Latest / The Office Politics Podcast with Fexingo: Workplace Dynamics, Influence, and Getting Things Done / How the Contrast Effect Shapes Your Office Reputation
Transcript
- Lucas: So Luna, quick scenario for you. You're interviewing two candidates back to back. The first one is a disaster — rambles, no prep, checks his phone. The second one is just... decent. Solid answers, polite, knows the product. What do you think of candidate number two? Luna: Honestly? I'd probably think they're great. Maybe even a relief. But if I'd seen the decent one first and the star later, I might think the star is average. Lucas: Exactly. That's the contrast effect in action. Your brain doesn't judge people on an absolute scale — it judges them against whatever came right before. And in an office, that sequence is often completely out of your control. Luna: So it's not just about how good you are, it's about who you're standing next to in the lineup. Lucas: Right. And the research goes back decades. Psychologists call it the 'contrast effect' — it's the same mechanism that makes lukewarm water feel hot after you've held ice, or makes a $50 bottle of wine seem cheap next to a $200 one. Your brain is built to compare, not to measure. Luna: And in the office, that means your performance review might depend on how your teammate just did in the meeting before yours. Lucas: Exactly. There's a classic study from a few years back where researchers showed that managers rated a job applicant more favorably when they'd just seen a weaker applicant, and less favorably when they'd seen a stronger one. Same résumé, same interview, totally different scores based on the order. Luna: So if you're up for a promotion and the person before you in the review cycle just bombed their presentation, you're in luck. Lucas: But flip it — if you're following a rock star, you're fighting an uphill battle. And that's the uncomfortable part: your performance is real, but the perception of it is relative. Luna: I've definitely seen that in my own teams. A new hire who was just okay looked like a genius because the previous person had been so bad. And then a genuinely great hire looked average because the bar had been set high. Lucas: It's the same pattern that inflates or deflates quarterly earnings comparisons. A company that misses by a mile makes the next quarter's modest beat feel heroic. It's all about the reference point. Luna: So how do you use this without being manipulative? Because there's a fine line between strategic and shady. Lucas: The key is to control the sequence of information, not to fake anything. For example, if you have to present a proposal, and you know a colleague is also presenting a rough draft earlier, you can schedule yours right after. You're not changing your content — you're just letting the contrast work in your favor. Luna: But isn't that a bit... gamey? Lucas: It's gamey if you're deceptive about it. But honestly, it's the same logic as a startup releasing a product after a competitor's buggy beta. You're not lying about your work — you're just aware of the context. Luna: That reminds me of a negotiation study I read. They found that if you make a low initial offer, your counteroffer seems more reasonable — even if it's still high. The contrast makes it look like a concession. Lucas: That's a classic anchoring plus contrast combo. In salary talks, if you anchor low, your 'real' ask feels like a climb. But if you anchor high, your ask feels like a compromise. The problem is, most people don't think about the sequence — they just react. Luna: So if I'm negotiating a raise, I should let the boss make the first move, or at least control what they see before I state my number. Lucas: Precisely. But here's a counterintuitive twist: sometimes you want the contrast to hurt you. If you're in a job interview and the previous candidate was stellar, you might proactively say, 'I know the last person was strong, but here's what I bring that's different.' That reframes the comparison. Luna: Oh, that's smart. You're naming the elephant in the room and flipping it. Lucas: Exactly. It shows self-awareness, which is a rare trait in itself. And it gives the interviewer a new dimension to compare on — not just 'good vs. great' but 'different strengths.' Luna: Let's talk about team dynamics, because the contrast effect can poison a team. If one person is constantly compared to a predecessor, that's exhausting. Lucas: Yeah, the 'new hire vs. legend' problem. Managers do this all the time — they mentally benchmark the new person against the person who left, and it's rarely fair. The new person has a different style, different strengths, different context. But the halo of the old person casts a huge shadow. Luna: I've seen that lead to resentment. The new person tries to mimic the old one, loses their own identity, and eventually burns out. Lucas: And the opposite happens too — when a weak predecessor leaves, the next person looks like a miracle worker for just doing the basics. That can inflate their reputation beyond what's accurate, which sets them up for a brutal fall later. Luna: So the contrast effect isn't just about perception — it's about long-term career trajectory. Lucas: Absolutely. And that's why you have to be intentional about how you position yourself, not just in the moment but over months. You want to be seen clearly, not just relatively. Luna: Speaking of being seen clearly — we should mention something here. If today's episode actually helped you think about your own office dynamics, the reason we can keep doing these deep dives ad-free is listener support. It's a small thing, but if you find this useful, you can buy us a coffee at buy me a coffee dot com slash fexingo. No pressure, just if it helps you make a smarter career move. Lucas: Yeah, that's a genuine link to what we're talking about — because the whole point is to help you see the invisible forces in your office. And listener support keeps that alive. Thanks for that, Luna. Luna: Absolutely. And honestly, even a coffee keeps us going. But let's get back to a practical tip — how do you combat the contrast effect when it's working against you? Lucas: One tactic is to create your own 'contrast moments.' If you know you're following a strong performer in a meeting, you can't change the order, but you can change the frame. Start by acknowledging their work — 'I really liked Sarah's approach, and here's a complementary angle.' That shifts the judge from comparing to integrating. Luna: That's smart. It turns a competition into a collaboration in the listener's mind. Lucas: Another trick is to use written communication to your advantage. If you know your in-person pitch will be compared to a strong one earlier in the day, send a follow-up email that reframes your points with a fresh comparison — like comparing your proposal to a different benchmark, not the one from the meeting. Luna: And what about performance reviews? Can you control the sequence there? Lucas: To a degree. You might not control who goes first, but you can control what you share beforehand. If you send a summary of your accomplishments before the review, you're setting the reference point for what 'good' looks like. That's not manipulation — that's just good preparation. Luna: Right, because the reviewer is going to compare you to something. Better it's your own strong list than a fuzzy memory of someone else's. Lucas: Exactly. And there's a meta-lesson here: when you're the manager, you can fight the contrast effect by using structured rubrics. That's why a lot of companies now use standardized scoring — it forces you to evaluate against criteria, not against the last person. Luna: So the fix for individuals is awareness and sequence control, and the fix for organizations is process. Lucas: That's a clean summary. And it's a reminder that the contrast effect is one of those biases that's so baked into how we think, we don't even notice it until someone points it out. Luna: So next time you feel like you're being judged unfairly, ask yourself: is it me, or is it just the person before me? Lucas: And if it's the person before you, you now have a toolkit. Control the frame, acknowledge the comparison, and always know your own baseline. Luna: That's a good place to leave it. Thanks for joining us, and we'll see you in the next one.