- 46:56But that's the case for very few L2 leaders.
- 46:58Very few people in general.
- 47:00But I also think there's a difference between the community organizing spirit and the like,
- 47:04I can negotiate with a head of state and raise a billion dollar spirit.
- 47:09They're both valuable and needed in this space, but in these different places.
- 47:13And so I think this kind of like slidness where L2s are like, I should be starting a
- 47:17charter city rather than like, I should be looking at the existing offerings and building
- 47:21up my community and locating inside them, leads to people like, whether it's in how
- 47:28they present themselves, how they think of themselves, how they project plan, thinking
- 47:31that like they are trying to like go and negotiate with governments for deals when they're just not
- 47:37at a size where or kind of like don't have a focus or a skill set where that makes sense
- 47:42so like it's all good unless you mix them up talking of l1 founders have you had much contact
- 47:50or do you know much about destiny this project a little bit i mean um olivier and roger are both
- 47:56investors in Pronomos, two of my larger investors. And, you know, I've tracked the project a little
- 48:01bit over the years. It's something that they've been kind of moving forward slowly on the side
- 48:05for a long time. And, you know, kind of my kind of professional opinion is that, I mean, this is
- 48:14not just them, everyone in the space, is that this stuff is already so hard. It doesn't really work
- 48:20as a hobby project. Like you need an absolute badass person full time to do this really hard
- 48:27thing. And so their project didn't have that for a long time. You know, they had money,
- 48:33they had conviction and a vision, which is great. And, you know, kind of now they actually have,
- 48:41it's mainly Olivier now, have gotten operational and they're, you know, actually negotiating with
- 48:48with Nevis and trying to do something. Um, and that's great. Uh, I'm not like,
- 48:53I'm not like deeply up to speed on it, but, but I've read a bit.
- 48:57No, it's just, when I first saw it, I thought it was an incredible project. I mean, we, we,
- 49:03like you say, we're a little bit starved of projects to talk about, but I haven't actually
- 49:07ever spoken to anyone about it who, who wasn't like I say, Olivia or Roger Veer is, you know,
- 49:13hard to speak to but um but it's it seems like um i mean when you say that you need to devote all
- 49:21your time to it which i agree do you think olivia is do you think that's what is that all he does
- 49:25now i you know i haven't caught up with him for a couple of years so i don't know okay
- 49:29need a pipeline of countries commas birds fly yeah birds fly fish swim and deals fall through
- 49:42this is the physics of the universe and because deals fall through and and you
- 49:49know note like asterisk as the the the larger the Institute and the worst governed the the entity you working with is the more likely deals are to fall through or stall out And so because of this I think that having like one about a country
- 50:08is not a wise idea because you're going to work with them and it's going to stall.
- 50:15And now what do you do?
- 50:17Now, you know, maybe you go back and kind of work on your plans
- 50:20to try to convince them, build up more credibility.
- 50:22but really like the failure rate of these country negotiations and like the degree of fit you need
- 50:29between your vision and the country and its leadership and its people.
- 50:34You know, you really want to be like talking to a bunch of countries and finding the ones that are
- 50:41best fit and pursuing multiple ones at the same time so that, you know, first off, you want them
- 50:47competing against each other and feeling that they're competing against each other.
- 50:52And you want when one stalls out, you put energy into the next one.
- 50:56And if that stalls out, you put energy in the next one.
- 50:58And so you've got multiple balls in the air, like because these balls move like very, very slowly.
- 51:05So, yeah, I think it's really important to have like a pipeline of countries.
- 51:09Now, there's an interesting question of like whether you should then try to build one or build multiple at the same time.
- 51:17You know, I to me kind of like building one makes the most sense.
- 51:22like Balaji says, nail and then scale it. But the approach we're taking with Alpha City,
- 51:26with my business partner Bradford, is much more of like, we're going to try to do like multiple
- 51:33of these at the same time, as many as we can. And, you know, have each of them like learning
- 51:38and informing the others, develop like things that we can apply across the multiple projects.
- 51:44You know, for example, if countries have like a similar constitution and treaties and you get similar zone law passed, that means you can actually set up the same regulatory system in multiple countries.
- 52:00It's almost like having data centers in multiple places, like redundant data centers.
- 52:05so you could you could incorporate in one of our alpha city jurisdictions and then you could just
- 52:11click and be like oh actually i wanted to move from this country in africa to this other country
- 52:16in africa because it's actually the same legal system um so there's definitely some things that
- 52:20you get by doing multiple at once but it does make it more challenging uh tippel has discovered
- 52:26that very real and i remember a couple of years ago when the strategy became right we are no longer
- 52:31are just pursuing one thing.
- 52:33And it was something that everyone talked about.
- 52:36But you better quantify what Alpha City is for people that don't know.
- 52:42Yeah, Alpha City is kind of our one incubated project in my Charter City Fund, Pronomos.
- 52:48My business partner, Bradford Cross, is the CEO.
- 52:52And we're working with multiple countries in Africa, mostly in West Africa, to spin up
- 53:00multiple charter cities that each have kind of different target industries based on the country,
- 53:06you know, ranging from agriculture, which is, you know, a huge lift available for all of Africa,
- 53:13to things like electric vehicle manufacturing, AI data centers using geothermal power,
- 53:22which of which there's a massive amount of untapped geothermal power, you know,
- 53:25cheap renewable energy five to ten cents a kilowatt hour maybe less in Africa
- 53:30and do they require a special zone status things like that yeah absolutely
- 53:35that's it's you know it's this charter city model where we work with the
- 53:39countries to pass national legislation to create a zone where the the city
- 53:46writes many of the laws and regulations that apply to it all right I didn't I
- 53:50They sounded they sounded more industry based so people living probably
- 53:54Okay, so especially
- 53:57And what stage are those projects are?
- 54:02we we're this year we're expecting to sign multiple land deals and
- 54:08And raise enough money to start building
- 54:10Wow
- 54:11So that's kind of like they'll all be under the umbrella term Alpha City even though they're all very different
- 54:16Well, the industry is a little different, right? But like the software tooling, right? Like the governance platform, like the regulations, a lot of the architecture, there's going to be a lot of things that are similar. And, you know, there's some industries like ag that work everywhere. And there's some things like AI data centers with geothermal that only work in those specific places. So it's a mix.
- 54:38But the basis, you know, the charters will be similar. Is that right?
- 54:42That's right.
- 54:43Identical or just similar?
- 54:44No, every country is different.
- 54:46You know, even countries with pretty similar history
- 54:50will have differences in their constitutions and treaties.
- 54:52So not identical, but similar.
- 54:57Near Enemies, LARPing and the Cloud.
- 55:02That sounds like a title of a book.
- 55:05Near Enemies, LARPing and the Cloud.
- 55:07I liked this one, actually,
- 55:08because this is actually something we talk a lot about
- 55:11from our end of the spectrum.
- 55:13The LARPing end of the spectrum is the other end of the spectrum, not us, but we're probably LARPers as well.
- 55:19But you're alluding to the sort of, yeah, go on, you explain it.
- 55:24Yeah, this is it.
- 55:25You know, a near enemy is like, it's kind of like Scylla and Sherbdis.
- 55:28It's like, it's this trap, like that you can be trying to do one thing and end up doing something that's similar, but actually does the opposite of what you want.
- 55:37And I have the most fun with this one, I would say, because it's the most controversial,
- 55:41because there's so much LARPing and so much the cloud in the space.
- 55:45And so, you know, for each of them.
- 55:47So LARPing.
- 55:48LARPing means live action role playing.
- 55:51Some people may know Feynman's cargo cult metaphor.
- 55:55It's when you imitate the superficialities of something without actually doing it.
- 56:00And the thing is that like starting a new country, if we go to the most fun, biggest version of the idea is so fun and so romantic and so exciting and so unbelievably hard that even if you seriously try to do it, as I have, like you're going to naturally find that it's so much easier to play with it and to and to say and do things that get the fun idea out there and get attention.
- 56:29than to actually make progress towards that insanely ambitious and difficult goal.
- 56:34And so for everyone, and again, this is something that applies to me just as much that I have
- 56:40to constantly watch out for, it's very easy to get sucked into the performing of the,
- 56:46I'm going to start my own country or society, and not the doing, because the doing is so
- 56:50much harder and gets you less attention and less rewarding, but it doesn't get it done.
- 56:58And I'm in this, I've spent like 25 years where this is like the thing that's been constant
- 57:05across 25 years as my mission, you know, because I actually want these to exist in the world.
- 57:10I enjoy playing with them.
- 57:12I enjoy the LARPing.
- 57:14I'm actually planning to do more of it this year than I have before because it's fun and
- 57:19it gets the word out.
- 57:21But I also really, really want to get the stuff built.
- 57:25And that's the issue there.
- 57:26And then on the cloud side, it's like, look, like the reason that I focus on the physical world is because it's really hard to start new jurisdictions.
- 57:38This is like the bottleneck and the limiting point.
- 57:41Things are much easier to do online.
- 57:43And as a result, they work much better.
- 57:45The barrier to entry to start something new is low.
- 57:47Things are mainly like opt in, like there's low friction to switch between things.
- 57:52And so in the cloud, yeah, everything's easier and everything works better.
- 57:56And so when projects have some physical aspect and some digital aspect, they often find the
- 58:02digital aspect gets developed much more quickly and launched much more quickly.
- 58:06But for me, you know, again, my North Star is physical territory with legal autonomy.
- 58:12And so getting sucked into the digital world is absolutely not what I want I not saying everybody should have this focus There lots of people developing lots of great stuff in the cloud and that great But it doesn change the world in the way that I want Things already work pretty well there And the pain point that I see and the thing
- 58:28that I want to fix requires legal autonomy on physical territory. So you wouldn't pursue
- 58:36something seriously unless those two prerequisites, physical territory and a degree of autonomy.
- 58:43That's right.
- 58:44100%.
- 58:44That's me.
- 58:45That's great.
- 58:46I assumed you were more network state.
- 58:49You're not.
- 58:49I have not done a good job.
- 58:51I find myself saying this a lot in individual conversations, like more and more, I need to do a much better job of getting the message out at scale.
- 58:59Let's practice.
- 59:00I'm Patrick Friedman, and what I'm all about is physical territory with significant legal autonomy.
- 59:06I think the problem probably lies in the fact that your peer group is the network state end, as far as I can tell, at least.
- 59:14I mean, I only come across you in that world, I suppose.
- 59:18And I'd say like the villages, the startup villages world.
- 59:22Those are the two adjacent, right?
- 59:23There's the kind of like cloud focus, cloud first, like network state stuff.
- 59:28And there's a lot of variety, right?
- 59:29There's network state projects that have no plans of ever doing physical autonomous territory.
- 59:34There's ones that do.
- 59:34It varies a lot.
- 59:35But on average, they're very cloud-oriented.
- 59:40And then there's the physical but non-autonomous.
- 59:44So there's the autonomous and non-physical of network state.
- 59:47And then there's the physical and non-autonomous of like, I'm going to build a new city outside Austin.
- 59:53Or I'm going to build some nomad villages in some nomad destinations.
- 59:58And those are kind of both adjacent.
- 59:59And I talk to those people, but those are not me.
- 1:00:03Do you think the network state is valid?
- 1:00:05Do you think it's a productive thing?
- 1:00:09I definitely think it's a productive thing.
- 1:00:12I think people are really having trouble figuring out how to actuate it,
- 1:00:17how to break it down into bite-sized pieces and make value for people.
- 1:00:22My own kind of reading of network state and my model of how I think about it
- 1:00:28is it's like we want to, you know,
- 1:00:31most of the parts of our civilizational OS are old.
- 1:00:35and they were written pre-internet.
- 1:00:36And we want to replace the civilizational OS
- 1:00:39with things that are internet first,
- 1:00:41which doesn't mean it's in the cloud, right?
- 1:00:43Like governance can be internet first, right?
- 1:00:45If you have a legal system that's like open sourced
- 1:00:47and tracked on GitHub, you know,
- 1:00:50and like great government portals
- 1:00:52and like digital identity and stuff, right?
- 1:00:54So, you know, so I think that, yes,
- 1:00:58we absolutely need to rewrite all parts
- 1:01:00of our civilizational OS, or most of them at least,
- 1:01:03to be internet first. And that's great, you know, but it's hard to, you know, it's hard to compete
- 1:01:11with a monopoly, right? It's like, if you wanted to replace education or healthcare, you know,
- 1:01:18I'm an American. And like, if I found some amazing new education system, I'm still paying the same
- 1:01:25taxes, you know, for the same schools, right? And so how do you actually, like, compete with the
- 1:01:34state for these things that you're trying to replace is tricky, but I think, like, worth doing.
- 1:01:42An interesting application of network state sort of theory I came across recently was
- 1:01:48sort of refugee communities or diasporas.
- 1:01:54You know, the Tibetans was the example given.
- 1:01:57Why not create a Tibetan network state which has power?
- 1:02:03Because in a sense, they're kind of landless.
- 1:02:07Where does it get the power?
- 1:02:08Well, the power comes in the ability to leverage the network state to get things done.
- 1:02:14So you could put services on it as well.
- 1:02:17You know, just like the Prosper platform, you could have services on it.
- 1:02:22You could have, because it's a nation without a nation in a way.
- 1:02:26It's become China or it's become people living in northern India.
- 1:02:30Right.
- 1:02:30But I mean, like those people live somewhere, you know, like I live somewhere and they're
- 1:02:35paying some government some amount of taxes and fees for some amount of services.
- 1:02:40And so it's like, well, like where do you get the money to give them more services?
- 1:02:45like now they're if you charge them for it now they're double paying and it has to be like really
- 1:02:51really good it's i i think i you know as as a tool for like organizing them absolutely but i don't
- 1:02:57really see the state part of it well that would be that would come it'd be great if it did once
- 1:03:03you have the organizational aspect you have the leverage to possibly create some kind of getting
- 1:03:09what you want. Because it's specifically for people that are disaffected. But on the whole,
- 1:03:16I mean, in your sort of hierarchy of wants, their physical territory autonomy,
- 1:03:20what would be the next one after that?
- 1:03:28Well, in order to work, I would say the economic engine. Because it doesn't work without it.
- 1:03:34Like number one reason people move is for jobs. Number two is family reunification.
- 1:03:39you know which which pulling people to a new place is not is not great at that's another reason for
- 1:03:43building for locals um yeah that's the that's the next piece so and powers it all in alpha cities
- 1:03:50case all your all your projects are based on an economic system absolutely you can't do anything
- 1:03:56without it i mean if you know someone wants to i mean even if someone was like here's 10 billion
- 1:04:01dollars you know make a city for syrian refugees or something like well what happens when that 10
- 1:04:07billion runs out, right? Like without an economic engine, you know, which means like making this
- 1:04:14stuff people want out of the efforts that, you know, the labor that people have and the resources
- 1:04:20that are available, right? I mean, it's not, I'm not talking about some kind of like theoretical
- 1:04:25thing. I mean, the economic engine, I mean, like people need to do work to make stuff that pays for
- 1:04:31their housing and their clothing and their food and their, and their healthcare. Otherwise you
- 1:04:35don't have a sustainable society where are we now pop-ups okay i i've got opinion on pop-ups
- 1:04:45pop-ups select for the roots list they still have value what does that mean you didn't actually go
- 1:04:52into these ones i think in the talk pop-ups yeah select for the root list this i mean it's a bit
- 1:04:58it's a bit similar to nomads but but like look if you're doing a if you're doing a three-day
- 1:05:03conference, then you can attract people who, you know, have, have families, right? Have kids in
- 1:05:12school. I mean, you know, I'm, I'm a single parent. And that limits my travel a lot, right? I can't go
- 1:05:19somewhere for a month, unless I bring my kid with me, and then where she go to school, and what
- 1:05:23happened to her friends and everything. And, and so, if you're like, I think the pop up thing is
- 1:05:30fascinating. Let's go someplace for a month or two or three. People have had some incredible
- 1:05:36experiences and they've been great. But you're selecting for the people who can pick up and go
- 1:05:43to some random place in the world for a month plus. And that is a very, very small subset of
- 1:05:49people who are very, very unusual. And I don't think they're the best long-term settlers for a
- 1:05:59society but but it's still useful as an experiment i was going to say isn't right and to build buzz
- 1:06:05and yeah aren't pop-ups designed for that i don't i i don't i i wasn't aware at least myself that a
- 1:06:12pop-up was designed to get people to come and stay forever kind of thing well i mean but but why is
- 1:06:16there such an overlap between you know network state and city projects and pop-ups you know they
- 1:06:22they seem to be kind of like using them as like um hey we're like we're going to do our pop-up
- 1:06:28and we're gonna gather a community
- 1:06:29and then, you know, dot, dot, dot, question mark,
- 1:06:32we're gonna build a city.
- 1:06:33Well, they're the LARPers, right?
- 1:06:34Yeah, exactly.
- 1:06:37I know, but like you say, LARPing's fun as well.
- 1:06:39Sure. Pop-ups are fun.
- 1:06:41Yeah.
- 1:06:42It's just different.
- 1:06:43Are they necessary, though?
- 1:06:44Is the LARPing necessary, do you think, just to keep sane?
- 1:06:48Or would you kind of, like, eradicate it completely?
- 1:06:52No.
- 1:06:52But know that you're doing it.
- 1:06:54And play with it when it's fun.
- 1:06:55But don't let it infect your actual, like, business plans and, you know,
- 1:07:00critical points and the things that you're doing.
- 1:07:02But play with it.
- 1:07:04Okay.
- 1:07:04Two more.
- 1:07:06We'll wrap it up in a sec.
- 1:07:08Okay.
- 1:07:08Okay, entrepreneurial lift early, legal arbitrage later at scale.
- 1:07:14So entrepreneurial lift early, legal arbitrage later at scale.
- 1:07:18Right, this one ain't explaining.
- 1:07:19So here's the thing, and we saw some of this today,
- 1:07:22is that we have all this data that legal systems with more transparency,
- 1:07:28less corruption, more freedom, lower taxes to some degree,
- 1:07:33result in higher GDP growth rates over time.
- 1:07:36And because of the math of exponentials and the fact that GDP growth is a compounding thing, you get things like Singapore or things like China in recent decades.
- 1:07:47And so over a period, a time span of, say, 50 years, the amount of wealth that you get by having 7% versus 4% GDP growth rate is many, many, many times over 50 years.
- 1:08:06So in the long term, this thing, and I should add that a lot of people in this space, so Octavio
- 1:08:12Sanchez is this incredible unsung hero of Honduras who created the Zeta program. He mentioned this was
- 1:08:19a big part of his inspiration. And over the long term, it really matters. But what I've seen in
- 1:08:26the space is people thinking that that's what's going to bring businesses there and form an economy
- 1:08:31in the short term. And that, I feel like, has absolutely not panned out and will not work.
- 1:08:37Before you have an economic engine, it's like when you have the engine firing and turning over,
- 1:08:43doing something to optimize its efficiency, we'll get it much faster. And then when you add, I mean,
- 1:08:48engine kind of misses out on this compounding aspect, which is where the power comes from. But
- 1:08:52you increase your compounded growth rate of something that's active and happening,
- 1:08:57over time you get a massive increase.
- 1:09:00But in order to create that economic engine
- 1:09:03at the very beginning,
- 1:09:05businesses aren't going to move there
- 1:09:08because GDP is going to grow at 7% instead of 4%.
- 1:09:11You have to figure out what are the skills and resources
- 1:09:16that people have that this country has,
- 1:09:18what industries are they not in that I can help them get in.
- 1:09:22You have to go in there as a market analyst
- 1:09:27and then as a salesperson, right,
- 1:09:30as in doing business development
- 1:09:32to figure out those industries,
- 1:09:34to find the companies,
- 1:09:35to see what it would take to get them to move there,
- 1:09:37to solve the problems that are blocking them
- 1:09:39and actually get these anchor tenants,
- 1:09:42get these businesses to locate there
- 1:09:44or maybe even start them if they don't exist,
- 1:09:47which is again, a lot of entrepreneurial lift.
- 1:09:50Like you have to hand build that economy at the beginning.
- 1:09:53You can't just create a great jurisdiction
- 1:09:56and have businesses come.
- 1:09:58Even though I do fully believe and agree
- 1:10:00that over the 50 years that lift is real and that we can make a bunch of Singapore you know over decades because of it but only if they get off the ground And getting off the ground requires that you know
- 1:10:14sales and customer focus
- 1:10:16and actually creating that economy.
- 1:10:20Is specializing important at that point?
- 1:10:22Yeah, because these places are small,
- 1:10:25you know, you're looking at like specific companies,
- 1:10:29specific types of businesses,
- 1:10:30and then growing that to industry clusters.
- 1:10:32I mean, you know, people interested in this should read about the history of Singapore,
- 1:10:36for example, right?
- 1:10:37It's like, yes, that better legal system helps everything.
- 1:10:42But the stuff that you need to be like hand putting together the economy, you know, you
- 1:10:47can't bring in everything.
- 1:10:48You have to like, what are the exports, right?
- 1:10:51What are we going to specialize in and give to the world that will get us the stuff that
- 1:10:55we want from the world?
- 1:10:56And so, you know, when you're small and you can only, you only have so many people or so
- 1:11:00much land or so much capital, you have to specialize. You should profoundly specialize.
- 1:11:07So in using your Alpha City projects as an example, where do you envisage that? What do
- 1:11:13you envisage they will look like in, say, 50 years? I mean, will they just turn into places?
- 1:11:19Like, it sounds like they have personalities, each one of them, you know, ag, you know, tech,
- 1:11:24whatever. Is that just a strategy to establish? And then in the future, you imagine they,
- 1:11:30they become something else.
- 1:11:32I mean, I would just look at the world today and the cities today, right?
- 1:11:35That like, like every city, every great city has lots of great restaurants and, you know,
- 1:11:40lots of great coffee shops and, and, and, and, and clubs.
- 1:11:44Well, there's a few of them don't have great clubs, but, you know, but, but their economies
- 1:11:50are driven by different things.
- 1:11:51You know, what, what powers San Francisco is different from what powers London.
- 1:11:55It's different from, you know, what powers Bali.
- 1:11:58It's different from what powers Lisbon.
- 1:12:00like there's there's there's some stuff that's everywhere and there's some stuff that's like
- 1:12:04many places like a financial center and there's some stuff that's um that's much more specialized
- 1:12:10and only in a few places and i would expect the same thing talking just on on the subject to that
- 1:12:16um what's your opinion on dubai right now and and you know obviously there's a lot of there's a lot
- 1:12:24of hyperbole around Dubai at the moment. And it's over, it's this, it's that, whatever.
- 1:12:29What's your opinion on the sort of long-term situation there? Do you think it's been impacted
- 1:12:34badly? I think it has been impacted significantly. You know, I talked to someone here who
- 1:12:39was in Dubai when the bomb started falling and he got out and he's like, all right,
- 1:12:47I'm going to stay out. You know, I don't really have the expertise to know like what the prospects
- 1:12:52are for how long the war is going to last. But I do think it's having significant impact.
- 1:12:57In general, I'm a huge fan of Dubai, especially in the UAE in general. It's this
- 1:13:03country that has multiple competing jurisdictions within the same country.
- 1:13:07They're pioneers and experts on zones. I often cite Dubai's financial center as a huge innovator
- 1:13:13in my space. They seem like countries that are run more like a startup, like Dubai, Singapore,
- 1:13:21Estonia, like, now maybe I'm done.
- 1:13:26Like listed like there not very many you know and it clearly has like incredible like execution and administration talent you know because because they not they not living large on on oil money like like like some some other places uh so yeah i i i a big
- 1:13:46fan but you know war puts a damper on everything yeah i i the only i wonder whether or not
- 1:13:52the impact is is as bad as people think because um i don't know what you obviously often when when
- 1:14:01people panic often is the best thing to do is wait a little bit and then it really doesn't
- 1:14:05matter yeah we'll see we'll see right last one sorry to keep you here we go do you know which
- 1:14:15one it is too much theory stop wonking yeah and build too much theory that's that's kind of love
- 1:14:22that kind of goes along with the love it's a particular it's a it's it's the type of of larping
- 1:14:28that's about policies and constitutions.
- 1:14:31It's like people who think that the bottleneck
- 1:14:34to making a new society is like one more idea,
- 1:14:39like one more policy, one more constitution.
- 1:14:43We are drowning in those, right?
- 1:14:45And that is not the issue.
- 1:14:47That's not the bottleneck.
- 1:14:49The bottleneck is people actually going out
- 1:14:51and building these and figuring out what is the demand,
- 1:14:54who are the customers, putting together the pieces
- 1:14:56to actually like move dirt.
- 1:14:59Like that's the bottleneck.
- 1:15:01You know, it's not that like someone hasn't quite designed
- 1:15:06the exact best constitution
- 1:15:07or figured out the exact best healthcare policy.
- 1:15:10Like, which is not to say
- 1:15:11that you shouldn't design those things, right?
- 1:15:13If you are building a city at some point
- 1:15:16in the actual building of an actual city
- 1:15:18that actual people are gonna live in,
- 1:15:20you're gonna need to create those policies
- 1:15:22which you're gonna do by trying to understand your customers
- 1:15:25and figure out what they want
- 1:15:26and see what the tech is available and what you can give to them.
- 1:15:29Like you absolutely want to do all of those things.
- 1:15:31It's doing those things way in advance without the customers kind of, you know,
- 1:15:36imagining like what they're going to want, you know,
- 1:15:40or thinking that that's going to get you any closer to actually building it at that early step.
- 1:15:45That's the mistake.
- 1:15:47I never heard that term wonking.
- 1:15:50No, I made up the word.
- 1:15:52A wonk is like a policy wonk.
- 1:15:54at somebody who's all about the different policies
- 1:15:56and there's a British word that I may be referring to.
- 1:16:02Right.
- 1:16:03Well, look, thanks.
- 1:16:05I like to end on a sort of macro view.
- 1:16:10You're a good person for that
- 1:16:11because you're kind of,
- 1:16:14I think you'd be one of the best
- 1:16:17probably with the macro view in the space.
- 1:16:20So what are you,
- 1:16:21what's your view from up on high for the next sort of i don't know let's say 25 years 25 years
- 1:16:29that's that's a long time all right um just give well i mean you're obviously i mean i think i
- 1:16:35think this stuff's gonna work i mean it it it's you know it's it's been a slow dragged out start
- 1:16:41but we're learning a lot getting more and more attention and more and more people interested
- 1:16:45you know this prospera surviving the hostile administration in honduras like the number one
- 1:16:51question i get asked is like won't the government just change their mind and take it over people
- 1:16:56aren familiar with the various legal stability protections that prevent that and now we had you know not just a very hostile administration but very early in a project right It was like a year or two like two years after Prosper opened the doors So they still
- 1:17:11too small to kind of have made lots of jobs and to have the resources. And they survived anyway.
- 1:17:18And that's an enormous testament to them. And it's a demonstration of the power of these legal
- 1:17:23stability protections. So, you know, and like, as my friend Joe McKinney is tracking like the
- 1:17:30Google trends on searches for charter cities and startup societies and network states have
- 1:17:34like doubled or tripled since July, you know, in the last like nine months.
- 1:17:39So I'm just seeing incredible growing interest.
- 1:17:44You know, the space is really taking off.
- 1:17:45And I kind of feel like the engine of like competition and learning, like it's kicked
- 1:17:52off.
- 1:17:52And so this stuff is going to happen.
- 1:17:54It's going to spread.
- 1:17:55It's going to grow.
- 1:17:56you know and meanwhile the world is going to be transforming falling apart in some ways getting
- 1:18:02improved in other ways around us and you know over 25 years like who knows what that nets out to
- 1:18:07i i i 100 agree with you and i think we can't underestimate the importance of what has just
- 1:18:14happened to prosper yeah because for i mean i've only been here four years but during that time
- 1:18:21the number one issue was give me a working example and now we have a working example that
- 1:18:28basically faced the final boss of free cities which is socialist governments and and won yeah
- 1:18:35and and proved as far as i'm concerned the the model and and the legal protections the community
- 1:18:41protections the everything about what was said played out in in in the way we kind of hoped it
- 1:18:49would and imagined it yeah it's phenomenal i mean it's great and it yeah it is anyway patrie thanks
- 1:18:54mate we enjoyed thanks for having me thanks for coming in and um yeah i'll see you another time
- 1:18:59all right you made it to the end of the show so i'm gonna go ahead and assume that you got some
- 1:19:10value out of this episode if you want to help the show please follow or subscribe right now
- 1:19:16It takes only two seconds and it massively helps.
- 1:19:21If you've got another 30 seconds, well, leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify.
- 1:19:27Honest reviews apparently are the single best way to help new listeners find us.
- 1:19:32If you want more, you can get bonus episodes and early access to episodes on fountain.fm
- 1:19:39for the price of one coffee for a whole month.
- 1:19:42or you can support the mission by streaming sats on any of the value for value platforms
- 1:19:48or use the bitcoin and fiat donation links in the show notes every contribution to the show
- 1:19:54makes a real difference believe me and one more thing if you know someone who'd love this episode
- 1:20:00share it directly with them that personal share beats every algorithm in the book all the links
- 1:20:06the community and the newsletter are in the show notes and jump on over to freecities.fm
- 1:20:13for a deep dive into all the episodes with descriptions and more that's the new free
- 1:20:19podcast website freecities.fm have a good week and see you next time