Latest / ZoukNerds • Learn | Build | Belong / Zouk's Dirty Laundry: Now Airing (S05 Ep42)
Transcript
- 0:01Do you feel confident with the standards of safety in our dance
- 0:05community? What can we do to protect,
- 0:09improve, and make it safer for everyone?
- 0:13Well, let's find out. Hello.
- 0:16Hello everyone, and welcome back to Zook Nerds.
- 0:18In today's episode, we are diving to a crucial and
- 0:21sensitive topic, behavioral issues within the dance
- 0:25community. We'll be addressing how we as a
- 0:29community deal with these challenges, what role each of us
- 0:32plays in fostering a safe environment, and how can we
- 0:37learn from past situations to make better decisions for the
- 0:40future. Stay with us as we navigate this
- 0:43complex situations in this episode.
- 0:46So let's go. Trigger warning this episode
- 0:59discusses sensitive topics including allegations of
- 1:02misconduct, abuse, and community safety.
- 1:06Listener discretion is advised. Hello, hello everybody and
- 1:12welcome back to another episode of Zook Nerds.
- 1:17My name is Alison Sanji and I'm here once again with our
- 1:22beautiful Co host Gee Prada. Hello, Gee.
- 1:27Hi, Alison. Hello, everybody.
- 1:29Welcome back. Thank you for being here once
- 1:31again, Gee. And today we have another very,
- 1:35very special Co host with us and you might already know her from
- 1:40previous seasons of Zook nerds when she was here with us every
- 1:45week. And it's Laura River.
- 1:47Hello, Laura. Welcome back.
- 1:49Hi, I'm happy to be Zach. And thank you for being here
- 1:52once again. We're very excited to have you
- 1:54back. In today's episode, we're going
- 1:57to be talking about behavioral issues in the community.
- 2:02Well, it's not something new to the community, unfortunately,
- 2:07but it's something that has happened over and over again.
- 2:11But today we want to address how we as a community are dealing
- 2:16with this and what role each of us play and how to keep safe and
- 2:22how to look in the past and in the future to make better
- 2:26decisions. Right.
- 2:27And one thing that I want to talk about a recent situation
- 2:30that just happened, if you are in the presidents of community,
- 2:34you might know what we're talking about is the fact that
- 2:37this happened and it didn't really happen within another
- 2:42person in the community per SE, right?
- 2:45So like other cases and other situations that has happened in
- 2:49the past, it was very much that, but this one wasn't.
- 2:53And we are curious to understand like how did that case affect
- 2:59the community in such, such a strong way, not just because it
- 3:06is something terrible, but also because it was an inside of the
- 3:11community. So we've seen a lot of
- 3:12discussions about that, and that's the first question that I
- 3:15have for you, Laura. How do we navigate things that
- 3:20happen inside of the community and outside of the community and
- 3:23how it affects what we do here as dancers?
- 3:27Well, I mean, in this specific case, what happened was very
- 3:34severe. It was indictments.
- 3:37There's a trial planned for it. So there's a degree of severity
- 3:41with this specific case that I think for the vast majority of
- 3:45people supersedes that difference between whether it
- 3:49was in or out of the community, right?
- 3:51Because we're always talking about like essentially a scale
- 3:54of severity. So there's, you know, is it a
- 3:57risk to the dance community or not a risk to the dance?
- 4:00Is it happen in or out of the key?
- 4:02Was it to a dancer or someone outside of the sea?
- 4:06And all of those things are affected by severity, right?
- 4:12Something happening in the scene that poses a risk to teen
- 4:15dancers that's lower may still be really significant, and
- 4:21something that's the same level outside of the community may not
- 4:25be significant. But in this case, it was so
- 4:28deeply disturbing to a lot of people that it really did not
- 4:32matter that this happened to people outside of the community.
- 4:36I think one of the reasons why we wanted you to come back,
- 4:39Laura, is because I think and we think that you have maybe one of
- 4:43the most influential voices in our community and has a
- 4:48moderation to your opinions. Everything you express considers
- 4:52the complexity of the situation. I think you can see through
- 4:56multiple lenses and understand maybe what's going on on the
- 5:04heads of the dancers, the heads of the teachers and of the
- 5:08attendees and of the organizers, right?
- 5:12And one of the things that got my attention a lot on this case
- 5:16was the immediate response to boycott the event, to cancel the
- 5:21event, to don't go there because there was this association that
- 5:26income that is made from the event is going to go directly to
- 5:29the defense. And we don't want that.
- 5:33We don't want him to have any of these resources.
- 5:36I don't want to pay for his defense basically and you
- 5:41presented like a very reasonable, sensible point of
- 5:45view in regards to events planning.
- 5:48So we don't jump into this conclusions that because we are
- 5:51paying tickets, the money on the tickets going to go to this
- 5:54thing and you present like a very nice point of view about it
- 5:57all. So my question to you about this
- 6:01is how is an event organizer who hire the artist?
- 6:06How do you go about this whole situation?
- 6:10How did you go about this whole situation?
- 6:13Or do you have processes in place for when something like
- 6:17this happens? And do you communicate with
- 6:21other organizers as well? I know you do because many times
- 6:25actually reach out to you for advice, but how do you see that
- 6:28part of the organizer in all of this?
- 6:31So there's kind of like 2 parts to that, right?
- 6:34So the first is what happened in this specific instance, right?
- 6:40And what was somewhat unique in this particular case is that the
- 6:44main organizer was the person indicted, right?
- 6:49Which to my knowledge, we have not had as dramatically in the
- 6:54scene before. I can only think of one other
- 6:56case where there was an organizer specifically that had
- 7:00something happen around their integrity, right?
- 7:05And so like this, this knee jerk reaction of a, we have to
- 7:07boycott, we have to not go there.
- 7:10In that sense, I understand where it came S Right.
- 7:14This situation was a little bit unique in that someone unrelated
- 7:19to the name organizer stepped into the ruins of the events
- 7:26that was in two weeks to kind of put something back together.
- 7:30And that was done very intentionally and things like
- 7:32that, which has essentially reincarnated it as something
- 7:36completely different, even though it's at the same hotel
- 7:38the same weekend, at the same pass as a family, right?
- 7:42So from an organizer standpoint, coming into this mess, that's
- 7:48kind of what needs to happen if you have an organizer
- 7:52specifically who is evolved in something of this severity,
- 7:56right? Who says people are boycotting
- 7:58the event created by the organizer because they are
- 8:01boycotting the organizer, right? That's a little different than
- 8:05if you're an organizer trying to manage the behavior of people
- 8:09that are hired or attending your event, right?
- 8:13Or like, and this person did something in the past, should I
- 8:16hire them for my event? And that becomes an exercise for
- 8:20the individual organizer in understanding where their values
- 8:24are for event organization. There's some organizers who
- 8:28don't share the same values as me, right?
- 8:31They may think that certain behaviors are OK or not OK that
- 8:35I'm not OK with or I'm OK with. And that reflects in the type of
- 8:40event they hold, the people that they invite to the event, the
- 8:43atmosphere that they create. And when they're doing that type
- 8:47of analysis, it's kind of a value first analysis.
- 8:50But I think the other part that goes into it is OK, as an
- 8:53organizer, if I am going to give this person the benefit of the
- 8:56doubt, how do I am sure that I am doing this in a responsible
- 9:00way, right? Because you can believe that
- 9:04someone is OK, but you also have a duty that if there is a
- 9:09whisper or a fluent or an allegation or something like
- 9:13that, to make sure that if they are involved in what you're
- 9:15doing, that you have safeguards in place that makes you
- 9:19confident it won't happen there. And that is not solely reliant
- 9:23on the person's light decisions, right?
- 9:26Because they might make bad decisions.
- 9:27People make bad decisions all the time.
- 9:29So if I know someone has had an issue behind closed doors and
- 9:33private lessons, OK, am I going to mandate that they can't do
- 9:37private lessons at my events is happened alone with a student,
- 9:40they require a chaperone approved by me, that type of
- 9:43thing, right? And that can help mitigate risk.
- 9:46And as an organizer, you have to decide, is this too much work or
- 9:49not enough work? But it's irresponsible at the
- 9:51end of the day to not put safeguards in place if there is
- 9:54a question, right? So a little bit of a meandering
- 9:58answer there. But this case itself is a little
- 10:01different than the average organizer role in adjudicating
- 10:05Bethy Page really, because in this case, the issue is the
- 10:07organizer. It's not a party at the event.
- 10:11That's true. I really appreciated that you
- 10:13didn't assume by default that the new person that stepped in
- 10:17knew or was aware of everything that happened or approved or
- 10:22agreed with everything that's happened on everything that the
- 10:24teacher did. So I liked that when everything
- 10:29was going in a direction of assuming that just because the
- 10:32person is close, they new or something to that extent, you
- 10:37gave the person that stepped in the benefit of the doubt.
- 10:41And it's like this person is just stepping in into this very
- 10:44complex situation and is willing to create something new, like
- 10:49you said. Like even though the same hotel,
- 10:50same dates and same tickets apply is willing to create
- 10:53something new and let's give this person a chance to show
- 10:58what can be done and how he can rearrange the whole event.
- 11:02So it works because you mentioned too that there are
- 11:05costs involved. There are things that have
- 11:07already been paid, you know, like the hotel and all these
- 11:10things. I don't know how that works
- 11:11because I never organized events.
- 11:14I never have been the person that got in contact with the
- 11:17hotel and did that part of the negotiation or the venue itself.
- 11:22But I think that you brought this consideration that there
- 11:26are some logistics in play who are given how close the event
- 11:29is, that it's already cost that has been, you know, it's like
- 11:34something that has been agreed upon already and just support
- 11:39the person who is taking over. I think that for attendees, they
- 11:44might and teachers as well, it might be like a subconscious
- 11:48thing that is very strong that even though it's a different
- 11:54event, different person, different name, because it's the
- 11:57same date or because it's substituting the previous
- 12:01events, they might still create a connection that is still the
- 12:05event. And it might be hard for people
- 12:08to separate both things. And I don't have a question
- 12:14here. I'm just like wondering how that
- 12:16aspects of the human mind can play an important factor on
- 12:20whether or not the person who stepped in can actually do
- 12:24something, you know, and not incurring these ginormous costs
- 12:29from the previous event. I mean, it's complicated because
- 12:34people have a right to feel emotions, right?
- 12:39There are some people for who attended this event might be too
- 12:44painful. It might be uncomfortable, that
- 12:47may be tainted, right? Just because of the proximity.
- 12:52Maybe they're a survivor themselves.
- 12:54Maybe they know someone who was survivor.
- 12:56Maybe the whole thing just makes them sick, right?
- 12:59So those people, I have a lot of empathy for that this role,
- 13:04emotional reaction of, you know, this is how I feel.
- 13:08And there's nothing that can be done that makes this OK, right?
- 13:13But we also have a parallel responsibility to recognize
- 13:18blame where it is owed. And you can be angry and you can
- 13:22choose not to attend an event. You can choose to request a
- 13:26refund without assigning blame to the person who stepping into
- 13:31the thing and recognizing that like especially with stuff like
- 13:34Barris, the people who are closest to this person, they're
- 13:38probably way, way worse off than any of the general population.
- 13:44Because I can't imagine any person being that close to the
- 13:48individual and saying, Oh yeah, I knew he was doing this.
- 13:52Like the level of twisted that would need to be there to have
- 13:55justified that behavior. Any not like knowing that that
- 13:59had happened. It's as far as I'm concerned,
- 14:03like I'm going to automatically assume they did not know, right?
- 14:07And so it's OK to be angry. It's OK to pull out of the
- 14:10event. It's OK to reserve that space
- 14:13emotionally and to have all of the big feelings as long as the
- 14:18blame doesn't get misallocated to like his wife, his partner,
- 14:23he's Co organizer who are now picking up all of the shattered
- 14:28pieces that have been shattered because of one person's actions,
- 14:31right? So there's no way they can
- 14:34refund everyone. The money's not there.
- 14:36And you think yell and scream and kick all you want, but all
- 14:39that's going to happen is the company's going to go bankrupt
- 14:41and you'll never see the cent. If everyone tries to claim a
- 14:43refund. It's impossible, right?
- 14:46The cost is sunk, and it's not their fault and it's not the
- 14:49intendee's fault. It's that person's fault, right?
- 14:52And so you can have all of those feelings.
- 14:54You can be mad that you can't get a refund.
- 14:57You can be mad that you've lost money.
- 14:59But it's not the problem of the people who are trying to do the
- 15:03best they can to manage is the problem of the person who made
- 15:06the decisions that hurt the community.
- 15:08And I think sometimes we're very bad at differentiating that
- 15:14because we want to do something now, we want justice, we want
- 15:17retribution, we want punishment, we want what's best for us,
- 15:23right? And like, emotions are wonderful
- 15:27and can be very motivational, cathartic.
- 15:30They can help in a lot of ways, but they can also cause us to do
- 15:35things irrationally and in a way that's not sealing the situation
- 15:41but is actually inflaming it and making damage worse.
- 15:44And I think that's where sometimes the Canadian members
- 15:47struggle a little bit because they feel so deeply and we want
- 15:52the best. And unfortunately, it's just a
- 15:55situation where there is no good outcome.
- 15:57There's just the best that can be done in the circumstances and
- 16:02learning to live with that and processing those complicated
- 16:05emotions, it's hard. It's not easy.
- 16:08Absolutely. Talking about this situation in
- 16:12particular, I think it's tragic. It's terrible based on the
- 16:17knowledge that we have. But then when you look at
- 16:20previous cases or previous behaviors that happened in the
- 16:25community, I remember being part of groups of conversations where
- 16:29people were divided between like, well, let's wait and see,
- 16:35or let's just bend that person forever because some people
- 16:41would sometimes even classify as well, There's no police report.
- 16:46It's just people talking about it or nobody has gone to jail,
- 16:51so then they don't deserve to be cancelled or something.
- 16:55So I remember in some cases people were making decisions
- 17:00based on that specific thing. Was there a police report?
- 17:05If no, then it's just people talking.
- 17:09Or did that person go to jail or go to trial or something?
- 17:13No. Well, then that person can still
- 17:14be part of the community because they were not found guilty.
- 17:18How do we actually navigate that?
- 17:22I know how I navigate because in terms of like these situations,
- 17:27I'm always very careful, very, very careful.
- 17:30If there is anything that you can do, system that you can put
- 17:32in place to make sure that your community safe, I will do that.
- 17:38If that means that if there's any question about somebody,
- 17:42maybe I shouldn't have them in my community, then I prefer not
- 17:47to have them in my community. Until proven that that person
- 17:51has not done anything wrong or that maybe a long, long time
- 17:57later they have changed, they have improved, they're different
- 18:01person. But is there any way that you
- 18:04would recommend people that are in the community to draw the
- 18:09line or is this something very individual?
- 18:12So when you're making decisions about bad, be safe here.
- 18:16The majority of cases are not like this recent one.
- 18:21There's maybe 4 cases that I can think of, maybe like in Zook
- 18:26specifically, if I broaden that to other dances that I've dealt
- 18:30with maybe under 10 that I know of where it's kind of this
- 18:34visceral. Everyone's agreed this is
- 18:37unacceptable. The person has to be gone now,
- 18:41right? That's a very small number
- 18:43considering the voice room of people, the number of dances,
- 18:47the number of events, the number of staff, artists, pros,
- 18:51attendees, whatever, right? So we're talking about these
- 18:55major cases, the very time percentage, everything else.
- 18:59People disagree. And people can disagree in a way
- 19:03that's reasoned and considered or in a way that's reactionary,
- 19:08right? And reactionary responses to bad
- 19:11behavior tend not to be conducive.
- 19:15And like, for example, there's statements like we must always
- 19:20believes victims, we must always do this.
- 19:24We must always remove the threat.
- 19:28If they have done anything, they should be gone because our
- 19:31scenes need to be completely safe.
- 19:33And I've seen people reserve that for like, oh, this person
- 19:37like forcibly someone to oh, you know, they crazed someone's
- 19:41bleed while they were death, right?
- 19:43And there's this visceral kind of that happens as soon as you
- 19:47hear that something is wrong, but it's nevertheless and full,
- 19:50first of all, because people, war victims are human, people
- 19:55who are perpetrators are human. And people react these in
- 20:00dramatically different ways. And the certain stances are just
- 20:05as varied and. There has to be, if you're going
- 20:09to make a reasoned decision on this, you have to consider all
- 20:12of those angles. And I think this whole police
- 20:16report versus not police report thing has a bit of a scapegoat.
- 20:20And we can actually use the current case as an example.
- 20:23There's no actual promote conviction yet.
- 20:25It's going to trial. He's been indicted and is being
- 20:28culled, but technically he hasn't been found guilty yet,
- 20:32right? But we've all decided that this
- 20:35is enough. This person shouldn't be here
- 20:37who's made that decision without a criminal conviction.
- 20:41It's just an indictment, right? And that, to me, is very
- 20:45reasonable given the nature of what has happened, given the
- 20:48amount of credibility involved, given the seriousness of the
- 20:54action statement to date, it makes sense, right?
- 20:57So using that same test, some organizers could say this person
- 21:01should be allowed. But we're not saying it in this
- 21:03case because it's bad enough, right?
- 21:07So it's a scapegoat. What is a more responsible way
- 21:11to go around it is to either develop the skills or find
- 21:15someone who has the skills to help you actually look at the
- 21:19different aspects. That means talking to people who
- 21:22say that they were victimized. That means talking to the person
- 21:27who is alleged to have done the things.
- 21:30It's looking for patterns of behavior.
- 21:33It's looking at the available information.
- 21:35It's essentially an investigation, right?
- 21:37And like, I've done that a lot and I've done that for little
- 21:40things and I've done it for big things and it's a lot.
- 21:44It's a lot emotionally, it's a lot time wise.
- 21:46But it's only when you have all of that information as an
- 21:51organizer that you can actually make a credible decision on what
- 21:55should be done in the individual instance.
- 21:57Is this something where a conversation will suffice?
- 22:00Is this something where if what is alleged is true, there's a
- 22:04great risk of harm to the people at my event?
- 22:07Or is the harm the great, the minimal?
- 22:10Is this something where I believe the person has insight
- 22:12into their actions or not? Does the person who was a victim
- 22:17want anything to be done or not? Is this a Gray area where it's
- 22:23an isolated incident, and because we don't have any other
- 22:26information, we need to wait and see if it happens again?
- 22:30Or is it compelling? And I can call back to a case
- 22:33that happened in around 2018. We had a guy who was very
- 22:38influential, no criminal charge or anything like that.
- 22:43And there was a massive effort to remove him from the scene
- 22:45because it turned out that there was, you know, pearls in seven
- 22:50different countries who did not know each other, who all had an
- 22:54experience of essentially grooming and coercion and
- 22:58control and abuse, right? And the whole thing was, oh, you
- 23:02know, like they're colliding. They're, you know, coming
- 23:05together to manufacture a story. No one's pressing criminal
- 23:09charges. You know, there's all of this,
- 23:11like, little bits, right? But there's nothing firm.
- 23:16But when you look at the totality, the idea that there's
- 23:21ten women in seven countries who all have described a similar
- 23:24pattern of behavior that has been witnessed over a period of
- 23:29years, overwhelmingly, they're probably not making this up,
- 23:35right? And so he may be, there's a
- 23:38little chance that he clearly had no idea what he was doing,
- 23:42right? He's so detached or there was
- 23:44this conspiracy or something. But overwhelmingly the
- 23:48information points that, look, I don't think it's safe for you to
- 23:52be here. I think there are risks of
- 23:54participants. I don't think you should be
- 23:56allowed to participate in this community because it's a risk,
- 23:59right? And that was controversial.
- 24:01There were organizers who said, Oh, no, no, no.
- 24:03No, no, like. You know, he's one of our best
- 24:05ticket resellers and you know, he supports everything and he
- 24:08was really helpful. He would never do this right.
- 24:12I'm not going to do anything else as a criminal charge.
- 24:14But is that responsible at that point?
- 24:17Have you actually like considered things?
- 24:19Because if you say, in light of all of this information, I still
- 24:25think you should be allowed to attend, you better have a reason
- 24:28for it. If you can't articulate the
- 24:30reason and the only thing you can say is there's no colluse
- 24:32report, it's not enough of a reason to allow someone
- 24:37continued access to a space where they have authority,
- 24:40influence and access to people. That makes sense.
- 24:43The inverse is also true. I know that there are people who
- 24:49have experiences that very much has text them, and I have
- 24:52empathy for that. Or like, you know, oh, this guy,
- 24:57you know, I thought we had something special.
- 25:00And then, you know, she cheated on me with somebody in the
- 25:03scene. He's an asshole.
- 25:04He needs to be banned. And you know what?
- 25:06Yeah, don't cheat. Just have an open relationship
- 25:10with you too. But be honest, right?
- 25:12That's a good person slash an integrity issue.
- 25:16That's not a safety of the community issue.
- 25:18Provided that everything that happened was generally
- 25:20consensual, Right? And to me, it would be, it's
- 25:25very, very wrong to ban someone for just kind of being a Dick,
- 25:30if that makes sense, Right. Or accidentally groping someone
- 25:34one time or thinking that they saw the signals that someone
- 25:37wanted to kiss and one time they kind of messed up.
- 25:40So those are conversations maybe you have, but it's not.
- 25:44This is not the same level as the people who have a perma ban
- 25:48from everything around the world because they did something so
- 25:51terrible, right? Does that kind of make sense?
- 25:55Yeah, 100%. The police reporting as you were
- 26:00mentioning, Laura, is so is, you know, it resonates with me
- 26:03strongly because my mother is, she's retired now, but she used
- 26:07to work for the police. She was like a police deputy for
- 26:1120 something years, you know. And this strength there is
- 26:15required sometimes from victims of situations like sexual
- 26:19harassment or abuse or anything on that regard that involves
- 26:24relationship with someone that they once trusted and loved is
- 26:28really difficult. It's really hard for someone to
- 26:34really go to the police and press charges, you know?
- 26:38And I was really close to a case that happened 2910.
- 26:43I remember the year right now, again with multiple women.
- 26:46There was a website and everything and my mom needed to
- 26:51go with one of them to the Police Department to support to
- 26:57be next to them so they could file the police report.
- 27:01You know, so it's not easy. And like you said, the argument,
- 27:05oh, if there's not a police report, then I cannot do
- 27:07anything for me reminded me of that difficulty for someone to
- 27:12actually do that. You know, it's not easy.
- 27:15And I think too, that when something like this happens and
- 27:20people have these strong reactions, I think it's a lot
- 27:24related to the relationship of trust that once existed with
- 27:29that particular individual is broken.
- 27:32And sometimes the gravity of breaking that trust for each
- 27:38person is going to vary. And I think that's the part that
- 27:42is very hard to mend because with certain people, we put them
- 27:47into this, you know, this shiny pedestal of ethics and morals.
- 27:51And when they do something wrong, and like you said,
- 27:53sometimes it's something grave and sometimes it's like
- 27:58something with the body or sometimes was a misunderstood
- 28:01signal that trust is broken and the person falls from the
- 28:05pedestal and suddenly becomes this horrible human being.
- 28:09And I think that's the hardest part to manage is to manage that
- 28:13perception of the person that once existed and now is not the
- 28:18same anymore. And this falls a lot into the
- 28:22organizers and community, local teachers that needs to go
- 28:26through this extensive process of investigation to understand
- 28:30all their circumstances and talk with everybody.
- 28:32And this is something that, you know, we have done here too, so
- 28:35many times. And I think we have come to you
- 28:38many times as well, like as I cry for help, like what do we
- 28:42do? How do we do?
- 28:43And it's not easy at all. So it's maybe one of the most
- 28:49challenging aspects of this job is dealing with dealing with
- 28:55that when the trust is broken or when the perception of someone
- 29:00as someone trustworthy is shattered for some reason.
- 29:03That's the hardest part for me. Yeah, I remember the case that
- 29:08you're talking about as well. And I think part of the
- 29:11difficulty is for some people, but trust shatters and for some
- 29:16people, they can't reconcile that they do trust or like the
- 29:20person or admire the person, and therefore they have to discard
- 29:24the information that's come to life, right?
- 29:27Because those are the kind of the two reactions and
- 29:30understanding that can be very empowering.
- 29:34Because very often when you have people who are supporting an
- 29:38individual, because it's not their experience with that
- 29:41person, right? You're essentially asking them
- 29:44to view the person as a villain that they never thought the
- 29:49person was. And that can be a very difficult
- 29:53thing if you really admire this person.
- 29:56For some people, it happens instantly.
- 29:58It's like, oh, you, you did this thing.
- 30:00So oh, you're, you're horrible. How dare you?
- 30:04And for some people, they never get there, right?
- 30:07They're like, no, no, they they can't have done that, right?
- 30:10It must be a misunderstanding. They didn't mean it.
- 30:14They must not have realized, oh, you know, they're struggling
- 30:17with things. And both of those perspectives
- 30:19are very valid. But you both have to be worked
- 30:23through to come to the realization that the idol is a
- 30:27person, right? And it doesn't matter how bad
- 30:31things are that someone has done, there were people that
- 30:35loved them. There are still people that love
- 30:37them. They have probably done
- 30:40something good in their lives. They may have been very helpful.
- 30:45They may have been very kind in other circumstances.
- 30:48And the holistic view of the perpetrator as a person, you can
- 30:52often add a lot of nuance, but it's also a lot to carry, right?
- 30:56To see a complex figure where we want to exclude or include.
- 31:03And so that kind of trusts piece of it figures into it extremely,
- 31:08extremely strongly in that in that viscerality that we have
- 31:11towards doing something or not doing something or wanting to
- 31:14ignore because it's very painful to confront.
- 31:16And I've talked to a lot of people who have been accused of
- 31:20things and as even the person from 9 or 10 years ago, I've had
- 31:24like a 2 hour conversation with him.
- 31:27And a lot of having those conversations is holding space
- 31:32for empathy, but not permission, right?
- 31:36And that's a very difficult thing to do because the vast
- 31:39majority of people who have done a bad thing, they don't do the
- 31:42bad thing because it's bad, right?
- 31:44The vast majority of people are not psychopaths or sociopaths
- 31:49where they truly are OK with doing something that they know
- 31:55is wrong and that they know is harmful because it benefits
- 31:58them. Everyone else does a whole lot
- 32:01of justifying to get to the point they did the bad thing
- 32:04right. They will do mental gymnastics
- 32:07to put themselves in a position where they don't have to feel
- 32:11bad about the thing that they did.
- 32:12And that doesn't mean it's OK, but it does mean that they're
- 32:15human and we cannot ask victims to do that.
- 32:19It's not the role of a victim to see the perpetrator as a
- 32:23three-dimensional human being, but especially if we're in a
- 32:26position of power or influence, we are not the victim.
- 32:30And my personal position is while you can be supportive of
- 32:34victims, you also can't be the support person of the victim.
- 32:38That is a different role because people who has been subjective
- 32:42things, they need to have someone who's 1000% in their
- 32:45corner, the person that they rant to, the person who
- 32:49validates the entirety of the experience that they are feeling
- 32:52as they feel it. But that is a different role
- 32:55than the person who is looking to make a reasoned decision on
- 32:59next steps forward, right? That person needs to be able to
- 33:02hold the reality of both the perpetrator and the victim.
- 33:06They need to be able to work through that bracing of trust
- 33:10and deciding is it repairable? Is it one time?
- 33:13Is it multiple times? Is it a risk?
- 33:15Is it not a risk they have to be able to push through that
- 33:19emotional layering to get to a resolution?
- 33:21And this is very similar to, and I know like both you and ID are
- 33:25lawyers by training, which means we've both been part of a
- 33:28regulatory body. And the role of a regulator in
- 33:32any sort of profession is that they are looking at the
- 33:35professional conduct and suitability of people who are
- 33:38practicing. And you can lose your license
- 33:40with things like malpractice, but you can also lose your
- 33:43license for things like criminal convictions or being charged
- 33:47with feeding a spouse or something like that, right?
- 33:50So there's things that are severe enough that are not
- 33:52related to the profession. There's things that are
- 33:54professionally related, right? We don't have that in Damps, but
- 33:58our professionals occupy a similar place of trust, but we
- 34:03don't have the mechanisms to deal with it, which means that
- 34:06it ends up falling to the organizers to figure out almost
- 34:09how to be a self regulator for the people that they're working
- 34:12with and for the general public. Sometimes we kind of idolize
- 34:18instead of viewing a whole person, and then we react
- 34:22emotionally in a way that often makes the situation worse, not
- 34:26better. That's just how it goes.
- 34:29Yeah. That's something that I was
- 34:31thinking about here. How do we deal with that in
- 34:34terms of a person of high power versus not, or is somebody
- 34:39famous versus not? Whether it's the dance community
- 34:43or the music industry, movies, whatever level that is.
- 34:49Sometimes we've heard terrible things about people in power,
- 34:55but then people are like, well, you know, it doesn't affect me.
- 34:58They're still great singer, they're still great actor,
- 35:01they're still great soccer player.
- 35:03Whatever doesn't affect me, I'm going to support and still love
- 35:06that person. But then when it's the dance
- 35:09community, because the dance community is so big but so small
- 35:12at the same time, it does affect everybody.
- 35:16So then, yeah, like, how do we navigate that comparison between
- 35:21like, wow, you know, this soccer player or this singer did same
- 35:24thing as that dancer, but people still support that guy, that
- 35:29famous powerful millionaire, but everybody wants to cancel the
- 35:33dancer. I mean, it's parasocial
- 35:36relationships, right? So a parasocial relationship is
- 35:38this idea that you feel like you know the person even though he
- 35:42don't actually know them. You know their persona, right?
- 35:46Like all three of us have people who are in a parasocial
- 35:50relationship with us where we don't know much about their
- 35:52lives, but they know a lot more about what we do, right?
- 35:56It doesn't mean they know us, but there's this like bond that
- 36:01goes one way unless that duality is established back to the other
- 36:05person, right? And what we're talking about
- 36:09kind of the support for the persona versus support for the
- 36:13person. It's such an individual values.
- 36:20You test, right? There's no right or wrong.
- 36:23There's what are your values? What do you view is important?
- 36:29What is the world you want to live in?
- 36:33Right, and I can give you an unrelated example here.
- 36:35I, I have a dear friend who has probably the one of the highest
- 36:40levels of integrity of anyone I know where this default thing
- 36:46is. Well, of course I'm going to
- 36:47claim every $20 that I make on my taxes because it's my civil
- 36:51duty to support the infrastructure of our society
- 36:54through taxes. And that's the world I want to
- 36:56live in. The vast majority of us don't
- 36:58declare $20 that we got at some random thing for a little thing,
- 37:03but he does because that's the world he wants to live in.
- 37:07And so he contributes in the way that reflects the place he wants
- 37:10to be right. And when we looked at this type
- 37:15of thing, you have people who really don't care about anything
- 37:19beyond them having a good time. They don't want to know the
- 37:22drama that's going on. They don't want to know what's
- 37:24going on. They would rather just live in a
- 37:27bliss bubble because this is what they do for fun.
- 37:31And we may not like that. It may not be the way we're
- 37:36geared, but that's who they are. And it would be wrong to try to
- 37:41force that person to live by a different set of morals than
- 37:46what their personal integrity demands, unless that is starting
- 37:51to harm other people. And so obviously there's like
- 37:55different things. You can put pressure on culture
- 37:58to go a certain way. You can normalize certain types
- 38:04of behaviors and shun other types of behaviors, reward the
- 38:07good behaviors, dissociate from the bad behaviors.
- 38:10And you do have people in the community who are like, I don't
- 38:13go to this organizers events because I don't like that, you
- 38:17know, they don't treat all of their artists as well or I
- 38:19support this person's events no matter what because I think that
- 38:23they act with integrity and I know that they treat people well
- 38:26and are trying to build something good, right?
- 38:28So you see the community aligning themselves with people
- 38:31of a similar value set and wherever at the balance of that
- 38:34power rests is the general tract of the community, right?
- 38:39And so that individual judgement piece figures into this.
- 38:44It's OK on a personal level to say, you know, I really love
- 38:49this person's music. I'm going to play their stuff.
- 38:52Even though they did this really bad thing and they're no longer
- 38:55part of the community. This old music to me, right?
- 39:00I love it. I want to listen to it, I want
- 39:02to dance to it. I just won't buy their new
- 39:03records. I won't fit them on, right?
- 39:06You have other people who are like, I don't want any imprints
- 39:10of this person on the community whatsoever.
- 39:11So I have never been afraid of their music and I am not going
- 39:13to listen to their music. I'm going to avoid dancing to
- 39:16their music. If it's played, also fine.
- 39:20But under both of those is a consideration, right?
- 39:24And to me, the more important thing is that people reflect on
- 39:29why they're making a decision rather than coming to a specific
- 39:34decision, right? And that's something that I also
- 39:36talk with organizers about when they asked me about, oh, this
- 39:41person that did a bad thing, should I hire them?
- 39:45Do you think they're better now? Right.
- 39:47And most of that conversation is not about, is the person
- 39:50actually better? It's what are your values as an
- 39:52organizer? Are you comfortable with this
- 39:54person representing your values? Are you comfortable controlling
- 39:58the situation? What level of risks do you think
- 40:01they post? It's not about are they better
- 40:04or are they not better? You can't know that you're not
- 40:07in their brain. You can only look at the
- 40:09available information to make that decision.
- 40:11And it's the same thing for the general.
- 40:14There's no right or wrong. Yeah, man, this reminds me so
- 40:17much of Michael Jackson for some reason, you know, because I
- 40:23think it's one of those situations, you know, as someone
- 40:25who made great contributions for art and pop culture and because
- 40:29of the things that happened, some people like don't want to
- 40:32hear his music and some people like, but he made such beautiful
- 40:38art. How come we can we not listen to
- 40:39his music, you know? So it's reminded me of.
- 40:43So is it like if somebody is a genius, they're excused?
- 40:47It kind of sounds like that sometimes if they're genius or
- 40:50if they're like one-of-a-kind human, then people tend to go
- 40:55like, well, yes, it's terrible, but they're genius and they kind
- 41:00of like just separate that. But then to to the person next
- 41:05to them, they'll go like, no, no, no, that person death
- 41:08penalty, you know, because they are not a genius, they're not a
- 41:11famous person, they're not superhuman or something.
- 41:14I mean, to be honest, sometimes that does happen.
- 41:17That's human nature. We don't like to work against
- 41:20our own self-interest, and that includes when we enjoy
- 41:24something. If we like it, we want to keep
- 41:27enjoying it. It's really, really hard to get
- 41:31people to give up something that they like.
- 41:35It's really easy for them to jump on the bandwagon if they
- 41:38don't actually have any stint in a day, right?
- 41:41And you see that with the geniuses, the one of the kinds,
- 41:46those influential people. Because for like the recent
- 41:52one's a good example, it had to be really freaking bad to come
- 41:56to that solution. Because there are other people
- 41:58who have done things and we still listen to their music.
- 42:02We still, you know, they still tour in some parts of the world,
- 42:06right? And that's an individual call.
- 42:08I know what call I would make as a person.
- 42:11I know what stance I would support with other organizers.
- 42:17But I can't control every single member of the community.
- 42:21And if I start putting judgement on anyone who disagrees with how
- 42:26I would handle it, we're going to go down a very, very weirdly
- 42:30pole really, really, really fast.
- 42:32And very divisive as well, right?
- 42:35That's kind of great. Like these different polarities
- 42:37all over. It's going to be pretty, pretty
- 42:39bad, as you were saying, Laura. I remember in law school, one of
- 42:43the first things I learned in law school was that whatever we
- 42:47do in law is never to find truth.
- 42:50We'll never find truth. We'll never understand what
- 42:53really happened. We will go around and try to get
- 42:57to something that is as close as possible to it by trying to
- 43:01understand everything that happened in talking to everybody
- 43:04and seeing all the circumstances.
- 43:06And like you said, there is people who need to be completely
- 43:10supporting both sides of whatever happened.
- 43:15And there is someone in the middle who understands
- 43:18everything and is trying to look at the brother picture in
- 43:23Portuguese. There is a word for it.
- 43:25There is true, which is Vedaji and there is Vero similians,
- 43:29which is something similar to the truth.
- 43:32That's what we are trying to get to, you know.
- 43:35So I, I really, really resonated with me when you mention the
- 43:39part of the someone who is supporting the victim, for
- 43:44example, through and through. And another component is having
- 43:49someone who is also looking to make a good informed decision,
- 43:54right. Because the other thing that in
- 43:56law school is interesting to learn in the criminal area in
- 43:59the criminal system is that this grading of how serious of how
- 44:06grave something is to decide the penalty.
- 44:09So if these things happen, the penalty is this much so you give
- 44:14the person a chance to do a community work and then they can
- 44:18go go back to society or they can remain society as they do
- 44:22the community work given the gravity of the situation.
- 44:24But some things are so, so grave that they need to be removed
- 44:29from society and stay years removed and then come back, you
- 44:35know, So like there is this, this scale that the criminal
- 44:40system follows. And because our community, you
- 44:44know, and many other dance community, art communities,
- 44:47there is no, of course, there's nothing like that.
- 44:50Even the smallest things, like you said, for example, my
- 44:53boyfriend's cheated on me. He should be banned, you know,
- 44:57like the gravity of the situation is 1 and the required
- 45:03consequence for that is this another one because we are
- 45:07dealing with someone who had the thing happened to them
- 45:09personally. So they want a strong reaction
- 45:11for whoever is making the decisions in the community.
- 45:15So as someone who studied these things and trains these things,
- 45:21I think in my mind immediately go to this aspects that the
- 45:26things that are learning in in law school.
- 45:29And then I and I think this way. And then when people talk to me,
- 45:33sometimes they want me to have a stronger statement or make a
- 45:40stronger decision or support here, support that and like fast
- 45:46come to a judgement and a decision on something.
- 45:51In this case that we start, we do, we start the episode with
- 45:55like we said it was, you know, it was pretty unanimous the
- 45:59decision giving how bad it is. In all the other cases that like
- 46:04you said, it's a minority of things.
- 46:06So it's like we can count in our hands how many.
- 46:09In the other cases. It's not that simple for me to
- 46:13go and then just to make a decision like that because I've
- 46:17have had a very close friend. He was a dancer, but it's
- 46:21something that happened completely outside of the dance
- 46:26where his case ended up in television.
- 46:29He needed to leave Brazil, he flee to Portugal.
- 46:33And then after years in courts, he was discovered that he didn't
- 46:38do the thing he was accused to do.
- 46:40And prosecution recommended that he goes and file an action
- 46:45against those who filed an action against him.
- 46:48But his life was so completely destroyed already that he didn't
- 46:52want to do, he didn't want anything to do with Brazil
- 46:55anymore or people from there. So he never came back.
- 46:59And I know two other cases like that, too.
- 47:02So for me, it's really difficult at times to come to a conclusion
- 47:07like that and say, this person is the devil you know.
- 47:11So I default to, OK, let's let's look at the complexity of
- 47:16everything. And then based on what we
- 47:18discover, we make a decision. And like you said, it takes a
- 47:21lot of time and a lot of emotional investment.
- 47:24It's pretty hard to do. And that's something that I
- 47:27don't think people, the dancers at large are fully aware or can
- 47:34fully grasp how much, how much goes into making a decision to
- 47:40spend someone or two, make someone stay away from the
- 47:43community for this many months. There's a lot that goes into it
- 47:47that I don't think it's easy to understand if you are not in it,
- 47:52you know, if you're not completely in it.
- 47:55It's very complicated. It's part of the job.
- 47:58That was not in the description when I first started.
- 48:02Yeah. I did so many things, not there
- 48:03anywhere. And it was very surprising to
- 48:06see and to experience these these things.
- 48:10I remember this thing from 2018 that you mentioned.
- 48:13It was it was a big one. And I remember being just like,
- 48:18Oh my God, I just looking to the sides and, you know, like seeing
- 48:21everything unfolds before my eyes because actually heroes
- 48:25also involved. So I don't know, just just
- 48:29slightly ranching a little me. I did something to that.
- 48:34It's difficult. It is very difficult.
- 48:37And I have a question about this whole situation because will
- 48:42this now kind of reset the bar for how the community reacts
- 48:48because this case is such like unanimous, nobody can argue with
- 48:53this case. Will that then in the future
- 48:57make people think twice before like a situation like you
- 49:01mentioned, somebody by accident touch somebody hips or somebody
- 49:05breasts or something like that and then they get bend.
- 49:08Will that kind of shake things up and make people think
- 49:12differently in the community? Or I mean, should they or will
- 49:16they? My guess is no, and I will tell
- 49:20you why. It is extremely difficult to
- 49:25fully remove people who have done really, really bad things.
- 49:28Like the amount of work that goes into that is gigantic.
- 49:33The amount of people who are truly banned from a community
- 49:37over small infractions, very small.
- 49:41And the reason for that is that typically if you're having
- 49:44people who are doing that kind of, I would hazard to say
- 49:47overreaction, right? You're usually dealing with very
- 49:53new or very emotionally charged local politics, Right, Because I
- 49:59can't think of any organizer of a major event where, oh, you
- 50:03know, this person cheated on so they should be banned.
- 50:07I don't I don't think I can think of a single and big
- 50:11organizer who would look at that and go like, Oh yes, they are
- 50:13definitely banned from my event, right.
- 50:16It doesn't reach the threshold for those who have been around
- 50:20to take that kind of decisive action, right.
- 50:23That's more of a local level thing.
- 50:24In my biggest cribe actually with some of the larger events
- 50:29is sometimes we don't do enough action on certain things or
- 50:33using behavioral agreements or like other tools to manage when
- 50:37something is small. And where I do think the current
- 50:41case Ningyi direct things is I, I actually think in this case we
- 50:45kind of got it right. I was a little worried at the
- 50:48beginning because some of the very early gut reactions were
- 50:52extremely charged and kind of throwing everything out of a
- 50:58window. But that shifted.
- 50:59I think there were enough people with a more moderate discourse
- 51:03that we found the right way to handle it in this situation.
- 51:09I think it's a lot thanks to you, to be honest, for your
- 51:13guidance in the community. Very, very much so.
- 51:17I think so too, because I was, I was monitoring the chats and the
- 51:21things. And after you said something the
- 51:24yes, there was like in the timeline of my experience, of my
- 51:28observations, they changed. I saw people changing their own
- 51:32speech after you said the thing. So there was like they had a
- 51:36torch in their heads. And then you said Sophie and
- 51:39they're like, oh, OK, let me put the torch down.
- 51:42You know, it was like not in the shift.
- 51:45So I think you you kind of like spearheaded this one.
- 51:49We pretty much just found about the whole thing almost around
- 51:54this hour after recording last Sunday.
- 51:57And for the first few hours, I was just like lost on the
- 52:02Internet. I was just like, what's going on
- 52:04until you started like posting your things.
- 52:09And then I think the entire community went like, OK, that's
- 52:13where that that's that's how you talk about something.
- 52:19That that's how you you go about something.
- 52:22Let's all recenter refocus because I think everybody was
- 52:26just lost. So thank you.
- 52:28Yes. Thank you for saying that I
- 52:31don't. I don't want to take your full
- 52:33credit for this. I appreciate her recognition.
- 52:37But what I was going to say with that is the moderateness in this
- 52:40face and whether it was like following my lead or other
- 52:44people just felt emboldened or had a similar thought process, I
- 52:48think we kind of got it really right.
- 52:51And like kudos to the new organizer as well for stepping
- 52:56up and seeking the support he needed and taking such steps.
- 53:00But I do think it could serve as a template for what to do in the
- 53:05wake of Ruin and how to talk about things.
- 53:08I don't necessarily think it will change the overall flow
- 53:12with the more Gray issues because I think that the problem
- 53:15with Gray issues continues to be there's no agreements.
- 53:19And when there's a lack of agreements, that's where things
- 53:22get really complicated because people start trenching into
- 53:26their own attitudes, right? This one, in some ways, even
- 53:30though it's so much worse than anything else, is so much
- 53:34simpler. That's.
- 53:35True, there's there's no one who disagrees, but we see it on the
- 53:38Internet like you could take any and poor rising topic take
- 53:42vaccines, take political stuff, take religious things say Tantra
- 53:48Zook. I don't know, but people have
- 53:51strong opinions and people are really, really bad at saying oh,
- 53:56maybe it came on too strong with that.
- 54:00Maybe I should consider another point and maybe I should try to
- 54:04understand before I respond. We're really bad at it.
- 54:07People are really bad at that just overall, and that's what
- 54:12makes the middle ground so challenging for so many people
- 54:16is that we don't want to think, we want to react, right?
- 54:20And even in leadership capacities, the amount of times
- 54:24that I've gotten like a panicked call being like, we need to do
- 54:27something, we need to say something, we need to act now.
- 54:31We need to make our position clear.
- 54:32And I'm like, but what is your position?
- 54:34Have you actually thought about what the rational position is
- 54:37here? Have you thought about how this
- 54:40is going to come across? Have you thought about the
- 54:43impact of what you say? Because the stakes are really
- 54:45low if you're some random person in the community.
- 54:50But the more power and influence you have, the more
- 54:53responsibility you need to take on to make sure you're
- 54:57considering those things because you will change how other people
- 55:02react and they will start modeling on your behavior and
- 55:04echoing your sentiments, Right. So emotional post by random
- 55:10banter that's been dancing six months in a really tiny town.
- 55:15Like, you can afford to have an unreasoned emotional, visceral
- 55:19reaction publicly because the scope of what will be impacted
- 55:25is small, right? But if you are the Prada and you
- 55:28post an unbought full rant on the Internet, you've changed the
- 55:33discourse of the entire community because anyone who
- 55:36follows you, like I'm aware of this in my capacity, but if you
- 55:39follow somebody, there's a lot of people that because they do
- 55:42that same idolization, whatever you take is now the truth.
- 55:47It doesn't matter if you thought it through, it's now true for a
- 55:51lot of people, right? And that's kind of where we, we
- 55:54run into these, these really charged and opposing things.
- 55:58And that's where I see the risk on these Gray areas.
- 56:01And that's kind of why I think we still need to be very aware
- 56:05of as we move forward, getting better at addressing the middle,
- 56:09not the extremes. That's a very random way to get
- 56:13to the point buttons. No, but I think that was a great
- 56:17way to summarize pretty much like the whole conversation, you
- 56:20know, like as a community, it's very clear when it's at the top
- 56:24or at the bottom. But those middle areas is where
- 56:29things just get out of hand, either get out of hand, get out
- 56:32of proportion or maybe are not recognized enough all of the
- 56:38that middle. Ground.
- 56:40It's very interesting because I was listening to a podcast
- 56:44interview with someone who coaches people in position of
- 56:49leadership in terms of what they say and how they say things.
- 56:52And he was saying that there is this trend that people in a
- 56:56position of power avoid saying sorry, avoid apologizing,
- 57:01because it can be seen as like either a sign of weakness or it
- 57:07can be seen as a confirmation that you did what you were
- 57:12accused of doing. And that is the thing that
- 57:16destroys your career. And that's the thing that
- 57:18destroys you in your position, whatever that is.
- 57:22So there is this indication of you don't apologize, you don't
- 57:25acknowledge what you did. And this is something that
- 57:29contributes to the polarization in political world, religious
- 57:33worlds and, and all these things.
- 57:35Because even though someone, you know, in their intimate circles
- 57:40understands that what they did was something, there was not
- 57:43something good for the community that they belong.
- 57:45They would not say they would not acknowledge that they did
- 57:48something because that acknowledgement will maybe
- 57:52disrupt their base, you know, like disrupt the people that
- 57:55support them no matter what they do.
- 57:57And it can be, it can potentially damage in their in
- 58:02their careers. I found that really fascinating.
- 58:07Although we don't have the same level in the dance community, I
- 58:11can see that happening in the way that people express their
- 58:15opinions with such, so strongly. But even even afterwards, the
- 58:20person recognized that their opinion was strong.
- 58:24There is a hesitancy in saying, oh, I acknowledge that my
- 58:27position was strong. They just changed narrative
- 58:31without the the acknowledgements.
- 58:34And like you said, if someone in a small community that just
- 58:38started, it just goes unnoticed. But if someone in a position of
- 58:43influence that is very much noticed and sometimes something
- 58:47that people ask for, something that people required to do,
- 58:51either position yourself or acknowledge that what you did
- 58:55was it was wrong. And there is all this like, like
- 58:59we're saying all this grey area, everything in between.
- 59:02And every time we have something of that magnitude that just
- 59:06happened this past week happening in the community, just
- 59:10all these discussions kind of like resurface and over time
- 59:14goes away again until something else happens then, you know, But
- 59:19there is one thing I think might change is, and I was talking to
- 59:24a friend about it, is that many times organizers welcome us in
- 59:29their homes. They not only welcome us in
- 59:31their homes, but they give us the key of the house, you know,
- 59:35the password of the safe. They like the level of trust
- 59:40that is given to us is so big. Sometimes people give their own
- 59:46bedrooms for us to sleep, and they sleep on the couch, you
- 59:50know? So what this friend of mine was
- 59:53pondering is if the trust that the organizers feel will change
- 59:59in the sense of welcoming us into their homes when we travel
- 1:00:05or if there will be more oversight or if there will be
- 1:00:09less information shared. Very speculative, but it was a
- 1:00:13good point that I didn't think about before because in this
- 1:00:17particular case, although it was not something that happened.
- 1:00:21In the dense scene is something that happened in the House of
- 1:00:24someone who trusted that person and welcomed them because saw
- 1:00:28this person is someone nice for their family and to be around.
- 1:00:33So I think based on this conversation, you resonated with
- 1:00:37me that that could be something that could be a consequence.
- 1:00:41That's something that could change in the way that we go
- 1:00:43about things in the deaf community to be seen.
- 1:00:47I didn't think of that, you know?
- 1:00:49It's very, very interesting point of view.
- 1:00:51I was like, oh boy, that's very true.
- 1:00:53And I was remember all the times that I was left alone in their
- 1:00:57homes with their animals, with all of their things, you know,
- 1:01:03and the things happening. But it just takes one case to
- 1:01:07change the entire landscape of things.
- 1:01:09So I don't know. You know, this conversation
- 1:01:13about like apologizing and taking ownership, I find it very
- 1:01:17interesting that many of us are so bad at it when it's all we
- 1:01:20want from other people. Because like talking about kind
- 1:01:24of like, I know we had chatted a bit of their like restorative
- 1:01:27justice as a principle versus punitive justice, right?
- 1:01:31Like do we punish or do we rehabilitate?
- 1:01:34And one of the biggest things that kind of goes into like
- 1:01:37that, I am not a fan of punitive justice.
- 1:01:41I'm a fan of restorative justice big time because I think people
- 1:01:45are complex and stupid and intelligent at the same time.
- 1:01:48And I think people are capable of pros as a default.
- 1:01:52They have to choose to bro, but they're capable of it.
- 1:01:55And when we think about people who have done something wrong,
- 1:01:59one of the biggest things is can they take ownership and
- 1:02:04recognize the harm that they have caused and being willing to
- 1:02:10take the steps to make it better.
- 1:02:13And I think one of the biggest things that I see people who
- 1:02:17have done something wrong struggle with is they want there
- 1:02:20to be an end goal to rehabilitation.
- 1:02:24Tell me what to do so that I can go back to how it was before,
- 1:02:29right? And as soon as it's approached
- 1:02:31that way, it actually tells me that they're not ready.
- 1:02:34Because the only way that someone can show that they're
- 1:02:38ready is if the conversation is not about when will I be ready?
- 1:02:42It's when will the community be ready for me?
- 1:02:46Can they be ready for me? Right.
- 1:02:47And that might mean waiting until the victim is no longer
- 1:02:51part of the community or making sure that you're not putting
- 1:02:55yourself into situations where people might be uncomfortable.
- 1:03:00It might mean never rejoining the community if it's caused a
- 1:03:04lot of damage. It might mean extensive therapy
- 1:03:08and self worth and apologies and being proactive on managing
- 1:03:13behaviors that may have led to that.
- 1:03:15Like, for example, if someone has mental health issues and had
- 1:03:18sometimes that come into play or substance abuse issues, things
- 1:03:23that may have impaired their reactions, it doesn't mean that
- 1:03:27the community will automatically be ready for them to return.
- 1:03:29But one of the biggest issues that I see is people who take a
- 1:03:33time out and want to come back, but then you talk to them and
- 1:03:37the insight isn't there. The reflection isn't there is I
- 1:03:41know I did a bad thing, but I'm better now.
- 1:03:43And you're like, but we're having this conversation so
- 1:03:45you're not. I know if you were, this would
- 1:03:49not be the conversation that we're having because I wouldn't
- 1:03:52have to tells you why it's inappropriate for him to be
- 1:03:55here. You would have done that
- 1:03:57reflection. You would have asked her for
- 1:04:00participating in the All Star and champion Jack and Jill, just
- 1:04:03example not a realized thing. But you would have asked before
- 1:04:06joining this if everybody was OK with that and comfortable with
- 1:04:10that, if the organizer was comfortable with that optic.
- 1:04:13But you didn't, right. So there are people who have
- 1:04:18rejoined after doing something because they actually did the
- 1:04:22works and what they did was something where they could
- 1:04:26reintegrate, right? I know people who have recovered
- 1:04:29from things and who have rejoined in constructive way.
- 1:04:33But it's hard. And more often than not the the
- 1:04:36greatest barrier to that is just wanting to come from serving a
- 1:04:41place itself. And I actually, I had a case
- 1:04:43where there was someone we banned from the local community
- 1:04:46over things that happened a decade ago when they had been in
- 1:04:50the community before. And the reason why I made the
- 1:04:53decision that they weren't allowed to return what they did
- 1:04:57had been really bad. But technically none of the
- 1:05:00people involved were still around.
- 1:05:02But in the conversation I had with them, they didn't tell me
- 1:05:05everything that happened. I had to find it out from other
- 1:05:07people. They didn't reflect on it.
- 1:05:09They had a rationale for everything that happens right
- 1:05:12there and then when I said no, they got very angry immediately.
- 1:05:18It was like a switch flipped and I saw a completely different
- 1:05:21person sitting in front of me when I told them no.
- 1:05:24And that actually makes the decision much easier.
- 1:05:28Yeah, that's been my issue with some of the people that have
- 1:05:31returned, to my knowledge, is the fact that from the
- 1:05:35conversations that have been present, they either still don't
- 1:05:41agree that they've done anything wrong or they're just leaving a
- 1:05:44complete denial of their fault. And they're just like, but I
- 1:05:49never did anything wrong. Like, OK, then we haven't moved
- 1:05:54a bit. And just to add on to that, you
- 1:05:57know, what's really interesting, there's, there's a few times
- 1:06:00where things were fabricated, right?
- 1:06:03And like I, I know of 1 where there was like a particular
- 1:06:06individual who went to different communities and essentially told
- 1:06:09the same story of it, whatever male pro was it, whatever
- 1:06:12community attached. And it was almost verbatim and,
- 1:06:15you know, caught people's fire and stuff like that from what
- 1:06:19they were saying. And then they hit someone in
- 1:06:20Zook, and the conversations are so different with the people who
- 1:06:26actually don't think they've done something wrong because
- 1:06:30there's this lack of defensiveness because they're
- 1:06:32just like, I really thought everything was OK.
- 1:06:36And I feel horrible. Like I'm trying to think of what
- 1:06:40possibly could have given them this feeling or this impression,
- 1:06:44like unwrapping my brain to pull up the dregs of, you know, did I
- 1:06:50do something? Did I say something?
- 1:06:53Was there something that I did? And it haunts them in like this,
- 1:06:56this deep, deep way that Oh my God, I might have hurt someone.
- 1:07:01And it's such a different conversation and such a
- 1:07:05different just everything, even if nothing actually happened.
- 1:07:10Yeah, it happened to me once in Australia.
- 1:07:12It was part of an event as an attendee.
- 1:07:14Basically. It was one of those times that I
- 1:07:17go to a zoo Congress just because I want to have fun and
- 1:07:20dance all weekend. And at the end of one of the
- 1:07:24nights, somebody came to me at 3:00 or 4:00 in the morning, a
- 1:07:27teacher friend of mine and told me, Hey, I need to talk to you.
- 1:07:30Then they explained the situation that somebody felt
- 1:07:33uncomfortable with one of the dances that I've had on that
- 1:07:35night. And immediately I was like in
- 1:07:38shock. And they, they kind of could
- 1:07:40tell me they're like, you're not aware, were you?
- 1:07:43And I'm like, absolutely not. Where is this person?
- 1:07:46Do they want to talk about it? Do they want to like, what
- 1:07:50should I do next? Because we, we just.
- 1:07:53Yeah. It was very, very much a
- 1:07:56situation where I was glad, very, very happy that somebody
- 1:08:00came to me and told me right away.
- 1:08:02Yeah. Something similar actually
- 1:08:05happened to me. It wasn't, it wasn't related to
- 1:08:08like a dance discomfort. It was actually someone who felt
- 1:08:12I had discriminated against them based on race.
- 1:08:15And I only found out through a podcast several years later that
- 1:08:20they had this oppression because I recognize a story that they
- 1:08:23were sharing. And I was like, I think that's
- 1:08:27me. I think that person that they're
- 1:08:29talking about is me. And there was like a hole, like
- 1:08:33I just went down this rabbit hole of internalized racism and
- 1:08:37wasn't motivated. And, and I can remember the
- 1:08:41conversation going off the rails and feeling it was going off the
- 1:08:44rails and trying to make it better.
- 1:08:46And everything that I was trying to do to like make it better and
- 1:08:49cushion it actually had the inverse effect.
- 1:08:52And it was, it was a very big like aha moment.
- 1:08:56And just like, OK, how do I not repeat this, right?
- 1:09:01How, how do I make sure that this is not the experience
- 1:09:04people have with me? Because this is the antithesis
- 1:09:06of what I stand for. This is the antithesis of what I
- 1:09:09want community to be, right? And it doesn't really matter
- 1:09:13that it wasn't my intention. And it could be, there could
- 1:09:17have been racism involved because the nature of these
- 1:09:21things is that there's all kinds of unconscious biases and
- 1:09:23there's all kinds of like latent conditioning that we have.
- 1:09:27And the best thing that we can do is just reflect and try to do
- 1:09:30better. And that includes both when
- 1:09:33we've been told that we've done something that makes someone
- 1:09:35uncomfortable or feel unsafe. And it also applies when we're
- 1:09:40reacting to highly emotional and sensitive situations where we
- 1:09:44might need to adjust what we do or what we think to make things
- 1:09:49better instead of force and see how can we respond in a better
- 1:09:54way that creates a community that we want to be in.
- 1:09:57Yeah, it's remind me that I've always also been at least in a
- 1:10:01conversation when someone like something similar to happen to
- 1:10:06you too has happened to me as well.
- 1:10:08And I was in a conversation with someone else and in a
- 1:10:12conversation with someone who was like, Nah, but there was not
- 1:10:15so bad. Come on.
- 1:10:16There was just like, we were just kidding.
- 1:10:19We just plain. Do you think I really meant
- 1:10:21that? You know, like it is, Oh my God,
- 1:10:24it's completely, totally, totally different.
- 1:10:27Totally different vibe for sure. Something maybe should be
- 1:10:31mindful of when dealing with situations like that.
- 1:10:34I mean, we're all human. We're all going to make a
- 1:10:37mistake at some point. There's going to be someone
- 1:10:39somewhere who has negative experience with us, whether we
- 1:10:43meant it or not, whether we were having an off day or not,
- 1:10:46whether we made a mistake or it was just a lack of awareness,
- 1:10:51right? But ultimately it comes down to
- 1:10:53ownership and responsibility. Yeah.
- 1:10:57And like you said that you found out about it about it years
- 1:10:59later in the podcast, They have had a situation that happened to
- 1:11:04me not related to dance that I found out six years later.
- 1:11:08It was like during the pandemic. And I get this audio from a
- 1:11:13friend. He was a dance friend from
- 1:11:15Jimmy, like back in the day in the 2007 eight nine.
- 1:11:19And I get an audio from him about something that happened in
- 1:11:23a BBQ party that we participated that when he came to greet me,
- 1:11:27apparently I greeted him with more like more dry or something
- 1:11:33like that. And then he created a whole
- 1:11:34story in his head that he thought that I was upset because
- 1:11:38he was dating the same person that I did it a couple years
- 1:11:42ago. And he thought that my behavior
- 1:11:45had to do with me disapproving of the relationship.
- 1:11:48And that created like this thing for six years until he finally
- 1:11:52like, man, can I tell you something?
- 1:11:54I have been and he was feeling guilty and everything, you know.
- 1:11:58And it was for me a wake up call of like how many interactions I
- 1:12:05might have had with people that they left thinking that I
- 1:12:10disapproved of something or thinking that I did something
- 1:12:14that I will never know. Or one day I will know.
- 1:12:19Like on the podcast or on like a 8 minute long audio message that
- 1:12:24comes out of nowhere on WhatsApp.
- 1:12:26You know? And this is mind boggling to me
- 1:12:29just to confirm that the exact same episodes can be interpreted
- 1:12:35in a wide variety of ways and that this wide variety of ways
- 1:12:41are all true to the person who is interpreting.
- 1:12:46And they leave with this impression or they leave with
- 1:12:48this thinking that we did this thing that we might never know,
- 1:12:52you know, And it's a little bit, I know it's when I think about
- 1:12:55that, I just want to stay in my room and never leave.
- 1:12:59But but I think it's just like something to that, you know?
- 1:13:04I know about it, but it still breaks my brain from time to
- 1:13:07time. I love hearing like stories of
- 1:13:10reflection like that 'cause I think it it's enonizes a lot of
- 1:13:15things. It's much easier to accept the
- 1:13:17flaws in ourselves when we can see other people as flawed but
- 1:13:23still be able to hold empathy and well, Ferda.
- 1:13:25And I think that that's something that we can just
- 1:13:27collectively improves, especially when we're trying to
- 1:13:31deal with kind of these charge situations, is to stop making it
- 1:13:34right or wrong and just reflect on the humanity of it and
- 1:13:38finding the best path forward in the circumstances.
- 1:13:41And sometimes the flaws are minor and don't leave a bunch of
- 1:13:45a follow up. And sometimes mistakes are made
- 1:13:48that require something more right or actions for somebody
- 1:13:52and need to be addressed in a more significant way.
- 1:13:56But ultimately, if we're expecting perfection, every
- 1:13:58single person is going to fail at some point.
- 1:14:01And we can't expect it of ourselves and we can't expect it
- 1:14:04of others. They can just try to do better
- 1:14:07constant. Though Yeah, yeah, I just want
- 1:14:10to say that I heard this thing super beautiful.
- 1:14:12Another day that Ester Perel says confidence means that
- 1:14:16understand yourself as a flawed creature, but it still holds
- 1:14:20yourself in high regard. And I and I really, really like
- 1:14:24that because she was saying that normally confidence is confuses
- 1:14:28cockiness and like understanding that nothing that you do is
- 1:14:32wrong, that everything you do is good and correct.
- 1:14:35But she said it's a misconception that is actually
- 1:14:38understand that you will make mistakes, but it still hold
- 1:14:41yourself in high regards and acknowledging that you are a
- 1:14:45flawed human, you know, So I really like that and have been
- 1:14:50reflection that ever since. And now that it just said that
- 1:14:52Laura, just you brought back this coach that I just heard.
- 1:14:56So just wanted to mention that because I found it very
- 1:14:58beautiful. For me, as you were speaking, if
- 1:15:02you rollback the video, see that I just went away on a trip for a
- 1:15:07second because like it made so much sense to me with so many
- 1:15:12moments in my life where I felt like I was wrong or misjudging
- 1:15:19the entire situation. Making a Long story short, I've
- 1:15:23made so many mistakes in my life, personal life,
- 1:15:26professional life, all of the lives, all of the areas, and
- 1:15:31I've learned so much from it. And I love that I've been able
- 1:15:35to learn so much from it. But when somebody else makes a
- 1:15:39mistake, somebody else is on the fire and everybody's talking,
- 1:15:44talking, talking and throwing stones and everything like that,
- 1:15:47I always feel like thinking about the person, thinking about
- 1:15:51like, what about what? What about them?
- 1:15:54You know, like, were they OK? How, how did somebody get to
- 1:16:00that point? Because I feel like connected in
- 1:16:04a way that I've been in so many dark places in my life and I've
- 1:16:09made terrible decisions when I was in those dark places that
- 1:16:13the first thought in my head is like, how bad was this person to
- 1:16:18get to the point of doing something like this?
- 1:16:21You know, so, and most of the times I just feel like I'm the
- 1:16:24odd one because everybody else has a very strong opinion about
- 1:16:29it. And I'm, I'm like on the
- 1:16:30opposite side, kind of like, yeah, so it made a lot of sense
- 1:16:35to me. It was very nice, very
- 1:16:37validating. I mean, there's absolutely in
- 1:16:40play. This is just more for like the
- 1:16:42general public. There's absolutely nothing wrong
- 1:16:44with having this strong commence, but you're responsible
- 1:16:47for what you do with that strong opinion.
- 1:16:50And like as I said earlier, it's not the victim's job to have a
- 1:16:55rational, logical response to trauma that has happened.
- 1:16:59It is not the job of someone who has been hurt by a person to
- 1:17:04find an empathetic orientation to process what has happened.
- 1:17:07It is not their responsibility. But if you're anyone else and
- 1:17:12you want to create a healthier community, you have to look at
- 1:17:16how do we put antiseptic on the wounds?
- 1:17:20Not salt, right? How do we calm it down?
- 1:17:24Not not sweep it under the rug, not pretend it didn't happen,
- 1:17:28not justify it, not erase a harm that has been done.
- 1:17:32Because all of these things are really little things and don't
- 1:17:34have to be a bad person to cause harm.
- 1:17:36He can also be a bad person and cause harm relatively.
- 1:17:40But you need to look at what response is going to help
- 1:17:46instead of fruit, Is what I'm saying me posturing for social
- 1:17:50media likes? Or am I contributing to
- 1:17:54something that's going to make this the better?
- 1:17:57Because if you're just yelling to yell because you know, people
- 1:18:02will comment and you get that little like, adrenaline boost
- 1:18:05when you see, oh, 200 people. I've liked my my post.
- 1:18:09Yeah, I did good. Uh huh.
- 1:18:11Then you're probably not coming at this from the best direction
- 1:18:14because that should not be the payoff.
- 1:18:16That should not be what you're seeking.
- 1:18:19You should not be seeking validation for holding your
- 1:18:21strong opinion. You should be looking at what is
- 1:18:24constructed to the community, what is going to help, what is
- 1:18:27going to seal, what is going to validate the experiences of
- 1:18:33those most affected by this in a way that is empathetic and that
- 1:18:37is reasonable and doesn't center you, who literally have nothing
- 1:18:42to do with this, in the center of a conversation that really
- 1:18:46should be centering the people immediately affected.
- 1:18:50All I can say is, wow, we are so, so lucky to have you in our
- 1:18:57community, not only because you're a beautiful person inside
- 1:19:01and out, but also because you're a very knowledgeable person who
- 1:19:06just has the biggest heart to help everybody who just knocks
- 1:19:13on your inbox or talks to you in person in any place that I've
- 1:19:17ever seen. So thank you, thank you, thank
- 1:19:19you so much for being here and for sharing all of this with us.
- 1:19:24Thank you for inviting me to be a part of it.
- 1:19:26I missed the the part of it, so I'm glad to see that.
- 1:19:30Yeah, I was going to say that we will invite you more back,
- 1:19:34Laura, to do more episodes, to talk about more things, because
- 1:19:39I think more people need to hear you as much as they read what
- 1:19:43you write. I think it's going to contribute
- 1:19:46a lot for the conversations we have here.
- 1:19:49Yes, please. Please write more.
- 1:19:51I don't know if we have that much time nowadays, but I've
- 1:19:55always loved reading your blog. Your blog.
- 1:19:59They're beautiful. I do have a couple.
- 1:20:02They're a little bit older now, but I do have a couple articles
- 1:20:05on how to navigate that behavior within a community.
- 1:20:08So within always a link to that or something like that, so that
- 1:20:12people. Can yes, we can post a link to
- 1:20:14that, access those descriptions of this.
- 1:20:16So once again, thank you, Laura. Thank you Guy for being here.
- 1:20:20This is an episode that for me and there were so many light
- 1:20:26bulb moments and moments that I think that will help a lot of
- 1:20:31people who are listening in the community for years to come.
- 1:20:35So thank you guys for being here.
- 1:20:38It's my pleasure. Thank you lots and thank you so
- 1:20:40much, Laura, the soul. So valuable insights and I will
- 1:20:44be hearing this episode again. That's true.
- 1:20:47You know, just so refresh the memory of several of the things
- 1:20:51you mentioned. Thank you all.
- 1:20:53Righty then, thank you so much everybody for listening and we
- 1:20:58hope that you enjoyed it. Please follow us on our YouTube,
- 1:21:03Instagram, Spotify, TikTok, all of the things if you want to
- 1:21:07keep up with our full episodes or our little short episodes
- 1:21:12that we post in our social media and we'll see you on the next
- 1:21:16one. Thank you, thank you Vicious
- 1:21:18versions, Abrasos and Ciao.