Latest / Ego and Other Things / Can You Live a Good Life While Being Wrong About Morality?
Transcript
- William: Okay. The the question today, as I drive home, is is it possible to live a good life while being wrong about important things? And I'm gonna say that my initial or intuitive answer to this question is going to be yes. But I can kind of already see the tension forming in the sense that if you believe that living a good life ultimately is something objective, right? It's about what you do, and not necessarily what your intentions are, what your feelings are, then you might ask yourself the fair question of On one hand, I believe that what I'm doing is good and right and just and and wonderful, and maybe my my genuine intentions are are for good, but actually it ends up where the results of it ends up being evil. in the sense of the objective actions end up being evil. So you might take the case of maybe like a Nazi a Nazi guard, right? And he thinks that what he's doing is good, because he is he's serving his country, he is promoting their interests, he's working the best job he can for his family. you know, he's kind of just dealt maybe the the crummy circumstances life, but you know, he believes that he really is doing living the best life possible or the good the the the the a good life in general, because based on his beliefs. But of course, his actions, being a Nazi guard, contributing to an evil, oppressive, totalitarian regime that's is killing lots of people and causing lots of suffering. this This would believe the kind of idea that He's living a good life, right? because he's objectively, his behavior is is objectively evil. and so and so the question is again, how can how can we resolve this, right? Is there a world in which you can be seriously wrong about moral questions and still be living a good life? And there's some nuance to it. And I think really you can split two kinds of evaluative streams here. the one on the one hand, talking about universal objective morality, you know, given God's idea of morality compared to you know an ideal standard, does the person live up to the ideal standard or or no? And the other stand of evaluation here is I I guess you could say more relative when you're asked where you're asking, okay. considering what we know about, you know, said person and said circumstances, said environment with said information. were did they live up to the moral standard as far as could be reasonably expected of a person given their circumstances and Those are our again two different kinds of evaluations, which we'll get into next time. All right, so on my way to work, gotta practice the yeah, talk talking on the top of my head. And I think I'll continue from just yesterday's topic. And I'm gonna try and just do it off of memory, the question, and what I was talking about yesterday, and see if if I can connect it. I'll yesterday only had like five minutes. So I couldn't do so much and I probably won't have a ton I'm trying to do today, so I just get right into it here. Yes, today's question was Can you live a good life while being seriously mistaken about some important things? And I think tension I was drawing out was that there was kind of two modes of analysis that you could you could do with this question. The first being the objective analysis, right? Which is to what degree does this person's actual actions Reflect standard of the good, whatever standard that is, right? You could take pretty much any standard, but you could say objectively, does this person's behavior reflect the standard of the good? That's one one side of it that you could look at. the other side that you could look at is can does this person's And when when it comes to the standard of the good and evaluating a person's actions objectively by that standard, everybody's gonna fall short. I think everybody is going to fall short of any standard of the good. We find this even when people apply their own internally devised standard, no matter what standard of the good that you give yourself, you will fall short of it in some kind of way. So everybody Fails this test of objective good because life is messy, right? We have incomplete knowledge, we have incomplete knowledge of the world around us, we have incomplete knowledge of the world around ourselves, we go in and out of different kinds of value hierarchies that are more or less that we are more or less aware of. We act impulsively, emotionally, selfishly. this kind of stuff happens, and it's not always entirely within our control. And even when things are in our control, we will still act we'll still act immorally just because of of in one sense bad intentions or because we we We desire something other than the good in the moment that we are acting rather than designing the good itself. And we're perhaps not conscious of that, or perhaps we are conscious of it, yet are we're just using our freedom to do the wrong thing anyway. But Because that's the standard everybody's going to fail to one degree or another, it's not exactly useful in talking about, okay, has somebody lived a good life. The objective moral standard is useful for understanding what the standard is, right? Understanding what are we measuring. What are we measuring in the ultimate sense? But Because it's necessarily an ideal, because it's something that people as a whole really can't live up to, because it's utopian in a sense, it is less practical to to measure actual everyday life and decisions against that, or even like the whole of a practical life against this ideal objective standard, which nobody ever reaches, even if it's the thing that that we are we're measuring against, right? And so instead of measuring against the ideal, against the the standard of the objectively the objectively good, we have to measure against the standard of the context of the person's life and time. the actual options available to a person, the information that they were likely to be privy to, their their power, their access to resources, that is the actual choices that were available to them, and the likelihood that they could have been aware of an alternative decision and have been had been able to think through that at all, right? So An example that I could probably draw from my own philosophy is that you know, looking at the I'm I'm an advocate of peaceful parenting, nonviolent, non-force-based parenting. And the example you could look at through history is that the further back that you go in our history, the further back that the pressures of survival were encompassing people in the past, the more necessary it was. For the adults at the time to use force and violence to mold children to what they needed to be in order to survive, right? So, example I've given before: if Timmy wants to be an artist, but I need Timmy to work on the field in order so that we don't starve the next summer. I'm going to use force and violence against him so that we don't starve, right? Now, objectively. You would say that the moral ideal there is to is to refrain from force and violence, to find involuntary means of incentivizing or motivating Timmy to to work on the farm rather than be an artist. But you know the the the the the peasant of the media of the early medieval area era who's trying to to farm enough resources so that him and his family don't starve in the in the winter, probably doesn't have the time or the access to education or the you know emotional regulatory the emotional regulation, I guess you could say, available to him. he probably wouldn't know where to even start if he was thinking about the question of of how to raise children in the first place beyond what his tradition or his religion gave him. He's incredibly constrained in his ability to know what to do, right? He has to deal with the most pressing concern in his face, which is the fact that his family is going to starve if Timmy doesn't help him on the field. And he has to default to the most immediate and practical. Solution to that problem, which is force and violence, which he uses against Timmy for for the sake of the immediate pressing value. And it while it's not objectively good, it's in one sense understandable given the context, the historical time, his access to education, his the actual time he would have to to contemplate and think about these things, the culture that's been given to him at the time, the religious environment that's been given him at the time. maybe it would have been possible for him not to use force and violence against Timmy, but the circumstances the the the circumstances so weigh against that option as to make it to render it understandable if he didn't do it. And your assumption would be that if he was placed in a sort of a modern environment, that he would act and react differently than he would back then. And so there's a there's a place for context in this analysis of of a good life even in the absence of of knowledge, right? Or even being mistaken about certain things. And we'll expand on that more in the next video. Alright, we're I'm gonna try recording with it sideways here. I don't know how much that's gonna work. I'm hoping that'll hold on the on the drive, but we'll we'll see. So let's see, last time the thing I wanna talk about today was to can kind of continue that conversation we were having a couple days ago about whether somebody can live a good life but be seriously mistaken about like their knowledge, right? So if like let's say they they just understand something wrong, but they think it's right or they think it's good. And you know, in one sense their intentions are good, but they're just mistaken about right and wrong, right? From right and wrong. And talked about how there's basically two standards of evaluation that are typically brought philosophically to this kind of question, the one being the objective standard where you look at, okay, you know, given what we can determine objectively about Right and wrong good and evil, does this person's behavior match that objective standard from what we can observe about them? That's sort of one standard of evaluation. And there's a second standard of evaluation, which is to say, okay, given what we know about this person's context, right, their their history, what time period they were what social expectations there were, what access to to resources and education and alternatives that they have, we can in one sense say, okay, well, while objectively they did something that was wrong, they did it out of a certain kind of of ignorance, right? And or really in the inability, because of their their social context, to do anything different. And you can in one sense give them grace in that, and you can say that, you know, within the context of their time, they may have even lived an exceptionally good life, even if they violated certain objective standards. So I I think about the the example that comes to mind here is that of Janis Korchak, who was a pedagogue of I guess you could say, a doctor, and he ran this children's orphanage during World War Two. He was Jewish and lived in Poland. He ran this orphanage I think through the first and second world war. And he is famous for advocating for the rights of children. And he I think he either wrote the Declaration of the Rights of Children or his work was the basis for the the Declaration of the Rights of Children. And he was one the first real Western intellectuals to give a lot of respect and humaneness to children up until that point. And really advocated for the advocated for treating them like like human beings, right? And giving them autonomy and respecting what they thought and felt and this kind of stuff, because up until that point children were in one sense or another viewed as you know akin to property. And really childhood wasn't even necessarily a solid concept for for much of our history. And by the standards of his time, you could look at someone like Giannis Korchuk and think, Wow, you know, really what a hero for children. because, you know, given the context of of the time that he grew up in, he could have s you know, seriously, He could done what most people did and and treat children with a lot of disrespect and and advocate and advocate an inhuman standard when it comes to to children. He could have gone along with Freud and and blamed children for their own internal states and and consider them to be innately evil rather than you know, in one sense products of their environment or you know, seriously under pressure on their environment. for his time. his views on children were were significantly advanced, right? But if you read back his the diaries he he wrote, some of the or like the works the compilation of his works I think you're called How to Love a Child. You read that. And there's definitely his own self described moments of of force violence, maybe hitting children, ignoring them when they're crying. Things that like modern day modern day like pediatricians and and and parenting and even like even the the vanguard of peaceful parenting today would look at a lot of the events in Ghana Scorchuk's life and say, you know, this behavior was not good, right? But he lived a great life because he was this he was this child's rights rights guy, because he was an advocate for child children's rights. And ultimately because he he sacrificed his his life and going to the concentration camp and ultimately the gas chamber, for the sake of the orphans he was willing with he was with, really in order to come to them. It's actually an amazing story if we never really got into it, but he He was the sort of Even if he didn't always stand up to an objectively good life, he was by the standards of his day compared to compared to how advanced morality had gotten at that point, he was, you know, head and shoulders above other people in terms of his moral behavior. and so you kinda give grace, right? I mean It's not even giving grace. It's not really like you have to. It's sort of almost not that response that we have. We give a certain degree of grace to the things that you might say the mistakes of Janus Gorchuk, or the things that he thought were right at the time that ended up not being right. because we understand that the the we understand his you might say his mission, exemplified by his objective behavior within the context of the standard. And so there's there from the outside, there is these two strands of analysis, right? You can ask, okay, was this behavior by this person strictly good? And by that standard you can say, no, this was not a good standard. And you can judge them by the standards of their and the more relative standard, you can say, you know, given the context of this person's history and how much they probably had to fight against fight against that context, can we give in one sense kudos to this person? did they morally advance life within the context of their time. and many of the historical heroes that we look at are heroes who conform to this period. You know, so for me it used to be like Dannis Korchuk or Benjamin Lay. People who were who were advancing morality well beyond the standards of their time in a sort of heroic way. That's a that's a not just a good life, but a heroic life. You might even say that I don't know, there's grades of it, right? So you could say like the typical life was a life that was living living in general accordance with the standards of your time, with the moral structures of the time, essentially what was expected. And of course the good the good life itself has its you know it its own definitions, but really no matter what definition of good life that you're considering, you can you can analyze it from the objective fact of whether it conforms with the standard of the good life or the relative standard, like given this person's context, you know, how how close or how far were they with the standard? Ultimately, again, everybody fails to live up to the standard. But there is a third There is a third layer of examination there as well. And that is the individual layer, which is the person's own analysis of themselves, and you might say whether or not they live up to their own moral standards individually. And we'll get into that in the next remote. So we talked about the objective standard, as one standard for evaluating whether or not somebody has lived a good life. And we talked about the subject or sorry, the relative standard as in comparing whether that person lived a relatively good life compared to their cultural circumstances. And how those are two sort of standards that we can look at. standard for evaluating this question would be an individual standard or a subjective standard or a standard which only the individual or the subject can ultimately really confirm for themselves. In this question of you know, can I be seriously mistaken that we can give kind of a lie? And The subjective standard is something that you understand about yourself, I think, when you look back and you reflect on being wrong in your life. Now every single person has a a moral standard. Everybody has a personal moral standard. Everybody has an understanding of right and wrong, whether that's an intuitive sense, whether that's explicit, whatever it is, everybody has a sense, a standard of the good. And Everyone kind of has a rolling tally in their own in the back of their mind about all the times that they've violated that kind of standard, that they've violated a a their own understanding of what was right, right? And maybe, you know, for a while they'll sort of try to justify it to themselves, they'll they'll intellectually pave over whatever they did by asserting a different kind of moral standard, but sort of, you know, in their gut or in their heart they understand that what they did was wrong. And so everybody has a sort of a rolling understanding in the back of their mind of what you might call their character, right? Like how often do I actually comply with what I think is the right thing? And you know, a sort of internal conscience. And they can present that to to other people as much as they want to, as differently as they want to, and many people too. And even at a certain point they can they can self-delude. but essentially everybody has a sense of this. And in the same way, everybody has a record or a sense of how have I reacted to being wrong in the past. Because a universal human experience should be the experience of being wrong. you know, like in my own life. I I like to say that I've been wrong all of my life. I've been mistaken all of my life because there's been so many things that I might have thought were true at one point that I later found out were not true. There are things that I reasoned to and had full, genuine belief in. And later when I I reasoned you know deeper or I found some new information or some conflict, I I realize that that was wrong. I've had ideas and philosophies that have you know had a strong emotional appeal to me that I was just reaching for you know, explanations and justifications for in order to, you know, fill in fill in justifications for a belief that wasn't really supported by the facts or evidence or reason. you know, there's many there's many assumptions and cultural beliefs that you can get sucked into just because you've you've never really had the chance to examine them or because everybody around you sort of just repeats the same thing and so you kind of just assume that it's true. you know, human beings are fallible. Human beings are limited. Human beings make mistakes. sometimes they're emotional and sometimes they're rational, what have you, but everybody makes mistakes in what they believe. That is a very common human experience. What the question becomes in in this notion of you know can I live a good life and be seriously wrong about something, is that in your life, when you are wrong about something, right? When you are seriously wrong about something, how do you react to that, right? How do you react to that? do you go towards further understanding? Or do you back away from it? Do you go towards trying to to to figure out the evidence that that disproves your your theory or your idea, or do you turn away from that, right? Do you embrace hearing about and learning about different perspectives and ideas from other people? Do you test your ideas? Do you do the things which are supposed to to mitigate against? error, right? Or Or do you or do you shy away from it? If you shy away from it or if you react to you know an to understanding if you react to A mistake of reason or a mistaken idea by shying away from it, then you kind of reveal to yourself that you're not you're not so much interested in the truth, right? And if that becomes a pattern in your life, then you in the back of your head you start to build an understanding of the character, a character that you know really isn't interested in the moral truth, really isn't interested in what is actually good, but is interested in in justifying what what you think. is good or what you want to for, right? Justifying your own behaviors rather than trying to actually figure out what is good in and of themselves. Now realistically you can only do this I think evaluation within yourself, right? You this is not evaluation with next which other people can necessarily do with you. maybe close friends or family might be able to track this, but really it's a it's an experience that people have on their own. Like you know when you're avoiding something or not. You know when you've been wrong about something and then either changed your mind and or sought new information or what have you, and when you've just doubled down on your own beliefs. And again, even if you've gotten to the point of of being self-diluted, there is going to be some part in the back of your mind that that understands that you're doing this and gets that sense that you you kind of have that slimy character. kind of have that that wishy washy you know character where you're avoiding the truth. Now, there can be some childhood psychological reasons, which we might get to in another video. But I think that a person can live a good life while being seriously wrong about things, you know, if they are willing to individually confront the things that they've been seriously wrong about, right? and if they have a track record of of responding to to being wrong, to being significantly wrong with with calm curiosity, and in the cases of some of a of a kind of moral wrong that actually does harm to people, at the very least apologizing and and and for for those of wrong beliefs. And If you want to know the key, really, if want to know the the the actual key to to developing that kind of mindset, it's really this purposeful authenticity towards towards ideas, right? I would say that, you know, g kind of a good thing is to you know, as far as is appropriate, but a good thing is to share your ideas with people around you, especially moral ideas in particular. share those ideas with the people around you. you know, talk about with them as with as many people as you can. Kind of just expose your own ideas to to people as you know as safely as you can. There there are certain limitations to it. But expose your ideas to people as really as far as you can because by doing so you're going to get all of the criticism that is really available to you. I mean this is the the benefit of something like reading is that you get to have you know different presentations of ideas, morality and goodness that conflict with your own and you have to be able to Test that and see whether your ideas can stand up to the test or not. but even just doing this with people is with the people in your life is I think a great practice. It's practice of okay, can my ideas repeatedly stand up to maybe common sense objections, for example, right? you know, part of the reason I'm doing this YouTube channel, I mean there's a there's a number of reasons I'm doing this channel, but one of the reasons is that I want to put my ideas out there, you know, as best as I can. I mean I'm I'm practicing the articulation as I'm doing this, but the best I can and get criticism about it, right? And, you know, I'm not necessarily looking for criticism from from academic philosophers or something like that. I'm I'm looking for criticism from from anybody, really. because you get a variety of perspectives. And if my ideas can survive you know repeated rounds of of that kind of engagement. then those ideas are are going are more likely to be true and they're going to be better refined and hopefully the the bad ideas get exposed and and you know new ideas come in to replace them and and I get closer and closer to an understanding of of the truth. And so from this individual perspective, if you want to live a good life, you know, the the the truth is that everybody's going to be seriously wrong about something in their lifetime. And the question isn't, you know, are you going to be wrong about things in your life? But how are you going to react when you're wrong about something in your life? If you react with openness, with curiosity, with apology, if it hurts somebody, with a desire to know, with a desire to test your ideas, with a desire for truth, I'd say, yes, you're living a perfect. Perfectly good light, even if you are wrong about that, in you know, according to the standard. but if you're shying away from that, if you're unwilling to expose your ideas, if you're unwilling to test your ideas, if when you when your ideas are exposed as as wrong, you sort of just double down and and and ignore, then that right there tells you that you're not particularly interested in the truth of what is good, right? You're just you're interested in what whatever you want it to be. and so I would say w it becomes much more difficult to live a good life in that kind of context.