Latest / Politics with Paul / Politics with Paul #52: Teaching and Preserving Political History and Civics w/ Alex Vassar
Transcript
- 0:00Welcome back to the Politics with Paul podcast.
- 0:02I'm your host, Paul Rader.
- 0:05We've got another great episode on tap because it won't be just me droning on.
- 0:09No.
- 0:09No.
- 0:09No.
- 0:09We have another guest.
- 0:11I always lead off guest episodes by saying I do not take specific stances for or against
- 0:16anybody's political views or any political groups they belong to, but that hasn't been a
- 0:20concern so far, and it's not today either because today we're talking about the
- 0:23importance of the preservation of political history.
- 0:27But it's not just because as the old saying more or less goes, those who do not know the
- 0:32mistakes of the past are doomed to repeat them.
- 0:35It's also about knowing why we got to where we are and how to improve things.
- 0:39So how do we best preserve political history?
- 0:43How do we make that history more accessible and engaging for other people, especially if
- 0:47they're not as interested in history?
- 0:50And these are just a couple key questions, not just for my own work, but for the work of my
- 0:54guest today, Alex Vassar.
- 0:56Alex is an historian and the communications manager for the California State Library.
- 1:02In 2,005, he founded joincalifornia.com, which is a repository and treasure trove of political
- 1:09history and data for the state of California going back to its early days of statehood.
- 1:13He's also the founder of the One Voter Project, which describes itself as an attempt to
- 1:18increase civic engagement or involvement, excuse me, in California, educating the public
- 1:23about the rich political history of California through joincalifornia.com and encouraging
- 1:28involvement in the current politics.
- 1:30So let's talk about that work in preserving and teaching political history and some lessons for
- 1:35other states undertaking the same endeavors.
- 1:38Please welcome Alex Vassar.
- 1:41Alex, how are you doing today?
- 1:42Doing good.
- 1:42Thank you for having me on the show, Paul.
- 1:44I really appreciate it.
- 1:45Yeah.
- 1:45No.
- 1:45I appreciate you being on here.
- 1:47So I wanna get back to the beginning for you because Yeah.
- 1:51I've mentioned Join California and One Voter Project, California State Library, but let's go
- 1:56before that because you've also worked in various capacities in state and local
- 2:00government as well.
- 2:01So what were your earliest experiences that led you to this interest in politics and in
- 2:06history?
- 2:07I grew up in Monterey County, California, which is on the Central Coast.
- 2:12And it's, it's where Steinbeck was from.
- 2:14It's, it's an interesting area.
- 2:16And so you kind of, you have a connection to the past there.
- 2:18It was, it was also prior to California becoming a U.
- 2:21S.
- 2:22State, Monterey was the, the longtime capital, during the Mexican era and back into the
- 2:27Spanish era.
- 2:28And so, being able to go places and see where people had, you know, done things, where people
- 2:35had lived their lives, was just really, really interesting.
- 2:37And so kind of had that interest as I went into college and became a history major.
- 2:42Turned out I was not a good history major.
- 2:45That came as quite a shock.
- 2:46I loved history and started as a history major and the way that they do it in California as
- 2:52they do in most of these places is they start you with the way far back.
- 2:56And I, I couldn't keep track of the ancient civilizations.
- 3:02I just, I could not keep track of.
- 3:03I was much more interested kind of in the more modern history where you can actually meet
- 3:08folks who have lived a certain era and and and understand by talking to them what that was
- 3:13like.
- 3:13And so that was kinda my introduction to this this strange and crazy world that we're
- 3:18navigating now.
- 3:20Yeah.
- 3:20This is it's a little similar for me.
- 3:22There is a point where it gets too far back that it's it's it's not something I can quite
- 3:28grasp it at least as well as as other people.
- 3:30I definitely am a little bit more modern.
- 3:33I guess, 250 years.
- 3:35I mean, depends on lots of people say that modern is, like, 500 years old or whatever, but
- 3:40I I don't I don't really get that definition.
- 3:43But that's another here and are there.
- 3:44So I mentioned that you founded joincalifornia.com in 02/2005.
- 3:49And over the course of twenty years, it is built up an immense database of information
- 3:56about California's political history.
- 3:59And I I I've found a couple of places sorta like it, but so far, I haven't quite want found
- 4:05one that's quite in-depth as Join California's is.
- 4:08So what convinced you of the need to build this project?
- 4:12That's you know, I I always like to attribute stuff to questionable life choices.
- 4:18Questionable life choices led me here.
- 4:20I, I was a political science major, and, that was high end.
- 4:23I started a history major.
- 4:24Ended up as political science and was doing a research project for, a paper that I was
- 4:29writing.
- 4:32And so built up a collection, kind of a well, I think it was about twenty years of statewide
- 4:36election results into a single spreadsheet.
- 4:38So you just so you could see who received the most votes, who received the fewest votes, and
- 4:43which is really another interesting area where you look at, like, different districts, at
- 4:47least in California, you know, are drawn with equal populations, but voter turnout is
- 4:51significantly different with different populations.
- 4:53And so you end up with massive discrepancies in the number of votes that people are elected
- 4:57with.
- 4:58So I I was working on all this, and a good friend of mine, said, why why don't you put
- 5:03this online?
- 5:05I said, well, who else would ever want to see this?
- 5:08I I I imagine most people live far more interesting lives than I do and, and would they
- 5:13would have no time for this.
- 5:14And he's like, no.
- 5:14No.
- 5:15This this could be good.
- 5:15And so, Shane Myers, actually, wrote the script that turned an Excel spreadsheet into the basis
- 5:23for this website.
- 5:24Then we were able to go in and put in a little bit more information, biologically not
- 5:28biological, biographical information about the different folks.
- 5:32And when I start getting interesting because you start running into when you're dealing with
- 5:36people's lives, people are all interesting.
- 5:41You very rarely whenever you find somebody that's not particularly interesting, it's
- 5:46generally, you know, you're looking at folks as a group.
- 5:47Oh, I I don't really like dentists.
- 5:50It's like, no.
- 5:50No.
- 5:51Like but you look at a specific dentist, and it's like, how did how did you end up, wanting
- 5:55to spend your life with your fingers in somebody else's mouth?
- 5:58And and it it's, it's fascinating.
- 6:00Like, individuals are are fascinating.
- 6:03And so just kinda getting into that was, kind of where where things really started expanding.
- 6:09Yeah.
- 6:09I I'm I kind of I like knowing those random tidbits of history partly to make myself sound
- 6:16more interesting than I actually am.
- 6:18They're like, if I just talk to somebody like, hey.
- 6:20You know this really weird thing that they more than likely won't care about, but it's I I
- 6:25still think it's it's it's funny and or interesting to to learn about.
- 6:29And I I'm trying to build up maybe not something quite similar to join California, but
- 6:35I I've been I've been trying to find, like, a partisan history of of of like, an all
- 6:40encompassing partisan history of The United States.
- 6:44And I have I've personally never found it, so I've I've been I don't know how long it's gonna
- 6:50be till I really get to make it fully public, but I've been building up this political
- 6:55history database of sorts myself doing it from the both for federal and state level because I
- 7:01think that state level stuff is is also just as fascinating.
- 7:04Obviously, we most of the focus is on the federal level, but there's so much more that's
- 7:10that's fascinating at the state level.
- 7:14So actually just made me think now.
- 7:15So what are some of the what are some of the sources that have really helped you to put
- 7:20these these this information together?
- 7:24And, obviously, you've got official lecture results from the secretary of state for
- 7:28California.
- 7:28But Yep.
- 7:29What what are some of the other ways that you found this information?
- 7:31So so starting at the the the basic, building blocks were the election results, and,
- 7:36California has published election results.
- 7:38So California was became a state 1850, and it was about 1892 ish, 1890, 1892, where the state
- 7:45of California, the secretary of state started publishing election results.
- 7:48And so you go prior to that, and it's a nightmare.
- 7:50It's it's It's all over the place.
- 7:53And I think most folks don't know that is election results were not published as a
- 7:58document.
- 7:59Right now it's so easy.
- 8:00But, yeah, back in the day, it was, you're relying on newspaper records.
- 8:04They would count the votes.
- 8:05They'd publish in the newspaper, but they would generally only publish your local results.
- 8:09And so, to the extent I could, using election results for 1890 onward.
- 8:16And then prior to that, a lot of what I was doing was just basing it on, who served in the
- 8:22legislature.
- 8:22So you don't necessarily know who lost, in a lot of these elections, but you know who
- 8:26served.
- 8:26And so you can kind of put them in and say, oh, they won.
- 8:30Not sure how many votes or who they ran against, but, you start with that.
- 8:34And then there's a publication that a lot of states used to do called the Blue Book.
- 8:39It was really, really popular.
- 8:40And so California published, we did our Blue Book from 1890, 1888 to 1975, And stopped in
- 8:50'75.
- 8:51We did one more in in, February, and then we haven't done one since.
- 8:54So in the last fifty years, we've only had one edition that's come out, which is really
- 8:59unfortunate because it's it's such a great it's got, biographies of the members, descriptions
- 9:03of the different departments within state government, which I always think kinda gives
- 9:08you insights into the problems that the state is trying to solve and also the the mechanisms
- 9:13the state is using to try to solve them.
- 9:15And so, yeah, just, that was a great resource.
- 9:18And then going farther back, I actually have some here.
- 9:22Should have pulled them out.
- 9:24Uh-huh.
- 9:29They had older publications just to print out, but, lists of state officers.
- 9:33And so
- 9:34Oh, wow.
- 9:35Well, going through that, these were published at each session of the legislature.
- 9:38And a lot of a lot of legislatures had this, and they would just it's kind of the basic
- 9:42information, name, place of birth, from where they immigrated, their age, their occupation,
- 9:50marital status, and political party.
- 9:52And so you kind of you can use that.
- 9:54And then if you have way too much time on your hands, can go on like ancestry.com or some of
- 10:00the other genealogy and try to track down these people and see, you know, more than just an age
- 10:05or a birth year, what was their specific birthday and, what happened with their lives
- 10:10afterwards?
- 10:11Because a lot of times, you know, somebody will live sixty, sixty five, seventy years and they
- 10:15were in the legislature, for two to four.
- 10:18And it's like, well, what else?
- 10:19What else did they do?
- 10:20What was the you know, what happened before that kind of would have would have educated
- 10:23them?
- 10:23And then and then what happened afterwards that would have, helped them, what would they have
- 10:28used their experience to to accomplish later?
- 10:31Yeah.
- 10:31It's it's a it's kind of a thankless job finding all these, like, little bits about,
- 10:37like, the state level.
- 10:38I mean, federal level is a lot easier to find information off at the state level and then the
- 10:42local level.
- 10:42You can almost a lot of times, can just forget about finding information for that just because
- 10:47like you said, it is there is a great disparity in in how accessible this information is.
- 10:53You bring it up the blue books.
- 10:55That just reminded me of this book right this book right here.
- 11:00It it's it it as part of I use it as part of my projects.
- 11:06I was talking about with the political histories in The United States.
- 11:08And then when I was working at Ballipedia, there was a project that I did for them too.
- 11:12But, basically, it's the party affiliation divisions in the state legislatures up until
- 11:172006 because the book the book came out, like, 02/2007.
- 11:21So but but you just like what you were talking about using newspapers and blue books and stuff
- 11:28like that.
- 11:28It's just like, it is very painstaking to find find that stuff, but it's it's stuff that
- 11:34really needs to be preserved.
- 11:35So I really appreciate you doing that kind of work.
- 11:38And speaking of which, I mean, it is pretty incredible the amount of information that is on
- 11:43joincalifornia.com.
- 11:45I I don't remember if we said it specifically yet, but you have election results.
- 11:49You have key historical figures, anniversaries, countdowns to elections, and other political
- 11:54events, and a lot more stuff.
- 11:56But, obviously, this is a massive undertaking, and it's been going on for a long time.
- 12:00So what has been the most difficult aspect or two in building up this database?
- 12:04The the still living folks.
- 12:08The the folks that are dead, are generally they they complain very little, about, the content
- 12:13you put in there.
- 12:14One of the things for for living folks, they're they're worried about, their reputations, both
- 12:21how they will be seen if they're gonna be running for additional offices.
- 12:25So one of things that that has been a a challenge is when, you'll have an elected
- 12:31official, they're they're married, and then they're not married.
- 12:35And, well, can you take my ex's name off of the page?
- 12:40And it's like, well, it was in your biography.
- 12:43I mean, is a significant part of your biography.
- 12:46And so, but I don't like her anymore.
- 12:49And, well, that that
- 12:51Doesn't mean she wasn't there.
- 12:52Yeah.
- 12:53Well, she she yeah.
- 12:53And and so so that is one of those things where it's, trying to balance respect for people's
- 13:00lives with, having an accurate telling of what happened.
- 13:04There's also, people die in interesting ways.
- 13:08And I would say for, god, that's awkward way to phrase it.
- 13:12But, you know, if you look at perhaps politicians in particular, they they tend to
- 13:19live interesting lives.
- 13:20And so, every once in while, you'll you'll run into just some amazing crazy thing.
- 13:26And that that tends to be if you're looking for, you know, you're looking for a specific
- 13:29name for someone, often the last articles that you find are are their obituary.
- 13:35So you get to find out, like, died of a heart attack in bed, set himself on fire in a hotel
- 13:41room, threw himself into the Potomac covered in chains.
- 13:44Like, I mean, it's it's, all of those
- 13:47Is that real thing?
- 13:48Real things.
- 13:49Yeah.
- 13:49And Okay.
- 13:50It's it's trying to have consistency.
- 13:55I mean, if you look at, like, a bio guide from Library of Congress.
- 13:58Mhmm.
- 13:59They have a formula.
- 14:00And and there there is value to that in in for in terms of consistency.
- 14:05But then there's also just to add a little bit more flavor, to like, here's he lost his arm in
- 14:12a threshing machine accident.
- 14:14It's like, oh, wow.
- 14:15That's that'll shape you.
- 14:18That'll that'll that'll change your your experience.
- 14:21And so yeah.
- 14:22So I I I do like putting in the details, and sometimes people are like, I don't I don't like
- 14:28that you do that.
- 14:29I say, well, that's that's okay.
- 14:30I actually, I actually made the website for me.
- 14:34That's what I tell folks.
- 14:35I made it to reflect my interests and my my worldview.
- 14:41And sure, if if you're willing to commit a couple thousand hours, you can make your own
- 14:47website, and, and and it can reflect, what what you have.
- 14:51But, yeah, it's, yeah, it's it's interesting dabbling with people's lives.
- 15:00Yeah.
- 15:00And there there if if it's if there's a piece of information that you don't care for, I mean,
- 15:04just skip it.
- 15:05Yeah.
- 15:05Yeah.
- 15:06It's not not I mean, there's gonna be some things that I'll find that I'm like, okay.
- 15:09I don't I don't that part is not not needed for whatever I'm doing.
- 15:13That's okay.
- 15:13Just just but somebody's gonna find it interesting.
- 15:16There's always gonna be somebody who finds it interesting.
- 15:18You're talking about bio guide, and I I I mean, obviously, I appreciate bio guide being there
- 15:25because people that you would have had no clue even existed, they have information on there,
- 15:29but it gets a little bit onerous to read just because of that whole every it's a it's a
- 15:34single paragraph.
- 15:35Everything's very dryly laid out.
- 15:37It's like, well, they could maybe use, like, a few bullet points or something like that just
- 15:41to make it easier for people to read.
- 15:43But but, anyways, I I I digress on that.
- 15:47So let's move on to one of your other big projects that I mentioned in the intro, which
- 15:51was which is the one voter project.
- 15:54So what led you to create that, and can you give us more details about its goals?
- 15:58I talked a little bit about them, what they're listed on the website, but just more detail
- 16:01about those.
- 16:02Sure.
- 16:02Yeah.
- 16:02So Join California, was was my attempt to make a a resource that was largely about election
- 16:08results and candid biographies.
- 16:10But when I was doing these candid biographies, found out that there there are stories.
- 16:13There are these great stories that really help people connect with history, whether it's a
- 16:18tragically flawed person or whether it's a hero.
- 16:21And so I I was trying to figure out, like, is there a good way on Join California to have
- 16:27something that's more than a a paragraph?
- 16:30Because a lot of times if I'm putting in a footnote or a bullet point, if you if you get
- 16:34above a a sentence or two, it starts getting pretty long.
- 16:37And so there are some stories, you know, that you just want three or four paragraphs to
- 16:41write.
- 16:41Sometimes it's a whole page.
- 16:43And but it's it's a good story.
- 16:45And so I created OneVoter primarily to serve as a place to to tell stories, from California
- 16:51political history or national political history, that people might not be familiar
- 16:56with.
- 16:57One of the things that, I have always done is try to avoid doing what other people are doing.
- 17:06And so, you know, one of my favorites, I think it was was in college.
- 17:10Somebody said, well, you know, do you know how long you'd have to study Congress to become
- 17:15like the leading expert on Congress?
- 17:18Oh, how long?
- 17:19And, probably about seventy years.
- 17:21Sixty, seventy years.
- 17:22Like, you know, to be the expert, would take that long.
- 17:26And it's like, well, what about, like, a a state legislature?
- 17:30It's like, depends on the state.
- 17:32Somewhere between ten and fifteen years, you really do become the expert on it, because
- 17:38there are not people paying that attention.
- 17:40And so, so I try not to tell the stories that other folks have told.
- 17:45Every once in a while, there's just a different angle, or a different lesson that I feel like
- 17:50is coming out of something that hasn't been conveyed before.
- 17:53And so, so I will retread what somebody else has done.
- 17:57But, but there there are just so many stories out there that, that I that I do share on on
- 18:03one voter, and on social media that are just, just great stories.
- 18:07I mean, just amazing, amazing stories.
- 18:11I love those.
- 18:13Yeah.
- 18:13And and I I really like that you that that's the approach you take as you all obviously, a
- 18:20lot of the well tread stories are very interesting, but then sometimes, like, okay.
- 18:24Tell me something I don't know about.
- 18:26And a lot of these are important stories that need to be preserved, or they're just just very
- 18:30curious, interesting things that somebody they need somebody to to talk about the story.
- 18:36And I think there's just a lot of people don't realize just how intriguing history is, which
- 18:43obviously we'll get into later on in the in this episode.
- 18:47But let's go more now to your work as the communications manager for the California State
- 18:52Library.
- 18:53So let's what are some of the projects you and your team have done with the library that
- 18:59you're really proud of that have helped to enhance civic and historical awareness in
- 19:04California?
- 19:05Sure.
- 19:05One of my favorites, we've done a lot of different projects.
- 19:10One of my favorites was, a few years ago, we had, a large quantity of letters, that were
- 19:16written in, World War I, between, soldiers and their families back in California.
- 19:22And, we had a project.
- 19:23It was a website called From the Page, and we would upload documents there and volunteers
- 19:29would just transcribe them.
- 19:30And so it was this really cool project where, and you'd have multiple people would transcribe
- 19:36each page.
- 19:37So you just kinda somebody wasn't sure, oh, I'm not sure what that said in cursive because
- 19:43cursive is not a thing we're taught so much anymore.
- 19:45You know?
- 19:45We would have multiple people looking at it.
- 19:47And so it was it was a really, really fun project because we were involving folks.
- 19:52Folks were getting to see letters that hadn't been seen in a hundred years.
- 19:56But also by them translating it, they were being actively involved in helping other folks,
- 20:05interact us.
- 20:05We also did a digitization project for the executive orders of California.
- 20:09Governors can issue executive orders that are a bypass to legislation.
- 20:14And so we had one of those questions like, hey, how many executive orders have they ran?
- 20:20Oh, shoot.
- 20:21I guess that's that's a number.
- 20:22I guess we could figure that out.
- 20:23And so, we actually had this system where we we built that up and, made a searchable database
- 20:29of executive orders so that people could understand what had led to executive orders,
- 20:34disaster declarations, proclamations, and how they might affect people's lives outside of the
- 20:40usual legislative process.
- 20:42Oh, that's really cool.
- 20:44Have you well, you're in California, so I'm sure you've heard of it because it's start
- 20:48start at UC Santa Barbara.
- 20:50But the American presidency project?
- 20:52Yes.
- 20:53Yes.
- 20:53Yeah.
- 20:53So you're the thing about the executive orders just made me think about how they have all of
- 20:58the executive orders that every president ever has ever signed and and written and that's I
- 21:05mean, I I'm not gonna be diving into every single one of them, but just to know that it's
- 21:09there, even if it's not something I'm gonna specifically access to know that it is there
- 21:14for somebody else to access who might have the time and and come up with something very
- 21:18interesting to write about, that's really cool.
- 21:20And especially with governors, it's a lot harder to keep track of those.
- 21:25And then the letters, just those little if not slice of life, but those those more intimate
- 21:31moments that they had, like, if they're if husband's running back to his wife or vice
- 21:36versa or, you know, running to their kids or their parents.
- 21:40And just it's just really interesting to see that, especially because of the whole the human
- 21:45aspect of it.
- 21:45It's just really cool.
- 21:46So really appreciate that you have that kind of project going on there.
- 21:50One thing, and it was Oh, god.
- 21:52It was it was it was so weird.
- 21:54It was it was and I love I I I I love the weird.
- 21:56It was it was a soldier.
- 21:58I believe he was from I think he might have been for he might have been a student at
- 22:01Stanford who got deployed as a pilot in World War I.
- 22:05And he had this he had photographs.
- 22:08He had letters.
- 22:09And and one of the things that he had done was a crow had landed.
- 22:12I think it had a injured wing or something that showed up at this airbase that they're using
- 22:16for their operations.
- 22:18And the guy started having it sit on his shoulder.
- 22:21And and then he taught it how to smoke cigarettes.
- 22:24And and you're just one of these, like, it's it's this yeah.
- 22:29This is this is a guy who's in his twenties, and he's in this epic war.
- 22:35And the insights you have into, like and, who teaches a crow to smoke cigarettes in in war?
- 22:45And it was like but he had he had pictures, and it was it was the most amazing it it I mean, in
- 22:49the age of AI, it looks totally it looks totally fake.
- 22:52But, but this was this was we've gone through this, like, 2017 to 2018 before AI got that
- 22:57good.
- 22:58And it's this picture of a guy in a World War one uniform with a crow on his shoulder, and
- 23:04the crow has a cigarette coming out of its mouth and looks so fake.
- 23:10It looks so fake by today's standards, but it was like, no.
- 23:12It's it's real.
- 23:13It's it's somebody was quirky enough to do this back in World War one.
- 23:17And we tracked down his family.
- 23:19They lived down on the Central Coast.
- 23:20Oh, wow.
- 23:20And I was like, can I can I ask you about, your your your father?
- 23:24It was a woman who was she was born after he came back.
- 23:28So did he have a really interesting sense of humor?
- 23:30She's like, he did.
- 23:31He did.
- 23:34I saw that.
- 23:35I saw that.
- 23:35Okay.
- 23:35That's great.
- 23:37Okay.
- 23:37I'm good.
- 23:38Thank you.
- 23:38Yeah.
- 23:39That that's awesome.
- 23:40I I gotta say, World War one and World War two veterans were something else.
- 23:46I mean, I and we we still have a few World War two veterans left, but obviously,
- 23:51unfortunately, we're very few and far between now.
- 23:54But, yeah, just just like, I mean, obviously, the the the sense of humor of some of them is
- 24:01is is, you know, giving a crow a cigarette is just I mean, that's that's that's timeless.
- 24:07That's funny no matter what generation you are.
- 24:10And then, obviously, of course, just how how young some of these guys were and they're going
- 24:15off to wars.
- 24:16Like, I I do not have the fortitude to do that.
- 24:19I do not have the capability, and I'm not I'm about to be 32 in in August, and it's just
- 24:25these some of these kids are 10, 12, 14 years younger than me.
- 24:28It's just I mean, they they were something else.
- 24:31That is for sure.
- 24:32But that's that's really cool to hear.
- 24:34So let's move.
- 24:35Yeah.
- 24:36Sorry.
- 24:36Go ahead.
- 24:36Oh, yeah.
- 24:37Was gonna I gonna say we we we so we do that.
- 24:38We also do tours.
- 24:40We have 4,000,000 books at the California State Library, and Cool.
- 24:43It's plenty to read.
- 24:44So I always I always tell folks this is my my advice for everybody is, you know, if if you're
- 24:48reading a book and you're not enjoying it, stop reading it.
- 24:51There there are plenty of other things to read.
- 24:53Don't don't feel like some folks if you started a book, oh, I gotta finish it.
- 24:57It's like, you do you don't.
- 24:58I promise you don't have to finish it.
- 24:59You can you can let it go.
- 25:01Yeah.
- 25:01I haven't done that with books, but I have done that with with other things before too.
- 25:06And I've done that later on, just like, why did I do that?
- 25:08I didn't enjoy it.
- 25:09Why am I why am I still doing this?
- 25:10But but let's move on from the more specific work that you do to just your work in general
- 25:17because Sure.
- 25:18We do have issues with civic awareness and understanding of history and society that need
- 25:24to be addressed.
- 25:24Obviously, much easier said than done.
- 25:27It's not gonna be fixed with this one podcast episode.
- 25:29But in your experience, what has been one or two of your biggest obstacles you've
- 25:34encountered in trying to improve civic and historical understanding amongst the public,
- 25:38and what are some ways that you've helped to, for lack of a better term, mitigate these
- 25:42roadblocks?
- 25:43Number one, far away is interest.
- 25:47People not feeling a connection, with their lives.
- 25:50And there really is very little that comes anywhere near second place.
- 25:57But, yeah, just people people's lives are busy and, feeling like politics is not something
- 26:03that they're involved in, that they don't they don't choose or I you know, or it's either that
- 26:07they don't feel connected, they're not doing anything involved in that.
- 26:11Or that by voting every two years, or perhaps you could vote in a primary too, you could vote
- 26:17twice every two years, that there that's the full and complete participation in a democracy.
- 26:25I go to jury duty when I'm called.
- 26:26I vote in elections.
- 26:28Ta da.
- 26:29And that's it.
- 26:31And people feel like they have checked off the box and it's like, no, no, there is more.
- 26:39There's definitely more involvement in a democracy.
- 26:42Folks are a lot.
- 26:44The obligations are higher.
- 26:45I guess that's one of the reasons.
- 26:46Both the rights and responsibilities are significant in a democracy.
- 26:53A really cool thing about dictatorship, which are not cool, is you really, you don't have to
- 26:59worry about voting.
- 27:00You don't have to worry about writing your elected officials.
- 27:03In a democracy, manifest.
- 27:09It is a requirement that the public remain involved.
- 27:13One of the I'd say if there was a secondary thing, the thing that I would say is there
- 27:21there's been a change in how this topic is taught, in k to 12 education.
- 27:26A few years ago, I was I was at a thrift store, here in Sacramento, and I found, a a civics
- 27:33textbook, from nineteen forties.
- 27:35And my goodness.
- 27:37If you have not seen civics textbooks from the World War II era, they are they're amazing.
- 27:43They're amazing.
- 27:44It's like, come on, Americans.
- 27:46Let's do this.
- 27:47And so I I saw this thing, and then I realized that there was a nineteen thirties civics
- 27:51textbook and a nineteen twenties civics, like, all on this row.
- 27:54Somebody had died, and and donated this to, to the thrift store.
- 27:59And so, you know, questionable life choices.
- 28:02I I bought them all, and I ended up with a collection of California.
- 28:06What started as civics textbooks back in about 1900 was when this collection started.
- 28:10And then by the nineteen eighties, it had shifted to government.
- 28:14They teach government now.
- 28:15And did not prior to reading these books, didn't think about it as I mean, they're
- 28:25roughly equivalent, right?
- 28:26It's like, they're not.
- 28:27Government is about them.
- 28:29Government is about a group of people that work for the government or are elected for the
- 28:32government.
- 28:33Civics is about the role of an individual in their society, in a democracy.
- 28:39And so civics is much more focused on you, and what what you are to do.
- 28:45And so, I that's one of the things I would say in California, at the the transition in the
- 28:50nineteen seventies into the nineteen eighties from civics as a class, to government, learning
- 28:57about how government works is a major loss that that we had and and will be very hard to
- 29:03recover from.
- 29:05Wow.
- 29:05I never even thought of it like that, the difference between teaching civics and teaching
- 29:09government.
- 29:10Now it's who it's focused on.
- 29:12I I I I really like that because, obviously, this this whole podcast and everything I do is
- 29:18is one of the big things devoted to improving civics education.
- 29:23And one of the the topic I talked about a couple weeks ago, or at least a couple weeks
- 29:27ago by the time this episode airs, it was political apathy and one of the things being
- 29:32just we don't really teach people why yes.
- 29:37There's some responsibility that that people have to be interested in this stuff, but at the
- 29:41same time, we have to give them a reason, tell them why they need to be interested.
- 29:46And I I think we don't really do as good of a job doing that, or or we do try to teach people
- 29:53why they should care, but just for what whatever reason, the information is just not
- 29:57accessible.
- 29:57And it's just I mean, it's a very complex situation, but I I appreciate you basically
- 30:04speaking to that that issue of of teaching history.
- 30:08Even if we you know, people who do wanna learn about history, sometimes it's hard for them to
- 30:13access it or just the way we we tell teach people about it is just not the right way or at
- 30:18least could be better.
- 30:20It it is substantially easier to teach someone government.
- 30:23There are three branches.
- 30:25Two are elected.
- 30:27One is a and it's it's like, government is leaps and bounds so much easier to teach than
- 30:33civics.
- 30:36You teach government, it's like, what's the outcome?
- 30:38Yeah.
- 30:38The outcome is a test.
- 30:40You teach civics, it's like, what what is what's the outcome?
- 30:42It's like an informed voter, who's an active participant in, their society.
- 30:46They go to city council meetings, talk try public comment, write letters.
- 30:51It it's it's a very different outcome, and it's much, much harder.
- 30:54And so I I get why why they made that transition, but something was lost.
- 31:01Yeah.
- 31:02I I I can definitely agree with that.
- 31:03If I if I do something with that concept, I will be sure to in future projects, I will be
- 31:10sure to quote you on that saying, I got this from Alex Vassar.
- 31:14He's a cool guy.
- 31:15You should listen to him.
- 31:16Guy.
- 31:16Yeah.
- 31:17Yeah.
- 31:18But more on this understanding of history because it is an important endeavor for all of
- 31:26us that well, all of us can do better in it.
- 31:28We're we're humans.
- 31:28We can all do better in it.
- 31:30But many people have their own conception of how history has played out.
- 31:33So not just more so we're talking more not the people who were trying to get interested in
- 31:40history.
- 31:40People who already have some interest, but they basically already have their idea of what
- 31:45history was and how it happened.
- 31:48So it's it's very difficult to make people reexamine their beliefs, right, unless they're
- 31:52self aware about it.
- 31:53So as an historian and civic advocate, what are one to two ways that you think are effective in
- 31:59making people more open to really trying to learn history without preconceived notions,
- 32:04trying to reexamine what they thought about history?
- 32:08I think
- 32:09one of the big, tools is and and going back with with the stories is is, just trying to
- 32:16find a different way, so that they don't feel like it's learning about someone else.
- 32:22It's learning about a different part of yourself, whether it's your family history, the
- 32:27things that that your ancestors might have dealt with, or or just a fact that shakes
- 32:35people up.
- 32:36You know, if you if you tell somebody something that doesn't fit within their kind of
- 32:44structure, what how they identify the world as having worked, the two options are they can
- 32:50dismiss it or or they can do the the long painful process of reevaluating how the world
- 32:57works together.
- 32:58And so I think one of the things that if you're going to be in that role is building up your
- 33:04credibility.
- 33:05Because if you if you just say, George Washington was a woman.
- 33:12I mean, something like that.
- 33:13And it's like people like, that is not that doesn't sound like I I am going to dismiss that
- 33:18out of hand.
- 33:19That is Yeah.
- 33:20It it will not change my understanding.
- 33:22There there really is not anything you could tell me that would cause me to believe that.
- 33:29So it just gets dismissed.
- 33:30And it's but it's like, you know, if you if you say, well, if you, you know, stick to the
- 33:34truth, and also you come and say, hey.
- 33:36I I've spent a lot of time looking into this.
- 33:40I have really tried to understand it.
- 33:41Here's my understanding of how this is.
- 33:43But, really, it's it's about how you are going to be voting, how you're going to be
- 33:49interacting with the people around you, your your society, your culture, your community.
- 33:59This is important, and really deserves the time and attention that you might not feel like you
- 34:03have, but it's important if we're going to last another two fifty years.
- 34:11So just trying to make people help people make the right decision when they're faced with one
- 34:18of those the fork in the road between dismiss it or change my understanding.
- 34:26Make make make the choice to not not dismiss it.
- 34:28Know, question the information you're getting just just because there was a really cool video
- 34:31that went along with it on, Twitter, doesn't mean it's real.
- 34:36But Boy.
- 34:36Yeah.
- 34:37But they they do, in fact, find, you know, documents sometimes that that really shake up
- 34:42how we understand
- 34:45Yeah.
- 34:45Our culture.
- 34:46Yeah.
- 34:47That's that's kinda one of my pet peeves.
- 34:49Just these really nicely packaged videos on social media, people just share them without
- 34:54another thought.
- 34:55And, like, they're clearly benched towards one side of the political aisle.
- 35:00I think whether the the the bringing up George Washington, I think, is a really interesting
- 35:04point besides the fact that
- 35:06Not a woman.
- 35:06Yep.
- 35:07Yeah.
- 35:07Well, yeah.
- 35:07Let's let's make sure that we make that clear.
- 35:09He was not a woman.
- 35:11But just just the founding fathers in general, obviously, are seminal to American history, but
- 35:17that that's kind of one of those flash points for I I I wouldn't say, like, a lot of people,
- 35:23but there's a sizable maybe louder contingent where if you talk about the founding fathers
- 35:30and you just talk about all the great things they did and all they contributed to the
- 35:32country, but kinda swept under the rug the fact that many of them were also slaveholders,
- 35:39you're a lot of people are going tune out.
- 35:42But then if you just focus on the slaveholding and then disregard how they contribute to the
- 35:47rest of the country, then you have another group of people that are just gonna tune you
- 35:49out, you gotta really come up with that full on context.
- 35:55And and sometimes it's it's difficult to confront with people.
- 35:59Like, you and and you can acknowledge how complex people are at the at the same time.
- 36:04Obviously, you can understand the context of, okay, well, a lot there were people that hailed
- 36:10slaves then.
- 36:11Doesn't make it right, obviously.
- 36:13But but it just it just kinda made me think of that with the whole founding fathers,
- 36:18especially.
- 36:19But what are some of the states do you have any particular states or school districts or other
- 36:26kinds of areas in The US that you have seen teach political history well?
- 36:31And if so, what do you think makes them so effective?
- 36:36One of one of the programs that I think has done them well, and and I I am far more
- 36:40familiar with California state government, California state operations than than other
- 36:44states.
- 36:45Within our state, one of the one of the programs that I think has worked best is, we
- 36:49have a program based at the state capital called the Fellows Program, and it is a one
- 36:56year paid internship where, each program has about eighteen, twenty, participants, which is
- 37:02in a state of 40,000,000.
- 37:04That's gonna take a long time to get through everybody.
- 37:07Not not everybody's doing this.
- 37:09But, it it brings students generally, I think you have to be 21 years old and a college
- 37:14graduate, and you come to Sacramento, and they have this, onboarding.
- 37:20You're meeting with, policy experts.
- 37:22You meet with historians.
- 37:23You do tours of state facilities.
- 37:24You go out to the highway patrol headquarters and see how highway patrol officers are
- 37:30trained.
- 37:30You you go out you can go out with a a Caltrans road crew and see, like, do you know how a
- 37:37pothole like, let's say there's one these little potholes.
- 37:38Like, how do they fill the pothole on the freeway so that it actually sticks and doesn't
- 37:43and so there there's this introduction to government, introduction to to the state of
- 37:49history, and then it's followed after about a one month, orientation.
- 37:53It's followed by twelve month or another ten months.
- 37:55Sorry.
- 37:56Total is twelve months.
- 37:57Another, eleven months of working in the state capital in a state legislator's office, working
- 38:03on, bills and understanding how the process works.
- 38:06How do you build consensus?
- 38:08And you learn I think one of the most important things that most folks don't know is the degree
- 38:14to which consensus, or compromise is critical to how government works.
- 38:21I would go in, I'd be hard charging, and I'd convince them with my reason, and I would win.
- 38:26And it's like, that's not how legislatures work.
- 38:29Yeah.
- 38:29Legislatures are built on compromise, and it's it's both, in this modern era, it's their
- 38:36weakness, because compromise is is not viewed positively.
- 38:40But it but it is ultimately in the long term, it is because you're you're trying to
- 38:43accomplish solution that meets, the needs of a really, really wide range of people.
- 38:48And so, yeah, it's hard.
- 38:52It's it's, you know, you can you can get 20 folks through at a time, per year, but it's
- 38:59it's a really, really good civic education.
- 39:03So I don't know.
- 39:04Good education is gonna it it it takes a while.
- 39:07It takes multiple opportunities and to have access to a lot of information, that most
- 39:13people in their daily lives are reaching for.
- 39:17Yeah.
- 39:17Definitely.
- 39:18And I I really can appreciate that that hands on learning.
- 39:21Even something you don't necessarily think it has you don't really automatically think has
- 39:26something to do with politics and government, simple as filling potholes.
- 39:30Well, actually, yeah, it does.
- 39:32And the thing about compromises, I I wanna do an episode of the podcast specifically about
- 39:38compromise.
- 39:38But, yeah, for some people, it is a dirty word, but or they they they want compromise.
- 39:43They just want the other side to compromise more, and they they don't wanna be able to have
- 39:48to give up anything.
- 39:49I was like, well, that's not how it works.
- 39:51Yeah.
- 39:51Everybody's gotta be a little taken give.
- 39:53Even even if a part one party has an outsized grip on a government, you need some level of
- 40:00compromise.
- 40:01But but speaking of more of that government work that you've seen up close because you have
- 40:08worked in government as a policy specialist and a chief of staff, So you got some deep
- 40:13experience with the legislative process too.
- 40:15So what do you think should be let's combine what you the work you did before in government
- 40:21with what you do now with history and civics.
- 40:24What do you think should be the state government's role in civic and historical
- 40:28education, whether it's for grade school kids, college students, adult education?
- 40:32And then how does local government factor into that?
- 40:36So in in California, local government has the the primary role.
- 40:41The state kinda sets curriculum standards, and then we have different parts of the state that,
- 40:47try to provide materials.
- 40:49But a lot of times, it's it's up to the actual teachers, and the school boards to to actually
- 40:52figure out what specific curriculum they're going to be making available to to folks.
- 40:58So I think I think the the local responsibility is often overlooked.
- 41:03The the modern era, everybody wants to solve the problem at the highest possible level, and
- 41:07it's that's that's not how we're we're not made that way.
- 41:11It's really it's if you solve stuff at the local level, there will be difference in
- 41:15outcome.
- 41:16And that's that's another thing that that is that's an issue, is, well, some folks are gonna
- 41:21be really well educated.
- 41:22Yes, they will.
- 41:23And some folks will not.
- 41:25So I think, in terms of, what we do, we we we try to make materials available.
- 41:32One of the things that we've really seen, particularly in California but in other places,
- 41:37is, like, digested materials, where it's you know, if you have an original document, whether
- 41:44whether it's a letter or, you know, some some like, we were talking about earlier, some
- 41:49something that was made at that time that kinda interprets, it's a product of of that era.
- 41:58It you're seeing it through the lens of that time, and it requires stepping outside of your
- 42:02own life and your experiences, which is in itself another useful activity.
- 42:09So much has been just digested where it's like, let me tell you about the founding fathers.
- 42:15Here's 10 pages on the and and it's just it's it's it's either gonna be oversimplified or
- 42:23it's going to be overly complicated person by person.
- 42:27And so, I always really like, connecting folks to to the original documents.
- 42:33Here here in California, we, each legislator, so we have a 120 state legislators, forty forty
- 42:40senators and 80 assembly members.
- 42:44Each one is entitled to, once a month, they have a box of state constitutions.
- 42:49It's the state constitution, the Magna Carta, the federal constitution.
- 42:53It's this it's a cardboard box.
- 42:56And they request it, and it gets delivered to their office, and they can do whatever the heck
- 43:00they want with, I think I think it's 24 copies of the state constitution and these other
- 43:04documents, articles of confederation.
- 43:06And so, I always love, you know, you can a lot of times, they don't request them all the time.
- 43:12And so you can go to a legislative office or visit a couple and say, hey.
- 43:16Can I have your box for this month?
- 43:18Can I have your box for this month?
- 43:19And and you can collect 200 copies of the constitution, very, very quickly and then find
- 43:26a school and and actually give students a copy.
- 43:30Not not just a you know, not like this is the one for the classroom.
- 43:33You're gonna it's like, no.
- 43:34No.
- 43:34This is yours.
- 43:36This this is the rule book by which we play.
- 43:40You should definitely have a copy of this document.
- 43:43And and so that's that's that's one of things that I I think is really good is is connecting
- 43:48people with the original documents, so that they can read it themselves and interpret it
- 43:53and think about what what things mean and what are the deficiencies in those documents.
- 44:00I really like that because and I was gonna say with cuts The US constitution especially, but
- 44:06it could also apply to the state constitution is people already come into it with their
- 44:11preconceived notions of what exactly the constitution is like if you talk about
- 44:15enumerated rights versus implied or how malleable the constitution is as in, like, as
- 44:22it is an original tense intent or or does the meaning change over the course of a time?
- 44:31Just those little things are really well, not really little things, but those really get the
- 44:36gears going in their minds so that they can think a lot more critically instead of take
- 44:42whatever it was that they were told to think by somebody else.
- 44:46So that's that's really cool to hear.
- 44:48And I enjoy learning about history in general, of course, but I especially enjoy finding out
- 44:54weird facts about history.
- 44:55We just talked about that at the beginning of the podcast.
- 44:59So since you've compiled just a massively encompassing database on California political
- 45:04history, you you mentioned a couple of them already, but what are a couple more wild
- 45:10standout and or interesting facts or stories about California political history that you
- 45:15want more people to know about specifically?
- 45:18So there there was there was one that that I I actually learned fairly early on, and it's it's
- 45:25not well known, should be, but it was, well, there was this conflict.
- 45:32It was called the Cold War.
- 45:33It was big.
- 45:34It was long.
- 45:35It was it was terrible.
- 45:37And it ultimately ended, which is so crazy.
- 45:42It it ended because The US upped defense spending, and the Soviet Union wanted to match
- 45:47them.
- 45:48Like, that was it was just this one for one ratio that's always match and match match.
- 45:53And so The US spent a ridiculous and stupid amount of money on its military.
- 46:01And when the Soviets tried to match it, they went bankrupt.
- 46:04Like, they ran out of money, and the Soviet Union collapsed, and the war ended.
- 46:08And so it's like, well, where did that come from?
- 46:13And it it came from, Reagan had a, secretary of defense, Casper Weinberger.
- 46:18And, Casper Weinberger had an autobiography where he talked about, like, that was kind of
- 46:23the idea was that they were gonna bankrupt the Soviet Union.
- 46:26And what he said was, he started his career.
- 46:30His earliest career was in the California State Assembly.
- 46:33And, so he served in the assembly for a while and then he served in the, he served as
- 46:39director of finance, running the governor's budget.
- 46:41When Reagan was the governor of California, Casper Weinberger was his, director of finance.
- 46:48And so what he said was between his time in the legislature and his time at director of
- 46:53finance, he heard all of the best arguments that anybody had for raising the budget.
- 46:58And he wasn't a big budget raiser, but you you get these, like, really compelling arguments
- 47:05for why we should spend more here.
- 47:07And so what he said was he used all of the arguments he'd ever heard, all the best
- 47:11arguments for raising budgets.
- 47:13He applied them to these defense programs, and that was how he got authority to up defense
- 47:20funding, up defense spending, up defense spending, and that was what ended this the the
- 47:24Cold War.
- 47:25And it was like, wow.
- 47:27Well, like, the training that he received in state government was the skills that he used
- 47:32that ended the Cold War, which for so long looked like it was gonna end very, very hot and
- 47:40very fast and very bright.
- 47:41And it ended with, what did I say?
- 47:44It was ended with a whimper instead of a bang.
- 47:46And gonna say the same thing, whimper.
- 47:48Yeah.
- 47:49It was it was I mean, that was what it was.
- 47:50And so, yeah, just kinda seeing how somebody was formed in in the state legislature and
- 47:57within state government and then took that to the national stage, was was amazing.
- 48:02So that was one of my my early, like, oh my gosh.
- 48:05We did that.
- 48:05We California State Assembly.
- 48:07That was us.
- 48:08That was us.
- 48:09My we sent him there.
- 48:12And then California you know, California's also had, we we've had in as many as some of the
- 48:16East Coast states, but we we've had three presidents, two of whom everybody acknowledges,
- 48:20and then one, I was look like, it's like, well, Reagan and Nixon.
- 48:23And it's like, we also had Hoover.
- 48:26Oh, that oh, that's right.
- 48:27Hoover was when when he was elected, it was it was Hoover of California was elected.
- 48:31And, oh my god, you would not believe how many awkward conversations I had a year ago when
- 48:37Harris was running for president.
- 48:39And people would say, well, she would be the third president from California.
- 48:45Actually, that that's what and people go, no.
- 48:49No.
- 48:49No.
- 48:49Because Gerald Ford moved to Palm Springs after the presidency.
- 48:52And they go, well, but Gerald Ford didn't count as a Californian.
- 48:54It's like, wasn't counting Gerald Ford.
- 48:57But, yeah, it was it was one of these, like, Hoover was Hoover of California, if if you
- 49:03check the, Electoral College results.
- 49:06And, yeah, it's just it's it's, California.
- 49:10We we we've do things sometimes.
- 49:14That I I I'd heard the whole bankrupting the the Soviet Union because of, you know, they
- 49:21couldn't match our defense spending.
- 49:22That that I'd I'd been taught in in back in high school, but I didn't know the part about
- 49:27how California had had factored into with Casper Weinberger and all that.
- 49:32So that that that was pretty cool.
- 49:34And, yeah, Florida, we technically, Donald Trump is a Florian.
- 49:38I don't think that really counts, though.
- 49:40I mean, I mean, he was originally representing what?
- 49:44New York.
- 49:45And, I mean, yeah, he he lives down here now.
- 49:48I don't know if I can count that as as a presidency.
- 49:51But but So, yeah, I just In in in case California's got us beat there, but but that's
- 49:58alright.
- 50:00Well, one more question, before we well, one more question before the nonpolitical,
- 50:08question.
- 50:09I found random question that I got.
- 50:11What is so now let's apply this to other places.
- 50:15So not California that wanna take something, whether it's something you've done or something
- 50:20you've seen done.
- 50:21What are some advice you've you'd give to other groups, be they educational groups, government
- 50:27agencies, whatever, that want to build political history databases similar to, like,
- 50:32joincalifornia.com or whatever you're doing at California State Library?
- 50:35What is some advice you'd give there?
- 50:36The the best advice I have is figure out what you want to include before you start.
- 50:44It is painful and disappointing to go back and add a category.
- 50:50I recently did that.
- 50:51I have a list.
- 50:51California's had 4,500 state legislators and, you know, I've got how old were they?
- 50:57Birthdays, birthplaces, other offices held.
- 51:00Got all this stuff.
- 51:01And then one of the things that came up that I didn't have was hometown.
- 51:04Oh, yeah.
- 51:06Where are they from?
- 51:07And I had to go back through 4,500 people, and I was like, oh my goodness.
- 51:15You know how much easier this would have been if I'd done this, to begin with?
- 51:18And it's just like, no.
- 51:19It's if you're gonna figure out, you know, what it's, you know, kinda doing folks are lines,
- 51:24and then the the information is the columns.
- 51:27Figure out your columns.
- 51:28Oh my god.
- 51:29Please.
- 51:29Like, it's it is painful to add another column later.
- 51:33Oh, yeah.
- 51:33So that's that's figure out what you wanna include and what you don't wanna include.
- 51:39I on on JoinCalifornia, I I have education as as a as a thing, but I only include this is
- 51:50stupid.
- 51:51But I only include universities that I attended, which drives some people to I they
- 51:57went to Harvard Law.
- 51:57I was like, I didn't.
- 51:59If you would like to get Harvard Law to admit me, I would be happy to
- 52:03They should they should have taken me.
- 52:04Should have taken me.
- 52:05I should have applied.
- 52:06But yeah.
- 52:07So so I I I only include the universities that I attended because I just felt like that was a
- 52:14way to put my little thing.
- 52:15You know, my mark goes my my thing on on this this system.
- 52:19And and and because I wasn't I don't know.
- 52:23I just I I don't it made it made it personal to me, the one of the great lines from Sicario,
- 52:31the movie.
- 52:32It's personal to me.
- 52:34Yeah.
- 52:34And so yeah.
- 52:36So just I you know, figure out what you wanna include, what you don't wanna include because,
- 52:40there will always be suggestions later.
- 52:42Oh, you should have included this.
- 52:43Oh, you shouldn't have included this.
- 52:47That's that's totally embarrassing that you included that.
- 52:49Yes.
- 52:50Thank you.
- 52:51So
- 52:51The education in particular, I mean, I I I kinda would do the same thing.
- 52:56I feel like if I were in your shoes where I was like it feels like that's a little too
- 53:01cumbersome to add, but if I knew somebody so the two bachelor's degree was University of
- 53:06South Florida in Tampa, and then I went to University of Florida for for grad school.
- 53:11So anytime I find especially for USF, if I find somebody that's from there, like, oh, I'm
- 53:15totally gonna I'm gonna note that.
- 53:17What are you you kidding me?
- 53:18Of course, I'm gonna do that.
- 53:19I mean, I think Harvard and Cornell and all of them, they they've they've already gotten many
- 53:24people who have may let you know that they're from an Ivy League school.
- 53:27So you guys you guys have had enough.
- 53:29It's okay.
- 53:30But I I do like jeez.
- 53:34Just it just left my head.
- 53:36Oh, you're talking about adding categories later on because I had a little bit of that
- 53:42issue with that political, the partisan history that I've been making that sometimes I find
- 53:51some new information on somebody who's like, wait.
- 53:53You know what?
- 53:54Maybe I should have looked to see if people from this other state had that, especially when
- 53:57you get to people who have multiple party designations, like if they did fusion voting.
- 54:03Oh, that's that purely from a from a selfish standpoint, fusion vote voting's annoying just
- 54:10because then you gotta I gotta actually note, hey.
- 54:13This person was also as a this this person, especially in New York, this per this democrat
- 54:19was also working families and independent, and then this republican was also conservative and
- 54:23and Yep.
- 54:24Independence party and and that just gets so
- 54:27So we we had them in California, and and what what I ended up doing was I was like, look.
- 54:33There there there's a there's a primary party.
- 54:35Even if this person was you know, there there were five parties currently operating, and they
- 54:38were nominated by three or even four of them.
- 54:40There was one primary party.
- 54:42And if you look at, like, the primary law, you had to win your own primary to win any of the
- 54:46others.
- 54:47That's who you know, that was gonna dictate who you're gonna vote for for speaker.
- 54:51Like, no.
- 54:53Just for simplicity.
- 54:54Like, you can you can change parties.
- 54:55We we've had folks that have changed parties, but but in terms of that, like, do wanna count
- 55:01Republican Democrats?
- 55:02Or there's Democrats, there's Democrat Republicans, Democrat Republican Greenback.
- 55:07That's like, no.
- 55:08No.
- 55:09No.
- 55:09Those those are all Democrats.
- 55:11This it's for clarity.
- 55:14I mean, there's there's and and that's one of those you're you're gonna make a choice between
- 55:19how precise do you wanna be and then how easy do you want people to be able to relate with it
- 55:24and understand it?
- 55:26Because there's no way that's not gonna take a paragraph footnote at the bottom saying,
- 55:32there's a subtle difference between a Democrat Republican and a Democrat.
- 55:37They were nominated by and it's it's like, I I I don't yeah.
- 55:42For most of my stuff, I've been like, that's that's not that useful.
- 55:45Yeah.
- 55:46Other folks other folks do it and swear by it, and I'm like, well, that's that's fine.
- 55:50That's fine.
- 55:50Yeah.
- 55:51If if it's something I think really needs to be pointed out, I'll make a I'll make a footnote
- 55:55of it personally.
- 55:56But but, yeah, it it definitely makes things get a little more tedious.
- 56:00But, you know, some sometimes you got you gotta wade through that.
- 56:03Somebody somebody's gotta do it, right, to wade through that information.
- 56:06And then, hey.
- 56:06If you wanna learn more about this other specific stuff, you can go to whatever.
- 56:11I got I got the an older version of it, but the congressional quarterly guide.
- 56:15So all the the governors and and US house and US senators up until '19 I think it was '94 is
- 56:24what what that that book has, but just just over a thousand pages of just a treasure trove
- 56:32of information.
- 56:33So it's it's still really cool.
- 56:34And then I find the other stuff online and in other places too.
- 56:37But so let's now move on to the final question here, the fun, random, nonpolitical question.
- 56:47So if you if you're new to the show, I like to end with one of these just to change things up
- 56:52a bit.
- 56:52Let listeners hear another side of the guest, and variety is is good.
- 56:56It's the spice of life as people say.
- 56:58So, Alex, today's random question of the day for you is what common grammatical or
- 57:06pronunciation mistake really grinds your gears?
- 57:18I've already got one locked and loaded.
- 57:19Oh, I was I was saying was saying the the one that, I just see so the Oxford comma, not not
- 57:26using the Oxford comma, is is one that you.
- 57:30It's just it it it it bugs me, because it just it's I just I see where it should be, more than
- 57:37anything else.
- 57:37There's there's also the the the, you know, inflammable also means flammable.
- 57:43Like, there there there's all those things in the English language that that don't quite make
- 57:47sense.
- 57:47But I I would say Oxford comma, I I I like precision.
- 57:52I like I like having thoughts when when they are separate thoughts.
- 57:56I like having them separated.
- 57:57And yeah, so that that's that's that's mine.
- 58:01Oxford comma.
- 58:02I am I I am with you there, brother.
- 58:04I am team Oxford comma.
- 58:05That's actually not what I was gonna It was not.
- 58:07Okay.
- 58:07But but I I just reacted because I heard you say it, and I was like, oh, he's team oxford
- 58:12comma?
- 58:13That that that's my guy.
- 58:14I I knew this was a good idea to bring you on this podcast.
- 58:17I just That's the test.
- 58:19Something just like, you need it to specifically separate those last two items.
- 58:24What what are what are we doing?
- 58:25What if it's an actual item that is a x and y?
- 58:28You know?
- 58:29Okay.
- 58:29So hold on.
- 58:30So what were you gonna say?
- 58:30What was your what was your answer?
- 58:31So mine is I try and I see this all the time.
- 58:38This drives me nuts.
- 58:39When people say would of, could've, should've, it's like, what are we doing here?
- 58:47You see there's an apostrophe v e.
- 58:50How do you get of out of that?
- 58:52It's would have, should have, could have.
- 58:54There's no no universe where should have or could have or would have makes any sense.
- 59:00What are we doing here?
- 59:02I don't I don't like like, this is the kind of stuff that we need to worry about more.
- 59:06Let's let's put aside the partisan and ideological stuff.
- 59:09Like, do you use an Oxford comma or not?
- 59:11Then I know whether to to listen to you.
- 59:12Okay.
- 59:13Maybe not that far, but but, no, I I'm totally with you there on the Oxford comma.
- 59:17The other one that that is real I think it's I think it's hilarious is what is Chad GPT uses
- 59:23the Emdash a little excessively.
- 59:25And so it's this whole thing.
- 59:26It's like, I I actually I I like the Emdash.
- 59:28I don't use it all the time, but I I do like it as a because I try I I write very much the way
- 59:34I talk.
- 59:35And so just having a a pause, I really like it.
- 59:39And but it but it's it's a mark of inauthenticity, these days.
- 59:44And so it's, no.
- 59:45It's I don't know.
- 59:46That was that was one of the the great sadnesses of the last year or so was you can't
- 59:50use it anymore.
- 59:52It's Oh, yeah.
- 59:52It will cause you as as an author, it will cause people to doubt you.
- 59:57And so, okay.
- 59:58Okay.
- 59:59I won't use it.
- 1:00:00It's a tool.
- 1:00:01It's a tool.
- 1:00:02And to take a tool off the table that's that's, you know, somewhat useful sometimes of shoot.
- 1:00:06Yeah.
- 1:00:07Don't do that.
- 1:00:07I use m dashes too, and sometimes I'll I'll use a a parenthesis instead.
- 1:00:12I might, like, go back and forth so I'm not, like, using one or the other too much, but
- 1:00:17people now complaining about Emdash is like, okay.
- 1:00:20Yeah.
- 1:00:21The you over usage of AI is a problem.
- 1:00:23But now everybody's just assuming that AI is being used, which is a totally other issue.
- 1:00:28That's one of the reasons I'm glad I started writing when I did back in the day because
- 1:00:32people are like, oh, well, was that was pre all of that.
- 1:00:34It's like, yes.
- 1:00:35Yes.
- 1:00:35Yes.
- 1:00:35Yes.
- 1:00:35I've been doing this for a while.
- 1:00:37That's Well, I I hope people notice that from from my own work too, but I I feel like we can
- 1:00:43complain about all these kinds of things all day, but unfortunately, we gotta wrap things
- 1:00:47up, and we we've we've we've all got other stuff we gotta do too.
- 1:00:51So I just wanna thank you, Alex, for being here.
- 1:00:54Real actually, real quick.
- 1:00:55Any other media or works that you would like to share?
- 1:00:58One one other thing just to kinda tied into your general topic, is, it's always the
- 1:01:04importance of of running for office and and voting.
- 1:01:07I question my life choices as always.
- 1:01:10I I ran for office in, 2016 and 2020.
- 1:01:14Okay.
- 1:01:15And for I I received zero votes.
- 1:01:20I received zero grand total of zero votes between my two elections.
- 1:01:23You didn't
- 1:01:24even vote for yourself.
- 1:01:25Actually, I respect that.
- 1:01:26No.
- 1:01:26I I did not appear on the ballot.
- 1:01:28I it was it was it was running it was a it was a five member board.
- 1:01:31There were three seats open, and the first time, I was the only candidate.
- 1:01:35And so the second time, I was one of three candidates for three spots.
- 1:01:37And so I'm always like, look.
- 1:01:39That's that's a problem.
- 1:01:40I mean, it's it's it's not my pro I I I really actually like that I got elected with zero
- 1:01:44votes, twice.
- 1:01:45I I served eight years on this local park district board, but I'm always like, no.
- 1:01:49You guys, like, it's it's not my failure.
- 1:01:51It's it's a failure of the community if you can't find enough candidates to at least make
- 1:01:59the people earn votes.
- 1:02:01And so yeah.
- 1:02:01So I'm always I'm always that that's that's that was one of those things I I I I did it.
- 1:02:04Did eight years as an elected official, having received zero votes, raised $0 in my
- 1:02:09fundraising, zero endorsements, but but still served eight years as an elected official.
- 1:02:17I I I always would like to encourage folks, please run run for office.
- 1:02:21You your voice is needed and and, vote vote consistently.
- 1:02:25Vote intelligently.
- 1:02:26That's a that's a whole other can of worms open up as the number of uncontested races, and then
- 1:02:32sometimes they don't even appear on the ballot nobody's running.
- 1:02:35They're like, okay.
- 1:02:36Well, this this one person there, we're not even gonna bother listing it here.
- 1:02:39But, yeah, that's might have to do an episode on that specifically.
- 1:02:44But, yeah, def definitely another one of our many problems we need to fix.
- 1:02:49But, unfortunately, we can't fix all our problems in this one podcast episode.
- 1:02:54But hope you all enjoyed listening to it anyways and for an hope obviously, think you
- 1:03:01all have gotten a lot out of this.
- 1:03:03I certainly have.
- 1:03:04So thank you all so much for for tuning in.
- 1:03:07My links in the show notes, and I'll add some of Alex's stuff as well.
- 1:03:12My Facebook, Paul Raider author and speaker, my LinkedIn, mymedium.com profile where I write it
- 1:03:17on political science from time to time, my website, my educational email course, five
- 1:03:24days, technically six days, where it talks about how to depolarize politics and how we
- 1:03:30unintentionally make polarization worse and how we can fix those mistakes.
- 1:03:34And my Matchmaker FM profile if you wanna be a guest on this podcast or you want me as a guest
- 1:03:40on your podcast.
- 1:03:41So with that being said, we are gonna wrap things up.
- 1:03:44So as always, thank you so much for listening, and until next time.
- 1:03:47Take care.