Latest / Communicate101 / FOLLOW UP AFTER INTERVIEW: YES OR NO?
Transcript
- 0:01Let me tell you about my very first job interview.
- 0:04I was in college eating lunch with my friends and suddenly the
- 0:08office boy called me to the admin office.
- 0:11I went there and they said there's a call for you.
- 0:15There was a call for me. No, there were no mobile phones
- 0:19that time. And the lady on the other side
- 0:21of the phone, she said, can you come for an interview at 4:00 PM
- 0:25today? I looked at my watch.
- 0:27It was already 1:45. And this was July in Delhi, so
- 0:32sticky, sweaty and soul melting hot.
- 0:36And I was actually a whole hour away from where the interview
- 0:40was. But I was terrified, excited and
- 0:44confused. I was also looking at my
- 0:46clothes. I said, whatever I'm wearing, is
- 0:48it appropriate or not? But thinking about all this
- 0:51commotion on the floor, I said of course yes, I'll be there.
- 0:56Now that was school, college time, and I barely had any
- 1:00money. But I blew a big chunk of my
- 1:04monthly budget on a cab because frizzy hair, auto rides, not a
- 1:08vibe. I marched in trying to look all
- 1:11cool and professional, as if I'm a pro at giving interviews.
- 1:15But who was I kidding? I looked like a drenched,
- 1:18nervous, shaky puppy. But somehow I survived the
- 1:22interview without passing out. Then I remembered after the
- 1:26interview, should I follow up Now How do I follow up?
- 1:34This was back when emails weren't a big deal yet.
- 1:37So I decided to call and leave a voicemail.
- 1:41Big mistake. Halfway through my super polite
- 1:44message, my nerves took over and instead of saying I appreciate
- 1:49your time, instead of that, you know what I said?
- 1:53I said I appreciate your love. Love.
- 1:57Did I just confess my feelings to the hiring manager?
- 2:02Total panic. I tried to fix it.
- 2:05I mean, your kindness, no, your time.
- 2:07Uh, thanks. Bye.
- 2:09Click slam phone down because there was number undo button.
- 2:14It was just me curling up, cringing into a black hole of
- 2:17embarrassment. Moral of the story, if you're
- 2:22leaving a voicemail, write it down first.
- 2:25Write down what you're gonna say, and maybe don't even
- 2:29accidentally declare your love to the potential employer.
- 2:33Hey everyone, welcome back to Communicate 101 Speaking writing
- 2:38tips, your go to guide for all things communication and career.
- 2:43I'm your host Sarika Singh, and today we're tackling a topic
- 2:46that many of us overlook, but can actually this can really
- 2:51break or make your chances after an interview.
- 2:54The follow up, when do you reach out?
- 2:58What do you say and how do you do it without sounding pushy?
- 3:02Stay tuned because I've got all the answers for you and at the
- 3:06end of the episode I promised to reply to the most relevant
- 3:09question someone wrote to me on my insta, which is Communicate
- 3:13101, a question which was so relevant to this episode.
- 3:18Time to dive. Jyothika, a finance analyst, had
- 3:25a fantastic interview with an investment firm.
- 3:28She assumed they'd reach out if they were interested, so she
- 3:31didn't send a follow up e-mail. The company had another equally
- 3:36strong candidate who followed up.
- 3:39He was reiterating his enthusiasm for the role.
- 3:42That candidate got hired, and Jyothika later learned from a
- 3:47connection that the firm had been waiting for her to express
- 3:51continued interest. It's a shame because Jyothika
- 3:54was even a better candidate for them, and she was so eyeing this
- 3:58Canary Wharf giant for such a long time.
- 4:01But it's gone. Anyway, the story with Anupam is
- 4:06a whole new dimension. Anupam is a software developer
- 4:10in Pune, Maharashtra. He's got a fantastic interview
- 4:14at a startup and in his excitement, he sends a follow up
- 4:18e-mail just one hour after the interview asking when he should
- 4:23expect the feedback. I know you're thinking why so
- 4:27fast Patience. But Anupam innocently messaged
- 4:31the recruiter on LinkedIn the next day.
- 4:35I don't have to tell you what was the outcome, but you've
- 4:38guessed it right. The hiring manager felt
- 4:40pressured, saw it as a red flag, and he thought if this candidate
- 4:45candidate is impatient now, how is he going to handle the
- 4:48workplace stress? Anupam was removed for the
- 4:52shortlist. Now, Anupam was removed from the
- 4:56shortlist because he reached out and Jyothika was not hired
- 5:01because she did not follow up. So what is right whether to
- 5:05follow up or not? Both Jyothika and Anupam were
- 5:09unlucky for the same reason. They didn't know if follow up
- 5:14was necessary or if follow up was very important.
- 5:18That's the exact puzzle we are here to solve today, and we're
- 5:24going to do it right away. Have you ever walked out of an
- 5:29interview feeling great? You literally nailed the
- 5:33interview. You walked out of that room
- 5:35feeling like a rock star. You answered all their trick
- 5:39questions, the situational questions with finesse, and you
- 5:43even managed to make the interviewer smile on some time.
- 5:46Now you wait and wait and wait. Days pass Radio silence.
- 5:56You start over analyzing everything.
- 5:59Did I talk too much? Did they hate my answer about my
- 6:03biggest weakness? Maybe I shouldn't have laughed
- 6:06at my own joke because no response, no feedback.
- 6:10And now you're wondering, do they even remember my name?
- 6:14This is where the art of follow up swoops in to save the day.
- 6:19Like seasoning and cooking, you need a little, not too much.
- 6:25Let's breakdown exactly when, how and why to follow up so that
- 6:29you stay on their radar without looking like a stage 5 clinger.
- 6:34Now, there are many schools of thought.
- 6:36Some say you must follow up. Others say don't ever follow up.
- 6:41Well, personally, I subscribe to the formal school.
- 6:45I say follow up. I'll explain why I think like
- 6:48that. To me, an interview is no
- 6:51different than a first date. You both show up, you know, you
- 6:55exchange pleasantries, you put your best foot forward, you try
- 6:59to get to know each other. Now, if it was a great date and
- 7:03you never texted again, the odds are the other person will assume
- 7:07you're not interested, right? I believe interviews work the
- 7:11same way. The employers want to know that
- 7:15you're genuinely excited about the opportunity because
- 7:19following up shows initiative, professionalism, and most
- 7:22importantly, keeps your name fresh in their minds.
- 7:26Because there's a sea of applicants, the follow up is
- 7:29your way of reminding them, hey, Remember Me?
- 7:32The one who perfectly aligns with your company needs and the
- 7:36one who will bring cupcakes on my first day.
- 7:39That's exactly why following up is crucial.
- 7:43A well timed follow up not only keeps you on their radar, but
- 7:47also reinforces your enthusiasm and professionalism.
- 7:51It shows you're genuinely interested in their role, that
- 7:54you value their time and that you're proactive.
- 7:57And these are qualities any employer would love to see.
- 8:02So if you were to take my counseling, I'd say yes, you
- 8:06must, must, must follow up. So now the question is when
- 8:11should you follow up? I'm gonna share that in the next
- 8:15leg. Alright, when should you follow
- 8:21up? Let's go back to the dating
- 8:23analogy. So you went on a date, the date
- 8:26was good. So now you need to follow up.
- 8:30When? Within the 1st 24 hours.
- 8:34Think of this as your polite post date text.
- 8:38Hey, had a great time, hope to see you again soon.
- 8:41Just that much you should send a thank you e-mail within 24 hours
- 8:46of an interview. Keep it short, keep it warm, but
- 8:50keep it professional like a perfectly brewed espresso.
- 8:55Also make sure the hiring manager can place you.
- 8:59He should not think of you as someone else, but be sure to
- 9:03write to him within the 1st 24 hours.
- 9:08A well crafted thank you note leaves a positive final
- 9:11impression and can set you apart from other candidates.
- 9:15But is just one follow up enough?
- 9:18Because you're waiting and waiting.
- 9:20You're refreshing your e-mail every now and then, even when
- 9:24you get get up to pee in the middle of the night, but all you
- 9:28hear is crickets. Complete radio silence.
- 9:33Should you send another follow up?
- 9:35Of course you can, but not so soon, not under a week.
- 9:41Maybe after a week it's time that you send a gentle follow
- 9:45up. It's OK, you're just sitting
- 9:47home refreshing your inbox every 5 minutes.
- 9:50But don't panic. Don't write to him in less than
- 9:55a week. You're not begging for a
- 9:57response, you're just showing interest so you can say
- 10:00something like please let me know if there's anything else I
- 10:03can provide to help you in the decision making process.
- 10:07If after two follow-ups they haven't responded boss, I would
- 10:13say apply elsewhere. There are other jobs too.
- 10:16They are clearly not interested. Don't badger them.
- 10:19No company wants to miss a good candidate.
- 10:22At the beginning of this episode I promised to reply to the most
- 10:28relevant question that someone asked me on my insta, which is
- 10:33communicate 101. So here it is, Divya from
- 10:37Gurgaon asked me what is the best method to follow up.
- 10:41Is it an e-mail? Should one write on LinkedIn or
- 10:45should you just call? That's a valid question Divya,
- 10:49and good thinking. To answer this, I'm going to ask
- 10:53you a question. How did you get the interview
- 10:56call? Was it a call or was it an
- 10:58e-mail? Actually, this is a clue to how
- 11:02you should ask the question how you should follow up.
- 11:06If it was a call, you may actually call to check in a
- 11:10second follow up. Having said that, e-mail is
- 11:13usually the best and most professional way to follow up.
- 11:18You're not professionally related to the recruiter in any
- 11:21way yet, so a LinkedIn message might seem a bit much.
- 11:27What I suggest here in this podcast is not a government law.
- 11:31It's just my suggestion from my 3 decades of experience.
- 11:36So here everything, try the suggestions.
- 11:39If they worked or they didn't work, do let me know because
- 11:43your feedback is what drives this podcast.
- 11:46Your questions are what fuel this podcast.
- 11:49So far we've talked about what you should do when you do follow
- 11:53up in an interview. But in the final leg, I'm going
- 11:56to throw light on what you should not do.
- 11:59Watch out the next segment. Follow up is an art, and like
- 12:06any art, there are ways to mess it up.
- 12:09There are three things you must never do when following up.
- 12:13The number one, you can't be overexcited.
- 12:16Don't send multiple emails in a day.
- 12:18So if you've emailed on Monday, don't check in again on Tuesday,
- 12:22Wednesday, Thursday. You don't want them to see your
- 12:25name in their inbox and blacklist you.
- 12:27Spam. So no overeager Beaver #2 I know
- 12:35you're wondering have they made a decision yet?
- 12:37But don't have a casual follow up.
- 12:41Hi, I was wondering, have you made a decision yet?
- 12:44Now that's not the way to go. You have to make your mail sound
- 12:48professional. I know I compared it to a date,
- 12:51but actually an interview is not a date.
- 12:53So keep it professional. I'll give you an example.
- 12:57A friend of mine recently advertised for an executive
- 13:00assistant. He got a lot of good CVS but
- 13:03this, this is what stuck with him and he in fact shared it
- 13:06with me. He got a WhatsApp message on his
- 13:09mobile on his personal mobile number which said hey are you
- 13:14looking for an EA? I've sent you my resume.
- 13:17My friend was shocked. This was a huge red flag.
- 13:22How did this person get a private mobile number?
- 13:26Was he stalking? And what's with this?
- 13:29Hey, are you looking for an EA? Why so casual?
- 13:34You don't want to know what my friend did.
- 13:35Of course he removed the person's CV from the shortlist
- 13:38candidates, even if the CV was good.
- 13:41But a casual follow up? MMM complete red flag #3 what
- 13:48you should not do. Imagine your date hasn't
- 13:52responded to your first follow up message.
- 13:55Now suppose you text something like.
- 13:58I guess I'll take your silence as a number.
- 14:01Believe you me, you're jumping right into the Whirlpool only to
- 14:05drown. So if your second message to the
- 14:08recruiter says I assumed you've moved on with other candidates,
- 14:12you are guilt tripping him. Why are you doing this passive
- 14:17aggressive nudge? This is a sure way to ruin your
- 14:21chances. So no overeager Beaver, no too
- 14:26casual follow up, and definitely no passive aggressive nudges.
- 14:31Keep it positive, keep it simple, keep it professional.
- 14:35I know rejections are tough, but there are also opportunities to
- 14:38learn. Always send a thank you note,
- 14:41follow up appropriately, and don't burn bridges.
- 14:45Even if things don't go your way.
- 14:47Sometimes, despite your best efforts, you get ghosted.
- 14:51It's frustrating, but it's not the end of the world if you
- 14:54don't hear back after your final follow up.
- 14:57Take the hint and move on. Treat it like a dating app match
- 15:01that never texted back there laws.
- 15:04You're amazing and another company will see it.
- 15:08Got a question reach out to me on my Insta which is communicate
- 15:12101 or visit my website communicate101.com.
- 15:16Thanks for tuning in and I'll catch you next time on your
- 15:19favorite show, Communicate 101 speaking writing tips.
- 15:27Thank you for listening to this episode of Communicate 101
- 15:30Speaking writing Tips with Sarika Singh.
- 15:33If you want to be notified of upcoming episodes, be sure to
- 15:36hit the subscribe button and follow the podcast.
- 15:39I'll be back to share more stories, more life experiences
- 15:42and more communication tips every Friday.
- 15:45If you want to reach me or connect with me, just put your
- 15:48comments in the comment box below or mail me at info at
- 15:51Sarikasingh in. I know you're going to rate and
- 15:54review this podcast, so a big thank you in stay tuned and
- 15:59think about what we talk today.