Latest / Public Health Review Morning Edition / 1097: Communicating in a Crisis
Transcript
- 0:00This is Public Health Review Morning Edition for Wednesday,
- 0:02April 1st, 2026. I'm John Sheehan with news from
- 0:06the Association of State and Territorial Health Officials.
- 0:09Today, Communicating in a crisis.
- 0:11We talk with Jessica Wieder, a former leader in external
- 0:14affairs at FEMA and the EPA and currently the President of Teal
- 0:18Skies Consulting, about how to communicate clearly when stakes
- 0:22are high and the science can be complex.
- 0:25Jessica will discuss crisis messaging and specifically
- 0:27radiological risk communication from a public health
- 0:30preparedness perspective, including coordinating messages
- 0:33across partners and addressing public concern and false and
- 0:36misleading information. It's the subject of her upcoming
- 0:39ASTO webinar. Jessica Wieder, welcome to the
- 0:42show. Thank you for having me, John.
- 0:44So, Jessica, what got you started in radiological
- 0:48preparedness? So I love that question because,
- 0:51you know, very few people are nine years old going.
- 0:53I really want to be in radiation preparedness when I grow up.
- 0:57And so for me, my story starts when I graduated college, right?
- 1:00I wanted a job. And my college roommate's mother
- 1:04was the director of the radiation protection division at
- 1:07the Environmental Protection Agency.
- 1:09They were looking for an entry level public affairs specialist.
- 1:11She gave my rest made of the hiring official.
- 1:13And then I stayed for 17 years. And what I thought was just
- 1:18going to be a job that was going to pay the bills very quickly
- 1:21became my profession. My second week on the job was my
- 1:24first emergency exercise. It was called Ruby slippers.
- 1:28The scenario was a satellite with a multi mission
- 1:31radioisotope thermoelectric generator or a large plutonium
- 1:34source crashed in Kansas. And that was a scenario, but I
- 1:39found myself asking a lot of questions like what is a multi
- 1:43mission radioisotope thermoelectric generator and
- 1:46what is a four day total effective dose equivalent?
- 1:50And what does that mean in terms of public health?
- 1:52And will a decision maker read a 12 page consequence management
- 1:57report in the middle of a disaster?
- 1:59And what I found was that I was surrounded by these wonderful
- 2:02people who are not only willing to take the time to answer my
- 2:04questions, but they were also willing to teach me and then
- 2:08change how they were thinking about operations based off the
- 2:12questions I was asking. And that for me to this day, I
- 2:15still feel like is a communicator superpower, right?
- 2:18The ability to see a situation, look at it from different
- 2:21perspectives, ask really good questions, and then ultimately
- 2:24change operations to better help people.
- 2:27You know, a satellite crash was not even a scenario that I had
- 2:31envisioned or I could have imagined, and now you've added
- 2:34one to my list. You know, I, I started with that
- 2:38as my very first exercise and then I actually got to plan for
- 2:42the Mars Curiosity and the Mars Perseverance launches, which
- 2:45both had multi mission radio isotope thermoelectric
- 2:48generators on board. So you're taking that exercise
- 2:51experience for real world of what if something actually went
- 2:53wrong during one of those launches?
- 2:55Yeah. How else have these kind of
- 2:58emergency preparedness communications exercises, how
- 3:02how have things evolved over the years?
- 3:05I mean, I think you got to realize when I graduated
- 3:07college, like you still had to go to the library to do research
- 3:09papers. You know, if you still had to,
- 3:12you were transitioning from Myspace to Facebook right in
- 3:14that time frame. That really ages me.
- 3:17But the speed of information and the sheer volume of information,
- 3:22good information and not good information is just increased
- 3:25dramatically from when I first started at the agency.
- 3:29And so we've really had to think about like how we think about
- 3:33messaging. So, you know, initially got very
- 3:36lucky, got a chance very early in my career to work with Doctor
- 3:39Vincent Cavallo. He sort of thought of as the the
- 3:42leader, the father of modern risk communication practices and
- 3:46he taught me about message mapping.
- 3:48It's this idea that during high stress situations, people can
- 3:51only comprehend 3 messages at a time.
- 3:53Low stress, 7 to 9 messages at a time.
- 3:56And that has really become the foundation of how I think about
- 4:00messaging. I think in three key messages
- 4:02all the time. And that's still very relevant I
- 4:04think in today's day and age. But I spent the last four years
- 4:09working at FEMA external affairs, and I really have a
- 4:11much greater appreciation that it's not just the words on the
- 4:14page that matter to be prepared. It's about how do you own the
- 4:18whole narrative, right? It's it's the the visuals that
- 4:21go with your story. It's the spokespeople, it's the
- 4:24seconders. It's like those people, those
- 4:26partners that are going to agree with your message to give it
- 4:29more trust in the message. And so it's, I've had to think
- 4:32about a whole more holistic approach to messaging to make
- 4:36sure that we're we're touching all of those different audiences
- 4:40that are chiming in through all of those different channels that
- 4:43we now have to reach. You know, whether it's influence
- 4:45or is the, you know, on Instagram and our traditional
- 4:49media, I can't under score the importance of traditional media,
- 4:52but making sure that our plans are more than just the words on
- 4:54the page. They take all that into account.
- 4:57So what are some aspects to A to a successful, concise
- 5:02communication that needs to make its way through different
- 5:06channels like the ones you just mentioned?
- 5:08Different external and internal partners.
- 5:12I mean, I think first you need to have a really clear message,
- 5:14right? What is it we're trying to say?
- 5:16Why are we trying to say it is really important, right?
- 5:19Who needs to take action or know this information?
- 5:22What do we want them to do with it has to be the basis of any
- 5:25good communications plan. And then the next piece is the
- 5:29person delivering that message has to be coming from a really
- 5:32genuine point of view. People can really tell when
- 5:36somebody is reading talking points but don't necessarily
- 5:39mean them. And I think that's a whole skill
- 5:42set of making sure you have the right spokesperson when we're
- 5:45talking about disaster response. Because people need to feel like
- 5:49the person on the other end is not just giving them good
- 5:51advice, but advice that they would follow themselves.
- 5:54And so authenticity really matters.
- 5:57That's really interesting. So often it seems like there's,
- 6:01I feel like you have to anticipate the, the emotional
- 6:04state of the audience receiving these in this information
- 6:06because you're getting people probably in a state of, you
- 6:10know, at least heightened emotions, at worst, panic, but
- 6:14definitely urgency. Oh, yeah, there's, there's a lot
- 6:18of urgency and I and I think people are trying to figure out
- 6:20what to do. And I think that the one thing
- 6:23that we collectively as a public health community can do better
- 6:26is validate people's feelings. I think we underestimate the
- 6:30importance of doing that. They were something like
- 6:32radiation, for example, where it's a fairly weak carcinogen.
- 6:36So we might say like their fear is unwarranted.
- 6:40We know from behavioral science that radiation is one of the
- 6:43most feared hazards that's out there.
- 6:46And so while their fear may not be warranted scientifically, but
- 6:51from a behavioral health standpoint, it is completely
- 6:53valid. In fact, it is normal during
- 6:57COVID. 2 of my very best friends are school teachers and when
- 7:01they had to go back into the classroom, they were incredibly
- 7:04scared and I was able to tell them right the best thing I can
- 7:07do for them was say you're feeling scared is normal right
- 7:10it this is a situation with a huge unknown.
- 7:13There is concern for your family.
- 7:16There is you're being forced into a situation you don't
- 7:19necessarily want to be part of. And all for all those reasons,
- 7:24the risk perception is really, really, really high.
- 7:27And once they felt like I had heard them and I acknowledged
- 7:31the fact that their fear was real and valid, then we could
- 7:35start talking about, well, how can you take back control,
- 7:38right? What are the things that you can
- 7:40and should be doing to ensure your safety, the safety of your
- 7:44the kids in your classroom, the safety of your family back home
- 7:47to put them back in a in a point of control.
- 7:49So when we're asking people during an emergency to take an
- 7:52action, acknowledging their feelings and validating their
- 7:55feelings first is really important to getting them to
- 7:58trust us to be able to give them the advice that they need to
- 8:01make informed decisions. Yeah.
- 8:04And getting back to this notion of, you know, making sure that
- 8:07your message is, is trustworthy and, and accepted across
- 8:11channels. What about?
- 8:13When that message gets taken over by by others that you have
- 8:18no control over and and your message, your message gets
- 8:22turned, in some cases by bad actors.
- 8:25Yes. So this is a problem that we're
- 8:27seeing more and more and I think that it is it is incredibly
- 8:32challenging and I think you need a strategy for how to deal with
- 8:36it. And I really want to give a
- 8:37shout out to FEMA's communications team for thinking
- 8:40through, you know, how do you combat rumors?
- 8:43And I think first we need to acknowledge that not all rumors
- 8:45need a response, right? There's some rumors that are
- 8:48going to self correct or there's some rumors that are never going
- 8:50to get legs. They're not going to go
- 8:52anywhere. They're not worth your time and
- 8:53energy. It's just going to go away.
- 8:56But then there are those rumors that you actually do need to
- 8:59address. So you need to ask yourself a
- 9:01couple of things, right? Is this rumor affecting our
- 9:04ability to complete our mission? Is this rumor affecting public
- 9:09health or safety in any way? Is this rumor growing with the
- 9:14potential to have a negative impact?
- 9:18So depending on your answers to that, you may want to respond.
- 9:22And I think when we think about how you respond to those,
- 9:25there's an indirect way or there's a direct way.
- 9:28The indirect way is you just say what you need to say, whatever
- 9:32the correct information is, without repeating the rumor and
- 9:35hope that that gets enough leverage.
- 9:37But if it is a bad enough rumor, if it is a rumor that is going
- 9:41to hurt people or hurt your mission, you may have to take
- 9:45the direct route of calling that out as here's the false
- 9:47information. It is false and here is what you
- 9:51need to know, here's the truth. And you have to do that across
- 9:56many, many different channels with as many trusted
- 9:59spokespeople and as many partners as you can when that is
- 10:03a particularly harmful rumor. One thing my, my FEMA Director
- 10:09of Digital communications would always emphasize was the use of
- 10:12our website, because the website is one of the few places where
- 10:16we own every single word that goes in that context.
- 10:22And so for example, like during Hurricane Helene, we had up a, a
- 10:26rumors web page. And that rumors web page got
- 10:29carried far and wide. I mean, we, we let everybody
- 10:34know that we had this, our state and local partners knew we had
- 10:36this and everyone was promoting it and it was getting picked up
- 10:39on mainstream media for over a week, which is almost unheard
- 10:42of. But it's, it's a really good
- 10:45resource for people to go to, to go, you know, what is the truth?
- 10:48And then for people to take and use verbatim on their own to
- 10:52help amplify that message. I feel like I was just re
- 10:55traumatized by some recent examples of bad messaging that
- 11:00needed to be redacted in public. Yeah, it is.
- 11:04And it it's hard to make the choice that you're going to go
- 11:07full scheme ahead on on addressing A rumor because it
- 11:11takes a lot of time, a lot of energy, and it puts you under a
- 11:15lot of scrutiny. So you better be prepared with
- 11:18all of your facts that are going to prove that something is in
- 11:22fact a rumor. And Jessica, So when when you're
- 11:26in the role of a communicator, sometimes you've got to also
- 11:29present a broad message that's got to filter through other
- 11:33smaller jurisdictions or, or or authorities.
- 11:37How do you ensure that your message stays consistent?
- 11:42You know, it's really challenging to to create
- 11:44consistent messaging. I think having pre-existing
- 11:46relationships helps that a lot because you want to make sure
- 11:50that you know the people, your partners, your neighbors.
- 11:53Because if one jurisdiction says one thing in another
- 11:55jurisdiction is giving contradicting guidance, we run
- 11:59into problems. We saw this during COVID.
- 12:01We really struggled with this idea of of different
- 12:04jurisdictions giving different guidance.
- 12:06So I think having a consistent message is incredibly important,
- 12:10you know, And let me give you an example.
- 12:12Well, I like to use the example of of a group of people going to
- 12:15lunch, right? So everybody's experienced this.
- 12:18A group of people are trying to go to lunch.
- 12:19One person says, hey, I think I want sandwiches.
- 12:22The next person says, hey, I also want sandwiches.
- 12:24And then the group probably goes for sandwiches, right?
- 12:27And then if you have a group of people and one person who goes,
- 12:29I really want sandwiches. And the next person says,
- 12:31actually, I'd really prefer a hamburger.
- 12:33Well, it's going to take that group of people longer to decide
- 12:36where to go to lunch, and that is just lunch, right?
- 12:40We've all experienced this. So if we're in an emergency
- 12:43situation and we need people to take timely action, making sure
- 12:47the action we're asking people to take is consistent is really
- 12:50important. East Palestine is a really great
- 12:53example where we had the train derailment.
- 12:55It was right on the border of Ohio and Pennsylvania, and the
- 12:58initial evacuation message that went out from Ohio and
- 13:01Pennsylvania was the same. If you were in one to two miles
- 13:04of that area, you were to leave because it was consistent from
- 13:08state to state. Nobody was questioning whether
- 13:10or not that was the right guidance.
- 13:12And people were able to get out of harm's way before they were
- 13:14allowed back into their into their homes.
- 13:17And so I cannot emphasize enough the importance of it.
- 13:21But I would also say there are times where jurisdictions are
- 13:24going to have different guidance.
- 13:26And one thing we can do better is explaining why.
- 13:29Why are we having different guidance from one place to
- 13:32another? What is the rationale that
- 13:34you're using to make that decision?
- 13:37If we can explain that, then I think people are going to be
- 13:40more willing to work with the decisions that the decision
- 13:44makers are making because they understand the rationale.
- 13:48And I think that during COVID, that was something we could have
- 13:50done a lot better. Turning the lens back to
- 13:53radiological events in particular, are there are there
- 13:57pieces of advice you would give to smaller, smaller agencies
- 14:01that are looking to revamp or in maybe some cases create a
- 14:05preparedness? Plan.
- 14:07I think the good news is is that you don't have to start from a
- 14:09blank piece of paper. Organizations like ASTA, for
- 14:12example, where you have the ability to ask for help and see
- 14:15what neighbors are doing. I think it's a great resource.
- 14:18I also would say that there are a lot of pre scripted messages
- 14:21out there. There is a document from I think
- 14:24comes out of FEMA that's called communicating in the immediate
- 14:27aftermath and that's for nuclear detonation response.
- 14:29There's communicating during and after nuclear power plant
- 14:32accident. There's a ton of pre scripted
- 14:34messages in it. CDC has a bunch of infographics
- 14:38for all different types of radiological disasters and and
- 14:41associated like what is Prussian blue?
- 14:43What are some like medical interventions, what is Ki, that
- 14:46sort of thing. But they have the many different
- 14:48languages, which is wonderful. And EPA's Radiation Protection
- 14:52Division also has a lot of great resources on how to communicate
- 14:55about radiation risk. They have a fairly new
- 14:58infographic on explaining radiation units, which is really
- 15:02challenging to do. So use the resources that are
- 15:05out there. And then I would say that if you
- 15:07are starting from scratch and you're thinking about how do we
- 15:10write a communications plan for any emergency, one of my
- 15:14favorite quotes is a brilliant scientific discourse is wasted
- 15:18if nobody listens or understands it right.
- 15:20So remember that who you are writing for, who needs to take
- 15:23this information, who needs to act on this information?
- 15:26And as long as you're putting people first at the heart of
- 15:29your plan, you're doing something right.
- 15:32Jessica Weider is the President of Teal Skies Consulting and a
- 15:36former leader in external affairs at FEMA and the EPA.
- 15:39Jessica will be the speaker for an upcoming ASTO webinar titled
- 15:43Past, Present, and Future Reflections from Our Radiation
- 15:46Readiness Professional. Find the link in the show notes.
- 15:50Effective public Health Communication depends not only
- 15:53on what we say, but how we share our message.
- 15:56In an upcoming webinar titled Storytelling and Public Health
- 15:59Lessons from STI Prevention and Care, join ASTO as we explore
- 16:03how strong storytelling can transform complex or sensitive
- 16:06health topics into stories that engage diverse audiences,
- 16:09inspire action, and drive change.
- 16:12This webinar will equip participants with concrete
- 16:14storytelling strategies to create impactful messages that
- 16:17resonate. Learn how to identify the core
- 16:19narrative in your. Work.
- 16:21Choose the right format for your story and connect with audiences
- 16:24on topics that are often technical or stigmatized.
- 16:27Find the link in the show notes an upcoming webinar provides.
- 16:32An in depth walkthrough. Of the Astro report, Driving
- 16:34impact with flexible funding, participants will explore how
- 16:38state health agencies can move beyond traditional funding silos
- 16:41to create more agile, high impact public health
- 16:43initiatives. Through real world examples and
- 16:46strategic analysis, we will examine the pathways to
- 16:48successfully adopting and expanding flexible funding
- 16:52models in a government setting. Find details in the show notes.
- 16:56This has been public health review morning edition.
- 16:58I'm John Sheehan for the Association of State and
- 17:00Territorial Health Officials.