Latest / Germ & Worm / 110: The Gut Microbiome: "I Contain Multitudes"
Transcript
- 0:09Na nga def?
- 0:09My name is Germ.
- 0:11I'm Worm.
- 0:11Welcome to episode 110 of the Germ and Worm Travel Health podcast.
- 0:15The gut microbiome: I contain multitudes.
- 0:18It's a big planet.
- 0:19See it in Good Health.
- 0:20I'm Dr.
- 0:21Paul Pottinger, also called Germ.
- 0:22I'm an infectious diseases specialist at the University of Washington in Seattle.
- 0:26I'm Dr.
- 0:27Chris Sanford, also known as Worm Family Practice Doc, also at the University of Washington.
- 0:31Well we're talking about the human microbiome, especially the gut microbiome, Right, Chris.
- 0:36We're going to answer all kinds of questions we've gotten from our listeners and other questions that we wish we had gotten, we will answer for ourselves.
- 0:42That includes the gut microbiome.
- 0:44What is it?
- 0:44How do we make it happy?
- 0:45How does travel affect the gut microbiome?
- 0:48What are the implications of taking antibiotics for travelers?
- 0:51Diarrhea?
- 0:51If my gut microbiome changes when I travel, what does that mean for my health and care when I come home?
- 0:57These questions and many a reminder to our listeners.
- 1:00Please contact us with your travel health questions, stories and your tips for success.
- 1:04Yes, we would love to hear those.
- 1:05Just Visit our website, germandworm.com or send us an email, germanworm@gmail.com.
- 1:11Our medical disclaimer.
- 1:12This podcast is designed to inform, inspire, and entertain.
- 1:15But before you travel, please see a qualified healthcare professional for recommendations specific to you and your itinerary.
- 1:21All right, Paul, start us off.
- 1:23What is the gut microbiome?
- 1:25Well, the gut, we know that's your intestines.
- 1:27So everything between your lips and your anus, that's your gut.
- 1:30That's how we're going to define it here.
- 1:31But the microbiome, what is that?
- 1:33Micro means small, bio means life, and ome means the world, the study of it.
- 1:38So the gut microbiome is the study of all the small things that live inside of our intestines and our guts.
- 1:43And there are other human microbiomes as well, right?
- 1:47There's the skin microbiome, the female reproductive tract microbiome, the pulmonary microbiome.
- 1:52There are other microbiomes, but the one that is so important, at least in the context of travel health, I think, is the gut microbiome.
- 1:59It contains multitudes.
- 2:00There's this very fascinating, actually, frankly, bewildering, complex community of microbes that lives inside of us here in 2026.
- 2:10We are still just beginning to understand what happens inside of us.
- 2:14And I mean that from even the most very fundamental question, how many germs live in us?
- 2:18Actually, nobody knows there are too many to count.
- 2:20We used to say that about 10 times the number of human cells that we are made of is the proper number of microbial cells.
- 2:28That's prob.
- 2:30The number is probably closer to one to one.
- 2:31But honestly, nobody really knows.
- 2:34You can't count them.
- 2:35And by the way, if you take antibiotics, you will dramatically impact that number as well.
- 2:38The key here is that there are many, many microbes in us, the trillions of cells that make up our own body.
- 2:46The same is true probably for the microbes that live in our intestines.
- 2:50And it's not just their numbers.
- 2:51It's the fact that they're a very diverse group.
- 2:54At least in good health, there should be good diversity.
- 2:56Right, Chris?
- 2:56This is a part of the body where we like to see a mixture of different germs.
- 3:00We'll get into that in minute.
- 3:01But that mixture, it's quite fascinating.
- 3:04It is probably individual for individual people.
- 3:07My microbiome, Chris, is going to be different from yours, et cetera.
- 3:10At least we think that's true.
- 3:12People who are really studying this area, including Dr.
- 3:15Jonathan Eisen at UC Davis, Dr.
- 3:18David Relman in his lab down at Stanford, and many others, they're trying to understand these patterns.
- 3:22So what microbes live in us?
- 3:24How many are there?
- 3:25How do they relate to each other, and how do they relate to our own health?
- 3:28This science of microbial understanding, it's not just infectious diseases.
- 3:32I mean, I think about germs and how to kill them.
- 3:34This goes way beyond that.
- 3:36This is about biology.
- 3:37This is potentially about health and wellness.
- 3:39It's also about staying savvy and avoiding scams.
- 3:42And we'll talk about that, too.
- 3:44Important area, right, Chris?
- 3:46Yeah, you bet.
- 3:47So this is stunningly complex, and I would say the research in this field is still very early.
- 3:53But obviously, when you have billions of organisms of hundreds of different species in billions of different people, each one with a unique pattern of germ nerms in their gut, we're still figuring out at a very rudimentary level what
- 4:07correlates to what.
- 4:08However, there are a couple large points I would make about keeping your gut biome happy with what we know about it.
- 4:16My first two points would be, number one, fiber is good.
- 4:20And we knew that 50 years ago because it brings down your risk of heart attack and stroke, also brings down your risk of colon cancer.
- 4:26But the bacteria and other organisms seem to have an optimal mix when you eat a lot of fruits, a lot of grain, a lot of vegetables, and wide variety.
- 4:36So fiber is good.
- 4:37Is one large meta point.
- 4:39The second one, antibiotics are to be minimized.
- 4:43An antibiotic is like a freight train with a hundred boxcars roaring through your gut, and it just kills the bad bacteria.
- 4:51Maybe you're trying to kill because of your illness that you're taking the antibiotic for, but it also kills a lot of what's in your gut, and it takes a while, if ever, to get back to normal.
- 5:00So those are two of the larger points.
- 5:02There's a lot of more subtle recommendations.
- 5:05The role of probiotics and taking that we're going to talk about in a little bit.
- 5:08It's kind of nuanced and maybe not as helpful as a lot of people think it is.
- 5:12Some other general things, the circadian rhythm that you have when you sleep, when you're awake, that can affect things.
- 5:18So getting your good sleep is good.
- 5:20Alcohol tends to be bad.
- 5:22So I would minimize or not drink at all.
- 5:25Stress is bad.
- 5:25That's not real actionable.
- 5:27We can't just wish our stress to be lower, but the gut microbiome changes with response to stress.
- 5:33Those are several things right there.
- 5:34Paul, anything else you would say that affects the microbiome?
- 5:39There are probably all kinds of things where we can influence the microbiome and it in turn influences us.
- 5:45Indeed, we are they.
- 5:46So, yeah, there's lots of things that go into that.
- 5:49And, you know, in the state of normal health, if you have a healthy person, that person's microbiome may be different from the next person next door.
- 5:57They can both be healthy.
- 5:59So that tells me a lot.
- 6:00There is no single microbial ingredient that gives us fountain of youth, everlasting health, or sex drive or whatever.
- 6:09This is about really humility, scientific humility, and understanding that although there are a lot of things we understand about this, there's still a lot for us to learn.
- 6:18Okay, Paul, this is a travel podcast.
- 6:21Suppose someone travels and both A, they don't get sick, and B, they do get sick with diarrhea.
- 6:26What happens to the gut microbiome?
- 6:29It's such a good question, and I think it's at the heart of the matter for this podcast.
- 6:33As an infectious diseases doctor, one of the things that I'll do with my patients is try to understand the patterns of antibiotic resistance that they keep inside of them.
- 6:42In other words, I see people who are sick more than I see people who are healthy.
- 6:46So if someone comes to my practice and they have a urinary tract infection, for example, one of the things I need to understand, even before I have prescribed them A medication even before I have seen the results of
- 6:57their urine testing.
- 6:58I really want to get that history.
- 7:00Where have you been?
- 7:01Tell me about your life.
- 7:02Where have you traveled in the world?
- 7:04Who is part of your own community?
- 7:06Because what we know, Chris, is that antibiotic resistance patterns differ in different parts of the world.
- 7:12If you travel to certain areas, you may be at much higher risk of being exposed to antibiotic resistant or partially resistant microbes.
- 7:21And so I've seen this time and again.
- 7:23I cannot tell you how many times we have someone who should have a treatable form of bacterial infection.
- 7:31And in fact, we are surprised to say, wow, this person's bacteria actually is not particularly treatable.
- 7:37And that's an issue for us because unfortunately, it looks like they may have acquired and been colonized by a more drug resistant strain as they've traveled around the world.
- 7:47So what can happen when you travel?
- 7:49Look, when you travel, you gotta eat, you gotta drink, you gotta be around other people.
- 7:52You've got to acquire the local microbes.
- 7:55You cannot avoid that.
- 7:56I mean, to do that, you'd have to live in a bubble.
- 7:57And then why would you, why would you travel?
- 8:00So when people travel, they're gonna eat and drink, and that food and drink will contain germs that are new and different.
- 8:05Just like we look for new and different experiences, our gut is doing the same.
- 8:08That's not necessarily bad.
- 8:10But what we're coming to understand is that antibiotic resistance profiles may be substantially different and worse in some parts of the world.
- 8:18So even if you're healthy, even if you're feeling fine, when you come home, you may have what ultimately might feel like a ticking time bomb in your colon, which is that if you ultimately get sick from some of
- 8:30those colonizing asymptomatic germs, they may be more difficult for me to treat as your doctor when you come to see me.
- 8:36That can happen in states of health and disease.
- 8:38But for those patients who go overseas and get sick with, let's say diabetes, diarrhea that requires antibiotic treatment, that can dramatically change the way the microbiome works.
- 8:50Look, even here in the good old domestic contiguous 48 states of the USA, you take antibiotics, you will profoundly impact the microbiome.
- 8:58Fewer numbers of germs and less diversity of germs.
- 9:01When we alter that microbiome, other new germs can move in that germ warfare that they're fighting with each other.
- 9:07We call these ecological niches.
- 9:09A niche is just an ecological position that a germ can take inside the body.
- 9:14If there's less competition.
- 9:15Something else could move in.
- 9:16Clostridium difficile or C.
- 9:18Diff is the classic.
- 9:19But there are others like this that happens wherever we take antibiotics.
- 9:23But if we happen to be overseas when we do so, the germs that move in may bring along with them some very nasty habits of being more and more resistant to antibiotics.
- 9:31So anybody can get antibiotic resistant bacteria when they travel internationally and that risk is elevated for those people who take antibiotics for the treatment of travelers diarrhea, the implication is eat and drink and be merry, but wash your
- 9:44damn hands.
- 9:45Be sensible about where you eat as we talk about here on German worm all the time, and recognize that if you are thinking about taking an antibiotic for, let's say, traveler's diarrhea, that might be the right move.
- 9:56But you need to have a clear plan about that because we're trying to minimize the unnecessary use of antibiotics.
- 10:05So, Chris, let's talk about that.
- 10:07If we are trying to reduce the impact of travel on the human microbiome, let's talk in a little bit more detail about the things we might be able to do or advise our patients to do before they travel.
- 10:20You bet.
- 10:20And it's an important topic and I'm loving all the research that's coming out on this.
- 10:24One thing that's coming out, which I think is fascinating.
- 10:27There's this thing called the gut brain axis, where basically chemicals in your body, neurotransmitters, go back and forth between your brain and your gut.
- 10:37And this is fascinating.
- 10:38So this may be one reason you feel fundamentally crummy when you have diarrhea.
- 10:42Maybe all of that bad feeling does not entirely come from your gut, but the gut is putting out chemicals that go to your brain that affects your mood and your pain sensation and things like that.
- 10:52Things you can do to try to keep your gut microbiome maximally diverse and healthy.
- 10:57One is, as I mentioned, is a high fiber diet before you travel for your whole life.
- 11:03And while you travel, if you're just doing barbecued beef on a stick and red wine.
- 11:08That sounds so good.
- 11:10That sounds so good.
- 11:12It's fun in the moment, but it's kind of the opposite of a healthy diet.
- 11:16High fiber diet keeps the gut happy.
- 11:19Second thing is, minimize antibiotics.
- 11:22Now, antibiotics are beautiful.
- 11:23They saved a lot of lives, millions of lives.
- 11:25But there are two tool.
- 11:26They're a tool like a jackhammer.
- 11:29Jackhammer does what you want it to do, but it can do a lot of damage if you misuse it.
- 11:33And I have to Say our threshold for using antibiotics is changing.
- 11:37A few decades ago we gave antibiotics out more liberally.
- 11:40Now we still give them out.
- 11:42But I would still stick with that four step plan for travelers.
- 11:45Diarrhea, self treatment.
- 11:47Maybe take some antibiotics with you just in case you feel good.
- 11:50Don't take anything at all.
- 11:51Mild diarrhea, don't break out the antibiotics yet.
- 11:54Do not take antibiotics at the first instance of diarrhea or stomach if you're still able to do your activities.
- 12:00Either take no drug and let it pass because it's probably going to be self resolving, or take loperamide, brand name Imodium, which is a gut anti motility agent, no prescription necessary.
- 12:10And that is good treatment for mild diarrhea.
- 12:13When we start to consider an antibiotic, it's when it's severe.
- 12:16We used to like count stools, which was kind of impossible, but now we more define it functionally if it's definitely interfering with your activities, if you're in bed and you can't go back a tourist, then an option is
- 12:28to take an antibiotic.
- 12:29But you can also not take an antibiotic because even that diarrhea tends to be self resolving.
- 12:33And you can take the loperamide with that.
- 12:36However, you don't want to take, just as an aside, the loperamide, the gut antimotility agent if there's signs of dysentery, which would be like fever or blood in the stool.
- 12:46And final part is if you get dysentery, fever or blood in the stool, maybe see a doc and don't take the loperamide.
- 12:51So anyway, that's a long way of saying is yeah, take an antibiotic with you, but really treat it like a big intervention.
- 12:58Maybe contact your medical person back home and get his or her advice on if you should take it or not.
- 13:03So high fiber and low antibiotic is good.
- 13:06And then just some of the other things I mentioned, try to get some sleep, go minimal or not at all, and alcoholic beverages.
- 13:12And that will in general keep a high diversity in your gut of bacteria and other organisms.
- 13:17Although it's difficult for us to quantify this and difficult to prove, I think it stands in good stead that if you're smart about your food safety and you're less likely to get diarrhea, you're more likely to conserve those
- 13:26healthy germs you bring with you when you travel.
- 13:28So that's about hand washing, that's about sensible choosiness when it comes to what you choose to eat, right?
- 13:34And boiling is a Beautiful thing.
- 13:36We talked in our last episode about Cyclospora and by the by that germ, and in fact, essentially all germs are killed by boiling.
- 13:43So if you even take lettuce, which is dubious, if you boil the bejesus out of it, you've killed everything that can make you sick of an organization, organism, nature.
- 13:51And that sounds like a great salad.
- 13:52A boiled lettuce salad.
- 14:00All right, Paul, concerning the gut microbiome, what is the role of probiotics?
- 14:05So what is a probiotic?
- 14:07I like, I like the word pro.
- 14:09It feels very positive.
- 14:10I'm probiotic, who wouldn't be probiotic?
- 14:12So this, I can't actually tell you where the name comes from, but generally speaking, when we talk about probiotics, we're talking about microbes, bacteria, fungi, parasites, anything that is microscopically small, but it's given to people as an intentional
- 14:27dose to try to boost their microbial community in the gut.
- 14:32So probiotics is usually a mixture of different organisms.
- 14:35It's usually bacteria, it usually contains Lactobacillus rhamnosus subtype gg, and it's usually bogus.
- 14:44I mean, there are some reasons to consider doing this and there's even a little bit of evidence for some benefit, but there's a lot of unsubstantiated claims that I have real concerns about.
- 14:55Is it possible to take a pill, a capsule, for example, and undo some of the damage that comes with antibiotics?
- 15:03Well, maybe actually the risk of antibiotic associated diarrhea, which is something many of our listeners will have experienced personally, take an antibiotic, get diarrhea.
- 15:12Why does that happen?
- 15:13Because we're killing off all the healthy germs in the intestine.
- 15:16So it makes good sense that we would just put back what we have killed off.
- 15:19As we mentioned at the top of the show, it's actually very difficult that.
- 15:23Right.
- 15:23Because everybody's community will be different in the gut and we don't have an easy way to study that, short of pooping in a cup and making your own frozen crap souls and then taking your own poop again.
- 15:33I don't know exactly how to do that, by the way.
- 15:35Is anybody out there interested in that topic?
- 15:37Let me know, chat me up on the, on the socials, slip into my DMs.
- 15:41I'm interested in this topic, but anyway, no.
- 15:43Can you go to a grocery store or a pharmacy, get something off the shelf that's made by the millions and have that replenish what we've killed off in your intestines?
- 15:51No, that will not happen, but it does happen to a certain degree.
- 15:55And in fact, when it comes to the risk of antibiotic associated diarrhea, there is a very modest, but I think consistently demonstrated benefit has been shown in a number of clinical trials.
- 16:06It's not a dramatic difference, but there's a slight difference.
- 16:09In my own clinical practice, as somebody who prescribes antibiotics for a living, yes, I do sometimes suggest that people consider taking an over the counter probiotic when they take antibiotics.
- 16:19For those who don't to do it, I have no hesitation.
- 16:21For those who cannot because of very exotic, unusual gut disturbances where the mucous membranes are no good and I don't want to give them a big dose of new bacteria.
- 16:31Occasionally I tell people not to.
- 16:33Usually I leave it up to the patient.
- 16:34If there's something that they've used before, something that they like, I'm okay with that.
- 16:39I do not know which brand is best and I don't know because nobody knows.
- 16:42We have really have not studied this in a way that can give us the great confidence that we would like before we recommend different products to different people.
- 16:50Is it better to take a probiotic that is live and frozen or refrigerated versus those that are on the, on the shelf and lyophilized?
- 16:58They're probably about the same.
- 17:00It's a question of dose, right, Chris?
- 17:01Theoretically, you'll get a higher dose with those that are kept in the fridge instead of on the shelf.
- 17:06But the reality is I cannot tell you that taking a live, refrigerated version is any better than what we would take from the, from the shelf.
- 17:15So are there reasons to do this?
- 17:17You know, if you're going to take antibiotics and you want to do this during an antibiotic course, I think that's perfectly reasonable.
- 17:23Would I give other health claims beyond that for these commercially available products, by the way, none of which are regulated by the fda?
- 17:31No, I do not.
- 17:32They're considered to be food supplements.
- 17:34We don't really fully understand from a quality improvement and quality assurance perspective what's even really, truly in there.
- 17:41So it's a bit of the Wild west when it comes to your colon and the pills that you could put into it from the shelf down at Walgreens.
- 17:48And let me explicitly point out that there has been significant research on the role of probiotics in preventing traveler's diarrhea, and it's been real mixed.
- 17:57But the bottom line conclusion is there's not evidence that taking a probiotic will reduce your risk of traveler's diarrhea.
- 18:03Sad to say, we wish there was.
- 18:06And you know, what about the ultimate probiotic experience?
- 18:09Fecal transplant.
- 18:10Yep.
- 18:11Somebody else's poop up in your own intestines.
- 18:14So fecal microbiota transplant, or fmt, that is a technique which we use in the hospital.
- 18:20It's in a very specific indication, and that's for people who are suffering with severe recurrent refractory Clostridium difficile or C.
- 18:29Diff infection.
- 18:30C.
- 18:30Diff is a dysbiosis.
- 18:32The ultimate dysbiosis.
- 18:33There's nothing left except for C.
- 18:34Diff, which is okay, except C.
- 18:36Diff makes a poison, a cytotoxin that can cause terrible, terrible diarrhea in some cases even life threatening chr.
- 18:43We know that if we can restore that microbial diversity almost instantly, these patients begin to feel better very, very quickly because of the competition in that new microbial community.
- 18:55So that's fmt.
- 18:56You solve the problem of someone who's nuked all of their healthy microbes by giving them antibiotics.
- 19:02Well, what we do is we put back what used to be there.
- 19:04But how do you operationalize that?
- 19:06You know, for many years that was done usually spouse to spouse or sometimes child to parent.
- 19:12You know, a lot of my patients who went through this process were really miffed that they hadn't heard about this sooner.
- 19:18You mean I can take some of my husband's feces and put it up in a milkshake and do a colonoscopy?
- 19:23Make me better.
- 19:23I've been putting up with this shit for years.
- 19:25I'll take a little more.
- 19:26Come on, bring it on.
- 19:26And so usually between married couples, this was okay.
- 19:30The reality is it was the doctors who are more squeamish about it.
- 19:33You do have to take a donated stool specimen from someone who's been screened for a whole, whole variety of infections which might be transmissible.
- 19:39Hepatitis, hiv, you name it.
- 19:41And then they do what comes naturally.
- 19:43Donate some poop, we strain out the food matter, make a very smelly looking brown tea, and then squirt that into the cecum during colonoscopy.
- 19:52It works.
- 19:53Well, it's a hassle.
- 19:54Today in 2026, we have a couple of options that are FDA approved, which are standardized approach.
- 20:01One of them is administered by colonoscopy or even by enema.
- 20:06The other is actually administered by capsules.
- 20:09We call them the crapsules.
- 20:10And people take these lyophilized crapsules, you can repopulate, or as I say, repopulate the gut and make Things better and more natural that way.
- 20:19So it's exciting times.
- 20:21But I just want to emphasize, folks, the indication for that is recurrent refractory, severe C.
- 20:26Difficile.
- 20:26It is not for patients who want to lose weight or look better on the socials or max their appearance or anything else like this.
- 20:36So that's something that you may read about, but it's something that I think the promise we should really focus on is at the moment, quite limited.
- 20:44So, Chris, let's talk about the microbiome.
- 20:45We're talking about why it's this precious resource.
- 20:47Diversity is good.
- 20:49I want you to give me your longtime physician's opinion about what it really is, what we wish it could be.
- 20:56What are the realities of what the microbiome can.
- 20:58Can do?
- 20:59You bet.
- 20:59And I'll also touch on what are the realities of what we know through scientific research and what we're ignorant about.
- 21:04So it is these billions of germs in your gut.
- 21:07Okay, that's normal.
- 21:09What it does, we're still learning.
- 21:12It affects digestion, it affects your mental health.
- 21:14So it affects, I think, your body and your mood and your health from head to toe.
- 21:18It may even have malignancy implications.
- 21:20We have a tremendous amount of information on it.
- 21:23We know the different species, we know their predictions, proportions of different species.
- 21:26We know the different medical illnesses which are associated with different proportions of different species.
- 21:32We know what travel does, we know what antibiotics does.
- 21:35Okay, but what is actionable?
- 21:38That's a huge leap.
- 21:39And the answer is not that much.
- 21:41Currently, as Paul just said, probiotics have not been shown to do much other than reducing the risk of antibiotic associated diarrhea.
- 21:50The microbiome does interact with your brain in some way.
- 21:54It puts out these neurotransmitters, including serotonin and dopamine, but we don't really know what combination is optimal.
- 22:01Now, this is opposed, say, to, let me talk about an older specialty that's better quantified.
- 22:06Cardiology.
- 22:07So in cardiology, we know that if your cholesterol goes up by a certain percentage, then your risk of heart attack and stroke goes up by a certain percentage.
- 22:15We know that exactly.
- 22:16Or if your blood pressure goes up by a certain amount, then your risk of heart attack and stroke goes up by a certain amount.
- 22:21We have nothing close to that with the gut microbiome.
- 22:24Maybe in 20 years, I can tell you, oh, you should have 1,200 different types of bacteria and 21% should be this species of E.
- 22:31Coli.
- 22:31And here's how to make the changes to make that happen.
- 22:33And here are the benefits you will see statistically if we get that mix.
- 22:37We are so far from that now that I'm glad there's ongoing research.
- 22:41But I think all I can say now, now is it's important.
- 22:44And eat your fiber, minimize the booze, don't take antibiotics unless they're really necessary.
- 22:49But is there enough ongoing research?
- 22:51I mean, so the potential promise in this area is felt to be untold, right?
- 22:56Autoimmunity, obesity.
- 22:58Boy, if you take the pellets of poop from a skinny mouse and give it to an obese mouse, the obese mouse gets skinny and vice versa.
- 23:06These experiments in animals have been done for a long time.
- 23:10Translating that into the human experience has yet to happen.
- 23:13Is it possible that we can reduce inflammatory bowel disease, lupus, all kinds of disorders?
- 23:20There's been all these promises about the gut microbiome.
- 23:23Look, today, in 2026, it's just not true.
- 23:26Is it possible that in 2036, 2046, this will come to pass?
- 23:30Maybe.
- 23:30I mean, theoretically some of that might be true, but the only way we can do it, as you said, is through research.
- 23:36And as we slash and burn the American experience with scientific and medical progress by not funding these trials, by stripping NIH to the bone, it just sets us back and it sets up our competitors, by the way, in
- 23:50other countries to do that work.
- 23:51So I think there's a lot that we can do in this area.
- 23:54But I would say that vision is one that's going to be a long game.
- 23:58And I think we need to invest in that research infrastructure.
- 24:00And I think it's premature to start doing things to yourself other than the small number of measures that I mentioned to affect your mix.
- 24:07So if you read an article or see something on TikTok that you should, I don't know, do something to your diet because that'll increase the right species of bacteria, be very suspicious.
- 24:17We're not near that research now, so I don't think there's much currently that is actionable.
- 24:22However, I'm not a GI doc, I'm not a researcher in this area, I'm not a microbiologist.
- 24:27So please, if folks know about studies to the contrary, I'm all ears.
- 24:32Germandwormmail.com.
- 24:41Chris, let me ask you a follow up question.
- 24:43If people are curious about their own microbial community, do you recommend that folks get an analysis of their feces?
- 24:52If you have symptoms, yes, you should have your stool analyzed.
- 24:56If you're just feeling good and want to continue to Feel good.
- 24:59I don't see a benefit in that.
- 25:01Currently, more information is not necessarily helpful.
- 25:05More information is just facts that are.
- 25:08We don't really know what to do with.
- 25:10So if you're asymptomatic.
- 25:12No, personally I would not recommend that at the current time there's any benefit to knowing exactly what your proportion is.
- 25:18I agree.
- 25:18And from just so our listeners understand, if you present to a medical doctor, let's say you have a GI symptom, you've got diarrhea and it's persistent, it's not getting better, you're worried that you may have acquired a treatable
- 25:30infection.
- 25:31We can look, even with a single test, we can look for more than 20 different pathogens.
- 25:38That's a molecular test.
- 25:39It immediately looks for a variety of things that we might choose to treat with antibiotics.
- 25:43That is very different from human microbiome analysis.
- 25:47That's not looking for one specific group of pathogens, that's trying to analyze everything that's in there.
- 25:52That is strict.
- 25:53In my opinion that is strictly for research use.
- 25:55And again, as I said before, we need to do more of this research.
- 25:58But I have to tell you, I do have patients who have come to my practice with a variety of maladies or concerns and some well intentioned person has done the wrong thing, they have sent off that person's poop
- 26:11for a full profile, a full analysis, trying to understand what's in there.
- 26:15Is there a candida in there?
- 26:16Yes, there is.
- 26:17Candida's always in the poop.
- 26:18It's normal, it's not a problem.
- 26:19You know, what are the amounts of enterococcus and E.
- 26:22Coli?
- 26:23I, as a medical doctor, do not know what to do with that.
- 26:26I'm not saying it's useless information.
- 26:27I'm saying it's useless to me because as somebody who has focused on states of health and disease for their entire career, I need that kind of information to be put through a clinical trial.
- 26:37We need rigorous study of this.
- 26:39At the moment, that's totally lacking.
- 26:41If you are feeling well, please do not analyze your poop.
- 26:43And if you're feeling sick, please understand that you probably should also so not analyze your poop.
- 26:47And it would certainly not be to look at the microbiome in that way.
- 26:51At least not outside of a research context.
- 26:53Right.
- 26:53I saw a patient not that long ago, nice man, visiting from Alaska.
- 26:57He had diarrhea.
- 26:58So I did testing and bang.
- 27:00I did that one test that Paul mentioned that checks for 20 things.
- 27:03He had giardia.
- 27:04He got it probably from his.
- 27:05Well Water.
- 27:05I gave him the drug for giardia.
- 27:07He got better.
- 27:08He was happy, I was happy.
- 27:09That's a different case.
- 27:10He was symptomatic.
- 27:12So, sure, if you have pretty much anything of a GI nature, chronic nausea, chronic abdominal pain, chronic diarrhea, chronic constipation.
- 27:19Yeah, see a doc and get some testing.
- 27:21But for the well person, does getting this information add value to your health status currently?
- 27:28I think not.
- 27:29I think that's right.
- 27:30And if we want to convert that kind of question from not helpful to helpful again, it is biomedical research that's going to do that.
- 27:38It's possible that we could invest millions of US dollars of our blood, soil and treasure into this area.
- 27:43And it is a flash in the pan and nothing much comes of it.
- 27:46I doubt it.
- 27:47I actually think there is a lot that's going on here.
- 27:49The gut associated lymphatic tissue, the galt, it's one of our biggest immune organs in the entire body.
- 27:55It's constantly trafficking antigens, what we eat and drink, trying to decide what's healthy, what's nutritious, what's dangerous.
- 28:01It's a very, very immunologically active organization, the intestines.
- 28:05And I think there's a lot to learn from that in states of health and disease.
- 28:09So I really think.
- 28:10I'm not a GI doctor, not even a microbiologist.
- 28:14I just slept at a Holiday Inn Express last night.
- 28:16But I'm telling you right now, this is important stuff.
- 28:18But we have to make that investment.
- 28:20And that's why I'm so eager for us to get a new administration that understands that science is the real thing and that we actually are willing as a society to say this is important.
- 28:29There could be long term benefits.
- 28:31We're going to make an investment, by the way, a very small investment to understand whether these great many fold health benefits may come thereafter.
- 28:48Chris, finally, just let's bring it back home to the reality of someone who is traveling internationally.
- 28:54They do develop diarrhea.
- 28:55It does not get better by itself.
- 28:57It's not bloody, but these patients are having fever.
- 29:00Their illness has gone on for several days.
- 29:02They want to take an antibiotic.
- 29:03To our listeners out there who may consider doing this, what antibiotics should they take and tell me what dose they should use?
- 29:09The antibiotic we give most commonly now for traveler's diarrhea is one called azithromycin.
- 29:15And there's no one standard protocol or dose for treatment of traveler's diarrhea.
- 29:19If I have half a dozen books on tropical medicine, each one has a Bit of a different recommendation.
- 29:25One recommendation is 500 milligrams once, another is one gram once, a thousand milligrams once.
- 29:30Another is 500 milligrams once a day for three days.
- 29:33Another is 500 milligrams Once a day for three days.
- 29:36Stop when better.
- 29:37So if you're better after day two, stop, then the gut microbiome does best with single dose treatment.
- 29:45And that actually is an important takeaway.
- 29:47So rather than two or three days, there's a lot of evidence that single dose treatment is sufficient for traveler's diarrhea.
- 29:54Most books who use the single dose recommend 1 gram.
- 29:59That has a pro and a con.
- 30:00It has a slightly higher cure rate than 500mg once, but it has a significantly higher GI side effect rate.
- 30:07People get abdominal pain, they get nausea doing one gram at once.
- 30:11There is increasing research that 500 milligrams once is sufficient.
- 30:15And there's not that many big a difference in cure rate between 500 milligrams and 1 gram.
- 30:19So bottom line, I think most people would do optimally well with 500mg once.
- 30:25However, that's not standard in every textbook and you'll hear different things from different people.
- 30:29And that's what I do in my own practice and also in my own body.
- 30:33When occasionally I need to do this, that's exactly how I would do it.
- 30:35Remember, my perspective is that as an ID doctor and someone who's been an antibiotic steward for near more than 20 years now.
- 30:43And so that is, I think, a wise word.
- 30:46Sometimes people get upset about this.
- 30:47What do you mean a single dose?
- 30:48Won't that cause resistance?
- 30:49Don't I need to finish my course?
- 30:51Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I submit to you that.
- 30:54No, please.
- 30:55In general, when it comes to antibiotics, less is more.
- 30:58And these long courses of 7 days, 14 days, something that sounds like the days of the week or a football score.
- 31:03It's been done traditionally and from custom, but it's not usually biologically required.
- 31:08Yeah, the fewer explosive depth bombs you drop into your GI tract, the better.
- 31:12Speaking of explosive death bombs, if you are suffering from GI illnesses or diarrhea, we would love to hear from you and figure out why you're sick, where you got sick.
- 31:21Please share that with us.
- 31:22However, no photos.
- 31:24You can send them.
- 31:25We will not look at.
- 31:38Everyone.
- 31:38That's a wrap for episode 110 of Germ and Worm.
- 31:40As always, we really welcome your questions on travel Health.
- 31:43Please send them to us or tips for travel success.
- 31:45Just send us an email germandworm@gmail.com or visit us online germandworm.com if you enjoy what you hear, please subscribe.
- 31:53Rate us favorably right on your device and spread the word with friends, family and on the socials.
- 31:57Those are free ways to support this podcast.
- 31:59Podcast I'm Jer.
- 32:00I'm Worm.
- 32:00It's a big planet.
- 32:01See you in good health.
- 32:02We look forward to seeing you next time.
- 32:04This podcast is designed to inform, inspire, and entertain, but it does not establish a doctor patient relationship and so it should not replace your conversation with a qualified healthcare professional.
- 32:13Please see one before your next adventure.
- 32:15The opinions in this podcast belong to Dr.
- 32:16Sanford and Dr.
- 32:17Pottinger alone and do not necessarily represent the opinions of the University of Washington or UW Medicine.