Latest / 323 Bourbon Library Podcast / 11/10/26 EPISODE 042: BOTTLE BREAKDOWN: COMMANDER'S CLUB GRAND CUVEE RESERVE by RARE CHARACTER
Transcript
- 323 Bourbon Library Podcast: I I think I yes. So seal I was trying remember how I got this bottle. Yeah. ⁓ might as well record this. I did. ⁓ we are recording. Yeah, I did it, man. I mean for the last 20 seconds. Folks, welcome back in. We are returning for another episode of Bottle Breakdown. And we got a fresh bottle out here. ⁓ I I you know, I bought this bottle and I was like, hey What am I gonna do with this? I was gonna sit on it, but I'm not. But we're gonna review it. But right now, let's go around the room and see who we we got a full a full group of folks in here to enjoy this amazing. Well, we hope amazing. I've never tried this bourbon or this whiskey, whatever it is. ⁓ Intros there? Yeah, this is James. I'm off camera. Off camera. We got the voice of God. John Carlo, sorry. I'm Scott and a big, big rare character fan. Big rare character fan. So this is right up his alley. Rounding it out with Shane, ⁓ Rock's Bourbon Review. Perfect. So we are going to be reviewing this evening ⁓ the as as Scott mentioned, the rare character release of Commander's Club. Kentucky Strait Bourbon Whiskey Grand Cuvie Reserve. ⁓ and so I'm gonna get this thing popped open here. We'll pour them up and then I'm gonna give a little bit of interesting history about rare character and specifically about this bottle. ⁓ this bottle came was super hard to find. There was a lottery for it. I missed out on the lottery, and randomly one day I got on the seal box website and I was just perusing what they had, and I saw this as an option. I hit add to cart, I hit purchase. It went through. I was like, okay, I missed the lottery. How did they have another one not in the lottery? I went back and apparently they only had one. So I got the last one that they had. I was like, shit, okay. I believe I paid four hundred dollars for this bottle. so it so not a cheap bottle. The color on this thing is dark, dark red, mahogany. ⁓ we'll give s we'll give it poured up, get the get the guys to give their thoughts on it. Hopefully you heard the barrel pot or cork pop there. So just thought maybe somebody just didn't pick up their bottle from the lottery. ⁓ why they would have it available on the website though. It's got a ship, so thank you. Yeah. So let's see what what is Commander's Club from Rare Character. ⁓ so this is back. They call it Batch One. It's highly limited, ultra premium. ⁓ it's released by Rare Character, and it represents a deliberate marriage of standout barrows selected for depth, balance, and character. This release reflects Rare Character's ongoing exploration of thoughtful blending and elevated curation, designed for collectors and enthusiasts who value rarity without excess. Whatever that means. ⁓ so quote Commander Commander's Club is a snapshot of Rare Character at this moment in time, said Pete Nevig Nevinglovsky. I'm terrible at his last name. Yeah, me ⁓ me too. Pete N. Very nice guy. Pete N. Very nice guy. ⁓ he's co founder co founder over there at Rare Character. We carefully selected each barrel to create a bourbon that is expressive, layered, and unmistakably memorable. There will be there will be no repeat run, no follow up releases under this name. Once it's gone, it's gone. I'd love that. so some facts about this this pour. It's sourced by rare character. It's distilled, aged, and bottled in Kentucky. It is an undisclosed distillery. ⁓ and it is a curated blend of barrels aging between 10 and 15 years old. It's bottled at 110.42 proof. ⁓ and some early secondary or retailers listings occasionally reference higher barrel proofs, but the official bottling is 110.42 proof. And that is what our bottle says as well. So some retailers don't know how to read ⁓ apparently. and how many bottles of this are out there? They said this is the one and only time they were ever going to release it. There are only a total of 2,325 bottles in the world. MSRP on this, which I'm surprised to say, is two hundred dollars. I don't think you're ever gonna see this for two hundred dollars. I got it off sealbox for four hundred dollars. ⁓ and then the secondary price market for this is somewhere between three to five hundred plus dollars. Blake is charging you double. Holy shit. Sealbox. Come on, dude. I know Ronnie should be getting everything at MSRP. How how do you just not call them up and listen, they didn't they didn't know they didn't know I was gonna buy this bottle. ⁓ now let me let me ask you guys before I continue. I I do have the rare characters tasting notes on this whiskey. Should I give those now or after we taste them? I agree after after we taste them. No suggestions. So I haven't nosed or tasted it. You guys have while I was talking. The nose is great. Talk about the nose while I get an opportunity. Phenomenal nose. I agree. Great nose. Deep, dark, caramel for me. Yeah. It's it's it's definitely more woody for for a rare character than I'm used to for sure. Yeah. Definitely ⁓ dark wood notes on that. Dark woods. Dark wood notes on it. What you know? Do you get any any comments on the nose? Dark fruits. Nothing. Nothing. ⁓ the nose for me. I'll go to palette, but I'll let y'all I mean it's it's like it's great. Saw his nose off of the fucking chainsaw. Skeletoral. I've no desired us I've no desire to smell it. Like let's drink That's interesting. That's interesting. That's crazy. So the I love nosing it. Like it's beer. I actually do love nosing it as well. I I love I love it's the experience. The And I think we did this on an earlier episode where we're Barish, we did that 1973 Crown Royal. And he's I've actually never smelled a Crown Royal. I only drink it. ⁓ And he's like, I gotta appreciate it maybe for the first. He's been fucking drinking Crown Royal for 20 years. Yeah. Never stopped to nose it. He's like, I would have never thought to nose it. ⁓ so I think there's a lot of oper, you know, experience you get out of the nose of a of a whiskey. I would have never thought to nose a crown, like ever. That's yeah. ⁓ man. The th the thing for me on this, I know you guys have noticed and given a couple of thoughts, ⁓ dark black cherry, rich vanilla notes on the nose for me. I it's so woody for me. I I agree. I I it is for me too. I I I get when you say when you say woody, what do you mean? Because I don't get like a a woody like like a damp wood. ⁓ almost like a double oak, almost. I I get lots of oak on the I get a bunch of sweet oak. Like a spiced sweet oak too. Yeah, yeah, yeah. ⁓ so what's funny is is I don't sniff, but I would I've already had a sip of it or two or three sips, and the cherry is full fledged in it. And I mean, it's very syrupy, in my opinion. All right, let's go. Very fruit, syrupy. Cherry feels great. It leads Like cobbler esque tobacco. It's delicious. Wow. Wow. I I I get what you're talking about, James. I get the chair. Dead cherry for sure. That because when you said the nose was cherry, I was like dead on the nose. I don't get the wood at all. Dark cherry. It's less wood on the palate. Dark like cherry syrupy. Syrupy and like s like it's got a like clove, cinnamon, baking spice to it's got a s like a the late mid palate to the finish. It's got the spice I wasn't expecting. Oof. This is only around a hundred and ten proof. Hundred and ten point four two proof. Man, that's nice. Which is a great proof point. I love that proof point. ⁓ wow. Lots of lots of cherry on it, just like you guys are saying. Yeah. Like extreme, rich cheriness. ⁓ like like a cherry filling syrupy, very filling syrupy that yeah. Yeah. The the viscosity, the great mouthfeel on this this this whiskey. One of the reasons I decided like when I when I saw there were only twenty three hundred bottles, I I really went between like, should I ever open this or should I like fuck it, let's open it. But after only after I read this one comment, someone somewhere online I I saw was like, There's buff turkey in this blend. And I'm like, Well, if there's buff turkey in it, I better try it because I love buff turkey. the cherry on the nose was giving me that buff turkey. The palate I I I would say maybe it's in there, but it's also been blended with some other whiskies where it's not standing out as a buff turkey, like that Sealbox fifteen they're about over there. ⁓ it's interesting. It's This is giving me the chills that's so good. Like shivers, goosebumps. Yeah. It's amazing. It it finishes incredibly well. It really does. It it does a long deep finish. Yeah, it does not. Taste like a 110, like at all. Mm-mm. The n the nose, I'm coming back to the nose. The vanilla on the nose is really popping out for me now. It's gotten a little bit of caramel sweetness on the back vanilla and then caramel. Cherry vanilla, caramel, think of it that way for me on the nose. Yeah. Wow. That's good. The baking spice does linger. I mean, at the end. It it drinks a little spicy for one ten. Yeah, it does. But I mean it's it's I enjoy it though. It's always I really like it's not it's not bitey. It's not at No. Yeah, it's just well, you know, that first sip was spicy. I'm coming back now. Second sip. The spice is there, but it's tamed down. It's and and let's let's be honest, this was a fresh crack. So with a little as we talk, air gets on it, we everyone's swirling it in their glass. It's gonna open up a little bit more as well. You it's so funny when you when when you get it in the back of your palate and you go back and you and then you put it on your nose again, you can really get that cherry. Like really get that cherry the second, third time. Yeah. Yeah, it's very cherry forward, which is I love. Intense flavors, I would say. I think cherry. So cherry is one of my favorite fruit notes to get on a bourbon. Like if I taste a bourbon and it doesn't have some sort of fruit or especially a cherry, I'm like, God damn, it's missing. It's missing a component. I love a fruit note. I love the sweetness, whether it's caramel, toffee, vanilla, and then a spice stuff. The spice component. I I really enjoy that as well. But if it's all spice and it's no sweet, I'm like, ⁓ this is no it's got some other fruit in there as well, some darker fruit. I can't really plum. I was gonna just gonna say that. ⁓ You're right on cherry and plum. On the on the palate or the nose? I don't nose. That's right. I forget he has no nose. On the palate, dark plum. No surface. Palate for sure. The plu now like a dark plum and cherry. Yeah. ⁓ I agree. That's spot on. But syrupy. It like there is it is the visc the mouthfeel on it. It does feel like and and I don't remember if I saw or said that this was uncut, unfiltered. My guess is it is it's a really random proof point. One fifty five point two one percent alcohol volume. Point two one. Love it. So I love it. So one hundred and ten point eight two proof. would would tend to lead me to believe they didn't water it down, right? ⁓ it's just straight from the barrel. It's a blend of ten to fifteen years old. So I definitely can taste that like younger component. And who knows, maybe it needed the fifteen year old needed that to kind of balance it a little bit. All right. So we got on our notes cherry, vanilla, plum, baking spice, baking spice. Wet oak. Yeah. Sweet oak. I got a little sweet oak. Anybody else got another note? Let's before I definitely woody for sure on that. Tobacco and leather notes, I got it. Tobacco leather notes. All right. So from rare character, ⁓ This is this expression is designed to showcase well aged Kentucky oak without the astringent bitterness that can accompany fifteen year old stocks. ⁓ yeah. Keeping the proof integrated and polished. On the nose, cherry pipe tobacco. Graham cracker, boot leather, strange strange note, toasted oak, scorched toffee, warm baking spices, ginger and clove. On the palate, rich coating, syrupy. I think that was probably the note that was said the most. Dominant notes of dark caramel cherry compote. There you go. Baked black plums. Hey, fuck you. We're pretty good. Dark sugar, bittersweet chocolate balanced out by a heavy oak foundation. Finish, long, warming, structured, which means oaky. Lingering dark cobbler fruits, dry spices, lingering oak tannins with a subtle touch of licorice and leather. Well, I didn't get the licorice at all. I love black licorice. You mentioned the cobbler right away though. Black licorice on the face is phenomenal. Now I want it. I do I like black licorice. You don't like black licorice, I love it. Hate it. On the palate, on the finish, let's see what I didn't get it at all. I didn't like it. I'm glad I didn't get it. Yeah. I would have liked it right away. Not a not a fan. I got it more that licorice flavor as a herbal note than actual like black licorice. Okay. Almost like a basil type basil type in there. I see what you're saying with that. Yeah. I don't necessarily get Wow man actually wait ten seconds after you've swallowed it. I think you whatever they mean by that black ric licorice. I understand what you're saying. I think is what pops out there. Yeah just in your mouth. My mouth If I could try to think about Very little. I would love it to have more because I love some black electricity. I do too. I do too. I don't get a lot of that on bourbons, which is which is that's why I was shocked. I was like, I didn't get it at all. So it's it's definitely different from any of the rare characters that I have for sure. I mean it is it is phenomenal. So wild is phenomenal. Wild release. I ⁓ when I was out in Fresno, California last month, ⁓ and I picked up some bangers, this one was also under the shelf. And I was like, I'm I said, hey, any are you willing to sell it? Not knowing if it was good or not, but I'm like, it's really limited. He's like, nah, I wanna I really wanna save that for a a ⁓ raffle he was gonna do. I might need to call him right now and be like, hey, did you do the raffle? If not, gonna need that commander's club from you. It's still sitting under the counter. It is. I actually picked up this four roses. Twenty seventeen release from underneath that counter as well. And yeah, the so the Commander's Club, it's a win. If so, if you guys have an opportunity to buy a Commander's Club, obviously if you're a fifty dollar bourbon drinker, this is probably not for you. No judging on that. No no judgment, yeah. But the MSRP's two hundred and you're likely to see this somewhere between three fifty to five fifty, probably. Plus. ⁓ plus worth it. And the longer they sit, it might it might go up since it's they're not going to release this again. You don't think it's worth it? In my opinion, I don't think anything's worth, you know, secondary. I mean, I just it's they're just so much they're just so much. What if they what if they had this for four hundred dollars? What if they offered it at four hundred dollars? Like what do you mean secondary? It's like what do you what would you pay for? Well when you said way more than, you know, four I mean, I just don't I just that's just my like I cut it off. I'm upset with Sillbox for Charging Ronnie four hundred. Sure. I mean they shouldn't charge two fifty like the MSRP or whatever. So you're just you're just upset that it's over MSRP. What what's the max you would pay for that then? I mean it's a phenomenal bottle. It is a phenomenal bottle, yeah. I don't know the the price, I mean number. I mean four hundred would probably be it because I don't do anything over that. Yeah. That's fair. Because you don't do anything over four hundred dollars. I don't do anything I try not to do anything over MSRP. Or what right around there. So I mean I thought the I thought it was four hundred, honestly, because that's what like I saw it for and that's what it is. So like the two fifty I've never I mean, I've never even seen that. I thought I've I've always seen four hundred, so that's why I see. I have as well. I've never seen it for sale at two hundred, so correct. So four hundred. So I would say four hundred. No one's ever said AI is ⁓ and Gemini specifically is the best at digging up details so they Gemini does screw up a little bit. They might have fucked that one up and this is maybe maybe is a lot or groc a four hundred dollar MSRP bottle. I think it might be. ⁓ I think it actually should be. ⁓ I mean I'm thinking of what else is out there for two hundred bucks. This is better than that. Especially for the amount of limited availability it has. I I would pay 400 for this. I would it this this is a a great zipper. This is something that I would share with my friends. I would pay four Yeah, if you want to pull this down and be like, hey, hey dude, check this out. This is a good bottle. This sounds good. Yep. Perfect. Well, listen, I'm glad you guys were able to try it here. We all got to sample it for the first time. Stay tuned. We're all going to be searching for more Commander's Club. ⁓ if there's a if if you're a retailer out there and you're trying to lose a few bottles because you can't sell them, send me a send me a message at the 323 Bourbon Library at gmail.com. Happy to come and figure out how to take those off your hands. And also ⁓ thank Ronnie for ⁓ sharing with his buddies. Yes, thanks. That's what we're here. This is this is great. That's what we're here for, fellas. So ⁓ we will see you next week for another episode on the 323 Bourbon Library Podcast. Cheers. Cheers.