Transcript

Trump vs Zelensky · The Front

0:04
Speaker 1: From the Australian. Here's what's on the front. I'm Claire Harvey.
0:07
Speaker 1: It's Friday, February twenty one. Anthony Albanezi and South Australian
0:14
Speaker 1: Premier Peter Malinowskis have unveiled a two point four billion
0:17
Speaker 1: dollar package to save why Our Steel Works. The vast
0:21
Speaker 1: majority of that money will be used to upgrade the
0:23
Speaker 1: steel mill so it can become a major producer of
0:27
Speaker 1: green steel under a new owner. To find out what
0:31
Speaker 1: that means, go to the Australian dot com dot au.
0:40
Speaker 1: Donald Trump versus Volodim Zelenski, an end to the US
0:45
Speaker 1: europe Alliance in support of Ukraine, warnings of World War
0:49
Speaker 1: III and Russian glee. That's the fast moving situation ripping
0:54
Speaker 1: through the war in Ukraine today. What Donald Trump says
0:58
Speaker 1: and what he means. Karon Stewart is the Australian's chief
1:05
Speaker 1: international correspondent, and it seems in recent days cam we're
1:09
Speaker 1: seeing a dramatic shift in the war in Ukraine or
1:13
Speaker 1: what could potentially be the peace process for the war
1:16
Speaker 1: in Ukraine. Let's go back a couple of days to
1:18
Speaker 1: a press conference Donald Trump gave at Mara Lago in Florida,
1:23
Speaker 1: where he said something that he said a few times before,
1:26
Speaker 1: that this war would have never started if he had
1:29
Speaker 1: been president at the time, and that he could have
1:31
Speaker 1: made a deal.
1:32
Speaker 2: I could have made a deal for Ukraine that would
1:36
Speaker 2: have given him almost all of the land everything, almost
1:39
Speaker 2: all of the land, and no people would have been killed,
1:41
Speaker 2: and no city would have been demolished, and one dorm
1:44
Speaker 2: would have been knocked down. But they chose not to
1:47
Speaker 2: do it that way.
1:49
Speaker 1: Do you think that's right.
1:50
Speaker 3: No, I don't think there's any evidence to suggest that
1:53
Speaker 3: that would be right. Claire. I don't think that American
1:57
Speaker 3: position on Ukraine was in any way a factor for
2:03
Speaker 3: Putent invading Ukraine at the time that he did. I
2:06
Speaker 3: think that is Trump thumping his chest to a degree
2:08
Speaker 3: and just saying, you know, he has the ass of
2:10
Speaker 3: the deal. He has said a lot of things wouldn't
2:13
Speaker 3: have happened had he been president during Joe Biden's presidency.
2:16
Speaker 3: I think that's just a bit of a chairmanship on
2:18
Speaker 3: Trump's part.
2:22
Speaker 2: President Puttin and I would talk about Ukraine. It was
2:24
Speaker 2: the apple of his eye, I will tell you that.
2:26
Speaker 2: But he never there was never a chance of him
2:28
Speaker 2: going in and they told him you better not go in.
2:30
Speaker 2: Don't go in, don't go in, and he understood that,
2:33
Speaker 2: he understood it fully. But I'm only interested. I want
2:37
Speaker 2: to see if I can save maybe millions of lives.
2:40
Speaker 2: This could even end up in a World War three.
2:42
Speaker 2: I'm to be honest with you. You've been hearing now
2:44
Speaker 2: Europe said, well, I think we're going to go in,
2:45
Speaker 2: and we're going to go all of a sudden, you
2:47
Speaker 2: can end up in World War three over something that
2:50
Speaker 2: should have never happened. And you know it's a very
2:53
Speaker 2: sad situation. Yeah, listen, what.
2:56
Speaker 1: Do you think about that? Is there any suggestion that
2:59
Speaker 1: of a European states I'm going to have boots on
3:01
Speaker 1: the ground, or that it's going to escalate to a
3:03
Speaker 1: wider europe wide conflict?
3:05
Speaker 3: Again, I don't think there is any evidence to suggest that.
3:08
Speaker 3: I mean, the war is very very bogged down, has
3:10
Speaker 3: been bogged down on a very defined front line for
3:14
Speaker 3: really over a year now with only marginal changes to
3:17
Speaker 3: that front line. That Russians don't have the manpower or
3:21
Speaker 3: the resources to continue this war forever, but they have
3:24
Speaker 3: many more men and resources to continue it compared to Ukraine.
3:29
Speaker 3: There really is no suggestion. I think that this war
3:32
Speaker 3: would expand if it kept going the way that it is.
3:38
Speaker 1: The next thing that has happened is that Donald Trump
3:41
Speaker 1: has taken to his platform Truth, Social and to X
3:44
Speaker 1: to make some quite remarkable claims about voladimes Alenski. He's
3:49
Speaker 1: a voice actor reading Donald Trump's words.
3:54
Speaker 4: Think of it a modestly successful comedian. Voladimir Zelenski chuck
3:59
Speaker 4: the United States of America into spending three hundred and
4:02
Speaker 4: fifty billion dollars to go into a war that couldn't
4:05
Speaker 4: be won, that never had to start, but a war
4:09
Speaker 4: that he without the US and Trump will never be
4:13
Speaker 4: able to settle.
4:15
Speaker 1: Trump said only he could successfully negotiate an end to
4:19
Speaker 1: the war with Russia.
4:21
Speaker 4: Biden never tried. Europe has failed to bring peace, and
4:25
Speaker 4: Zelensky probably wants to keep the gravy train going. I
4:28
Speaker 4: love Ukraine, but Zelensky has done a terrible job. His
4:32
Speaker 4: country is shattered and millions have unnecessarily died, and so
4:37
Speaker 4: it continues.
4:40
Speaker 3: Europe has been quite shocked by the approach of the
4:43
Speaker 3: Trump administration has taken this week. It started with the
4:46
Speaker 3: Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth, who said that there'd be no
4:50
Speaker 3: US troops stationed in Ukraine in any peace deal, that
4:54
Speaker 3: Ukraine could not expect to get its old borders back.
4:57
Speaker 3: In other words, the territory Russia has taken, and Trane
5:00
Speaker 3: could not expect to be a member of NATO after
5:04
Speaker 3: this war. Now only a matter of days later, as
5:07
Speaker 3: you say, Trump has almost confirmed this with an extraordinary
5:11
Speaker 3: attack on Zelensky, claiming that he is a dictator without elections,
5:16
Speaker 3: which is ironic given that Putin is exactly a dictator
5:20
Speaker 3: without elections, and you know, teasing him as being a
5:24
Speaker 3: modestly successful comedian.
5:26
Speaker 4: On top of this, Zelensky admits that half of the
5:29
Speaker 4: money we sent him is missing. He refuses to have elections,
5:34
Speaker 4: is very low in Ukrainian polls, and the only thing
5:38
Speaker 4: he was good at was playing Biden like a fiddle.
5:41
Speaker 4: A dictator without elections, Zelensky better move fast or he
5:46
Speaker 4: is not going to have a country left.
5:48
Speaker 3: And of course Ukraine was locked out of the first
5:50
Speaker 3: negotiating talks between Russia and the US in Saudi Arabia.
5:56
Speaker 3: So he put all these factors together, and there is
5:58
Speaker 3: I think genuine lama amongst many European nations, and of
6:02
Speaker 3: course in Ukraine, that the way that the Trump administration
6:06
Speaker 3: is going about these negotiations is initially hugely favoring Russia.
6:12
Speaker 2: I don't want all these people killed anymore. I'm looking
6:15
Speaker 2: at people that are being killed, and they're Russian and
6:18
Speaker 2: Ukrainian people, but they're people, doesn't matter where they're from,
6:21
Speaker 2: on the whole planet. And I think I have the
6:24
Speaker 2: power to end this war.
6:26
Speaker 3: And what does that ultimately mean for any peace deal
6:30
Speaker 3: that is struck. Does it really mean that Putin gets
6:34
Speaker 3: punished for his invasion? Does he pay any price whatsoever
6:38
Speaker 3: for his behavior in relation to Ukraine? Or does he
6:40
Speaker 3: walk away with the twenty percent of Ukraine, no security
6:44
Speaker 3: guarantees for Ukraine in the future, and no real punishment
6:48
Speaker 3: for Putin. That certainly is the fear that has been
6:51
Speaker 3: engendered by the events this week.
6:55
Speaker 1: Ken One interpretation of the way Donald Trump is speaking
6:58
Speaker 1: is that this is a either the way he thinks
7:02
Speaker 1: that he genuinely does believe that Vladimir Zelenski is a
7:05
Speaker 1: thief and a liar and that he has ripped off
7:07
Speaker 1: the United States.
7:08
Speaker 2: But today I heard, oh, we weren't invaded, Well, you've
7:11
Speaker 2: been there for three years. You should have ended it
7:13
Speaker 2: three years, you should have never started and you could
7:15
Speaker 2: have made a deal.
7:17
Speaker 1: Or the other way to interpret it is that this
7:19
Speaker 1: is a big Donald Trump sound and fury, dramatic moment,
7:23
Speaker 1: and it's aimed at changing Vladimir Zelenski's expectations of what
7:27
Speaker 1: he can get from a peace process. That he would
7:30
Speaker 1: then be able to bring Zelenski to the table with
7:32
Speaker 1: an expectation that he's not going to get everything he wants.
7:35
Speaker 1: He's going to have to seed some territory. Which of
7:38
Speaker 1: those two things do you think is more likely?
7:41
Speaker 3: Look, I think Donald Trump is definitely playing the game
7:45
Speaker 3: of being the noisy deal maker to try to get
7:50
Speaker 3: both sides to fall into line and get into a
7:53
Speaker 3: position where a deal can actually be made. I mean,
7:56
Speaker 3: he's certainly telling Ukraine that it's unrealistic to have the
8:00
Speaker 3: expectations it does have in this war, and that is
8:03
Speaker 3: to have NATO membership and to reclaim the territory it's
8:06
Speaker 3: lost in this war. And I think that Trump is
8:08
Speaker 3: correct in saying that's unrealistic for Ukraine to do this.
8:11
Speaker 3: The thing, though, is that they've said this in public
8:14
Speaker 3: rather than as a negotiating tactic behind closed doors, and
8:17
Speaker 3: that is the area where a lot of people in
8:20
Speaker 3: Europe are saying, well, hold it that you've just given
8:22
Speaker 3: away these concessions publicly without even starting negotiations with Russia.
8:26
Speaker 3: So this only works from Trump's perspective if the Russians
8:30
Speaker 3: then give something in return. And what the Russians would
8:33
Speaker 3: have to give is an acceptance of some sort of
8:36
Speaker 3: security guarantee for Ukraine short of NATO membership. But that
8:40
Speaker 3: would satisfy Ukraine and would satisfy Europe, and there certainly
8:44
Speaker 3: is no early sign that this will be the case.
8:48
Speaker 3: The Russian Foreign Minister Lavrov, in the talks in Saudi
8:51
Speaker 3: Arabia said he would not Russia would not agree to
8:55
Speaker 3: European troops being stationed in Ukraine as part of any
8:59
Speaker 3: peace agreement. Now that's the case, that's a non starter
9:03
Speaker 3: for Europe. So what we've seen already is Trump telling
9:07
Speaker 3: Ukraine that it's going to have to have a lot
9:09
Speaker 3: of concessions and not getting any concessions that we're aware
9:13
Speaker 3: of from Russia. And that's very concerning, I think.
9:20
Speaker 1: Coming up what Vladimir Putin and Vladimir is Lensky say.
9:36
Speaker 1: Vladimir's Zlensky responded to those claims overnight, saying Donald Trump
9:40
Speaker 1: has fallen for Russian disinformation.
9:43
Speaker 5: We have seen this disinformation. We understand that this is
9:46
Speaker 5: coming from Russia. We understand this, and we have evidence
9:49
Speaker 5: that these numbers are being discussed between America and Russia. Unfortunately,
9:54
Speaker 5: President Trump, with who we have great respect as a leader.
9:58
Speaker 5: I'm the American people who support us, but unfortunately he
10:02
Speaker 5: lives in this disinformation space.
10:05
Speaker 1: Vladimir Putin says nobody is excluding Ukraine, that it will
10:08
Speaker 1: be included in negotiations, and is called Zelensky hysterical. Finally
10:15
Speaker 1: came in the background to all of this is a
10:17
Speaker 1: dispute over Ukraine's rare earths. Ukraine has much of the
10:22
Speaker 1: world's sources of critical minerals that are important for things
10:26
Speaker 1: like semiconductors. US officials, according to American media, suggested to
10:30
Speaker 1: volodimme Zelenski that the US could be granted fifty percent
10:33
Speaker 1: ownership of those rare earths, and that's something that Zelenski declined.
10:38
Speaker 1: That's before this onslaught of criticism from Donald Trump.
10:42
Speaker 3: What is that, Well, it's interesting. Trump seems to be
10:45
Speaker 3: suggesting that Ukraine owes America a great financial favor because
10:51
Speaker 3: it's been supporting its military with billions and billions of
10:54
Speaker 3: dollars over the whole three year war, and Trump is
10:57
Speaker 3: more or less saying, look, you os four what we've
11:00
Speaker 3: given you. And so that attempted deal with the rare
11:04
Speaker 3: earths was a part of Trump basically trying to get
11:07
Speaker 3: something back for the United States for what it has
11:10
Speaker 3: given the Ukraine. But of course the Ukrainians and Zelenski said, well,
11:15
Speaker 3: we're not going to do that without security arrangements being
11:18
Speaker 3: attached to that deal. You know, if you want a
11:21
Speaker 3: good deal on rare earths, then you need to give
11:24
Speaker 3: us the security guarantees we need to proceed. And so
11:28
Speaker 3: that's why it's a non starter with Zelenski. But I
11:32
Speaker 3: think the fact that Trump even tried this with Ukraine
11:36
Speaker 3: just shows that he really sees that Ukraine owes America
11:39
Speaker 3: for the support that it's given it over the war.
11:44
Speaker 1: Cameron Stewart is The Australian's chief international correspondent. Thanks for
11:52
Speaker 1: joining us on the front. For all the best journalism
11:55
Speaker 1: from Australia and the world, join our subscribers at the
11:58
Speaker 1: Australian dot com