Latest / CLEs You Actually Want to Hear / Trial Tutorials: Persuasive Storytelling
Transcript
- 0:03And welcome to another installment of our trial
- 0:06tutorial series. This program is on persuasive
- 0:09storytelling. I'm Allapoli Castro, Director of
- 0:13Education and Professional Development at Beverly
- 0:15Hills Bar Association, and I am absolutely delighted
- 0:17to welcome back our speakers for this program,
- 0:20Elizabeth Hernandez and Scott Glowski. Scott
- 0:23is an award -winning trial attorney and founder
- 0:26of the law offices of Scott Glowski. His practice
- 0:29focuses on taking on health insurance companies
- 0:31in the face of coverage denial. Scott has represented
- 0:34individuals and large classes of plaintiffs in
- 0:37his pursuit for justice. Among other honors,
- 0:40which are too numerous to name here, Scott is
- 0:42the recipient of the California Lawyers Magazine
- 0:45California Attorney of the Year Award and the
- 0:48Consumer Attorneys of California Street Fighter
- 0:51of the Year Award. He is also a faculty member
- 0:54at Trial Lawyers College where he teaches lawyers
- 0:56from around the country how to successfully try
- 0:58cases. Elizabeth is an attorney with BD &J PC.
- 1:03She handles the most complex and life -altering
- 1:06cases. For years, Elizabeth has served clients
- 1:09across Southern California as they navigate the
- 1:12complicated world of catastrophic personal injuries
- 1:15and wrongful death. Elizabeth's outstanding outcomes
- 1:18for her clients have earned her numerous industry
- 1:21accolades, including recognition by her peers
- 1:23as best lawyer in America in the personal injury
- 1:26litigation practice area, a place on the Daily
- 1:29Journal's top women lawyers, and as the 2025
- 1:33Mexican -American Bar Foundation's Professional
- 1:36Achievement Award recipient. Elizabeth holds
- 1:39memberships and leadership positions on numerous
- 1:41professional organizations and is currently the
- 1:44president -elect of CALA. We can't wait to hear
- 1:47what they have to share with us today. So I'm
- 1:48going to turn it over to them. Good afternoon,
- 1:52everyone. And thank you for being here. We really
- 1:55appreciate it. Scott, I'll let you say hello
- 1:58to everybody. Hello, everybody. Thanks for joining
- 2:01us. We're happy to be here, and hopefully we
- 2:03can share some ideas. And feel free, if you have
- 2:07questions after the program, even to reach out
- 2:10to us any time, we're happy to jump on the phone
- 2:12and see how we can help. And we just want to
- 2:17give you an overview of what we're going to cover.
- 2:19So this is kind of a part two of our storytelling.
- 2:23And we are going to get into some specific examples,
- 2:27including on vadayar, jury selection, and also
- 2:31with opening statements. But what's most important
- 2:34at any part of the trial and any part of the
- 2:36case is really discovering the story. And we're
- 2:40going to be talking about that some more in -depth
- 2:42and give some examples. And we would like to
- 2:46share some information, so hopefully this will
- 2:48help you all tell your client's story. So all
- 2:52of us as attorneys, whether we're trial attorneys,
- 2:55litigators, or whatever type of attorney, we
- 2:58represent clients, so we get the privilege of
- 3:00telling our clients' stories. We are all storytellers.
- 3:04So it's important to note that the majority of
- 3:09our clients I've never been through anything
- 3:11like this before. I primarily handle catastrophic
- 3:15injury cases. So you're dealing with folks who
- 3:20have life altering injuries that not only affects
- 3:24themselves, but also their family and their loved
- 3:27ones. A lot of times it may be hard to get information
- 3:32out of them. because some of them are living
- 3:36and dealing with pain on a daily basis or significant
- 3:40loss, and it's not something that it's easy to
- 3:43talk about. So part of trying to bring out the
- 3:47client story, whether it's at mediation or working
- 3:50up the case, and especially at trial, is really
- 3:53trying to build that connection with the client
- 3:55and even others, family members, friends, coworkers,
- 4:01colleagues, what have you, to try and put that
- 4:04story together to make it as most effective as
- 4:07possible. Scott, I don't know if you want to
- 4:10share anything. Yeah, no, I just want to reiterate.
- 4:13I mean, trial lawyering is about connections,
- 4:18connections with our clients, connections with
- 4:20the jury, connections with judges. And the way
- 4:23we connect with people is through our emotions,
- 4:27through our feelings, and through stories. So
- 4:30a lot of what you're gonna hear us talk about
- 4:32today is discovering the story for your trial,
- 4:36what's gonna resonate with the jury. And I'm
- 4:40distinguishing the facts from the story because
- 4:43stories are what drive verdicts, stories with
- 4:46emotional connections, not facts. So what we
- 4:52first wanna talk about is how we would... look
- 4:55at the fact pattern that's been presented. I
- 4:57believe most of you, if not all of you received
- 4:59the fact pattern with some materials. I will
- 5:03share some portion of the materials that were
- 5:06provided. We didn't provide slides just because
- 5:10it was about spending a lot of time in providing
- 5:14some detailed information in the materials to
- 5:18share with everybody. If you're not familiar
- 5:21with the fact pattern, this involved a married
- 5:24couple who went on a vacation on a cruise. And
- 5:28during the cruise, the husband decided voluntarily
- 5:31to get involved in one of the contests that were
- 5:35being held by the cruise ship for a belly flop
- 5:38contest. And during that contest, he dove in
- 5:43head first. into one of the pools that was on
- 5:46the cruise ship. It happened to be four feet
- 5:49deep throughout the pool, and he dove in head
- 5:52first, hit his head, and sustained some serious
- 5:55injuries, including head injuries, neck injuries,
- 5:59cervical spine, and back. So that's a gist, and
- 6:03his wife was there and present at the time. I
- 6:06don't know if you want to add anything about
- 6:07the fact, Scott. No, that's good. Okay. So in
- 6:12first looking at the facts and going through,
- 6:15there's a lot of information there that whether
- 6:19you're on the plaintiff's side or the defense
- 6:21side, because it is a civil litigation case that
- 6:24we're dealing with. So it's not a criminal case.
- 6:27And so it's basically piecing things together
- 6:30to start putting together the story and something
- 6:34that we both like to do separately on our cases.
- 6:39is consider the themes, look at obviously the
- 6:44liability and what facts there are that we know
- 6:47of so far. And it's basically getting more facts
- 6:51to add to the story or bringing out the facts
- 6:55to help us tell the story, but also looking at
- 6:57what should we be concerned with, what we often
- 7:01refer to as danger points. So. we wanted to cover
- 7:06that first and go through how we would look at
- 7:09this fact pattern and pulling out that information.
- 7:13This is all a process of putting together the
- 7:15story. And then in terms of just taking the voir
- 7:20dire, how we would approach in the voir dire,
- 7:24what issues we would want to bring up specifically
- 7:28to prospective members of the jury. to find out
- 7:32what their beliefs are, if there's any biases,
- 7:35and give specific examples of questions, also
- 7:41in terms of framing certain issues and reframing.
- 7:46So with that in mind, what I'll go ahead and
- 7:49do is I'm just going to share some of the materials
- 7:52that were sent. We're not going to go through
- 7:55all of the materials, but just a portion. So
- 7:58in the beginning here, there's some potential
- 8:02liability themes. We put it up the front. It
- 8:05doesn't mean you're gonna know your themes in
- 8:07the very beginning. That takes some work in exploring
- 8:10what the facts are, gathering as many facts as
- 8:13possible, seeing what evidence you have. But
- 8:15for this particular case, the fact pattern that
- 8:18was provided to us, some liability themes we
- 8:22would want to know in terms of negligence of
- 8:26the cruise ship and the directors, its employees.
- 8:30assumption of the risk or comparative fault in
- 8:34with respect to our client Nathan the husband
- 8:38and also we want to know about the scene what
- 8:43was there who was there at the pool what was
- 8:47there were there any signs anything about no
- 8:50diving especially headfirst so that's some of
- 8:53the issues and then since we're dealing with
- 8:57a cruise ship line and a company, corporate responsibility
- 9:02is often a big theme in these cases and in terms
- 9:06of catastrophic injury cases. So the cruise line
- 9:11is vacations by the sea. You know, was there
- 9:14any training of their staff on safety issues?
- 9:18Was there anything that the staff did on that
- 9:21day or the higher ups of vacations by the sea
- 9:26to prohibit belly flop contests or to make sure
- 9:34that any contestants will be safe? Was there
- 9:37any type of failure to supervise? And so those
- 9:41are some just general themes. Scott, you want
- 9:45to add anything to that? No. Okay. So then in
- 9:49terms of danger points, the goal is we want to
- 9:52identify them and for some of the danger points
- 9:56that pertain to the plaintiff side, we want to
- 9:59reframe those danger points. So some just overall
- 10:03danger points that we may look at when we go
- 10:06through this fact pattern is one, are there any
- 10:09kind of common sense biases? For example, again,
- 10:13this is a big issue. The pool was only four feet
- 10:16deep. Isn't that obvious to anybody? even say
- 10:20without signs, even without some type of warning,
- 10:23isn't it obvious that no one should dive in head
- 10:26first? That's something we would have to, that's
- 10:30a possible significant danger point. Again, the
- 10:36potential or prospective jurors may be thinking,
- 10:39well, didn't Nathan know better? He's an adult.
- 10:41How would he not know you shouldn't be diving
- 10:43in head first? We learned that as a kid, right?
- 10:46Why would you do that as an adult? There's also
- 10:49another issue in terms of the fact pattern where
- 10:54it does talk about he went after this incident
- 10:59happened while on the cruise ship. He was escorted
- 11:04to the infirmary where a general practitioner
- 11:07doctor did some type of evaluation. There's question
- 11:11marks as to the extent of the evaluation. But
- 11:15the next day, the cruise was over and he then
- 11:19waited a week before getting any medical treatment.
- 11:24But during that week before he received medical
- 11:28treatment, he had already retained a lawyer.
- 11:31So those are definitely red flags. You can call
- 11:34them red flags, danger points, however you want
- 11:36to phrase it. But those are some things that
- 11:38we have to look at. So just a general overview.
- 11:42If you're the plaintiff representing the plaintiff,
- 11:45and these red flags or danger points come up,
- 11:48one thing you want to do to try and reframe is,
- 11:52for example, the pool being four feet deep. Now,
- 11:57we know that in some pools, in one side of the
- 12:01pool, it could be the shallow end, so you have
- 12:04the pools four feet deep. But on the other side,
- 12:07it could be that it's much deeper. That wasn't
- 12:10the case in our fact pattern. The fact pattern
- 12:12said the pool that was used was four feet deep
- 12:16throughout. Now, you also need to know that on
- 12:20this cruise ship, obviously, there's not just
- 12:23one pool for everybody to use. There were other
- 12:26pools on this cruise ship. So why the organizers
- 12:31decided to use this particular one when it's
- 12:34only four feet deep? That's also something to
- 12:37consider. But in terms of rephrasing this particular
- 12:40danger point or red flag, a way to do that is
- 12:44emphasize that the passengers are guests on the
- 12:48ship. They're paid guests. They rely on the crew
- 12:51staff who's putting on these programs. They rely
- 12:55on them to make sure that they're going to be
- 12:57safe. No one is voluntarily going to do something.
- 13:01that where they're going to injure themselves
- 13:03significantly. That's the other way, that's one
- 13:06way to kind of rephrase it. And comparative fault
- 13:11themes, this is what also needs to be explored
- 13:14in discovering the story. Was Nathan impulsive?
- 13:19Was he just being impulsive? Did he think this
- 13:21through? Had he been drinking alcohol? Was he
- 13:26impaired in any way? Or even if he wasn't drinking
- 13:29alcohol, what about medication? Was he taking
- 13:32any medication that made him groggy? On cruise
- 13:36ships, people on vacation primarily, they're
- 13:39having a good time. Some people are out partying
- 13:42until late. Was Nathan sleep deprived where he
- 13:45wasn't completely focused? Also in terms of...
- 13:49his build, was he physically fit to even be doing
- 13:52this type of contest? So those are some things
- 13:56to look at. But there's a list here that's providing
- 13:59the materials of comprehensive danger points
- 14:02or red flags. And there's going to be plaintiff
- 14:08can put together their red flags or danger points
- 14:12and defense can put together theirs. But some
- 14:14you can see, one we talked about is the pull
- 14:17depth, four feet. Second, he dove in head first.
- 14:21Three, we'd want to know there was no lifeguard
- 14:24present. What about medical staff? We know a
- 14:27lot of times when there's some type of contest
- 14:30or competition or even race, you sign up for
- 14:32a 5K run. There's usually some type of medical
- 14:35staff present. The facts didn't indicate whether
- 14:37there was a medical staff present. So these are
- 14:40all danger points. You want to gather this information
- 14:42and this is going to help when you speak with
- 14:44your client. Again, the danger points that you
- 14:48gather, whether you're on the defense side or
- 14:51the plaintiff side, you want to gather all of
- 14:53these and these are things that you want to talk
- 14:56about in discovering the story with your client.
- 15:00Questions about whether a waiver was signed,
- 15:02that comes up. You can see there's a number of
- 15:05them that I put here. Also, there was an issue
- 15:09with when Nathan went to the doctor. a week after
- 15:14he disembarked from the ship, that it was doctors
- 15:18that his attorneys sent him to. So that's definitely
- 15:22a red flag or a danger point that needs to be
- 15:24addressed by the plaintiff's side. So in looking
- 15:29at again, the pool depth of four feet. As we
- 15:33mentioned, the defense is gonna frame it as an
- 15:36obvious risk, it's shallow water. The plaintiff
- 15:38will reframe it that contestants rely on the
- 15:43staff to ensure safety, okay? That's one thing.
- 15:47Lifeguard, no lifeguard or medical staff present,
- 15:50the defense may frame that as it wasn't a dangerous
- 15:53event, so there was no need to have them there.
- 15:56Whereas the plaintiff, may reframe that issue.
- 16:00The crew staff hosted a physical contest. Medical
- 16:04standby should have been required. Again, you're
- 16:07putting that responsibility on the cruise ship.
- 16:11I want to pause there to see, Scott, if you have
- 16:14anything that you wanted to add regarding the
- 16:16danger points of the red flags. Sure. Yeah, let's
- 16:19let me step back a little moment just to talk
- 16:21about this concept of danger points and jury
- 16:24selection. Our You know, our goal in jury selection
- 16:28is twofold. One is to find out as much as we
- 16:34can about the jurors and how they're going to
- 16:36feel about the issues in our case. And two is
- 16:39the connection, the connection between ourselves
- 16:43as the lawyer and the juror so we can have credibility
- 16:48and build credibility and essentially develop
- 16:51the credibility so that we can be building a
- 16:53tribe with the jury where we're the leader of
- 16:55the tribe. And so when we talk about danger points,
- 16:59to me, what that involves is looking at the issues
- 17:03in the case that bother us. Like here, for example,
- 17:06as Liz was talking about, one of the first things
- 17:08is that there are signs that say no diving and
- 17:12signs that say that's four feet deep. So by being
- 17:17open and honest about our feelings about the
- 17:20danger points with the jury and voir dire, we
- 17:23can open up a dialogue. where we're not trying
- 17:26to convince them or persuade them. We're being
- 17:31open and honest about an issue that we want to
- 17:34know about, that we're concerned about, which
- 17:37invites the jurors to open up and be honest and
- 17:40say how they feel about it. For example, I might
- 17:44say in a case like this, look, what you'll learn
- 17:49later on when the evidence is shown is you'll
- 17:52learn that there was signs that said no diving
- 17:55and signs that said four feet is the depth of
- 17:58the pool. When I look at that, part of me thinks
- 18:02that, well, if there are signs that say no diving
- 18:06and it's only four feet deep, why did Nathan
- 18:12jump into the pool? How do you feel about that?
- 18:17and sort of open it up to the jurors so that
- 18:19we can start a dialogue with the jurors. We're
- 18:22having a real conversation about a real issue
- 18:24in the case so that we can find out if some people
- 18:27are going to be like, yeah, you know, I think,
- 18:30you know, I believe in personal responsibility
- 18:32and no one would ever, you know, no one should
- 18:34ever jump in a pool with signs like that. Of
- 18:37course, remember, this is jury selection. And
- 18:40when it comes to opening statement is when we
- 18:42would sort of present the facts. in a way that's
- 18:45going to win the case for us. But in jury selection,
- 18:48we're trying to foster this open communication
- 18:51to where the jurors feel safe to share how they
- 18:54feel about things so we can see who they are.
- 18:56And the more we can see who they are, the more
- 18:59we can see if they're jurors that we want on
- 19:00the case. That Liz? Yes. And those are all great
- 19:06points. And in terms of jury selection, a lot
- 19:10we want to get the jury to talk. And so it's
- 19:14open -ended questions, really. But we give some
- 19:17specific examples just to kind of get to the
- 19:21point here. So for example, the voir dire or
- 19:24jury selection themes that we may want to approach
- 19:27with the jury and question them about is trust.
- 19:31How do they feel about, you know, their trust
- 19:32in authority, their belief in the crew staff's
- 19:36responsibility, expectations of safety and organized
- 19:39activities. you know, finding out if some folks
- 19:41have participated in organized activities, marathons,
- 19:45half marathons, those types of things. Another
- 19:48thing that we want to question the jury about
- 19:50would be personal responsibility versus institutional
- 19:54duty. You know, attitudes towards personal risk
- 19:59taking is something when you go on vacation and
- 20:01you know that you're on a cruise ship and you
- 20:04have people who are paid and hopefully trained.
- 20:07to put on organized events that you want to know
- 20:11that you're going to be safe in doing it. So
- 20:14why not go and enjoy? Does it mean you're taking
- 20:17the risk that you may have a cervical spine injury
- 20:22as a result? No. Also a big issue is we want
- 20:26to know about, from prospective jurors, their
- 20:29views on corporate accountability. Then in terms
- 20:32of the medical issue with him getting sent to
- 20:36doctors by his attorneys, him retaining an attorney
- 20:39before even getting medical treatment. There's
- 20:43also some facts that show that even though he
- 20:47did have to take some time off, he was able to
- 20:52return to work. When he returned to work, he
- 20:55returned to work in the same position, making
- 20:57the same money. you're really limited in terms
- 21:01of loss of future earnings. You don't know if
- 21:05there's going to be any. And so is this primarily
- 21:08a non -economic damages or general damages case
- 21:13in addition to the medical care and treatment?
- 21:16So we want to know about any medical biases,
- 21:20skepticism that potential jurors have toward
- 21:23injury claims, opinions. We definitely want to
- 21:27know opinions on attorney -referred care. So
- 21:31here's kind of a little bit of a checklist that
- 21:35we provided facts to elicit to get some information
- 21:38out of jurors. And then in terms of specific
- 21:41questions, I just will scroll down to that. So
- 21:44let me, for example, trust and authority and
- 21:47safety expectations. What is our goal with that
- 21:51with respect to jury selection? We want to identify
- 21:55jurors who expect safety from crew staff and
- 21:58organize activities. So some questions to start
- 22:01things off. in terms of picking a jury is have
- 22:05you ever participated in a cruise or resort activity
- 22:08where you assumed organizers had insured it was
- 22:12safe? Do you believe people should be able to
- 22:15rely on staff to explain safety rules clearly?
- 22:18How do you feel about companies hosting contests
- 22:21or games in environments like pools or gyms?
- 22:23You open it up at first, and then you want people
- 22:26to talk. And once they do talk, give their input
- 22:29opinions. You thank them for it. If it's something
- 22:33that you know they're defense oriented, still
- 22:36thank them. And then find out, does anyone else
- 22:39feel the same way? And then if it's quiet, welcome
- 22:43the silence. Someone will speak up. but then
- 22:46you can also ask Mr. Smith or prospective juror
- 22:49number one, how do you feel about that? And those
- 22:52open -ended questions will allow you to get people
- 22:55to open up and then you'll start to see that
- 22:57people are either agreeing or disagreeing and
- 23:00that helps a lot. In terms of the... Common sense
- 23:07versus institutional responsibility. Another
- 23:09theme, the goal is to reframe, he should have
- 23:13known better into they should have protected
- 23:16him. So some questions, do you think people should
- 23:19be protected even when they make impulsive decisions?
- 23:23Do you believe warning should be given even for
- 23:26things that seem obvious? And in terms of the
- 23:29medical treatment or the delays, The goal, again,
- 23:34is to address skepticism about delayed care,
- 23:37attorney referred doctors, and conservative treatment.
- 23:42In the facts, it says that one of the doctors
- 23:44he treated with had recommended that he have
- 23:47surgery. But Nathan decided for some conservative
- 23:51treatment. such as injections and also physical
- 23:55therapy. Some questions that you may want to
- 23:59address or topics when picking a jury is, have
- 24:03you or someone close to you ever delayed seeking
- 24:06medical care because you weren't sure how serious
- 24:08the injury was? How do you feel about people
- 24:11seeing doctors recommended by their attorney?
- 24:14Then we also have with their personal responsibility
- 24:17and risk -taking. And there's more that's put
- 24:20in the materials, but I want to give Scott the
- 24:22opportunity to give some input on this Yeah,
- 24:25I just want to add you know the idea that You
- 24:29know many books have been written about communication
- 24:31and the key to communication is Listening so
- 24:36that when we're picking a jury You know, it's
- 24:42more important my friend Joshua Carton who's
- 24:44a phenomenal phenomenal communications expert
- 24:47who Elizabeth knows and has been teaching lawyers,
- 24:50our colleagues for many, many years, talks about
- 24:53the urgency, the need to connect with the listener.
- 24:59We're separate and more important than the content
- 25:02of what we're saying is active listening with
- 25:06the potential jurors, the people that we're talking
- 25:09to. Many lawyers, myself included, We get nervous.
- 25:14We're standing up in front of a jury thinking
- 25:16about our next question. And it's so easy to
- 25:18ask a question and get an answer and then just
- 25:21want to move on to the next question and think
- 25:23in your head about what am I going to ask next?
- 25:25But I would urge everybody to read about active
- 25:29listening, because if we want to connect with
- 25:32jurors, having experience in tuning in to what
- 25:36the jurors are feeling, making strong eye contact
- 25:39and really listening until you get their response
- 25:45and then when you get their response honoring
- 25:47their response so they understand they can feel
- 25:50that you listen to them and that you hear them
- 25:52and there's training in psychodrama which is
- 25:54one form of active listening but but I just want
- 25:57to emphasize that point that communication is
- 25:59about is always about the listener so regardless
- 26:03of our content it's more important I believe
- 26:08for us to make that connection so that we're
- 26:11trusted and credible because we care. And that's
- 26:16a great point that I can't over emphasize. It's
- 26:19so important. So as attorneys, when we're talking,
- 26:23whether in the office or we go attend events
- 26:26or at mixers, we're talking about a lot of different
- 26:30things. And it's very common that we are talking
- 26:33over each other, not trying to be rude, but it
- 26:36just happens. Now, when you're picking a jury,
- 26:40you are going to have an outline. You're not
- 26:42going to have questions word for word because
- 26:44you don't know how the prospective jurors are
- 26:47going to answer. So that's where Scott is saying
- 26:50the listening is so important. You know in your
- 26:52mind what key topics you want to be able to cover.
- 26:56So you're already going to have that down. What
- 26:59you want to know is what the jurors, prospective
- 27:03jurors feel. And in order to know that, you really
- 27:07have to listen to not only how they physically
- 27:10are appearing, if they become rigid or tense
- 27:13up with a question or an answering, their tone,
- 27:17and especially what they're saying. That is so
- 27:20important to be able to really, really listen
- 27:24and take in what they're saying, not just follow
- 27:26an outline and say, okay, thanks, next question.
- 27:29No, you wanna... really be able to take that
- 27:32in. Let me add real quick that this is a talk
- 27:40about persuasion. We are never going to change
- 27:44who a juror is in a million years. Their beliefs,
- 27:48their perspectives on the world, the way we persuade
- 27:52in jury selection is by letting them talk and
- 27:58listening. Because if we can find out who they
- 28:01are, they're either going to decide our case
- 28:05or not, depending on what we learn from them.
- 28:07And so many lawyers I know strongly believe,
- 28:10I agree, that the way we persuade is by listening
- 28:14to who they are and having them on the jury or
- 28:17not having them on the jury so that the actual
- 28:19jurors that hear our case are open to hearing
- 28:22the case. And we want to wrap up just this portion,
- 28:28but let me just share another screenshot. And
- 28:33again, it's in the materials, but there's a chart
- 28:36that's been put together about reframing these
- 28:39danger points or red flags, plaintiff versus
- 28:41defense. So some of the key issues is, for example,
- 28:45Attorney referred doctors. How would the defense
- 28:49frame that? He only saw doctors after hiring
- 28:51a lawyer. Isn't that a little suspicious? Well,
- 28:55the plaintiff will want to reframe that and use
- 28:57a different strategy that Nathan sought help
- 29:01when symptoms worsened. Attorney referrals are
- 29:04common when insurance or access is limited. So
- 29:08if he didn't have access to doctors or didn't
- 29:10know where to go and he wants to get proper care,
- 29:14then It's common for attorneys to help. That's
- 29:17a way to rephrase it. No emergency treatment
- 29:21sought immediately. He waited a week, but in
- 29:23that week, he first hired an attorney. Defense
- 29:26is going to frame that. He didn't seek medical
- 29:28help right away. So how serious could his injury
- 29:31be? He wasn't really that injured. And the plaintiff
- 29:34will reframe that and use a strategy that, well,
- 29:37Nathan was confused. He hit his head. He was
- 29:39groggy. He relied on the ship staff. you know,
- 29:43to tell him if he had a serious injury, which
- 29:46they didn't tell him that. They allowed him to
- 29:50stay on the ship overnight and then get off the
- 29:53next day. They didn't call a specialist. They
- 29:56didn't fly him out someplace. They basically
- 29:59said, you know, take some Advil would have you
- 30:02something minor and rest up. Also, the delay
- 30:06was due to a lack of onboard care and unclear
- 30:09symptoms. They didn't do the diagnostic testing.
- 30:12They weren't equipped to do it. So that's a way
- 30:15that you can also reframe it and that's all in
- 30:18the materials as well. But turning now to more
- 30:23on discovering the story. What we've talked about
- 30:26already is discovering the story, but now we're
- 30:30dealing with your client specifically. You've
- 30:33gathered these danger points and red flags. You're
- 30:35going to be talking to your client, but it's
- 30:38how to really bring out the story from the client.
- 30:44Something to keep in mind is, depending on who
- 30:47the client is, we also need to be mindful of
- 30:50what is the client's age. Is it someone who identifies
- 30:56as a man, someone who identifies as a woman?
- 30:58Also, what is the cultural background of somebody?
- 31:02I know in my family, I'm Mexican -American. So
- 31:07if my dad, who is very much proud, you know,
- 31:11the image of being the machismo. If he was injured,
- 31:17he wouldn't show it because you don't show pain.
- 31:21Showing pain is a sign of weakness, how he especially
- 31:24was brought up. And that's common in certain
- 31:28cultures. So you want to be mindful of who your
- 31:30client is to try and start basing that connection
- 31:35and building that trust. Scott, did you want
- 31:39to? Yeah, no, that's great. Okay, so when we
- 31:45want to get information from our client, a lot
- 31:48of times we will have, some will call the client
- 31:51up and have the client come to the office. That
- 31:56perhaps works. Everyone is very different, but
- 32:00again, it's building that connection with the
- 32:03client. As I mentioned in the beginning, most
- 32:06of our clients, it's the first time they've been
- 32:08involved in anything like this, this type of
- 32:10litigation, and they have serious injuries that
- 32:14have changed their lives. So coming into an attorney's
- 32:17office, they may not feel 100 % comfortable,
- 32:20but they'll do it because their attorney wants
- 32:23to meet with them. Sometimes it's good to think
- 32:27about figuring out where is the space where the
- 32:32client feels the most comfortable. And sometimes
- 32:34that could be in their home. Sometimes it could
- 32:37be at a relative's home. Whatever that may be,
- 32:41it is helpful in discovering the story to actually
- 32:45take the time to go out to the client's home
- 32:49and to meet with the client. to even meet with
- 32:53family members that the client may be living
- 32:55with, and you'll find out that they will be very
- 33:00comfortable or a lot more comfortable than in
- 33:03an attorney's office and be willing to open up.
- 33:05Plus, there are things that we as attorneys are
- 33:08looking for that we know would help to basically
- 33:12help us tell the story and put together a strong
- 33:17case. The clients don't know that. Oftentimes
- 33:20clients may think, oh, these pictures aren't.
- 33:24they're not relevant or the attorney doesn't
- 33:26even know about all of these things. And if you
- 33:29go to a client's home, you not only see pictures
- 33:33on the wall, you might see memorabilia, you might
- 33:36see some photographs they have in a photo album
- 33:40or on a computer. They may tell you about videos.
- 33:43There's a number of things that you may see and
- 33:46they're willing to open up and talk to you about.
- 33:49So that's one way to discover the story. The
- 33:52other way is to have the client sit there and
- 33:57even if it's somebody who is not comfortable
- 33:59kind of you sitting on the couch and them sitting
- 34:02on a chair kind of face to face but not right
- 34:04in front of each other perhaps it's something
- 34:07that you know if they don't feel comfortable
- 34:10facing you you can have them sit in a chair with
- 34:13their back towards you and start asking them
- 34:16questions however they're going to feel comfortable
- 34:18but One thing to do in discovering the story
- 34:21is to take them back to that day. As hard as
- 34:25it is, they're going to have to talk about it
- 34:27during their deposition that you have to prepare
- 34:30them for, and they're going to have to talk about
- 34:32it at trial in front of a bunch of strangers
- 34:35who are going to determine the outcome of their
- 34:39case and their trial. Just meeting with the client
- 34:43at first and sitting down and discovering the
- 34:47story that way and to get them to go back to
- 34:50that day as painful as it may be. You have to
- 34:53be very delicate and sensitive, but just have
- 34:56them work with you. I want to take you back to
- 34:59that day. And then we can do a little role playing
- 35:03here too. Scott's going to play the role of Nathan.
- 35:07So, Nathan, I know that how difficult this may
- 35:11be, but to help us really understand what you
- 35:16went through and be able to explain it to a jury
- 35:20when we go to trial, I want to talk about it
- 35:23now. And we can take breaks, but I want you to,
- 35:29in your mind, go back to that day when you're
- 35:32on vacation with your wife, okay? Okay, and tell
- 35:36me when you're ready Okay, all right and let's
- 35:41go to the point of when you were heading over
- 35:44to the pool before you decided to to join the
- 35:49contest take us back and Tell us What you were
- 35:55how you were feeling that day? Yeah, I'm sitting
- 35:58on The deck chair which is It has these white
- 36:05rubber strips and it's white with white strips
- 36:10and blue strips. And I'm on the deck chair. It's
- 36:14a beautiful sunny day. I can feel the sun on
- 36:19my hands and on my legs. I can feel a little
- 36:23bit of the breeze that's coming, a little bit
- 36:27of a cool breeze that's coming and going. And
- 36:29I can look in front of me and I'm in front of
- 36:32my deck chair. I'm right at the pool. And the
- 36:35pool's right in front of me. When I look in front
- 36:37of me, I see the pool's this beautiful blue water
- 36:42with the pool sort of in a rectangular shape.
- 36:45And right in front of me, it's about, the pool
- 36:46starts like about five feet in front of me and
- 36:49it's probably 30, 30 feet long and about 20 feet
- 36:56width -wise. And I've got, on my right, I've
- 36:58got All the other deck chairs that are lined
- 37:01up with people lying in the deck chairs and I
- 37:04look over to the left I see that the railing
- 37:07of the ship and beyond that just the beautiful
- 37:10blue ocean and I can smell the the fried food
- 37:16like the the Chicken strips from the guy next
- 37:24to me is eating chicken strips and french fries
- 37:26and I can hear lots of people talking. Then this
- 37:31guy is standing at the corner of the pool with
- 37:35his uniform on. He obviously works for the company
- 37:40and he's telling us about the pool. He's trying
- 37:46to get everybody in to come join the belly flop
- 37:49contest. We'll pause there for a second. The
- 37:55ultimate goal is to want to get as much detail
- 37:58and information as you can from the client. We
- 38:02know that the clients, you may have some clients
- 38:06who are talkative and somehow you're trying to
- 38:09really pull the information out of them. This
- 38:13is a process. You may not get a client like Scott
- 38:17right now who is going to be that detailed at
- 38:19first. you take it in bits and pieces to try
- 38:23and bring out as much detailed information as
- 38:26possible. Before you get to, you're setting the
- 38:29scene, setting what your client saw at the time,
- 38:33how he was feeling, what he observed, all of
- 38:37the senses so that you can bring that to life
- 38:41as to what he was going through and how he was
- 38:44feeling at the time. Do you want to add to that,
- 38:46Scott? No, I'm feeling great. I mean, my wife's
- 38:48next to me. We're celebrating her birthday. You
- 38:52know, I'm drinking my 7 -Up and relaxing. It's
- 38:57so nice to be here on vacation in this, you know,
- 39:01beautiful place. And then this guy, this guy
- 39:04who kind of reverse roles with the activities
- 39:09director. Yes, and... And for the audience, this
- 39:13is something you can do. If you want him to play
- 39:17the role of someone else who was there, or perhaps
- 39:22the defendant, you can have him, your client
- 39:25do that as well. So Scott's showing you different
- 39:29roles that you can have the client play. One
- 39:31is the client going back to that day, what he
- 39:34observed, how he felt, the senses. And the other
- 39:37is OK, now I want to be in the role of this director,
- 39:43the cruise ship director. So go ahead, Scott.
- 39:45Yeah. Come on, everybody. It's time for the belly
- 39:47flop contest. Come on. Come on. This is great.
- 39:51We do this every cruise. And for the winner is
- 39:55going to get a gift certificate for the bar.
- 39:59So come on. Don't just sit there. Come on. Let's
- 40:02do this. Let's do this. Whoever can do the best
- 40:05belly flop and, you know, we belly flop. We're
- 40:07going to. We're all going to just jump in one
- 40:10by one. We're going to get in line and do this.
- 40:13Come on, sir. Don't lie down just on that. Don't
- 40:16relax. Come on, have some fun. You're on vacation.
- 40:18This is a fun day. It's a fun cruise. Come on.
- 40:23So this is a good example of when you're talking
- 40:27with someone, whether it's a client or a family
- 40:29member and someone is telling you about, you
- 40:31know, their their day at a football game or Disneyland
- 40:36or what have you, they may say, oh yeah, this
- 40:39person told me A, B, and C. But it's one thing
- 40:43that they're telling you what the person said
- 40:46and it's another for you to actually see how
- 40:49this person was coming across. So this also helps
- 40:52to tell the story because you could have your
- 40:55client. mimic what he saw, how this cruise ship
- 41:01director was acting with his expressions, with
- 41:04his voice, his inflection with his hands, to
- 41:08give you a better understanding of what your
- 41:11client observed and why your client, that led
- 41:15your client to make the decision to enter this
- 41:18contest. Do you want to add anything Scott? Well,
- 41:20I can give a soliloquy in my role as Nathan that
- 41:24the more positive reviews I get, from the customers,
- 41:30the better I'm going to do, I can potentially
- 41:34get a bonus. I can potentially get a promotion.
- 41:38So I need to make sure all of these people have
- 41:41as much fun as possible because that's going
- 41:43to help me in my work for the ship. So I've got
- 41:48to make sure I get these people up and moving
- 41:50because if they're involved in the activities,
- 41:52they're going to have fun and I'm going to get
- 41:53better reviews and I can make more money. And
- 41:56that helps with one of the themes, the corporate
- 41:58responsibility versus assumption of the risk
- 42:02with there's some type of reward that this employee
- 42:07from the cruise ship who's putting on the event,
- 42:09it's not about safety. And there's some information
- 42:14in the facts also that says that his supervisor
- 42:18specifically told him no more belly flop contests,
- 42:21but the cruise ship director still did that.
- 42:25Part of this version is his motivation or incentive
- 42:30was not about safety. It was about money. He
- 42:34wanted to get the bonus. He wanted to make extra
- 42:37money. So was he really thinking about Nathan's
- 42:40safety and the safety of the other passengers?
- 42:44That's not what the motivation was. So it also
- 42:47helps to get into the mind of the defendant and
- 42:50the different actors who were there and the different
- 42:54individuals who were there. Okay then so we want
- 42:59to get to the part about the belly flop and then
- 43:02obviously because of the injury and the extent
- 43:07of the injuries and Nathan going on this cruise
- 43:10for fun the vacation with his wife you know he
- 43:15thought he would he would be safe because they
- 43:17are They are telling them, come on. We've got
- 43:20your back. We have you. Come on and do this contest.
- 43:24It's going to be fun. Well, you think if you
- 43:27do something and you put your safety in someone's
- 43:31hands, there's some type of feeling of betrayal
- 43:34when you are injured. It's like, whoa, they weren't
- 43:37really looking after my safety or my well -being.
- 43:39They were looking just to make money. So we want
- 43:43to explore that also. So why don't we continue
- 43:46in your role as Nathan about what happened during
- 43:50the time of the incident and then talking about
- 43:53the betrayal? So, yeah, so I, you know, I didn't
- 43:58really want to get up and jump in the pool, but
- 44:03this guy is right in front of me telling me I
- 44:06got to get up and do it. I should do it. It's
- 44:08fun. And I don't, you know, I'm I'm sort of a
- 44:12people pleaser and I just thought that okay,
- 44:15well I'll do it. So I got up and then I waited
- 44:18in line and I'm standing in line next to like
- 44:23there's like roughly 10 people in front of me
- 44:25and one by one they're jumping in and I'm not
- 44:29a big swimmer. I don't swim very often and I
- 44:36don't really know about different dives and things
- 44:40but everybody was just jumping in so when I went
- 44:44and then they were going like one by one and
- 44:47you know one by one by one and When they jumped
- 44:50in they'd go and the next person would jump in
- 44:53and then I went and I just went to jump in and
- 44:57I just went And I like I normally do to jump
- 45:00in a pool and went like this And then I don't
- 45:12remember very much, but I remember the pain.
- 45:17My neck immediately hurt like a heck. And I felt
- 45:22foggy and dizzy. And I remember just not knowing
- 45:29which way was up when I was in the water and
- 45:33they helped me out of the pool. My wife helped
- 45:37me out and Nathan helped me out. and everything
- 45:40was dizzy and I had trouble walking. They took
- 45:45me to the sick, the infirmary or whatever they
- 45:49call it on the ship. My life has not been the
- 45:56same. He told me to join the contest and I figured,
- 46:09If this is what they do every cruise, and it's
- 46:14part of the package, part of the activities,
- 46:17the thought didn't occur to me in a million years
- 46:20to think about how deep the pool was or read
- 46:24signs. We were there on vacation to have a good
- 46:30time, and I was just following what he told me
- 46:33to do. I had no idea that the pool was... I mean,
- 46:40in a million years, I would never jump into a
- 46:43pool if I knew it was dangerous. But this is
- 46:48their, you know, I was doing what he told me
- 46:51to do. It's their ship, their activities. And
- 46:57my life's never been the same. And pausing here,
- 47:03so in setting up the scene, you saw that Scott,
- 47:06who's playing the role of Nathan, but Scott got
- 47:08up and he's standing up. Have your client do
- 47:11that as well. You want, use whatever you have.
- 47:14If you're at the client's home and you need to
- 47:16use a chair, you need to use. a table, any type
- 47:19of props to set things up so you get the complete
- 47:23visualization of how everything looked. Do that.
- 47:28Have them get up and talk about it. It's one
- 47:31thing for them to say it verbally, but another
- 47:34thing for them to actually show you where it's
- 47:38going to help you to bring the story together.
- 47:41Then the feelings of betrayal. Again, we know
- 47:45this. Many of us in prepping our clients for
- 47:48a deposition, let alone a trial, it's been very
- 47:52difficult at times to get clients to open up
- 47:56because they have no choice in the matter. They
- 48:00have this pain. They have these injuries that
- 48:03they're living with day in, day out, but they
- 48:06have families or they need to work to support
- 48:09their families. They need to continue on with
- 48:11their lives. So a lot of times they'll put up
- 48:15barriers. And when you want to really bring out
- 48:19what their life was like before and what their
- 48:23life is like after this incident and how it's
- 48:25dramatically changed, to them, it takes time
- 48:30to get them to open up about it because, again,
- 48:33they're so used to putting this wall up. But
- 48:36you can't overemphasize enough to them that this
- 48:40is your time to tell them, how this has changed
- 48:45your life. You're not the same person you were
- 48:48before. And in this case, Nathan's wife, we would
- 48:52be talking to her as well. She's turned into
- 48:55an independent woman that he had fallen in love
- 48:58with. Now they're brand new parents to a caregiver,
- 49:01not just for their newborn, but for her husband.
- 49:06So this is all a process in bringing out the
- 49:10story. And then Scott, I want to open it up.
- 49:13for you to comment. And then Scott's going to
- 49:16also give you an example of an opening statement
- 49:20regarding these facts as well. Yeah, you know,
- 49:23maybe I'll just jump to that since we're limited
- 49:25in time. So this could be a piece, you know,
- 49:28of the opening or a piece of the closing, but
- 49:31it'd be something like this. Like, like. If you
- 49:36were there. You would have seen that. It's a
- 49:42beautiful day Outside the pool on the ship There's
- 49:50a cool breeze going through the air the Sun is
- 49:54shining Nathan's lying on a deck chair in his
- 49:59bathing suit Lying down on the white deck chair
- 50:04with the with the like rubber strips across the
- 50:07deck chair and he's lying there next to his wife,
- 50:12and there's a row of deck chairs with other people.
- 50:16The person next to him is eating chicken strips
- 50:20and french fries, and that air, you can smell
- 50:23the chicken strips and that fried smell in the
- 50:26air. And there's a pool that's about 30 feet
- 50:31by 20 feet, right in front of beautiful blue
- 50:34water. And if you look over the left side, You
- 50:38can see the edge of the ship and the railing
- 50:40and the beautiful ocean behind it. And if you
- 50:43saw Nathan at that time, you'd see Nathan was
- 50:47sitting lying down in the in the chair. It's
- 50:51a beautiful day. Got my seven up. My wife's next
- 50:56to me. I'm so happy. I feel great. So relaxing.
- 51:05And then. What happened next is Nathan, the activities
- 51:11director, walked over and this is what you'd
- 51:15see. Come on everybody, it's time for the belly
- 51:21flop contest. Come on, come on. This is part
- 51:25of the cruise. We do this every cruise and there's
- 51:29gonna be a gift certificate for the winner for
- 51:31the bar and we're gonna see which of you can
- 51:33do the best belly flop. Come on, sir, come on.
- 51:37This is a great day. It's a fun day and You've
- 51:41got to join the activities. Come on. Don't just
- 51:43sit there and be lazy come have fun We're all
- 51:46gonna have fun. Come on you sir. Come on, sir.
- 51:48Come on here. Come on I'll even help you up.
- 51:51Come on everybody. This is so much fun. It's
- 51:54great we're gonna jump off the right here off
- 51:57the side of the pool one by one and we're gonna
- 52:00see which one of you can actually make a big
- 52:04splash and We're not just going to have a gift
- 52:08certificate for the winner, but you're also going
- 52:10to take photographs, and that's part of your
- 52:13cruise. We're going to put a smile on your face.
- 52:15Come on, everybody. Come on. That's just a little
- 52:20piece of what could be in an opening statement.
- 52:24As you do reenactments with your clients and
- 52:28discover actually what happened, there's going
- 52:31to be different things that you would emphasize.
- 52:33But by putting it in a first -person, fashion,
- 52:37the jury is actually watching it happen. And
- 52:40it's happening in the present tense. And so the
- 52:43jury is actually seeing it. So it's one method
- 52:47of persuasion that can be incredibly powerful
- 52:49when it's used for the right part of the case.
- 52:54That has a lasting impact. It's, you know, you
- 52:57could tell someone something, but they may forget.
- 52:59But if you show them and they have certain feelings
- 53:03from seeing it, that's going to leave a lasting
- 53:05impression. And if you could get that across
- 53:09to the jury, that's going to be even more powerful.
- 53:15Most of the members of the jury don't want to
- 53:17be there. They're bored. They're twilling their
- 53:19thumbs. They're looking at our shoes, fingernails,
- 53:22what have you, not really paying attention. Some
- 53:25are bobbing their head, falling asleep, or some
- 53:27even fall asleep. But if you present that story
- 53:31and bring it to life as though you were taking
- 53:34them back to the day when this happened and they
- 53:38can see for themselves, it's one thing for the
- 53:42cruise ship director to get on the witness stand
- 53:44and testify. and he's going to say his version
- 53:47of the story. It's another to actually get up
- 53:49and show like Scott did in terms of. taking them
- 53:55back there to what Nathan observed on that day
- 53:58of how the cruise ship director was acting, how
- 54:02inviting he was, how he was making this appear
- 54:05to be so innocent. No problems whatsoever. Don't
- 54:09worry. Everyone's fine here. This is just for
- 54:12fun, meaning no risks involved whatsoever. Why
- 54:15would anyone think there's going to be any type
- 54:17of risk? When you show the jury and bring out
- 54:21the story that way, that tends to leave lasting
- 54:24impressions. So with that, we want to find out
- 54:30if anyone has any questions. If you do, please
- 54:33feel free to put them in the chat. I don't know
- 54:37if the facilitator has seen any questions come
- 54:41up. If not, we can wrap things up. We still have
- 54:45a little bit of time, but we have more content
- 54:47we can cover as well. We've got a couple of questions
- 54:50and I'll read them. The first one is, What strategies
- 54:53do you use to ensure a client's testimony at
- 54:57trial remains authentic and does not come across
- 55:00as rehearsed after several recitals trial prep?
- 55:05That's very important. We definitely don't want
- 55:08you don't want the testimony to the point of
- 55:11being rehearsed. You want it to be authentic,
- 55:12but I'm going to hand this over to Scott because
- 55:15he is has a wealth of information on it as well.
- 55:21Yeah, so. That's a great question. And the idea
- 55:24is it's got to be truthful. So the way that I
- 55:28like to do is when you're doing your reenactments,
- 55:34when you're doing it with your client to discover
- 55:37what happened, you're going to go through it
- 55:39and ask, well, what are you seeing? What are
- 55:41you hearing? What's your soliloquy? What's your
- 55:45internal voice telling you at this time? And
- 55:47as long as it's true and authentic, it's not
- 55:52going to appear rehearsed because it's true.
- 55:55That's the key is that when you work with your
- 55:57clients, make sure that you tell them, what I
- 56:01do is, before we go back and do a reenactment,
- 56:03I say, okay, I want you to take a minute. I want
- 56:06you to close your eyes. I want you to tune in
- 56:10with back in this moment. I want you to go there
- 56:13and I want you to visualize how your body is.
- 56:19I want you to breathe the way that you were breathing
- 56:21back then. I want you to feel yourself in your
- 56:25body so that they can tune in. And when you're
- 56:29tuned in, then I want you to open your eyes.
- 56:32And then you're asking essentially questions
- 56:34like, what happened next? What are you seeing?
- 56:37What are you feeling? What are you hearing? So
- 56:38there's no direction in the sense that you're
- 56:41not telling them, well, I want you to say this
- 56:43or I want you to say that. You're just listening.
- 56:46You're just listening. and asking questions that
- 56:49you're curious about so that when you do a reenactment
- 56:55in the courtroom, you know it's true because
- 56:58you've seen it. You've watched your client do
- 57:00it and you've gone over it with your client.
- 57:03But if it's true and authentic, which it will
- 57:05be, it's not going to come across as rehearsed
- 57:10or fake because it's true. I'll read the second
- 57:13question, Liz. How would you handle a case of
- 57:15a client who has what may be considered as negatives.
- 57:19My client's an adult movie star. She has severe
- 57:22facial scarring as a result of vehicular injury.
- 57:25There's no loss of earnings, so we need to go
- 57:28into some details about her job. Do you want
- 57:30to start that, Liz, and then I'll jump in after
- 57:32you? Sure. Thank you for that question too, Mark.
- 57:37So it appears there is a loss of earnings. So
- 57:40that's why they he would need to go into details
- 57:42about her job and being an adult movie star.
- 57:46Yes, that's definitely something that has to
- 57:48be explored, especially you're going to want
- 57:50to find out how prospective members of the jury
- 57:52feel about that. However, that's in this particular
- 57:56situation, that's where discovering the client
- 57:59story is very important, because what led to
- 58:03what led your client to. decide on that profession.
- 58:08Is it something that she felt she was forced
- 58:10into? What are her circumstances, her upbringing?
- 58:13You want to get into that. Maybe there's, she
- 58:17didn't have any support as a child or there's
- 58:20some things that may have happened in her past
- 58:22that you want to be able to explore. And it may
- 58:24be painful, but you want to be able to explore
- 58:28all of that so you can get the full story. And
- 58:30then from there, once you have all that information,
- 58:34you can then reframe it in a way that it may
- 58:37not appear to be a negative to some people. Was
- 58:41this something that she voluntarily wanted to
- 58:43get into? This was her dream to be an adult movie
- 58:47star? Likely, there's a lot more to it that led
- 58:51her into that profession, and part of it has
- 58:54to do with her upbringing. Scott? Yeah, and I
- 58:59would embrace it. I wouldn't look at this as
- 59:00a negative. I would look at it as something that
- 59:04I would deal with the first thing in voir dire.
- 59:07Like, hey, look, my client is in the adult entertainment
- 59:12business. This is what she does for a living.
- 59:16So part of me thinks that people who are in that
- 59:18business, that's not something that I condone.
- 59:22What do you think about it? And you're going
- 59:24to get a bunch of jurors who are going to be
- 59:25like, some of the jurors are going to be like,
- 59:28Maybe yes, I think it's immoral. I think this
- 59:31which is great. They tell you that you know that
- 59:33other jurors gonna be like That's her job. That's
- 59:36what she does. That's how she makes a living
- 59:38and if if she's injured and can't make money
- 59:41that way Then of course, she's entitled to justice
- 59:44just like anybody else would so I would I would
- 59:47not run from that at all and Mark you or anybody
- 59:50else if you want to Contact us contact us afterwards
- 59:54and and talk about it further happy to do that
- 59:58Michelle, read the next question. I'm sorry,
- 1:00:00Liz, do you want to add? Oh, no. I was just going
- 1:00:02to say that for any of whatever the client's
- 1:00:06profession is or some circumstances, at first
- 1:00:08glance, you may look at it like a negative, but
- 1:00:10I'm with Scott. I would embrace that. There will
- 1:00:14be members or the jury or prospective members
- 1:00:18of the jury who they may say, hey, it's not my
- 1:00:21place to judge. Who am I to judge? So whatever
- 1:00:24she decides to do for her profession, I'm not
- 1:00:26going to have an issue with it. If she had to
- 1:00:28take off time from work, then yeah, we'll consider
- 1:00:31the evidence before us whether she deserves to
- 1:00:34get paid for that time. So you will hear from
- 1:00:38people and people will speak up about that. But
- 1:00:40you will find that there's going to be people
- 1:00:42who aren't going to hold any judgment. But you
- 1:00:45also want to explore this whole story of what
- 1:00:48led her to that profession as well, just so you
- 1:00:50have the full picture. Yeah. Let me add to that.
- 1:00:54Things like this, like this is the perfect issue
- 1:00:56where you see something in a case where you're
- 1:00:58like, oh, my God, how can I win this case? My
- 1:01:01client's an adult porn star. These are the issues
- 1:01:04that are the key to big verdicts because the
- 1:01:08insurance companies look at something like this
- 1:01:10and they're like, we're not gonna pay any money
- 1:01:12on a case like this because the jury's gonna
- 1:01:13hate them because they're immoral or whatever.
- 1:01:16And these kinds of things are really enable us
- 1:01:20as trial lawyers to deal with the truth, the
- 1:01:23honest truth and do really great things for our
- 1:01:26client. I'll tell you, I'm always afraid of stuff
- 1:01:28like this. I'm always afraid if my client uses
- 1:01:32meth, you have these things that look like they're
- 1:01:35such big problems, but in reality, they're not
- 1:01:37because if you deal with them openly and honestly
- 1:01:40with the jury, people understand just because
- 1:01:43which of us are perfect, which of us don't have
- 1:01:47things in our life that we're not ashamed about
- 1:01:50or embarrassed about, but everybody gets that
- 1:01:54and everybody understands that. Well, let me
- 1:01:58read the last one, Brenda. Brenda, sure. I'll
- 1:02:03go ahead and read. In cases where a client has
- 1:02:06suffered severe injuries, there may be situations
- 1:02:09where they're unable to communicate due to the
- 1:02:12extent of their condition. In those instances,
- 1:02:16is someone appointed to speak on their behalf
- 1:02:19during trial depositions? If so, what does that
- 1:02:22process typically look like? Do you want to start
- 1:02:25off with that? Sure. Yes. The way that works
- 1:02:29is if your clients can't talk, for example, one
- 1:02:34thing I wonder is are they able to communicate
- 1:02:36at all? Are they able to write? Normally in court,
- 1:02:43no one would be appointed to speak on their behalf,
- 1:02:47but you would have other witnesses that would
- 1:02:49be able to talk about what their experiences
- 1:02:51are. In other words, if you have someone who
- 1:02:53suffered a brain injury, you obviously have hopefully
- 1:02:56witnesses to the injury itself, or you would
- 1:02:59have experts to talk about the way the injury
- 1:03:02occurred and what the impact is, and so that
- 1:03:06you can have other people talk about what your
- 1:03:10client is going through, both a percipient witness
- 1:03:12and expert witnesses, to talk about that. But
- 1:03:15there's also something that we use in psychodrama
- 1:03:17called surplus reality, where when you want to
- 1:03:21learn about what their experience is but they
- 1:03:23can't talk, you can do some reenactments with,
- 1:03:26you know, with putting yourself or an auxiliary,
- 1:03:30another person in the role of your client and
- 1:03:32reenacting what they went through and reenacting
- 1:03:35what it's like to be in a position now to be
- 1:03:37where if you're in a hospital bed, unable to
- 1:03:41speak and tuning in to what those feelings are
- 1:03:45and understanding what the truth is in living
- 1:03:51like that. that can give you tremendous insight
- 1:03:55to what your client's going through that can
- 1:03:58help tremendously in your case. I know this is
- 1:04:02a complicated question, and I'm happy to chat
- 1:04:05with you offline about it because there's lots
- 1:04:08of things, creative things that you can do that
- 1:04:11can really help you represent your client. I
- 1:04:15know we're probably going to have to wrap up,
- 1:04:17but let me just add to that. I had a client who
- 1:04:21is a minor child had autism and a severe, meaning
- 1:04:26a severe traumatic brain injury. Defense counsel
- 1:04:30wanted to take his deposition. We filed a motion
- 1:04:34for protective order. The judge ruled in favor
- 1:04:37of the defendants. The deposition took place
- 1:04:40and it was so clear that the extent of our client's
- 1:04:47injuries, the deposition barely, it didn't even
- 1:04:50go an hour. Defense counsel kept asking our client
- 1:04:53questions. He wasn't focused. He wasn't able
- 1:04:56to verbally communicate that well, but he was
- 1:04:59able to say no more during the deposition. But
- 1:05:03you could clearly tell. And it was probably maybe
- 1:05:07like half hour, 40 minutes and they stopped the
- 1:05:09deposition and that was it. But just in that,
- 1:05:13if you have your client and they want to take
- 1:05:16your client's deposition and it does go forward,
- 1:05:19then defense counsel will likely get the realistic
- 1:05:22picture that how severe the brain injury is,
- 1:05:25because just by the inability to verbally talk
- 1:05:29or the expressions, that came across so crystal
- 1:05:32clear. And shortly after that, we ended up settling
- 1:05:35the case. So, I know we've gone over about five
- 1:05:39minutes. I want to thank you and I'll turn it
- 1:05:41over to Scott to thank you for spending this
- 1:05:44hour, little over an hour with us. We're both
- 1:05:46available if you want to reach out to us and
- 1:05:49we thank you for your time. Scott? Yeah, I just
- 1:05:52want to say it's wonderful the fact that you're
- 1:05:55taking time to better your skills, to learn,
- 1:05:59to help your clients. Fantastic. That's congratulations
- 1:06:04to you for doing that. because you will get better,
- 1:06:08and we're all getting better. We're all learning
- 1:06:10and growing constantly. I know there was a question
- 1:06:13someone, I think, had asked for our emails, and
- 1:06:15I'm not sure if that was put up on the chat.
- 1:06:18But my email is sglovsky at scottglovskylaw .com.
- 1:06:23That's S -G -L -O -V -S -K -Y at scottglovskylawlaw
- 1:06:31.com. And Liz? Mine's listed on the written materials
- 1:06:36at the very end, the last page, but it's EAH,
- 1:06:39my initials for Elizabeth Ann Hernandez, EAH
- 1:06:43at BDJ .com. B as in boy, D as in Daniel, J as
- 1:06:48in John .com. Thank you all again. We appreciate
- 1:06:52it. Thank you. Have a great day, everybody.