Latest / Partnered with a Survivor: David Mandel and Ruth Reymundo Mandel / Season 5 Episode 13: Coercive Control & Children Conference Podcast: The Role of Language in Global Responses to Domestic Abuse
Transcript
- 0:17David Mandel: and we're back we're back and, uh, this is a special ask me anything.
- 0:22David Mandel: Partner with a Survivor for the North American European Course of Control in Children Conference by Safe and Together.
- 0:29David Mandel: I'm David Mandel, ceo of the Safe and Together Institute.
- 0:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I'm Ruth Ramundo Mandel and I want to do a little bit of a land acknowledgement.
- 0:37Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So Safe and Together Institute recognizes the traditional custodians of the land and honors those elders past, present and emerging.
- 0:48Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And currently we are on Tunxis Masako land and it snowed today.
- 0:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Today was the first snow, so we have a beautiful blanket of fresh snow, which I'm not quite excited about, but it's really good because we haven't been getting a lot of rain.
- 1:05Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So welcome everyone, and I think you wanted to start off.
- 1:10David Mandel: I did, and this is our first podcast in front of a live studio audience.
- 1:15David Mandel: This is kind of very cool.
- 1:17David Mandel: It's gonna be a short one, about 40 minutes, yeah, and we're gonna ask each other a question, each of us a question to start, and then we're going to open up.
- 1:26David Mandel: So you know, hopefully people are out there We'll have questions.
- 1:30David Mandel: If not, we've got more questions.
- 1:31David Mandel: We've got Nicola and Leah in the wings.
- 1:33David Mandel: So, ruth, you know we put this podcast together.
- 1:39David Mandel: Actually it was your idea.
- 1:40David Mandel: You came to me and said you know, let's do this podcast, partner with a survivor and let's talk about, um, how this uh works and um, so what?
- 1:52David Mandel: I, I, um, I'm really curious.
- 1:54David Mandel: You know, where did the, the persona cranky survivor, come from?
- 1:59David Mandel: deep inside my bones how much much of it is a persona, how much of it is it really you?
- 2:06Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Okay, well, the answer is that it's both.
- 2:09Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Having been a person who grew up in an institution and experienced a lot of institutional behaviors both in that institution and then post institution, where I was seeking assistance, I have a lot of empathy for the way that victim survivors navigate through the environment.
- 2:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But one of the people who really influenced me was a woman by the name of Courageous Fire, and I always give her credit for this because she's amazing and you should look her up.
- 2:44Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I always give her credit for this because she's amazing and you should look her up.
- 2:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And she does a training where she teaches professionals how to engage, particularly with Black women, and she pulls up the main archetypes that are believed in our society about Black women, which also applies a lot to Hispanic and Latina women and she does this as a way to try to train professionals into not responding to those particular sets of behaviors, especially during trauma and threat, in further harmful ways.
- 3:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Again, it's a strategy for partnering.
- 3:29Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I feel like all of us are really not good at conflict.
- 3:33Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We avoid it, we try not to engage in it.
- 3:37Ruth Reymundo Mandel: When we're in a professional capacity and we feel like we're being criticized, our immediate defensiveness comes up and, after having been in the medical field I knew that the way that people respond to those moments of conflict and challenge to their practice is an integral part of their ability to do effective practice and that in the medical field people who don't respond to that well practice.
- 4:06Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And that in the medical field people who don't respond to that well often are people who have multiple malpractice suits against them.
- 4:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And so for me it's a way to try to anesthetize inoculate professionals against that reflexive behavior that when they hear anger and criticism and real alarm from survivors, particularly women, who are of different cultures than them, then they respond by doubling down, by removing self-determination, by labeling that victim survivor as the problem and problematic, because they're really pushing on the practices and the ways that that professional is behaving.
- 4:45Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So in a way it's a dual strategy.
- 4:48Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Absolutely Cranky survivor leaves deep in my bones and there was no way I could keep her from coming out.
- 4:54Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But that it's a very intentional strategy.
- 4:57Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That when I feel that outrage inside of my body at the illogic, the insanity of our collective behaviors when we're dealing with victim survivors, that it's so important for people to hear how that impacts victim survivors in a real, tangible way and hear the anger and outrage and pain and suffering, confusion and the loss of self-determination that's happening.
- 5:28David Mandel: You know I love Cranky Survivor.
- 5:30Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's a good thing.
- 5:33David Mandel: I love Cranky Survivor as you and I love Cranky Survivor as the persona.
- 5:37David Mandel: And all I'll say to add to that is just, I think, to professionals, if we want to assume the mantle you know claim to be domestic abuse informed and trauma informed, by which a lot of us aspire to, which is appropriate that, um, we need that ability here.
- 5:54David Mandel: Survivors anger, anger the system, anger how they've been treated.
- 5:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: not personalize it, not, um, you know, uh, not take it on, not deny it, listen to it and understand it being abusive or being they're being abused in their organization, their practices being abusive of institutional unaccountability impacting them, and you see an organizational response where somebody stands up and represents the institution and takes it personally.
- 6:38Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is absolutely a sign that their organization is not dealing internally with issues in their practice, with problems with their policy, with professional unaccountability, perhaps even professional criminality.
- 6:56Ruth Reymundo Mandel: There is no reason that, as professionals, we shouldn't be trained into conflict management that allows us to hear that type of anger without responding like children, very defensively, with a lot of emotion.
- 7:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We're professionals, right?
- 7:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Isn't that the definition of professionalism?
- 7:16David Mandel: Sorry.
- 7:16David Mandel: So that's cranky survivor question.
- 7:18David Mandel: Do you want to ask me?
- 7:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I absolutely do, and then we'll take questions from the audience.
- 7:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I absolutely do, but I need to get my glasses because I'm blind.
- 7:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So one of the things that I'm curious about and I think it's really important to name the fact that we're working with relationships and that that can be deeply personal, even though we're professionals and we're trained to work with people around violence.
- 7:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We're professionals and we're trained to work with people around violence, but you know, as a man working to disrupt male violence and gender double standards, what's been your biggest personal struggle about engaging this work and living that as a value?
- 7:58David Mandel: You know, we create these questions and that was, you know, a huge, huge question for me.
- 8:02David Mandel: You it, I think for me what I'll say is it goes back, you know, decades in some sense.
- 8:11David Mandel: Where you know, I, um, was asked when I went through my first training with the duluth um organization, a domestic use intervention project which is famous for the power and control wheel and coordinated community response, and I got trained by Ellen Pence and um.
- 8:29David Mandel: They asked us in the training to to focus and, and you know, acknowledge where we've been controlling.
- 8:37David Mandel: And it was, you know, and I thought I had done a lot of work even at that point.
- 8:41David Mandel: It was not new to me.
- 8:42David Mandel: I, I looked at patriarchy and gender and men had some education around feminism.
- 8:51David Mandel: I was young, I was in my early 20s and but it was a profound question to really just directly say look at your controlling and acknowledge.
- 9:02David Mandel: And I had to look back at my past at that point in relationships and acknowledge where I'd been controlling.
- 9:07David Mandel: And for me it's been a journey, constant journey.
- 9:14David Mandel: I think of it as a spiritual one, not just a one about gender, but about acknowledging where I'm powerless, acknowledging where I have control, being very focused on being as consent based as I can in my relationships and and one of my favorite examples of it is is where I do doing work with men I was looking at sort of conflict resolution.
- 9:38David Mandel: Again, this is going back years and saying it's uh, when I say I'm sorry, it's not quite the same same thing as saying I'm wrong and and so I really kind of looked at you know sort of embracing, sort of admitting I was wrong as a practice when I made a mistake or did something might have hurt somebody, or just acknowledge that I didn't know.
- 10:00David Mandel: I just I really kind of try to embed that and I think where it kind of comes into gender is you know, men are taught that you're not supposed to admit that you're wrong.
- 10:09David Mandel: Men are taught that you're not supposed to admit that you don't know Men are taught that you're not supposed to kind of accept limits or powerlessness or feeling afraid, or feeling afraid and you know I don't want to say, you know, at this point are there tensions around it?
- 10:24David Mandel: still, sure, but it's a, it's a this point.
- 10:26David Mandel: It's a real practice for me to kind of look at those things yeah, that's.
- 10:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I think that's so important, um, to acknowledge that so many of these responses we have to not being in control, to being afraid, to not knowing, have been shaped and formed by our views around gender control, competency, and really sit and reflect on how much we respect people who have the ability to cleanly and clearly say I made a mistake, that was wrong of me, I didn't know, I was afraid, or whatever you know, just to acknowledge that.
- 11:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I, I, I love that, I love that as a practice.
- 11:16David Mandel: Yes, thank you.
- 11:17David Mandel: So all right.
- 11:18Speaker 3: So so let's open it up to the studio.
- 11:23David Mandel: See, you know, and I don't know if, if you want to raise your hand, alexia, if you can help us, or Jumi, you know.
- 11:33Speaker 3: Yeah, absolutely.
- 11:34Speaker 3: We have a question from Dr Carol Jones.
- 11:35Speaker 3: She says I work with a lot of soldiers and their families.
- 11:38Speaker 3: What are your thoughts about bi-directional violence?
- 11:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's.
- 11:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: A lot of people you know talk about that as mutualized violence.
- 11:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You know, we have a little bit of a different perspective on it.
- 11:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's really important that when there's two people that are displaying behaviors that would be considered violent, that there is an analysis done of who has power and control in the relationship.
- 12:03Ruth Reymundo Mandel: People are really bad at understanding power dynamics, right?
- 12:07Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's one of the key things about this is that in understanding violence, you do have to understand the power dynamics of the situation, and a lot of times when people use the term mutualized violence, bidirectional violence, they're actually naming that survivors engage in what I call acts of resistance and sometimes that includes physical acts of resistance and that we have neutralized every single action.
- 12:38Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We've said it's all equal.
- 12:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well, it's not all equal.
- 12:41Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's absolutely incorrect.
- 12:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: If you have a person who's sitting on the ground and their perpetrator is over them screaming and yelling at them and they get up and push that person or they slap that person, that is not the same interaction.
- 12:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: There is not the same level of control or power or fear within that situation, and so, where we spend a lot of time on ascertaining the motivations of people who are violent to each other that don't know each other, we make a really horrible assumption that people who know each other are on equal footing, and that's not real.
- 13:21David Mandel: What I would add is I love that.
- 13:23David Mandel: What I would add is that Carol is one is this is the value of a coercive control approach, because you need to contextualize it and you know, if somebody is shown that they're willing and able to use violence, then somebody may strike first because they're worried about worse violence happening, but just to kind of to land this you know, with with the perpetrator pattern mapping tool, you know, and then the safe at the other model.
- 13:49David Mandel: What we do is we'll tell people, map each person's pattern, of course, control and actions taking to harm the kids, and and look at that and look at them independently, actions taking the harm of the kids and and look at that and look at them independently.
- 14:03David Mandel: The value of the perpetrator pattern-based approach is it cites the pattern in the person, not the relationship.
- 14:06David Mandel: So you're going to look at both people and you're going to list both their behaviors separately and their patterns and their patterns across relationships and their patterns to their kids and past partners, maybe outside the relationship, maybe somebody the relationship, maybe somebody's law enforcement, maybe somebody's a gang member, maybe somebody's got training in martial arts, you know, and you put all those things together and what I'll tell you is it used the term bidirectional, ruth kind of used the term mutual.
- 14:34David Mandel: My experience is coming from a state where we had at once a 15% dual arrest rate, you know, which is really high, but mostly men and women, you know, male and female getting arrested.
- 14:44David Mandel: That this was something I was confronted earlier in my career quite a bit and it worked really well and rarely.
- 14:50David Mandel: What I'll tell you is when you got down to the behavior patterns of each person, it was rarely mutual.
- 14:56David Mandel: Sometimes it was unclear, rarely was it situational kind of mutual, equal, both people were not afraid.
- 15:04David Mandel: Usually there wasn't wider patterns of control, but almost always this approach actually showed you.
- 15:12David Mandel: You's why I love the model behavioral approach.
- 15:14David Mandel: It would show male perpetrator and female victim, but times it would show the reverse, which is, show it's sensitivity.
- 15:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, I think there's one more point that we need to make about that language, because that language is often leveraged and used more often against women who are of minoritized status.
- 15:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Just FYI, there's a lot of bias about that.
- 15:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You know, in communities that have historically been focused upon by carceral entities that those women give as good as they get, and actually what those women are doing is they're engaging in legitimate self-defense for their physical safety and also for their self-determination and their freedoms, their liberties, their rights and their dignities.
- 16:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So I want to just point out that when that mutualizing, bidirectional language is used, there's often an element of the female survivor being a woman who is from a marginalized population, and that is an absolute bias.
- 16:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And that's where spicy Latina comes in.
- 16:31David Mandel: Which is different than cranky survivor.
- 16:33Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Which is different than cranky survivor, because it is an archetype that people overlay on women of certain ethnicities and races.
- 16:43David Mandel: Okay, Alexia.
- 16:44David Mandel: Next question Do you have anything else coming in?
- 16:47Speaker 3: Yeah from Esther.
- 16:48Speaker 3: Can you suggest some modalities that a survivor can use to release the anger, not stuff it in or tone it down?
- 16:55Speaker 3: It's not about anger management, it's about owning it and releasing it so it doesn't make us sick.
- 17:01Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Oh yeah, let me give you some strategies.
- 17:04Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I love this question and it is true.
- 17:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You know, if you've had your liberties removed, if you've had your self-determination removed, if you've had your bodily autonomy removed, if you've been treated like a punching bag, you are going to be angry.
- 17:23Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is a normal human reaction to having your boundaries crossed.
- 17:25Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And first that's the first place I want to start Anger is not the problem.
- 17:29Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Anger is a physical response.
- 17:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is a biological, hormonal, physical response to having our boundaries crossed, our self-determination removed, or to being injured and harmed repeatedly by someone.
- 17:44Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And so, for me, working with the anger is first acknowledging that it has some value, that it is valuable as an emotion, that it doesn't always equal violence, that it's not actually a problem.
- 17:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And I want to look at anybody who makes their anger a problem, who's been abused, and say you are so brilliant.
- 18:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Look how brilliant your body is.
- 18:10Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It knows exactly when your boundaries are being crossed.
- 18:12Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It's telling you and no one is paying attention.
- 18:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And it's happening over and over again.
- 18:18Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Of course you're angry, be angry, but let's talk about how, once you're in a place where you're safe and you're not constantly being triggered and your boundaries are not constantly being crossed.
- 18:31Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So hear that you have to be in a situation where you're safe to truly deal with that pent up anger.
- 18:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Everybody needs to hear that you have to be in a situation where you're safe to truly deal with that pent-up anger.
- 18:38Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Everybody needs to hear that If you have a survivor who's still being stalked, who's still being abused, who's being abused by systems, they are legitimately going to still be angry.
- 18:47Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Do not try to take that from them, because their body is telling them that people are doing things that are harmful for them.
- 18:55Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's a good thing, but what can be done to help us to heal after we're in a situation where we're safe is to, first of all, really love the way that our anger gave us information, say thank you, you're awesome.
- 19:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You told me you did that, you did a good job.
- 19:15Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Nobody else responded.
- 19:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You told me you did that, you did a good job.
- 19:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Nobody else responded.
- 19:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You knew exactly what was happening.
- 19:19Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And then also to really just have conversations about it, to express it I'm feeling very angry right now.
- 19:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I'm feeling very frustrated.
- 19:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I do this with you and you're he's really good at when I get angry because, believe me, when I come against industry stuff, frankie Survivor comes out and she's ah, and I'm Latino, so very expressive and you're very good at just knowing that this is anger is an appropriate response to the things that we're seeing, that it's not being directed at somebody, it's generalized anger.
- 19:52Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So anger gets translated into blame that doesn't have any grounding in reality, or into self-destructive actions or into further abuse of other people, demeaning them, harming them, removing their liberties.
- 20:11Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's when anger is no longer beneficial to our experience in the world and is harming other people.
- 20:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I don't know if you want to add on that.
- 20:19David Mandel: I don't have a lot.
- 20:20David Mandel: I don't want to add anything to your experience as a survivor and speaking as a survivor to another survivor with how I train professionals and talk to professionals is really trying to teach or support professionals in supporting women and supporting survivors in their room to maneuver and engage in acts of resistance.
- 20:51Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And express it.
- 20:53David Mandel: One of the things I do when I train family court professionals is, I say we're so, of a parental alienation being used as a weapon against survivors?
- 21:01David Mandel: Right, and it's a way to shut survivors up.
- 21:04David Mandel: Right, it's a way to shut survivors anger up Survivors protective capacities.
- 21:09Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Depends to draw boundaries.
- 21:10David Mandel: Draw boundaries, draw boundaries.
- 21:16David Mandel: And so one of the questions I asked a group of report writers in Family Corps is tell me where you think it's actually appropriate and correct and good parenting for a survivor to resist her children having contact with the abusive parent?
- 21:27David Mandel: So actually, instead of skirting around the issue, I want to run right at it.
- 21:32David Mandel: I want to directly kind of say to people look like a parent who actually says no, you can't have my kid because you're going to sexually abuse them.
- 21:43David Mandel: And if they're angry that's okay, if they're boundary that's good.
- 21:47David Mandel: That's, in fact, something we should applaud.
- 21:49David Mandel: We should applaud that kind of anger, we should applaud that kind of boundary setting, and I think we tiptoe around these things well, we want them to be mama bears, but we don't want them to be mama bears.
- 22:02David Mandel: Let's be honest I love that, and we don't want to direct it at us, and we want them to do it when we think it's appropriate we want women to be like I will die for my children, but they people don't internalize what that actually means, but only on only under the conditions that I think that she should do you can only die this way.
- 22:19David Mandel: Only under the circumstances I deem as being justified.
- 22:21David Mandel: Yeah, so, yeah, absolutely so, that's the only thing I want to add is that we need, as professionals and for those of you who don't listen to our podcast and haven't, this is often we talk about these different perspectives, but for me, I'm focused on the professional saying run towards survivor's anger, like, embrace it.
- 22:42David Mandel: Ask yourself how prepared you are to hear survivors be angry at you, angry at the system, angry that if you're like, for instance, child protection, survivors should quote unquote be angry that you're showing up in their life because somebody else's choices and behaviors.
- 23:00David Mandel: Absolutely, that's a normal, healthy reaction because they're being forced to deal with a system because of somebody else's problems, and so I think it's.
- 23:11David Mandel: I want to create more space.
- 23:12David Mandel: You know all this.
- 23:13David Mandel: The coercive control concept is so useful because it's about it helps keep us focused on.
- 23:18David Mandel: People have the right to maneuver the room, to maneuver the room for action, and that room for action should be dictated and shaped by the circumstances.
- 23:27David Mandel: So somebody like you said, just to wrap up, you know it's a natural, normal response, and if professionals aren't trained to be embracing, of that.
- 23:36Ruth Reymundo Mandel: There would be something wrong with that person if they were not angry.
- 23:41David Mandel: Yeah, that's right, so that's it, so all right.
- 23:45Speaker 3: Any other questions?
- 23:46David Mandel: Yeah, what's next, alexia?
- 23:47Speaker 3: Yeah, we have a two-part question from Lauren.
- 23:50Speaker 3: Lauren says we rightly put so much emphasis on the language that we use and document in the safe and together framework.
- 23:58Speaker 3: Do you feel that the safe and together will ever use the term abuse rather than violence and do?
- 24:04David Mandel: you think it matters oh yeah, global sense of the model we actually do use the term we're really shifting and we're shifting through our language and it's it's a slow project to help a whole country shift with us.
- 24:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So keep it up, brett.
- 24:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, thank you.
- 24:20David Mandel: So we're trying to use first is no language is perfect.
- 24:24Ruth Reymundo Mandel: No, it's not.
- 24:25David Mandel: You know people will talk about the word perpetrator and people have different issues and with that.
- 24:29David Mandel: But we're trying to actually change in recognition of feedback we've gotten and the advancement in the field.
- 24:37David Mandel: Remember, the model is started about 20 years ago, so there's a constant kind of updating we're trying to do and so you'll hear us more frequently use domestic abuse informed.
- 24:48Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yes.
- 24:49David Mandel: Because we think that's more reflective of the global conversation, the language used in places in the United Kingdom, and we're're trying to decenter North America, particularly United States, in our work.
- 25:00David Mandel: And so absolutely and, and.
- 25:04David Mandel: What I would say is and, and even then the word won't be perfect.
- 25:08Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah.
- 25:09Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I talk a little bit about the nature of language actually philosophy and English major over here Can't help myself of language actually philosophy and English major over here Can't help myself and that is is that somehow we believe that we're going to get to these finite definitions and our language is always going to be the same.
- 25:26Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I want to challenge that notion a little bit.
- 25:28Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We always have to evolve with the strategies of perpetrators and the language that they are using and the way that language in our industry is being used by them to leverage their power and control.
- 25:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Which means if we find that all of a sudden there's a pattern of people using a specific term in a specific way to hide their perpetration, that means we all have to address that pattern and shift with that.
- 25:53Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That is so challenging in systems that are static and non-dynamic.
- 25:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: But life is dynamic, people are dynamic, language is dynamic and we are coming from an English language framework.
- 26:09Ruth Reymundo Mandel: There's a lot of other languages that have a lot of different words and ways to communicate violence and that's why one of the reasons why relying on those jargon pieces is problematic.
- 26:22Ruth Reymundo Mandel: They don't shift with people's behaviors, they don't describe behaviors, they're a label, right?
- 26:30Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So then when you label something as this, people assume they know what you mean.
- 26:35Ruth Reymundo Mandel: No, we need to go deeper.
- 26:37Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We actually need to talk about behaviors, because behaviors give context.
- 26:41Ruth Reymundo Mandel: If we live in the world of jargon, we don't actually tell the story of what's going on and we don't contextualize it.
- 26:49Ruth Reymundo Mandel: And decontextualization is the favorite tool of perpetrators, favorite tool.
- 26:57Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Decontextualize it.
- 26:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Make everything equal.
- 26:59Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Use the jargon.
- 27:00Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Let's use the jargon.
- 27:02Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You notice how easily manipulated that is.
- 27:11David Mandel: The last thing I'll kind of add to that's a great question is about the Institute, is we're actively we actually try to balance a couple of things, which is listen and contextualize to the local environment and evolve and evolve and also and this is some great feedback we've gotten is also stay true to our principles and what is essential about the model and an example of that is not about the word domestic abuse or domestic violence, but the word partnering.
- 27:33David Mandel: And I got approached in a family court setting with saying well, you know, courts don't partner.
- 27:39David Mandel: I love that.
- 27:40David Mandel: Courts, we don't partner with anybody.
- 27:41David Mandel: And the way you can make I can sort of not make fun of it but just to be like, of course not, but that's true.
- 27:51David Mandel: Courts need and we want courts.
- 27:54David Mandel: Let's be really clear, all the kind of jokey aside we want courts to be objective.
- 27:58David Mandel: We want them to to start from a neutral place, not prejudging anybody based on race, ethnicity, demographics, gender, gender.
- 28:06David Mandel: Look at evidence, you know, and be evidence based.
- 28:08David Mandel: We want that told.
- 28:16David Mandel: Well, that partnering language doesn't work for the court.
- 28:17David Mandel: I had to think about it and we may still evolve around this, but I still kept that language in the training for a family court and what I said was let's break down the behavior behind partnering, which is kind of what you said, ruth, which is that partnering really what it means in the court setting is we start from neutral and objective.
- 28:32David Mandel: We don't prejudge, we use a transparent behavioral lens or understanding, of course, control and action taking the harm of the kids.
- 28:38David Mandel: We apply that equally to both parties, fairly to both parties.
- 28:41David Mandel: We gather the evidence about those behavior patterns and the harm they create and then, based on that, if we end up with which we do a lot of times with a primary aggressor who's consistently engaged in these abusive behaviors harmful to kids, has not engaged in change in a meaningful way, and we have on the other side of protective parent, that it makes sense that the court will make decisions supportive of and in alignment with the protective parent, full stop.
- 29:07David Mandel: Now, whether you call that partner or not, that's about children's best interests, children's safety.
- 29:13David Mandel: It's in line with what the court's mission is and what their statutory responsibility is.
- 29:18David Mandel: So I kind of presented that back to them.
- 29:21David Mandel: They said that makes sense to us.
- 29:23David Mandel: We're okay with the language if it's kind of explained that way, and that's why they're getting underneath the jargon, even our own jargon at the Institute is so important.
- 29:33Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right, yeah, and constantly assessing how it's playing out in practice, in all reality.
- 29:38Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's a very important thing, that's right.
- 29:41David Mandel: All right, we have time for one more question, maybe two, depending on how we answer.
- 29:45David Mandel: So, alexa, anybody else kind of on deck?
- 29:48Speaker 3: Yeah, this next question is from Gina.
- 29:50Speaker 3: Which aspects of coaching have you found to be the most effective in supporting practitioners and making the shift in practice, beyond documentation with families?
- 30:00David Mandel: Oh wow, that's a big question.
- 30:07David Mandel: I'll take this as a behavioral modification, yeah no, I'll tell you, what I've had the most fun with and I think is super effective and I've done it in versions of this in different settings is I will often get, in trainings but other settings, people saying when they hear the model say well, when do you hold the victim parent responsible?
- 30:29David Mandel: Okay, for what, what do we hold?
- 30:31David Mandel: Well, right, exactly.
- 30:32David Mandel: So, when you know, and and and.
- 30:36David Mandel: There's different ways to deal with it, but one is a kind of coaching, experiential way.
- 30:40David Mandel: Okay, and so what I'll say to them is all right, can you go along with me?
- 30:45David Mandel: You can do this in a one-on-one setting or in a small group setting.
- 30:48David Mandel: It doesn't need to be in a training setting.
- 30:49David Mandel: I'll say okay, so you're absolutely right that if I'm a victim parent, a survivor parent, I have legal responsibilities to my kids and I have things I have to be accountable for legally as a parent.
- 31:02David Mandel: Nobody's going to argue I won't argue with that, and I doubt the survivor will argue with you about that that they care about the kids.
- 31:08David Mandel: They want to take care of their kids.
- 31:09David Mandel: I said okay, so what I want you to do and this is the coaching slash, role playing I tell it to that person you're the social worker.
- 31:19David Mandel: I'm the mother, so this becomes very experiential.
- 31:22David Mandel: You're going to talk to me about my responsibilities to my kids.
- 31:27David Mandel: The only ground rule is you cannot blame me for my partner's behavior.
- 31:32Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I've seen him do this a million times.
- 31:34David Mandel: That's the only ground rule.
- 31:36David Mandel: You can't blame me for what the perpetrator's done and the effects of what the perpetrator did.
- 31:41David Mandel: And what I can tell you is, for instance, from a coaching point of view, giving people that experiential and they'll say well, this is what I would say to mom.
- 31:48David Mandel: I'd say, no, you have to talk to me as if I'm the mom, because it's in the embodying.
- 31:53David Mandel: So this is one of the takeaways in the embodying, in the practicing, I think.
- 31:58David Mandel: A lot of times talking about, like you said about jargon earlier, it lets us kind of hide from ourselves and from some of our more difficult challenges.
- 32:08David Mandel: But but when, when they do that, I have to tell you, almost every single time, people will stop and start.
- 32:13David Mandel: They'll be like well, mom, I think you should, oh, that's going to sound bad.
- 32:17David Mandel: Well, mom, you really need.
- 32:19David Mandel: Oh, that's like.
- 32:20David Mandel: And so what they're really doing is they're trying to find a way to blame her for his behavior, what he's doing to the kids.
- 32:26David Mandel: But when they hear themselves say it out loud, or they're about to say it out loud, they catch themselves.
- 32:31David Mandel: And I think, from a coaching point of view, whether they end up getting it or not, everybody else gets it watching it.
- 32:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: You know it's so funny because this is totally going to reveal.
- 32:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I grew up in the 80s, I think of like Pac-Man, where Pac-Man keeps running under the wall Right and he's trying to, and it's really true, now I've got the Pac-Man noise, maybe we need a video game, a partnering video game?
- 32:57Ruth Reymundo Mandel: the pac-man noise like the scooter.
- 32:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Maybe we need a video game, a partnering video game, um, but you know, I I think that one of the things that's so important to remember is that we have all been raised, trained, grown up in the soup of mother blaming and victim blaming and ignoring the violence of violent men or skirting around the issue, trying to avoid it, covering it up, being afraid to address it.
- 33:18Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Because we're afraid, because it's hard, confrontation is hard.
- 33:21Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We know that we're going to become a target and so we've all been raised in this environment.
- 33:27Ruth Reymundo Mandel: We all have those habits and the real way to deal with that is for us to collectively support each other in modeling different behaviors through that type of behavioral approach.
- 33:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So if you have training, you know people who are heads of training and you notice that a worker is struggling with this, do some actual role-playing and behavioral role-playing so that they can really get the feeling of doing that in real time.
- 33:58Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Right, you know, it's important.
- 34:00David Mandel: I think, going back to the anger thing, you know, you know I might say to somebody okay, I want, I want to role-play this, or I'm going to give you, I'm going to coach you to go back out and talk to mom, and I would do this all the time.
- 34:10David Mandel: We have our six steps of partnering and that's really, you know, really kind of a guide for us around coaching workers.
- 34:16Ruth Reymundo Mandel: For a little while.
- 34:17Ruth Reymundo Mandel: There was a, there was a, there was a image floating around a partnering as dance steps.
- 34:23Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Because I was trying to do some physical behavioral stuff with people.
- 34:31David Mandel: So we might pull that back up and shoot it out for you guys.
- 34:32David Mandel: But you know to say to people, instruction could be to coach them.
- 34:34David Mandel: I said go back out and validate mom's anger, you know, or approach mom and the only rule is you can't blame her for his behavior and you can't make her anger about her situation or problem.
- 34:47David Mandel: So let's or let's role play that specific instructions and these kind of when you have this map that lets you break down and safety, other really in my mind, is meant to give you that map.
- 35:02David Mandel: Cause sometimes when people see me doing things, all I'm doing is using the model, All I'm doing is focusing on behaviors, All I'm doing is pivoting to the perpetrator and just applying that rigorously over and over again.
- 35:13David Mandel: And so you know, coaching people to be like okay, tell me about his pattern of behavior, Tell me what that looks like, and if they're doing something else this is the key Bring them back to that.
- 35:25David Mandel: You know, if there's talking about his childhood history, make a note and just say, okay, we're hearing about his history, but I'm not sure what the relevance of that history to his current pattern is.
- 35:35David Mandel: So there's a lot of ways we can coach, but that's just kind of a rubric to think about.
- 35:40David Mandel: So we have four minutes.
- 35:43Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Sadly, we have to start to wrap up here, yeah, and it's been wonderful doing this at our conference.
- 35:50Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I hope that you all enjoyed the experience and always, as always, we want to hear from you about the topics and the practice information that's important to you.
- 36:05Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So if you have suggestions for the podcast, if there are things or people or organizations that you would want us to highlight, to interview, please let us know.
- 36:15Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Yeah, yeah.
- 36:17David Mandel: Yeah, and I really value this concept that you brought to life.
- 36:24David Mandel: You know that we brought to life.
- 36:26David Mandel: It was your concept of the podcast to have our dialogues, you and I, and to model this.
- 36:33Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Well, it's kind of funny.
- 36:34Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So maybe this is a bit cultural, but I've noticed that a lot of people think that they aren't existing in relationships.
- 36:46Ruth Reymundo Mandel: As professionals, we're in the business of healthy relationships, people.
- 36:51Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's what we're trying to facilitate here in this world, both for the well-being and safety of children, but also for the well-being and the functionality of our communities and our societies, which means that men and women need to be able to work together and collaborate together real in real time.
- 37:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: Real in real time.
- 37:20Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So giving people an example about how a professional who has a lot of industry experiences responds to somebody who's a survivor, especially in anger criticism, deep pain, is a really important behavioral modeling of how men and women can collaborate and work together to change the reality that we're living in right now.
- 37:39Ruth Reymundo Mandel: It is possible.
- 37:40Ruth Reymundo Mandel: There are good relationships, there are good collaborations, people who are out there that are nurturing and sustaining our connections and relationships, and lots of people doing amazing things.
- 37:53Ruth Reymundo Mandel: So let's really reflect in and on ourselves how we're approaching this work, if we really are internalizing the work itself and we're bringing it to our own relationships and our own communities and our own families, because if we're not doing that, then we're not actually doing the work that we need to do.
- 38:13Ruth Reymundo Mandel: That's great, that's great so so this has been partnered with the survivor, the live version, the studio audience version.
- 38:22David Mandel: I'm still David Mandel.
- 38:23Ruth Reymundo Mandel: I'm still Ruth.
- 38:24David Mandel: Ramundo.
- 38:24David Mandel: Okay, and with that we are we're out.
- 38:27David Mandel: We're out.