Latest / Comeback Project: Survival, hope & second chances / Why Hiding Your Excitement Feels Safer Than Sharing It Openly | Comeback Project
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of silence that falls over a room the moment you admit you’re actually happy. It’s not malicious, but it is heavy, and it pulls the air right out of your lungs. I want you to take a deep breath with me right now. Just one. In through the nose, hold it for a second, and let it out slowly. Good. Because I need you to be present for what I’m about to say, and your nervous system needs a moment to settle before we dive into the quiet ache of this topic. We’ve talked before about the courage it takes to walk away from things that drain us. We discussed the golden handcuffs and how exhausting it is to wear them. But today, I want to talk about something quieter, something sneakier. It’s the way we hide our joy. Not the sad stuff—the pain we share because it invites comfort. No, I mean the good stuff. The excitement. The spark in your chest when something new looks possible. Think back to the last time you had a genuine reason to celebrate. Maybe you got a compliment at work that felt true. Maybe you finished a project you were proud of. Or maybe you just bought flowers for no reason at all, and for ten minutes, you felt light. Did you tell anyone? If you did, how did they react? And more importantly, how did you feel immediately after you spoke? For many of us, the answer is a strange mix of relief and immediate regret. We shrink back. We minimize. We say, "Oh, it was nothing," or "It’s probably not going to go anywhere." We apologize for taking up space with our happiness. Why? Because somewhere along the line, we learned that being too happy makes us vulnerable. That it makes us targets. That if we show our cards, someone might flip the table. Let’s name the fear clearly. It’s not just that people might be jealous. Although yes, envy is real, and it’s ugly, and it hurts. But there’s a deeper terror. It’s the fear of being seen as naive. As immature. As someone who doesn’t understand how hard the world really is. I remember a few years ago, I landed a writing gig that I thought would change everything. I was thrilled. Truly, deeply thrilled. I told my closest friend, and she looked at me with this soft, pitying smile and said, "Be careful, Carole. Don’t get too attached. Things like this don’t last. You’ll only hurt yourself more when it ends." On the surface, it sounded protective. But underneath, it felt like a bucket of ice water dumped on my spirit. She wasn’t wrong, necessarily. Things didn’t last. But in that moment, her caution felt like a punishment for my hope. It taught me that excitement was a liability. That if I wanted to be safe, I should keep my enthusiasm locked down tight, behind a wall of cynicism and low expectations. So we start doing it to ourselves. We preemptively dampen our own light. We practice saying, "It’s okay if it fails," before it even has a chance to succeed. We lower the bar so high that we can’t possibly fall. But here’s the truth: lowering the bar doesn’t protect you from disappointment. It protects you from living. It keeps you safe, yes, but it also keeps you small. And I am not here to advocate for smallness. Why do we do this? Why does hiding our excitement feel safer than sharing it openly? Because sameness is comfortable. Even when sameness is miserable, it is predictable. We know the shape of our sadness. We know how to navigate the landscape of our grief. We have maps for those territories. But joy? Joy is uncharted. Joy requires us to step off the cliff and trust that we will learn to fly before we hit the ground. That is terrifying. Especially if you’ve been burned before. Especially if you’ve spent years believing that suffering is the price of admission for adulthood. I hear from women every day who tell me they feel guilty for feeling good. They feel like they’re betraying their past selves by allowing themselves to be happy now. They think, "If I’m happy, then what I went through didn’t matter. Or worse, it means I was wrong to struggle." But listen to me closely: your joy does not erase your pain. Your excitement does not invalidate your history. They are separate rooms in the same house. You can sit in the kitchen, mourning the loss of who you used to be, and then walk into the living room and allow yourself to dance. One does not cancel out the other. Yet, we treat joy like it’s a forbidden fruit. Like if we bite into it, the whole structure of our identity will crumble. It won’t. But it might require you to build a new foundation. And building is messy. Building is loud. Building invites eyes to turn toward you. And that visibility feels dangerous. What did that cost you? That’s the question I always come back to. What is the cost of keeping your excitement hidden? The first cost is isolation. When you don’t share your wins, big or small, you deny others the opportunity to celebrate with you. You deny them the chance to reflect your light back to you. We are social creatures. We regulate each other’s nervous systems. When you whisper your joy, you miss out on the resonance. You miss out on the collective lift that comes when a community says, "Yes! Look at you!" The second cost is stagnation. Excitement is fuel. It’s the energy that propels us forward. When you suppress it, you lose momentum. You start moving through life in neutral gear. You go through the motions, but you aren’t driving. You’re just riding in the car, watching the scenery blur by, wondering where you’re supposed to be. And the third cost, the heaviest one, is self-betrayal. Every time you shrink your joy to make others comfortable, you send a message to yourself. You tell yourself that your feelings are too much. That your happiness is inconvenient. That you must earn the right to feel good by first proving you’ve suffered enough. This is a lie. A dangerous, corrosive lie. You do not need to suffer to deserve joy. You are human. That is enough. So how do we stop hiding? How do we start sharing our excitement without flinching? It starts with identifying your safe harbor. Not everyone deserves your joy. Some people are still in the dark, and they will try to extinguish your candle because its light reminds them of their own shadows. Protect your spark from them. Find the one person who listens to understand, not to fix. Find the friend who gets excited with you, not for you. Share with them first. Let yourself feel the relief of being seen. Feel the warmth of their reflection. Then, gradually, expand your circle. Practice saying, "I’m really excited about this," without adding a qualifier. Without saying, "...but I know it might not work." Just let the statement stand alone. Let it hang in the air. Notice the discomfort. Breathe through that. Stay in the discomfort until it passes. Because it will pass. And in its place, you’ll find a new kind of strength. A strength that comes from owning your narrative. You are allowed to be hopeful. You are allowed to be ambitious. You are allowed to be delighted by the mundane details of your life. Do not apologize for your light. Do not dim your bulb to spare someone else’s eyes. They can adjust their sunglasses. You focus on shining. I want to leave you with this thought. Your excitement is not a threat to the world. It is a gift. When you share your joy authentically, you give others permission to access their own. You break the spell of cynicism. You remind people that life is not just about enduring, but about experiencing. It doesn’t have to make sense yet. You might still feel the urge to pull back. You might still catch yourself apologizing for your happiness. That’s okay. Notice it. Acknowledge it. And then gently, firmly, choose to speak anyway. Choose to say, "I’m happy." Choose to say, "This matters to me." Choose to let your voice shake if it needs to, but let it be heard. We are rebuilding our lives, piece by piece. And joy is one of the most important pieces. Don’t leave it in the box. Take it out. Dust it off. Hold it up to the light. See how it glows. See how it changes the room. Breathe through that. It’s yours. All of it. The pain, the growth, and the glorious, unapologetic excitement of being alive. Claim it. Share it. Let it ripple outward. Because the world needs your light, not your shadow. And honestly? So do you. Thank you for sitting with me in this quiet space. I’m holding space for you, always. Until next time, breathe, shine, and keep coming back to yourself. I’m Carole Goff. Take care of that beautiful heart of yours.