Latest / Inside Commerce: Ecommerce Strategy, CX and Technology Podcast / EP298: The Future Of CMS For Ecommerce: The Evolution of Page Builders, Headless CMS and AI Code Generators with Rotate CTO Jim Tattersall
Transcript
- 0:00They could find it quite hard to see the opportunities outside of
- 0:02it. The other one is that this is
- 0:03right for me now, but in 24 months, right?
- 0:05Business agility is so crucial, right?
- 0:07You kind of go, oh, this is the right decision Now look at the
- 0:09rate of change at the moment. It's absolutely phenomenal,
- 0:12right? There might be ACMS that comes
- 0:13out in six months time that blows everything out the water.
- 0:16An e-commerce platform that blows things out the water in
- 0:17six months time. We don't know, right?
- 0:19Having business agility and flexibility, we're not logged
- 0:22into decisions as well. This is the right decision now.
- 0:25We don't know if it's the right decision in 12 months.
- 0:27We don't know, but we have to have a certain level of business
- 0:30and agility so that we can change.
- 0:33You listen to Insidecommerce, a weekly ecom strategy, technology
- 0:36and CX focus podcast hosted by experienced digital consultants
- 0:39and re platform specialist James Gedacle Rogers.
- 0:41Get insights into ecom strategy, leading brands, hear from
- 0:44industry thought leaders and leading tech vendors with
- 0:46practical advice to help you improve your online CX.
- 0:51This podcast is sponsored by Shopify.
- 0:54Our topic today is an interesting one is what's the
- 0:56feature of CMS for e-commerce? So looking at the evolution of
- 0:59page builders, where Headless is headed, and also the advent of
- 1:02Gen. AI into content generation and
- 1:05where the PIM space might be evolving to as well and how the
- 1:08those technologies dovetail together.
- 1:11So before I set up why we're talking about, it's a warm
- 1:14welcome to a guest who's been on previously.
- 1:17So Jim, who's the founder at CTA Rotate.
- 1:19Hey, Jim, good to have you back on.
- 1:21Great to be back. It's such a short period.
- 1:23I've missed you. It's great to be here.
- 1:25Excellent. You probably eat your cards.
- 1:27Stay away from us. So you know, So for those who
- 1:30haven't listened to a previous episode yours, you want to give
- 1:32it a a a little bio of who you are and what rotate is.
- 1:35Yeah. So Rotate is a kind of
- 1:38composable commerce agency. We've been going for 12 years.
- 1:42I've been a developer since, well I've been coding since the
- 1:44late 90s. But yes, we are a 30 person
- 1:48strong technical partner and we worked with the likes of Rafa
- 1:52and Jamie Oliver, Track Smith at Big Green Egg and lots of great
- 1:56brands that we're proud to work with.
- 1:58Amazing. Thank you.
- 1:59And we've recently had Jim on along with Seth.
- 2:01He's the VP Marks, and that's a conversator to talk about the
- 2:06impact of AI on coding and how that might change the ratio
- 2:09between agencies and e-commerce brands.
- 2:12We're diving into specifically the CMS side and because all
- 2:15three of us spend a lot of time working with various brands
- 2:18around like content management strategies or RE platform and
- 2:23look at the role the CMS plays within that.
- 2:26And things are changing. And the way different business
- 2:29types use CMSS and what they need from them is changing and
- 2:33the limitations people face with specific bits of technology can
- 2:37have a pronounced impact on, on their way of working.
- 2:40So Paul, do you want to kick off?
- 2:41Let's let's get this started. Yeah, absolutely.
- 2:44The only other thing I was going to add for like pre context is
- 2:47that I think we we just all jumped on this and then started
- 2:50to think actually, let's cover all of the questions in the
- 2:54first half and then maybe move on to kind of where how this
- 2:57area is going to evolve and like where AI fits in and everything
- 3:00else. So it is we are riffing a little
- 3:03bit between us, but I personally think it'll be a really
- 3:05interesting discussion. And for the first question, So
- 3:09what is the role of Acms and how does this vary by business type
- 3:15or size? And I guess like, yeah, why, why
- 3:17do your customers tend to use ACMS and where does it sit?
- 3:22Yeah. So I suppose it's like saying in
- 3:24terms of the type of business, I think one thing, you know,
- 3:27within this space that we forget is that not every brand is
- 3:30e-commerce first. Some brands are kind of content
- 3:331st and e-commerce is actually like a secondary on to their
- 3:35business. And I think the other thing is
- 3:37actually as businesses evolved, that kind of changes over time.
- 3:40They might be content 1st and then they kind of move into
- 3:42being e-commerce 1st and all this kind of stuff.
- 3:44So sometimes it's kind of right, you know, around that.
- 3:46But often actually as they grow and they change, they kind of
- 3:49hit pain points or they see opportunities and that's why
- 3:52they kind of, you know, bring it in.
- 3:54So it might start off with something like storytelling.
- 3:56I think that's quite a common one and as native kind of page
- 4:00bills get better, you know, like to fight, that's less of a
- 4:02demand, but I think storytelling is often one of them.
- 4:05I think sometimes it's just a headless byproduct, which is I
- 4:07think is the worst. You know, when it's kind of
- 4:09like, oh, we're going headless and now we're going to need to
- 4:11have a headless CMS apart this. Sometimes they bring it in as a
- 4:15kind of pseudo PIM. So they bring it in to kind of
- 4:18almost have a very light PIM. So they might not have a massive
- 4:21inventory, but they want to have a light PIM where they have kind
- 4:24of structured, consistent kind of product data.
- 4:27Then you get things like content publishing flows.
- 4:30Actually the team evolves, they've more people involved and
- 4:32actually want a better editorial and publishing kind of flow.
- 4:36And then there's also things like multi, multi headed, right?
- 4:40So it's like, cool, we've just got a store and then you might
- 4:43have multiple stores on different e-commerce platforms
- 4:46potentially in different markets.
- 4:48I mean, obviously traditionally people have multiple shop
- 4:51finances, that's less of a thing now.
- 4:52But there are obviously clients who have licensing agreements
- 4:55and things like this where actually in different
- 4:57territories they have completely different ecommerce platforms.
- 4:59Or it might be an Alexa skill. It might be, you know, for
- 5:04completely different areas of the business.
- 5:05Actually having a consolidated centralised kind of data or or
- 5:10content layer becomes really, really important as a business
- 5:12kind of grows. Yeah.
- 5:14I, I think the critical thing here is what type of business
- 5:17and what size and complexity and what does content mean.
- 5:19Because I, I've worked with quite, we will work with
- 5:23probably relatively different styles of businesses, although
- 5:26there is some, if we put a vendelogram, there'd be some in
- 5:28the middle that are quite similar.
- 5:30So working with with businesses that are that where digital
- 5:35content is purely for online and an e-commerce store, that
- 5:38simplifies the need for content management massively because
- 5:41you're not doing distributed content and different content
- 5:43formats to different digital outputs.
- 5:45And often then it is it's looking at a page build, it's
- 5:48looking at component design and it's looking at flexible
- 5:51components that can be used in different ways across different
- 5:53user journeys. And the bit that normally is a
- 5:57compromise is the publishing piece where people are willing
- 6:00to live with not so much depth of publishing control unless
- 6:04they're working in a more global environment where that becomes
- 6:06critical and then they'll maybe build some additional on top.
- 6:09Where I see the CMS challenge being the hardest for digital
- 6:14teams is where they have like a big store estate and they have
- 6:16digital take digital screens within stores and they're
- 6:20wanting to put contextually relevant content into different
- 6:22stores based on the location of where there's regional store
- 6:25specific and they've got different screen formats in
- 6:28different places and they're doing like digital other
- 6:31channels and they're looking like interactive on top of it.
- 6:36Then all of a sudden you realise that the the role of ACMS is
- 6:39fundamentally different and the need for workflow based content
- 6:43management and for tighter publishing schedules becomes
- 6:46much much harder. And that's that's not so many
- 6:51businesses to do. But for me, the role of the
- 6:53CMFCMCMF, that's a totally different acronym.
- 6:56Don't know what that means but it's it's really determined by
- 7:02the complexity of the businesses content needs.
- 7:06Yeah. And I think that often changes
- 7:07over time, right? As in I think as a business
- 7:09becomes more, you know, more mature, actually their focuses
- 7:12expand and they kind of realise actually the capacity of
- 7:14advantage of having a really strong content arm.
- 7:17And actually how that's, you know, in terms of longevity of
- 7:19the brand and actually building up brand equity, how important
- 7:21that is and consolidating that and having like tools to kind of
- 7:25really supercharge the team around that is becomes more and
- 7:28more vital as a business kind of matures quite often.
- 7:30One, one thing I was going to add as well, So you mentioned
- 7:33Shopify and I don't want to eat into the next question because
- 7:36James is going to ask a question the second around native page
- 7:39builders. But I think it's really
- 7:41interesting with Shopify in particular because they've
- 7:44obviously like really improved the kind of ability or
- 7:48flexibility around product data and there is a lot more room for
- 7:53like complex catalogues and, you know, having, you know,
- 7:57complexity within matter fields and everything else.
- 7:59But it does feel like they're still quite far behind from a
- 8:02content perspective. And I think there was a lot of
- 8:05talk a couple of years ago from them around the time they
- 8:10invested in which few of us did they invest in.
- 8:13I forgot sanity, sanity. I thought it was sanity around
- 8:17the town they invested in that where they were going to
- 8:18introduce like native content models and like a lot more
- 8:21flexibility. But I do feel like as much as
- 8:24it's very intuitive, I feel like from a yeah, content models,
- 8:30workflows shows you all of that perspective, they're still quite
- 8:33far behind. What do Mattel, Victoria,
- 8:37Beckham, Sennheiser and Glossier all have in common?
- 8:42They power their businesses with Shopify.
- 8:46Shopify is the most innovative and scaled commerce platform on
- 8:49the planet. It also happens to have the best
- 8:53converting check out on the planet Shopify Powering the
- 8:58future of enterprise commerce. Find out more at
- 9:01shopify.com/enterprise. Yeah.
- 9:05And I think this list bleeds into the next question
- 9:07perfectly, which is about constrained to native page
- 9:09wheel. Because when we're looking at
- 9:11tech or content management, you always want to reduce
- 9:14complexity, right? You don't want to add in tools
- 9:16for the sake of it, which might not be used or might add in
- 9:20additional challenges for like upskilling, learning and
- 9:23integration. But native page builders, which
- 9:26is where people normally start, have limitations.
- 9:28And one of the big limitations is workflow publishing and the
- 9:32ability if you're on a team I've worked with, with teams where
- 9:36they are making changes to a single page multiple times a
- 9:39day, that's the cadence of their content changes.
- 9:43And you know, a legacy back from like a sales force.
- 9:46Although it's very basic in terms of the interface, one
- 9:48thing it does quite effectively is allow you to schedule content
- 9:51slots and do that and have that complexity.
- 9:54It's not what you want from a modern interface, but the, the
- 9:57capabilities there. Then you flip to a modern like
- 9:59SAS product and you look at but and actually the publishing
- 10:02workflow isn't there. But that's my starting point
- 10:04about there are constraints. But Jim, what do you see in
- 10:07terms of when, when people are working away to pay bills?
- 10:09What are the bits that you guys are seeing when you're coming up
- 10:12with the constraints where you have to build worth around?
- 10:15Yeah, I think ultimately looking at this high level, it's
- 10:18completely different paradigm and it's completely different
- 10:21relationship, right? Whether you're looking at native
- 10:24CM s s built into something like Craft or you're looking at
- 10:26native, you know, CM s s built to Shopify.
- 10:28You know, the idea is actually because it's like this
- 10:31monolithic platform which have loads of advantages.
- 10:33It's not just, you know, I know, composable fanboy, but the key
- 10:38thing is actually your presentation layer and your, you
- 10:41know, and your input is really quite heavily coupled, right.
- 10:45And I know in terms of things like catalog information and
- 10:48stuff like, you know, e-commerce platforms have gotten better
- 10:51with this sort of stuff. But in terms of actually a page,
- 10:53a lot of it is kind of like a this one to one relationship
- 10:55between input data and like presentational output.
- 10:59A good for me, a good kind of like headless CMS kind of is way
- 11:04less, you know, it cares way less about the final
- 11:08presentation. And the great thing about this
- 11:09is obviously that's the part that you change the most, right?
- 11:15I spout this a lot internally, right?
- 11:16Like the further the technology is away from like the end user,
- 11:20the less you iterate on it, right?
- 11:21So that the front end experience we're constantly iterating on
- 11:23right? Now, if you've got this one to
- 11:25one relationship with data input, that means you can quite
- 11:28quickly and especially with like the Shopify, you know, Cogen
- 11:32stuff that's come out with, you know, Glock, if you can quickly
- 11:34create blocks and you'll each time you've got new kind of
- 11:37inputs directly for that. And I go, well, quite quickly.
- 11:40You're going to end up in quite a lot of administrative like
- 11:42issues here, unless you then build a layer on top to kind of
- 11:45like manage that at a higher kind of level.
- 11:47So I think at a high level, you kind of go at like the first
- 11:50thing is quite a, you know, a power line shift where you're
- 11:53kind of going, actually, this isn't about building, this is
- 11:55about content 1st and kind of going this is the content.
- 11:58And then think about how that flows into presentation and
- 12:00accepting that as a business, how you present and how you
- 12:02communicate to your audience. It's going to change over time.
- 12:05And if you want to change a styling of something that
- 12:08shouldn't really have much implication to the underlying
- 12:10data. But with the native white
- 12:12platform, it has a real, you know, close and kind of like
- 12:15hard connection. So you're, you've got a few
- 12:17issues, right? You are, you've got these
- 12:19constraints. We've got this one to one
- 12:20relationship. Therefore, you've not got
- 12:22generally good underlying structured data that you would
- 12:25like to, you know, it's like cool FAQs, you know, like all
- 12:28these are on the products and then they flow through on an
- 12:30individual like level or maybe that, you know, how that data
- 12:34interacts with the experience. And I think the kind of over
- 12:38time, you just see these workarounds again and again.
- 12:40And for me, that's like one of the key things where you kind of
- 12:43go, oh, it's time, you know, the time is now, right?
- 12:46When people are kind of duplicating loads of content,
- 12:49you know, like your entire content team of losing their
- 12:51hair because they're just, you know, they're inputting the same
- 12:54thing in lots of different locations and the data becomes
- 12:56more and more kind of unstructured.
- 12:58And then you start leaning on 3rd party plug insurance to kind
- 13:00of work around this rather than stopping and kind of going
- 13:03actually, we need to clean this up.
- 13:04We need to have a more structured approach.
- 13:06And actually data is so and content data is so imperative
- 13:09for the business that we need to make sure that this is kind of,
- 13:12you know, it's part of IP. So let's make sure that it's
- 13:14kind of like true to the such. Yeah, I I think that's such a
- 13:17good point because one of the one of the limitations without
- 13:20creating hacks. So if you have a a standardized
- 13:23component that you want to be able to have in multiple
- 13:27locations, but you update it once and then it populated out
- 13:31all those pages. You can, you can duplicate
- 13:33things, but you're working on page template by page template
- 13:35basis. Therefore, you don't have that
- 13:39that I update it here and I can then make sure it's repopulated
- 13:44to a six or seven places appears without using more advanced
- 13:48implementations of it. So that, yeah, for some teams
- 13:51that becomes much more painful in terms of a time management.
- 13:54Base, I think my previous point just to caveat is slightly I
- 14:00think was probably more for very content LED businesses in terms
- 14:03of where you know, there's still quite a lot that needed from a
- 14:07Shopify perspective. But I do think they have
- 14:11improved a lot since I've interviewed matter objects and
- 14:13like you know pushed sections since they started moving from
- 14:17that point. That's obviously having a knock
- 14:21on impact in terms of I guess how the market receiving
- 14:26headless and the need for more control in this area and a
- 14:29headless CMS is part of a border front end stack.
- 14:33In your from your perspective, how are you seeing these vendors
- 14:37kind of evolving based on the change in this landscape as shop
- 14:44fibre? Others as well are getting a bit
- 14:46more, are getting a bit stronger in this area?
- 14:49Yeah, I mean, I think for for the NGS there's I mean just
- 14:53taking shop fires and incidents, right, There are fewer reasons.
- 14:57So my, you know, to go, to have a, you know, to be fully
- 14:59headless like then there were, I mean, I was thinking about a
- 15:03project we did, you know, eight years ago, right, where, you
- 15:06know, for Tracksmith, we were headless CMS.
- 15:08We did this. We didn't go headless in terms
- 15:10of Shopify, we had a completely headless CMS.
- 15:12And then when you put in the data, it kind of actually
- 15:14created that code and injected the straightest software.
- 15:16But yeah, sorry, sorry, I've completely lost my train of
- 15:22thought. But in terms of there's less of
- 15:26a need now, sorry, that's my point.
- 15:27There's less of a need now because as they evolve, you
- 15:29know, when there was wasn't markets and things like that,
- 15:31there was obviously less of a need in terms of like the CMS
- 15:35kind of platforms in terms of how they're treating things like
- 15:37this. Different CMS, headless CMS
- 15:40platforms have very different kind of approaches to this,
- 15:43right. So some of them like sanity or
- 15:46contentful try to be very front end agnostic and they don't
- 15:51really care about that too much. Then you've got things like I'd
- 15:53say builder IO and also I think like storyblock where there's
- 15:59actually they're kind of taking what Shopify's doing, you know,
- 16:03they they're kind of creating that one to one relationship.
- 16:05You know, they're very visual 1st and they're kind of just
- 16:09mirroring that. I feel this is like quite a
- 16:13before it wasn't much of a thing, but as we kind of now get
- 16:16into this place where Shopify is really pushing forward, I think
- 16:18this will be a split and actually the arguments for
- 16:20moving some from something like Shopify to story, but I think a
- 16:23less less, you know, enticing than they have been previously.
- 16:28I think something like sanity, it's just a complete sanity or
- 16:30consentful, like it's just a completely different offering,
- 16:33right? So it's a different kind of like
- 16:34construct that they're kind of like pushing.
- 16:37So, so yes, that's you answer your question.
- 16:40I went on a ramble so I'm not sure I think.
- 16:42It does and I think it's kind of dits of what you were saying
- 16:45there. Definitely.
- 16:46I think another thing that I think we might see is more
- 16:49consolidation around third parties that support a core ecom
- 16:56platform. So like is a good example where
- 16:59you're seeing some CMS vendors like invest more time into in
- 17:04terms of like media storage and like manipulation.
- 17:07And I feel we'll see more of that maybe PIM as well
- 17:09potentially. But this kind of takes me on a
- 17:12little bit to the next question. So I think you talked a bit
- 17:15about, you know, within the last editions and within Shopify's
- 17:19New Horizon stuff, they've moved to kind of the ability to use AI
- 17:23to build a component and maybe there's a bit more kind of no
- 17:27code shifting in terms of managing content in the front
- 17:31end generally. How do you think this will
- 17:35change how brands? And I guess that's just Shopify,
- 17:39but then in alongside shop boundary, obviously I've tried
- 17:43to avoid just making things about shop fire.
- 17:45Well, obviously they are a big proportion of the industry and
- 17:47everything else. But alongside that, you know
- 17:50you've got all the kind of no code paid builders as well and
- 17:54other platforms that are kind of targeting that same space.
- 17:58How do you think that will change how people look at these
- 18:02page builder solutions and CMS solution?
- 18:05Yeah, from a from a gem AI perspective specifically.
- 18:08I think as a result of that shift where maybe they're almost
- 18:13training people and I think the same applies with, yeah, some of
- 18:16the other CMS solutions out there, like more fully featured
- 18:19CMS solutions. Do you think that's kind of
- 18:23maybe training the industry? To think that they don't
- 18:28necessarily need it. Yeah, I mean, I think again that
- 18:32there's definitely a fork in the in the road, right, where you're
- 18:34getting some places we're kind of going actually, we're going
- 18:37to try no more like some CMSS that's saying we're going to try
- 18:39no more of this, right? We're going to try and own
- 18:42personalisation. We're going to try and own like
- 18:44insights where, you know, cohort segmentation, all this kind of
- 18:48stuff. And they're trying to own more
- 18:50and more and more. And I think that's where it's
- 18:52going to get quite a tension point because obviously Shopify
- 18:55is trying. I shall fight over so much of
- 18:57it, right? You know, and you're either
- 19:00going to, as you know, people already do, you're already, you
- 19:02know, see, obviously lots of vendors kind of going cool,
- 19:04we're going to push search to Algolia, we're going to push
- 19:06this to this. And I think that's where you
- 19:08kind of get the attention for the platforms because now more
- 19:11than ever, some of these headless platforms are really,
- 19:13really overlapping. I would say sanity contempt full
- 19:17less so I'd say like builder IO, you know, story block to a
- 19:21lesser extent, Dato to a lesser extent.
- 19:24They are, you know, there is that kind of like friction and
- 19:27you're right totally in terms of things like media management and
- 19:29dam and taking that over. I mean, you know, I feel you
- 19:34look at something, you know, people like cloud ring stuff.
- 19:35It's like, oh, this is quite challenging because actually
- 19:39it's quite convenient to kind of go actually this is already
- 19:41stored here. We don't have to connect with
- 19:42third party dam. You know, this stuff is kind of
- 19:45pretty evolved now and says what people are looking for in terms
- 19:47of the dam. So yes, I think I think it is
- 19:50pushing forward. I think we are kind of going to
- 19:52end up in a real kind of tension point.
- 19:53I think the CMS is that are going to like do well out of
- 19:56this are the ones who have a differentiated kind of like
- 19:59paradigm within this. Like Gen.
- 20:01AI looks so different in something like builder compared
- 20:05to compared to something like sanity, right, because sanity
- 20:09doesn't care about the presentation.
- 20:11The sort of Gen., you know, Gen. IAI stuff it's doing is kind of
- 20:14going. Cool.
- 20:15You've got this audience say for instance, we've got we're doing
- 20:18this with brands at the moment. We've got an audience and
- 20:21there's quite different cohorts, right.
- 20:22And we do really rich kind of personalization.
- 20:25We're saying, actually, we've got an audience that are 7, two
- 20:28to like 80. We've got an audience that are
- 20:2920 to 30. We want the same page to
- 20:32communicate so differently to these people, reference
- 20:34different products, like different kind of tone of voice,
- 20:37all this kind of stuff. And you're like, cool, well,
- 20:40this can all be automated from a content perspective with AI and
- 20:43sanity's technology at the moment does such a great job at
- 20:46this sort of these sort of tasks.
- 20:48So you kind of go, cool, that's great.
- 20:50And then also things like I'm launching in Japan.
- 20:53Cool. I want to translate every piece
- 20:55of content we've done. Even though it's all really
- 20:57structured from a data perspective, I want to translate
- 20:59it all into Japanese. Here's like my tone of voice for
- 21:02the Japanese market. So that's what kind of, I
- 21:05suppose Gen. AI looks like in that space.
- 21:07And it's a mixture of, you know, generating like truly new
- 21:10content, transforming content to kind of, you know, different
- 21:13image, I mean, even different imagery, right?
- 21:14You imagine like an econ page, right.
- 21:16And you're talking about the benefits of, I mean, the client
- 21:19moment, talking about the benefits of collagen right now,
- 21:21if I'm talking to a, a younger audience or an older audience,
- 21:24the sort of models I want to be using in that I wouldn't be
- 21:27pulling different kind of assets in.
- 21:28So it's more relatable when it's more compelling a story right
- 21:31now, I know we have, and this is the, the, you know, the spectrum
- 21:34of personalisation, right? But quite often personalisation
- 21:37doesn't need to be really completely unique to everyone.
- 21:40And you kind of actually know, I do want to have more curated
- 21:42experience, manually curated experience for like tighter
- 21:45cohorts and for things like that.
- 21:47That's the sort of space that someone like Sanity that seem
- 21:50like contentful is kind of like where they are.
- 21:52Whereas obviously Shop Fi is looking at this from a, you
- 21:55know, OK, it's got translations and stuff, but it's looking at
- 21:57from quite a different perspective, right?
- 21:59It is more kind of tied to that actual end experience and it's
- 22:02more kind of tied to like generating code and actual like
- 22:05fronts and experiences. And Builder is actually doing
- 22:08this sort of stuff as well. So they're just turning to very
- 22:11different kind of type types of platforms and where it kind of
- 22:14settles. I'm not really sure.
- 22:17Helpful answer, right? No, I think this is this is a
- 22:20really important conversational point because the ecosystem that
- 22:25you are sat in as a as a business will influence where
- 22:29you go with tooling. Because if you are in take
- 22:33centre for example, by default you are not using the native
- 22:37page builder. Therefore you're using a third
- 22:40party CMS and it suits. I think then it changes the
- 22:43dynamic in how businesses think about content from strategic
- 22:46level as part of a project to, to launch on the platform.
- 22:50Because you're not working within a constraint of a theme,
- 22:52you're not working in constraint of the, the, that capability.
- 22:56You're thinking about what is the content that you need and
- 23:00then you can then you are also thinking about future.
- 23:03Well, I might not be ready for personalisation.
- 23:06I might not have the bandwidth in my team to generate the
- 23:08assets that Dr. personalisation for 5-6 segments even if I've
- 23:11got really cool bit of AI able to help on that.
- 23:16But I might, I'm going to be there in 20-4 months and I need
- 23:18my tool ready for that. If you go down the locked in
- 23:21route where you're using a page builder, yes, the capabilities
- 23:24will extend, but they're never going to get to that level.
- 23:27I cannot see that happening in the foreseeable future.
- 23:30Then you've got the other dynamics on that, which is what
- 23:32else might you be trying to achieve from a site content
- 23:36point of view in terms of SEOURL structures, analytics and data
- 23:41for everything you want to track, which informs your
- 23:43analysis. That then drives your
- 23:45optimization of your content, your merchandising, etcetera,
- 23:48which should be thought of in the terms of content management.
- 23:51Because what can you, what can you put from a data layer and an
- 23:54analytics tracking point of view about having loads of extra
- 23:56third part. So you get all of these
- 23:59additional dependencies you need to think about in terms of where
- 24:02you are now and where you're in future.
- 24:03And I think the ecosystem point is really important because the
- 24:05plan and you buy into will have a pros and cons for all of those
- 24:09areas. Such a massive point.
- 24:12That's that's such a massive point.
- 24:13I love it because you know, you're, there's a few things you
- 24:16said that really, really resonated 1 is that actually
- 24:18people when they're in an ecosystem, they find it quite
- 24:20hard to see outside of it. They can't, they find it quite
- 24:22hard to see the opportunities outside of it.
- 24:25The other one is that you said like, oh, this is right for me
- 24:27now, but in 24 months, right? Business agility is so crucial,
- 24:30right? You kind of go, oh, this is the
- 24:31right decision now. And it's like no one knows.
- 24:33Look at the rate of change at the moment.
- 24:35It's absolutely phenomenal, right?
- 24:37There might be Acms that comes out in six months time that
- 24:40blows everything out the water. An e-commerce platform that
- 24:42blows things out the water in six months.
- 24:43Like we don't know, right? And having business agility and
- 24:46flexibility. So you can kind of go, look,
- 24:49we're not logged into decisions as well.
- 24:50We this is the right decision. Now we don't know if it's the
- 24:53right decision in 12 months. Like we don't know, but we have
- 24:56to have a certain level of business resilience and agility
- 24:58so that we can change. I think This is why I'm always
- 25:01banging the drummer out of composability.
- 25:03I know I'm so boring about it, but like, but that for me is the
- 25:06fundamental core thing about composability, just kind of
- 25:08giving business agility and saying actually, you know, you
- 25:12made the right decision now that would change or business change
- 25:14would change, opportunities and challenges would change.
- 25:16And so you need to be kind of adaptable, especially in a time
- 25:19where technology is moving at a rate that I've never seen.
- 25:22It's like totally exciting, but also from a, from a vend, you
- 25:26know, from a merchant's perspective, probably quite
- 25:28scary at the same time. I think I just wanted to comment
- 25:32on that because I think, I mean, we could do a whole episode on
- 25:34this. But I actually think one of the
- 25:35most, one of the biggest variables in the industry and
- 25:38the all the ecosystems and everything else right now is
- 25:41that speed of change thing and the speed that technology and
- 25:45businesses are moving at. And I think I was going to do a
- 25:48big post about actually, I think it's, but I decided not to.
- 25:51But I think it's the easiest it's ever been to build
- 25:55something from a tech from any perspective right now, like
- 26:00business and tech. And I think it's the hardest
- 26:03it's ever been to scale something.
- 26:05And I think the reason for that, I mean, I've seen so many people
- 26:08build product that are like insane and they're so good.
- 26:13And they've got to a certain point, they've got to a certain
- 26:15level of usage. And then suddenly a load of
- 26:19other vendors in the industry will introduce that
- 26:21functionality and or you will get additional vendors go and
- 26:25raise 20 million VC money and then blur them out the water.
- 26:29And then suddenly this company is pivoting.
- 26:31And I just think there's this crazy cycle at the minute.
- 26:36And it's like, it's amazing for innovation, but it's, I think
- 26:39it's really scary. But yeah, it's it's nuts.
- 26:43And like the speed that you're seeing these businesses move at,
- 26:46it's just ridiculous. This is a tangent, to be honest,
- 26:51but I think you talked about it. And I actually don't think that
- 26:54many people are talking about it.
- 26:55And I think it's, yeah, it's, it's nuts out there.
- 27:01Yeah, great point, really good. Carry on.
- 27:02We'll carry on with the podcast now that I I'm.
- 27:05Waiting for that post though, Paul.
- 27:06We'll wait for that post It. Yeah, I think, I think it's such
- 27:08a really, really important point, right.
- 27:10And like saying it's easier to spin stuff up now than ever.
- 27:13And actually being able to adapt and change once you're kind of
- 27:16there, it's that much, it's that much more challenging.
- 27:18And you said you tools are kind of popping up every day and it's
- 27:20like, how do you navigate that? So the one thing for Shopify is
- 27:23like their rate of evolution is pretty amazing.
- 27:26Like I don't know a business that invests in R&D like they
- 27:28do. It's insane.
- 27:30And I suppose the one thing is, you know, actually you're in it
- 27:34like the tough thing is that your innovation and what's right
- 27:36for your business might not perfectly lie, but they are
- 27:39bringing you things all the time, which is a great
- 27:41competitive advantage in itself. But it might be that actually
- 27:44quite often with a certain size of business maturity that
- 27:46actually the things that are unique to your business that
- 27:48that really differentiates you in the market aren't going to be
- 27:50things that come out-of-the-box, which I think is where it kind
- 27:52of gets a bit challenging. But anyway, another podcast.
- 27:56Yeah. And not really an interesting
- 27:58discussion because I think talking about this in the
- 28:00context that shop fires are is like is super interesting.
- 28:03And I think there's so many things that they're doing that
- 28:06are like under the radar that are just going to make them so
- 28:10hard to compete with for anyone else.
- 28:12But yeah, we'll skip this and move back to the backups, back
- 28:16to. The.
- 28:17Backups. Paul has finished his party
- 28:19political broadcast for sure. And now we will talk about
- 28:24technology agnostic CMS. But it isn't interesting because
- 28:31because the whole point of this episode was to to help
- 28:34e-commerce teams, people working in the e-commerce teams to
- 28:36understand where the entries go and what the implications are,
- 28:38how you make bad decisions. And the reality is the speed of
- 28:42change in the shocked by ecosystem.
- 28:44It does create a warp of perspective.
- 28:46And I'm not mean that from a critical point of view, but it's
- 28:49I think sometimes that makes it hard for people to then
- 28:53understand the differences and the pros and cons between
- 28:57different platforms, approaches, etcetera.
- 28:59So I mean, let's come on to another question because I think
- 29:02this is an interesting one as well, which is the CMSS are
- 29:05rapidly evolving, whether that's headless vendors increasing
- 29:09their capabilities. You were talking to him only
- 29:10about the personalisation capabilities of some sanity or a
- 29:14page builder. Yeah, launching it's Gen.
- 29:16I Gen. AI capability and and you know,
- 29:19improving it's publishing capabilities.
- 29:23So at what point do these, are these tools going to like make
- 29:29the need for a PIM superfluous or will a PIM always from a
- 29:34content management point if you play a fundamental role?
- 29:37Because you've got Paul, you're talking about before we start
- 29:39recording modern Pims like Mfas who are doing some really cool
- 29:43things and they're building in content capabilities.
- 29:46So Gen. II capability, you know,
- 29:48translations around like SEO stuff.
- 29:51So is there a convergence or is the PIM side I'd come to you
- 29:57first and you know is the PIM side changing away from its core
- 30:01around just structured product data?
- 30:06Yeah. I mean, I think with all of
- 30:07these things and I think that, you know, in terms of like, I
- 30:10suppose motivations for even going headless in the 1st place,
- 30:13right? There has to be a business case
- 30:16for it. I think so often there isn't,
- 30:17right, which is kind of crazy. And the same thing for a pin
- 30:20PIM. Sorry.
- 30:21You know, you've got to look at what your businesses
- 30:25opportunities and challenges are, the impact this is going to
- 30:27make and and just like ground it in in business, kind of like
- 30:32reasoning, right? So if you've got a small CAF, I
- 30:34mean, for us, for, you know, clients we work with, if they've
- 30:37got a small, smallish catalog, we won't we won't use a PIM
- 30:39quite often. We'll use, you know, we pretty
- 30:42much exclusively work with headless CMSS and we'll use a
- 30:44headless CMS to kind of as a PIM, a light PIM, right?
- 30:49And actually, you know, like Jamie Oliver, for instance, I
- 30:52mean, it's not a PIM, but you know, a huge, enormous recipe
- 30:55day space like, you know, decades of and it's like, cool,
- 30:58it was kind of structured in a pretty chaotic way.
- 31:00And it's like, OK, no, this is this is almost like a PIM of
- 31:03sorts, right? And actually we're going to
- 31:05store this, have the data structured and all this kind of
- 31:07stuff. So I think in terms of the role
- 31:08of PIM, a lot of the things that PIM is doing in, you know, M
- 31:11fast union in terms of like some of the AIAI stuff, it's quite
- 31:15similar to some of the headless, some of the head of CMS kind of
- 31:19like moves as well in terms of kind of going actually, we're
- 31:22going to and you can build on top of it as well.
- 31:24So with sanity, for instance, you might kind of go, here's the
- 31:26main information about a product and then it'll kind of just
- 31:29decorate all these additional things based on that.
- 31:32From an AI perspective, if that's not supported, you can
- 31:34build your own kind of AI actions and all this kind of
- 31:36stuff. So there will be, you know, a
- 31:39point, but ultimately the pin differentials will be the kind
- 31:42of ones that they always were right, which is kind of going
- 31:44OK. So I want to quickly look up,
- 31:46you know, like products once certain reporting on the kind of
- 31:49like product inventory and all this kind of stuff.
- 31:50So I think it's scale. The arguments for a PIM is still
- 31:53there. I don't think the CMS will take
- 31:55over and I think it's CMS tries to take over that space.
- 31:58You'll end up with a pretty crappy product because it won't
- 32:00be focused on actually what it's called kind of intent is meant
- 32:03to be. So as I said, for me, for a
- 32:05business with not enormous product catalog, I would argue
- 32:08generally you're going to be fine with a good headless CMS
- 32:10like the structure dated there. For you know a business with
- 32:13enormous catalog, I'd still at the moment recommend you know
- 32:16using a dedicated PIM. Yeah, that makes sense.
- 32:21And the next one to kind of going back to the kind of core
- 32:24use cases for headless CMS. So under what circumstances have
- 32:29you seen the needs for headless CMS and when isn't it needed?
- 32:32And one thing I would say as well, because I know that you
- 32:35guys are very well known for their, you know, your work in
- 32:38the composable base and headless, but I know you also do
- 32:41work with like liquid. And I guess you ever use any of
- 32:44these specialist bird party in situation where you're not
- 32:49actually working on a head lift though?
- 32:52Yeah. So I mean the signs that
- 32:54business as I said like previously, like ultimately you
- 32:58have to start with the business case.
- 32:59I know you guys would be advocates for that, right?
- 33:01Like actually what the challenges, what are the
- 33:02opportunities of business? Does this make sense bringing
- 33:05this in, because obviously when you bring in head to CMS, it
- 33:09often brings in a lot of other kind of like caveats and
- 33:12trade-offs. And so you've got to be really
- 33:13intentional about it. Signs that a business kind of
- 33:17like needs to move to something like that.
- 33:19They said like your content team are completely stressed out.
- 33:21Them, you know, productivity and velocity has like massively kind
- 33:25of gone down. You're hacking the platform like
- 33:27that's such a classic one. Like you'll be, I mean, you'll
- 33:30you would have all seen it. You're going to, you know, your
- 33:32econ platform of choice and you look at this like you've worked,
- 33:36you've hacked the system to make this work.
- 33:38And actually, therefore the editorial, you know, experience
- 33:41has become absolutely horrific. And obviously then, you know,
- 33:46kind of content, you've got lots of content that's living outside
- 33:48of the like the native kind of platform in spreadsheets and
- 33:51Notion, all this kind of stuff. Your editorial processes are
- 33:54really slow and repetitive. Data is duplicated and
- 33:57inconsistent. You know, ultimately the way I
- 34:00see a headless CMS is I'm going like the primary user is the end
- 34:04user, right? They're the people buying the
- 34:05products, whatever. But then the next most important
- 34:07user is like the actual editorial, you know, the
- 34:11editorial kind of like user. And it's like, if I can improve,
- 34:13prove their productivity, if I can improve their workflow,
- 34:16how's that going to impact the business, right?
- 34:18What how's that going to impact them in terms of how fast they
- 34:21can move? They're kind of like a
- 34:22competitive advantage. And I think that's where it
- 34:25comes really messy because you look at this and you kind of go,
- 34:28you're hacking ancestor so much. This is, it's crazy what you're
- 34:31having to do. And ultimately what you've
- 34:33realized if you've gone, we've now built A-Team, we've built
- 34:35processes and a team around a platform rather than designing a
- 34:39solution around a team and their objectives.
- 34:42And I think fundamentally that's what it kind of comes down to.
- 34:44You kind of go, oh, we've got all these people and they're all
- 34:46working and they're doing all these hacks to kind of like
- 34:48create what they want to create. It's like, no, this is, this is
- 34:51ugly, crazy what you're trying to achieve.
- 34:53Now let's just design. And that's a great thing with
- 34:55the, like we said, the CMS is they're so flexible.
- 34:58You can completely design the interface.
- 34:59And if you want to kind of go, you know, you click 1 little
- 35:02tick box and that creates like loads of blocks of all this
- 35:04information pulled in data from what you can do that, right?
- 35:07But it's understanding how we accelerate, how we empower,
- 35:10like, you know, merchant teams to kind of move fast and they
- 35:14would be able to otherwise. Yeah, I'd like, I'd like to come
- 35:18back to the Jamie old for example, actually, and I think
- 35:20be interesting for people to hear, hear the that, that
- 35:23migration pop and building antennas and what they what,
- 35:27what they the development benefits, but also the benefits
- 35:29to merchants, but some of the challenges.
- 35:32So, yeah, I'd love to like if you could pull out a few
- 35:34highlights from from that process and also a few gotchas a
- 35:38lot what people need to think about because the people are
- 35:40thinking, right, we're constrained.
- 35:41Actually, we should be going to a special CMS.
- 35:44We know like, you know, the the path is not littered with gold.
- 35:46There's always challenges. What, what, what were the, the,
- 35:50I guess the development of benefits for you and what are a
- 35:53couple of the key learnings through that process?
- 35:57Yeah, I mean, I think from from our side, from an agency side,
- 36:01we want to empower the client as much as possible.
- 36:03So we want to design a system where it empowers them as much
- 36:06as possible. We don't want to be doing
- 36:08anything that is not completely unique to what we can do.
- 36:12So if we can design a system that completely empowers them,
- 36:14kind of, oh, I can spin up, you know, these, you know, loads of
- 36:18different landing pages. I can do personalization, I can
- 36:20do experimentation, I can do this all without an engineer.
- 36:24That's great because then the things that we're working on are
- 36:26the things that are truly unique to us that while we're adding
- 36:28the highest kind of value. And I think that's, you know,
- 36:30where we often, you know, we don't want to be fighting the
- 36:33system. We want to empower the client
- 36:34somewhat Combined velocity is as fast as possible.
- 36:38In terms of Jamie Oliver, they were like battling with
- 36:42multiple, multiple WordPress kind of like databases.
- 36:46One of those was a database of recipes, which is as you can
- 36:49imagine, absolutely enormous because it's decades worth of
- 36:52recipes, the data really poorly structured and from them we're
- 36:56like this is this is like your intellectual property.
- 36:59This is jamieoliver.com. You know, their recipes is kind
- 37:02of like their primary, you know, intellectual property, right?
- 37:04So you kind of go this is we need to kind of put this on the
- 37:06pit at all this deserves. Now that just sits in a headless
- 37:10CMS and the migration path for that was obviously it.
- 37:13To be honest, it was way quicker than someone might think.
- 37:15You know, within a week we built a migration script which kind of
- 37:17just went into all these different kind of like databases
- 37:22and then kind of remodeled the data.
- 37:25And an engineer spent just under a week kind of like designing
- 37:27that migration kind of like script.
- 37:30And then obviously that kind of, and then that was run and then
- 37:34all the kind of recipes in a way more structured format things,
- 37:37you know. And once it's all structured,
- 37:39you can kind of go, OK, let's look up the average time for a
- 37:42chicken recipe. Let's look at like you can
- 37:44leverage that data in way more intrusive ways.
- 37:46And if you think for them as a business, having that as a
- 37:49really accessible, good content structured data means that they
- 37:53can leverage that IP in a multitude of ways.
- 37:56That wasn't really possible when it was this kind of weird one to
- 37:58one relationship with kind of like presentation and all this
- 38:01kind of stuff. And when you're looking at like
- 38:03a migration like that, you might kind of some of it quite often
- 38:06you're kind of actually we're migrating this content, but in
- 38:08addition to that, we have these extra fields that we want to
- 38:10capture. Now additional data like Gen.
- 38:14AI is really good in this, you know, in this instance where you
- 38:16kind of say actually we're going to pull this information in, but
- 38:19we also now need this information and the core like
- 38:22the data's in there, but it's not in a format that we want it
- 38:25in. So you might say there's a
- 38:26description and we're going to use that to pull out.
- 38:29You know, say for instance, you had a big content block and it
- 38:31has all the ingredients in it. And you say, cool, OK, AI pull
- 38:35out the ingredients from this structure this in this format
- 38:37instead and do this. And I think that's where things
- 38:40kind of get really nice, where it's that sort of, you know,
- 38:42that kind of play where you kind of go actually this is where AI
- 38:45is just way more effective, right?
- 38:47Otherwise, we're writing a script to kind of go read
- 38:49through this, look up against a database of of ingredients, pull
- 38:52these things out. So that's where you kind of see
- 38:55those kind of real benefits in terms of speed, adding a light
- 38:57touch of AI just to kind of get the data to a better place.
- 39:00As I said, once the data's there, how you can leverage
- 39:03that, especially in the space we're in at the moment.
- 39:05Especially like with technology moving on so quickly, having
- 39:08really clear, clean, underlying data, structured data is so
- 39:13powerful. AI is only as good as the data
- 39:15and the contextual awareness you're kind of giving it.
- 39:17And actually, if you format that in a structured way like, you're
- 39:20going to be setting yourself up for success.
- 39:22Yeah, I think that that makes a lot of sense of where I'm seeing
- 39:26the where I'm potentially seeing the future like divergent in
- 39:29terms of when people stick the native versus going to
- 39:31specialist is I think the publishing and workflow thing or
- 39:34at least like core publishing capabilities will be sold by
- 39:38lights with shopified relatively soon.
- 39:40I know it's been worked on. I don't know when, but so I
- 39:43don't think where people have simple, non high level
- 39:46personalized content needs and non complexities journeys.
- 39:50I don't think the publishing thing will be an issue in the
- 39:52future or where I think it will be, will be where there be style
- 39:56of the data and the structure of it needs to be closely
- 39:59controlled and manipulated and used in different ways for
- 40:01different user journeys or different user types.
- 40:04I've, I can definitely see where where that will be a future
- 40:08briefing for brands. But Paul, what, where's your
- 40:11let's do some parting thoughts on this.
- 40:14Where are you? Where are you seeing this going
- 40:16in terms of? Of the type of of when paid
- 40:20builders are going to be solving the the need for business versus
- 40:23when actually these specialist EMS composable approach is
- 40:26actually going to be beneficial. So I personally think the need
- 40:29for what is available on the market today will shrink.
- 40:32Pretty quickly. However, I think those solutions
- 40:36will evolve and double down on more advanced functionality
- 40:41within the areas we're already covering.
- 40:43I think they'll start to do more in the dam space.
- 40:46I think I'll have their own AI capabilities.
- 40:48I think, yeah, personalization, segmentation, reporting, I think
- 40:53there'll be. And I think this applies as a
- 40:55rule to the whole industry. Like I think businesses like
- 40:58Shop buy just going to get bigger and bigger and bigger and
- 41:01then the specialist solutions are just going to have to double
- 41:03down down on functionality that they will never be able to get
- 41:06quite a deep in see that, that's kind of where I think that we'll
- 41:11get, I think the solution for just go like, yeah, broader
- 41:15around content and yeah, automation and yeah, anything
- 41:20around that. Yeah, and Jim, your your parting
- 41:24thoughts and wisdom for the masses.
- 41:27I'm not sure about that, but but yes, I yeah, I completely agree
- 41:30with you know, everything that kind of like Paul said, right, I
- 41:33think a lot of the kind of fundamental CMS functionality
- 41:37that's been there for a long time shop.
- 41:38Five will. You know, they'll lock it down,
- 41:40they'll get it and they'll kind of push it out.
- 41:42I think where things the reality is obviously Shop 5 is trying to
- 41:45do a lot of things right. Whereas if you're dedicated CMS,
- 41:47you're quite, you know, now you're more narrowly focused.
- 41:49I think the CMS is that stay narrowly focused.
- 41:51It will serve them well, you know, just to be because they'll
- 41:54be able to drive innovation in a much kind of smaller space.
- 41:57So someone like sanity is an example.
- 41:59As I said, if you're right now, I can build a workflow insanity
- 42:03where I kind of write some content and I say run workflow.
- 42:06It will then do the translations.
- 42:07It will create multiple versions for different kind of like
- 42:10different cohorts. It will, you know, set up an
- 42:13approval process for like my, you know, for my boss, but like,
- 42:17but it will do all these things for me, right?
- 42:19And that's where it's at. That's where it's at now.
- 42:21I mean, and when, you know, Shopify brings this things,
- 42:24sanity will move on in all these different ways, but they're
- 42:26focused and that's why I like them.
- 42:28They focus on that narrow kind of like, we're going to do this
- 42:30one thing. We're going to do it really
- 42:32well, probably better, you know, than anyone.
- 42:34And Shopify won't be able to catch up on that.
- 42:36But what Shopify will do is move ahead in so many other ways.
- 42:39And I suppose it's like when you kind of go as a, as a merchant,
- 42:42it's actually worth making that move, all these extra things
- 42:44that this does. Is it worthwhile when actually
- 42:46Shopify is covering 90% or you know, 8090% of my use cases?
- 42:50I think the the only other thing I said well is I think we talked
- 42:53about Shop Fly in today's state as well where they are
- 42:57definitely reducing room for some vendors.
- 43:02But I do also think Shop Fly's long term play and long term
- 43:07monetization strategy is probably quite different to what
- 43:10it is today. Like I think you know a lot will
- 43:12be a play on the data that they own.
- 43:15I think they'll be a bigger play around ads.
- 43:18I think they'll monetize the platform and the ecosystem more.
- 43:22And I think with all of that, there'll be, yeah, additional
- 43:25opportunity. Excellent.
- 43:29So that's been really interesting.
- 43:31Thanks as always for for joining us, Jim.
- 43:33And if anyone listening wants to debate what we said, chat about
- 43:38it in more detail or even challenge us and tell us we're
- 43:40talking complete nonsense, do reach out.
- 43:42You can get contact all of us on LinkedIn.
- 43:44I hope you've enjoyed that episode.
- 43:46Until next time everyone, you're listening to the Insidecommerce
- 43:50podcast. Hosted by experienced
- 43:51consultants James Gerd and Paul Rogers, Insidecommerce is your
- 43:55fast tracked additional knowledge feature in interviews
- 43:58with leading e-commerce retailers, industry thought
- 44:00leads and the C-Suite key tech companies to explore the latest
- 44:03digital strategy, customer experience and tech.
- 44:06Discover what the latest trends really mean and get practical
- 44:09advice based on experience to help fine tune your E Comm
- 44:11strategy and tech. Follow us on LinkedIn and reach
- 44:15out to James and Paul if you'd like to discuss an e-commerce
- 44:17project. We hope you enjoy the latest
- 44:19episode.