Latest / Credit Union Exam Solutions Presents With Flying Colors / Why Raising Deposit Insurance Could Hurt Credit Unions
Transcript
- 0:02Speaker: Hey everyone, this is Mark T Trike with another episode of With Flying
- 0:04Colors Again, flying solo here today.
- 0:07So I saw an article in the Wall Street Journal which caught my
- 0:10attention, and that's what I'm gonna be talking about here today.
- 0:13And I'll just say it's not often that I agree with the big banks in
- 0:17America, but I do in this instance.
- 0:19And it's not often that I disagree with politicians when you have the
- 0:23DS and the R'S agreeing on something, which doesn't happen very often.
- 0:26So with that.
- 0:27I'm going to jump into the Wall Street Journal article that I saw
- 0:31this morning, which is big banks are fighting a new $10 million FDIC cap.
- 0:37So that's where I agree with the big back banks and what they're
- 0:40fighting and why I fight it is I think it would be very bad for credit
- 0:44unions if that got put in place.
- 0:46And I'll walk through the article and I'll explain why.
- 0:49An increase in the insured.
- 0:51Insured deposits to $10 million at FDIC, I think would be bad for credit unions.
- 0:56So the sub headline is Scott Bessett and Elizabeth Warren want
- 1:00to raise the deposit insurance cap.
- 1:02A Senate bill proposes a 40 fold increase, so 40 fold would be 250 K to 10 million.
- 1:08Here's the article.
- 1:10In a nightmare scenario for the nation's biggest bank banks, treasury
- 1:15Secretary Scott Bassett and Senator Elizabeth Warren, Democrat from
- 1:18Massachusetts both want to raise the $250,000 limit on uninsured shares.
- 1:25That unlikely alliance is boosting efforts from mid-size banks that argue
- 1:29higher caps would help deter Rapid bank runs like those seen during the
- 1:332023 failures of Silicon Valley Bank.
- 1:37Signature Bank.
- 1:38Their efforts have helped spark a Senate bill that proposes raising
- 1:42the insurance limit to as much as $10 million for certain accounts.
- 1:47For the biggest banks, which are the primary funders of the FDIC
- 1:50corporation, a cap of that size would come with a hefty price tag.
- 1:55Deposit insurance has proved a dilemma for banks, regulators.
- 1:59And lawmakers.
- 2:00While 250 K is a lot for a consumer account, many businesses were holding
- 2:05far more in accounts at Silicon Valley Bank and raced to pull their money out.
- 2:10Fearing they would lose it in the event of a collapse, but increasing the limit
- 2:14risks emboldening banks and depositors to take more risks and could make financial
- 2:19crises much more costly for the FDIC.
- 2:23Banks backstop.
- 2:24The FDIC deposit insurance funds, not taxpayers.
- 2:28They pay quarterly, quarterly premiums and special assessments.
- 2:31If the FDIC fund needs to be re topped after a failure, their
- 2:36contributions are largely determined by their size and riskiness.
- 2:40In late 2023, big banks reported collectively paying more than
- 2:44$9 billion to replenish the FDA's deposit insurance fund.
- 2:49With JP Morgan Chase funding 2.9
- 2:51billion and Bank of America ponying up 2.1
- 2:54billion.
- 2:55Smaller banks also contributed, but in smaller amounts,
- 2:59despite their chunky payments.
- 3:01Big banks were largely seen as the winners of the 2023 crisis since deposits shifted
- 3:07from the regional banks into their vaults.
- 3:10That has driven a renewed interest in insurance reform
- 3:13with Bessant Warren and others.
- 3:15Viewing a raise to the cap as a way of providing a critical bulwark for smaller
- 3:21banks as behemoths like JP Morgan have come to dominate the playing field under
- 3:26the Senate bill Co-sponsored by Senators Bill Haggerty and Angela also Brooks.
- 3:31The $10 million limit would only apply to the type of accounts that the set
- 3:35at the center of the 2023 bank runs are those typically used by businesses for
- 3:40payroll and other operational expenses.
- 3:43Silicon Valley Bank, which catered to technology, startups and high net
- 3:47worth venture capitalists, held a high number of so-called non-interest
- 3:51bearing transaction accounts.
- 3:53In the lead up to the crisis, more than 94% of the bank's deposits were uninsured.
- 3:59Shortly after the bank's failure, the government government announced
- 4:03that it would be making an exception to the insurance policy and, and
- 4:06would make all depositors whole.
- 4:08In an effort to stop the crisis from spreading to other banks, the
- 4:12largest banks would be eligible for the additional insurance.
- 4:15Those types of accounts under the proposed bill, but would still have access to the
- 4:19250,000 max payouts for all accounts.
- 4:23We wanna, we want to get back to a level playing field, Bassen said at a
- 4:27conference on community banking at the Federal Reserve earlier this month.
- 4:31While he hasn't endorsed any specific legislation, the Treasury
- 4:34Secretary has been pushing the Senate to advance the Haggerty.
- 4:37Also, Brooks Bill.
- 4:39Some regional banks saw their share of the country's deposits decrease during
- 4:43the 2023 crisis as businesses fled to the safety of larger institutions
- 4:48perceived to be too big to fail.
- 4:51Smaller community banks have also been on the ropes.
- 4:54The number of community banks in the US has declined by
- 4:56about 45% for 45% since 2020.
- 5:01But editorial comment.
- 5:03About the same amount of reduction in credit unions.
- 5:06Raising the limit for transaction accounts would help smaller banks compete
- 5:10and would also require big banks to start paying for some of this insurance
- 5:14coverage that they've implicitly.
- 5:16Been receiving for free.
- 5:18Senator Warren has said the sudden emergence of a bipartisan push to
- 5:22raise the limit more than two years after Silicon Valley Bank's failure has
- 5:26caught some in the industry by surprise.
- 5:28The last raise to the insurance cap, which occurred in response
- 5:32to the 2008 financial crisis.
- 5:34Was from a hundred thousand.
- 5:36Big banks have so far been sharply critical of the Senate bill and
- 5:40have questioned the rationale for the $10 million figure.
- 5:43A massive expansion of FDIC insurance is unwarranted and would do little to
- 5:47improve the fundamental determinants of bank safety and resilience.
- 5:52Sean.
- 5:52Campbell head of a policy research at the Lobby Group Financial Services
- 5:56Forum wrote, while midsize banks were broadly supportive of the bill, community
- 6:02Banks typically defined as a bank with less than 10 billion in assets.
- 6:05FYI just like credit unions.
- 6:07Have been less uniform in their response.
- 6:10The Independent Community Bankers of America on October 14 said it was
- 6:14endorsing the $10 million cap bill after lawmakers added a provision
- 6:19exempting community banks from paying for any associated costs with
- 6:23the, with the raise for 10 years.
- 6:28But some community banks skeptical of the proposal said Christopher
- 6:31Williston, chief Executive Office.
- 6:34Chief Executive of the Independent Bankers Association of Texas, which counts
- 6:38many smaller banks among its members on member visits this month, Williston said
- 6:43he asked about the deposit insurance reform and found hardly anyone who
- 6:47thought 10 million was the right number.
- 6:49Some said 1 million, some or 2 million, or maybe 5 million would be helpful.
- 6:54Coming up with the right number is tricky for lawmakers.
- 6:57Regulators acknowledge that they have limited data, which would assess.
- 7:01With which to assess the size and distribution of non-interest bearing
- 7:05transaction accounts across the country.
- 7:07The health and wellness of the deposit insurance fund is something we should
- 7:11make sure we don't lose sight of.
- 7:13Williston said you're just talking about more expensive bank failures.
- 7:19Then there's a correction in amplifications the
- 7:21independent com community.
- 7:22Bankers of America said it was Endor.
- 7:24It was endorsing the Senate bill with $10 million cap proposal.
- 7:28An earlier version of this article incorrectly said.
- 7:30The Independent Community Bankers Association made the endorsement.
- 7:34Even the Wall Street Journal makes mistakes, stakes, apparently.
- 7:37Okay, so.
- 7:38Back when Silicon Valley Bank and Signature Bank imploded they ignored
- 7:43the insured levels and then it got real political and they bailed
- 7:47them out with some phone calls over the weekend to the the powers that
- 7:51be at the Biden administration.
- 7:52And Janet Yellen bailed them out, said it wasn't a bailout, but bailed 'em out.
- 7:57So now we've got both sides saying for big business accounts checking accounts,
- 8:02non-interest, bearing checking accounts, those should have a $10 million.
- 8:06Insurance about meaning that the, when they failed, you'd still be paying those.
- 8:11So the, a net effect would be maybe there wouldn't have been a
- 8:15run because they would've said, oh, we have $10 million insurance.
- 8:19And then they wouldn't have had to pull the plug and, and say, Hey, we're gonna
- 8:22give you insurance that doesn't exist.
- 8:24But if that same thing, if 10 million wasn't enough and you had a Silicon Valley
- 8:28bank and everybody had a hundred million and they had 98% uninsured deposits.
- 8:32The treasury would cave and the insurance fund would lose
- 8:36the disciplines that it has.
- 8:39Now, the other problem I have with this is if the FDIC gets it, what
- 8:43does, what do credit unions get, and let's just say it happens to be in
- 8:48these, these business type accounts?
- 8:50Well, guess what?
- 8:51Credit unions will lose their business type accounts.
- 8:53If the N-C-U-S-I-F doesn't have.
- 8:56The matching insurance amount, right?
- 8:59So well then you say, okay, let's go get the matching insurance amount.
- 9:03So the FDIC gets 10 million.
- 9:06The trade groups run and say, Hey, we need to have 10 million too.
- 9:09Well what 10 million does that apply to?
- 9:11Right?
- 9:12So I did some simple math and if we, and, and this is a big assumption I'm
- 9:18making, but if we look at the data.
- 9:22Roughly recently, rough justice 12% of deposits in credit unions are uninsured,
- 9:27which is a good thing compared to banks.
- 9:29They don't have the big deposits.
- 9:32If we assume that 90% of that 12% is in business type accounts, which may
- 9:38or may not be accurate, but just for the sake of argument, let's say it's
- 9:4190% of those 12%, that gets us to 10.8%
- 9:46of that.
- 9:47Of shares that would need to be insured.
- 9:50Okay, so 12% times 90% is 10.8%.
- 9:54If we look at the net operating level, that NCO a's goal is, it's just 1.33
- 10:01versus the current operating level of the net of the N-C-S-I-F, which is 1.28.
- 10:07If we inflated.
- 10:09The sh the numerator and the denominator.
- 10:13If we, if we inflated the denominator by 10.8%.
- 10:17Okay?
- 10:18So for every dollar of insured shares in the N-C-U-S-I-F, there is now $1 and 10.80
- 10:25cents.
- 10:26Credit unions would, would put in a deposit of that amount.
- 10:32To get so that their, their required 1% was in the N-C-U-S-I-F.
- 10:39The problem with that is N C's denominate Numerator is the $1 that credit unions
- 10:45put in plus 28 cents of retained earnings.
- 10:47So 1.28,
- 10:49that's where the operating level, the, the current net operating level comes from.
- 10:53So 1.28
- 10:54divided by one is 1.28,
- 10:57but if you have 1.28
- 10:59divided by 1.108.
- 11:01The current operating level falls to 1.1
- 11:045, 5 2 3.
- 11:06Didn't round that.
- 11:07So 1.16,
- 11:08let's say that.
- 11:09So the problem with that is that the Federal Credit Union Act requires
- 11:15where's the specifics I have on this?
- 11:18So it would require a, the statutory minimum of the N-C-O-S-I-F is 1.2%.
- 11:25So falling to 1.15
- 11:26would trigger a mandatory requirement for NNC A to either assess a
- 11:30premium or adopt a restoration plan.
- 11:33Now again, the trade groups would say, we don't want the full premium,
- 11:36we need a restoration plan, and we wanna get it back up to the required
- 11:41level by a certain amount of time.
- 11:43And my recollection is that NCUA.
- 11:46Can only bring the ratio back to 1.25%
- 11:49unless they decide that they wanna go above that to get to the 1.33%,
- 11:56which would get credit unions and the trade group screaming.
- 12:00So.
- 12:02If NCUA if Congress was to ensure credit union deposits up to the
- 12:0910 million, and assume that 90% of the 12% that are uninsured were in
- 12:15the type of accounts that would be insured, that would drop it to 1.15%.
- 12:21Okay.
- 12:22And NCOA is currently saying via its most recent.
- 12:27Operating level the equity ratio was at 1.28,
- 12:32as I said, and the normal operating ratio is at 1.33%.
- 12:36So if they kept the normal operating ratio at 1.33%
- 12:41and it dropped to 1.15%.
- 12:44NCUA could do a premium backup to the 1.20
- 12:50which then would leave no margin for air.
- 12:51They could do a, a assessment up to the 1.28
- 12:55to get it back to where it was.
- 12:57They could do it up to 1.3%,
- 12:59but they can't go over the 1.3%.
- 13:02Only above.
- 13:031.30
- 13:05has to be the result of retained earnings from the insurance fund.
- 13:08So the reality is if this number goes up, and if most of it was to be insured there
- 13:15would be a big premium that would take money out of your cash account at credit
- 13:19unions and put it in to the N-C-O-S-I-F deposit account, and which means you can't
- 13:25borrow it out, you can't use it as your cash, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
- 13:29Not a good thing.
- 13:30And if they don't get the number increased for those types of accounts, then those
- 13:36types of accounts would move to banks.
- 13:38So again, my example was a, an aggressive amount saying 90% of 'em
- 13:43would be member business type accounts and is probably closer to half of that
- 13:48or a third of that, pick a number.
- 13:50But it would impact the operating norm, the equity ratio and would then put.
- 13:57The equity ratio further away from the normal operating level,
- 14:00putting pressure on the board.
- 14:02Currently the board of one, to assess a premium or develop a plan.
- 14:07And again, that gets really, really political when that all plays out.
- 14:11So in the final analysis, I think the 10 million sounds good to Bassett..
- 14:16It sounds good to Elizabeth Warren.
- 14:18But I think it's more lipstick on a pig because I think 'cause a, a
- 14:22failure comes along in a Silicon Valley bank type institution, you're
- 14:27gonna have a council over 10 million.
- 14:29Those, a council over 10 million are gonna scream bloody murder to their
- 14:32friends in DC and then voila, they're gonna cover it over the limit anyway.
- 14:36So if that's the case.
- 14:37Why increase it?
- 14:39I would be much more supportive of something that puts a cost of
- 14:43living increase or a cost of deposit insurance, increase that if a dollar
- 14:48today is worth a dollar and then going forward with inflation in five
- 14:52years, a dollar is a dollar five.
- 14:54I would say that a $250,000 limit should go up.
- 14:59By 5% that, that makes more sense to me than this jump from 250 to 10
- 15:05million and without it with, without changing the rules for credit unions.
- 15:11At the same time, you have the haves being the FDIC insured banks and
- 15:15the have nots being credit unions.
- 15:16But then when you do it, you gotta look the reality in the face and
- 15:19what that does to the insurance fund.
- 15:21And the politics of that gets real ugly real quick.
- 15:24All right that's all I've got on that topic for today.
- 15:27There were a couple other things I wrote down.
- 15:29There was also an article in the Wall Street Journal I posted on,
- 15:34on LinkedIn about the repo man saying repos are going through the
- 15:38roof, which is not a good sign.
- 15:40And I also saw articles that were touting how good credit unions
- 15:46were handling giving interest rate loans to their members due to the
- 15:50federal government shutdown which was getting some really good coverage
- 15:54on Capitol Hill, which is, you know, showing the credit union difference.
- 15:57So that's cool.
- 15:58Those credit unions that are out there, some of them I, I
- 16:01know quite well are doing that.
- 16:02I, I really.
- 16:03Appreciate that as it's good anecdotal evidence that credit
- 16:07unions are, are doing a good job.
- 16:09Alright, that's it.
- 16:10This is Mark reel signing off with flying colors.
- 16:12I hope you will listen again soon, and I thank you for listening or watching.
- 16:17As always, thanks again.