Latest / TheThinkingAtheist / The Ghost Hunter
Transcript
- 0:02Three, The Thinking Atheist. It's not a person, it's a symbol,
- 0:09an idea. The population of atheist in this country is going through the rule,
- 0:13rejecting faith, pursuing knowledge, challenging the sacred. If I tell the
- 0:19truth, it's because I tell the truth, not because I put my hand
- 0:23on a book and made a wish and working together for a more rational world.
- 0:29Take the risk of thinking. Feel so much more happiness, truth,
- 0:32beauty, and wisdom will come to you that way. Assume nothing, question
- 0:38everything, and start thinking. This is the Thinking Atheist podcast hosted by Said
- 0:47Andrews. Don't forget to subscribe to my second podcast, available on all major
- 1:02podcast apps, five minute vignettes about interesting stuff, releasing three times a week.
- 1:07You can subscribe pretty much anywhere, True Stories with Zeth Andrews. There
- 1:15is a video of the conversation today. That YouTube link is in the description
- 1:19box of the show. I know a lot of atheists, they don't believe
- 1:29in gods, but what about ghosts, the spiritual other, the unknown?
- 1:37Ah, there are many atheists who do believe. And I find this fascinating,
- 1:41and I myself would like to believe. It's like that Fox Mulder poster
- 1:45in the X files. I want to believe, and I love ghostly things,
- 1:49but I want to talk to a what I call you a debunker,
- 1:56I would not. I would call me a just an investigator. That's all
- 2:00because, as far as I'm concerned, debunking is the result of an investigation.
- 2:05That's when you get all your data together and you come to your conclusion
- 2:07based on that data, and it says, hey, you know what,
- 2:09the original claim is false. And that's what debunking is, taking the falseness
- 2:14out of a claim. So so you say debunker, it's essentially you're broadcasting
- 2:20that I'm front loading that I think this is bunk where you want to be
- 2:23more of a neutral observer. Yes, you know, it's it's no different
- 2:25than calling someone a believer. If you just go in and say, well,
- 2:29you're just a believer, and I get the same thing, you're just
- 2:31a debunker. Those terms are automatically setting a bias. It's already setting you
- 2:37up that you're on one side or the other. And like you said,
- 2:38I just want to go in neutral. I want to be Switzerland, you
- 2:42know, go in there. It's telling somebody, though, Kenny, I
- 2:44was telling somebody that I was going to talk to you, and they believe
- 2:47in spirits and stuff, and they were like, well, you know,
- 2:52they're not going to find anything, because I mean they may say that they're
- 2:54open and they just want to find evidence if there is, and they're genuinely
- 2:59curious, but you know, deep down there they think it's all a bunch
- 3:02of crap. And I'm sure you've heard that. Yeah, yeah, you
- 3:06know what. And for those people, I say, you're making an assumption
- 3:09for me, you're speaking for me, and you really can't do that because
- 3:14I know me better than you do. So for me, I'm fascinated with
- 3:19the entire idea of the paranormal ghosts and monsters and UFOs everything that goes along
- 3:23with that. I'm fascinating and I would absolutely love to find something genuine and
- 3:30like this is proof of the afterlife. That would be great. I would
- 3:34love that. Unfortunately, every investigation I go and does not conclude that way,
- 3:38and it's not because of me. It's because that's where the data leads
- 3:43me. Now, why are you stealing my joy? When I go to
- 3:45the Conjuring movies and I see the Warrens, they just seem so real incredible
- 3:51to me. I'll get to the Warrens. Really, I'll get to them.
- 3:54No, I'm just I'm full of crap. I'm just I'm just blowing
- 3:58smoke. Let's do a formal introduction. Kenny Biddle. You may have seen
- 4:02his work as featured in Skeptical Inquiry. You're still running the blog. I
- 4:06know you've got the podcast. Kind of tell everybody who you are, so
- 4:11yeah, right now, my current position is the chief investigator for the Committee
- 4:15for Skeptical Inquiry, and before that, I and still do. I host
- 4:19a show called The Skeptical Help Bar every Friday night. It's a live show.
- 4:24I also do videos for this Center for Inquiry YouTube channel called Ghosts in
- 4:29the Machine, and that's videos. Basically it's the same idea of my articles
- 4:32in Skeptical Inquiry. It's basically taking like ghost hunt in equipment or I take
- 4:36it apart, or I go out to locations that are alleged to be haunted
- 4:41or have a big foot and you know you follow me along. I take
- 4:44you along on the adventure, and I do lectures. I've spoken at science
- 4:48conferences such as Psicon about solving mysteries. I have a whole strategy that I
- 4:51followed that I try to teach during workshops, and that's it. I mean,
- 4:57I started as a ghost hunter. I was a ghost hunter in a
- 5:00the late nineties early two thousands, and I transitioned over to the skeptical side
- 5:04of the fence. Come on, Kenny, you can't throw that out.
- 5:09So I mean, are you like those guys at ghost Adventures for your Like,
- 5:12the temperature just dropped fifteen degrees, I saw an orb in the camera.
- 5:16And the reason I'm doing the accent is because I have been And this
- 5:19is not an insult to you, Kenny, but I have come to the
- 5:23conclusion that the people, the experts who go on television to investigate are just
- 5:29as thick as a post like these are the least qualified people possible. What's
- 5:34a ghost hunt look like in your ghostly past? Honestly, I mean,
- 5:39it's embarrassing now to talk about it, but it's important to talk about it.
- 5:43So yeah, I was basically what you saw on TV. I went
- 5:46in with gadgets that I honestly didn't know how to use, and I sat
- 5:49in the dark. I talked to the dark. I asked questions, thinking
- 5:53ghosts were all over the place. I thought anytime I got a shiver,
- 5:57like felt a cold spot, that it was a ghost. That pictures of
- 6:01little balls of light in my images, or smoky substance going across the scene
- 6:08I thought was evidence of a ghost. All of this stuff, I was
- 6:12right there with you. I got my start right before the ghost hunting shows
- 6:17came on the air. Ghost Hunters was actually the first show, first modern
- 6:21reality show that would come on the air. And I grew up with things
- 6:26like in Search of Sightings and shows like that where they presented all these mysteries.
- 6:31So I wanted to do that, And for me, I called a
- 6:34local group that I found the first time I got a computer, back in
- 6:39the nineties, when you know, like the Internet was a brand new thing.
- 6:43I called up a group. They said, yeah, come on out.
- 6:46And my first ghost hunt was a cemetery, of all things, because
- 6:49you know, by the time that people get there there, they are already
- 6:53dead. So I don't know why cemeteries are haunted, but I didn't know
- 6:57any better. So come on, I mean, I've seen those shows where
- 7:00they take you to one of the most I don't know, creepy. Please
- 7:04a cemetery. It's an old abandoned asylum, a prison, with the electric
- 7:10chair or whatever. I mean, by the time you walk in the door,
- 7:13aren't you just you're ramped, right, You're already scared. Before you're
- 7:16scared, right, exactly, You've already read the stories you I mean,
- 7:21if you look behind me, there's tons of books back here, and many
- 7:25of them are regional ghost story books that you can pick up at any bookstore
- 7:29or any tourist trap in the area. So as a ghost hunter, that's
- 7:32what I used to do all the time. As soon as I got there,
- 7:35it's like, all right, what can I buy? And buy the
- 7:38books, read the stories, and that's where I want to go. So
- 7:42when you're arriving at the front door, you already believe the place is haunted.
- 7:46You already believe that all the gadgets that you brought with you do something
- 7:50either communicate with ghosts or capture ghosts or detect their presence. And then when
- 7:56you gather everything up, you're so hyped up. It's like you you drank
- 8:00like a dozen red bulls all at once, and you're walking into this building
- 8:03and you're like, yeah, I can't wait. I mean, I can't
- 8:05tell you how many times I see people preach that I can't wait to get
- 8:11all these evidence tonight, Like they're not even there yet, and they already
- 8:15believe that they're going to get this big, huge body of evidence that the
- 8:18place is haunted. So yeah, you walk in, you set things up.
- 8:22You're like, oh, you know, I'm on a ghost hunt.
- 8:26I'm in the dark, and I'm with a bunch of people that I barely
- 8:28know, and that's gotta be a bonding experience. Though. You're all in
- 8:33a box hoole together, right and your tribe all of a sudden, Yeah,
- 8:37you're you're You're part of a group, you know, and everybody shares
- 8:39their beliefs, and as soon as something weird happens. It's not during my
- 8:45ghost hunting days and even today when I go out, because a lot of
- 8:48times I go and with like pay to play events where I pay a few
- 8:52dollars and I attend an event, a ghost hunting event with a group,
- 8:56and they teach you all the stuff that they do. And when you're sitting
- 9:00there in the dark and something weird happens, it's not usually a hey,
- 9:05let's investigate and see what caused that noise or that shadow down the end of
- 9:11the hall. It's I think that's a ghost, and then everyone else times
- 9:13in Oh, I think so too. Oh you know what, that's where
- 9:16they'll ghost is supposed to be seen, like people have seen that before,
- 9:20and they justify it. They convinced themselves that what they experienced was a ghost
- 9:24without actually investigating it. And that's what I did. I used to do
- 9:28that. I mean, truth be told. I just I didn't investigate.
- 9:31I didn't fact check, I didn't check up on what I was doing,
- 9:35and I didn't bother to find a source. I just believed. And that
- 9:39was my problem. You've mentioned the gadgets a few times, and I want
- 9:41to talk about the tools of the trade, but I don't want to put
- 9:46you on the spot. You don't have to answer. But when I was
- 9:50watching The Scariest Places on Earth and Ghost Hunters, etc. I just couldn't
- 9:56help but think that one of the production assistants ran in the other room them
- 10:00and through like a piece of lead pipe on a concrete floor to make a
- 10:03sound, right, And I staged, Come on, did you ever get
- 10:07the vibe that you know, someone yank in our chain? Yeah? I
- 10:11mean I can't speak for all of them, and I again, like I
- 10:16have not been on set. I'm not wanted to get invited onto the ghost
- 10:20hunting shows. I don't know why. I mean, I'm always available,
- 10:24strange, but yeah, I would see there's certain scenarios where like, well,
- 10:28that just looks staged. It very much looks staged because one camera placement.
- 10:35Camera placement is always in the right spot at just the right time to
- 10:39capture exactly what they want to capture and nothing more. So that's always a
- 10:45red flag for me. But I don't know if they're all staged. I
- 10:48think there's a lot of misinterpretation. I also think that in some cases,
- 10:54maybe with certain shows ghost adventures, that they maybe a two way radio to
- 11:00make some of these gadgets go off. A few of them do operate off
- 11:03of radio frequency or are affected by a radio frequency. So if you have
- 11:07a like a two way radio that you picked up at Walmart, you can
- 11:11go like in the basement or a floor above or in the next room and
- 11:15key it up and wave it around and it'll make some of these devices light
- 11:20up or beep. And you know, nothing excites a ghost under more than
- 11:24when a gadget lights up and beats. Doesn't matter what the measurement is it's
- 11:31as long as it beats tools of the trade. Now I've seen the ev
- 11:35stuff and the white noise, I don't know what doing a very poor job
- 11:41of. I mean, tell me what the tools are as a hunter of
- 11:45ghosts. So you have a bunch of tools, I mean pretty much.
- 11:48The standard is a EMF meter, so that basically stands for electromagnetic field meter.
- 11:56And these meters are actual tools. I mean you can get them in
- 12:01like home depot, or you can get more sophisticated and accurate ones from science
- 12:05websites. But they measure the strength of an electromagnetic field. So like anything
- 12:11electrical will give off a field when powers flowing through a line, you'll get
- 12:15an electromagnetic field from that that wire, and you can read that you can
- 12:18measure to strength of it. And I think that is really based off the
- 12:22pk E meter from Ghostbusters. I honestly think that's where it came from,
- 12:26because you see, I mean Ghostbusters was a big influence and you can actually
- 12:31see you like above my head here there's a PKE meter on the shelf.
- 12:33But when Ghostbusters came out, that was in nineteen eighty four, and that
- 12:37was before you saw these reality ghost hunting shows, and not many people used
- 12:43gadgets. Of course, you had like SBR. They were using practical stuff
- 12:48like rope and powder and candles, stuff to check four footprints and airflow through
- 12:54a hallway or out a window, practical stuff like that. It wasn't until
- 12:58after Ghostbusters came out that all these gadgets started peering with groups where they're like,
- 13:03oh, what can we grab that's handheld that we can walk around with
- 13:07and that'll give us readings. So I think, yeah, the EMF meter
- 13:11was the first one that came up, and it really doesn't do much.
- 13:13There's another one called the rempod and I don't remember what rem r em stands
- 13:18for, but it's it's not anything real. We're technical. I think it's
- 13:22more of a made up word, but basically it's a junior Thermin device.
- 13:28So a thuramin is a musical device. It works without touching it. It
- 13:31has two antennas. One controls the volume, one controls the pitch or the
- 13:35tone of the sound coming out of it, and it's a really cool machine.
- 13:39You don't actually touch it to play it. You just get closer and
- 13:43closer to the two antennas. And it creates sounds. So a junior THEURAMIN
- 13:58is a novelty version of it. It's based electronics toy and this is used
- 14:03inside usually three D print bodies, and it lights up. It either plays
- 14:07beeps at different tones or some music that it plays. You can switch between
- 14:11the two. But the closer anything that's conductive gets close to it, it
- 14:16starts making noises and it starts lighting up. This is one of the things
- 14:20that can also be used with a two way radio. I can make those
- 14:24things go off from like two or three rooms away, so it's very easy
- 14:26to manipulate, just like the K two meter. What else we got.
- 14:31We got motion sensors, we got temperature guns that read the infrared energy coming
- 14:35off of surface objects. And we have ghost boxes. Oh, ghost boxes
- 14:39are very popular because you know ghosts, but these are broken radios. They
- 14:46are literally broken radios. So what that does is sweep through the AM or
- 14:50FM band, So it sweeps through and instead of stopping on a station that's
- 14:56coming in clear, it continues to cycle through. So the disabled the feature
- 15:03where it stops on the next available station and it just cycles through, so
- 15:05you're getting snippets of each local station. Coming through, so you can hear
- 15:11bits and pieces of music, news commercials, any kind of radio broadcast,
- 15:18and ghost hunters will make a habit of sitting around in a room with one
- 15:22of these boxes going off, and honestly, it's so annoying when you have
- 15:26to hear this, When you have to listen to this for like more than
- 15:30thirty seconds, it's so annoying. Is there anybody here with us? We
- 15:35have family members here and we're here to be friendly. We just wanted to
- 15:37come say hi and see if there's anybody here that wanted to say hi or
- 15:41talk or tell us something. They ask questions thinking that they are communicating with
- 15:56a ghost and that somehow a ghost can manipulate the radio frequencies coming into that
- 16:02box and create words. I don't know how it, Kenny, it manufactures
- 16:11the box? Like is that ever? A question like where did this come
- 16:15from? Who put it together? What are the components? How do we
- 16:18know it works? So the first one that I remember seeing was the radio
- 16:22shack hack, and it was basically a radio shack radio. It was a
- 16:26white radio, yeah, and you opened it up and there was one connection
- 16:30in the back where you snipped it and that connector was the one that controlled
- 16:34when it started sweeping through the station, it would stop at the next available
- 16:40station. So when you snip this little connector, it stopped that action,
- 16:45so it would continually sweep through it. And I have I have one out
- 16:48in the display case here. Basically it came from that people were plugging speakers
- 16:52in and they were going, hey, you know, can you tell me
- 16:53your name? And they were hearing different things, and you're hearing you're basically
- 16:56hearing phonetics. You're hearing these different saying and when you're primed to hear something,
- 17:03when you're expecting to hear an answer, such as a name, that's
- 17:07what you're going to pick out. So in all this static and all this
- 17:11clutter of different radio stations, and again you're talking about like commercials for furniture,
- 17:17for vacations for you have news broadcasts that have politics and sports, and
- 17:22you know the local murders that happen. All this stuff is going through this
- 17:26radio and coming out the speakers. So if you say, hey, what's
- 17:30your name, I guarantee you're going to hear something that sounds like a name.
- 17:34It's something like backward masking. During the Satanic panic. You know,
- 17:38the pattern seekers in us are going to find something, and then we're going
- 17:41to find something that validates what we expected to find in the first play exactly.
- 17:45There's even a problem where the conversation switches depending on what the radio says.
- 17:51And this is what blows my mind. You can have a group of
- 17:53people ask something like hey, what's your name, and somebody will say,
- 18:00well, I just heard chair. I just heard chair, and instead of
- 18:04saying or, the logical thing to me would be like, well, that's
- 18:07not answering my question. I asked for a name, the conversation will switch
- 18:12and say, well you have a chair? What chair? That chair in
- 18:17the corner? Did you die in that chair? And that's it, Like
- 18:21the conversation just shift. It completely shifted from what they were asking to something
- 18:26different because the radio told them. And I'm just picture you watching some of
- 18:30these shows, just vibrating in your chair like you're on the ch like what's
- 18:36wrong with you? Ask this question? What do you do? I just
- 18:38picture that you're doing that, dude. People still use divining rods because I
- 18:41was scanning the other day and sobody. First of all, for those who
- 18:45don't know what a divining rod is explain what it is and what it's supposed
- 18:48to do and why it's why it is bullshit. Yeah, I'll say it,
- 18:52go ahead, go ahead. So defining rod Originally they were used to
- 18:59find minal rules or water and people used a divining rod, but it was
- 19:03a stick. It was a forked stick that they picked up from a tree.
- 19:07I think it was usually like birch or something like that. But they
- 19:10go around and it held it in a weird way, like in a way
- 19:12that promoted the stick wanting to go down because you can't hold the position.
- 19:18And if you look at older photos you'll see like the way they're holding it,
- 19:21and it's very uncomfortable, very awkward, and very just dumb to put
- 19:26it bluntly, But basically, people thought they could find water, sources of
- 19:30water underground or minerals. And there's there's a historical context with this, and
- 19:37forgive me, it escapes me now. But the first person that wrote about
- 19:40it, I think was in the seventeen hundreds, and he wrote a manual
- 19:42about finding minerals and he touched on the idea of divining rods and dowsing,
- 19:48and actually the first paragraph of his description is used to promote divining rods as
- 19:53you know, something that's real. But if you actually read on the rest
- 19:56of the paragraphs, you find out that the the author just dismisses it.
- 20:00He's like, no, it doesn't work. And he explains that why because
- 20:04you can actually find vegetation and pretty much anywhere you dig you're going to find
- 20:08water. So he explains it, but that part is usually left out modern
- 20:12times, people use two usually like either brass rods in holders in handles so
- 20:18they swivel easier, So they are making it easier to get an anomaly.
- 20:25Here, can you point me towards the nearest buried silver? See how that
- 20:33both the rods are pointing in that direction. That's where we're going to walk,
- 20:40and the rods have crossed. Look what happens when I step back the
- 20:45rods open. The rods are crossed. Now I'm going to walk forward.
- 20:52See what happens to the rods They've opened, so we know around this area
- 21:02it's buried silver. So they're in the handles, they're two of them,
- 21:06and they usually ask questions of ghosts. They think they can communicate with ghosts
- 21:11with this because they ask yes or no questions and if the rods cross,
- 21:15that's a yes, and if they split apart that's a no. Or you
- 21:19can ask for direction and the rods apparently go back and forth. So that's
- 21:23basically what I see dowsing rods used for divining rods. There, it's interchangeable
- 21:29divining rods. Dowsing rods ato my subconsciously maneuvering. I mean, because a
- 21:34lot of these people I think are sincere. Oh look it is leaning left,
- 21:38it's right, it's crossing, and I don't sense and who really knows,
- 21:42but I don't sense that they're in on it. Yeah, well,
- 21:47I mean it's a juggle. It really is because some people I just flat
- 21:52out think they know exactly what they're doing. Other people, yes, they
- 21:56don't realize what they're doing, and until you show them, they believe that
- 22:00something is manipulating in rods. Some time ago, a friend of mine named
- 22:03Mit Silverstein made a simple device and I have it here. So this is
- 22:07a simple device for testing dowsing rods. It's two acrylic blocks and there's a
- 22:12bubble level up there. You can see that that's on the lower thing and
- 22:17the handles here. So these handles are the original handles for the dowsing rods,
- 22:21it's what comes with them, so they are locked into the blocks,
- 22:23so now I cannot manipulate them independently, which is great. And if you
- 22:30try to tilt the whole thing first, I'll see you tilting it like a
- 22:33steering wheel, so that's an obvious red flag. But if you tilt it
- 22:37in any way, the bubble level will let me know that you're moving it.
- 22:41So this locks it in place, won't let you manipulate them. And
- 22:45when I use these, I've used these for years now, and everyone that's
- 22:48tried these has not been able to get the dowsing rods to work. So
- 22:52for the audio podcast, listener and check me if this is right. But
- 22:56essentially, it's a device that removes, at least to a degree, a
- 23:00great degree, the human element. Yea rods kind of pivot on top.
- 23:03You aren't actually holding the rods directly at the pivot portion directly in your hand,
- 23:08and there's a level on the device to make sure that you're not sort
- 23:11of rotating at like a steering wheel to make the rods move. Is that
- 23:15close enough, Kenny, Yes, that's correct, that's correct. And there's
- 23:19another method too that I use when people are convinced that they are still doing
- 23:25something the vine. Let's say, I usually set up a video camera at
- 23:29the level of their elbows, because usually when you're you're using dousing rods,
- 23:33you have your arms bent like this and your forearms are straight out and you're
- 23:37holding the rods. So when I set up a video camera level with their
- 23:41elbows, I get the full I'm looking directly down their arms, and I
- 23:45take video of them as they are asking questions and getting responses, and then
- 23:52we watch the video played back at at least double the speed. So when
- 23:56you double the speed, you get the sea. All the movements of their
- 24:00hands are greatly exaggerated, and it shows them that they are not holding their
- 24:06hands still, that they are manipulating them, even if they don't do it
- 24:10on purpose, but they are manipulating them. And once I've done that,
- 24:14for the most part, people realize, like crap, it's me, which
- 24:18is good, I mean they realize it. Unfortunately, most of them still
- 24:21continue to do it because you know, they get paid. Kenny Biddle stealing
- 24:27the joy, robbing us of the awe and wonder of possibility out there.
- 24:33He just takes your dreams and smashes them to the ground. Sad sad man.
- 24:37I'm sure you probably heard some of that, Like I want to believe
- 24:41it's probably a great way to put it, like why would you want to
- 24:45kill this in me? You know, I'm sure you hear some of that.
- 24:48You know what. I find joy in solving that mystery. I used
- 24:52to find excitement from being in spooky place and going, oh, you know,
- 24:56I think that's a ghost. I think I saw a shadow that probably
- 24:59is a spirit from somebody from like, you know, three hundred years ago
- 25:02or something like that. I used to get excited about that, And then
- 25:04the more I learned, the more I realized, wow, you know what,
- 25:07there's a reason that I'm seeing this or there's a reason I'm getting these
- 25:11on photographs. And I found that more exciting than the alleged ghost part.
- 25:17I love going into a place and solving the mystery, figuring out what actually
- 25:21happened, and recreating it and saying, look, we solved this. We
- 25:25Scooby dude this. I mean, that's what better thing. I mean for
- 25:30somebody that grew up with Scooby do Like that's the ultimate goal. I'm reminded
- 25:33of that line by Hitch and I totally agree what he was talking about.
- 25:37Once you've seen the wonder of the natural world, why would you ever be
- 25:40impressed by a burning bush? You know exactly? And the psychology of belief
- 25:45and honestly, the real world is wonderful enough. More with Kenny Biddle in
- 25:53just a second, I want to talk about Ada and Lorraine Warren, best
- 25:57known for the Conjuring Films, Real people who investigated real ghosts. Oh,
- 26:03we're gonna get into that next. I'm talking here with Kenny Biddle, probably
- 26:18best known for his work with Skeptical Inquirer. He is a paranormal investigator more
- 26:26than twenty years investigating gadgets and haunted houses and psychics and evidence quote unquote evidence
- 26:33of the after life. I want to come back to the Warrens, I
- 26:37confess, Kenny. I'm I like the Conjuring films. Well, I like
- 26:42the first one except for the last ten minutes. I mean I enjoyed it
- 26:45like Hyde and Clap scared the shit out of me. Okay, I took
- 26:49the journey, but the Warrens right. Whenever people invoke the Warrens, I
- 26:56do die a little bit inside. Can you tell us who the Warrens are
- 27:00and why people care, Well, I can tell you who they are why
- 27:04they care. I don't know. Maybe maybe that's a poor phrasing of the
- 27:11question, but I'm struck by them, right, I mean, I think
- 27:15most of this started around Amityville, is that correct? Right? You're talking
- 27:18the seventies, where, well, we didn't have the internet. It wasn't
- 27:22easy to look up for information, so it really took time. You had
- 27:26to go to historical societies or libraries and newspaper actually the buildings where you had
- 27:33to go and research. So there was a lot of work. It was
- 27:36very easy to pull off a hoax or just to perpetuate or promote a hoax.
- 27:41But back then, yeah, we had the Warrens. They actually got
- 27:45their start with little cases where they thought everything was demonic, everything was demonic
- 27:51and ed and Lorraine Warren. They were a couple, they were married couple,
- 27:56they had a museum. But I think they really started big with the
- 28:00Annabelle story. So apparently they had this aparliament. There was an apartament that
- 28:04was being haunted by a demon. Because that's the only thing that comes up
- 28:08when they're involved. It was a demon and it manipulated this raggedy Ann doll
- 28:14and moved it around, and that was the story. The doll itself is
- 28:18not haunted or possessed. It was just this demon was using this doll to
- 28:22play around and that became famous. It made the news, and I think
- 28:26it really propelled them into like the public eye. And then you had things
- 28:30like the Amityville House. Then you had the Conjuring House, which is a
- 28:34famous movie. But I guess from a standpoint of watching a film, it
- 28:40was entertaining. You could watch it as a horror film, that's fine,
- 28:44But because it was based on a true story and I used that loosely,
- 28:47then I look at it in a different light and I have a problem with
- 28:49it. So edul Lorraine Warren again, were they called themselves demonologists every time
- 28:55they went to a location. As soon as it popped up in the news,
- 28:57as soon as there was some inkling that there was weird stuff going on
- 29:02in a house, they showed up. Whether it was the Conjuring House,
- 29:06Amityville, Endfield case over in the UK, there was one in Connecticut.
- 29:10But they were there, and they weren't there to help. As far as
- 29:14I'm concerned, they weren't there to help. They were there to exploit.
- 29:18And they went in, they got a story, they added to the story,
- 29:22they embellished the hell out of the story, and then went on a
- 29:26lecture series and talked about it. So they charged people to come to their
- 29:30lectures. They would hire a writer to write a book about that story,
- 29:34regardless of what the family thought. They would get permission from the family to
- 29:40write about it, with the idea that they were going to help, that
- 29:42the warrants were going to help them. And in every case, if you
- 29:47talk to the families, they did not help. All they did was to
- 29:49exploit. So to me, and this is my personal opinion, that's my
- 29:55disclaimer, they were horrible people that exploited others for their own gain. And
- 30:00I think they're terrible, and I and anybody that follows them and thinks they're
- 30:04legitimate, I think you need to rethink your entire life because they're just horrible
- 30:08people. But now you segue us into the more insidious part of this.
- 30:14I mean, you know, you drive over near area of fifty one and
- 30:18you see the gift shop and you go in and get the alien figurine.
- 30:21Okay, great, whatever, knock yourself out. I mean I see for
- 30:22those watching on video, I see a lot of your office is like a
- 30:26story that would take six months to tell because you have just so much stuff.
- 30:32It is just one corner. The first step, Kenny, is to
- 30:36admit you have a problem. I have a problem. I'm well aware of
- 30:41it and I love it. But it's big business and people selling hope.
- 30:48You know that type of thing. You can speak to your dead grandmother or
- 30:51the spouse or child you lost. All we need is on and a thousand
- 30:56dollars of your hard one or hard earned money kind of thing. Let's talk
- 30:59about the dark side of this stuff. What do you want to talk about.
- 31:02I want to talk about the grifters. I want to talk about the
- 31:04people who were saying I will come to your home, or you come here,
- 31:07we'll have a seance. I have a crystal ball. You know.
- 31:11It's just sort of that paranormal for profit angle that you started us down.
- 31:15Well. I see a lot more with psychics and mediums, not so much
- 31:19with ghost hunters. Ghost hunters, I guess on the positive side, they
- 31:22don't usually charge for anything. They are happy to come to your house and
- 31:27you know, hang out for a few hours and enjoy the darkness and talk
- 31:32to themselves. I mean, did you pay I know you recently stayed at
- 31:34a ghost house. Did you pay a fee to spend the night there?
- 31:37Yes? Yeah, So in those instances where I pay, usually like twenty
- 31:42thirty forty dollars. Most of the time the money goes back to the location.
- 31:47So if it's a historical location that is in need of repair or something,
- 31:52usually that's a benefit to that. The money goes back to that.
- 31:55Well. I'm going to be clear too, I'm not setting you it because
- 31:56I've admitted in the past and I would still do this. I would pay
- 32:00one hundred bucks or whatever to stay the night in a ghost house or whatever.
- 32:02I don't see that that's not the same category as someone coming in and
- 32:07I don't know being what Susan Gerbeck called the grief vampire. That's a different
- 32:13thing, right, Yeah, yeah, I mean at there's places like you
- 32:15just said, I would pay just to be there because I like going to
- 32:19places that are alleged to be horne. It's the places that I've heard about
- 32:22all my life. I would pay to stay overnight. I mean that's just
- 32:25what I do. I also pay to go to movie locations because I like
- 32:30that. I'm a big nerd. But when it comes to charging for profit,
- 32:35and again, like Susan Gerbeck, that was a great way to bring
- 32:37it up about psychics and grief vampires that come in and claim that they're going
- 32:42to contact your loved ones, and they do it for a fee, and
- 32:47usually it's an expensive fee, but they give this impression that they're talking to
- 32:53ghosts, and I just I find that very deceitful and journey because you're exploiting
- 33:01a person's grief. Because if somebody lost a child, especially if it's a
- 33:06child or a loved one like their wife or husband or partner, and you're
- 33:10you're saying, hey, you know what, I have this little bit of
- 33:13hope here. I can talk to your your deceased loved one, you know,
- 33:16four nine five, I can do this, And in that moment the
- 33:22person is grieving, there's desperation. They desperately want to talk to their loved
- 33:28one again. You know, maybe they want to apologize or something for something
- 33:31they did. Maybe they want to know that it's okay, you know,
- 33:35they're all right in whatever after life they're in. So they pay this money
- 33:39and the psychic or medium. Usually it's a medium because that's what you know
- 33:45that, that's the definition mediums the difference. So mediums are the medium before
- 33:51between the living and the dead. They are the like interpreter. I guess
- 33:54you can call it, yes, where psychics are ones that claim to be
- 34:00able to see into the past, or see into the future or make predictions.
- 34:05If mediums could really talk to the dead, we should have no unsolved
- 34:09murder cases. We should have no missing persons. We just shouldn't, and
- 34:15we do. We have thousands of kids every year that go missing and or
- 34:21are killed by various people, kidnappings and whatnot, and their murders go unsolved.
- 34:27But yet these mediums claim that, Hey, for nine five, I
- 34:31can talk to your dead and glob one and tell you like how much they
- 34:35love you. Yeah, it's I'll never tell you where where the pot of
- 34:38gold is buried, for sure. It's funny, Kenny. I don't know.
- 34:42Maybe I'm showing my hand here, but knowing what I know about my
- 34:45former evangelical past, I feel like that knowledge if I wanted to use it
- 34:52in a malicious way, or if I wanted to become a grifter, I
- 34:54could use my knowledge of how the system works to grift this system. I
- 35:00could go back and say I was wrong, I found Jesus and then hit
- 35:04the circuit right at the end of an offering plate, and I could totally
- 35:07cash in because I know the system. I look at you when I think
- 35:12you're a guy who was seen behind the curtain and you know how the toys
- 35:15work. Yet, if you were not a person of morals, you could
- 35:21use that knowledge to cash in. Man, you could play that, you
- 35:24could you could literally feel it'd be like printing money in my mind. I
- 35:29don't know. Can you ever think about that? Like what if I wasn't
- 35:31an honest guy? I do every time I look at it, like investigate
- 35:37a gadget that's supposed to be talking or detecting ghosts, because I mean some
- 35:43of them, most of the gadgets that I take apart, there's maybe five
- 35:47to ten dollars worth of parts in there, and maybe in a half hour
- 35:52or an hour of putting it together, not a lot. And they sell
- 35:55this stuff for two, three four dollars each and they solved tons of them.
- 36:02If I went onto a TV show and just said, hey, you
- 36:06know what I'm I'm an expert. I'm an expert in the paranormal and just
- 36:09said, yeah, you know like that that it probably is old Uncle Fred
- 36:14haunting the attic. And and this ball of light that's not a dust particle,
- 36:19that's not a bug, No, that's a spirit. And if I
- 36:22kept doing that and maybe you know, made my own hair all crazy like
- 36:24the crazy hair guy on the alien shows, you know, did guest spots,
- 36:30or if I if I said, hey, you know, because I've
- 36:31done cold readings many times, I've done cold readings in college classes. When
- 36:36I've lectured college classes, humanist groups, I've just launched into the cold readings
- 36:40and been able to figure out like someone's aunt passed away from a heart attack
- 36:45or something like that. And I mean, I'm not doing anything special,
- 36:50and I honestly I think I suck at it, but I still get through
- 36:53it and convinced them that I'm real. So yeah, every time I do
- 36:59that, I think I could be rich. I could be rich. I
- 37:02could have I could I could make some good money and I could hit the
- 37:07road. We could we could call the two, we could broadcast our own
- 37:10channel and we could just go and it'd be Goden ghost baby. Well you
- 37:15and I would just go and print money. It would be amazing. As
- 37:17we get close to the end of our conversation and you've been so generous with
- 37:21your time, come on, has there been any one just way out there
- 37:24wacky even if you knew it was crap, but just wacky experience you've had
- 37:29when you've stayed at a haunted place where you were like, this is just
- 37:32off the chain. Have you seen anything just crazy, even if it was
- 37:37human made? So I guess the craziest thing that I saw well heard because
- 37:45I went to a place called Whispers Estate. This was early on, but
- 37:50I went there because it was famous for hearing voices. Like people didn't have
- 37:53to have recorders. They would start talking and doing their ghost hunt thing,
- 37:59and then sometimes during the night they would hear the voice of a little girl
- 38:01suddenly start singing lullabies and it was a big deal. It made its rounds.
- 38:07It was very popular in the early two thousands, and I got to
- 38:12visit. I was part of a podcast that was streaming live from that site
- 38:16and they invited me to go along and I was like, oh, great,
- 38:19you know this is cool. I'm finally going to get there and I'm
- 38:22talking to people. There was only about ten of us in the house,
- 38:24and all of them have experienced this singing. They all heard it, and
- 38:29they all thought it was great. And I'm getting pumped up. I'm trying
- 38:31not to, but I'm getting pumped up because I'm like, these are all
- 38:34people and like all they're saying, I can't I can't like figure out what's
- 38:38going on yet. And then I take a look at the stairway because it
- 38:44was like a foyer where the sounds were coming from, and the main stairs
- 38:47were there, and it was a little just a little area, and I'm
- 38:52looking at it and I'm like, well, there's a panel on the stairway.
- 38:55Like the whole stair is the under side of the stairway is enclosed.
- 39:00There's one panel that doesn't match. And I was like, there's something wrong
- 39:04with this. And I didn't want to take it apart because I didn't have
- 39:06permission from the owner to take up the panel off because it had screws in
- 39:09it and you would be able to take it off, so I didn't have
- 39:12a permission. I didn't do it. I went and did something else,
- 39:15and when I came back a little bit later, a few of the ghost
- 39:19hunters had taken up pond There's themselves to take that panel off, which was
- 39:23good for me, but not for them because they The owner got pretty pissed
- 39:28off. But we got to sea downstairs and we got to see that there
- 39:31was a shoot. There was a metal shoot going from under the stairs into
- 39:36the cross space, and so I went down to the basement, found the
- 39:39cross space, crawled up into it and there was just enough room. If
- 39:44I sat on my butt, I would still have to hunch over, so
- 39:49it was very tight. I'm crawling around. I get to this metal shoot,
- 39:52which I think used to be for coal. I think they used to
- 39:55load coal into some kind of compartment and it went down into basement. But
- 40:00I stood up in the shoot. I started talking and there was an echo
- 40:05and everyone stopped and they're like, that sounds exactly like the Ghost Girl,
- 40:09like this whole echo, this metallic echo, and I was like, really,
- 40:14you know, And I start singing horribly because I can't sing, but
- 40:17they're like, wow, you know, this really does sound like it.
- 40:22So that made me want to crawl around some more just to take a look,
- 40:24and I accidentally kicked something by one of the pillars supporting support pillars.
- 40:30I kicked something. I went and looked it up. It was a speaker.
- 40:32There was a speaker there, and I traced the wire. It went
- 40:36around certain polls and went all the way back to the main basement where there
- 40:40was a whole collection of audio equipment, and then I found another speaker that
- 40:45matched it, and it was right in the same area. There was no
- 40:47reason why a speaker would be there, much less propped up the way it
- 40:52was propped up, And that, for me was probably one of the weirdest
- 40:57things. I was really expecting to hear this music with the sound the singing,
- 41:00and instead I found the best evidence for a hoax going on. So
- 41:06that probably is the weirdest. I know, you were probably expecting a ghost
- 41:09or something. I come away with that story, Kenny, I think I
- 41:13would get a bigger rush from discovering the charade I did. I stood up.
- 41:20I held that speaker up like, oh, I mean, I got
- 41:24the pat on my head, like you're holding Simba up in front of everybody.
- 41:30Yeah, look at this, bitches sounded Kenny. You're awesome, You're
- 41:36fun to talk to. To send everybody to your stuff, kind of tell
- 41:39everybody where to find you if you would. The easiest place to find me
- 41:43is Skeptical Inquirer dot org. If you look that up, look up my
- 41:46name Kenny Biddle, you'll find my articles. You'll see I have a whole
- 41:50page of articles and then the ghosts and the machine videos that I do for
- 41:54them for the Center for Inquiry. You can find me online on Facebook.
- 42:00I am Kenny Biddle. I post a lot of stuff there. I'm on
- 42:04Twitter, I'm on Instagram. I'm on TikTok because TikTok is a fun place
- 42:07to find all kinds of really bad videos. But I recreate them. I
- 42:13do love that. I do love that I have a channel. It's it's
- 42:15Kenny Biddle CSI and I literally go through all the paranormal videos that I find
- 42:20and I recreate them here. So we reproduce the same effects so you can
- 42:23see how they're done. Because I show you what we do, like I
- 42:27recreate it. You see the recreation first, and then you see how I
- 42:30did it, so you can understand it better. And you know when next
- 42:35time you see a video like that, you're like, I know how that
- 42:37was done. Okay. I wish we were neighbors. I just wish we
- 42:40were neighbers. I would be such a pest. He would be like cussing
- 42:44me, like lock the door, keep him out, Like he's driving me
- 42:46crazy. Because this is my that's my jam. That sounds like big fun
- 42:51to me. Oh it is. It is all right, Kenny Biddle.
- 42:52I'm going to include the SI link in the description box. And you're fun
- 42:57and you're necessary, and I appreciate you talking to us about these alleged paranormal
- 43:02and let's cross pass again soon. Okay, absolutely good talking to you,
- 43:06sir. Follow The Thinking Atheist on Facebook and Twitter for a complete archive of
- 43:10podcasts and videos, products like mugs and t shirts featuring the Thinking Atheist logo,
- 43:15links to atheist pages and resources, and details on upcoming free thought events
- 43:21and conventions. Log onto our website, The Thinking Atheist dot com.