Latest / Blue Leader Nation Podcast / Episode 30: From Doer to Decider — Why High Performers Struggle When They Get Promoted
Transcript
- from doer : Let me describe somebody and you tell me if this sounds familiar. For years this person was the one everybody wanted next to them when a call went sideways. They could calm down a family fight that had already worn out two other units, then go back to the station and write a report that the prosecutor actually enjoyed reading. All right, enjoyed might be a stretch. Let's just say the reports didn't get rejected. Every squad has one of these people. They're the go to. And they get noticed. Supervisors notice, peers notice, and eventually a promotion board notices. So one day this person gets handed stripes or bars, shakes a few hands, gets a new set of keys, and walks into their first shift as a supervisor. Within about a week, those same instincts that made them the go-to started causing problems. Something gets hard, and they do what they've always done. They step in and handle it because that's who they are. And that's what got them there. This is what today's episode is all about. For years, you were the go-to, and that's a big part of why you got promoted. The job you have now asks you. To become something else. It asks you to become the decider. And figuring that out is one of the hardest turns in a law enforcement career. This is Blue Leader Nation. We're here to develop those men and women in law enforcement who want to be respected leaders and to mold you into becoming a legendary leader. If it's leadership, personal growth, and self-development, we're talking about it. Whether you're new or a veteran, you found your new home. This is the Blue Leader Nation. Now, here's your host, Dr. Ed Hallis. Welcome back to the Blue Leader Nation podcast. I'm your host Ed Palace. This is where we talk honestly about leadership and law enforcement, what it actually takes, and what nobody bothered to mention to you before you pinned on the new rank. I have a personal stake in today's topic because I didn't handle this well when I first got promoted. I'd love to tell you that I figured it all out on day one as a new sergeant. I did not. I figured it out gradually, usually right after I did something wrong. And to be honest with you, even late in my career, I'd catch myself sliding back into some of the same old habits. So if you hear yourself in some of this, you're in good company. What I want to talk about is The move from being the go to person on the squad to being the person responsible for making sure that the whole team gets things done. Those sound familiar, but they're two different jobs. And I think a lot of new supervisors struggle because nobody sits them down and says, by the way, the scoreboard just changed. Think about how you were measured as an officer or detective or deputy. It was pretty concrete. You handled the call, you made the arrest, you closed the case, and you got the report in before the end of the shift. At the end of the night, you could point to your work and say, That's mine. Your value was tied pretty directly to what you personally produced. But then you get promoted and the questions shift underneath you, usually without anybody announcing it. Now it's whether your squad is performing, whether people know what is expected of them, whether the problems on your shift are getting fixed or just getting handed to the next shift, whether your people are actually getting better or just getting older. The last one is where I want to stay for just a minute. A big part of leadership gets measured by what your people can handle, both when you're there and when you're off. It's a very different yardstick. It's the one you've been using your whole career. And it takes a while to get used to. One way I found to describe the change is by the question you ask yourself when something lands on your desk. Before promotion, the natural question is: what should I do? After promotion, The better question is usually what needs to happen? I know on paper it sounds like a word swap, but try it on a real problem and you'll feel the difference. What should I do puts you right in the middle of the thing. You're the one acting. What needs to happen makes you step back and look at the whole picture. Who's available? Who has the experience? Who needs the experience? What's the timeline? And whose job is it really? The second question is whether the decider starts to show up. Part of what makes this so hard is that doing the work yourself feels good, especially when you're good at it. You've done it a hundred times, you know how it's going to go, and you get that immediate little hit of satisfaction when the report is approved or the scene is cleared or the bad guys in handcuffs. There's certainly that and there's control. Leadership in the moment is often a lot less satisfying. You make a decision and somebody else carries it out. You guide them and then you have the trust that your guidance will be followed, more or less. The way you pictured it. You hand off an assignment and then you spend the afternoon trying not to walk past their desk every twenty minutes. Trust me, I've been that guy. And the officer, the detective, the deputy, they always know, by the way, you're not as subtle as you think you are. Sometimes you also have to sit there and watch somebody solve a problem differently than you would have. And it can drive you nuts. Because often the way they're handling it is not wrong. It's just different. For a lot of high performers, that is genuinely uncomfortable. There's a competence trap buried in here. And it's really the engine that drives the whole go-to trap. The more capable you are, the more people come to you. And the more people come to you, the easier it is to talk yourself into just handling it. Because the reasons all sound pretty reasonable. It'll be faster. You always know what to do. They're struggling, and we don't have time. You can knock it out in 10 minutes flat. And you're probably right. You can probably do it faster. And today, maybe even do it better. The trouble is what happens over months. If you keep taking the work away from your people because you're faster, your people will never get faster. If you grab every hard problem, they never get to practice hard problems. And if you answer every question the second it is asked, they learn that thinking is Critical thinking is optional because the sergeant will just tell them do that long enough and you end up with a team that can't function without you. From the inside, that can feel a lot like strong leadership. I mean, after all, you're needed. Your phone never stops ringing. You're still everybody's go to. But what you've actually built is dependency. Independency has a way of looking like leadership right up until you take a week of leave. I've worked with supervisors who were some of the hardest working people in the building. First in, last out, reviewing every report, fixing every problem, answering every question. From the outside, it looked impressive. And in a lot of ways, let's be honest, it was. But when one of them went on vacation, the whole unit kind of limped along until they got back. And that tells you something. A good leader makes the team better. Better while they're there. A really good one leaves behind a team that can run without them. This is one of the reasons I wrote about this topic in my book, Leader Armor. When I was putting the book together, I kept thinking about new sergeants and the people getting ready to become sergeants. Because that transition catches almost everybody. The skills that got you promoted aren't The same skills that make you successful after you get promoted. And it helps to know that going in rather than discovering it in month three or six months in. So if you're new in the role or heading there, that's one more resource you might find useful. Those were the folks I had in mind when I wrote the book. Your experience doesn't go anywhere, by the way. You just use it differently. Instead of showing up in the report you write, it shows up in the questions you ask about somebody else's report. It shows up in your decisions and the standards you set and in your sense of when to step in and when to stay out. And I want to be careful here because I don't want anybody walking away from this thinking good leaders stand back with their arms folded. And just watch everyone else work. That's not leadership either. That's just a different way of not doing your job. There are absolutely times that you need to step in, and sometimes step in hard. An officer safety issue, an emergency where seconds matter. Something that smells like an ethical problem or maybe even a legal problem. A situation that's beyond somebody's training, experience, or even authority. If a young officer is about to make a decision on a scene that's going to end up in a courtroom or on the evening news for all the wrong reasons, you don't let that play out in the name of professional development. You take it and you debrief it later. The thing I'd ask you to be honest with yourself about is why you're stepping in. Is it because the situation actually calls for the leader? Or is it because doing it yourself is more comfortable than watching someone else wrestle with it? In the moment, those two can feel exactly the same, but they're very different reasons. And with some practice, you can get better at telling which one is driving you. Let me give you the most common version of this I've seen, and I suspect some of you have lived it this week. An officer brings a report to the sergeant. It's complicated. Maybe a burglary with multiple suspects, maybe a domestic with lots of moving parts. The sergeant starts reading it, and by the second paragraph is thinking, this is rough. What does the sergeant, who used to be the squad's go to, want to do? They want to pull a chair over, take the keyboard, and fix it. Ten minutes later it's a solid report. It goes up the chain. Everybody moves on with their night. Except the only thing that got fixed was the report. The officer is exactly the same as they were ten minutes ago. The next complicated report that officer writes is going to have the same problems and it's going to land on your desk again or somebody else's desk after you've moved on. In other words, you've solved today's problem and quietly set up tomorrow's problem. The slower way looks something like this. Have the officer sit down with you. Ask them to walk you through what happened and what they were trying to get across. Show them where the narrative loses the reader or where the elements of the crime aren't clearly supported. Ask what they think needs to be changed. Then hand it back, let them rewrite it, and look at it again when they're done. This could take twenty or thirty minutes instead of ten. And on a busy shift, I get that feels expensive. But when you're done, you don't just have a better report, you have an officer who writes better reports. And that pays you back every week after. What's the saying? Slow is smooth, smooth is fast. Same thing when somebody walks up and says, Sarge, what should I do? The easiest thing in the world is to just tell them. And to be fair, sometimes you should. If it's time sensitive or they're clearly in over their head, give them the answer. But a lot of time it's worth asking them something first. What are you thinking? Or what options have you looked at? Or even just what's bothering you about it? The first couple of times you do this, some officers are going to look at you like you're being difficult on purpose. And you know what? That's fine. What you're doing is building their judgment, problem solving, and decision making capability. And judgment is probably the most important. Important thing we can develop in people coming up behind us. Because at some point that officer, that deputy, is going to be standing on a scene at two in the morning with half the information that they like to have and a bunch of people looking at them to see what they're going to do, and you won't be there. The only question at this point is whether we spend the previous few years teaching them to think or teaching them to call us. You see a version of this on critical incidents too. A barricade, a missing child, whatever it is. A newer supervisor shows up and within a couple of minutes they're on the radio, placing individual units, working the perimeter, maybe even trying to talk to the subject themselves. All of the things that they're very good at. Meanwhile, nobody's thinking about bigger questions, whether we need more resources or Whether the command post is in the right spot, who's notifying the chain of command, and what's the plan if this goes on for hours instead of minutes, maybe even days. The go to instinct pulls you towards the task that you know. The scene needs somebody standing back enough to see the whole thing. And that night that somebody is you. I think this is really where the craft changes when you promote. In this profession, we put a lot of emphasis on technical skills, and rightfully so. Interviewing, investigations, tactics, report writing, all of that matters. And you still need that credibility as a supervisor. Your people need to know you understand the work. And that you've done it. As you move into leadership, what you're really being judged on starts shifting toward things like setting priorities, making decisions with incomplete information, coaching, and deciding where limited people and limited time should go. More and more your job is creating clarity for other people so they can do their jobs well. One strange side effect is that your work gets less visible. As a patrol officer, you could look back at the end of the shift and point to what you did. As a sergeant or maybe even a lieutenant, some nights your most important contribution was one conversation. Or a decision that kept a problem from ever happening, which by definition nobody saw. Or you handed a problem back to the right person. Instead of solving it yourself, they handled it and you got zero credit. Nobody writes a commendation for an incident that didn't occur. It still matters, and honestly, it matters more than most of what you did as an officer. The problem doesn't go away as you move up either. It just changes shape. At every level, you have to loosen your grip on some of what made you successful. At that level before. The sergeant who's still trying to be the best officer on the squad struggles. The lieutenant who's still trying to be the best sergeant struggles. And the captain who's rewriting all the lieutenant's work, well, you've probably worked for that captain. And I'm guessing you have opinions. What you end up with if you're not careful is leaders working one level. Below their actual responsibility. They're busy, they're tired, they're putting in the hours, but they aren't doing the work that only they could and should do. That's a question I wish somebody had asked me earlier. What work can only I do in this role? There's probably plenty of people on your shift who can write that report, handle that call, or at higher levels. Build that PowerPoint. There's usually one person responsible for setting the priorities and making the hard call, having the uncomfortable conversations with the officer whose attitude is dragging the entire squad down. And also deciding where overtime goes. That's your work. The higher you go, the more true that becomes, and the more it costs you when you get it backwards. So what do you actually do about all this? I think it just starts with noticing, catching the moment when you feel yourself reaching for the problem, and when you catch it, run through three questions. They're simple on purpose because you'll need them in the middle of a busy shift, not sitting in a quiet office with a cup of coffee. The first one is this does this actually require me? Notice that's not can I do it? You can. We've established that. The question is whether it needs you specifically, your rank or your authority, your experience, or whether you just happen to be standing closest to it. The second question is who should own this? Sometimes the honest answer is you. A lot of time it's somebody else. And sometimes it's somebody who has never owned anything like this before and needs a chance. The corporal who wants to make sergeant someday might be exactly the right person to run the detail on Saturday. The detective who keeps asking you how to handle a difficult victim's family night might be ready to take the lead on your next meeting. The third question is what does that person need for me to succeed? Maybe it's clear direction, maybe it's resources or the authority to make a call without checking with you first. Goodness forbid. Maybe it's some coaching up front and a check in halfway through. And sometimes, honestly, when what they need from you is for you to get out of the way. You'll notice none of these questions is how fast can I take this over? That was intentional. I I also want to be really clear about something because delegation gets misread a lot. Handing something off is Doesn't mean you stop caring how it turns out. I mean, you're still responsible for the outcome. If the detail on Saturday goes sideways, nobody's going to accept, well, I delegated it. That doesn't work. It doesn't fly. So you set the expectations up front. You check in, you look at the work, and you give feedback. And if and if it's heading somewhere it shouldn't, you step in. You can hand off the work, but the accountability stays with you. Now, some of you listening haven't been promoted yet. Maybe you're studying for the next process, maybe you're still thinking about it. I'd say this is worth working on now before anybody pins anything on your collar or sews some stripes on your sleeves. This is a big part of why I put together the police promotion challenge. I don't think promotion prep. Should just be about passing the test. You have to understand the process, whether there's a written exam or oral board, an assessment center, or whatever your agency has come up with this year. But underneath it all, the process is trying to figure out whether you're ready to think at that next rank. The candidates who do well, and more importantly, the ones who do well afterward. Have usually already started making that shift. They're paying attention to things beyond their assignment. They're helping the newer officers without being asked. They're thinking about how a decision affects the whole shift and not just the call in front of them. Anybody can learn to sound like a sergeant for forty five minutes in front of a panel. What you really want is to be most of the way there already. So that when your name comes out on the list, the job isn't a surprise. Because eventually the testing ends, the list comes out, and if your name's on it, you actually might have to go out there and lead people. That's the real exam. And it doesn't come with an answer key. One more thing before we wrap up, and this is specifically for the go-to people listening. When people hear an episode like this. Sometimes their takeaway is stop working so hard. Or stop being so good at your job. And that's not what I'm saying at all. Your work ethic still matters. Your competence still matters. And your credibility with your people, the fact that they know you can do the job matters a lot. Willingness to jump in when the moment really does call for it. Is something your people will remember for a long time. Those qualities just have to grow a little. Your value as a leader can't rest only on being the best person in the room at the task. Because eventually your people have to get good too. They will get better than you. If you've been doing this a while, you've probably already had somebody work for you. Who got better at some part of this job than you ever were. The first time you notice it, there might be a little flicker of ego. Let that pass. What's underneath it if you've done your job is something a lot closer to pride. If you can develop people who make good decisions without you, solve problems without you, lead other people without you, and someday take your job? That doesn't mean you've become less valuable. That's about the best evidence there is that you're a good leader, that you've actually led. So here's what I'd ask you to try this week. Pay attention to the moment you feel the urge to jump in. You don't have to fight it every time. And some of those times jumping in will be exactly the right call. But before you do, run the three questions. Does this require me? Who should own it? What do they need from me? And if you want a fourth one that chew on, try this. Am I solving the problem or am I developing the person who's going to solve the next 10 problems? You spent years getting good at this job, and none of that goes to waste. But the job changed when the rank did. More and more, your value comes from the decisions you make, the standards you set, the people you develop. And what your team can handle because you were there. For years you were the go to. The work now is becoming the decider. And like I said at the top, most of us get there by doing it wrong a few times first. Thanks for spending some time with me on Blue Leader Nation. If this one hit home, pass it along to somebody who just got promoted, or somebody who's about to. They probably won't admit that they need it. Send it anyway. Keep learning, keep growing, keep leading. I'll see you next time. You've listening to the Blue Leader Nation podcast. Our passion is anyone within the thin blue line who wanna take it to the next level. We hope you didn't mind the dad jokes, by the way. If you enjoyed the show, make sure to like, rate, and review. And we'll be back soon. But in the meantime, hit the website at www.blueleadernation.com.