Latest / Under The Pallet Wrap / Episode 26 - Packaging Is Boring... Until You See What It Costs You (with Fred Lill)
Transcript
- Keith: Welcome to Under the Pallet Wrap, episode 26 which signifies six months, Dan I can't believe it. Quick high five, virtual high five. Dan Culverhouse: Gone in a flash. Keith: Today we have a very special guest to mark the occasion. Fred Lill. I've known him for many, many years. He's here to tell us that packaging is not boring, basically. It's not an after thought Fred, quick intro. Fred Lill: the whole boring bollocks packaging sector is something that we're keen to basically defy, you know, here at Lil Packaging because actually, ultimately it pays to be a packaging geek. You know, I still swear that the biggest probably story we tell, you know, we are the biggest cost saving implement implementation ever by Amazon Europe. You know, sneaking every package or as many packages as possible through that Royal Mail large letter was a dream in two thousand. So it really does pay to be a packaging geek, you know, we don't take ourselves too seriously and yeah. Our big thing actually is if in our lifetimes we can just you know, propel this journey to eradicating single use plastics from e commerce, then we'll sit on a park bench with a packet of chips as eighty year olds and think, actually we've done pretty damn well. So that's the way we judge our mission really. But no thanks for the intro guys. Dan Culverhouse: Like the sound of that. Keith: It's safe to say you live and breathe packaging Fred. mean as long as I've known you I feel your passion coming through. Fred Lill: Well, I I think in honesty, man, it it it kinda grew up over the kitchen table, My mum and dad, I'm not a founder, I'm not a entrepreneur, I don't consider myself to be my my mum and dad were brave enough to start a printing company that we were previously known as mainline flat packs. and, you know, when they retired in the mid two thousands, my brother and I thought pfft right, there's no specialist player of e commerce packaging That that's gotta be a pretty good place to go. And instead of making, photo enlargement wallets, Kodak was a big contract for us in my dad's time. thought actually e commerce has got to be a pretty good place to be, and sometimes in life you just get lucky, and I swear that's what it was. It was, you know, right time, right place, inventing, you know, these, the little envelope, to get the most through you know, your royal mail large letter size post through here and you know the kind of the rest is history. Keith: I've always pictured you as a bit of an inventor. So what were you like at school? Were you into science? Fred Lill: So so in in reality, right? I mean I I love that because technically I am an inventor, you know, I've got three patents to my name, which, you know, on the intellectual pro intellectual property office IPO classes you as an inventor. But in reality, I kind of think there's a bit in any of us of just enjoying a bit of Blue Peter here's what I made earlier. You know, maybe it's you know but a lot of boredom as a kind of child of pair of scissors. a sheet of cardboard. all of my fancy dress costumes at school and my brother growing up was my dad basically saying, I'll tell you what, boy, why don't you go as a jack of hearts? I can get a sheet of cardboard from work. We'll attach it to your front attachment to your back like an apron. And there you can go to school as a jack of hearts. And it was stuff like that. So, yeah, fun times even just making like a box fort in your lounge with some leftover boxes. that's all it is. I wouldn't say that, you need a degree or anything to be creative. you just gotta have a bit of homage. Dan Culverhouse: And is that how you see yourself that way? Has it always been who you've been? like this creative, you know, just, you know, because I guess, so if you took over from your parents in the business, I mean, was that like when you were 18 or 20 or, you know, did you do anything before? Fred Lill: So give it all away now. So I'm forty five. I effectively started Dan Culverhouse: Just to keep them. Fred Lill: working you know, outwork, it was called back then, born nineteen eighty. In about nineteen ninety, my dad would be like, we're doing a job for British Airways at the moment, lads, ticket wallets where it needs stuffing with flyers inside. there's a hundred thousand of them to do. If I bring them home, do you wanna earn a couple of extra quid you know, fulfilling them. what he didn't tell me it was like it was fifty P a thousand. And my my dad's best ever intro when I first got into sales, at age twenty two, he said to my customer I just went, he said, I'll tell you what's great about having family working for you. They're really cheap. it's a lot of fun actually working in packaging. And in in reality, you know, a lot of my friends still say, God, you've been saying literally since being ten year old, God, that's boring bollocks. that's been my phrase, school, work or whatever. And there's all s everyone's got something in their job that is boring bollocks, whether it's opening the post or or whatever. But I think creation of you know packaging that can mean, you know, you get a box of matchmakers for the first time ever through, you know, a large letter size guide like that plot, and instead of posting it for six quid. Keith: it's just why I'm thrilled. Fred Lill: You post it for one pound four. Keith: It's why I'm thrilled with packaging. It's why I'm so... I'm a geek too. I mean interestingly my dad was a builder and I was too clumsy. I really ended up being a builder but in another industry so you know. But... The connections is what's always got me between when building something you have to do things in order and you have to consider the whole picture and that's what I love about packaging. It's part of the picture. It's not just a pretty box. The fact that you're thinking about failed deliveries through the letterbox. Not everyone's thinking that way for some reason. It's almost too simple. Fred Lill: I think the best story of that I still think the founder of Bloom and Wild, right, and that's a guy that hasn't particularly thought about what he wants to do in business. I think he's had background in love film or something like that. that has gone, okay, what's a product type that I can squeeze through the letterbox that nobody'd done before? And you know, home delivery flowers was always through high street florists. big bouquets where you get, a rose that's already this fat, no way on earth is it gonna fit through that slot when it's a rosebud or other flower. he thought, actually, if people just allow these flowers to develop from being a small bud, they're patient for it to develop, you know, forty eight hours at home. We can get them through that slot, you know, before it fully buds. So lo and behold, you know, postal flowers through the letterbox that yeah arguably you know like I guess posting green bananas they eventually ripen and what a game changing business. Dan Culverhouse: do you find that, you you meet people and you tell them, yeah, I'm in packaging, you get the rolling of the eyes and people suddenly start to think, I need a drink at the bar. And what's your one-liner Fred Lill: She is you. Dan Culverhouse: to bring them round? when people, Fred Lill: A a taste. Dan Culverhouse: think it's boring bollocks, what do you say to them? Fred Lill: actually there's probably two you know, put it into two components. Firstly, if it's like a social environment, and then if it's like the elevator pitch with the client. going into something like that, I'm gonna end up being seated next to the tax man and the parking inspector or something like that. Dan Culverhouse: The auditor. Fred Lill: Yeah, ultimately, I'm boxman, I'm the packaging guy, sorry that you're sat next to me. but genuinely, it's the easiest way to make a point of difference, being in a very boring industry, then standing out and being someone a little bit different. I'm sorry you're sat next to a boxman, but actually We invented the packaging that the largest internet retailer uses day to day now. You probably have ordered from them. And it just starts a a topic of conversation because, you know, making Dan Culverhouse: That begins the intrigue. Fred Lill: I mean when you're making a million units a day, the chances are everyone has touched one of your inventions. And that's a lovely feeling. yeah, elevator Dan Culverhouse: That is cr- Fred Lill: pitch is slightly different. ours is, we're the inventor of packaging for the world's largest internet retailer, make a million units a day, and actually we're going to be the world's first net zero packaging manufacturer, roughly by the year 2037, 2038 That's generally it. but it is quite a cool thing to be able to say with the biggest cost saving ever implemented by that client. Because if you think about right, this is year two thousand six, right? And I'd encourage all your, anyone listening to this podcast, just try and remember how many DVDs, CDs were being sold back then. And DVD box sets, whether you wanted the Indiana Jones trilogy or Lost Season 8 or Star Wars trilogy box set. You know, it's a thick DVD with like three little DVD discs in there in a triple case. And it was as fat as this. they all measured between eighteen and twenty three millimeters. all these massive internet retailers that are, shipping hundreds of millions of D V D box sets per year, suddenly faced by Royal Mail, instead of posting by weight, you know, saying, if it doesn't fit through the slot, I'm really sorry, you don't get parceled tariffs anymore. You're gonna have to pay like three quid fifty. it's two pound fifty at the time. inside one of these, mentioned a little envelope, to go through that large letter slot like so was just you know magic. so if you imagine every single order immediately slash two pounds postage off every single CP button. Dan Culverhouse: And the number of first time deliveries, right? mean, you know, amount of times that you had to go and collect stuff because they weren't in when they came, you know what I mean? It is game changing. So tell us a bit, a little bit about how did you end up creating this for the world's biggest, you know, well, the world's biggest retailer Fred Lill: So so Dan Culverhouse: now, Fred Lill: we were at the time and we'd grown quite steadily. my brother and I joined the business in 1999 so we already had seven years under our belt. and we were really had rapidly grown in the cobweb envelope sector. So with my dad's first major client being Kodak, also came with like Kodak enlargement envelopes, like a postal envelope. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, Fred Lill: and then like carrier envelopes, City Link, don't think they exist anymore. TNT, DHL, all these carrier companies. and basically trying to think, okay, we surely can make an equivalent of like a bubble mailer from you know cardboards as a sustainable option. and we had been trying to develop that for probably a year prior to the Royal Mail in August 2006 saying, All right, here you go, have this large letter Pricing in proportion. And that's when I say we got lucky. it took about four months, and this is at least fifty percent of each working day, four months to find a telephone number for Amazon. They work so hard. They have a s a team of people who deliberately make sure their communication numbers are, erased from internet knowledge. And I found it, found the number on Bedfordshire County Council planning application portal for a bike shed to be erected at their main fulfillment centre in Ridgemont, near Milton Keynes. And and you have that moment in your career or your life, it can even be as a personal thing, where you try and call a call a girl or or or call someone up. And I called, I thought, I'll try that number. And immediately my god, I'm through to the right person. okay, we're Europe's largest cardboard envelope manufacturer. We've just come up with this invention that guarantees you to get every single D V D box set through the new Royal Mail large tariff, which I imagine is costing you two pound fifty to post at the moment and we can pretty much safely get everything posted for 54p Well. Very good. You should meet this person in Luxembourg next week. And the rest is history. It was yeah, just Dan Culverhouse: Wow. Fred Lill: that was probably as long as the phone call was. Twenty five seconds. Dan Culverhouse: Incredible Fred Lill: and Keith: Wow, your heart must have been, you must have been elated. Fred Lill: well actually at that point I was just bricking it. Dan Culverhouse: I think you're so right. Keith: you Fred Lill: but yeah I so I had this I was twenty it's 2006 twenty-five at the time, booked a flight to Luxembourg. And yeah, driving through the tiny little city of Luxembourg, which is like Almost like a a medieval r town right at its core. Very strange. And that was the Amazon head office. And yeah, we had this amazing meeting, and they were yep, we'll trial a thousand units. I was thinking, Mm, that's you know, a couple of boxes worth now like no, we mean pallets when we mean units. And I got back into the car and the first thing that played on the radio on this hind I guess was status quo Keith: Living in a box. Fred Lill: Rocking all over the world. That was the moment. But Dan Culverhouse: memorable moments. Fred Lill: yeah, and I think that's the best way to look at your career. Try and think, okay, building this collection of memories that at some point, you know, on a park bench with a bag of chips, you know, remembering it all. So that's up there. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, but talk about, how easy it would have been to given up looking for that number and that never happening. it's about sliding doors. Fred Lill: I think that about that a lot, Keith: You believed in this idea? Fred Lill: Dan. That's a really good point. I I 'cause I think tenacity is probably the one of the biggest underrated things. And to this day I don't know why I gave up actually, I'll tell you probably what it is. I about six months prior, I was talking to my best pal, he's like said the time we were twenty five. He said, are you ever dealt with Amazon? I went, They're just like bits and bobs, aren't they? I don't really read books. They do they do books? He went, mate, they do everything. And Dan Culverhouse: Ha ha ha! Fred Lill: I was like, I'd probably best try them then. 'Cause my mate shamed me. I've not ordered online from Amazon and you know, at that point in two thousand and five. I was probably a late Dan Culverhouse: Thank Fred Lill: adopter. But anyway, it's funny, being shamed sometimes is the best motivator, if you know what I mean? Dan Culverhouse: Yes, it is. And that solution, Fred, is there anything real IP in that or is it simply a cardboard envelope or is it something from development? Fred Lill: yeah, I'll let the cat out of the bag here. So actually that was one thing. I had a patent pending on this and Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Fred Lill: Ama Amazon made it very clear with me in Luxembourg, said for the minimization of risk, Amazon has globally a policy of having multiple source, at least two suppliers capable of doing any one product. So we'll make this very clear for you, Fred. Either you continue with your patent application and you know, good luck with that. And you will never have any supply with Amazon for this product ever. Or you retreat from your patent application and you enjoy comfortable supply with Amazon for a very long period of time. So I chose the latter. and Dan Culverhouse: Good choice. Fred Lill: sliding doors moment, it could have been very different. And you know, you like to think you made the right decisions in life. Keith: It could have Fred Lill: I think actually the best decision was back then in 2002 my brother and I said, Actually nobody's yet dedicated to e commerce, let's try that. that's probably what led to it, but Keith: Which would have been unpopular at the time because when I joined my journey in EComm no one believed in it. And Fred Lill: Mm. Keith: look how that became... I mean that's crazy now when you think about this. No one believed in it. Fred Lill: Yeah, nobody wanted to invest in it, Keith. in e commerce in 2002 to 2005 everyone's e-commerce packaging suite was, we sell the odd hat online. Let's use the hat box. we use this tie envelope to put ties in. Do you remember? I think I had this conversation with you, Keith. Like, people were just using whatever box was already being used in the company. Dan Culverhouse: you were thinking in those days that is this really going to take off? Are people really going to put their credit card details on the Internet? You know, surely it's never going to take off. I was working for Tesco. Yeah. Keith: credit card. I didn't even own one. I didn't even have one. I didn't have a phone. But Fred, we met in the luxury world when I was at Net-A-Porter And I was going to ask you a question. I think we're like-minded in this respect. Waste drives you. So despite it being the perception of, look at how wonderful this is. This is exactly what the customers want. I think I was often driven by this feeling like it's only because they don't know what they don't know. That if they were to get a delivery first time, if they were to get cheaper shipping, they wouldn't be so in love with this with this luxury packaging. Fred Lill: I completely agree. I think there's just some things that make you shudder to the core and waste is mine just like yours, Keith. In the same as I mean, my wife when she sees me with blue and green shudders to the core. She says, my god, your fashion sense is dreadful But yeah, I I think for me I mean, still the sight of a bubble mailer When bubble mailer manufacturers go, they can be recycled if the consumer pulls the plastic lining out of the white paper Keith: No one does that. Fred Lill: on the inside, you're like, Man, nobody does that. Nobody's ever done that. Dan Culverhouse: for the... Keith: Take the thinking away. Yeah, make it second nature, Yeah. Fred Lill: I mean, you know, apparently all sandwich cartons that you get at supermarkets, that triangle pack is now also capable. But again, when have you ever bloody seen somebody take that plastic lining out of a c Dan Culverhouse: Pull the plastic button out the middle. Fred Lill: I I think a lot of founders have no idea the penalties that logistics companies charge when you don't comply with that maximum parcel restriction. DPD FedEx, thousand millimeters or centimeters, a hundred centimeters by seven hundred by six hundred high, if you're a millimeter over that, fifteen quid fine. Fifteen Per package. so if you've got a good rate of, maybe three or four quid per parcel, that's pretty elite. But to then pay a penalty of fifteen it's absurd. Keith: You came to I say we go back to the challenges when you've walked into. certain businesses. What tends to be the blocker when you're trying to explain the benefits? Fred Lill: actually that that's how we've always done it. Two thousand and two to two thousand five was a lot more actually emerging gun ho mavericks that were willing to take a punt and just try different things. Maybe they got investment for the first time from CEO or senior management. But now it is no the boxes have always been that size. All right. But does anyone of us in the no in this room here, there's twelve of us, have any understanding of why? And it's just always a tumbleweed moment. Right, well then that needs to be challenged. I I would say that's probably the number one inefficiency in any retailer. Someone in that room not knowing why the box sizes are that size. You know, I mean if you think that Amazon have a total of seventeen different packaging lines to do everything. Seventeen. I I mean, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, that's pretty remarkable. Keith: No more. Fred Lill: you know, then If there's a retailer out there, struggling along with forty two different box sizes, then they need a review. most most businesses, particularly in a market specific market, beauty or fashion, should be able to rationalise that to less than six. Ideally three or four. So yeah, and that begin bins economies of scale. If you can try and rationalise forty different lines onto three or four, Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, Fred, have a question for you. And in the room here, I'm probably the Luddite when it comes to packaging compared to you two. But when I look at that, packaging that's behind you right now in your wonderful backdrop, the one thing that's always kind of intrigued me is why companies want to write their name like Ted Baker or &S on the outside of the box. Doesn't that just say to somebody in the supply chain, this is something you might want to put in under your coat? Fred Lill: Right? If you want to try a new brand, what's your first touching point? Dan Culverhouse: when it's delivered to you, yeah, it's the box. Fred Lill: This this is your first touching point. Right. You experience the website, that's fair enough. You have a good experience. right, ten percent offer, that's nice, I've got that. referral from friend, lovely. okay. Five clicks to check out, great. Then you play the waiting game, you know, twenty four hours, whatever for delivery. But this is the first touching point. A and genuinely I I could put you on like a you know, whatever it is, Some sort of clever emotional spectrometer or whatever it is that said, All right, let me try and measure your excitement when you receive a brown box with a label on it and then something that actually has an icon you would think is iconic, let's say the swoosh, Nike, whatever. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah. Fred Lill: that is symbolic to what you remember ordering 24 hours ago, it is so very different. And it's That that captures the excitement, the loyalty, the emotional engagement with the brand. And then I I personally think the best with this outer brand experience is this. Because somebody in logistics doesn't know what that diamond is. Keith: Yes, that's good. Yeah. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, Fred Lill: But actually a client of that brand very much knows the diamond. Dan Culverhouse: And maybe that is it because it's always, and I'm happy to say that, I'm that logistics guy who would not know what that was, you know, not particularly brand driven person. But, you know, that's that's not why we're here today. And for me, I've always thought that wouldn't it be great. if you don't have on the outside, when you open it and there is on the inside of the box, then you get that hit then. But then you don't have the risk and security issue of someone saying, Ted Baker or Ooh, whoever that brand was. Keith: You have to weigh it up don't you? You have to weigh it up. I was going to say your very second touch point is if you Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I don't know. I it's just... I always come to the pragmatic, practical thing. Keith: open it and everything's broken. Who cares what it looks like on the outside? But I do buy into what Fred says because when I joined a particular company and I was inspired to go in the very next day and change the packaging because I placed the stuff... order in my early days. I got home there was this ugly grey plastic bag on the doorstep and then had to use a knife to open it and inside was another cardboard box. I went straight into work next day and said we're doing something about this. We're gonna change this. so many things I factored in. Unboxing was one of them because it's a big thing at the time wasn't it? On Instagram especially. People would film themselves opening the box. The product inside. Yeah. And Dan Culverhouse: Blows my mind, but yes they do, Keith: no one's filming themselves. know, if no one's filming themselves opening your product. They don't like the packaging. mean, it's like Fred says, it's a touch. But if the packaging Dan Culverhouse: I buy it. Keith: is infuriating you, that does actually tar your opinion in my view. And you don't need to go all out with colours. That's the you know. Again, bigger picture thing isn't it? Why up the actual theft versus the perception of... Fred Lill: See, I challenge that, Keith. Keith: Challenge what? Fred Lill: Ink ink is the cheapest asset any box producer has to give away. It's also the biggest myth and the biggest con that most packaging manufacturers take advantage of. So, you know, if somebody wants to place an inquiry for boxes, normally a box manufacturer like myself says, how much ink coverage are you planning on doing? Are you planning on you know printing it all over like this, or is it just gonna be a swoosh? a swoosh. yeah, that's three percent ink coverage. this one, hundred percent ink coverage. I'm afraid your price is gonna go up thirty percent. It's absolute rubbish. Ink cost me about a pound a kilo and I can print about six thousand boxes with a kilo, I think. the other thing you'll love, Dan, why in e commerce packaging does you know logistics director or operator director say, yeah, slap the label on the top, right? If you are having a Tiffany, you know, lovely little turquoise jewelry box that's got the ribbon on top, where do you want a bloody label? Just slapped on the top, no you bloody wouldn't. this Keith: They're thinking of warehouse efficiency. Yeah, it's not joined up. It's not joined up. Yeah. Fred Lill: No keep, right? It's there. Right? Nobody needs to see the label apart from the bloody person in logistics. Put it underneath. Keith: I guess but this is where that bigger Dan Culverhouse: That's very good. Keith: picture that that care and attention needs to be taken into account. Packaging covers so many things and you know I've even worked out before the cost of tape the cost of tape in a warehouse. Dan you must have seen it before the use of stickers. we're put a sticker on this book saying valuable or fragile. Why? Who agreed to do that? I don't know. But if you work out it costs thousands a year to do. You have to challenge your perceptions. Fred Lill: I I think probably ninety five percent of founders have lost the disconnect of what the three PL or the logistics their own warehouses costing them, then it's twenty five P per minute cost to business of labour. Right? Fifteen quid an hour divided by sixty minutes in every hour, simple math, fifteen divided by sixty, is twenty five P per minute. So what you just said, Keith, I'll go have a fanny around putting a label on the inside and put some tape on the outside and you waste a minute. That's 25p Doesn't matter that a label Keith: That's a trade-off. Fred Lill: only costs you a penny, that's 25p. Keith: It's a trade-off. The smallest things. Fred Lill: Time. Keith: So it has to be a project that involves everybody. Packaging. often do you find that it doesn't? When you go to a business, do you ever see that a Fred Lill: I I I th yes. Keith: successful packaging project involves the right stakeholders? Do you ever find that that's not the case? Fred Lill: Yeah, 'cause actually the it's because of the stereotype. do you wanna see if your founder wants to come along? I asked him and said you the packaging company wants to invite you to the meeting and he said no. Keith: Yeah, but there are ones who probably saying, Fred Lill: That's why there's this stereotype. Keith: I don't like the design. I want it to have gold stitching. Fred Lill: Yeah, honestly, it is that that stereotype slams involvement often of a lot of senior manager being involved with a big decision like this. Because actually give credit where it's due to Net-A-Porter and Mr. Porter they they knew that that experience, that complete I mean I still think the Mr Porter unboxing experience was second to none. That for me was just literally poetry and motion or from an e commerce packaging experience. I didn't make it, I'll confess, but it was bloody beautiful. Keith: That's probably why there was a bit of opposition as well to streamline it. I mean I would push back and say I don't want the box every time. A lot of people did who worked there. don't want, do the customers want the signature box every time? Some do, so you gave them a choice. That's how we got round up on, we gave them a choice. Fred Lill: That was a clever that that that was a clever strategy from Net-A-Porter of extra profitability. here's the experience where you get a lovely experience inside of a rigid box and tissue paper, whatever that. and this is, your your item that you can buy for £120. but if you don't want that in internal packaging, you can opt out and you still just have your order. Well, it's still Keith: Get the car up up up. Fred Lill: £120 quid. They're just taking out two quids Dan Culverhouse: But you didn't get a disco. Fred Lill: worth of internal packaging cost. it's actually quite clever additional profitability. Keith: Yeah I'm not really sure what the split was anymore, I can't remember but a lot still opted for the signature packaging. More than I expected just because I would Dan Culverhouse: bit. Keith: have liked the experience once but not maybe again and again but that's me. Fred Lill: If you if you if you could buy a car if you could buy a car without wheels for the same price, you wouldn't you know Dan Culverhouse: Not sure that's the best analogy ever. Because I think it still works. Fred Lill: th they managed to Keith: We have to think of another one before the end. Dan Culverhouse: No. Keith: But yeah, choice is a good lever, isn't it? Fred Lill: yeah. Keith: This is the impact of the purchase. I think most people are aligned. Fred Lill: Yeah. Yeah, I actually I I think you know trying to score high on all fronts you know in e commerce packaging i is what we try and hit every time for a retailer. So we have like I call it the surf philosophy, S U R F. You know, and it's advice to any retailer if you try and outperform your competition, their standard of packaging With improved sustainability, improved unboxing experience, reduced returns and faster fulfillment, you will fly, Dan Culverhouse: much. Fred Lill: in terms of outgrowing your competitors. And and that's so true. Keith: Yeah. And you might, yeah, you might break even on one or two areas, but if overall you've made a real big impact, that's a good case for me. I think some people are just a bit blinkered that it's all about marketing or it's all about efficiency or it's all about shipping. there's at least seven elements that you should take into account when making that choice. But what about upcoming developments such as PPWR and EPR? Are people aware? Are people paying attention? It is boring. So how do you get people on board with the uplift? You've got such an opportunity. Fred Lill: That's boring bul that's boring bollocks. what who calls a PP Right I mean, firstly, I say, alright, nobody remembers PPWR. That isn't, you know, an extreme packaging Keith: in it. Fred Lill: geek like me. Apart from who would call a regulation packaging and packaging, waste regulation. It's like packaging Dan Culverhouse: Thank Fred Lill: and packaging. What the bloody is I remembered Keith: A beautiful cat. Fred Lill: this right? So yeah, PPWR packaging and packaging waste regulations. I mean, Dan Culverhouse: Off the turn, isn't it? Fred Lill: dear, an EPR extended producer responsibility responsibility. What a lot of brands don't know is actually that bill only applies to you to pay for basically the recycling of the waste that goes to consumers if it's got your branding on it. you know that actually if it's an unprinted box, old muggins over here has to pay for that bill. So actually, what I've seen is acceleration of brands debranding. I mean my bill was about sixty grand last year for packaging that didn't say these names on it. So I then become the producer responsible for putting this packaging into consumer waste that household recycling centres like Huntingdonshire District Council, Cambridge County Council has to recycle it into more recycled waste. So that's a scary thing for me that actually brands are sacrificing the unboxing experience and then branding and the emotional connection with the brand to save forty or sixty grand a year on EPR annual bill. But pfft Keith: So how, what's your counter argument though? What do you say to them? When you're trying to reduce the margins, because it costs so much to ship at this moment in time, there's never been more. What's your counter argument to encourage them not to lose the branding as a trade off to that fee? Because it's a lot when someone's asking you to justify all your costs. So what do you do? What's your advice? Fred Lill: Yeah, I I a lot of brands firstly don't realise it only applies if you're more than something like see I even I don't know is something like if you're more than three million revenue. So actually Keith: do you mean the UK? Yeah, obviously in EU it differs but it's some... Fred Lill: Yes. So yeah, I mean generally if you're maybe an under twenty staff operation, you might just skirt Keith: Yeah Fred Lill: underneath that and actually not have to worry about that fine. But yeah, in honesty, Keith, I don't know the answer to that. When o other than saying hey, you remember the reasons of why you wanted to go down the branding route, that was to get the engagement and the first touch points being a brand ex experience and the cost to print was not much because ink is only one pound a kilo. So yeah, it's another bill to face, but you know, some you've just got to pay. because, you know, let's just say a a business doing a million dispatches a year in this kind of stuff is probably gonna face a bill in the region of about fifteen or twenty thousand pounds. that's a Finger anyway. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Fred Lill: So yeah, it's a sizeable bill, but actually one at which I hope isn't enough that these companies doing a million dispatches a year should probably you know, be you know, a thirty or fifty million revenue company that hopefully they can find a way of you know, satisfying that cost. Dan Culverhouse: Swallowing it. Keith: Don't you think it's an opportunity perhaps to review the end-to-end supply chain and sort of look at all the different elements that lead to waste? mean for the more patient businesses it's an opportunity to look at everything and understand where that trade-off is rather than just see it as a cost and just immediately say god we're not paying it. Fred Lill: They but they do say the best taxes are the ones that have been well calculated that people can just about afford to absorb. The silent taxes, Keith: Yeah. Fred Lill: are they probably won't, you know, do anything about it, they'll just have to pay it. A and, you know, whether you want to call it stealth tax or whatever, I mean it's don't get me wrong, for the right reasons of funding good recycling because actually the reality is, you know, less than eight percent of any plastics ever produced been recycled. So the whole point of this is to get more investment and more capability that when s when all this stuff is being chopped into a blue recycling bin and goes into your recycling centre, that magnets are pulling the metals away, that the glass is sinking down to be into a different stream, that everything is getting filtered into its right recycling source. Dan Culverhouse: So I was about to ask that question with regardless of what behavior it changes from the retailer or the purchaser of that. Do you actually think that the money that's being raised or do you think it's a good thing to have it in? So you believe that it is going to improve. Fred Lill: So so so here's the real here's the reality of recycling. And I feel for the you know the recycling authorities and the companies that do the recycling for the councils, you know, it's a very, very loud labour manual labour sortation system. Some of these audience might have seen like I think it's Superman II the scene from Superman, where good Superman's fighting bad Superman on a conveyor belt with some sort of rocks going through, right? That's a recycling centre. A load of crap on a conveyor belt that people are picking things of commercial value, right? This this material has one P, so hundredth of a pound, one P is worth of commercial value. That board being repulped into making another one of these worth five or ten P is worth one P's worth of material. A Coke can is worth something like five P, for example. So they're trying to pick out as fast as this things of commercial value, right? A cellophane wrapper, bugger all, let that carry on the covenant. god, a big sheet, a mattress, a piece of film that sealed a mattress when it was bought. Right, let's get that off. That's probably worth about 25p. a magazine that's worth about 12p. That it's picking things of commercial value. On a belt that's going about 80 meters per minute. No, 120. That's jogging speed. So imagine Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah. Fred Lill: Imagine jogging past a long table on a marathon where you've got the drinks available. Lucozade Sports don't don't want to promote that brand over others. but drinks available for them to grab as they're jogging along. That's what recycling centres have to do. And instead of picking their favourite flavour, Ribena or whatever, that they're picking things of commercial value. That's why it needs investment. A lot of people don't realise that is as basic as it is in recycling sorting centres. Keith: It's out of sight out of mind isn't it? So what Dan Culverhouse: For sure. Yeah, yeah. Keith: what do you think people need to understand about packaging this week? Tomorrow? What's the first thing a founder should be thinking? Fred Lill: Hmm. an open question to me, Keith. What should brands and retailers be thinking? Keith: What should be most on their mind when they're considering their packaging? Just sitting there looking at their packaging thinking I don't like it. Fred Lill: Doing what I have never done before that I could be first at. I don't think I've seen a box of matchmakers available online for a couple of quid. But look. I bought these at Pound Land because I couldn't believe they were at Pound Land for a pound. But I could sell that online for two quid. Dan Culverhouse: Not for long. Keith: Is it because most of the average consumers of matchmakers are above the age of using technology? Fred Lill: Steve Jobs with the iPhone, right? Steve Jobs was all about saying, I want to make the unboxing of the iPhone, you know, like theatre. His word, right? And actually if you remember what mobile phones were like with the Nokia thirty two ten, eight ten, all this stuff. It was like a pizza box, litholaminated, you know, sometimes as big as this. clunky thing about this size actually for a mobile phone, you know, and it had all your charging point in there and everything else. Well, actually, no, Keith: I'm starting Fred Lill: Steve Jobs himself put so much effort, it became about the size of the iPhone, right? Dan Culverhouse: Thank you. Fred Lill: And the vacuum, there's a special name for it, and I'm not all that familiar with rigid box making because most of that is done in the Far East now. But it's like that special friction gravity eventually sinks of its own accord. That is precision manufacture. and Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Fred Lill: it's trying to remember, nothing had been done like that at the time. And I swear that's part of what made the iPhone incredible. That iPhone box, there was nothing like it. Right? And and Dan Culverhouse: Thank you. Fred Lill: I see even silence from you now. You agree with me. And Mc McDonald's, right? Dan Culverhouse: I do, Fred Lill: Who who that happy meal box? That happy Keith: I'm a Samsung guy. Fred Lill: meal box. I I'm sad that my lads are now seventeen and sixteen and we don't go and get that anymore. But there's something magical about the Happy Meal box, right? Tiffany Dan Culverhouse: except for what's in it, but yeah. Fred Lill: Tiffany, that blue box with the ribbon on, you know, it's there's certain iconic things that I think even everyone can relate to that you just think, actually, bloody good effort that one. and it's still, you know It brings a lot of smile to my face seeing an iPhone box for that reason, because it's still unique. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I think I think there's a really good message in there that. know when when and I think it's things like, you know, when you've when you made this kind of revelation of the things that you can get through a letterbox, you know, you're a fan. That is not going to be on, you know, that's not going to occur to you. But when someone says to you, you know, I can increase your first time delivery performance by whatever percentage or reduce the cost of your delivery by. simply by doing this. it's like, the reality is, right, that there are many, different things in that packaging journey that are like that. And you just need to get the attention. Keith: It can solve so many obstacles, so many problems, a business. Fred Lill: Well actually if I I I could rattle off so many of these just to do with, clever thinking get through the Royal Mail and large letter size button. QVC. They were the first ever to develop a zippo style jewelry box. Instead of the clamshell opening like that, which is fifty millimeters high, they developed a zippo style one so that was only twenty two millimeters thick and hey presto, you could slide it through here. Graze dot com, first ever snack pack that you could get, on subscription, three ninety nine per you know, day or whatever, of you know, a box of nuts and various different dried snacks. Phenomenal. Dan Culverhouse: I was actually an early adopter of that. Yeah, that's great. Fred Lill: Were you? I love it. vitamins. vitamins had always been cylindrical tub with a a clamshell lid on the top. And these twenty-one millimeter style flat vitamin pots that all became hugely popular posted out from the Channel Islands before the VAT loophole under fifteen pounds de minimis ceased in twenty fifteen, something like that. yeah, so to get things like vitamins and pills straight through that slot also. they have so many clever examples, but trying to adopt it to your specific industry is i is often the really application. So, you Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. Fred Lill: know, funnily enough I was just talking to somebody about a special design of box for a you know a mountain bike and I said why don't you just put a toblerone tube it? If you've always got problems with stability, you know, it's a bike that comes in from the Far East frame and separate wheels. Why don't you just have it in that you know pyramid shape? it won't topple over that way. So it's it's things like that. I mean that's actually the common way that posters are now dispatched in a you know triangular poster Dan Culverhouse: Thank you. Fred Lill: tube. and yeah Dan Culverhouse: . Fred Lill: it's again having the mindset I Either two glasses of wine and a pad of paper health or a couple of bottles of beer, just that peaceful Dan Culverhouse: Thank Fred Lill: mindset in the evening to think, Okay, how can this be done differently? And quite often it's nicking the idea from a different industry. Like the Toblerone box. Everyone knows what that looks like. But for bicycles. so Keith: Well it works if you're comparing what you want to achieve. Who else does it? Who else manages it? Fred you must hate those people who have those old-fashioned tiny little letter-books. Fred Lill: The tiny what sorry? Keith: Those people with the old-fashioned doors with the tiny little letterboxes, they drove me mad as a paperboy. Fred Lill: so Keith, right, this is another story. I well geeked out on that. I spent about two weeks measuring all the letter boxes in the town I previously lived in, and they're all either six inches wide, eight inches wide, ten inches or twelve inches, and they are all one and a half inches high. So one and a half inches, thirty eight millimeters. So generally never make a box more than thirty five millimeters high if you want a chance of it gliding through that letterbox. And if you wanna be sure of getting it in there, try and stick to less than six. And have a guess how wide bloom and wild is. Five and three quarter inches. So that's the sign there. So yeah. Dan Culverhouse: going to say just under six. Is this why you had to move Fred because you went around measuring everybody's letterbox. Fred Lill: yeah. Yeah. You know, people a lot of Keith: Is that, yeah, that's why you moved, Fred Lill: people when they were kids did knock and run. I did measure and run. Dan Culverhouse: Not good measure. Fred Lill: At Keith: That was before the advent of Ring doorbells, I assume. Dan Culverhouse: Yes, yes. Fred Lill: Yeah, yeah, maybe there would be something deemed as prison offense. Keith: I've worked in the Fred Lill: Yeah, Keith: So what inspires you next then Fred? Fred Lill: Volumetric shipments. Most, especially UK brands, are very excited to be doing quite a lot of international export. Anyway, international dispatches are often completely based on volumetric shipping cost. What that means is it's the overall size of parcel done by a multiplication factor of its weight. So volumetric weight. So actually the whole point of the Lil brand, Lil, is that it's snug fit cute packaging. That's it in a nutshell. Mail Happy is the slogan of it because Dan Culverhouse: No install required. Fred Lill: it's eco-friendly and it's easy to pack, all that stuff. But Lil hopefully personified that, so actually trying to make variable height boxes across our range. I mean, that that's probably my actually most exciting invention since the Lil Lil envelope in two thousand six, is what's called Lil Crash Lock now, where all comes with variable height creases, so you can split the the the the corners down to make it to three quarters high, half height or forty percent high if you only want to put in there, you know, a small lip bar. so you're changing the volumetric weight of that box, even though the weight is staying the same, to a third. Right? So instead of that being like a Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, and that's a lot cheaper than, yeah, sorry, I'm say that's a lot cheaper than an automated box cutter that cuts it to size, right? they're very impressive, but they're a big investment, right? Fred Lill: They are so Keith: Simple, Fred Lill: so Keith: simple is often best. Fred Lill: So everyone that's got into automation that's not doing two million parcels per year has always struggled to get a return on investment. Right? In Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, yeah. Fred Lill: reality, that puts only about 40 internet retailers into a possibility of buying automation, right? Two million dispatches Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, for that purpose. Fred Lill: a year is elite, elite, elite. I mean, when you're thinking about buying something Dan Culverhouse: Yeah. From a packaging perspective, yes. Fred Lill: well, no, so the capital outlay generally for automation is about 2.2 million euros. Of 1.8 million quid. What people forget is you generally need about three staff paid on the origin of 60 to 80,000 pounds to maintain and service that machine. And then what people don't realise is the actual cardboard, like the it's called like fanfold cardboard, a bit like you used to put paper into an old-fashioned printer, dot matrix printer, you know, concertina effects, that costs more than normal corrugated. So actually people will go, okay, well, yeah, we only need now a total of twelve staff instead of, eighteen or twenty-two. but we've had to pay two point two million euros. We've now got this team of a quarter million pounds worth of staff to run it. and there are problems with it. And actually, even at peak, it doesn't have enough capacity to do it. So we still have twenty two people at peak. So we we've found that generally speaking, The the companies that have always looked into automation continue to do so, but it isn't a journey that many new brands do. and actually a lot of people are surprised that, you know, the world's largest internet retailer isn't as heavily as automated as you would think. You know, I mean ultimately, you know there's a lot. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, I think when you're talking about packaging lines, I'm with you. are, if you're talking about a logistics center and how they can automate certain picking activities and that, it's a very different discussion. But I do, I will agree with you on automating packing lines. It's a difficult sell because there's a lot of investment, a limited amount. Fred Lill: Yeah, it's it's it's quite well documented. It's quite well documented in twenty twenty six online and in journals. the white company, they've stopped using their automation. that's a credible high volume retailer that that struggled to make return. and and going back to Dan Culverhouse: If they were sold the wrong equipment, I'm not surprised, but if you sold the right equipment, it can definitely deliver. I'm slightly biased maybe because I've made a career out of automated solutions, not in packaging at all, but in operations. And I have seen many deliver incredible results, but you got to get it right. Fred Lill: Th the re yeah, I now now the reason why I think it'll always struggle in e-commerce automation, the moment you buy it, you're constraining your capability. And that's the opposite of selling it online. Right? Selling online should be a right, I can sell infinite number of products here. Yeah, I might have a certain amount of warehouse space that I need to say constrained to because space costs money. But actually that I can sell an infinite amount of different possibilities. Now in reality, the purpose of a machine is it's built to a specification to be able to do a certain job. So actually, you know, Play dot com, I believe that one of the reasons Play dot com in Jersey struggled, it used to be a customer of ours, was because they heavily invested in automation and then they could only do C D, right? Dan Culverhouse: And I would say to you, I agree, but robotics has changed that quite a lot because robotics is very much more flexible and can be manipulated and changed. And it's very modular. And you know, don't have to spend millions. You can do it modulant. You can lease it. You can put it in. You can take it out. It's much more flexible than it used to be. But you know what you're saying is not incorrect. know, people are infinitely more flexible than a machine, but the machineries now are pretty different. You're not talking about bolting down big pieces of equipment. You're talking about mobile robotics, which actually is pretty adaptive now. But you know, Fred Lill: Yeah, but but Keith: I think that. Dan Culverhouse: this is a whole other podcast. Keith: The bigger picture is what drives it all, isn't it? Don't rush into anything because it touches on so many things. But I think it's a good time, Dan Culverhouse: Absolutely. Fred Lill: Yeah. Keith: it's a good opportunity to try. I think we talked about packaging being boring, yet we could have spoken and probably will speak again about packaging for two hours because it's far from boring. It has so many benefits to the business. It intrigues me, it intrigues all of us. So thanks Fred, it's been amazing to chat about your passion and your achievement. Dan Culverhouse: It's interesting, know, this really reminds me, did a couple of weeks ago, we did an episode around customs and cross border trading. Again, another thing you consider a pretty dry topic, right? But actually it's fascinating of the opportunity that's there that people just don't see. And if you're willing to step into it and do a little bit investigation or adopt the right level of support, the amount of margin improvement you can drive through that. is incredible and I think this sits in exactly the same space. You could just see a box or you can see a real business opportunity for marketing, for cost saving, Keith: You can look at what it represents. Yeah, beginning to end. Dan Culverhouse: for speed, for productivity. It's all there, It's sustainability. Fred Lill: Expensive expensive headaches are always the bit that you can gain the most gain from if you put in the effort. Completely agree. Dan Culverhouse: 100 % 100 % agree. And yeah, and this has just been another great example of when you start to dig below the surface and you see that there's a goldmine of opportunity in this. And Fred, thanks for bringing it to our attention. It's been a really, really enjoyable conversation. And to understand a little bit about little Packaging's journey has been fascinating. And some of the things that you've introduced are, yeah, brilliant game changing stuff. Fred Lill: Man, You know I I always love talking to you guys. I think the the energy, is always fun. It reminds me of being at school again. It's just a lot of fun and it's how life should be really, treating your own work like a hobby and just you know, not taking life too seriously, definitely. Keith: Yeah, just being passionate about what you do. It's a gift. Dan Culverhouse: Yeah, absolutely. OK, well, that'll do for this week. Thanks, Fred. And thanks, everyone, for listening. And we can't wait to hear what you've got to say about this one. But please like, share and subscribe, as we always ask. And we'll see you again next week.