Latest / Comeback Project: Resilience, recovery & starting over / The Brave, Messy Art of Being a Beginner Again | Comeback Project
Transcript
- There is a specific kind of terror that lives in the space between your old competence and your new clumsiness. It’s the feeling of holding a paintbrush for the first time in twenty years and realizing your hand doesn’t remember what your heart still wants to create. Let’s breathe through this for a second. We spend so much of our adult lives curating a version of ourselves that looks solid. You know the one. The professional who never makes typos. The friend who always has the right advice. The partner who remembers every anniversary without checking their phone. We build these identities like fortresses, brick by careful brick, because being good at something feels safe. It feels like proof that we are worthy, that we are capable, that we are not falling apart. And I get it. I really do. When I was working as an investigative journalist, my identity was entirely wrapped up in being sharp. In being the person who found the truth when everyone else was looking away. That skill protected me. It gave me purpose. But it also meant that when I burned out, when the world got too loud and my nervous system finally pulled the plug, I didn’t just lose my job. I lost my sense of self. I became a stranger to myself. And that is why returning to being a beginner can feel less like play and more like a threat. Because if you are bad at something, if you are clumsy and slow and wrong, then who are you? Are you still the strong one? Are you still the reliable one? Or are you just… failing? We have to talk about the ego, because it will try to stop you from trying anything new. It’s a loud, protective voice that says, 'Why bother? You’re not going to be good at this. Why waste your time?' It sounds logical, doesn’t it? Efficient. Adult. But it’s actually fear wearing a suit. It’s fear dressed up as pragmatism. I see this all the time in the stories women share with me. They want to pick up pottery, or learn Spanish, or start running, but they freeze. Not because they don’t have the time, but because they don’t have the permission to be bad at it. They think that if they’re going to do something, it has to be done well. Or they shouldn’t do it at all. This perfectionism is a trap. It keeps us stuck in the roles we’ve played for decades, even if those roles are exhausting us. It keeps us from discovering who we are beneath the resume, beneath the titles, beneath the expectations of other people. Let’s be clear: being a beginner is not a failure. It is a privilege. It means you are expanding. It means you are allowing yourself to grow into spaces you haven’t mapped yet. And yes, it is uncomfortable. It is supposed to be. If it weren’t uncomfortable, it wouldn’t be growth. It would just be maintenance. I remember the first time I tried to throw a pot on a wheel. I was living in that small coastal town, trying to rebuild my life slowly. I signed up for a weekend workshop, thinking, 'How hard can it be? It’s just mud.' Oh, how naive I was. I sat at that spinning wheel, hands covered in gray slip, heart pounding like I was about to give a major interview. I pressed my hands into the clay, and instead of rising, it collapsed. It slid off the baton. It made a mess. The instructor, a gentle woman named Elena, smiled and said, 'It’s okay. The clay knows you’re tense. Relax your shoulders.' I wanted to cry. I wanted to leave. All around me, other beginners were making lopsided bowls, cups with handles that looked like ears. Everyone was struggling. Everyone was failing. But I felt exposed. Like my inability to control the material was a reflection of my inability to control my life. I sat there, staring at the puddle of wet earth, and I realized something profound. No one was judging me. They were too busy fighting their own battles with gravity and moisture. And that was the gift. In that room, nobody cared about my past. Nobody knew I was a former reporter. I was just Tiegan, the woman who couldn’t make a cylinder stand up straight. For the first time in years, I was invisible. And in that invisibility, I found freedom. I started over. Again. And again. Until, finally, I had a bowl that held water. It wasn’t perfect. It was thick on one side, thin on the other. But it was mine. And it was beautiful because it was real. This brings me to a question I ask often in this show, and I’m asking it now: What did that cost you? What did it cost you to stay competent? To stay safe? To keep performing the role that everyone expected you to play? Sometimes the cost is your joy. Sometimes it’s your curiosity. Sometimes it’s the simple pleasure of learning something just for the sake of learning it. When we refuse to be beginners, we refuse to be alive in the present moment. We live in the past, clinging to what we already know. But life happens in the unknown. Life happens when you pick up the guitar and strum three chords that sound terrible. Life happens when you write a poem that rhymes badly. Life happens when you cook a recipe from memory and burn the garlic. These moments are not failures. They are invitations. Invitations to drop the armor. Invitations to say, 'I am here. I am trying. I am imperfect.' And isn’t that enough? Isn’t that more than enough? The bravery isn’t in succeeding. The bravery is in showing up when you know you might fail. It’s in trusting that your worth is not tied to your performance. It’s in believing that you are worthy of love and respect even when you are clumsy. Even when you are slow. Even when you are figuring it out. So how do we do this? How do we invite the beginner’s mind back into our lives without overwhelming ourselves? We start small. Very small. Don’t sign up for a masterclass. Don’t buy the expensive equipment. Just try one thing. One tiny, ridiculous, low-stakes experiment. Buy a cheap sketchbook. Doodle. Make lines that go nowhere. Listen to a foreign language podcast while you wash dishes. Don’t worry about understanding it. Just let the sounds wash over you. Dance in your kitchen while dinner cooks. Stomp. Jump. Look silly. These acts seem trivial, but they are revolutionary. They are declarations of independence from the demand to be perfect. They are ways of reclaiming your body, your mind, your time. And they don’t require anyone’s approval. You don’t need to post it on social media. You don’t need to tell your friends. You just need to do it. And when you do, notice how it feels. Notice the resistance. Notice the shame. And then notice the relief that comes after. The relief of having tried. Of having moved. Of having existed outside of your usual box. This is the work. Not the result. The process. The messy, glorious, frustrating process of becoming someone new. Someone who is allowed to change. Allowed to evolve. Allowed to be a work in progress. I want to honor the dignity of your struggle. I know it’s hard. I know it feels vulnerable to put yourself out there when you’re used to hiding behind competence. But vulnerability is not weakness. It is courage. It is the willingness to be seen, exactly as you are, in this moment. Not as you were ten years ago. Not as you hope to be ten years from now. But as you are right now. With your shaky hands. Your uncertain steps. Your open heart. This is where the magic lives. Not in the polished final product, but in the raw, unfiltered act of creation. When you allow yourself to be a beginner, you reconnect with a part of yourself that is playful. Curious. Alive. You remember what it feels like to wonder. To explore. To discover. And that spark? That spark is fuel. It sustains you through the hard days. It reminds you that you are more than your trauma. More than your job title. More than your mistakes. You are a creator. A learner. A survivor. And you are just getting started. So please, be gentle with yourself. Be patient. Give yourself permission to suck. Give yourself permission to quit if it stops bringing you joy. Give yourself permission to try again tomorrow. There is no timeline. There is no race. There is only this moment. And this moment is yours. I want you to know that you are not alone in this. So many women are sitting in their kitchens, or their cars, or their beds, wishing they could just start over. Wishing they could shed the skin of who they’ve been and become who they are meant to be. We are all beginners in different areas. Maybe you’re great at your career but terrible at dating. Maybe you’re an amazing parent but a hopeless mechanic. Maybe you’re financially secure but emotionally stunted. We all have blind spots. We all have places where we need to learn again. And there is beauty in that. There is connection in that. When we admit we don’t know everything, we open the door to community. We invite others in. We say, 'Help me.' And when we do that, we break the isolation that burns us out. We build bridges. We find our tribe. People who are also figuring it out. People who are also stumbling. People who are also trying. And in that shared humanity, we find strength. We find resilience. We find the courage to keep going. So take that step. Pick up that brush. Turn on that music. Be brave enough to be bad. Be brave enough to be new. It doesn’t have to be perfect, it just has to be yours. And that is enough. More than enough. It is everything. Thank you for letting me sit with you in this space today. I’m rooting for you. Always. Until next time, keep being beautifully, messily human. Bye for now.