Latest / Behind Gym Doors | A Fitness Business Podcast / 356: How to Create Offers That Drive Gym Growth
Transcript
- 0:001 So if you studied marketing at all, or been any type of student of marketing, at least from any credible source, you've already learned that there is absolute correlation between a strong offer and a great outcome when it comes to your marketing efforts. With that, I'm actually sitting here with Michael Freeman of Super Fit Grow Out in Australia. Now he is one of the co-founders.
- 0:221 I've had Benji on the show already and, I've just I've been in all of these guys and what they've done for gyms all over the world. We actually think they do such a good job on the digital marketing side of the lead gen side, that we've actually sent all of our advertising clients to them. And we worked out a deal, of course, but they generate more leads at a at the same budget and higher qualified leads, meaning they're further down the funnel ready to make a decision.
- 0:471 So it just made all the sense in the world of keeping true to our mission of we want to help gyms grow and so with that, though, one of the things that makes them so successful is their ability to really get great offers and intestines within all the gyms that they work with. And so between his experience and my experience, which means working with over 4000 gyms across the world, we're able to really dive in deep into this particular episode and bring to you what we've learned makes a really strong, compelling offer that speaks to the person that you're wanting to target perfectly and makes them compelled to take action, learn more and eventually become
- 1:241 a member. So without further ado. All right. So one of the things that I think is pretty common knowledge now in the marketing world is that the offer is a very important variable in the marketing tactics that you deploy. And if you don't have a compelling offer, you could have the coolest tech, the greatest, integrations. You could also have wonderful branding, beautiful logos, colors, all that stuff.
- 1:521 But if the offer is really weak, it can be very challenging. Now, the offer, I've learned, isn't the end all. Be all. There's companies that don't actually have a great offer in the traditional sense. For example, Apple. Tesla doesn't really do offers in the traditional sense, but their offer defined the way it actually is, is you get a top of the line product at a very expensive rate, which is worth it because it's top of the line.
- 2:201 That's what people know. Now, some of you listening might say, well, I'm top of the line. I don't want to discount either. Well, if the amount of people that know Tesla and Apple also know you, you're probably right. If there's a big difference between the amount of people that know Tesla and Apple and you, then you're probably wrong.
- 2:371 And therefore a traditional offer in the sense in which we're going to be speaking of today might be valuable. So, Michael, I want to dive into this really quickly with you. When we talk about offers, the traditional sense, what is a typical offer look like for a typical small business, just so we can get that started and we're going to dive into the problems that having a not having an offer solve.
- 3:032 Yeah. Well, with a, with a typical small business, if we're looking at a gym or a fitness studio, we would say, out there in the marketplace, a seven day trial or three day pass, just something to entice the, prospective member, to make a decision to come in for that experience. That initial introductory package.
- 3:221 Got it. And I want to dive into the customer psychology of this. So when it comes to the customer psychology of a great offer, why don't you help break that down a little bit? What's your take on that?
- 3:372 Well, what we what you want to do with an offer is you want to have a high perceived value to the consumer. You want to. There's so much competition out there and there's so much noise. And to be able to cut through that noise, we need something that actually resonates with your ideal consumer. So what is an offer?
- 3:542 An offer is something that is of perceived of high perceived value to the consumer, something that is tangible, that will make someone get off the couch, show some interest and engage with that with that product or service.
- 4:091 So what makes an offer irresistible?
- 4:142 It depends on it, depends on the situation. But from a gym or fitness studio perspective, we see that in the marketplace quite often three day trials, a free pass. And these, these offers typically don't seem to generate a lot of leads, a lot of interest. But when we, add some additional components to the offer. So when it has a time frame, when it has the benefit to the consumer and when it has a power, and you have three components in addition to the value stack as what is the consumer going to get for, you know, getting off their couch and going into the gym, for example?
- 4:532 I'll give you an example. I recently joined a DFT locally, and I had the choice between, to two local four studios eight minutes apart. One was offering two weeks for $49, the other one was two weeks for $20. But in addition, if I decided to sign up in the first week, I was going to get a free heart rate monitor and I was going to get also $10 discount if I was going to sign up for six months.
- 5:172 So I decided to go with option B because I knew that I was Cindy interested in a long term membership and there was more value in that particular offer. So that's what I decided to go for.
- 5:271 And for the listeners that don't know, BFT is a fitness studio concept. And you also mentioned value stacking and, that's a very, very important piece. So one of the things that makes a great offer, a lot of people think it's discounting, but you don't have to discount. What you really need to do is create a big gap between what they get and what they have to give in order to get it.
- 5:491 Another way to say that is increase the perceived value, right? So if you're going to buy a house for $100,000, easy math. Can't find a house like that anymore. But if you were to buy a house for $100,000, you would like to believe that that house is worth at 120 or 130,000. That's where you feel like it's a good decision.
- 6:061 Nobody wants to buy a house. It's $100,000 at $100. That feels like it's worth 100,000. You want to get a house that you feel is better. That's where you feel like you got a good deal. The killer deals like the house where 200,000. You got it for 100, right? So what we want to do is create a discrepancy, a big gap between what I have to give and what I have to get.
- 6:251 Easiest way to do it, but not the most profitable way to do it is to just discount just, hey, half off, 50% off. But another way to do it is to value stack. So with that, Michael, why don't you dive into value stacking. What is value stacking.
- 6:402 So what is value stacking is adding additional components to that offer. So the added tangible and intangible items that a consumer will receive in that initial introductory package. So as I mentioned earlier, one of them could be like a free hot rate monitor. We could have a 1 to 1 personal training session and nutrition guide. Those those are the types of things that someone might even find more valuable than simply just a free trial.
- 7:092 So what is the consumer going to get in that first two weeks, three week, four week period? Maybe there's a welcome pack, maybe there is a towel and a drink bottle. Even though they might sound small, those little additional benefits, increase that perceived value. Again, differentiating it from simply a seven day, free trial. Again, don't need to give away for free.
- 7:322 You can definitely offer it for a price, but you don't need to advertise the price, if that makes sense.
- 7:381 100% and one of the things that I learned to be sure you have to, Michael, is that when you're creating those additional things that you would bolt on to the offer in order to make it like a bigger offer, right? You value stack. You stack new, valuable things on top of the offer. It's very important to choose things that you would stack on that are very, very intriguing to that same target audience.
- 8:041 So, for example, we did something called mother May was a great promotion. It drove in 300 this one gym or best gym that did it. You got 309 leads in six days with $0 in Aspen if you were to rent out. So you got probably five, 600 leads, right? But that was $0 in Aspen, 309 leads in six days.
- 8:221 But it was a mother's May promotion. So everything that was stacked on top of that offer was all things that are appealing to the typical mom you would target, which is between that 30 or 45 range. So it was like a one hour, $50 Lululemon gift card. A lot of you were like, well, wait, they're going to a $50 if they sign up?
- 8:401 Yes, because what you'll learn is even with that, if you're closing more people, your customer acquisition cost still improves. Then if you give nothing away but you close less people and you spend the same amount of money in marketing. He also threw in stuff like a free massage, which he had a massage studio that actually offered to give a free massage to anybody that joined, knowing that that's probably a good client because they're spending money on advertising anyway, this is even better.
- 9:061 So there were a lot of things, and if you guys actually want to see the breakdown of the entire offer, just a lot of stuff that we in, you can actually go to you loud rumor.com/great-offers again that's loud rumor.com/great offer. So you can see exactly how we built it out. Tons of gyms modeled after this and got a ridiculous amount of leaves at very, very little cost.
- 9:311 Okay. So we talked about that. And I love the idea that you guys value stack, because although I do believe that there is a place for discounts and, you know, lowering the price in some cases, I do feel like the better deal is when you can stack value instead. But one of the things that I know you talk about is the importance of understanding that customers pain points a desire.
- 9:541 So when we're creating the offer, how do you guys take in account their pain points and their desires?
- 10:022 So again, of course, it really depends on the brand or the modality and what that consumer might be looking for. So typically if you, if they're individuals looking for a transformation, right. Body transformation, that's, that's what they therefore and they want to improve the look and feel, of the of their physique over a period of time.
- 10:232 Then including the word transformation in offer can be quite appealing. As opposed to, let's say another example might be a sculpt program because people want to sculpt their body. So having these types of words as, part of the offer is, is matches what the consumer might be looking for, for, for the product or service that you're offering.
- 10:451 Love it. Now let's talk about the structure of the offer. So what are the different types of offers you got discounts, bundles, limited time stuff like help me break those down.
- 10:582 I might just start with an an example a case study. So we've had a client, they had a three free class offer. And what we did is we crafted a different offer from that. So we didn't change it too much, but we formed a three class. A free, sorry, a three free classes bootcamp experience. And what happened was they generated four times the number of leads by just simply tweaking the name of the offer because we offer a boot, bootcamp.
- 11:272 Right. So that's just a win example. And in terms of the components, what's important here. So you've got your your time frame or quantity of classes. So typically from a time frame perspective might be a seven day, 14 day or 21 day or 28 day experience. And then you're looking at the middle section of the offer, which is what is the benefit or what is the service.
- 11:512 So is it a is it a bootcamp? Is it a transformation? Is it beginners boxing? What are we offering the consumer. So it can be really, really clear that that offer. And then finally the last component is that power powered at the end. So is that a kick start. Is it a program? Is it an experience? So what it is just sort of finishes off the naming of that.
- 12:142 When you have all those three components in place, it genuinely sparks a lot more interest. It, it, generates more late and, and makes more sense when you're reading it in, in, in your, in your a copy, whether it's paid with whether you're running paid ads or whether it's organic.
- 12:321 I love it. So let's dive into that. Those types now. So the discounts bundles limited time deals. So we talked a little bit about discounts I mean that's where you just break down like a seven day 14 day trial something like that. Then you get your bundles which is like the value stacking right where you just add in different things, give it a container.
- 12:501 And then we got limited time deals. What kind of limited time deals have you guys seen that work really well.
- 12:562 So limited time deals adding scarcity. So we sort of talking about scarcity with that particular offer. It's not necessarily, a necessity to add, but it's definitely worth testing to limit that time, of the promotion. So particularly around a seasonality. So if it's a mother's day offer or if it's, a winter special or something to do with the actual season, then putting a limited time with that offer can entice consumers to make a decision.
- 13:272 A little bit more quickly, quickly, knowing that that particular offer will end. And, and shortly.
- 13:341 And so let's go into the piece I think a lot of people miss out on and that's you got this great offer, but then you have a week or no real good call to action or CTA. So what are some of the best practices for, compiling different types of CTAs that you could have call to action?
- 13:551 Well, let's start with what is a call to action. And then we'll go into what are the different types of call to action to use and where do you use them. Sure.
- 14:042 So call to action is there to in and to instruct the consumer on where to go next. So if you've got an offer but you need to tell them where to go. So typically what we see in with gyms and fitness studios they're using either sign up or learn more. And that's again, it's really important to test a variety of call to actions to see what works best for you.
- 14:292 Learn more is is good to use because it's less friction there where if you have, say, sign up, you're potentially pushing people away because they might not be ready to to make a decision right there and then. And they want to learn more about your brand. So we recommend learn more as a, as a softer call to action.
- 14:492 And obviously with that next step being there's some more information about the brand and service that they can read and and understand before making that next, taking the next step to, to convert into, say, or book a trial.
- 15:041 Yeah. You know, the, urgency and scarcity are very important as well. And they can really help because like what you said, not everybody's ready to take action right now. And if there's one thing, that one thing that many humans are good at is procrastinate. We're very good at holding off. I can't tell you how many gift cards I have in my wallet.
- 15:231 I don't know how many. I got a lot. A lot of gift cards. And everyone gives you a $25 gift card here, $75 gift card, their $50 gift card here. And I got, like, probably at least 30 to 50 gift cards. And I don't care because I know that, like, I'm going to use them when I want to use them.
- 15:381 But I remember I was going through my gift cards to find this one gift card for a restaurant. And as I went, I saw a Nike gift card and it said expires 2024. And it was coming up. It was like December, I have to go get this now or I'll say, lose it. And I didn't even need shoes.
- 15:561 I had no real need for shoes. I just didn't. I felt like I was losing by not getting shoes. So the same thing goes for this. Somebody that is reading this particular ad has an interest, just like I did have an issue when I got the Nike gift card, I was happy. I was like, cool, I like Nike, I know I'm going to wear Nike's one day, but I use this gift card.
- 16:191 So people are reading the ad for the gym. They are interested in working out with it, maybe don't have that pressure right now. They may be procrastinating. They're not ready to go. When you add in urgency, which it's usually like, time bound. So only seven days left or ends on the 31st, or scarcity, which is only five available or only three left.
- 16:431 You're able to get that person like you spoke about that's just not ready right now to be ready, because they don't want to lose the deal. What are some things that you've seen in your tests when it comes to scarcity and urgency? Like is a 30 day window too big? Is a seven day window three day? Or what about quantity?
- 17:011 Is it 50 available? 20 available. Like what do you what do you see?
- 17:052 Look I've definitely variety things do work so limited spots remaining is generic. The number of spots that you can actually intake in a certain particular period of time might sound a little bit more legitimate than simply. I only have, you know, I've got 30 spots. So saying that you can only take 5 or 10 spots this week, you've got the time, time down.
- 17:292 So this particular offer, ends on a specific date. Works, works very well. It really just depends on, again, what we're offering at the time of year. And if not, must make sense for you, for your brand. But certainly adding scarcity or urgency to the offer does increase. The, number of, of late. You've got to you've got to do it.
- 17:502 Otherwise people won't make that decision right now.
- 17:531 Yeah. So so sounds like it does depend. But is there some that you've you're like, that's too long. Like it's 30 days too long. It's 50 days. 45 days. What about with like quantity is like 100 too many is 50 too many? Like, what have you seen in your tests that, like, you know, what I can say confidently is generally this is too much.
- 18:142 Yeah. I think if you what from what we've seen, if you, have a, urgency, over like a month period, then it's not really going to hold any, any way. So do you want something that ends in soon within the next week or two weeks? That being said, when you're looking at if you're looking at it from a pay rates perspective, you also want to have something that is also evergreen in a sense.
- 18:392 So it's it's you can you can test with and you can test without, without. Then you can have an evergreen offer that, doesn't necessarily have an end date, but you could have a certain number of spots or slots available in that particular month. And that's more legitimate, right? Rather than having this particular end date, you want you want something you want something believable, something that's.
- 19:052 Yeah. You don't want to be lying about what you do because you want to get that. You want to get more members. You want to get more, more leads. So we want to be honest with what we do.
- 19:161 I agree. So when you're measuring the effectiveness of any of your offers because obviously you're testing things and that's how you know, like, okay, we've just we just changed the title of this offer and that gave us for X. What are some of the key metrics that you're looking at in order to decide whether or not I should make a change or let this ride on this particular offer?
- 19:362 Yeah. Yeah, definitely. So yeah, we track all our offers, when running paid ads for our clients, we look typically look at three core metrics. We look at the cost per lead, obviously. So the, cost per each individual lead, they click through right CTR. So the percentage of people that actually click on the ad and then the cost per click, and if we see that cost to lead below, say a $20 $20 mark, $15 mark, we know it's performing well.
- 20:082 If it's cost per ladies say above 30, $40, we know that the offer is it's just not not resonating with with the local market.
- 20:171 Yeah. And here's the thing to for everyone listening and Michael, I know you know this the cost per lead really depends on that particular business. Like if you have a gym that charges $79 a month and you have a 10% churn, well, that means your lifetime value is probably going to be like $800 versus if you have, like, you know, $400 a month membership average and you have a 3% churn, meaning you're only losing 3% of your members every month, you have like an 8 to $12,000 lifetime value.
- 20:481 So $800 versus 8000. I would be willing to pay significantly more money to get a customer that's going to pay the $8,000 versus one that's only going to pay me 800. So it's important to know, like what is our lifetime value? And then also what is our cost to acquire a customer. Because your goal is to constantly reduce that cost, to acquire a customer and raise that lifetime value.
- 21:111 We actually for anybody watching, listening wants a free training on its you understand it. You can do the math behind it. If you go to loud groomer.com/ltv-cac again that's LTV CAC. Since for lifetime value and customer acquisition cost you can get the free training. It breaks down the math. It's super simple. Like if you're ten years old, you've done basic math.
- 21:341 You can do this math. You just got to know what to do. So. So Michael, I get it. I've been in your shoes before. Some people are getting a $40 cost per lead, like do this is great. And then other people are like kind of mathematic needs to be $50 or less. That's a big, big, important piece a lot of people miss.
- 21:491 What do you typically see is like a, a general cost per lead. And I know it depends. I just I'm literally arguing against my own point. But what do you see right now in the fitness space is a typical cost per lead.
- 22:052 So it really again it depends on the type of lead as well. So and the quality of the lead. So you can have a free offer and free office work back in the day in the wild wild West. And you'd get a lot of cheap leads. But is the quality of the leads any good. So you can do a free offer and you can get $5 leads.
- 22:232 Fantastic. But are those consumers coming through? Are they genuinely interested in the product or do they just simply want something for nothing? So we don't necessarily recommend running Free Office. Well, with a with a good, strong offer, what we'd like to see is cost per leads anywhere in the vicinity between $15 to $20. On a it's sort of every day of the week type of thing.
- 22:482 They can go a lot higher than that. We sometimes see cost per leads go up to $30, even $40. However, the client's happy because the quality of the lead is is great. We're getting we're getting really good conversions, meaning that we're getting the right type of buyer coming in the right type of consumer coming in. That really resonates with their with their product or service.
- 23:092 And so there's not necessarily a right cost per lead, but from a market perspective, on average, anywhere between 15 and $20 is is a solid, price point.
- 23:211 Love it. Love it. Okay. So when we're making adjustments in the optimization process, you know, certain things that you could definitely do as the ad agency, there's certain things that the customer could possibly do. What are some things that we go, hey, let's tweak this or let's tweak that. And these are the things I'd like it if we start with the most important stuff, like the stuff that typically has a greatest impact.
- 23:441 If we change that, what are the changes that you would make?
- 23:492 Yeah. Good. Good question. So first of all, it's so important to have an open mind, a growth mindset around testing different offers and and being open to variations, to seeing what works best for you and your brand and your, your clientele. You what we see and what I believe in. First of all, we obviously getting that offer right is the most important piece, followed by you're copying creatives and things like that.
- 24:162 With the offer, again at a high, a high value high perceived offer is directly correlated to the cost per lead. So a good offer will generally bring the lead costs down. So what are some of the things that we can do to optimize and test. We can test different timeframes. So we can test short term offers versus long term offers.
- 24:382 Right. Seven days versus 20 days. We can test price based offers and we can test Non-price based offers is a really good one. So a lot of we get you know, we work with a lot of clients and they tend to say, look, we want to do a seven days for for $45 okay. Fantastic. Try that. However, they be open minded and test that offer against a recommended offer, such as a seven day beginner's experience, for example, without necessarily advertising the price, you can still sell it.
- 25:112 Sell that introductory offer for $45. But you don't need to necessarily lead with the price because people buy based on the emotion. Not necessarily will definitely not not necessarily on logic. And so we want to make that emotional connection with our ideal ideal clientele. So again testing non price with price free not three different types of benefits within that offer.
- 25:372 So whether you offer a let's say you're a boxing studio beginners boxing or it could be strength in boxing inside the offers a different nines with the offer. And then once you had that offer. Right. So let's say you land on a 28 day beginners boxing program that's working really well. What we can do is we can gift wrap that differently, from month to month, to ensure that it doesn't fatigue in the local marketplace.
- 26:022 Because if the, if you consumers see that offer, every single wait time, time again, it just won't resonate with them. So adding that seasonality could be a winter. A winter boxing challenge, for example, could still be 28 days. You still selling that initial offer for $149, be it just gift wrapping it differently to to make it exciting and enticing.
- 26:251 Yeah, it's funny, the we actually talked about this the other day with a couple, we have our power calls that we do it louder. And, it was about getting in the conversation. It's already in their head. So when when it's Christmas time, you're already seeing Christmas. You're thinking about Christmas, you're thinking about the sales that are coming up.
- 26:411 You think about the things that you have to buy. You think about all the food that you're going to eat. And so when you see Christmas come up on your feed, you're tied to it, and therefore you're more likely to read the ad than if it was just a seven day free trial that we'd say in August. Same thing goes Valentine's Day, right?
- 26:571 If it's Valentine's Day, is coming up, you see that Valentine's Day thing? You're more likely to stick to it and read it than you are. If it was just a seven day pass, it's evergreen, so I definitely agree with that, which is great. You guys do it. Okay, so creating a great offer and understanding what a great offer.
- 27:161 Very, very important. If you're want to get good at marketing, this is a very important piece. You have two ways you can go. You can either get really, really good at this, which I don't see any value being taken away from you getting really, really good at it and doing it. Or you can partner up with somebody to bring them on your team to be really good at it for you.
- 27:321 That's, you know Michael here and his. But you saw partner Benji these guys over at Super Fit Grove got it dialed in. If you want to learn more about how to work with them, you can go to, super fit grow.io. That's super, super fit, grow io. And these guys will take great care of you. I sent over, I don't know, 100 so clients to them, and these guys are rocking it.
- 27:541 They're killer. And if you guys want to learn how to do it yourself, which, you know, I don't suggest unless you're bored or just really, really into marketing. We can just go to our macom forward slash great offers and you'll be able to watch it happen and be able to be a fly on the wall as I break it down.
- 28:121 So, Michael, thanks so much for coming on and talking offers with me now.
- 28:162 Thanks for having me. Really appreciate it.
- 28:181 I love it, I can't wait to have you again. We're going to have you on more episodes because I'm learning a lot from you as well. So thank you guys so much for tuning in, for listening and watching, and we will see you next time.