Latest / Automotive State of The Union / Elon Says “Hang Onto Stock”, Auto Auctions Boom, Consumers Prefer AI In Review Replies
Transcript
- 0:00[gentle music] There you go. Friday time, March 21st. We three-quarters of the way through March? I think we are. So- SoDeCON's coming in.
- 0:09Elon's telling his employees to hang onto their stock, and we're telling you whether or not consumers like AI responses to reviews. Elon's like, "Hold onto your star- stock. Park your cars in your garage." Yeah, yeah.
- 0:24[laughs] Hold onto your stock. Sentry mode on. [laughs] I know. I know. What a wild- That's great... what a wild world. Um, you know- What a wild world... we are three episode... Are we three episodes away or two?
- 0:33Unbelievable. We're two ep- Three. No. Today- Well, if you include the Saturday- Saturday, Monday... yes, Saturday, Monday. Okay, it's three. Three, yeah. If we include today, three episodes away from episode 1,000.
- 0:40Kyle and I have been doing this show for 1,000 episodes- Wow... driving our producer Nathan nuts for 1,000 episodes, and we're- Actually, more like 200 of them. The first 800 it was like, "You know, you're cool."
- 0:53The last 200 is when we've driven him crazy. Yeah, yeah. I'm kidding. [laughs] We're, we're working on it.
- 0:57Well, he, he's actually been, been at work in the back channels putting together a really rip-roaring 1,000th show. Ah. So we're gonna, like, make a deal of it and have a, we have a LinkedIn event.
- 1:07Uh, so if you go to, uh, SoDo on LinkedIn and just click on events, you can now join the livestream event. Kyle's flying into Syracuse. We're gonna set up in the studio. Um- It's gonna be so much fun...
- 1:15we're, we're gonna have a lot of fun. We have, uh, some special guests, some throwbacks, uh, some really fun stats about how many times we've said certain words and done certain things or mentioned certain OEMs.
- 1:26[laughs] So, uh- [laughs]... it'll, it'll be a real, a real walk.
- 1:28And it, all of it, all of it, all 1,000 episodes are really, in our minds and hearts, a tribute to you, who are actually out there every day working the industry, taking care of the people, paying attention to the information, helping one another so we can get better.
- 1:42So it's really about- It's great... a celebration of 1,000 episodes of that. Of this community. Yeah. That's exactly it. That's exactly it. Uh, a- also, we got a SoDeCON coming in hot. Yeah.
- 1:51Obviously, we are like 52 days away from that thing. If you don't have your tickets, get your tickets now, 'cause we, we bumped the prices up, just like everybody in the known universe when it comes to events.
- 2:01[laughs] So you don't wanna, you don't wanna hit the price, uh, the price jump, and you definitely don't wanna miss out on the primary hotel room block. Uh, we've only got a few rooms left, so get in on that.
- 2:10Obviously, if you don't get that, if you're, if you're, you know, a procrastinator, we have other hotels on the docket. But, uh, make sure, you know- And some great ways to get you around- If you know you're coming...
- 2:19from hotel to hotel- Oh... we're about to tell you about. Yes, exactly. It involves Nathan and a motorcycle with a sidecar. [laughs] Can we get that please? Yo. Okay, well.
- 2:30That would be a great publicity stunt, like we just get some motorcycles with some sidecars, and like, hey, if you're, you... Like, we can only take one at a time. Do I, do you imagine?
- 2:38[laughs] Do I have, do I have a say in this? I'm in. Do I have- I'm in on that. I'll do it. I'm volunteering. I will do it. [laughs] I will do it.
- 2:43If you find a motorcycle with a sidecar, I will go to the other hotels and pick people up one at a time. Oh, there's so many people I wanna see in a sidecar with a half helmet on. [laughs] I, I volunteer Bob- In polo...
- 2:54I volunteer Bob Laudam for number one, ride number one. [laughs] Can you, c- could you picture Ben Stock doing that? Uh, I, I- No. I've lost- If it's- I'm all done. [laughs] I see it in my mind's eye. It's unbelievable.
- 3:07[laughs] If you think of all the partnerships that have just come up, I think we should just do a thing, right? Like, now VinQ and Ben Stock are working together, so we got Ben Stock on the bike- Yeah...
- 3:14with Danny in the sidecar. [laughs] Like... [laughs] It's unreal. It's unreal. All right. We need to get AI on this ASAP. Upload some headshots and let this... Let's get this going. [laughs] Oh, sidecars to sidecar.
- 3:25I mean- Everybody's taking their sidecars to SoDeCON... hold on. Here, here's the last magical component of this. Okay. Give it to me. I'm ready. This is a critical component.
- 3:34Oh, scarf on them- The scarf is a critical component-... too, just waving in the background. [laughs]... of any sidecar extravaganza. Come on. And I real- Oh, man. The, the, the ideas just come to me. They just- Yeah.
- 3:46[laughs]... they're just, they just flow. And usually- Unbelievable, Paul... they're super dumb, but every once in a while you hit some magic, and that's wonderful. Yeah. All right. Let's talk about some news, shall we?
- 3:54Um- Speaking of super dumb and every once in a while you, you hit some magic. Hit some magic. [laughs] Ah. Oh, man. It's a Friday. [laughs] Yeah, you can tell. E- Hit 'em with it, Paul...
- 4:06Elon Musk held a surprise all-hands meeting at Tesla's Gigafactory on Thursday night, reassuring employees amidst a steep stock drop in value.
- 4:14He urged employees and investors to, quote, "Hang onto your stock," while prompting Tesla's Cybercab and Optimus... Or promoting the Cybercab and the Optimus robots.
- 4:23He addressed, uh, the stock drop, which has lost roughly half of its value since December, attributing future success to autonomous driving and AI.
- 4:31The operations team being tasked with ramping up Cybercab production, which Musk says will use a high-speed electronics style manufact- manufacturing process.
- 4:40So basically he said these were pushing the limits on manufacturing. I read, I read through most of the meeting.
- 4:46He said, "We're gonna manufacture these cars much more like a consumer electronic would be manufactured, not a car." Mm-hmm.
- 4:53"And we're gonna push the limits of how big of a stamping machine we can actually build and push the limits of physics." Now, this is a crazy Elon Musk statement. He said,
- 5:03"I imagine a world where we can get close to producing a Cybercab in, oh, say five seconds." Excuse me? Uh, yeah. That's what he said. Okay, keep moving. [laughs] Tesla plans- I'm like-... to build... Yeah, I know.
- 5:18I, I had to read it twice. What? But when you look at how they make, like, sophisticated electronics, they make 'em in, like, five seconds. It's like- They do. Yeah... one stamp, two, three, four. Yeah.
- 5:27Drive yourself to the dock. Uh, Tesla plans- Wow... to build thou... It seems so impossible, but they plan to build thousands of humanoid Optimus robots, aiming at producing, guess this, at least one legion.
- 5:38They're using the word, a legion of robots- Oh, no... sounds ominous. I don't love it. I don't love it. No, I, I don't love it.
- 5:43I think the, the, they got a messaging, need to, they get the PR department back a little on that one. Um, this- Call Will Smith about that, right? [laughs] Yeah, it literally, like, conjures all those images.
- 5:53But ba- It does... basically they, a legion, they're saying they have the capability and the parts to manufacture 10,000 robots as of right now in their, in their possession. Wow.
- 6:02They, he said, "But I think we'll probably be able to m- um, manufacture 5,000 by the end of this year."Which is the size of, of Roman legion.
- 6:10Um, Musk admitted he's stretched pretty thin, saying, "I have, like, 17 jobs at this point." Obviously managing multiple companies and, uh, couple two, three government advisory roles. So there you go.
- 6:22Yeah, I mean, I think there are people like this. You, you, you look at a Gary Vee, you look at an Elon Musk, y- you look at even, um, you know, the, a- any, like Zuckerberg, right? Purebred entrepreneur.
- 6:36Any purebred entrepreneur- Right... they are just juggling so many things, and I think some people look at that and go, "There's no way you can do all that." It's just a different type of human, right? Mm.
- 6:45Um, you know, I... It is interesting to see a CEO kind of pulling employees aside and being like, "Hold your stock," right? Um, it, it's a, it, it almost seems a little bit, like, fearful for the first time.
- 7:01Like he's, like he's hanging onto something- Man, I don't-... that doesn't, that doesn't seem- I don't feel that way-... like him... because I- Really? I feel, I feel like, no, it's not...
- 7:08I think what he means, and again, I don't know the man- Right... but I have read the, the really long biography, which helps me understand how he thinks and why he makes decisions.
- 7:17And the holding your stock, I truly believe is his belief that, like, hey, I, if, if the employees dump their stock, right, it doesn't make a massive difference- Right. To him... overall- Yeah...
- 7:27'cause it's a small amount overall. But I think he's like, he wants his people to be like, "No, no, no, no. Hold it. Like, it's gonna go..." 'Cause he was just like, "It's gonna go," like- Tides are gonna turn. Yeah...
- 7:37way higher. And even some of the, like, very well reputable stock analysts still put Tesla's target at, like, 2,200. I'm sure it is. Right? Without a doubt. Because it's not- Like, they're gonna be fine...
- 7:46it's not just about the cars and the Teslas. He, you know, he obviously spoke about the Teslas and, and, but didn't, uh, didn't talk at all about politics. Employees were allowed to ask questions.
- 7:56And so it's really interesting. If you click through the link on the article, the Business Insider article- Yeah... gives, like, a lot of insight and detail on it. So it was open floor for employees to ask question.
- 8:04No one asked any questions about politics. Um, and there you go, so that's just one instance. He, I think he said, like, "I pretty much work, go to sleep, wake up, work, and go to sleep, and I do that seven days a week."
- 8:16Which- Yeah... is something I've heard in the book, right? It's not out of the ordinary for him to just do that. It's just a different type of human.
- 8:21And these different type of humans, like you look at X stock right now, um, it's, it's rebounding fabulously. Different types of humans also just find a way, right?
- 8:30And I think that's, that's, like, where I get, we, we come back to, like, Elon's a car guy, right? They just find a way. Always. The entrepreneurship of a, quote-unquote, car guy, car gal is just w- I'm gonna find a way.
- 8:43Um, so I think, I think T- Tesla's gonna rebound and, and this Cybercab I think, if, if they pull it off, it will be insane. If they- It'll be a massive disruption... if they can pull it off. A lot of questions- Yep...
- 8:53still, but, you know, there you go. Uh, I wish I had a better segue for this one. We don't have a segue today. But, um, a lot of people are trading in their Teslas. Speaking of trade-ins- Hey. [laughs] Segway. Time.
- 9:03[upbeat music] [laughs] Whoops. The National Auto Auction Association reports that 2024 saw the highest number of vehicles sold at auction since 2020, marking a strong recovery for the wholesale market.
- 9:16Uh, their member auctions moved nearly 7.6 million vehicles in 2024, which is a notable rebound of the 12 million vehicles offered, 61.3% were sold, the second-highest conversion rate ever recorded.
- 9:29So these vehicles are rolling. Wow. Average wholesale price fell 5% to 13,921, but volume gains helped drive the total sales to over 105 billion.
- 9:39They credit auctions as, quote, "the backbone of vehicle remarketing, offering vital services, redistribution, logistics, reconditioning, titling, and all those services."
- 9:48Uh, here's a quote from Larry Dixon, Vice President of Auction Data Solutions, says, "Our members reported year-over-year growth despite all the headwinds."
- 9:56Well, you know what I think this actually points to, in my opinion, the, the heightened, the, the increase in wholesale vehicles is because I think that dealers are getting a lot more savvy as to the type of inventory that works for their lot, right?
- 10:12Mm. We haven't seen, like, massive increases in day supply, so it's not like there's a lot of offload and 60, 90-day vehicles- Be more strategic... that are going to that. Mm-hmm.
- 10:20It's, I think it's actually a bit more strategy when people are saying, "That's not the right car for my lot.
- 10:24That's the right car for my lot," and they understand profitability, they understand their c- their buyer base a bit more.
- 10:30And so that's just gonna increase the wholesale market transactions happening because dealers are trying to find the right car for the right lot. Mm-hmm.
- 10:38Well, look, I think dealers are definitely getting smarter about the inventory. This is just another- Yeah... indicator.
- 10:44I love seeing it's high since 2020, you know, that point where everyone, like, sent their stuff to the auction. [laughs] Everybody. I, I still, one of my- They were like, "See you in bye"...
- 10:52one of my, one of my greatest accomplishments, I think, was buying a vehicle right at peak panic mode. That- So smart... is, is, I was like- You just- Uh, I- You just hit the, hit the dial at the right time...
- 11:02I bought a, just the, got a sick deal on a fully loaded Navigator with 45,000 miles. I got it for 58 grand. [laughs] So silly.
- 11:10I flew, I had to fly, fly to Milwaukee to get it, but there was no one on the plane, so that was fine, too. Yeah. And the toll booths were all closed on the way home, so. [laughs] Oh my goodness.
- 11:18You were, you just ca- got out of it so easy. I know. Unbelievable. I know. I know. Unbelievable. All right. What are we talking about? We're talking about reviews. We're talking about reviews. Reviews.
- 11:26Who should respond to online reviews is a question, uh, that Bright Local's Consumer Review Survey has been trying to answer, as they found that consumers actually prefer an AI-generated response- Ooh...
- 11:37over those written by humans. Very interesting. In two separate tests, a restaurant in 2024 and a vet clinic in 2025, 58% of respondents preferred AI-generated responses over human-written ones.
- 11:48So just slightly tipping, uh, the 50/50 scale. Right, this isn't saying that they knew it was AI. Right. Exactly. Right. Yeah. It's just, like, they preferred it, they engaged with it. The way it responded, what it said.
- 11:57They, yeah. Yeah. Exactly. 89% of consumers are more likely to shop at a business that responds to reviews, while 56 hesita- 56% hesitate if a business ignores them. So that review response is extremely important.
- 12:10While cu- consumers prefer AI-written responses, 46% also say reviews-... quote, "feel fake if they, uh, seem," and I- Seem AI generated... review responses feel fake if they seem AI generated. Yeah.
- 12:24So just if there's like a sniff of it. Um, yeah, similar kind of interaction with social media posts, ads, all of that type of stuff.
- 12:32I think, you know, I was actually talking to a buddy yesterday that there's, there's a, a growing audience that understands, like, what to look for, you know? Mm-hmm.
- 12:41Um, and the, the wider the adoption rate of AI, the more people are gonna be keen to the, like, what to watch out for- Yeah... with AI. Yeah. So I think that this, this may change over the next year. Yeah, it will.
- 12:53It will. Well, so here's, here are a couple sample responses, right? You're like, "Well, how different do they sound?"
- 12:57So, uh, I'm gonna read a response, the human response first that was generated, then the AI response they tested it up against, seeing which one, uh, humans responded to better. Here's the AI... Here's the human version.
- 13:09"Denise, we appreciate the confidence you have in Dr. Evans and the entire team at Animal Hospital. We value senior dogs as much as young pups, and do everything in our power to keep them all healthy.
- 13:17Thank you so much for your kind remarks and terrific five-star review. It means so much to us." That's the human. Here- Here's the AI. Okay. "Sup, dog. I'm just kidding." [laughs] "You did-" That was well played.
- 13:30That'd be a good one. Well played. No, written by AI. [laughs] "Thank you so much, Denise, for your kind words and trusting us with the care of your senior pup. Dr.
- 13:37Evans and our entire team truly enjoy being here for you both. We're so happy to hear that you feel comfortable with the care we provided.
- 13:42Supporting pets and their families is what we're all about, and it means the world to us to know that we've earned your trust. We look forward to many more happy visits with you and your furry companion.
- 13:50Warm regards, Animal Hospital." The AI one's better. It, it absolutely is. It feels more human. [laughs] So I asked...
- 13:57I, I, when, when we were gonna do this story, I asked GPT, I said, "Why would people prefer AI responses to r- to reviews over human responses?" And I think that there's a couple things in here.
- 14:09One was consistency in tone and quality. So when you think about, like, just, okay, review after review, and when people are, like, looking at these review responses, is there quality? Is grammar there?
- 14:21Is professionalism there? Um, speed and responsiveness, always on availability. I think that this is the big one.
- 14:28Um, and, and this is the one that, like, this is hard to do as a human, but emotionally neutral and professional. AI doesn't get defensive, sarcastic, or flustered, which is- Ooh...
- 14:38especially valuable for responding to negative reviews. It keeps things calm and constructive. And I think that that can be balanced on both sides.
- 14:47So it may even be a place where, like, if you want a human response, hey, hit GPT for emo- is this emotionally neutral and profesh- professional, before you respond to something, even if you wanna actually type the words to make it feel more human.
- 15:02Because that's where people can, like, really sniff out, you know, a review to a negative response that has some, you know, vindictive nature to it- Yeah... or something. You know. So. You, you get, get this.
- 15:13I just dropped both responses into GPT and I said, "Which one was more likely written by a human?" It says the second one. Aw. It fooled itself. Fooled itself.
- 15:25It says it feels more genuine and conversational with phrasing like, "So happy to hear," "Being here for you both and furry companion." It uses empathetic language like, "You mean the world to us."
- 15:35It says the s- the structure and flow sounds more like a spoken note or a tone, and subtlety in expression. So there you go. Yeah. AI thinks AI sounds more like a human.
- 15:43Well, because I think our, like, our native human instinct when writing professional elements is to over-professionalize it sometimes. Yes. Oh, absolutely. Right? And that's, that's where we get into trouble.
- 15:54It's a major turnoff. Watch out. People are like, "This isn't real. This is fake." Hey, we hope we delivered on episode 100,997. I mean, we just try to give it our best swing every day. Every day.
- 16:04Episode 1,000 coming up in three episodes, but go to asotocon.com and be with us in person in May.
- 16:11[upbeat music]