Latest / Kernow Damo / Arrest Backfires in Israel as Whistle-blower Scandal Explodes!

Transcript

Arrest Backfires in Israel as Whistle-blower Scandal Explodes! · Kernow Damo

• 0:00
  Right, so imagine being Israel's top military
• 0:03
  lawyer, years spent defending the most moral
• 0:06
  army in the world, inverted commas, turning war
• 0:09
  crimes into paperwork as that entails, and then
• 0:12
  one day realising the paperwork itself has become
• 0:14
  the crime. That was Yifat Tomer Yerushalmi. She
• 0:18
  leaked the footage from Stey Taiman, soldiers
• 0:20
  assaulting a bound Palestinian prisoner. She
• 0:23
  was the whistleblower. She resigned. She vanished.
• 0:26
  She was found again, and was promptly arrested.
• 0:29
  Soldiers, though, out on bail, arguing due process.
• 0:32
  The whistleblower treated like a spy, though.
• 0:35
  That's Israel's most moral army for you, though,
• 0:37
  isn't it? Aside from all of their misconduct
• 0:40
  on the battlefield, back at home torture gets
• 0:42
  court management, truth gets handcuffs, and the
• 0:45
  best part? The system thinks it's proving its
• 0:47
  own integrity by prosecuting the only honest
• 0:49
  person in uniform. They tried to bury a whistleblower
• 0:52
  and instead the state has indicted itself once
• 0:55
  more as amoral, bereft of legitimacy, and worthy
• 0:58
  crime of speaking out is the worst crime of all.
• 1:02
  Right, so Israel's top military lawyer leaked
• 1:04
  proof of a war crime committed by her own state
• 1:06
  military. How mad a sentence is that at any time,
• 1:09
  anywhere? Instead of addressing what is a massive
• 1:12
  scandal in any other state, the system she served
• 1:15
  came for her instead of for the soldiers. Major
• 1:18
  General Yifat Tomer Yerushalmi wasn't some dissident
• 1:21
  clerk, she was the head of the army's law machine,
• 1:24
  the woman who signed off every operation the
• 1:26
  politicians called legal. When she confirmed
• 1:29
  she'd leaked the Steve Tayman video, soldiers
• 1:31
  surrounding a restrained Palestinian prisoner
• 1:33
  and assaulting him, she didn't just break secrecy,
• 1:36
  she broke the illusion that the law still ruled.
• 1:39
  She resigned last Friday over it, but by Sunday
• 1:41
  she'd gone missing. Her car abandoned on a Tel
• 1:45
  Aviv beach, a letter at home that made her family
• 1:47
  fear the worst. Hours later police said she was
• 1:50
  safe, and then they arrested her. The soldiers
• 1:53
  stayed free, the lawyer went in cuffs. That's
• 1:56
  Israel's moral order laid out in sequence for
• 1:58
  you. Ste Tamon isn't a secret anymore. It's a
• 2:02
  desert compound where Palestinians are dumped
• 2:04
  after raids. Shackled, blindfolded, left unnamed.
• 2:08
  It's a place notorious for beatings, medical
• 2:10
  neglect and deaths in custody. Physicians for
• 2:13
  human rights Israel called it a torture site.
• 2:16
  The government called it lawful. The footage
• 2:18
  made those denials collapse, though. Nine reservists
• 2:21
  questioned, five indicted for severe abuse, but
• 2:24
  not for anything more severe than that. Their
• 2:26
  lawyers now say the case must be dropped because
• 2:28
  the leak hurt the army. The IDF has a hurtie.
• 2:32
  Well, you can't put a plaster on a snowflake,
• 2:34
  I'm afraid, but that's the defence. Exposure,
• 2:37
  not assault, that's the injury. When a state
• 2:40
  prosecutes the proof before the crime, you know
• 2:42
  what kind of law it's practicing. Israel's leaders
• 2:45
  didn't call it cover -up, they called it security.
• 2:47
  Defence Minister of the demented Israel Katz
• 2:50
  said the leak was a severe violation of discipline.
• 2:52
  Far -right Finance Minister Bezalel Smotrich
• 2:54
  said those who leak endanger us all. No -one
• 2:57
  promised to close the camp though. The emergency
• 3:00
  was the truth. The press followed the cue. Herets
• 3:03
  kept to the facts. Search letter to arrest. The
• 3:06
  tabloids went for total character assassination.
• 3:09
  Unstable under strain. Channel 14 anchors demanded
• 3:12
  punishment. Overnight the narrative turned from
• 3:14
  torture to gossip about a woman's nerves. As
• 3:17
  you erase a scandal in real time you question
• 3:20
  the witness. Inside the army panic passed for
• 3:23
  discipline. The military advocate general's office
• 3:26
  exists to give operations a legal gloss. Once
• 3:29
  its chief becomes a defendant though every past
• 3:31
  opinion starts to look like a cover note. The
• 3:34
  institution that certified the Gaza war as legal
• 3:37
  has now indicted its own proof of illegality
• 3:39
  and so the contradiction is total. Law and power
• 3:42
  can't coexist. One has to serve the other. In
• 3:45
  Israel, power won that fight long ago. Of course
• 3:49
  what is happening now isn't new. It's all been
• 3:51
  done before. Mordecai Vannunu infamously blew
• 3:54
  the whistle and showed the world the nuclear
• 3:56
  stockpile. Israel still denies that it exists
• 3:59
  all the way back in 1986 and he got 18 years,
• 4:02
  11 in solitary for that. And at CAM leaked documents
• 4:06
  proving illegal assassinations and got four and
• 4:08
  a half. Breaking the silence collected soldiers'
• 4:11
  testimonies about what they had been up to and
• 4:13
  released them, resulting in them being banned
• 4:15
  from schools. Every time the pattern held. Crimes
• 4:19
  are tolerable, but disclosure isn't. Tomi Erashalmi
• 4:22
  knew that pattern and leaked anyway. That is
• 4:26
  courage in a country that treats honesty as sabotage,
• 4:28
  isn't it? Her family's fear wasn't melodrama
• 4:31
  either, therefore it was precedent. In Israel,
• 4:34
  telling the truth can end your life as you know
• 4:36
  it. When she vanished, people didn't imagine
• 4:39
  arrest, they imagined revenge. She came back
• 4:41
  alive, but indicted. The law she once defended
• 4:44
  now calls her its enemy. The same command that
• 4:47
  ignored abuse in the desert now hunts leaks in
• 4:49
  the capital. They call it order restored, but
• 4:52
  look closer. The order is silence. Every authoritarian
• 4:56
  habit Israel denies owning is written into this
• 4:59
  case. Secrecy is virtue. Loyalty as morality,
• 5:02
  punishment as proof of control. A government
• 5:05
  that can't refute evidence redefines it as treason.
• 5:09
  That's why her trial has to happen behind closed
• 5:11
  doors now, because sunlight is lethal to the
• 5:14
  myth. The gender smear was no accident either.
• 5:18
  The first woman to run the Advocate General's
• 5:20
  office exposes male soldiers for sexual violence
• 5:23
  and suddenly she's fragile. The ridicule about
• 5:27
  breakdowns and hysteria Wasn't cultural noise,
• 5:30
  it was message discipline. Power reasserting
• 5:33
  who's allowed to speak for the army. A woman
• 5:36
  telling the truth shames the hierarchy twice,
• 5:38
  once for the crime, once for needing her to hide
• 5:41
  it. Abroad the fallout has begun in the quiet
• 5:44
  language diplomats use when they're cornered,
• 5:46
  under strain, complicates cooperation. We continue
• 5:49
  to monitor. Those phrases mean one thing. The
• 5:53
  story's indefensible. Washington and Brussels
• 5:56
  built their defence of Israel on robust internal
• 5:58
  oversight, but oversight just got arrested, didn't
• 6:01
  it? So worm your way out of that one now. The
• 6:03
  legal firewall keeping the ICC at bay is crumbling
• 6:06
  line by line, warrant by warrant. You can almost
• 6:09
  hear the lawyers in the Hague marking her name
• 6:11
  as corroboration now. According to media reports,
• 6:15
  officers inside Israel's legal corps have begun
• 6:17
  conveying decisions verbally instead of recording
• 6:20
  them, a change triggered by the Ste Tamon leak.
• 6:23
  Military lawyers said the episode sent shockwaves
• 6:25
  through the core. In practice, the institution
• 6:28
  that once sold moral superiority through self
• 6:31
  -investigation now behaves like one afraid of
• 6:33
  its own paperwork, guarding not legality but
• 6:36
  deniability. The political culture turns the
• 6:39
  screw even more. National security has become
• 6:42
  a religion with one commandment, thou shalt not
• 6:45
  embarrass the army. Everything else, journalism,
• 6:49
  law, conscience, is all subordinate. Israeli
• 6:52
  commentators on several domestic channels even
• 6:54
  suggested she should have been kept under supervision
• 6:57
  to prevent further leaks, describing it as protection.
• 7:00
  Protection for the state, not for her of course.
• 7:03
  Many high -ranking figures don't want her to
• 7:05
  open her mouth, the anchors said. No outrage
• 7:07
  followed that. In Israel that kind of statement
• 7:09
  passes for normal. Abuse of Palestinians can
• 7:13
  still be managed through the usual euphemisms
• 7:15
  though. Irregularities, disciplinary measures,
• 7:19
  isolated incident. But a senior officer defying
• 7:22
  the gag is something else. It shows the machine
• 7:25
  is cracking from the inside. Her confession turned
• 7:27
  a human rights allegation into legal fact. That's
• 7:30
  why the reaction had to be swift, had to be public
• 7:33
  and punishing. The leak threatened the currency
• 7:35
  Israel trades in, moral legitimacy. Without it
• 7:39
  every ally's defense falls apart. At the disciplinary
• 7:42
  level and at the diplomatic level that's already
• 7:45
  happening. The ICC can now argue that Israel's
• 7:48
  military justice system isn't independent. The
• 7:50
  argument writes itself, doesn't it? When the
• 7:52
  head of the system is prosecuted for exposing
• 7:54
  abuse, there can clearly be no internal remedy
• 7:57
  for that. The jurisdiction door opens. Israel's
• 8:00
  allies know it, which is why their statements
• 8:02
  have shrunk to murmurs. They can't afford to
• 8:05
  acknowledge what this looks like. A democratic
• 8:08
  partner under stress, that's how they'll phrase
• 8:10
  it until the headlines move on. But the files
• 8:13
  will stay open. At home the case deepens to rot.
• 8:17
  Legality in Israel now operates like a broadcast
• 8:19
  for foreign consumption. Every inquiry is staged
• 8:21
  for optics. Every minor conviction offered as
• 8:24
  proof that the system still functions. But the
• 8:27
  facade has cracked. Tomer Yerushalmi exposed
• 8:30
  the gap between what Israel tells the world and
• 8:32
  what it does in the dark. The few Israelis who
• 8:35
  still believe the law can mean something are
• 8:36
  watching institutions that no longer believe
• 8:39
  it themselves. Officials going through the motions
• 8:41
  of justice while dreading what real justice would
• 8:44
  expose. They're terrified of justice in other
• 8:47
  words. They're cowards. Snowflakes. Pick your
• 8:49
  poison. The army says her prosecution is necessary
• 8:53
  to protect national security. What is protecting
• 8:55
  is reputation. The phrase security now means
• 8:58
  control of narrative. Justice means containment.
• 9:01
  Accountability means a press conference. It's
• 9:03
  not self -correction. It's self -preservation.
• 9:06
  A state that equates exposure with danger. will
• 9:08
  always choose ignorance. And that's where Israel
• 9:11
  stands now, a country claiming to defend civilisation
• 9:14
  by criminalising conscience. The machinery still
• 9:18
  works, the moral engines blown itself to bits,
• 9:21
  though. What you're seeing now is legality drained
• 9:23
  of all meaning, form without function, rules
• 9:26
  without conviction. And the advocate general
• 9:28
  who proved it has been erased from the very system
• 9:31
  she once upheld, treated not as a guardian of
• 9:33
  law, but as a threat to its illusion. The deeper
• 9:36
  you look, the clearer it gets. This isn't a scandal,
• 9:39
  it's an x -ray. You can see the whole structure,
• 9:42
  the political spine, the legal muscle, the press
• 9:45
  nerves, all tightening around the same reflex.
• 9:48
  Protect the image. That's the unspoken law of
• 9:52
  Israeli power. The state can absorb atrocity,
• 9:54
  but it can't absorb shame. It can't tolerate
• 9:57
  that. And what Tomer Yerushalmi leaked was shame
• 10:00
  in its purest form, filmed, authenticated and
• 10:04
  undeniable. The government's line never changes.
• 10:08
  They say these are isolated lapses, that the
• 10:10
  moral fabric of the army remains intact. But
• 10:13
  a moral fabric that tears every time someone
• 10:15
  tells the truth isn't fabric, it's camouflage.
• 10:18
  Each case they dismiss as exceptional is proof
• 10:21
  of the exceptions of the rule. Steve Tayman was
• 10:23
  supposed to be an off -book holding area, a necessary
• 10:26
  roughness of war. Instead it became a crime scene.
• 10:30
  And the person who said so out loud was the one
• 10:32
  who wrote the laws. That's the nightmare for
• 10:35
  Israel here. Not that the world might see the
• 10:37
  footage, but that Israelis might see what their
• 10:39
  law has become. What's the language the press
• 10:42
  uses? National trauma, sensitive material, breach
• 10:45
  of trust. Every word chosen to suggest confusion
• 10:48
  rather than intention. But nothing here is confused.
• 10:52
  The soldiers made choices. The government made
• 10:54
  choices. The prosecutors now charging the whistleblower
• 10:57
  are making choices. The paperwork tells the story
• 11:00
  if you read what's missing. No charge of rape,
• 11:02
  no instigation into command responsibility, no
• 11:06
  protection for the source. Every omission is
• 11:08
  a confession. Abroad officials pretend distance.
• 11:11
  The White House calls it an internal matter.
• 11:13
  The Foreign Office says Israel's legal system
• 11:16
  is capable of dealing with it. But capable of
• 11:18
  what? Capable of arresting its own conscience?
• 11:21
  Certainly. Capable of restoring credibility?
• 11:23
  Not a chance. Each line of diplomatic caution
• 11:27
  reads like complicity. They need Israel to look
• 11:30
  lawful, so they pretend this is law in action.
• 11:32
  But it's not law, it's maintenance. Inside Israel's
• 11:36
  legal core, the chill is already setting in.
• 11:38
  Officers whisper that they'll refuse certain
• 11:40
  assignments. Others update their wills. Not because
• 11:43
  they expect death, because they expect disgrace.
• 11:46
  When telling the truth becomes a security offence,
• 11:49
  everyone with access to the truth becomes a liability.
• 11:52
  That's how institutions die. Not with riots,
• 11:54
  but with silence. People stop writing, they stop
• 11:57
  arguing, they stop remembering. Look at what's
• 11:59
  happened to language itself. National security
• 12:02
  means protecting the myth. Integrity means obedience.
• 12:05
  Transparency means whatever the censor allows.
• 12:09
  The same terms that once described democracy
• 12:11
  now describe control. This is what happens when
• 12:15
  a country wages a permanent war and calls it
• 12:17
  normal life. The war comes home. It starts policing
• 12:20
  its own lawyers. And there's a personal dimension
• 12:23
  that never makes it into the headlines too. A
• 12:25
  woman who spent her career proving Israel's legality
• 12:28
  ended up proving its corruption. She broke rank
• 12:31
  because her conscience finally outweighed her
• 12:33
  fear. For that she's in custody, labelled a traitor.
• 12:37
  The soldiers she exposed walked free. That contrast
• 12:40
  is the whole story. Israel didn't just arrest
• 12:44
  a whistleblower, it arrested the idea that legality
• 12:46
  might still mean decency. And yet our act changed
• 12:50
  the terrain. The footage is evidence now. It's
• 12:52
  in the hands of the ICC, the UN, every major
• 12:54
  human rights body. The more Israel suppresses
• 12:57
  it, the more official it becomes. You can't un
• 12:59
  -leak the truth. You can only prove over and
• 13:02
  over that you're scared of it. And that's the
• 13:04
  paradox they built for themselves. Every punishment
• 13:07
  becomes another disclosure. Every gag order reads
• 13:11
  like a confession of what they're hiding. Western
• 13:13
  politicians will keep calling Israel a democracy
• 13:15
  until the phrase loses all oxygen, but... Democracies
• 13:19
  don't need to jail their lawyers to stay upright.
• 13:22
  Democracies don't vanish people for a day and
• 13:24
  then parade them in court for leaking proof of
• 13:27
  abuse. Democracies don't downgrade the most serious
• 13:30
  sexual assault to severe misconduct. These aren't
• 13:34
  democratic mistakes, they're the authoritarian
• 13:36
  instincts performed in a democratic costume.
• 13:39
  The uniform doesn't make the system clean, it
• 13:41
  makes the system look civilized whilst it rots
• 13:43
  from the inside out. The bigger collapse is moral.
• 13:46
  For decades Israel sold the line of being the
• 13:48
  most moral army in the world. It's in every briefing,
• 13:52
  every embassy talking point, every sympathetic
• 13:54
  newspaper column. That line kept the weapons
• 13:57
  flowing and the criticism muted. Now the army's
• 14:00
  own lawyer has proved that morality was just
• 14:02
  paperwork. You can't rebuild that with press
• 14:05
  releases. Once your own conscience testifies
• 14:08
  against you, the trial's already over. The state
• 14:11
  can still convict her, it can strip her pension.
• 14:13
  gag the hearings, reassign the judges, it can
• 14:16
  even destroy the footage. But what it can't destroy
• 14:18
  is the order of events. The abuse happened, the
• 14:21
  leak happened, the arrest happened, in that sequence
• 14:24
  on record beyond spin. That timeline will outlive
• 14:28
  every career involved. One day when the court
• 14:31
  files open it'll read like an autopsy of legality.
• 14:35
  This is where Israel finds itself now, a state
• 14:37
  defending its reputation with the tools of repression
• 14:40
  it used to deny owning. The same logic that built
• 14:43
  the occupation is now policing the truth. You
• 14:45
  can't call that democracy, you can only call
• 14:47
  it decay. Tomi Erashalmi's disappearance, her
• 14:51
  letter, her arrest, these are not footnotes of
• 14:53
  the anatomy of a government afraid of its own
• 14:55
  reflection. For a moment when she was missing
• 14:58
  the mass slipped, Israelis saw what it means
• 15:00
  to live in a country where honesty is a hazard.
• 15:03
  Finding her alive didn't close the wound, it
• 15:05
  marked it. The wound is trust and it's bleeding
• 15:08
  out through every courtroom door. History will
• 15:11
  remember her differently from the way the headlines
• 15:13
  frame her now, not as a traitor, not as unstable,
• 15:16
  but as the point where the system confessed.
• 15:19
  She didn't leak secrets, she leaked reality,
• 15:21
  and the reaction proved that reality is the one
• 15:23
  thing this Israeli state cannot survive. They
• 15:27
  can keep her under house arrest, they can drag
• 15:29
  the case through years of hearings, they can
• 15:31
  rewrite the law to make sure no one ever tries
• 15:33
  it again. But the story is fixed. The world has
• 15:37
  seen who gets punished and who doesn't. the soldiers'
• 15:40
  names will fade, hers won't. Israel wanted to
• 15:43
  bury the whistleblower, it buried its own pretence
• 15:45
  of having law of integrity instead. And no amount
• 15:49
  of silence will learn a thought. Speaking of
• 15:52
  matters of honesty and integrity though, the
• 15:54
  very basis for Israel's wars is now a matter
• 15:57
  of conjecture in such regards. So desperate is
• 16:00
  Netanyahu for an all -new war front, it seems,
• 16:02
  he's now basically made one up. And no, I'm not
• 16:05
  kidding. Check out this video recommendation
• 16:07
  here. as you're suggested next watch to find
• 16:09
  out more. Please do also hit like, share and
• 16:11
  subscribe if you haven't done so already, so
• 16:13
  as to ensure you don't miss out on all new daily
• 16:15
  content. Sort of spreading the word and helping
• 16:17
  to support the channel at the same time, which
• 16:18
  is very much appreciated. Holding power to account
• 16:20
  for ordinary working class people. I'll hopefully
• 16:23
  catch you on the next vid. Cheers folks.