Latest / The World Unexplained / IS THE EARTH FLAT
Transcript
- 0:02The world Unexplained. The word a podcast that explores the unusual beliefs, conspiracies,
- 0:11customs, rituals, and traditions from around the world. This is your
- 0:17host, doctor Carlos Well. Some of you may not find it too shocking,
- 0:40but physicists are finding it shocking that there are plenty of people around the
- 0:44world who genuinely believe the Earth is flat. We're going to explore why such
- 0:49views are increasingly taking hold and how the physics community could respond. In twenty
- 0:55seventeen, a rapper by the name of Bob Real named Bobby Ray Simmons started
- 0:58a crowdfunding campaign to launch a satellite. The rapper, a proponent of flat
- 1:02Earth theory, wanted to raise a million dollars in his GoFundMe to help him
- 1:06find the curve. It's the term that flat Earthers use to describe the edge
- 1:10of our supposed dishaped planet, not a globe. The rapper's quest may seem
- 1:15like a joke or a publicity stunt, and there's no evidence that he raised
- 1:18much money or got anywhere near his goal. However, in the last few
- 1:21years, there has been an alarming rise and the number of people who like
- 1:23the rapper believe in flatter theories. There's an actual flat Earth conference in the
- 1:29US, the most of which was attended by more than six hundred people.
- 1:34Physicists may mock the notion of a flat Earth, but the idea is gaining
- 1:38traction, particularly among people susceptible to other wild theories. You gu say,
- 1:44they actually do believe it. In a book called Respecting Truth, Will for
- 1:49Ignorance in the Internet Age, philosopher Lee McIntyre described it, and he knows
- 1:55firsthand how sincerely flat earthers hold their views. He actually attended a flat earth
- 2:00conference in Denver, Colorado. A psychologist who also is at the Denver Media
- 2:06agrees, if flat earthers are genuine and they're not lying, if they were
- 2:08trolling, they're incredibly good actors. She talked to more than ninety members of
- 2:14the flat earth community and they all seemed very sincere in their beliefs. They
- 2:21believe that family and friends, they talk to their family and friends about flat
- 2:23Earth, NASA and others are space lies. In fourteen plus ways the Bible
- 2:28says flat earth are some of their evidence. Flat Earth ideas, though,
- 2:32are based on basic scientific misunderstandings that can be easily refuted For most people,
- 2:38even those who have no physics background. The evidence of a spherical Earth is
- 2:42obvious, so why do these ideas of a flat Earth continue. The idea
- 2:46of the Earth is a sphere was all but settled by ancient Greek philosophers Aristotle,
- 2:51who obtain empirical evidence after traveling to Egypt and seeing new constellations of stars.
- 2:55Today's flat earth believers are not, though, the first to doubt what
- 3:00seems unquestionable. The notion of a flat earth initially surfaced in the eighteen hundreds
- 3:04as a backlash to scientific progress, especially among those who wish to return to
- 3:08Biblical literalism. Perhaps the most famous properment was the British writer Samuel Robotham.
- 3:14He proposed the Earth as a flat, immovable disc centered at the North pole,
- 3:17with Antarctica replaced by an ice wall. The International Flat Earth Research Society,
- 3:23which was set up in nineteen fifty six by Samuel Shelton, was regarded
- 3:28by many as merely a symbol of British eccentricity. But in the early two
- 3:31thousands, with the Internet now and a well established vehicle for offbeat views,
- 3:36the idea began to bubble up again and relaunched through The Flatterirth Society was relaunched
- 3:42in two thousand and nine. As with any movement, there are disagreements in
- 3:45several different flat earth models exist to choose from. Some models proposed the Earth's
- 3:49edges are surrounded by a wall of ice holding in the oceans. Others suggest
- 3:53our flat planet in its atmosphere encased in a huge hemispheric snow globe, from
- 3:59which nothing can fall off the edges. To account for night and day,
- 4:02most flat earths think the Sun moves and circles around the north pole, with
- 4:05his light actively acting like a spotlight. The most recent US model, for
- 4:11example, suggests that the Sun and the Moon are fifty kilometers in diameter and
- 4:14circle the dishaped Earth at a height of about fifty five hundred kilometers, with
- 4:17the stars above this on a rotating dome. By the way, many flat
- 4:23earthers also reject gravity, with the UK model suggesting that the disc is itself
- 4:27accelerating up at nine point eight millisecles to give the illusion of gravity. Physicists
- 4:33will hoopoo these ideas, but the worrying things that they're spreading and gaining proponents
- 4:38while they may not be as many in Europe, there are as loud as
- 4:42their colleagues. In the US, they're growing alarming. Polling data by the
- 4:47firm Delta Fola, for example, indicate that seven percent of the Brazilian population
- 4:53almost eleven million people believe the Earth is flat. A shocking number has been
- 4:57attributed to a resurgence of evangelical churches, but there are also signs of religious
- 5:01fundamentalism is spreading these ideas in Islamic countries. In twenty seventeen, a website
- 5:06reported that a geologeology student in Tunisia was intending to submit a PhD defending her
- 5:12work on a flat Earth model flat earthers. I believe a selection of conspiracy
- 5:20theories as well, including that government controls the weather and camtrails from aeroplanes consists
- 5:26of chemical biological agents. Now, I'm not going to get into just because
- 5:30one person believes one thing, they can believe all the other ones. And
- 5:31you know, some are conspiracies and some have been we haven't been able to
- 5:34really pinpoint a lot of these conspiracies don't have a lot of evidence to either
- 5:41dispute them or to support them. And this is what makes them a very
- 5:44exciting conspiracy theory because you can't prove it one way or another, and reason
- 5:49and intuition doesn't always work. In the UK, who has met flat earthers
- 5:54at a London meet up a philosopher by the naum of Mick Effingham. So
- 5:58they says that we won't know. We often don't recognize the extent to which
- 6:01confidence and authority shapes our beliefs when we try and prove something like the Earth
- 6:05being round. Because it's a belief that we are sure of, we underplay
- 6:09the justify a role of authority. Most people are therefore comfortable accepting the world
- 6:13as a globe, even if they can immediately recount the scientific evidence. Now
- 6:17flat earth as seem to have a very low standard of evidence where they want
- 6:20to believe, but an impossibly high standard of evidence for what they don't want
- 6:24to believe. It was McIntyre's work the Philosopher Working on Science Denial that led
- 6:30into the twenty eighteen conference in Denver, where delegates spend time discussing the evidence
- 6:35and finer details of their theory. Now he believed if he could understand how
- 6:44to push back against flat earthers, so he wanted to go there to learn
- 6:46about their theory and the finer details. He could use the same techniques to
- 6:49fight it back against other people who believe other conspiracies. After all, their
- 6:55ideas are all generally based on fallacies and misunderstanding of science. He says,
- 7:00some of the flat earthers know enough physics to throw around the vocabulary, but
- 7:02they don't actually I understand enough physics to be compelled by the truth end quote.
- 7:08And this is true with a lot of people in today's Internet and chat
- 7:10cheepy Team and things of that nature. They throw some phrases and concepts out
- 7:14there really basic, rudimentary style and misinterpret them or give more of a dogmatic
- 7:20view of them when it's really nuanced and you can tell the naivete of these
- 7:25individuals. So what is going on? How do we approve against this?
- 7:30But even without the visual confirmations of pictures taking from space, which flat earthers
- 7:34believe is fake, anyway, you can start with the foucos pendulum, the
- 7:39device named after the French physicist Leone Foco, who in nineteen fifty one hung
- 7:44a twenty eight kilogram brass bulb from a sixty seven meter chain in the Pantheon
- 7:48in Paris. Such a pendulum, which can swing in any plane, changes
- 7:53direction during the course of the day, which points out the evidence of Earth's
- 7:58rotation. Another phenomenon the prove's the Earth is spinning of the globe is the
- 8:01coriolist force, which acts perpendicular to the direction of motion of a spinning mass.
- 8:07This force leads the cyclone swirling clockwise in the southern hemisphere and counterclockwise in
- 8:11the north. Long range military snipers even have to make allowance for the deflections
- 8:16caused by the corealist effect, But that deep critical thinking is what's often missing
- 8:22among flat earthers consider photos of distance skylines, which are often wheeled out as
- 8:28proof that the Earth is flat. If you go back to the philosopher he
- 8:33was going back taking was commonly shown a picture of Chicago taken from Lake Michigan,
- 8:35in which the city scrapers skiddy city skyscrapers are clearly visible, despite being
- 8:41viewed from a distance of one hundred kilometers out. Given the curvature of the
- 8:43Earth, you shouldn't be able to see the skyline of the city from that
- 8:46far out, he says. The reason the buildings are visible lies in the
- 8:50fact that air directly above the water surface is colder the air higher up.
- 8:54This inverse temperature gradient means the light rays refract toward the colder, denser air,
- 9:00allowing an image of the reflected skyline formed in the water below the horizon
- 9:03to appear almost hovering above the horizon. This notion can easily be verified by
- 9:09taking a photo even further away, where the superior mirage will disappear, but
- 9:16this type of reason is unlikely to convince any flat earthers. The physicist again
- 9:22McIntyre described as frustration with flat earthers in a paper last year in which he
- 9:26challenged physicists to come up with simple, straightforward answers to refute the evidence of
- 9:31a flat Earth that could be understood by everybody. Someone who rose to the
- 9:35bait was retired physicist Bruce Sherwood, who realized that just citing the scientific facts
- 9:39is not going to convince anybody. Instead, given that flat earther's played so
- 9:43much emphasis on naked eye observations, he and a colleague decided to create a
- 9:46navigable a navigable three D computer simulation of a flat Earth to see how it
- 9:52would well replicate Based on the US version of the flat Earth model that allows
- 9:56anyone virtually to flow to rome or flat world walking around it. There were
- 10:01many things that showed tremendous discrepancies. One of the major problems is the sight
- 10:05and brightness of the sun and the flat Earth model. This varies by more
- 10:09than a factor of two from sunrise to midday, something we obviously do not
- 10:13see. The night sky also differs in the northern hemiverers. Here we see
- 10:16constellations rising in the east and arcing across the sky, but in the flat
- 10:20Earth model these would just circle at a constant height. But again, that
- 10:28improve very much for those who really stuck to their beliefs. It's called perseverance
- 10:33belief effect. So what do we do with these individuals? Many argue that
- 10:46physicists need to be more involved. There's really no excuse for them to sit
- 10:48back and laugh at these individuals, because while they're laughing, these people are
- 10:52recruiting people to believe these crazy ideas. They say. Many flat Earthers distrust
- 10:58scientists to begin with, against the scientific method. The majority of that put
- 11:01them a lot of faith actually for it. There's a lot of curiosity and
- 11:05a lot of skepticism, and a lot of the really good qualities that make
- 11:07scientists. But while the spirit of experimentation may be there, flat earthers are
- 11:11not always prepared to change their minds when their experiments fail. And that's why
- 11:16many hopes some physicists might go with them with them to future flat Earth conferences
- 11:22to help them understand it better. So as the world flat, it really
- 11:26doesn't seem so. There's plenty of evidence, scientific evidence out there. And
- 11:30if you think they're lying to us, what's the motive. What's the real
- 11:35motive of having a flat Earth? What was the motive of us landing on
- 11:39the Moon? Why would it be a hoax? I think this one is
- 11:48explained. I think the Earth is spherical and global. It's really up to
- 11:52them to prove me wrong.