Latest / Friendship Files: Adult friendship, connection & real life / The Tightrope of Mentorship: How to Guide Without Controlling | Friendship Files
Transcript
- You love her, but you’re terrified that every piece of advice you give will either smother her or push her away. Let’s sit with that tightness in your chest for a second. There is a specific kind of exhaustion that comes from caring deeply about someone who is younger than you, less experienced than you, and currently navigating a storm you’ve already weathered. It’s not just worry. It’s this heavy, suffocating responsibility that settles into your shoulders like a wet wool coat. You see the pothole before she does. You hear the tone in her voice that signals another spiral. And instinctively, your body tenses because you want to reach through the screen, through the phone, through time itself, and shake her gently by the shoulders and say, 'Please, just stop. Look at what I did. Look how much it hurt. Don’t do this.' But you don’t. Because you know that if you do, you cross a line. You become the mother, the teacher, the boss, or the annoying older sister who no one wants to hang out with anymore. So you swallow the words. You take a sip of wine. And you watch her drive toward the cliff edge anyway, screaming silently from the passenger seat while holding onto the dashboard for dear life. We need to talk about the difference between being a friend and being a mentor, because they are not the same thing, even though they wear similar clothes. In my last few episodes, we talked about 'maintenance' friendships—those where you only text when you’re bored or lonely. That’s not friendship; that’s maintenance. But mentoring? Mentoring feels active. It feels important. It feels like work. And here is the brutal truth: adult friendship requires active effort, yes, but it does not require you to manage another adult’s life choices. When you start offering unsolicited guidance on how she should handle her job, her dating life, or her creative ambitions, you are shifting the dynamic from peer-to-peer to superior-to-subordinate. And that shift is dangerous. It creates resentment on both sides. She feels controlled. You feel unappreciated. And suddenly, the beautiful, messy, equal bond you built over years of shared secrets and cheap drinks becomes a transactional relationship where you are the advisor and she is the client. And clients rarely call their advisors just to laugh until they cry on a Tuesday night. I have done this. Oh, I have absolutely done this. Early in my thirties, after moving cities and feeling that profound isolation I mentioned before, I latched onto a younger colleague. She was brilliant, hungry, and exactly where I was ten years prior. I thought I was helping her. I thought I was paying forward the kindness my own mentors had shown me. But really? I was trying to live my life through her. I wanted her to succeed so badly that I couldn’t stand to see her fail. And when she made a mistake—a normal, human, inevitable mistake—I felt personally offended. I took it as a rejection of my wisdom. I took it as proof that I wasn’t good enough at guiding her. This is the ego trap. We convince ourselves that our experience is a currency that must be spent wisely, and if it isn’t accepted, we have failed. But let me tell you something that might sting a little: your experience is not a blueprint. It is a map drawn in a different terrain. The mountains look the same, but the rivers have changed course. If you try to force her to follow your path, you aren’t being helpful. You’re being controlling. And that’s not friendship; that’s maintenance of your own self-image as the wise, capable woman. So how do you stay in the game without becoming the coach? You change the question. Instead of saying, 'You should quit that job,' you ask, 'What part of that job makes you feel alive?' Instead of saying, 'He’s not worth your time,' you ask, 'What do you notice when you’re around him? Does he make you feel smaller or bigger?' This is the radical empathy in action. It assumes she is smart. It assumes she has the answers inside her, waiting for the right conditions to surface. When you ask questions, you hand her the steering wheel. When you give commands, you keep your hands on the wheel and hope she doesn’t notice. There is a profound dignity in letting someone else find their own way, even if it’s the wrong way. Especially if it’s the wrong way. Because the scar tissue she builds from making her own mistakes will be stronger than any armor you could provide for her. Your job isn’t to prevent her pain. Your job is to be the person who sits with her in the dark when the pain happens. Tell me more about the silence between you two now. Is it filled with judgment, or is it filled with space? Setting boundaries around this dynamic is not an act of rejection. It is an act of self-respect. It means you respect her enough to believe she can handle her own chaos. And it means you respect yourself enough to not carry the weight of her outcomes. This is hard. It goes against every instinct we have as women who are socialized to nurture, to fix, to smooth things over. We are taught that love looks like sacrifice. But in friendship, love looks like trust. Trust that she is capable. Trust that she will learn. Trust that your role is to witness, not to steer. When you step back, you might feel guilty. You might feel like you’re abandoning her. But you’re not. You’re actually giving her the greatest gift you can offer: autonomy. And in return, she gets to choose you. Not because you’re forcing her to listen, but because she values your perspective. That changes everything. It transforms the relationship from one of obligation to one of genuine connection. She calls you not because she needs a solution, but because she misses her friend. And that is where the magic lives. Not in the advice, but in the presence. Remember when we talked about embracing the shift from nightlife to naps? From chasing excitement to finding comfort in stillness? Mentoring requires a similar shift. We used to think connection meant doing everything together, solving every problem, being available twenty-four seven. Now, we know that real connection is quiet. It’s the ability to sit in a room with someone and not fill the silence with noise. It’s the ability to let her struggle without rushing to rescue her. It’s cozy. It’s safe. It’s intimate in a way that performance-based friendship never is. When you stop trying to impress her with your wisdom, you start connecting with her in her truth. And that is where the deepest bonds are forged. Not in the grand gestures or the perfect advice, but in the small, mundane moments of being seen. Just as she is. With all her mess, her confusion, her beautiful, imperfect humanity. You don’t need to fix her. You just need to be there. To hold the space. To remind her that she is loved, not for what she achieves, but for who she is. That is the only authority you truly have. And it is enough. Be gentle with yourself today. Be gentle with her. And remember, you are allowed to put down the white knight cape. You’re just a friend. And that is plenty. I’ll be here tomorrow. Until then, keep it cozy.