Latest / The Psychology Undergrad Podcast / Involuntary Commitment: When Courts Order Mental Health Treatment (Civil vs Criminal)
Transcript
- 0:00Imagine paying your debt to society. Like, you
- 0:04sit in the cell for years. You mark off the days
- 0:07until the calendar finally hits zero on your
- 0:09sentence. Right. You're packing your stuff, expecting
- 0:12to just walk out the gates. Exactly. You expect
- 0:14to walk out a free person. But instead of walking
- 0:16free, a judge legally intercepts you, and they
- 0:19send you to a secure island facility indefinitely.
- 0:22Which sounds completely made up. Right. It sounds
- 0:24like a dystopian novel, but not for a new crime
- 0:27you committed. for a crime a doctor thinks you
- 0:29might commit in the future. And that is an absolute
- 0:33reality in the American legal system today. It
- 0:35really is. You know, usually when we talk about
- 0:38the law, there is this expectation of, like,
- 0:41mechanical precision. Yeah, totally. Like, you
- 0:43run a red light, the traffic camera snaps a picture,
- 0:45and the judge looks at the objective evidence
- 0:47and issues a $50 fine. It's broken law, or not
- 0:51broken law. It's clean, it's binary, and honestly,
- 0:54it is comforting. It is comforting. We inherently
- 0:56want human behavior to be visible and, you know,
- 1:00measurable. Right. Easily categorized into neat
- 1:02little boxes of right and wrong. It just makes
- 1:04society feel manageable. But the moment you step
- 1:07into the world where the human mind and the legal
- 1:10system collide, that neat binary traffic camera
- 1:13just... shatters completely. Oh, absolutely.
- 1:15The landscape gets incredibly murky. Welcome
- 1:18to the psychology undergrad. As fellow psychology
- 1:21undergrads, we spend a lot of time analyzing
- 1:24the internal workings of the brain. But today,
- 1:26you are our third study buddy in the room as
- 1:29we take a special deep dive into the source material.
- 1:32And we're going to explore exactly what happens
- 1:33when a mental disorder spills over into the legal
- 1:37realm. Yeah. Specifically, we are looking at
- 1:40court ordered treatments, which encompass both
- 1:43civil and criminal commitments. And the philosophical
- 1:46and moral stakes we are dealing with here are
- 1:48just profound. I mean, society inherently values
- 1:51freedom, right? We've built our entire legal
- 1:54architecture around the protection of individual
- 1:56liberty. But simultaneously, we heavily value
- 1:59public safety. So the ultimate question becomes...
- 2:03When a person's mind becomes a danger to themselves
- 2:06or to others, how do we ethically strip them
- 2:09of their autonomy without violating their basic
- 2:11humanity? Which is such a tough balance. It is.
- 2:15Scholars and medical professionals constantly
- 2:16debate this tension. Like, is it more moral to
- 2:20let someone in the throes of a severe mental
- 2:22crisis die with their rights on, or do we forcibly
- 2:25intervene and make them live with their rights
- 2:27off? Live with their rights off, wow. It is a
- 2:30devastating choice to have to make either as
- 2:32a society or as a family member watching a loved
- 2:35one struggle. Absolutely. So to help us navigate
- 2:38this labyrinth of legal and psychological overlap,
- 2:42we are going to use a structural framework from
- 2:43our source materials today. Think of it as the
- 2:46two C's and the P. The two C's and the P, right.
- 2:48Yeah, that stands for civil, which dictates what
- 2:50happens before a crime, criminal, which dictates
- 2:53what happens instead of a conviction, and post
- 2:56-conviction. which manages what happens after
- 2:58a sentence is actually served. That framework
- 3:00gives us a perfect roadmap, I think. So diving
- 3:05into the first C, we have to explore the mechanics
- 3:07of how the government can lock someone inside
- 3:09a psychiatric facility when that person has done
- 3:12absolutely nothing illegal. Which inherently
- 3:14feels so counterintuitive, right? I mean, from
- 3:17day one, we are taught that you cannot be locked
- 3:20up without committing a crime. Right. So let's
- 3:22look at the actual mechanism of civil commitment.
- 3:25How does the state even justify that? Well, civil
- 3:28commitment is a non -criminal process. A court
- 3:31basically orders involuntary psychiatric treatment
- 3:34and sometimes actual physical confinement for
- 3:37someone who is deemed unsafe due strictly to
- 3:39a mental disorder. Let's use Oregon system as
- 3:42our practical example here. The process typically
- 3:45begins with an emergency hold. A designated official
- 3:47or a medical provider can issue a notice of mental
- 3:50illness. An NMI, right? Exactly, an NMI. This
- 3:53essentially hits the pause button on a person's
- 3:55freedom. It allows them to be held on an emergency
- 3:57basis for up to five business days before a judge
- 4:01is legally required to review the case. I think
- 4:03we really need to look at the historical context
- 4:05here, though, because this strict five -day review
- 4:08process and having judicial oversight, it's actually
- 4:11a relatively modern invention. Oh, very modern.
- 4:15For a long time. The threshold for stripping
- 4:18someone of their freedom was terrifyingly low.
- 4:21You are exactly right. The modern system was
- 4:23entirely shaped by a landmark 1975 Supreme Court
- 4:27case, O 'Connor v. Donaldson. Right, Kenneth
- 4:29Donaldson. Yeah. Kenneth Donaldson was a man
- 4:31whose own father had him committed to a Florida
- 4:34state psychiatric hospital back in 1957. And
- 4:38he stayed there for a really long time, didn't
- 4:40he? He stayed locked in that ward for over 15
- 4:42years. 15 years. Just gone. And he had no criminal
- 4:46record. Right. He hadn't harmed anyone. He simply
- 4:49carried a diagnosis of schizophrenia. Exactly.
- 4:51And the wildest part is he wasn't even receiving
- 4:54meaningful therapeutic treatment. It was purely
- 4:56custodial confinement. So they basically just
- 4:58warehoused him. They warehoused him. Eventually,
- 5:01though, he managed to sue the hospital superintendent
- 5:04under Section 1983. And this is a crucial detail
- 5:08from the sources. Section 1983 is a federal civil
- 5:11rights statute originally passed as part of the
- 5:14Ku Klux Klan Act of 1871. Oh, wow, really? Yeah.
- 5:17It was designed to allow citizens to sue state
- 5:20officials in federal court for blatant civil
- 5:23rights violations. Oh, that makes sense. Right.
- 5:26So Donaldson utilized this exact same statute
- 5:28to argue that his doctors who were acting as
- 5:31state officials had unconstitutionally stripped
- 5:34him of his right to liberty. The Supreme Court
- 5:36agreed with him, right? They ruled that just
- 5:39a finding of mental illness alone is not a sufficient
- 5:42constitutional basis for locking a person up
- 5:44against their will. Exactly. Like the state cannot
- 5:46just fence in people who are eccentric or harmless
- 5:49simply because society feels uneasy looking at
- 5:52them. Right. So the court established a new,
- 5:55really vital threshold. To forcibly take someone's
- 5:58freedom, a psychiatric diagnosis is just not
- 6:00enough anymore. You need more than just the illness.
- 6:03Exactly. There must be an imminent danger. meaning
- 6:06they pose a direct physical threat right now,
- 6:09not hypothetically next month. Okay, so imminent
- 6:12danger. Or the other option is they must be suffering
- 6:15from a grave disability, which... clinically
- 6:18means their cognitive state has deteriorated
- 6:21so severely that they are completely unable to
- 6:23meet basic survival needs, like getting food
- 6:26or shelter. OK, so let's elevate our traffic
- 6:29camera analogy for a second to really conceptualize
- 6:32this imminent danger standard. I like it. Think
- 6:34of civil commitment like the state's response
- 6:36to a check engine light on a car. If you have
- 6:39a dented bumper, which in this metaphor is a
- 6:42diagnosed mental illness like depression or schizophrenia.
- 6:45Yeah. the state has absolutely no right to impound
- 6:47your vehicle. Right. You're totally allowed to
- 6:50drive a dented car. Exactly. The state is only
- 6:52allowed to legally pull you over, rip the keys
- 6:55out of the ignition, and encounter the vehicle
- 6:56if the engine is actively on fire and about to
- 6:59explode on a crowded highway. That brilliantly
- 7:02illustrates the friction, honestly. the friction
- 7:04between the state's mechanical legal tools and
- 7:08the organic human mind. The government literally
- 7:11requires the fire to justify the intervention.
- 7:14I do struggle to reconcile that with the clinical
- 7:16reality on the ground, though. What do you mean?
- 7:18Well, by forcing the legal system to wait until
- 7:21the engine is actively on fire, aren't we structurally
- 7:24failing people? That is the big pushback. Right.
- 7:27We are essentially demanding that a person hit
- 7:30absolute rock bottom. Like losing their housing,
- 7:34alienating their families, completely deteriorating
- 7:37cognitively before the law finally allows us
- 7:39to offer mandated, life -saving help. It creates
- 7:42a massive paradox. And disability advocates and
- 7:45families, they agonize over this constantly.
- 7:47I can imagine. Because on one hand, the strict,
- 7:50imminent danger standard is absolutely necessary
- 7:52to prevent government overreach, like we saw
- 7:54with Donaldson, and protect civil liberties.
- 7:57But structurally, it ties mental illness directly
- 7:59to violence or total collapse in the public.
- 8:01guy. So society is legally mandated to just sit
- 8:05back and watch a person become highly dangerous
- 8:07or gravely disabled before involuntary treatment
- 8:10can legally begin. Exactly. Which introduces
- 8:12our next massive procedural hurdle. Right. If
- 8:15the government is going to wait until the engine
- 8:17is on fire to intervene, how do they objectively
- 8:20prove the fire is real in a courtroom? Like,
- 8:24psychological danger isn't a photograph of a
- 8:26red light violation. It's predicted. It's extremely
- 8:29hard to quantify. Right. Which brings us to the
- 8:31legal burden of proof. Yes. So to understand
- 8:35the mechanics of proving psychological danger,
- 8:38the sources point us to a 1979 Supreme Court
- 8:40case. Addington v. Texas. Okay, Frank Addington.
- 8:44Right. Frank Addington had a long history of
- 8:46schizophrenia and had been actively threatening
- 8:48his mother. He was involuntarily committed to
- 8:51the Texas State Lunatic Asylum, which we now
- 8:53know as the Austin State Hospital for an indefinite
- 8:56period. But Addington didn't just accept the
- 8:59commitment, right? He challenged the very math
- 9:02the court used to lock him up. He did. Addington's
- 9:05legal team argued that if the state of Texas
- 9:07was going to deprive him of his liberty, there
- 9:09should be required to prove his future dangerousness
- 9:12beyond a reasonable doubt. Which is the absolute
- 9:14highest standard in our legal system. It's the
- 9:16one utilized in criminal murder trials. Exactly.
- 9:19But Texas countered by arguing that civil commitment
- 9:22isn't a criminal punishment. They said it's a
- 9:24civil health intervention. Oh, interesting. Right.
- 9:28Therefore, they argued they should only have
- 9:30to meet the preponderance of the evidence standard.
- 9:33That's the lowest standard used in civil lawsuits.
- 9:36It essentially means it is 51 % more likely than
- 9:39not. So Addington is demanding absolute microscopic
- 9:43certainty. And the state is basically arguing
- 9:46for a bare majority probability. Basically, yeah.
- 9:50And the Supreme Court recognized that neither
- 9:52extreme was really appropriate for the psychological
- 9:55reality of mental illness. Because predicting
- 9:58human behavior is inherently subjective. It can
- 10:01rarely be proven beyond a reasonable doubt. Exactly.
- 10:04But on the flip side, stripping someone's freedom
- 10:07is way too severe a consequence for a mere 51
- 10:10% probability. Right? A coin flip shouldn't lock
- 10:12you up. Exactly. So they created a specific compromise
- 10:16standard. They called it clear and convincing
- 10:19evidence. OK, so let's use a grading scale. to
- 10:24visualize how a jury actually applies this cognitive
- 10:27burden. Oh, that's a good way to look at it.
- 10:29Yeah. So preponderance of the evidence that 51
- 10:31% it's a D minus grade. It just barely tips the
- 10:34scales. Barely passing. Right. Then beyond a
- 10:38reasonable doubt is a 99%. It's an A plus. It
- 10:41demands overwhelming near perfect certainty.
- 10:44Right. The Supreme Court's compromise. Clear
- 10:47and convincing evidence is a solid B+. You don't
- 10:50need absolute 99 % perfection because predicting
- 10:53human behavior makes that impossible. But the
- 10:56evidence of danger has to be substantially undeniably
- 11:00clear. It perfectly reflects the gravity of the
- 11:02intervention. The court acknowledged that while
- 11:04civil commitment is labeled treatment, it still
- 11:07results in a massive deprivation of liberty.
- 11:09And it carries a profound social stigma. Exactly.
- 11:12A D minus level of certainty simply cannot justify
- 11:15locking the doors behind someone. I mean, just
- 11:17imagine being a juror in that situation for a
- 11:19second. You are asked to grade the likelihood
- 11:23of someone's future violent behavior with a B
- 11:25plus level of certainty, knowing their total
- 11:28freedom rests entirely on your grade. That is
- 11:31an immense psychological burden. Truly. But this
- 11:34B plus standard of clear and convincing evidence
- 11:37only protects people who haven't committed a
- 11:39crime. the math completely changes the moment
- 11:42an arrest is actually made. So we are now moving
- 11:45from the first C, civil, to our second C. Criminal.
- 11:49Criminal, exactly. Yeah, the moment the criminal
- 11:51justice system gets involved, we run head first
- 11:54into a massive bottleneck, the competency crisis.
- 11:57Oh, man, the statistics on this are wild. They
- 12:00really are. Across the entire country, state
- 12:02psychiatric hospitals are just overflowing with
- 12:05what the system calls aid and assist patients.
- 12:07In Oregon, they are legally designated as three
- 12:10seven zero patients. The demographic shift outlined
- 12:13in the source text is staggering. Like in the
- 12:16year 2000, these specific patients made up just
- 12:189 % of the Oregon State Hospital's population.
- 12:21Just 9%. Right. But recently, that number skyrocketed
- 12:25to over 40%. And we have to look at the mechanism
- 12:28of why they are taking up nearly half the hospital.
- 12:31These are individuals who have been arrested
- 12:34for a crime, but a psychological evaluator has
- 12:37determined they are mentally incompetent to stand
- 12:39trial. Okay. Meaning what, clinically? meaning
- 12:42their cognitive state is so fractured they do
- 12:45not fundamentally understand the charges against
- 12:48them and they cannot rationally assist their
- 12:50defense attorney. So they are committed to the
- 12:53psychiatric hospital for the sole purpose of
- 12:55being restored. Restored. Let's look at the mechanics
- 12:58of that restoration because this is where a really
- 13:01deep ethical dilemma in psychology arises. It's
- 13:03a huge issue. The hospital isn't necessarily
- 13:06tasked with healing the trauma or curing the
- 13:09underlying disorder for the patient's, you know,
- 13:11holistic Not at all. They're tasked with stabilizing
- 13:14the patient, often through heavy antipsychotic
- 13:17medication and direct education about court vocabulary.
- 13:21Just enough so the person understands what a
- 13:22judge and a jury are. So we're pausing a person's
- 13:25constitutional right to a speedy trial, forcing
- 13:28them into psychiatric treatment. strictly so
- 13:31the state can eventually prosecute and punish
- 13:33them. It absolutely medicalizes the pathway to
- 13:36punishment. The cognitive dissonance for the
- 13:38treating psychologist there is immense. I can't
- 13:40even imagine. And the system breaks down even
- 13:43further when we ask, what happens if a patient's
- 13:46cognitive decline is organic and irreversible?
- 13:49Like what if they can never be restored? Exactly.
- 13:52The text highlights this case of Jose Vegia in
- 13:55Massachusetts. Vegia suffers from severe advanced
- 13:58dementia. Which you can't just cure. Right. There
- 14:01is no medication that will restore his competency.
- 14:04Yet, because the charges remain active, he is
- 14:07transported to court every few months for a 60
- 14:10-second hearing. 60 seconds. Just 60 seconds,
- 14:13purely so a judge can legally confirm he still
- 14:15has dementia before sending him right back into
- 14:18the system. It is just an endless loop of procedural
- 14:21theater. I mean, it is agonizing for a cognitively
- 14:24impaired defendant. And honestly, it offers absolutely
- 14:27zero closure. or justice for the victims of the
- 14:30crime. It doesn't help anyone. So to circumvent
- 14:33that endless loop, Oregon actually created a
- 14:36specific legal classification. They call it the
- 14:39extremely dangerous and resistant to treatment
- 14:41commitment. OK, what does that do? This applies
- 14:44to defendants charged with violent offenses who
- 14:46have deeply entrenched disorders that will not
- 14:49respond to restoration efforts. It allows the
- 14:52state to transition them out of that endless
- 14:55trial loop and into an involuntary commitment
- 14:58for up to two years. With options for renewal,
- 15:01right? Right. Thereby maintaining public safety
- 15:03without pretending a trial will ever actually
- 15:05happen. Okay, so that addresses defendants who
- 15:08are fundamentally disconnected from reality in
- 15:10the present moment. But what if the defendant
- 15:12is competent today? Right. Like they understand
- 15:14the courtroom, they know who the judge is, but
- 15:16at the exact moment the crime was committed,
- 15:18their mind was completely hijacked by a disorder.
- 15:22Ah, yes. This brings us to one of the most debated
- 15:24intersections of morality and law. The insanity
- 15:27defense, legally known in Oregon as guilty except
- 15:31for insanity, or GEI. Right. And to truly comprehend
- 15:35the weight and the mechanism of a GEI verdict,
- 15:38the text walks us through the tragic reality
- 15:40of the Andrea Yates case. Such a devastating
- 15:43case. In 2001, Andrea Yates drowned her five
- 15:46children in their bathtub. But this catastrophic
- 15:49event did not just happen in a vacuum. It was
- 15:52the culmination of years of severe escalating
- 15:55and documented mental illness. Right. Following
- 15:58the birth of her fourth child, she had suffered
- 16:01a massive psychotic break. She attempted suicide
- 16:04multiple times and was diagnosed with severe
- 16:07postpartum psychosis. And we should clarify postpartum
- 16:10psychosis is not just severe depression. No,
- 16:12it is a fundamental break from reality. It's
- 16:14often accompanied by intense auditory and visual
- 16:17hallucinations. Exactly. And despite explicit
- 16:20warnings from a psychiatrist that having another
- 16:22child would likely trigger another psychotic
- 16:24episode, she became pregnant with her fifth child
- 16:27shortly after. The source material focuses heavily
- 16:29on how her psychosis completely co -opted her
- 16:32beliefs and her moral framework. Yes, that is
- 16:35a key detail. Her mind was operating under a
- 16:38strict though entirely delusional internal logic.
- 16:41She genuinely believed that she was an inherently
- 16:44evil entity. And because she was evil, she believed
- 16:48she had corrupted her children. She actually
- 16:50explained to her prison psychiatrist her belief
- 16:53that her children's souls were destined for hell.
- 16:56Wow. In her profoundly altered state, she believed
- 16:59that killing them while they were still young
- 17:01and innocent was the absolute only moral action
- 17:04she could take to ensure their souls would go
- 17:06to heaven. So she knew the act was legally against
- 17:09the law, but her psychosis convinced her it was
- 17:12the ultimate moral imperative. Exactly. But during
- 17:15her initial trial, the prosecution called a psychiatric
- 17:18expert who provided false testimony. Wait, false
- 17:21testimony? Yeah. The expert claimed that a television
- 17:24episode of Law & Order had recently aired featuring
- 17:26a woman who drowned her children and successfully
- 17:29pleaded insanity. Oh, wow. The implication presented
- 17:32to the jury was that Yates had seen the show
- 17:34and premeditated a fabricated insanity defense.
- 17:37That is awful. That false testimony directly
- 17:40undermined the legal threshold of insanity in
- 17:43the eyes of the jury, basically suggesting premeditation
- 17:46rather than delusion. Exactly. And she was convicted
- 17:49and sentenced to life in prison. But that wasn't
- 17:51the end of it. No. It was later proven that no
- 17:54such television episode even existed. So her
- 17:57conviction was rightfully overturned on appeal.
- 17:59In her 2006 retrial, the jury was able to accurately
- 18:03weigh the clinical reality of her psychosis.
- 18:06And she was found not guilty by reason of insanity.
- 18:08Right. She was committed to a secure psychiatric
- 18:11hospital, where she actually remains today. In
- 18:13fact, the sources note she voluntarily waives
- 18:16her right to annual release hearings, choosing
- 18:18to remain in the facility. You know, to understand
- 18:20the fundamental logic of the insanity defense,
- 18:22I like to tell people to think of it as a software
- 18:25versus hardware dynamic. Oh, that's a good analogy.
- 18:28Yeah. So the legal system is basically built
- 18:30to punish the hardware operator, the person for
- 18:34making a malicious choice. Right. But a GEI verdict
- 18:37legally acknowledges that a catastrophic software
- 18:40virus like postpartum psychosis or severe schizophrenia
- 18:43entirely hijacked the operating system. The user
- 18:46is no longer in control. Exactly. Sending the
- 18:49person to a standard prison cell doesn't fix
- 18:51the corrupted code. They require a psychiatric
- 18:54patch in a secure medical facility. That's a
- 18:56great way to put it. However, that software analogy
- 18:59doesn't necessarily alleviate the pain of the
- 19:01victims. No, not at all. The text includes a
- 19:04striking photograph of a bench dedicated to crime
- 19:07victims, and it bears this inscription. It says,
- 19:11justice isn't served until crime victims are.
- 19:14That's powerful. The Insanity Defense creates
- 19:16an incredible difficult tension. How does a society
- 19:20balance its inherent demand for moral retribution
- 19:23and closure with the clinical reality that the
- 19:26perpetrator's consciousness was fundamentally
- 19:28shattered at the time of the act? It is a tension
- 19:30that lags a perfect resolution. I mean, we want
- 19:33the hardware to pay the price even if the software
- 19:35was at fault. Exactly. Which brings us perfectly
- 19:37to the final letter of our structural framework,
- 19:40the P -Post Conviction Commitments. So we've
- 19:42examined the state intervening before a crime,
- 19:45and the state treating a person instead of a
- 19:47criminal conviction. Right. But what happens
- 19:49when a person is sent to prison, serves their
- 19:52entire mandated sentence, and the calendar hits
- 19:55zero? Well, in a standard legal framework, they
- 19:58are released. But in certain jurisdictions, like
- 20:01Washington state, we see the implementation of
- 20:04post -conviction civil commitments. And this
- 20:06is primarily utilized for sex offenders, right?
- 20:08Yes. If an individual finishes their entire prison
- 20:12sentence, but the state determines they suffer
- 20:14from a psychological anomaly that makes them
- 20:16a continuing high -risk threat to the community,
- 20:19they are not released. So what happens to them?
- 20:22Instead, they are civilly committed to a secure
- 20:25facility. Washington uses an operation on McNeil
- 20:28Island, for instance, where they are held indefinitely
- 20:31for treatment. I am really struggling to see
- 20:33the conceptual difference between this and double
- 20:35jeopardy. A lot of people do. I mean, you serve
- 20:38the time the judge handed down, but society basically
- 20:41refuses to give you the receipt. The state justifies
- 20:44this by claiming the offender has a disorder,
- 20:46like pedophilia, that makes them inherently dangerous.
- 20:49Right. But wait, if they have a disorder, why
- 20:52didn't they qualify for the insanity defense
- 20:54during the original trial? That's the million
- 20:57dollar question. It feels like the system is
- 20:59using the clinical word treatment as a convenient
- 21:02loophole to just inflict permanent extra judicial
- 21:06punishment. And that is precisely the constitutional
- 21:08argument levied by defense attorneys and civil
- 21:11rights advocates. They argue it is literally
- 21:14a second punishment disguised as health care.
- 21:16What does the Supreme Court say about it? Well,
- 21:18the Supreme Court has historically upheld these
- 21:21post -conviction commitments. They accept the
- 21:23state's argument that the primary intent is not
- 21:25punitive, but rather the management of an ongoing
- 21:28danger. OK, but when we look at the clinical
- 21:31and demographic reality of how this is actually
- 21:33applied, a massive equity problem emerges. It
- 21:36really does. I mean, the statistics cited in
- 21:38our sources are impossible to ignore. They reveal
- 21:41deep structural biases. According to the data,
- 21:45black sex offenders are twice as likely as white
- 21:48sex offenders to be flagged and civilly committed
- 21:51post -sentence. Twice as likely. Yeah. Furthermore,
- 21:55men who have male victims are two to three times
- 21:58more likely to be indefinitely committed than
- 22:00men with female victims. Wow. This strongly indicates
- 22:04that the subjective determination of who constitutes
- 22:07a continuing threat is heavily influenced by
- 22:10systemic, racial, and homophonic biases rather
- 22:13than pure Objective psychological risk. Exactly.
- 22:17The prejudices of the system are essentially
- 22:19dictating who gets to walk free and who gets
- 22:21warehoused under the guise of therapeutic intervention.
- 22:24That is incredibly sobering. It is. Well, let's
- 22:27recap the terrain we've covered today. We use
- 22:29the framework of the two C's and the P to navigate
- 22:31this intersection of psychology and law. Right,
- 22:33our roadmap. We looked at civil commitments where
- 22:36the state must prove a B -plus level of clear
- 22:38and convincing evidence that an engine is actively
- 22:41on fire before intervening. We examine criminal
- 22:43commitments. where defendants are either stuck
- 22:46in a competency restoration loop or utilizing
- 22:50the insanity defense when a virus overtakes their
- 22:53cognitive software. Exactly. And finally, we
- 22:56explored post -conviction commitments where the
- 22:58state extends confinement beyond a prison sentence
- 23:01based on predictive risk. And underlying all
- 23:04of these mechanisms is the fundamental challenge
- 23:06of predicting human behavior. But You know, I
- 23:10want to leave you with a final provocative thought
- 23:12to mull over before your next class. Oh, all
- 23:15right. Let's hear it. So we have heavily discussed
- 23:18the strict requirement of imminent danger as
- 23:20a safeguard for civil liberties. Right. But right
- 23:23now, predictive algorithms and artificial intelligence
- 23:25are advancing exponentially. What happens in
- 23:28the near future if we develop a psychological
- 23:30algorithm capable of predicting a person's future
- 23:33violent behavior with 99 % beyond a reasonable
- 23:37doubt accuracy? Oh, wow. Right. If we can mathematically
- 23:40prove a fire will start tomorrow, will society
- 23:43be tempted to abandon the imminent danger requirement
- 23:45entirely. That's a scary thought. Will we prioritize
- 23:49absolute preventative safety over the fundamental
- 23:53human right to freedom? I mean, if the traffic
- 23:56camera of the mind actually starts working flawlessly,
- 23:59do we write the ticket before the person even
- 24:01gets behind the wheel? Exactly. It's a terrifying
- 24:04and fascinating question. Thank you so much for
- 24:06joining us as our third steady buddy on this
- 24:09deep dive into the source material. Thanks for
- 24:11listening. Keep questioning the mechanics of
- 24:14the mind, keep challenging the systems built
- 24:15around it, and we will catch you next time on
- 24:18The Psychology Undergrad.