Latest / The Sean O'Connell Show / Scott Mitchell on the House vs NCAA settlemet, what this means for Utah Athletics + more
Transcript
- 0:07Speaker 1: It's the Sean O'Connell Show. You were home of the
- 0:11guest inside of your use Let's get back to OC
- 0:14from a murder Chevrolet studio of ESPN seven hundred and
- 0:18ninety two to one am. Welcome back to the.
- 0:31Speaker 2: Shan o'conna shelf. Our number two.
- 0:35Speaker 3: On a Monday, we check in with Scott Mitchell, hosted
- 0:38Down in Dirty right here on ESPN seven hundred Utah
- 0:40quarterbacking legend, color analyst on your Utah Football radio broadcast
- 0:45eighty two days away from the Utah football season kicking
- 0:50off that night game against UCLA will now feature for
- 0:53the first time, two football teams where the athletes are
- 0:57paid by their universities directly.
- 1:01Speaker 4: The House Settlement was approved last Friday, which means you're
- 1:05expected to pay your teams, and Mark Carlin and Utah
- 1:12Athletics announced that they plan on doing exactly that. Those
- 1:15payments could begin as early as July. First wild times
- 1:20in college sports. Scott Mitchell mentioned these things on The
- 1:23Down and Dirty and now we talk about them together
- 1:26here on the Sean O'Connell Show.
- 1:27Speaker 2: Hey, Scott, welcome, How are you.
- 1:30Speaker 1: I'm doing wonderful, Sean, Yeah, crazy stuff I just think
- 1:36this is the beginning of it. I don't think this
- 1:38is the end. I don't even think it's the solution ultimately,
- 1:41but it's certainly unprecedented territory.
- 1:47Speaker 2: Well, I'm glad you said that.
- 1:49Speaker 4: I put a poll question out this morning, and people
- 1:51are I think, having a hard time forming their own
- 1:54opinions on this House settlement. We knew it was coming,
- 1:57but how are we going to look back at it
- 1:59in ten years? Is this Are we going to say, Okay,
- 2:02we fixed the money problems with this settlement. Are we
- 2:04going to say this is the thing that killed college sports?
- 2:07Because it's not going to kill football and basketball, but
- 2:10it very well might kill a lot of the non
- 2:11revenue sports. Are we going to look back and say
- 2:14this didn't make a difference. Are we going to look
- 2:16back and say this made the mess worse?
- 2:21Speaker 1: I think it is kind of everyone coming to the
- 2:26reality that amateur sports and football in college aren't the same.
- 2:33It's really I think this has been the whole rub
- 2:36with this thing from the very very beginning. I think
- 2:40I think college football has been a business for quite
- 2:44some time, and so it doesn't it doesn't work in
- 2:47the college experience it's not, hey, let's win one for
- 2:50the team. There's not this, you know, and you kind
- 2:53of feel it around around colleges. I don't know that
- 2:56there's the same like camaraderie, the same excitement with a
- 3:00lot of places about hey, we're going to all go
- 3:03support our team on Saturday. It's it's it's really a business.
- 3:07It's a good business. It's a great business. College football
- 3:10is an incredible business. College basketball is really a really
- 3:13good business as well. And and and so I think
- 3:17when we look back on it, it's going to be
- 3:18more of This was the time when they finally came
- 3:23to the realization, they finally were honest with themselves. They
- 3:26finally defined what college sports are and are not. And
- 3:31I think, personally, I think they should just separate football
- 3:35out from all of it. Just treated as as a
- 3:38as a business. And it's it's part of the you know, colleges,
- 3:42but it's but it's treated as business because it's twenty
- 3:45million dollars. It's paid out to their athletes. It's not
- 3:48paid out to their football programs. So you have to
- 3:52believe that a line share of it has to go
- 3:54to the money revenue sport. So what happens to all
- 3:58these other sports. I don't know that. On my show,
- 4:00I said, you know, maybe, I mean there's still locations
- 4:03with these programs. Now, there's some there's some schools that
- 4:07have club sports, you know, lacrosse in some schools does
- 4:10and doesn't. There are a lot of schools that have
- 4:14Olympic sports and and and and they're they're highly emphasized.
- 4:19And maybe maybe you have schools that do that. But uh,
- 4:23you know, if they if they can't survive without the
- 4:25funding for football, then maybe a lot of them go away.
- 4:30And then that brings in Title nine. You know if
- 4:33Title nine where you have to have equal and the
- 4:37same types of opportunity for both men and women. Uh,
- 4:41and and you have to eliminate programs because you can't
- 4:44fund them. You know that that really, you know, that
- 4:47really changed the landscape a lot. But I think today
- 4:50is that we've defined what it is and now now
- 4:53how it looks moving forward could be a lot of
- 4:55a lot of different things. And my suggestion is to
- 4:59take football out of the equation, make it a professional
- 5:02support in college.
- 5:04Speaker 4: How do you think this is going to affect nil
- 5:06Because part of the settlement was all right, now we're
- 5:11going to establish this new college Sports Commission. There's going
- 5:13to be an app called nil Go, and you have
- 5:17to clear all of your clear all of your NIL
- 5:20deals through a clearing house where we determine we being
- 5:25a list of random experts, I guess, we determine whether
- 5:29or not this is a fair market value for what
- 5:32you're doing and whether it's actually for the sake of
- 5:35NIL what it was designed to be, and not just
- 5:38more pay for play. How effective do you think that
- 5:43enforcement's going to be? How do you think that this
- 5:45settlement in practice is going to affect what we do
- 5:48with NIL right now?
- 5:51Speaker 1: All right, if we know one thing about college football,
- 5:54whether there's NIL or there's not, there's cheating that goes on,
- 5:59there's a bag and there's somebody there. These schools it's
- 6:02too important for them to win. They're going to find
- 6:05every opportunity they can to, uh, you know, entice players
- 6:09to come to their school. They've been doing it for years. Uh,
- 6:13it just kind of came out in the open and
- 6:14became semi legal for a period of time with the
- 6:17NIL and I don't think that ever changes. I don't
- 6:20think it's going to change now because they have an
- 6:22app that's you have to and and and the other
- 6:25side of of this. You know, fair market value sean,
- 6:29what that's a subjective term. You know, it's like art
- 6:33artist artist subjective. You know, one person could look at
- 6:36Picasso and go, I'll pay millions of dollars for it,
- 6:39and another person goes, that's the ugliest thing I've seen
- 6:41in my life. I won't give you two cents. And
- 6:43so to say, you know it's worth it's worth a
- 6:46million dollars a day for me to have this athlete
- 6:49represent my business, I don't care, you know, So how
- 6:53how do you determine what fair market value really is?
- 6:56I think it's and I think it's just so nuanced
- 6:59about all.
- 6:59Speaker 2: That different.
- 7:02Speaker 1: Way to manage or uh to to you know, kind
- 7:06of hold people in check. I appreciate it, I really do.
- 7:10And I appreciate them because it has you know, you
- 7:14need a fair playing field for everyone. And so I
- 7:16I like the attempt. I think, you know, that might
- 7:20be the other significant part of of what happened with
- 7:24this settlement is that it's an attempt to gain some
- 7:28kind of control or or ordered the cheating out of it.
- 7:38I really don't and uh uh you know, it's probably
- 7:42all the good and honest schools we'll we'll follow, but
- 7:45the ones that are dirty are still going to be dirty.
- 7:49Speaker 4: So talking to people, you know, the like b y
- 7:53U and Utah, they're going to pay out. They're gonna
- 7:55they're gonna say, all right, we're going to give football
- 7:57whatever the percentage we decide is of twenty point five million,
- 8:01but we're going we're spending up to twenty point five million,
- 8:04Mark Harlan said, We're prepared to pay the max, and
- 8:07b YU is gonna do the same thing.
- 8:09Speaker 2: I don't think Utah State can. I don't like.
- 8:14Speaker 4: Fresno State UNLB like Utah plays Wyoming this year. There's
- 8:18not twenty million bucks around for them. Maybe this year,
- 8:22not five years from now. It's just so what's gonna
- 8:26happen with a group of five schools.
- 8:31Speaker 1: I don't know how much of an impact it changes
- 8:35on them other than you know, if you if you
- 8:37think about a Utah State, you know, they might have
- 8:41one player or two you know, on occasion, maybe not necessarily.
- 8:47Maybe maybe it is that it's a real elite talent,
- 8:51it goes on and plays in the NFL, or you know,
- 8:55whatever I mean, you think of Bobby Wagner at Utah State,
- 8:59but and maybe Jordan Love. But you know, there's not
- 9:03a whole lot here, so they probably have enough money
- 9:07to find a player like that or two, but that
- 9:09I don't know that that would be any difference than
- 9:11it is now. It's I think it's a challenge for uh,
- 9:19you know, so the group of five. I don't think
- 9:21it's much of a challenge. I think more of the
- 9:22challenges is for a team like where you know, and
- 9:29and yeah, they have the revenue, but maybe it's some
- 9:32of the other programs, like in these lower conferences that
- 9:36that twenty point five million dollars to find and budget
- 9:40and have that that could be a stretch and you
- 9:43you know, you you could lose players, you could not
- 9:47you know, be able to manage that plus all the
- 9:49other things. You got more more of an impact on well,
- 9:56and maybe not the most strong Power four conferences the
- 10:01eighties and the Big twelve.
- 10:03Speaker 4: Scott mitchells our guests here we're talking the fallout of
- 10:05the House settlement.
- 10:06Speaker 2: I want to localize this to the utes.
- 10:10Speaker 4: I went and I looked at the spring football roster
- 10:13that Utah has gotten. I think with the transfers out,
- 10:17I think before the freshmen come in, the guys that
- 10:21are being added to the roster this fall and camp
- 10:24is what like a month and a half away. You've
- 10:27got you got a hundred guys already on the roster,
- 10:30and your limit is one hundred and five, which means
- 10:33you can you can grandfather in the house settlement says
- 10:38athletes that are already on the roster don't have to
- 10:41be subject to twenty twenty five twenty twenty six roster limits,
- 10:45so you can if you want to keep everyone on
- 10:50this roster. I don't foresee that happening, because again, it's
- 10:53a cost basis sort of a situation. Nobody's got an
- 10:58extra fifteen scholarships worth the money around. So if the
- 11:02freshman come in and that brings you to one hundred
- 11:04and twenty guys, fifteen dudes on this roster at Utah
- 11:08are probably getting a call today, tomorrow, sometime during the
- 11:12summer and saying, hey, you can't play with us anymore.
- 11:16Speaker 2: That that sucks. Scott.
- 11:22Speaker 1: Yeah, it's a hard thing to swallow. I'm sure that
- 11:26you know this is probably very low end of the roster.
- 11:30You know that this happens at because if you're a
- 11:34guy that you know maybe is questionable and you you
- 11:39are already in the transfer portal, I don't know how
- 11:43many guys that has it. Coach Whittingham talked a lot
- 11:46about the impact that it has or going to have
- 11:49on on how they practice. Attrition is becoming a much
- 11:55even bigger deal. I think the team that that can
- 12:00handle Attrician the best in college football is ones that
- 12:03typically have the most success. And the more depth you have,
- 12:08the better off you're going to be as far as
- 12:10your team, uh, you know, banking through the season healthy
- 12:16and competing for a championship at the end. But so
- 12:19this changes. Kyle Whittingham has been known to have very physical,
- 12:23tough programs and this really changes, you know, his his
- 12:29his program and and uh and and even how they practice,
- 12:33they can they can't afford to to get people beat
- 12:36up like maybe they could in the past. And that
- 12:39may be hard for him, you know, because that that's
- 12:42his DNA. And so having this limited roster and not
- 12:45only sucks for some of and it does, but it
- 12:48also I think the bigger impact is on how they
- 12:52practice and can you still get the quality of work
- 12:55you you could before with the with the extra bodies.
- 12:58Speaker 4: So I did. I did a little bit of math,
- 13:02and let's say that eighty percent. Is that a reasonable number?
- 13:05Eighty percent of this revenue sharing money goes to football?
- 13:08Speaker 2: You think.
- 13:10Speaker 1: Eighty percent?
- 13:12Speaker 4: Do you think that's a realistic number or should we
- 13:14go with a different number?
- 13:16Speaker 1: I think I think it might change a lot based
- 13:19on the school you're at, because you may have programs.
- 13:23You know, Utah has a gymnastics program that's one of
- 13:27the top in the country, and they may be willing
- 13:29to spend more gymnastics that could, you know, than other
- 13:33other places. I think, uh, you know, there's you know,
- 13:37there's some schools where football is kind of it. So
- 13:41but I'll go with your eighty percent. I think it
- 13:44may be more than that, but eighty is probably a
- 13:47safe number.
- 13:47Speaker 4: Okay, If we go with eighty percent, that's roughly sixteen
- 13:50million dollars to be distributed among one hundred and five
- 13:55players on this Utah roster. That's a again that's directly
- 14:00from the school. I mean, let's say you do it
- 14:04across the board. Everyone gets the same Everyone gets one
- 14:06hundred and fifty grand to be a college football player.
- 14:09Speaker 2: That's amazing. That's wonder.
- 14:12Speaker 4: That's a healthy salary for a grown adult with the family.
- 14:16But if you're Devin Dan Pierre and you're getting one
- 14:20hundred and fifty two thousand dollars and so is GUYE
- 14:23number one oh four on the roster, I mean you've
- 14:27been in a locker room where these financial dynamics have
- 14:31been in place. I was not in a locker room
- 14:33where this was happening, because this is long after I
- 14:36was a crappy walk on. So, like does that even play?
- 14:40And of course everyone gets an al money on top
- 14:42of that, But how does the number change the way
- 14:46that these teams work?
- 14:50Speaker 1: Well, I think, you know, and I like that, you
- 14:54know breakdown of things. The challenge you now come in too,
- 15:00is is, uh, if everyone let's just take like BYU
- 15:04and Utah and and they're all working off of the
- 15:06same budget and and so now it becomes recruiting now
- 15:11becomes important again, uh, you know, being you know because
- 15:15because this this guy that's uh, you know, because you're
- 15:20gonna get the same wherever he goes. So the money
- 15:23isn't going to change. And it's not your top tier
- 15:25guys like they're they're just gonna get more. I mean
- 15:28as far as like making a locker room happy. If
- 15:30you could at least pay all of your players that
- 15:33much money, that would be huge. Uh So that so there,
- 15:37it's it's the player, uh you you now got to
- 15:41recruit them. Culture now comes back into things. I think
- 15:44it was going away. I don't think that's a bad thing.
- 15:47I think it's actually a really good thing. But then
- 15:50then the the other side of it is now now
- 15:55n I L and your ability to be creative in
- 15:58ni L, to still be in the NIL market, uh
- 16:02and to to be very active in it. That's that's
- 16:06that's going to be the difference maker. If you can
- 16:08figure out a way to supplement that so you can
- 16:12go out and attract that upper tier talent. Uh and
- 16:17and and now because because that upper tier talent, you know,
- 16:21you're still going to have quarterbacks in the country, is
- 16:24still going to be buying for two million dollars a year.
- 16:27Uh and and schools schools that that have at schools
- 16:31that find and and and you could argue that a
- 16:35very well known quarterback, high profile guy, you could argue
- 16:40that his value is worth is worth that in your
- 16:43in your marketplace. I mean, you saw that with Cam Rising,
- 16:46Like Cam Rising was very popular and and and he
- 16:50was well sought after, and so you could you could
- 16:52justify the value. So if you're just I love the
- 16:55idea of of of a spreading out the money equally,
- 17:00but I really think where you're going to make a
- 17:03difference in your program is to still be in that
- 17:06nil space.
- 17:08Speaker 4: So with a clearing house that you have to put
- 17:10your nil deals through, Now, do you think that they're
- 17:15actually going to like, let's say that there's a Cam
- 17:17Rising type player, right, a guy who has established himself.
- 17:22Are they going to be able to say no, by they,
- 17:26I mean the commission the clearinghouse. Are they going to
- 17:29be able to say no, you can't have a million
- 17:32dollars from the school because his agent, his lawyer is
- 17:36going to be like, what are you talking about? Like,
- 17:38he's absolutely worth this money. It's going to be harder
- 17:41with freshmen that are incoming people, you know, high school
- 17:44players getting a big, you know, chunk of change from
- 17:48an il when they haven't done anything in a Utah
- 17:50uniform or a Michigan uniform whatever. That's a harder case
- 17:53to make. But when we're talking about you know, Devin
- 17:57Dan Pierre. If you say, well, look I have a
- 18:01million dollar deal with whatever the business is, do you
- 18:04think this clearing house is going to say no, or
- 18:07are they just like they wanting there. The stated goal
- 18:11is to try to even the playing field. Are they
- 18:14really going to try to even the playing field? Are
- 18:16they just going to make sure that you're actually getting
- 18:18nil instead of pay for play booster money.
- 18:24Speaker 1: Yeah. So the way I understood NIL initially was you
- 18:27went to the school. They weren't going there because you
- 18:31were going to be promised money and I owe money.
- 18:35You went there, and then once you were there, then
- 18:38you could establish, you know, what a market was for
- 18:41your name, image and likeness. So it wasn't a pay
- 18:44for play. And I think what happened is the NCAA goes, look,
- 18:49we're being sued like crazy. We have we don't have
- 18:52the bandwidth to fight all of this stuff. So I
- 18:56think the NCAA just gave up. I think they said, oh, yeah,
- 19:00want to transfer portal whenever you want, you want n
- 19:02l A nil money. I don't think there was there.
- 19:05There's been no enforcement of it. There's been no there's
- 19:08been no you know, oversight on it. Only because I
- 19:12think the n Diego's we don't want to be sued more.
- 19:16And and I think that I think this commission or
- 19:18this clearinghouse may have the same issue and may have
- 19:22the same problem because you know, you can argue like
- 19:25Arch Manning as a freshman going into Texas is a
- 19:29very popular and valuable person without ever being paid anything.
- 19:34And and so because he comes with some cachet, he
- 19:37comes with an image that that is marketable. And there
- 19:41are other players around the country, these I mean these players,
- 19:44the well known players before they get to college. A
- 19:47lot of them are very well known, and so they're
- 19:50they and and and for for the sake of the player,
- 19:54you know what, they should be paid something because they
- 19:56do have that. Now, whether they pan out in college
- 19:58is a totally different thing. But still they're recognizable and
- 20:02there's value in that. And if someone's you know, going
- 20:06to to kind of be the police on that, that's
- 20:10a scary thing. And they may just get the point
- 20:12to say forget it. Yeah, you know, they're just going
- 20:15to kind of lay down and just so they don't
- 20:18end up in lowsuits, or if there's a way that
- 20:20they can have a consistent analysis for you know what
- 20:26a proper deal is and if they can and if
- 20:31they have the ability to do that or implement that
- 20:34where it's very clear, it's very cut and dried, and
- 20:37you understand going into it. Okay, yeah, you can get
- 20:40paid for this. You can't get paid for that that
- 20:43that works. You can only get this after you've enrolled
- 20:45in a school whatever. You know. I don't, and I
- 20:49don't know what that looks like or how they're going
- 20:51to put that together. But I think there's the potential
- 20:54of a lot of lawsuits. And let's face it, there's
- 20:57a lot of money involved here, and there's going to
- 20:58be lawsuits if people feel like they've been harmed or
- 21:02injured by not capitalizing on a professional sport that they're
- 21:07a part of.
- 21:08Speaker 4: So back when NIL became allowable in a thing, I
- 21:12was doing Serious XM radio and I was on with
- 21:14Rick Neuheisel and we were talking about will this change
- 21:19the stars for any program? And the conclusion for the
- 21:22most part largely was well no, because you know, Texas
- 21:26is still going to be Texas and Ohio State is
- 21:28still going to be Ohio State. And my prediction was
- 21:31that actually it could help BYU and it could help Stanford.
- 21:35It has not helped Stanford. It has helped BYU. Is
- 21:39this is the house settlement and the new guard rails.
- 21:42Is it going to change the stars for everyone or anyone?
- 21:48Speaker 1: Oh? I think some people will benefit from it.
- 21:52Speaker 2: I really do.
- 21:53Speaker 1: I think it, you know, especially with players today, knowing
- 21:57I don't have to go to a blue Bloe program
- 22:00to get to the next level. I really need to play.
- 22:05And if I can go out and I can play,
- 22:07and I can play in a good program uh and excel,
- 22:11then then that will get me to the next level.
- 22:14Because the reality is is the best way to grow
- 22:17and develop as a player is to play. And I'm
- 22:19a firm believer in that. And I don't care where
- 22:22the level is or you know, what conference you are
- 22:24in or what color your jersey is. If you're out
- 22:27on the field taking reps in game situations, man, you
- 22:31you're learning and and and so. So these players can Yeah,
- 22:38maybe there could be a school they go I don't
- 22:41have to go to the bluebread program, and that school
- 22:44has a pretty solid NIL strategy and they can entice
- 22:49me away. I absolutely think it can can change a
- 22:55school situation one one thousand percent. But you'll still have
- 23:00Ohio State, and you'll still have Texas, You'll still have
- 23:02all those schools. Will will never go away. They may
- 23:08they may kind of change from time to time. You know,
- 23:10it makes way to Tennessee for a while, and of
- 23:13Florida and away from Georgia and Alabama. But but those
- 23:16big programs in the SCC and the Big ten, they're
- 23:19they're always gonna always gonna be there.
- 23:23Speaker 4: Well, we're getting closer to when we get to talk
- 23:25about real football instead of all this crazy stuff. And
- 23:28I know you look forward to that as much as
- 23:29I do. But thanks for joining me today, Scott.
- 23:33Speaker 1: Yeah, you got a great topic and always the pleasure
- 23:35to talk to you.
- 23:35Speaker 4: Sean Scott Mitchell, Utah quarterbacking legend, color analyst on the
- 23:41Utah Radio Broadcasts, friend of the program, host of The
- 23:45Down and Dirty Right Here on ESPN seven hundred ninety
- 23:48two to one FM, immediately preceding the Sean O'Connell Show,